sign in sign up
<<
Home , Chait, Christopher Lyon, Clark Johnson, Imerys, Josephine Johnson, Katherine Johnson

Neutral As of: May 5, 2020 7:00 PM Z

In re Johnson & Johnson Talcum Powder Prods. Mktg., Sales Practices & Prods. Litig.

United States District Court for the District of April 27, 2020, Decided; April 27, 2020, Filed Civil Action No.: 16-2738(FLW), MDL No. 2738

Reporter 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533 * MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, IN RE: JOHNSON & JOHNSON TALCUM POWDER RED BANK, NJ. PRODUCTS MARKETING, SALES PRACTICES AND PRODUCTS LITIGATION For ADA RICH-WILLIAMS, 16-6489, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; Prior History: In re Johnson & Johnson Talcum Powder Richard Runft Barrett, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL Prods. Mktg., Sales Practices & Prods. Liab. Litig., 220 NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW OFFICES F. Supp. 3d 1356, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 138403 OF RICHARD L. BARRETT, PLLC, OXFORD, MS; (J.P.M.L., Oct. 5, 2016) CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ.

For DOLORES GOULD, 16-6567, Plaintiff: PATRICIA Core Terms LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; studies, cancer, talc, ovarian, causation, , GORE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT reliable, Plaintiffs', cells, talcum powder, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PRATT & epidemiological, methodology, cohort, dose-response, ASSOCIATES, SAN JOSE, CA; CHRISTOPHER unreliable, products, biological, exposure, case-control, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & Defendants', relative risk, testing, scientific, opines, ROTH, PC, RED BANK, [*2] NJ. inflammation, consistency, expert testimony, in vitro, causes, laboratory For TOD ALAN MUSGROVE, 16-6568, Plaintiff: AMANDA KATE KLEVORN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ Counsel: [*1] For HON. JOEL A. PISANO, Special BAR, BURNS CHAREST LLP, NEW ORLEANS, LA; Master: JOEL A PISANO, LEAD ATTORNEY, WALSH PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP, NEWARK, NJ. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, For JAMES CHAKALOS, 14-7079, Plaintiff: CARMEN , TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; MICHAEL JAMES KUHARSKI, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For MARY R ROBB, 16-6608, MELISSA ANN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KUHARSKI, LEVITZ & AGUILAR, 16-6608, FREDY AGUILAR, 16-6608, GIOVINAZZO, ESQS., STATEN ISLAND, NY; Plaintiffs: CHARLES C WEDDLE, III, Joe E White, Jr, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, USDC-NJ BAR, WHITE & WEDDLE PC, OKLAHOMA Page 2 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *2

CITY, OK; DEREK K. BURCH, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BURNS CHAREST COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Burch LLP, DALLAS, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD & George, Oklahoma City, OK; John P Zelbst, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD BAR, Zelbst Holmes & Butler, Lawton, OK; MATTHEW ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, J. SILL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT DALLAS, TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SILL LAW GROUP, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Oklahoma City, OK; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For RENE SLAYDEN, 16-7315, Plaintiff: DAVID T. BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & RED BANK, NJ. ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For NANCY BORS, 16-6693, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, NOT ADMITTED [*3] TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Casey LLP, , PA; DENA YOUNG, LEAD ATTORNEY, WEITZ & LUXENBERG, P.C., CHERRY For PATRICIA KUHN, 16-7312, Plaintiff: CHARLES F. HILL, NJ; MARK ALAN HOFFMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARRETT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ROSS FELLER CASEY LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA; ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Neal & Harwell, PLC, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, United Sta, Nashville, TN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & RED BANK, NJ. ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ.

For TANASHISKA LUMAS, 16-6694, Plaintiff: JOHN W. For NELL ROSE STRICKLAND, 16-7337, CHARLES L. BARRETT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT STRICKLAND, 16-7337, ALLISON M. WALKER, 16- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BARRETT LAW 7503, Plaintiffs: JOHN RAYMOND BEVIS, LEAD GROUP, LEXINGTON, MS; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO BAR, BARNES LAW GROUP LLC, MARIETTA, GA; USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER PATRICIA LEIGH [*5] O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. MONTGOMERY, AL; Patrick Alan Dawson, Robert David Cheeley, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT For KEVIN RICHARDS, 16-6661, Plaintiff: DANIEL R. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Cheeley Law Group, LAPINSKI, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, LLC, Alpharetta, GA; Roy E. Barnes, LEAD CHERRY HILL, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, The Barnes Law Group, LLC, Marietta, GA; BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. RED BANK, NJ. For RICHARD PHILLIPS, 16-7336, Plaintiff: PATRICIA For ELOUISE ANDERSON, 16-7087, KENNETH J. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BATISTE, 16-7499, Plaintiffs: AMANDA KATE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; KLEVORN, Korey Arthur Nelson, LEAD ATTORNEYS, WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX; USDC-NJ BAR, BURNS CHAREST LLP, NEW CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, ORLEANS, LA; DANIEL H. CHAREST, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. ATTORNEY, [*4] PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT Page 3 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *5

For BARBARA LEE, 16-7414, Plaintiff: DOUGLAS For BRENDA TRAYLOR, 16-7425 AND 17-8236, ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL Plaintiff: ANDREW J. HILL, III, HENRY G. GARRARD, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE DUGAN III, JOSH B. WAGES, PATRICK H. GARRARD, LEAD LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT NJ BAR, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; JAMES B. MATTHEWS, III, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. USDC-NJ BAR, BLASINGAME BURCVH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO For BRENDA SHELTON, 16-7415, Plaintiff: PATRICIA USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Patrick Dean McMurtray, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED [*6] TO USDC-NJ BAR, Frazer Law LLC, Nashville, TN; Payton Dwight For ANGELA LOVATO, 16-7427, KATIE BASBAGILL, Hoover, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 16-7427, SYBLE BREWER, 16-7427, DAWN DURBIN, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Campbell and 16-7427, ANGELA FEDE, 16-7427, BARBARA Associates, PA, Charlotte, NC; THOMAS ROE FICACCI, 16-7427, TONI GROSS, 16-7427, PATRICIA FRAZER, II, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, HINES, 16-7427, MARY JAUBERT, 16-7427, PAMELA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KIDD, 16-7427, AL MARTINEZ, 16-7427, DONILA FRAZER PLC, Nashville, TN; Thomas Roe Frazer, III, MARTINEZ, 16-7427, ARTHUR SMOLLER, 16-7427, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, NOT ADMITTED BARBARA VINCENT, 16-7427, Plaintiffs: Joshua TO USDC-NJ, Frazer Law LLC, Nashville, TN; Bradley, MARGARET MOSES BRANCH, TURNER W. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, BRANCH, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Branch Law Firm, Albuquerque, NM; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT [*8] ADMITTED TO For CHARLES FENSTEMAKER, 16-7418, Plaintiff: USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY; HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI SHKOLNIK PLLC, MELVILLE, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For ROBERTA JOHANSON, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; Sean Patrick Barth, LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, BAR, NAPOLI SHKOLNIK, Edwardsville, IL; ALASTAIR PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. FINDEIS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MELVILLE, NY; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For NANCY CREWS HICKS, 16-7428, BRANNON PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RICE HICKS SR, 16-7428, Plaintiffs: JOHN RAYMOND RED BANK, NJ. BEVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BARNES LAW GROUP For SISI HARRY, 16-7418, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH LLC, MARIETTA, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICK A DAWSON, Sean Patrick Barth, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL [*7] ROBERT D. CHEELEY, LEAD ATTORNEYS, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NAPOLI COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SHKOLNIK, Edwardsville, IL; CHRISTOPHER ALPHARETTA, GA; Roy E. Barnes, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, The ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Barnes Law Group, LLC, Marietta, GA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Page 4 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *8

ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Law Office of Eusi H. Phillips, LLC, New Orleans, LA; Marion Dean Floyd, For SHINTELLE JOSEPH, 16-7465, Plaintiff: DAVID S. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO SCALIA, DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD USDC-NJ BAR, Marion D. Floyd, Attorney at Law, ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- Kenner, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD NJ BAR, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LA; James Randolph Dugan, II, LANSON LEON BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL BORDELON, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, The Dugan Law Firm, RED BANK, NJ. APLC, New Orleans, LA; PATRICIA [*9] LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; For LEON POCHE, 16-7501, KEVIN POCHE, 16-7501, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, CELESTE POCHE, 16-7501, Plaintiffs: Brian Edward PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Adorno, LEAD ATTORNEY, Brian E. Adorno, Attorney, LLC, Metairie, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; TIMOTHY R. For GYLMORE SIMPSON, 16-7473, Plaintiff: BRIAN RICHARDSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, USRY WEEKS & JAMES HOLMES, Michael Thomas Mertz, LEAD MATTHEWS, NEW ORLEANS, LA; CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & NJ BAR, HURLEY MCKENNA & MERTZ, CHICAGO, ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For CAROL ROBINSON, 16-7502, Plaintiff: Elizabeth PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, Ann Roche', LEAD ATTORNEY, BURNS CHAREST, RED BANK, NJ. LLP, New Orleans, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL [*11] PLACITELLA, For LINDA BLAZIO, 16-7489, LAUREN MATTHEWS, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. 16-7490, OLIVIA PROUT, 16-7474, Plaintiffs: Casey William Moll, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Law Office of John D. For BARBARA ROSS, 16-7529, Plaintiff: KENNETH Sileo, LLC, New Orleans, LA; JOHN D. SILEO, LEAD BRIAN MOLL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOLL LAW GROUP, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ CHICAGO, IL; Kurt D. Hyzy, LEAD ATTORNEY, The BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, Law Group, Ltd., Chicago, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ.. For PHILIP FRANCIS, 16-7530, Personal For THOMAS DUVALL CASEY, 16-7477, Plaintiff: Ann Representative of the Estate of Maggy Francis, Plaintiff: B. Oldfather, ROBERT SEAN DESKINS, LEAD ANTHONY M. GEORGES-PIERRE, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- REMER & GEORGES-PIERRE PLLC, MIAMI, FL; NJ BAR, Oldfather Law Firm, Louisville, KY; JENNIFER PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, A. MOORE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, [*10] MOORE LAW PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, GROUP PLLC, LOUISVILLE, KY; PATRICIA LEIGH BANK, NJ. O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; For MICHAEL OLICHNEY, 16-7537, Plaintiff: PATRICIA CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. AL; Timothy Brown, LEAD ATTORNEY, Murray Law Firm, New Orleans, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For PAULA JACKSON, 16-7488, Plaintiffs: Eusi H. PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, Phillips, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BANK, NJ. Page 5 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *11

LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX; DANIEL E. GUSTAFSON, DANIEL C. For LUCY REMPAS, 16-7571, Plaintiff: ERIC D. HEDLUND, LEAD ATTORNEYS, GUSTAFSON GLUEK , LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN; KOREY A. NELSON, LEAD PEARSON, IRVING, TX; John Wilson Pate, LEAD ATTORNEY, MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, Heygood, Orr & Pearson, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, Irving, TX; Michael M Cushing, LEAD ATTORNEY, Law MONTGOMERY, AL; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD Offices of F. John Cushing III, P.C., Chicago, IL; ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, DALLAS, TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, MONTGOMERY, [*12] AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. For ERIC DAVIS, 16-7844, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & For DOLORAE HANDY, 16-7570, Plaintiff: DAVID J. ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ; DENNIS M. GEIER, LEAD STANOCH, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK, ATTORNEY, COHEN PLACITELLA & ROTH, RED P.C., PHILADELPHIA, PA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD M. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. GOLOMB, RUBEN HONIK, STEVEN D. RESNICK, TAMMI MARKOWITZ, LEAD ATTORNEYS, GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C., PHILADELPHIA, PA; CHRISTOPHER For EDWARD SPENNY, 16-7884, Plaintiff: Amanda M MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & Williams, LEAD ATTORNEY, Gustafson Gluek PLLC, ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. Minneapolis, MN; DANIEL H. CHAREST, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX; DANIEL E. GUSTAFSON, DANIEL C. For JAMIE JOHNSTON, 16-7581, Plaintiff: PATRICIA HEDLUND, LEAD ATTORNEYS, GUSTAFSON GLUEK LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; [*14] PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. For PATRICK BARKER, 16-7656, Plaintiff: CHAD M. TUSCHMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, WILLIAMS DECLARK For BRIDGET MCBRIDE, 16-7891, Plaintiff: Damon R. TUSCHMAN CO., LPA, TOLEDO, OH; PATRICIA Pourciau, LEAD ATTORNEY, Ardoin Law Firm, Kenner, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, LA; LINDSEY A. CHEEK, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, CHEEK LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; Scott Michael Galante, LEAD ATTORNEY, Galante For GREGORY KEHRES, 16-7657, ADAM G. KEHRES, & Bivalacqua LLC, New Orleans, LA; CHRISTOPHER 16-7657, ANDREW S. KEHRES, 16-7657, EMILY D. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & KEHRES, 16-7657, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; Ralph C. Megargel, LEAD ATTORNEY, Megargel & For KATINA HARPER, 16-7892, Plaintiff: PATRICIA Eskridge, Ravenna, OH; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, AL; Timothy Brown, LEAD ATTORNEY, Murray Law BANK, NJ. Firm, New Orleans, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, For DEBORAH JOHNSON, 16-7664 () [*13] BANK, NJ. on behalf of, HEIRS OF PAMELA WOODS, Plaintiff: AMANDA KATE KLEVORN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO For LUCY TETLOW, 16-7893, Plaintiff: Betsy J. Barnes, HAC VICE, CHAREST LLP, NEW ORLEANS, LA. LEAD ATTORNEY, Morris Bart, LLC (New Orleans), Amanda M Williams, LEAD ATTORNEY, Gustafson New Orleans, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Gluek PLLC, Minneapolis, MN; DANIEL H. CHAREST, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD LEE Page 6 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *14

ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORRIS BART & Raleigh E. Hansman, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Meierhenry ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA; CHRISTOPHER Sargent, LLP, Sioux Falls, SD; PATRICIA LEIGH MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. For DIANA SHINSKE, 16-7894, DANIEL J. SHINSKE, 16-7894, Plaintiffs: JOSEPH H. SAUNDERS, LEAD For JACKIE EPPS, 16-7890, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH ATTORNEY, SAUNDERS & WALKER PA, PINELLAS O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; PARK, FL; Michelle Whitman, LEAD ATTORNEY, THOMAS F. CUFFIE, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE CUFFIE Danziger & De Llano, LLP, [*15] , TX; LAW FIRM, ATLANTA, GA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD LEE ROOT, LEAD BANK, NJ. ATTORNEY, MORRIS BART & ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For AMY REBECCA WOOD, 16-7986, GEORGE E. WOOD, JR., 16-7986, Plaintiffs: James Kendall Clark, For DOLORES CERRONE-KENNEDY, 16-7895, JOSH LEAD ATTORNEY, Clark Robb Mason Coulombe & KENNEDY, 16-7895, Plaintiffs: ASHLEA GAYLE Buschman, Miami, FL; MICHAEL AUSTIN ROBB, LEAD SCHWARZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, PAUL LLP, KANSAS ATTORNEY, Clark Robb Mason Coulombe & CITY, MO; Jack D. McInnes, V, LEAD ATTORNEY, Buschman, Coral Springs, FL; PATRICIA LEIGH Paul McInnes LLP, Kansas City, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, RICHARD M. PAUL, III, SUSAN BECKER, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. ATTORNEYS, PAUL LLP, KANSAS CITY CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, For PAUL ANTHONY RESOR, JR., 16-7989, Plaintiff: PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. Casey William Moll, Law Office of John D. Sileo, LLC, New Orleans, LA; JOHN D. SILEO, NEW ORLEANS, For LISA WILSON, 16-7886, Plaintiff: ANDY D. LA; PATRICIA [*17] LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BIRCHFIELD, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER WILSON ALLEN, CROW & METHVIN, PC, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & MONTGOMERY, AL; LAURENCE S. BERMAN, LEAD ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. ATTORNEY, LEVIN FISHBEIN SEDRAN & BERMAN, PHILADELPHIA, PA; MICHAEL M. WEINKOWITZ, For CAMMY D MARCHETTI, 16-8082, MICHAEL A LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SEDRAN & BERMAN LLP, MARCHETTI, 16-8082, Plaintiffs: JOHN RAYMOND PHILADELPHIA, PA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BEVIS, LAW GROUP LLC, MARIETTA, GA; PATRICIA ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; Robert AL; PATRICK A DAWSON, ROBERT D. CHEELEY, Allen Smith, Jr., Smith Law Firm, PLLC, Ridgeland, MS; ALPHARETTA, GA; Roy E. Barnes, LEAD ATTORNEY, Ted G Meadows, Beasley, Allen, Montgomery, AL; The Barnes Law Group, LLC, Marietta, GA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ.

For16-7887, CARLYNE WILLIS, Plaintiff: C Don For PEGGY VALLOT, 16-8086, Plaintiff: PATRICIA Freeman, III, MICHAEL SHANE [*16] LUCADO, LEAD LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, ATTORNEYS, SHELBY RODEN LLC, Birmingham, AL; AL; JOHN D. SILEO, ORLEANS, LA; CHRISTOPHER PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. For CHRISTINA BIRDSONG, 16-8224 and 16-8810, MARY GRANT, 16-8224, DELIALA PATTERSON, 16- For CAROL SHOUP, 16-7889, Plaintiff: Clint L. Sargent, Page 7 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *17

8224 and 16-8815, CONNIE , 16-8224 and 16- ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; William Hugh 8816, VIOLA IVY THORPE, 16-8224 and 16-8827, McAngus, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, Chappell Smith and VANESSA WAGENKNECHT, 16-8224 and 16-8828, Arden, Columbia, SC; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; SINDHU SUSAN BANK, NJ. DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARON & BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, For KAY LORRAINE JOHNSTON, 16-8564, SHARON COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. R. RANDALL, 17-10593, CYNTHIA WHITSON, 17- 9588, KELLY BUBOLTZ, 17-10843, DONNA LYNN For ANNIE WILLIAMS, 16-8224 and 16-8829, Plaintiff: SMITH, JAMES SMITH, 16-8564, 16-8564, PATRICIA MAGUA BIANCA BENSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, LYONS, 17-8627, CHARLES MEGLIORINO, PAMELA ATLANTA, [*18] GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD STARR, 17-10569, 16-8564, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; SINDHU SUSAN HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLAND GROVES DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARON & BUDD PC, SCHNELLER & STOLZE LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; DALLAS, TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. MONTGOMERY, AL; RANDALL SETH CROMPTON, LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. For MARY JO SCHOFIELD, 16-8331, Plaintiff: ERIC HOWARD WEINBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAW OFFICES OF ERIC H. WEINBERG, NEW For MELINDA HOLCOMB, 17-10595, CHARLES BRUNSWICK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LYONS, JR., 17-8627, PAULA D. MEGLIORINO, 16- ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; SINDHU SUSAN 8564, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARON & BUDD PC, LEAD ATTORNEY, , NY; ERIC D. DALLAS, TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLAND GROVES COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BANK, NJ. SCHNELLER & STOLZE LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; RANDALL SETH CROMPTON, For AMY MAUERER-MARTIN, 16-8365, RONALD LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL MARTIN, 16-8365, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, PLACITELLA, [*20] COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; ROBERT T. PC, BANK, NJ. DASSOW, William Frederick Eckhart, LEAD ATTORNEYS, HOVDE DASSOW & DEETS LLC, INDIANAPOLIS, IN; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For KIM WOOMER, 17-8625, RICKIE WOOMER, 17- PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, 8625, LILY FIMBRES, 17-8622, GILBERT FIMBRES, BANK, NJ. 17-8622, CINDY JETT, 17-8523, DEAN JETT, 17-8523, MARSHA ROBBINS, 17-8522, JERRY ROBBINS, 17- 8522, THERESA MCGUIRE, 17-10641, on behalf of For KENT D. DAVIS, 16-8366, RUTH ANN MARTIN, MARIA MCGUIRE, MARY JO WOOLF, 17-8793, 16-8367, Plaintiffs: Andrew W. Hutton, BLAKE A. KIMBERLY MURRAY, 17-9841, CHANTIL BROWN, 17- SHUART, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Hutton & Hutton Law 9837, MARY HARPER, 17-9203, BARBARA SPICER, Firm, LLC, Wichita, KS; MARK B. HUTTON, LEAD 17-9202, PATRICIA O'BRIEN, 17-8882 (TX), DIANE ATTORNEY, HUTTON & HUTTON, WICHITA, KS; SPROCH, 17-9174, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY; ERIC D. PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, HOLLAND, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, RANDALL BANK, NJ. SETH CROMPTON, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; For WILMA HARPER, 16-8565, Plaintiff: [*19] CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, GRAHAM LEE NEWMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. CHAPPELL SMITH & ARDEN, COLUMBIA, SC; Mark Dale Chappell, LEAD ATTORNEY, Chappell and Smith, For MARVALENE LEACOCK, 16-8564, WINSTON Columbia, SC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Page 8 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *20

LEACOCK, 16-8564, TAMMY BIVENS, 16-8564, DIXIE ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BULLOCK, 16-8564, MARK MURRAY, 16-8564, BAR, WICHITA, KS; MARK B. HUTTON, LEAD DIANNA PRESTON, 16-8564, CATHERINE ARTHUR, ATTORNEY, HUTTON & HUTTON, WICHITA, KS; 16-8564, MARGENE WIRTZ, 16-8564, KELLI PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, STAPELTON, 16-8564, Plaintiff: ERIC D. HOLLAND, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, RANDALL SETH LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, CROMPTON, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, For SCOTT DAWSON, 16-8749, Plaintiff: John-Russell PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Bart Pate, LEAD ATTORNEY, The Pate Law Firm, St. Thomas, VI; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For TANJA SMITH, 17-9840, Plaintiffs: [*21] ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, NY; ERIC D. HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEYS, RED BANK, NJ. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, For STACEY D. WILLIAMS, 16-8738, Plaintiff: ERIC COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. HOWARD WEINBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAW OFFICES OF ERIC H. WEINBERG, NEW For HEATHER A CARLIN, 16-8699, WILLIAM H BRUNSWICK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD CARLIN, 16-8699, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DENNIS PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, M. GEIER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN PLACITELLA & RED BANK, NJ. ROTH, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO For LAQUITA A HOLLINQUEST, 16-8769, Plaintiff: USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. For WALTER THOMPSON, SR, 16-8722, WALTER LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL THOMPSON, JR, 16-8722, MARIAM THOMPSON, 16- PLACITELLA, [*23] COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, 8722, CRYSTAL THOMPSON, 16-8722, Plaintiffs: PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, Brendan S Thompson, LEAD ATTORNEY, Cuneo COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Gilbert and LaDuca LLP, Washington, DC; PATRICIA CELLINO & BARNES, BUFFALO, NY. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; For GWENDOLYN JOLLA, 16-8774, CALLISTA CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, GLOSTER LEE, 16-8805, LISA DANIELS, 16-8806, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. Plaintiffs: Betsy J. Barnes, Morris Bart, III, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Morris Bart, LLC (New Orleans), New For JANIE POTTS, 16-8725, LARRY POTTS, 16-8725, Orleans, LA; PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, Plaintiffs: MATTHEW RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD NJ; MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES, BAR, DALLAS, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BUFFALO, NY. ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For BETTY BIER, 16-8793, Plaintiff: Betsy J. Barnes, PLACITELLA, [*22] COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, Morris Bart, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, Morris Bart, LLC PC, RED BANK, NJ. (New Orleans), New Orleans, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For CARL MILLER, 16-8728, Plaintiff: Andrew W. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; Hutton, LEAD ATTORNEY, Hutton & Hutton Law Firm, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, LLC, Wichita, KS; BLAKE A. SHUART, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; RICHARD Page 9 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *23

LEE ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ADMITTED TOU SDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. COLUMBIA, SC; Mark Dale Chappell, LEAD ATTORNEY, Chappell and Smith, Columbia, SC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For LAURA SILLARS, 16-8831, Plaintiff: PATRICIA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LOUIS, MO; William Hugh McAngus, Jr, LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; ATTORNEY, Chappell Smith and Arden, Columbia, SC; SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARON CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, & BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. For ANDREA MEYER, 16-8964, SARAH WALKER, 16- 8963, LEGGERD GRAY, 16-8966, Plaintiffs: Betsy J. For ELIZABETH JARRETT, 16-8900; 17-7268, Plaintiff: Barnes, Morris Bart, III, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Morris ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, Bart, LLC (New Orleans), New Orleans, LA; PATRICIA COUNSEL [*24] NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT IRVING, TX; Michael B. Pross, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; Wallace and Graham, P.A., Salisbury, NC; PATRICIA CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. For GERALD C SCHIRMER, 16-8967, MICHAEL J. CARTER, 16-9101, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, For JAMES H. ABELL, 16-8901, on behalf of ESTATE Philadelphia, PA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD OF LINDA E. ABELL, Plaintiff: Abigale R. Green, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, Grossman & Moore, PLLC, Louisville, KY; BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL JENNIFER A. MOORE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LOUISVILLE, KY; RED BANK, NJ. PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, For JULIE M. SEGREAVES, 16-9119, JOHN [*26] G. COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. SEGREAVES, 16-9119, Plaintiff: JENNIFER LYNN RUHL, LEAD ATTORNEY, The Grossman Law Firm, Freehold, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For JAMIE LUBBEN, 16-8942, Plaintiff: PATRICIA ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, RED BANK, NJ. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DALLAS, TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. For RICHARD ARNOFF, 16-9228, MARILYN PASSANDER, 16-9229, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For MARIA E SANDOVAL, 16-8961, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller SHERRI L. PLOTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; PATRICIA LEIGH RHEINGOLD, GIUFFRA, RUFFO & PLOTKIN, LLP, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT NEW YORK, NY; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL [*25] PLACITELLA, RED BANK, NJ. COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ.

For BRENDA HAMMOND, 18-14524, Plaintiff: Betsy J., For PHOEBIE FERGUSON, 16-8962, Plaintiff: LEAD ATTORNEYS, Morris Bart, LLC (New Orleans), GRAHAM LEE NEWMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, New Orleans, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Page 10 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *26

ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MICHAEL HINGLE & ASSOCIATES, LLC, SLIDELL, BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; Morris Bart, III, LEAD LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. BAR, New Orleans, LA; LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; RICHARD For ODELL HOLLIDAY, 16-9507 AND 17-7271 on LEE ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT behalf of ESTATE OF LINDA PEARSON, MARSHALL, ADMITTED TOU SDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. Plaintiff: DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL For RON CAVOLT, 16-9400, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT [*27] LA; MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, For SONIA DOLINGER, 16-9485, Plaintiff: KRISTIE RED BANK, NJ. MARIE HIGHTOWER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAKE CHARLES, LA; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, For VICKI ALFORD, 16-9506, Plaintiff: GERALD COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOSEPH DIAZ, JR., JAMES RUSSELL SEGARS, III, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ USDC-NJ BAR, MADISON, MS; PATRICIA LEIGH BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; RED BANK, NJ. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. For NATHAN ROGERS, 16-9482, Plaintiff: Eric Donovan Pearson, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For SANDRA [*29] LEACH, 16-9556, Plaintiff: BRIAN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Irving, TX; PATRICIA A. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BUFFALO, NY; ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. For JESSICA CRADDUCK, 16-9482, Plaintiff: Eric Donovan Pearson, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For SALLY MEREDITH, 16-9562, Plaintiff: MICHAEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Irving, TX; PATRICIA HINGLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL HINGLE & LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ASSOCIATES, LLC, SLIDELL, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For BRENDA ADAMS, 16-9498, CRYSTAL For REBECCA HALL, 16-9596, Plaintiff: PAIGE BELLANGER, 16-9500, GWENDOLYN S. ELLIOTT, 16- NICOLE BOLDT, LEAD ATTORNEY, WATTS GUERRA 9514, BRENDA D. BROWN, 16-9508, VILMA [*28] P. LLP, San Antonio, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD SISSAC, 16-9524, CAROL MONTZ, 16-9523, RUTH ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, HARRIS, 16-9522, SANDRA LEACH, 16-9556, RITA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JONES-WILDER, 16-9571, MASHANDER BEZUE, 16- MONTGOMERY, AL. 9564, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL HINGLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, Page 11 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *29

For MARCUS WITHERSPOON, 16-9615, on behalf of For PAUL HVIZDOS, Plaintiff: AMANDA KATE Mary Ann Witherspoon, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH KLEVORN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW PLACITELLA, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- ORLEANS, LA; Beau D. Hollowell, LEAD ATTORNEY, NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; Warren Burns, LEAD COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ Cleveland, OH; DANIEL H. CHAREST, LEAD BAR, Burns Charest LLP, Dallas, TX. ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DALLAS, TX; DANIEL R. KARON, LEAD ATTORNEY, KARON, LLC., For ALME KENNEDY, 17-30, Plaintiff: Charles W. CLEVELAND, OH; KOREY A. NELSON, LEAD Miller, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Dallas, TX; Eric BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, Donovan Pearson, [*30] LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Irving, PLACITELLA, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- TX; Glenn Loewenthal, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; SPENCER M. COX, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Glenn LEAD ATTORNEY, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, Loewenthal, P.C., Atlanta, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH TX; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. PLACITELLA, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. For WENDY SCHWARTZ, 17-99, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA For PENNY MOSS, 17-33, RICHARD MOSS, 17-33, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT Plaintiffs: GREGORY L. LAKER, JEFFREY STEVEN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; GIBSON, JONATHAN ANDREW KNOLL, TAKEENA DANIEL R. SEIDMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL MONETTE THOMPSON, LEAD ATTORNEYS, NOT ADMITTED TO USDCV-NJ BAR, BELLEVILLE, IL. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER For FLORENCE KUNTZ, 17-97, Plaintiff: Alex J Brown, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED Michelle Whitman, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. NOT ADMITTED [*32] TO USDC-NJ BAR, Houston, TX; CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, For MICHAEL D SHACKELFORD, 17-40, JOSHUA NY; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, WAYNE VICKREY, 17-40, PEYTON ARCHER, 17-40, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, GLENNA MARIE LINDSAY, 17-40, Plaintiffs: COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Christopher J Bergin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL MONTGOMERY, AL; W. MARK LANIER, LEAD NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Edmond, OK; ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MATTHEW J. SILL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL BAR, TEXARKANA, TX. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Oklahoma City, OK; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COUNSEL For AMY F. DARNOLD, 17-96, Plaintiff: CARMEN NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL AL. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, For PHV ROBERT HARRIS, 17-47, Plaintiff: MICHAEL COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JAMES WILLIAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL MONTGOMERY, AL; Holly L. Deihl, LEAD ATTORNEY, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BUFFALO, PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO NY; [*31] PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD USDC-NJ BAR, Pittsburgh, PA; John D. Hurst, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAR, Morgantown, WV. MONTGOMERY, AL. Page 12 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *32

For RODELLA BROWN-HARRISON, 17-80, Plaintiff: ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ [*34] BAR, MONTGOMERY, CASEY RYAN COBURN, EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD AL. ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, PHILADELPHIA, PA; CHRISTOPHER For ROBERT GENDELMAN, 17-461, Plaintiff: MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; GEOFFREY B. GOMPERS, LEAD ATTORNEY, For STEVEN HARRISON, 17-80, Plaintiff: Voorhees, NJ; JEFFREY R. LESSIN, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA ATTORNEY, JEFFREY R. LESSIN & ASSOCIATES LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; EDWARD M. NASS, [*33] LEAD ATTORNEY, For ROY J VILLELLA, 17-512, Plaintiff: represented by COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, AMANDA KATE KLEVORN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO PHILADELPHIA, PA. HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For KENNETH PIRRAGLIA, 17-81, Plaintiff: PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; John Chapman, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For ANTOINE EDWARDS, 17-513, Plaintiff: ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Irving, TX. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT For RUTHIE WALKER SMITH, 17-82, Plaintiff: ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA THOMAS F. CUFFIE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSERL LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATLANTA, GA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; JOHN KENNETH CHAPMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, For DOMENICA C PROVENZ, 17-516, Plaintiff: COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA IRVING, TX. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; For JILLIAN ASHMORE, 17-136, Plaintiff: William B Thompson, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Dallas, TX. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. For CATHY MORRIS, 17-549, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, For GWENDOLYN AYERS, 17-154, Plaintiff: LEAD ATTORNEYS, [*35] COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; SINDHU LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DALLAS, TX. GARY A ANDERSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BIRMINGHAM, For AUDREY EDWARDS, 17-627, B. ELAINE AL. HOUSTON, 17-713, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, For MARILYN SAVAGAE, 17-395, Plaintiff: BILL B. LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO BERKE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; WARREN T ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CAPE CORAL, FL; BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. . LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT Page 13 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *35

For KIMBERLY CARNEY, 17-796, GLORIA ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- AMOGRETTI, 17-796, ANNETTE BASSEY, 17-796, NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. ONDER, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, Michael J. Quillin, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ [*37] BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. ONDER, Michael J. ST. LOUIS, MO. Quillin, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT For GLEN LOWDER, 17-11059, on behalf of ESTATE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. OF GEROLDINE LOWDER, DECEASED, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA For DENNA ARCHER, 17-8543, DEBBIE MCDOUGAL, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT 17-9369, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO JAMES G. ONDER, Michael J. Quillin, STEPHANIE USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ONDER, Michael J. Quillin, STEPHANIE LYNN BAR, PORT WASHINGTON, NY. RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. For DAVINDER SALLY, 17-10274, on behalf of LOUIS, MO. ESTATE OF ASHOK SALLY, DECEASED, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA For BETTY [*36] BRADLEY, 17-9321, Plaintiff: LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT JAMES G. ONDER, Michael J. Quillin, STEPHANIE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD JAMES G. ONDER, Michael J. Quillin, STEPHANIE ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; T. MATTHEW LECKMAN, PHILADELPHIA, PA. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CONSHOHOCKEN, PA. For VIVIAN THARP, 17-9038, SANDRA UNRUH, 17- 796, DEBBIE WILLIAMS, 17-8653, BEATRIZ For DARLENE BROCK, 17-8542, NATALIE CANIPE, FRAUSTO, 17-796, CHARLES GEISER, 17-11099 on 17-10190, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL behalf of ESTATE OF PATRICIA GEISER, DECEASED, PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD JESSICA D'ORSI, 17-11119 on behalf of ESTATE OF ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- JOYCE PASQUARELLI, DECEASED, DIANA BRYANT, NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. ONDER, 17-796, BARBARA ABRAMS, 17-8783, CAMELA [*38] Michael J. Quillin, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, MCKINLEY, 17-9261, INGE NATTRESS, 17-796, JOHN WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, STEIN, 18-12969, BRIAN MARINO, 17-7427 on behalf COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. of ESTATE OF MARIE MARINO, DECEASED, LOUIS, MO LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD CYNTHIA MUSGROVE, 17-9264, JOANNE, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ WILLIAMSON 17-796, YVONNE TIMIAN, 17-9275, BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. . CARRIE BROWN, 17-10736, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO For ELIZABETH GRANNIS, 17-8623, Plaintiff: USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER, Michael J. Quillin, STEPHANIE LYNN COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LOUIS, MO. Page 14 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *38

O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- For FELICIA VEGA, 17-9017, Plaintiff: LAUREN NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. For JOHN SOLOWSKI, 17-806, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. [*40] GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For WYNESTER LOGAN, 17-9357, Plaintiff: DAVID T. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BUFFALO, NY; MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. LOUIS, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. For MICHELE HARRELL, 17-797, AMY MCCALL, 17- 9363, LEAH TAYLOR, 17-9361, Plaintiffs: For DEANNA VALLE, 17-798, ROBERTA ADAMS, 17- CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 798, CHERYL BRENDEL, DANIEL ESQUIVEL, 17- ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED 10505 on behalf of BERTHA ESQUIVEL, LILLIAN BANK, NJ; D. Todd Mathews, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI GARCIA, 17-798, LETICIA GIRADO, 17-9824, AND JULIAN, P.C., Edwardsville, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH CARMELA GRAMUGLIA, 17-798, PAMELA HARPER, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL 17-9865, DOROTHY JOHNSON, 17-10718, PLACITELLA, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- LABRENDA JONES, 17-9106, ALISE KHAZZAKA, 17- NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. 798, ROBIN LAZARUS, 17-798, JILL LEWIS, 17-11095 on behalf of KAREN SCHAMP, PEGGY MASON, 17- For SANDY MCKENNEY, 17-11841, [*39] JULIE 9866, SERGEANT JOHN MAZZUCA, 17-798, NEJMAN, 17-9366, SANDRA SALAMONE, 17-11842, individually and as Representative of the Estate of Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, Kathleen Mazzuca, deceased, DONALD MCCARTER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, 17-11192 on behalf of SANDRA MCCARTER, LOUISE PC, RED BANK, NJ; D. Todd Mathews, LEAD MOORE, 17-798, VERONICA ROPER, 17-9137, ATTORNEY, GORI AND JULIAN, P.C., Edwardsville, SHERRI SANDERS, 17-9089, JANET SHIRK, 17-9058, IL; DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI DORIS STILLINGS, 17-798, CHRISTINE TAYLOR, 17- JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; 798, SYLVIA THOMPSON, 17-9026, AMANDA PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, VOLKER-LOGUIDICE, 17-798, LYNN WEBB, 17-798, MONTGOMERY, AL. DIANA WHITAKER , 17-9638, TERRY W HAFLEY, 17- 11169 on behalf of TERRY K. HAFLEY, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA For DONNA MASON, 17-802 AND 17-4556, Plaintiff: LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ADMITTED [*41] TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BANK, NJ; MICHAEL J. MILLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- For JUDY BLACKMON, 17-7410, HARRIET COOMER NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; TAYJES MATTHEW 17-9863, SAMANTHA CRUZ, 17-7415, LANITA DIXON, SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, 17-9864, CHARLOTTE HARDIN, 17-11183, SUSANA ORANGE, VA. SALAS, 17-7381, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- For CLYDE G. MASON, JR., 17-802, Plaintiff: NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. BANK, NJ; MICHAEL J. MILLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, LOUIS, MO; ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA; PATRICIA LEIGH IRVING, TX. Page 15 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *41

NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, [*43] MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For KAREN CRUM, 17-8579, SARAH DIXON, 17-8598, PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD JANICE JACKSON, 17-cv-9036, MARIA ORTIZ, 17- ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- 10400, JANET SHEPHERD, 17-8704, Plaintiffs: NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; LOUIS, MO. STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO; ERIC D. PEARSON, JASON RICHARD, 17-874, JENNY CALLAHAN, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO 874, BETTY PREJEAN, 17-873, CHAD RHODES, 17- USDC-NJ BAR, IRVING, TX; LAUREN KLOESS 838, RONALD PICOU, 17-838, MARY PICOU, 17-838, RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT JAMES TINGSTROM, 17-839, SEBASTIAN FERMAN, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-841, Plaintiffs: Alton Jerold Hall, Jr., Bobby J. Delise, LEAD ATTORNEY, Delise & Hall (Covington), Covington, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For SUZANNE MARTINCHALK, 17-9322, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER Plaintiff: [*42] BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ. BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- For ROBERT C REDDY, 17-877, Individually and in his NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN Capacity as Personal Representative of the Estate of RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Sandra Faye Reddy, Deceased, Plaintiff: COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, Delise & Hall (Covington), Covington, LA; For THERESA SLADE, 17-8707, DEBRA SMITH, 17- PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, 798; 17-8722, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN For JOYCE WILLIAMS, 17-799, MARSHA KAY RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ANDERSON, 17-8957, ALLEN BRAITHWAITE, 17-799, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. MARGERY BURKHART, 17-11182, MARY CANGE, 17- LOUIS, MO; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD 799, SUSAN CONTE, [*44] 17-799, CURTIS DAVIS, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 17-799, JOANN E DEVONE, 17-799, CATHERINE BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. FAIRBROTHER, 17-799, CHRISTINA FELTER, 17-799, ALICE GREEN, 17-799, DONALD HUGHES, 17-10063, on behalf of PEGGY HUGHES, JOHNNETTA HODGE, For HELENE STOPCYNSKI, 17-11012, Plaintiff: 17-799, CONSTANCE JOHNSON, 17-799, ROSA CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD JONAS, 17-799, ROBERTA MEACHEM, 17-799, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & , ST. RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, LOUIS, MO; STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, LOUIS, MO. MINNEAPOLIS, MN.

For SHEILA GAIL BAIZE, 17-10647, Plaintiff: For DAWN VANNA, 17-8993, Plaintiff: CARMEN CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL Page 16 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *44

ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED of CINDY ANGEL, BRENDA DOWNEY, 17-8604, BANK, NJ; NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, P.C., , CA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, MICHAEL LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE JOSEPH QUILLIN, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW For REATA CRABTREE, 17-8200, Plaintiff: METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD For SHIRLEEN BEGAYE, 17-10159, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE [*45] PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. ONDER, MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & For MARY GALLOW, 17-790, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER For JOAN DITTRICH, 17-10298, DOLORES HAYNES, SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; 17-10315, ANDREA HUTCHINSON, 17-10318, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, MONTGOMERY, AL. LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, For DIANA AHLBIN, 17-790, TAMMY ABELL, 17-8789, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER MARVA AIMES, 17-8790, CHERYLE BECHTOLD, 17- SHELTON O'LEARY [*47] & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, 790, ALVETTA CARROLL, 17-7821, LYNETTE MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CEPHAS, 17-9097, SOMBEN CROMER, 17-790, MONTGOMERY, AL; STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, SUZANNE DUKEWITS, 17-790, ALMA JEAN LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, EASTMAN, 17-790, CANDICE ELLISON, 17-790, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. FAITH FOWLER, 17-790, FREYA GORDON, 17-790, BRENDA GRIFFIN, 17-790, SARAH JANE HILTON, 17- 790, LEXI HOLLAND, 17-790, LAKISHIA HOWARD, 17- For E.J. HAYNES, 17-11134, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER 790, JAUICE LAMAR-DAVIS, 17-10417, BARBARA MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LANDRY, 17-9128, MARIA MARTINEZ, 17-790, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, MICHAEL BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON JOSEPH QUILLIN, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STUART WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For LYNDA HELMS, 17-7900, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For SARAH MARIE ANGEL, [*46] 17-9279, on behalf PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. Page 17 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *47

GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, Delise & Hall MONTGOMERY, AL. (Covington), Covington, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE For LYNDA MACK, 17-9130, MONIQUE MCCORMICK, LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD 17-9132, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON For WILLIE R. GIVENS, SR., 17-8583, on behalf of O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. ESTATE OF DENITA SHANTAI GIVENS, DECEASED, Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, CHRISTA GOEB, 17-8618, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, [*48] NJ; O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. JAMES G. ONDER, MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, For PHILIP SELLS, 17-910, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. GREGORY L. LAKER, JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COHEN & MALAD LLP, For CARMEN KIRKPATRICK, 17-7650, FRED INDIANAPOLIS, IN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LAYFIELD, 17-7884, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JOHN For ALMETRA PERRY, 17-10988, BETH PLOCHER, RANDOLPH DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, SLACK & 17-799, SHARON POPOV, 17-799, JOY SHELTON, 17- DAVIS LLP, AUSTIN, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, 10985, CONNIE SMOCK, 17-8724, MARIA SOLIS, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE 10250, SHIRLEY TAVENDER, 17-8713, NANCY LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD TEAGARDENER, 17-799, ROSALYNNE TITUS, 17- ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & 9967, JULIA RANDALL VICIAN, 17-11139, NADINE PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. VICTORINO, 17-799, MOBILE WILLIAMS, 17- 799, [*50] MELISSA ACEVEDO, 17-10155, VICTOR For STEPHANIE G. SMITH, 17-881, KRISTIN AREVALO, 17-10510, on behalf of, ESTATE OF KNISKERN, 17-904, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER RACHEL AREVALO, JANICE BAHMLER, 17-800, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHELLE LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON For ANGELA LEACH-JAYROE, 17-10420, Plaintiff: O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, STEPHANIE LYNN For NINA SEMITKA, 17-8984, DEBRA SPROFERA, 18- RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, 13123, WANDA R. STRONG, 17-8991, Plaintiffs: ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, LOUIS, MO; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PORTIS [*49] & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Page 18 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *50

ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM For ANDRIA ARSEN, 17-cv-7826, JUDITH MURRAY, WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON 17-9139, ANA MAQUIRE, 17-790, KAREN O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. MCQUILLEN, 17-790, BARBARA MILES, 17-9136, ANGELA MORTON, 17-9657, DOROTHY PACKER, 17- For REBECCA SMALLEY, 17-8717, Plaintiff: 790, CARRIE , 17-790, BELINDA , CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 17-790, REGINA SCOTT, 17-9975, MELISSA STRETZ, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED 17-9728, DEBBIE KAY THOMPSON, 17-9033, BANK, NJ; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD TIMOTHY TREMMEL, 17-9452, other, DEBORAH BAY, ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN DECEASED, JULIE WALLEN, 17-8668, KENAH PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICIA WHEELER, 17-790, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*51] MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON For CLAUDIA WILLIAMS, 17-8169, Plaintiff: O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. BANK, NJ; HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, For SHARON MONAHAN, 17-7881, MARY MORRIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE 17-7883, Plaintiffs: represented by, CHRISTOPHER LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, [*53] NJ; WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA For DAVID WOJNAR, 17-11141, BERTHA BARMES, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, 17-10151, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, For ROSA MUSE, 17-11016, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MINNEAPOLIS, MN; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PARKER For CAMEO MCCLENDON, 17-943, Plaintiff: WAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY; Michael CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, [*52] LA; L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM Page 19 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *53

WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For DEBBIE NETTERVILLE, 17-8022, Plaintiff: MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STUART LEE BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN; WILLIAM WYLIE LOUIS, MO; Michael J. [*54] Quillin, LEAD BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, For JIM T. RUNNELS, 17-807, JOSEPHINE RUNNELS, WASHINGTON, DC; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, 17-807, Plaintiffs: BRIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, CELLINO & BARNES PC, BUFFALO, NY; PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For TIFFANY PROVITT, 17-8980, Plaintiff: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY For LOLA ACEVEDO, 17-792, WENDY FEREIRA, 17- RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER 792, TERESA GUNBY, 17-9666, TONYA HILL, 17- MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, 11847, DEBBY MCFADDEN, 17-11844, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. CRYSTAL [*56] RICHARD, 17-11850, JOYCE ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON SOWLES, 17-9676 AND 17-792, Plaintiffs: O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BANK, NJ; DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM MONTGOMERY, AL. WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. For JOHN ANDERSON, 17-9434, on behalf of, ESTATE OF CHARLOTTE ANDERSEN, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. For EVELINE THAYER, 17-9812, Plaintiff: MCCORMICK, JR., MARK ALAN HOFFMAN, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. BANK, NJ; DENA RACHEL YOUNG, SCOTT S LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD [*55] BERGER, JR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ROSS FELLER ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN CASEY, LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA; PATRICIA LEIGH RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. For SARA TIBBETTS, 17-10429, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED For RALPH ALCALA, 17-11166, on behalf of, ESTATE BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, OF SUSANA ALCALA, DECEASED, Plaintiff: Page 20 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *56

CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD SHLIGER, 17-800, SHIRLEY SIMS, 17-8782, JAMES ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED STODDARD, 17-800; 18-14746, on behalf of ESTATE BANK, NJ; NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD OF SHARON STODDARD, DECEASED, LYNN ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, TRAVIS, 17-800, DEBRA VANPAGE, 17-9722, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, DEBORAH WYATT, 17-800, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, [*57] AL; MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For DEL BAUM, 17-11054, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For RISA BOND-RAST, 17-9670, SHARON PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL MARCHESE, 17-9678, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PARKER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & WAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY; ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAVID T. SIROTKIN, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, YORK, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD [*59] LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For DIANA BEDROSIAN, 17-7653, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For DAWNCINA BURNELL, 17-8546, ABBIE OLIVER, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED 17-9995, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL BANK, NJ; JOHN RANDOLPH DAVIS, LEAD PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, ATTORNEY, SLACK & DAVIS LLP, AUSTIN, TX; RED BANK, NJ; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICIA LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. pETERSON LLC; ST. LOUIS, MO. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For DARLENE BERDUE, 17-800, DELLAJEAN COMBS, 17-800, CARMEN DE LA CORDAD DIAZ (PR), 17-8692, DIANA DIVINE, 17-800, JUDY For EVELYN FLEMING, 17-8613, PATRICIA GUYON, DULANEY, 17-800, BRYAN FRIEND, 17-800, on 17-9984, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, behalf [*58] of ESTATE OF DARLENE FRIEND, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; EDWARD GREGORY, 17-11106, on behalf of ESTATE CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, OF VICKI GREGORY, DECEASED, GREGORY PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA JOHNER, 17-800, on behalf of ESTATE OF DIANE LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, JOHNER, DECEASED, KATHLEEN KELLY, 17-800, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONICA KENT, 17-800, THERESA MCDOWELL, 17- ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. 10065, on behalf of ESTATE OF AUDREY BLOUNT, LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD DECEASED, MARY JO MILLS, 17-11155, JULIA ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & MOORE, 17-10900, NAOMI MORALES, 17-800, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. DONNA PETERSON, 17-800; 18-14588, on behalf of ESTATE OF SYLVIA PAIGE, DECEASED, DAYNA Page 21 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *59

For DEBRA M. HAYNES, 17-11158, Plaintiff: SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, MO. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED [*60] BANK, NJ; NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, For DAMON ROSE, 17-7882, on behalf of ESTATE OF BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS BRENDA ROSE, DECEASED, HAROLD ANGELES, CA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD STRASSBERG, 17-7880, on behalf of ESTATE OF ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN DOROTHY STRASSBERG, DECEASED, Plaintiffs: RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JOHN WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON RANDOLPH DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, SLACK & O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. DAVIS LLP, AUSTIN, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE For LEE HELLER, 17-9436, on behalf of ESTATE OF LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON SANDRA HELLER, DECEASED, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; CHRISTOPHER O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, [*62] MO. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DENA RACHEL YOUNG, For GEORGIANA RUSSO, 17-9055, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. SCOTT S BERGER, JR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ROSS MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller FELLER CASEY, LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA; MARK Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; CHRISTOPHER ALAN HOFFMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS FELLER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & CASEY LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA; PATRICIA LEIGH ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For SAMEKA WHEELER, 17-8172, Plaintiff: For LISA HILL, 17-11020, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL S. WERNER, GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, Delise & Hall LEAD ATTORNEY, PARKER WAICHMAN LLP, PORT (Covington), Covington, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, WASHINGTON, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, [*61] AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For SHERITA ANTOINE, 17-10503, on behalf of For CHARLENE MONTGOMERY, 17-10187, CHARLES BEVERLY ANTOINE, APRIL HARRIS, 17-11205, on RIOS, 17-10193, on behalf of ESTATE OF DEBRA behalf of LINDAY CLAY, ANNETTE HARRISON, 17- RIOS, DECEASED, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER 8337, AMBER LUCAS, 17-8343, LAURA HOMEYER, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & 17-8338, HEATHER MCCANN-MUELLER, 17-8344, ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, ERIKA MOORE, 17-8345, DEBORAH OWENS, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE 8347, PAMELA PALUMBO, 17-8348, TAMI PHILLIPS, LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON 17-8349, HELENE POLLY, 17-8350, Plaintiffs: [*63] O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STUART CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DEREK H. GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN; POTTS, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE POTTS LAW FIRM, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER Page 22 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *63

LLP, HOUSTON, TX; David M. Zevan, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DEREK H. ATTORNEY, THE ZEVAN AND DAVIDSON LAW FIRM, POTTS, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE POTTS LAW FIRM, St. Louis, MO; JOSEPH D. MCMULLEN, LEAD LLP, HOUSTON, TX; David M. Zevan, LEAD ATTORNEY, JACOBS O'HARA MCMULLEN, ATTORNEY, THE ZEVAN AND DAVIDSON LAW FIRM, HOUSTON, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD St. Louis, MO; JOSEPH D. MCMULLEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; Patrick J. O'Hara, ATTORNEY, JACOBS O'HARA MCMULLEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, JACOBS AND OHARA PC, HOUSTON, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Houston, TX; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; Patrick J. O'Hara, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & LEAD ATTORNEY, [*65] JACOBS AND OHARA PC, PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. Houston, TX; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. For JAMES R BEDFORD, 17-791, PATRICIA COLLINS, 17-791, KERIJANE CASTRO, 17-791, VICTOR DELGADO, 17-791, SOLMAZ FAHIMI, 17-791, For HOLLIE TURNER, 17-1035, MARGIE F TURNER, JOHNNIE HARGROVE, 17-791, RUBINA HUSSAIN, 17-1035, RENEE BERG, 17-1291, Plaintiffs: 17-791, LORINE KENNEDY, 17-791, KENNEDY CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, KOCH, 17-791, MARY MCQUILLAN, 17-790, CAROLE MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; NORMANDIN, 17-8346, JAMES O'BRIEN, 17-791, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LILING PAN, 17-791, VAN PAULSON, 17-791, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ARNEST M PIPER, 17-791, MICHAEL RENNA, 17-791, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DEREK H. POTTS, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE POTTS For BERTRAND FISHER, 17-1050, SYLVIA FISHER, LAW FIRM, LLP, HOUSTON, TX; David M. Zevan, 17-1050, MARIE LAFONTANT, 17-1050, Plaintiffs: LEAD ATTORNEY, THE ZEVAN AND DAVIDSON LAW CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD FIRM, St. Louis, MO; JOSEPH D. MCMULLEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, JACOBS O'HARA MCMULLEN, BANK, NJ; JONATHAN MICHAEL SEDGH, LEAD HOUSTON, TX; PATRICIA [*64] LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, WEITZ & LUXENBERG PC, NEW YORK, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; Patrick J. O'Hara, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, JACOBS AND OHARA PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. Houston, TX.

For RENEE ANDERSON, 17-8832, MICHAEL BURNS, For MICHAEL RENNA, 17-791, CARRIE SIMMONS, 17-8530, on behalf of Debora Winsor, ROSIE 17-791, ANNIE RUTH TAYLOR, 17-10067, LEILANI BLISSETT, 17-9619, TERRI CAPPELLO, 17-8554, TORIBIO, 17-791, DONNA URICK, 17-791, Plaintiffs: BLANCA DAVIS, 17-8595, WILHEMIA HILL, 17-9736, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, BANK, NJ; DEREK H. POTTS, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE PC, RED BANK, NJ; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD POTTS LAW FIRM, LLP, HOUSTON, TX; David M. ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN Zevan, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE ZEVAN AND PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICIA DAVIDSON LAW FIRM, St. Louis, MO; JOSEPH D. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, MCMULLEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, JACOBS O'HARA AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD MCMULLEN, HOUSTON, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH ATTORNEY, [*66] ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, Patrick J. O'Hara, LEAD ATTORNEY, JACOBS AND LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & OHARA PC, Houston, TX. pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For FRANCES SAVAGE, 17-8352, SHEILA SIMPSON, For RONALD ARMSTEAD, 17-793, GLADYS 17-8353, CANDICE SMITH, 17-791; 17-8354, NANCY BAZEMORE, 17-10180, MARY BUSBY, 17-793, WAARDENBURG, 17-8355, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MACKENZIE CHASE, 17-10883, on behalf of LEEANA MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, Page 23 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *66

WOODS, DELAIDE COMEAUX, 17-10502, on behalf of For MICHELLE HAYDEN, 17-7932, Plaintiff: CARMEN SUSAN COMEAUX, JENNIFER D'ORSI, 17-793, SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY DONNA DODSON 17-9810, BEATRIZ FRAUSTO, 17- RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER 793, CHRISTOPHER HAYES, 17-793, MARTHA MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, HIGDON, 17-793, SARAH JOHNSON, 17-793, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA DEBORAH JENSEN, 17-9811, KELLEY KILTY, 17-cv- LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, 09814, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, [*68] ST. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD For TAMMY HECKMAN, 17-9061, Plaintiff: BRITTANY ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For EVELYN DIOVANNI 17-8715, LAURA ELZIE 17- PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, 8600, DEBORAH HECKMAN, 17-9061, Plaintiffs: PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; Michael J. BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, For JUANITA HERNANDEZ, 17-10235, Plaintiff: AL; STEPHANIE LYNN [*67] RADOS, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STEVEN For FRANK FIORE, 17-1094, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA; WILLIAM WYLIE PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; LEE B. BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON BALEFSKY, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & SPECTER, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. PHILADELPHIA, PA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; PRISCILLA E. For BETTY HYCHE, 17-1118, LINDA WESEMAN, 17- JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & SPECTER PC, 1119, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PHILADELPHIA, PA. PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL For CONSTANCE GALLOWAY, 17-1095, EDWARD JOHN SOBIERAY, LEAD ATTORNEY, STEWART & GALLOWAY, 17-1095, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER STEWART, CARMEL, IN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*69] MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; GREGORY L. LAKER, JONATHAN ANDREW KNOLL, For DEBORAH BROUGHTON, 17-1121, NANCY LEAD ATTORNEYS, COHEN & MALAD LLP, BURGESS, 17-1125, VICKI DAVISTON, 17-1131, INDIANAPOLIS, IN; Jeff S Gibson, TaKeena M VICKI FOSTER, 17-1134, TERESA FRANKLIN, 17- Thompson, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Cohen & Malad LLP, 1135, SUZANNE KWAS, 17-1137, EILEEN Indianapolis, IN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD McDERMITT-WEBER, 17-1138, ELIZABETH ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. WILLIAMS, 17-1150, GEORGE VELARDO, 17-1154, MARIA VELARDO, 17-1154, ANNE GILES, 17-1158, Page 24 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *69

DAREN GILES, 17-1158, CONNIE HILDABRAND, 17- For JOSEPH WEBER, 17-1178, SHARON LYNN 1159, SAMANTHA COLON, 17-1160, VALERIE HILL, WEBER, 17-1178, JENNIFER BROWN, 17-1168 17-1136, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL (), on behalf of ESTATE OF KATHERINE PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, DUNN, HEATHER COX, 17-1168, BRIGETTE DUNN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MEKEL 17-1168, HAL DUNN, 17-1168, Plaintiffs: SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE DUGAN CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LAW FIRM APLC, NEW ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, BANK, NJ; HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD AL. ATTORNEY, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For ARLENE F EDWARDS, 17-1129, CHRIS L EDWARDS, 17-1129, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER For WALTER [*71] J. BAHNSEN, JR., 17-1254, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, Plaintiff: CHAD M. TUSCHMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; WILLIAMS DECLARK TUSCHMAN CO., LPA, GREGORY L. LAKER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN & TOLEDO, OH; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN; JEFFREY STEVEN PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PATRICIA LEIGH PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For MARSHA STORY-SMITH, 17-1152, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For SANDRA L. HUGGINS, 17-1269, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. BANK, NJ; KRISTIE MARIE HIGHTOWER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For GRACE WATKINS, 17-1155, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL [*70] PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED For DAVID FOSTER, SR., 17-1365; 17-7671, Plaintiff: BANK, NJ; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MONTGOMERY, AL. BANK, NJ; CRAIG M. SILVERMAN, CRAIG M. SILVERMAN, Sullivan Papain Block McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo, PC, Sullivan Papain Block McGrath & For LOUIS COLEMAN, 17-1156, ANGELA CUTRER, Cannavo, PC, New York, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH 17-1157, WILLIE SMITH, 17-1157, Plaintiffs: Alton O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. Jerold Hall, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, Delise & Hall (Covington), Covington, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For JEANIE FOSTER, 17-1365, RUTH EDWINA PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA EWING, 17-1366, 17-7673, DEBORAH KURSCH, 17- LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, 1363, 17-7676, JOHNNY SLAMPA, 17-1363, KARI AL. SLAMPA, 17-1363, DAVID HAGSTROM, 17-1364; 17- 7669, KAREN POPP, 17-1384, BARBARA WOLF- GORDON, 17-1403, ELIZABETH GILL, 17-1382, RITA For SHEILA BOBO, 17-1161, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER HINKEL, 17-1383, ELLA V. HEID, 17-1599, DEBORAH MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, A. MILLER, 17-1602, JAMES M. NAPIER, 17-1604 PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; D. Todd (Maryland), [*72] LINDA L. NAPIER, 17-1604, Plaintiffs: Mathews, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI AND JULIAN, P.C., CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Edwardsville, IL; DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, BANK, NJ; CRAIG M. SILVERMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Sullivan Papain Block McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. PC, Sullivan Papain Block McGrath & Cannavo, PC, Page 25 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *72

New York, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD behalf of LORI O'HARA, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, For JAMES BRUCE, 17-1367, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & AL; Philip G Clarke, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, Philip G PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. Clarke III Law Office, Charleston, SC.

For EFREN CAPULONG, 17-1480, Plaintiff: For JEFFREY RUPERT, 17-1362, ROSA L RUPURT, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 17-1362, Plaintiffs: BRIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, CELLINO & BARNES PC, BUFFALO, NY; BANK, [*74] NJ; GREGORY L. LAKER, JEFFREY CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COHEN & ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN; PATRICIA LEIGH BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For JOHN DUSENBERY, 17-1484, SANDRA K. For VENUS SPENCER, 17-1390, Plaintiff: DUSENBERY, 17-1484, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; Daniel BANK, NJ; JENNIFER A. LENZE, LEAD ATTORNEY, Anthony Rottier, LEAD ATTORNEY, Habush Habush & LENZE MOSS PLC, MANHATTAN BEACH, CA; Rottier S.C., Madison, WI; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. MONTGOMERY, AL.

For BRADY ALFRED, 17-1485, EDDIE ALFRED, SR., For JACQUELINE GESLICKI, 17-1433, Plaintiff: BRIAN 17-1485, EDDIE ALFRED, JR., 17-1485, KIMBERLY JAMES HOLMES, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*73] HURLEY GIPSON, 17-1486, DAVID HARTWELL, 17-1487, MCKENNA & MERTZ, CHICAGO, IL; CHRISTOPHER CHARLES HARRIS, 17-1502, CHERYL LANDRY, 17- MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, 1504, on behalf of Mary Gafford, Plaintiffs: Betsy J. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA Barnes, LEAD ATTORNEY, Morris Bart, LLC (New LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, Orleans), New Orleans, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL AL. PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA For TRACY MARROW, 17-9176, Plaintiff: LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD AL; RICHARD LEE ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MORRIS BART & ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA. BANK, NJ; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN For DENEE DIAMONDS, 17-1503, CAROLYN ENGLE, PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICIA 17-1583, Plaintiffs: Betsy J. Barnes, Morris Bart, III, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Morris Bart, LLC (New Orleans), AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, New Orleans, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD PLACITELLA [*75] & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD LEE ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORRIS BART & ASSOCIATES, NEW For HELEN MCGOWENS, 17-793, KATHLEEN ORLEANS, LA. O'CONNOR, 17-cv-09816, JAMIE O'HARA, 17-793, on Page 26 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *75

For LISA F. HOLMES, 17-1506, Plaintiff: Arthur Mahony LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, Murray, LEAD ATTORNEY, Murray Law Firm, New WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Orleans, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; VICTOR H. LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PRIBANIC, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRIBANIC & PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PRIBANIC, WHITE OAK, PA. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For ANGELIQUE SIMPSON, 17-cv-1546, Plaintiff: For DONALD S. WILLIAMS, 17-1507, JANET DIANNE CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD WILLIAMS, 17-1507, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BANK, NJ; CHRISTOPHER V. TISI, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JOHN LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL, RAYMOND BEVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARNES LAW RAFFERTY [*77] & PROCTOR PA, PANSACOLA, FL; GROUP LLC, MARIETTA, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH James Francis Green, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. & GEREL, LLP, Alexandria, VA; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; Nathan M. Peak, LEAD For M.D. DAVID WALLACE, 17-1509, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, LLP, Landover, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD MD; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MONTGOMERY, AL. BANK, NJ; Daniel Anthony Rottier, LEAD ATTORNEY, Habush Habush & Rottier S.C., Madison, WI; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, For DIANNA C KENT, 17-1547, DOUGLAS KENT, 17- AL. 1547, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MELISSA For OSCAR THOMAS BENAVIDES, 17-1533, NORA S HEDRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEDRICK LAW FIRM, SMITH, 17-1769, RODNEY SMITH, 17-1769, Plaintiffs: OKLAHOMA CITY, OK; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME [*76] BURCH GARRARD For ESTATE OF DEBORAH VERDALE THOMPSON, & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, 17-1564, EDWARD R. EMERSON, 17-1795, TERRI A. LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. YACENECH-EMERSON, 17-1795, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED For BRENDA WILDER, 17-1543 AND 17-9603, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD NEFATINIA WILDER, 17-1543 AND 17-9603, TARVISH ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; YONATHAN WILDER, 17-1543 AND 17-9603, ELIZABETH BROWN, AMSELEM, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTROSE LAW LLP, 17-1544 AND 17-9591, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER DURHAM, NC. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & For TANYA JARRETT, 17-1575, Plaintiff: GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAE YEOL LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD LLP, NEW YORK, NY; For LINDA NARD, 17-1545 AND 17-7916, MARK PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, NARD, 17-1545 AND 17-7916, Plaintiffs: MONTGOMERY, AL. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERNEST J. PRIBANIC, LEAD ATTORNEY, For GERALD V. HEATH, 17-1571, ROSLYN PRIBANIC & PRIBANIC LLC, WHITE OAK, PA; James ALEXANDER, [*78] 17-1576, Plaintiffs: Francis Green, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD GEREL, LLP, Alexandria, VA; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Page 27 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *78

BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For CHRISTINE FARQUHARSON, 17-1650, SHEILA ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; WARREN T PAYNE, 17-1654, KELLY HAYES, 17-1660, Plaintiffs: BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For ORLANDO JIMINEZ, 17-1582, on behalf of Estate ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. of Susan Jiminez, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA For LESLIE BREAUX, 17-1681, D'JUANA CHARLES, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, 17-1681, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL AL; TERENCE J. SWEENEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CHATHAM, NJ. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; LINDSEY A. CHEEK, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE CHEEK LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, For BETTY MOORE, 17-1609, PRESTON MOORE, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. 1609, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC D. For BARBARA SMITH, 17-1711 (Louisiana), Plaintiff: PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & Alton Jerold Hall, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, [*80] Delise & PEARSON, IRVING, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, Hall (Covington), Covington, LA; Bobby J. Delise, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, Delise & Hall (New Orleans), New Orleans, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, For RAECHELLE S VIX, 17-1621, Plaintiff: PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC R. NOWAK, LEAD ATTORNEY, HARRELL & NOWAK LLC, NEW ORLEANS, LA; For JACQUELINE GRAY, 17-1770, 17-9879 AND 18- PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, 2839, Plaintiff: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL; Patrick Lindsey Williams, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN ATTORNEY, P. Lindsey Williams, Attorney at Law, New PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; Orleans, LA; Shirin E. Harrell, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Harrell & Nowak, LLC, New Orleans, [*79] LA. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & For YOLANDA CRISOSTOMO, 17-1633, LENORE ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, KOEHLER, 17-1666, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PARKER WAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For IAN KIRK SMAAGAARD, 17-1144, KIM MONTGOMERY, AL. SMAAGAARD, 17-1144, CHARLES SALYER, 17-1143, YONA SALYER, 17-1143, SANDRA POTTS, 17-1142, MARGARET MULE', 17-1141, SALVADORE MULE', For CYNTHIA PEREZ, 17-1643, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. 17-1141, BRENDA MORRIS, 17-1140, Plaintiffs: MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BANK, NJ; MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA ATTORNEY, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM APLC, NEW LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD AL. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. Page 28 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *80

For SHARON BALL, 17-1783, [*81] Plaintiff: NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD MAUNDRELL BARBIERE & POWERS, MASON, OH; ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BANK, NJ; KEVIN M. FITZGERALD, LEAD COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATTORNEY, FITZGERALD LAW GROUP, PORTLAND, MONTGOMERY, AL; TODD MATTHEW POWERS, ME; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO MONTGOMERY, AL. USDC-NJ BAR, MASON, OH; Todd M. Powers, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Schroeder, Maundrell, Barbiere & Powers, Mason, For LINDA A BATMAN, 17-1784, Plaintiff: OH. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For MELISSA MOORE, 17-1820, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PAUL, MN. BANK, NJ; KATHERINE L. BARBIERE, MEGAN AHRENS SULLIVAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SCHROEDER For BENJAMIN BROCK, 17-1820, OZZIE BROWN, 17- MAUNDRELL BARBIERE & POWERS, [*83] MASON, 1820, LUCILLE BURKS, 17-1820, DEBORAH OH; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CRENSHAW, 17-1820, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MONTGOMERY, AL; TODD MATTHEW POWERS, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MAGUA LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO BIANCA BENSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATLANTA, GA; USDC-NJ BAR, MASON, OH; Todd M. Powers, LEAD PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS F. CUFFIE, LEAD BAR, Schroeder, Maundrell, Barbiere & Powers, Mason, ATTORNEY, THE CUFFIE LAW FIRM, ATLANTA, GA. OH.

For WILLIAM DUKES, 17-1820, BENJAMIN For SHERYL SCHMEAR, 17-cv-09817, Plaintiff: EDWARDS, 17-1820, CHERYL FITCH, 17-1820; 18- CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 16112, ZACHARIAH FITCH, 17-1820; 18-16112, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED JOSEPH GUTHRIE, 17-1820, JOENATHAN HARRIS, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD 17-1820;18-14687, WANDA HOLDEN, 17-1820, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LEONARD HYMES, 17-1820, WALTER LLOYD, 17- BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN 1820, NINDA ROSSER, 17-1820, ALLISON SALTER, RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 17-1820, DOROTHY SMITH, 17-1820, TOIYA VINSON, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON 17-1820, [*82] Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ MAGUA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON BIANCA BENSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATLANTA, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For KATHERINE SLOWEY, 17-8712, Plaintiff: MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS F. CUFFIE, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSERL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED NJ BAR, ATLANTA, GA. BANK, NJ; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & For DR. HUGH MOORE, 17-1820, Plaintiff: MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICIA LEIGH CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; BANK, NJ; KATHERINE L. BARBIERE, MEGAN STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, AHRENS SULLIVAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO [*84] USDC-NJ BAR, Page 29 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *84

ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD AL. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, For MIRA BLAIR, 17-1872, DIANA DAVIS-BLAIR, 17- ST. LOUIS, MO. 1872, LARRY LOSE, 17-2023, TAMARA PACE, 17- 2103, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For LOVEJOY, 17-1822, Plaintiff: PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, Delise & Hall BANK, NJ PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD (Covington), Covington, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For TERRY HAHN, 17-1893, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER BAR, CELLINO & BARNES, BUFFALO, NY. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC D. For LISA JEFFERSON HUNTER, 17-1850, Plaintiff: PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, PEARSON, IRVING, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For LAWRENCE PARMENTIER, 17-1935, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Plaintiff: [*86] CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, For MICHELLE UPCHURCH, 17-1851, LINDA ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. MUHLBACH, 17-1970, JOHN SCAGLIONE, 17-1970, LOUIS, MO. ROBERT , 17-1971, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For JAMES MITCHELL, 17-2005, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN BANK, NJ; GREGORY L. LAKER, JEFFREY STEVEN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON GIBSON, JONATHAN ANDREW KNOLL, LEAD O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For RHONDA [*85] E RUDNICK, 17-1853, Plaintiff: MONTGOMERY, AL. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED For ALVINA JACKSON, 17-2009, Plaintiff: BANK, NJ; MARK W. HAFELI, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD HAFELI STARAN & CHRIST PC, SYLVAN LAKE, MI; ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BANK, NJ; MATTHEW RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For MELISSA DEAN, 17-1858, KYLE COOPER, 17- ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. 1859 AND 17-9605, TAMMY EDWARDS, 17-2066, TAMMY EDWARDS, 17-2066, Plaintiffs: For THE ESTATE OF JUDITH SWAN, 17-2008, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Plaintiff: ADRIAN O. VEGA, KEDAR BHASKER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, WILL FERGUSON & ASSOCIATES, BANK, NJ; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ALBUQUERQUE, NM; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA Page 30 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *86

PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA BAR, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For VICTORIA RUSSO, 17-2206, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, For SONYA BROOKS, 17-2081, Plaintiff: PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; RED [*87] BANK, NJ; JENNIFER A. LENZE, LEAD SHERRI L. PLOTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, LENZE MOSS PLC, MANHATTAN RHEINGOLD, GIUFFRA, RUFFO & PLOTKIN, LLP, BEACH, CA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD NEW YORK, NY. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For STANLEY JONES, 17-2211, BRIAN ABRAHAM, For DEBRA J. GERLACH, JOYCE W. LUTES, 17-2088, 17-2255, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL JAMES WIMERT, 17-2089, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; CRAIG M. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ SILVERMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, Sullivan Papain Block BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo, PC, Sullivan Papain ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, Block McGrath & Cannavo, PC, New York, NY; DALLAS, TX. PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For KAYCE ANN CHAPMAN BOGGS, 17-2219, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, For JULIE BALDRIDGE, 17-2174, STEVE PARTON, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; 17-2174, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*89] ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL; GRAHAM LEE NEWMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BAR, CHAPPELL SMITH & ARDEN, COLUMBIA, SC. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For JAY COBB, 17-2349, LINDA TREADWELL, 16- For DIANNA KIHN, 17-2188, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER 9495, WARREN TREADWELL, 16-9495, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT AL; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. For CARLA DONOHUE, 17-2399, Plaintiff: CARMEN For WENDY MARIE LEPAGE, 17-2189, KIMBERLY SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL SUE MAXWELL, 17-2184, PATRICIA PAYSEUR, 17- NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE 2190, JANIE LOZANO, 17-2191, CHARITA GARBO LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL BRAZZEL, 17-2192, JULIA BAILEY, [*88] 17-2258, PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, NICOLE FOSTER, 17-2259, SIOBAINNE DANIEL, 17- RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD 2260, ANGELA BERGHAUS, 17-2262, KELLY KIDD, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 17-2263, LESLIE NELSON, 17-2264, VICTORIA BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; Richard J. Zabbo, LEAD READE, 17-2265, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TOU SDC-NJ PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, BAR, Boston, MA. RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For SUSAN AUSTIN, 17-2400, Plaintiff: BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD Page 31 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *89

CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ERIC D. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT KELLY E. REARDON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, IRVING, TX. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE REARDON LAW FIRM PC, NEW LONDON, CT. For JAMES GARY ALBERTINE, JR., 17-2389, BRENT ALBERTINE, 17-2389, JAMES GARY ALBERTINE, III, For MARY YOUNG, 17-2403 (Georgia), Plaintiff: C. 17-2389, TAYLOR ALBERTINE CLINE, 17-2389, DORIAN BRITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*90] COUNSEL TIMOTHY SYMONS, 17-2389, Plaintiffs: NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KARSMAN CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA MCKENZIE & HART, SAVANNAH, GA; LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA Charles Marshall Thomas, Gina Marie Palermo, LOGAN LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT SCHONEKAS ALBERTINE, Stephen Micheal Huber, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, New Orleans, LA. For TERESA FORD, 17-2370, MICHELLE PERKINS, 17-2371, WILLIAM PERKINS, 17-2371, Plaintiffs: For NIKI JO, 17-2390, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; CHRISTOPHER USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, For MELANIE FINLEY, 17-2391, Plaintiff: LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; For KATHLEEN CORGLIANO, 17-2383, Plaintiff: JORDAN KOEL MERSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, Merson BRIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL Law, [*92] PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BUFFALO, NY; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA For RICHARD WARNOCK, 17-2435, Plaintiff: LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; For PILAR HESTRESS, 17-2384, Plaintiff: NICOLE DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAUREN BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DANBURY, CT. For TONYA BISCHOFF, 17-2455, Plaintiff: For RONALD HERRINGTON, 17-2386, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA BRANDI R. HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; LEXINGTON, MS; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL YONATHAN AMSELEM, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATTORNEYS, [*91] COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO DURHAM, NC. USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; Timothy L. Williams, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For ALLEN ABERNETHY 17-10577 on behalf of ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Bend, OR. ESTATE OF NANCY ABERNETHY, DECEASED, LORAINE ALLEN, 17-2394, REBECCA ALTRINGER, For KARA J KENT, 17-2376, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER 17-2394, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL Page 32 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *92

PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. ONDER, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO For DAWN BARDWELL, 17-8829, Plaintiff: USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO Michael J. Quillin, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Louis, MO. BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. For ROBYN ANDERSON, 17-8792, TRACEY LOUIS, MO; JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, BRITTANY ANDERSON, 17-8791, GEORGIA BROWN, 17-9191, SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEYS; Michael J. SHERRY BROWN, 17-2394, ESTATE OF KAREN Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, ARNOLD, DECEASED, LANI BURDICK, 17-2394, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD JA'NEL BURRELL, 17-9825, KRISTINE COOPER, 17- ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN 8863, MARILYN DAVIS, 17-2394, [*93] JEFFREY RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON DUNCAN, 17-10483, on behalf of ESTATE OF LINDA O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM DUNCAN, DECEASED, EVELYN DEJESUS, 17-2394, WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON LUCILLE DESSLER, 17-9173, MICHELLE DUNCAN, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. 17-9175, JENNIFER FLEENOR, 17-9177, LAUREN GRIJALVA, 17-2394, BARBARA HINTON, 17-2394, For SUE BOND, 17-8669, STEPHANIE ANN BROWN, VIRGINIA JONES, 17-11157, TRENESSA JAMES, 17- 17-2394, on behalf of ESTATE OF KAREN ARNOLD, 9045, BILLIE JEAN KERPASH, 17-2394, JANICE DECEASED, Plaintiffs: on behalf of, ESTATE OF LONG, 17-2394, DIANE LOVEJOY, 17-9170, ELOISE KAREN ARNOLD, DECEASED; CHRISTOPHER MAITLAND, 17-2394, LAWRENCE , 17- MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD [*95] ATTORNEY, 2394, NADIA QADEER, 17-11096, SHEILA REVELL, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; 17-9344, PAULINE RIMP, 17-2394, JANET SMITH, 17- JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER 2394, ELIZABETH A. SWETISH, 17-8716, DELLA SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; ZANE, 17-2394, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON For REGINA BUTLER, 17-8547, TERESA CRIDER, 17- O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. 8671, THERESA K. CUSHING, 17-8584, CHERYL HAROLD-GRAHAM, 17-8626, CHANEL HOROWITZ, 17-10098, on behalf of LINDA SHAPIRO, DECEASED, For EVELYN AUTRY, 17-7986, Plaintiff: JULIE STEWART, 17-9667, Plaintiffs: on behalf of, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LINDA SHAPIRO, DECEASED; CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ATTORNEY, [*94] ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHELLE A. O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; LAUREN PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY WASHINGTON, DC; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MONTGOMERY, AL; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & Page 33 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *95

MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & BANK, NJ; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA BLAIR, [*96] LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. AL.

For NIKKI CHOPIN, 17-2379, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER For TAMMY BRIGMAN, SHARON BROWN, 17-11231, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CHERIE DAVIS, 17-11237, JOAN FENNIGKOH, 17- PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; Charles 11239, CINDY GINN, 17-11243, STEPHANIE Marshall Thomas, Logan S. Albertine, LEAD GREMILLION, 17-11244, ANNE HERMILLER, 17- ATTORNEYS, Huber, Slack, Thomas and Marcelle, 11249, DARRYL KOYM, 17-11252, THOMAS LEE, 17- New Orleans, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD 11296, JENNIFER LYNCH, 17-11256, EXIA MONROE, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-2397, HALIMA SHILLEH, 17-11258, VICKI SHORTT, 17-11297,Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For JACQUELINE RIVERA, 17-2380, Plaintiff: PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC S. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD JOHNSON, TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL; PATRICIA BANK, NJ; DAVID ALLAN CHANDLER, LEAD LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, ATTORNEY, KARST & VON OISTE LLP, NEW YORK, AL. NY; JOSEPH D. MCMULLEN, RYAN NICOLE JACOBS, LEAD ATTORNEYS, HOUSTON, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For BARBARA BUBOLTZ, 17-11234, Plaintiff: MONTGOMERY, AL. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, [*98] PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC S. JOHNSON, TRENT B. For NIKITA LONG, 17-2469, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEYS, SIMMONS HANLY MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CONROY, ALTON, IL; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, AL; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC MONTGOMERY, AL. VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX.

For LINDA CARTER, 17-10011, KAREN GALLIA, 17- For KIM-JUDITH RAMOS, 17-2470, Plaintiff: BRADLEY 10256, CHRISTINE HICKS, 17-9980, CASSANDRA DEAN HONNOLD, LEAD ATTORNEY, Goza & MOORE, 17-10254, LYNNE THOMPSON, 17-2404, Honnold, LLC, Overland Park, KS; CHRISTOPHER Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, MONTGOMERY, [*97] AL. EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For ROBIN A KANE, 17-2494, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For KRISTY ALLEN, 17-10064, BARBARA BRYANT, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC 17-10204, TERESA BROWN, 17-2404, CHRISTINE DANIEL ROSLANSKY, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE RUTH CORBETT, 17-9992, DONNA DORSEY, 17-10219, LAW TEAM, ST. PAUL, MN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, NANCY EHRIG, 17-10087, BETTY GALBREATH, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. 10258, MARCIA GOINS, 17-10207, MABEL MOORE, 17-2404, DOREEN NICASTRO, 17-10074, MICHELLE For LISA THOMPSON, 17-2495, MARC WOLFF, 17- SCHUSTER, 17-10210, DORIS STOGNER, 17-9998, 2496, DORIAN DANIEL, 17-2498, Plaintiffs: LISA SURRENCY, 17-10053, LARRY ADAMS, 17- CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 10455, on behalf of, PATRICIA ADAMS, SHAWNA Page 34 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *98

CUFF, 17-10056, JILL EARP, 17-10037, LADONNA For BEVERLY DENNY, 17-8207, LINDA HESELTON, GARLAND, 17-10089, PENNY GENTRY, 17-10246, 17-8208, KAREN NEWPORT, 17-8155, CYNTHIA RACHEL HAUCK, 17-10061, DEBRA MADDEN, 17- YARNELL, 17-8202, SARAH BROOKS, 17-8143, 9983, CERMORIA MILLER, 17-10015, DONNA JAYSON CHRISTENSEN, 17-10813, on behalf of, MORTON, 17-10084, DANIEL PARKER, [*99] 17- JODIE STEELE, KRISTAL KNIGHT, 17-8209, GALE 10465, on behalf of, CHARLOTTE PARKER, SUSAN SAYLES, 17-9178, BRENDA STEINBARTH, 17-8156, STOPCHINSKI, 17-10035, ERIKA WILSON, 17-9993, JULIUS STOEHR, 17-9531, on behalf of, JOANNE STEPHANIE FOX, 17-9977, ELISHER IRONS, 17- STOEHR, REBECCA WALL, 17-8631, BETTY WILLIS, 10251, KATHLEEN LEDBETTER, 17-9972, CONNIE 17-8325, JOAN DOUGLAS, 17-8520, CYNTHIA LEMELLE, 17-10203, DONNA RUSH, 17-10077, ANN ACKERMAN, 17-8303, CAROLYN LESTER, 17-8214, SMITH, 17-10068, NEACOLE BROWN, 17-9968, LORRAINE TURK, 17-8216; 17-8216, DESIREE JAMES KEVIN RUSSEL, 17-9963, BRANDI DIXON, 17- YOUNG, 17-8422, CHERYL PIMENTEL, 17-8403, 9986, TRINA HADLEY, 17-10152, SHERRIE SHEILA BUNCH, 17-8405, LAURA GAMBLE, 17-8407, KAKOURIS, 17-10419, ELIZABETH LAWLOR, 17- DONNA KALMAN, 17-8417, PAMELA KNAPP, 17- 10412, DORIS OLDHAM, 17-9988, SUSAN PARRISH, 8519, CATHY SWEENEY, 17-8431, ELEANOR 17-10017, CAROLANNE SANTOS, 17-2404, MARIA CARRINGTON, 17-9523, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER WALLACE, 17-10057, LARRY WRIGHT, 17-10450, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA & [*101] ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, IL. MONTGOMERY, AL; Patrick R Dowd, Randall S. Crompton, LEAD ATTORNEYS, HOLLAND LAW FIRM LLC, St. Louis, MO. For LYNNE THOMPSON, 17-2404, EXIA MONROE, 17-2397, HALIMA SHILLEH, 17-11258, VICKI SHORTT, 17-11297, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER For CLAUDIA GREGORY, 17-10814, BRUCE MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, KUMFER, 17-2398, BRADLEY ASCHINGER, 17-10941, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC S. on behalf of, ESTATE OF MARY ASCHINGER, JOHNSON, TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEYS, DEANNA SMITH, 17-2398, JANICE BAKER, 17-2398, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL; PATRICIA KIMBERLY STEIN, 17-10945, on behalf of, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, TAUBIG, DECEASED, SHEILA BUNCH, 17-8405, AL. LAURA GAMBLE, 17-8407, DONNA KALMAN, 17- 8417, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For JOSEPH RAY, 17-10459, LISA HUBBARD, 17- PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC D. 2507, ROBIN LOWE, 17-8204, Plaintiffs: HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEY; PATRICIA LEIGH CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Patrick R Dowd, Randall S. Crompton, LEAD BANK, NJ; DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEYS, HOLLAND LAW FIRM LLC, St. Louis, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, MO. EDWARDSVILLE, [*100] IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For STEVE GREGORY, 17-10814, CLYDE LAGRONE, 17-10828, on behalf of, MARTHA LAGRONE, For VLADISLAV BLACK, 17-10591, on behalf of, INNA DECEASED, MICHAEL PAUL, 17-9397, on behalf of, BLACK, DECEASED, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER LOLA PAUL, DECEASED, DON BIGELOW, 17-2398, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LULA USSERY, 17-9548, REBECCA WALL, Plaintiffs: PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICK CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD R DOWD, CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, ERIC ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED D. HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEYS, SIMMONS HANLY BANK, NJ; ERIC D. HOLLAND, ERIC D. HOLLAND, CONROY, ALTON, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEYS, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; Randall S. ALTON, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Crompton, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLAND LAW FIRM ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; [*102] Patrick R LLC, St. Louis, MO. Dowd, Randall S. Crompton, LEAD ATTORNEYS, HOLLAND LAW FIRM LLC, St. Louis, MO. Page 35 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *102

MO. For DONNA SUMMERLIN, 17-2511; 17-8171, TIMMY SUMMERLIN, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For ELIZABETH R MOREL, 17-2532, HENRY MOREL, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, 17-2532, DIANNE E DICKEL, 17-2391, JEFFREY PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. DICKEL, 17-2381, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL GARRARD, III, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; James Francis Green, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, LLP, Alexandria, DANIEL ROSLANSKY, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE RUTH VA. LAW TEAM, ST. PAUL, MN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For LEENA BARSHAY, 17-2509 AND 17-10334, GLENDA FERRELL, 17-9599, Plaintiffs: For DEBORAH SMITH, 17-2382, Individually and as, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Administrator of the Estate of Kathalene Williams, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, BANK, NJ; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, PATRICK KELLY LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, ROTH, [*104] PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH WASHINGTON, DC, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. G. MCGRATH, LEAD ATTORNEY, MCGRATH LAW FIRM PA, MOUNT PLEASANT, SC. For JAYSON CHRISTENSEN, 17-10813, on behalf of, JODIE STEELE, KRISTAL KNIGHT, 17-8209, ROBIN For CHERYL HADDIX, 17-2569, JEFFREY HADDIX, LOWE, 17-8204, ROBIN PARKER, 17-8206, PAMELA 17-2569, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD KNAPP, 17-8519, CATHY SWEENEY, 17-8431, ATTORNEY, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, NM; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC D. HOLLAND, CATHERINE BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD THEODORA HEACOX, ERIC D. HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEYS, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For RICHARD WAGGONER, 17-2589, Plaintiff: MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICK R DOWD, Randall S. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Crompton, LEAD ATTORNEYS, [*103] HOLLAND LAW ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED FIRM LLC, St. Louis, MO. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL BANK, NJ; DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY; PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHELLE PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY; PATRICIA LEIGH MONTGOMERY, AL. O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For STANTRA NORMAN, 17-2593, Plaintiff: For THOMAS GRESKE, 17-10764, Plaintiff: DAVID I. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD CATES, LEAD ATTORNEY, CATES MAHONEY LLC, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED SWANSEA, IL. BANK, NJ; Erik M. Tadda, Jeremy Steven Hader, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Tadda Law Firm, Baton Rouge, LA; For TAHNEE JOHNSON, 17-8518, Plaintiff: MICHAEL J. REMONDET, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, ERIC D. JEANSONNE & REMONDET, LAFAYETTE, LA; HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEYS, SIMMONS HANLY PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CONROY, ALTON, IL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA For CYNTHIA JACKSON, 17-2603, CRYSTAL WEST, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, 17-2604, MYRA WEST, 17-2604, LISA MARIE AL; Patrick R Dowd, Randall S. Crompton, LEAD JOHNSON, 17-2605, MELISSA ORTIZ, 17-2606, ATTORNEYS, HOLLAND LAW FIRM LLC, St. Louis, Page 36 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *104

PATRICIA O'CAIN, 17-2607, CHERYL TYREE, 17- Rhinelander, WI; TIMOTHY S. TRECEK, LEAD 2608, Plaintiffs: [*105] CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ATTORNEY, HABUSH HABUSH & ROTTIER SC, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MILWAUKEE, WI. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, For LESLEYANN PHILLIPS, 17-2663, MARY ZIERK, AL; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON 17-2663, Plaintiffs: ASHLEA GAYLE SCHWARZ, BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. RICHARD M. PAUL, III, LEAD ATTORNEYS, PAUL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL For KATHLEEN HAHN, 17-2621, WILLIAM HAHN, 17- PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, 2621, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. AL; Susan Becker, LEAD ATTORNEY, Paul McInnes GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME LLP, Kansas City, MO. BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For CAROL ANDREWS, 17-10070, FELICIA BENSON, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-11015, on behalf of ESTATE OF LOLA BENSON, DECEASED, SHERYL BLANCHETT, 17-9479, REGINA For JANE M FRYE, 17-2645, RICHARD FRYE, 17- BONDWEAVER, 17-2396, LILLIAN BURNS-GARCIA, 2645, DAVID C. KROMM, JR., as Personal 17-9481, CAROL CHIMENTO, [*107] 17-2396, Representative of the Estate of Deborah A. Kromm, 17- SUNITA CHINAPANA, 17-9485, ANNIE JONES, 17- 2648, BONNIE PETRO, 17-2649, KARL PETRO, 17- 2396, LEE COLEMAN, 17-2396, BETHANY 2649, KAREN S. RUSSUM, 17-2650, RALPH CONNOLLY-AMBURGEY, 17-9488, SHARON RUSSUM, 17-2650, DAVID SANDERS, 17-2651, GAIL CRIADO, 17-9476, VICTORIA DAVIDSON, 17-9465, SANDERS, 17-2651, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER PAMELA ESTELLE, 17-2396, VIRGILIO GARCIA, 17- MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, 10592, on behalf of ESTATE OF MERCEDES GARCIA, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; CRAIG M. DECEASED, STANLEY GLOSTER, JR, 17-2396, SILVERMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, Sullivan Papain Block DAWN HOUSE, 17-2396, JOANN IANNIELLO, 17- McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo, PC, Sullivan Papain 9493, TABITHA JOHNSON, 17-2396, DEBRA KYTE, Block McGrath & Cannavo, PC, New York, NY; 17-9496, LISA LITTLEFIELD, 17-2396, REMIJIO PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LONGORIA, JR, 17-10072, on behalf of ESTATE OF MONTGOMERY, AL. ALMA LONGORIA, DECEASED, BOBBY LOWMAN, 17-11092, on behalf of ESTATE OF PAMELA LOWMAN, DECEASED, JERRY MARSHALL, 17- For BOBBY V KARRICK, 17-2653, KIMBERLY A 10476, on behalf of ESTATE OF LACEY MARSHALL, KARRICK, 17-2653, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER DECEASED, JOHN A. MACY, 17-2396, JOYCE MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*106] MCGONIGLE, 17-2396, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MATTHEW PALMER LAMBERT, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. GAINSBURGH BENJAMIN DAVID MEUNIER & ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON WARSHAUER LLC, NEW ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, AL. L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN For DANIEL M LIBECKI, 17-2666, VICTORIA P PAPA, RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON 17-2666, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; Daniel A O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. Rottier, LEAD ATTORNEY, Habush Habush & Rottier SC, Madison, WI; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For BERNADETTE [*108] CARTER-CRUZ, 17-8558, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; Peter M Young, CORNELL CLEMENTS, 17-8532, DOROTHY LEAD ATTORNEY, Habush Habush & Rottier SC, GRIFFITH, 17-8628, ALAN HARRISON, 17-10320, on Page 37 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *108 behalf of ESTATE OF KRYSTAL DERY HARRISON, For KAREN HERNANDEZ, 17-10438, LINDA DECEASED, MANDY MYERS, 17-9979, Plaintiffs: METTLER, 17-10444, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. LOUIS, MO; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; Michael J. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, RADOS, [*110] LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STUART ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN; O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. MO.

For ELSA DIBERNARDO, 17-8699, DOMINIQUE For TERRI KOEHLER, 17-8721, Plaintiff: HAMILTON, 17-9031, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LOUIS, MO; JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ATTORNEY, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON IN; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA [*109] LEIGH STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For CECILIA OGLESBY, 17-8813, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For NITRA HEDRICK, 17-9495, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, LOUIS, MO; JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. ATTORNEY, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, IN; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEIGH [*111] O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ONDER PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STEVEN DAVID SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD For TAMMY PECK, 17-8254, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON Page 38 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *111

O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, KIMBERLY WILSON WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD WILSON LAW PA, RALEIGH, NC; Michael J. Quillin, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE [*113] LYNN ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, LOUIS, MO. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, For MARCIA PHILLIPS, 17-10463, Plaintiff: PA. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, For SANDRA VANNOY, 17-7974, Plaintiff: KIMBERLY ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. WILSON WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, WILSON LAW LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, PA, RALEIGH, NC. ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For JIM MCDOWELL, 17-2697, JUDY M. MCDOWELL, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, 17-2697, JOANNE BUSSINGER, 17-2730, PATRICIA WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ONDER GRELLING, 17-3294, Plaintiffs: BRETT A. EMISON, SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; LEAD ATTORNEY, LANGDON & EMISON LLC, STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEXINGTON, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL GOLDENBERG LAW [*112] PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MN. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, For PAULINE ROBERTS, 17-11093, SANDRA AL. SEMENAS, 17-2396, HAYLEY TENNYSON, 17-10927, DIRK THOMAS, 17-2396, MICHAEL VARVIL, 17-8564, For URSULA JACKSON, 17-2708, Plaintiff: on behalf of, ESTATE OF CONSTANCE VARVIL, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD DECEASED, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BANK, NJ; George R. Irvine, III, Laura C. Strachan, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. LEAD ATTORNEYS, Stone, Granade & Crosby, P.C., ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON Daphne, AL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN For TINA SHERLOCK, 17-2751, SHIRLEY KEARNEY, RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, 17-2865, VERNA ELLIS, 17-2866, Plaintiffs: ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; RAVI KISHAN For REGINALD SMALL, 17-10957, on behalf of, SANGISETTY, LEAD ATTORNEY, SANGISETTY LAW ESTATE OF MAXINE DRIVER, DECEASED, Plaintiff: FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, [*114] LA. STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. For CAROL EIDSON, 17-2753, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED For MYRA THOMPSON, 17-9629, on behalf of, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ESTATE OF VERNA THOMPSON, DECEASED, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. Page 39 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *114

CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED For RANDY BAKER, 17-2760, TAMARA BAKER, 17- BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD 2760, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; J. CHRISTOPHER ELLIOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, For FREIDA ETIENNE, 17-2890, GUY RANDALL, 17- BACHUS & SCHANKER LLC, DENVER, CO; 2890, JAMES RANDALL, 17-2890, LEE RANDALL, 17- PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, 2890, on behalf of, THERESA N. RANDALL, CAROLYN MONTGOMERY, AL. ROBERTS, 17-2890, SYLVIA ROBERTS, 17-2890 (Louisiana), RITA ROQUEMORE, 17-2890, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For YVONNE WADE, 17-2775, JAN FORSBERG, 17- ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED 2780, MARY KNIGHT, 17-2910, FAY GEURIN, 17- BANK, NJ; MICHAEL JOHN SOBIERAY, LEAD 2979, BARBARA A. PARRISH, 17-3117, JILL STUART, ATTORNEY, STEWART & STEWART, CARMEL, IN; 17-3381, JULIA M. LATHROP, 17-3386, KORTETE PATRICIA [*116] LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COOPER, 17-3413, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MONTGOMERY, AL. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, For SANDRA CROWL, 17-2936, AMIE CAVAZOS, 17- AL; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC 2938, BRENDA ANDREWS, 17-2939, VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. GORDON, 17-2940, SUSAN GRAF-SPIEGEL, 17-2942, YVONNE ORE, 17-2984, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For UNZIALINA HUSAIN, 17-2832, ESTATE OF PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHELLE JOYCE ROWLAND, 17-3276, Plaintiffs: BARRY R. A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & EICHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, Eichen Crutchlow Zaslow GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH & McElroy, LLP, EDISON, NJ; CHRISTOPHER O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, For RICK SUTTON, 17-10338, Plaintiff: AL. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, For [*115] DONNIE WALKER, 17-2859, Plaintiff: ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED AL; PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; WILLIAM G. COLVIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, WILLIAM G. COLVIN PLLC, CHATTANOOGA, TN. For FAY STAFFORD, 17-2941, MICHAEL STAFFORD, 17-2941, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For LIN ORA MARIE BELL, 17-2871, Plaintiff: PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; RACHEL BETH MONTGOMERY, AL. ABRAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For JAMES BELL, 17-3040, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For JERRY SUSAN RENN, 17-2856, MARK RINK, 17- PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC D. 3153, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; PEARSON, [*117] IRVING, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH Page 40 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *117

O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. Boston, MA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For KRISTI CLAIR, 17-3078, JODY DICKEN, 17-3079, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. GINA GATCHELL, 17-3081, ADRIANA RAINEY, 17- 3084, SHARYN VAN DERVORT, 17-3085, SHELDA WALLACE, 17-3086, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER For BROOKLIN GRAVES, 17-3215, Plaintiff: MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, BANK, NJ; DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, AL; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY; BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For SANDRA APPLEFIELD, 17-3080, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For PEGGY HUGHES, 17-3267, RAY SCOTT ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED HUGHES, 17-3267, DARLENE KERNAN, 17-3465, BANK, NJ; JOSEPH H. SAUNDERS, LEAD GARY KERNAN, 17-3465, MONICA BELCHER, 17- ATTORNEY, SAUNDERS & WALKER PA, PINELLAS 3452, JAMES JOBE, 17-3474, MEMARIE JOBE, 17- PARK, FL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD 3474, LAWRENCE NUNLEY, 17-3476, SANDRA ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. NUNLEY, 17-3476, DAVID PAULEY, 17-3487, SHERRY PAULEY, [*119] 17-3487, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For JAMIE ENGEL, 17-2998, Plaintiff: CARMEN ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY BANK, NJ; MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, NEW ORLEANS, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; John Daniel Hays, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, Taylor King Law, Springdale, AR; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For RANDALL WILLMORE, 17-3277, JUNE CHAPMAN, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-3362, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MEGHAN For ELTON WELCH, 17-3139, MICHELLE M. TURNER, ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN 17-3182, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., DENA SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; RACHEL YOUNG, MARK ALAN HOFFMAN, SCOTT S PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERGER, JR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Ross [*118] Feller MONTGOMERY, AL. Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA For JILL BURZYCH, 17-3278, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, AL. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MATTHEW RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX; For ESSIE BEARFIELD, 17-3162, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For PAUL ZIMMER, 17-3300, on behalf of, SHARON ZIMMER, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For PAUL FELDMAN, 17-3163, Plaintiff: ANDREW M. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAE YEOL ABRAHAM, LEAD ATTORNEY, ABRAHAM & LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD LLP, ASSOCIATES PC, BOSTON, MA; Andrew E. Oliva, NEW YORK, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, Abraham & Associates, P.C., ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. Page 41 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *119

For BRENDA J. ANDERSON, 17-2943, KIMBERLIE COULSTON, 17-7161, VICKI SUE HATMAKER, 17- For JACQUELYN GRADY, 17-3425, Plaintiff: 2943, DONNA JONES, 17-2943, MARITZA RIVERO, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 17-7909, KATJE SPIER, 17-2943, BARBARA KEZER, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED 17-2943, NORMA KRZYZOSIAK, 17-2943, JONNIE BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH [*120] O'DELL, LEAD SALMON, 17-2943, MARY VINSON, 17-2943, Plaintiffs: ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; Robert T. Naumes, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, The Law Office of Jeffrey S. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Glassman, Boston, MA. BANK, NJ; James P. Holloran, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLORAN AND SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. Louis, MO; For SHAWN C WILLS, 17-3426, Plaintiff: KATIE A. HUBBARD, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD GOLDENBERG HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BANK, NJ; Justin Anthony Browne, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS J. LECH, Janet Jenner and Suggs LLC, , MD; LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER, PC, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. MONTGOMERY, AL. For SUSAN CHANDLER, 17-7622, CHARLES DIAL, For KARON DECKER, 17-3440, MONIQUE CAYE, 17- 17-7054, on behalf of BETTY JO DIAL, DECEASED, 3441, Plaintiffs: ANDREW GEIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARSHA INIGUEZ, 17-7199, HEIDI MEADE, 17-7631, ALLAN BERGER AND ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LOLA TARR, 17-7626, Plaintiffs: BRANDI R. LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BARRETT LAW GROUP PA, LEXINGTON, MS; BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, [*122] COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; James P. Holloran, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLORAN AND SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. For PATRICIA DILLARD, 17-3473, Plaintiff: Louis, MO; KATIE A. HUBBARD, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD GOLDENBERG HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BANK, NJ; DAVID WAYNE STEWART, MICHAEL ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS J. LECH, JOHN SOBIERAY, LEAD ATTORNEYS, STEWART & LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER, PC, SYEWART, CARMEL, IN; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For EDNA KEYS-CHAVIS, 17-7370, TIMOTHY SWIFT, For DENNIS P HLAVSA, 17-3505, Plaintiff: 17-7667, on behalf of STAR SWIFT, DECEASED, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD GLORIA GRAHAM, 17-7186, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BANK, NJ; JORDAN REID WAGNER, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; James P. ATTORNEY, KIBBEY WAGNER PLLC, STUART, FL; Holloran, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLORAN AND PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. Louis, MO; KATIE A. HUBBARD, MONTGOMERY, AL. [*121] LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA For JOE ANN HAYES, 17-3525, Plaintiff: LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD AL; SARAH STERLING STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS; THOMAS J. BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LECH, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS P. PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. CARTMELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. For CAROL LITTLE, 17-7023, CAROL SILVER, 17- 7020, VIOLA SMITH, 17-7021, Plaintiffs: Page 42 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *122

CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 17-7702, VELSA MALDONADO, 17-8279, VICKIE ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED NELSON, 17-7703, WANDA PARKER, 17-7666, BANK, NJ; James P. Holloran, LEAD ATTORNEY, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, HOLLORAN AND SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. Louis, MO; LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, KATHERINE BARRETT RILEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, PC, RED BANK, NJ; James P. Holloran, LEAD DON [*123] BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS; KATIE ATTORNEY, HOLLORAN AND SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. A. HUBBARD, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG Louis, MO; KATIE A. HUBBARD, LEAD ATTORNEY, HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; GOLDENBERG HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS J. LECH, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS J. LECH, ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER, PC, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER, PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. EDWARDSVILLE, IL; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For LINDA WINHELD, 17-7060, CLARA BELL WILLIAMS, 17-2943; 17-7056, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For DOUGLAS SCHULZ, 17-10790, on behalf of MARY ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED SHUMPERT, DECEASED, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH BANK, NJ; James P. Holloran, LEAD ATTORNEY, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; HOLLORAN AND SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. Louis, MO; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC KATIE A. HUBBARD, LEAD ATTORNEY, VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. GOLDENBERG HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD R. BARRETT, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEXINGTON, MS; [*125] For MARIE TAYLOR, 17-10786, on behalf of THOMAS J. LECH, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG REJANE DUCROT, DECEASED, Plaintiff: WARREN T HELLER, PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For ROBERTA KEENE, 17-7254, Plaintiff: CARY LITTLEJOHN, LEAD ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT PA, For MARGARET WILSON, 17-7763 (Kentucky), LEXINGTON, MS; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL NANCY FIOLA, BARBARA LEE KOROTKA, Plaintiffs: PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; James P. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Holloran, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLORAN AND BANK, NJ; James P. Holloran, LEAD ATTORNEY, SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. Louis, MO; KATIE A. HUBBARD, HOLLORAN AND SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. Louis, MO; LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER & KATIE A. HUBBARD, LEAD ATTORNEY, ANTOGNOLI, PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA GOLDENBERG HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD AL; THOMAS J. LECH, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS J. LECH, GOLDENBERG HELLER, [*124] PC, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER, PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. EDWARDSVILLE, IL; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For SHERICA DAVIS, 17-7093, SUSAN FONDREN, 17- 7083, VALERIE ROBINSON, 17-10677, DEMARIAS SOJKA, 17-7080, EMMA JEAN TODD, 17-7091, For BOBBIE WALTON, 17-3532, JOHNNY FULLEM, CAROLYN BANKS, 17-7076, ELLA EDWARDS, 17- 17-3536, RAYNA HARRISON, 17-3665, ESTATE OF 7288, LANIE LAMA, 17-7078, REBECCA KATHLEEN THOMPSON, 17-3667, Plaintiffs: ARREDONDO, 17-7249, RHONDA CIUCHTA, 17-8275, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD JOANN CAMPBELL, 17-7665, DEBRA HIGGINS, 17- ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED 7251, MARGARET LANGLEY, 17-7253, JAMES D. BANK, NJ; HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD MERCER, 17-8702, on behalf of JEAN MERCER, ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & JESSICA BUTLER, 17-7767, SUSAN HEFFERNAN, ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, Page 43 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *125

LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For MELVIN ANDERSON, 17-10715, on behalf of FLORENTYNE ANDERSON, DECEASED, Plaintiff: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC For BONNIE JAMES, 17-3602, Plaintiff: VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, [*126] TX. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; GRAHAM LEE NEWMAN, LEAD For DONNA DEVER, 17-10693, SERAH STEWART, ATTORNEY, CHAPPELL SMITH & ARDEN, 17-2943, DONNA WHICKER, 17-2943, Plaintiffs: COLUMBIA, SC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; James P. Holloran, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLORAN AND SCHWARTZ, LLP, St. Louis, MO; For LINDA VITIELLO, 17-3619, MARY BODIE, 17-3771, KATIE A. HUBBARD, LEAD ATTORNEY, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, GOLDENBERG HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS J. LECH, ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG HELLER, PC, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. MONTGOMERY, AL.

For KATHLEEN CLARK, 17-3539 AND 17-7664, For SALLY B HUDSON, 17-3632, Plaintiff: Arthur SANDRA LEE, 17-3548, WILLIAM LEE, 17-3548, Mahony Murray, LEAD ATTORNEY, Murray Law Firm, RONALD GOODWIN, 17-3551 AND 17-7721, New Orleans, LA; CAROLINE THOMAS [*128] WHITE, PATRICIA GOODWIN, 17-3551 AND 17-7721, MOSES Stephen B Murray, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MURRAY LAW MINTZER, 17-3555, 17-7725, GARY PANKONIEN, 17- FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL 3568; 17-7764, JANET PANKONIEN, 17-3568; 17- PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, 7764, GEORGE EVANS, 17-3570 AND 17-7719, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA SUSAN EVANS, 17-3570 AND 17-7719, Plaintiffs: LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD AL. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; John E. Deaton, LEAD ATTORNEY, The For MARK CAIN, 17-3670, Plaintiff: BARRY R. Deaton Law Firm, East Providence, RI; PATRICIA SUGARMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, SOMERVILLE, NJ; LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD AL; TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. BANK, NJ; ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX; MARK For RONALD CLARK, 17-3539 AND 17-7664, ANTHONY COX, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL CARVER, 17-3549, JAMES REULE, 17- MARK A. COX PLLC, EDMOND, OK; PATRICIA LEIGH 3572, WINNIFRED REULE, [*127] 17-3572, CARLA O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. LONG, 17-3573, NELSON LONG, 17-3573, BARBARA ANTHONY, 17-3574, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER For NIKKI CAIN, 17-3670, Plaintiff: BARRY R. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, SUGARMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, SOMERVILLE, NJ; PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; John E. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Deaton, LEAD ATTORNEY, The Deaton Law Firm, East ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED Providence, RI; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD BANK, NJ; MARK ANTHONY COX, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. LAW OFFICE OF MARK A. COX PLLC, EDMOND, OK; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For TERESA ELLIS, 17-3588, Plaintiff: ADAM TAL MONTGOMERY, AL. FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, POTTS LAW FIRM, Houston, TX; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, Page 44 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *128

For MARGARET LEISTLER, 17-3672, VIKKI HOLDREN, 17-3671, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER For ANTONIO AMARAL, 17-3752, Plaintiff: ADRIANA MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, SKIKOS PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAE YEOL CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD LLP, CA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD NEW YORK, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For KIMBERLY LAYER, 17-3692, [*129] DIANA PALAFOX, 17-3693, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER For LISA FORLIVESI-AMARAL, 17-3752, Plaintiff: MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, FRANCISCO, CA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL AL; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, For MELANIE FINLEY, 17-3704, Plaintiff: AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ST. LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JORDAN KOEL MERSON, LEAD For JOHN A. SEVERINO, 17-3765, MONICA JANE ATTORNEY, Merson Law, PLLC, NEW YORK, NY; SEVERINO, 17-3765, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLIZZARD & For CHRISTOPHER EVANS, 17-3728, DOUGLAS W. NABERS LLP, HOUSTON, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH SMITH, 17-3729, Personal Representative of the Estate O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. of Amanda Rose Lee Smith, Deceased, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For RONALD GAINES, 17-3804, on behalf of the Estate ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED of Faye Gaines, GLORIA COOPER, [*131] 17-3839, BANK, NJ; DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ANITA CLEMENT, 17-3846, Plaintiffs: ANDREW MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY; GEIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ALLAN BERGER AND PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA; CHRISTOPHER MONTGOMERY, AL. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA For MARION PIERCE, 17-3750, RALPH PIERCE, 17- LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, 3750, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL AL. PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA For VERNEVA FREEMAN, 17-3840, Plaintiff: LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD AL; RONNIE GLYNN PENTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BOGALUSA, LA. BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS P. For CYNTHIA COOPER-MCNULTY, 17-3751, SZIDON CARTMELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & MCNULTY, 17-3751, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER [*130] CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MEGHAN For SCOT COLLINS, 17-3849, Plaintiff: ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL. Page 45 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *131

ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; SARAH STERLING STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT PA, LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD LEXINGTON, MS. ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For DANNETTE PETTIGREW, 17-3869 AND 17-6574, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, For KELLY CAMBRIA, 17-3946, JOSEPH CRAVENOR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, 17-10271, KEAUDREA DEGRAFFENREID, 17-9794, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD MARY FANSLER, 17-3946, ANNA FOCHT, 17-11019, ATTORNEY, NEWPORT BEACH, CA; NICOLE KEVIN GAHM, 17-3946, SHIRLEY GIBBS, 17-8615, LAUREN BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, VENTURA JOHN HIGGINS, 17-3946, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER LAW, DANBURY, CT; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL For ALICE BARNES, 17-3917, HARVEY BELGARD, JOSEPH QUILLIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER 17-3918, BARBARA HARTSFIELD, 17-3928, SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, THERESA HUBBARD, 17-3829, [*132] JOEVA MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, JACKSON, 17-3930, MURRAY JAMES, 17-3931; 18- MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, 14488, BILLY JERRO, 17-3932, CLEATHER LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE JOHNSON, 17-3933, PHILLIP LAFLEUR, 17-3934, BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD LEE For EVELYN HAWKINS, 17-9798, TINA HENRY, 17- ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORRIS BART & 11188, ARI-GRACE HENSLEY, 17-3946, NANCY ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA. JACQUEZ, 17-3946, AUDREY MARLOW, 17-11189, JILL MCLEAN, 17-3946, MONA MCQUEEN, 17-10571, on behalf of ESTATE OF LYDIA MATHURINE, For KERRY GORMLEY, 17-3944, Plaintiff: DECEASED, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PLACITELLA & ROTH, [*134] PC, RED BANK, NJ; BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, ST. PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For MILDRED ACKERMAN, 17-9367, Plaintiff: For JUDY HENRY, 17-4492, on behalf of ESTATE OF CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD SOPHIE JOHNSEN, DECEASED, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LLP, Philadelphia, PA; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, LEAD PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DENA PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH RACHEL YOUNG, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS FELLER O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, [*133] CASEY, LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA; JAMES G. ONDER, AL; PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY KLINE & SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA; PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MARK ALAN Page 46 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *134

HOFFMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS FELLER CASEY ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA; MICHAEL JOSEPH BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, QUILLIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, LEAD PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; SCOTT S O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; BERGER, JR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS FELLER PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & CASEY, LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA; STEPHANIE SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA; STEPHANIE LYNN [*135] RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, LOUIS, MO. MO.

For GLADYS JONES, 17-3946, Plaintiff: For CAROL OBERLIN, 17-3946; 17-8258, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD CHRISTINA MARIE GRAZIANO, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BANK, NJ; DANIEL J. THORNBURGH, LEAD HAUSFELD LLP, WASHINGTON, DC; CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BAR, PENSACOLA, FL; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES D. ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON GOTZ, STEVEN B. ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & HAUSFELD LLP, BOSTON, MA; JAMES G. ONDER, PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; PETERSON LLC, [*137] ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. JOSEPH QUILLIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. MONTGOMERY, AL; RACHEL BETH ABRAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD For MICHELLE LANG, 17-9069, YAZMEIN MOORE, ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, 17-8950, RONALD NEUMAN, 17-8948, on behalf of LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ESTATE OF BEVERLY NEUMAN, DECEASED, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD For YVETTE ALVAREZ-PEREZ, 17-3944, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. [*136] LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON MO. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For SUSAN LAWSON, 17-9501, Plaintiff: For LINDA BARRETT, 17-8537, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD Page 47 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *137

ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN BANK, NJ; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICIA O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For DELIA LANDRY, 17-3935;18-14543, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For MICHAEL [*138] BEARDEN, 17-3944, AUDREY ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BEGAYE, 17-10156, ROYCE BUCZEK, 17-3944, BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD DAVID CUPINA, 17-11300, on behalf of ESTATE OF ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD LEE DONNA CUPINA, DECEASED, DEBORAH DOWD, 17- ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED 3944, MARY FRITSON, 17-9823, PATRICIA TOU SDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. FROWNFELTER, 17-10609, VICTORIA HARDIN, 17- 10989, on behalf of ESTATE OF MARY ROBINSON, For EVA BECK, 17-10679, CARRIE BEHUNIN, 17- DECEASED, MERIDITH HOLMES, 17-3944, DEWAN 8666, JUDITH KNOTTS, 17-cv-8708, Plaintiffs: HUFFMAN, 17-3944, DEBBIE JEFFERS, 17-3944, MS. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, [*140] LEAD BETTY JOHNSON, 17-3944, BRENDA JOYCE, 17- ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED 11102, on behalf of ESTATE OF PATRICIA BLAND, BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, DECEASED, VERA JEAN LANE, 17-3944, MARY ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LYNN LAVIGNA, 17-3944, MARY LEADLEY, 17-3944, LOUIS, MO; LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BONNIE LEE, 17-10594, on behalf of PATRICIA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COHEN & MALAD LLP, NUNLEY, DECEASED, NAZEL LANE LEE, 17-3944, INDIANAPOLIS, IN; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD MICHAEL MCNAMARA, 17-10625, on behalf of ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ESTATE OF BONNIE MCNAMARA, DECEASED, BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For KRYSTAL GOODALE, 17-8952, COLLEEN HAAS, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, 17-cv-9989, PATRICIA KING, 17-9155, DEBORAH LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE MCCORMACK, 17-9364, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. [*139] NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED For DYANN COOK, 17-7412, SANTA DELLEVAS, 17- BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, 7429, on behalf of ESTATE OF ALEXANDRA ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. DELLEVAS, DECEASED, FRANK HINDS, 17-7430, on LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, behalf of DEBRA HINDS, DECEASED, TAMARIS COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LYLES, 17-7431, DEBRA MUTTA, 17-7419, Plaintiffs: ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, BANK, NJ; ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX; JAMES G. O'LEARY [*141] & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED For TONYA JONES, 17-cv-9982, BRENDA MUNN, 17- TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. 10437, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Page 48 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *141

PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; LAUREN pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, For INGE PARSHALL, 17-cv-10038, KARINA PIERCE, MONTGOMERY, AL; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD 17-10033, TIMMY R. ROAD, 17-3944, CHERYL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ TEMPLE, 17-3944, KATHY SUE THOMPSON, 17- BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; 3944, TARA THOMPSON, 17-10947, [*143] on behalf PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, of ESTATE OF CYNTHIA EDWARDS, DECEASED, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LLOYD WARNER, 17-8559, on behalf of ESTATE OF LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE DENIESE WARNER, DECEASED, PAMELA BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON WILLIAMS-PERKINS, 17-3944, KATHRYN WILLS, 17- O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. 3944, FRANK ALBERDING, 17-3945; 18-12711, GAIL BIGGS, 17-3945, LIDIA LIZBETH CARBAJAL, 17-3945, For YVETTE LUCANTONI, 17-7765, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. DONNA CARDWELL, 17-9498, LINDA CARROLL, 17- GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 9500, KYNDA COOK, 17-3945, LAURIE DESTEFANO, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BUFFALO, NY; 17-3945, LORRAINE GOLDSTEIN, 17-3945, GRETA CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD KAREN HAMM, 17-10606, on behalf of ESTATE OF ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED CINDY WILLIS, DECEASED, DELBERT LEATH, 17- BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, 3945, SHERRY MURPHY, 17-10538, on behalf of ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. ESTATE OF SHELLEY MURPHY, DECEASED, LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, DIANNA METZLER, 17-3945, Plaintiffs: COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM [*142] ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For LOIS MCCALL, 17-10683, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLIZZARD & LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED [*144] NABERS LLP, HOUSTON, TX; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, For CHARLETTE WRIGHT, 17-7439, on behalf of LEAD ATTORNEY, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE MARGARET STEVENSON, DECEASED, Plaintiff: BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For VICTORIA PALACIOS, 17-3944, Plaintiff: JAMES HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX; JAMES G. G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED Page 49 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *144

TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON For MICHELE PYRAM, 17-3946, CAROLYN O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. STREETER, 17-8262, CYNTHIA WINSTEAD, 17-8264, Plaintiffs: CHRISTINA MARIE GRAZIANO, LEAD For LORETTA LATIN, 17-3936, LLOYD LOUPE, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 3937, BONNIE LOWREY, 17-3938, PATRICIA BAR HAUSFELD LLP, WASHINGTON, DC; MATHERNE, 17-3939; 18-14495, LAURA SMITH, 17- CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 3940, WAYNE TAUZIER, 17-3941, RICHARD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED WHITSON, 17-3943, NETTIE COLLINS, 17-3919, BANK, NJ; JAMES D. GOTZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHARLES CUTRER, 17-3920, ASHLEY DOERER, 17- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR 3921, JACKLEEN DUCKWORTH, 17-3922, [*145] IRIS HAUSFELD LLP, BOSTON, MA; JAMES G. ONDER, ENGLISH, 17-3924, CARROLL DUFRENE, 17-3923, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO TOYA ESTES, 17-3925, ASHLEY FRUGE, 17-3926, USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY VANESSA GALLE, 17-3927, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL JOSEPH MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, QUILLIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR ONDER SHELTON LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, RICHARD LEE ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NOT ADMITTED TOU SDC-NJ BAR, MORRIS BART & MONTGOMERY, AL; RACHEL BETH ABRAMS, LEAD ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA. ATTORNEY, LEVIN [*147] SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For PAUL PELTIER, 17-10105, on behalf of, ESTATE BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. OF JERRI LYNNE PELTIER, DECEASED, PAULA LOUIS, MO; STEVEN B. ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRESWORSKY, 17-8770, GEORGE SMITH, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR Individually and as Administrator of the Estate of Linda HAUSFELD LLP, BOSTON, MA; WILLIAM WYLIE Smith, Deceased, 17-3946, SEAN SHARKEY, 17- BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED 11202, on behalf of ESTATE OF CATHLEEN MANCINI, TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & DECEASED, GAIL STEELE, 17-3946, DONNA STOTT, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. 17-9483, JILL TONEY, 17-3946, DEBRA WILLIAMS, 17-9592, ATWOOD WILLIAMS, JR, 18-13138, RHONDA WOODEARS, 17-10490, on behalf of For DENISE STONE, 17-3946; 17-8260, Plaintiff: ESTATE OF MARCELLA WOODEARS, DECEASED, CHRISTINA MARIE GRAZIANO, LEAD ATTORNEY, DONNA ZUCKER, 17-3946, JEAN KRUEGER, 17- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR 3945, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL HAUSFELD LLP, WASHINGTON, DC; CHRISTOPHER PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES D. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT GOTZ, STEVEN B. ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL BOSTON, MA; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOSEPH QUILLIN, LEAD [*146] ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, LEAD LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, Page 50 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *147

ST. LOUIS, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; RACHEL BETH ABRAMS, Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ FRANCISCO, CA; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO [*148] RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For MICKEY R. HOWDER, 17-3954, KEVIN AQUILINA, For RACHEL MARTIN, 17-10166, Plaintiff: 17-3960, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA BANK, NJ; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, [*150] L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For JOE DON GEORGE, 17-3949, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MONTGOMERY, AL; SEAN MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR CELLINO & BARNES ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PC, BUFFALO, NY; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL BAR, MIAMI, FL; TEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, For MICHELLE ROBERTS, 17-3950, Plaintiff: CARMEN ST. LOUIS, MO. SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE For DIANA MILLER, 17-3945, CINDY MORGAN, 17- LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL 3945, DONALD NEMECEK, 17-12982, ELISABETH PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PAOLILLO, 17-11185, BRENDA PARKS, 17-9528, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA JAMES PENDERGAST, 17-10477, on behalf of, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ESTATE OF BRENDA PENDERGAST, DECEASED, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. CARMEN PINHEIRO, 17-9431, JANNAE POSEY, 17- 3945, FELIPE PRICE, 17-11193, on behalf of, ESTATE For CHRISTINE GRIMM, 17-9966, [*149] JACKLYN OF INEZ PRICE, DECEASED, MELISSA REGISTER, HALL, 17-10001, ERIKA MATULICH, 17-9633, 17-9532, ALICE RHODEN, 18-12964, RENEE SILVA, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD 17-3945, BARBARA STORY, 17-3945, STEPHANIE ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ VAI, 17-3945, CYNTHIA WHITE, 17-11180 (Arcadia, BAR BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & Louisiana), MARY WILLIAMS, 17-3945, (Nash, ), MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; CHRISTOPHER SANDRA WARREN, 17-8605, GARY WEBSTER, 17- MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, 10548, on behalf of, ESTATE OF DIANE WEBSTER, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. DECEASED, SANDRA WEST, 17-11184, SHELLI ANN ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT WHEELER, 17-9675, LOUIELENE WILLIAMS, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON 11199, on behalf of, ESTATE OF CHARVETTE O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. WILLIAMS, [*151] DECEASED, SHEILA WINFIELD, 17-8591, DEBRA WOODSIDE, 17-10580, on behalf of, Page 51 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *151

ESTATE OF DONNA EPPERLY, DECEASED, WILLIS MARUNA, 17-11114, VERONICA MICHELLE MOORE, For JOAN L. ONOPA, 17-4012, LEONARD ONOPA, 17- 17-11203, on behalf of, ESTATE OF VERONICA 4012, NAILA FARUQI, 17-4033, Plaintiffs: MOORE, DECEASED, NESTOR TABOAS, 17-10897, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD on behalf of, ESTATE OF GLADYS PABON, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED DECEASED, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL BANK, NJ; GREGORY S. SPIZER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ANAPOL WEISS, Philadelphia, PA; PATRICIA LEIGH PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; JAMES G. O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED For CHRISTINE MUNSON, 17-4061, CRAIG MUNSON, TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. 17-4061, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*153] COHEN, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For DAVID HOUSTON, JR., 17-4090, JAMES EDDIE HOUSTON, 17-4090, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER For JACK TAYLOR, 17-3942, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ERIC D. ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HEYGOOD ORR & ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PEARSON, IRVING, TX; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD LEE [*152] LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. TOU SDC-NJ BAR, MORRIS BART & ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For DON ENOCHS, 17-4118, YVONNE ENOCHS, 17- 4118, BEVERLY EVANS LEE, 17-4122, Individually and For CALVIN JONES, 17-3976, Plaintiff: ADAM TAL on behalf of the Estate of Cynthia Evans, KATHERINE FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED BRUMLEY, 17-4123, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER TO USDC-NJ BAR, POTTS LAW FIRM, Houston, TX; MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MEGHAN ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. For LAVINIA LUPE, 17-3965, ROBERT LUPE, 17-3965, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, For LAURA EVANS, 17-4150, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAVID J. DIAMOND, LEAD PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAVID T. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*154] MORELLI LAW BAR, GOLDBERG & OSBORNE, TUCSON, AZ; FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY; PATRICIA LEIGH PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. MONTGOMERY, AL. Page 52 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *154

For DON JAMES, 17-4194, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; LANCE C. UNGLESBY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For KEITH GERSIN, 17-4126, SHARON THOMAS, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, UNGLESBY LAW 4342, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL FIRM, BATAN ROUGE, LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; HENRY G. USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLASINGAME BURCH For PAUL M RASHBA, 17-4282, Plaintiff: CARMEN GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA; PATRICIA SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE ADMITTED [*156] TO USDC-NJ BAR, LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL MONTGOMERY, AL. PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA For FREDDIE LANDRUM, 17-4032, 17-9587, KELLY LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT FRANCES COGLIANDRO, 17-4348, ROBBIE DOLLAR, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-4349, EDNA HOWARD, 17-4350, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD For ANGELA HALLIDAY, 17-4164, on behalf of ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ESTATE OF WILMA JEAN SAUNDERS, DECEASED, BANK, NJ; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, SHIRLEY MICHEL, 17-4164, REBECCA NORTON, 17- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 4300, JOYCE BREEDING, 17-4304, SAUNDRA ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA CURRY, 17-4307, LATOSHA ANDERSON, 17-4308, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; For ROLAND MEDINA, 17-4365, TYRON R MEDINA, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD 17-4365, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, RED [*155] BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS CHRISTOPHER PINEDO, LEAD For CHERYL GORDON, 17-4315 AND 17-12052, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, BAR, HILLIARD MUNOZ GONZALES LLP, CORPUS LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, CHRISTI, TX. PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For ANGELA HARRELL, 17-4351, LAURA SALDANA- BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD KINTNER, 17-4353, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, BAR, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN; PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHELLE TREVOR BRUCE ROCKSTAD, LEAD ATTORNEY, A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DAVIS ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, & CRUMP PC, GULFPORT, MS. WASHINGTON, DC.

For BERTHA BROWN, 17-4340, Plaintiff: For AMANDO R RAMOS, 17-4367, AMANDO RAMOS, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD JR., 17-4367, CARLOS JAVIER RAMOS, 17-4367, ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED JOSE RAUL RAMOS, 17-4367, [*157] ROLAND BANK, NJ; JENNIFER A. LENZE, LEAD ATTORNEY, RAMOS, 17-4367, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED USDC-NJ BAR, LENZE PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, MOSS PLC, MANHATTAN BEACH, CA; PATRICIA PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; THOMAS Page 53 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *157

CHRISTOPHER PINEDO, LEAD ATTORNEY, 4390, on behalf of, ESTATE OF ALLYN MAHER, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PlaintiffS: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, HILLIARD MUNOZ GONZALES LLP, CORPUS LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, CHRISTI, TX. PC, RED BANK, NJ; Leon R Russell, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED USDC - NJ BAR, The Russell Law Firm, Dallas, TX. For JOY C. FAUST, 17-4369, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAVID For CAROL A. YANDELL, 17-4414, Plaintiff: WAYNE STEWART, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, STEWART & ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED SYEWART, CARMEL, IN; MICHAEL JOHN SOBIERAY, BANK, NJ; ERIC S. JOHNSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, USDC-NJ BAR, STEWART & STEWART, CARMEL, IN. SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL.

For TIFFANY DAWKINS, 17-4372, Plaintiff: For GEORGE YANDELL, 17-4414, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD BANK, NJ; ERIC S. JOHNSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ COUNSEL [*159] NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAR, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM APLC, NEW ORLEANS, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. LA; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For MARVIN R CAVETT, 17-4401, PATRICIA G MONTGOMERY, AL. CAVETT, 17-4401, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, For EMILY COLBERT, 17-4376, JAMES COLBERT, 17- PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; ELWOOD 4376, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL CLEMENT STEVENS, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, DOMENGEAUX WRIGHT ROY & EDWARDS, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; DAVID J. LAFAYETTE, LA. DIAMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GOLDBERG & For DEBRA COBBS, 17-4447, WANDA JEANENE OSBORNE, TUCSON, AZ. GAGE, 17-4451, MARILYN A REINHOLD, 17-4725, FORMEIKA D BRYANT, 17-4726, DANEEN RENEE For MICHAEL ANDERSON, [*158] 17-4612, SONIA M RAMEY, 17-4843, Plaintiffs: GREGORY DONALD ANDERSON, 17-4612, GAIL QUIROS, 17-4614, BROWN, KELSEY LOUISE STOKES, LEAD Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, BAR, HOUSTON, TX. PC, RED BANK, NJ; MICHAEL RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For MARK MARTINEZ, 17-4474, MARY YVETTE BAR, HOUSTON, TX. MALTOS, 17-4633, RUBEN MALTOS, 17-4633, ANN MARIE HERRYGERS, 17-4634, RANDY HERRYGERS, For GARY GROSE, 17-4379, PATRICIA GROSE, 17- 17-4634, CHARLES J. KNIPE, 17-4635, MARY ANN 4379, DENISE MITCHELL, 17-4380, Plaintiffs: KNIPE, 17-4635, PATRICIA BUHLER, 17-4743, CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD BEULAH LYNETTE BANKS-HARRIS, 17-4838, DANIEL ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED LIGHTFOOT, 17-4838, ROBERT BINIUS, 17-4832, BANK, NJ; MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD BOBBIE WHITAKER, 17-4834, SHEILA GODWIN, 17- ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN 4835, LEALON GRAHAM, 17-4836, LINDA S FRANCISCO, CA. GRAHAM, 17-4836, DEBORAH REMMEREID, 17- 5014, PAUL MARTIN REMMEREID, 17-5014, DIANE FISHER, 17-5098, JASON RE, 17-5174, Plaintiffs: For AMY MAHER, 17-4390, GEORGE MAHER, 17- MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD Page 54 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *159

ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN For KEVIN MOON, 17-4580, LILA STEWART, 17-4973, FRANCISCO, CA. THERESA IRWIN, 17-5140, Plaintiffs: HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA. For MICHAEL GRONDAHL, 17-4467, [*160] KIMIE LEIGH CHAVEZ, 17-4871, KAREN HILL, 17-5032, ROBERT HILL, 17-5032, BRENDA LINFIELD, 17-5036, For VALERIE J MASSEY, 17-4590, Plaintiff: THOMAS WARREN LINFIELD, 17-5036, MARTHA MOORE, 17- P. CARTMELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & 5063, DONNA DARNELL, 17-5129, PATRICK CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. DARNELL, SR, 17-5129, MEREDITH CHAPMAN, Decedent 17-5263, MATHAIS PHILLIPS, 17-5263, LEE For ALLAN RAPPOLD, 17-cv-4596, Plaintiff: WELLS, 17-5315, LUCIENNE WELLS, 17-5315, ROBIN MATTHEW B. MORELAND, LEAD ATTORNEY, LYONS, 17-5326, STEVE LYONS, 17-5326, TANYA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JIM S. VALURE, 17-5344, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD HALL & ASSOCIATES, LLC, METAIRIE, LA. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, POTTS LAW FIRM, Houston, TX. For JIMMY SELLS, 17-cv-4607, MARGARET SELLS, 17-cv-4607, ROGER REESE, 17-cv-4608, Plaintiffs: For SHERRYLEE GREAVES, 17-4461, CLARA JONES, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO 17-4490, THOMAS JONES, 17-4490, KIMBERLY USDC-NJ BAR, GOLDBERG & OSBORNE, TUCSON, ANNE GIBBS, 17-4706, DENISE MILLER, 17-4902, AZ. FRANK MILLER, 17-4902, JOSHUA SLINGERLAND, 17-5137, MAKIKO SLINGERLAND, 17-5137, CHRISTINA STILLWAGGON, 17-5307, JASON For NANETTE HALVORSON, 17-4632, MARY STILLWAGGON, 17-5307, ALICE MCALEXANDER, 17- BERNHARD, 17-4611, RICHARD BERNHARD, 17- 5342, LEWIS MCALEXANDER, 17-5342, MICHAEL 4611, Plaintiffs: MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD DOUGLAS, 17-5346, PATRICIA DOUGLAS, 17-5346, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO [*162] Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD USDC-NJ BAR, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM APLC, NEW ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ORLEANS, LA. BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; DENA RACHEL YOUNG, LEAD ATTORNEY, WEITZ & For JAMES C. LOOMIS, 17-4636, LANA M. SING, 17- LUXENBERG, P.C., CHERRY HILL, NJ; MARK ALAN 4878, CHRISTIN WILEY, 17-4879, ALECIA WILLIS, 17- HOFFMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS FELLER CASEY 4880, BILLY G. HAYES, 17-4887, TAMMY ACORD, 17- LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA; SCOTT S BERGER, JR, 4888, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS FELLER CASEY, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LLP, [*161] PHILADELPHIA, PA. BAR BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. For DONALD LUCAS, 17-4526, Plaintiff: Joseph M. Bruno, MELISSA A. DEBARBIERIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, For CHARLYN CARPENTER, 17-792, DOROTHY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED USDC - NJ BAR, Bruno & STUMPF, 17-4644, WILLIE MAE DEANES, 17-4645, Bruno, New Orleans, LA. BARBARA JOHNSON, 17-4851 (New ), Plaintiffs: SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For CRYSTAL BOYD, 17-4539, MOSES CUDDON, 17- BARON & BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX. 4958, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, For PATRICIA W HILL, 17-4679, HELEN DEE, 17-5049, DALLAS, TX. ROBERT DEE, 17-5049, DELLA JOYCE FOWLER, 17- 5114, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD For JOHN R. HALL, 17-4535, Plaintiff: DAVID T. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. PLLC, NEW YORK, NY.

For SONIA M. ANDERSON, 17-4612, DENISE Page 55 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *162

SIERRA, 17-5168, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLIZZARD & NABERS LLP, For JOANN LEAMY, 17-4800, Plaintiff: CATHERINE HOUSTON, TX. THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. For DENNIS MARONEY, 17-4620, JO ANN MCALPIN, 17-04621, ELFA ROSALEE REED, 17-4624, Plaintiffs: For CALPRICIA , 17-4855, Plaintiff: CARMEN BRETT A. EMISON, LEAD ATTORNEY, LANGDON & SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL EMISON LLC, LEXINGTON, MO. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For PATRICIA ACHILLES, 17-4700, BARBARA COX, 17-4701, KAY HANCHETT, 17-4702, JAMES M. For ANDREA PETRIDES, 17-4870, Plaintiff: MICHAEL BUSSEY, 17-5347, as Special Administrator [*163] of S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PARKER the Estate of Mary F. Bussey, deceased, SUSAN WAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY. BLAKE, 17-5343, CLARA L HARRIS, 17-5349, Plaintiffs: BLAKE A. SHUART, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For BESSIE H. HINDS, 17-4877, JEAN PITEO, 17- WICHITA, KS. 5217, LESLIE MICHAEL COSBY, 17-5360, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO For THOMAS W. STEWART, 17-4708, KAREN KOHL, USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY 17-4729, THOMAS KOHL, 17-4729, JERRY FOSTER, PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. 17-4767, JUDY HARRIS, 17-4761, JASON RISSLER, 17-4795, SONYA RISSLER, 17-4795, JESSE FLORES, 17-4796, NICOLE ZMIJEWSKI, 17-4796, ROGENNA For PATRICIA ARRINGTON BESSELMAN, 17-4923, KNOX, 17-4896, HAROLD TRAMMEL, SR., 17-4961, MARY LOVELL, 17-5222, MICHELE SETTIPANI, 17- CONNIE JONES, 17-4972, JOSEPH FORBES, 17- 5224, LORRAINE TERANDO, 17-5225, ELEANOR 5018, HOWARD ASTON, 17-5259, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MILLER, 17-5226, VIRGINIA KING, 17-5227, MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER KIMBERLY SOUSA, 17-5309, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WASHINGTON, DC. For PATRICIA RICE, 17-4719, VICKI PETERSON, 17- 4720, ROSA QUAIDER, 17-4721, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE For GREGORY HOLMES, 17-4907, on behalf of, A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ESTATE OF SUSAN HOLMES, Plaintiff: CARYN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WASHINGTON, DC; MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. LOUIS, MO.

For WENDY KIRKLAND, 17-4953, Plaintiff: ERIC D. For YVONNE CROTTEAU, 17-4744, Plaintiff: PEARSON, LEAD [*165] ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD, LEAD ATTORNEY, Goza ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR HEYGOOD ORR & & Honnold, LLC, Overland Park, KS. PEARSON, IRVING, TX.

For RHONDA DEAN, 17-4784, MARK MARBLE, 17- For SHARON LEGROS, 17-4974, ALTA LEGROS 4939, Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD EAGLIN, 17-4974, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL WARREN ATTORNEY, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOHNSTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LEVENSTEN JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. LAW FIRM PC, Philadelphia, PA.

For LISA ROSS, 17-4791, Plaintiff: ERIC D. HOLLAND, For ELEAZAR BARAJAS, 17-5001, ELIZABETH LEAD ATTORNEY, [*164] HOLLAND GROVES BARAJAS, 17-5001, SUSAN M THOMPSON, 17-5035, SCHNELLER & STOLZE LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. KATHERINE MCCAIN, 17-5096, Plaintiffs: ERIC S. Page 56 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *165

JOHNSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SIMMONS HANLY For DONALD HACKNEY, 17-5220, Plaintiff: NICHOLAS CONROY, ALTON, IL. W. MAYLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KILLIAN DAVIS For DORI ANNE BEYNON, 17-5023, DARWYN RICHTER & MAYLE PC, GRAND JUNCTION, CO. ABERNATHY, 17-5113, JAMES CARTER, 17-5117, Plaintiffs: JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD For STEVEN WEISBROT, 17-5293, Plaintiff: KATIE A. ATTORNEYS, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, HUBBARD, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT IN. ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, GOLDENBERG HELLER & ANTOGNOLI, PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. For SERITA BLACK, 17-5037, TREMAYNE BLACK, 17- 5037, SANTANA BLACK, 17-5037, Plaintiffs: For GLORIA APONTE RODRIGUEZ, 17-5371, Plaintiff: TOMISLAV GEORGE ANTUNOVICH, LEAD DAE YEOL LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LIEBHARD LLP, NEW YORK, NY. BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, CA.

For GARY WILSON, 17-5385, Administrator of Deborah For DOROTHY MAXWELL, 17-5097, VICKIE JEAN J. Wilson's Estate, LOIS B. LEVIN, 17-5386, JOHN AUSTIN, 17-5116, GLORIA BELL, 17-5125, DIANE SHANNON, 17-5389, as Administrator [*167] of Jo DYCKMAN, 17-5130, WILLIAM P. DYCKMAN, 17-5130, Shannon's Estate, NIRKA BOSQUET, 17-5390, BRYNNE HAYMAKER, 17-5133, Plaintiffs: DAVID B. Plaintiffs: PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, VERMONT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT KLINE & SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ, DURHAM, NC.

For DAVID C. WALDMAN, 17-5391, SUSAN A. For JOHN LOVE, 17-5107, Plaintiff: SETH ALAN KATZ, WALDMAN, 17-5391, GERALD L. MCCLURE, 17-5392, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO HEIDI M. MCCLURE, 17-5392, CHARLES MUSTARO, USDC-NJ BAR, BURG SIMPSON ELDREDGE HERSH 17-5387, MARYANNE E. MUSTARO, 17-5387, & JARDINE, [*166] ENGLEWOOD, CO. ELIZABETH KALDROVICS, 17-5388, MICHAEL J. KALDROVICS, 17-5388, Plaintiffs: PRISCILLA E. For ROSE MOORE, 17-5148, Plaintiff: MARK P JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & SPECTER PC, ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PHILADELPHIA, PA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ROBINSON CALCAGNIE INC, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. For JACKIE DILDINE, 17-5401, ELIZABETH CAMACHO, 17-5599, RICHARD MCCLEAD, SR., 17- For LUZ ZAMORA, 17-5171, ALCIDES SANCHEZ, 17- 5601, CYNTHIA HUGHES, 17-5644 (Tennessee), 5329, AMANDA SANCHEZ, 17-5329, TRACEY NOBLE, JOSEPHINE JOHNSON, 17-5645, Plaintiffs: 17-5331, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. MN. LOUIS, MO.

For GUADALUPE MEZA, 17-5172, SONJA MINCH, 17- For ROBIN HENSON, 17-5415, VIVIAN PRUITT, 5197, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD DWANE EPLIN, 17-5541, DIANNA DELANUEZ, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 5627, WILLIAM DELANUEZ, 17-5627, Plaintiffs: BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN. For LAUREN S. KRUSKELL, 17-5143, Plaintiff: LAUREN S. KRUSKALL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For DEBRA MCGEE, 17-5436, Plaintiff: DAVID B. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, VERMONT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT KANSAS CITY, MO. ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, HELMSDALE LAW Page 57 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *167

LLP, DURHAM, NC. SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For ZEBBIE ODOM, 17-5421, ALICE COTA, 17-5447, PATRICIA CLARK, 17-5696, MARIE RUGGIERO, 17- For JEANNE WEISGARBER, 17-5490, Plaintiff: 5699, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS [*168] MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS T. LOCKE, LEAD CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. ATTORNEY, SEYFARTH SHAW LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. For TINA CORENNE JONES, 17-5438, KENDALL LAMM, 17-5598, LINDA DIANE LAMM, 17-5598, LINDA For AMBER L DIXON, 17-5530, MARY ANN MORTON, SUE LEPKOWSKI, 17-5596, KENNETH LEPKOWSKI, 17-5534, RONALD BUCKHOLZ, 17-5537, Plaintiffs: SR., 17-5596, BARBARA MARTINEZ, 17-5597, SAM PHILIP BOHRER, LEAD ATTORNEY, BOHRER LAW MARTINEZ, 17-5597, VONTRECIA HARVEY, 17-5631, FIRM. BATON ROUGE, LA. JAMES JONES, 17-5632, MARIE JONES, 17-5632, JOANNE MATIKONIS, 17-5635, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN For LYNSHINA GRAY, 17-5531, DAVON YATES, 17- ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN 5536, DEBORAH A DAVIS, 17-5555 (Alabama), SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. LADONNA JOHNSON, 17-5557, DELORIS SCHMIDT, 17-5558, CHRISTOPHER MCELHANEY, 17-5564, For ERIC DIEFENDERFER, 17-5424, TRACI LAURA MITCHELL, 17-5677, Plaintiffs: TAYJES DIEFENDERFER, 17-5424, SANDRA CHAPEL, 17- MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER 5520, JAMES WOODALL, 17-5538, JANET FALK, 17- FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. 5615, THOMAS HERSHEY, 17-5658, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, POTTS LAW FIRM, For MELISSA C ADAMS, 17-5571, RICHARD S Houston, TX. ADAMS, 17-5571, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLIZZARD & NABERS LLP, For CINDY GAY HOWELL, 17-5433, GARY LYNN HOUSTON, TX. SONIER, 17-5433, Plaintiffs: TIMOTHY DALE BRANDENBURG, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAW FIRM OF For LAURA OREM, 17-5589, RICHARD OREM, 17-55, ROGER "ROCKY" WALTON PC, ARLINGTON, TX. Plaintiffs: STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB [*170] & HONIK PC, For JEANNE WOHLERS, 17-5453, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. PHILADELPHIA, PA. MCCORMICK, JR., MARK ALAN HOFFMAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, For JOAN MALLETT, 17-5593, RHONDA GONZALEZ, PA; DENA RACHEL YOUNG, SCOTT S BERGER, JR, 17-5628, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEYS, ROSS FELLER CASEY, LLP, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PHILADELPHIA, PA. BAR HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX.

For JOSEPH ANDRE, 17-5448, KATHLEEN For TIMOTHY J STAFFORD, 17-5620, FRANCINE HAZLEWOOD, 17-5464, KATHY JAMISON, 17-5481, SIMEONE ANDERSON, 17-5872, DARLENE A KIMBERLY DARLING, 17-5480, KIMBERLY LEMCHAK, 17-5872, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, ROSENBARKER, 17-5482, ROXANNE RUTKOWSKI, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, 17-5483, [*169] KAREN TOTOS, 17-5488, ELIZABETH Philadelphia, PA. BURNS, 17-5738, ROBERT ISENBERG, 17-5674, on behalf of Robin Isenberg, deceased, DANYELLE EMERY, 17-5675, on behalf of Diane Emery, deceased, For MARTHA RICKS, 17-5622, Plaintiff: EDWARD A. Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, WALLACE, LEAD ATTORNEY, WEXLER WALLACE MONTGOMERY, AL. LLP, CHICAGO, IL.

For MARY OBERDIER, 17-5479, Plaintiff: MEKEL For KATHLEEN LATHAM, 17-5625, DIANE Page 58 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *170

JEFFERIES, 17-5670, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. For JULIE TELLESON, 17-5663, JOHN HAWKINS, 17- PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 5664, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WASHINGTON, DC. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES, BUFFALO, NY. For AL DEVILLE, 17-5636, PAMELA DEVILLE, 17- 5636, LILLIAN SONDGEROTH, 17-5638, THOMAS For JON MATEYUNAS, 17-5689, AIDE MONTOYA, 17- SONDGEROTH, 17-5638, Plaintiffs: LINDSEY A. 5787, EDITH LUNA, 17-5777, NICOLE GOSS, [*172] CHEEK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 17-5824, BRENDA JOSEPH, 17-5848, Plaintiffs: ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE CHEEK LAW MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PORT WASHINGTON, NY. For MICHAEL HOLSCHBACH, 17-5639 AND 17-12202, on behalf of, ESTATE OF JUDITH HOLSCHBACH, For RITA M OGLETREE, 17-5709 AND 17-5874, Plaintiff: MICHAEL K. JOHNSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, BONITA MARINACCIO, 17-5711 AND 17-5873, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MARISA EWING, 17-96147, MARTHA KLEMETSON, JOHNSON BECKER, PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN; ROLF T. 17-5716 AND 17-5870, JACKY A VIENT, 17-5707 AND FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 17-5847, LINDA KINDLEY, 17-5708 AND 17-5871, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER SHERRY L FRANKLIN, 17-5701 AND 17-5861, PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MT. PLEASANT, SC; Donald A. Migliori, LEAD For RAYMOND YOUNG, [*171] 17-5616, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DAVID M. PETERSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, NJ BAR, Motley Rice LLC, Providence, RI. PETERSON & ASSOCIATES PC, KANSAS CITY, MO.

For PEGGY L DUNBAR, 17-5710, RITA DICARLO, 17- For JUSTIN BURKEEN, 17-5642, KAREN BURKEEN, 5713, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD 17-5642, TRISTAN HOLLAND, 17-5642, TIFFANY ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ROGERS, 17-5642, TOREE ROGERS, 17-5642, BAR, MT. PLEASANT, SC. JASON M. RITCHIE, 17-5771, Individually, JUDY A. RITCHIE, 17-5771, Individually, TERRY LEE RITCHIE, 17-5771, Individually, TODD N. RITCHIE, 17-5771, For MARISA EWING, 17-96147, LINDA DONALDSON, Individually, JANELLE A. STORY, 17-5771, Individually, 17-5715, 17-5856 AND 17-9607, Plaintiffs: CARMEN Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MT. PLEASANT, BAR BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., SC; Donald A. Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LOS ANGELES, CA. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC -NJ BAR, Motley Rice LLC, Providence, RI; MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For PAUL D SHEARLOCK, 17-5617, Plaintiff: BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For CHRISTINA MACMURPHY, 17-5700, SHAWN MACMURPHY, 17-5700, SHARON [*173] CUNNIGAN- WILSON, 17-5702, WESLEY WILSON, 17-5702, For JEANNA FIORDILISO, 17-5652, Plaintiff: MICHAEL Plaintiffs: DEREK T. BRASLOW, LEAD ATTORNEY, WARREN JOHNSTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE THE BRASLOW LAW FIRM, LLC, #20, WAYNE, PA. LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC, Philadelphia, PA.

For JO ANN HOPKINS, 17-5727, ROZELLA For SHARON FAN, 17-5659, Plaintiff: CORRIE WARHURST, 17-5727, Plaintiffs: BLAKE A. SHUART, JOHNSON YACKULIC, LEAD ATTORNEY, CORRIE LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO YACKULIC LAW FIRM PLLC, SEATTLE, WA. USDC-NJ BAR, WICHITA, KS. Page 59 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *173

For DONA AUGSBURGER, 17-5718, SHELLEY For SHERRY WAGNER, 17-5657, as Fiduciary of the BEARDSLEY, 17-5718; 17-6618, JANET ELROD, 17- Estate of Rose M. Krull, Plaintiff: ROBERT GORDON 5718, KAREN HAMILTON, 17-5718; 17-6715, JANICE KNAIER, LEAD ATTORNEY, FITZGERALD KNAIER HILL, 17-5718, DEBORAH OWEN, 17-5718; 17-6696, LLP, SAN DIEGO, CA. CHARMEL RICE, 17-5718, CAITLIN SELLERS, 17- 5718; 17-6717, ZENOVIA CLAYTON, 17-6699, LADEE For PEGGY L. DUNBAR, JOAN FEMMINELLA, 17- HOMM, 17-5718; 17-6754, PATRICIA HOWELL, 17- 5860, DAVAHN CHANTHAPANYA, 17-5853, RITA 5718; 17-6750, KELLY KLIMAN, 17-5718, MARGIE DICARLO, 17-5855, MARY GUPTILL, 17-5869, LORI K. KRIEG, 17-5718 and 17-6730, ELEANOR MOFFITT, WHITNEY, 17-5875 (), Plaintiffs: Donald A. 17-5718, KIMBERLY RICHBURG, 17-5718; 17-6694, Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BEVER-LEIGH SMITH, 17-5718, BETH VARIAN- ADMITTED TO [*175] USDC -NJ BAR, Motley Rice WILLIAMS, 17-6712, EILEEN WINGET, 17-5718; 17- LLC, Providence, RI. 6607, Plaintiffs: ANTHONY G. SIMON, BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, John G. Simon, LEAD ATTORNEYS, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. For DOROTHY DERRENBACHER, 17-5854; 17-6491; 17-9580, Plaintiff: Donald A. Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - For CHRISTYNN VIERRA, 17-5762 (New Orleans, LA), NJ BAR, Motley Rice LLC, Providence, RI; MARK P Plaintiff: DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA; RICHARD CHARLES ELY, CA. LEAD ATTORNEY, METAIRIE, LA.

For JOANN ZINGONE, 17-5668, GEORGANNA For CRYSTAL M. ROSENSTEEL, 17-5781, ANNIE B FOREMAN, 17-5669, THOMAS FOREMAN, 17-5669, BULLOCK, [*174] 17-5779, Plaintiffs: ERIC S. Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD JOHNSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SIMMONS HANLY JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. CONROY, ALTON, IL.

For LORNA MCWATTY, 17-5906, Plaintiff: John David For KIM KNIGHT, KEITH ABBEDUTO, 17-5812, Hurst, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED Plaintiffs: PETER J. FLOWERS, LEAD ATTORNEY, TO USDC- NJ BAR, Motley Rice LLC, Morgantown, MEYERS & FLOWERS LLC, ST . CHARLES, IL; WV. TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. For ELLEN GAVIN, 17-5907, Plaintiff: SETH ANDREW DYMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, BELLUCK & FOX LLP, For ESTHER RUSSO, Plaintiff: SHERRI L. PLOTKIN, NEW YORK, NY. LEAD ATTORNEY, RHEINGOLD, GIUFFRA, RUFFO & PLOTKIN, LLP, NEW YORK, NY. For MADELENA FIELDS, 17-5949, Plaintiff: KELLY A. FITZPATRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, The Flood Law For MOLLY BECKER, 17-5844 AND 17-6494, Plaintiff: Firm, LLC, Middletown, CT. Donald A. Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC -NJ BAR, Motley Rice LLC, Providence, RI; John Eugene Herrick, LEAD For DORIS ANDERSON, 17-5718; 17-cv-6721, NICOLE ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Mt. Pleasant, SC. AKRIDGE, 17-cv-6718, DENNIS J. GOODE, 17-cv- 6804, FRANCES BALLEW, 17-6737, CAROL BOLTON, 17-5718 and 17-6733, LYDIA HILL, 17-6689, TAMMY For LEQUISA WILSON, 17-9596, MICHIKO BRAZELL, SMITH-COWAN, 17-5718, LISA BURNETT, 17-6744, Plaintiffs: MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, KARINA COSIO, 17-6690, SUSAN FINERD, 17-6731, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNNA FRANK, 17-6765, VIVIAN GREEN-KNOX, 17- NEWPORT BEACH, CA. Page 60 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *175

6724, CHERN HALE, 17-6707, [*176] MARI MARY ROLLINS, 17-10047, BIANCA JIMENEZ, 17- JACKSON, 17-6720, CAROL KOCHER, 17-6710, 10497, GENALYN KING, 17-5719 on behalf of ESTATE PATRICIA LEWIS, 17-6729, KIM BAKER, 17-6793, OF SARAH SAN FILIPPO, DECEASED, ROBYN ERIK MCMURRAY, 17-6802, YVONNE NASON, 17- SMITH, 17-5719, JAMES LEWIS THOMAS, 17-5719 on 6732, DINA SMITH, 17-5718 and 17-6726, behalf of ESTATE OF DIANNE G. THOMAS, JACQUELINE BARTLETT, 17-6801, LILA DUFFY, 17- DECEASED, JENNIFER VERNON, 17-9942, 6723, DIANA JENNINGS, 17-6697, NIVIA TORRES 17- KATHERINE WESTHERFORD, 17-5719, KATIE 6713, JEANNIE WILLIAMSON, 17-6681, BERKITA WILKES 17-9944, ORVILLE WOLF, 17-5719 on behalf WILSON, 16-6753, LAURA WINDNAGLE, 17-6772, of ESTATE OF SUSIE WOLF, DECEASED, LINDA JACQUELYN WRIGHT, 17-6695, MARGARET YARO, 17-9945, MARION ZGRODNIK, 17-9946, BERNAL, 17-6771, DEBRA COUCH 17-6746, INGRID Plaintiffs: JAMES G. ONDER, Michael J. Quillin, [*178] GRIFFIN, 17-6749, RENALLDA BRADEN, 17-6752, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, individually, and on behalf of Charlene Robinson and LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO the Estate of Charlene Robinson, MICHELLE TOLIVER, USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY 17-6734, Plaintiffs: ANTHONY G. SIMON, BENJAMIN PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. R. ASKEW, John G. Simon, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE For SANDRA M CRESPO, 17-11174, Plaintiff: JAMES SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. G. ONDER, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT For NICOLE LAUREN BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; NICOLE VENTURA LAW, DANBURY, CT. K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. For CASSANDRA FISHBEIN, 17-7075, SHELLEY LYTLE, 17-7061, LYNN ROLFE, 17-7072, Plaintiffs: ANTHONY G. SIMON, BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, John G. For ELOISE FORET, 17-8939, REGINA MORGAN, 17- Simon, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT 8941, Plaintiffs: JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE SIMON LAW ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO; ERIC D. PEARSON, LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; USDC-NJ BAR HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARON IRVING, TX. & BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, For TONYA ARMITAGE, [*177] 17-10659, BERNITA LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & CHARLIE & Q BARBORKA, 17-5719, JONI pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. BARNHART, 17-5719, CAROL BROWER, 17-5719, LONDA COMBS, 17-5719, DIANE EVANS, 17-5719, LISA HARRIS, 17-10008, EVONNE HERRING, 17- For DEBBIE HAMMER, 17-8620, Plaintiff: JAMES G. 5719, DONNA HIGGINBOTHAM, 17-10010, PAULA ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON HOSALE, 17-10493, SUSAN ITURRERIA, 17-5719, O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; LAUREN MARCEL JONES-PURYEAR, 17-10016, LISA KELLEY, KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY 17-9504, THOMAS KERP, 17-5719 on behalf of ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, ESTATE OF SUSAN KERP, DECEASED, TINA MONTGOMERY, AL; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD KREMER, 17-10018, COLLEEN LABAT, 17-10023, ATTORNEY, ONDER [*179] AND SHELTON, L.L.C., ANNA LANDRY, 17-10024, TINA LOFLIN, 17-cv-10036, St. Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ANDREA MARTIN, 17-11191, MARY MALENICK, 17- ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & 9687, JACQUELINE MCGOUN, 17-11112, ETTA PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, MULDREW, 17-10043, KAREN NARCAVAGE, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & 10044, CHRISTINE PADILLA, 17-10045, ELOISE pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. POWERS, 17-5719, JOANNA J RAK, 17-5719, FRANK RAU, 17-9463, MARY BETH RAULSTON, 17-10046, Page 61 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *179

For MELISSA JARRETT, 17-10672, DWANA ROBY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MARLIN & SALTZMAN 17-10513, Plaintiffs: JAMES G. ONDER, WILLIAM LLP, AGOURA HILLS, CA. WYLIE BLAIR LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON For MARY JO BARCLIFF, 17-5999, ROBERT O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. Michael J. KENDALL, 17-5999, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. FIEBIGER, Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, Louis, MO; SEAN MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD MN. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MIAMI, FL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For RONICA DUNCAN, 17-5999 AND 17-11781, on BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. behalf of ESTATE OF MARY JO BARCLIFF, Plaintiff: LOUIS, MO. ERIC S. JOHNSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED [*181] TO USDC-NJ BAR, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, For BERTHA PRYOR, 17-8939, Plaintiff: JAMES G. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MN. STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD For DEBBIE BAKMAN, 17-5720, CHARLA BISHOP, 17- ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & 5720, OLLIE BOWEN, 17-10582, SHARON MCBEE, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. 17-5720; 18-14753, DONNA DOWE, 17-5720, WILLIAM GORDON, 17-5720, LYNDA GILBERT, 17-5720, KIMBERLY JETTON, 17-9570, JACQUELINE JOCK, For LINDA RABASCA, 17-9673, Plaintiff: JAMES G. 17-11186, DARLETTA KITHCART, 17-11091, ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON PATRICIA MARKS, 17-5720, KIMBERLY O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. MCCORMICK, 17-9571, CYNTHIA MEIER, 17-5720, Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND ADELLA OLSON, 17-9574, ELLEN ORTIZ, 17-5720, SHELTON, [*180] L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; STEPHANIE PATRICIA PEARSON, 17-9576, CHACKA RUFFIN, 17- LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON 10604, DEANNA PIERCE, 17-9578, NANCY POWELL, O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; STEVEN 17-5720, PATRICK SANCHEZ, 17-10479, LA RAYNE DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & STEENS, 17-5720, GLORIA WILKERSON, 17-5720, HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA; WILLIAM WYLIE CYNTHIA B. WILLIAMS, 17-9594, LAYMON DUNN, 17- BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON 10474, ROSE HEARD, 17-5720, ANNETTE LANDRUM, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. 17-5720, JUDITH MORTON, 17-9572, ROGER SULLIVAN, SR, 17-10584, DANIEL TRAMONTOZZI, For DEBORAH WILLIAMSON, 17-8596, Plaintiff: 17-5720, Plaintiffs: JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED [*182] TO USDC-NJ BAR, LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For MICHAEL MERRY, 17-5996, TAMI MERRY, 17- 5996, REBECCA CECIL, 17-5997, ALAN STEVEN LAZAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For JOSHUA CAIN, 17-6006, THOMAS A. Page 62 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *182

STALNAKER, 17-6010, Plaintiffs: PRISCILLA E. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & SPECTER PC, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PHILADELPHIA, PA. STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. For MICHELLE HAMMER-ALLEN, 17-8624, LATANYA LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD HEARVEY, 17-8630, KARAN ELAYNE LABRIOLA, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 9066, REGINA LYONS, 17-9138, Plaintiffs: JAMES G. BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY [*184] & ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For GABRIELLA TURI-MILIC, 17-6007, PATTY ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN MENHAL, 17-6370, MARY STALLWORTH, 17-6369, CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, ELIZABETH MORRELL, 17-6368, YVONNE WRAY, 17- MONTGOMERY, AL; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD 6371, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For SUGIRTHA DEVI RAJAMOHAN, 17-6012, Plaintiff: ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HEYGOOD ORR ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ & PEARSON, IRVING, TX. BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For SHAWNTA GIBSON, 17-6018, TERESA GIBSON, 17-6018, JULIET HARVEY, 17-6018, VIRGINIA MARIE For LENA HERNANDEZ, 17-9228, Plaintiff: JAMES G. THOMASON, 17-6020, BASSAN SALLOUM, 17-6201, ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MAUREEN SALLOUM, 17-6201, MARIA C COOK, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER 6202, GRISEL RODRIGUEZ-DIAZ, 17-6232, Plaintiffs: SHELTON [*183] O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FRANCISCO, CA. ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For TERRY DAILEY, 17-6046, BONNIE HENNLEIN, 17- ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. 6049, WAYNE HENNLEIN, 17-6049, MARY LOUIS, MO; T. MATTHEW LECKMAN, LEAD MCPARTLIN, 17-6050, THOMAS MCPARTLIN, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 6050, EDWARD MEDVED, 17-6052, PHYLLIS BAR, POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD, MEDVED, 17-6052, DAVID SCHEELE, 17-6057, CONSHOHOCKEN, PA; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD SUSAN SCHEELE, 17-6057, DYTON MATTHEWS, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 6063, MEGAN MATTHEWS, 17-6063, TIKA SCOTT, BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, 17-6070, JOANNE MORALE, 17-6073, ROBERT ST. LOUIS, MO. MORALE, 17-6073, KIMBERLY SNYDER, 17-6086, MICHAEL SNYDER, 17-6086, KAREN BURNS, 17- 6087, MARGIE SCHAPPERLE, 17-6088, MARK [*185] For HEATHER HERRIGES, 17-9056, PATRICIA SUE SCHAPPERLE, 17-6088, NILE DALEY, Personal HITZ, 17-9070, CAROL AUFMAN, 17-8845, Plaintiffs: Representative of the Estate of Robbin Daley, 17-6089, BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, NANCY QUINN, 17-6142, THOMAS QUINN, 17-6142, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Plaintiffs: DEREK T. BRASLOW, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES THE BRASLOW LAW FIRM, LLC, WAYNE, PA. PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, For SANDRA WILSON, 17-6043, Plaintiff: ADRIANA ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL Page 63 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *185

NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SKIKOS Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. CA. Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. For MICHAEL COWAN, 17-6058, LARKIN MARTINEZ, LOUIS, MO; STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD 17-6060, JENNY STONER, 17-6069, THOMAS ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MONCALIERI, 17-6071, on behalf of Eileen Moncalieri, BAR, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN; deceased, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ NOT ADMITTED [*187] TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For DAVID L. MIER, 17-6063, KIMBERLY L. MIER, 17- 6067, Plaintiffs: ANNE MEDLIN LOWE, WILLIAM N. For DEBORAH LEWANDOWSKI, 17-6091, Plaintiff: RILEY, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT MATTHEW RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, INDIANAPOLIS, IN. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX. For HARRY J. SCHEINFELD, 17-8955, DIANNA SUTHERLAND, 17-9815, GINGER YOUNG, 17-8539, For RUTH CARVER, 17-3549, Plaintiff: TAYJES Plaintiffs: JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For JEFFERY BROWN, 17-6139; INDIVIDUALLY, AND ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; AS REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF SHELIA PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BROWN, DECEASED, ROGERS BROWN, 17-6139, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED [*186] TO USDC-NJ BAR, LLOYD RICKS, 17-6302, ALVIN MEADOR, 17-6303, MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LOUIS, MO. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & For ELIZABETH FORD, 17-6140, Plaintiff: GRANT D. pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. AMEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW OFFICE OF GRANT D. AMEY For DANA ARENZ, 17-6074, RANDI LARSEN, 17-6206, LLC, FAIRHOPE, AL. Plaintiff: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For JERRY FERRIER, 17-6246, Plaintiff: BAR, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. CHRISTOPHER L. SCHNIEDERS, LEAD ATTORNEY, CVOUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For ALLISON ALLEN, 17-6082, SHERI TALBOTT, 17- WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO; 6078, TRACIE FEY, 17-6182, CATHERINE HAMPTON, WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC 17-6190, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For JAMES CLOUSER, 17-6258, CONNIE BIRMINGTON, 17-6257, Plaintiffs: PHILIP BOHRER, For MARK THOMAS, 17-11124, Plaintiff: JAMES G. LEAD ATTORNEY, BOHRER LAW FIRM. BATON ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ROUGE, LA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. For ANNE CHANDLER, 17-6280, DARLENE Page 64 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *187

GARNER, [*188] 17-6289, EULA HOLLEY, 17-6297, 6993, CAROL TAYLOR, 17-6354, ANA VALIAN, 17- MADELINE PARKER, 17-6308, LYNDA KINNAIRD, 17- 7089, DEBORAH VASQUEZ, 17-6975, BEVERLY 6307, MARCHELLE YVONNE GOLLIDAY, 17-6312, WARSHAWSKY, 17-6986, ROY ELDRIDGE, 17-6747, NANCY L. KITTLE, 17-6324, IMO LOIS NIXON BUNT, JANICE HILL, 17-6735, Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. 17-6329, TRACI J BURNS, 17-6344, WILMA POWELL, ASKEW, John G. Simon, LEAD ATTORNEYS, THE 17-6345, Plaintiffs: GARY A ANDERSON, LEAD SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ENVIRONMENTAL LITIGATION GROUP PC, For VALERIE MARTIN, 17-6384, JO ANNE FINN, 17- BIRMINGHAM, AL. 6548, MELISSA TAYLOR, 17-6558, PENNY GILBERTSON, 17-6576, PAUL CURTIS JOHNSON, For KASEY JOHNSON, 17-6313, Plaintiff: CATHERINE JR., 17-6583, on behalf of LINDA KETNER JOHNSON THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE CHERYL STARKS, 17-6592, GLADYS STRAIN, 17-cv- LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. 6663, GLADYS STRAIN, 17-cv-6663, MELISSA TAYLOR, 17-6558, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. For JACQUELINE GUNTHER, 17-6315, Plaintiff: NICOLE LAUREN BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR For FATIMA MIRROW, 17-6388, ERIK MIRROW, 17- VENTURA LAW, DANBURY, CT. 6388, as Heir of the Estate of Heidi, Mirrow Schulze, on behalf of Morris Seymour Mirrow, [*190] GINGER WELLS PENNINGTON, 17-6479, JONATHAN WELLS, For LORI K. WHITNEY, 17-6355 (Georgia), Plaintiff: 17-6479, MITZI WELLS, 17-6479, Plaintiffs: TIMOTHY Brian Weinstein, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT DALE BRANDENBURG, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAW ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, WEINSTEIN FIRM OF ROGER "ROCKY" WALTON PC, COUTURE PLLC, SEATTLE, WA. ARLINGTON, TX.

For BRIAN KNODEL, 17-6356, DAVID KNODEL, 17- For MARIE SHARKEY, 17-6407, MICHAEL SHARKEY, 6356, STEVEN KNODEL, 17-6356, Plaintiffs: KEVIN S. 17-6407, ASHLEY PERSICO, 17-6408, JOHN HANNON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT THOMAS TURNER, 17-6410, MONICA TURNER, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE HANNON LAW 6410, DWAYNE DUSKIN, Civil Case No. 3:17-cv- FIRM LLC, DENVER, CO. 06650, PATRICIA ROSS-DUSKIN, Civil Case No. 3:17- cv-06650, Plaintiffs: HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD For DENISE AUSTIN, 17-6965, Plaintiff: BENJAMIN R. ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR THE SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., LOUIS, MO; John G. Simon, LEAD For WENDY WOOLRIDGE, 17-6414, STACY ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- NEVAREZ, 17-6431, CHERYL JORDAN, 17-6686, NJ BAR, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., St. [*189] WALTER MAJESKI, 17-6764, JOY DAFOE, 17-6763 Louis, MO. AND 17-11389, ROBERT DAFOE, 17-6763 AND 17- 11389, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD For JULIA BARLOW, 17-6972, EDDIE BOZEMAN, 17- ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. 6996, GEORGE BUNTING, 17-7001, on behalf of ESTATE OF MARGARET BUNTING, BETTY C. For MICHAEL BOTCHIE, 17-6421, Plaintiff: David CAMPBELL, 17-6983, SANDRA DICARLO-WAKELEY, Joseph Dickens, LEAD ATTORNEY, The Miller Firm 17-7120, JUDITH EPPERSON, 17-6966, KAREN LLC, Orange, VA. HUDSON, 18-1409, CYNTHIA HUGHES, 17-6990 (Missouri), KARA LEON, 17-6991, LILLIE LEWIS, 17- 6354, DAWN LOBIANCO, 17-6974, CRYSTAL For JEAN BENECKE, 17-6423, JOHN BENECKE, 17- OWENS, 17-7117, LAWRENCE PETERSON, 17-6997, 6423, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, on behalf of ESTATE OF LORETTA PETERSON, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. DENISE RABURN, 17-6987, REGINA REYNOLDS, 17- Page 65 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *190

For BRIAN D. BAKKER, 17-6450, ALYSON P. MOAK, For STEPHEN HARTLEY, 17-6566, CATHERINE 17-6450, BARBARA J. MOAK, 17-6450, TYLER A. HARTLEY, 17-6566, PAULETTE LOCKE, 17-6568, MOAK, 17-6450, ZACHARY R. MOAK, 17-6450, CAREY BAUMGARTEN, 17-6504, JOSEPH BARBARA E. SINGER, 17-6483, TINA L. WOLF, 17- BAUMGARTEN, 17-6504, TERI WILLIAMS, 17-6520, 6534, KENNETH W. WRIGHT, 17-6534, [*191] WIN J. VERA SILVER, 17-6499, JANESE PERSON, 17-6644, WRIGHT, 17-6534, JORGE MARMOL, 17-6536, JULIA Plaintiffs: SEAN MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD REDONDO, 17-6536, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. ATTORNEY, MIAMI, FL. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. For EDWARD JASON, 17-6575, CYNTHIA FAIRCLOTH, 17-6740, LINDA SEMBLER, 17-6803; For ALJANETTE PERRY, 17-6470, ROCHELLE INDIVIDUALLY, AND AS REPRESENTATIVE OF THE JOHNSON SCOTT, 17-6478, CAMILLE GAVIN, 17- ESTATE OF SUSAN SEMBLER, DECEASED, 6484, SHEILA NORRIS, 17-6475, DAWN EMMONS, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD 17-6556, KAY PAYNE, 17-6502, DARYL PERKINS, 17- ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & 6594, PAULA COLE, 17-6525, DENISE STRONG, 17- PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. 6632, DARYL PERKINS, 17-6594, PAULA COLE, 17- 6525, DENISE STRONG, 17-6632, Plaintiffs: WARREN For STEPHANIE SYKES, 17-6569, Plaintiff: JENNIFER T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, A. LENZE, LEAD ATTORNEY, LENZE MOSS PLC, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. MANHATTAN BEACH, CA.

For DOUGLAS W. NELSON, 17-6471, Plaintiff: SCOTT For ROBERT SNYDER, 17-6510, SHARON SNYDER, ANDREW KITNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, STANLEY LAW 17-6510 (Michigan), Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ GROUP, DALLAS, TX. DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For SHALETTA ALSTON, 17-6473, EDWARD THOMAS KEATING, 17-6476, DAVID FRANK SOFI, For JOANNA WALLBILLICH, 17-6512, Plaintiff: JOHN 17-6505, MICHAEL ROBERTS, 17-6503, Plaintiffs: D. SILEO, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEW ORLEANS, LA. JAMES LAMAR WARD, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, MCGOWAN HOOD & FELDER LLC, MOUNT PLEASANT, SC. For RHONDA KAYE DEAN, 17-6586 AND, 17-6761, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL; TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, For HORACE E LUMPKIN, 17-6492, Plaintiff: MICHAEL LEAD ATTORNEY, [*193] THE MILLER FIRM LLC, JAMES WILLIAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, CELLINO & ORANGE, VA. BARNES, BUFFALO, NY.

For ANITA DAVIDSON, 17-6604, TAMARA DUROVEY, For MARILYN JOYCE, 17-6495, JANET MARIE 17-6606, LIBBY MCQUAIN, 17-6616, CHRISTY EDWARDS, 17-06611, Plaintiff: DAVID T. MATHEWS, GRIFFEE, 17-cv-6615, DENA BELCHER, 17-6602, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN.

For DAVONNA MOSS, 17-6543, Plaintiff: DANIEL R. For TAWANA G BOSTIC, 17-6608, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. SEIDMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*192] SEIDMAN MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller MARGULIS & FAIRMAN LLP, BELLEVILLE, IL. Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA.

For ALMA MARTINEZ, 17-6545, PHILIP MARTINEZ, For GREG COWAN, 17-6610, DANIEL BEARDSLEY, 17-6545, Plaintiff: DAVID J. DIAMOND, LEAD 17-6618, MITCHELL WEISBERG, 3:17-cv-6613, ATTORNEY, GOLDBERG & OSBORNE, TUCSON, AZ. VICTOR RIVERA, 17-6621, GEORGE HAUG, 17-cv- 6656, DALE L. ANSPACH, JR., Civil Case No. 3:17-cv- Page 66 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *193

6651, REBECCA ANSPACH, Civil Case No. 3:17-cv- YEOL LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN 6651, DWAYNE SMITH, 17-6666, KATHRYN SMITH, LIEBHARD LLP, NEW YORK, NY. 17-6666 (Ridgeville, SC), ANTOINETTE PRUNTY, 17- cv-6658, ROBERT PRUNTY, 17-cv-6658, JANET For JACK NIEDERMAYER, 17-cv-6617, ROBIN ELROD, 17-6678, JUDY DEBAUN, 17-cv-6682, MARIA NIEDERMAYER, 17-cv-6617, Plaintiffs: JAMES DEANN SHIELDS-MARLEY, 17-6684, CAMI MARIE DOUGLAS BARGER MDL, LEAD ATTORNEY, RAMIREZ, 17-6687, LISA WISNIOWICZ, 17-cv-6691, AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ PLLC, CATHY PORTER, 17-6728, JOHN CUSHMAN, 17- PENSACOLA, FL. 6716, DALE SAUSMAN, 17-6741, BRUCE DESOTELL, 17-6742, JULIE DESOTELL, 17-6742, BOBBY BURNETT, JR, 17-6744, KELLY KILMAN, 17-6745, For DEBRA OSBORNE, 17-6643, Plaintiff: MARK P PATRICA LAWRENCE, 17-6751, RONALD WINGET, ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEWPORT 17-6607, JOHNNY EARL OWEN, 17-6696, HOBERT BEACH, CA. LEE VANOVER, 17-6791, individually and on behalf of Terresa Vanover's and the Estate of [*194] Terresa For DIANA ZITELLA, 17-cv-6683, Plaintiff: ANTHONY Vanover, BRIAN EDGE, 17-6794, WALLACE V. G. SIMON, BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD LINSEY, 17-cv-6795, MAUDE HARRIS, 17-cv-6796, ATTORNEYS, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. DAVID C. MYERS, 17-cv-6799, Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. LOUIS, MO. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. For JAMES ZITELLA, 17-cv-6683, DONALD MOFFITT, 17-6685, JOHN KOSZALKOWSKI, 17-6688, MICHAEL For ROBERT GREENBERG, 17-6605, MARY LOUISE BELL, 17-6748, CHARLES GRISSOM, 17-6736, DIXON, 17-6640, L. DIXON RICHARD, 17-6640, THOMAS MCCALLA, 17-6743, Plaintiffs: ANTHONY G. PAMELA J RIZZI, 17-6649, RICHARD A. MAYS, 17-cv- SIMON, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, 6657, on behalf of ESTATE OF MARGARET JOANN P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. MAYS, ROGER MAYS, 17-cv-6657, on behalf of ESTATE OF MARGARET JOANN MAYS, MARGARET L WEBSTER, Civil Case No. 3:17-cv-06654, YAVONNE For ILENE YOUNG, 17-06708, FARINA SCOTT, 17- CAROLYN CUNNINGHAM, 17-cv-6662, Plaintiffs: M. 06709, JESSE WEST, 17-06711, surviving spouse of BRANDON SMITH, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHILDERS Tanya Renae Brookshire, deceased, Plaintiffs: SCHLUETER & SMITH LLC, ATLANTA, GA. MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For MIKE WALKER, 17-6609, Plaintiff: AMANDA LYNN WASHINGTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, MCGLYNN GLISSON & MOUTON, BATON ROUGE, LA. For LEWIS N MYERS, Individually, and as Administrator of the Estate of Phyllis Myers 17-6786, JOYCE E. KUDEK, 17-6788, ROGER R. KUDEK, 17-6788, For ABBIE WEISBERG, 3:17-cv-6613, ANA RIVERA, Plaintiffs: [*196] CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD 17-cv-6621, LAURA HAUG, 17-cv-6656, ZINA ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. KOSZALKOWSKI, 17-6688, ADRIANA CIANCIO, 16-cv- 6692, DAISY JOHANSEN, 17-6722, the Personal Representative of Maria Johansen's Estate, ALICIA For JOE SMITH, 17-6800, individually and on behalf of GRISSOM, 17-6736, ATHALA KING, 17-6738, ROSIE Beverleigh Smith and the Estate of Beverleigh Smith, LOPEZ, 17-6739, LESLIE SAUSMAN, 17-6741, EMMA KRISTINE SYMES, 17-6862, FRANK LOBIANCO, 17- JEAN MCCALLA, 17-6743, MARYLADENE PRINGLE, 6974, JOHN BARLOW, 17-6972, VEARL CAMPBELL, 17-6766, REGENIA BREWER, 17-6797, Plaintiffs: 17-6983, MARGARET CARNEY, 17-6986, ROBERT ANTHONY G. SIMON, BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, [*195] WARSHAWSKY, 17-6986, DANNY RABURN, 17-6987, John G. Simon, LEAD ATTORNEYS, THE SIMON LAW JAMES HUGHES, 17-6990 (Missouri), ALFRED LEON, FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. 17-6991, JENNIFER LEITNER, 17-6976, F.B. BOZEMAN, JR., 17-6996, RICHARD ENGLE, 17-6978 on behalf of ESTATE OF MARY ENGLE, KARI For TAMMY BOHANNON, 17-cv-6597, Plaintiff: DAE TAYLOR KILE, 17-6999, DOUGLAS PASTERNACK, Page 67 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *196

17-7010 on behalf of ESTATE OF BEVERLY For CAROLYN A CLEAR, 17-6839, KARLA S PASTERNACK, MARIE CORLEY, 17-7042, VIRO GONZALEZ, 17-7170, DEBRA E JACKSON, 17-7493, VALIAN, 17-7089, LISA RILEY, 17-7118, Plaintiffs: Plaintiffs: ANDREW FRANK SULLO, LEAD BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE ATTORNEY, SULLO & SULLO LLP, HOUSTON, TX. SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. For CHRISTINE ANNE SENEROTE, 17-6847, MARY For CAROLYN DIANE PERKOLA, 17-6835, CHRISTY ANN ROGERS, 17-7004, SABRINA ALLEN, 17-cv- NEESE, 17-7075, CYNTHIA ROBINSON, 17-7075, 7339, SAMANTHA ALLEN, 17-cv-7339, SAMUEL AMANI WELLS ONYIOHA, 17-7137, ANNA SKINNER, WAYNE ALLEN, 17-cv-7339, Plaintiffs: TIMOTHY DALE 17-7137, DONALD JOYNER, 17-7431, ERNEST BRANDENBURG, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAW FIRM OF MAZUREK, JR., 17-7423 on behalf of ELLEN ROGER "ROCKY" WALTON PC, ARLINGTON, TX. MAZUREK, ERNEST MAZUREK, III, 17-7423 on behalf of ELLEN MAZUREK, AMANDA ZERMANANN, 17- For MELISSA ELLIS, 17-6861, MARITZA LOPEZ, 17- 7423, BOBBY SIMMONS, 17-7424 on behalf of NANCY 6867, CATHY CRAWFORD, 17-6878, REBECCA SIMMONS, DECEASED, SALANDRIA STEVENSON, OSWALT, 17-6880, LAURA JO SHELTON, 17-6890, 17-7439, LEONARD LEE SPANN, 17-7436 on WITALY KASTANAS, 17-6937, GERALD ANDERSON, behalf [*197] of SHERRIE SPANN, DECEASED, 17-6950, MERCEDES WHITLEY, 17-7154, JERRY RAMONA BECKS CARSON, 17-7444, Plaintiffs: ERIC FLORES, SR, 17-7235, TOM SCHULZ, 17-7237 on D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & behalf of JoAnn Schulz, deceased, JOYCE PEARSON, IRVING, TX. BORCHARDT, 17-7318, DEBRA FRANK, 17-7321, MELBA LANDEROS, 17-7325, NORMA WHATLEY, 17- For KERRY ANNIS, 17-6836, CINDY BASSETT, 17- 7326, KAY ALFORD, 17-7426, JANET HARRIS, 17- 7357, MICHELLE ASHLOCK, 17-7362, WENDY 7510, BARBARA CHANEY, 17-7513, KAREN CLUTS, CREAMER-ZINTEL, 17-7366, ABPAHECIDO DOS 17-7527, ADELA DE CORO DE LOZA, 17-7533, REIS, 17-7367, CLEIDE DOS REIS, 17-7367, GERARD Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD DUBE, 17-7369, SUSAN DUBE, 17-7369, GRACIELA ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. EURIBE, 17-7372, PATRICIA GAITANOS, 17-7373, KAREN GORDON, 17-7375, SCOTT BASSETT, 17- For ANNIE CLAYBORNE, 17-6869, JOSEPH APELIAN, 7357, MARY JO CARLSON, 17-7365, REBECCA 17-7016, [*199] LISA BOYNE, 17-7068, PATRICIA YOUNG, 17-7353, THEODORE MCCARVER, 17-7407, WAMSLEY, 17-7334, BRIDGET CUMMINGS, 17-7359, TRACY MCCARVER, 17-7407, KELLY MOYER, 17- ROGER CUMMINGS, 17-7350, Plaintiffs: TAYJES 7408, BARBARA J. NEWTON, 17-7409, ROBERT MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER GARY O'KELLEY, 17-7413, SHERRI O'KELLEY, 17- FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. 7413, FERMIN PINA, 17-7414, MARGIE PINA, 17- 7414, MARCY RAINDORF, 17-7416, CHARLES GRIFFIN, 17-7403, KAREN GRIFFIN, 17-7403, SHEILA For CATHEY CHAMPAGNE, 17-6882, MARK HOINES-MEAD, 17-7404, REBEKAH HOYT, 17-7405, CHAMPAGNE, 17-6882, BARBARA VAN VOORHIS, TARSHA MARTIN, 17-7406, LEE SNEAD, 17-7461, 17-6893, ROGER VAN VOORHIS, 17-6893, Plaintiff: VANESSA SNEAD, 17-7461, CHRISTY STRUKEL, 17- ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BRANCH LAW 7463, KRISTA UPTON, 17-7464, EMMA WILLIAMS, FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. 17-7465 (Conley, Georgia), ERIC WILLIAMS, 17-7465, MARTHA WILLIAMSON, 17-7467, DEBORAH WYLLIE, For MERLYN BONTY, 17-6916, KISHA SCOTT, 17- 17-7468, DIANE RICE, 17-7455, MERRY ROE, 17- 6916, MELANIE O'CONNOR, 17-6917, LINDA BALL, 7456, REBECCA SALTERS, 17-7457, KERRI 17-6918, JO-ANN STUCHENKO-SPARKS, 17-6919, SEEKINS, 17-7458, NATHAN BOEHM, 17-7557, GERALDINE SAUNDERS, 17-7255, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. NICOLE BOEHM, 17-7557, ROXANNE [*198] COKER, FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON BECKER 17-7558, DEBORAH DIONESOTES, 17-7560, PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. JENNIFER LAWSON, 17-7562, DAVID RYZHLICK, 17- 7562, Plaintiffs: MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For WILLIAM L SMITH, 17-6920 on behalf of ESTATE OF CHERYL A. RENNIE-SMITH, Plaintiff: MICHAEL S. Page 68 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *199

WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PARKER WAICHMAN For JULIE CARNES, 17-7055, Plaintiff: NICHOLAS W. LLP, WASHINGTON, NY. MAYLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, KILLIAN DAVIS RICHTER & MAYLE PC, GRAND JUNCTION, CO. For MELISSA DEES, 17-6940, Plaintiff: ERIC D. HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLAND GROVES For OLGUITA BERNSTEIN, 17-7043, RHONDA SCHNELLER & STOLZE LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. SAWYER-DEAQUINO, [*201] 17-7047, Plaintiffs: KATHERINE BARRETT RILEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. For TABETHA GRAY, 17-6942, JOSEPHINE RITA OAKES, 17-6968, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LEVENSTEN For CLARENCE EDWARDS, 17-7048, DARLENE LAW FIRM PC, Philadelphia, PA. EDWARDS, 17-7048, MARLIN RUPP, 17-7421, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. For CYNTHIA LEAMAN FRANK, 17-6944, Plaintiff: CARY LITTLEJOHN, LEAD ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. For LINDA HAYS, 17-7065 (Tennessee), EMILY VINSON, 17-7066, Plaintiffs: ANTHONY G. SIMON, BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, John G. Simon, LEAD For SARAH L SMITH, 17-6984, BELINDA TURNER, 17- ATTORNEYS, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. 6992, [*200] JOAN MCEUEN, 17-6995, MARTHA L LOUIS, MO; ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAWRENCE, 17-6982, RON PALMER, 17-7051 on HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX. behalf of ESTATE OF BARBARA PALMER, Plaintiffs: BRANDI R. HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BARRETT LAW GROUP PA, LEXINGTON, MS. For NATASHA HELVESTON, 17-7067, BARBARA JEAN STEWART, 17-7116, GERALDINE STEPHENS, 17-7164, WANDA BARTON, 17-7281, CYNTHIA For THERESA HAYDEN, 17-7000, GLORIA SUE MCDEAVITT, 17-7283, DEBORAH STEWART, 17- MARTIN, 17-7274, KELLY DAVIS, 17-7285, Plaintiffs: 7287, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD SARAH STERLING STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, DON ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. DALLAS, TX.

For EDDIE DEAN DERRICK, 17-7014 on behalf of For BARBARA HALL, 17-7099 (Wyoming), Plaintiff: SHIRLEY MAE DERRICK, DECEASED, Plaintiff: JOHN F. FOLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, SIMMONBS DAVID MALCOLM MCMULLAN, JR., LEAD HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL; TRENT B. MIRACLE, ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. LEAD ATTORNEY, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. For ANTHONY JOEY HODGES, 17-7032, JACK HODGES, 17-7032, TIFFANY HODGES, 17-7032, For CURTIS GUSTAFSON, 17-7112 on behalf of ANDREW M. SIEJA, 17-7032, ANGELITA OSUNA MARILYN GUSTAFSON, DECEASED, Plaintiff: GOMEZ, 17-7175, ELIJAH LOUIS GOMEZ, 17-7175, RICHARD BARRETT, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEARNED, JORGE GOMEZ, 17-7175, TRINITY HUERTA, 17-7175, MS. Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. For LISA A HERBICK, 17-7146, Plaintiff: GREGORY S. SPIZER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ANAPOL WEISS, Philadelphia, PA. For MICHAEL SUCHOMEL, 17-7033, GREGORY TAPLEY, 17-7211, ANDREW CILIBERTO, 17-7345, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD For MARIA GARZA, 17-7165, [*202] RONALD E. ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & FUNG, 17-7190, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL RAY CLINTON, PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. LEAD ATTORNEY, BLIZZARD & NABERS LLP, HOUSTON, TX. Page 69 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *202

ATTORNEY, POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD, CONSHOHOCKEN, PA. For LAVINIA BENSON, 17-7188, MERRITT F. BENSON, JR., 17-7188, Plaintiffs: HAYTHAM FARAJ, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARTINIAN & ASSOCIATES, INC., For DIANE SCOVENS, 17-7179 AND 18-00567, LOS ANGELES, CA. Plaintiff: BRETT A. EMISON, LEAD ATTORNEY, LANGDON & EMISON LLC, LEXINGTON, MO; ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON BECKER For KRISTIE MCCONAHIE-GEORGE, 17-7205, PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. Plaintiff: TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. For DOLORES SHEA, Plaintiff: LYNNE M. KIZIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, WILENTZ, GOLDMAN & SPITZER, PA, For TRUDY A. LEHMAN, 17-7195, Plaintiff: MICHAEL WOODBRIDGE, NJ. JOHN SOBIERAY, LEAD ATTORNEY, STEWART & STEWART, CARMEL, IN. For MARY ELLEN SZWEJKOWSKI, 17-7378, THOMAS SZWEJKOWSKI, 17-7378, Plaintiff: ALAN STEVEN For KENNETH L JENKINS, 17-7215, Plaintiff: BILL B. LAZAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARLIN & SALTZMAN BERKE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERKE LAW FIRM PA, LLP, AGOURA HILLS, CA. CAPE CORAL, FL.

For FRANKLIN L JONES, JR., INDIVIDUALLY AND AS For LEON BAGLEY, 17-7228, ROSEMARIE PACILLI, EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF ELSIE C. JONES 17-7231, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD (DECEASED) 17-7352, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, CELLINO & BARNES DALLAS, TX. PC, BUFFALO, NY.

For MARTHA COMBS, 17-7240 formerly known as For MARY BURLEIGH, 17-7440, JULIANNE MARTHA KLEMETSON, Plaintiff: HENRY G. GIANCURSIO, 17-7442, MARY JONES, 17-7443 GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME (Alabama), BARBARA HALL, 17-7445 (New York), AMY BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA. SCHMALZ, 17-7462, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, For MARY LOUISE GUIDRY, 17-7260, TERRI J. WASHINGTON, DC. HOLLOWAY, 17-7519, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. For JENNA RAY, 17-7446 AND 18-01561, [*204] PLEASANT, SC. Plaintiff: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY; For EUGENIA WATTS, 17-7282, Plaintiff: CARYN MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. For CARMEL HINES, 17-7481, Plaintiff: STEVEN For NORMA HOLSTROM, 17-7296, Plaintiff: BRADLEY DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & DEAN HONNOLD, [*203] LEAD ATTORNEY, Goza & HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. Honnold, LLC, Overland Park, KS. For DEBRA LYNN KACZMAREK, 17-7522, THE For MARY BETHDA, 17-7327, Plaintiff: THOMAS P. ESTATE OF BERTHA ALEXANDER, 17-7544, RHETA CARTMELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & M RULAND, 17-7547, Plaintiffs: JOHN RANDOLPH CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, SLACK & DAVIS LLP, AUSTIN, TX.

For LYNNE FAZIO, 17-7292, KEVIN KREUSLING, 17- 7292, Plaintiff: T. MATTHEW LECKMAN, LEAD For CHASTITY S REED, 17-7530, Plaintiff: KIMBERLY Page 70 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *204

WILSON WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, WILSON LAW PA, RALEIGH, NC. For FREDERICK REYNOLDS, 17-7594, Plaintiff: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For KAREN NILAN 17-7563, MARY RUSSELL 17-7564, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALICE SEALE, 17-7565, EUGENE SEALE, 17-7565, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. LINDA SULLIVAN, 17-7566, MICHAEL SULLIVAN, 17- 7566, JANICE WILLIAMS, 17-7567, DAVID CAHN, 17- For DENISE BAIRO, 17-7619, MARK A. CABRAL, 17- 7568, LORNA CAHN, 17-7568, Plaintiffs: MEKEL 7619, MARK CABRAL, JR., 17-7619, STEPHEN SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT CABRAL, [*206] 17-7619, SUZETTE C. RODRIQUEZ, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For CYNTHIA CARTER 17-7548, Plaintiff: JENNIFER BAR, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., A. MOORE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LOS ANGELES, CA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOORE LAW GROUP PLLC, LOUISVILLE, KY. For LAURANCE E ANDERSON, 17-2943, Plaintiff: SARAH STERLING STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, For KENNETH BORNY, 17-7555, DIANA L SMITH, 17- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON 7772, ANGLIA PENTECOST, 17-7959, PATRICIA BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. FORRESTER, 17-7960, LESLY SANTIAGO, 17-7961, REGINA SHELTON, 17-7962, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE For DEANNA ADDISON, 17-7644, LYNDA WEBER, 17- LYNN RADOS, LEAD [*205] ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 7758, LINDA MARIE BOZIC, 17-7760, Plaintiffs: NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX.

For CYNTHIA SKONORD, 17-7571, Plaintiff: TIMOTHY For SENATOR CHRIS SMITH, LINDA YARDEN, S. TRECEK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Plaintiffs: Brian Alan Goldstein, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HABUSH HABUSH & Cellino & Barnes, P.C. (NYC), New York, NY. ROTTIER SC, MILWAUKEE, WI.

For TONI L FANFA, 17-7646, Plaintiff: NICOLE For DAWN DIMARINO, 17-7587, KARON BRUBAKER, LAUREN BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 17-7578, PETER BRUBAKER, 17-7578, KIMBERLY NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, VENTURA LAW, CHESTNUT, 17-7581, DAVID CARLIN, 17-7582, DANBURY, CT. DAWN ROLLER, 17-7582, CYNTHIA RUIZ, 17-7584, RIGOBERTO RUIZ, 17-7584, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER For LINDA BROCCOLI, 17-7674, JANICE ALLISON, FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. 17-7679, Plaintiffs: TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. For PAMELA STANEK, 17-7576, VAN SLAMES, 17- 7579, ZORA EURE, 17-7685, KERESA RICHARDSON, 17-7736, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For LINDA MICHAELIS, 17-7692, LIZABETH MILLER, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 17-7694, Plaintiffs: STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. For ARGIRIOS SOULIOS, 17-7635; individually and as Executor of the Estate of Deborah Soulios, deceased on behalf of DEBORAH SOULIOS, DECEASED, Plaintiff: For ELEANOR PIMENTEL, 17-7705, LISA A. RICHARD R. BARRETT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MCLAUGHLIN, 17-7706, Plaintiffs: CARMEN COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD [*207] ATTORNEY, LEXINGTON, MS. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Page 71 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *207

MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PRIBANIC & PRIBANIC, WHITE OAK, PA. For CAROLE MAE CORRALEJO, 17-7713, ANTWANZA WOODEN, 17-cv-7715, Plaintiffs: For CYNTHIA ALBANESE, 17-7801, CYNTHIA MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, COUNSEL NOT CABRERA, 17-7804, SABRINA CARMACK, 17-7805, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES, KATHLEEN , 17-7808, TRACY WILLIAMS, 17- BUFFALO, NY. 7831, ROXY FRY, 17-7810, LISA GARNES, 17-7824 and 17-9251, TONYA MINNA, 17-7827, Plaintiffs: TOMISLAV GEORGE ANTUNOVICH, LEAD For KELLY DAZEY, 17-7723, PAUL DAZEY, SR., 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 07723, HEATHER DUARTE, 17-7724, Plaintiffs: BRIAN BAR, BISNAR CHASE, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; DENA YOUNG, LEAD For LAVINIA ORECCHIA, 17-7811, KATHRYN SMITH, ATTORNEY, WEITZ & LUXENBERG, P.C., CHERRY 17-7815 (West , OH), Plaintiffs: PATRICK HILL, NJ; MARK ALAN HOFFMAN, SCOTT S KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BERGER, JR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ROSS FELLER ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL CASEY, LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA. LLP, WASHINGTON, DC.

For JENNIFER PUCILOSKI, 17-7728, SUSAN JONES, For BROOK ALLISON HENRY, 17-7822, [*209] 17-7766 (Florida), EDGAR C JONES, JR., 17-7766, BRADY DOUGLAS WILLIAMS, 17-7822, DALE CHRISTOPHER VINTON, 17-7777, STEPHANIE WILLIAMS, 17-7822, on behalf of, ESTATE OF BARBY VINTON, 17-7777, SANDI BABCOCK, 17-7778, BRENT WILLIAMS, DECEASED, Plaintiffs: JOHN RANDOLPH BENBOW, 17-7781, CHRISTY BENBOW, 17-7781, DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT CHERYL COOPER, 17-7785, CLAUDIA CRANDALL, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SLACK & DAVIS LLP, 17-7789, ROGER CRANDALL, 17-7789, Plaintiffs: AUSTIN, TX. MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW For CRAIG C JENSEN, 17-7915, Plaintiffs: J. DEVLAN ORLEANS, LA. GEDDES, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GOETZ BALDWIN & For CORINNE BAXTER, 17-7780, ALAN CHANEY, 17- GEDDES PC, BOZEMAN, MT. 7783, KRISTI CHANEY, 17-7783, MICHELLE CHARTIER, 17-7784, DONNA GORMAN, Civil Case For GLYNNDA L. DAVIS, 17-7903, LAWRENCE No. 3:17-cv-07857, JOSEPH GORMAN, JR., Civil Case , 17-7936, YASMIN SYED, 17-7931, No. [*208] 3:17-cv-07857, JENNIFER GRIFFITH, Civil CHERYL TIPTON, 17-7935, Plaintiffs: KRISTIE MARIE Case No. 3:17-cv-07856, MICHAEL GRIFFITH, Civil HIGHTOWER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Case No. 3:17-cv-07856, Plaintiffs: MEKEL SMITH ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LUNDY LUNDY ALVAREZ, DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD SOILEAU & SOUTH LLP, LAKE CHARLES, LA. ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For DEANNA ORLANDO, JOHN ORLANDO, Plaintiffs: HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For JENNIFER LEO, 17-7798, MICHAEL LEO, 17-7798, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATHENS, GA. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. For LISA RONEY, 17-7925, TIMOTHY RONEY, 17- 7925, Plaintiffs: CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD For ALFORD IANUALE, 17-7776; husband, JENNIFER ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ J. IANUALE, 17-7776, Plaintiffs: ERNEST J. PRIBANIC, BAR, MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. VICTOR H. PRIBANIC, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Page 72 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *209

For CAROL SHERMAN, 17-8068, Plaintiff: SEAN COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL HAUSFELD LLP, BOSTON, MA. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MIAMI, FL. For MICHELE PULASKI, 17-8289, Plaintiff: CHRISTINA For PAUL HENAULT, 17-8006, CHERYL HILL, 17- MARIE GRAZIANO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 8007, DAN COURSE, 17-8009, CATHY FLYNN, 17- NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, 7846, DEBRA MCBRAYER, 17-8087, SHANNON WASHINGTON, DC; JAMES D. GOTZ, STEVEN B. WEST [*210] TURNER, 17-8217, MICHAEL J. ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT OVERTON, 17-8218, SHERYL NEWMAN OVERTON, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, 17-8218, ROBERTA OKERSON, 17-8219, RINA BOSTON, MA; RACHEL BETH ABRAMS, LEAD STICKLER, 17-8228, MANUEL PEREZ, 17-8229, ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN DAYMARA RAMON, 17-8229, PATRICIA PHEIFER, 17- FRANCISCO, CA. cv-8220, LORILYN PHILLIPS, 17-cv-8221, BETTY ALLDAY, 17-8436, PAULA ATKINSON, 17-8445, RITA For SANDY MERKURIS, 17-8088, SAFFRA MILANO, GARRETT, 17-cv-8437, JUDITH FAYNE, 17-cv-8438, 17-8089, ALVIN ENGLISH, 17-7845, LESLIE ENGLISH, JENNIFER COLELLA, 17-cv-8439, MATTHEW 17-7845, DEROME MILLS, 17-8090, SYBIL MILLS, 17- COLELLA, 17-cv-8439, GINA BURTTRAM, 17-cv-8441, 8090, TEANICKE SULLIVAN, ANNA LIVELY, 17-8093, Plaintiffs: MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD PATRICIA A. DAVIS, 17-8095, TERESA DELAROSA, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ RALPH JACK PHILLIPS, III, 17-cv-8221, LYNN BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. PULCINI, 17-cv-8224, LIYA SHATASHVILI, 17-cv-8226, LISA SIMMONS, 17-cv-8227, Plaintiffs: DOUGLAS For SYLVIA HUNT, 17-8070, Plaintiff: FRANK C. ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL PANETTA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE DUGAN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MASSIMO & PANETTA LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; MEKEL SMITH PC, MINEOLA, NY. ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For JEANETTE PAWLOW, 17-8071, HEATHER MITCHELL, 17-8073, Plaintiffs: PATRICK KELLY For [*212] DIANE MILLER, 17-7839, Plaintiff: KRISTIE LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MARIE HIGHTOWER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR ASHCRAFT & GEREL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LUNDY LUNDY LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. SOILEAU & SOUTH LLP, LAKE CHARLES, LA.

For CHERYL HAYNES, 17-8085, FOREST HAYNES, For MARGARET O'BRIEN, 17-8094, HELENA 17-8085, RICK BURKEY, 17-8086, Plaintiffs: MEKEL SPEARS-HAMILTON, 17-8124 formerly known as SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT HELENA SPEARS, MARK WHEELER, 17-8172, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. SANDRA WILLIAMS, 17-8174 (Texas), Plaintiffs: HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For DARLINE BURKEY, 17-8086 AND 18-1457, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Plaintiff: MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATHENS, GA. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA; WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, [*211] BURNS For SARITA HOUSTON, 17-8083, SHARON HAYES, CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. 17-8248, LAURA BUCHITE, 17-8330, CAROLE NORMADIN, 17-8346, CYNTHIA COGAN, 17-8331, DONNA R DAVIS, 17-8332, DONNA R DAVIS, 17- For KIMBERLY BOYKINS, 17-8268, Plaintiff: 8332, BILLIE BRAMEN, 17-8356, LINDA DEPAULO- CHRISTINA MARIE GRAZIANO, LEAD ATTORNEY, HARGRAVES, 17-8333, KAREN GREENE, 17-8335, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DEBIE GRILLO, 17-8336, DENISE JANSEN, 17-8339, HAUSFELD LLP, WASHINGTON, DC; JAMES D. KATHLEEN GRACE JENKINS, 17-8340, TERRI GOTZ, STEVEN B. ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, JONESOF, 17-8341, FAY DILLARD, 17-cv-08334, Page 73 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *212

ROSAL LOUDERBOUGH, 17-8342, MICHELE LEE GIBSON, 17-8212, ANN GORDON, 17-8213, ROBERTS, 17-8351 (New York), MICHELLE KIMBERLY FANCIULLO, 17-8319, CHRISTINE MCCOMBS, 17-8414, NANCY ROE, 17-8415, BOBBY JUDKINS, 17-cv-8320, KAY DAWSON, 17-cv-8322, PORTER, 17-8215, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN ROBERTA MORELLO, 17-8323, SHIRLEY RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT STRICKLAND, 17-cv-8324, CARROL JANAK, 17-cv- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON 8327, JUDY MACDONALD, 17-8420, NICOLE O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. RAPOSO, 17-8423, MARI WOOLDRIDGE, 17-8424, JANICE BAILEY, 17-8425, ROSALIE JOHNSON, 17- 8427, MICHELLE KIRBY 17-8428, LYNNE SMITH, 17- For LINDA REMMER, 17-8103, SUSAN WINTERS, 17- 8430, DANIEL SMITH, 17-8430, JOHN SWEENEY, 17- 8077, BOBBIE STEPHENS, 17-8108, LAWANDA 8431, DAVID CLARKE, 17-8432, LINDA CLARKE, 17- ILENE GORE, [*213] 17-8123, GERTIE LUCAS, 17- 8432, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, 8112, JAMES NAPIER, 17-8126 (West Virginia) on LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW behalf of DONNA NAPIER, KATHLEEN COURTER, 17- YORK, NY. 8129, MARY LABOK, 17-8132, WILLADEAN DUFF, 17- 8116, JOYLENE KUHN, GLENDA FAYE BRANCH, 17- 8133, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For BRIAN MCDONALD, 17-8154, LAURA ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MCDONALD, 17-8154, TERESA COLLINS, 17-8157, BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. CHRISTINA M. HOFF, 17-8401, DALE K. HOFF, 17- 8401, DEBORAH ELLIS, 17-cv-8394, JACKIE BULLARD, 17-8411, CAROLYN VICKERSTAFF, 17- For DONNA HETHERINGTON, 17-8076, SHIRLEY 8412, PATRICIA WEATHERWAX, 17-8410, EMMA DAVIS, 17-cv-8397, SHARON ROY, 17-cv-8398, WILLIAMS, 17-8413 (Livonia, MI), EVA NELSON, 17- Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD 8416, VALERIE WOOD, 17-8419, Plaintiffs: MATTHEW ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FEARS For CAREN ELLISON, 17-8836, Plaintiff: PATRICIA NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX. LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; For AARON JEFFERS, 17-8159, JEFFREY DAVID STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PEASE, 17-8158, SHAUNA CHARMAINE PEASE, 17- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 8158, Plaintiffs: [*215] MEGHAN ELIZABETH ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES LOUIS, MO. ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA.

For RUGINER CHRISTIAN, 17-8122, Plaintiff: DAVID T. For JUDITH ANDERSON, 17-8170, 17-10452, Plaintiff: MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; SEAN MICHAEL CLEARY, For BARBARA BRIGMAN, 17-8135, ROSALYN LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ANDERSON, 17-8140, JOAN LEE IKEMOTO, 17-8141, USDC-NJ BAR, MIAMI, FL. DELORES JAY, 17-8144, DINA PALACIOS, 17-8145, Plaintiffs: STEFAN BJORN FEIDLER, LEAD For KATHRYN MCCLURG, 17-8147, THOMAS ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MCCLURG, 17-8147, THELMA ROSENBERG, 17- BAR, ANASTOPOULO LAW FIRM, CHARLESTON, 8272, LORI DEMAILLE-SMITH, 17-8302, JEFFREY SC. SMITH, 17-8302, Plaintiffs: SEAN MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO For LAURIE LANDRUM, 17-8137, MINA LEON, 17- USDC-NJ BAR, MIAMI, FL. 8210, CATHY HAWKINS-PANEK, [*214] 17-8211, JOYCE FOX, 17-cv-8307, SUZANNE BELLOTTO, 17- For WILLIAM J WELTER, 17-8164, Plaintiff: MICHAEL cv-8311, MARY FAMEREE, 17-cv-8318, JOYCE STEVEN GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Page 74 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *215

ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MORGAN & MORGAN Philadelphia, [*217] PA. PC, TAMPA, FL. For AMBER TAYLOR, 17-8194 (Missouri), Plaintiff: For KAROL FOWLER, 17-8148, Plaintiff: John A Willis, ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LEAD ATTORNEY, Fox & Farley, Clinton, TN. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. For CECILEE RAMIREZ, 17-8150, Plaintiff: T. MATTHEW LECKMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For BRADLEY G JONES, 17-8288, Plaintiff: SARAH NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, POGUST STERLING STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL BRASLOW & MILLROOD, CONSHOHOCKEN, PA. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. For JACK ALLENBERG, 17-8152 on behalf of Tamara Allenberg (deceased), HELEN ALLISON, 17-8153, TIM For TATIANA L. YOUNG, 17-cv-8266, NORMA L. CAIN, 17-8237, SHARON COOPER, 17-8238 GONZALES, 17-cv-8270, Plaintiffs: KIMBERLY (Kentucky), BETTY DAHL, 17-8243, SABRINA WILSON WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT DANTZLER, 17-8247, WESLEY EARLE, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WILSON LAW PA, 8249 [*216] on behalf of LISA ANN EARLE RALEIGH, NC. (DECEASED), NORA GARCIA, 17-cv-8268, JESSICA GLADSTONE, 17-cv-8269, NORMA L. GONZALES, 17- For ANTHONY MORIGI, 17-8297, on behalf of cv-8270, DONNA GREENWALD-HILL, 17-cv-8271, KATHLEEN MORIGI, DECEASED, Plaintiff: CARY KATHRYN HAGAN, 17-8273, KATHRYN HAGAN, 17- LITTLEJOHN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 8273, CAROL HOSKINS, 17-8276, MICHELLE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON BARRETT PA, RENDLEMAN, 17-cv-8308, LOIS JACOBS, 17-8278, LEXINGTON, MS. SASHA LANDERS, 17-8280, DIANE MAHLERT, 17- 8281, VICTORIA SPENCER, 17-cv-8313, LINDA WRIGHT, 17-8372, TINA MARIE VARNAUSKAS, 17- For KIM LEE TENGBERG, 17-8360, DEAN ROSS, 17- 8366, GLADYS ROMAN, 17-8376, KAREN HURSIN, 8361, DONNA B. ROSS, 17-8361, Plaintiffs: KELLY A. 17-8294, MARGARET MICHON, 17-8298, THURMAN FITZPATRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, Middletown, CT. PARSONS, 17-8300, MELISSA PREISS, 17-8301, NELLIE RACKOV-TOKICH, 17-8305, Plaintiffs: For JOANN D BOYCE, 17-8259 AND 17-12670, LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, THOMAS M BOYCE, 17-8259 AND 17-12670, Plaintiffs: COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HOWARD STUART ROSS, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ROSS PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. LAW OFFICES PC, SHARON, MA.

For KATIE ESTRADA, 17-8176, KEITH SCAMAN, II, For JOHN SALAVICS, 17-8267, on behalf of PAMELA 17-8176 on behalf of LINDA SCAMAN, Plaintiffs: JOHN SUE SALAVICS, Plaintiff: JAMES D. GOTZ, LEAD RANDOLPH DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SLACK & DAVIS BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, BOSTON, MA; RACHEL BETH LLP, AUSTIN, TX. ABRAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES [*218] ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For RANDALL A. HATCHER, 17-8177, PATRICIA D. BLACK, 17-8205, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS For DORTHY HARBIN, 17-8382, JERRY LITTLE, 17- SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 8380, Plaintiffs: BRANDI R. HAMILTON, LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE LLC, ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT MT. PLEASANT, SC. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BARRETT LAW GROUP PA, LEXINGTON, MS. For DONNA PETROSKY, 17-8234, Plaintiff: GREGORY S. SPIZER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ANAPOL WEISS, For ARTHUR L. BUSTOS, 17-8290, Plaintiff: Camille Page 75 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *218

Cordova, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, The Alarid Law Firm BAR, ENVIRONMENTAL LITIGATION GROUP PC, PC, Albuquerque, NM; Michael Alarid, Jr., LEAD BIRMINGHAM, AL. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Michael Alarid, Jr & Associates, Albuquerque, NM. For KRISTIN MOJICA, 17-8455, Plaintiff: BRUCE W. STECKLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For LARRY MAXWELL, 17-cv-8321, Plaintiff: DARREN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, STECKLER GRESHAM RAY WOLF, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COCHRAN, DALLAS, TX. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, EDLUND GALLAGHER HASLAM MCCALL WOLF & WOOTEN PLLC, DALLAS, For FAROUQ FARAZI, 17-8252, on behalf of, Rahima TX. Farazi (deceased), JENNIFER FIELD, 17-8265, on behalf of, Cornelius Baillargeron (deceased), JEAN For MARY JANE TAXTER, 17-8364, PAUL R. TAXTER, BOUDREAUX, [*220] 17-8538, PEGGY CALDWELL, 17-8364, Plaintiffs: SHERRI L. PLOTKIN, RHEINGOLD, 17-cv-8552, GRACE DARK HORSE, 17-cv-8589, LEAD ATTORNEY, GIUFFRA, RUFFO & PLOTKIN, ROBERT COHAGAN, 17-8534, on behalf of, Julia LLP, NEW YORK, NY. Childress, JAMES BOWEN, 17-8511, on behalf of, Julie F. Bowen, MONICA BRADLEY, 17-8513, on behalf of, Kathy L. Bradley, JAMES L. BROWN, 17-8515, on For RENEE GEORGE, 17-8293, Plaintiff: William A behalf of, Angela Brown, TONYA MARIE COLEMAN- Yearout, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT SANDOVAL, 17-cv-8561, PATRICIA HATCH, 17-8686, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, YEAROUT & SUSAN ALDRIDGE, 17-8645, JEANNE AMADON, 17- TRAYLOR PC, Birmingham, AL. 8648, KATHERINE CONSTANT, 17-8568, MARY COLLEEN SHORT, 17-cv-8706, KATHY ANN For JIM BARROW, 17-8433, JACK OBERT 17-8434, ARNEBERG, 17-8650, LORRAINE LAFAYE FOX, 17- MELINDA OBERT 17-8434, JANINE BURGERT 17-cv- 8698, SHARON SMITH, 17-8726 (Louisiana), SHARON 8442, DANA HOTTINGER 17-8435, MARY CARPENTER, 17-8657, PAUL F. CROLLARD, 17-8868, HOTTINGER 17-8435, MARIO DIAZ, 17-8517, SILVIA BRANDY LEFLORE, 17-8822, Plaintiffs: LAUREN DIAZ, 17-8517, MARILYN RECCEK, 17-8629, DARRYL KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT RECCEK, SR., 17-8629, [*219] STEVEN NORRIS, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN 8631, ALVIN LINGNAU, 17-cv-8795, RITA LINGNAU, CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, 17-8795, JAMES PALUMBO, 17-8775, VIRGINIA MONTGOMERY, AL. PALUMBO, 17-8775, ANITA WILSON, 17-8780, JADE CONDE, 17-8786, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA For HEIDI SANTIAGO, 17-8473, Plaintiff: CARYN HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. For KEITHA BRUNELL, 17-cv-8443, THOMAS BRUNELL, 17-cv-8443, NANCY BERRY, 17-cv-8444, For RICHARD BENNETT, 17-8474, DARLENE E SANDRA GILL, 17-8636, WALTER GILL, 17-8636, ADAMS, 17-8500, JERRY G ADAMS, 17-8500, GAIL THERESA THOMAS, 17-8638, HENRY THOMAS, SR., SCHELLINGER, 17-8502, ALBERT R BALDWIN, 17- 17-8638, LAURA LEE STILWELL, 17-8639, DENISE 8504, JAMIE CHRIS BALDWIN, 17-8504, Plaintiffs: SMITH, 17-8640, LYNDA SCOTT, 17-8641, TARA ZOLLIE CARLTON STEAKLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, OKON, 17-8643, JANE MOOMEY, 17-8644, DENA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KRAUSE, 17-8646, LYNN HEINZ, 17-8649, LORI HARRISON DAVIS [*221] STEAKLEY MORRISON RAND, 17-8642, Plaintiffs: MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, PC, WACO, TX. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For REMONA BURROUGHS, 17-8476, PATRICIA K SUMNER, 17-8142, Plaintiffs: STEFAN BJORN For ANITA REVIS, 17-8454, RALPH B. JENKINS, 17- FEIDLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 8801, Plaintiffs: GARY A ANDERSON, LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ANASTOPOULO LAW Page 76 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *221

FIRM, CHARLESTON, SC. KORNMAN, 17-8741, DENISE LUTJENS, 17-8742, KATHRYN MALM, 17-8744, MARY MCNEELY, 17- 8745, HELEN MERCER, 17-8746, CYNTHIA C. For STEVE MASSAGEE, 17-8479, Plaintiff: ZOLLIE MOORE, 17-8748, ETHEL OFFILL, 17-8752, SHELLY CARLTON STEAKLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ORTEN, 17-8753, MELINDA POYNTER, 17-8756, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HARRISON DOLORES RANZIE, 17-8757, SHERRY TRENT, 17- DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON PC, WACO, TX. 8773, BONNIE STARKES, 17-8772, BARBARA SALERNO, 17-8758, LISA SEAMONE, 17-8759, JANET For DESIREE MERITT, 17-8256, Plaintiff: JAMES D. F WHITE, 17-8774, MICHELLE WOODS, [*223] 17- GOTZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED 8776, BETTY ARMSTRONG, 17-8777, DAWN TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, ONE MARINA GILBERT, 17-8778, THERESA SOUTHARD, 17-8765, PARK DRIVE, BOSTON, MA; RACHEL BETH KATHY SHELTON, 17-8761, SALLY SMILEY, 17-8764, ABRAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS MARY WOLFE, 17-8731, KAREN JEWELL, 17-cv- LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. 08738, BRENDA MCGEE, 17-8779, LYNN NATHAN, 17-8781, SHIRLEY SIM, 17-8782, DONALD SWANSON, 17-8784, FRANCES SWANSON, 17-8784, For JOANN LAVERDE CURCIO, 17-8263, Plaintiff: EVA AFFOLTER, 17-8785, JOETTA ALEXANDER, 17- SEAN MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD ATTORNEY, 8787, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MIAMI, FL. BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. For LORRAINE MAGGIORE, 17-8480, JESSICA ZEIGLER, 17-cv-8536, TONI WOOD, 17-cv-8545, JOE For LESLIE DONNETTA FRANKLIN, 17-cv-8544, WOJCICKI, 17-cv-8550, NAOMI WATSON, 17-cv-8555, SHERRY L HURLEY, 17-8585, SUSAN DONNA JEAN WILLIAMS, 17-cv-8599, PEYTON FRANKENBERRY, 17-8821, Plaintiffs: CASEY RYAN SWICK, 17-8569, on behalf of, Kathleen F. Orr, JANICE COBURN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT VINCENT, 17-8674, CHARLES SISK, 17-8572, on ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PHILADELPHIA, PA; behalf of, Linda Sisk, EMILY VANERUNEN, 17-8679, EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL WILLIAM SILVER, 17-8578, on behalf of, Janice D. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS Silver, KELLY GRIMMETT, 17-8684, BARBARA CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. TROGDON, 17-8687, JACQUELINE D. WOODLEY, 17- 8647, [*222] TRACINE SMOOT, 17-8719, NATALIE THOMPSON, 17-8690, MATELINE PATRICIA For CHERYL BERRY, 17-cv-8557 (Tennessee), THOMAS, 17-8691, DEANNA WILLIAMS, 17-8655, BRENDA F. EDWARDS, 17-cv-8593, ELIZABETH DOVIE THIGPEN, 17-8696, TERESA A. SMITH, 17- CROLEY, 17-8509, on behalf of, Jacqueline Trigg, 8725, DENISE M. TESSUM, 17-8730, MARIA BREED, THOMAS DAVIS, 17-8512, on behalf of, Christine 17-8803, PATRICIA EDWARDS, 17-8806, JULIA Elaine Davis, VICKI J. MOLLOY, 17-8514, GORDON D. GILLISPIE, 17-8807, EDITH GLEASON, 17-8808, ELDRIDGE, 17-8562, on behalf of, Nancy Eldridge, KATHLEEN GRAVER, 17-8809, PAMELA SCOTT, 17- JOHNNY LEE GAGE, SR., 17-8571, on behalf of, Hattie 8866, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD Gage, JANICE EMBREY, 17-cv-8607, WENDY ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BREWER, 17-8672, DIANE T. BRODNICK, 17- BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. 8681, [*224] VICKI BROOKS, 17-8685, TERESE DOMINSKI, 17-8723, VIKKI BAKER, 17-8652, KATHRYN DANIELS, 17-8689, CARMEN DE LA For CAROL ASHWORTH, 17-cv-8482, TRACIE CORDAD DIAZ, 17-8692, TERRI ANN BARANICH, 17- AUSTIN, 17-cv-8485, VANESSA BANKS, 17-cv-8488, 8656, JUEL DONOVAN, 17-8728, ELLEN BAIRD, 17- KENDALL BAUGH, 17-cv-8489, VALLERIE 8865, ANITA BRACE, 17-8823, LUANN BAKERd, 17- BELIZEARD, 17-cv-8490, PATRICIA BISHOP, 17-cv- 8871, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD 8491, KIM HAVLIC, 17-cv-8492, MARK HAVLIC, 17-cv- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 8492, DENISE BOCK, 17-cv-8493, TERRI BROGAN, BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & 17-cv-8495, PEGGY GAUGH, 17-8497, EVELYN MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. BROOKS, 17-8498, VICKIE CHVAL, 17-8521, MABLE GRAY, 17-8499, DARYL STAMPS, 17-8524, TERRY Page 77 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *224

For SHERRY SUMNER GRIMSLEY, 17-cv-8588, ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; JEFFREY LINDA GREEN, 17-cv-8590, Plaintiffs: TAYJES STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COHEN & MALAD LLP, FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. INDIANAPOLIS, IN.

For MALCOLM BUTLER, 17-8531, on behalf of, Judy For JUSTIN GRAY, 17-8740, ELIZABETH FRYMIRE, Butler, BENJAMIN ALLEN, 17-8507, LAUREL ANN 17-8693, KRYSTAL WILLIAMS, 17-8729, Plaintiffs: CHAVEZ, 17-8560, TRACY CHRISTIAN, 17-8563, WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC CYNTHIA FIELDS, 17-cv-8610, CATHY FOSTER, 17- VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, [*226] DALLAS, TX. cv-8612, SHERRI ESPOSITO, 17-8678, SANDRA L. CRONE, 17-8573, JADWIGA GUZY, 17-8683, For RUTH WILLIAMS, 17-8651, Plaintiff: CAROLYNN GAETANA F. CARDELLO, 17-8654, RACHEL CARROLL O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY. FLORES, 17-8694, GARY LANDRUM, 17-8816, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For SONIA T BARBER, 17-8594, Plaintiff: CARMEN BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; PATRICIA LEIGH NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For DAVID M BURGER, 17-8566, Plaintiff: ALAN For CRYSTAL FURLONG, 17-8505, JAMES STEVEN LAZAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT FURLONG, 17-8505, Plaintiff: MATTHEW RYAN [*225] ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MARLIN & SALTZMAN MCCARLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LLP, AGOURA HILLS, CA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX. For AMBER TAYLOR, 17-8695 (), Plaintiff: STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD For JAMES SCOTT HURLEY, 17-8585, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL BAR, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. For CAROLINE WERTHER, 17-8735, DANIEL WERTHER, 17-8735, Plaintiffs: MARTIN G. For MARIA THELMA FLORES, 17-8660, RICARDO RUBENSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT FLORES, III, 17-8660, Plaintiffs: NICOLE LAUREN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEVY BALDANTE BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT FINNEY & RUBENSTEIN PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, VENTURA LAW, DANBURY, CT. For GARY WALLS, 17-8810, on behalf of, KATHLEEN A. WALLS, Plaintiff: KIMBERLY WILSON WHITE, LEAD For KESSIE DAVIS, 17-8670, CHARLES KNOTTS, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ cv-8708, RHONDA LOW, 17-8727, CHERYL L. BAR, WILSON LAW PA, RALEIGH, NC. JOHNSON, 17-8733, MURRAY JOHNSON, JR., 17- 8733, CAROL PATTERSON, 17-8818, DARLENE For WANDA BENNETT, 17-8874, JEANETTE ZERINGUE, 17-8824, RODDIE BARDWELL, 17-8829, BERNHARDT, 17-8876, LORI ELLEN BISHOP, 17- Plaintiff: JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD 8877, JANE BLADES, 17-8878, BENEDICT LAZARE, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 17-8814, on behalf of, Debra Lazare, SHIRLEY BAR, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN. ARTEAGA, 17-8839, SHAY AMBURN, 17-8831, PAMELA BLAKE, 17-8898, TRACEY T. BOOKHART, For KATHY GEBARD, 17-8688 and 17-9959, Plaintiff: 17-8899, IRMA GASKIN, 17-8940, APRIL AVENT, 17- DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 8852, LEKISA BELL, [*227] 17-8944, TIPPHANY NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & FULLER, 17-8925, LAURIE GAY, 17-8947, EVELYN Page 78 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *227

AYO, 17-8860, ELOISA GARCES, 17-8935, NANCY SCHULZ, 17-9065, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH GWENDOLYN BRANSWELL, 17-8906, GALE O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BRAVERMAN, 17-8908, MARSHA BRAWAND, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. 8910, DEBORAH K. DAUGHERTY, 17-8914, RHONDA KAY DAVIS, 17-8917, ROBIN LAFLORA LEMELLE, 17- For JAMIE ALLEN, 17-8827, MELISSA ANN CARR, 17- cv-9022, MANDY JANE GRIFFETH, 17-cv-9025, 8661, BRENDA COLEMAN, 17-8667, CHERYL CLINE, NATOSHA HEARN, 17-9042, KAREN JEAN 17-8840, , 17-8937, formerly [*229] known PETERSON, 17-9018, LAUREN HARKINS, 17-cv-9034, as Mrs. Veronika M. Ross, SHARON VERONICA CHRISTY HARRIS, 17-cv-9037, GINA HERRERA, 17- KAOUGH, 17-8927, CAROLANN COLEMAN, 17-8855, 9048, on behalf of HILDA HERRERA, DOROTHY HARRY COLEMAN, 17-8859, MICHAEL J. ROST, 17- HOGAN, 17-9072, CHER HUDSON, 17-cv-09077, 8933, on behalf of PHYLLIS ROST, REGINALD ESTELLE INOCENCIO, 17-9083, TAMMIE GOTHARD, GREENFIELD, 17-8909, on behalf of AMELIA 17-8961, PATRICIA GIFFEN, 17-8965, THERESA GREENFIELD, LANETTE RYANS, 17-8909, PAUL GILBERT, 17-8949, LABRENDA M. JONES, 17-9106, RUETZLER, 17-8913, on behalf of SALLY A. ELSA S. KEY, 17-9140, JOHN KINBERGER, 17-9146, RUETZLER, LOUELLA REED, 17-cv-9024, BARBARA on behalf of CYNTHIA KAY KINBERGER, MAGGIE JACKSON, 17-cv-9029, KAREN JAMES, 17-9040, JONES, 17-9109, LOIS GOODSON, 17-8956, CINDY CRYSTAL JACKSON, 17-cv-9032, DEBORAH JAY, 17- KING, 17-9149, JOANN JUDD, 17-9113, IVA 9046, DAGMAR JENSEN, 17-9050, MATILDA Y. LEE, KAMINSKY, 17-9118, EVELYN KELLY, 17-9134, 17-9071, MEVLUDE MELBA LIKA, 17-9075, JANICE KIRK, 17-9161, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SHAUNDRA LILLY, 17-9079, JANET LONGMAN, 17- SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 9107, BONNIE JEAN MITCHELL, 17-8954, CORA NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN MACKEY, 17-9144, ROBERT LOUGHLIN, 17-9110, on CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, behalf of KELLY ANN LOUGHLIN, CONNIE MAIDEN, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-9150, SHIRLEY LOVE, 17-9117, REBECCA JINRIGHT, 17-9064, DEBORAH STEINKAMP For JEAN PERERA, 17-8875, Plaintiff: ALAN STEVEN LANDRY, 17-9067, JOANNE MARR, 17-9171, Plaintiffs: LAZAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MARLIN & SALTZMAN COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LLP, AGOURA HILLS, CA. BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For JAMES SPROUSE, [*228] 17-8826, on behalf of Marlena Sprouse, JANE WEST, 17-8659, MARY For ANGELA COPPOLECCHIA, 17-8828, PAULA WEISLO, 17-8662, PATTIE WALSH, 17-8665, MCLAUGHLIN, 17-8841, BILLY JO KLINGER, 17-8830, KANTINA SHANNON, 17-8843, other JASSMEKA VIRGINIA CARLISLE, 17-8892, JEANETTE JONES, MCGAUGHY, DECEASED, FRANK SEMAN, JR., 17- 17-8850, RITA MITCHELL, 17-8853, CASSANDRA 8847, on behalf of JOAN D. SEMAN, ADA MIZELL, 17- HARRIS, 17-8854, BENNETT GRIFFITH, 17-8861, 8936, TEANN HARTMAN, 17-8924, ROSELLE JONES, FRANCINE WOODARD, 17-8834, [*230] WENDY 17-8926, TONI KOERNER, 17-8928, LINDA LANAHAN, HAWKINS, 17-8978, MARY ANNE HOUSER, 17-8979, 17-8930, JUNE LEBER, 17-8934, PATRICK SHAUT, KATHLEEN HUBBARD, 17-8981, JANET HUGHES, 17- 17-8835, on behalf of ESTATE OF MARIE SHAUT, 8983, PAMELA HUNTER, 17-8985, DEBORAH ALEDDA BOTTOMS, 17-8919, CYNTHIA HAMPTON, OLIPHANT, 17-8987, JOHNNIE WILLIAMS, 17-8988, 17-8922, MARY L MILLER, 17-8958, CAROLYN SUE PATRICIA STEFFEE, 17-9078, KATHRYN STEMPF, TROVER, 17-cv-9021, ELIZABETH ANN TOBIN, 17-cv- 17-9080, SUSAN BROCK, 17-8989, JANET WALKER, 9023, KAREN THOMPSON, 17-cv-9030, CARRIEN 17-9084, MAUREEN CUMMINGS, 17-9101, KAREN TENHET, 17-9041, DENA SUTER, 17-9044, JUDITH L. FERRO, 17-9106, MONICA GARCIA-WILKINSON, 17- TRUDEAU, 17-9020, DEBORAH SPENCE, 17-9049, 9087, KAREN DUTTON, 17-8975, DEBORAH DELYNN M. SNOW, 17-9052, RONEKA , DAWSON, 17-8968, REBECCA DIOSO, 17-8970, 17-9081, PAMELA SCHENKER, 17-9086, NANCY CLAUDIA DUFFY, 17-8972, DONNA NUZZO, 17-9142, MOON, 17-8951, KATHLEEN RODRIGUEZ, 17-9143 DEBORAH RAWLS, 17-9151, BETTY REUTER, 17- (), DENISE ROBERTSON, 17-9147, SHARON 9154, KATHRYN HOTH, 17-9156, BRENDA GRAY, 17- RHYMES, 17-9148, BETSY ROSS, 17-9131, MARTHA 9114, DEBORAH JEAN HORTON, 17-9116, DEBORAH SMITH, 17-9057, PATRICIA E. SEAGO, 17-9062, KACKLEY, 17-cv-09157, DEANNA VANDALL, 17-cv- Page 79 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *230

09160, LINDA KNOX, 17-9119, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE 17-8969, ROBBIE MAE CLARK, 17-8971, [*232] LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT JAMES H. FITZGERALD, 17-8973, Plaintiffs: CARMEN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For DAVID DELUCA, 17-8880, JANET DELUCA, 17- 8880, PATRICIA STUCKER, 17-8879, Plaintiffs: For DENISE MARIE MARCELLO, 17-8902, PATRICIA MATTHEW RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, SILVER, 17-8903, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. PARFITT, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX. USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. For MATTHEW LOUVAR, 17-8881, NICOLE ELIZABETH LOUVAR, 17-8881, LINDA J. HOBBS, 17- For MICHAEL LOGAN, 17-8938, PATRICK LOGAN, 17- 8883, CHARLES WASHINGTON, 17-8884, DEENA 8938, SHAMIKA MARIE GORDON, 17-8946, Plaintiffs: JAMISON, 17-8995, CAROL COSTLEY, 17-8997, ELLA TIMOTHY DALE BRANDENBURG, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEGAY, 17-8998, [*231] KEITH BEGAY, 17-8998, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW FAWN ALLEN, 17-8999, ANITA CLARK, 17-9000, FIRM OF ROGER "ROCKY" WALTON PC, WILLIAM CLARK, 17-9000, PATSY WINCHESTER, 16- ARLINGTON, TX. 8564, PETER REYNOLDS, 17-9002, ROBBIE REYNOLDS, 17-9002, SANDRA GROLEAU, 17-9003, For DIANE PERSONS, 17-8942, RAYMOND MARSHAI NEVILLE, 17-9004, NICOL CORBIN, 17- WILLIAMS, 17-8974, Plaintiffs: SINDHU SUSAN 9005, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BARON & BUDD PC, YORK, NY. DALLAS, TX.

For RACHAEL CASTILLO, 17-8812, Plaintiff: For PATSY KINSEL, 17-9059, Plaintiff: DAVID KIMBERLY WILSON WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, MALCOLM MCMULLAN, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON WILSON LAW PA, RALEIGH, NC. BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS.

For BETH M BROWN, 17-8664, Plaintiff: MICHAEL For RODGER E HUGHES, 17-8982, Plaintiff: PATRICK RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLIZZARD & NABERS ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, HOUSTON, TX. LLP, WASHINGTON, DC.

For RUBY MARIE BREAUX, 17-8900, Plaintiff: For NANETTE CRISTOBAL, 17-9159, ANITA LOUISE ELWOOD CLEMENT STEVENS, JR., LEAD GRYWALSKY, 17-9153, Plaintiffs: SARAH STERLING ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, DOMENGEAUX WRIGHT ROY & EDWARDS, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON BARRETT PA, LAFAYETTE, LA; James Parkerson Roy, LEAD LEXINGTON, [*233] MS. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- NJ BAR, Domengeaux Wright et al (LAF), Lafayette, LA. For PERRY MCKENNIE, JR., 17-9172, Plaintiff: BRANDI R. HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC For WYNETTE SIMMONS, 17-8901, MARSHA KAY VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ANDERSEN, 17-8957, SARAH WHOBREY, 17-8996, BARRETT LAW GROUP PA, LEXINGTON, MS. BETTY JEAN KLEIN, 17-8977, DEBORAH WHITE, 17- 8994, PENNY AXELROD, 17-8959, GENIE SUE BLACK, 17-8962, LILA S. BRASSELL, 17-8964, For GINGER JONES, 17-9204, PATRICIA WRENN, 17- KATHLEEN BRUESHABER, 17-8966, SUSAN I. BUZA, 9206, MICHELLE LAPORTE, 17-9207, KATHY Page 80 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *233

HYLAND, 17-9208, LAKISHA WASHINGTON, 17-9209, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MURRAY LAW FIRM, BOB CHIN, 17-9210, LISA CHIN, 17-9210, HERBERT NEW ORLEANS, LA. SCHENCK, 17-9211, VICKIE SCHENCK, 17-9211, ANGELA ENRIQUEZ, 17-9213, OSVALDO ENRIQUEZ, For MICHELLE CANNADY, 17-9346, Plaintiff: DAVID T. 17-9213, RONALD BROWN, 17-9214 (Georgia), on MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT behalf of NELL BROWN, DECEASED, AIMEE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & REMILLARD, 17-9217, Plaintiffs: MEKEL SMITH ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONE CANAL PLACE, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For JUDY MARKS, 17-9163, GEROLDINE LOCKLEAR, 17-9094, LOTTIE LODGE, 17-9099, DAWN LOWE, 17- 9121, KAYLA LUKEY, 17-9124, CHRISTY CAIN, 17-cv- For CONSTANCE LEONARD, 17-9053, CONNIE 9283, MARGIE CARSON, 17-cv-9287, KARI CASSITY, DALTON, 17-cv-09074, HAROLD FINGERHUT, 17- 17-cv-9291, SANDRA CHAPMAN, 17-cv-9295, 9076, SUSAN FINGERHUT, 17-9076, BARBARA TERESA HEIKES, 17-9331, LAURA [*235] BETH CHECK, 17-9055, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, HAWKS, 17-9318, DEBRA FITZPATRICK, 17-cv-9311, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED REATHA JOHNSON, 17-9336, RHONDA JOHNSON, TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, 17-9374, NICOLE KINTZ, 17-9378, WENDY KLINE, 17- Philadelphia, PA. 9379, THERESA A. KORNACKI, 17-9382, MONA KOTERASS, 17-9385, CHRISTINA KRUSEMARK, 17- For TAMI MITCHELL, 17-9082, Plaintiff: SEAN 9386, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MIAMI, FL. BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For SANDRA WHITE, 17-11322, Plaintiff: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For DEBRA WILLIAMS, 17-9165 (Chicago, IL), ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON KIMBERLY WILLIAMS, 17-9166, MARTA LOGAN, 17- O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, [*234] MO; cv-09169, CAROL GOVEIA, 17-9182, BARBARA STEVEN ALAN HART, LEAD ATTORNEY, Hart HANCOCK, 17-9183, ANNETTE HENNINGER, 17- McLaughlin & Eldridge, Chicago, IL United Sta. 9185, LAURA HOFF, 17-9186, DIANNE WOLFE, 17- 9090, GERALDINE HORNER, 17-9187, BRIDGETTE JACKSON, 17-9188, PATRICIA ALEXANDER, 17-9189, For DONNA DAWE, 17-9129, THOMAS DAWE, 17- MARSHA HANAVAN, 17-cv-8737, TRACY DOUTHIT, 9129, CARL HACKERMAN, 17-9111, on behalf of 17-9245, KARY EDDINS, 17-9248, JERI BERRY, 17- SHARON HACKERMAN, Plaintiffs: T. MATTHEW 9096, DENISE BARNES, 17-9190, TINA CHILDERS, LECKMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 17-9193, CHERI COOMBS, 17-9193, ROBERTA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, POGUST BRASLOW & PACHT, 17-9266, BILLIE ALBERS, 17-9195, SUSAN MILLROOD, CONSHOHOCKEN, PA. PATTERSON, 17-9271, STACY POWERS, 17-9274, MARY ANN WILLIAMS, 17-9277 (Homosassa, Florida), For DONNA M. BURGE, 17-8967, Plaintiff: BRITTANY CATHY LEE LEMELIN, 17-9256, TERRI LAKE, 17- SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 9123, YVONNE ATHERTON, 17-cv-9285, ANNETTE NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN BIBEAU, 17-cv-9288, TAMA CALDABAUGH, 17-cv- CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, 9290, DAYTON, 17-cv-9294, DEBORAH MONTGOMERY, AL; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, PARSONS, 17-9316, MARY PERRI, 17-9317, [*236] WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, JANET RIDENER, 17-9332, PHYLLIS GUEST, 17-cv- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 9297, JENNIFER HARRIS, 17-cv-9298, BRENDA ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. HENDERSON, 17-cv-9299, VICTORIA JENSEN, 17-cv- LOUIS, MO. 9300, KATHRYN KELLY, 17-cv-9302, LAUREN LASHBROOK, 17-cv-9303, SONIA LOOMIS, 17-cv- 9304, JEANNE MYERS, 17-cv-9305, DENISE ROBB, For SUSAN HUNT, 17-9158, Plaintiff: CAROLINE 17-9335, ANTHONY POULIN, 17-9320, DEBRA THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT POULIN, 17-9320, MARGARET ORISCHAK, 17-cv- Page 81 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *236

9308, LISA OWENS, 17-cv-9312, JOCELYN SMITH, MCCARTY, 17-9349, [*238] AMBER MAXEY, 17-9325 17-9360, ANNE RUBIN, 17-9347, JANET RIDLEY, 17- on behalf of ESTATE OF DONNA MAXEY, DEANNA 9324, SANDRA SANTIAGO, 17-9350, CATHY MOORE, 17-9398, ARTHUR MATATT, 17-9494 on SCHNEBELEN, 17-9354, TAMMY SILBY, 17-9358, behalf of Caroline Matatt, DIANE ANDERSON, 17-9502, LINDA ROBBINS, 17-9337, RITA CEBALLOS, 17-9503, CATHY MCGOUGH, 17-9375, CLIFFORD MCKAY, 17- JOHN NICOTRA, 17-9412, BRIANNA ROWE, 17-9345, 9380, BROOKER MCKINNEY, 17-9383, CLAUDIA PENNY YOUNG, 17-9497, DEBORAH HERNDON, 17- MEACHAM, 17-9391, LISA MICHAUD, 17-9393, 9516, ANDREA HOSHKO-SMITH, 17-9518, KATHRYN SANDRA MILBURN, 17-9395, PAMELA MCCANN, 17- MAUER, 17-9522, ROSE MARIE MENDOZA, 17-9525, 9338, TONIA BEAR, 17-9507, SNJEZANA LATA, 17- Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD 9417, TAMMY ANDERSON, 17-9423, JOYCE ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BORDEN, 17-9520, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LOUIS, MO. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For COLLEEN DRISCOLL, 17-9182, DAVID A. DRISCOLL, 17-9181, SAM B. ZENTI, 17-9184, CARMELLA ZENTI, 17-9184, RAMON BERNARDO, For PAMELA YOUNG, 17-9212, BARBARA WELCH, 17-9203, JOSE HERNANDEZ, 17-9196, MARIA 17-cv-9229, BRENDA M. WHITMAN, 17-9224, LINDA HERNANDEZ, 17-9196 (), MELVA WHITMAN, 17-cv-9223, SAMILYA VEAL, 17-cv-9232, JOHNSON, 17-9197, JENNIFER JASTROW, 17-9198, ANTOINETTE WATKINS, 17-cv-9231, LISA WRIGHT, CHERYL BERGER, 17-9401, JAMES BERGER, 17- 17-9215, Sherri Sanders, 17-9089, MARY JANE 9401, DEBORAH FASCE, 17-9405, STACEY [*237] WILSON, 17-9221, DODI WRIGHT, 17-9220, HOMMEL, 17-9399, ANITA LAFAVER, 17-9402, CAROLINE TUCKER, 17-9235, JEANA WRIGHT, 17- JAMES LAFAVER, 17-9402, DONALD B. MATTHEWS, 9218, BEVERLY TERESA TODD, 17-9246, MARK 17-9404, PATRICIA SUE MATTHEWS, 17-9404, SAMAREL, 17-9095 on behalf of RUTH SAMAREL, MONIQUE WILLIAMS, 17-9403, DENISE DAMM, 17- JOANN THOMPSON, 17-9252 (Georgia), TINA RYLEY, 9409, ROBERT DAMM, 17-9409, JANICE 17-9100, DEBRA TAPP, 17-9265, BARBARA RUSSO, FITZGERALD, 17-9407, BETTY OWENS, 17-9406, 17-9122, LISA SWIGER, 17-9270, MARION TARANTO, ELEANOR GILBANE, 17-9394 on behalf of ESTATE OF 17-9258, SUSAN STUMPF, 17-9276, MARY L. MARY RAY HEARD, JERRY DODGE, 17-9527 on RUCKER, 17-9125, DOROTHY M. ROWSEY, 17-9326, behalf of CAROL DODGE, DAVID CARRINGTON, 17- CHERYL SOBER, [*239] 17-cv-9289, JOANNE 9523, KATHLEEN GRIMLEY, 17-9517 on behalf of SPINELLI, 17-cv-9286, SHEREE STRONG, 17-cv- ESTATE OF KATHLEEN LECOMTE, Plaintiffs: 9281, AZALEE SCOTT, 17-cv-9293, BERTA REY- CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD MOLINA, 17-9334, DEIDRAE SAPP, 17-cv-9314, ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, SUSAN SCHNELLE, 17-cv-9306, CINDY PYBURN, 17- NY. 9368, MARGARET RUTLAND, 17-9323, JANET RACKOW, 17-9348, CINDY QUARLES, 17-9357, LOIS O'DEAR, 17-9490 on behalf of Jacqueline Simmons, For CAROL BLEDSOE, 17-cv-9222, MARILYN DEBRA POWELL, 17-9388, GENEVA POWERS, 17- BOSTIAN, 17-cv-9225, CLAUDINE BRUNSON, 17-cv- 9384, DIANE PRINCE, 17-9381, NORALEAN 9227, CHERYL ANGELA BURDYCK, 17-cv-9234, PRINGLE, 17-9376, JOAN PROCTOR, 17-9373, LINDA JOHNSON, 17-9093, ELIZABETH A. ADAM, 17- DEANNA POELING, 17-9416, BONNIE TOMPKINS, 9216, JUDY ADDELSTON, 17-9219, MATTHEW 17-9418 on behalf of DELORES WIESE, STEVEN BARRERA, 17-9237 on behalf of KARLA BARRERA, SALPETER, 17-9426 on behalf of SUSAN WIDEN- JOANEVA BURNS, 17-9243, MARECYA BURTON, 17- SALPETER, JAMES SPAAR, 17-9422 on behalf of ANN 9244, MARY CLINE, 17-9249, KATHLEEN P. F. SPAAR, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD CORSETTI, 17-9254, ALONDA DAVIS, 17-9267, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PATRICIA CRAIG, 17-9262 (Alabama), DONNA ELLIS, BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-9273, RHONDA KAMLITZ, 17-9120, MICHAEL KEESEE, 17-9126 on behalf of ESTATE OF MELISSA KEESEE, LISA FINCK, 17-cv-9282, ALICE MAIOCCO, For JOHN CROWLEY, 17-9201, ARLIS BURKE, 17- 17-9319, DIANE MARIE MAHER-DRISCOLL, 17-cv- 9199, DARRELL G BURKE, 17-9199, DAVID BLEASE, 9309, SELINA D. MCCLAIN, 17-9359, PAULA 17-9200 on behalf of ESTATE OF TIERNEY BLEASE, Page 82 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *239

DECEASED, Plaintiffs: DAVID J. DIAMOND, LEAD on behalf of JOANNE DEWITT, JENNIFER [*241] ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PERKINS, 17-9691, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, BAR, GOLDBERG & OSBORNE, TUCSON, AZ. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. For LYNNE MILLER, 17-9240, Plaintiff: CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MURRAY LAW FIRM, For RON NEATE, 17-9362, Plaintiff: ADAM TAL FUNK, NEW ORLEANS, LA. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. For MICHELE COOPER, 17-9122, Plaintiff: WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, [*240] LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER For KATHLEEN M. NAGEL, 17-9396, LARRY J. SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, NAGEL, 17-9396, CASSANDRA J. STEPHENS, 17- MO. 9396, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., For SHARON MOSKOWITZ, 17-9268, STACY LOS ANGELES, CA. SCHOTT, 17-9327 on behalf of ESTATE OF PATRICIA L. TAYLOR, DECEASED, SANDRA ARGUETA- FRAZIER, 17-cv-9296, Plaintiffs: T. MATTHEW For JEFFREY LAWSON, 17-9501, Plaintiffs: LECKMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, POGUST BRASLOW & SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. MILLROOD, CONSHOHOCKEN, PA. For DEBRA ELY, 17-9420, KEVIN ELY, 17-9420, For JACOB SOWELL, 17-9255, Plaintiff: ADAM TAL JANICE JOHNSON, 17-9421, WILLIAM ROBERSON, FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED 17-9421, Plaintiffs: HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ALBUQUERQUE, NM. BAR, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA. For PAULA ELLIS, 17-9127, THOMAS TOMLIN, 17- 9715, Plaintiffs: SEAN MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD For JOYCE TUCK-LYNN, 17-9339, Plaintiffs: BARRY R. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ EICHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, Eichen Crutchlow Zaslow BAR, MIAMI, FL. & McElroy, LLP, EDISON, NJ.

For AMBER ORMOND, 17-9620, MICHAEL For WANDA L ROSS, 17-9427, Plaintiff: MICHAEL RAY REINHART, 17-9625 on behalf of ESTATE OF CONNIE CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT REINHART, DECEASED, JOSEPH RABASCA, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLIZZARD & NABERS 9673, GARY SULLIVAN, 17-9713, TAMMY HAYES, 17- LLP, HOUSTON, TX. 9727, CHRISTOPHER HAYES, 17-9727, MARY WHITEHURST, 17-9778, Plaintiffs: STEVEN DAVID For REGINA GRIER, 17-9616, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL [*242] PHILADELPHIA, PA. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES PC, BUFFALO, NY. For NANCY J. EDWARDS, 17-9413, Plaintiff: MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For PHILLIP A. BURNETTE, 17-9521, Plaintiff: NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & STEPHEN J. RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARNES, BUFFALO, NY. JONATHAN A ORSEN, PC, PRINCETON, NJ.

For JEAN FEATHERS, 17-9370, TIM DEWITT, 17-9865 For DONALD ROBINSON, 17-9524, Plaintiff: WARREN Page 83 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *242

T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, CURRIE, 17-9806, LAURA LANETTE FERRELL, 17- BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. 9813, ELIZABETH ANN FRITZ, 17-9819, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES For DONNA WOODS, 17-9519, DIONNE ZASKE, 17- PC, MONTGOMERY, [*244] AL. 9509, LISA MARIE ROBERTS, 17-9328, JENNIFER YOUNG, 17-cv-09514, JOANNE ELAINE WOOD, 17- 9533, DEBORAH WOLFE, 17-9537, ANGIE WAIT, 17- For TIMOTHY JENKINS, 17-9793, Plaintiff: SEAN 9706, NANCY J. WAITE, 17-9700, JOANN T. ROACH, MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD ATTORNEY,COUNSEL 17-9776, SUSAN WHITACRE, 17-9644, CARLA NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MIAMI, FL. RICHTER, 17-9781, JERRI LYNN WATKINS, 17-9688, PIXIE L. SOLIS, 17-9624, MICKEY WHILLANS, 17- For CARIE GAYTAN, 17-9511, NANCY CLARK, 17- 9661, DORIS SKILLINGS, 17-9761, MARY I. WILSON, 9560, JOYCE KENNEDY, 17-9561, BARBARA 17-9540 (Texas), LACIE VOSGIEN, 17-9768, KATHY MCINTYRE, 17-9562, ROBIN TERRY, 17-9563, SPELMAN, 17-9750, RYNDA STRAHAN, 17-9746, ELIZABETH TINCHER, 17-9564, ASHLEY ABELL, 17- LETHA WALKER, 17-9694, SINDY PUGH, 17-9796, 9569, GLENDA WHITTINGTON, 17-9565, MARY JOSEPHINE SALAZAR, 17-9800, TANYA SEGEBART, YOUNG, 17-9567 (Wichendon, ), JULIE 17-9803, HEATHER TRUJILLO, 17-9807, CATHERINE GRAHAM, 17-9515, VALERIE BROWN, 17-9601, SNEED, 17-9755, LISA WHITE, 17-9631, Plaintiffs: MAJESTIA MCLEAN, 17-9705, MARY ALEJO, 17-9716, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, LISA ALBERTIN, 17-9708, MICHELLE BENGE, 17- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 9717, TAMMIE LOCKE, 17-9696, KATHLEEN LYNCH, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-9701, MARILYN MARTIN, 17-9702, FRANCES ROSATO, 17-9663, ELMIRA BALDON, 17-9769, DIANE For PENELOPE KUDERIK, 17-9795, on behalf of PLETSCH, 17-9641, MELISSA LOPEZ, 17-9774, ARLENE MONDRO, EUMEKE GASSAWAY, 17-9719, JACQUELINE HARRISON, 17-9686, MARIE LYONS, ANGELA GRIFFITH, 17-9772, RANDY GRIFFITH, 17- 17-9777, JENNIFER BROWN, 17-9721 (Dumas, 9772, LYNN CORNWELL, [*243] 17-9687, FRANK Texas), SALLY FRY, 17-9729, NICKI PARSONS, 17- MALENICK, 17-9687, JESSE CRANDELL, 17-9646, on 9779, TERRI STAFFORD, 17-9730, JEANNETTE behalf of ESTATE OF ANGELA GLASS, DECEASED, PRIMMER, 17-9647, JESSICA QUINTON, 17-9581, GABRIEL ORELLANA, 17-9658, KATHLEEN DORIS RIGSBY, 17-9583, VIRGINIA STEWART, 17- ORELLANA, 17-9658, LACINDA SULLIVAN, 17-9713, 9584, MIRIAM SULLIVAN, 17-9586, KIMBERLEY AUNDREY LONG, 17-9764, on behalf of ESTATE OF TRAHAN, 17-9589, CAROL TRULL, 17-9590, TRACY CRYSTAL LYNNE LONG, IJEOMA SOPHIA MEMEH, RADEMACHER-HAMILTON, 17-9649, VERONICA 17-9757, MARIE MATTEI, 17-9618, Plaintiffs: STEVEN RICHARDSON, 17-9652, LESIA BEACH, 17-9598, DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HELEN HATTEN, 17-9689, MARY ROBERTSON, 17- HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. 9656, BAMBI BUCHANAN, 17-9723, BEVERLY JORDAN, [*245] 17-9692, TONYA CARRIERE, 17- 9724, TONI ADAMS, 17-9726, ARRETTA DALE, 17- For JEANNE BOOTH, 17-9510, MARY JO MCAVEY, 9543, JOANNA ELSMORE, 17-9554, MARIAN FARRIS, 17-9330, SHARYN BORTLE, 17-9529, VICTORIA 17-9558, CHEREE FRIZELL, 17-9555, ANN DIPSEY, 17-9534, JEANETTE DUBOSE, 17-9538, HERZFELD, 17-9545, MELISSA HUGHES, 17-9547, LAURIE NUNES, 17-9710, DONNA MARIE NEWBURY, ALICIA RIGGS, 17-9539, SONDRA TURNER, 17-9541, 17-9697, SUSAN LEE NICHOLSON, 17-9704, SARAH HERRERA, 17-9802, LAWONA KISER, 17- REBECCA MOORE, 17-9640, PEGGY POLLARD, 17- 9808 AND 17-10621, MARY M WASHINGTON, 17- 9773, MARY POPPINS, 17-9780, JOAN 9858, BELINDA CAMPBELL, 17-9859, KELLY WEBB, OBENDORFER, 17-9740, LEILANI MORALES, 17- 17-9818, ANASTASIA TAYLOR, 17-9731, AMY 9650, MARY K. OLIVO, 17-9759, ANGELA MORTON, MACDONALD, 17-9883, VIRGINIA TOMPKINS, 17- 17-9657, VERONDA JANE EVANS, 17-9544, 9733, MARILYN WALKER, 17-9893, DEBRA VANLIER, CRYSTAL FARMER, 17-9553, CYNTHIA FALLS, 17- 17-9860, JACQUELINE MCCLEARY, 17-9884, LAURA 9549, LORI ANN OPPERMAN, 17-9765, KATHERINE PARSONS, 17-9885, RUTH SALCE, 17-9886, LISA LETT, 17-9693, REBECCA LYN OLIVAREZ, 17-9752, WELCH, 17-9887, KATHYRINE WHITTINGTON, 17- LAURA MARTINEZ, 17-9627, WANNETTA FINCH, 17- 9888, GWENDOLYN CASS-ROBERTS, 17-9862, 9797, SANDRA MAE BRANDON, 17-9805, JOYCE Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD Page 84 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *245

ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PAMELA WERTHEN, CARLA ROBINSON, 17-9820, PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. TAMEKA HOWARD, 17-9612, on behalf of DELILAH BURNS, EILEEN WITMER, 17-9613, FRANK WITMER, 17-9613, CRAIG S. SMITH, 17-9840, Plaintiffs: For CHERYL NOELLE ADAMS, 17-9411, CHERIANNE CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD YVONNE BISHOP, 17-9411, MICHAEL LEE DAVIS, 17- ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, 9411, RIO DEAN DAVIS, 17-9411, WILLIAM LANCE NY. DAVIS, 17-9411, CODY LYNN THEODORE TENDICK, 17-9411, DECEDENT CONNIE LU TENDICK, 17-9411, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD For GAIL H. GILLIES, 17-9579, RAY O. GILLIES, II, 17- ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, 9579, DENNIS YORK, 17-9609, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. For RHONDA HAYNES, 17-9329, SARAH SOTO, 17- 9645, LINDA COLES, 17-9623, TAMMY HOLT, 17- For WENDY FERREIRA, 17-9707, FARRAH STARKS, 9739, KEVIN STEEN, [*246] 17-9660, DIANE 17-9711, SYLVIA LIDDELL, 17-9695, APRIL MILES, LAUZIERE, 17-9741, VALERIE LONG, 17-9742, 17-9699, CHERI RATLIFF, 17-9703, LISA ISHAM, 17- NEOLIA FORD, 17-9726, VICKIE ELIZARDO, 17-9628, 9690 GREGORY GOUDINE, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. LOTTIE FRANK, 17-9732, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For JOHN C. ERICKSON, JR., 17-9955, Plaintiff: For JOSEPH RODRIGUEZ, 17-9559, KILE DON Donald A. Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, BIGELOW, 17-9566, ANDY FRAZIER, 17-9573, on Providence, RI; Vincent L. Greene, IV, LEAD behalf of JULIE L. PETERS, SHAWKY SHEHATA, 17- ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Providence, RI. 9568, on behalf of MARGRIT SHEHATA, JAMES PEVERARO, 17-9513, on behalf of JANE PEVERARO, For EVELYN [*248] ADAMS, 17-10041, Plaintiff: ERIC DAVID MILLER, 17-9577 (Wisconsin), on behalf of D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & MARILYN MILLER, ALBERT MELENDEZ, 17-9536, on PEARSON, IRVING, TX. behalf of JUDY MELENDEZ, DONNA JEAN COVAULT, 17-9602, BARBARA PATRICK, 17-9604, NANCY WEIN, 17-9593, SCOTT WEIN, 17-9593, MARIANNE For KELLY COLLEVECHIO, 17-9642, MELVA DUNN, VAN DERHYDEN, 17-9606, GARY MACIK, 17-9597, 17-9654, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD DOLORES NORDAN, 17-9582, JANET SYDLAR, 17- ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, 9585, MICKEY WHITSON, 17-9588, BARBARA NY. BRIGHT, 17-9546, CHARLES HAYER, 17-9556, on behalf of CHARLENE HAYER, DEONCA JEFFERS, 17- For MARIA ESCOBEDO, 147-9743, MIQAELA 9548, GARY MOBERG, 17-9542, SCOTT MUELLER, ESCOBEDO, 17-9743, on behalf of ESTATE OF 17-9552, HENRY GANN, 17-9608, on behalf of DEBRA GUADALUPE ESCOBEDO, DECEASED, BRENDA J. GANN, ELAINE LEHEW, 17-9610, REBECCA EDWARDS, 17-9745, CAROL L. JOHNSON, 17-9747, ATWOOD, 17-9799, WILLIAM ATWOOD, 17-9799, Plaintiffs: JOHN RANDOLPH DAVIS, LEAD GERALDINE NEWMAN, 17-9831, ROBERTA WEINER, ATTORNEY, SLACK & DAVIS LLP, AUSTIN, TX. 17-9832, ROGER OLMSTEAD, 17-9834, on behalf of JANET RIEGSECKER, DEBBIE MAZZA, 17-9835, JOHN [*247] MAZZA, 17-9835, HAROLD SKEELS, 17- For ERIKA ALEJANDRE, 17-9551, SHARAN 9843, on behalf of TERRY SKEELS, LINDA BARNHART, 17-9550, Plaintiffs: JAMES G. ONDER, HOLLOWAY, 17-9838, ANTHONY C. PARLA, 17-9844, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY MELISSA GRANDBERRY, 17-9839, on behalf of PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, FRANCES FULLER, ALICE GONZALEZ, 17-9845, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. KELLI STAPLETON, 17-9842, on behalf of ANITA Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD PARADISE, ROBERT MURRAY, 17-9841 (Maryland), ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & BILL WERTHEN, Plaintiff in 17-9611, on behalf of PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, Page 85 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *248

LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & 17-9925, KAREN JACOBS, 17-9919, FLOSSIE LAMAY, pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. 17-9920, LAURA LEGGETT, 17-9921, KIMBERLY MAREIRA, 17-9922, NANCY KEILY, 17-9897, SUSAN GREEN, 17-9683, LISA CARTER, 17-9947, JOY For STACY CARDWELL, 17-9557, Plaintiff: MARK P SAWYER, 17-9939, ROBYN SMITH, 17-9940, ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEWPORT BARBARA KALIB, 17-9948, DENICE BROWN, 17- BEACH, CA. 9791, KAREN LOWERY, 17-9949 (Florida), CATHERINE TORREY, 17-9941, KAREN PAULSON, For FRANCES LUDD, 17-9744, Plaintiff: ALAN 17-9913, KHALILAH RAHMAAN, 17-9911, EMILY STEVEN LAZAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARLIN & RIGGS-STEPHENSON, 17-9912, MARY ANN SALTZMAN LLP, AGOURA HILLS, CA. SCARBOROUGH-OLAGUE, 17-9908, LESLIE TRAMEL, 17-9910, SUSAN TURNER, 17-9909, VIRGIE REDMON, 17-9950, KATHERINE WEATHERFORD, For KAREN REED, 17-9752, Plaintiff: STEVEN D. 17-9943, MARCIA WILKS, 17-8603, LORI SCHERER, RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, 17-9951, JULIE STEIN, 17-9952, JUSTIN MATTHEW PHILADELPHIA, PA. GILMER, 17-10059, on behalf of APRIL RENEE GILMER, BRANDON MARTIN, 17-10060, LORENE For KELLY PELLETIER, [*249] 17-9758, Plaintiff: GRAY, 17-10003, ANNETTE HARRIS, 17-10006, CARYN MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD KAREN SWINDLE, 17-9953, JULIE D CONNER, 17- ATTORNEY, JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. 9954, ALISON MARTIN, 17-9917, REBECCA MCCORMICK, 17-9918, RUTHANN O'DONNELL, 17- 9916, MARIANNE OAKES, 17-9915, DONNA For THEODORA WOOD, 17-9734, LOUISE CARLE, PUGLISSI, 17-9914, CRYSTAL TAYLOR PETTIFORD, 17-9890, JOHANNA ZAPPITELLI, 17-9889, 17-10067, EDWARD GIANNOTTI, 17-10069, [*251] on CATHERINE PETERSON, 17-9891, SHARON A. behalf of ESTATE OF BARBARA GIANNOTTI, SMITH, 17-9892 (Madison, Wisconsin), DIANA DECEASED, RACHEL GOTTLIEB, 17-10070, on behalf DAWSON, 17-9668, VICTORIA OLLER, 17-9867, of CAROL LEE ANDREWS, CAROL MITCHELL, 17- ROBIN WOODS, 17-9821, DIANA BALLARD, 17-9873, 10042, KATHERINE DUNN, 17-9926, BRENDA JANE BARILE, 17-9874, DARLENE PAYNE, 17-9868, GIBSEN-HERRON, 17-9927, LINDA GRECO, 17-9928, AMBER SARGENT, 17-9869, LORRAINE SLOMOVIC, CORINNE HIGDON, 17-9929, CASHANNA 17-9870, MELANIE SMALLS, 17-9871, PAULA SMITH, WASHINGTON, 17-9931, KATHLEEN BARRISH, 17- 17-9872, DONNA MARTIN, 17-9898 (Arizona), DEBRA 10115, LISA COLE, 17-9932, CANDACE CRIPPEN, 17- MILLER, 17-9899, SYLVIA OESTERLE, 17-9900, 9933, PATRICIA HUVAL, 17-10117, SCOTT HUVAL, JULIANA ENGLISH, 17-9671, JEANINE FAHRBACH, 17-10117, BECKY SOLLECITO, 17-10116, Plaintiffs: 17-9674, LOUISE O'FARRELL, 17-9901, SUSAN STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, ONDER SHELTON CALLAHAN, 17-9875, RACHEL CRAFT, 17-9876, EVA O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. DESANTIS, 17-9877, LISA EWANITSKO, 17-9878, KRISTIN GRINDLE, 17-9880, ROEANER JACKSON, 17-9882, HODGE JOHNNETTA, 17-9881, For BRENDA FISHER, 17-9632, SHARON HERRING, JACQUELINE FARRINGTON, 17-9679, KAY FLIPPO, 17-9735, NANCYANN BALOUGH, 17-9617, CYNTHIA 17-9680, SHARON WEATHERLY, 17-7933; 17-9681, HOLDEN, 17-9737, CARYL WILEY, 17-9672, DARIS JILL GARRISON, 17-9853, SUSAN GUSTMAN, 17- GIDCUMB, 17-9635, JOHELEN GOLDEN, 17-9637, 9854, GINGER JORDAN, 17-9855, LINDA THOMAS, CHRISTINE T. OWEN, 17-10007, AMBERS GILBERT, 17-cv-09822, SARA MCDOWELL, 17-9856, CAROLE 17-10101, on behalf of LYNDA JAY GILBERT, MARK SEXTON, 17-9857, KATIE GROSS, 17-9934, HAMBY, 17-10091, SAMANTHA PARSONS, 17-10109, GEORGIA HARTLEY, 17-9935, DIANE HEFFERNAN, ANNETTE TROY MCNAIR, 17-cv-9971, JO-ANN 17-9937, CAROLE WHITE, 17-9894, KAREN PACHECO, 17-10013, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS ARNHOLT, 17-9905, BEVERLY BROWN, 17- RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW 9907, [*250] ANJILLA CLOUD, 17-9906, SHARON METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. DALTO, 17-9903, SANDRA FARINO, 17-9904, ANGELA GOFORTH, 17-9895, VIRGINIA HAGAN, 17- For MARK W. LAKE, 17-9615, MICHELLE LAKE, 17- 9896, JANET JONES, 17-9938, LAURA BELCHER, 17- 9615, ISABELLE RIOS, 17-10138, Plaintiffs: MARK P 9923, SHERRY CARREON, 17-9924, PAMELA CRAIG, ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEWPORT Page 86 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *251

BEACH, CA. For CELESTE MARTIN, 17-cv-9483, RAY GLADMAN, 17-9450, on behalf of DIANE GLADMAN, Plaintiffs: PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & For KATHLEEN SMITH, 17-9846, LISA RAE SNOW, SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. 17-9847, BONNIE GREEN, 17-9848, [*252] ALAN FRIED, 17-9849, JULIE FRIED, 17-9849, CYNTHIA RICH, 17-9850, MICHELLE SHADIX, 17-9851, LAURA For SUSAN OTT,, 17-cv-9482,, AKIN ROSS, 17-9428, FRANCKS, 17-9852, MICHAEL FRANCKS, 17-9852, PATRICIA O'BRIEN, 17-9788 (GA), ANNIE SCOTT SANTA, 17-9827, on behalf of KIMBERLY ANN PATTERSON, 17-9792, JOYCELYN REISEN, 17-9785, EMERSON-SANTA, JAY BUTLER, 17-cv-09830, on DIANNA RYAN, 17-10004, HARRIETT RUCKER, 17- behalf of JOANNA BUTLER, MARY ANN LIMA, 17- 10009, PAULA SO, 17-10082, EMILY WAGNER, 17- 9789, JOHN REILLY, 17-10085, KATHLEEN REILLY, 10090, DAVID WRIGHTSMITH, 17-9440, on behalf of 17-10085, GARY HOLLAND, 17-10100, DONNA CAROLINE SHALLMAN, RONALD TAUCHER, 17- HIXSON, 17-10088, MARY LILLY, 17-10071, NORMAN 10104, CRYSTAL WITTEVEEN, 17-9442, on behalf of JONES, 17-10095, LAURIE NELSON, 17-10102, ANN CINDY [*254] ARMSTRONG, CRYSTAL O'CONNOR, 17-10106 (), TINA COOK, 17-10139, WILLIAMSON, 17- 9444, on behalf of ANITA on behalf of MILDRED GRISHAM, REBA WILLIAMS, WILLIAMSON, RICHARD POTTER, 17-10094, SUSAN 17-10141, KATHY KIENZLE, 17-10075, MARTIN STEWART, 17-10086, ARTHUR WHITMORE, 17-9447, KIENZLE, 17-10075, RAMONA GONZALEZ, 17-10078, on behalf of EVONNE H. WHITMORE, SHERRY L. RYAN JONES, 17-10142, SHANNON L. JONES, 17- PETERS, 17-10030, DONNA DAVIS MADISON, 17- 10142, THEODORE DOHERTY, 17-10143, on behalf of 10108, HAMPTON WEISS, 3:17-cv-9449, on behalf of DIANA DOHERTY, JUDITH CULLERS, 17-10144, PATRICIA WEISS, KARINA , 17-10033, BRIAN MEHL, 17-10145, on behalf of REBECCA SHERRY ROSS, 17-cv-9969, CLAUDIA RODRIGUE, MEHL, SHANNON PELL, 17-10111, Plaintiffs: 17-10014, ELLEN H PFEIFFER, 17-9435, BILLIE J. CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD PARTEN, 17-cv-9477, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. NY. For CYNTHIA DIANE WHITE, 17-9634 AND 17-2394 For BRADLEY DEAKLES, 17-cv-9475, VICKIE (Florida), Plaintiff: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, PATTERSON, 17-9902, GERRIANN MURRELL, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW 9677, REBA GRESHAM, 17-9828, MICHELLE NEAL, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; 17-9684, CATHERINE BANKSTON, 17-9430, JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER ELIZABETH DAVIS, 17-9790, LYNN PROCTER, 17- SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; 9786, STEVE DESCHAMPS, 16-2738, on behalf of Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND THERESA GAGLIARDI, MICHAEL [*253] CORMIER, SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; PATRICIA LEIGH 17-10099, on behalf of Marsha Cormier-Franco, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. ROBERT M DAVIS, 17-10103, MILTON A. STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, FULLERTON, JR., 17-9443, on behalf of ANN ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. FULLERTON, MISTY COOPER, 17-10093, TANIA LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD HUTCHISON, 3:17-cv-9446, on behalf of KIMBERLY ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ARNOLD, RUSSELL BLADEN, 17-9432, GEORGE pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. HARPER, 17-10107, DANIEL LAWRENCE, 3:17-cv- 9448, on behalf of DEBORAH LAWRENCE, ELDON For SHERITA CHAVIS WILLIAMS, 17-9669, Plaintiff: COLLETT, 17-9433, ROSEMARY CIULLA LEONE, 17- DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI 9451, CONNIE HENSLEY, 17-10032, KERRY JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL; ELIZABETH HAMMETT, 17-10012, MAUREEN ROGER C. DENTON, [*255] LEAD ATTORNEY, GROVE, 17-cv-9974, CHERYL LITTLE, 17-10112, on COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, behalf of ESTATE OF VALERIE MILLER, DECEASED, SCHLICHTER AND BOGARD, LLP, ST. LOUIS, MO; Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, ONDER SHELTON ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO WILLIAM PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. Page 87 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *255

For CHRISTOPHER RAST, 17-9670, Plaintiff: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM For OTIS RENCHER, 17-10174, Plaintiff: NICOLE PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. LAUREN BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, VENTURA LAW, DANBURY, CT. For RAUNDA LUTHY, 17-10113, CINDI ANN PARKER, 17-10034, SHERRY O. CANTRELL, 17-10157, CAROL For TERESA ANN DAVIS, 17-9682, Plaintiff: MICHAEL CLARK, 17-10160, THOMAS CARTER, 17-10205, on WARREN JOHNSTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE behalf of Arlita J. Carter, NANCY CLASS, 17-10163, LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC, Philadelphia, PA. AMANDA K. CAMP-GRAY, 17-10169, SANDRA M. CALHOON, 3:17-cv-10171, VIVIAN CHAMBERS, 17- For DAVID MORRISON, 17-10188, ROSEANN 10223, on behalf of Angela Turner, MARVIN CLARK, MORRISON, 17-10188, DANIEL GIRARD, 17-10227, 17-10252, TINESHA CAMPBELL, 17-10196, RONALD GEORGETTE GIRARD, 17-10227, VALERIE JENKINS, K. HELTON, 17-10390, ISABEL HEREDIA, 17-10039, 17-9793, RENEE EDMONDS, 17-10096, Plaintiffs: RAMONA B. OVERSTREET, 17-cv-9999, KAREN SEAN MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD ATTORNEY, MIAMI, HANCOCK, 17-10303, JUNE HARRIS, 17-10309, FL. VALERIE CORDOVA, 17-10261, DESTINY CRAVENOR, 17-10271, on behalf of TERESA DIANE CRAVENOR, VEDA CROSS, 17-10278, CHERYL For CHERYL PETERSON, 17-9639 AND 18-1703, MUSGRAVE, 17-10427, DEBBIE HEBDON, 17-10325, Plaintiff: CARYN MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD CELESTE GAINES, 17-10283, NIKITA WILLIAMS, 17- ATTORNEY, JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX; 10451, [*257] JENNIFER E. SHIPLEY, 17-10393, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, CAROLYN D. WILLIAMS, 17-10453, PAMELA WYATT, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. 17-10442, 17-10516, TYRONE PARKER, 17-10396, on LOUIS, MO. behalf of ESTATE OF SHERRY IVORY, MARY A. MURRAY, 17-10434, ERMELINDA ROMAN, 17-10590, For JEANNE RAM, 17-9829, Plaintiff: JAMES A. ANGIE STAUFFER, 17-10602, on behalf of Charlotte MORRIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORRIS LAW FIRM, Kathleen Donnelly (deceased), Plaintiffs: LAUREN Burbank, CA. KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For JOHN MOE, 17-9787, on behalf of CORRINE MOE, Plaintiff: STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, For DARCY ARENA, 17-10147, JUDITH BARYCKI, 17- PA. 10148, ASHTON GILMORE, 17-10149, NAKIA WHITFIELD-GILMORE, 17-10149, RAYMOND L. CLOUD, 17-10150, on behalf of ESTATE OF RUTH A. For JANICE ROOHAN, 17-9784, Plaintiff: WARREN T CLOUD, MICHAEL ZAVISTOSKI, 17-10158, BRENDA BURNS, LEAD [*256] ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, ZAVISTOSKI, 17-10158, HERBERT SOUZA, 17-10229, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. SARA SOUZA, 17-10229, JAMES LAMB, 17-10302, VALERIE MCALISTER, 17-10418, NICHOLAS For KARMA MOORE, 17-10002, SHERRY BONEY, 17- NESBETH, 17-10424, JORDANNE NESBETH, 17- 10005, JENNIFER PEEBLER, 17-9990, TURESSER 10424, ARPAN SALLY, 17-10274, MARILYN KLEINER, GRAVES, 17-9973, SUSAN FULLER, 17-10052, 17-10287, ALBERT GARZA, 17-10431, ESTATE OF Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, MICHELLE GARZA, DECEASED, Plaintiff in 17-10431, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, HELENE GROSSMAN, 17-10440, PETER WARD, 17- IL. 10514, VALERIE WARD, 17-10514, Plaintiffs: STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. For RONALD NOGA, 17-10257, Plaintiff: GREGORY S. SPIZER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ANAPOL WEISS, Philadelphia, PA. For WALTER CUNNINGHAM, 17-9437, GRACE ALLEN, 17-10201, on behalf of Charlene Ault, SUSAN HARRELL, 17-10021, DONNA LINDSEY, [*258] 17- Page 88 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *258

9458, CYNTHIA IRENE LITTLE, 17-9460, HALCYON MARQUETTE BLAKE, 17-10164, GLENDA LONG, 17- For LORI BEAULIEU, 17-10131, LIBERTI VEGAS, 17- 9464, DARNELL HARTWELL, 17-10028, EVETTA 10130, formerly known as PAULA BOHANON, BENSON, 17-10168, JENNIFER BORN, 17-10225, BERLINDA WALKER, 17-10132, RHONDA DUNN, 17- KATHLENE FULLER, 17-10370, MELISSA BOLDEN, 10133, JAQI BAXLEY, 17-10121, on behalf of THE 17-10209, DESIREE BROWN, 17-10255, KATINA ESTATE OF TAMMI BAXLEY, RONALD DAHLY, 17- HENDERSON, 17-10392, KENNETH R. GROVER, 17- 10127, on behalf of FRANCIE R. HORN-DAHLY, cv-9996, KATHY BUDA, 17-10306, TERA BYNES, 17- ERNEST GRAY, 17-10123, MICHELE GRAY, 17- 10328, IRENE BROWN, 17-10263, RENESSA 10123, DEBRA HUNT, 17-10128, JUANITA BROWN, 17-10268, LISA MARIE BUTLER, 17-10319, PAJAO, [*260] 17-10122, PATRICK PAJAO, 17-10122, BETTYE F. JONES, 17-10428, JUDITH ANN BUTTS, LINDA SUE SCHROEDER, 17-10125, JEROME 17-10324, JOSEPH BUCCIERI, 17-10282, SAMMY SIWICKE, 17-10134, on behalf of GEORGEANN HILL, 17-10394, MARIAN DARR, 17-10336, LINDA K. SIWICKE, ELLEN WALLACE, 17-10135, GEORGE ASHBURN, 17-10441, TOYE ELKINS, 17-10337, WALLACE, 17-10135, BELMA MARRERO, 17-10369, DEMETRIUS HOOVER, 17-10398, WENDY JONES, JOSEPH PURDY, 17-10371, KRIS GARRETT, 17- 17-10435, MISTY M. BRINLEE, 17-10238, BEVERLY 10380, STEPHEN H. GARRETT, 17-10380, SARA GIVENS, 17-10515, DIANE CARTER, 17-10456, MOHABEER, 17-10382, MELISSA SMITH, TERRY Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD SMITH, 17-10317, JOEL BERNBAUM, 17-10311, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ELEADREA BURKES-HAYES, 17-10301, VAN BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. WALKER, on behalf of SHERRI WALKER, ANTOINETTE BRATHWAITE, 17-10279, PAMELA For KEVIN MACDONALD, 17-10058, SUSAN COX, 17- COLVIN, 17-cv-10332, on behalf of SUSAN COLVIN, 9474, MARIA FERRAN, 17-9466, CARMELA GUERRA, TODD KAYTON, on behalf of MARY JILL KAYTON, 17-9468, NANCY HEINZ, 17-9471, JEFFREY LORBER, HEATHER AMICI, 17-10600, STEVEN AMICI, 17- 17-9470, BONNY ENRICO, 17-10260, NANCY 10600, JOANN BROWN, 17-10519, RAY BROWN, 17- MICHAUD, 17-10601, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN 10519, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. YORK, NY.

For JESS WYATT, 17-9438, LESA RENNA WILBURN, For NORMA J. BATTLE, 17-10154, PRISCILLA M. 17-10199, TERRI [*259] REBSTOCK, 17-10019, PANTOJA, Plaintiff in 17-10020, Plaintiffs: JAMES G. KRISTINE WHELAN, 17-10202, STEVE UYEMURA, ONDER, Michael J. Quillin, STEPHANIE LYNN 17-10208, ROXANN RAVENSCROFT, 17-9461, on RADOS, WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEYS, behalf of SUSAN RAVENSCROFT, NANCY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ELIZABETH PETERSON, 17-9472, MARISHIA ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. QUALLS-MAY, 17-9467, DONNA RAINS, 17-10027, LOUIS, MO; LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD MARILUZ ZAMBRANO, 17-10167, SHEILA KAYE ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN SUTTON, 17-10211, SARAH STROUD, 17-10216, on PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. behalf of Kecia Laquette Stroud, DANIEL STETTNER, 17-10220, on behalf of Jean Boffardi Stettner, AMANDA For LISA PALETTA, 17-10161, CLYDEAN SIMANSKIS, SCHULTZ, 17-10372 (TX), DONNA MARIE HUDSON, 17-10162, DANIELLE TIER, 17-10165, [*261] 17-10379, ELIZABETH JOHNSON, APRIL TREATISE JENNINGS, 17-10191, Plaintiffs: STEVEN YOUNGBLOOD, 17-10195, TAMARA F. MCDOWELL, D. RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK, 17-10383, LAURIE SCHMANDT, 17-cv-9987, KATHY P.C., PHILADELPHIA, PA. A. SCHMIDT, 17-cv-9978, SUE SCHERER, 17-cv-9997, KIMBERLY HAYES, 17-10313, JUDY JANE SMITH, 1710267, CHRISTY L. RIVERA, 17-10395, TREVIA For THOMAS OAKLEY, 17-10119, ADELYN PERO, 17- STEPHENS, 17-10236, SCOTT STEMM, 17-10243, 10335, Plaintiffs: MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. For JESSIE JOHNSTON, 17-10200, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. Page 89 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *261

MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MIAMI, FL. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. For GERALD WHITE, 17-10197, NINA WHITE, 17- 10197, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD For CORDA ADAMS, 17-10126, REBECCA SUE ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MCCLANAHAN, 17-10124, SHARON LEE BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; DENA STEPHANSEN, 17-10136, LINDA JACKSON, 17- RACHEL YOUNG, SCOTT S BERGER, JR, LEAD 10206, on behalf of MARGARET J. MILLER, KAREN ATTORNEYS, ROSS FELLER CASEY, LLP, SMITH, 17-10206, CLAUDETTE WISE, 17-10192, PHILADELPHIA, PA; MARK ALAN [*263] HOFFMAN, KAREN JENSEN, 17-10316, DEANN DAUGHERTY, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS FELLER CASEY LLP, 17-10646, DANIEL SCHMITZ, 17-10633, GLENDA PHILADELPHIA, PA. CROFT, 17-10642, KATHLEEN WILLIAMS, 17-10742 (New York), DEANA DANIELS, 17-10753, ANDREW For CASAUNDRA FLETCHER, 17-10310, BENSON PERRY, 17-10783, DORIS MELISSA CHANTHONY FOREMAN, 17-10312, LAMAR-DAVIS, HAMILTON, 17-10783, CLAYBORN LEONARD PERRY 17-10417, DEMARIUS MCCASTER, 17-10262, DELIA JR, 17-10783, Plaintiffs: JAMES A. MORRIS, LEAD OCHOA, 17-10270, ANA MAGUIRE, 17-10423, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ WALTER WEDDINGTON, 17-10281, CYNTHIA BAR, MORRIS LAW FIRM, Burbank, CA. COLEMAN, 17-10433, LUCILLE ALLCHIN, 17-10237, Plaintiffs: STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD For CAROLYNN MAUPIN, 17-10137, DAVID MAUPIN, ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, 17-10137, Plaintiffs: JOSEPH H. SAUNDERS, LEAD MINNEAPOLIS, MN. ATTORNEY, SAUNDERS & WALKER PA, PINELLAS PARK, FL. For DALE SPIEGEL, 17-10304, Plaintiff: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS For WILLIAM LOVE, 17-9456, TARA LOVE, 17-9456, CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. REBECCA STIDHAM, 17-9473, Plaintiffs: PRISCILLA [*262] E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, For CHARLES BECK, 17-10679, PATRICE RADER, 17- KLINE & SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. 10688, RUSSELL RADER, 17-10688, Plaintiffs: JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, For CECILIA YANG, 17-10022, SARA SAMMONS, 17- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 10277, CLIFFORD FORD, 17-10422, JENNIFER COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN. JOPEK, 17-10266, CAROLYN ROBERTSON, 17- 10265, MISTY SUBER, 17-10264, CINDA TYES, 17- For CHRISTOPHER ROMAN, 17-10327, EVELYN 10280, MABEL MOORE, 17-10426, SHARON ROMAN, 17-cv-10327, CANDICE GUILDS, 17-cv- MAGUIRE, 17-10284, EMMANUEL HERNANDEZ, 17- 10331, JERRY GUILDS, 17-cv-10331, Plaintiffs: 10436, MARY JANE COLLETT, 17-10399, DOROTHY ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, MITCHELL, 17-10443, on behalf of YUN KIM, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN LAURIELEE STEWART, 17-10518, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. FRANCISCO, CA. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. For TROY WARICK, 17-10603, Plaintiff: MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For BARBARA SULLIVAN, 17-10026, MELISSA TORRES, 17-10685, NANCY HASKET, 17-10275, THOMAS HASKETT, 17-10275, TANYAGALE For BEATRICE BAKER, 17-10445, DAVID M. MONDEAUX, 17-10712, DIANE SOTO, 17-10721, GIAMPAPA, 17-10605 on behalf of Kathy J. Giampapa, CYNTHIA SALISBURY, 17-10732, KATEY BRUST, 17- TOMMY HUGHES, 17-10401, CHRISTA CARSON, 17- 10738, KIMBERLY JOYNER, 17-10771, JESSICA 10449, JEFFERY HESTER, [*264] 17-10610, TORRES, 17-10776, Plaintiffs: SEAN MICHAEL CHARLENE BRITTON, 17-10248, ALICIA FREDERICK, CLEARY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 17-10364, GWENDOLYN CLARK, 17-10462, Page 90 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *264

MARLENE FRIEND, 17-10367, CARL EVANS, 17- FERGUSON, 17-10403, ROBIN JENKINS, 17-10410, 10341, KARA JOHNSON, 17-10530, WILLIAM Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, FESPERMAN, 17-10346, LENORA JONES, 17-10621 GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, on behalf of ZINA PEEPLES, SHAWN FINDLEY, 17- IL. 10352 on behalf of DIANNA MOYER, VIRGINIA DEGAND, 17-10470, KATHERINE JONES, 17-10532, For CONSTANCE SONDELSKI, 17-10245, DANA CATHERINE FOGG, 17-10356, IOLA FOY, 17-10358, KOSTON, 17-10527, Plaintiffs: SEAN MICHAEL LOIS FRANKLIN, 17-10362, VERONICA C. HAYES, CLEARY, [*266] LEAD ATTORNEY, MIAMI, FL. 17-10524, RHONDA JORDAN, 17-10550, CHRISTINA DIANNE KOJETIN, 17-10632, RHONDA JONES, 17- 10541 (Tennessee), CRYSTAL FLOYD, 17-10556, On For NICOLE DESTEFANO, 17-10523, BROCK SUSKA, behalf of Brenda Jean Bartley, CLAUDE JENKINS, 17- 17-10469, on behalf of CAROLYN SUSKA, 10405, SHAUN KOTLEWSKY, 17-10638, DONNA DECEASED, CATHLEEN BENTLEY, 17-11156, ZINA FAIRCHILD, 17-10511, EVA KIRK, 17-10581, ERIN CRAVEN, 17-11162, CHRISTINA EVANS, 17-11160, AUSTIN, 17-10586, COLEEN MOORE GENN, 17- KAREN PERRY, 17-11163, MICHAEL SWANCUTT, 17- 10599, PAMELLA KELLY, 17-10565, PATRICIA 11161, on behalf of ESTATE OF LAUREEN KIMMEL, 17-10575, ROBIN JOHNSON, 17-10408, SWANCUTT, JEANNE HEROUX, 17-10716, MARLENE TAMMY DICKERSON, 17-10475, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY KOUTOUJIAN, 17-10719, SUSAN LAWRENCE, 17-cv- SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY 10726, ANITA STOWERS, 17-10733, CARRIE ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, BROWN, 17-10736, GLADYS CALTON, 17-10745, on MONTGOMERY, AL. behalf of LA'KIESHIA CALTON, Plaintiffs: STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. For VIOLA WILLIS, 17-10446, SHIRLEY VALENTINE, 17-cv-10468, ROGER CHISLER, 17-10244, MARY MANNING, 17-10607, LORI H. WARD, 17-10461, For ROSE M. MALLON, 17-10608, CRYSTAL COLLEEN LALLY, 17-10402, SHUNTEKA LOGAN, 17- HORTON, 17-10376, MICHELLE NOLAN, 17-10404, 10612, CINDY DAVIS, 17-10342, DEBRA DAVIS, 17- PAULA ANN SAPPER, 17-10365, JANET SMITH, 17- 10345, [*265] SUSAN DIXON, 17-10347, IGNACIO 10363, MS. REBECCA LORRAINE SCHORY, 17- DOZIER, 17-10350, on behalf of ESTATE OF 10368, CLARA L. FAISON, 17-10339, BRENDA LEE CONNIESTINE DOZIER, DECEASED, MARSHA FLACK, 17-10344, MONA HOLLAND, 17-10349, GAIL DUNN, 17-10353, SHANA MILLER, 17-10546, LINN, 17-10613, KATHERINE PATINO, 17-10354, DAKOTA MIDDAUGH, 17-10549, MARTHA MIRACLE, PAMELA SIDERS, 17-10357, SHARON RATCLIFF, 17- 17-10535, DANIEL MITCHELL, 17-10528, on behalf of 10360, LORI REYNOLDS, 17-10361, PEGGY NEWBY, ESTATE OF CHRISTINE MITCHELL, CHRISTOPHER 17-10664, ERIC SUPPLE, 17-10555, On behalf of RATHBONE, 17-10553, TRACY LEWIS, 17-10635, Chrystal Supple, CONNIE SUE MARSEE, 17-10597, EVELYN PAPP-ROCHE, 17-10596, AUDRE'AS SCHESTER MARTIN, 17-10667, BARBARA MCGRAW, DE'MONG LANE, SR., 17-10406, DONNA FAYE LANE, 17-10563, JAMES SIZEMORE, 17-10670, TRACY 17-10639, PEGGY ELIZABETH MENZEL, 17-10561, KOPPENHAVER, 17-10724, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA MICHELLE LILLY, 17-10617, NATHAN TOWNSEN, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*267] Plaintiff in 17-10583, KIM MATONIK, 17-10573, MONTGOMERY, AL. CAROLYN JEAN MCCLENDON, 17-10567, RUBY CAROL MASON, 17-10579, KATHLEEN LAWRENCE, For MARY A RAY, 17-10755, Plaintiffs: DAVID I. 17-10411, ROSIE STAMPS, 17-10478, SHERRI CATES, LEAD ATTORNEY, CATES MAHONEY LLC, REDDIX, 17-10481, MICHELLE PAYNE, 17-10484, SWANSEA, IL. SUZANNE PATTERSON, 17-10487, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, For BONITA CARTER, 17-10378, TONEKO KAYZER, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-10375, LISA SCHUTTE, 17-10377, RETHA BACKUS, 17-10366, SUSAN PAIGE, 17-10343, PAUL THOMAS, 17-10340, KIMBERLY VILLNEUVE, 17- For CHRISTINA AGUILAR, 17-10520, on behalf of 10351, LINDA GIROUX, 17-10359, JODY HAYES, 17- Patricia Thompson, TONESHA JOHNSON, 17-10521, 10355, JOYCE KNUTSEN, 17-10534, JON PEARSON, on behalf of YOLANDA KENDRIX, TAISKA Page 91 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *267

17-10534, DIANA CUSTER, 17-10536, LISA MANDEL, REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF DEBORAH 17-10630, JOSEPH RUSSO, 17-10630, JENNIFER WILLIAMS, DECEASED, ROGER SULLIVAN, JR, 17- TAYLOR, 17-10544, SHARON JOHNSON, 17-10636, 10584, CHARLENE LANE, 17-10574, on behalf of ELBERT LEE HALL, 17-10616, DONNA KOVAL, 17- ESTATE OF CHERINA H. LANE, DECEASED, 10558, B.J. WEBSTER, 17-10640, JAMIE WEBSTER, AMANDA DAVIS, 17-10587, CHRISTINA RIFFEL, 17- 17-10640, WILLIAM JOHNSON, 17-10585, MICHAEL 10566, LANA HOLLAND, 17-10589, OTIS P. GRIER, PARE, 17-10564, KAREN ROBINSON, 17-10572, 17-10578, KIMBERLY HALL, 17-10578, on behalf of ELAINE PEPIN, 17-10407, PATRICIA BREEDEN, 17- ESTATE OF ELLEN JOYCE GRIER, JOSEPH 10588, FRANK KELLEY, 17-10588, KENNETH J. BOWMAN, 17-10482, TIMOTHY [*269] GOAD, 17- COLE, 17-10576, TERRI COLE, 17-10576, Plaintiffs: 10489, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. NY. For SYLVIA MINOR, 17-10634, Plaintiff: MEGHAN For BARBARA SABER, 17-10611, BLAINE DUDUIT, ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, RACHEL BETH ABRAMS, 17-10637, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN ELIZABETH LEAD ATTORNEYS, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES SAN FRANCISCO, CA. ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For SHERONDA L. AUSTIN, 17-10615, Plaintiff: For JOHN GENTRY, 17-10348, Plaintiff: MARK P CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEWPORT MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC; JAMES G. BEACH, CA. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, For ALICE M. BERNDT, 17-10623, DAWN M. L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD BLANCHARD, 17-10622, [*268] Plaintiffs: CARMEN ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC.

For CHARLES BULL, 17-10964, MARYLOU DEMELIA, For ALICE ROBINSON, 17-10447, LINDA BENGE- 17-10971 PABLO VALDEZ DIAZ, 17-10981, Individually RODRIGUEZ, 17-10249, JEFF GUTE, 17-10539, ROY and on behalf of Celida Diaz- Regus and the Estate of L KIKER, 17-10665, Plaintiffs: STEVEN DAVID Celida Diaz- Regus, DOUGLAS HITE, 17-11007, RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, Individually and on behalf of Florence Fudge-Hite and PHILADELPHIA, PA. the Estate of Florence Fudge-Hite, CARRIE LARSON, 17-11013, Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD For DEBRA GILBERT, 17-10614, ANNA CONROY, 17- ATTORNEY, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, 10626, Plaintiffs: TOMISLAV GEORGE ANTUNOVICH, MO. LEAD ATTORNEY, BISNAR | CHASE, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. For GRACE E. BENNETT, 17-10618, JAMES A. BARAFF, 17-10619, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS For DAVID ENGELHARDT, 17-10545, STEVEN SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. POWERS, 17-10471, SUSAN COSTANZO, 17-10551, PLEASANT, SC. JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD VERNA GULLETTE, 17-10554, ERNIE HURLEY, 17- ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON [*270] O'LEARY 10543, on behalf of NINA HURLEY, JESSIE HARRIS, PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. Quillin, 17-10512, SHANNON KLINKHAMMER, 17-10560, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. SAMIR RANA, 17-10473, LYNN FARRELL, 17-10509, Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD on behalf of ESTATE OF MARILYN FARRELL, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & DECEASED, CHERYL GASNER, 17-10562, PATRICIA PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, BERGANTINO, 17-10508, KARIN GIRARD, 17-10598, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & INDIVIDUALLY AND AS THE PERSONAL pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. Page 92 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *270

For JILLENE THOMSEN CORRIGAN, 17-10986, Plaintiff: KRISTIE MARIE HIGHTOWER, LEAD For SHARON PIKE, 17-10669, KIMBERLY G ATTORNEY, LUNDY LUNDY SOILEAU & SOUTH LLP, FLETCHER, 17-10700, CYNTHIA L JOHNSON, 17- LAKE CHARLES, LA. 10705, RANAE THOLE, 17-10737, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLIZZARD & NABERS LLP, HOUSTON, TX. For BIBI KARIM, 17-10747, JANICE KEESLER, 17- 10750, CHRISTINE JOHNSON, 17-10754, BRENDA RACINE, 17-10792, ANJANETTE BROWN, 17-10796, For SHARON RADER, 17-10409, Plaintiff: DAVID T. PATRICIA BRISSETTE, 17-10800, LETTON SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM WILLIAMS, 17-10643, on behalf of LINDA WILLIAMS, PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. COLLEEN RUSSELL, 17-10644, JEFF RUSSELL, 17- 10644, NICO STEEN, 17-10645, KENNETH LEAK, 17- For HERMAN E. CHISHOLM, JR., 17-10686; cv-10803, AMEALIA CLARKE, 17-10805, DIANNA individually and as successor of Joyce Ann Chisholm, SMITH, 17-10759, JENNIE DUNCAN-FORD, [*272] Deceased, WINONA W. BISHOP, 17-10682, DONNA K 17-11017, DONNA SMITH, 17-10769, JAMES SMITH, REYNOLDS, 17-10678, NATALIE R. EDGERTON, 17- 17-10769, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA 10680, PEGGY COREA, 17-10766, Plaintiffs: HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. For DEANNA SMITH, 17-10747, Plaintiff: DAVID I. For PAMELA MATIAS, 17-10689, DEBRA MCKINLEY, CATES, LEAD ATTORNEY, CATES MAHONEY LLC, 17-10696, Plaintiffs: PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD SWANSEA, IL. ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. For NOREEN FEWRY, 17-10748, JOYCE LATTA, 17- 10758, CHARLEEN SMITH, 17-10999, RUTH For JANICE BARKER, 17-10694, RHONDA DANIELS, SOLOMON, 17-11005, NICOLE RANDALL, 17-10887, 17-10698, DENISE KHOURY, 17-10701, VICTOR JUDITH , 17-10768, ALESIA CORNELIOUS, KHOURY, 17-10701, JOHN L. MOEN, 17-10703, 17-11139, PATRICIA RINGLE, 17-11135, HELEN RICHARD SLACK, 17-10707, LORRAINE VEGA, 17- BOOS, 17-11143, on behalf of ESTATE OF 10711, [*271] Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE ANNE LYONS, MARGARET BOOS, RONALD ROBINSON, 17-11136, LEAD ATTORNEY, WALTON TELKEN FOSTER LLC, on behalf of JOAN ROBINSON, BERNADETTE EDWARDSVILLE, IL. STROM, 17-11138, HEIDI GILL, 17-11164, Plaintiffs: STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. For TINA KOSICEK, 17-10695, RODNEY BODE, 17- 10699, MAURICE COOK, 17-10704, KATHY RAINS, 17-10704, BARBARA DERTON, 17-10706, For LISA NELSON, 17-10749, RICHARD REIFSTECK, KATHERINE SANDIFER, 17-10708, JAMES 17-10787, DEBBIE SCRUGGS, 17-10793, LOUISE EBERSOLDT, 17-10713, CONNIE BALLEZ, 17-10714, LOMBARDO, 17-10684, KATHERINE JOHNSON, 17- WENDY GAUTHIER, 17-10717, AMELIA PERDUE, 17- 10673, DAVID LAYTON, 17-10676, SUSAN NICE, 17- 10720, PHYLLIS MYER, 17-10722, DAVID SHOVAN, 10763, HELENA SCULLIN, 17-cv-10809, MARY 17-10724, GENA MALDONADO, 17-10725, KIRRA WINTERS, 17-10915, LINDA YOST, 17-cv-10918, JONES, 17-10739, SONYA YOUNG, 17-10743, CINDY ZENZEL, 17-cv-10926, TABITHA VICTORY, 17- Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD 10909, JAMES VICTORY, 17-10909, RONALD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. REDMOND, 17-10778, Plaintiffs: PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. For ALIZA AMBRIZ, 17-10741, Plaintiff: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C. LOS ANGELES, CA. For LORA THACKER, 17-10751, BRET BOX, 17- 10756, [*273] LINDA KULICK, 17-10756, GLENDA KALLEN, 17-10782, ROBIN HEIFNER, 17-10784, Page 93 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *273

JANICE KAONA, 17-10788, KATHLEEN RODRIGUEZ, THORNBURGH, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 17-10789 (Florida), STEPHEN PANTALONE, 17-10791, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, AYLSTOCK WITKIN RUNNETTE OWENS, 17-10795, TAMARA JONES, 17- KREIS & OVERHOTLZ, PLLC, PENSACOLA, FL. 10798, LEAZETTE VALENTIN, 17-10801, SONJA WARE-BOYD, 17-cv-10802, DEBORAH For KIMBERLY NAIR, 17-10649, SHARON PHILLIPS, BARANOWSKI, 17-10862, SCOTT BRODY, 17-10859, 17-10651, MICHELLE RICE, 17-10652, LINDA HAYS, MICHAELA JONES, 17-10861, LANA JEAN 17-10991 (Kentucky), DIANE TAYLOR, 17-10653, RAGSDALE, 17-10860, MAX RAGSDALE, 17-10860, RONALD VIDOCK, 17-10943, on behalf of ESTATE OF CLINTON WALKER, 17-10858, NAOMI WRIGHT, 17- BARBARA VIDOCK, JOANN FANGROW, 17-10767, 10863, EDWARD HARMON, 17-10869, JENNIFER MARY J DELANEY, 17-10949, ALICE LOCKLEAR, 17- ATKINSON, 17-10872, SHAWN FERGUSON, 17- 10660, on behalf of ESTATE OF BERNICE 10866, JEAN MASTRIANNI, 17-10868, other MARIE LOCKLEAR, DECEASED, [*275] JAMES DANIELS, MASTRIANNI, KATHRYN TURNBULL, 17-10864 next 17-10955, on behalf of MORIE DANIELS, BRYAN of Kin Roberta Logan, THOMAS ZETTERSTROM, 17- BOND, 17-11008, SCOTT BURNS, 17-11002, 10877, SADIE NELSON, 17-10761, TONJERELLE RICHARD DISNEY, SR, 17-11006, RICHARD SNELL, MILNER, 17-10886, MARY PEARSON, 17-10892, on 17-11010, on behalf of ESTATE OF KATHLENE KAY behalf of JOANN PEARSON, DOROTHY SMITH- SNELL, DECEASED, ROBERT READ, 17-10959, on MCCLURE, 17-10894, AMBER BOHNET, 17-cv-10914, behalf of CYNTHIA READ, MARIA GOMEZ, 17-10889, MARY ELLEN DUGOSH, 17-cv-10928, DONESHIA HANNAH TAYLOR, 17-10885, JONAH TAYLOR, 17- GORDON, 17-cv-10922, LISA RIDDEL, 17-cv-10917, 10885, GENA STANLEY, 17-10762, ALEXANDRA DOUGLAS PLAUTZ, 17-10906, SALLY PLAUTZ, 17- COBBS, 17-10891, GLENN EVERLITH, SR, 17-10893, 10906, SABRINA MANLEY, 17-10910, ASHLEY on behalf of THE ESTATE OF LINDA EVERLITH, PACHOV, 17-10772, CHRISTINE SKENANDORE, 17- DECEASED, AUGUSTINA PARR, 17-cv-10916, 10775, DOLORES BORGES, 17-10779, Plaintiffs: DWIGHT EDMONDS, 17-10895, PAUL EDDY, 17- TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE 11021, EVALYN SCHIFFMAN, 17-10902, WILLIAM MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. LORENZ, 17-10904, on behalf of ESTATE OF CATHY LORENZ, MARIE MORICETTES, 17-10770, DOROTHY For CAROLYN GAUTHIER, 17-10786, Plaintiff: [*274] EVANS, 17-10774, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN EDWARD A. WALLACE, LEAD ATTORNEY, WEXLER RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT WALLACE LLP, CHICAGO, IL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For VICTOR E. AUSTIN, 17-10797, on behalf of For JAMES WEST, 17-10873, on behalf of ESTATE OF ESTATE OF PATRICIA AUSTIN, ALLEN W. FRAZIER, NANCY WEST, TRACY MATHIS, 17-10875, KAREN 17-cv-10804, DIANA HETHERINGTON, 17-10968, GLENN, 17-10903, Plaintiffs: THOMAS P. CARTMELL, CHRYSIAN GARCIA, 17-cv-10808, Plaintiffs: LAUREN LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL LLP, KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY KANSAS CITY, MO. ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For CHRISTOPHER O'SHEI, 17-10867, Plaintiff: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For ELLIS G. REYNOLDS, 17-10678, COLETTE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & NORENBERG, 17-10674, Plaintiffs: PRISCILLA E. ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. For ROBIN DULA, 17-10992, CRYSTAL TUCKER, 17- 10979, MERIAL FARVE, [*276] MICKEY FRIGON, For ROBERT N. WILLIAMS, 17-10871, on behalf of DEBORAH HONOLD, 17-11001, 17-11000, 17-10997, ESTATE OF BETTY JO WILLIAMS, DECEASED, MOLLIE ARNDT, 17-10944, ROZETT BATTLE, 17- WALTER HOOD, 17-10874, on behalf of ESTATE OF 10946, PAMELA BENOIT, 17-10950, JAMES A. ICIE HOOD, DECEASED, GLADYS JONES, 17-10876, BROOKS, 17-10952, SHATEMA BROUGHTON, 17- ANGELA LOFTUS, 17-10880, GERALD LOFTUS, 17- 10956, MICHAEL ABELSON, 17-10984, REBECCA 10880, LYNN DORSEY, 17-10969, Plaintiffs: DANIEL J. ALRUBAIIE, 17-11009, ANNIE BECKLEY, 17-10987, Page 94 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *276

RONALD DENNING, 17-10958, KENDALL EATON, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, 10960, SHERRY FLOWE, 17-10963, BROCK CA. HARDISON, 17-10962, THOMAS FURNISH, 17-10965, MICAH HARTER, 17-10966, JEANNE GRANT, 17- For BRENDA BERG, 17-10807, SCOTT BERG, 17-cv- 10970, ANNE GRANUM, 17-10972, LARRY 10807, BRADLEY ANDREWS, 17-10675, MELISSA BYINGTON, 17-10990, JEAN GRAWBADGER, 17- ANDREWS, 17-10675, KARIE HUDSON, 17-10901, 10973, HENRY HENDERSON, 17-10975, CYNTHIA KENNETH HUDSON, 17-10901, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL JANE, 17-10977, DIANE BARTON, 17-11365, SOLLIAH FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*278] COUNSEL NOT BRYANT, 17-11366, STEPHANIE ERIN HURLBUT, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, POTTS LAW FIRM, 11367, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD Houston, TX. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WASHINGTON, DC. For FRANCIS CERNIGLIA, 17-10662, on behalf of JANET CERNIGLIA, DECEASED, Plaintiff: ERIC D. For TERRI FRASCONE, 17-10993, THOMAS HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOLLAND GROVES STEWART, 17-10983, BEVERLY CORMIER, 17-10976, SCHNELLER & STOLZE LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For CHARLES GOODWIN, 17-10882, Plaintiff: HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLASINGAME For DAVID DESORCY, 17-cv-11224, PATRICIA BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA. ENRIQUEZ, 17-10996, KARRIE SEVERANCE, 17-cv- 11229, GUY RHOADS, PAMELA RHOADS, 17-11235, 17-11235, RALPH MASSENGILL, 17-11241, surviving For JOAN ASTUDILLO, 17-cv-10920, MARK spouse and surviving beneficiary for the wrongful death ASTUDILLO, 17-cv-10920, Plaintiffs: CARYN MICHELE of Shirley Massengill, STEPHEN GILMORE, [*277] 17- PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT cv-11246, TERESA BALL, 17-10954, LATRICE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON LAW MASON, 17-11047, Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. For PATRICIA JEAN RALPH 17-11011, Plaintiff: MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD For LISA MARIE CRUCE, 17-10994, JEFFREY E. ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN BROWNLEE, 17-10661, REBECCA DRAYTON, 17- FRANCISCO, CA. 11159, ALEISA A. SMITH, 17-11154, KAIA O. DALLAS, 17-11027, ROBERTA RAE JACOBS, 17-11137, MARY For EARL MUSE, 17-11016, RITA RYAN, 17-11024, LEE SULLIVAN, 17-11140, MARY L. TRUMAN, 17- GERARD RYAN, 17-11024, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL S. 11142, Plaintiffs: KRISTIE MARIE HIGHTOWER, LEAD WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PARKER WAICHMAN ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY. BAR, LAKE CHARLES, LA.

For SANDRA BEAVER, 17-11018, CARRIE BENNING, For THOMAS JACKSON, 17-10654, KATHY JORDAN, 17-11025, HELEN LINCECUM, 17-11046, DEBORAH 17-10879, on behalf of VIRGINIA ROLLING, RALPH NEUMAYER, 17-11051, DAWN MAYKOWSKI, 17- JOHNSON, 17-10995, NANCY SHULAR, 17-10655, 11050, PENNY SWEET, 17-11052, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. RENEE ARCHULETA, 17-10656, JANET OWENS, 17- FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON BECKER 10656, KRISTEN TROOP, 17-10657, DAWN MOLINA, PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. 17-10658, JEFFREY MURPHY, 17-10663, Plaintiffs: STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. For ANGELO MASSARO, 17-11026, NANCY MASSARO, 17-11026, Plaintiffs: WENDY R. FLEISHMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For ENRIQUE VICENTE OCHO, 17-10942, AILEEN ADMITTED TO USDC BAR-NJ, [*279] NEW YORK, OCHOA, 17-10942, Plaintiffs: TOMISLAV GEORGE NY. ANTUNOVICH, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Page 95 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *279

17-11074, ROGER FRYE, 17-11074, SHAWN FRYE, 17-11074, on behalf of, ESTATE OF KATHLEEN FRYE, For CHRISTINE TODD, 17-10773, THERETHA SHANNON MEADOWS, 17-11074, CHARIS SANDLIN, 17-10780, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH LANCASTER, 17-11075, DANIEL BOYD LANCASTER, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 17-11075, on behalf of, ESTATE OF HOLLI ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. LANCASTER, JEFFREY LANCASTER, 17-11075, MICHAEL LANCASTER, 17-11075, ZACHARY For ALVIN B. GLASER, 17-11363, JONATHAN LANCASTER, 17-11075, TRICIA COURSE-CISLO, 17- GLASER, 17-11363, Plaintiffs: Brian Alan Goldstein, 11236, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, Cellino & Barnes, P.C. (NYC), New ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ York, NY. BAR, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN.

For STEVEN BAGGETT, 17-11048, Plaintiff: For RANDALL SCOTT WHITECOTTON, 17-11028, CHRISTOPHER ANDREW MCNUTT, LEAD GREGORY MCNEIL DOHERTY, 17-11032, Plaintiffs: ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD BAR, HOLLIS WRIGHT CLAY & VAIL PC, ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN BIRMINGHAM, AL. FRANCISCO, CA.

For JOELLEN HOOVER, 17-11165 individually, EMMA For DARREN ALCALA, 17-11166, JONATHAN MASHBURN, 17-11165 domestic partner, Plaintiffs: ALCALA, 17-11166, [*281] JOSEPH ALCALA, 17- NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, 11166, RYAN ALCALA, 17-11166, SAMARAH COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAUM ALVARADO, 17-11166, BERNITA CHARLIE HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS BARBORKA, 17-11168, FRANK A. BARBORKA, 17- ANGELES, CA. 11168, JUANITA PRUIETT, 17-11167, TAWANA SMITH, 17-11167, ANGELICA CRESPO, 17-11174, KATHLEEN CORTEZ CRESPO, 17-11174, LUIS For LEON ASHLOCK, 17-11080, KENNETH DAVIS, 17- CRESPO, 17-11174 spouse, SAADIA CRESPO, 17- 11079, on behalf of, DONNA DAVIS, MARCIE 11174, VICTOR CRESPO, 17-11174, KEITH R. BRADLEY, 17-11081, ILA R ALLEE, 7-11084, SHIRLEY HOLLAND, JR., 17-11174, LETITIA MATTHEWS, 17- JEAN ASHFORD, 17-11083, OLEITA BOWLING, 17- 11158, CRAIG SMITH, JR., 17-11158, Plaintiffs: 11082, JAMES A. GILL, 17-11086, PATRICIA NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, McCORKLE, individually and as next of kin to COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAUM NATHALIE McCORKLE, deceased. 17-11087 on behalf HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS of, NATHALIE McCORKLE, Plaintiffs: MATTHEW J. ANGELES, CA. SILL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SILL LAW GROUP, Oklahoma City, OK. For DOROTHEA MORGAN, 17-11029, LINDA NORMAN, 17-11062, PATRICK NORMAN, 17-11062, PEGGY WAUGH, in 17-11069, CYNTHIA FOGLE, 17- For NAOMI STEVENS, 17=11077, on behalf [*280] of, 11071, FLORENCE NIBA, 17-11035, SHEREE ESTATE OF JEAN STEVENS, LADAWN PERKINS, 17- PEOPLES, 17-11211, CASSIE SMITH, 17-11212, 11065, SARAH SANDERS, 17-11063, LESA BENTON, LYNN STROM, 17-11054, Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. 17-11030, LORETTA CORDELL, 17-11033, ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT GEOFFREY EGLEN, 17-11072, GINA EGLEN, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE SIMON LAW 11072, GREGORY EGLEN, 17-11072, THE ESTATE FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. OF LAURA EGLEN, 17-11072, AMY DANAHEY, 17- 11034, BRITTANY COOPER, 17-11078, other, SHARON COOPER, CAMERON COOPER, 17-11078, For TOMMICA WINZER, 17-11060, Plaintiff: D.O. RICHARD COOPER, 17-11078, on behalf of, CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ESTATE OF SHARON COOPER, EMILY KEESEE, 17- ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, 11078, ARLENE DUGAN, 17-11036, RUBY ELLIOTT, NY; STACY KATHRYN HAUER, LEAD ATTORNEY, 17-11038, AUDREY FRYE, 17-11074, JEFFERY FRYE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Page 96 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *281

JOHNSON BECKER, ST. PAUL, MN. BASSACK, JR, 17-11105, on behalf of, MABEL BASSAK, THOMAS ROSELL, 17-11108, on behalf of, ELIZABETH ROSELL, JESSICA WOLF, 17-11107, on For JOSEPH LEE GONZALES, 17-11171, on behalf of, behalf of, MOLLY HAWKINS, REBECCA SANCHEZ, MARYJANE GONZALES, [*282] MELISSA M. 17-11110, LAUREN COVINGTON, 17-11125, BILLY FOSTER, 17-11173, on behalf of, THE ESTATE OF RILEY, 17-11127, on behalf of, ESTATE OF ILLA RAE NELL BARNES, THOMAS P. QUIRK, 17-11172, on RILEY, DECEASED, STEVEN TERNER, 17-11130, on behalf of, RAMONA N. QUIRK, MARSHA LYNNE behalf of, ESTATE OF ELLEN SHAPIRO TERNER, DIXON, 17-11113, REVA MAE FURBY, 17-11115, FLINT CRILEY, 17-11131, MARIETTA SPANGLER, 17- JUDY ANN MALGERI, 17-11064, GLENN A. FULLER, 11292, CAROLYN MAHARRY, 17-11295, DEANAH 17-11070, on behalf of, ESTATE OF THRESIA E. SHEARER, 17-10911, on behalf of, ESTATE OF LINDA FULLER, DEBORAH ARLENE DOWLER, 17-11037, BROOKS, [*284] DECEASED, MARION T YOUNG, III, JAMES E. ALLEN, 17-11109, BETTY S. HAMPTON 17-10913, on behalf of, ESTATE OF JANET YOUNG, GUZIK, 17-11126, GENEVA GARRISON, 17-11057, BRYAN NOVAK, 17-11023, on behalf of, ESTATE OF Plaintiffs: KRISTIE MARIE HIGHTOWER, LEAD GWENDOLYN LICKTEIG, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, LUNDY LUNDY SOILEAU & SOUTH LLP, LAKE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON CHARLES, LA. O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For NANCY ADCOCK, 17-11313, SOPHIE M For SHIRLEY GRACE, 17-11176, BONNIE WAMSLEY, HOLLIFIELD, 17-11333, Plaintiffs: STEVEN ALAN 17-11178, ELSA ROSALES, 3:17-cv-10288, RAYMOND HART, LEAD ATTORNEY, Hart McLaughlin & Eldridge, DOIEL, 17-10294, TRESA STROUD, 17-10811, Chicago, IL United Sta. RANDY STROUD, 17-10811, LARRY H. LAMPLEY, 17- 10373, DENIS CHAREST, 17-10818, NANCY For CAROL CAMBRIA, 17-11175, on behalf of, KELLY CHAREST, 17-10818, KATHLEEN GRIMLEY, 17-10821 CABRIA, DECEASED, MILLICENT REESE, 17-11177, (Individually), KAREN WITCHER, 17-11287, Plaintiffs: CONSTANTINE MILLER, 17-11117, KENNETH CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD STEVENS, 17-11118, TRISHA SCHOCK, 17-11187, ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, WANDA JOSEPH, 17-11198, THOMAS WEEDMAN, NY. 17-11179, on behalf of, CAROL WEEDMAN, GEORGE SMITH, 17-11197; INDIVIDUALLY AND AS For MARY TAVAKE, 17-10289, SYLVIA SCRUGGS, REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF LINDA K. 3:17-cv-10292, KEVIN HACKETT, 17-11294, Plaintiffs: SMITH, DECEASED, SAIDA RUIZ, 17-11200, JAMES DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL WEIRICH, 17-11201, on behalf of, Estate of Genevieve NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & Weirich, PATRICIA HOGUE, 17-11204, PAUL ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. GORDON, 17-11196, on behalf [*283] of, ESTATE OF MARIA GORDON, KEVIN COURTNEY, 17-11195, MICHAEL COMBS, 17-11194, MARCY BERST, 17- For TIM GENSTER, 3:17-cv-10293, on behalf of, EMMA 11190, ELLA FRAZIER, 17-11090, TERESSA ANN GENSTER, WILLIAM SULLIVAN, 17-10812, on behalf MILLS, 17-11090, on behalf of, ESTATE OF ELLA of Mary Sullivan, KRISTEN HINDS, 17-10816, JOHN FRAZIER, DECEASED, JOSEPH GRANT, 17-11121, NICOLAN, 17-cv-10820, VICKI ROSSER, 17-10822, on behalf of, ESTATE OF MELINDA GRANT, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD DECEASED, MARY FRANCES KITHCART, 17-11091, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ JAMES RITTENHOUSE, 17-11123, on behalf of, LISA BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & RITTENHOUSE, , 17-11093, MARY MILES [*285] PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. HAYES, 17-11094, LOLA LUCE, 17-11094, KAREN SCHAMP, 17-11095, NAUMAN TAHIR, 17-11096, For JANICE BUCKLEY, 17-10295, DANIEL DYER, 17- DEBORAH KOCHE, 17-11097, KATHLEEN SPLAIN, 10810, on behalf of, Valerie Dyer, BRIDGETT LATRICE 17-11097, MARY ELLEN BOXER, 17-11098, RICHARD MAXWELL, 17-10815, CHERYL JEAN MIZAK, 17- BOXER, 17-11098, PATRICIA GEISER, 17-11099, 10819, CECILIA PATTERSON, 17-10824, VERONICA BRIAN BUTLER, 17-11100, JEANINE CONTE, 17- PORTER, 17-10826, Plaintiff: BRITTANY SAMANTHA 11101, KIMBERLY HEALY, 17-11103, STANLEY Page 97 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *285

SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For CAMILLE ROGERS, 17-11041, Plaintiff: John G. Simon, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, For MARIZELA MUNNS, 17-11116, Plaintiff: JENNIFER P.C., St. Louis, MO. LYNN ORENDI, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WASHINGTON, DC; For STEPHANIE BRAZZLE, 17-11215, CONNIE STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, HAMM, 17-11248, KATHY TEAGUE, 17-11286, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MICHAEL WELLS, 17-11290, MARY REA, 17-11291, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. MARIE GALLEY, 17-11293, Plaintiffs: TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For BOBBIE JEAN SHAW, Plaintiff in 17-11068, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SIMMONS HANLY MELODY SHAW, Plaintiff in 17-11068, on behalf of, CONROY, ALTON, IL. ESTATE OF BOBBIE JEAN SHAW, DECEASED, WENDY NYMAN, 17-11031, KATHY GIANNINI, 17- For CATHERINE HARMER, 17-11042, Plaintiff: 11039, CANDICE ELLISON, 17-11073, KAREN MICHAEL K. JOHNSON, LEAD [*287] ATTORNEY, MARTIN, 17-11043, MARY BAUM, 17-11054, Plaintiffs: COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL JOHNSON BECKER, PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PARKER WAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY. For GLORIA JONES BOLTON, Plaintiff in 17-11076, JAMES BOLTON, 17-11076, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER For STEPHEN BRAHM, 17-11053, Plaintiff: ADRIANA ANDREW MCNUTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HOLLIS WRIGHT NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SKIKOS CLAY & VAIL PC, BIRMINGHAM, AL. CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For EILEEN MARTEN, 17-11245, BARBARA HAX, 17- 11238, RACHELLE WIENER, 17-11251, DIANNE For JAMES PARK, 17-10299, RITA PARK, 17- WRIGHT, 17-11255, JUANITA PEARSON, 17-11273, 10299, [*286] Plaintiffs: MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD TONETTE BROWN, 17-11257, ANGELA LISNICH, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 11284, MARGARET BURNS, 17-cv-11259, LOUIS BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. JANN, 17-11289, BETTY ALLEN, 17-11281, THERESA SAWYER, 17-11279, GEORGINA DIAZ, 17-11260, For MS. SHERRY SHIPLEY, 3:17-cv-10374, JOYCE ARCIUOLO, 17-cv-11216, ELAINE BIELBY, 17- SHANNON STOCKTON, 17-10183, Plaintiffs: cv-11221, MARIE BRACKINRIDGE, 17-cv-11227, PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, KATHY HARRIS, 17-cv-11232, TAMBRIA FULLER, 17- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 11263, NANCY SINKOVEC, 17-11309, BRENDA MONTGOMERY, AL. FUOSS, 17-11268, JOYCE WHITE, 17-11303, LOVELL MCKEE, 17-11306, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO For SUSAN SUMMERS, 17-10817, VERONICA TATE, USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, 17-10825, GERALDINE THOMPSON, 17-11285, WASHINGTON, DC. LAJUAN DINKINS, 17-11272, SHILINDA SCOTT, 17- 11283, ETHEL GASPARD, 17-11274, DESTINY GASS, 17-11282, MARTHA GRIFFIN, 17-11278, LINDA For ALICE EMERY, 17-11120, JUDITH SMITH, 17- KIRKSEY, 17-11280, JEANNE GOMBETTA, 17-11298, 11122, ROXANNE RUE, 17-11128, GREG WRIGHT, CRYSTAL MORRIS, 17-11262, SANDRA PRESLEY, 17-11129, DAVID COMPSTON, 17-11132, LAURA 17-11266, EUGENE CAFARO, 17-11269, VALERIE WALLICK, 17-11022, Plaintiffs: STUART LEE CROOKS, 17-11270, Plaintiffs: PATRICK KELLY GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GOLDENBERG [*288] Page 98 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *288

LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. 17-11315, LYNN JONES RICHARDS, 17-11315, NATHANIEL SIMS, 17-11328, DIANA FRANKLIN, 17- 11408, JANE ROBERTS, 17-11410, SYLVIA TRAPINI, For BRENDA MAXWELL, 17-10912, Plaintiff: JASPER 17-11409, DETRA DEESE, 17-11147, on behalf of D. WARD, IV, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ESTATE OF ROSA ALLEN, DECEASED, WANDA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JONES WARD PLC, BATES, 17-11148, on behalf of ESTATE OF SUSAN LOUISVILLE, KY. ROSS, DECEASED, STEVE PETRIE, 17-11150, on behalf of CHRISTINA PETRIE, PAMELA STUBBS, 17- For JOIANNE PYRAM, 17-11214, Plaintiff: CHRISTINA 11152, STASIA AHEARN, 17-11572, KRISTIN MARIE GRAZIANO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LARSON, 17-11571, BONNIE YOUNG, 17-10930, on NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, behalf of ESTATE OF SANDRA YOUNG, DECEASED, WASHINGTON, DC; JAMES D. GOTZ, STEVEN B. AISHA COLEMAN, 17-11611, JAMES EVANS, 17- ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT 10933, CHRISTINE HARDERS, 17-10939, Plaintiffs: ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, BOSTON, MA. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For ROBERT PLOTNER, 17-11299, on behalf of, DEANNA PLOTNER, DECEASED, Plaintiff: For GINNIE CHILDRESS, 17-11323, MICHAEL KATHERINE BARRETT RILEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHILDRESS, 17-11323, MARIE H. CLARK, 17-11320, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON VERONICA MINIX, 17-11325, JOSE FAGUNDO, 17- BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. 11332, SHARON FAGUNDO, 17-11332, CAMERON MITCHELL, 17-11327, JENNIFER MITCHELL, 17- 11327, LEANN CAMPBELL, 17-11334, LINDA [*290] For MARIE CAROLE HEYING, 17-11443, SANDRA K DOSTER, 17-11336, BRUCE DOSTER, 17-11336, JOHNSON, 17-11449, Plaintiffs: BRANDI R. DIANE FEHER, 17-11338, MICHAEL FEHER, 17- HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, 11338, ROSEMARIE PETTI, 17-11340, TRAVIS COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SALISBURY, 17-11343, EVELYN HUDGINS, 17-11345, BARRETT LAW GROUP PA, LEXINGTON, MS. LINDA DIANE MERCER, 17-11347, KELLI BALL RAKOZY, 17-11350, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN ELIZABETH For MASUD AHMED, 17-11302, Plaintiff: MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. For JANE STOROZYSZYN, 17-11324, MAGDALENA LETOURNEAUT, 17-11330, CHERYL B SAYEGH, 17- For EMMA WILBORN, 17-11308, RUBY WYROSDICK, 11331, YOKITA SEYMOUR, 17-11329, ROBIN E 17-11310, Plaintiffs: PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD SIZEMORE, 17-11326, ASHLEY W BENFORD, 17- ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, 11339, LISA L CULLEY, 17-11337, SHERRY TABOR, WASHINGTON, DC. 17-11344, Plaintiffs: STEVEN ALAN HART, LEAD ATTORNEY, Hart McLaughlin & Eldridge, Chicago, IL.

For ROBBIE BURTON, 17-11311, THOMAS BURTON, 17-11311, ANNETTE ELLISON, 17-11312, RICHARD For JENNIFER E. WHITE, 17-11423 (), ELLISON, [*289] 17-11312, STEPHANIE JOHNSON, KRISTIN L. GIDARO, 17-11429, LUCIANO BIANCO, 17-11314 (North Carolina), BARBARA SEMAN, 17- 17-11515, WILLIAM A CAMBRIA, 17-11513, LINDA 11316, JEROME SEMAN, 17-11316, ELVERA TOURO, CURTIS, 17-11511, BARKER A SHIRLEY, 17-11511, 17-11318, THEONE TOURO, 17-11318, CYNTHIA Plaintiffs: PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, BINGHAM, 17-8931, Plaintiffs: SINDHU SUSAN KLINE & SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, BARON & BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX. For ELEANOR HERNANDEZ, 17-11242, Plaintiff: MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, For HOWARD JONES, 17-11315, WANETTA PEAVY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. Page 99 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *290

For MARVELL FAIR, 17-11362, ROBERT KIRKENDALL, 17-11359, STEVEN STRONG, 17- For WILLIAM LIGGETT, 17-11240, MARTHA NELSON, 11361, Plaintiffs: MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD 17-11240, LUDMILA BRINDAR, 17-11520, Plaintiffs: ATTORNEY, NEW ORLEANS, LA. WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For CORTISHA RICHARDSON, 17-11368, KAMARR FAIR, 17-11368, Plaintiffs: STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, For BRENDA JONES, [*291] 17-11475, Plaintiff: LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE PHILADELPHIA, PA. SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO.

For DIANNA SLEETER, 17-11380, JANET SLEETER, For JACK NASATSKY, 17-11341, MARGARET 17-11380, MICHAEL SPENCER, 17-11370, PATRICIA BAFALON, 17-11346, Plaintiffs: KENNETH BRIAN SPENCER, 17-11370, A SHAWNMONIQUE BAINES, MOLL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOLL LAW GROUP, 17-11398, DORA PADILLA, 17-11393, RICHARD CHICAGO, IL. PADILLA, 17-11393, FAYE JENKS, 17-11405, GARY JENKS, 17-11405, RENEE BLUE, 17-11415, IDA For NATALIE PAGE NEWTON, 17-11342, H. R., JR., MURPHY, 17-11415, NICHOLE ALLISON, 17-11575, 17-11342, L. R., 17-11342, M. R., 17-11342, AMY M LINDA PRATT, 17-11576, EILEEN HOPPE, 17-109334, RICO, 17-11342, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MARY TERRY LARSON, 17-10934, MARTHELL MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ANDERSON, 17-11638, CAROL BROSSARD, 17- ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. 11673, CHERYL BROWN, 17-11677, MARIO MICETIC, 17-11673, EULOGIO BEJEC, 17-11699, LILIA BEJEC, 17-11699, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD For DARLENE ARDEN, 17-11351, DEBRA A. LANEAR, ATTORNEY, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, 17-11348, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, NM. LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For ASHLEY ESSIG, 17-10507, Plaintiff: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY For MARY A. CASERTA, 17-11352, SHERRI DUPART, ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, 17-11355, PATRICIA RIZZO, 17-11354, TINA MARIE MONTGOMERY, AL. VACCA, 17-11354, RANDY CASERTA, 17-11352, Plaintiffs: MARY E. ALEXANDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARY ALEXANDER & ASSOCIATES PC, SAN For LINDA F. BARBEE-COUGLER, 17-11392, Plaintiff: FRANCISCO, CA. GREGORY DONALD BROWN, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOUSTON, [*293] TX; KELSEY LOUISE STOKES, LEAD ATTORNEY, FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ LLP, For DARYL VINSON, 17-11356, MARGO VINSON, 17- HOUSTON, TX. 11356, COLLEEN BILYEU, 17-11395, CYNTHIA STANLEY, 17-11394, WILLIAM STANLEY, 17-11394, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD For MADELINE TOMS, 17-11391, DIXIE TURNQUIST, ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, 17-11390, TOM TURNQUIST, 17-11390, SUSAN NY. KOERPERICH, 17-11413, ALFREDA MONDRAY, 17- 11418, DONALD PELLETIER, 17-11420, GLORIA PRICE, 17-11422, TAMMATHA WADE, 17-11426, For DALE COURT, 17-11369, CYNTHIA CRANE, 17- SCOTT KIEKBUSH, 17-11500, MICA BAILEY, 17- 11374, MARY DIETTERICH, 17-11375, VIRGINIA 11556, DEBORAH BOWDEN, 17-11546, EDWARD O'NAN, 17-11372, MARSHA CASTRO, 17-11388, DONALDSON, 17-11552, SABRA MILLER, 17-11544, HAZEL EDWARDS, 17-11386, LENA FALLS, 17-11384, CYNTHIA NEWMAN, 17-11549, DIANNA OLIVER, 17- Plaintiffs: [*292] DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD 11555, MYNA MASON-REIBSON, 17-11582, DAVID ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, MILLER, 17-11580 () on behalf of ROSEMARY NY. RIOS, BARBARA PAYNE, 17-11583, DANIEL REIBSON, 17-11582, JANICE TICEAHKIE, 17-11581, Page 100 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *293

TRUDY HERRING, 17-11585, WENDY KIKUGAWA, 17-11149, JEAN HARRIS, 17-11151, MARY ELLEN 17-11587, BROWN, 17-11623, CLYDE TILTON, 17-11153, JULIA RANDALL-VICIAN, 17- CREECH, 17-11624, BRENDA DIXON, 17-11625 11139, Plaintiffs: [*295] STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, (North Carolina) on behalf of ESTATE OF ANNIE MAE LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, CARLTON, JOAN GLAUSSER, 17-11626, ALICIA MINNEAPOLIS, MN. LOMBARDI, 17-11627, GREGG MCKAY, 17-11629, LAWRENCE POLTER, 17-11634, RAMONA For COCANDRA THOMAS, 17-11566, KENNETH PRESCOTT, 17-11598, HATTIE MAE RACHAL, 17- THOMAS, 17-11566, Plaintiffs: JENNIFER A. LENZE, 11630, BRIDGET ULMAN, 17-11631, KARLA WALKER, LEAD ATTORNEY, LENZE MOSS PLC, MANHATTAN 17-11633, THOMAS FOLEY, 17-10931, STACEY BEACH, CA. GATHERS, 17-10936, JASMYN JORDAN, 17-10938, CARL PFEIFFER, 17-11684, PAM BAILEY, 17-11690, JAMES BISHOP, 17-11689, LORRAINE BISHOP, 17- For MARGARET C. MARTIN, 17-11264, Plaintiff: 11689, [*294] KRISTY M BROOKS, 17-11694, PHILIP BOHRER, LEAD ATTORNEY, BOHRER LAW WILLENE DAVIS, 17-11692, ANN DITMORE, 17- FIRM, BATON ROUGE, LA. 11687, HOWARD FRALEY, JR., 17-11688, MICHAEL HALL, 17-11691, CYNTHIA LEE, 17-11693, Plaintiffs: For NICOLE KERR, 17-10439, Plaintiff: DAVID T. TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL.

For JOSEPH ALVY, 17-11406, GAIL HERNANDEZ, 17- For TERESA FENSTEMAKER, 17-11247, Plaintiff: 11663, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. TX.

For LUANN EDWARDS, 17-10929, Plaintiff: For JOHN DAVIDSON, 17-11404, Plaintiff: JAMES STEPHANIE RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY. LAMAR WARD, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, MCGOWAN HOOD & FELDER LLC, MOUNT PLEASANT, SC. For CARMELITA HOLDCRAFT, 17-10936, Plaintiff: JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER For KERRIE MCCARTHY, 17-11498, PAULETTE C SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; PETERSON, 17-11497, Plaintiffs: BRANDI R. Michael J. Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER AND HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN BARRETT LAW GROUP PA, LEXINGTON, MS. RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM For DIETRA MOTEN, 17-11490, BIRTTIE FRANKLIN, WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON 17-11491, Plaintiffs: SARAH STERLING STARNS, O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. LEAD ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. For DOLORES GRIEGO, 17-11618, REBECCA LUTON, 17-11619, DOLORES GREIGO, 17-11618, For KAREN STANSBURY, 17-11495, Plaintiff: KELLY MARKUS, 17-11620, LUTON REBECCA, 17- KATHERINE BARRETT RILEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, 11619, PATRICIA REYNOLDS, 17-11621, Plaintiffs: DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS. TOMISLAV GEORGE ANTUNOVICH, [*296] LEAD ATTORNEY, BISNAR | CHASE, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. For ELEANOR MARGARET WILLIE, 17-11144, CAROL S. ZANCA, 17-11146, Plaintiffs: KRISTIE MARIE HIGHTOWER, LEAD ATTORNEY, LUNDY LUNDY For JAMES ARMIJO, 17-11653, IDA M CLARK, 17- SOILEAU & SOUTH LLP, LAKE CHARLES, LA. 11652, LUDIVINA GOMEZ, 17-11648, JANET POSEY, 17-11647, RALPH D SMITH, 17-11647, SUSAN SMITH, 17-11647, SANDRA TOLBERT, 17-11647, For LASHAWN NUNN, 17-11145, RAMONA TINOCO, Page 101 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *296

MICHALENE BOUZON, 17-11662, ROBERT L HILL, 11709, MARY LOU POPE, 17-11702, RUTH 17-11658, BILLY MOORE, 17-11656, Plaintiffs: ZOLLIE SANDERS, 17-11704, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH CARLTON STEAKLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, HARRISON O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON PC, WACO, TX. For CHARLES DEGIDIO, 17-11707, JAMES L. KING, For FREDERICK C. BURGESS, 17-11614, MELVA 17-11710, ISIS HOLLIS, 17-11714, Plaintiffs: STEVEN LYNNE BURGESS, 17-11614, KENNETH PATTEN, 17- DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & 11610, STEPHANIE WELKER, 17-11610, Plaintiffs: HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. BETH KLEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLEIN & FRANK PC, BOULDER, CO. For LINDA AMBROSE, 17-11726, DANIEL SHARON, 17-11730, LINDA FOSTER, 17-11757, NANCY For FLOYD ARNOLD, 17-11649, Plaintiff: CHAD GOUCHER, 17-11761, MARLENE MONTIHO, 17- ETHAN IHRIG, LEAD ATTORNEY, NIX PATTERSON & 11770, Plaintiffs: CHAD ETHAN IHRIG, LEAD ROACH LLP, AUSTIN, TX. ATTORNEY, CHAD ETHAN IHRIG, AUSTIN, TX.

For MILTON DEMUS, 17-11672, VICTOR ISAACS, 17- For DONNA BISHOP, 17-11713, LARRY BISHOP, 17- 11676, Plaintiffs: AARON CLARK JOHNSON, LEAD 11713, ALONZO CAINE, 17-11729, JUDY CASSETTI, ATTORNEY, SUMMERS & JOHNSON PC, WESTON, 17-11760, KARA CASSETTI, 17-11760, Plaintiffs: MO. ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, [*298] NM. For JUDY ALSOP, 17-11441, APRIL GOMEZ, 17- 11444, ANGELICA RIVAS, 17-11445, LINDA KELLY, For KANDY BROOKS-HILLIARD, 17-11737, CHARLES 17-11436, SHNO AZIZ, 17-11696, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA CONLEY, 17-11736, MANDY CONLEY, 17-11736, LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, CHARLES HILLIARD, 17-11737, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN AL. ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For PAMELA ANN ATKINS, 17-11700, Plaintiff: ETHAN L. SHAW, LEAD ATTORNEY, SHAW COWART LLP, For RITA GUTIERREZ, 17-11717, Plaintiff: KEITH AUSTIN, TX. DAVID GRIFFIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, GIRARDI | KEESE, 1126 WILSHIRE BOULEVARD, LOS ANGELES, CA. For PEGGY LEE GIROUX, 17-11695, Plaintiff: CARYN MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*297] JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. For PAUL A PERKS, 17-11755, Plaintiffs: Donald A. Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Providence, RI. For CHRISTINE PUTZ, 17-11697, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. For CLAIR SHAW, 17-11739, PAMELA WARYAS, 17- 11738, ELIZABETH ACHENBACH, 17-11569, CRYSTAL WILLOUGHBY, 17-11111, Plaintiffs: For STEVEN SEWARD, 17-11686, PATRICIA STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGNER, 17-11685, WAYNE ALLEN, 17-11746, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. JOHN BAILEY, JR., 17-11749, JUDITH BELK, 17- LOUIS, MO. 11744, JOHNATHAN GREEN, 17-11743, LARRY NIXON, 17-11745, WAYNE WAITE, 17-11747, LINDA WONG-FARENBAUGH, 17-11748, Plaintiffs: TAYJES For MARTHA SPEARS, 17-11772, Plaintiffs: ETHAN L. MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER SHAW, LEAD ATTORNEY, SHAW COWART LLP, FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. AUSTIN, TX.

For JANIE CLARK, 17-11706, CHERYL MCLUCAS, 17- For EVELIA DIAZ-GALARZA, 17-10839, JONATHAN Page 102 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *298

PILAPIL, 17-10841, ELIZABETH , 17- 10844, MARY ANN HODGE, 17-10848, JANICE For MARY ALICE NIELSON, 17-11783, Plaintiff: Scott RAWLINS, 18-10851, ANGEL ROBLES, 17-10940, B. Hall, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice, LLC, Kansas Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD City, [*300] MO. ATTORNEY, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For LILLIAN THOMPSON, 17-11780, Plaintiff: PHILIP BOHRER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For KATHLEEN P BASILO, 17-11793, Plaintiff: CASEY ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BOHRER LAW FIRM, RYAN COBURN LEAD ATTORNEY, PHILADELPHIA, BATON ROUGE, LA. PA; EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, NASS CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, [*299] PA. For LINEECE BUSHAW, 17-11802, Plaintiff: SARAH STERLING STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON BARRETT For LAWRENCE BASILO, 17-11793, WAYNE PA, LEXINGTON, MS. JOURNEY, 17-11784, Plaintiffs: EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS CANCELLIERE BRENNER, For ETHEL MARIE PLUMMER, 17-11805 AND 18- PHILADELPHIA, PA. 1826, Plaintiff: DAVID MALCOLM MCMULLAN, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS; For JAMES L. CARR, 17-11782, Plaintiff: PHILIP MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL BOHRER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BOHRER LAW FIRM, GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. BATON ROUGE, LA.

For ROSEMARY LAMANTIA, 17-11809, Plaintiff: KEVIN For BARBARA CLAFFEY, 17-11792, ALAN DAVIS, 17- S. HANNON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 11792, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE HANNON LAW COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FIRM LLC, DENVER, CO. BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM.

For JOHNNY MCKENZIE, II, 17-11803, KATHERINE For CHERYL L JOURNEY, 17-11784, Plaintiff: CASEY SHEPPARD, 17-11835, KELTON SHEPPARD, 17- RYAN COBURN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 11835, KRISTINA WENGERT, 17-11868, Plaintiffs: ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PHILADELPHIA, PA; ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS ALBUQUERQUE, NM. CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA.

For KAREN BAILEY, 17-11800, PENNY GILBERT, 17- For BOBBIE N LANDRETH, 17-11788, Plaintiff: KEVIN 11804, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD R. DEAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE, MT. BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. PLEASANT, SC. LOUIS, MO.

For CHARMAINE E MIGHELLS, 17-11779, Plaintiff: For JERRY THARP, 17-11806, Administrator of the Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice Estate of Debra [*301] A. Llanes, Plaintiff: MICHAEL LLC, Providence, RI. RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLIZZARD & NABERS For DONNA M MURPHY, 17-11785, Plaintiff: Brian LLP, HOUSTON, TX. Weinstein, LEAD ATTORNEY, WEINSTEIN COUTURE PLLC, SEATTLE, WA. For CAROL CARPENTER, 17-11845, VALERIE Page 103 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *301

KIBBLE, 17-11854, LYNNE THOMSON, 17-11840, For VICTORIA HALFON, 17-11920, Plaintiff: HENRY G. Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLASINGAME BURCH JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA.

For CHARLES A ANDRUS, 17-11831, SHARON KAY For MAMIE MCCLINTON, 17-11911, CONSTANCE JACKSON, 17-11832, LEONARD J. ANNALORO, 17- MCMILLAN, 17-11909, PHYLLIS MEYER, DENISE 11860, LUCILLE J. ANNALORO, 17-11860, Plaintiffs: NELSON-EDWARDS, 17-11906, BILLIE BRITTAIN, 17- CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, 11935, GWENDOLYN JEMISON, 17-11946, MICHELLE COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOINER, 17-11954, RHONDA JONES, 17-11952 MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. (Illinois), DANIEL KIELBASA, 17-11942, KATHLEEN KIELBASA, 17-11942, DOLORES KOWALSKI, 17- 11950, GINA LEWIS, 17-11947, DELORES JACKSON, For EARL CLIFTON, 17-11837, MARIAN U. LITTLE, 17-11957, CECILIA KEY, 17-11958, MICHELLE KING, 17-11830, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD 17-11959, MAUREEN JANIGA, 17-11980, PERRY ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, JANIGA, 17-11980, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, DALLAS, TX. LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. For LINDA J HARDEE, 17-11824, JOHN F. HENDON, 17-11928, Plaintiffs: John David Hurst, LEAD For LAURA BYRD, 17-11938, [*303] BEVERLY ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Morgantown, WV. DONAHUE, 17-11956, RICHARD DONAHUE, 17- 11956, DOULOS GAIUS, 17-11989, PEGGY GAIUS, For ANTHONY J MURRAY, 17-11822, GLORIA J 17-11989, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD MURRAY, 17-11822, Plaintiffs: ZOLLIE CARLTON ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ STEAKLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON PC, WACO, TX. For DEANDRE AGUILAR, 17-11969, Plaintiff: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For JULIE BARNETT, 17-11869, on behalf of ESTATE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & OF KAREN HIPPELY, Plaintiff: ROLF T. FIEBIGER, ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, [*302] JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. For MARGIE A. FABRE, 17-11967, KATHRYN KEMPE, PAUL, MN. 17-11968, NORM RAY KRUSE, 17-11965, JASMINE M. TRACY, 17-11966, PRIMROSE BAILEY, 17-11977, For GRACIE GRIER, 17-11864, Plaintiff: TAYJES STANLEY BUTTERFIELD, 17-11981, LAWANDA MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FITTEN, 17-11983, CANDICE FITZGIBBON, 17-11970, FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. JAMES GREER, 17-11985, HERBERT HICKS, 17- 11977, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. For KIMBERLY PERKINS, 17-11863, Plaintiff: TIMOTHY DALE BRANDENBURG, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW For RICAHRD HOLMES, 17-11964, Plaintiff: DAVID FIRM OF ROGER "ROCKY" WALTON PC, PATRICK DANIEL, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ARLINGTON, TX. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DANIEL & ASSOCIATES LLC, HOUSTON, TX.

For RITA BUTLER, 17-11930, BARBARA MANGES, 17-11921, ANNA MCCARTHY, 17-11919, Plaintiffs: For MALUDI WEEKS, 17-11058, MARY VOLK, 17- DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI 11056, KAREN GLAZIER, 17-11040, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER Page 104 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *303

PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL.

For EILEEN ADAMS, 17-12009, TERRI KING, 17- For CEOLA TURNER, 17-11973, JEANNE C FRENCH, 12009, Plaintiffs: TYLER JOSEPH SCHNEIDER, LEAD 17-12050, RICHARD FRENCH, 17-12050, JASON ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- GRIGSBY, 17-12044, KATHLEEN M MOORE, 17- NJBAR, [*304] TORHOERMAN LAW, 12053, KARI MORRIS, 17-12048, Plaintiffs: TAYJES EDWARDSVILLE, IL. MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. For JUDITH CALLAHAN, 17-11987, Plaintiff: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For LILY WILLARD, 17-11992, CARL WILLARD, JR., ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HEYGOOD ORR & 17-11992, Plaintiffs: JENNIFER A. LENZE, LEAD PEARSON, IRVING, TX. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED USDC-NJ BAR LENZE MOSS PLC, MANHATTAN BEACH, CA. For JUANITA COX, 17-12000, Plaintiff: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For JEFFREY GOLDBERG, 17-12034, Plaintiff: HENRY ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA. For MELVINA LAY, 17-11995, JACQUELINE LUCAS, 17-11999, CAROL MEYER, 17-11996, CRYSTAL For SARAH SUE HARRELSON, 17-12039, AUDREY WILLIAMS, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS PATTON, 17-12045, Plaintiffs: DAVID MALCOLM REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF VERA MCMULLAN, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT GARLINGTON, DECEASED; 17-11454, Plaintiffs: ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON BARRETT PA, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEXINGTON, MS. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. For CARMEN B. JENNETTE, 17-12051, Plaintiff: John LOUIS, MO. David Hurst, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Morgantown, WV. For FRED LEE, 17-11976, GLORIA LEE, 17-11976, JOAN LOMBARDI, 17-11974, JOSEPH LOMBARDI, For MARY T. ALZAMORA, 17-10173, Plaintiff: 17-11974, NICOLE PALMER, 17-12042, RUBYANN BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, PEREZ, 17-12049, LATOSHA RICHMOND, 17-12037, COUNSEL NOT [*306] ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MELLONIE RUSSELL, 17-12047, PERMEISHA BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES OWENS, 17-12070, DEBRA PAULSEN, 17-12054, PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. TERESA PIASCIK, 17-12056, LINDA PIKE, 17-12066, LYNDA SCHAFFER, 17-12072, SHARON SIMMS, 17- 12076, EVELYN SMITH, 17-12074, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. For JAMES ANTOS, 17-12077, Plaintiff: MARK P SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. For MOYA M MCKOY, 17-11982, NOEL W MCKOY, 17-11982, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL STEVEN For DORA GOTTLIEB, 17-12065, LAWRENCE GOETZ, [*305] LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT GOTTLIEB, 17-12065, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MORGAN & MORGAN LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO PC, TAMPA, FL. USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. For ANTHONY SANCHEZ, 17-11971, Plaintiff: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For LAUREL LUND, 17-12055, Plaintiff: CARY ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & LITTLEJOHN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Page 105 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *306

ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DON BARRETT PA, 12105, STANLEY CHOLEWA, 17-12105, DIANA LEXINGTON, MS. CLARK, 17-12109, GARY CLARK, 17-12109, CHARLES COHEN, 17-12111, PHYLLIS COHEN, 17- 12111, ANNA DIENER, 17-12116, KEVIN DIENER, 17- For TRENA KAY SEPTER, 17-12079, Plaintiff: ERIC D. 12116, DAVID EVEREST, 17-12118, NICOLE PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT EVEREST, 17-12118, HARRY FOX, 17-12115, JOANN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HEYGOOD ORR & ARGUELLO, 17-12135, LAKISHA BIDDINGS, 17- PEARSON, IRVING, TX. 12131, CAROLYN BICHELL, 17-12145, ROBERT BICHELL, 17-12145, JOHN BOWDEN, 17-12140, For SARINA COOK, 17-10172, TOSHA DAVIS, 17- ALEXANDER BOWENS, 17-12142, Plaintiffs: [*308] 10175, CARLA EVANS, 17-10177, SABRINA DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI JACKSON, 17-10178, BETH KUCHARSKI, 17-10184, LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. Plaintiffs: STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For JESSICA CAPUTO, 17-12117, JOHN HURTADO, BAR, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. 17-12114, LINDA HURTADO, 17-12114, PAUL MORELLO, 17-12117, JAMES YOWS, 17-12130, For CYNTHIA ANDERSON, 17-12087, Plaintiff: MARY YOWS, 17-12130, Plaintiffs: TAYJES BRANDI R. HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. BARRETT LAW GROUP PA, LEXINGTON, MS. For RENIA JACKSON, 17-12108, JOYCE MCINTYRE, For DEBORAH HACKETT-MAINE, 17-12085, MICHAEL 17-12108, Plaintiffs: SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD MAINE, 17-12085, HAZEL HILL, 17-12102, LAURA ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ DONNELLY, 17-12125, RICHARD [*307] DONNELLY, BAR, BARON & BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX. 17-12125, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For ESPERANZA CASTILLO, 17-10185, Plaintiff: BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For PAMELA HUNSAKER, 17-12059, Plaintiff: Scott B. BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES Hall, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice, LLC, Kansas City, PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. MO. For JANET BOWENS, 17-12142, BRITT VITOLS, 17- For NOEL MCKOY, SR, 17-12089, Plaintiff: 12354, MARY ODOM VESSELS, 17-12412, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. For EDWARD COCHRAN, 17-12156, GAIL BIRD, 17- 12148, KARA DAWN ROWLAND, 17-12159, For WILLIAM J. PEAL, 17-10853, CYNTHIA ROBERTO TAVERA, 17-12272 on behalf of YORMARY BRINKMAN, 17-10856, DEBORAH KELSH, 17-10854, TAVERA, DECEASED, PEGGY SWANEY, 17-12286, DOREEN WILLIAMS, 17-10846, SUSAN SITZLER, 17- FRANCES QUINI, 17-12309, YVETTE ROMERO, 17- 10852, TRACY WRIGHT, VICKY ONEY, 17-10849, 12314, Plaintiffs: BRANDI R. HAMILTON, LEAD Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BARRETT LAW GROUP ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, PA, LEXINGTON, MS. NY. For LOSSIE HORNE, 17-12162, RAY JOHNSON, 17- For EDWARD R.T. BULLARD, 17-12115, WANDA 12185, SUSAN LENORT, 17-12222, MARK [*309] CAMPBELL, 17-12100, DENNIS CARROLL, 17-12112, WILLIAM FRIEND, 17-12315, GLENNA MARIE TAMARA CARROLL, 17-12112, LINDA CHOLEWA, 17- FRIEND, 17-12315, GARY BEARDEN, Page 106 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *309

REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF DONNA ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, BEARDEN, DECEASED/ 17-12337, MARIA GARCIA, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-12363, ADRIAN BRIZUELA, 17-12403, NORMA VAZQUEZ, 17-12403, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, For ROSE MARIE ROSZAK, 17-12181, Plaintiff: LEAD ATTORNEY, BRANCH LAW FIRM, KATHERINE BARRETT RILEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. DON BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS.

For NORMA H. IBARRA, 17-12147, MARYANNE For OCEAIN WALLIS, 17-12176, Plaintiff: M. PIOREK, 17-12153, TAL-EE E. ROBERTS, 17-12150, BRANDON SMITH, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHILDERS BARBARA SANTO, 17-12334, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. SCHLUETER & SMITH LLC, ATLANTA, GA. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. For KATHLEEN R. DYE, 17-12226, Plaintiff: Jonathan D Orent, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, For MARTHA OHLMS, 17-12157, ORVILLE OHLMS, Providence, RI. 17-12157, SALLY PALUH, 17-12158, THOMAS SOFIELD, 17-12160, ERNESTINE FERGUSON, 17- 12223, WILLIAM SCHLOSSER, 17-12225, CHRISTINE For CHRISTINE ANN GRAVES, 17-12227, HEIDI S GAIGL, 17-12290, CAROL BAKER, 17-12353, LISA SIMON, 17-12228, Plaintiffs: [*311] Brian Weinstein, BORDEAUX, 17-12355, KELLY DEVINE, 17-12357, LEAD ATTORNEY, WEINSTEIN COUTURE PLLC, ANNA FILIPSKI, 17-12360, JANE HOLLER, 17-12362, SEATTLE, WA. CHERYL LAMOTHE, 17-12364, JOHN MCKEAL, 17- 12373, TREVA PERRY, 17-12371, CONSTANCE VAN For DIANE M. ZEGLEY, 17-12206, RENEE L. DOREN, 17-12367, JULIA WARREN, 17-12370, CARL HOWARD, 17-12219, CRISTINA MUNOZ-ANELLO, 17- YOUNG, 17-12372, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN 12221, Plaintiffs: GREGORY DONALD BROWN, LEAD RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ATTORNEY, HOUSTON, TX; KELSEY LOUISE O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. STOKES, LEAD ATTORNEY, FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ LLP, HOUSTON, TX. For BRUNO PAGNANI, 17-12165, MERRITT STANSFIELD, 17-12167, MALEA DAUGHTON, 17- For MARK BRODOWSKI, 17-12215, JUSTIN HOUK, 12169, JERILYN NEEME, 17-12168, NAJARA LAURA HOUK, 17-12216, Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ JOHNSON, 17-12257, WANDA M. THOMAS, 17-12256, DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, SKIKOS CRAWFORD ALEXANDER [*310] HOLCOMB, 17-12385, MARIE SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. LUGO, 17-12396, BRYAN ROGERS, 17-12386, DAVID TURMAN, 17-12384, ANTHONY BLACKMAN, 17- 12433, KATHY CANINE, 17-12428, LYNN CHERAMIE, For MARY ROEBUCK, 17-12218, ROSEMARIE 17-12434, CONNIE FRENCH, 17-12444, ALICIA MOERSCHEL, 17-12268, Plaintiffs: ALAN STEVEN GUERRERO, 17-12435, LAURA HUTSON, 17-12438, LAZAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARLIN & SALTZMAN RAMINTA KALEDA, 17-12440, ELBERT LOPEZ, 17- LLP, AGOURA HILLS, CA. 12446, TINA SCHAFFNER, 17-12426, WANDA STERBA, 17-12441, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW For CHANDRA CRISP-SILVA, 17-12229, ROGELIO SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, SILVA, 17-12229, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, ORANGE, VA. JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. For LILLIAN DEFRANCE, 17-10496, SANDRA DUFFIN, 17-10501, BONNIE CUNNINGHAM, 17-12209, MARY For CHANTEL KNUTSON, 17-12244, NATASHA GEUS, 17-12211, LAURA JONES, 17-12214, LEONA BLAISDELL, 17-12261, SYLVIA ROBERTS, 17-12263 MOORE, 17-12217, CATHY PRATT, 17-12233, DEBRA (Indiana), BOBBIE EVANS, 17-12301, BRENDA REDDICK, 17-12234, CHARLES P. SMITH, 17-12235, PARKER, 17-12302, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, KATHY LEE TOSKIN, 17-12237, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY EDWARDSVILLE, IL. Page 107 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *311

John Eugene Herrick, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Mt. Pleasant, SC. For DONNA MARTIN, 17-12247 (Pennsylvania), Plaintiff: MARK R. MUELLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MUELLER LAW FIRM, AUSTIN, TX. For MARY A. HANCOCK, 17-12329, ANNE MARIE WEISS, 17-12318, LETTIE MAE DONALD, 17-12336, MARJORIE ANN HALL, 17-12388, SHARON GIBER, For YVONNE DANIELS, 17-12259, Plaintiff: MARILYN 17-12681, Plaintiffs: DAVID MALCOLM MCMULLAN, T. MCGOLDRICK, THORNTON & NAUMES, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT PA, BOSTON, [*312] MA. LEXINGTON, MS.

For BETTE TURNER, 17-12262, LIZABETH R For EDITH LAWSON, 17-12322, FRED LAWSON, 17- WOODS, 17-12264, MICHAEL WOODS, 17-12264, 12322, Plaintiffs: NICHOLAS RYAN ROCKFORTE, Plaintiffs: DAVID J. DIAMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, PENDLEY BAUDIN & COFFIN LLP, GOLDBERG & OSBORNE, TUCSON, AZ. PLAQUEMINE, LA.

For DALE DEVELLIS, 17-12285, BESSIE DORSEY- For JESSICA NICOLE LUNA, 17-12324, DAVID BASS, DAVIS, 17-12287, HOPE KERBY, 17-12289, RENNA 17-12332, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, RICE, 17-12283, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, PLEASANT, SC. DALLAS, TX.

For BARBARA TUTTLE, 17-12321, LAURA For MICHAEL EDWARD HELLER, 17-12292, KELLEHER, 17-12335, KATHLEEN M. REDMAN, 17- Individually and on behalf of the Estate of Angela Marie 12340, MARGARET O'CALLAGHAN, 17-12349, Heller, CHRISTOPHER MAULDEN, 17-12291, ROSANNE FISHER, 17-12345, RIONA CRUZ, 17- KATHERYN MAULDEN, 17-12291, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN 12391, PATTY SCHOEN, 17-12467, Plaintiffs: SARAH ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN STERLING STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, DON SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. BARRETT PA, LEXINGTON, MS.

For CHARLES SCHNIER, 17-12279, MIRIAM For STEVEN J GRUNDY, 17-12338, JOHN M SCHNIER, 17-12279, Plaintiffs: MORRIS S. DWECK, GOODWIN, 17-12344, CHIPPER J MCBRIDE, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, Bernstein Liebhard LLP, New York, 12342, MARCY L MCBRIDE, 17-12342, MEREDITH NY. MULLER, 17-12344, ANNALISA TIFFANY WOLTERSDORF, 17-12346, MICHAEL J For HAROLD ANDREWS, 17-12307, SUSAN M WOLTERSDORF, 17-12346, Plaintiffs: JAMES BARTH-ANDREWS, 17-12307, HARRIET D GIDDENS, STEVEN ROGERS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAW OFFICES 17-12313, PERRY GIDDENS, 17-12313, Plaintiffs: OF JAMES S. ROGERS, SEATTLE, WA. MICHAEL STEVEN GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORGAN & MORGAN PC, TAMPA, FL. For [*314] SUSAN REEVES, 17-12339, BEVERLY LOGAN, 17-12684, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH For KATHY COLLINS, 17-12298, MITZIE M FISHER, O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL. 17-12382, Plaintiffs: Thomas David Hoyle, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice, LLC, Mount Pleasant, SC. For KEN GRUNDEN, 17-10806, on behalf of BETH GRUNDEN, PHILOMENA SHERRY TRISTANI, 17- For MAUREEN S DOUGLAS, 17-12296, Plaintiff: 10492, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD Donald Alan Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN LLC, Providence, RI. PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For [*313] CORIENA WATERS, 17-12297, Plaintiff: For ELLSWORTH AMOS, III, 17-12368 on behalf of Page 108 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *314

MARY JO AMOS, JAMES THOMPSON, 17-12361, on ATTORNEY, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, behalf of JANICE THOMPSON-LOTT, DAVID MN. CRAWFORD, 17-cv-12615, Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, For NOELIA MARTINEZ, 17-12439, BRUNILDA VELEZ, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. 17-12439, Plaintiffs: WENDY R. FLEISHMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEW YORK, [*316] NY. For ROBERT BAYNE, 17-12392, SUSIE BRAGG, 17- 12393, CANDACE BROCK, 17-12394, DEBRA For MALI SCHMUCKER, 17-12667, SHELA SIMMONS, BUTLER, 17-12395, DORIS SHAY, 17-12389, KAREN 17-12671, DAWN WAMACK, 17-12683, DEBORAH BEAM, 17-12414, JANICE CAPPELLO, 17-12397, SHORT, 17-12686, GEORGE SHORT, 17-12686, JAMES CARDWELL, 17-12398, PAMELA CARR, 17- Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD 12400, CRISTINA CARROLL, 17-12401, MARY ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. CHAMPION, 17-12405, LAVERNE COLEMAN, 17- 12407, EDNA COLEY, 17-12409, VIRGINA DAVIS, 17- 12411, PAMELA FASSE, 17-12415, OZELLA HARRIS, For BRENDA BUTTERFIELD, 17-12680, KATHY 17-12416, LINDA HAWKINS, 17-12417, JENNY KRICHBAUM, 17-12688, Plaintiffs: W. STEVEN HOPPER, 17-12419, LISA HUDGINS, 17-12402, BERMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI SHKOLNIK KHRISTINA IRETON, 17-12420, CHENIKA JACKSON, PLLC, MARLTON, NJ. 17-12421, THELMA JONES, 17-12422, JANET LANCASTER, 17-12423, BONNIE LUCAS, 17-12424, For TINA M , 17-12448, Plaintiff: STEVEN CAROL MONROE, 17-12425, AMEY NAVA, 17-12427, ALAN HART, LEAD ATTORNEY, Hart McLaughlin & CHARLES [*315] PEASLEE, 17-12430, ANNE Eldridge, Chicago, IL United Sta. SCHULZ, 17-12418, YASDELI SEGUI, 17-12431, HELEN SMITH, 17-12413, WILLIE MAE SHIELDS, 17- 12455, LILLIAN TRUPIA, 17-12456, TONY For CARMEN RICO-SCHLEGEL, 17-12546, Plaintiff: ALEXANDER, 17-12472, MICHELLE URBANCZYK, 17- HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, 12461, DARRELL WALKER, 17-12464, JUANITA BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, WHITE, 17-12466, TRACEY WHITT, 17-12469, ATHENS, GA. MAJORIE HUGHES, 17-12556, THERESA M. ALLEN, 17-12473, ALYSSA RENEE ATKINSON, 17-12474, For MICHAEL W BREWER, 17-12468, Plaintiff: BRIAN THERESA G BAKER, 17-12477, Plaintiffs: RANDI A. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, CELLINO & ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, SANDERS BARNES PC, BUFFALO, NY. VIENER GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN CITY, NY.

For CASEY STOVER, 17-12471, Plaintiff: TRENT B. For ARTURO JIMENEZ, 17-12383, LILIBET JIMENEZ, MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, SIMMONS HANLY 17-12383, Plaintiff: MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, CONROY, ALTON, IL. CELLINO & BARNES, BUFFALO, NY.

For RONALD BROWN, 17-12489 (California), on behalf For KAREN KLEIN, 17-12376, Plaintiff: JAMES A. of, ESTATE OF VIRGINIA BROWN, LYNETTE CRASE, MORRIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORRIS LAW FIRM, 17-12557, ROBERT CRASE, 17-12557, JOANN Burbank, CA. DEMEDUK, 17-12597, ARLENE DONIS, 17-12629, JAMES DONIS, 17-12629, FELICE BERNADETTE For JOANNE BENSON, 17-12443, KEITH GRAHAM, GRANT, 17-12657, JOSHUA GRANT, 17-12657, 17-12437 on behalf of ESTATE OF GRACE GRAHAM,, CATHERINE HARRIGAN, 17-12663, SALLY GASPER, SUZANNE COVINGTON, 17-12453, AMELITA 17-12691, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD LAMZON, 17-12458, SHARON MARTINEZ, 17-12453, ATTORNEY, OUNSEL NOT ADMITTED [*317] TO SHEILA RANSOM, 17-12450, SHELBY USDC-NJ BAR, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. RAUENHORST, 17-12458, KAMALA SILVA, 17-12449, SUSAN THORESON, 17-12451,ELISABETH MARTIN, For JOSEPH CANTRELL, 17-12492, FRANCES 17-12465, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD BARROSO DE LEON, 17-12481, MELISSA MURRAY, Page 109 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *317

17-12486, CHANTELL VILLENUEVE, 17-12483, JULIA For RENEE GROSSE, 17-12475, GARY JOHNSON, CARROLL, 17-12494, KAREN CLINIGAN, 17-12504, 17-12493, RACHEL HOUDE, 17-12690, LOIS KELLY KREPPS, 17-12498, JERRY T. GUNTER, 17- JACKSON, 17-12539, ASHLEY LOWE, 17-12544, LISA 12548, MORGAN CONNERY, 17-12506, LARRY WALKER, 17-12549, MINNIE CHAMPION, 17-12567, DAVENPORT, 17-12514, TERESA CUTRONE FOX, JOHN FOOTE, [*319] 17-12560, PATRICIA SMITH, 17-12510 & 17-12511, MELANIE SWANAGAN, 17- 17-12575, NIKKI CRAWFORD, 17-12615, BERNARD 12507, JIM DAVIS, 17-12516, SYNTHIA DAWIEC, 17- KENNEDY, 17-12642, on behalf of, SUSAN KENNEDY, 12530, EPHRAIM DIEFENDERFER, 17-12532, Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, SANDRA DOHNERT, 17-12534, WALTER ENDICOTT, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. 17-12535, DEBORAH FIMPLE, 17-12537, JOSEPHINE LOUIS, MO. FLECHA, 17-12538, CARMEN SONIA CLAUDIO GARCIA, 17-12541, ANN GEARTY, 17-12547, For DELPHINE MASON, 17-12479, Plaintiff: TRENT B. MARITZA ESTEVES RUIZ, 17-12536, JESSIE MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT THOMAS, 17-12551, KIMBERLEY ELAINE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SIMMONS HANLY CHRISTMAN, 17-12566, BEATRICE HAWKINS, 17- CONROY, ALTON, IL. 12552, TERRAH HOLLINGSWORTH, 17-12554, JAMES MIKE HUGHES, 17-12556, JOHNNIE INGRAM, 17-12558, PATRICIA ANNE KARLIC, 17-12559, For KIM PETERS, 17-12480, CHARLOTTE INGRID LEBRON, 17-12561, EDNA LOSOYA, 17- FREELAND, 17-12496, BRENDA MAZANETZ, 17- 12565, TONEY MCGEAR, 17-12569, WILLIE MILLER, 12499, ROSE FOXWELL, 17-12509, SUZANNE 17-12563, CARMEN LOZADA RAMOS, 17-12568, PERRY, 17-12513, APRIL SAUVE, 17-12515, Plaintiffs: DAWN HARRINGTON, 17-12550, DEBRA BRENZO, ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON 17-12589, ANGEL ROSARIO CAUSSADE, 17-12595, BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. MARIA RODRIGUEZ COTTO, 17-12594, OMAYRA RIVERA DEL HOYA, 17-12592, LEMARIE GONZALEZ, For STEPHANIE LACHAYE WESLEY, 17-12488, 17-12591, TIFFANY LYNN LOWERY MEEKS, [*318] GLADYS ROBINSON, 17-12702, JENNY SHONING, 17-12578, ANGELA MEYER, 17-12571, MARTA 17-12698, KATHY SUE VARNER, 17-12695, ROBERT MORENO, 17-12572, WENDY OXENDINE, 17-12579, N TUNE, 17-12685, DEBORAH R YOUNG-TUNE, 17- BARBARA PERRY, 17-12580, LINDA RABAGO, 17- 12685, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD 12585, LUISA RAMOS, 17-12582, BELLEN RAMOS ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, RESURECCION, 17-12587, PRISCILA QUINONES NY. RIVERA, 17-12581, BRENDA RIVERS, 17-12593, SORAIDA MERCADO VASQUEZ, 17-12570, ALICE MARIE PERRY WEATHERS, 17-12573, JADE YOUNG, For ALICIA BUENO, 17-12500, MARGARETTE 17-12588, TERESA CUTRONE FOX, 17-12510 SANDERS, 17-12505, HELEN SMALL, 17-12508, (Individually), TERESA CUTRONE FOX, 17-CV-12511, DAVID ADDISON, 17-12730, RICHARD ALLISON, 17- on behalf of, ESTATE OF FRANCES CUTRONE, 12731, on behalf of, ESTATE OF OMA ALLISON, PATRICIA WILBANKS COLE, 17-12618, BRENDA EMERY, 17-12732, on behalf of, ESTATE OF CHRISTOPHER RIESTRA-SCHNEIDER, 17-12607, MARGO DECKER, BARBARA EVANS, 17-12734, on LLOYD SAUNDERS, 17-12603, JANET SMITH, 17- behalf of, ESTATE OF VIRGINIA MARUTIAK, MARTIN 12608, MELISSA SONNIER, 17-12609, DAWN FORD, 17-12735, on behalf of, ESTATE OF SQUIRES, 17-12610, BERNARD TABARINI, 17-12611, ISABELLA [*320] FORD, INDIA HENRY, 17-12737, on LENORA TAGUE, 17-12622, ANITA TAUZIN, 17- behalf of, ESTATE OF BESSIE EDELEN, PATRICIA 12612, HOLLY TAYLOR, 17-12613, OTIS VARNADO, HINDLE, 17-12738, on behalf of, ESTATE OF 17-12614, CAROLYN WAKEN-HALL, 17-12616, JEANETTE RODENBAUGH, BONNIE MALEK, 17- TAMMY WHITTEN, 17-12617, CAROLEE WOLFE, 17- 12739, on behalf of, ESTATE OF DONNA JOHNSON, 12619, DONNA WOOD-DONATELLI, 17-12620, C.R., Plaintiffs: KEITH DAVID GRIFFIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, 17-12627, LISA RAY, 17-12627, Plaintiffs: RANDI COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LOS ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ANGELES, CA. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, GARDEN CITY, NY. For BRANDI SMITH, 17-12502, Plaintiff: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS Page 110 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *320

CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. MCMACKIN, 17-12533, JOANNA PILIPOVICH, 17- 12521, PETER HAMPTON, 17-12546, CHRISTOPHER HANSON, 17-12542, LUPE HANSON, 17-12542, For DAVID T. THOMPSON, 17-12503, LEASA THOMAS EDWARDS, 17-12638, Plaintiffs: HENRY G. THOMPSON, 17-12503 (New Mexico), WANDA GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LASTER, 17-12693, DAVID T. THOMPSON, 17-CV- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATHENS, GA. 12503, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. For ROBERT MALONE, 17-12520, ROBERT MALONE, 17-CV-12520, PAMELA CLARK, 17-12621, MARK JONES, 17-12721, TRACI O'CONNELL, 17-12722, For DEBRA WIINIKAINEN, 17-12497, Plaintiff: DAVID LEVESTER SAGO, 17-12717, [*322] Plaintiffs: MALCOLM MCMULLAN, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LEXINGTON, MS. LOUIS, MO.

For BETTY HIGHTOWER, 17-12692 (Texas), CANADA For ESTHER ANN BROWN, 17-12545, Plaintiff: ROLANDA, 17-12700, LINDA GYURO, 17-12704, PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & ROLANDA CANADA, 17-12700, ROBERT GADFIELD, SPECTER PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. 17-12704, JANET GRIFFIN, 17-12697, CHARLENE KONDRLA, 17-12689, AMANDA L. BERNING- SZCZESNY, 17-12676, Plaintiffs: W. STEVEN For EVELYN E. VANDERSCHAAF, 17-12553, Plaintiff: BERMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI SHKOLNIK SARAH STERLING STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PLLC, MARLTON, NJ. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEXINGTON, MS. For BETTY A. YOST, 17-12512, MARION JOE ODOM, 17-12628, Plaintiffs: KATHERINE BARRETT RILEY, For NORMAN FELLS, 17-12576, Plaintiff: ERIC D. LEAD ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT [*321] PA, PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & LEXINGTON, MS. PEARSON, IRVING, TX.

For HELEN WILLIAMS, 17-12696, KAREN CASEY, 17- For TRISHA NICHOLS, 17-12574 AND 17-13826, 12699, KIM LEIGHTON, 17-12699, GEORGE CUTTER, Plaintiff: MICHAEL BRADY LYNCH, LEAD ATTORNEY, 17-12654, JANIS CUTTER, 17-12654, DORIS COOK, THE MICHAEL BRADY LYNCH FIRM, WINTER PARK, 17-12703, JERRY COOK, 17-12703, ANITA COOK- FL; RANDI ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, WILDER, 17-12705, LESLIE DIAZ, 17-12712, ANDY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MAGGARD, 17-12656, CAROL MAGGARD, 17-12656, GARDEN CITY, NY. ELEANOR MANCINI, 17-12662, LISA MORRIS, 17- 12664, PATRICIA CHRISTIAN, 17-12719, RENEE For ANGELA E. KISER, 17-10624, LINDA KNOTTS, 17- DOYLE, 17-12715, JAMES FIERRO, 17-12716, JANIE 10628, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, FIERRO, 17-12716, DORA FUNDERBURK, 17-12719, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW JASON KINCEL, 17-12715, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. For VIRGINIA A. SEMAAN, 17-12623, SHANEDRA WASHINGTON, 17-12710, Plaintiffs: BRANDI R. For BROOKE ARISPE, 17-12526, MARJORIE COPE, HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, 17-12524, DOLORES ELLIANO, 17-12525, BETTY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NOBLE, 17-12528, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW LEXINGTON, MS. SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. For CINDI AHARONIAN, 17-12625, EMILY HORNE, 17- 12625, JULIA MARTIN, 17-12630, KATHY L For DEBORAH FERGUSON, 17-12523, VIOLET Page 111 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *322

MCKENZIE, 17-12633, VICTORIA RICHARDSON, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 12634, EBONI WEAVER, 17-12635, PATRICIA BAR, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. WEBER, [*323] 17-12636, ROBERT WEBER, 17- 12636, Plaintiffs: JOHN REILY CRONE, LEAD For NICHOLE PACHECO, 17-12720, DEANNA ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ PORTILLIES, 17-12723, Plaintiffs: PETER ANDREW BAR, ANDRUS WAGSTAFF PC, LAKEWOOD, CO. MILLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MILLER DELLAFERA, For MARY R. GRAY, 17-12631, SUE A. HESS, 17- HENRICO, VA; TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD 12632, LYDIA A PETERSON, 17-12626, SAL KUREH, ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. 17-12728, DEBORA BASORE, 17-12733, Plaintiffs: JOHN C. THORNTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For WENDELL MELTON, 17-12740 on behalf of NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ANDREWS ESTATE OF PHYLLIS MELTON, EDWIN NASSIFF, 17- THORNTON HIGGINS RAZMARA LLP, IRVINE, CA. 12741 on behalf of ESTATE OF GLORIA NASSIFF, MARK PEACH, 17-12743, SAVENO SILENO, 17-12744 For , 17-12586, Plaintiff: ERIC D. on behalf of ESTATE OF VIVIAN SILENO, ROBERT HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT SMITH, 17-12746 on behalf of ESTATE OF BETTY ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. SMITH, CONNIE TAYLOR, 17-12747 on behalf of ESTATE OF NORMA BROCK, JERRY UMFLEET, 17- 12748 on behalf of ESTATE OF PENNY UMFLEET, For JOSEPHINE CASIANO, 17-12708, ARWANI LIM, RALPH WOHLERS, 17-12749 on behalf of ESTATE OF 17-12711, Plaintiffs: SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD THELMA WOHLERS, LORETTA WONG-SAMUEL, 17- ATTORNEY, BARON & BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX. 12751 on behalf of ESTATE OF ESTHER HASFAL, Plaintiffs: [*325] KEITH DAVID GRIFFIN, LEAD For EBONY JAMES, 17-12672, JOSEPH MORRILL, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 12669, Plaintiffs: KRISTOFER S RIDDLE, SHANNON BAR, LOS ANGELES, CA. MARIE MCNULTY, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CLIFFORD LAW For ELENA NOVIKOFF, 17-12736, HOPE BATES, 17- OFFICES PC, CHICAGO, IL; ROBERT A. CLIFFORD, 12745, ERIKA BISCHOFF, 17-12742, MARGARITA LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO JUGO, 17-12750, GENEVIEVE MCGARVEY- USDC-NJ BAR, CLIFFORD LAW OFFICES, CHICAGO, TANENBAUM, 17-12753, TERRY MCGARVEY- IL. TANENBAUM, 17-12753, Plaintiffs: JOHN C. THORNTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For BOBBIE CLARK, 17-12678, LORI EDE, 17-12679, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, IRVINE, CA. CONNIE RICKETTS, 17-12682, Plaintiffs: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For STEPHAN BRIEN, 17-12755, CLAIRE BRIEN, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. 12755, ELLEN BRUECKER, 17-12756, DONNA ELIZABETH LOWE, 17-12757, GREGORY LOWE, 17- For PAUL BARTON, 17-12725, FREDDIE 12757, ROBYN STANLEY, 17-12758, ROSEMARY OVERSTREET, 17-12714, Plaintiffs: [*324] BRADLEY VESA, 17-12760, DANIEL GRAY, 17-12761, DEAN HONNOLD, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT JACQULIN GRAY, 17-12761, ELMER HALL, 17-12763, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Overland Park, KS. KAREN HALL, 17-12763, DANIEL KNIGHTEN, 17- 12764, MARY OFIELD, 17-12767, SHOMARI ROSS, 17-12769, LAURA WESTON, 17-12771, JEANNINE For CINDY CAGLE, 17-12729, DONONA HAYES, 17- ZILLMER, 17-12772, KATHY BREEDLOVE, 17-12811, 12727, Plaintiffs: MATTHEW J. SILL, LEAD MATTIE BISE, 17-12822, DAVID BRECKENRIDGE, 17- ATTORNEY, SILL LAW GROUP, Oklahoma City, OK. 12825, IDA BRECKENRIDGE, 17-12825, ANDREW CHICK, 17-12820, EVA NEEL DIGGS, 17-12814, For MICHAEL LASTER, 17-12724, LIQUN Y. JAMIE HARTWELL, 17-12817, CHERYL JONES, 17- SCHAPIRO, 17-12726, STEVEN WORLEY, 17-12718, 12818, GARY JONES, 17-12818, SYLVESTER Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD MILLER, 17-12822, LORI PROVINCE, 17-12821, Page 112 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *325

HAROLD SHULAR, 17-12819, VICKI SHULAR, 17- 12804, MARY BARGE-CHAMBERS, 17-12806, 12819, MICHAEL ZEGRAIN, 17-12817, LISA CATHERINE BASSFIELD, 17-12807, DIXIE BRUBAKER, 17-12876, SHARON A PLATH, 17-12885, BREDEMEIER, 17-12805, DEBBIE BRINSON, 17- ELIZABETH LIGGON REDDING, [*326] 17-12887, 12803, RONALD BRINSON, 17-12803, BROOK STACEY DAWN RENIE, 17-12888, KATHY ANN GULICH, 17-12801, JOHNNY LOSURE, 17-12795, CUBBAGE, 17-12877, KATHERINE EDSILL, 17-12878, RHONDA LOSURE, 17-12795, ROBERT SPITZ, 17- JACQUELINE FLICKINGER, 17-12879, GENEVA 12794, SHEILA SPITZ, 17-12794, SALLY O'DONNELL, LAVENA FRENCH, 17-12881, BECKY A SIERRA, 17- 17-12897, VANESSA PORTER, 17-12905, DEBORAH 12898, on behalf of GLORIA R. SIERR, DONALD GUY, RICHARDSON, 17-12896, JANEEN PIRTLE, 17-12899, 17-12923, DOROTHY , 17-12918, NIKKI JO EDWARD PENNINGTON, 17-13009, NANCY STINSON, 17-12921, CARL TAYLOR, 17-12922, PENNINGTON, 17-13009, CYNTHIA PRYOR, 17- VIRGINIA L. TAYLOR, 17-12922, TANYA A. THOMAS, 13021, CHRISTINE SADOWSKI, 17-13013, PAUL 17-12923, MARCY M. BIRCH, 17-12945, WYNN SADOWSKI, 17-13013, HEIKE SILLIN, 17-13017, BIRCH, 17-12945, VIKKI FAJKUS, 17-12959, KEVIN SILLIN, 17-13017, ANNIE ROGERS, 17-13024, FRANCESIA JOHNSON, 17-12958, DEBORAH J. Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, WHITE, 17-12925, MARCENE JOHNSON, 17-13005, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. WALTER L. SMITH, III, 17-13007, DAISY WARD, 17- 12978, KELLY WEDEL, 17-13006, MICHAEL WEDEL, For VIRGINIA MAY, 17-12809, [*328] Plaintiff: 17-13006, MELINDA LEA DAVIS, 17-13010, JEANNE KRISTOFER S RIDDLE, ROBERT A. CLIFFORD, ALLISON NIETO, 17-13016, SHIRLEY E. THORNOCK, SHANNON MARIE MCNULTY, LEAD ATTORNEYS, 17-13014, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. CHICAGO, IL.

For RODNEY D ST. CLAIR, 17-12759 on behalf of For DIANE MCNEILL, 17-12812, Plaintiff: PATRICIA ESTATE OF VIRGINIA ST. CLAIR, Plaintiff: KENNETH LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT J. GRUNFELD, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. HONIK, P.C., PHILADELPHIA, PA.

For BRENDA PROST, 17-12793, THERESA For SHANNON STARZYK, 17-12752, RONNIE WINKELSPECHT, 17-12856, GARDENIA INGRAM, 17- WIMBERLY, JR, 17-12752, Plaintiffs: SOPHIA M. 12880, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ASLAMI, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. BAR, IRVING, TX.

For CHERYL BERRY, 17-12789 (California), GENNEL For KELLEY SHEA, 17-12790, Plaintiff: CATHERINE FALLS, 17-12830, KEYONA HARDEN, [*327] 17- THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE 12830, TOMMIE JOHNSON, 17-12830, LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. CHRISTOPHER KENNEDY, 17-12830, Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SAN For TERRY NASH, 17-10422, CONNIE WILSON FRANCISCO, CA. RICHARDS, 17-10830, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, For GERALD HASAKA, 17-12778, ROXANNA AL. HASAKA, 17-12778, NATASHA HARRIS, 17-12802, DEBORAH ANN HEARD, 17-12850 AND 18-5370, KENNETH HEARD, 17-12850, DAVID KEITH, 17- For IDA OFFUTT, 17-10498, MELISSA O'NEAL, 17- 12862, KATHLEEN KEITH, 17-12862, Plaintiffs: ADAM 10495, IVY NADINE BALL, 17-12984, SANDRA M. TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, OUNSEL NOT KISSING, 17-13000, TONJA MCCARTY, 17-13001, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. CASTEL I. GROSSETT, 17-13008, JANICE E. PAYSON, 17-13019, LAURIE VANNURDEN, 17-13015, SARAH DEARMAN, 17-13028, LINDA FERGUSON, 17- For BUDDY ANDERS, 17-12804, NAOMI ANDERS, 17- Page 113 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *328

13034, MARY GRAENING, 17-13027, MONICA SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. SIZEMORE, 17-13025, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For DARLENE STEWART, 17-12762, WILLIAM L. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. RANDALL, 17-12891, GASECENER WHITE, 17-12598, Plaintiffs: DAVID MALCOLM MCMULLAN, JR., LEAD For MARYANNE CARNELL, 17-12823, Plaintiff: ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ CARYN MICHELE [*329] PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD BAR, LEXINGTON, MS. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HOUSTON, TX. For MYRA BROOKS, 17-12860, Plaintiff: PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & SPECTER PC, For ANTHONY CENTRILLA, 7-12834, EILEEN PHILADELPHIA, PA. CENTRILLA, 17-12834, MARVIN HARRIS, 17-12836, JULIE KRAMP, 17-12845, LINDA LEAHY, 17-12839, For DINAH N. OWUSU, 17-12800, SHEILA BUTZOW, MICHAEL LEAHY, 17-12839, NINA MYRIE, 17-12829, 17-12913, ROBERT GAINES, 17-12596, PENELOPE CANDI NOYES, 17-12846, MICHAEL NOYES, 17- GABBARD, 17-12906, PATRICIA A. BOTTO, 17-12895, 12846, DIANE PIEKANSKI, 17-12837, CAROL Plaintiffs: SARAH STERLING STARNS, LEAD TODECHEENE, 17-12832, PATRICIA BUCK, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 12903, RAY BUCK, 17-12903, KAREN DIRKMAN, 17- BAR, LEXINGTON, MS. 12972, Plaintiffs: T. MATTHEW LECKMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CONSHOHOCKEN, PA. For ALLISON SCHMITT, 17-12869, Plaintiff: IRENE M. MCLAFFERTY, LEAD ATTORNEY, MESSA & ASSOCIATES, P.C., PHILADELPHIA, PA. For ELIZABETH DIPPOLD, 17-12824, Plaintiff: THERESA M. WALSH, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LANCASTER, NY. For NILDA ROVIRA OLIVERAS, 17-12602, Plaintiff: RANDI ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, For MARY SUE HUGHES, 17-12844, CYNTHIA GARDEN CITY, NY. SORRELS, 17-12847, JACKIE LEE GAUTIER, 17-cv- 12848, Plaintiffs: ALEX C. DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For BILLY MASON, 17-12600, Plaintiff: TIMOTHY LOUISVILLE, KY. DALE BRANDENBURG, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ [*331] BAR, ARLINGTON, TX. For JOHNNA JUMP, 17-12835, DIANNE THOMPSON, 17-12831, NICHOLE DENOCHICK, 17-12874, LISA CHAMPLIN, 17-12606, MARY ERICKSON, 17-12599, For THOMAS W. BROWN, 17-12893, Plaintiff: HENRY Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ATHENS, GA. LOUIS, MO.

For PETER MOTOLA, 17-12882, RUTHLA J For LAURA HONEY, 17-12858, SUE ANN ROBERTSON, 17-12916, Plaintiffs: KELLY A. THOMPSON, 17-12859, EVELYN SMITH, 17-12863, FITZPATRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, The Flood Law GWENDOLYN SMITH, 17-12861, VERONICA AKERS, Firm, LLC, Middletown, CT. 17-12936, [*330] HELEN DELTOUR, 17-12960, DIANE HUTSON, 17-12971, TAMMY STEWART, 17-12962, For CARYN PLETZER, 17-12886, Plaintiff: NICOLE Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAUREN BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DANBURY, CT.

For DONALD WRIGHT, 17-12855, Plaintiff: MEGHAN For SABRINA SAMUELS, 17-12884, Plaintiff: ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN Page 114 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *331

BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD, LEAD ATTORNEY, SABRINA CARPER, 17-12998, WENDELL CARPER, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 17-12998, WENDY J. CARPER, 17-12998, REBEKAH Overland Park, KS. SWAREY, 17-12998, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LOS ANGELES, CA. For RAUL CHAVEZ, 17-12907, ADONICA L BROOKS, 17-12919, DAVID CAGLE, 17-12919, Plaintiffs: DAVID J. DIAMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For CANDACE JOHNSON, 17-12976, Plaintiff: PETER ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, TUCSON, AZ. LAWRENCE KAUFMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LOS ANGELES, CA. For MARCY GONZALEZ, 17-12914, Plaintiff: ERIC D. HOLLAND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. For JILL NEWMAN, 17-13004, RAENELL CALLIES, 17- 13012, DEBRA [*333] TUTTLE, 17-13018, Plaintiffs: ETHAN L. SHAW, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For MARILYN BABICH, 17-12926, MICHELLE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, AUSTIN, TX. DUNLEVY, 17-12928, JOSIE GATES, 17-12930, BERT HICKS, 17-12931, LEE ANN JONES, 17-12933, ROBERT O'CONNELL, 17-12935, FRANCISCO For DIANE ZORNES, 17-2663; 17-12956, Plaintiff: PADILLA, 17-12942, ANASTASIA PANIAGUA, 17- ASHLEA GAYLE SCHWARZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, 12944, LESLEYANN PHILLIPS, 17-12947, SONYA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, RICHARDSON, 17-12948, WENDY SMITH, 17-12951, KANSAS CITY, MO; CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ANGELA WEBSTER, 17-12953, O'CONNELL PLACITELLA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN, ROBERT, 17-12935, Plaintiffs: [*332] RICHARD M. PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED BANK, NJ; PATRICIA PAUL, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KANSAS CITY, MO. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; RICHARD M. PAUL, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KANSAS CITY, For MARY ANN MARTIN, 17-12952, Plaintiff: MICHAEL MO; SUSAN BECKER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL J. WILLIAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, OFFICE OF THE NJ NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KANSAS CITY, ATTORNEY , TRENTON, NJ. MO.

For SHARRON F STINNETT, 17-12937, Plaintiff: For MONICA SIZEMORE, 17-13025, SHERRY BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, BOULER, 17-13041, LORI NEVEL 17-13037, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DOROTHY M. ADAMS 17-13390, ALEXANDER AIME Philadelphia, PA. 17-13396, MARIE ASHTON 17-13410, CHERYL S. BENSON 17-13414, KATHERINE BLAND 17-13459, For LIANA HUTCHINSON-COURSE, 17-8009, RUTH ELAINE BOWE 17-13417, HENRY CALHOUN GEORGEANN CARTER, 17-8440, TERRY ATKINSON, 17-13455, ANGELA CARTER 17-13422, APRIL 17-8445, DENISE SMITH, Plaintiffs: DOUGLAS DURHAM 17-13457, 17-13424, ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL BETTY J. FIESTER 17-13425, NORMA C. GELLER 17- NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, 13426, MARGARET GOMEZ 17-13436, JOLYNNE LA. HEIMLICH 17-13437, LOIS JORDAN 17-13438, SYNTHIA LAKE 17-13441, DOLORES LUND 17-13442, LOIS A. STARR 17-13448, ANNA STUART 17-13452, For BARBARA BECKER, 17-12985, DEAN BECKER, MARY HAYS 17-13533, PATRICIA JOSEPH 17-13536, 17-12985, Plaintiffs: ELIZABETH ANNE FEGAN, LEAD GLORIA [*334] LOCKE 17-13539, Plaintiffs: LAUREN ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, CHICAGO, IL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For GAVIN CARPER, 17-12998, MARK RONALD For GAIL TYRE, 17-13030, ROBERT F. WEAKLAND, CARPER, 17-12998, NATHANIEL CARPER, 17-12998, 17-13022, BETTY M. GILMORE 17-13073, LEWIS Page 115 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *334

SLAYTON 17-13070, ROSEMARY S. SLAYTON 17- SARANTOPOULOS 17-13513, JAMES STAUBER 17- 13070, MARTY CLEMENTS 17-13134, MARY 13512, Plaintiffs: MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD COSTLOW 17-13134, KRISTA A. GERYCH 17-13133, ATTORNEY, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. CHERYL A. GRANGER 17-13132, ROBERT D. HARDY 17-13125, KATHLEEN R. HARDY 17-13125, KAREN A. For DORIS STUMBAUGH 17-10472 on behalf of HUNT 17-13131, KEVIN LAWRENCE 17-13135, ESTATE OF ELIZABETH HANCOCK, DECEASED, SYLVIA LAWRENCE 17-13135, DORIS MEYERS 17- MARY MURPHY [*336] 17-10663, Plaintiffs: STEVEN 13126, LABRONDA A. MILLER 17-13129, RHONDA L. DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & SHAMBURGER 17-13124, MELODY L. SMART 17- HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. 13128, DESIREE A. CARR 17-13223, DARRELL COPELAND 17-13224, TAKESHA COPELAND 17- 13224, DOROTHY ERVES 17-13227, WANDA D. For MS. CHERYLANN FERNANDES, 17-13067, YOUNG 17-13230, CLAUDIA CANALES 17-13232, Plaintiff: Joel E Brown, LEAD ATTORNEY, Peoria, IL. JERRY COLLINS 17-13238, KIMBERLY A. COLLINS 17-13238, SUZANNE FOSTER 17-13241, MANUELA For JOHN W. HUNT 17-13061, EILEEN ALTER 17- NOWAK 17-13233, SANDRA FORTIER 17-13263, 13087, MARY PARRISH 17-13090, REBECCA TERRY FORTIER 17-13263, JUDY M. JONES 17- STRONG 17-13088, WARREN POWELL, SR. 17- 13258, ANN B. MURPHY 17-13246, GARRY PHILLIPS 13215, TAMMY DABBS 17-13489, BARRY DEAN 17- 17-13249, GERALDINE PHILLIPS 17-13249, JAMES 13494, ADRIENNE LIEBERMAN 17-13498, CINDY SNOW, III 17-13251, MARGARET A. STUDEBAKER LIND 17-13491, SPARKLE MCNAIR 17-13492, 17-13255, PENNY C. TUCKER 17-13247, JOHN PAMELA SCHOLL 17-13499, MICHAEL WOLF 17- WOLFE 17-13265, RAMON SANTOS 17-13481, 13495, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ASHLEY LIANE SMITH 17-13485, MINH NGUYEN 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 13477, SHELBY RUTTER 17-13471, [*335] MICHAEL BAR, ST. LOUIS, MO. THOMPSON 17-13477, JANET WESTLING 17-13478, CHARLOTTE ALLEN 17-13514, ANDREW DAWSON 17-13516, TINA GOMEZ 17-13520, KAREN L. For JESSIE FITZPATRICK 17-13068, Plaintiff: LOWERY 17-13521 (Georgia), RONALD LEE LYERLA MICHAEL D. GREER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 17-13543, ARLENE MITCHELL 17-13524, WILLA NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GREER MOORE 17-13531, RACHEL NEALEY 17-13525, JOHN RUSSELL DENT & LEATHERS PLLC, TUPELO, MS. PAWLICK 17-13532, DIAN PEDERSON 17-13534, SCOTT RICHARD 17-13535, DAVID TIMMONS 17- For MARY HARRIGER 17-13079, PATRICIA 13540, MARCIA TINGEL 17-13538, COREYONNA NONNWEILER 17-13077, KATHLEEN W. REDMAN 17- WELCH 17-13528, SHULA WOODWORTH 17-13527, 13082, Plaintiffs: JEFF THOMAS SELDOMRIDGE, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. USDC-NJ BAR THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA.

For BRIAN L. WING, 17-13023, as Surviving heir and For ERIC IVASIECKO 17-13071, VENISSA IVASIECKO spouse of Roxann Wing, Plaintiff: ETHAN L. SHAW, 17-13071, BRENDA ROSSER 17-13072, DIANA LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO GOODE 17-13198, KEVIN GOODE 17-13198, USDC-NJ BAR SHAW COWART LLP, AUSTIN, TX. GWENDOLYN TAYLOR 17-13197, DOROTHY PLEMONS 17-13235, JOEANN MARTIN 17-13320, For WILMA J LATHAM 17-13046, DOREEN L LEE 17- SAMUEL J RUSSELL 17-13317, DAVID CHAVEZ 17- 13069, DR. JAMES LEE 17-13069, Plaintiffs: BRIAN A. 13352, Plaintiffs: [*337] BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR CELLINO & BARNES USDC-NJ BAR, Philadelphia, PA. PC, BUFFALO, NY.

For PATRICK J PHALEN 17-13104, SUSAN M For JERE SCRUGGS 17-13045, MARILEA PHALEN 17-13104, Plaintiffs: TIMOTHY S. TRECEK, DOERFLINGER 17-13060, AMANDA TROUT 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, HABUSH HABUSH & ROTTIER 13311, SUSAN WARREN 17-13310, CHARLOTTE SC, MILWAUKEE, WI. Page 116 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *337

ORTIZ 17-13179, Plaintiffs: Mathew P. Jasinski, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Hartford, CT. For ANNETTE WARDY 17-13120, WILLIE J. WARDY 17-13120, JAMIE LEIGH WELLS 17-13114, BECKY WHITE 17-13116, FRANK L. WHITE 17-13116, WILMA For PETER MOTOLA 17-13144, Plaintiff: NICOLE JOYCE WHITLEY 17-13117, ILONA A WILLIAMS 17- LAUREN BARBER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 13115, ARLETA WOODS 17-13118, NANCY S. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DANBURY, CT. WRIGHT 17-13119, JOANN ZINGONE 17-13113, SADE BUTLER 17-13469, CHARLES GERMANO 17- For REGINA WHITE 17-13161, Plaintiff: MEGHAN 13465, TRACEY GERMANO 17-13465, KELLIE HILL ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN 17-13466, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. For JAMIE M. BOCK 17-13228, VALETTA CHANEY 17- 13242, TERRI DANIELS 17-13234, ZHENYA DOZIER For BERNADETTE BORSELLA 17-13138, LOUIS 17-13231, LYNN MACARTHUR 17-13245, SANDRA BORSELLA 17-13138, MARILYN CARLSTEAD 17- SMITH 17-13236, GERALDINE [*339] GILBERT 17- 13158, ROSANNA P DINEYAZHE 17-13164, 13259, TERESA MULLINS 17-13252, SHARON YTELL LEUTERIO TAPIA 17-13164, RALPH JONES 17-13192, 17-13250, CAROL BERGERON 17-13321, CLIFTON DEAN PENDERGAST 17-13195, SANDRA BRADSHER 17-13334, JAMES GENTRY 17-13330, PENDERGAST 17-13195, EDWARD RIORDAN 17- ANNE MARIE INNOCENTI 17-13318, SHARON 13201, PATRICIA RIORDAN 17-13201, CASEY STAFFORD 17-13315, DONALD WALTON 17-13328, SKOMP 17-13188, Plaintiffs: DAVID J. DIAMOND, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI USDC-NJ BAR, TUCSON, AZ. JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL.

For SHEILA GAIL BOONE 17-13155, JAMES CLARKE For GLORIA LOWE 17-13218, ROBERT LOWE 17- 17-13143, Plaintiffs: SARAH STERLING STARNS, 13218, ADRIENNE MAROFSKY 17-13500 LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO (Pennsylvania), DAVID MAROFSKY 17-13500, THALIA USDC-NJ BAR, [*338] LEXINGTON, MS. FERRY 17-13419, DEBBIE HAVILAND 17-13432, TIMOTHY HAVILAND 17-13432, FLOYD KAUP 17- For SHIRLEY M. BORN 17-13140, JEROLYNN 13470, VIRGINIA KAUP 17-13470, CHRISTY BERTHELSEN 17-13180, Plaintiffs: DAVID MALCOLM LEMASTER 17-13419, FRANCES PERRY SMITH 17- MCMULLAN, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 13456, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEXINGTON, MS. OUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. For KATHLEEN FRANCIS 17-13165, KIRK MCCUMBER 17-13171, on behalf of Evelyn McCumber, For LORETTA MORAN 17-13214, Plaintiff: TIMOTHY deceased, PATSY WILSON 17-13264, GEORGINA DALE BRANDENBURG, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL CHUN SERIKAKU 17-13360, SHIRLEY ADAMS 17- NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ARLINGTON, TX. 13439, KATHY GARRARD 17-13446, IRINE WINTERS 17-13458, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD For MARLENE ARIENO 17-13288, ALICE OVER 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 13277, BENNIE THORNELL 17-13283, STEPHANIE BAR, IRVING, TX. THORNELL 17-13283, Plaintiffs: THOMAS P. CARTMELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & For NORA KRASINKIEWICZ 17-13153, SHAWN CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. BROWN 17-13183, Plaintiffs: BRANDI R. HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT For RHODA GOODMAN 17-13305, DONNA GRESHAM ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEXINGTON, MS. 17-13304, MARY HUBER 17-13302, JANET KENNEDY 17-13306, Plaintiffs: SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD For CANDACE A MAZUR 17-13160, SHERLEEN ATTORNEY, [*340] BARON & BUDD PC, DALLAS, Page 117 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *340

TX. SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For THOMAS MICHAEL COLLINS 17-13253 AND 18- 1854, Plaintiff: RANSE MURPHY PARTIN, LEAD For DEBRA BAILEY, 17-13547, NAKIA JOHNSON, 17- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 13549, VIRGINIA SZITAS, 17-13561, ETHEL B. BAR CONLEY GRIGGS PARTIN LLP, ATLANTA, GA. BOWMAN, 17-13613, GAIL LAYMON, 17-13619, BARBARA LINTZENICH, 17-13616, FRANCIS LINTZENICH, 17-13616, LASHAE Y. STRADFORD, 17- For DAVID DIFRANCESCO 17-13326, MAUREEN 13610, LAURA SULLIVAN, 17-13603, MALCOM N. DIFRANCESCO 17-13326, Plaintiffs: MARK R. BUCKLEY, 17-13626, DONALD DENATO, 17-13668, MUELLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT TAMMY HAMILTON, 17-13669, NICK HERSHAN, 17- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR MUELLER LAW FIRM, 13627, JOANNE SEABREASE, 17-13638, LEANN AUSTIN, TX. FISHER SELLERS, 17-13636, ARMAND SPADONI, 17- 13633, JAMES VERMES, 17-13646, WILLIAM A For JAYNE DEAK 17-13375, JOHN A. DEAK 17-13375, WATKINS, SR., 17-13631, NECKO WIGGINS, 17- Plaintiffs: GREGORY S. SPIZER, LEAD ATTORNEY, 13623, ERNEST H. WINES, 17-13629, RONALD L. ANAPOL WEISS, Philadelphia, PA. WORSFOLD, 17-13625, MARY J. SALVATORE, 17- 13714, BECKI DANIELLE PERRONE, 17-13758, BERNARD EBLE PERRONE, II, 17-13758, Plaintiffs: For TIMOTHY RANDALL 17-13324, Plaintiff: DAVID T TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MATTHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY. MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA.

For LINDA TANNENBAUM 17-13429, HOWARD For LYLE C. BURNS, 17-13559, SHERYL KAY FOGLE, TANNENBAUM 17-13429, Plaintiffs: ALAN STEVEN 17-13556, CARLENE ELAINE MIZELL, 17-13552, ERIC LAZAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ALAN STEVEN LAZAR, R. NATERA, 17-13546, BRENDA SMITH, 17-13562, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARLIN & SALTZMAN LLP, Plaintiffs: BARRY R. EICHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, AGOURA HILLS, CA. Eichen Crutchlow Zaslow & McElroy, LLP, [*342] EDISON, NJ. For GEORGE ARLEDGE 17-13523, Plaintiff: PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & For WANDA L. GUNTER, 17-13567, KATHERINE GEREL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. MARTIN, 17-13548, VINCENT MATSAYKO, 17-13554, KATHY MAXEL, 17-13560, CAROL MCFALL, 17- For FRANK DIVITA 17-13518, Plaintiff: DAVID 13563, TERRY MICHAELS, 17-13564, KAY MILLER, PATRICK DANIEL, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 17-13565, JAMES MCRAE SR., 17-13602, MARIO NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DANIEL & MYRICKS, 17-13605, ELIZABETH NEFF, 17-13607, ASSOCIATES LLC, HOUSTON, TX. DEBORAH PATTI, 17-13600, KATHLEEN PETTI, 17- 13755, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN For LISA DUENES 17-13506, Plaintiff: ADRIANA PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For JOSEPH MARTOVITZ, 17-13553, LAURA MARTOVITZ, 17-13553, DIANA MAYO, 17-13643, WADE MAYO, JR, 17-13643, CAROLINE MARTINEZ, For AMANDA SMITH 17-13541 AND 18-00809, 17-13695, FRANK MARTINEZ, 17-13695, VERDMAY Plaintiffs: PHILIP [*341] BOHRER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MATTHEW, 17-13688, YVONNIE MCCORMICK, 17- BOHRER LAW FIRM, BATON ROUGE, LA; TAYJES 13716, FRANCIS MCKNIGHT, 17-13750, THERESA MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER MCKNIGHT, 17-13750, MADELINE LUSARDI, 18-10, FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. TONY LUSARDI, 18-10, MARCIA MCVAY, 18-31, THOMAS MCVAY, III, 18-31, ALICE MARIE For BRYAN WRIGHT, 17-13506, Plaintiff: ADRIANA MICHAELS, 18-51, CRISTINA MILLER, 18-cv-129, Page 118 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *342

RODD MILLER, 18-cv-129, JOEL PARKER, 18-cv-130, For RICHARD PARKER, 17-13694, JEFFERY KAMALESH PATEL, 18-cv-126, NILABEN PATEL, 18- POWELL, 17-13690, SUSAN POWELL, 17-13690, cv-126, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ALLA SHIMANOVSKY, 17-13692, BERNARD ATTORNEY, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, HARTWEG, 17-13696, LINDA NOLTING, 17-13697, NM. BARBARA MANTHEIY, 17-13817, FRANCIS MANTHEIY, 17-13817, PATRICIA KEMP, 17-13717, BARBARA MONSON, 17-13721, LEEZA KRONICK, 17- For JAMES OULES, 17-13569, JANICE BOLES, 17- 13722, JUDY KIRALY, 17-13821, LATASHA M. BELL, 13671, PAMELA BEATY, 17-13675, ROSEMARY 18-11, STAVROULA K. BENNINGTON, 18-12, MARY BURKE, 17-13674, Plaintiffs: PATRICK KELLY LYONS, JONES, 18-13 (Clinton, Mississippi), KATHLEEN LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, [*343] YVONNE JOWERS, 18-16, PAMELA LAWSON, 18-20, WASHINGTON, DC. PAMELA ANN ANDREWS, 18-46, TINA ARTERBRIDGE, 18-39, DERRICK BETTS, 18-40, For CYNTHIA ANN PALMER, 17-13612, KIRSTEN JENNIFER BOURQUE, 18-22, BRIDGET CASTLE, 18- ROWE, 17-13615, DEBORAH SAMUEL, 17-13618, 41, SHAWN CHOATE, 18-47, CHRISTINE DIFRANCO, STEVEN SCHURKMAN, 17-13622, SUSAN 18-42, STEPHANIE FAHNSTROM, 18-43, MARTHA MITCHELL, 17-13670, SHELLY SCHWALBACH, 17- FOLEY-LANDRY, 18-44, PATRICIA L. GARY, 18-23, 13628, ANN SHANNON, 17-13632, ANN SMILEY, 17- HARRY HEFLIN, 18-45, SHIRLEY MITCHELL, 18-21, 13635, MARGARET WILEY, 17-13640, BRENDA PATRICIA RIGGINS, 18-25, AMYJON SMITH, 18-26, WINDHAM, 17-13645, MICHAEL GOLDEN, 17-13672, DEBORAH SMITH, 18-27, ELAINE GARNER, 18-67, CLYDE BASHORE, 17-13701, RAVEN LYNN JONETTE JANET, 18-69, ELAINE LEATHERWOOD, SINCLAIR, 17-13699, NEESHAWNDRA FAIRLEY, 17- 18-70, MARGARET LEWIS, 18-71, RUTHIE E. 13745, JANICE HOLMES, 17-13748, GAYLE MALY, LONGMIRE, 18-72, SHUNDA MANNING, 18-73, DIANE 17-13752, JANICE LOUISE NELSON, 17-13756, PINEIRO-ZUCKER, 18-79, DANIEL F PETERS, [*345] BELINDA WHOBREY, 17-13761, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY GARLAND RENCHEN, 18-80, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For LISA BARNES, 17-13639, MANUELA BURRELL, For IRIS AYERS, 17-13709, VALERIA MISARES 17-13642, ARTHUR CAMPBELL, 17-13661, PAMELA MOTRONEA, 17-13703, Plaintiffs: PETER ANDREW A. CAMPBELL, 17-13661, CHERYL COPENHAVER, MILLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MILLER DELLAFERA, 17-13648, LUCY CORDOVA, 17-13641, JULIE HENRICO, VA. DALTON, 17-13662, JOAN FREETHY-HOCKRIDGE, 17-13644, ALICE HERNANDEZ, 17-13652, BRIDGET For RONALD PATTERSON, 17-13704, ANGELA IVORY, 17-13647, DONNA MCCAFFERY, 17-13659, STEWART, 17-13705, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE DREW MCCAFFERY, 17-13659, CHRISTY NELSON, THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE 17-13649, INGRID PULLEN, 17-13665, RANDY LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. PULLEN, 17-13665, CORALEE RAMENSKY, 17-13655, VICTOR RAMENSKY, 17-13655, DAVID M. STEGALL, 17-13657, ELIZABETH STEGALL, 17-13657, TINA For KAREN ARTHUR, 17-13799, KARIN BARRETT, TAMURA, 17-13651, KATHERINE TIERNEY, 17-13650, 17-13802, MARIA BENNETT, 17-13804, CAROLYN VIRGINIA K. WATERS, 17-13637, [*344] Plaintiffs: CARSON, 17-13805, SHANTA CRUZ, 17-13806, MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEW CYNTHIA DAVITT, 17-13809, BRENDA ORLEANS, LA. ENGVALDSEN, 17-13812, LESSA ESLINGER, 17- 13813, SHARON FREEMAN, 17-13814, TEDDI GALANIS, 17-13816, SUSIE GAMBREL, 17-13818, For SHARYN URIBE, 17-13630, SIOBHAN JULIA TONI GIPSON, 17-13822, DELORES HARRELL, 17- MCNICHOLAS, 18-33, Plaintiffs: SARAH STERLING 13823, PAULA HEIM, 17-13825, SHERRIE HERTLING, STARNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, DON BARRETT PA, 17-13831, KAREN HUFFMAN, 17-13833, DELORES LEXINGTON, MS. KELLER, 17-13839, MARIE KELLER-LORENZO, 17- 13835, NANCY KELLY, 17-13838, SONIA LEWIS- Page 119 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *345

JONES, 17-13836, VESTINA LUCAS, 17-13837, EMILY ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. VAN HOUTEN, 17-13855, TERESA MCGARVEY, 17- LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL DREW DICKS, MESA, AZ. 13844, KATHLEEN MCINTYRE, 17-13845, BRENDA MIDKIFF, 17-13846, SARAH PORTER, 17-13847, For LYNN THOMAS, 17-13830, Plaintiff: MARK R. ROBIN POZGAR, 17-13848, MARJORIE PULLMAN, MUELLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MUELLER LAW FIRM, 17-13849, CAROLYN RICHARDS, 17-13840, AUSTIN, TX. YOLANTA ROVITO, 17-13850, [*346] CATHY SHERK, 17-13851, KATHY SMITH, 17-13841, NANCY SMITH, 17-13852, GAIL STEPHENSON, 17-13853, DOROTHY CLAUDIA BERUBE, 18-4, Plaintiff: Donald A. Migliori, TUCKER-SCOTT, 17-13854, MICHELLE VANELLA, 17- LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Providence, RI. 13856, DAWN VARGO, 17-13857, DEBORAH WILDERSON, 17-13858, KERSTA WOODS, 17-13859, For CHRIS BRAMMER, 18-17, JOYCE ANN MARY ZECHMAN, 17-13860, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE BRAMMER, 18-17, Plaintiffs: ZOLLIE CARLTON LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON STEAKLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, HARRISON DAVIS O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. STEAKLEY MORRISON PC, WACO, TX.

For ANGEL BLANK, 17-13795, Plaintiff: KEITH DAVID For DHIMITRAQ BANDILLI, 18-37, FELIKS BANDILLI, GRIFFIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, GIRARDI | KEESE, LOS 18-37, LEONARDO BANDILLI, 18-37, Plaintiffs: ANGELES, CA. NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS For BETTY DYE, 17-13778, THOMAS N. DYE, 17- ANGELES, CA. 13778, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. For WILLIAM JONES, JR., 17-13842, Plaintiff: STEVEN D. DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, TORHOERMAN LAW For ELVIA LONGORIA, 17-13791, Plaintiff: ETHAN L. LLC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. SHAW, LEAD ATTORNEY, SHAW COWART LLP, AUSTIN, TX. For BARBARA F NICKELL, 18-52, Plaintiff: BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD, LEAD ATTORNEY, Goza & For CRISTINE ANN BOTZENHARDT, 17-13718, Honnold, LLC, Overland Park, KS. DEBORAH ANNE SENTER, 17-13827, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL BRADY LYNCH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE For LESTA ROGERS, 18-54, Plaintiff: WARREN T MICHAEL BRADY LYNCH FIRM, WINTER PARK, FL. BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For CHARLES MANDEL, 17-13741, MARCIA MANDEL, 17-13741, Plaintiffs: T. MATTHEW LECKMAN, LEAD For PAULA TAYLOR, 17-13801, Plaintiff: CORRIE ATTORNEY, POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD, JOHNSON YACKULIC, LEAD ATTORNEY, CORRIE CONSHOHOCKEN, PA. YACKULIC LAW FIRM PLLC, SEATTLE, WA.

For STEVEN MCCORD, 17-13754, Plaintiff: JEFFREY For CYNTHIA NETTLES, [*348] 18-103, SHIRLEY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COHEN & RAMSEY, 18-105, Plaintiffs: GRAHAM LEE NEWMAN, MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN. LEAD ATTORNEY, CHAPPELL SMITH & ARDEN, COLUMBIA, SC. For KIMBERLY PULLEY, 17-13749, Plaintiff: CARYN MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*347] For HOLLY RUSSELL, 18-104, CINDY WILLSON, 18- JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. 102, Plaintiffs: TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. For DENISE JOHNSON, 17-13834, Plaintiff: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, For MARGARET WILSON, 18-119 (), Page 120 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *348

CARRIE COX, 18-68, BETTY J. LEWIS, 18-98, STACY 18-00351, BRENDA DUNCAN, 18-516, MARTHA LEWIS, 18-107, ROBIN NIXON, 18-100, SHIRLEY GRAY, 18-00519, MARY JONES, 18-00523 (Byram, RAMSEY, 18-105, BETTY STONE, 18-112, LOUISE Mississippi), REGINA HERNANDEZ, 18-534, SHELLI BIGELOW, 18-140, RACHAEL DURBIN, 18-142, OLSON, 18-537, MICHELLE ZUCATI, 18-527, Plaintiffs: GRAHAM LEE NEWMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, DOROTHY BYRDSONG, 18-614, ELIZABETH COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HANSELMAN-WONG, [*350] 18-613, ROSHONE CHAPPELL SMITH & ARDEN, COLUMBIA, SC. NATHAN, 18-00634, ABIGAIL HAMMOND, 18-00639, TERRY SCHATTILLY, 18-00636, DEBORAH STEPHENS, 18-00651, ANTRENA WICKS, 18-00648, For LINDA JEAN NICOLETTE, 18-85, GLORIA AMBROSINA WIMBERLY, 18-00643, MARY BERNSTEIN, 18-157, LEONARD BERNSTEIN, 18-157, GRIFFITH, 18-659, MARY ANN PEREZ, 16-00653, THERESA KNUDSEN, 18-178, MICHAEL RIEGEL, 18- SANDRA BEACH, 18-00670, SHARON PIERCE, 18- 236, SANDRA RIEGEL, 18-236, MARTIN 688, BRENDA SIMMONS, 18-684, VIVIAN HEFLIN, 18- SCHMUCKER, 18-260, MELANIE SCHMUCKER, 18- 00700, VALERIE PHILLIPS, 18-00699, TOMMIE 260, SHARON SCHROER, 18-294, JESS POOLE, 18-00690, CATHERINE WINTERS, 18-00693, SCHUMACHER, 18-366, JODY LYNN SCHUMACHER, CATHY ZANDARSKI, 18-00711, LUZ ANDERT, 18-724, 18-366, DORA TAGGART, 18-427, JACK TAGGART, KARIN MCGREGOR, 18-720, JUDY MCCLENDON, 18- 18-427, ILENE TARSKY, 18-449, WILLIAM TARSKY, 00230, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD 18-449, FRANCISCO CONTRERAS, 18-529, Plaintiffs: ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT DALLAS, TX. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. For HAROLD LUBOFF, 18-135, SHEILA LUBOFF, 18- 135, NELSON MOYER, 18-146, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. For JOHN ROSE, 18-91, ADA ROTHWELL, 18-92, MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL CHARLES SMITH, 18-94, NANCY LAURIE NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey WESTBERRY, 18-96, [*349] Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. LLP, Philadelphia, PA. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD For JACK G. GIBBS, JR., 18-159, Plaintiff: DANIEL N. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ABRAHAM, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COLLEY SHROYER & ABRAHAM, COLUMBUS, OH. For CASSANDRA HUDSON, 18-144, LEA-NEA HUDSON, 18-144, REGINA MACHIA, 18-360, For JOEL MAGALLANES, 18-143, LISA DARDEN, 18- THERESA MCCUE, 18-361, RAY MILLISON, 18-363, 281, JENNIFER MARIANO, 18-281, Plaintiffs: Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For ANGELA FINNEY, 18-168, DIANE PONTIOUS, 18- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ [*351] BAR, NEW 155, VIRGINIA SHIPLEY, 18-165, DONNA MOORE, ORLEANS, LA. 18-174, KATHLEEN RICKETTS, 18-00232, CHARLES WHITAKER, 17-11430, MARY MAHER, 18-240, KATHRYN THOMAS, 18-237, NANCY GODBEE, 18- For JEREMY SYAS, 18-152, WILTON ALLEN SYAS, 00247, MARYANN ROSSEY, 18-00243, IRMA SMITH, SR., 18-152, WILTON ALLEN SYAS, JR., 18-152, 18-00250, ALICE GUMINSKI, 18-00268, ADELITA Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, SANCHEZ, 18-00265, ELIZABETH STALLINGS, 18- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 00274, JULIE DINKEL, 18-276, MARLENE MORELLI, HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX. 18-282, PATRICIA MERCHANT, 18-300, YASMEEN REID, 18-303, BRENDA BLEDSOE, 18-00311, KEITH For STEVEN DORBER, 18-328, JAMES HELMS, 18- STELZMILLER, as Trustee of the Estate of Shannon 326, ADGENDA TURNER, 18-329, ERIKA WATSON, Montague, deceased/ 18-00321, VICTORIA GROSS, 18-325, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD Page 121 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *351

ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. BARRETT LAW GROUP PA, LEXINGTON, MS. LOUIS, MO. For GEORGINA ENCINAS, 18-446, JOE GANO, 18- For CHRISTI MCCOY, 18-235, Plaintiff: CASEY L. 446, MARIO GANO, 18-446, ROBERT GANO, 18-446, LOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED Plaintiffs: CRAIG ALLEN KNAPP, LEAD ATTORNEY, TO USDC-NJ BAR, LANGSTON & LOTT PLLC, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BOONEVILLE, MS. KNAPP & ROBERTS, SCOTTSDALE, AZ.

For LATINA POWELL, 18-255, Plaintiff: MATTHEW For JILL RENEE KLEIN, 18-436, ANTHONY C. RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL RODGERS, 18-436, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL STEVEN NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FEARS GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX. ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MORGAN & MORGAN PC, TAMPA, FL. For JEANNINE MAHONEY-SEXTON, 18-278, Plaintiff: CHRISTINA MARIE GRAZIANO, LEAD ATTORNEY, For JANIE R WALLER, [*353] 18-465, Plaintiff: JAMES COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, A. MORRIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT HAUSFELD LLP, WASHINGTON, DC; JAMES D. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MORRIS LAW FIRM, GOTZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED Burbank, CA; LOUIS M DIESEL, PETER AKMAJIAN, TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, BOSTON, MA; LEAD ATTORNEYS. STEVEN B. ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, For PETER MILES, Plaintiff: CORRIE JOHNSON BOSTON, MA. YACKULIC, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CORRIE YACKULIC For JULIE MACLIN, 18-333, Plaintiff: STEVEN B. LAW FIRM PLLC, SEATTLE, WA. ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, [*352] HAUSFELD For CHARLES BLAIR, LINDA S BLAIR, AARON LLP, BOSTON, MA. CORRIE, JAMES A CUMBERLAND, 18-487, MARCELEINE A CUMBERLAND, 18-487, MICHAEL For KATHRYN NIELSON, 18-282, Plaintiff: JEFFREY COALSON, 18-00499, CHRISTOPHER A GARCIA, 18- STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 00575, TERMINATED: 02/05/2020, RONNIE A ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COHEN & MALAD LLP, GERDUNG, 18-00577, DAMIEN KEKAHUNA, 18- INDIANAPOLIS, IN; JAMES D. GOTZ, STEVEN B. 00580, WILLEMMA KEKAHUNA, 18-00580, MOISES ROTMAN, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT LAGUNA, 18-00582, MARIA G LOPEZ GUTIERREZ, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAUSFELD LLP, 18-00582, NOAH ALMAREZ, 18-00592, ALFRED B BOSTON, MA. MONTES, 18-00583, JOSEPHINE OPPENBERG, 18- 00585, LAWRENCE L OPPENBERG, 18-00585, MARIA L ORTIGOZA, 18-00588, EDWARD J PECK, 18-00590, For EUGENA COLE, 18-423, SCOTTY COLE, 18-423, STEPHANIE RAMIREZ, 18-00592, JASON J REIS, 18- KIM FARRINGTON, 18-426, PHILLIP FARRINGTON, 00593, SHIRLEY B REIS, 18-00593, CARLOS ZUNIGA, 18-426, NANCY KOSTICK, 18-428, SANDRA HEARD, 18-00588, KELLY SCHLAHT, 18-00630, JOHN G 18-430, ALAN HILLEMAN, 18-437, TRACY SENTZ, 18- SCHWARTZ, 18-00635, LING D VAN BREE, 18-662, 484, ROSE BRYANT-FRANCE, 18-507, PATRICK ROBERT VAN BREE, 18-662, Plaintiffs: DAVID J. FRANCE, 18-507, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER R. DIAMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GOLDBERG & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, OSBORNE, TUCSON, AZ. Melville, NY.

For BRENDA FAYE GLOVER, Plaintiff: DAVID T For DONNA BANEY, 18-442, Plaintiff: BRANDI R. MATTHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY. [*354] HAMILTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, Page 122 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *354

For AMBER ADAMS, 18-483, LINDA ALLIZZO, 18-488, For CECILE E GORDON, 18-530, Plaintiff: MICHAEL MICHELE ANDRIOLA, 18-489, DONIELLE RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT AUFDENCAMP, 18-490, CHRISTINE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLIZZARD & NABERS BARTHOLOMEW, 18-491, TERESA BELARDEES, 18- LLP, HOUSTON, TX. 492, TRACY BLAKE, 18-494, KARYN BLANCHETTE, 18-00495, KAREN BUNCY, 18-00496, TISHYLINDA For CARLOS CINTRON, 18-607, ELMA CINTRON, 18- BUNK, 18-00500, AMANDALEE BURGESS, 18-00501, 607, SANDRA DIVENANZO, 18-611, EMILY JEFFREY, CHRISTINE CASTONGUAY, 18-00502, JANE 18-605, Plaintiffs: STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, LEAD TREMBLAY, 18-00570, PHYLLIS CHARNOFF, 18-506, ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, STEPHANIE CHO, 18-517, SUNANTHA CLARK, 18- PA. 00520, KAREN COE, 18-00522, JO LYNN CUCINOTTA, 18-526, SUZANNE CUTLER, 18-538, VICTORIA DUNPHY, 18-539, DEBRA GORSKY, 18- For BARABARA PARMER, 18-608, CLARENCE 541, RINA GUTIERREZ, 18-542, TRINA HAMMACK, PARMER, 18-608, Plaintiffs: FRANCISCO J. 18-543, KAYLA HAYES, 18-544, MARY HYSLOP, 18- RODRIGUEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, Javerbaum Wurgaft 545, LISA INTREPIDO, 18-546, ELIZABETH JAMES, Hicks Kahn Wikstrom & Sinins, P.C., Jersey City, NJ. 18-547, LORI JENSEN, 18-548, BADYRE JORDAN, 18- 549, CAROL JORDAN, 18-551, SANDRA For CYNTHIA SHEAFFER, 18-603, [*356] KARL KARAWETIAN, 18-552, KAREN KEEVEN, 18-553, SHEAFFER, 18-603, REGINA TAN, 18-609, CATHERINE KERKESLAGER, 18-557, VICKIE PAULETTE WATFORD, 18-604, Plaintiffs: STEVEN MAXWELL, 18-558, KRIS-ANN MCCANN, 18-559, DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & DENISE MCKIE, 18-554, PEGGY SIMON, 18-555, HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. DEBORAH YOUNG, 18-556, CYNTHIA NOWELL, 18- 00560, KATHERINE O'CONNOR, 18-00561, THERESA PRASIL, 18-00562, ANTIONETTE PRINCE, 18-00563, For TAMMY OLIVER, 18-716, COLETTE PATRICIA RAMBO, 18-00564, EVELYN ROMERO, 18- SHOEMAKER, 18-719, KIMBERLY YOST, 18-712, 00565, LAUREN SAVAGE, 18-00566, LORETTA Plaintiffs: MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, SULLIVAN, 18-00568, AMY TOMASI, 18-00569, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MADRIGAL ULLOA, 18-00571, [*355] ASHLEY NEWPORT BEACH, CA. VANDENBROEKE, 18-00572, CONNIE WHITE, 18- 00573, LYNN CORNFIELD, 18-525, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. For MARY D PRINCE, 18-714, Plaintiff: CASEY RYAN FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COBURN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PHILADELPHIA, PA; PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS For ANGELA OLIVER-WRIGHT, 18-505, WILLIAM CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. WRIGHT, 18-505, Plaintiffs: HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO For WILLIAM PRINCE, 18-714, Plaintiff: EDWARD M. USDC-NJ BAR, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED ASHLEY, ATHENS, GA. TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. For TERRY COLLIER, 18-535, Plaintiff: SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For SANDRA HART, 18-122, Plaintiff: PATRICK KELLY ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BARON & BUDD PC, LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT DALLAS, TX. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. For IRENE CRISO, 18-533, FLORIA TREADWAY, 18- 531, Plaintiffs: BARRY R. EICHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, For AMY TOMASI, 18-00569, JANE TREMBLAY, 18- Eichen Crutchlow Zaslow & McElroy, LLP, EDISON, NJ. 00570, MADRIGAL ULLOA, 18-00571, ASHLEY Page 123 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *356

VANDENBROEKE, 18-00572, CONNIE WHITE, 18- SCHATTILLY, 18-00636, DEBORAH STEPHENS, 18- 00573, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD 00651, ANTRENA WICKS, 18-00648, AMBROSINA ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- WIMBERLY, 18-00643, MARY GRIFFITH, 18-659, NJ, BAR JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. MARY ANN PEREZ, 16-00653, SANDRA BEACH, 18- 00670, SHARON PIERCE, 18-688, BRENDA SIMMONS, 18-684, VIVIAN HEFLIN, 18-00700, For RONNIE A GERDUNG, 18-00577, DAMIEN VALERIE PHILLIPS, 18-00699, TOMMIE POOLE, 18- KEKAHUNA, 18-00580, WILLEMMA KEKAHUNA, 18- 00690, CATHERINE WINTERS, 18-00693, CATHY 00580, [*357] MOISES LAGUNA, 18-00582, MARIA G ZANDARSKI, 18-00711, LUZ ANDERT, 18-724, KARIN LOPEZ GUTIERREZ, 18-00582, NOAH ALMAREZ, 18- MCGREGOR, 18-720, DWANA HAIRSTON, 18-00726, 00592, ALFRED B MONTES, 18-00583, JOSEPHINE JUNE CASSADA, 18-748, MIGDALIA MEDINA, 18-740, OPPENBERG, 18-00585, LAWRENCE L Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, OPPENBERG, 18-00585, MARIA L ORTIGOZA, 18- PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. 00588, EDWARD J PECK, 18-00590, STEPHANIE RAMIREZ, 18-00592, JASON J REIS, 18-00593, SHIRLEY B REIS, 18-00593, CARLOS ZUNIGA, 18- For CARLOS CINTRON, 18-607, ELMA CINTRON, 18- 00588, KELLY SCHLAHT, 18-00630, JOHN G 607, SANDRA DIVENANZO, 18-611, EMILY JEFFREY, SCHWARTZ, 18-00635, LING D VAN BREE, 18-662, 18-605, CYNTHIA SHEAFFER, 18-603, KARL ROBERT VAN BREE, 18-662, ADAM SUNSHINE, 16- SHEAFFER, 18-603, REGINA TAN, 18-609, 00655, KATHERINE C WENKER, 18-00704, THOMAS PAULETTE WATFORD, 18-604, HAROLD LOCKLEAR, WENKER, 18-00704, Plaintiffs: DAVID J. DIAMOND, 18-00602, Plaintiffs: STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ATTORNEY, [*359] GOLOMB & HONIK PC, USDC-NJ BAR, GOLDBERG & OSBORNE, TUCSON, PHILADELPHIA, PA. AZ. For LYNN CORNFIELD, 18-525, Plaintiff: ROLF T. For STEPHANI STOCKTON, 18-00578, GLEN TERRY, FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 18-00587, SHAWNA TERRY, DAVID THAI, 18-00595, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER ISRAEL VAISBEN, 18-00759, CANDACE STEWART, PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. 18-771, LLOYD STEWART, 18-771, CORINE MCCURTY, 18-783, STEPHANIE PEARSON, 18- For AGNES DEMERS, 18-610, BOBBY MCGHEE, 18- 00860, THERESA WARE, 18-00868, CHARLES 00762, LULLA MAE CHAMBERS, 18-958, KATHERINE WRIGHT, 18-00881, DEBRA USHER, 18-937, RAY, 18-960, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD RAYMOND USHER, 18-937, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED BAR, HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX. TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. For BARABARA PARMER, 18-608, CLARENCE PARMER, 18-608, Plaintiffs: FRANCISCO J. For DIANE LUNN, 18-00596, THOMAS SMITH, 18- RODRIGUEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, Javerbaum Wurgaft 00975 on behalf of ESTATE OF PATRICIA SMITH, Hicks Kahn Wikstrom & Sinins, P.C., Jersey City, NJ. JEANELLE STEHLY, 18-00970, JEFFREY STEHLY, 18-00970, ERIKA TARLOW, [*358] 18-00971, TONYA VERA, 18-976, MARGARET CLICK, 18-1016, For ANNEMARIE O'CONNELL, 18-00632, EDWARD JOSEPHINE MILLER, 18-1015, LETICIA NINI, 18-1014, O'CONNELL, 18-00632, KELLY BROUCEK, 18-00731, ROBIN GABBERT, 18-01038, Plaintiffs: CALLY MAE MCKINNEY, 18-00757, JOE MADDEN CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, PERSINGER, 18-00754, SUSAN KATZ PERSINGER, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli 18-00754, DELTA RACHEL REYNOLDS, 18-00756, Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. BILL WOODEN, 18-00761, ESTHER WOODEN, 18- 00761, RONALD GENE BAUER, 18-768, TODD JEFFREY BAUER, 18-768, BARBARA HATCHER For DOROTHY BYRDSONG, 18-614, ELIZABETH BETTS, 18-763, BILLY MACK BETTS, 18-763, ROGER HANSELMAN-WONG, 18-613, ROSHONE NATHAN, KLADKE, 18-766, CYNTHIA KRONER, 18-766, TRACY 18-00634, ABIGAIL HAMMOND, 18-00639, TERRY L. THOMAS, 18-764, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN ELIZABETH Page 124 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *359

MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. For KEYSYA REED, 17-13746, Plaintiff: Daniel Christopher Lyon, LEAD ATTORNEY, Elliot For SANDRA HART, 18-122, Plaintiff: PATRICK KELLY Morgan [*360] Parsonage, PLLC, Charlotte, NC; ROLF LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. For BEVERLY MILES, 18-743, TERRY MILES, 18-743, For ALFREDA DRINKHOUSE, 18-00665, SHARON THERESA PETERSON, 18-746, FLOYD PIKE, 18-749, HALL, 18-00820, DEBORAH MOSSA, 18-00952, DANA TAMMARA PIKE, 18-749, JANICE ROBERTSON, 18- NASSOUR, 18-00951, JANET NEWLIN, 18-00954, 795, LAWRENCE SALAZAR, 16-00797, VERONICA VERNA NICHOLS, 18-956, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SALAZAR, 16-00797, SUSAN WILDER, 18-938, SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM ELIZABETH WILSON, 18-939, LARRY WILSON, 18- PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. 939, DAVID WRIGHT, REBECCA WRIGHT, 18-940, SUSAN HERRING, 18-1009, Plaintiffs: JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For JAMES DUPUY, 18-00695, LORI BALL, 18-831, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COHEN & MALAD LLP, PHYLLIS BERRY, 18-832, BETTY HAWLEY, 18-833, INDIANAPOLIS, IN. KRISTI KEUERLEBER, 18-834, CHARLES MAUPIN, 18-835, GLORIA OTERO, 18-836, JANE SCHMIDT, 18- 890, DAWN COLLINS, 18-967, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE For JOHNNY WILLIAMS, 17-1820, Plaintiff: LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL PLACITELLA, LEAD ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON ATTORNEY, COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, PC, RED O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. BANK, NJ; PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL; THOMAS [*362] F. For TAMMY OLIVER, 18-716, Plaintiff: MARK P CUFFIE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSERL NOT ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE CUFFIE LAW ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, FIRM, ATLANTA, GA. CA.

For GLORIA A. CARTER, 17-9152, JANE L. LUND, 18- For MARY D PRINCE, 18-714, Plaintiff: CASEY RYAN 00950, KATHRYN E. RUSSELL, 18-979, PERRY J. COBURN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT WILLIAMS, 18-984, LARRY FERRELL, 18-00992, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PHILADELPHIA, PA; NADINE WILLIAMS, 18-00995, Plaintiffs: CARMEN EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC.

For WILLIAM PRINCE, 18-714, Plaintiff: EDWARD M. For DORIS A MENKING, 18-792, COLLIS OVERTON, NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED 18-786, GAYLE W OVERTON, 18-786, SHARON M TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS CANCELLIERE [*361] SNYDER, 18-794 (), Plaintiffs: MICHAEL RAY BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLIZZARD & NABERS For COLETTE SHOEMAKER, 18-719, KIMBERLY LLP, HOUSTON, TX. YOST, 18-712, DANA FLINN, 18-00732, GREGORY FLINN, 18-00732, ANTHONY FOSSETT, 18-00737, For STACY SENN ROBERTS, 18-787, JANICE RITA ITURRALDE, 18-00736, ED TACKABURY, 18- ASHTON, 18-00877, PATRICIA CANNON, 18-00887, 00871, CODY TAYLOR, 18-00879, LEESA GREEN, 18- MARYANNE DIEMER, 18-00907, HELEN LEHMAN, 18- 891, CHRISTY KENNY, 18-888, Plaintiffs: MARK P Page 125 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *362

00917, AMANDA SCHULTZ, 18-00923 (GA), CAROL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ [*364] BAR, FEARS BEADLING, 18-934, MARCEE BODEN, 18-936, NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX. JOANNE HELLERSTEDT, 18-926, ROSANNE SCOZZAFAVA, 18-932, DAVID L DISHMAN, 17-8533 For CHERYL CICERO, 18-852, LINDA FROST, 18-853, on behalf of ESTATE OF BRENDA JANE DISHMAN, WESLEY FROST, 18-853, GORDON WOELFEL, 18- DECEASED, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA 854, ROSEMARIE WOELFEL, 18-854, Plaintiffs: SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT THERESA M. WALSH, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BROWN CHIARI CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, LLP, LANCASTER, NY. MONTGOMERY, AL.

For TAWNYA HALL, 18-00867, Plaintiff: CARYN For WANDA PATTERSON, 18-773, MARJORIE L. MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GRUBER, 18-00884, RICKIE BLOW, 18-00974, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Plaintiffs: [*363] CHAD ETHAN IHRIG, LEAD JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NIX PATTERSON & ROACH LLP, AUSTIN, TX. For JEWEL CROOK, 18-00876, Plaintiff: GARY A ANDERSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For PATRICK HALL, 18-00809, Plaintiff: PHILIP ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ENVIRONMENTAL BOHRER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LITIGATION GROUP PC, BIRMINGHAM, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BOHRER LAW FIRM, BATON ROUGE, LA. For ERIN WILSON, 18-00920, Plaintiff: KELLY A. FITZPATRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, The Flood Law For VICTORIA A PACKER, 18-00802, LAURA PRATT, Firm, LLC, Middletown, CT. 18-00805, STYLIANA SIMONETI, 18-00805, ULLA N STEVENS, 18-00801, WILLIAM A STEVENS, 18- 00801, SANDRA KELLAR WALKER, 18-00799, For JANNETTA COOK, 18-961, DEBRA E. MORALES, WALTER THOMAS WALKER, SR., 18-00799, BRIAN 18-00962, Plaintiffs: DANIEL J. THORNBURGH, LEAD WALTON, 18-00807, ETHEL COLISTER, 18-889, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ANDREW D SHOTTER, 18-00915, DIANE LYNN BAR, PENSACOLA, FL. SHOTTER, 18-00915, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For CAROL FRAZIER, 18-00969, Plaintiff: DAVID NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey PATRICK DANIEL, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LLP, Philadelphia, PA. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DANIEL & ASSOCIATES LLC, HOUSTON, TX. For JOYCE WILLIS, 18-00810, Plaintiff: PHILIP BOHRER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For DARBY CROWLEY, 18-985, DAVID CROWLEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BOHRER LAW FIRM, 18-985, Plaintiffs: WENDY R. FLEISHMAN, LEAD BATON ROUGE, LA; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO BAR-NJ, NEW YORK, NY. USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. For ANN JOHNSTON, 18-983, DARLENE BUTCHER, [*365] 18-1026, KAREN DURBIN, 18-1026, For EDWARD ANDERSON, JR., 18-844, Plaintiff: PAUL CARVER, 18-01039, Plaintiffs: SINDHU SUSAN JAMES A. MORRIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MORRIS LAW ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BARON & BUDD PC, FIRM, Burbank, CA. DALLAS, TX.

For MARK ROSINSKI, 18-843, Plaintiff: MATTHEW For FRANKLIN KIRK, 18-981 (Wisconsin) on behalf of RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ESTATE OF MAUREEN KIRK, Plaintiff: MORRIS S. Page 126 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *365

DWECK, LEAD ATTORNEY, Bernstein Liebhard LLP, PETERSON, 18-1395, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER R. New York, NY. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. For NANCY KRAJCIK, 18-982, Plaintiff: HELEN ZUKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KEISEL & LAW LLP, BEVERLY HILLS, For KRISTIN BOERNER, 18-1052, SHARON L. CA. BARNHART, 18-1183, REGINA SHELTON, 18-01213, KAREN E. TURNER, 18-01215, VIRGINIA CUNNINGHAM, 18-1185, DORIS HILL, 18-1187, For JOSEPH ADAMS, 18-00994, Plaintiff: CATHERINE DANIEL KELLY, 18-1190, ANTHONY KOZAK, 18-1194, THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE EVA KRANICH, 18-1197, LINDA LOPOSKY, 18-1202, LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. NANCY MCMILLEN, 18-1205, DONNA PRITCHARD, 18-1208, RUSSELL JOHNSON, 18-1269, SANDRA For SHAUNA BERSON, 18-01001, Plaintiff: GRAHAM JONES, 18-1273, Plaintiff, ANNE MARIE [*367] LEE NEWMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT KIERNAN, MARY KRISTIN SANCTIS, 18-1278, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CHAPPELL SMITH & BERLINDA HENDRICKS, 18-01248, SEAN HILL, 18- ARDEN, COLUMBIA, SC. 01256, ANDREA KAY ALLISON, 18-01431, CYNTHIA BARNES, 18-01434, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For DAWN M. ARMSTRONG, 17-6804, CYNTHIA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN HIRL-BELL, 17-6748, Plaintiffs: ANTHONY G. SIMON, CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MONTGOMERY, AL. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO; John G. Simon, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, For TERESA HARVEY, 18-1056, ANNE WYGAL, 18- P.C., St. Louis, MO. 01079, AMEILA FROOM, 18-01214, ROSANNE LOPA, 18-01210, EVELYN AUSTIN, 17-7929, DORI-ANNE GREEN, 18-1358, NICHOLE HENDERSHOT, 18-1360, For SAMUEL CHARLES, 18-01027, KATHLEEN DOROTHY LATTING, 18-1361, TERRI LEMASTER, 18- JOHNSON, 18-01032, Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ 1362, GLENN LOTHIAN, 18-1365, LELA MURRAY, 18- DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 1366, FRANCISCA ORTIZ, 18-01378, HEIDI ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SKIKOS CRAWFORD PORTEOUS, 18-01369, SANDRA ROGERS, 18-01370, SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. MARIE SMEDLEY, 18-01372, KIM THROOP, 18-01377, TAMMY WHITTY, 18-01373, KATHLEEN WILLIAMS, For RUSSEL [*366] JOHNSON, JR., 18-01032, ELLA 18-01376 (Upson County, GA), Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE MADDEN, 18-01028, GREGORY MADDEN, 18-01028, LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT CLARA HAZELWOOD, 18-1293, GEORGE MAHER, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON 18-1291 (Grapevine, TX), on behalf of, ESTATE OF O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. ELIZABETH MAHER, JIMMIE TAYLOR, 18-1294, FREDERICK THOMPSON, 18-1295, JOAN For BRIAN KURTIS ADAMS, 18-01060, DOROTHY THOMPSON, 18-1295 (California), CHARLES ALGER, 18-1117, Plaintiffs: M. BRANDON SMITH, WESTBROOK, 18-1299, SHAUNTEL WESTBROOK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO 18-1299, Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, USDC-NJ BAR, CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO LLC, ATLANTA, GA. USDC-NJ BAR, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For ALLAN BURNETT, 18-01083, DIANA A. BLACKWOOD, 18-1142, Plaintiffs: CHAD ETHAN For ARTHUR MORRIS, 18-01030, SHARON MORRIS, IHRIG, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT [*368] 18-01030, CAROLE MCTIGUE, 18-1033, TERRENCE ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NIX PATTERSON & MCTIGUE, 18-1033, TERESA CHAMBERS, 18-1043, ROACH LLP, AUSTIN, TX. KATHRYN TADDEI, 18-01062, RUSSELL TADDEI, 18- 01062, KELLY AZZARI, 18-1166, CONNIE L Page 127 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *368

For DONNA TUTTLE-KOLL, 18-01069, Plaintiff: USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, SC. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, For JANNETTA SNELL, 18-1130, FLORELL BERRY ATHENS, GA. WILSON, 18-1132, JULEE E. BLAKE, 18-1162, CHRISTINA FAULTERSACK, 18-1153, DENISE For CLAUDIA DEPREZ, 18-1091, JOHN VOGELEY, REYNOLDS, 18-1168, DIANA STOPINSKI, 18-1160, 18-1091, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ANGELA CHURCH, 18-01243, HAZEL MARIE ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. MANNING, 18-01249, INGRID ANNELORE PRUITT, 18-01254, KRISTA ROCHELLE SEIPLE, 18-01263, KELLY L. SZUMERA, 18-1135, Plaintiffs: TAYJES For ESTATE OF LISA A. CHEESE, 18-1125, Plaintiff: MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER ANDREW JOHN CALCAGNO, LEAD ATTORNEY, FIRM LLC, [*370] ORANGE, VA. CALCAGNO & ASSOCIATES, LLP, CRANFORD, NJ.

For SYMONE SIMMONS, 18-1179, Plaintiff: ERIC D. For AMY KILPATRICK, 18-1134, MADELINE RUBY, PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 18-1131, ADELAIDA BASICH, 18-1171, ERMA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HEYGOOD ORR & BREITHAUPT, 18-1181, MARIA BUSCIACCO, 18- PEARSON, IRVING, TX. 1177, LAURA CLARKE, 18-1174, TONYA CRAMER, 18-1167, DEBORAH LAKES, 18-1175, BONNIE LITTLE, 18-1145, DIANE PLASS, 18-1164, VICTORIA For RAYMOND STOTLER, 18-01211, KENNETH M. SELLERS, 18-1178, OFELIA WALKER, 18-1169, BROWN, 18-1189, ROSHANDA CHENIER, 18-1192, LINDA WEST, 18-1148, JENNIFER YETTNER, 18- GAETANO LOGRASSO, 18-1207, ROCCO 01212, AMPARO CARRERO, 18-1198, JANIS GARZA, LOGRASSO, 18-1207, CLYIVE L. PRITCHETT, 18- 18-1200, JAYNE LORD, 18-1196, ANNIE 1199, GAETANO LOGRASSO, 18-1207, ROCCO ROBERTSON, 18-1209, PAMELA ROSS, 18-1204, LOGRASSO, 18-1207, CLYIVE L. PRITCHETT, 18- BRENDA WISE, 18-1200, MABLE DORTCH, 18-1137, 1199, BRUCE KLINGAMAN, 18-01227, BLAKE PAMELA FOSTER, 18-1141, CARLA NARCOMEY, 18- LUNDBERG, 18-01225, WILLIAM REASOR, 18-01231, 1139, DENA STRAUGHN, 18-1143, SAMANTHA JACQUELINE SELLARDS, 18-01371, BETTY SEITZ, REYNOLDS, 18-1266, DENNIS BREIER, 18-01232, 18-01375, NANCY SEITZ, 18-01375, OSCAR EMERY, ROY COLLINS, 18-01233, ROBERT FELTON, 18- 18-1364, Plaintiff: JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD 01228, JEFFREY MILLER, 18-01229, [*369] TIMOTHY ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MILLER, 18-01229, CANDACE, PERKINS, 18-01236, BAR, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN. BRYAN SHIRLEY, 18-01234, JAY WEBB, 18-01237, ANA ARROYO, 18-01239, MARY LUANN HICKMAN, For EVELYN AUSTIN, 17-7929, DAWN HANNAH, 18- 18-01242, PATSY LECKEY, 18-01245, VITA 1422, Plaintiff: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD MATERASSO, 18-01259, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, For NINA MARIE QUILES, 18-1108, ZELINDA K. ST. LOUIS, MO. DIXON, 18-1105, DIANNE J. BEAUCHAMP, 18-1180, SARA E. DEFFLER, 18-1156, KELLY RAE LINDGREN, For JERIE RHODE, 17-7910, Plaintiff: JAMES G. 18-1170, PENNY PATTON, 18-1163, SEUNG JAE ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT HONG, 17-10627, on behalf of, Seung Yeon Hong, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON ELIZABETH SMITH, 18-1298, MICHAEL C. TULEO, 18- O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. 01304, MARCELLA J. HARTMAN, 18-1351, JOE Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY, [*371] COUNSEL NOT EDWARD TOLBERT, 18-1401, WANDA F. WALLACE, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND 18-1391, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, SHELTON, L.L.C., St. Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Page 128 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *371

ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR ONDER SHELTON For PATRICIA A TOLLARI, 18-1292, Plaintiff: CASEY O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM RYAN COBURN, EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON NJ BAR, PHILADELPHIA, PA. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For CATHY BEEGLE, 18-1329, LORI COLLINS, 18- For SANDRA CURTIS, 18-1274, CATRINA M. 01342, SHERRI COUGHLIN, 18-01331, KATHLEEN WAGNER, 18-1277, REBECCA STROTH, 18-1285, LEILANI SHELTON DAHILIG, 18-01333, SHERRI AMY CUNNINGHAM, 18-1419, AMY FELDMAN, 18- DIEU-STEELE, 18-01338, DELORIES JOHNSON, 18- 1417, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD 01337, KAYDEE MILLER, 18-01335, CHARLOTTE ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, RICHARDSON, 18-01345, PEGGY SCHWARTZ, 18- DALLAS, TX. 01346, PATRICIA SOBOCINSKI, 18-01332, LORI WINSTEL, 18-01330, JENNIFER YESTER, 18-01336, KATHY ZWALD, 18-01345, FATIMAH AL-NURRIDIN, For DEIRDRE DUDDY, 18-1281, ENILDA VASQUEZ, 18-1353, KAREN HILLIARD, 18-1352, CATHY 18-1265, DEBORAH PRIEVO, 18-01235, GINA PARAS, WHALEN, 18-1356, VERA ALEX, 18-1479, ELIZABETH 18-01240, DOTSIE L. STURDIVANT, 18-01246, BOUTCHER, [*373] 18-1473, DEBORAH BRAAK, 18- BRENDA S. TALLEY, 18-01253, SANDY TORO, 18- 1483, ERIN CAMPI, 18-1487, MARGARET CRAVEN, 01261, JESSICA L. KIETUR, 18-1283, SHARON KATH, 18-1481, Plaintiffs: CARYN MICHELE 18-1320, SHARON KELLER, 18-1322, ELEONOR PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MACIAS, 18-1321, TAMMIE BLANCHARD, 18-01301, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON LAW LEANNE BROWN, 18-01307, TINA DENT, 18-01308, GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. LANNETTE DRAYTON, 18-01311, SAMANTHA GORRELL, 18-01313, CINDY JOHNSON, 18-01315, Plaintiffs: TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, For TONRIA DUNBAR, 18-1318, KIM POST, 18-01314, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. For ARCHIE WINTERS, 18-1271, RITA WINTERS, 18- 1271, Plaintiffs: ZOLLIE CARLTON STEAKLEY, LEAD For TAMARA WILLIS, 18-1324, Plaintiff: JOHN REILY ATTORNEY, COUNSEL [*372] NOT ADMITTED TO CRONE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT USDC-NJ BAR, HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ANDRUS WAGSTAFF MORRISON PC, WACO, TX. PC, LAKEWOOD, CO.

For MARGARET ARNOLD, 18-01219, DAVID For GLORIA TRIBBLE, 18-01310, VICKIE HAINEY, 18- ARNOLD, 18-01219, Plaintiffs: ALAN STEVEN LAZAR, 1414, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, USDC-NJ BAR, MARLIN & SALTZMAN LLP, AGOURA NY. HILLS, CA. For JOANNE CALVIN, 18-01347, Plaintiff: DAE YEOL For JOYCE ROSE, 18-1300, GEORGE LUIS MACIAS, LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD LLP, 18-01309, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD NEW YORK, NY. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. For JOY WASHINGTON, 18-1354, MARIE WASHINGTON, 18-1354, Plaintiffs: PATRICK KELLY For ANTHONY TOLLARI, 18-1292, Plaintiff: EDWARD LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS CANCELLIERE LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. For KERRY MICHAEL HOELLER, 18-01374, Plaintiff: Page 129 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *373

ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. ST. LOUIS, MO.

For TINA MCDANIEL, 18-01383, Plaintiff: KEITH DAVID For VICTORIA VERLIE, 18-1421, Plaintiff: DAVID GRIFFIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT JOHN STANOCH, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GIRARDI | KEESE, HONIK, P.C., PHILADELPHIA, PA. LOS ANGELES, CA. For DONOVAN BROUSSARD, II, 18-1452, Plaintiff: DANIELLE WARD MASON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - NJ BAR, [*374] For GAIL SILVER, 18-01379, SCOTT SILVER, BEASLEY, ALLEN, CROW, METHVIN, PORTIS & 18-01379, Plaintiffs: DENNIS M. GEIER, LEAD MILES P.C., MONTGOMERY, AL. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COHEN PLACITELLA & ROTH, RED BANK, NJ. For KIMBERLY FREEMAN, 18-1486, Plaintiff: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, BURNS For KAYLA NICOLE BRYANT, 18-1410, JEFFERY CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. SCOTT HUDSON, 18-1409, MICHAEL BRIAN HUDSON, 18-1409, GEORGE NEEL, 18-1410, HOLT TRISTAN NEEL, 18-1410, SAMINATHA NEEL, 18- For DOROTHY GOODWILL, WHITE 18-1490, Plaintiff: 1410, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD GREGORY DONALD BROWN, KELSEY LOUISE ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ STOKES, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT BAR, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HOUSTON, TX. LOS ANGELES, CA. For MARJORIE HEIN, 18-1495, SHARON MURPHY, For TONI DONART, 18-1389, Plaintiff: THOMAS P. 18-1498, LISA PAGE, 18-1492, PAULA SANDERS, 18- CARTMELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 1497, AMY JO WORSECK, 18-01448, ELAINE GILL, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WAGSTAFF & 18-01460, KARALYN LACKEY, 18-01463, TABRIL CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. WHITE, 18-01501, RITA GUIDRY, 18-1541, ANNE O'CONNOR, 18-01534 (Pennsylvania), DEBRA TRAHERN, 18-01529, ROBIN MARTIN, 18-1543, For ETHEL M NUCKOLS, 18-1409, Plaintiff: MICHAEL SUSAN COOK, 18-01550, DEBORAH SALMON, 18- BRADY LYNCH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MICHAEL 01551, TONI STEWART, 18-01547, ELAINE ROBLES, BRADY LYNCH FIRM, WINTER PARK, FL. 18-1552, PATRICIA [*376] STOCKTON, 18-1556, MARION TAYLOR, 18-1555, TANYA COCA, 18-1567, For GEORGE HARTER, 18-1420, Plaintiff: JAMES STEPHANIE PRESLEY, 18-1564, LYNN ROSS, 18- LAMAR WARD, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 01803, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MCGOWAN ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, HOOD & FELDER LLC, MOUNT PLEASANT, SC. DALLAS, TX.

For AMY JOHNSON, 18-1423, Plaintiff: JAMES G. For ROBIN JOBLONOWSKI, 18-1477, JOAN ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT SCHAFLE, 18-1489, KERRIE SCOTT, 18-1494, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON JEANNETTE WILLIAMS, 18-1491, DONNA WITTWER, O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; Michael J. 18-1485, PAULA KNAPIK, 18-1509, PAMELA Quillin, LEAD ATTORNEY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED PARISHER, 18-1506, PAULA RUSSO, 18-1512, CINDY TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., St. WOODRUFF, 18-1514, DONCELLA YOUNG, 18-1507, Louis, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, [*375] LEAD CATHERINE BANACH, 18-01504, VICKI BARAN, 18- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 1517, VICKY CARPENTER, 18-1516, PAMELA HILL, BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. 18-1518, MARCIA MAZZARELLA, 18-1683, MICHAEL LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD W. LUNA, 18-1696, PAMELA LUNA, 18-1696, Page 130 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *376

MARQUETTE MCGRIFF, 18-1691, JENNIFER R. 01531, ESTEBAN FLORES, 18-1542, LEAH M. NABZDYK, 18-1688, THOMAS E. NABZDYK, 18-1688, FLORES, 18-1542, MICHAEL S. PINKERTON, 18- JAMES MICHAEL PETERSON, 18-1703, KELLY 1545, PAULETTA BAXENDALE, 18-01546, ANGELA SUNDGREN, 18-1705, KIMBERLEE BYRNE, 18- LEMIRE, 17-11472, CARLA THOMPSON, 17-11473, 01710, CAROLE LATIMER, 18-01714, SANDY CEDRIC HUNT, 17-11596, executor of the estate of MASSIE, 18-01708, MICHAEL G. MULDER, 18-01714, EVELYN HUNT, KAREN PRICE, 17-11595, executrix of NANCY CASSELMAN-KENDALL, 18-1730, the estate of GRAYCE NADEAU, JOHN JR. SIGET, 17- ELIZABETH WAGNER, 18-1732, SAUNDRA RENEE 11903, DENNIS FOERSTER, 17-11469, son of Carol BEDFORD, 18-01737, STARLENE AGUIRRE, 18-1886, Foerster, deceased, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW STACIE SVANDA, 18-1885, THOMAS KERSHNER, 18- SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, 01884, on behalf of ESTATE OF TAMMY KERSHNER, ORANGE, VA. ANDREA WHITE, 18-01883, EULA DEKEYZER, 18- 1906, KERRI BERGER, 18-1946, RONALD BERGER, For HEATHER ZIMO, 18-01430, CHERYL WILLIAMS 18-1946, SANDRA EVANS, 18-1925, [*377] TERESA ANDERSON, 18-01438, BARBARA SELTZER, 18- FERRIS, 18-1939, PAMELA HODOROVIC, 18-1910, 01444, SUNNY MILLINGER, 18-01450, Plaintiffs: JAMIE KESTERSON, 18-1933, CAMELLIA MARTINEZ, LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, 18-1914, STEPHENIE MOTTER, 181931, JULIE COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, TREADWELL, 18-1944, Plaintiffs: CARYN MICHELE BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HOUSTON, TX.

For FRANCES DELGADO, 18-01439, CONNIE For CURTIS D. PIERCE, SR., 18-1446, PATRICIA DENGLER, 18-01441, LILLIE HARRIS, 18-01443, PIERCE, 18-1446, Plaintiffs: DEREK T. BRASLOW, WILLIE D. HARRISON, 18-01447, PAMELA SUE LEAD ATTORNEY, THE BRASLOW LAW FIRM, LLC, HUFF, 18-01449, BARBARA JOHNSON, 18-01451 WAYNE, PA. (Florida), WAYNE MEIER, 18-01459, PATRICIA MEYER, 18-01453, MARY ANN ARMONTROUT, 18- For PATRICIA RYAN, 18-1471, DIANE KAHN, 18- 01557, JANICE PIZZO, 18-01559, HEIDI SHERMAN, 01882, Plaintiffs: MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD 18-01562, AMY JO WALDOW, 18-01563, MILDRED ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ GODWIN, 18-1583, ALICE CARELLA, 18-1900, BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. Plaintiffs: [*379] BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN For SAMMIE SCHINDLER, 18-1474, KURT KNIERIM, PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. 18-1526, on behalf of ESTATE OF PATRICIA LOUISE KNIERIM, DECEASED, PETER KNIERIM, 18-1526, on behalf of ESTATE OF PATRICIA LOUISE KNIERIM, For GUILDA CLAVETTE, 18-01462, Plaintiff: KEVIN S. DECEASED, WILLIS KNIERIM, 18-1526, on behalf of HANNON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ESTATE OF PATRICIA LOUISE KNIERIM, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE HANNON LAW DECEASED, TONI CORBY, 18-1753, JULIAN FIRM LLC, DENVER, CO. KREISBERG, 18-1891, on behalf of ESTATE OF MARCIA PERL KREISBERG, DECEASED, SUSAN For KIMBERLI M HARNEY, 18-01461, Plaintiff: MARIE JOHANNSEN, 18-01987, on behalf of, ESTATE CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, OF MARILYN HALLORAN, DECEASED, Plaintiffs: COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX. For RANDY HILL, 18-1464, Plaintiff: ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For LORIE A. VANMETER, 18-1476, STUART NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SKIKOS VANMETER, 18-1476, LAWRENCE [*378] CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, MCDONALD, 18-1536, JANET M. VIOLA, 18-1539, CA. MARCIA WELLS, 18-1538, HUGH COVINGTON, 18- Page 131 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *379

For PAMELA SAARI, 18-01500, JASON WATTS, 18- TERESA A. CORLEY, 18-01972, TABATHA S. COTE, 01502, LAURA WATTS, 18-01502, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. 18-01982, BEVERLY A. FOLDS, 18-01993, LORI S. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL SAUCER, 18-02002, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LLP, Philadelphia, PA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For MARINA LOVE MORENO, 18-1535, SHANNON LOVE HARMON, 18-1535, MELISSA PATTERSON, 18- For CONNIE GARNER, 18-1611, EUGENE M LITTLE, 01582, Plaintiffs: LINDSEY A. CHEEK, LEAD 18-1614, Plaintiffs: BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE CHEEK LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. BAR, Goza & Honnold, LLC, Overland Park, KS.

For CLAUDIO PONTARELLI, 18-1554, NANCY For ANGIE BURNS, 18-1619, Plaintiff: JEFFREY PONTARELLI, 18-1554, ROSE PORTER, 18-1553, SCOTT QUINN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT SHARON POLAND, 18-1565, CYNTHIA POWELL, 18- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEKMAN MARDER & 01574, GEORGE POWELL, 18-01574, LISA ADKINS LLC, BALTIMORE, MD. ROBINSON, 18-01569, ELIZABETH [*380] COOLEEN, 18-1632, JULIO FIGUEROA, 18-1629, MARY For JOHN STAPLES, 18-1630, MICHELE STAPLES, FIGUEROA, 18-1629, REGINA CORNS, 18-1637, 18-1630, Plaintiff: KEVIN M. FITZGERALD, LEAD ANTHONY CRAIG, 18-1634, PATRICIA CRAIG, 18- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 1634 (Ohio), ELISE FLOWERS, 18-1636, MARTIN BAR, FITZGERALD LAW GROUP, PORTLAND, ME. HIGGINS, 18-01640, TALECHA WILLIS, 18-01639, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. For ARTHUR MEYHOFER, 18-01625, MARY MEYHOFER, 18-01625, LINDA INNIS, 18-01969, , 18-01967, JAMES KENNEY, 18- For ROBYN PHILLIPS, 18-01570, Plaintiff: RANDI 01965, SUSAN KENNEY, 18-01965, Plaintiffs: ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, SANDERS COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli VIENER GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN CITY, NY. Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY.

For JERRY YARBROUGH, 18-187, LESLIE CRANE, For BRIAN MALESKI, 18-1678, RENE MALESKI, 18- 18-1761, MARIANNE DENNIS, 18-1762, MELLISA 1678, Plaintiffs: ASHLEIGH ELIZABETH RASO, LEAD DUFAULT, 18-1760, KEVIN LOONEY, 18-1766, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ CHERYL RABOLD, 18-01772, OLGA RODRIGUEZ BAR, MESHBESHER & SPENCE, CHANG, 18-01768, VICTORIA TERIFAJ, 18-01769, MINNEAPOLIS, [*382] MN. VANASHA WATSON, 18-01767, EDUVIGES CARO, 17-9292, ALICE WILLIS, 17-10500, CHRISTINA DIEMER, 18-1929, CHRIS LANGE, 18-1926, For DAVID ADLER, 18-01720, ENID ADLER, 18-01720, CHRISTINA MASON, 18-1916, MARIAH VASQUEZ, Plaintiffs: MARTIN G. RUBENSTEIN, LEAD 18-1919, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LEVY BALDANTE FINNEY & RUBENSTEIN PC, BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. PHILADELPHIA, PA. LOUIS, MO.

For ANN DEVORE, 18-01713, DOUGLAS DEVORE, For CINDY A. COMBS, 18-1595, KATHLEEN A. 18-01713, Plaintiffs: BARRY R. EICHEN, LEAD GLEISSNER, 18-1627, DUANE E. MOORE, 18-01655, ATTORNEY, Eichen Crutchlow Zaslow & McElroy, LLP, FRANCES L. BURGESS, 18-1739, ROSA MARIA EDISON, NJ. PARK, 18-01808, CAROL J. RICE, 18-01849, TERESA D. ARNOLD, 18-01870, SUSAN J. LOGOZZO, 18- For BERNADETTE CLARK, 18-1728, RANDALL 01873, [*381] NANCY J. THERIOT, 18-01862, Page 132 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *382

CLARK, 18-1728, DANIEL BERRY, 18-01813, Plaintiffs: ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. ANNA MAURINE CARROLL, LEAD ATTORNEY, HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS LLC, BIRMINGHAM, For DONALD P CHIARI, 18-01841, Plaintiff: THERESA AL. M. WALSH, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BROWN CHIARI LLP, For PATRICIA GRAZULIS, 18-1791, JOLENE SIMON, LANCASTER, NY. 18-1790, MARCELLE CARREAU, 18-1831, SHIRLEY GUNTER, 18-1827, JANESS PIVAC, 18-1823, For JENNA S LAND, 18-1902, BRENDA WALKER, 18- ANDREA J. THOMPSON, 18-1829, PATRICIA 1902, Plaintiffs: JOHN REILY CRONE, LEAD TRAHAN, 18-1832, LINDA G. LEGAY, 18-01836, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAR, ANDRUS WAGSTAFF PC, LAKEWOOD, CO. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. For JORGE RUEDA, 18-1901, Plaintiff: MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For CELESTE Y. NAZIM, 18-1792, Plaintiff: PATRICIA NOT ADMITTED [*384] TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT & BARNES, BUFFALO, NY. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MONTGOMERY, AL.

For JOSHUA DUNCAN, 18-1956, ROBERT HAINES, For CLAIRE WALTER, 18-1789, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. 18-1958, SHARON HAINES, 18-1958, NEIL L GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT RUDOFSKY, 18-1957, GARY HANDYSIDE, 18-01960, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES GLORIA HANDYSIDE, 18-01960, ANNMARIE K PC, BUFFALO, NY. O'DONNELL, 18-01959, JOSEPH O'DONNELL, 18- 01959, Plaintiffs: DAVID J. DIAMOND, LEAD For JOHNATHAN MADKINS, 18-01840, THE ESTATE ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ OF ESSIE BAKER, 18-01840, Plaintiffs: BAR, GOLDBERG & OSBORNE, TUCSON, AZ. TREVOR [*383] BRUCE ROCKSTAD, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For JOAN GARDNER, 18-01985, Plaintiff: WILLIAM BAR, DAVIS & CRUMP PC, GULFPORT, MS. WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON For FRED MUNSON, 18-01839, Plaintiff: CORRIE O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. JOHNSON YACKULIC, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CORRIE For ANDREA STEWART, 18-02009, BILL STEWART, YACKULIC LAW FIRM PLLC, SEATTLE, WA. 18-02009, CHRISTINE BIALE, 18-02011, WILLIAM BIALE, 18-02011, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA For ESTELITA DAVIS, 18-1893, Plaintiff: MEKEL HEACOX, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For NALINI L. HARBAJAN, 18-02013, GARY For JOSEPH DONIA, 18-1890, LISA DONIA, 18-1890, KIRKWOOD, 18-02012, ALLAN TAYLOR, 18-02010, on behalf of ESTATE OF MILDRED DONIA, Plaintiffs: CARMEN TAYLOR, 18-02010, MIRANDA CARBY, 18- ROLF T. FIEBIGER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 2210, JENNIFER ZATEZALO, 18-2212, Plaintiffs: NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, LEAD BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW YORK, NY. For JOHNNY JONES, 18-1888, LORETTA TRAVER, 18-1892, RANEY NAUGHTON, 18-1913, Plaintiffs: For PATRICIA A. CHACON, 18-02035, MELANIE M. DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL HUANG, 18-02036, CATHERINE WOOTEN, 18-02032, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & ELIZABETH CORRAL, 18-2019, ALEX Y. CORRAL, Page 133 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *384

JR., 18-2019, ZARAH GOATEE, 18-2017, KATIE ROGER BODWALK JR., 18-2057, MARLENE BURT, HUGHES, 18-2030, LYNN M. SLAYER, 18-2023, 18-2059, JOANN CONNERS, 18-2061, JOHN DAVIS, CEANNA [*385] HARP, 18-02038, MARGARET 18-2062, LYDIA GIULIANO, 18-2063, JANE HARELL, BAPTISTE, 18-2048, BETH CHRISTEL KRUSE, 18- 18-2064, PEARL HILLIARD, 18-2066, MARY HOOD, 2049, ANNETTE MCCARTHY, 18-2050, CRYSTAL 18-02067, PATRICIA LANGAN, 18-02068, LINDA BOTHWELL, 18-02158, VIRGINIA JAAFAR, 18-02154, LANSBERRY, 18-02069, CAROLYN ANN LARSON, ANDREA ZULAICA, 18-02153, KARLA AKEMANN, 18- 18-02070, KAREN LIHANI, 18-02073, JOANNE 02169, CHRISTY CARLSON, 18-02176, ANA L. MILLER, 18-02071, GAIL DIXON BROWN, 18-2244, GUTIERREZ, 18-02172, JANET S. NEWKIRK, 18- DOLORES LINDNER, 18-2246, VALERIE ANDERSON, 02177, LAURIE TOWNSEND, 18-02170, KATRINA DE 18-02423, PATRICIA ANTHONY, 18-02425, Plaintiffs: LOS REYES, 18-02186, JUAN CARLOS ARREOLA BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, VILLA, 18-2220, on behalf of ESTATE OF MARIA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SANCHEZ HERNANDEZ, SUSAN PAUL, 18-2218, BEASLEY [*387] ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & KELLI DENISE RUMSEY, 18-2217, ROBERT MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. RUMSEY, 18-2217, MARY JANE SPRINKLE, 18-2227, BEVERLY A. URBAS, 18-2229, DAVID G. WILD, 18- For ERICKA CARR, 17-11896, on behalf of ESTATE 2221, RANDY WILD, 18-2221, DANA BENJAMIN, 18- OF FANNIE MAE CARR, TERRIE BLEDSON, 17- 02231, LEANNA PARSLEY, 18-02238, JEAN SHIPOS, 11891, on behalf of ESTATE OF MARY 18-02232, MARTHA VILLALOBOS, 18-02234, MARY E. WITHERSPOON, RICHARD PICOU, 17-11884, on BUTLER-SISNROY, 18-2325, LORETTA V. CLEMENS, behalf of ESTATE OF ROSE PICOU, DENNIS WEBER, 18-2324, ANDREA ENCINAS, 18-2315, JOHN 17-11886, on behalf of ESTATE OF DOROTHY MORYKAN, 18-2316, SUSAN LINDA MORYKAN, 18- WEBER, JOE PELT, 17-11887, on behalf of PEGGY 2316, RICHARD B. PHILLIPS, 18-2313, ROXANN PELT, TRUDY LAUVAS, 17-11467, CHRISTINA M. PHILLIPS, 18-2313, CARMELITA ROBBINS, 18-2310, JARAMILLO, 18-02412, LEROY JARAMILLO, 18- ROSEMARY ROCKWOOD, 18-2323, DENISE D. 02412, JEFFREY KILGORE, 18-02410, LETITIA TAYLOR, 18-2314, JULIE BRYANT, 18-02352, KEVIN KILGORE, 18-02410, CYNTHIA K. LAYMAN, 18-02409, BRYANT, 18-02352, KELLY COLE, 18-02350, TONIA BRENDA L. NIEVES, 18-02408, ROBERT NOVAK, 18- GAY COLE, 18-02350, HENRY GACCETTA, 18-02346, 02406, WILLIAM R. PHIPPS, 18-02405, NICOLE WANDA GACCETTA, 18-02346, ROGER KENNEDY, RANDLE, 18-02403, DENISE BROOKS, 18-02420, 18-02345, NANCY MACKIEWICZ, 18-02345, NOREEN M. DEPALMA, 18-02419, ROBERT BERNADINE [*386] ADKINS, 18-2366, CAROL DEPALMA, 18-02419, TERRY ENGLISH, 18-02416, IV MARROTT, 18-02411, MELANIE ATLEY, 18-02421, WOFFORD HUMPHRIES, 18-02415, DEBBIE AIMEE G. BACHELIER, 18-02417, CODY HARRIS, 18- WATSON, 18-02416, JOHN BLACKBURN, 18-02424, 02418, Plaintiffs: CARYN MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, ERICA CHRISTINA DANCY, 18-02422, DONALD LEAD ATTORNEY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO HUMPHREY, 17-11898 on behalf of ESTATE OF USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, LINDA HUMPHREY, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW TX. SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. For KAREN CARTER COLLINS, 18-1854, Plaintiff: RANSE MURPHY PARTIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, For ROBERT C. STEVENS, 18-2080, GWENDOLYN B COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, STEVENS, 18-02080, Plaintiffs: CHERISSE HEIDI CONLEY GRIGGS PARTIN LLP, ATLANTA, GA. ALCANTARA CLEOFE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KIESEL LAW For OSWALD PETERSON, 18-02041, Plaintiff: BRIAN LLP, BEVERLY HILLS, CA. A. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES For LORI J CREED, [*388] 18-02075, RAYMOND PC, BUFFALO, NY. NAVARRO, 18-02079, MARIA THERESA RUIZ-LAW, 18-02077, CATHY RYDEN, 18-02076, KARL RYDEN, For JOANNE SEMAN, 18-02037, LYLE WASSON, 18- 18-02076, JOANNE THWEATT, 18-02078, SUSAN 02046, ESSIE L. ANDERSON, 18-2047, MICHELLE HAYNES, 18-2367, WILLIAM HAYNES, 18-2367, ARMENI, 18-2052, SHEILA BARLOW, 18-2056, ROSE LALOGGIA, 18-2359, JAMES LALOGGIA, 18- Page 134 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *388

2359, CHRISTOPHER TENNYSON, 18-2361, SHERYL CAROLINE MATTHEW, 18-02243, VELMA JEAN TENNYSON, 18-2361, MARIA CARMEN BERUMEN, SHUPP, 18-02242, LATEASHA WILLIAMS, 18-2245, 18-02369, BRYAN DAVID WALSH, 18-02371, DORA BRENDA CARTER, 18-2360, LINDA JOHNSTON, 18- JEAN WALSH, 18-02371, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN 2364, GREGORY K JOHNSTON, 18-2364, ROSE ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN VASTERELLA, 18-2362, SYLVIA JONES, 18-02370, SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For MARTHA PASCHANG, 18-02091, SONYA MILLER, 18-02094, SARAH ANDERSON, 18-02165, LAURIE For JIM THOMAS, 18-02100, GEORGANNA O'NEILL, ANGUSTAIN, 18-02163, LARRY BAKER, 18-02164, 18-02344, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD SUSAN HAINES, 18-02162, KIMBERLY ROBERTS, 18- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 02166, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD BAR, BRANCH [*390] LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ NM. BAR, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. For JENNIE M. TRIMARCO, 18-02113, Plaintiff: MICHAEL STEVEN GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, For JENIFER TERRY, 18-02086, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL MORGAN & MORGAN PC, TAMPA, FL. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. For CAROLYN D. UPSHUR, 18-02119, NANCY E. HAINS, 18-02127, HELENA JEAN BROWN, 18-02145, For ANALYDE APONTE, 18-02107, TIFFANY DAWN BETTY J. NOULLET, 18-02150, TONIA SNIDER, 18- DAY, 18-02267, BRANDIE HUKIC, 18-02267, KRISTA 02149, JANICE E. DIXON, 18-02268, ELMAS F. JOHNSON, 18-02267, RONDA NIE, 18-02267, GROFF, 18-02271, MARIA G. HERNANDEZ, 18-02277 Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, (Nebraska), SALVADOR LICON, 18-02263, CYNTHIA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, L. MCLAURIN, 18-02266, HARRY MOLLERE, SR., 18- HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX. 02285, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For PHYLLIS [*389] BECRAFT, 18-02105, RICHARD BECRAFT, 18-02105, Plaintiffs: T. MATTHEW LECKMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For BERNICE LONGO, 18-02130, JOAN PALUMBO, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, POGUST BRASLOW & 18-02141, BERNADETTE SOTO, 18-02138, Plaintiffs: MILLROOD, CONSHOHOCKEN, PA. CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. For CHRISTINA ESPOSITO, 18-02124, DEBORAH KITTLE, 18-02126, SARAH FOX, 18-02134, JUDY HALEY, 18-02132, LAURA HUBBARD, 18-02131, For EVA COLEMAN, 18-02142, Plaintiff: STUART LEE JOSEPH KESSENICH, 18-02135, on behalf of CAROL GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT KESSENICH, BETTY MARTINEZ, 18-02137, LISA ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GOLDENBERG LAW MASCITELLI, 18-02151, JANYCE FRANSEN, 18- PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. 02178, JOSEPH HAZZARD, 18-02179, DONNA PAULETTE, 18-02180, Plaintiffs: WILLIAM WYLIE For ANGELA A. ADKINS, 18-02159, Plaintiff: John BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED Eugene Herrick, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & Mt. Pleasant, SC. pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For MARION BOND, 18-02160, MARY TERESA For MILDRED RANKIN, 18-02125, MARIA ROSATO, GOLOSEWSKI, 18-02152, Plaintiffs: John Eugene 18-02120, PATRICIA LOUDON, 18-02128, CHESTER Herrick, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice [*391] LLC, FERGUSON, 18-02175, WILLIAM MARTIN, 18-02173, Mt. Pleasant, SC. Page 135 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *391

MATTHEW JOSEPH HAINDFIELD, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, For SHARON CROWE, 18-02157, Plaintiff: MICHAEL BRADSHAW FOWLER PROCTOR & FAIRGRAVVE K. JOHNSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PC, DES MOUNES, IA. ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER, PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. For GAIL J AZDAR, 18-02279, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For NILDA MENDEZ, 18-02161, Plaintiff: Thomas David ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES Hoyle, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice, LLC, Mount PC, BUFFALO, NY; MICHAEL JAMES WILLIAMS, Pleasant, SC. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES, BUFFALO, NY. For BARBARA A LAND, 18-02184, Plaintiff: Donald Alan Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, For ROBIN WYNN, 18-02282, Plaintiff: MICHELLE A. Providence, RI. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, For MELVIN FEKIN, 18-02202, Plaintiff: MICHAEL WASHINGTON, DC. JAMES WILLIAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES, For BART MOORE, 18-01458, also known as ESTATE BUFFALO, NY. OF MARSHA CLARY ROYSTER, BRAD MOORE, 18- 01458, also known as ESTATE OF MARSHA CLARY For BARBARA E SMITH, 18-02181 (New York), ROYSTER, Plaintiffs: JENNIFER A. MOORE, LEAD Plaintiff: DANIEL R. LAPINSKI, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MOTLEY RICE LLC, CHERRY HILL, NJ. BAR, MOORE LAW GROUP PLLC, LOUISVILLE, KY.

For CAMILLE ZANNI, 18-02233, Plaintiff: CASEY RYAN For MARY MCCUTCHEON BANKS, 18-2296, COBURN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT CYNTHIA T. CUNNINGHAM, 18-2297, ROSE [*393] ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PHILADELPHIA, PA; ANN GADSON, 18-2298, ANNA MARIA JEFFERSON, EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 18-2299, BRIAN LEE JEFFERSON, 18-2299, SHEILA NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NASS G. KELLER, 18-2300, JACK L. PRESCOTT, 18-2301, CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. Plaintiffs: KRISTIE MARIE HIGHTOWER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LUNDY LUNDY SOILEAU & SOUTH LLP, LAKE For BRENDA BATES, 18-2255, BONNIE DAVIS, 18- CHARLES, LA. 2256, EDITH SMITH-JOHNSON, 18-2254, on behalf of ESTATE OF BELINDA WALKER, TIMOTHY STICK, 18- 2251, on behalf of ESTATE OF KATHLEEN STICK, For CECELIA BROWN EYES, 18-2309, Plaintiff: CARRIE VICARI, 18-2247, GAIL WASHINGTON, 18- DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY, 2253, ELLEN WHITFIELD, 18-2252, SONDRA PIERCE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, NEW 18-02259, Plaintiffs: ROLF T. FIEBIGER, [*392] LEAD ORLEANS, LA; MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. PAUL, MN. BAR, NEW ORLEANS, LA.

For ANNA KANELLOPOULOS, 18-02264, For FAYE EMERT, 18-2305, PATRICIA MOSS, 18- ELEFTHERIOUS KANELLOPOULOS, 18-02264, 2306, MELISSA WILBURN, 18-2308, Plaintiffs: Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAR, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. FRANCISCO, CA. LOUIS, MO.

For DONNA M LUBAHN, 18-02265, Plaintiff: For ELIJAH HOLMES, 18-02426, Plaintiff: DAVID I. Page 136 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *393

CATES, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CATES MAHONEY LLC, SWANSEA, IL. For BRENDA DIXON, 18-2373 (Georgia), JOSEPH D GILL, 18-2428, CASSANDRA GOLDSCHMIDT, 18- For CASSIE ALLEN, 18-2389, JOYCE EVERHART, 18- 2383, CHAD GOLDSCHMIDT, 18-2383, LINDSEY 2391, Plaintiffs: CATHERINE THEODORA HEACOX, BLAKE LEAN, 18-2431, TERESSA MILLER, 18-2384, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE LANIER LAW FIRM, NEW CYNTHIA PROKOP, 18-2385, CINDY ROBBINS, 18- YORK, NY. 2386, MARK ROBBINS, 18-2386, ANNETTE SZAFRANSKI, 18-2387, JACKIE LEE STEWART, 18- 2433, Plaintiffs: DAVID I. CATES, LEAD ATTORNEY, For KAREN ASCHOFF, 18-2379, DEBRA CURRY, 18- CATES MAHONEY LLC, SWANSEA, IL. 2377, DEBORAH JOHNSON, 18-2378 (Ohio), RON HEITMAN, 18-2491, CINDY SINGLETON, 18-2489, MICHELLE DAILEY, 18-02550, CLAUDETTE For BRAD R. JOHNSON, 18-2397, MARY ANN OSBORNE, 18-02545, JUANITA LUCIUS, 18- ZACCARIA JOHNSON, 18-2397, ROBERT STACY, 18- 2554, [*394] TOM VELMONT, 18-02538, HADI 2402, SHERRIE STACY, 18-2402, TARAN STARR, 18- ALAVAIN, 18-2655, RUNELL GRAFF, 18-2656, MARY 2400, HERMAN YARBER, III, 18-2398, SARA MAHN, DIANE JOHNSON, 18-2643, LISA MONTOYA, 18- 18-02782, SANDRA PERRY, 18-02785, CHRISTIE 2644, BRANDY RADFORD, 18-2657, KRISTI ROSENCRANCE, 18-02781, Plaintiffs: TAYJES UNDERWOOD, 18-2659, LORNA YOUNG, 18-2658, MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER KIM PEELER, 18-02702, Plaintiffs: WILLIAM WYLIE FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For SHACARA NICHOLS, 18-2375, on behalf of ESTATE OF ADELE EUNICE NICHOLS, DECEASED, For SHANNON BECK, 18-2394, TERESA GRIZZLE, Plaintiff: ERIC D. PEARSON, HEYGOOD ORR & 18-2395, SHARON NEUMANN, 18-2396, LYNN PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, IRVING, TX. ZAMBERLAN, 18-02526, PAMELA V. ZAWISTOWSKI, 18-02530, Plaintiffs: CARYN MICHELE For CARMEN COOK-ELLISON, 18-2474, NICKOLE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON LAW MUNSON, 18-2481, DENNIS OCKERT, 18-2499, GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. Plaintiffs: LAUREN [*396] KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN For PAULA BELL, 18-2427, KATHY BLASKO, 18-2429, PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. MARIE CARROLL, 18-2435, KATHRYN A. CONNER, 18-2436, DONNA L. CULLEN, 18-2440, GREGORY For BETHANY KENNEDY, 18-2480, CAROL ORTEGA, DARLING, 18-2449, LUANN FRAZIER, 18-02451, 18-2485, ELAINE ALMOND, 18-02504, DEANNA ANNA GALATI, 18-02454, JANET GERETY, 18-02459, ERWIN, 18-02502, RHONDA FLEMISTER, 18-02510, CHARLOTTE MADDEN, 18-02472, HERBERT DIXON NORMA GRAYS, 18-02509, JOANNE CHARGING MCCUMBEE, JR., 18-02473, CAROL GERMOND, 18- HAWK, 18-02505, DEBORAH HORTON, 18-02503, 02461, DONNA GOBBEL, 18-02462, SHANNON MARION MORRISON, 18-02507, , HANLEY, 18-02463, E. CADER HOWARD, 18-02467, 18-02537, CECILIA PEREZ-MATOS, 18-02536, JULIA HUNT, 18-02468, MICHELLE E. KIRSCHT, 18- DONALD PETERSON, 18-2743 (Pennsylvania), on 02470, NANCY PARK, 18-02734, SHARON RAMBO, behalf of ESTATE OF DELLA PETERSON, LILLIE 18-02736, KAY REAMES, 18-02737, JANA RODGERS, ROBINSON BROWN, 18-2745, Plaintiffs: WARREN T 18-2741, SHIRLEY RODGERS, 18-2740, JESSIE BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS ROGERS, 18-2744, JULIE ROGERS, 18-2747, CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. CANARY RUFFIN, 18-2760, KAREN WALES, 18- 02778, JANET [*395] WENTURINE, 18-02783, SHARON COLEMAN, 18-02826, LINDA DANDO, 18- For FRANKLIN KIRK, 18-02456 (Ohio), on behalf of 02820, MARY ANN DE TROLIO, 18-02829, MERRY ESTATE OF MARTHA LYNN KIRK, Plaintiff: PATRICK DEVLIN, 18-02822, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW GEREL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. Page 137 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *396

For DEBORAH CHARLES, 18-2492, Plaintiff: ADRIANA For LINDA M BARRY, 18-02586, DAVID BORCHARDT, SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, SKIKOS 18-02588, NANCY J BORCHARDT, 18-02588, CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, BRITTANY C CASTILLO, 18-02591, LYNN FOX, 18- CA. 02593, GRACE V GANDARILLA, 18-02595, [*398] JOSE A GANDARILLA, 18-02595, DONNA J SNYDER, 18-02598, Plaintiffs: JOHN C. THORNTON, LEAD For LEWIS GLORIA, 18-2496, SHERRIE GLORIA, 18- ATTORNEY, ANDREWS THORNTON HIGGINS 2496, TERESA REDD, 18-2494, on behalf of J.H. 1, RAZMARA LLP, IRVINE, CA. J.H. 2, J.H. 3 and J.H. 4, MINOR CHILDREN OF ALISHA REDD, Plaintiffs: DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE DUGAN LAW For HELEN ROBINSON, 18-02581, JANET FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; MEKEL SMITH ALVAREZ, HABERSHAM, 18-02611, DONNA HOLLIS, 18-02613, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONE CANAL PLACE, NEW CATHERINE VANARIA, 18-02604, ARDITH ORLEANS, LA. CAMPBELL, 18-02697, DANA ERNST, 18-02698, PATRICIA GARLAND, 18-02699, ANGELA HUNTER, 18-02700, RAQUEL NDZEIDZE, 18-02703, NANCY For TATINA PEMBERTON, [*397] 18-2493, FULK, 18-2716, Plaintiffs: TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD LAWRENCE MOORE, 18-2570, Plaintiffs: MARK P ATTORNEY, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. For DANA CROSS, 18-2612, SHUVON REID, 18-2612, Plaintiffs: CRAIG M. SILVERMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, For ANN CANTRELL, 18-02547, STANLEY Sullivan Papain Block McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo, GOLDFARB, 18-02731, MIKE MARTIN, 18-02738, PC, Sullivan Papain Block McGrath & Cannavo, PC, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD New York, NY. ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY.

For LINDA S FLASHMAN, 18-2607, ELIZABETH M For JENNIFER MEDLEY, 18-02543, TAMMY SCHNECK, 18-2609, Plaintiffs: JOHN EUGENE THOMPSON, 18-02542, TARA WARREN, 18-02541, HERRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, Mt. Plaintiffs: STACY KATHRYN HAUER LEAD Pleasant, SC. ATTORNEY, JOHNSON BECKER, ST. PAUL, MN.

For ROBIN ANNETTE FULLER, 18-2606, ANN M For SARAH TERESA CANADA, 18-2562, VALERIE MOODY, 18-2605, SUE SOMMER-KRESSE, 18-2603, WARDELL STILL, 18-2563, CHARLENE MITCHELL Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD TERRY, 18-2564, Plaintiffs: KRISTIE MARIE ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. HIGHTOWER, LEAD ATTORNEY, LUNDY LUNDY SOILEAU & SOUTH LLP, LAKE CHARLES, LA. For GABRIELA W ROSPOND, 18-2600, Plaintiff: JOHN DAVID HURST, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, For BRIAN GUTIERREZ, 18-2560, BRYANA Morgantown, WV. GUTIERREZ, 18-2560, HON. CARLOS GUTIERREZ, 18-2560, EVELYN GUTIERREZ, 18-2560, STEPHANIE GUTIERREZ, 18-2560, JOSEPH JOHN KELEHER, 18- For GILBERT LOCKHART, 18-02616, LOURDES 2561, JORDAN LANE MILLER, 18-2561, Plaintiffs: ALVARADO, 18-2642, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD SIROTKIN, [*399] LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. FRANCISCO, CA. For PATSY LUCILLE RIDGES, 18-02619, Plaintiff: For LUCY E STEWART, 18-2569, Plaintiff: CAROLINE HENRY G. GARRARD, III, LEAD ATTORNEY, THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, MURRAY LAW BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. ATHENS, GA. Page 138 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *399

N. DAVID, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEW YORK, NY. For DEIDRE M KERN, 18-2635, SCOTT KERN, 18- 2635, ELISE DIVJAK, 18-2706, JOHN DIVJAK, 18- For ROBERT KNAPEREK, 18-02817, BETH , 2706, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD 18-02817, MEAGAN ALDER, 18-2806, BRENDA ATTORNEY, PARKER WAICHMAN LLP, PORT BORZONE, 18-2804, ROBIN PETERS, 18-2804, WASHINGTON, NY. ADRIENNE RAE, 18-2806, LEAH KAY SCHARP, 18- 2806, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, For CATHY JEAN AMENTA, 18-02662, CODY P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. BARNEBURG, 18-2713, Plaintiffs: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, NM. For DENISE ARCHULETA, 18-2789, MARILYN CALDWELL, 18-2790, MARA CASTELLO, 18-2795, MARSHA SHEPHERD, 18-2761, DOROTHY B. For KATHLEEN LAMBERTI, 18-02664, BRENDA SHILLMAN, 18-2763, LARI SILVA, 18-2764, CAROLYN OWENS, 18-02665, CINDY THORNE, 18-02663, STEHLER, 18-2765, ANGELA TOLBERT, 18-2770, ROCHELLE GOBLE, 18-2693, BETTY HIGHTOWER, KIMBERLY JILL TROMAN, 18-2771, SHERI VANCE, 18-2695 (Maine), CHEVELLE LAWLER, 18-2728, 18-2776, JILL WEILAND, 18-2787, CAROL CLINE, 18- Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, 2799, DEANNA FORD, 18-2830, JOHN FRANZ, 18- GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, 2831, SHIRLEY LYNN GEORGE, 18-2833, IL. VIRGINIA [*401] GILMORE, 18-2835, ROSA GOMEZ, 18-2837, MS. HELEN GREEN, 18-2842, TINA MARIE For LILLIE KAYE MCDONALD, 18-2679, Plaintiff: HAMMITT, 18-2846, SANDRA HESS, 18-2849, MARY DANIEL J. THORNBURGH, LEAD ATTORNEY, HELEN JENKINS, 18-02861, CACHET JOHNSON, 18- PENSACOLA, FL. 02850, JERENA JOHNSON, 18-02855, RENEE JOHNSON, 18-02857, CHRISTINE KESHIAN, 18- 02863, JANET KILGORE, 18-02866, BARBARA For BARBARA A SIMON, 18-2727, Plaintiff: Donald A. LAFONTANO, 18-02870, GLORIA E. LEACH, 18- Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, 02871, PATRYCE LESTER, 18-02875, ALBIZIA Providence, RI. MAPLES, 18-2876, MARYLOU MARQUEZ, 18-2877, SHELLY MCKEE, 18-2878, KATHLEEN RAMIE, 18- For JASON KERWIN, 18-02739, ARLYN ROCCO, 18- 2882, PATRICIA SHAW, 18-2882, GLORIA THOMAS, 02735, ROBERT ROCCO, 18-02735, Plaintiffs: BRIAN 18-2885, TOMMY URREA, 18-2884, MARLIN A. J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller GREINER, 18-2981, MINDY SLOANE, 18-2982, Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. ARLENE SUGERMAN, 18-2985, RENONDA TAYLOR, 18-2983, HERBERT L. WRIGHT, 18-3017, MARGARET CROSBY, 18-3071, LESLEY M. LANGFORD-KEEHN, For PENNY M. DEARY, 18-02814, CHRISTOPHER 18-3073, BRENDA OREBAUGH, 18-3145, BELINDA GEPHARDT, 18-02811, CORY GEPHARDT, [*400] 18- POE, 18-3146, BONNY ROCK, 18-3147, REBECCA 02811, DAVID GEPHARDT, 18-02811, CAROL A. SHANK, 18-3149, JOAN BRODE, 18-03138, KRISTINA HATTON, 18-02812, HOWARD WAYNE HATTON, 18- MARIE KNUTSON, 18-03140, ARTHUR MCCLENDON, 02812, CARA M. KEENAN, 18-02811, SANDRA L. 18-03141, KAREN MCNEESE, 18-03143, JANA MARTINEZ, 18-02812, SARAH A. STITT, 18-02812, ROGERS, 18-2741, PATRICIA BURKHALTER, 18- JESHIVA DICATALDO, 18-02817, SARAH JO 03252, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, FORLANO, 18-02817, PHYLLIS JONES, 18-02817, on LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW behalf of LAURA KNAPEREK, ANTHONY KNAPEREK, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. 18-02817, CHRISTOPHER KNAPEREK, 18-02817, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, For ANITA MARCOLINE, 18-2797, HEATHER P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. VILLYARD, 18-2887, JANICE MOSS, 18-03139, Plaintiffs: PATRICK KELLY LYONS, [*402] LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, For LILLIAN MARTINEZ, 18-02824, Plaintiff: MICHAEL WASHINGTON, DC. Page 139 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *402

MADISON, 18-2937, KIMBERLY MANAOIS, 18-2938, SHIRLEY MINKLER, 18-2934, ANTONIO MOORE, 18- For MICHELLE SMALL, 18-2775, TONDELIA M. 2939, JANET MYRICKS, 18-2940, PAMELA PHELPS, SMITH, 18-2773, JIM B. ASHBY, 18-02960, LEE ANN 18-2935, MARY LOU RENNINGER, 18-2941, ASHBY, 18-02960, LORA K. HUTCHENS, 18-02959, MARGARET TROUTT, 18-2942, PATRICIA WALKER, SANDRA SKIERKOWSKI, 18-02972: TAYJES 18-2933, VIRGINIA PASS, 18-03094, GAYLE TOLLE, MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER 18-03095, BETH CORBALLY, 18-3125, SHERYL FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. DUNN, 18-3128, JAYME GREEN, 18-3126, LISA LEWIS, 18-3127, JANE O'CONNOR-FITZGERALD, 18- For KIM R HOLLAND, 18-2808, Plaintiff: MATTHEW 3129, MARILYN SCALA, 18-3123, FRANK RYAN MCCARLEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, FEARS SIGNORINO, 18-3132, ERIN GOSMAN, 18-3178, NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX. CLAUDE COLE, JR, 18-3237, DIANA FLOYD, 18-3238, Plaintiffs: WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. For STEVE HURST, 18-2802, SUE HURST, 18-2802, LOUIS, MO. Plaintiffs: RICHARD WILLIAM SCHULTE, LEAD ATTORNEY, Wright & Schulte, LLC, Vandalia, OH. For CASEY MARSH, 18-2911, Plaintiff: MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEWPORT For JANICE STODGHILL, 18-2844, ERIC KEEL, 18- BEACH, CA. 02963, Plaintiffs: DAVID PATRICK DANIEL, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, DANIEL & ASSOCIATES LLC, HOUSTON, TX. For SARAH LAMBERT, 18-02967, KAREN KURETZKAMP, 18-3167, CAROL KERIK, 18- 3231, [*404] Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, For DONNA LEA STEVENS, 18-2947, Plaintiff: LEAD ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. THOMAS ROE FRAZER, II, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, FRAZER PLC, Nashville, TN. For VALERIE MCKEEVER, 18-02973, Plaintiff: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, For ARISHA EDWARDS, 18-02868, ANGELICA BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES JONES, 18-02913, DEBORAH LAMB, 18-02926, PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, DONALD E. LAMB, 18-02926, JAZMINE LOISELLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, 18-02920, JEFFRIE PETTIS, 18-02968, MARJORIE VA. PETTIS, 18-02968, SHARON WEEKS, 18-2980, STEPHEN E. WEEKS, 18-2980, KARL SIECKMAN, 18- 03003, AMY WHITE, 18-02991, JANE ADAMS, 18- For CINDY G. SAXON, 18-02969, KATHLEEN C. 1060, EXCELL HOLMAN, 17-11438, on behalf of EVANS, 18-3201, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL STEVEN JOYCE HOLMAN, DECEASED, Plaintiffs: M. GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORGAN & MORGAN BRANDON SMITH, LEAD [*403] ATTORNEY, PC, TAMPA, FL. CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH LLC, ATLANTA, GA. For SULMA RIYADH, 18-2989, Plaintiff: JENNIFER LYNN ORENDI, LEAD ATTORNEY, WASHINGTON, For SUSAN B KAUFMAN, 18-02864, Plaintiff: CARMEN DC; STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For ALLISHA CARTER, 18-02990, RANDALL For CHERYL BATEMAN, 18-2907, DARLA BROSIUS, DELORDO, 18-02994, REBECCA ROSE, 18-02993, 18-2910, LOIS CLESTER, 18-02914, DONNA Plaintiffs: STEVEN D. DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, CONKLIN, 18-02916, CHERYL COWLES, 18-02918, TORHOERMAN LAW LLC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. JEAN DIETZ, 18-02919, THERESA EDE, 18-02927, SUSAN GRAY, 18-02928, MELANIE IBARRA, 18- For NAOMI J GOODEN, 18-03001, SUZANNE M 02929, NELLIE KATHAIN, 18-02930, CAROL THOMAS, 18-3018, Plaintiff: CAROLINE THOMAS Page 140 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *404

WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, MURRAY LAW FIRM, 18-03193, MARY ANN JARAM, 18-03190, NANCY NEW ORLEANS, LA. VALUEFF, 18-03191, ANDREA KLIMKE, 18-3218, KIM PHILLIPS, 18-3185, PAMELA WELLS, 18-3215, TRACY [*406] WOOD, 18-3213, STEVEN For KARL SIECKMAN, 18-03003, KARL SIECKMAN, KITTENPLAN, 18-3222, Plaintiff: DAVID T. MATHEWS, 18-03003, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL BRADY LYNCH, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, ATTORNEY, THE MICHAEL BRADY LYNCH FIRM, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. WINTER PARK, FL.

For FRANCIS A COYE, 18-3162, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. For SAMANTHA CREWS, 18-3031, VIVIAN GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, CELLINO & BARNES HOMATOPOULOS, 18-3023, RENE KENNEY- PC, BUFFALO, NY. CHAPMAN, 18-3029, NANCY OVERDAHL, 18-3034, Plaintiffs: EDWARD A. WALLACE, LEAD [*405] ATTORNEY, WEXLER WALLACE LLP, CHICAGO, IL. For VONDA INNIS, 18-3173, Plaintiff: LINDSEY A. CHEEK, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE CHEEK LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For DANIEL NAPIERALA, 18-3021, REBECCA NAPIERALA, 18-3021, LILI WINSLOW, 18-3024, STEPHEN WINSLOW, 18-3024, Plaintiffs: ADRIANA For NANCY J. WARF, 18-3166, Plaintiff: MARILYN T. SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, SKIKOS MCGOLDRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, THORNTON & CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, NAUMES, BOSTON, MA. CA. For PATRICIA YGLESIA, 18-3206, Plaintiff: WARREN T For SANDRA STEWART, 18-3056, CATHY DUBOIS, BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS 18-3081, KATHRYN LAMI, 18-3072, Plaintiffs: CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. CHRISTOPHER L. SCHNIEDERS, LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. For MAURICE THOMPSON, 18-3236, Plaintiff: BARRY R. EICHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, Eichen Crutchlow For PAMELA DEVINE, 18-3067, Plaintiff: TOMISLAV Zaslow & McElroy, LLP, EDISON, NJ. GEORGE ANTUNOVICH, LEAD ATTORNEY, BISNAR | CHASE, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. For JILL ANN BAILEY, 18-03283, Plaintiff: BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE SIMON LAW For CAROLE ELGART, 18-3079, Plaintiff: DAE YEOL FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD LLP, NEW YORK, NY. For LYNNETTE ARMISTEAD, 18-1830, Plaintiff: PATRICIA LEIGH O'DELL, LEAD ATTORNEY, For HONG NGUYEN ZIMMERMAN, 18-3076, Plaintiff: MONTGOMERY, AL. MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN For CAROLYN CHILES-PATT, 18-03256, DOROTHY FRANCISCO, CA. DERAKHSHANI, 18-03258, CINDY FAVORITE, 18- 03260, EVELYN GLASSON, 18-03261, For HOLLY For ALMA BROWDER, 18-03102, KELLY IRVING, 18-03262, KATHERINE AULTMAN, 18-03316, CARPENTER, 18-03106, JUDY KIRKENDALL, 18- KAREN ANN LUDWICK, 18-03317, LINDA MACK, 18- 03101, VIRGINIA PASS, 18-03094, RUTHANN 03318, LISA STARR, 18-03310, LOUISE B. VON SOGUILON, 18-03103, ORALIA MARTINEZ, 18-3108, BROCKDORFF, 18-03312, ADELHEID [*407] Plaintiffs: HAYTHAM FARAJ, LEAD ATTORNEY, WATKINS, 18-03313, LINDA YOUNG, 18-03314, MARTINIAN & ASSOCIATES, INC., LOS ANGELES, PATRICIA BENJAMIN, 18-3274, SARA CAYLOR, 18- CA. 3334, MARY GOLDSMITH, 18-3305, JOYCE JOHNSON, 18-3306, MARIA KNEBEL, 18-3266, ANNIE LAYELL FUNDERBURK, 18-3269, CYNTHIA LEWIS, For LARRY COGAR, 18-03189, PAULA DUNAWAY, Page 141 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *407

18-3307, JANE LIVINGSTON, 18-3308, SANDRA K 18-03509, AVA RILEY, 18-03512, MAURICE MCCREIGHT, 18-3270, WANDA W. MICHALES, 18- DISHMON, JR., 18-03561, OTILIA HERNANDEZ, 18- 3321, DENISE MOFFETT, 18-3324, LORETTA J. 03555, DONNA LEWIS, 18-03558, JEAN POWERS, 18- NEILL, 18-3325, MARGIE A NIESEN, 18-3271, NITA 03601, JESSICA REYES, 18-03604, JAMIE ROSE, 18- OLLER, 18-3272, CHIQUITA RANDLE, 18-3326, 03605, LINDA SAIA, 18-03602, TANESHA SPEARS, EARLINE B. RICHARD, 18-3328, VIOLA RITENOUR, 18-03603, LAURA TARABINI, 18-03606, CLARA 18-3330, DIANE RODDY, 18-3336, KATHLEEN LOUISE WISE, 18-03607, NEYDA ELIZONDO, 18- SHILLING, 18-3273, WINDY SNELL, 18-3309, 3584, Plaintiffs: WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD YOLANDA WILLIAMS, 18-3332, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY [*409] & A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. For ROGER KING, 18-3342, Plaintiff: SHANNON For CHERYL DEMPSEY, 18-03247, RUSSELL MARIE MCNULTY, LEAD ATTORNEY, CLIFFORD DEMPSEY, 18-03247, TANYA KELLY HUDSON, 18- LAW OFFICES PC, CHICAGO, IL. 03249, KAMMIE PARDO, 18-3458, ELIZABETH PEREZ-VALDEZ, 18-3457, JUAN VALDEZ, 18-3457, For VICKI LIRA, 18-3356, MARGARET MCCLURE, 18- Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, 3425, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY.

For LINDA D. JONES, 18-03254, DONNA MCKEAN, For GERALD F. WILSON, II, 18-3348, TERESA F. 18-03257, SONIA MERINO, 18-3276, REBECCA S. WILSON, 18-3348 (OH), MARILYN F. WOMACK, 18- NAGEL, 18-3278, BARBARA J. SCOTT, 18-3281, 3346, Plaintiffs: CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD JUDY DOUGLASS, 18-03369, PATRICIA KOFFLIN, 18- ATTORNEY, NEW ORLEANS, LA. 03368, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, For TIMOTHY EDWARDS, 18-3385, Plaintiff: Frank V MONTGOMERY, [*408] AL. Cesarone, Peter John Flowers, LEAD ATTORNEY, MEYERS & FLOWERS LLC, St. Charles, IL. For BENJAMIN BATTLE, 18-3302, Plaintiff: MICHAEL STEVEN GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For MARGEAUX LOPEZ, 18-3386, Plaintiff: John ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MORGAN & MORGAN Eugene Herrick, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, PC, TAMPA, FL. Mt. Pleasant, SC.

For RANDALL BORN, 18-3011, Plaintiff: RANDI For KAREN E GRAH, 18-03380, CHRISTY L TYLER, ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 18-03365, GLADYS W MAYSON, 18-03476, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, SANDERS PlaintiffPlaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD VIENER GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN CITY, NY. ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA.

For JUDITH CARDINALE, 18-3286, PAMELA For JULIE LAMORE, 18-3409, RONALD LEINEN, 18- TRAMONTANO, 18-3288, APRIL WILLIAMS, 18-3280, 3433, CORA ROBINSON, 18-3408, JOSEPH R SANDY WILLIAMS, 18-3344, ELIZABETH SPANO, 18-3396, MONICA CAMBRON, 18-03446, ALYINOVICH, 18-03381, MELANIE BLOIS, 18-03384, DAWN DISPENSA, 18-03439, DARLENE HOLLAND, CHRISTINA ELKINS, 18-03378, RENEE GEIBIG, 18- 18-03444, LISA O'NEAL, 18-03445, ANTONIO VIRATA, 03383, EROLETTA PIASCZYK, 18-3391, MARITZA 18-03447, MARICA DORSEY, 18-03450, AMANDA RODRIGUEZ, 18-3400, CHRISTEN SCHUDE, 18-3393, JOYCE, 18-03448, CHARLETTE HEIN, 18- NORMA SINE, 18-3389, JEWELL VAN HORN, 18- 3479,Plaintiffs: KRISTOFER S RIDDLE, 3403, JANICE BLISH, 18-03469, VALARIE ELLIS, 18- SHANNON [*410] MARIE MCNULTY, LEAD 03472, TERESA HOPKINSON, 18-03466, CHRISTIE ATTORNEY, CLIFFORD LAW OFFICES PC, CONRAD, 18-3465, CONNIE PHILLIPS, 18-3484, CHICAGO, IL. TERESA SENSIBAUGH, 18-3483, RENEE MCGRAIL, Page 142 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *410

For SHERRY LESTER, 18-3419, DENISKA STROZIER, PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; ROGER C. DENTON, LEAD 18-3418, Plaintiffs: MATTHEW RYAN MCCARLEY, ATTORNEY, SCHLICHTER AND BOGARD, LLP, ST. LEAD ATTORNEY, FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM LOUIS, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD PLLC, DALLAS, TX. ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; Ted G Meadows, LEAD ATTORNEY, Beasley, Allen et al., Montgomery, AL; For DALE SCHLEEF, 18-3423, Plaintiff: Frank Vincent WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER Cesarone, LEAD ATTORNEY, Meyers & Flowers, Llc, SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, St. Charles, IL; PETER J. FLOWERS, LEAD MO. ATTORNEY, MEYERS & FLOWERS LLC, ST . CHARLES, IL. For KAREN DEMELLO, 17-726, KATIE PARKER, 17- 726, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD For JUANITA TUCKER, 18-5020, Plaintiff: DAVID T. ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; PLLC, NEW YORK, NY; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & For MARLA WRIGHT, 18-3432, Plaintiff: MATTHEW J. pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. SILL, LEAD ATTORNEY, SILL LAW GROUP, Oklahoma City, OK. For ERIN FRANK, 17-726, FRANCES [*412] HALLIDAY-CORNELL, 17-726, CHERYL HEFFNER, For NICOLE DOZIER, 18-03468, Plaintiff: BARRY R. 17-726, LORI NAPOLITANO, 17-726, Plaintiffs: EICHEN, LEAD ATTORNEY, Eichen Crutchlow Zaslow BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, & McElroy, LLP, EDISON, NJ. BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; ROGER C. DENTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, SCHLICHTER AND BOGARD, LLP, ST. For LOU JEAN GREGORY, 17-790, Plaintiff: LOUIS, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, PC, MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; MICHAEL JOSEPH QUILLIN, STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, ST. For HAZEL AUDREY BETHEA, 18-03541, Plaintiff: LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD DANIEL J. THORNBURGH, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY, [*411] ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PENSACOLA, FL. pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For JACKIE CLERENCE BOND, 18-03549, JOHN For WILLA PACE, 18-3451, Plaintiff: MICHAEL JAMES CHRISTOPHER BOND, 18-03549, ELIZABETH WILLIAMS, LEAD ATTORNEY, CELLINO & BARNES, WARNER, 18-03549, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, BUFFALO, NY. LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, IRVING, TX.

For MARJORIE BABB, 17-726, SHERYL BUTLER, 17- 726, HEIDI HUSMAN, 17-726, JOYCELYN HUYLER, For JOYCE FREDERICK, 18-03553, Plaintiff: WARREN 17-726, FRANCES LOOKINGBILL, 17-726, SHARON T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, MARTENS, 17-726, JENNIFER MATHENY, 17-726, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. LAURALEE MCTAMNEY, 17-726, HEATHER MILLER, 17-726, MARIA MONZON, 17-726, Plaintiffs: For DARRELL LEWIS, 17-6354, Plaintiff: BENJAMIN R. BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE SIMON LAW FIRM, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES Page 143 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *412

P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For LINDA FORSTING, TOMICA HOOD, LATRECIA MARSHALL-PARRIS, CHERYL MATTHEW, For JYRONNE GOULD, TYRONNE GOULD, CECILIA CHRISTINA RENFER, DEBRA ROSENBAUER, MULLER, Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD KAREN ZIER, TRICIA ADAMS, PAULA RODGERS, ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. ERIKA COULL, JANIS GOODALL, KATHLEEN LARSON, NANCY IRENE MANNING, PAMELA For SHEREE MCKINLEY, MARIA PEREZ, VIDALINA MATTHEWS, DOROTHY CARLOTTA, RIVERA, BRIDGET SILBY, Plaintiffs: RANDI ALYSON CYNTHIA [*413] MARTIN, DANIEL MCDONOUGH, KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, SANDERS VIENER DEBBIE TERRELL, LISA VALENTE, CYNTHIA VELA, GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN CITY, NY. JESSICA WOODY, LISHA ZUNIGA, SAMANTHA HORTON, KATHERINE MARTINEZ, ELIZABETH NEELEY, DENISE NIELSEN, DAVID O'BRIEN, JANICE For ROSA ESCOBEDO, VICTORIA MARGARITA ADAMS, JENNIFER DAVIS, DEBORAH EKUWSUMI, EHART, KELLY HUNTER, Plaintiffs: DAVID PATRICK LANOME LANG, CONNIE MCFALL, Plaintiffs: WILLIAM DANIEL, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, DANIEL & WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON ASSOCIATES LLC, HOUSTON, TX. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For MARY C TAYLOR, BILLIE SHEPPARD, Plaintiffs: For MILAGROS B. BRACERO, Plaintiff: MICHAEL JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, STEVEN GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORGAN & COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, IN. MORGAN PC, TAMPA, FL.

For MILDRED L BALOGH, REGINA L VICE, KEVIN For DEBORAH DEWALSCHE, CHRISTOPHER D BUCK, MESHELL APPLEGATE, DANNY MEDLIN, JR, MORGAN, JAY S KOO, DOROTHY R. FAY, Plaintiffs: REBECCA K. SNOWDEN, PHYLLIS M. JONES, CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, PAMALA ONUCHUKWU, MICHAEL MASON, Plaintiffs: MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. CHRISTOPHER L. SCHNIEDERS, LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. For KERRY GHORMLEY, Plaintiff: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY For ROBERT T. GRIFFITH, SR., Plaintiff: NICHOLAS ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, RYAN ROCKFORTE, LEAD ATTORNEY, PENDLEY MONTGOMERY, AL; JAMES G. ONDER, STEPHANIE BAUDIN & COFFIN LLP, PLAQUEMINE, LA. LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEYS, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For RICHARD HARPER, Plaintiff: WARREN [*415] T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS For MARY L BENNING, SUSAN E. BROWN, LINDA C CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. MCCLURE, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, BLIZZARD & NABERS LLP, HOUSTON, For ROBIN ZIGMAN, Plaintiff: BRIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, TX. LEAD ATTORNEY, CELLINO & BARNES PC, BUFFALO, NY. For ALICE BROWN, EVELYN COHEN, VALERIE COLLINS, DONNA DELPIER, ANNIE JOHNSON, For GREGORY JOSEY, GREGORY VARNER, JOYCE CANDICE JONES, LISA ROEMISCH, FAYE SELIG, HUDGINS, CHRISTINE GRAHAM, DANIELLE HOEME, CARMELIA TAYLOR, DEFLOY DICK, TONI DINGESS, LAWRENCE HOEME, DAVID HUDSON, Plaintiffs: SUSAN ELLINGTON, THERESA A EVANS, DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI PRISCILLA [*414] FAY, DEBORAH FYHRIE, LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. GERALDINE GREEN, LOIS GRONE, RUBY GINNY GUPTON-BEARD, JACQUELYN HARRIS, KIMBERLY HARRIS, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, For CINDY STAUFFER, BEVERLY TOWLER, Plaintiffs: Page 144 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *415

ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN For JOSEPH R. MERCURIO, LISA J. GOYER, FRANCISCO, CA. Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, For JANET ADAMS, AMELIA CULPEPPER, SHARON P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. DEE DUNCAN, KAMALJIT GREWAL, MATTIE P. GRIFFIN, BARBARA HARDISON, DANISHIA For LARRY CANN, Plaintiff: ADAM TAL FUNK, LEAD HARGRAVE, KATIE HARRIS-DAVIS, MARJORIE ATTORNEY, BRANCH LAW FIRM, ALBUQUERQUE, HATCHER, JULIE KIERNAN, MARTHA LARSON, NM. MARCI MCANALLY, CATHIE MILLER, PAMELA MYERS, MARISELA ORTIZ, LOUISE PERRY, SARAH PHILLIPS, CARMELYN PULEO, JANIS LOUISE For JUDITH A. REESE, GERALDINE O'CONNELL, ADAMS, CLAIRE ALLEN, NORMA ALVARADO, Plaintiffs: CARYN MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD BARBARA CLACK, DARCY COYLE, DIANE ATTORNEY, JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. MACALUSO, ROSE ELIZABETH RITSON, MELISSA RUSSELL, CYNTHIA SLACK, CAROL ANN SMITH, For SHANE LIGAMMARI, JOHN PATRICK RIST, HARLENE SMITH, DOROTHY SOARES, DAY'LE RAEANNA RIST, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN [*417] LATHON, JOSHALYN LAWRENCE, TERESA ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN STEWART, TERIA LETISA THOMPSON, PATRICIA SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. TIMS, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For MARY ELLEN HENJUM, Plaintiff: ALAN STEVEN LAZAR, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARLIN & SALTZMAN LLP, AGOURA HILLS, CA. For [*416] RONNA KULL, Plaintiff: DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; MEKEL SMITH For SCOTT TRAINER, LINDA HALE, PATRICIA ALVAREZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONE CANAL PLACE, CHUDY, Plaintiffs: STEVEN D. DAVIS, LEAD NEW ORLEANS, LA. ATTORNEY, TORHOERMAN LAW LLC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. For JAMES F. AGRESTA, Plaintiff: LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For JONATHAN YOKELEY, Plaintiff: PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. For MICHAEL SUMMERVILLE, MARIA PACE, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. For AVE JACKSON, SHARON COOPER, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, PARKER WAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY. For SHARON SADLER, THOMAS SADLER, Plaintiffs: CORRIE JOHNSON YACKULIC, LEAD ATTORNEY, CORRIE YACKULIC LAW FIRM PLLC, SEATTLE, WA. For BARBARA ANDERSON, LOWELL ANDERSON, SHIRLEY ARMSTRONG, PRAKASH MIRCHANDANI, RAJINI MIRCHANDANI, DOROTHA RIDENOUR, For MORRIS RAY CHAPPELL, MICHELLE R. Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD DILLARD, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For DEBRA BARCENA, SUSIE BRUCE, MARGARET HULLINGER, RHONDA HYDE, VICKIE MEADOWS, For ELAINE HOLMQUIST, ROSALIND MCMILLER- Plaintiffs: TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, IFEADIKE, Plaintiffs: MATTHEW RYAN MCCARLEY, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. LEAD ATTORNEY, FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM PLLC, DALLAS, TX. Page 145 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *417

For PETER SCHNEIDER, Plaintiff: WENDY R. PAMELA BYRNES, 18-05380, LISA EVELAND, 18- FLEISHMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, NEW YORK, NY. 5283, HOWARD GALLOW, 18-5278, TIFFANY HOGANS, 18-5271, BARBARA KAPLAN, 18-5276, MARIA LAZO, 18-5273, MICHAEL SKUNDA, 18-5280, For BRANDY LAFORCE, Plaintiff: Mark J King, IV, Plaintiffs: WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, Craig Swapp & Associates, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Spokane Valley, WA. ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For WILLIAM HAROLD, Plaintiff: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, For KATHLEEN WILLIAMS, 18-4566 (Arkansas), EDWARDSVILLE, [*418] IL. WALLACE ALEXANDER, 18-04609, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER L. SCHNIEDERS, LEAD ATTORNEY, For DENZEL R. KING, Plaintiff: MELVIN WAYNE CVOUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRUNSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, MELVIN W. WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. BRUNSON, ATTORNEY AT LAW, MOBILE, AL. For JUDITH I. PETERSEN, 18-892, Plaintiff: CARMEN For PATRICIA CICCONE, Plaintiff: ERIC D. PEARSON, SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE IRVING, TX. LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC.

For CHRISTINA DELGADO, Plaintiff: Justin Ross For MARIA COPPOLA, 18-04724, IDA DIX, 18-04725, Kaufman, LEAD ATTORNEY, Kelly Durham & Pittard, ELAINE RUTLEDGE, 18-04727, MARTHA S. SHALLY, LLP, Santa Fe, NM; Rosalind Bienvenu, LEAD 18-04736, WENDY SNOW-TRUGLIO, 18-04740, ATTORNEY, Heard Robins Cloud LLP, Santa Fe, NM. MARCELL CAMPBELL, 18-04749, BETTY L. DOUGLAS, 18-04748, CHERYL MESEROLE, 18- 04752, EVELYN ORTIZ, 18-04741, WILLORA For JAMES NEY, 18-4572, MARY ALICE NEY, 18- PHILLIPS, 18-04750, AMY SARANTOU, 18-04746, 4572, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD LOUISE M. WOODLE, 18-04744, BETTY WRIGHT, 18- ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ 04751, Plaintiffs: MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT [*420] & GEREL, WASHINGTON, For JASON SMALDONE, 18-4582, Plaintiff: JEFFREY DC. STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COHEN & MALAD LLP, For DENA GOMEZ, 18-04726, ESSIE HAMILTON, 18- INDIANAPOLIS, IN. 04723,HERSHER KERNER, 18-04718, SHARON KERNER, 18-04718, NANCY M. NICOLL, 18-04720, For MARVA WARD, 18-4586, CASEY MOSES, 18- ROBERT NICOLL, 18-04720, WILLIAM STONER, 18- 04607, DEMERITA ANDERSON, 18-4771, DEANNA 04719, JACQUELINE JOHNSON, 18-04728, PAM A. BOWEN, 17-4773, SUSAN JONES, 18-4767 (Oregon), MILLER, 18-04730, LISA SHORTRIDGE, 18-04737, MARTHA BROOKS, 18-04963, ELIZABETH TABATHA STEVENS, 18-04733, MICHELLE L. BRUNELLE, 18-04993, DEB DAHMS, 18-04994, WEEKS, 18-04729, JESSICA P. BALL, 18-4715, ANNEMARIE DONOVAN, 18-04995, KATHRYN DEBORAH K DAVIS, 18-4717 AND 18-4377 (Kansas), NETTLES, 18-04967, DAJON PEREZ, 18-04988, KATHRYN T. CHAPMAN, 18-4763, OREN GREER, On BARBARA REINCKE, 18-04989, IRENE ROBERTS, behalf of Judith A. Greer 18-4769, DORIS M. 18-04970, GINGER SCHABER, 18-04991, MARY STOERMER, 17-4759, Plaintiffs: TAYJES MATTHEW SKALA, 18-04992, VICKI EVERSOLE, 18-04996, SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, MARGARET HARWICK, 18-04997, GUSSIE HOLMES, ORANGE, VA. 18-5002, LAKYDA [*419] JONES, 18-5003, KATHERINE LYLE, 18-5004, ANN GAYS, 18-5118, For GINGER PRICE, 18-04721, Plaintiff: ADAM TAL LINDA O'NEILL, 18-5123, LYNDA PAXMAN, 18-5124, FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED Page 146 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *420

TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, For ROBERT BAILEY, 18-4778, DEBRA CLAY, 18- ALBUQUERQUE, NM. 4780, NANCY DAVIS, 18-4784, ANGELA GLOVER, 18- 4787, ALLYSSA GODFREY, [*422] 18-4793, DONALD REZEK, 18-4797, SALLIE WINDOM, 18-4800, SUSAN For NANCY STRUTHERS, 18-04722, STEPHANIE MORGAN, 18-04823, PERCILLA HEARD, 18-4999, JOHNSON, 18-5266 (Louisiana), DENISE PELLECHIA, TOMMIE JACKSON, 18-5006, BRIAN KAMPMAN, 18- 18-5268, LINDSEY SILAS, 18-5266, Plaintiffs: 5016, JOYCE MILNER, 18-5007, BERNICE NICHOLS, PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, 18-5008, MICHAEL TAYLOR, 18-5010, HENRIETTA COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, TROWBRIDGE, 18-5011, MIKE VACA, 18-5013, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For HERBERT BOUCHARD, 18-4753, Plaintiff: Donald BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & A. Migliori, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. ADMITTED TO USDC -NJ BAR, Motley Rice LLC, Providence, RI. For DANIEL DEMORGANDIE, 18-04986, YVONNE BARNES GALLOWAY, 18-04990, BETTIE GILMORE, For MARIA LUISA VIDAL, 18-04739 AND 18-2979, 18-4998, Plaintiffs: LAUREN KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD Plaintiff: M. BRANDON SMITH, [*421] LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & BAR, CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH LLC, MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. ATLANTA, GA; MICHELLE A. PARFITT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ For LYNDELL MCDONALD, 18-04959, Plaintiff: BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL, WASHINGTON, DC. CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli For SUZANNE GATES, 18-4650, Plaintiff: MEGHAN Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For BARBARA SURBER, 18-04818, Plaintiff: EDWARD A. WALLACE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For MONNIE PHIPPS JENKINS, 18-4613, MICHAEL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WEXLER WALLACE JAMES WINKELSPECHT, 18-04822 on behalf of LLP, CHICAGO, IL. ESTATE OF THERESA WINKELSPECHT, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For JAMES WARREN, 18-04981, Plaintiff: RANDI NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HEYGOOD ORR ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL & PEARSON, IRVING, TX. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN CITY, NY. For DELONA SHOEMAKER, 18-4712, MICHELLE TUCKER, 18-4713, ROBERT WORSHAM, 18-4714, For MARK BOULIER, 18-5009, TAMARA BOULIER, 18- GREGORIA CORDOVA, 18-04747, NAOMI SMIGEL, 5009, Plaintiffs: SUSAN ANN FAUNCE, [*423] LEAD 18-04745, Plaintiffs: TRENT B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BERMAN & SIMMONS, LEWISTON, ME. BAR, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL.

For CYNTHIA MURRAY, 18-5028, ROBERT MURRAY, For BYRON L WILLIAMS, JR, Individually and as the 18-5028 (Colorado), Plaintiffs: J. CHRISTOPHER Executor of the Estate of Jane Williams (deceased) 18- ELLIOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 4762, ROBERT COLANTINO, 18-5397, CAROL ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BACHUS & CEFFALIA, 18-05400, Plaintiffs: BRIAN A. SCHANKER LLC, DENVER, CO. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CELLINO & BARNES PC, BUFFALO, NY. For JUDY SHATTUCK, 18-5017, BETTY SMOTHERS, 18-5023, IRA THOMAS, 18-5025, LUCINDA THOMAS, Page 147 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *423

18-5025, ANTHONY TIMMS, 18-5019, GINGER For SARAH COSTANZO, 18-05244, GERMAINE S. TIMMS, 18-5019, LATONIA WILLIAMS, 18-05376, HESTER, 18-5365, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL STEVEN Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, MORGAN & MORGAN PC, TAMPA, FL. For MARY ELLEN YANNONE, 18-4859, Plaintiff: JENNIFER A. LENZE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For ANN FALCHECK, 18-05234, DEBRA HOLICKA, 18- NOT ADMITTED USDC-NJ BAR, LENZE MOSS PLC, 05239, DAVETTA JOHNSON-WAITES, 18-05238, MANHATTAN BEACH, CA. ABBEY KRYS, 18-05231, BARBARA MAXWELL, 18- 05236, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, For FELICIA FERKETICH, 18-05102, Plaintiff: DALLAS, TX. TOMISLAV GEORGE ANTUNOVICH, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BISNAR | CHASE, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. For DELLA JOHNSON, 18-05249, KENNY LOQUIST, 18-05246, JOSEPHINE MERENA, 18-05242, ALEX ZABROSKY, [*425] 18-05242, Plaintiffs: STEVEN D. For SUNDRA RAMONA MCWOODS, 18-05110, DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Plaintiff: KAY L. VAN WEY, LEAD ATTORNEY, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, TORHOERMAN LAW COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, VAN LLC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. WEY LAW PLLC, DALLAS, TX.

For LANA BRATTON, 18-05374, BARBARA For PHILIP PELLETIER, 18-05105, Plaintiff: MARILYN CARPENTER, 18-05368, LAWRENCE GUISE, 18- T. MCGOLDRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 05381, ELBA JONES, 18-05367, ENEDINA MEJIA- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THORNTON & CORDOVA, 18-05378, BLANCH SHEETS, 18-05387, NAUMES, BOSTON, MA. LEE TEBBUTT, 18-05377, SIDNEY FESSLER, 18- 5391, DEBORAH GOLDEN, 18-5366, DEBRA ILGES, For ROSE REYNOLDS, 18-05098, FRANKLIN A. 18-05538, BARBARA SHANDOR, 18-05539, MICAH SMITH, 18-05098, Plaintiffs: NICOLE [*424] K.H. BAILEY, 18-05536, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAUM HEDLUND USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. EDWARDSVILLE, IL.

For JENNIFER WHITE, 18-13130 (Missouri), Plaintiff: For KENNETH GARNETT, 18-5290, Plaintiff: RICHARD JAMES G. ONDER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LEE ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER ADMITTED TOU SDC-NJ BAR, MORRIS BART & SHELTON O'LEARY PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA. LAUREL LI HARRIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PORTER & For CATHLEEN NORTON, 18-5395, Plaintiff: Jonathan MALOUF PA, JACKSON, MS; STEPHANIE LYNN D Orent, LEAD ATTORNEY, Motley Rice LLC, RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT Providence, RI. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. For HERBERT DETRES, 18-05401, ISADORA DETRES, 18-05401, ADRIENNE MAROFSKY, 18- For JOE WARREN, 18-5125, JAMES ANDERSON, 18- 05405 (Michigan), Plaintiffs: RICHARD M. GOLOMB, 5396, JEANNE ZIMMERMAN, 18-05399, Plaintiffs: LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C., SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, PHILADELPHIA, PA. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BARON & BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX. For NATASHA VANNESS, 18-5413, AVERL RENEE HARBIN, 18-05530, LUANNE MCMICKLE, 18-05415, Page 148 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *425

Plaintiffs: DAVID PATRICK DANIEL, JR., LEAD 6760, AARON ANDREWS, 18-6762, ANITA ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ DAVIDSEN, 18-6764, DARNELLA ENGLEHART, 18- BAR, DANIEL & ASSOCIATES [*426] LLC, 7019, DEBRA GRIMES, 18-7023, GERALDINE HOUSTON, TX. KUHLEMAN-HEATH, 18-7025, LEIGH MARKLEY, 18- 7029, PATRICIA MANWARREN, 18-7810, CAROLYN ASTON, 18-7964, MARTI DEJON, 18-8001, KIMBERLY For GREGORY LAPERE, 17-11457, ROGER MCGLONE, 18-8005, SHERRI STEWART, 18-8003, ZOELLER, 17-11459 on behalf of ESTATE OF Plaintiffs: WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, CYNTHIA ZOELLER, DANIEL M ADAMS, 17-11455, on COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, behalf of ESTATE OF DECEDENT, PATRICIA LYNN ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. ADAMS, CYNTHIA LANDES, 17-11456, Plaintiffs: LOUIS, MO. HELEN ZUKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KEISEL & LAW LLP, BEVERLY HILLS, CA. For GINA GRAHAM, 18-5544, PATRICK NOONAN, 18- 7634, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, For JOE KING, 18-05545, Plaintiff: KELLY E. NY. REARDON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE REARDON LAW FIRM PC, NEW LONDON, CT. For WALTER IWANOW, 18-5562, on behalf of, ESTATE OF CHRISTINE KOT IWANOW, DECEASED, JERMEL WILKERSON, 18-5637, on behalf of, ESTATE For DARREN CARTWRIGHT, 18-05535, MAUREEN OF CAROLYN WILKERSON, CATHERINE KNIGHT, KASSIMALI, 18-05534, Plaintiffs: JAMES G. ONDER, 18-6319, [*428] on behalf of, ESTATE OF CATHERINE LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO COLLUM, SEAN KNIGHT, 18-6319, on behalf of, USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY ESTATE OF CATHERINE COLLUM, Plaintiffs: ERIC D. PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO; STEPHANIE LYNN PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HEYGOOD ORR & ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON PEARSON, IRVING, TX. O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO; WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ONDER SHELTON For PHYLLIS SMITH, 18-5556, Plaintiff: BRIAN J. O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; Dena R Young, Mark A. For JUDY WILLIAMS, 18-05532, Plaintiff: DOUGLAS E. Hoffman, Matthew A. Casey, Scott S Berger, LEAD ADAMS, II, LEAD ATTORNEY. ATTORNEYS, Ross Feller Casey, LLP, Philadelphia, PA; JOEL J. FELLER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS For KELLY FRAZIER, 18-5558, CAROL TAUSCHER, FELLER CASEY, PHILADELPHIA, PA; ROBERT 18-5548, DESIRAE OWEN, 18-5654, LILLIAN ROSS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ROSS, FELLER & CASEY, URBANSKY, 18-5651, SHIRLEY CASEMAN, 18-05676, LLP, PHILADELPHIA, PA. WANDA HARDUNG, 18-05672, BEATRICE HORNBECK, 18-05673, ROBIN SCHULTZ, 18- For DARDANELLES ESTES, 18-05547, Plaintiff: 05677, [*427] MARISA TELESCA, 18-05666, ANN JESSICA MEEDER, LEAD ATTORNEY COUNSEL CONSIGLIO, 18-5736, DONNA MCNICHOLS, 18-5722, NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MURPHY NENITA FRANCK, 18-05790, CATHERINE KEMPNER, FALCON & MURPHY PA, BALTIMORE, MD. 18-05788, PEGGY LYLES, 18-05782, SHELLEY SHAWNEE, 18-05796, CATHERINE SIMMONS, 18- 05798, STANLEY THOMAS CIZEWSKI, JR, 18-5812, For STARLIN PATRICK, 18-05586, DENNIS PATRICK, NANCY JACKSON, 18-5804, EILEEN MOHAMED, 18- 18-05586, LUKE BREWER, 18-5640, CLIFF CORAN, 5806, JULIANA NORIEGA, 18-5801, DAVID 18-05818, EVELYN CORAN, 18-05818, JAMES RAPPARD, 18-5810, WENDY RICH, 18-5813, SAMUEL, 18-06018, BETTIE SAMUEL, 18-06018, JYOSTNA HADA, 18-5921, KENT KRATTENMAKER, TAMIKA ERVIN, 18-06101, NITA RUFUS, 18-6309, 18-6062, BETTY MARTIN, 18-2137, MARY VAVIS, 18- RADFORD WALKER, 18-6305, SHARON WALKER, Page 149 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *428

18-6305, ANGEL HOPKINS, 18-6607, Plaintiffs: For DOUGLAS SCOTT, 18-05747, Plaintiff: PATRICK CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY, KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Napoli ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, [*429] NY. LLP, WASHINGTON, DC.

For JERRIANNE SWANGIM, 18-05588, Plaintiff: For EARLINE WAGONER, 18-05820, ELEANOR KIM- MICHAEL RAY CLINTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, DOMINGUEZ, 18-5824, EILEEN MCFETRIDGE, 18- COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, 5822, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD BLIZZARD & NABERS LLP, HOUSTON, TX. ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. For MARJORIE WILSON, 18-5599, PATRICIO SANJORJO, 18-6741, PERPETUA SANJORJO, 18- For APRIL HANAWAY, 17-6855, on behalf of, ESTATE 6741, Plaintiffs: CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD OF MARTHA JANE ODLE, Plaintiff: DANIEL N. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ ABRAHAM, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, COLLEY SHROYER & ABRAHAM, COLUMBUS, OH. For DENIS DEMYAN, 18-5641, DOROTHY KNAPP, 18- 5648, DOREEN LACEY, 18-5645, DOROTHY For MISTY BAKER, 18-5844, KATHLEEN BECK, 18- PINCKNEY, 18-5653, DONNA PRUITT, 18-5644, 5853, ANGELA BOTTONE, 18-05858, JOYCE BRYAN, FLEESA ROBINSON, 18-5828, ESTHER WATSON, 18- 18-05863, KIMBERLY CAMPBELL, 18-05873, KAREN 5827, Plaintiffs: WARREN T BURNS, LEAD CHELF, 18-05877, BARBARA BOURGEOIS, 18-05932, ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, LAURA CLEM, 18-05935, MACHELLE GLASSO, 18- DALLAS, TX. 05937, MARY NYHAN, 18-05923, GLORIA ROSAS, 18- 05926, SARAH TABOR, 18-05929, VALERIA COLVIN, 18-5883, NANCY ESPARZA, 18-5892, JANICE FITCH, For KEVIN RIEDMUELLER, 17-7575, on behalf of, 18-5901, LAURIE GARCIA, 18-5905, SHIRLEY ESTATE OF VICKI HOLCOMB, Plaintiff: TAYJES HUSAK, 18-5906, RENA KEENOY, 18-5907, MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER MARGARET KHONG, 18-5909, BARBARA FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. MUNCH, [*431] 18-5916, EVA NOEL, 18-5920, JOANNE WAITE, 18-6060, MODISHA WILLIS, 18- For VERONICA WILDER, 18-5705, Plaintiff: GARY W. 6061, LISA OWENS, 18-06048, CHERYL RALLS, 18- JACKSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, LAW OFFICES OF 06050, WENDY JOANN SAHYOUN, 18-06055, JANE SCOTT FARRIN, DURHAM, NC. CHRISTINA SCHROEDER, 18-06056, MARILYN STEWART, 18-06058, MELBA RUTH TUCKER, 18- 06059, ALICE CLARK, 18-6589, SUSAN DOMINGUEZ, For BEVERLY MEIERS, 18-5717, RICHARD MEIERS, 18-6369, RUTH KNIGHT KNABB, 18-cv-6620, DENISE 18-5717, LESLIE PIERCE, 18-5726, SUSAN PIERCE, LYNETTE MONTES, 18-cv-6623, VICTORIA NIX, 18- 18-5726, Plaintiffs: MARK P ROBINSON, Jr, LEAD cv-6627, JAYNE WHITE, 18-cv-6631, ELLIS ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ DACOVICH, 18-6596, SHARON DOWD, 18-6601, BAR, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. KATHLEEN FORDYCE, 18-6603, Plaintiffs: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For EVELYN WITTIG, 18-5693, ALAN BRAMAN, 18- NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN 7661, ELIZABETH ANN BRAMAN, 18-7661, CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MILAGROS RUIZ, 18-7658, MARIA [*430] THERESA MONTGOMERY, AL. RUIZ-LAW, 18-7658, BETTY LASSETER, 18-8007, SAMUEL LASSETER, 18-8007, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. For JOAN MILLIS, 18-6079, JENNIFER COOPER, 18- MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 6618, WILLIAM COOPER, 18-6618, Plaintiffs: NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Ross Feller Casey GREGORY S. SPIZER, LEAD ATTORNEY, ANAPOL LLP, Philadelphia, PA. WEISS, Philadelphia, PA. Page 150 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *431

For JOSHUA NATHANIEL JOSEPH FOOTMAN, 18- TAL FUNK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL [*433] NOT 6292, ASHLEIGH LAWRENCE, 18-06292, LAUREN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRANCH LAW FIRM, LOHR, 18-06110, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. ALBUQUERQUE, NM. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAUM HEDLUND For VINCENT WEBER, 18-7956, Plaintiff: ADRIANA ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SKIKOS For CAROL DOOHER, 18-6321, GEORGE DOOHER, CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, 18-6321, Plaintiffs: KELSEY WALTER SHANNON, CA. LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LYNN LAW FIRM, SYRACUSE, NY. For DANIEL GENTHERT, 18-7976, LINDA CLAIRE GENTHERT, 18-7976, ANDREW GENTNER, 18-7975, For PETER SAIA, [*432] 18-6354, CAROL GREEN, SCOTT "ANDY" GENTNER, 18-7975, TREVOR 18-7953, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL J. MILLER, LEAD GENTNER, 18-7975, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT BAR, THE MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. For BETHANY L. PARKER, 18-6621, Plaintiff: DOUGLAS E. CHABOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For CAROLYN MATTHEWS, 18-7995, Plaintiff: SEAN NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, DECOF DECOF & MICHAEL CLEARY, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL BARRY PC, PROVIDENCE, RI. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MIAMI, FL.

For JANET GRESKE, 17-10764, Plaintiff: DAVID I. For MINDY CARETTO, 18-8006, JULIA WILLIAMS, 18- CATES, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 8002, KENNETH WILLIAMS, 18-8002, Plaintiffs: ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CATES MAHONEY MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LLC, SWANSEA, IL. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PARKER WAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY. For MEGAN DALY, 18-6744, ELAINE MORAVINSKI, 18-6753, Plaintiffs: RANDI ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD For CHRIS NIXON, 18-7992, JASON NIXON, 18-7992, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ JOHN AARON KENNETH NIXON, 18-7992, Plaintiffs: BAR, SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN RONNIE GLYNN PENTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, CITY, NY. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BOGALUSA, LA. For PAULINE BRIEN, 18-7579, THOMAS GALLEGOS, 18-7552, BONNIE HEINKING, 18-7568, CYNTHIA For CHARLES DENNIS, JR, 18-8061, Plaintiff: BERGQUIST, 18-7586, BONNITA O'NEILL, 18-7610, BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD, LEAD ATTORNEY, MARY RICHMOND, 18-7598, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, Goza MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT & Honnold, LLC, Overland Park, KS. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. For NICOLE RAULT 18-8047, [*434] Plaintiff: MICHAEL STEVEN GOETZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, For HARRY MOAK, 18-7703, MARIA SOTO, 18-7717, MORGAN & MORGAN PC, TAMPA, FL. Plaintiffs: BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE For LINDA RICE 18-8055, MICHELLE FERGUSON 18- SIMON LAW FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. 8124, HILDA HOUSTON 18-8128, BEVERLY JOHNSON 18-8131, ERIKA HARRIS 18-08182, For NARENDRA PATEL, 18-7938, URMILA PATEL, 18- Plaintiffs: JENNIFER LYNN ORENDI, LEAD 7938, EMMA SUE BOLDIN, 18-7958, Plaintiffs: ADAM ATTORNEY, WASHINGTON, DC; STUART LEE Page 151 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *434

GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG For AARON KENT, SR 18-08104, Plaintiff: THOMAS F. LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. CUFFIE, THE CUFFIE LAW FIRM, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE CUFFIE LAW FIRM, ATLANTA, GA. For SYLVIA SILER 18-8051, EDWIN T. BECKMAN 18- 8285, YVETTE COLE-GRAHAM 18-8286, ALICE F. For JUNI PRAWOTO 18-08094, WILLIAM SLOCUM 18- MATTOX 18-8287, BARBARA J. COLLINS 18-08288, 08096, Plaintiffs: JENNELL KRISTINE SHANNON, CHARLOTTE HANSON 18-08293, HELMS M. EVARY LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. 18-8294, ELLA K. GRANT 18-08361, HERBERT KEYS PAUL, MN. 18-08366, LISA R. KEYS 18-08366, JUSTINE SOLBRIG 18-08358, TRACY L. ARTHUR 18-8343, For LANA K BYNUM 18-08143, SHERON CHURCH 18- FLORA J. BROOKS 18-8375, ERIN M. HANSON 18- 08146, JULIE JOHNSON-SUMMERS 18-08149, 8339, LINDA H. HILL 18-8344, JENNIFER WIGGINS DELOISE SINCLAIR 18-08157, Plaintiffs: [*436] 18-8370, JENNIFER WYMAN 18-8338, Plaintiffs: THOMAS ROE FRAZER, II, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE HAC VICE, FRAZER PLC, Nashville, TN. MILLER FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA.

For DARLEEN DYE 18-08154, HEIDI FINIGAN 18- For DAVID EVANS 18-08068, DELBERT LEATH 18- 08152, SHIRLEY SCHWARZE 18-08156, HATTIE 08071, KENNETH ROBINSON 18-08074, DOROTHY DILLON 18-08165, MELINDA MATHEWS 18-08162, CHURCH 18-08188, ROSALEE CRAWFORD 18- BOLTON WHYTE 18-08160, DIANNE ARRAO 18- 08190, FAYE DETTLING 18-08191, BETTY LUALLIN 08170, PEGGY BRNASDORFER 18-08169, REGINA 18-08193, TIMOTHY RUPP 18-8194, DEBORAH GATES-GREEN 18-08167, TERESA LEPORIS 18- SANDERS 18-8197, EVA SCHWARTZ 18-8199, 08173, PAMELA ROBINSON 18-08174, MAUREEN DONNA SMITH 18-8205, ELIZABETH SOLOMON 18- ALEXANDER 18-08278, JUSTINE DEBONO 18-08281, 8209, CYNTHIA TODD 18-8215, BRENDA VEITCH 18- RAMONA VAUGHN 18-08279, PABLO ATKINSON 18- 8217, MARGARET VIDETIC [*435] 18-8221, RITA 08324, VICKEY BALENTINE 18-8379, LINDA ELDER ANNE ANDERSEN 18-08327, MARIA ANTONIO 18- 18-8381, COURTNEY ENDICOTT 18-8385, 08328, DIRK BENDER 18-08329, SHARI BRANHAM ELIZABETH NEFF 18-8371, DELORES SOZA 18-8373, 18-08331, GEORGE FRAZIER 18-08365, KEVIN TANNY THOMPSON 18-8374, YVONNE WEAVER 18- MICHAELS 18-08353, LATASHA SPARKS 18-08357, 8376, BELINDA BALL 18-08412, STEFANIE DAWSON LAURA GEORGE 18-8333, VIOLET GLOVER 18-8336, 18-08414, MARIA GONZALEZ 18-08411, KATHLEEN MICHAEL HERSHBERGER 18-8337, BARBARA A. PEDRONI 18-08392, HOLLY BRUMMOND 18-8421, HILLAND 18-8346, JACQUELINE JOHNSON 18-8348, LINDA FORSE 18-8420, KRISTIN JORDAN 18-8419, JEFFREY L. KLEKAS 18-8349, JOHN B. LEGRAND LINDA RAYBURN 18-8424, RUTH SILVA 18-8417, 18-8351, YVONNE PARTRIDGE 18-8369, Plaintiffs: Plaintiffs: WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES LOUIS, MO. PC, MONTGOMERY, AL.

TERENCE SMITH 18-08161, JAMES TINER 18-8138, For ERICA BROUGHTON 18-08117, Plaintiff: MINNIE COHEN 18-08183, CHARLOTTE BOES 18- BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD, LEAD ATTORNEY, Goza 08233, CHERYL ANN MORENO 18-8252, JESUS & Honnold, LLC, Overland Park, KS. SANTOYO MORENO 18-8252, BETH POTTER 18- 8210, DEBORAH SHUMAKE 18-8151, KEITH For SARA HALL 18-08091, Plaintiff: JENNELL SHUMAKE 18-8151, ANTOINETTE PAGE 18-8475, KRISTINE SHANNON, JOHNSON BECKER PLLC, ST. Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER [*437] R. LOPALO, LEAD PAUL, MN. ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY.

For MICHAEL INGRAM 18-08099, Plaintiff: ERIC D. For JULIANNE R LORETH 18-8126, TODD LORETH PEARSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, HEYGOOD ORR & 18-8126, MARJORIE RABENA 18-8125, PHILIP PEARSON, IRVING, TX. RABENA 18-8125, MECHELL WASHINGTON 18-8120, PATRICIA SIMON 18-8447, Plaintiffs: CARYN Page 152 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *437

MICHELE PAPANTONAKIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, JOHN SHERKANOWSKI 18-08466, Plaintiffs: RANDI JOHNSON LAW GROUP, HOUSTON, TX. ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN CITY, NY. For CHRISTIE CAMPBELL 18-08177, DEBORAH MUNCEY 18-8283, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, For SANDRA A STEELE 18-8310, Plaintiff: DANIEL J. LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, THORNBURGH, LEAD ATTORNEY, PENSACOLA, FL. GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. For LENA OWENS 18-08314, Plaintiff: PRISCILLA E. JIMENEZ, LEAD ATTORNEY, KLINE & SPECTER PC, For DAWN PERROTT 18-08184, CONNIE MILLER 18- PHILADELPHIA, PA. 08244, MICHELLE MCINTOSH 18-8247, Plaintiff: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI For JOANNE R. CLARK 18-8368, MICHAEL CODY 18- JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. 8382, KAREN DAVIS-THOMAS 18-08399, JUDITH DIVINCENZO 18-08401, ELIZABETH JONES 18-8448, For CINDY CHEELY-HALL 18-8248, LYDIA Plaintiffs: JEFFREY STEVEN GIBSON, LEAD FERNANDEZ 18-8250, LLOYD JACKSON 18-08316, ATTORNEY, COHEN & MALAD LLP, INDIANAPOLIS, NANCY JACKSON 18-08316, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. IN. SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. For DEBORAH LEMASTER 18-8477, BERTHA MCMILLER 18-8469, EMELENA PRECIADO [*439] 18- For DIANA J ARMSTRONG 18-08262, TARONE EZRA 8472, Plaintiffs: DAVID PATRICK DANIEL, JR., LEAD FERGUSON 18-08257, Plaintiffs: GREGORY DONALD ATTORNEY, DANIEL & ASSOCIATES LLC, BROWN, LEAD ATTORNEY, HOUSTON, TX; KELSEY HOUSTON, TX. LOUISE STOKES, LEAD ATTORNEY, FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ LLP, HOUSTON, TX. For TAMMY NEWTON 18-8422, JUDITH VANSIPE 18- 8476, DORIS DAVLIN 18-08459, REBECCA GARCIA For SHARON K. MUNOZ 18-08263, RAYMUNDO 18-08462, LINDA HERRMANN 18-08463, KETTA ARROYO 18-08491, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL JAMES KELLER 18-08467, Plaintiffs: TRENT B. MIRACLE, WILLIAMS, CELLINO & BARNES, BUFFALO, NY. LEAD ATTORNEY, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, ALTON, IL. For JULIETTE PERRY 18-08277, CHAUNCEY J WILLS 18-08275, [*438] AMANDA JOHNSON 18-08409, For GERALD CAVANAUGH 18-08492, Plaintiff: RAYMOND LARSON 18-08400, JUDY K. LYNN 18- MICHAEL P. KENNY. 08405, MICHAEL TILLMAN 18-08403, ELKE BURGETT 18-8473, TERRI JOHNSON 18-8418, CHRISTINE For LINDA PIPER 18-08490, VICTOR PIPER 18-08490, SCHLOSSER 18-8479, VIRGINIA ALLEN 18-08458, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD KIM CAGLE 18-08464, Plaintiffs: RANDI ALYSON ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA; KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, SANDERS VIENER DENA YOUNG, LEAD ATTORNEY, WEITZ & GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN CITY, NY. LUXENBERG, P.C., CHERRY HILL, NJ; MARK ALAN HOFFMAN, JOEL J. FELLER, MATTHEW A. CASEY, For WILLIAM J. ELLIOTT 18-08290, DEBORAH ROBERT ROSS, SCOTT S BERGER, JR, LEAD PEARSON 18-08289, DEBORAH PEARSON 18-08289, ATTORNEYS, ROSS FELLER CASEY LLP, MICHAEL PEARSON 18-08289, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. PHILADELPHIA, PA. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. For PAMELA SMITH, 18-08496, TERRENCE SMITH, 18-08496, LUCRETIA ARMSTEAD, 18-08514, For RIGOBERTO SANCHEZ 18-8299, CAROL LEONARD BOYD, 18-08514, WANDA JACKSON, 18- THOMPSON 18-8304, BONNIE WILSON 18-8303, 08513, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD Page 153 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *439

ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO.

For VICTORIA WELLS, 18-08500, SABYNE ALLEN, For CAROLE JOY DODDROE, 18-8568, EULA 18-8598, KIVON SALTERS, 18-8617, on behalf of DILLASHAW, 18-08576, KATHLEEN BLINDER, 18- SYDNEY SALTERS, Plaintiffs: M. BRANDON SMITH, 08635, KENNETH BLINDER, 18-08635, KAREN LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO TENEBRUSO, 18-8671, CAROL DELACRUZ, 18-8796, USDC-NJ BAR, CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH Plaintiffs: MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD ATTORNEY, LLC, ATLANTA, GA. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR PARKER WAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY. For REGINA ETHERIDGE, [*440] 18-08531, MARILYN S. FORTI, 18-08532, ROBERT M. FORTI, 18-08532, For CASWALYN LANDRY, 18-8575, Plaintiff: MICHAEL LISA A. NAGY, 18-08529, REGENA THIGPEN, 18- ALLEN AKSELRUD, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL 08530, WAYNE WILCOX, 18-08533, DEBORAH Y. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR THE LANIER LAW COTTON, 18-8537, GLORIA F. HENSEL, 18-8543, FIRM PC, WOODLAND HILLS, CA. RICHARD HENSEL, 18-8543, BERNICE P. MARANO, 18-8541, GEORGETTE W. KNECHT, 18-08715, For RONALD LEMIRE, 18-8577, SHANNON KELLY, SCOTT KNECHT, 18-08715, VONDELL LEWIS, 18- 18-08569, SUSAN MURRY, 18-08581, SHERRY L. 08710, DORENDA SHIPLEY, 18-08709, ANGELA SMITH, 18-08584, ESPERANZA CASTILL, 17-10185, SIMMONS, 18-08718, NANCY TRULL, 18-08707, MARIE FITZGERALD, 17-9712, Plaintiffs: LAUREN PATTY J. WOODS, 18-08717, Plaintiffs: TAYJES KLOESS RAZICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT MATTHEW SHAH, LEAD ATTORNEY, THE MILLER ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BEASLEY ALLEN FIRM LLC, ORANGE, VA. CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. For LINDA C GISO, 18-08515, Plaintiff: BRENDAN P. LEYDON, LEAD ATTORNEY; JACQUELINE E. For JILL TIPTON-BELL, 18-8566, DARLENE FUSCO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT WHITTAKER, 18-8570, STACEY WINTHER, 18-8572, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR WOCL LEYDON LLC, SHARON WOOLFOLK, 18-8574, CAROL MCCOWN, STAMFORD, CT. 18-08551, LUBERTA MCCOY, 18-08556, KERRY MISKOFSKI, 18-08557, DONNA OWENS, 18-08561, For CHARLES JOYCE CAIN, 18-8540, SONIA IMRAN, USHA RIHAL, 18-08562, VALLERIE [*442] ROGERS, 18-8538, MARTHA ANN JONES, 18-8542, STEPHEN 18-08564, DOROTHY ROSS, 18-08565, STEPHANIE PERCHINSKY JR, 18-8545, SHELLEY HODGES, 18- YEAKEL, 18-08580, CANDY ATKINS, 18-08590, VICKI 8661, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. MATHEWS, LEAD YOUNG, 18-08585, JULIE BERNTHOLD, 18-8673, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ LAURIE BONJO, 18-8664, DEBORAH BRADFORD, 18- BAR, GORI JULIAN & ASSOCIATES PC, 8666, RACHELLE BROWN, 18-8675, KAREN FRYE, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. 18-8691, RACHEL GAY, 18-8694, MICHELLE GOLDSTEIN, 18-8696, JENNIFER GOMES, 18-8697, PATRICIA HUND, 18-8699, MARY JACKSON, 18-8700, For STEPHEN LODAHL, 18-8539, Plaintiff: STEVEN D. JANET JOHANNSEN, 18-8701, SHARRON LIBONATI, DAVIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT 18-8702, MARIE LOLLO, 18-8703, CORTNEY ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, TORHOERMAN LAW BUTLER, 18-08679, BARBARA CASTERLIN, 18- LLC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. 08680, ZULEMA CUEVAS, 18-08685, TULANE DUKE, 18-08686, ROSE MARIE ESPENSHADE, 18-08687, For JOYCE PAINTER, 18-8534, LARRY SQUILLACE, SALLY FRANKLIN, 18-08690, ANNA CUEVAS, 18- 18-8544, NORA MCKAY, 18-08558, DUSTY MINOR, 8739, CHRISTINE GAFFNEY, 18-8740, ALLEN 18-08546, PEGGY [*441] ANN HOSKINS, 18-08909, PULLIAM, 18-8738, ROBIN HENRY, 18-08781, MARY JAMES KEITH, 18-08910, VICTORIA A RIPKA, 18-08776, RITA HOSTON, 18-8815, LOUISE MACFARLAND, 18-08905, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER L. SCHULTE, 18-8816, ELLI , 18-08844, MARY SCHNIEDERS, LEAD ATTORNEY, CVOUNSEL NOT GRAY, 18-08824, JANICE HOLLAND, 18-08846, ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WAGSTAFF & SHADA KAWELO, 18-08855, VICTORIA RESNICK, 18- Page 154 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *442

08826, LILLIE TURBIN, 18-08822, ROSEMARY BAR, ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. BEARFIELD, 18-8892, JOANNE CAREY, 18-8893, Plaintiffs: WILLIAM WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, For DORIS L. BREAUX, 18-08656, MURALL D. COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HANCOCK, 18-08652, DELIA B MARTIN, 18-08649, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & pETERSON LLC, ST. Plaintiffs: GREGORY DONALD BROWN, KELSEY LOUIS, MO. LOUISE STOKES, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR FLEMING NOLEN For DAVID MEYER, 18-08578, VINCENT RICCIUTI, & JEZ LLP, HOUSTON, TX. 18-08579, JACQUELYN BAKER, 18-08589, Plaintiffs: CHAD [*443] ETHAN IHRIG, LEAD ATTORNEY, For CURTIS COY, 18-08645, KELLY KERR, 18-08749, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR NIX Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., LEAD PATTERSON & ROACH LLP, AUSTIN, TX. ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR Ross Feller Casey LLP, Philadelphia, PA. For GERALDINE SOUTHARD, 18-08592, MARY SCHOFIELD, 18-8596, SANDRA SILVA, 18-8600, For JANICE MAHINSKE, 18-08658, LAURA SUTTLE, CAROLYN TERRELL, 18-8597, Plaintiffs: DAE YEOL 18-8663, , 18-08682, GLORIA LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD LLP, FAUGHT, 18-08902, BONNIE GOLDEN, 18-08895, NEW YORK, NY. CAROL KING, 18-08901, MICHELLE LOEHR, 18- 08900, LAWANA RODWELL, 18-08897, Plaintiffs: For MICHELLE BARNES, 18-8606, NEOMI BERFECT- RANDI ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, CULLER, 18-08640, BETTY BUSH, 18-08660, KIM COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, BUSH, 18-8665, NIKITA CHEDAKA, 18-8667, LINDA SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN LLP, GARDEN CITY, FONTENOT, 18-8692, CATHERINE COBB, 18-08683, NY. KAREN COOPER, 18-08688, GAIL GRAY, 18-08752, LINDA GUILLOT, 18-08755, SHAPHONIA HARDY, 18- For WILLIAM CLINE, 18-08684, Plaintiff: STUART LEE 08852, Plaintiffs: RICHARD LEE ROOT, LEAD GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TOU SDC-NJ ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR GOLDENBERG LAW BAR, MORRIS BART & ASSOCIATES, NEW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. ORLEANS, LA.

For DIANE L ALLBRIGHT, 18-8732, CHARLOTTE K For BRIAN P BOYCE, 18-8613, JAMES BOYCE, 18- MARRUFO, 18-08747, Plaintiff: JESSICA MEEDER, 8613, PAMELA L. WOJTA, 18-8610, STEVEN KENT LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO CLARK, 18-8870, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. USDC-NJ BAR MURPHY FALCON & MURPHY MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT PA, [*445] BALTIMORE, MD. ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. For SHARON THORP, 18-08711, Plaintiff: PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For LEONARD HALL, 18-8611, Plaintiff: LYNN ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR ASHCRAFT & GEREL MARTHA SEITHEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR SEITHEL LAW LLC, JOHNS ISLAND, SC. For GLADYS BAZEMORE, 17-18180, Plaintiff: STEVEN DAVID RESNICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLOMB & For RUTH K NICHOLS, 18-8601, M. DUANE GHERE, HONIK PC, PHILADELPHIA, PA. 18-8791, Plaintiffs: CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD ATTORNEY, MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW [*444] ORLEANS, LA. For LETICIA GIRADO, 17-9824, Plaintiff: BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR BEASLEY ALLEN For MAUREEN SAVONA, 18-8594, Plaintiff: LEAD CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES PC, ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ Page 155 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *445

MONTGOMERY, AL. NOT ADMITTED TOU SDC-NJ BAR, MORRIS BART & ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For SARA MCDOWELL, 17-9856, Plaintiff: STEPHANIE LYNN RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For BEVERLY HENRY, 18-8891, MIRIAM JABLON, 18- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR ONDER SHELTON 8865, KAREN RUSSELL, 18-8858, Plaintiffs: WILLIAM O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. WYLIE BLAIR, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON LLC, ST. LOUIS, MO. For LYNDA CAMERON, 18-8733, Plaintiff: AMANDA LYNN WASHINGTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For HELEN HUBBARD, 18-8861, MARILEE NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR MCGLYNN PETERSON, 18-09028, Plaintiffs: CARMEN SESSIONS GLISSON & MOUTON, BATON ROUGE, LA. SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MOTLEY RICE LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. For HOWARD D BROWN, 18-08775, WENDY BROWN, 18-08775, KRISTI BROWN GAMBRELL, 18-08775, For SHERI ROE, 18-8857, Plaintiff: TOMISLAV SCOTT THOMAS GRABER, JR., 18-08775, XAN GEORGE ANTUNOVICH, [*447] LEAD ATTORNEY, MUNZER, 18-08834, Plaintiffs: MEGHAN ELIZABETH BISNAR | CHASE, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. MCCORMICK, RACHEL BETH ABRAMS, LEAD ATTORNEYS, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN For JOSEPH SIEBER, 18-8859, GERALD IVERSON, FRANCISCO, CA. 18-09157, CHRIS PATRICK PREVOST, 18-09208, JACQUELINE GOLEMATIS, 18-09223, Plaintiffs: For DONNA BROWN, 18-8790, DANNY HUBBARD, 18- PATRICK KELLY LYONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, 8792, GREGORY ROGERS, 18-8789, CAROL ASHCRAFT & GEREL LLP, WASHINGTON, DC. WAMPLER, 18-8793, Plaintiffs: SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For AMY MARIE VANCE, 18-8870, E. WILLIAM ADMITTED [*446] TO USDC-NJ BAR, BARON & PASTOR, 18-09227, Plaintiffs: NICOLE K.H. BUDD PC, DALLAS, TX. MALDONADO, LEAD ATTORNEY, BAUM HEDLUND ARISTEI & GOLDMAN, P.C., LOS ANGELES, CA. For JOAN ANGILLETTA, 18-08853, Plaintiff: CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL For SHERRIE MULLIS, 18-8915, CYNTHIA VALVO, 18- NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, MOTLEY RICE 8916, Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER L. SCHNIEDERS, LLC, MT. PLEASANT, SC. LEAD ATTORNEY, WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL LLP, KANSAS CITY, MO. For KURTIS MAUER, 18-08820, Plaintiff: BENJAMIN R. ASKEW, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT For ALTON FUGLER, 18-08928, LINDA TORRES, 18- ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR THE SIMON LAW 08965, SONIA VAZQUEZ, 18-8968, KEVIN FIRM, P.C., ST. LOUIS, MO. HARTNETT, 18-09019, AMANDA CROCKER, 18- 09174, CHANNING DAVIS, 18-09165, CHANTELLE For BARBARA ROSINSKI, 18-08838, Plaintiff: BRIAN D OTTENS, 18-09168, CORINNE RAKIN, 18-09162, CHASE, by BRIAN D CHASE LEAD ATTORNEY; DONNA FODERA, 18-09271, JONI MACKEY, 18- TOMISLAV GEORGE ANTUNOVICH, LEAD 09280, RONALD RAGIS, 18-09282, WILLIAM ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BOWMAN, 18-9329, CHARLENE BUSHMAN, 18-9341, BAR BISNAR - CHASE, NEWPORT BEACH, CA. SUE WILLIAMSON, 18-9339, PHYLLIS MANNING, 18- 09384, JESSICA CRUZ, 18-09390, TAMARA PAGE, 18-09385, CRYSTAL R. WILLIAMS, 18-09407, For DEANNA HARRIS, 18-8864, BRENDA Plaintiffs: RANDI ALYSON KASSAN, LEAD HIGHTOWER, 18-08963, PATRICIA HILLARD, 18- ATTORNEY, SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN LLP, 8970, WILHEMINA JAMES, 18-8990, MABLE JONES, GARDEN CITY, NY. 18-09188, DEBRA MILSTEAD, 18-09300, Plaintiffs: RICHARD LEE ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL Page 156 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *447

For GLORIA HIDALGO, 18-08921, RONNICA WOODARD, 18-9319, TERRI GRAHAM, 18-9364, LAURENT, 18-09221, JOYCE LEWIS, 18-09225, DONNA HATFIELD, 18-9363, YVONNE K. PEGGY [*448] LEWIS, 18-09260, KATHY MABILE, 18- CHRISTOPHERSON, 18-9368, CHERYL A. 09270, KATHERINE MELANCON, 18-09272, Plaintiffs: D'OLIVEIRA, 18-9370, LYDIA LINDSEY, 18-9366, LOIS RICHARD LEE ROOT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORRIS PAYNE, 18-9367, Plaintiffs: STEPHANIE LYNN BART & ASSOCIATES, NEW ORLEANS, LA. RADOS, LEAD ATTORNEY, ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, ST. LOUIS, MO. For DEMETRICE L SCOTT, 18-08922, CATRINA CHASE, 18-9117, JOHN GIBBONS JR., 18-9118, For KATHERINE LOBDELL, 18-08938, KRISTIN Plaintiffs: CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD TEMPLETON, 18-09153, MICHAEL TEMPLETON, 18- ATTORNEY, Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, Melville, NY. 09153, Plaintiffs: ADRIANA SUAREZ DESMOND, LEAD ATTORNEY, SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, SAN FRANCISCO, [*450] CA. For HELEN HENDERSON-HILDEBRAND, 18-8948, LENA JENNINGS, 18-8949, JEROLENE JOSEY, 18- 8950, DEBBIE KHALIQ, 18-8952, HELEN LORAINE For GRETCHEN BECK, 18-08998, TANYA MORRIS, WEAVER, 18-8953, IRIS K. WILSON, 18-8956, TERRY 18-08997, BRENDA MUTTS, 18-08996, LESLIE BOSSERMAN, 18-08941, GAIL BRUENS, 18-08944, MCINNIS, 18-8994, ADELAIDA MENDOZA, 18-8992, DONNA FRANCIS, 18-08945, LAURIE HAWKINS- CAROLE YARMO, 18-9351, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. BELDEN, 18-09021, SHIRLEY LIEURANCE, 18-09024, SIROTKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORELLI LAW FIRM MARGARET JOHNSTON, 18-09131, JANEEN PLLC, NEW YORK, NY. ALMEIDA, 18-9340, CHARLES R. ANGEL, 18-9345, JULIE ANN BENZER, 18-9348, LISA BRADY, 18-9352, For PATRICIA HOUMIEL, 18-09004, DIANE VAZQUEZ, BETH BROCK, 18-9356, ANTHONY BROWNING, 18- 18-09123, Plaintiffs: MICHAEL S. WERNER, LEAD 9365, MARY ANN STONE, 18-09400, JEAN FORMAN, ATTORNEY, PARKER WAICHMAN LLP, PORT 18-09410, MARY GILLESPIE, 18-09411, JUANITA P. WASHINGTON, NY. HANSON, 18-09412, GAY HUGHES, 18-09413, MARIE KAMP, 18-09415, WANDA LADDUSAW, 18-9416, KATHLEEN LUTZ, 18-9417, DEBORA MCDONALD, For CAROL J. BUNDOCK, 18-8973, MICHAEL 18-9418, MARY BETH MUDRICK, 18-9419, Plaintiffs: BUNDOCK, 18-8973, JOANNA J BROWN, 18-09278, BRITTANY SAMANTHA SCOTT, LEAD ATTORNEY, Plaintiffs: CAROLINE THOMAS WHITE, LEAD BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES ATTORNEY, MURRAY LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, PC, MONTGOMERY, AL. LA.

For RUTH BOND, 18-08947, [*449] SHAWNA For KATHLEEN SEYMOUR SWETMAN, 18-9013, KLINGER, 18-08946, BARBARA HINTON, 18-08967, Plaintiff: JOHN C. ENOCHS, LEAD ATTORNEY, SUSAN BOVIDGE, 18-09059, ANNE FAUSTMANN, 18- MORRIS BART LLC, NEW ORLEANS, LA. 09062, MICHELLE HICKS, 18-09063, MARY HOFFMAN, 18-09060, DANIELLE HURST, 18-09061, For JANET MARIE JOHNSON, 18-09020, EDITH BARBARA MAGANA, 18-09064, ANNETTE CLARK, GARRETT, 18-9096, LISA OGLE, 18-9094, MATTHEW 18-9054, SONJA FREDRIC, 18-9067, ELIZABETH OGLE, 18-9094, Plaintiffs: BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR., HART, 18-9074, SANDRA KENT, 18-9055, KATHLEEN LEAD ATTORNEY, Ross Feller Casey LLP, KILBANE, 18-9051, MARTHA MORGAN, 18-9044, Philadelphia, PA. STARLA NEILSON, 18-9069, GRACITA ROBINSON, 18-9072, NANCY SYNDER, 18-9049, LINDA TOLLISON, 18-9065, EFFIE WILLIAMSTON, 18-9050, For CATHERINE BLANKENSHIP, 18-9053, CHARLES KEELA PUGH, 18-09209, LISA QUINION, 18-09211, GRAVES, 18-9053, CLINTON SMITH, 18-9047, KORRI ROOT, 18-09212, QUINTETTE ALFINITO- Plaintiffs: BRIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, RENTA, 18-9311, MARIE BAPPLE, 18-9313, PAMELA CELLINO & BARNES PC, BUFFALO, NY. FRANKLIN, 18-9314, NIKKI JOHNSON-TYNER, 18- 9312, JOHANNE KNOPPEL, 18-9316, KARIE LUCAS, For ELIZABETH KLEIN, 18-9052, ALLAN KLEIN, 18- 18-9310, JAMES MSZYCO, 18-9317, DARLA Page 157 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *450

9052, Plaintiffs: MARILYN T. MCGOLDRICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, THORNTON & NAUMES, BOSTON, MA. For PATRICIA GRAZULIS, 18-09299, Plaintiff: GARY A ANDERSON, LEAD ATTORNEY, ENVIRONMENTAL For PAMELA BURGART, 18-9097, MARY ANN LITIGATION GROUP PC, BIRMINGHAM, AL. DELAVEGA, [*451] 18-9098, PAMELA LEHR, 18-9100, RICHARD ESTABROOK, 18-09122, Plaintiffs: TRENT For SARA NORTON, 18-09304, MARY NUNN, 18- B. MIRACLE, LEAD ATTORNEY, SIMMONS HANLY 9309, WILLIE PATTON, 18-9421, Plaintiffs: CHRISTINE CONROY, ALTON, IL. BRANDT, LEAD ATTORNEY, MORRIS BART LLC, NEW ORLEANS, LA. For THOMAS G. WALTERS, JR, 18-9111, Plaintiff: DANIEL J. THORNBURGH, LEAD ATTORNEY, For YVONNE DYKSTRA, 18-9337, PATRICIA PENSACOLA, FL. BARLOW, 18-9353, WANDA MCDANIEL, 18-9354, KATHY TWOREK, 18-9350, Plaintiffs: DAVID T. For SHANTELL KAAUWAI, 18-09156, Plaintiff: DAVID MATHEWS, LEAD ATTORNEY, GORI JULIAN & B. VERMONT, LEAD ATTORNEY, HELMSDALE LAW ASSOCIATES PC, EDWARDSVILLE, IL. LLP, DURHAM, NC. For BROOKS B WASHBURN, 18-9377, JO ANN NIED For SHEILA ZADEKAS, 18-09134, Plaintiff: DAE YEOL WASHBURN, 18-9377, Plaintiffs: ANDREW FRANK LEE, LEAD ATTORNEY, BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD LLP, SULLO, LEAD ATTORNEY, SULLO & SULLO LLP, NEW YORK, NY. HOUSTON, TX.

For CHARLOTTE PARKER, 18-09177, Plaintiff: M. For CYNTHIA 'CINDY MATRANGA, 18-09394, BRANDON SMITH, LEAD ATTORNEY, CHILDERS MICHAEL J MATRANGA, 18-09394, Plaintiffs: SCHLUETER & SMITH LLC, ATLANTA, GA. MEGHAN ELIZABETH MCCORMICK, LEAD ATTORNEY, LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA. For ROBERT Q. TABOR, 18-09161, Plaintiff: EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, NASS CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. For ANNETTE VEGA MENDOZA, 18-9376, Plaintiff: ALISHA STEPHANIE DAVENPORT. For TAMMY P. TABOR, 18-09161, Plaintiff: CASEY RYAN COBURN, LEAD ATTORNEY, PHILADELPHIA, PA; EDWARD M. NASS, LEAD ATTORNEY, NASS Judges: Freda L. Wolfson, Chief District CANCELLIERE BRENNER, PHILADELPHIA, PA. Judge.

For PAMELA HALL, 18-09193, Plaintiff: STUART LEE GOLDENBERG, LEAD ATTORNEY, GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC, MINNEAPOLIS, MN. Opinion by: Freda L. Wolfson

For BILLENA PORTER, 18-09269, Plaintiff: THOMAS CHRISTOPHER PINEDO, LEAD ATTORNEY, HILLIARD MUNOZ GONZALES LLP, CORPUS Opinion CHRISTI, TX.

For KAREN BROWN, 18-09297, MARY COUGHLIN, WOLFSON, Chief Judge: 18-09298, CAROL PALAZZO, 18-09296, Plaintiffs: Individual consumer-plaintiffs ("Plaintiffs") brought WARREN T BURNS, [*452] LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO product-liability actions in their respective states against HAC VICE, BURNS CHAREST LLP, DALLAS, TX. defendants Johnson & Johnson ("J&J"), Johnson & Page 158 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *452

Johnson Consumer Inc. f/k/a Johnson & Plaintiffs' motions are DENIED. Importantly, the Johnson [*453] Consumer Companies, Inc., reasoning in this Court's Opinion, applies with equal Talc America, Inc. f/k/a Luzenac America, Inc. f/k/a Ro force to the remainder of the pending Daubert motions; Tinto Minerals, Inc. ("Imerys"),1 and Personal Care and, in that regard, the parties are directed to confer Products Council ("PCPC") (collectively, "Defendants"), and raise any issues with respect to specific experts, alleging that the prolonged perineal use of talcum e.g., qualifications, that are not covered by this Opinion, powder products manufactured by J&J has caused within 45 days of the date of the accompanying Order.4 ovarian cancer. Those cases have been transferred to this Multidistrict Litigation ("MDL") by the MDL Panel for pretrial coordination purposes. Plaintiffs' theory of BACKGROUND liability centers on their claim that talcum powder causes ovarian cancer, in substantial part, because it contains The following factual overview is derived from Plaintiffs' traces of cancer-causing asbestos and other heavy Amended Long Form Complaint. J&J manufactures metals. After years of discovery, both parties have certain Baby Powder and Shower to Shower products proffered their experts on various scientific issues that contain talcum powder as their main ingredient. related to, inter alia, causation and testing of talcum Imerys was in the business of mining and distributing powder for asbestos, and each side has moved to talc for use in those J&J products during the relevant 5 exclude the testimony of the other side's experts. time period. PCPC is a national trade association Although each party has named numerous experts, a representing the personal care and cosmetics industry combined total of more than 35 experts, the Court held for the purposes of interacting with and influencing local, a Daubert hearing in which only five experts testified on state and federal government agencies on issues behalf of Plaintiffs, and three experts testified on behalf related to the regulation and marketing of talc based of Defendants.2 In this Opinion, the Court determines body [*455] powders, including J&J talc products. whether these eight experts are qualified [*454] to An inorganic mineral, talc is a magnesium trisilicate that testify in this case and whether their proffered testimony is mined from the . While talc powder is used for is admissible under Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of many different purposes, J&J talc products use talcum Evidence. For the reasons set forth below, Defendants' powder to absorb moisture and to dry when applied motions are GRANTED in part and DENIED in part3 ; on the human body. According to Plaintiffs, J&J advertised and marketed their talc products as safe for

1 During the pendency of these matters, Imerys petitioned for bankruptcy in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the to asbestos. Defendants' motion to exclude Plaintiffs' general District of Delaware. As such, all cases against Imerys have causation experts, Dr. McTiernan, Dr. Clarke-Pearson, and Dr. been stayed as a result of the automatic stay, and no Daubert Carson, is granted in part and denied in part; the general motions have been filed on behalf of Imerys. causation experts will not be permitted to opine as to their theory that ovarian cancer may be caused by the inhalation of 2 The Daubert hearing was held as a result of a number of talcum powder that travels through the lymphatic system to the motions filed by both parties to disqualify each other's experts. ovaries. Rather than calling every expert challenged by the motions, the parties selected certain experts as representatives of each 4 PCPC has joined J&J's Daubert motions to exclude Plaintiffs' field of science involved in this case. The following experts experts. (See PCPC's Mot. to Join & Adopt J&J's Daubert testified on behalf of Plaintiffs: Dr. Ghassan Saed, Dr. William Mots., ECF No. 9721.) In addition, Plaintiffs filed a motion to Longo, Dr. Arch Carson, Dr. Anne McTiernan, and Dr. Daniel disqualify PCPC's epidemiologist, Jonathan Borak, who did Clarke-Pearson. The defense experts who testified are as not testify at the Daubert hearing. Although that motion is not follows: Dr. Benjamin Neel, Dr. Gregory Diette, and Dr. Cheryl addressed here, the reasoning, discussed in this Opinion, as Saenz. to why Plaintiffs' motions to exclude Drs. Neel and Saenz are denied, apply with equal force to PCPC's expert. 3 Defendants' motion to exclude the testimony of Dr. Saed is Nevertheless, if there are any remaining issues as to Dr. granted in part and denied in part; Dr. Saed will not be Borak, the parties may bring it to the Court's attention within permitted to testify that his in vitro study demonstrated a 45 days of the date of the accompanying Order. causal relationship between talc and ovarian cancer. Defendants' motion to exclude the testimony of Dr. Longo is 5 Imerys is the successor or continuation of Luzenac America, granted in part and denied in part; Dr. Longo will not be Inc. and Minerals, Inc. Imerys is legally responsible permitted to opine on the results of his PLM testing nor will he for the conduct of Luzenac America, Inc. and Rio Tinto be permitted to opine as to whether talc users were exposed Minerals, Inc. Page 159 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *455 use by women in the genital area in order to keep skin McTiernan, Carson, and Clarke-Pearson were proffered feeling dry and comfortable. Compl.,¶ 26. In that regard, as experts in epidemiology. Dr. Saed was presented as Plaintiffs claim that J&J touted that its products are an expert in oxidative stress and ovarian cancer. And, "clinically proven gentle and mild." Id. at ¶ 25. finally, Dr. Longo testified on behalf of Plaintiffs as an expert in materials science. Defendants seek to The Complaint details various studies, conducted as disprove such a correlation and presented Dr. Diette as early as 1971, that suggest an association between the an expert in epidemiology, Dr. Neel as an expert in 6 perineal use of talc and ovarian cancer. See Compl., ¶¶ molecular biology, and Dr. Saenz as an expert in 28-33. In fact, according to Plaintiffs, J&J knew the gynecology and oncology. danger of talc as early as the 1970s. Id. ¶ 29; see also Compl., Ex. 8. In that regard, Plaintiffs maintain that Defendants knew of the adverse risks of using talc and DISCUSSION talc-based body powders in the perineal area and developing ovarian cancer, and had a duty to warn about the potential hazards associated with use of those products. Compl., ¶ 50. Distilling Plaintiffs' claims to I. LEGAL STANDARD their essence, central [*456] to this case is whether the use of talcum powder increases the risk of ovarian The admission of expert testimony is governed cancer. In support of their claims, Plaintiffs, first, by [*457] Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, theorize that the presence of asbestos fibers, among which provides that other heavy metals, in talcum powder likely increases A witness who is qualified as an expert by the risk of ovarian cancer. Moreover, Plaintiffs submit knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education that the vast majority of the epidemiological7 studies may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise if: prove a positive and strong correlation of talc use and (a) the expert's scientific, technical, or other ovarian cancer. specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in Plaintiffs seek to prove such a correlation through issue; experts in the areas of epidemiology, biology/oxidative (b) the testimony is based on sufficient facts or stress and ovarian cancer, and materials science. Drs. data; (c) the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods; and 6 Because of talc's alleged carcinogenic properties, studies (d) the expert has reliably applied the principles and continue to be conducted by the scientific community. In fact, methods to the facts of the case. during the pendency of these motions, the parties have updated the Court with a number of studies that have been Fed. R. Evid. 702. It is well-established that "Rule 702 recently released on this topic. Those submissions, however, embodies a trilogy of restrictions on expert testimony: do not alter the Court's Daubert analyses in this Opinion, since qualification, reliability, and fit." Ruggiero v. Yamaha the parties have not requested leave to supplement any expert Motor Corp., U.S.A., 778 F. App'x 88, 93 (3d Cir. 2019) reports based on newly published studies. Rather, because (quoting Schneider ex rel. Estate of Schneider v. Fried, the experts who are the subject of these Daubert motions did 320 F.3d 396, 404 (3d Cir. 2003)). In Daubert v. Merrell not review the newly-released studies in forming their expert Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579, 113 S. Ct. opinions challenged here, I will not consider those studies for the purpose of resolving the pending motions. However, this 2786, 125 L. Ed. 2d 469 (1993), the Supreme Court does not foreclose the possibility that the parties may seek defined the operation and scope of Rule 702 with leave from the Court to supplement an expert's report based respect to expert testimony. The Daubert Court ruled on any new and relevant studies. And, indeed, if such that trial courts must perform a gatekeeping function to supplemental reports impact my Daubert decisions made in ensure the relevance and reliability of expert testimony. this Opinion, I may amend my rulings at a later time. Id. at 589-95. In conducting this analysis, courts are to consider "all aspects of the expert's testing: the 7 Epidemiology is the study and analysis of the distribution methodology, the facts underlying the expert's opinion, (who, when, and where), patterns and determinants of health [and] the link between the facts and the conclusion." ZF and disease conditions in defined populations. Michael D. Meritor, LLC v. Eaton Corp., 696 F.3d 254, 291-92 (3d Green, et al., Reference Guide on Epidemiology, in Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence 549, 551, 623 (Fed. Jud. Ctr., Cir. 2012) (alteration in original) (quoting Heller v. Shaw 3d Ed. 2011) Indus., Inc., 167 F.3d 146, 155 (3d Cir. 1999)). Page 160 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *457

Moreover, courts must ensure that expert admissibility." Feit v. Great-W. Life & Annuity Ins. Co., testimony [*458] reflects accepted standards within the 460 F. Supp. 2d 632, 641 (D.N.J. 2006). relevant scientific and business communities. See In re Johnson & Johnson Derivative Litig., 900 F. Supp. 2d In evaluating whether an expert's particular 467, 492 (D.N.J. 2012) ("[T]he Court's role under Rule methodology is reliable, a trial court may consider any of 702 is to ensure that expert testimony reflects accepted these several factors: (1) whether a method consists of standards within the relevant scientific and business a testable hypothesis; (2) whether the method has been communities—it is not to serve as an umpire between subject to peer review; (3) the known or potential [*460] competing subsets of a given community."). rate of error; (4) the existence and maintenance of standards controlling the technique's operation; (5) The first prong of admissibility considers whether an whether the method is generally accepted; (6) the expert is qualified "to render an opinion when he or she relationship of the technique to methods which have 'possesses specialized expertise.'" In re Human Tissue been established to be reliable; (7) the qualifications of Prods. Liability Litig., 582 F. Supp. 2d 644, 655 (D.N.J. the expert witness testifying based on the methodology; 2008) (quoting Pineda v. Ford Motor Corp.,520 F.3d and (8) the non-judicial uses to which the method has 237, 244 (3d Cir. 2008)). This factor is applied liberally been put. See United States v. Downing, 753 F.2d and "courts have been cautioned not to exclude expert 1224, 1238-39 (3d Cir. 1985); see also Pineda, 520 testimony merely because the court feels that the expert F.3d at 247-48 & n.8; Elcock v. Kmart Corp., 233 F.3d is not the best qualified or that the expert does not 734, 745-46 (3d Cir. 2000) (noting that "each factor possess the most appropriate specialization." Id. need not be applied in every case"). While the court's reliability analysis is focused on the methodology The second prong of admissibility concerns the employed by the expert, as opposed to his or her reliability of the expert's methodology. See Fed. R. Evid. conclusions, the Supreme Court has acknowledged that 702(c). The Third Circuit has explained that "'an expert's "conclusions and methodology are not entirely distinct testimony is admissible so long as the process or from one another." General Elec. Co. v. Joiner, 522 U.S. technique the expert used in formulating the opinion is 136, 146, 118 S. Ct. 512, 139 L. Ed. 2d 508 (1997). reliable." Pineda, 520 F.3d at 244 (quoting In re Paoli Thus, it is acceptable for the court to conduct "at least a R.R. Yard PCB Litig., 35 F.3d 717, 742 (3d Cir. 1994)); limited review of the expert's conclusions 'in order to see also In re TMI Litig., 193 F.3d 613, 663-64 (3d Cir. determine whether they could reliably flow from the facts 1999), amended, 199 F.3d 158 (3d Cir. 2000). This has known to the expert and the methodology used.'" In re been interpreted to mean that an "expert's opinion must Human Tissue, 582 F. Supp. 2d at 656 (quoting Heller be based on the 'methods and procedures of science' v. Shaw Indus., Inc., 167 F.3d 146, 152 (3d Cir. 1999)). rather than on 'subjective belief or unsupported speculation.'" [*459] In re Paoli, 35 F.3d at 742 (quoting The third prong of admissibility, fit, concerns whether Daubert, 509 U.S. at 590); see also Karlo v. Pittsburgh the expert's testimony will be helpful to the trier of fact. Glass Works, LLC, 849 F.3d 61, 81 (3d Cir. 2017) ("'The See Fed. R. Evid. 702(a). The Third Circuit has test of admissibility is not whether a particular scientific explained that "admissibility depends in part on 'the opinion has the best foundation, or even whether the proffered connection between the scientific opinion is supported by the best methodology or research [*461] or test result to be presented and unassailable research.' Instead, the court looks to particular disputed factual issues in the case.'" In re whether the expert's testimony is supported by 'good Paoli, 35 F.3d at 743 (quoting Downing, 753 F.2d at grounds.'" (citation omitted) (quoting In re TMI, 193 F.3d 1237). Whether an expert's testimony meets the fit at 665). In Paoli, the Third Circuit explained that even if requirement "is not always obvious, and scientific the judge believes that "there are better grounds for validity for one purpose is not necessarily scientific some alternative conclusion," or that there are some validity for other, unrelated purposes." Id. (quoting flaws in the scientist's methods, the expert's testimony Daubert, 509 U.S. at 591). should be admitted so long as there are "good grounds" for his or her conclusion. Id. at 744. In that connection, "an expert opinion is not inadmissible because it may II. PLAINTIFFS' EXPERTS contain flaws, nor is it excludable because it provides testimony regarding only one facet or aspect of an The Court will discuss each expert, and the relevant action but does not prove the whole case; such legal issues that pertain to each of them, separately. vulnerabilities affect the weight of the testimony, not its Page 161 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *461

cancer." (Id. at 276.) Accordingly, in the fall of 2017, Dr. A. DR. GHASSAN SAED Saed and his laboratory began an in vitro9 study to explore the role of talc in the carcinogenesis of ovarian cancer. (See Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 116.) Upon completion of the study, Dr. Saed submitted a i. Qualifications manuscript setting forth the results of his study for publication to Gynecologic Oncology, a peerreviewed Plaintiffs proffer Dr. Saed as an expert in inflammation journal, which declined to publish the study. [*463] (Id. and oxidative stress. Dr. Saed is the Director of Ovarian at 67.) Ultimately, Dr. Saed's manuscript was published Cancer Research and an Associate Professor at Wayne in a journal, Reproductive Sciences, after undergoing State University in Detroit, Michigan. (Saed Daubert Hr'g peer review. (Id. at 18.) Tr., at 2.) He serves as a faculty member of the School of Medicine in the departments of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Cell Biology, and Anatomy & Physiology, ii. Dr. Saed's Experiment Design and is also an Associate Professor in the Department of Oncology at Karmanos Cancer Institute in Detroit, In his expert report, Dr. Saed opined that talc, like Michigan. (Id.) Before then, the doctor received a Ph.D. asbestos, is a silicate mineral that has been linked to in Molecular Biology at the University of Essex in have potential carcinogenic effects. (Saed Expert Rep., Colchester, England. (Id.) Dr. Saed's laboratory "studies at 10.) In order to determine whether there is a the effect of oxidative stress, inflammation in the molecular basis for the association between the use of causation of diseases, especially [*462] cancer." (Id.) talcum powder and ovarian cancer, Dr. Saed designed a Indeed, he has purportedly published over 140 peer- cellular experiment wherein he explored talc and its reviewed articles in different specialty journals, over 50 causal connection to the pathogenesis of ovarian cancer of which are "specifically related to oxidative stress and and the relationship between inflammation and other ovarian cancer." (Id.)8 pathological conditions in ovarian cells. (Id. at 13.) A summary of his methodologies is set forth below. In August 2017, Plaintiffs contacted Dr. Saed to "discuss the possibility of acting as a witness expert in ovarian First, Dr. Saed chose six different cells for his cancer[,] inflammation, and oxidative stress." (Saed experiment: 1) three separate types of ovarian cancer Dep. Tr., Jan. 23, 2019, at 25.) Thereafter, Dr. Saed met cells (i.e., SKOV-3, A2780 and TOV112D); 2) human with Plaintiffs' counsel and "agreed in principle to serve macrophage cells; 3) human primary normal ovarian as a consultant for what [he is] an expert in, which is epithelial cells; 4) immortalized human fallopian tube oxidative stress and ovarian cancer, and [he] promised secretory epithelial cells. The cells were grown pursuant to run data, do some work, because [he] wanted to find to each of their respective specifications. (Id.) Second, out if there is molecular evidence to support the effect of the cells were then seeded in 100mm cell [*464] culture talcum powder on the . . . markers for risk of ovarian dishes. After 24 hours, certain cell dishes were treated with a mixture consisting of talcum powder and a solvent, DMSO. The cells were treated with either 0, 5, 20 or 100 ug/ml of the mixture for 72 hours. (Id. at 14.) 8 Defendants do not specifically challenge Dr. Saed's Thereafter, cell pellets were collected for RNA, DNA, qualifications to testify as an expert in his stated specialty of and protein extraction. Cell culture was collected for CA- "inflammation and oxidative stress that is linked to ovarian 125 analysis, as well. cancer." (See Defs.' Br., in Supp. Mot. to Exclude Dr. Saed ("Defs.' Saed Br.,") at 5-6; Saed Dep Tr., Jan. 23, 2019, at 27.) Once the cells were prepared, Dr. Saed performed the Nevertheless, Defendants note in their briefing that Dr. Saed is following tests: not experienced in conducting studies with talc. (Defs.' Saed Br., at 5.) Notwithstanding this position, the Court is satisfied that Plaintiffs have met their threshold burden of demonstrating Dr. Saed's qualifications to testify as an expert in this matter. Simply because Dr. Saed had not previously 9 In vitro is defined as "[a] research or testing methodology that conducted any studies involving talc does not disqualify him uses living cells in an artificial or test tube system, or that is from testifying as an expert with respect to his in vitro study on otherwise performed outside of a living organism." Bernard D. talc, see In re Human Tissue, 582 F. Supp. 2d at 655, and Goldstein & Mary Sue Henefin, Reference Guide on Defendants do not suggest that Dr. Saed is unqualified to Toxicology, in Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence 633, conduct in vitro studies related to oxidative stress. 682 (Fed. Jud. Ctr., 3d ed. 2011). Page 162 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *464

1. Real Time-PCR ("RT-PCR") "to quantify RNA The other way which I like to do in cases like this is expression using redox gene specific primers." to, instead of getting one cell line, divid[ing] it into (Pls.' Saed Br., at 10.) In other words, the cells three, I got six different cell lines and I used them. were subjected to reverse transcriptase, a method So if you find the effect, the same that we found used in order to detect the presence of specific with talcum powder in six different cell lines, it will proteins in the cells. Dr. Saed explained that the be way more powerful than finding this effect in one presence of certain proteins or enzymes is an cell line split into three. indicator that the cell is in a pro-oxidative state, or experiencing oxidative stress. (Saed Expert Rep., (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 50-51.) Further, Dr. Saed at 4.) According to Dr. Saed, those indicators maintained laboratory notebooks of his research, where include, inter alia, ß-actin, CAT, GSR, iNOS, MPO, he, or an assistant, recorded the collected data for each GTX, and SOD3. (Id.) To opine on whether certain assay or test. Dr. Saed explained that his laboratory's cells were experiencing oxidative stress, Dr. Saed instruments are computerized, so all the data is measured the presence of these proteins or collected from "the of the assay machine to a enzymes and recorded the data accordingly. main computer" where the data is transferred to an Excel spreadsheet. (Id. at 19.) The spreadsheet of data 2. Commercially available ELISAs, which "measure for a certain assay is then printed and glued into the redox protein levels and [*465] enzyme activities. experiment's notebook. (Id. at 19-20.) The methodology (Pls.' Saed Br., at 9-10.) Dr. Saed explained that being used for each assay is additionally set forth in the ELISAs are "a well-established technique" and notebook adjacent to the relevant table [*467] of data. were used to measure CA-125, a cancer antigen (See id.) Dr. Saed claims that these practices "are and "marker of inflammation," and the enzymes established methods in [his] laboratory and also very CAT, SOD3, GSR, GPX1, and MPO. (See Saed well known to the scientific research community." (Id. at Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 12, 54; Saed Expert Rep., at 20.) 15.) Based on the collective results of the various assays ran 3. MTT cell proliferation assay, "which is a very by Dr. Saed's laboratory, the relevant literature, and his commonly used assay to measure cell divisions." experience in the field of oxidative stress, Dr. Saed (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 54; Pls.' Saed Br., at 10.) makes several essential conclusions in his report: Cell proliferation "is cell division, but in cancer cell (1) Johnson's Baby Powder elicits an inflammatory division which is uncontrolled." (Saed Daubert Hr'g response in normal ovarian and tubal cells and in Tr., at 56.) ovarian cancer cells that can result in the development and the progression of ovarian 4. Caspase 3 colorimetric assays "to measure cancer. apoptosis and programmed cell death." (Pls.' Saed (2) This pro-carcinogenic process involves oxidative Br., at 10; Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 54.) Apoptosis stress, alteration of the redox environment by is "a programmed cell death that occurs in the body increasing oxidant enzymes and decreasing anti- that eliminates bad cells that develop very single oxidant enzymes, promotion of cell proliferation, minute in our body." (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 56.) inhibition of apoptosis, and induction of specific genetic mutations. 5. Taqman SNP Genotyping Assay, which (3) Johnson's Baby Powder exposure results in "identif[ies] DNA point mutations induced by talcum elevation of CA-125, a clinically relevant biomarker powder treatment." (Pls.' Saed Br., at 10; Saed for ovarian cancer, in normal and ovarian cancer Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 54.) cells. Each of the tests was performed across all six cell lines (4) The molecular effects resulting from Johnson's and the samples, according to Dr. Saed, were assayed Baby Powder exposure exhibit a clear dose- in triplicate. At the Daubert Hearing, the doctor response pattern. explained the concept [*466] of testing in triplicate and (5) In [his] opinion, based on established molecular how he conducted his study: mechanisms for the pathogenesis of [*468] ovarian Triplicate . . . in cell culture as we do it. We do it in cancer (as evidenced in the peer-reviewed scientific one way to take one cell, one plate, and divide it literature and [his] previously published research) into three different plates, and that's considered the and [his] in vitro experiments, Johnson's Baby triplicate. Page 163 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *468

Powder exposure can cause ovarian cancer. at 56-59.) Moreover, Defendants argue that Dr. Saed's study fails to establish any carcinogenic potential of talc (6) In [his] opinion, based on established molecular at the in vitro level. (Id. at 60-64.) mechanisms for the pathogenesis of ovarian cancer (as evidenced in the peer-reviewed scientific Before discussing the reliability of Dr. Saed's study, the literature and [his] previously published research) Court addresses Defendants' contention that the results and [his] in vitro experiments, Johnson's Baby of Dr. Saed's study do not support his opinion that the Powder exposure worsens the prognosis for use of talc causes ovarian cancer. (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g patients with ovarian cancer. Br. 56-64.) Defendants submit that "(1) [Dr. Saed] (Saed Expert Rep., at 20-21.) admitted that he needed to - but did not - conduct animal studies to confirm that his dish findings faithfully replicate what would happen in vivo; and (2) iii. Dr. Saed's Opinion on Talc Use and Ovarian even his conclusions about what he found in his petri Cancer dishes are not supported by the data his experiment generated." (Defs.' Saed Br. at 56.) Defendants challenge the admissibility of Dr. Saed's opinions on multiple grounds. First, Defendants attack In vitro studies, like the one conducted by Dr. Saed, the reliability of certain methods employed by Dr. Saed must have good grounds to reach conclusions regarding and his laboratory in conducting his study. Defendants human results. These particular studies "involve the contend that Dr. Saed's study is unreliable pursuant to examination of disease 'within an [*470] artificial Daubert because (1) he failed to follow his own environment, such as a test tube.'" In re Human Tissue, methods; (2) he failed to use a relevant dose of talc; (3) 582 F. Supp. 2d at 663 (quoting Michael D. Green, et the results of the study were not replicated; and (4) his al., Reference Guide on Epidemiology, in Reference lab notebooks are rife with errors that undermine the Manual on Scientific Evidence 439, 444 (Fed. Jud. Ctr., study. (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br. at 46-56.)10 Second, 2d Ed. 2000)). In that connection, they "are not as Defendants argue that the results of Dr. Saed's study do helpful as either epidemiological or animal studies not support his ultimate [*469] opinions. (Id. at 56-64.) because they are conducted outside of a biological Specifically, Defendants maintain that Dr. Saed's study environment, and the conclusions of these studies will is one step removed from demonstrating causation always remain one step removed from directly providing because it is an in vitro study and the results have not causation." Id.; see also In re Accutane Prods. Liab., been duplicated in either an in vivo or animal study. (Id. 511 F. Supp. 2d 1288, 1294-95 (M.D. Fl. 2007) ("The problem with [the in vitro] approach is also extrapolation—whether one can generalize the findings 10 Defendants additionally challenge Dr. Saed's expert from the artificial setting of tissues in laboratories to testimony based on his alleged failure to properly disclose to whole human beings."). Nevertheless, such studies "can Gynecologic Oncology and Reproductive Sciences that he provide a reliable basis for medical and scientific was retained by Plaintiffs' counsel to act as an expert in this opinions as long as their extrapolations are warranted." matter and that Plaintiffs' counsel funded a portion of his In re Human Tissue, 582 F. Supp. 2d at 663. In other study. (Defs.' Saed Br., at 75-79.) While this argument may words, there must be "good grounds" for the undermine Dr. Saed's credibility as an expert, it does not extrapolation. See Paoli, 35 F.3d at 742. render his study so unreliable as to warrant exclusion under Daubert. See Venus v. Seville Food, LLC, No. 14-2476, 2017 I do not find that Dr. Saed's opinion—that the use of talc U.S. Dist. LEXIS 83115, 2017 WL 2364192, at *17 (D.N.J. causes ovarian cancer—is a supported extrapolation May 31, 2017) (declining to exclude expert testimony based from his in vitro study. In his expert report, Dr. Saed on evidence of bias and instructing defendant that to the extent it sought to challenge the expert's bias, "it is permitted explains that his study (and the related research) to do so on cross-examination"); In re Welding Fume Prods. "demonstrates that talcum powder induces inflammation Liab. Litig., 534 F. Supp. 2d 761, 766 (N.D. Ohio 2008) and alters the redox balance favoring a pro- ("[A]bsent a showing of bias so extreme that exclusion is oxidant [*471] state in normal and [epithelial ovarian appropriate under Daubert, the Court believes that disclosure cancer] cells." (Saed Expert Rep. at 186.) Dr. Saed then of possible financial bias coupled with cross-examination by extrapolates from that finding that talcum powder can the parties is a more appropriate and fine-tuned mechanism cause ovarian cancer. (See id. at 186-87.) However, Dr. for arriving at the truth."). Although relevant, possible bias Saed fails to support his conclusion that such an alone is not a basis for exclusion here, but instead a proper extrapolation is scientifically sound. In his deposition avenue for cross-examination by Defendants. Page 164 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *471 testimony, Dr. Saed candidly admitted that the study did The lack of support for Dr. Saed's extrapolation is not show any "transformation of normal ovarian cells to consistent with, and bolstered by, comments Dr. Saed cancerous cells" because he used immortalized cells received from peer reviewers at Gynecologic Oncology, which "do not transform." (Saed Dep. Tr., Feb. 14, 2019, criticizing his manuscript. One reviewer specifically at 464.) Significantly, Dr. Saed did not "test for actual noted that "[t]he first bulleted highlight, 'Oxidative stress cell transformation." (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 58.) is a key mechanism to the initiation and progression of Instead, Dr. Saed explained at the Daubert hearing that cancer' is not supported by this investigation and should he relied upon apoptosis and proliferation11 as "strong be omitted." (Tersigni Cert., Ex. B-23, at 2.) The indicators of cells on their way to transformation." (Saed reviewer further recommended that an animal study be Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 57.) In that connection, however, Dr. conducted to corroborate Dr. Saed's opinion on ovarian Saed further conceded at his deposition that cell cancer, because "the cell lines studies alone and the proliferation can occur "as a normal response of all increase in CA-125 while intriguing are not sufficiently normal cells to agents." (Saed Dep. Tr., Feb. 14, 2019, convincing." (Id.) A second reviewer pointedly at 264.) And, he acknowledged that he was unable to questioned the conclusions of the study because the determine through his study whether the cell "data do not show, despite the author's claim, any proliferation was simply an acute response to talc, evidence that [the] cells are transformed." (Id. at 3.) because "[i]n cell culture you cannot distinguish Indeed, the second reviewer noted that the study did not between [*472] acute response versus chronic document either "tumor initiation nor progression" and response." (Id.) Dr. Saed's testimony in this regard is highlighted that "[w]hile changes in redox damning to his own conclusion that talc use can potentially [*473] play an important role in tumor ultimately lead to ovarian cancer. biology in general, the present data are insufficient to back up the claim that talcum is central to the development of ovarian cancer." (Id.)

11 Defendants argue that Dr. Saed's data on the proliferation In addition to being unsupported by his study, Dr. analysis was erroneously recorded. Specifically, Defendants Saed's opinions with respect to causation are similarly questioned Dr. Saed at the hearing regarding a ninth line of inadmissible because certain aspects of Dr. Saed's data that appeared in the tables, setting forth an analysis that study render that portion of the opinion unreliable. was not identified in the table's key. (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br. at 49-52; Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 209-21.) While Dr. Saed Defendants argue in their opening brief that Dr. Saed testified that the ninth line of data must have been the control, relied on "irrelevant" cell lines in conducting his in vitro 12 (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 210), that testimony conflicts with study. (Defs.' Saed Br. at 44-46.) Plaintiffs, however, the laboratory notebooks, which appears to indicate that the maintain that the cell lines used by Dr. Saed are seventh line of data was actually disregarded as the control. appropriate because the purpose of Dr. Saed's in vitro (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br. at 50-51.) Indeed, Dr. Saed did not study was not to determine human causation but to provide a satisfactory explanation regarding the type of data "determine the effects of talcum powder on the recorded on the ninth line, and whether in fact, an error had expression of key redox enzymes, CA-125 levels, and occurred. In that regard, it appears that the reliability of the cell proliferation and apoptosis in normal and [epithelial data on cell proliferation is called into question. However, even ovarian cancer] cells." (Pls.' Saed Br. at 39-40.) In his if the relevant data is accurate, Dr. Saed's experiment results study, Dr. Saed used six different cell lines: three with respect to cell proliferation are not admissible, because, as discussed infra, the doctor is not permitted to provide distinct ovarian cancer cells, human macrophage cells, opinion testimony that talc use causes ovarian cancer. This is human ovarian epithelial cells, and immortalized human 13 so, since Dr. Saed, himself, explained that "[p]roliferation is fallopian tube secretory epithelial cells. (Saed Expert cell division, but in cancer cell division which is uncontrolled. Rep. at 13.) So the cells keep dividing without control mechanism." (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 56.) But, as Dr. Saed admitted, the A critical factor in determining the reliability of an in presence of cell proliferation only evidences a degree of cell vitro [*474] study is "whether the test is predictive of in transformation, not that a cell was fully transformed into a cancer cell. (Id. at 57 (testifying that he "found an increase in proliferation in uncontrolled cell division, which is a "strong 12 Defendants do not re-raise this argument in their Post- indicator[] of cells on their way to transformation").) Hearing briefing. Accordingly, the Court need not resolve whether any error occurred when performing the cell proliferation assay, 13 Dr. Saed explained at his deposition that immortalized cells because Dr. Saed is not permitted to testify as to those "do not change unless you really beat them up." (Saed Dep., results. Feb. 14, 2019, at 464.) Page 165 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *474 vivo outcomes related to the same cell or target organ called "critical" to show transformation, the Court further system." Goldstein & Henefin, supra at 646. For finds that his study cannot support his opinion that talc example, in In re Rezulin Products Liability Litigation, can cause ovarian cancer. the district court excluded expert testimony where the experts relied on studies that did not use normal human Relatedly, Dr. Saed's study failed to show actual liver cells to opine that the drug in question caused mutation of relevant single nucleotide polymorphisms silent liver injury in humans; rather, the expert used ("SNPs"). Dr. Saed explains in his expert report that a animal cells. See 369 F. Supp. 2d 398, 429 (S.D.N.Y. SNP "occurs as a result of gene point mutations" and 2005). The Rezulin court determined that those studies that common SNPs "are known to be strongly were not a reliable basis for the expert's opinions. Id. at associated with an altered enzymatic activity in these 430. Here, similarly, the Court finds that Dr. Saed's in enzymes and helps explain the enhanced redox state vitro study is not a reliable basis for his opinion that the that has been linked to several [*476] malignancies, use of talc can cause ovarian cancer in vivo because, including ovarian cancer." (Saed Expert Rep., at 7.) Dr. as Dr. Saed admitted, the cell lines he used did not, and Saed explained that his study "found that if you expose could not, actually transform into cancer cells. normal surface epithelial cells from the ovary to talcum powder 100 micrograms per mill for 72 hours, you get a Furthermore, Dr. Saed's failure to conduct a neoplastic switch in the genome in the DNA sequences that transformation assay14 demonstrates that his findings corresponds to these key enzymes that regulate the with respect to any "cause and effect" relationship redox balance."15 (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 57; see between talc and ovarian cancer are unsupported. In a also Saed Expert Rep., at 19 (finding that "talc treatment "Budget Proposal" created by Dr. Saed in planning his induced gene point mutations that happen to in vitro study, he expressed "Three Aims" for his study. correspond to SNPs in locations with functional effects, (See Cert. of Tersigni, Ex. B-25.) The third aim of the thus altering overall redox balance for the initiation and Budget Proposal sets forth a goal of demonstrating that development of ovarian cancer"). Dr. Saed admits, "[e]xposure to talc results in neoplastic transformation of however, that his treatment of talc showed only an normal ovarian surface epithelial cells." (Id. at 4.) To induction of these mutations and no actual mutation or show such transformation, the Budget Proposal cell transformation occurred. (See Pls.' Saed Br., at 42; provides that a neoplastic transformation assay would Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 58 (noting the "gene mutation be conducted as neoplastic transformation "is critical in is before transformation" and that "[J&J] Baby Powder establishing a cause and effect relationship" between was able to induce mutations in key oxidant enzymes talc and ovarian cancer. (Id.) Dr. Saed, however, did not and antioxidant enzymes . . .").) But, induction does not perform such an assay because, as he explained: equate mutation. While Dr. Saed states that treatment of talc induces certain mutations of relevant SNPs, his I proposed three specific aims [for his study], not study fails to support the notion that those mutations one, three specific aims: Aim 1 to look at the actually occurred, or that any of the cells [*477] were redox [*475] balance change and look at genetic transformed into cancer. Without evidence of mutation mutation. Aim 2, looking at inflammation; Aim 3, of relevant SNPs, the Court finds that this is yet another looking at neoplastic transformation. We started reason why Dr. Saed's opinion that talc can cause one by one. We got convincing evidence from ovarian cancer is unreliable. Aim[s] 1 and 2; and when we did the proliferation and apoptosis, which are strong indicators of cell What is more, Dr. Saed's findings with respect to CA- transformation, we were happy with that finding. We 125 further demonstrate that his opinion with respect to didn't need to do a new transformation assay. ovarian cancer causation is unreliable. Dr. Saed explains in his expert report that his study showed (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 123.) As Dr. Saed's testimony heightened levels of CA-125. (See Saed Expert Rep., at reveals, the tests that he ran showed cell proliferation 19.) CA-125, as explained by Dr. Saed, is a cancer and apoptosis, which "indicated" cell transformation, but the tests did not show whether neoplastic transformation had occurred. As Dr. Saed never conducted the test he 15 Plaintiffs and Defendants further dispute whether cell mutation can even occur in a 72-hour period. (See Defs.' Saed Br., at 48-49; Pls.' Saed Br., at 42.) The Court need not 14 A neoplastic transformation assay is conducted to determine address this dispute because, as explained above, the fact whether "normal ovarian cells chang[ed] into cancer cells." remains that Dr. Saed only showed an induction of cell (See Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 120-21.) mutation and not actual mutation. Page 166 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *477 antigen marker that is used to "monitor patient any trial in this matter that his study demonstrated a link response" to treatment for ovarian cancer. (Saed between use of talcum powder and ovarian cancer. Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 59.) Defendants do not challenge Dr. Saed's finding of increased levels of CA-125 in the treated cells, but dispute whether CA-125 is a clinically ii. Dr. Saed's Conclusion Regarding Talc Use relevant biomarker for showing increased risk of ovarian Causes Cellular Inflammation and Oxidative Stress cancer. (See Defs.' Saed Br., at 73-74.) Indeed, Dr. Saed admitted as much at the Daubert hearing, Having determined that Dr. Saed cannot opine on a testifying that that measurement of CA-125 levels is not causal link between talc use and ovarian cancer, the used to diagnose ovarian cancer and conceding that he Court next determines whether Dr. Saed may opine on knew of no studies that showed an association between the association of the use of talc and cellular oxidative elevated CA-125 levels and increased risk of ovarian stress. In that regard, unlike his opinion on talc use and cancer. (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 144-45.) Ultimately, it ovarian cancer, I find that Dr. Saed's study is sufficiently is apparent [*478] that elevations of CA-125 are not a reliable under Daubert to show that the use of talc may reliable measure of the risk of ovarian cancer resulting cause inflammation and oxidative stress. Dr. Saed's from talc use. This is one of many reasons why Dr. opinion in this regard is based on "methods and Saed's conclusion with respect to ovarian cancer procedures of science," as opposed to his own causation is unsupported by his study.16 subjective beliefs. See In re Paoli, 35 F.3d at 742. Moreover, the Court finds that several of the factors that For all these reasons, the Court finds that Dr. Saed's are to be considered with respect to reliability are opinion that talc causes ovarian cancer is unsupported satisfied by Dr. Saed's testimony: Dr. Saed's experiment by the findings of his study—which can only arguably used [*480] a methodology that consisted of a testable demonstrate that use of talcum powder causes hypothesis; his work was subject to peer-review; and inflammation in ovarian cells. Dr. Saed's extrapolation the methodology is generally accepted in the scientific from inflammation to ovarian cancer is a step too far to community. See id. The Court addresses the arguments constitute a reliable scientific opinion and, therefore, that raised by Defendants as to why Dr. Saed's methods opinion will be excluded from his testimony. Indeed, it is were unreliable, in turn, below. Ultimately, the Court within my discretion to exclude unreliable portions of an finds that Defendants raise issues that go to the weight expert's testimony "[w]hen faced with . . . testimony that of Dr. Saed's testimony, the resolution of which is contains both reliable and unreliable opinions." In re preserved for the factfinder, not for the Court in its Pfizer Inc. Securities Litig., 819 F.3d 642, 665 (2d Cir. capacity as a gatekeeper on a Daubert motion. 2016). The Court need not "'prune away all of the problematic' elements of an expert's proposed testimony Defendants first argue that Dr. Saed's expert opinion is 'to save the remaining portions, however small.'" Id. unreliable because he predetermined his conclusions (quoting Bricklayers & Trowel Trades Int'l Pension Fund before conducting the study and failed to follow his own v. Credit Suisse Sec. (USA) LLC, 752 F.3d 82, 96 (1st methods. Defendants' argument is premised on the Cir. 2014)). But, where "the unreliable portion of an "Budget Proposal" drafted by Dr. Saed, which proposed opinion can be easily distinguished from testimony that three aims for his study. It appears that the Proposal could help the jury, it may be an abuse of discretion to was drafted sometime after Dr. Saed's first meeting with throw out the good with the bad." Id. [*479] (citing City Plaintiffs' counsel in or around August 2017. (See Saed of Tuscaloosa v. Harcros Chems., 158 F.3d 548, 564 Dep. Tr., Jan. 23, 2019, at 25, 276.) The Budget (11th Cir. 1998)). The Court will thus excise only this, Proposal details Dr. Saed's aims and "expectations" for admittedly critical, portion of his proposed testimony his research on the role of talcum powder exposure in because, as set forth below, the Court finds that other ovarian cancer. (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 60-65; Pls.' aspects of Dr. Saed's opinions meet the Daubert Saed Opp. Ex. F.) At the Daubert [*481] Hearing, Dr. standard. In sum, Dr. Saed is not permitted to testify at Saed explained that before his laboratory begins a new project, the laboratory "outline[s] the project in a hypothesis-driven research [budget]." (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 61.) The doctor further explained that this 16 While the Court will not permit Dr. Saed to testify that CA- format is used by federal agencies and follows a 125 evidences cell transformation into ovarian cancer cells, "hypothesis rationale," which asks "what are your based on the Court's findings, infra, he will be permitted to expected results, what do you expect to get; if you don't testify as to his opinion that CA-125 is a marker of get what you expect to get, what is your alternative inflammation. Page 167 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *481 approach, and what is your future direction." (Id. at 61- conclusion that the Court has not permitted Dr. Saed to 62.) In this context, Dr. Saed clarified that "expectation testify, the failure to conduct the assay does not impact doesn't mean this is what I want to get. It means based Dr. Saed's other opinions regarding cell oxidative stress on the results would show positive, this is what we or inflammation for the purposes of Daubert. Indeed, would get, and then we would have a[n] alternative unlike the cases cited by Defendants in support of their approach if our approach doesn't work." (Id. 63-64.) argument, Dr. Saed did not fundamentally alter the way his studies were conducted on an ad hoc basis to Based on the general purpose of the Budget Proposal, I achieve some desired result. See, e.g., Amorgianos v. cannot find that the Budget Proposal, in of itself, reveals Nat'l R.R. Passenger Corp., 303 F.3d 256, 268-69 (2d that Dr. Saed drew his conclusions before conducting Cir. 2002) (excluding expert testimony where expert his study. Indeed, whatever flaws in Dr. Saed's study failed to include in his calculations available data might be borne out at trial, the Budget Proposal is an regarding variables that he stated should be included in internal document used by the laboratory to set forth the any such assessment); Soldo v. Sandoz Pharms. Corp., methodology of the study and its estimated costs. (See 244 F. Supp. 2d 434, 561 (W.D. Pa. 2003) (excluding Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 59-61.) Based on its plain expert testimony where experts inconsistently language, the [*482] expectations proposed in the applied [*484] their stated methodology); Wade-Greux Budget Proposal neither support nor confirm that Dr. v. Whitehall Labs., Inc., 874 F. Supp. 1441, 1460, 29 Saed reached any definitive conclusions regarding the V.I. 206 (D. V.I. 1994) (excluding expert testimony relationship between talcum powder and ovarian cancer where expert failed to conduct certain tests required to before conducting his in vitro study, or that Dr. Saed support his conclusion).17 somehow designed this study to reach certain results. The cases cited by Defendants in support of this Defendants next argue that Dr. Saed's testimony should argument do not lend significant support for their be excluded because Dr. Saed did not "attempt" to use position. In those cases, the proffered experts were a relevant dose when exposing the cell lines to talcum excluded because they signed affidavits setting forth powder. As part of the in vitro study, Dr. Saed testified their conclusions before reading the relevant literature, that his laboratory used doses of talc of "zero, five, 20, see Claar v. Burlington N. R.R. Co., 29 F.3d 499, 502- and 100-micrograms per milliliter."18 (Saed Daubert Hr'g 03 (9th Cir. 1994); or there was clear evidence that the Tr., at 50.) According to Dr. Saed, these doses were expert manipulated data to achieve a specific result, see chosen because they are "similar" to doses used in Snodgrass v. Ford Motor Co., No. 96-1814, 2002 U.S. published studies that discuss "testing talcum powder Dist. LEXIS 13421, 2002 WL 485688, at *12 (D.N.J. and determining whether the powder has a biological Mar. 28, 2002). Here, the mere use of the word "expect" in the Budget Proposal does not establish the necessary result-driven bias to exclude Dr. Saed's opinion under 17 In their Post-Hearing Brief, Defendants additionally take Daubert. issue with the fact that Dr. Saed did not perform "all the tests for redox balance in his proposal" or "single nucleotide Defendants further argue that Dr. Saed's failure to polymorphism ('SNP') testing for BRCA mutations." (Defs.' conduct a neoplastic transformation assay, as written in Post-Hr'g Br., at 47.) While Defendants highlight that Dr. Saed the Budget Proposal, evidences that he failed to adhere did not perform these particular tests, they do not explain how to his own methodology, such that it substantiates the that failure impacts the reliability of Dr. Saed's study, except to unreliability of Dr. Saed's whole study. I disagree. As I suggest that he departed from his "own specified methods." (See id.) Indeed, it is unclear to the Court what impact these discussed above, the lack of neoplastic transformation tests would have had on Dr. Saed's experiments. Rather, is fatal to Dr. Saed's opinion that talc [*483] use causes Defendants are free to explore this issue on cross- ovarian cancer. However, this type of assay has no examination; at this stage, the Court finds it inappropriate to bearing on the doctor's opinion on inflammation and exclude Dr. Saed's testimony, particularly in light of the fact oxidative stress. As already noted, Dr. Saed's that this testing method, which was suggested by Dr. Saed, experiment had three separate aims; while Dr. Saed himself, has not been shown here to be indispensable or failed to conduct the neoplastic transformation, which required by the scientific community. would satisfy aim three of his experiment, it does not 18 render other parts of his study, i.e., conclusions as to Dr. Saed testified that he determined the doses by first the first and second aims, unreliable. Rather, because treating the cells with high levels of talc—starting with 1000 micrograms, then 500 micrograms, and then 200 micrograms. the transformation assay would tend to prove or (Id. at 148.) Dr. Saed then chose the relevant doses used for disprove that talcum powder causes ovarian cancer, a the study. (Id.) Page 168 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *484 effect in cells." (Id. at 50.) Indeed, the published studies that the use of talc can cause ovarian cancer, are are as follows: Shukla, et al., Alterations in Gene excluded as unsupported. Absent that conclusion, the Expression in Human Mesothelial Cells Correlate with question of dose is critical. Courts have generally Mineral Pathogenicity, 41 Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol. determined that "in vitro tests provide useful information 114-123 (2009); Buz'Zard, et al., Pycnogenol reduces about metabolic processes at a cellular level, and may Talc-induced Neoplastic Transformation in Human supplement existing [*487] animal and human data." Ovarian Cell Cultures, 21 Phytother. Res. 579-586 See, e.g., Bourne ex rel. Bourne v. E.I. Dupont de (2007); Akhtar, et al., The Primary role of iron-mediated Nemours & Co., Inc., 189 F. Supp. 2d 482, 496 (S.D. W. lipid peroxidation in the differential cytotoxicity cause by Va. 2002) (citing Allen v. Pa. Engineering, 102 F.3d 194, two varieties of talc nanoparticles [*485] on A549 cells 198 (5th Cir. 1996)). Only where experts extrapolated and lipid peroxidation inhibitory effect exerted by human causation from the results of in vitro studies do ascorbic acid, 24 Toxicology, 1139-1147 (2010); Akhtar, questions of relevant dose arise with respect to the et al., Cytotoxicity and Apoptosis Induction by reliability of the expert's methods. See id. at 498 Nanoscale Talc Particles from Two Different (excluding expert testimony where they relied on animal Geographical Regions in Human Lung Epithelial Cells, and in vitro studies that involved high dosage of the Environ. Tech. (2012). (See Pls.' Saed Br., at 32.) Dr. relevant chemicals and long exposure periods). Here, Saed explained that relying on these studies was helpful because Dr. Saed's study can only be admitted to show in ensuring that he was "right in the range of doses and that the use of talc may cause inflammation in cells, his not using an excessive dose that may kill the cell." Saed failure to use a relevant dosage that mimics actual Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 50.) human use in an in vitro study does not render the study regarding inflammation unreliable. See Feit, 460 F. Nevertheless, on cross-examination during the Daubert Supp. 2d at 641. hearing, the doctor was pressed as to whether those doses he used "are similar to or the same level of Defendants next argue that Dr. Saed's methodology exposure in women who use talc." (Id. at 146.) In was unreliable because he failed to properly replicate response, Dr. Saed conceded that he was not aware of his experiment. (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br. at 48-49.) Dr. the doses of talc that women use in real life. (Id.) Based Saed stated in his manuscript that all assays were on that concession, Defendants contend that Dr. Saed's performed in triplicate. (See Tersigni Cert., Ex. A38, at testimony should not be admitted because he did not 5-7, 9.) As discussed above, Dr. Saed explained that he use a dose similar to that used by women in real life. performed each part of the study in triplicate by dividing (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br. at 46-47.) Plaintiffs counter each cell into three different plates and, further, by that a determination of the relevant dose was not performing each test on six separate cell lines. (See necessary since Dr. Saed's study was never intended to Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 50-51; see also Saed mimic the dose used in humans. (Pls.' Saed Br. [*486] Dep. [*488] Tr., Jan. 23, 2019, at 123-26.) Defendants, at 31-32.) nonetheless, insist that Dr. Saed's purported failure to conduct his experiment in triplicate, and in a manner The Court does not find Defendants' argument consistent with how their own experts would conduct the persuasive. First, Defendants do not suggest what experiment, renders his study unreliable and impossible specific doses would have been appropriate for the to reproduce. Plaintiffs respond that Dr. Saed did purpose of Dr. Saed's testing. Indeed, Defendants do conduct his experiments in triplicate and that his study not dispute that the doses used by Dr. Saed were can be reproduced. (Pls.' Saed Br. at 37-39.) While appropriate in conducting his in vitro study on cellular there can be no doubt that replication is an important inflammation or oxidative stress. On this issue, part of the scientific process, the Court is satisfied that Defendants' own expert, Dr. Brooke Mossman, a Dr. Saed's methods, in this regard, are reliable under toxicologist, testified that the doses used by Dr. Saed Daubert. are "appropriate concentration levels to determine pathogenicity of asbestos and talc." (Mossman Dep., at Dr. Saed's testimony demonstrated that the specific 355-358.) Rather, Defendants take issue with Dr. Saed's triplicate methodology he used was based on known failure to use a dose that would mimic the amount of talc scientific methods and was regularly conducted by his that a woman uses. But, that apparent failure does not laboratory. (See Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 51-52.) render the doctor's opinion on inflammation or oxidative Indeed, Dr. Saed testified that he had published peer- stress unreliable. As discussed above, portions of Dr. reviewed studies that employed the same triplicate Saed's testimony that pertain to human causation, i.e., methodology. (See id. at 52.) Most critically, the Court Page 169 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *488 reiterates that the article, written by Dr. Saed and Finally, Defendants argue that errors and published in Reproductive Sciences, that discusses the inconsistencies in Dr. Saed's laboratory notebooks in vitro study at issue was peer reviewed, and the further indicate the unreliable of his in vitro study, methodology was not a concern of those who reviewed because these errors make it "impossible to replicate his the article.19 The fact that [*489] a study has been work." (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br. at 49-56.) For example, subject to peer review "does not equate with reliability," Defendants identify the following issues with Dr. Saed's but it does suggest that good science was used by the laboratory notebooks: (1) use of white-out throughout authors. Oddi v. Ford Motor Co., 234 F.3d 136, 145 (3d the notebooks; (2) errors in certain calculations; and (3) Cir. 2000) (quoting Daubert, 509 U.S. at 593); see also missing pages. (Id. at 49-55.) Dr. [*491] Saed testified Daubert, 509 U.S. at 593 ("[S]ubmission to the scrutiny at length regarding his laboratory notebooks during both of the scientific community is a component of 'good his deposition and the Daubert hearing.21 science,' in part because it increases the likelihood that substantive flaws in methodology will be detected."). I find that the fact that Dr. Saed's study was peer 20 In addition to the arguments set forth, supra, Defendants reviewed, suggests that the triplicate methodology is additionally assert that Dr. Saed's study is unreliable because based on "good science." he "failed to use valid controls." (Defs.' Saed Br., at 37.) Although this argument is raised in their moving brief, Defendants, nonetheless, argue that Dr. Saed's Defendants did little to cross-examine Dr. Saed on this issue triplicate procedure was wrong. Defendants do not, at the Daubert hearing and do not focus on it in their post- however, cite to any scientific support for this assertion. hearing brief. (See Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 148-51.) In their Rather, Defendants refer to the Court a single statement view, Dr. Saed improperly treated certain cells with dimethyl from one of their experts, Dr. Mossman, who, without sulfoxide ("DMSO") without "rul[ing] out the possibility that citation or elaboration, provides in her expert report that DMSO and talc interacted in a way that skewed the results" Dr. Saed failed to perform his experiment in triplicate. (id. at 36-38), and for allegedly failing to incorporate other (See Defs.' Saed Br., at 43 & n.120 (quoting Mossman "negative controls such as glass beads, cornstarch, or other inert substances to verify that the alleged changes in protein Expert Rep., at 33).) Moreover, although Dr. Neel, a levels and DNA are caused by exposure to talc specifically, rebuttal expert to Dr. Saed, heavily criticizes Dr. Saed's rather than exposure to foreign particulate matter generally." in vitro study, Dr. Neel's report does not provide any (Id. at 39-41.) However, as Plaintiffs point out, and which explanation as to the purported flaws of the triplicate Defendants do not dispute, DMSO is a "universal solvent" methodology. Indeed, Dr. Neel's testimony at [*490] the typically used in the scientific community as a control in in vitro Daubert hearing on this issue is similarly limited; he studies. In fact, Defendants' own expert admitted this fact. testified as to his understanding of how to conduct an (See Boyd Dep., at 36.) Dr. Saed explained that if there were experiment in triplicate, but he did not comment upon, or any unusual interactions with DMSO and talc, he would have explain why, the methodology used by Dr. Saed was been able to observe such interactions by the design of his flawed. (See Neel Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 308-09.) Without experiments, and the doctor testified that no such interactions any evidence that Dr. Saed's triplicate methods are occurred. (See Saed Dep., Jan. 23, 2019, at 272-73.) In somehow contrary to those used in the scientific addition, Dr. Saed claims that for the purposes of his experiment, he did not include any negative control such as community, the Court has no basis to find that those cornstarch or glass beads. (Id.) Essentially, the points raised methods were unreliable. To the extent Defendants' by Defendants with respect to Dr. Saed's choice of controls go experts may disagree with Dr. Saed's triplicate not to the reliability of his methodology but to the weight of his methodology, the Court is faced with a classic battle of testimony, because they reflect mere disagreements over the the experts scenario. See United States v. W.R. Grace, controls used by Dr. Saed. See W.R. Grace, 455 F. Supp. 2d 455 F. Supp. 2d 1196, 1199 (D. Mont. 2006) ("It is not at 1199. the Court's role to settle scientific disputes."); see also Dzielak v. Whirlpool Corp., No. 12-0089, 2017 U.S. Dist. 21 Defendants additionally contend that Dr. Saed altered his LEXIS 39232, 2017 WL 1034197, at *26 (D.N.J. Mar. methodology after receiving comments from a peer reviewer at 17, 2017).20 Gynecologic Oncology. (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 55.) Defendants explain that Dr. Saed's manuscript and initial reports stated that he treated cells with talc for 48 hours. (Id.; see also Tersigni Cert., Ex. A38, at 1.) Dr. Saed's expert report 19 As discussed supra, the reviewers at Gynecologic Oncology and final published manuscript, however, state that the cells criticized certain aspects of Dr. Saed's in vitro study. However, were treated for 72 hours. (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 55.) Dr. those criticisms did not involve the triplicate methodology used Saed explained that this was "an error in the actual by Dr. Saed. manuscript" and that no such error appeared in his laboratory Page 170 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *491

Defendants point out the improper use of whiteout in Dr. (Id.) Dr. Saed explained that this was not his ordinary Saed's laboratory notebooks. While admitting that using practice of maintaining laboratory notes, but that the whiteout in laboratory notebooks is not "proper missing pages had no substantive effect on his study laboratory practice," (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 177), Dr. because they "are completely for a different [*493] Saed testified that whiteout was used only where the project." (Id. at 33-34.) Moreover, to the extent that methodology was written out, and he emphasized that handwritten methodologies were replaced with the there was "no white-out in any of the original data." (Id. computer-generated data, Dr. Saed explained that such at 178.) Indeed, on cross-examination, defense counsel data is glued into the notebooks once the calculations reviewed several instances in which whiteout was used are completed. (Id.) with Dr. Saed. (See id. at 177-82.) These instances included (1) an entry where "Johnson & Johnson" was Certainly, each of these issues calls into question the written over whiteout; (2) an entry where a reference to credibility of Dr. Saed's testimony as to his explanations the sterilization method used was written over whiteout; of these errors, but they do not fundamentally (3) an entry where the name of a cell line used was undermine the methodologies Dr. Saed utilized when whited-out and rewritten below the whiteout; and (4) conducting the cell line testing, itself. While these errors, several entries where part of the date entry was whited- taken together, may well impact whether Dr. Saed out. (Id.) exercised good practices and his credibility, especially since certain mistakes were admitted by Dr. Saed to be Defendants also note computation errors that appear in improper laboratory conduct, the laboratory notebooks Dr. Saed's laboratory notebooks. (See id. at 183-85.) clearly disclosed the methods and procedures used in For example, at the Daubert hearing, defense counsel conducting the experiment. Cf. Rembrandt Vision highlighted an erroneous [*492] average calculation in Techs., L.P. v. Johnson & Johnson Vision Care, Inc., a table measuring glutathione reductase ("GPX") levels 282 F.R.D. 655, 667 (M.D. Fla. 2012), aff'd 725 F.3d of the cell lines. (See Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 184; 1377 (11th Cir. 2013) (excluding expert testimony where Tersigni Cert., Ex. B-13 at 122.) For a particular cell line, expert "failed to document and disclose the procedures the average of 2.17, 2.46, and 2.39 was listed as 2.47. he used to conduct tests").22 While Defendants point out (See Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 184; Tersigni Cert., Ex. these errors, what this Court lacks is how these errors B-13 at 122.) Dr. Saed explained that these impacted the reliability of the conducted studies such computations are conducted by a computer program that I must exclude Dr. Saed's opinion wholesale. that determines what outliers should be excluded. (Saed Indeed, having reviewed the multiple entries of the Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 184-87.) notebooks, I find that careless mistakes [*494] and shoddy record keeping occurred. They do not indicate, Finally, with respect to missing pages in his laboratory however, that the actual data collected from the cell notebooks, Dr. Saed explained at the hearing that lines were unreliable or somehow altered in bad faith. certain pages had been removed from the notebooks by As such, these issues go to the weight of Dr. Saed's a new research assistant who "was not familiar with the opinion and the credibility of his testimony. Crowley v. . . . normal practice of lab notebooks." (Id. at 33.) Dr. Chait, 322 F. Supp. 2d 530, 540 (D.N.J. 2004) ("Daubert Saed explained that does not require that an expert's testimony be excluded She wanted to keep everything related to talcum simply because he admitted . . . his own mistakes or powder in one notebook. So she started a different retracted his false statements."); see also Oddi, 234 project in those two pages. So she decided to take F.3d at 145-46 (the test of admissibility is not whether a them out. I instructed her not to do it. This is very particular scientific opinion has the best foundation or bad laboratory conduct. whether it is demonstrably correct); Mahli, LLC v. Admiral Ins. Co., No. 14-175, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 108754, 2015 WL 4915701, at *7 (S.D. Miss. Aug. 18, notebooks." (Saed Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 38.) Dr. Saed testified 2015) (holding that any miscalculations or inaccuracies that "trainees[,] like clinical residents and fellows" draft the go to the weight of the expert's opinions, not its manuscript and he later reviews and corrects any errors that do not match what is in the laboratory notebooks." (Id. at 38- 39.) The Court has reviewed Dr. Saed's laboratory notebooks and finds that the data in the notebooks confirms that the cell 22 See also Hanson v. Colgate-Palmolive Co., 353 F. Supp. 3d lines were treated for 72 hours. (See Tersigni Cert., Ex. B13 at 1273, 1284-85 (S.D. Ga. 2018) (excluding expert's testimony 26 (setting forth methodology and stating that "after 72 hours where he failed to record the location of fibers alleged to be treatment, collect cells and medium for ELISA").) asbestos found in talc). Page 171 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *494 admissibility); Aetna Inc. v. Express Scripts, Inc., 261 engineering; and Ph.D. in materials science and F.R.D. 72, 81 (E.D. Pa. 2009) ("'[F]laws' in an expert's engineering from the University of Florida. (Longo investigative process do not render the opinion Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 441.) Dr. Longo explained that excludable. An expert's opinion is suspect when it is materials science "is literally the study of materials[,] based on a 'subjective belief' or 'unsupported both to characterize them, to understand them, and to speculation' but remains admissible so long as the develop new materials." (Id.) Dr. Longo is currently the process used by the expert is reliable."); Southwire Co. president of Materials Analytical Services ("MAS"), a v. J.P. Morgan Chase & Co., 528 F. Supp. 2d 908, 935 company that tests materials for asbestos, among other (W.D. Wis. 2007) (finding that "alleged errors and substances. (Id. at 441, 447.)23 In the late 1980s and inconsistencies are grounds for impeaching the early 1990s, Dr. Longo served on the Environmental credibility of the experts . . . however, mistakes and Protection Agency ("EPA") peer review group for the miscalculations are not grounds for excluding EPA's asbestos engineering program. (Id. at 449.) In evidence"); Phillips v. Raymond Corp., 364 F. Supp. 2d that capacity, Dr. Longo collaborated on the creation of 730, 743 (N.D. Ill. 2005) (noting that miscalculations and the American Society for Testing of Materials ("ASTM") inaccuracies [*495] in an expert's testimony go to protocol for testing asbestos materials with a weight); Astra Aktiebolag v. Andrx Pharms., Inc., 222 F. transmission electron microscope [*497] (ASTM-5755). Supp. 2d 423, 493-94 (S.D.N.Y. 2002) (finding that the (Id. at 452.) There is no dispute that Dr. Longo is fact that expert's test results had very high standard qualified to testify as an expert on the issue of whether deviation went to weight, not admissibility); In re TMI the subject talc products contain asbestos. I will note at Litigation Cases Consolidated II, 911 F. Supp. 775, 813 the outset that while Defendants repeatedly reference (M.D. Pa. 1996) (the potential rate of error of expert's Dr. Longo's status as a "professional expert," the fact study goes to weight to be accorded the testimony). that he testifies on behalf of plaintiffs regularly raises Indeed, serious questions have been raised by questions of his credibility, rather than his expertise, Defendants which a jury will have to weigh. which are reserved for the factfinder. See In re Paoli, 35 F.3d at 753-54. In conclusion, the Court will admit the testimony of Dr. Saed, but subject to the limitations outlined above. In this proceeding, Dr. Longo and MAS tested 72 While Dr. Saed's opinion may not be "supported by the historical talc samples from J&J and Imerys from the best methodology or available research," Karlo, 849 1960's, 1970's, 1980's, 1990's, and the early 2000's for F.3d at 81, or without flaws, I ultimately conclude that in asbestos using two methods: transmission electron light of my limited role as gatekeeper on a Daubert microscope ("TEM") and polarized light microscope motion, the flaws in Dr. Saed's testing and record ("PLM"). (Longo 2d Supp. Rep., Feb. 1, 2019, at 2, 5; keeping do not so undermine the reliability of the see also Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 473-75.) In short, doctor's opinion as to warrant exclusion. Defendants after performing these tests, Dr. Longo found that have not presented sufficient grounds on which the "[t]here was a total of 50 positive containers ([TEM] and Court can find that Dr. Saed's opinions, other than his PLM combined) out of the 72 tested that gave an overall cursory conclusion that the use of talc can cause 69 % positive result for the historical [Johnson's Baby ovarian cancer, are not "good science" or otherwise Powder/Shower to Shower] containers and Imerys' "inadmissible junk science." The potential flaws in Dr. railroad car samples that were tested for [Dr. Longo's] Saed's lab practices and the study may well negatively report." (Longo 2d Supp. Rep., at 32.) Based on this impact the weight that a factfinder gives to Dr. Saed's testimony, Dr. Longo opines that [*498] "individuals that opinions, [*496] but those flaws may be tested by used Johnson & Johnson talcum powder products cross-examination, and do not warrant exclusion of Dr. (Johnson's Baby Powder and Shower to Shower) in the Saed's testimony. past, would have, more likely than not, been exposed to significant airborne levels of both regulated amphibole asbestos and fibrous (asbestiform) talc." (Id.) B. Dr. William Longo

Plaintiffs present Dr. Longo as an expert in materials science, who will testify as to the presence of asbestos 23 in Defendants' talc products. Dr. Longo received a Plaintiffs have also designated Dr. Longo's former-assistant, Mark Rigler, as a potential expert in this matter as the Bachelor of Science in microbiology, with a minor in coauthor of Dr. Longo's expert report. (See Longo Daubert chemistry; a Master of Science in materials science and Hr'g Tr., at 597-98.) Page 172 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *498

Having considered the parties' arguments and Dr. alleged cause of ovarian cancer) from cleavage Longo's Daubert hearing testimony, I find that Plaintiffs' fragments (which no scientific literature has linked to have met their burden of demonstrating that the doctor's ovarian cancer)." (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 33.) testimony regarding the results of his TEM analysis is Defendants' argument in this regard is based on their reliable for the purposes of admission under Daubert. disagreement with the "counting rules" used by Dr. See Crowley, 322 F. Supp. 2d at 537 ("The proponent Longo in the morphology step of the TEM method. (See bears the burden of establishing admissibility by a id. at 33-34.) preponderance of the evidence.") Indeed, the Court finds that Defendants' arguments in support of excluding The EPA AHERA regulations identify as asbestos any of Dr. Longo's testimony, as to his testing, more the designated asbestos minerals (i.e., tremolite, appropriately go to the application of his methodologies, actinolite, or anthophyllite) that are fibrous; the rather than their reliability. However, with two critical regulations specify that a mineral is fibrous if it has 1) exceptions as detailed infra, the Court excludes Dr. parallel sides; 2) is at least .5 microns in length; 3) and Longo's testimony to the extent he bases his opinions has an aspect ratio of 5-to-1 or greater. (See Longo on his PLM analysis or opines on the exposure of talc Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 467-69.) Defendants argue that Dr. users to asbestos. Longo should not have relied upon these regulations, because they were "not designed to distinguish between The Court first addresses the reliability of Dr. Longo's asbestos and cleavage fragments,"24 and were [*501] TEM methodology. Dr. Longo testified that he followed instead intended "for asbestos remediation in school the three-step TEM [*499] method, a scientifically buildings, where there is no question that the building accepted method when analyzing a material to previously contained asbestos." (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at determine whether it contains asbestos. (Id. at 487.) 34.) Defendants posit that because these regulations The first step—morphology—involves measurement of are not "designed" to distinguish cleavage fragments "the dimensions of the fiber or bundle of asbestos." (Id. from asbestiform, Dr. Longo's use of the regulations at 488.) The second step is "called energy dispersive X- regarding "counting" is unreliable. ray analysis [("EDXA") which] determine[s] the chemistry of that particular asbestos structure." (Id.) At the outset, the Court finds that Dr. Longo's reliance Finally, the third step is "what's called selected area on the AHERA regulations does not render his opinion electron diffraction or SAED, which gives you unreliable. While Defendants contend that the AHERA information on the crystalline structure of that asbestos regulations should not be followed in a situation, such structure." (Id.) Defendants do not challenge the as this, where it is not known whether asbestos is reliability of the three-step TEM methodology. That present in the test subject, Defendants do not identify methodology is a generally accepted method in the different "counting rules" that should be used, or point to scientific community and is recommended by the EPA any other specific rules used by the scientific community Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act ("AHERA"), under these circumstances; this is fatal to their (see Asbestos-Containing Materials in Schools argument. See In re Air Cargo Shipping Servs. Antitrust ("AHERA Regs."), 52 Fed. Reg. 41826 (Oct. 30, 1987) Litig., MDL No. 1775, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 180914, (to be codified at 40 C.F.R. pt. 763)); ISO Methods 2014 WL 7882100, at *17 (E.D.N.Y. Oct. 15, 2014) 22262-1 and -2, (see Cert. of Tersigni, Ex. A74 (ISO (finding that the mere fact a party disagrees with an 22262-1); id., Ex. A75 (ISO 22262-2)); and the expert's methodology is not a basis for exclusion under American Society for Testing Materials ("ASTM") Daubert), report and recommendation adopted, 2015 Standard 5755. Notably, Defendants have employed the U.S. Dist. LEXIS 90402, 2015 WL 5093503 (E.D.N.Y. same three-step TEM analysis for testing their own talc July 10, 2015); In re Heparin Prods. Liab. Litig., 803 F. products for asbestos. (See Johnson & Johnson, Supp. 2d 712, 733-34 (N.D. Ohio 2011) (holding that Analysis of Powdered [*500] Talc for Asbestiform "[t]he fact that different studies [have] obtained different Minerals by Transmission Electron Microscopy, Mar. 8, results does not render [the expert's] opinions 'junk 1989, Pls.' Hr'g Binder, Tab 6.) science[,]'" so long as the results are [*502] the product

Instead, Defendants take issue with Dr. Longo's application of the three-step TEM method. First, 24 A cleavage fragment is a crushed-up piece of non- Defendants maintain that "Dr. Longo's hearing asbestiform rock. (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 569.) Dr. Longo testimony made clear that his TEM methodology failed testified that "a true cleavage fragment is not asbestos," but to distinguish asbestos particles or asbestiform (an cleavage fragments may meet the AHERA counting rules. (Id. at 569.) Page 173 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *502 of reliable methods). steps two and three of the TEM eliminate most of those fragments based on their chemistry and electron I stress that, as the Supreme Court has advised, "[t]here diffraction pattern. (See also id. at 502 (explaining that are no certainties in science," Daubert, 509 U.S. at 590, an analyst would not identify a fiber until all three TEM and establishing reliability does not require Plaintiffs to steps have been completed); id. at 517 (stating that a prove that the assessments of their experts are correct. fragment would not be identified as asbestos if "[i]t See id. Perceived weaknesses in Dr. Longo's methods, doesn't meet one of [the] criteria, the morphology, the such as those identified here by Defendants, go to EDXA, the chemistry, or the electron diffraction weight rather than to admissibility, particularly since Dr. pattern"); see also id. at 578.) Defendants' position on Longo has published numerous peer-reviewed studies this issue does not take into account that steps 2 and 3 in which he applied the AHERA "counting rules" in of the TEM seek to eliminate certain fibers, which are situations where the substances were not previously counted in step 1, that are not asbestos. But, more confirmed to contain talc. (See Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., importantly, Defendants do not challenge whether Dr. at 489-96). The Court finds that Dr. Longo's reliance Longo performed his counting in accordance with the upon the AHERA regulations to designate asbestos AHERA counting rules. Indeed, those rules do not minerals does not render his opinions unreliable. eliminate the possibility that cleavage fragments could be included in step 1. Again, Defendants make no Next, Defendants dispute Dr. Longo's utilization of the suggestion that there are other scientific methods which AHERA "counting rules" because, they argue, the should have been used in counting asbestos fibers in regulations do not appropriately distinguish between this instance. [*505] Instead, Defendants take issue asbestiform and cleavage fragments, which permits Dr. with the rules themselves. In other words, Defendants Longo to include in his findings of what is "asbestos," contend the AHERA counting rules are not accurate, but minerals that do not meet the "universal" definition of yet, they do not identify to which set of rules Dr. Longo asbestos, i.e., the "asbestiform version of six regulated should have adhered. What this boils down to is that minerals"—chrysotile, crocidolite, amosite, Defendants raise a scientific disagreement that is not for tremolite, [*503] anthophyllite, and actinolite. (Defs.' the Court to decide in its capacity as a gatekeeper Asbestos Br., at 6, 26.) Defendants further argue that under Daubert. See, e.g., W.R. Grace, 455 F. Supp. 2d while Dr. Longo accepts the universal definition of at 1199 ("It appears that there is some scientific asbestos, the AHERA "counting" rules he applies in his disagreement as to the dangerousness of cleavage study "sweep[] in minerals that cannot be asbestos," fragments and as to how these fragments should be including cleavage fragments. (Id. at 29.) Plaintiffs treated when performing asbestos sampling. It is not the counter that Dr. Longo's method was not overinclusive Court's role to settle scientific disputes."); see also Broe because he "eliminated non-asbestos fibers that did not v. Manns, No. 15-985, 2016 WL 7048988, at *4 (M.D. meet the requisite morphological criteria" and Pa. Dec. 5, 2016) ("Any disagreement plaintiffs have subsequently "subjected the fibers to further analysis by with the expert can be dealt with through cross- SAED and EDXA to confirm they are asbestos." (Pls.' examination, presentation of contrary evidence and Post-Hr'g Br., at 62.) proper jury instructions."); In re Gabapentin Patent Litig., Fundamentally, the dispute between the parties is their MDL Dkt. No. 1384, 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 158494, disagreement over what fibers should be identified as 2011 WL 12516763, at *10 (D.N.J. Apr. 8, 2011) "asbestos." Defendants take the view that the "counting (concluding that disagreement between experts rules" of the AHERA regulations are, when applied in regarding application of a methodology presents "a this instance, overly broad, such that cleavage battle of the experts" to be resolved by the trier of fact); fragments are counted as asbestos when they are not. In re Asbestos Prods. Liab. Litig., 714 F. Supp. 2d 535, On this issue, Dr. Longo explained that during the first 544 (E.D. Pa. 2010); In re Diet Drugs Prods. Liab. Litig., step of the TEM testing, the purpose is to count the MDL No. 1203, 2000 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 9661, 2000 WL number of asbestos fibers contained in the talc sample 962545, at *13 (E.D. Pa. June 28, 2000) (finding that by utilizing the AHERA counting rules. Because certain disagreement with the methods used by an expert is a cleavage fragments do in fact resemble asbestos fiber, question that "goes more to the weight of the evidence Dr. Longo agrees [*504] that—at the first step—certain than to reliability for Daubert purposes"). cleavage fragments could be counted as asbestos in accordance with the rules. (See Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., In short, I find that the three-step TEM method applied at 577-78.) However, Dr. Longo goes on to explain that by Dr. Longo, [*506] and his reliance on the AHERA counting rules, were reliable; thus, any disagreement Page 174 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *506 with those rules is a question for the jury. See Walker v. that the analysts who conducted the testing had "no Gordon, 46 F. App'x 691, 695-96 (3d Cir. 2002). Indeed, objective way of determining whether a particle is a the role of this Court on a Daubert motion is "simply to single fiber or bundle." (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 36.) evaluate whether the methodology used by the expert is reliable, i.e., whether, when correctly employed, that The Court again finds that these issues go to the weight methodology leads to testimony helpful to the trier of of Dr. Longo's opinions, rather than reliability. The fact." Id. at 695. Accordingly, the Court declines to genesis of Defendants' argument in this context is that exclude Dr. Longo's testimony on the grounds that he Dr. Longo's counting method is inaccurate when it improperly counted cleavage fragments as asbestos at comes to differentiating between bundles and fibers of step 1 of the TEM method. asbestos. They illustrate the inconsistencies by comparing different images of asbestos structures from Related to their argument regarding inadequacies in the Dr. Longo's expert reports and argue that one report AHERA counting rules, Defendants also argue that the classifies certain structures as a fiber, and in the prevalence of "bundles" of asbestos fibers in Dr. supplemental report, those similar structures [*508] are Longo's step 1 analysis underscores the unreliability of identified as bundles. Putting aside the inconsistencies, his methods. (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 35-36.) A the AHERA counting rules, as iterated above, group bundle is defined by the EPA as "[a] structure composed bundles and fibers alike as asbestos. Simply stated, the of three or more fibers in a parallel arrangement with rules call for the counting of both structures as each fiber closer than one fiber diameter." AHERA asbestos. Indeed, Dr. Longo's explanation in this regard Regs., 52 Fed. Reg. at 41858. The AHERA counting is consistent with the purpose of the rules; he testified rules provide that asbestos structures may be that distinguishing between a fiber and a bundle is one designated as "fibers, bundles, clusters, or matrices." Id. of the more difficult aspects of the TEM analysis. But, at 41867; see also Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 524 ("One whether a particular asbestiform is a fiber or bundle is not more asbestos than the other. It is all regulated does not make any qualitative difference since they are asbestos [*507] if it is a fiber bundle or what have both asbestos. (See Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 528 you."). Of the asbestos fibers found in the historical talc (stating that it does not "make a difference whether it is samples examined by Dr. Longo, 93 % of identified a fiber or bundle in terms of whether it is asbestos").) asbestiform are designated as bundles. (Longo Daubert Significantly, Defendants do not express any views on Hr'g Tr., at 592.) Defendants' challenge to Dr. Longo's how the purported inconsistency between the finding of bundles is twofold: (1) the increased differentiation of bundles and fibers impacts Dr. Longo's prevalence of bundles in Dr. Longo's supplemental overall test results about the quantity of asbestos found expert report constitutes a sudden reversal of opinion in any given historic sample of talc. In fact, Defendants that undermines the reliability of his testimony,25 and (2) do not dispute that bundles and fibers are both asbestiform that must be counted under AHERA regulations. In short, because bundles and fibers are both qualitatively asbestos, to challenge the 25 Notably, in a report from March 2018, referenced by reliability [*509] of Dr. Longo's testing results, Defendants, with respect to testing conducted on Defendants' Defendants must explain how the inconsistency impacts products, Dr. Longo states that 53% of the identified asbestos the overall study. Simply pointing out that certain were counted as bundles. (See Tersigni Cert., Ex. E14; see asbestiform should be counted as bundles rather than also Tersigni Cert., Ex. E26, at 153.) In that report, Dr. Longo tested 30 talc samples that had been provided to him by fibers and vice versa, does not somehow impugn Dr. various law firms. (See Tersigni Cert., Ex. E14, at 4.) Then, in Longo's analysis under step 1 of the TEM. Dr. Longo's expert reports in this MDL proceeding, he classified 96% of the counted asbestos as bundles. (See Moreover, regarding the identification of bundles and Longo 2d Supp. Rep., Feb. 1, 2019, at 25.) Importantly, in fibers, Defendants argue that Dr. Longo and his preparation for the MDL reports, Dr. Longo tested different historical samples that were provided by Defendants. (See id. samples constitutes a change in opinion. I note that during the at 2 ("The J&J and Imerys' containers and samples analyzed Daubert hearing, Dr. Longo attempted to address this very for this report were all supplied by both J&J and Imerys from issue, however, counsel did not provide the doctor the their historical inventory.").) In that respect, Defendants' opportunity to explain this purported discrepancy. (See Longo position does not take into account that each of these rounds Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 592-94.) Hence, in resolving this question, of testing were conducted on different talc samples. the Court painstakingly reviewed all of Dr. Longo's past reports Accordingly, the Court does not find that the fact Dr. Longo submitted by the parties, including the ones prepared for the reported different numbers of bundles from different talc MDL. Page 175 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *509 analysts do not have an objective method to ensure that Longo adhered, SAED is intended to "verify the their counting of bundles and fibers can be replicated. identification of the pattern by measurement or Dr. Longo testified that the AHERA rules, on this issue, comparison of the pattern with patterns collected from are inherently subjective; that is, depending on the standards under the same conditions." AHERA Regs., analyst and the manner in which he or she conducts the 52 Fed. Reg. at 41870; (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 508). analysis, different analysts may come to differing Dr. Longo explained that this final step of the TEM is counting results. To account for this subjectivity, Dr. critical "to distinguish between the fibrous talc and Longo and his laboratory conducted a quality control anthophyllite asbestos." (Id. at 508.) Defendants study—which is not required under the AHERA disagree with Dr. Longo's approach and contend that his regulations—"to measure the error rate of the four TEM SAED methodology is unreliable because he did not analysts counting and looking at the same grid openings take multiple diffraction patterns at different zone-axis and determining how many asbestos structures that orientations. Defendants further contend that "[i]n order they are seeing and identifying compared to the next to uniquely identify a mineral by SAED, the analyst must analyst." (Id. at 524-25.) That control study determined obtain diffraction patterns from 'near-exact zone axis the percentage of agreement among the analysts as to orientations.'"27 (Defs.' Asbestos Br., at 52.) In support whether an asbestos was [*510] a fiber or a bundle was of their argument, Defendants primarily rely on a TEM 72 % with respect to tremolite, and 83.7 % with respect protocol authored by Dr. George Yamate in the early to anthophyllite. (Id. at 526.) Because Dr. Longo, in his 1980s. (See id.) I disagree with Defendants' view, considered that to be a low percentage of error position [*512] on this issue. rate, he was satisfied that his lab was accurately differentiating between bundles and fibers, and more The SAED methodology that Dr. Longo applied is importantly, that the lab was counting these structures derived from the AHERA regulations and the more as asbestos.26 (See id. at 524-28, 575.) In any event, recent ISO standards. These standards have not been any errors in differentiating between fibers and bundles, challenged by Defendants as unreliable, and indeed, at step 1 of the TEM, does not ultimately demonstrate there is no dispute that these standards are generally that Dr. Longo's testing is unreliable, because steps 2 accepted by the scientific community. Moreover, Dr. and 3 further confirm whether the counted fibers or Longo testified that ISO Standard 22262-1 specifically bundles—at step 1—are asbestos or cleavage provides that "laboratory samples in general seldom fragments. require zone axis measurements." (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 512.) That is because, Dr. Longo explained, "the Accordingly, pursuant to Daubert, the Court cannot find types of asbestos [they were] looking at, beside the that Dr. Longo's counting method in this regard was anthophyllite, which you should tilt for the two diffraction unreliable. On a threshold level, Dr. Longo's test results patterns, either the tremolite series or the anthophyllite as to step 1 of the TEM rest on "good grounds" and are series, is fairly straightforward and you are not dealing based on reliable scientific methods under the AHERA in unknowns." (Id. at 513.) To the extent Defendants rules. See United States v. Mitchell, 365 F.3d 215, 244 disagree with Dr. Longo's methodology and advance (3d Cir. 2004). To the extent Defendants seek to attack that the Yamate protocol is superior—that is an issue for Dr. Longo's opinion in this context, they may do so cross-examination.28 Indeed, this is a classic "battle of before a jury, as any purported inaccuracies in his method of counting go more appropriately to the weight of his opinion rather than reliability. 27 At the Daubert hearing, Dr. Longo testified that "[i]n some cases, some of the analysts did perform zone axis. Our Defendants next challenge [*511] the reliability of step mineralogists will tend to do it from time to time, but it is not 3 of Dr. Longo's TEM methodology—the SAED analysis. required. It is not a required step in the EPA AHERA method A SAED analysis "gives you information on the other than a typical what we'll call a d-spacing diffraction crystalline structure of [the particular] asbestos structure pattern that allows you to say this is an amphibole." (Longo being examined." (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 489.) Daubert Hearing Tr., at 507.) According to the AHERA regulations, to which Dr. 28 Defendants rely on Hanson v. Colgate-Palmolive Co., 353 F. Supp. 3d 1273, 1285-86 (S.D. Ga. 2018), to support their 26 Putting aside that this control study was not necessary argument that a zone-axis analysis is required. In that case, under the AHERA regulations, Defendants do not suggest that the court excluded expert testimony where an expert followed these percentages were statistically significant or do not an unreliable "modified Yamate method" that did not involve demonstrate a low error rate. using step 3 of SAED. Here, Dr. Longo does not rely on the Page 176 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *512 the experts" scenario. See In re Gabapentin Patent portions of his proposed testimony related to the results Litig., 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 158494, 2011 WL derived from the PLM testing. I note that while Dr. 12516763, at *10. Longo was not required by any of the relevant scientific methods to use the PLM methodology, he nevertheless Defendants' final argument with respect to the doctor's conducted the PLM analyses to further support his TEM analysis relates to the second step of TEM— results under the TEM. In his report, Dr. Longo explains EDXA. Defendants maintain that Dr. Longo's opinions that "[t]he PLM method is primarily used today for the should be excluded because [*513] his EDXA analysis analysis of asbestos-added products where the was unreliable and "deliberately designed to be asbestos-content of these products are typically over unverifiable." (Defs.' Asbestos Br. at 62.) Specifically, 1% by weight." (Longo 2d Supp. Rep. at 5.) Dr. Longo Defendants fault Dr. Longo for omitting certain states: numerical data from his EDXA graphs. (Defs.' Asbestos Br., at 66.) The EDXA analysis, which is required by the The strengths of the method are that it can AHERA regulations, involves "compar[ing] spectrum positively identify the different regulated profiles29 with profiles obtained from asbestos asbestos [*515] mineral types and provide a standards. The closest match identifies and categorizes qualitative estimate of the weight percent of the structure." AHERA Regs., 52 Fed. Reg. at 41887; asbestos. The primary weaknesses of the method (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 503). Dr. Longo testified that are 1) analytical sensitivity issues for samples that the AHERA method does not require inclusion of any may contain less than 0.1 wt. % of asbestos such numerical values of each element because this step "is as cosmetic talcs and 2) because asbestos fiber [solely] a visual comparison [of the profiles] to the and bundle structure resolution in the PLM method asbestos standards." (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 504.) is dependent on the wave length of light, asbestos He then went on to explain that the numerical values are particles must be at least 0.5 um in the smallest similarly not required by the ASTM and ISO methods. dimension to be visible. . . . For [this] analysis the (Id. at 506.) Defendants do not contest Dr. Longo's ISO 22262-1 PLM method was used. visual comparisons of the profiles from the talc samples and the standard asbestos profiles. Instead, they insist (Id. at 5.) In addition to the ISO 22262-1 PLM that Dr. Longo should have included certain numeric methodology, Dr. Longo conducted a heavy liquid data that Defendants, themselves, have not disputed separation before conducting the PLM analysis because are not required under the relevant standards. These it "increase[es] the analytical sensitivity of the PLM numeric data, Defendants posit, are essential to analysis for cosmetic grade talc." (Id. at 5.) verify [*514] Dr. Longo's results. However, because Defendants argue that Dr. Longo should have followed Defendants' challenge does not go to the reliability of the PLM methodology set forth in ISO 22262-2, as the methodologies employed by Dr. Longo, this is, opposed to ISO 22262-1.30 Defendants assert that ISO again, an issue for cross-examination. Defendants may 22262-1 states that "when the asbestos concentration present evidence and argue to the jury as to why this found is between 0% and 5% and 'it is necessary to numeric data is important, even though generally make critical decisions on the basis of the results' accepted scientific methods do not require it. Hence, the (including a result of 'non-detected') then ISO 22262-2 Court will not exclude Dr. Longo's testimony on this should be used." (Defs.' Asbestos Br., at 74.) Indeed, ground. Defendants correctly point out that [*516] under the However, the same does not hold true as to Dr. Longo's more powerful TEM microscope, Dr. Longo claimed to testing using the PLM methodology. Because I find Dr. Longo's testing in this context unreliable, I exclude any 30 The Court's analysis of whether ISO 22262-1 should have Yamate method and, further, his methodology complies with been utilized in the context of PLM method does not impact other generally accepted scientific methodologies for TEM Dr. Longo's usage of ISO 22262-1 in conducting his TEM analysis—namely, the EPA's AHERA regulations and ISO analysis. Both ISO 22262-1 and ISO 22262-2 set forth Standard 22262-1. Accordingly, I find that the Hanson decision separate standards for testing asbestos in materials using does not alter my analysis of this issue. TEM and PLM. See Cert. of Tersigni, Ex. A74 (ISO 22262-1); id., Ex. A75 (ISO 22262-2). Importantly, while Defendants 29 A spectrum profile is a graph generated by the EDXA that challenge Dr. Longo's use of ISO 22262-1 with respect to his shows "the ratios and levels of different elements that are PLM analysis, they do not do so as to his use of the ISO shown in the mineral." (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 503.) standards in the TEM testing. Page 177 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *516 have detected asbestos at concentrations ranging from report, replication of Dr. Longo's [*518] testing is .0092% on the high end to .0000033% on the low end. difficult. I agree. Dr. Longo was questioned on the stand With this ultra-trace amount of asbestos, there is no during the Daubert hearing as to why he did not disclose conceivable reason why Dr. Longo determined that the the weight percentages. (Id. at 611-615.) He did not ISO 22262-1 standard was appropriate for testing have an adequate explanation. This is troubling, cosmetic talc. Tellingly, nowhere in Dr. Longo's expert because the weight percentages are central to the report, his testimony, or even Plaintiffs' opposition asbestos analysis under the PLM; indeed, these papers, is there an explanation as to why Dr. Longo percentages were used by individual lab analysts to used ISO 22262-1. To quote Dr. Longo, the "primary determine the amount of asbestos in a given sample. weakness" of this method is "the analytical sensitivity Without that information, which is internally created by issues for samples that may contain less than 0.1 wt. % MAS, reproducing Dr. Longo's test under the PLM would of asbestos, such as cosmetic talcs." (Longo 2d Supp. not be possible, and hence, the testing is unreliable. Rep. at 5.) Even having so admitted, Dr. Longo, nevertheless, used this standard to perform his PLM This reproducibility issue was made plain by Dr. Longo's analyses. decision to have a third-party laboratory replicate his findings. Dr. Longo requested Dr. Lee Poye of J-3 Significantly, this very decision is contrary to Dr. Longo's Laboratory ("J-3") to perform a PLM analysis using the view prior to this litigation, as demonstrated by the same ISO 22262-1 method on 22 of the historical talc following Daubert hearing testimony: samples. (See Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 618.) Q. Prior to issuing your MDL report, you had not However, J-3's PLM analysis was negative for asbestos used PLM in your initial report. Correct? for each sample. (Longo 2d Supp. Rep. at 20.) While Dr. A. That is correct. Longo attempted to explain away why this discrepancy Q. And in fact you were of the opinion back then in occurred, he nevertheless conceded that "[t]hese 2017 and 2018 that PLM basically wasn't going to differing results between the two labs will require further work. Correct? investigation to understand the reason for these differences." [*519] (Longo 2d Supp. Rep. at 5.) Again, A. Using the standard method, yes [*517] ma'am. Dr. Longo had no explanation. This underscores the Q. You were of the opinion that PLM was not very real reliability and reproducibility issues plaguing appropriate for this kind of cosmetic talc analysis. Dr. Longo's PLM testing. As such, Dr. Longo is not Correct? permitted to testified as to his testing results under the A. That is correct. PLM.

(Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 606-07.) The fact that Dr. Finally, Defendants argue that Dr. Longo's testimony Longo changed his view regarding the use of PLM to should be excluded as it is irrelevant to the issue of test cosmetic talc for asbestos solely for the purposes of general causation because he failed to conduct any sort this litigation, and combined with the lack of an of exposure analysis. (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 40.) This appropriate explanation as to why ISO 22262-1 was argument specifically challenges Dr. Longo's opinion used, I cannot find, on these bases, that Dr. Longo's "that individuals who used Johnson & Johnson talcum PLM testing is reliable under Daubert. powder products (Johnson's Baby Powder and Shower to Shower) in the past would have, more likely than not, What is more, as Defendants further point out, Dr. been exposed to significant airborne levels of both Longo's PLM methodology is unreliable because it was regulated amphibole asbestos and fibrous (asbestiform) replete with subjectivity and reproducibility problems. Dr. talc." (Longo 2d Supp. Expert Rep., at 32.) Dr. Longo Longo explained at the Daubert hearing that pursuant to opines as such, despite the fact that he has described the PLM methodology, for positive asbestos samples, the amount of talc in Defendants' products as "ultra- the quantity of asbestos in the samples was determined trace." (See Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 559-61.) Indeed, by visual examination "based on past standards, based Dr. Longo and the MAS analysts have found asbestos on petrographic that show what the various percentages levels of less than one percent in the asbestos products are." (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 611-13.) These tested. (See id. at 559.) Defendants cross-examined Dr. standards (weight percentages) were generated by Longo on this issue at the Daubert hearing: MAS and were not produced to Defendants. (Id. at 614.) Defendants argue that because Dr. Longo did not Q. And what you state in your report, disclose this information in connection with his expert Doctor, [*520] is that you were of the opinion that Page 178 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *520 individuals who used Johnson & Johnson talcum (Longo Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 560-62.) powder products in the past would have more likely that not been exposed to significant airborne levels The Court agrees that Dr. Longo has not presented of both regulated amphibole asbestos and fibrous "good grounds" for this opinion. Dr. Longo fails to offer asbestiform talc. Right? any scientific support for his opinion that the use of A. That's correct. Defendants' talc products causes exposure, let alone Q. So it is your opinion that individuals who used significant exposure, to asbestos. It is well-established this product have a significant exposure. Correct? that "nothing in either [*522] Daubert or the Federal A. Yes. Rules of evidence requires a district court to admit Q. But you haven't done in this MDL an exposure opinion evidence that is connected to existing data only analysis. Correct? by the ipse dixit of the expert." Gen. Elec. Co. v. Joiner, A. Not with these samples, no. 522 U.S. 136, 146, 118 S. Ct. 512, 139 L. Ed. 2d 508 Q. Meaning you have not calculated, Dr. Longo, (1997). In that connection, "[a] court may conclude that whether or not it is even possible for those ultra, there is simply too great an analytical gap between the ultra trace levels that we just looked at to make it data and the opinion proffered." Id. By failing to conduct out of a bottle and into a human being who is using an exposure analysis, Dr. Longo's opinion on the that product as a consumer. Correct? likelihood that talc users were exposed to "significant" A. We haven't done that study. If it is in the bottle, amounts of asbestos, and indeed, any exposure, is too and even though those, quote, ultra, trace attenuated from his findings of trace levels of asbestos concentrations are still very significant, it is going to in talc. Accordingly, Dr. Longo is not permitted to testify get out of the bottle, will get it up in the air, and be as to this opinion at any trial in this matter. in the breathing zone. THE COURT: How do you use the term Nevertheless, the Court finds that Dr. Longo's remaining "significance"? opinion on the presence of "ultra-trace" asbestos in Defendants' talc products is still admissible as useful to THE WITNESS: I term it as, can we measure it? So the trier of fact. Indeed, the issue of whether there is it is 10 to 20 times above background. In this case, asbestos, and the amount of asbestos, in Defendants' there is very little to no background involving talc products are key issues in this litigation. For tremolite and anthophyllite. It is not on a [*521] example, Plaintiffs' epidemiology experts rely upon Dr. health basis. It is, is there an exposure? Longo's report for the assumption that Defendants' talc . . . products contain asbestos to support their opinions that Q. You just said 10 to 20 times above background. talc use is associated with ovarian cancer. [*523] (See The fact of the matter here, as it relates to the MDL McTiernan Expert Rep., at 57; Carson Expert Rep., at 5; samples, you haven't measured or calculated Clarke-Pearson Expert Rep., at 6.) Hence, the Court, in anything at all? its discretion, only excludes Dr. Longo's opinion on A. Not with the MDL samples. exposure. See In re Pfizer, 819 F.3d at 665 ("When Q. And it is not that your facility at MAS doesn't faced with expert testimony that contains both reliable know how to do an exposure simulation, Right? and unreliable opinions, district courts often exclude A. Right. We have done those, not with the MDL only the unreliable testimony."). In that connection, to samples. the extent that other Plaintiffs' experts in this litigation THE COURT: What was your opinion based on; it rely upon Dr. Longo's findings, their reliance will be was significant in the MDL? limited solely to his finding that Defendants' talc THE WITNESS: That it is significant in that they products contain asbestos, and they cannot rely on his would have had an exposure that more than half of opinion that talc users were exposed to asbestos. the samples that we measured were positive for asbestos. We have done exposure calculations in the past with Johnson & Johnson in which we have C. Plaintiffs' General Causation Experts calculated these exposures with Johnson & Johnson products and made a measurement. The following three experts testified on behalf of THE COURT: How about these samples that you Plaintiffs on the issue of general causation, i.e., whether were given? use of talc products can cause ovarian cancer: Dr. Anne THE WITNESS: No, ma'am. McTiernan, an epidemiologist; Dr. Daniel Clarke- Pearson, a gynecologic-oncologist; and Dr. Arch Page 179 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *523

Carson, a toxicologist (the "general causation experts"). Dr. McTiernan opines that use of talcum powder A plaintiff in a products liability action must prove both products in the female genital perineal area can general and specific causation. In re Zoloft Sertraline increase the risk of, or indeed cause, ovarian cancer. Hydrochloride Prods. Liab. Litig., 176 F. Supp. 3d 483, (Id. at 720.) Dr. McTiernan explained her methodology, 491 (E.D. Pa. 2016). Specifically, "[g]eneral causation is which included formulating a question to answer, i.e., (1) whether a substance is capable of causing a particular "What is the association between talcum powder injury or condition in the general population, while products and ovarian cancer," and (2) "can the use of specific causation is whether a substance caused a talcum powder products cause ovarian cancer." (Id. at particular [*524] individual's injury." Id. Generally 726.) Dr. McTiernan then conducted a systematic speaking, "epidemiology is the best evidence of general review of the available evidence — "in this case, causation in a toxic tort case." Id. (quoting Norris v. epidemiologic evidence, and [she did] a careful [search] Baxter Healthcare Corp., 397 F.3d 878, 882 (10th Cir. through a database and through relevant journal articles 2005)). to make sure [she had] the totality." (Id. at 726-27.) She then reviewed the data and in doing so Because the parties address the admissibility of these experts collectively, the Court, first, sets forth the considered the statistical data, the strength and experts' qualifications and opinions, and then weaknesses of study type, the effect of possible determines the admissibility of those opinions under bias, chance, confounding and differences in Daubert. exposure measures. [She] considered dose- response . . . . [She] also considered data from non-epidemiologic lines of evidence, such as i. The Experts animal, cell, clinical and pathological studies. [She] [*526] considered non-talc components of talcum powder products and impact on carcinogenicity such as asbestos, fibrous talc, a. Dr. Anne McTiernan, Ph.D., M.D. heavy metals, and fragrances.

Dr. McTiernan is proffered as an expert in epidemiology. (Id. at 727-28.) Dr. McTiernan explained that her opinion She completed a Ph.D. program in epidemiology at the was based "on the statistically significant elevated risk University of Washington Seattle in 1982. (McTiernan seen with the epidemiology data when they are Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 715.) She obtained her medical combined, the pathological evidence, the consistency of degree at New York Medical College in 1989, and results across geographic areas, and in different race thereafter, did a residency in internal medicine at the and ethnic groups, evidence of a positive dose- University of Washington in 1992. (Id.) Dr. McTiernan response effect and the plausible biological currently serves as a member of the Fred Hutchison mechanism." (Id.) Dr. McTiernan further extracted Cancer Research Center in Seattle, Washington, where certain information from the studies, including she conducts epidemiologic research, identifies risk the study characteristics that would be most factors for women with respect to breast and ovarian important to know about the breadth and depth of cancer, and studies "prevention methods to reduce the individual studies, particularly to be able to population and other markers of cancer risk." (Id. at know how large the study was, where it was 716.) The doctor is also a research professor in the conducted, when it was conducted, how many epidemiology and gerontology and geriatric medicine cases were included, how many people without departments at [*525] University of Washington cancer were included, if it was a cohort, [and] how Schools of Medicine and Public Health. (Id.) The Court long it had been followed. [She] looked at dose- finds that Dr. McTiernan is qualified to act as an expert response. The key metric is relative risk. Relative in epidemiology.31 risk is clearly the important element. And [she] also

McTiernan's testimony. As set forth below, the Court finds that 31 Defendants attempt to present Dr. McTiernan's opinions as Dr. McTiernan reliably applied the Bradford Hill factors and unreliable and "made for litigation" based on the fact that Dr. considered the body of epidemiologic evidence. To the extent McTiernan met with Plaintiffs' counsel before testifying before Defendants wish to explore any possible biases of Dr. Congress regarding the alleged connection between talc and McTiernan's opinions and/or testimony, that is an issue for ovarian cancer. (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 78.) The Court is cross-examination. See Venus, 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 83115, unconvinced that this undermines the reliability of Dr. 2017 WL 2364192, at *17; see also infra, note 32. Page 180 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *526

looked at the statistical testing on cancer subtype. c. Dr. Arch Carson (Id. at 728-29.) Based on that information, Dr. McTiernan conducted a Bradford Hill [*527] analysis32 Dr. Carson is offered as an expert in toxicology. Dr. "to assess for causality" and based on her independent Carson is an associate professor at the University of judgment and weight of the relevant evidence, she Texas School of Public Health and "a physician scientist reached her conclusion "that use of talcum powder who specializes in medical toxicology." (Carson Daubert products, including Johnson & Johnson Baby Powder Hr'g Tr., at 1258.) He received an M.D. from Ohio State and Shower to Shower, in the genital perineal area can University and a Ph.D. in toxicology from the Kettering cause ovarian cancer." (Id. at 720.) Laboratory at the University of Cincinnati. (Carson Expert Rep., at 1.) The doctor is currently an Associate Professor at the University of Texas School of Public b. Dr. Daniel Clarke-Pearson Health [*529] and the Program Director of the Occupational and Environmental Medicine Residency Dr. Clarke-Pearson has been presented as an expert in training program at the University of Texas Health gynecologic oncology. (Clarke-Pearson Daubert Hr'g Center in Houston, Texas. (Id.) Dr. Carson's Tr., at 1519.) Dr. Clarke-Pearson received a Bachelor of professional activities "have included patient care, basic Science in biology from Harvard University and an M.D. and applied research, teaching of medical students, at Case University. (Id.) He completed both a graduate students and post-graduate medical trainees, residency in obstetrics/gynecology and a fellowship in and professional consulting." (Id.) Dr. Carson has also oncology at Duke University Medical Center. (Id.) been the Program Director of the National Institute for Following his fellowship, for 18 years, the doctor was Occupational Safety and Health-funded Education and part of the faculty at Duke University. (Id.) During his Research Center at the University of Texas for 19 of the career in academic medicine, Dr. Clarke-Pearson has past 21 years. (Id.) Based on his professional published approximately 250 peer-reviewed background, I find that Dr. Carson is qualified to testify publications, most of which "are in the field of as an expert.33 gynecologic oncology, and some have dealt with ovarian cancer, in particular, clinical trials describing In this proceeding, Dr. Carson opines that advances in the treatment of ovarian cancer." (Id. at Johnson's Baby Powder and Shower to Shower 1523.) Dr. Clarke-Pearson is qualified to act as an pose a significant health hazard. The expert in this matter. epidemiological studies show me that there is a consistent positive relationship between the genital Dr. Clarke-Pearson followed [*528] a similar methodology as Dr. McTiernan. He first conducted a literature search and reviewed the epidemiological 33 Despite the Third Circuit's liberal approach to Rule 702's studies, including "case-control studies, cohort studies, qualification requirement, see Pineda, 520 F.3d at 244, pooled studies, and meta-analyses." (Id. at 1531.) Dr. Defendants raise certain challenges to Drs. McTiernan's and Clarke-Pearson explained that based on his "extensive Carson's qualifications. Specifically, Defendants argue that research," he "believes that genital application of talcum Drs. McTiernan and Carson are not qualified to opine on powder, such as Johnson & Johnson's Baby Powder certain issues that go outside their areas of stated expertise, and Shower to Shower, increases the risk of epithelial epidemiology and toxicology, respectively. (See Defs.' ovarian cancer in all women and can cause epithelial Qualifications Br., at 3-5, 17-19.) For example, Defendants ovarian cancer in some women." (Id. at 1530.) The claim that Dr. McTiernan is not an oncologist or gynecologist such that she can opine on issues related to biological doctor also applied a Bradford Hill causation analysis to plausibility, and that Dr. Carson cannot opine on epidemiology. reach his conclusion, which is "similar to what I do in I disagree and decline to exclude these experts on that basis. medicine with an evidence-based medicine decision As Defendants candidly conceded in their brief, it is well- analysis to come to the conclusion what's best to treat a accepted that an expert should not be excluded "merely patient." (Id.) because the court feels that the expert is not the best qualified or that the expert does not possess the most appropriate specialization." In re Human Tissue, 582 F. Supp. 2d at 655. 32 A Bradford Hill analysis involves consideration of the As set forth in detail supra, Plaintiffs have sufficiently Bradford Hill criteria, "which are nine factors widely used in the demonstrated that Drs. McTiernan and Carson are qualified to scientific community to assess general causation." Gannon v. conduct a Bradford Hill analysis utilizing various United States, 292 F. App'x 170, 172-73 (3d Cir. 2008). epidemiological data. Page 181 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *529

use of talcum powders and about a 30 percent 3d Ed. 2011).34 increase in ovarian cancer. Talcum powder clearly migrates through the female reproductive tract In weighing the Bradford Hill factors, the general when it's applied to the perineum and exposes the causation experts conducted a review of the available ovaries. epidemiologic studies, which included 28 case control studies, 3 cohort studies, 3 meta-analyses, and 1 Inhalation of dust during those applications is a pooled analysis. Both case control and cohort studies potential secondary route. Talcum [*530] powder are observational studies. See id. at 556-57. The produces chronic inflammation in the tissues in difference between case-control and cohort studies is which it contacts and is sequestered. "that cohort studies measure [*532] and compare the Johnson's Baby Powder and Shower to Shower incidence of disease in the exposed and unexposed contain mineral fibers including asbestos and ('control') groups, while case-control studies measure fibrous talc that intensifies this exposure, and the and compare the frequency of exposure in the group inflammatory responses including cell growth and with the disease (the 'cases') and the group without the proliferation. disease (the 'controls')." Id. at 557. A meta-analysis Johnson's Baby Powder and Shower to Shower are aggregates information from published studies and carcinogenic, and I believe the regular genital use "collects this number called relative risk from different of Johnson's Baby Powder and Shower to Shower studies and they combine those relative risks so that can cause epithelial ovarian cancer. they could have one relative risk. It gives you a very big summary of what the literature looks like overall." (Id. at 1259-60.) Dr. Carson reached this conclusion by (McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 733.) A pooled analysis performing a "step-by-step risk assessment process that "is where individual level data are obtained from the is similar to the one that is used by the National Institute individuals in the study" and the "data then are analyzed for Occupational Safety and Health." (Id. at 1261.) That as if it is one large study," creating a Norris v. Baxter process involved "identification of the hazard followed Healthcare Corp., 397 F.3d 878, 882 (10th Cir. 2005). by assessment of whether or not there is potential for summary of the statistics. (Id. at 734.) exposure, then assessment of response to what is known of regarding response to that exposure, and then As a general matter, "consideration of the Bradford Hill characterization of the risk." (Id.) Dr. Carson also factors is a reliable method for determining causation." performed a Bradford Hill analysis, through which he In re Roundup Prods. Liab. Litig., 390 F. Supp. 3d 1102, determined that "genital application of talcum powder 1130 (N.D. Cal. 2018); see also In re Zoloft (Sertraline over time raises the risk of ovarian cancer in everyone Hydrochloride) Prods. Liab. Litig., 858 F.3d 787, 795 (3d exposed and causes ovarian cancer in some of the people who are exposed." (Id. at 1310.) 34 The Court relies on the Reference Guide on Epidemiology for guidance on how a Bradford Hill analysis is conducted in ii. The Experts' [*531] Bradford Hill Analyses the scientific community. This guide is a part of a series of guides included in the Reference Manual on Scientific Plaintiffs' experts formed their general causation Evidence, promulgated by the Federal Judicial Center. The opinions using the Bradford Hill criteria, "which are nine Manual's purpose is "to provide the tools for judges to manage factors widely used in the scientific community to assess cases involving complex scientific and technical evidence." general causation." Gannon, 292 F. App'x at 172-73. Fed. Judicial Ctr., Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence, at Those nine factors are (1) temporal relationship; (2) xv (3d ed. 2011). Indeed, the Reference Guide on strength of association; (3) dose-response relationship; Epidemiology has been relied upon by many courts in this Circuit in assessing the admissibility of an experts' Bradford (4) replication; (5) biological plausibility; (6) Hill analysis. See, e.g., Rowland v. Novartis Pharms. Corp., 9 consideration of alternative explanations; (1) cessation F. Supp. 3d 553, 562 n.21 (W.D. Pa. 2014); Pritchard v. Dow of exposure; (8) specificity of the association; and (9) Agro Sciences, 705 F. Supp. 2d 471, 484 (W.D. Pa. 2010); In consistency with other knowledge. Michael D. Green, et re Human Tissue, 582 F. Supp. 2d at 663; Magistrini v. One al., Reference Guide on Epidemiology, in Reference Hour Martinizing Dry Cleaning, 180 F. Supp. 2d 584, 590 Manual on Scientific Evidence 549, 600 (Fed. Jud. Ctr., (D.N.J. 2002). Various Courts of Appeals have also cited to the Guide in assessing the reliability of an expert's general causation analysis. See, e.g., Goodpaster v. City of Indianapolis, 736 F.3d 1060, 1068 n.1 (7th Cir. 2013); McClain v. Metabolife Inter., Inc., 401 F.3d 1233, 1239 (11th Cir. 2005); Page 182 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *532

Cir. 2017) (acknowledging that the Bradford Hill analysis The meta-analyses and pooled analysis showed is "generally reliable"); Wendell v. GlaxoSmithKline LLC, that risk of ovarian cancer among users of talcum 858 F.3d 1227, 1235 n.4 (9th Cir. 2017) ("The Bradford powder products is 22-31% higher than in women Hill methodology refers to a set of criteria that are well who never used these products. A total of 28 case- accepted in the medical field for making causal control studies, 3 prospective cohort studies, 2 judgments."). Nevertheless, the Third Circuit has meta-analyses, and one pooled analysis were cautioned that "despite the fact that the [*533] reviewed in depth. The meta-analyses found a methodology is generally reliable, each application is statistically significant 24-25% increased risk of distinct and should be analyzed for reliability." Zoloft, developing serous ovarian cancer—representing 858 F.3d at 795. Accordingly, the Zoloft court held that 52% of epithelial ovarian cancer cases—in women "the specific techniques by which the weight of the who had ever used talcum powder products evidence/Bradford Hill methodology is conducted must compared with never users. The pooled analysis, themselves be reliable according to the principles which included data from 5 previously published articulated in Daubert." Id. at 796. In other words, "the and 3 unpublished case-control studies, found 'techniques' used to implement the [Bradford Hill] similar statistically significant increased risks for analysis must be 1) reliable and 2) reliably applied." overall epithelial ovarian cancer and serous ovarian Id.35 cancer (24% and 20%, respectively). Thus, when combining these studies through meta- Defendants argue that the Bradford Hill analyses analyses, [*535] the totality of the evidence shows conducted by Plaintiff's general causation experts are a statistically significant increased risk of ovarian "unreliable and conclusion driven." (See Defs.' General cancer with use of perineal talcum powder Causation Br., at 31.) In response, Plaintiffs maintain products. Viewed in the context of the high that the experts' analyses are reliable under Daubert consistency of the study results across time, and that Defendants' arguments go only to the weight of diverse study populations, and strong study their testimony. (Pls. General Causation Br., at 75-76.) designs, bias and chance as explanation for the Below, the Court addresses the reliability of the experts' increased risk are unlikely. Further, my confidence applications of each Bradford Hill factor. in the reliability of the data on magnitude of the risk is enhanced. Therefore, my analysis of these studies strongly supports a causal association and, a. Strength of Association given the high prevalence of the use of talcum powder products in this population, these levels of The strength of association factor asks "[h]ow strong is risk present a clinically significant public health the association between the exposure and disease." concern. [I] placed high weight on this aspect of Green, supra, at 602. Strength of an association may be determination of causality. measured in terms of "relative risk," which is the approach taken by Plaintiffs' experts. [*534] See id. at (McTiernan Expert Rep., at 63-64 (footnote omitted).) 566. Relative risk "is defined as the ratio of the Drs. Clarke-Pearson and Carson, for similar reasons, incidence rate . . . of disease in exposed individuals to afford this factor significant weight in their Bradford Hill the incidence rate in unexposed individuals." Id. analyses. (See Clarke-Pearson Expert Rep., at 8; Carson Expert Rep., at 8-9.) Plaintiffs' general causation experts placed significant weight on the strength of association factor, finding a Defendants argue that these experts' opinions with 1.2 to 1.6 relative risk. Dr. McTiernan explains in her respect to this Bradford Hill factor are unreliable expert report: because "they mischaracterize the objective magnitude of the association reported in the studies and rest on inapposite comparisons to causal relationships." (Defs.' 35 In assessing the experts' analyses of the Bradford Hill Post-Hr'g Br., at 18.) They further [*536] argue that factors, the Court refers to case law outside of the Third while the experts opine that the association between Circuit. While a number of district courts in this circuit have use of talc products and ovarian cancer is strong, it is in examined these factors, they do not discuss each factor with fact, objectively weak. (Id. at 15-16.) In that connection, the type of detailed analysis that this Court is called upon to Defendants maintain that at least one court has conduct here. Moreover, there is a dearth of case law in the recognized the 1.2 to 1.6 relative risk identified by the Third Circuit on these issues. Accordingly, where appropriate, experts as "a weak, not strong, association by any the Court seeks guidance from out-of-circuit cases. Page 183 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *536 objective measure." (Defs.' General Causation Br., at 32 One Hour Martinizing Dry Cleaning, 180 F. Supp. 2d (citing Carl v. Johnson & Johnson, Nos. ATL-L-6546-14, 584, 591 (D.N.J. 2002). The Reference Guide on ATL-L-6540-14, 2016 N.J. Super. Unpub. LEXIS 2102, Epidemiology explains that relative risk can be 2016 WL 4580145, at *18 (N.J. Super. Ct. Law Div. interpreted as follows: Sept. 2, 2016).)36 Defendants further fault Plaintiffs' If the relative risk equals 1.0, the risk in exposed causation experts for relying primarily on case-control individuals is the same as the risk in unexposed studies, as opposed to cohort studies, which individuals. There is no association between the Defendants maintain provide more reliable results. (See exposure to the agent and disease. Defs.' General Causation Br., at 34-41.) If the relative risk is greater than 1.0, the risk in I find that the opinions of the general causation experts exposed individuals is greater than the risk in with respect to this factor are admissible. The experts, unexposed individuals. There is a positive both at the Daubert hearing [*537] and in their expert association between exposure to the agent and the reports, provided good grounds for their decisions to disease, which could be [*538] causal. place significant weight on the strength of association If the relative risk is less than 1.0, the risk in factor. Defendants have not presented any compelling exposed individuals is less than the risk in grounds for the Court to find otherwise. First, unexposed individuals. There is a negative Defendants' argument with respect to whether the association, which could reflect a protective or association is "weak" or "strong" is one that goes to the curative effect of the agent on risk of disease. weight of the experts' testimony, not the reliability. Green, supra at 567 (footnotes omitted). A relative risk Relative risk is the foundation of the strength of of 2.0 means the risk has doubled, "indicating that the association factor and "[d]etermining the relative risk is risk is twice as high among the exposed group as important in understanding the results of a study compared to the non-exposed group." Magistrini, 180 F. because virtually every disease associated with a risk Supp. 2d at 591. In epidemiology, there is, however, no factor also occurs, at some rate, in the general threshold, or a magical number, of a relative risk that population not exposed to the risk factor." Magistrini v. must be found in order to place significant weight on the strength of association factor. Indeed, "[a] relative risk of 2.0 is not so much a password to a finding of causation 36 Carl is a parallel New Jersey mass tort litigation involving as one piece of the evidence, among others for the perineal talc use and ovarian cancer. The court in Carl issued court to consider in determining whether an expert has its decision in 2016, excluding the epidemiological experts employed a sound methodology in reaching his or her presented by the plaintiffs in that matter, prior to a significant conclusion." Magistrini, 180 F. Supp. 2d at 606 (quoting number of additional studies and testing having been Landrigan v. Celotex Corp., 127 N.J. 404, 419, 605 A.2d conducted, and more data having been published, on the 1079 (1992)).37 Courts may also "consider whether the possible link between talc use and ovarian cancer. Importantly, the epidemiological experts presented in Carl are different than those presented by Plaintiffs in the instant matter. Indeed, the experts in this case, at arriving their 37 I note that in the context of relative risk, courts have conclusions, relied upon epidemiological studies that have endorsed "a flexible Daubert inquiry rather than bright-line been released since Carl. See, e.g., Taher, et al., Critical rules." Pritchard, 705 F. Supp. 2d at 486 (concluding that "a Review of the Association Between Perineal Use of Talc relative risk of 2.0 is not dispositive of the reliability of an Powder and Risk of Ovarian Cancer, 90 Reproducers. Toxicol. expert's opinion relying on an epidemiology study, but it is a 88 (2019); Penninkilampi, et al., Perineal Talc Use and factor, among others, which the Court is to consider in its Ovarian Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, evaluation"). Accordingly, in the context of relative risk on a 29(1) Epidemiology 41 (2018); Berge, et al., Genital Use of Daubert motion, the Court's role is to determine whether the Talc and Risk of Ovarian Cancer: A Meta-Analysis, 27(3) Eur. expert has reliably arrived at, based on sound scientific J. Cancer Prev. 248 (2018); Schildkraut, et al., Association methods, a relative risk that in his or her view could be Between Body Powder Use and Ovarian Cancer: The African clinically significant. See, e.g., Pick v. Am. Med. Sys., Inc., 958 American Cancer Epidemiology Study, 25(10) Cancer F. Supp. 1151, 1160 (E.D. La. 1997) ("A relative risk above 1.0 Epidemiol. Biomarkers Prev. (2016). But, more importantly, is statistically significant, even if not sufficient, by itself, to one crucial difference between the proofs of causation in Carl establish causation by a preponderance of the evidence."); and in this MDL, is the theory of asbestos and the biological Miller v. Pfizer Inc., 196 F. Supp. 2d 1062, 1079 (D. Kan. testing conducted in light of the alleged presence of asbestos 2002) (declining to find, as a matter of law, that a relative risk in talc products, which was not done in Carl. must be above a certain number to be clinically significant). Of Page 184 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *538 authors of the study found the association to be finds that the experts' reliance on the case-control statistically significant and, where the authors found an studies does not render their opinions unreliable under association to not be statistically significant, an opinion Daubert. Defendants submit that there is a hierarchy of may be unreliable." Pritchard, 705 F. Supp. 2d at 486. observational epidemiologic studies, "which include[s] in descending order of reliability — cohort studies, case- The question of whether the relative risk found by control studies and cross-sectional studies." (Defs.' Plaintiffs' experts [*539] can be categorized as "strong" General Causation Br., at 10.) Based on that hierarchy, or "weak" is best left to the jury. As to reliability, the Defendants posit that "it is especially unreliable for Court's inquiry, here, must focus on whether the experts plaintiffs' experts [*541] to characterize the objectively used a sound methodology in reaching their conclusion 'weak' 1.2-.6 figure as indicative of a strong association that the relative risk range of 1.2 to 1.6 demonstrates a because that figure is artificially inflated by the fact that risk association between talc powder use and ovarian it is based primarily on case-control studies." (Id. at 34.) cancer. Defendants do not challenge the experts' basis What is more, Defendants contend that Plaintiffs' for this conclusion, and in fact, do not suggest that the experts fail to consider the weaknesses of the case- experts' calculation of relative risk, based on the control studies, i.e., recall bias and confounding. (Id. at aggregate studies, was not reliably reached. Instead, 35-41.) Plaintiffs counter that "even the most basic they focus solely on whether the relative risk can be epidemiology textbooks teach that there is not a rigid characterized as objectively "weak" or "strong." In hierarchy [of evidence]," and maintain that their general Defendants' view, a range of 1.2 to 1.6 is a weak causation experts properly considered the strengths and indicator of associational risk. But, the resolution of that weaknesses of all relevant talc studies. (Pls.' General dispute is a question that goes to the weight of the Causation Br., at 114-131.) evidence. As previously explained, the Court is satisfied that Plaintiffs' general causation experts employed a The Court finds that Plaintiffs' experts reliably sound methodology in deciding to place a significant considered all the relevant studies. Dr. McTiernan weight on the "strength of association" factor. The explained at the Daubert hearing, which I found experts examined, as they must, the totality of the credible, that there are "benefits and drawbacks" to both available epidemiological evidence on talc use and the case-control and cohort studies. (McTiernan ovarian cancer, and drew conclusions based on sound Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 737.) Dr. McTiernan expressed her scientific reasoning. Even [*540] if the range of relative belief that the case-control studies are better suited for risk given by Plaintiffs' causation experts is found not to assessing the relationship between talc usage and be objectively "strong," it is not for the Court to decide ovarian cancer, and explained that whether they reached the correct conclusion on strength when you are looking at what a woman has used, of association or to otherwise disagree with their and you want to know her lifetime exposure, [*542] opinions. See Daubert, 509 U.S. at 595 (noting that the and you want details, you are going to see that best court's focus "must be solely on principles and described in a case-control study that can be methodology, not on the conclusions that they focused. The cohort studies have their strengths, generate"). In fact, to do so would unnecessarily and we'll go over those in a bit also. I found both broaden the scope of this Court's role as a gatekeeper. types of studies provided useful information, and I See In re Viagra Prods. Liab. Litig., 572 F. Supp. 2d summarized that in my deliberations. 1071, 1081 (D. Minn. 2008) ("[O]n a Daubert motion involving general-causation evidence in an MDL matter, (Id.) Dr. McTiernan also explained her opinion with lack of statistical significance under some respect to the weaknesses in the cohort studies, more in circumstances 'does not detract from the reliability of the depth, in her report, noting that study.'" (quoting In re Phenylpropanolamine (PPA) Prods. Liab. Litig., MDL No. 1407, 289 F. Supp. 2d three cohort studies have reported on talcum 1230, 1241 (W.D. Wash. 2003))). powder use and ovarian cancer risk. The Women's Health Initiative recruited from the general Moreover, contrary to Defendants' position, the Court population of postmenopausal women from 40 clinical centers around the U.S. The rate of course, the greater the relative risk, the stronger an response was only around 1-2%, however, and association would be, and indeed, if the relative risk is 2.0, the therefore the cohort is unlikely to represent the "agent was more likely than not the cause of an individual's population of American postmenopausal women. disease." Magistrini, 180 F. Supp. 2d at 591. Page 185 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *542

The Nurses' Health Study recruited nurses from serous epithelial ovarian cancer, which is the most around the U.S. Their rate of response was higher common and most deadly form of the disease." (Carson than for the Women's Health Initiative, but they are Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1277.) Dr. Carson explained further all nurses, and therefore have different health that he did not cite to the cohort studies in his expert knowledge, income, and socioeconomic status report, because he was not of the view that the "three compared with the general U.S. population. The cohort studies contributed to the opinions that [he] Sisters' Study recruited from the general population, expressed," and noted that he "did cite to the meta- targeting women who had at least one sister with analyses that included them and looked at those data. breast cancer. [*543] The responding participants So they are included within those meta-analyses, and therefore represent only women with a family that was much [*545] more fundamental to [his] history of breast cancer, and given their self- opinions." (Id. at 1418.) Moreover, Dr. Carson stated selection, likely differ from the general population in that "those cohort studies likely suffered from an vulnerability to cancer and other characteristics. underpowered condition, and when they reanalyzed (McTiernan Expert Rep., at 16.) them as a group with a larger sample size [in the meta- analyses], they were able to increase the power and Dr. Clarke-Pearson testified that he did not find the were able to detect an effect." (Id. at 1422.) cohort studies "useful in terms of going to the totality, and that what we're trying to talk about." (Clarke- Based on this testimony, the Court is satisfied that the Pearson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1678.) Instead, general causation experts have demonstrated that their [w]hat [he] did was to look at the case-control decisions to rely on the case-control studies, as studies, the cohort studies, and the pooled studies, opposed to the three cohort studies, is supported by and then the meta-analysis. So looking at the good grounds and does not constitute a "rigid" dismissal totality, the meta-analyses, were much more helpful of the cohort studies. See Carl, 2016 N.J. Super. and stronger evidence to identify the real outcome Unpub. LEXIS 2102, 2016 WL 4580145, at *19. Indeed, of use of talc in the perineal area which increases this is not a situation where the experts purposefully the risk of ovarian cancer in every one of those ignored the cohort studies entirely because they were meta-analyses. inconsistent with their opinions.

(Id. at 1678.) Dr. Clarke-Pearson further elaborated on The Northern District of California addressed a similar his decision not to cite to the cohort studies in his report, dispute over the relevant weight of observational explaining that "the cohort studies were included in the epidemiology studies in In re Roundup Products Liability meta-analysis, so I was considering them in that setting, Litigation, 390 F. Supp. 3d 1102 (N.D. Cal. 2018). In but just not isolated as cohort studies." (Id. at 1679.) Dr. Roundup, as here, the plaintiffs' experts relied heavily Clarke-Pearson went on: on the case-control studies and meta-analyses, whereas defendants maintained that a cohort study was [The cohort studies] contributed to the meta- more reliable and not properly considered by plaintiffs' analysis; and even though they were not very experts. Id. at 1116-26. The court reviewed the relevant strong studies [*544] in many ways, and were not studies and the plaintiffs' experts' reasons [*546] for statistically significant, they did show an increased relying on the case-control studies versus the cohort relative risk. They were included in the meta- study; the court ultimately found that the studies were analysis, and they didn't bring down the fact the "open to different interpretations, and the potential flaws meta-analysis showed a statistically significant in the data from the case-control studies and meta- increased risk of developing ovarian cancer with analyses are not overwhelmingly greater than the perineal talc use. If I excluded them, the results in potential flaws in the data from the [cohort] study." Id. at the meta-analysis would have been even more 1126. Accordingly, the Roundup court concluded that negative in the use of talc in the perineal area. "an expert who places more weight on the case-control (Id.) studies than the [cohort] study cannot be excluded as categorically unreliable for doing so." Id. Finally, Dr. Carson testified that he reviewed the cohort studies in connection with his review of the meta- The same holds true here. The Court cannot deem analyses, and that "when [the meta-analyses] looked at Plaintiffs' experts' opinions unreliable simply because the cohort studies alone, they showed that there was a they determined that the case-control studies were significant and positive relative risk associated with entitled to greater weight than the cohort studies, Page 186 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *546 particularly since the experts' explanations of their confirm the presence of differential recall between methods were supported by scientific reasons. In the cases and controls. end, Defendants may disagree with the experts' (McTiernan Expert Rep., at 26.) interpretations of those studies and their usefulness, but such issues go to the weight of the experts' testimony, Nevertheless, Defendants contend that Dr. McTiernan's and not their reliability. Defendants may cross-examine opinion on this point is supported only by her own ipse the experts on questions of interpretation. See, e.g., dixit, and assert that "major U.S. newspapers" have Stecyk v. Bell Helicopter Textron, Inc., 295 F.3d 408, written on the relationship between talc and ovarian 414-15 (3d Cir. 2002) ("A party confronted with an cancer. (Defs.' General Causation Br., at 36-37.) adverse expert witness who has sufficient, though However, at least one study relied upon by Dr. perhaps [*547] not overwhelming, facts and McTiernan came to the same conclusion. [*549] As assumptions as the basis for his opinion can highlight explored at the Daubert hearing, the authors of one those weaknesses through effective cross- meta-analysis determined that "[w]hile the results of examination."); Gutierrez v. Johnson & Johnson, No. 01- case control studies are prone to recall bias especially 5302, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 80834, 2006 WL 3246605, with intense media attention following commencement at *8 (D.N.J. Nov. 6, 2006) ("[D]isagreements about the of litigation in 2014, the confirmation of an association in conclusions to be drawn from a particular test affect the cohort studies between perineal talc use and serious weight of a[n expert] report, not its admissibility."); see invasive ovarian cancer is suggestive of a causal also Smith v. Ford Motor Co., 215 F.3d 713, 718 (7th association." (See McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 944 Cir. 2000) ("The soundness of the factual underpinnings (quoting Penninkilampi, et al., Perineal Talc and Ovarian of the expert's analysis and the correctness of the cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, 29 expert's conclusion based on that analysis are factual Epidemiology 41 (2018)).) In the end, Defendants and matters to be determined by the trier of fact, or, where their experts may disagree with Plaintiffs' general appropriate, on summary judgment."). causation experts' assessment of recall bias in the case- control studies, but that does not render their opinions Finally, I do not agree with Defendants that Plaintiffs' unreliable under Daubert. See Walker, 46 F. App'x at general causation experts failed to consider issues of 694. confounding and recall bias in relying on the case- control studies. Defendants maintain that the experts The same is true for Plaintiffs' general causation specifically failed to consider the issue as to whether experts' assessment of potential confounders in the media attention to the relationship between talc and epidemiologic literature. Defendants argue that these ovarian cancer skewed results in certain of the case- experts "fail to meaningfully address" certain possible control studies and, further, whether certain results are confounders. (See Defs.' General Causation Br., at 38- skewed by "confounders," such as douching. (See 42.) "Confounding occurs when another causal factor Defs.' General Causation Br., at 35-41.) However, a (the confounder) confuses the relationship between the review of the experts' reports and testimony reveals that agent of interest and the outcome [*550] of interest." they in fact accounted for these external circumstances Green, supra at 591. Dr. McTiernan explained her and factors. [*548] For example, Dr. McTiernan's expert methodology as to confounding factors at the Daubert report details her findings with respect to the possible hearing: sources of bias in the epidemiological studies she In all but one of the case-control studies presented reviewed. As to recall bias and media attention, Dr. the information on confounders. The problem with McTiernan explained that confounding, you can't assume from reading the [f]or the case-control studies, media reports of paper that these are all the potential confounding associations between talc and ovarian cancer could variables because the studies will present the have influenced cases such that they recalled use confounding variables and they will present them of talcum powder products to a greater degree than for their data for their own study; and you can't controls. However, the studies for which data assume something should be a confounder, if it collection pre-dated news reports of this association wasn't in that study. It's always study specific, the showed similar effects to those for which data were confounding. collected afterward. Thus, "recall bias" is unlikely to be an issue. As mentioned above, recall bias is a I did go through the exercise of looking at those theoretical bias; studies that have investigated individual studies that had reported on when they other sources of data on exposures have failed to took the confounders into account and when they Page 187 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *550

didn't, when they had a relative risk that was just a over time, there is little doubt there is consistency plain old relative risk and then had one that among those studies almost all showing a positive odds adjusted for these confounders and then presented ratio or relative risk, and the majority of those being both of those types of data, and the relative risk statistically significant studies."); Clarke-Pearson were almost identical in all but one, and that one Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1530 ("Looking particularly at the only changed, that relative risk changed a small epidemiologic studies in their totality, there are many amount. That tells me if the relative risks don't studies - and it's only fair to look at them in their totality - change with adjusting for confounding, then it really the data shows really consistent statistically significant wasn't a problem in their study. If the relative risk increase risks of developing epithelial ovarian cancer looks the same after the adjustment, [*551] then it after application of talcum powder to the perineum.").) didn't affect the relative risk. More to the point, Dr. McTiernan provides a detailed (McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 759-60.) Again, consistency analysis in her expert report, Defendants' argument reveals their disagreement with explaining [*553] that 24 of the 28 case-control studies the conclusions of the experts—not the methodology show relative risks greater than 1.1 "for women who had employed in consideration of the studies. To the extent any perineal exposure to talcum powder products, Defendants contend that the general causation experts' compared with never users." (McTiernan Expert Rep., at consideration of confounding elements is insubstantial 64.) Of those 24 studies, Dr. McTiernan notes that 16 or weak, they may explore those inquiries on cross- were statistically significant. (Id.) The doctor observes examination. See Daubert, 509 U.S. at 596 ("Vigorous that 7 of the 8 studies that were not statistically cross-examination, presentation of contrary evidence, significant "had a sample size lower than that estimated and careful instruction on the burden of proof are the to be needed to have power to detect a statistically traditional and appropriate means of attacking shaky but significant result." (Id.) With respect to the cohort admissible evidence."). studies, the doctor opines that they "on average showed more attenuated relative risks of ovarian cancer in relation to use of talcum powder products," likely b. Consistency because the "studies were not well designed to determine true risk for ovarian cancer and perineal talc The consistency factor considers whether the results of use." (Id.) Thus, Dr. McTiernan finds that the cohort the relied upon studies have been replicated. See studies' "results as a group do not negate the significant Green, supra at 604. As explained in the Reference case-control study findings and the significant results of Guide: the meta-analyses and the pooled analysis." (Id.) Nevertheless, Dr. McTiernan opines that the cohort In epidemiology, research findings often are studies, similar to case control studies, also tend to replicated in different populations. Consistency in show a positive association between talc use and these findings is an important factor in making a ovarian cancer, albeit the connection is weaker. Overall, judgment about causation. Different studies that as [*554] explained by Dr. McTiernan, because both examine the same exposure-disease relationship cohort and case control studies demonstrate a positive generally should yield similar results. Although association, they are consistent. (See McTiernan inconsistent results do not necessarily rule out a Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 752.) causal nexus, any inconsistencies signal a need to explore whether different [*552] results can be Defendants raise two main arguments in challenging reconciled with causality. these experts' opinions on consistency. First, Defendants contend that the epidemiological studies are Id. With respect to this Bradford Hill factor, Plaintiffs' not, in fact, consistent, in that the cohort and case- general causation experts found that both the case- control studies have reached different results. (See control and cohort studies are "remarkably consistent" in Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 19.) In other words, Defendants "indicating increased risk of ovarian cancer in women argue that because no cohort study concluded there who used talcum powder products compared to women was a statistically significant association between talc who do not use them." (McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at use and ovarian cancer, the two types of studies cannot 752; see also Carson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1311 ("If you be consistent. (See id.; see also Defs.' General consider the forest plot of the various studies looking at Causation Reply Br., at 26.) Moreover, Defendants the connection from an epidemiological point of view argue that the experts unreliably "attack the long- Page 188 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *554 established concept of statistical significance" in opining the presence of significant findings. If a causal on this Bradford Hill factor. (See Defs.' General connection does not actually exist, significant Causation Br., at 61-66.) Specifically, Defendants findings can still occur due to, inter alia, inability to maintain that the causation experts found consistency of control for a confounding effect or detection bias. A the association simply because a majority of the studies standard based on replication of statistically show a relative risk greater than 1.0. (See id. at 63.) By significant findings obscures the essential issue: a so opining, Defendants reason that the experts "ignore causal connection. This is not to suggest, however, the statistically [*555] insignificant nature of purportedly that statistical significance is irrelevant. Despite the positive results" from cohort studies that may not even problems with treating statistical significance as a support an association. (Defs.' General Causation Reply magic criterion, it remains an important metric to Br., at 35.) distinguish between results supporting a true association and those resulting from mere chance. Defendants' challenge to Plaintiffs' general causation experts' opinions on consistency is, fundamentally, a Zoloft, 858 F.3d at 793 (footnote omitted). dispute over the role that statistical significance plays in determining the consistency of epidemiological studies. Despite Defendants' arguments to the contrary, the In assessing whether epidemiology studies are causation experts considered statistical significance with statistically significant, it is important that an expert respect to both cohort and case control studies, and did determine whether a positive association (a relative risk so in a reliable fashion. For example, at the Daubert greater than 1.0) "represents a true association or is the hearing, Dr. McTiernan testified that, in reviewing each result of random error." Green, supra at 575. The study, she considered the type of statistical significance Reference Guide on Epidemiology identifies two analysis performed—whether p-value or confidence methods for assessing random error: (1) by calculating interval. (McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 830.) In a p-value, or (2) by using confidence intervals.38See id. addition, Dr. McTiernan explained that she also gave at 576-77. weight to positive, non-significant results where such weight was [*557] warranted: The Third Circuit addressed the role of statistical Q. Would it be appropriate as a scientist to dismiss significance in proving causality in In re Zoloft. There, studies due to their p-Value? the court declined to adopt a bright-line rule and instead A. I believe it would be especially when you are stated certain guiding principles: looking in the totality of evidence than to say one study is statistically significant and one is not, and, A causal connection may exist despite the lack of therefore, to dismiss the one where the p-Value is significant findings, due to issues such as random greater than something doesn't give you the full misclassification or insufficient power. Conversely, picture. You really need the full picture. a causal connection may not exist [*556] despite Q. Would it be inappropriate methodology to dismiss as a finding a result that is not statistically significant? 38 A p-value "represents the probability that an observed A. To dismiss a study that is not significant, not positive association could result from random error even if no statistically significant? It would be inappropriate to association were in fact present." Green, supra, at 576. Thus, dismiss that, yes. "[t]o minimize false positives, epidemiologists use a Q. It would be inappropriate? convention that the p-value must fall below some selected level known as alpha or significance level for the results of the A. Inappropriate. study to be statistically significant." Id. Calculating a Q. Dr. McTiernan, looking at this forest plot of both confidence interval, the Reference Guide explains, "permits a case-control and cohort studies, what does the data more refined assessment of appropriate inferences about the from this forest plot of the epidemiological studies association found in an epidemiologic study." Id. at 579 "A that you reviewed both case-control and cohort tell confidence interval is a range of possible values calculated us about the consistency of the data from your from the results of a study. If a 95% confidence interval is review? specified, the range encompasses the results [one] would expect 95% of the time if samples for new studies were A. It tells me it is remarkably consistent because repeatedly drawn from the same population. Thus, the width of you could see that almost all of those relative risk the interval reflects random error. The narrower the confidence data points are to the right of the line. They are all interval, the more statistically stable the results of the study." indicating increased risk in ovarian cancer in Id. at 579-80. Page 189 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *557

women who used talcum powder products explained why the results of cohort studies may have compared to women [*558] who do not use them. yielded a non-statistically significant [*560] casual Q. That's regardless of study design. Is that connection, they nevertheless concluded that these correct? cohort studies, like the case control studies, are A. Yes. consistent because they show a positive association (greater than 1.0 relative risk). In arguing that the (McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 751-52.) experts' opinions should be excluded in this context, Defendants challenge the causation experts' conclusion The doctor's view in this regard is based on a recent that cohort studies, which show a weaker association expert opinion by Dr. Kenneth Rothman, a leading between talc use and ovarian cancer, are designed with epidemiologist, in Modern Epidemiology. Dr. Rothman flaws. Specifically, Defendants take issue with the opined that "[i]t is sometimes claimed that a literature or experts' position on the cohort studies' lack of statistical set of results is inconsistent simply because some of the power, for employing an insufficient follow-up period in results are statistically significant and some are not. light of the long latency period of ovarian cancer, and for This sort of evaluation is completely fallacious even if failing to ascertain the exposure of each participant to one accepts the use of significance testing methods." talc. (Defs.' General Causation Br., at 50-58.) What is (Id. at 934-35.) In other words, according to the experts, evident, however, from Defendants' arguments is that in the epidemiology context, inconsistent statistical they dispute the experts' conclusions and interpretations significance from one study to the next does not, in of of the different studies, not the experts' methodologies. itself, show inconsistency under Bradford Hill. Stated differently, Defendants may very well disagree While Defendants may disagree with the general with Plaintiffs' criticisms of the cohort studies, but a causation expert's approach to statistical significance, dispute over whether the experts are correct in the Court does not find that their methodology is discounting the causative results of the cohort studies unreliable and unsupported by science. Rather, at this relate to the weight of their testimony, [*561] not their stage, I find that they have provided detailed reasons for reliability. See Stecyk, 295 F.3d at 414-15. their findings and their approach to considering statistical significance within the studies in determining consistency. What Defendants have ultimately c. Biological Plausibility presented on statistical [*559] significance is a battle of The next Bradford Hill factor weighed by the general the experts. See In re Gabapentin Patent Litig., 2011 causation experts is biological plausibility, i.e., whether U.S. Dist. LEXIS 158494, 2011 WL 12516763, at *10. the purported association biologically plausible and For instance, Defendants' epidemiology expert, Dr. consistent with existing scientific knowledge. See Diette, as discussed infra, follows the exact method of Green, supra at 604. Commenters have observed that assessing consistency that Defendants promote to be biological plausibility is a difficult criterion because it the correct methodology. Defendants may well believe "depends upon existing knowledge about the this is the better approach, but that is not a question for mechanisms by which the disease develops." Id. this Court to decide when Plaintiffs' experts have Indeed, "observations have been made in epidemiologic provided good grounds for their approach. studies that were not biologically plausible at the time but subsequently were shown to be correct. When an Defendants additionally argue that the general observation is inconsistent with current biological causation experts "mostly ignore the inconsistency knowledge, it should not be discarded, but the between cohort and case-control studies or brush the observation should be confirmed before significance is cohort studies aside as flawed and irrelevant." (Defs.' attached to it." Id. at 604-05. General Causation Br., at 48 (footnote omitted).) Stated differently, Defendants argue that the experts fail to Plaintiffs' general causation experts present two theories meaningfully address the cohort studies, which show a of biological plausibility, both of which are premised on weaker connection between perineal talc use and the their understanding that talc contains asbestos and increased risk of ovarian cancer. (Defs.' General other heavy metals.39 Drs. McTiernan, Carson, and Causation Reply. Br., at 50.) As the Court discussed supra, I do not find that the experts dismissed the cohort studies outright without considering them in conducting their Bradford Hill analyses. Indeed, while the experts 39 The Court finds that the causation experts can reasonably rely on the assumption that talc contains asbestos. Indeed, as Page 190 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *561

Clarke-Pearson present two different theories as to how through the female reproductive system. . . . the purported carcinogens in talc reach the ovaries and The earliest [study] being Egli and Newton in 1961 fallopian tubes: (1) talc migrates up and through the where they looked at the transport of carbon female reproductive system when [*562] applied to the particles through the female reproductive system perineum, or (2) inhaled talc particles travel through the and noted that transport occurred. lymphatic system to the ovaries and fallopian tubes. In 1979, Venter and Iturralde, they studied the Then, once talc is present in the ovaries, the migration of technetium-labeled particles through carcinogens contained in talc cause chronic the reproductive system from the vagina to the inflammation which can lead to carcinogenesis and peritoneal cavity and ovaries and showed that ovarian cancer. occurred as well.

Defendants argue that the theory of the experts that talc There have been [*563] other studies since notably "migrates up" the female reproductive system to the studies on retrograde menstruation and Halme and ovaries must be excluded as unsupported by medical colleagues in 1984, that showed that retrograde evidence. (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 67.) In support of menstruation occurs frequently in many women. this theory, Dr. Carson testified that The Kunz article in 1997 studied the uterine [t]here are a number of studies that have been peristaltic pump, which is produced by muscular done over the years looking at various kinds of activity in the uterus and fallopian tubes, and particulate substance and their ability to migrate showed that sperm traveled much faster through the reproductive system than would be expected based on their motility, and in fact non-motile sperm I have already determined, Dr. Longo, on whose report these traveled at about the same rate all the way through experts rely, will be permitted to testify as to his opinion that the reproductive system. J&J talc contains asbestos. Apart from asbestos, Defendants There was a study by Heller in 1996 that showed argue that Dr. Carson's testimony—that the heavy metals perineal cosmetic talc usage and the relationship of contained in talc, i.e., cobalt, chromium, and nickel, may also talc being found in ovarian specimens. . . . cause ovarian cancer—is unreliable, because these metals [T]here were animal studies that were done mostly have not been proven to be specifically carcinogenic to the in rodent species, and it was determined by the ovary. (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 43-45.) At the outset, for the purposes these Daubert motions, Defendants do not authors that rodents really are not a good model of dispute that talc powder may contain these heavy metals. the human reproductive system. As a matter of fact, (See id.) Dr. Carson explained that while there are no studies there is not really a good nonprimate model of the linking these specific metals to ovarian cancer, they have been female reproductive system for this purpose. And identified by the International Agency for Research on Cancer so I pretty much discounted animal research trying ("IARC") as carcinogens, and these metals have been linked to look at this issue. to specific types of cancer. (See Carson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1308.) However, importantly, the IARC, in its 2012 Monograph There was one study in monkeys that was done by explains that while it may identify certain carcinogens as an investigator named Wehner and colleagues that having specific target organs or tissues where an increased looked at migration in monkeys. They did not risk of cancer has been shown, it further states that find [*564] that migration occurred in these "identification of a specific target organ or tissue does not monkeys, but the authors still were of the opinion preclude the possibility that the agent may cause cancer at that this was a viable transport mechanism and other sites." Int'l Agency for Research on Cancer, 100C listed reasons why their study may not have been Monographs on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to able to show that. . . . Humans: Arsenic, Metals, Fibres, and Dusts, at 29 (2012) (emphasis added). As such, in conducting this analysis, Dr. [T]he Food & Drug Administration has reached the Carson relied, inter alia, on the IARC's conclusions and, opinion that while there exists no direct proof of talc consistent with that conclusion, opined that similar to and ovarian carcinogenesis, the potential for asbestos, the carcinogenic heavy metals found in talc may particulates to migrate from the perineum and the plausibly cause other types of cancer, such as ovarian cancer. vagina to the peritoneal cavity is indisputable. And In that regard, because Dr. Carson's opinion is based on then the Health Canada report, . . . stated: biological plausibility, the Court will permit him to testify that it "This evidence of retrograde transport supports the is plausible that, as carcinogens, these heavy metals may biological plausibility of the association between cause ovarian cancer with respect to his Bradford Hill analysis perineal talc application and ovarian exposure." only. To the extent Defendants take issue with that opinion, they may cross-examine Dr. Carson on that basis. Page 191 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *564

(Carson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1279-81.)40 Dr. Clarke- there's been arguments I've read where: Well, there Pearson, an expert in gynecologic-oncology, explained is a flow out of the uterus, menstrual period, and These are all human experiments where the first that sort of thing, and that's true. But this peristaltic one, carbon particles, were put in the vagina, pump in mid-cycle when there is not a menstrual radioactive particles were put in the vagina, glove period, is actually going the other direction, pulling powder just on the pelvic examination came off the things up into the fallopian tubes. gloves. It was not intentionally put in the vagina. It was just glove powder. (Clarke-Pearson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1560-62.)

In those three papers, migration from the vagina to As Defendants point out, the studies cited by Drs. the fallopian tube and ovary occurred within 24 Clarke-Pearson and Carson do not directly support their hours. Then you could say: Well, wait a minute. theory that externally applied talc can migrate up the This is a particle. It [*565] doesn't have any motility vagina to the ovaries. (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br. at 66.) to it. It's just a carbon particle or radioactive However, biological plausibility does not require microsphere. How did it get here? certainty or even proof for the biological mechanism in So this paper on uterine peristaltic pump, it's been question—the relevant question is "whether the well demonstrated with ultrasound that the uterus hypothesized causal link is credible in light of what is actually has - the uterus is contracting in labor to known from science and medicine [*567] about the push the baby out. But the uterus during the human body and the potentially offending agent." menstrual cycle contracts and has a retrograde so it Milward v. Acuity Specialty Prods. Grp., Inc., 639 F.3d pumps upward, if you will, and that pumping 11, 25 (1st Cir. 2011). The fact that there remains mechanism increases in the early part of the debate in the scientific community as to the mechanism menstrual cycle until the mid-cycle, right before the which permits talc to migrate up to the ovaries does not follicle comes out, before the egg comes out of the preclude admission of the experts' theory. See In re follicle. That gets the maximum pumping Fosamax Products Liability Litigation, 645 F. Supp. 2d mechanism in a retrograde fashion which pumps 164, 183 (S.D.N.Y. 2009) ("That the mechanism things up and works toward getting that egg into the remains unknown does not mean that the one proposed fallopian tube. by the [plaintiffs'] experts is not widely accepted as It can also pump sperm, and that's intense. I think plausible." (emphasis added)); see also In re PPA, 289 biologically, the pump is pulling sperm. If we just F. Supp. 2d at 1247 ("The fact that the mechanism put sperm in the cervix and believe it is going to get remains unclear does not call the reliability of the to the tubes in a very short period of time, the opinion into question . . . ."). Indeed, "biological sperm is motile, but it doesn't move fast. The plausibility is not the same as biological certainty." In re experiments with this peristaltic pump show that Abilify Products Liab. Litigation, 299 F. Supp. 3d 1291, sperm moves much faster than what would be 1308 (N.D. Fl. 2018); see also Milward, 639 F.3d at 22 expected up into the fallopian tube to hopefully ("Lack of certainty is not, for a qualified expert, the same achieve pregnancy because of this peristaltic pump. thing as guesswork." (quoting Primiano v. Cook, 598 F.3d 558, 565 (9th Cir. 2010))). Thus, Bradford Hill and So there is this pump that's going backward, [*566] Daubert do not require that an expert prove the and it is a demonstration of putting microspheres on proposed mechanism—they need only provide reliable the cervix at different points in the menstrual cycle. support that demonstrates that the mechanism is In mid-cycle, when you want to biologically optimize plausible. The Court is satisfied that these experts, pregnancy, that pump is bringing sperm up into the based on the various studies and their past scientific uterus and fallopian tubes. experience and knowledge, have done so under So whether it's the pump bringing up sperm or Daubert; I will permit them to testify as to this theory of bringing up talcum powder or other things, it pumps biological plausibility. Of course, Defendants may or pulls that up. It's not just a passive flow, because vigorously cross-examine the experts on this theory [*568] before a jury.

40 Dr. McTiernan testified similarly on the issue, stating that For the same reasons, the Court will permit Plaintiffs' "several clinical studies in humans show that application of general causation experts to testify that it is biologically particles of similar size to talc when applied to the genital tract plausible that talc can lead to chronic inflammation, can move up to the Fallopian tubes and ovaries." (McTiernan which in turn increases the risk of ovarian cancer. First, Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 780-82.) Page 192 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *568 with respect to whether talc can cause chronic 983 F. Supp. 2d at 1161; see also Hopkins v. Dow inflammation in the ovaries, Defendants fault the experts Corning Corp., 33 F.3d 1116, 1124-25 (9th Cir. 1994); for failing to cite any studies that have found that talc Glaser v. Thompson Med. Co., 32 F.3d 969, 972-75 (6th causes chronic inflammation in the fallopian tubes or Cir. 1994). ovaries. Again, the question of biological plausibility does not require proof of the mechanism. Abilify, 299 F. The Court, however, excludes the inhalation theory Supp. 3d at 1335-36. And, indeed, Plaintiffs' experts presented by Plaintiffs' general causation experts. In provided a solid basis for their theory. Dr. Clarke- addition to positing that talc can migrate up the female Pearson explained at the Daubert hearing that in vitro reproductive system to the ovaries—which the Court studies in which ovarian cells are treated with talc have finds plausible—the experts additionally opine that talc "demonstrated an inflammatory response." (Clarke- particles can reach the ovaries through inhalation. Dr. Pearson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1544.) Dr. Clarke-Pearson Carson explained, albeit not convincingly: further explained that research on this issue is limited A portion of talcum powder that is aerosolized as because in vivo studies cannot be performed due to dust during hygienic applications can be inhaled ethical issues. (Id.) Thus, the in vitro studies provide the into the respiratory system. A very small portion of best evidence—as of now—for the theory that talc that may enter the bloodstream and be able to exposure causes a "chronic inflammatory response to circulate to other tissues including the ovaries. I the ovary . . . which then leads to oxidative stress, think the potential for that to be a significant production of [*569] cytokines and then gene exposure is very insignificant, and it is although a mutations, and those mutations result in cancer." (Id. at secondary route of exposure to perineal 1552-53.) Furthermore, as opined by Dr. Saed in this application [*571] of talc I think it is an extremely case, when ovarian cells are treated with talcum minor one. powder, inflammation and oxidative stress may occur. I have allowed that testimony to be introduced at trial. (Carson Daubert Hr'g Tr. at 1282-83.) Dr. Clarke- Accordingly, in the context of demonstrating biological Pearson's testimony on this theory was similarly scant: plausibility, the Court is satisfied that the hypothesis that Q. Let's transition from migration and talk just briefly talcum powder can cause chronic inflammation, which about inhalation. Did you consider inhalation as may ultimately lead to cancer, is reliable under Daubert. another route of exposure to the ovary? The hypothesis is based on scientific research and A. Yes. I think it's possible. reasoning. Contrary to Defendants' position, the fact that THE COURT: Possible or probable? the mechanism has not been proven does not negate A. I think its plausible. It's less likely than the the reliability of the experts' opinion on this issue. ascension through the vagina and the genital Moreover, Defendants have not introduced any application. I think it's much stronger. evidence that this theory has been disproven as a matter of science, and therefore, I have no basis to find (Clarke-Pearson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at1563-64.) that such a hypothesis is implausible so as to warrant exclusion under a Daubert inquiry. See Berg v. Johnson Dr. McTiernan similarly provided very little support for & Johnson, 940 F. Supp. 2d 983, 993 (D. S. Dakota the inhalation theory, explaining in her expert report 2013). To the extent Defendants seek to challenge the that: basis for Plaintiffs' theory further, they may do so before Data also plausibly indicates that inhalation of a jury and that jury will determine what weight to ascribe talcum powder products can result in exposure to this scientific hypothesis. See In re Neurontin Mktg., leading to cancer, including mesothelioma. Studies 612 F. Supp. 2d 116, 159 (D. Mass. 2009) ("[D]isputes also show that talcum powder products can be over [the expert's] [*570] theory of biological plausibility absorbed and transported via the lymphatic system 'should be tested by the adversary process - competing or blood stream. Therefore, inhalation of talcum expert testimony and active cross-examination—rather powder products could result in similar ovarian than excluded from a jury's scrutiny." (quoting Ruiz- exposure. Published scientific data shows that talc Troche v. Pepsi Cola of P.R. Bottling Co., 161 F.3d 77, reaches the ovary and becomes imbedded in the 85 (1st Cir. 1998))); In re PPA, 289 F. Supp. 2d at 1248 ovarian tissue. (finding that an expert's opinion on biological plausibility is reliable when that opinion is founded on "reports, (McTiernan Expert Rep., at 66.) The "studies" referred textbooks and treatises, and the clinical experience of to by Dr. McTiernan in this testimony presumably refer several experts and other scientists"); see also Berg, to the study [*572] cited for this proposition in her Page 193 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *572 expert report: the 2007 Cramer study.41 (See McTiernan risk of disease." Green, supra at 603. The Reference Expert Rep., at 59.) However, that study, which Guide on Epidemiology states that revealed the presence of talc in a patient's pelvic lymph [g]enerally, higher exposures should increase the nodes, makes no findings as to how the talc ended up in incidence (or severity) of disease. However, some the pelvic lymph node, let alone suggest that the talc causal agents do not exhibit a dose-response entered the lymphatic system through inhalation. See relationship when, for example, there is a threshold Cramer, supra, at 498-501. phenomenon . . . . Thus, a dose-response relationship is strong, but not essential, evidence Aside from these experts claiming that the inhalation that the relationship between an agent and disease theory may be plausible, they fail to otherwise provide is causal. any scientific basis for the theory that talc somehow moves through the lymphatic system to the ovaries. Id. Plaintiffs' general causation experts generally found More particularly, the experts fail to give any scientific this factor to support causation. Dr. Carson explains in support that findings of talc in the pelvic lymph nodes his expert report that "[a]lthough some studies have lends credence to their opinion that talc, once inhaled, failed to find evidence of a dose-response relationship, moves through the lymphatic system to the reproductive several more recent reports [*574] have shown a clear tract and ultimately to the ovaries. While, as the Court dose-response when the number of subjects rose to a discussed above, biological plausibility does not require level producing sufficient statistical power to allow the proof of the biological mechanism, any such opinion analysis after subdivision of subjects into pertinent must be "derived from and supported by reliable categorical groups, and frequency and duration were scientific knowledge and reasoning." Abilify, 299 F. measured." (Carson Expert Rep., at 9.) Dr. Clarke- Supp. 3d at 1308. This Court need not "admit opinion Pearson noted that there has been difficulty in evidence that is connected [*573] to existing data only assessing dose-response because it is dependent on by the ipse dixit of the expert." Soldo v. Sandoz Pharms. the recollection of the user, and studies have attempted Corp., 244 F. Supp. 2d 434, 563 (W.D. Pa. 2003) (citing to determine the frequency of use and/or duration. Joiner, 522 U.S. at 146). That is precisely what Plaintiffs' (Clarke-Pearson Expert Rep., at 9.) Nevertheless, Dr. experts have done in connection with their theory that Clarke-Pearson notes that "a number of studies have inhalation of talc can cause ovarian cancer. For these demonstrated an association between 'dose' and the reasons, I will exclude Plaintiffs' general causation occurrence of [epithelial ovarian cancer]" and the doctor experts' opinion on their secondary theory of biological expresses that he expects more data on this factor "as plausibility, i.e., inhalation. more in vitro studies are performed with talcum powder." (Id.) Dr. McTiernan similarly placed significant weight on this factor, noting that more recent studies contained d. Dose-Response information that relate to dose-response. (McTiernan Expert Rep, at 65-66.) She specifically relied on the Under Bradford Hill, the dose-response factor considers meta-analyses, which "found evidence of relationships whether there is a "dose-response relationship," between increasing amount of exposure to talcum meaning "that the greater the exposure, the greater the powder products in the perineal/genital area . . . and increased risk of developing epithelial ovarian cancer." (Id.) 41 The 2007 Cramer study was a case study that examined the At the Daubert hearing, Dr. [*575] McTiernan described pelvic lymph nodes of a 68-year old woman with stage III her methodology for finding a dose-response serous ovarian cancer and "used talc daily for 30 years as a body powder on the perineum and also applied it to underwear relationship, explaining that the relevant question she and sanitary napkins." Daniel W. Cramer, et al., Presence of asked when looking at the studies was "[d]oes Talc in Pelvic Lymph Nodes of a Woman with Ovarian Cancer increasing use of talcum powder products increase risk and Long-Term Genital Exposure to Cosmetic Talc, 110(2) of ovarian cancer." (See McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at Obstetrics & Gynecology 498, 498 (2007). The Cramer study 791-98.) For example, Dr. McTiernan explained how the concluded that its finding of "talc in pelvic lymph nodes of a Terry pooled analysis42 assessed dose-response. (Id. at long-term talc user with ovarian cancer may begin to reshape understanding about the relationship between talc and ovarian cancer and shed new light on whether talc used externally in the genital area is capable of migrating into the pelvis." Id. at 42 The Terry pooled analysis "estimated the association 501. between self reported genital powder use and epithelial Page 194 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *575

791.) Dr. McTiernan explained that in that study that tells us long-term use has an effect. Five of participants were divided "into four categories by level of those studies they included [in] the meta-analysis use of talcum powder products, and compared to never had total lifetime applications. So its frequency users" based on their relative risk of ovarian cancer. times duration. And they divided those into two (Id.)43 The study showed an increasing relative risk categories corresponding to daily use for 10 years. based on level of use—the relative risk for never users So 3600 total applications more or less, and you did was 1.0; for the first category of users the relative risk see an increase. You see a relative risk of 1.32 for was 1.14; "for the second, 1.23; the third, 1.22; and the the lower group users and 1.42 for the higher, and fourth, 1.32." (Id. at 792.) According to Dr. McTiernan, this is compared to non-users. The confidence "[t]he authors' calculated confidence intervals for each intervals did not include one, so they are of those levels of relative risk, and they all show statistically significant. significance or near significance." (Id.) Moreover, Dr. McTiernan referred to the Penninkilampi44 meta- (Id. at 796.) Finally, Dr. McTiernan explained that while analysis's finding on dose-response, explaining a few studies did not look at dose-response in this fashion, or at all, or, if the study did look at dose- they were able to find most studies that had some response, it did not find any effect, she nevertheless information either on duration [*576] of use or total found, based on the totality of available evidence, there lifetime applications. When they looked at the 12 is a dose-response relationship between talc use and studies who had duration of use, they looked at for ovarian cancer. (See id. at 796-97.) those women who used for more than 10 years compared to less use, the relative risk was 1.25. So Defendants submit that "evidence of dose-response is integral to an assessment of whether talc use causes ovarian cancer" and that the causation experts' ovarian cancer risk in eight population based case control studies." Kathryn L. Terry, et al., Genital Powder Use and Risk testimony demonstrate that "dose-response data are of Ovarian Cancer: A Pooled Analysis of 8,525 Cases and absent in many studies, and the data that do exist are 9,859 Controls, 6 Cancer Prevention Research 811 (2013). inconsistent." (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 26.) Defendants The Terry study concluded that "genital powder use is a further argue that the studies relied on by the experts do modifiable exposure associated with small to moderate not, in fact, support their conclusions. (Id. at 28.) increases in risk of most histologic subtypes of epithelial Plaintiffs, however, contend that Defendants' argument ovarian cancer." Id. ignores the Bradford Hill definition of dose-response and rests on the false requirement that evidence of dose- 43 The four categories of use were based on an estimate of response "be clear and seen consistently 'through the lifetime number of application of talc "by multiplying total body of data.'" (Pls.' General Causation Br., at 155-56.) months of use by frequency of use per month, for all direct and indirect genital powder applications." Terry, supra at 815. More Plaintiffs, instead, maintain that in the context of a specifically, "[n]ever regular users of genital powders and Bradford Hill analysis, the relevant question is whether women who only reported nongenital use were coded as there is any evidence that would support a dose- having zero lifetime genital powder applications." Id. The four response relationship. (Id. at 159-60.) Plaintiffs disagree categories of talc users "were determined on the basis of the with Defendants' position that the studies, upon which specific quartile cutoff points in controls (25th, 50th, and 75th the causation experts rely, do not support the experts' percentile cutoff points are 612, 1,875, and 5,400 for opinions. (See id. at 161-62.) participants 40 years old; 612, 2,160, and 7,200 for 41 [to] 50 years; 720, 3,600, and 10,800 for 51 [to] 60 years; 1,440, Essentially, the parties' dispute with respect to dose- 5,760, and 14,440 for 61 [to] 70; 840, 7,200, and 18,800 for 70 response raises two issues: (1) the weight dose- years)." Id. response [*578] is given in a Bradford Hill analysis, and correspondingly, what type of data is required for finding 44 The Penninkilampi meta-analysis examined the results of of a dose-response; and (2) whether Plaintiffs' general observational studies, both case-control and cohort, that involved at least 50 cases of ovarian cancer. Ross causation experts' finding of a dose-response is Penninkilampi, et al., Perineal Talc [*577] Use and Ovarian adequately supported by the studies on which they rely. Cancer: A systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, 29(1) On the first issue, as a threshold question, the parties Epidemiology 41, 41 (2018). The authors of the Penninkilampi dispute how to weigh dose-response in the greater study conclude that although there is "[s]ome variation in the Bradford Hill inquiry. Defendants, on one hand, assert magnitude of effect . . . when considering study design[,]" "[i]n that dose-response "is integral to an assessment of general, there is a consistent association between perineal whether talc use causes ovarian cancer," whereas talc use and ovarian cancer." Id. Page 195 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *578

Plaintiffs maintain that, in the context of a Bradford Hill response relationship. While Defendants disagree with analysis specifically, a strong dose-response Plaintiffs' general causation experts' interpretation of relationship is not necessarily essential. those studies, the experts provided "good grounds" for their interpretations. For example, Defendants argue Generally, "while precise information concerning the that, in their view, the Terry study "concluded that there exposure necessary to cause specific harm to humans was no trend in risk with increasing talc use," and does and exact details pertaining to the plaintiff's exposure not actually support a dose-response, contrary to Dr. are beneficial, such evidence is not always available, or McTiernan's interpretation. (See id.) In support of their necessary, to demonstrate that a substance is toxic to argument, Defendants point to the Terry study's humans given substantial exposure and need not conclusion that "[a]lthough a significant increase in risk invariably provide the basis for an expert's opinion on with an increasing number of genital powder causation." Westberry v. Gislaved Gummi AB, 178 F.3d applications was found for nonmucinous epithelial 257, 264 (4th Cir. 1999) (admitting expert testimony that ovarian cancer when non-users were included in the exposure to talc caused sinus problems despite inability analysis, no trend in cumulative [*581] dose was to determine threshold level of exposure evident in analyses restricted to ever users of genital necessary [*579] to cause plaintiff's injuries). Here, the powder." (See McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 888.) On Court acknowledges, as correctly pointed out by that point, however, Dr. McTiernan explained that she Defendants, that strong evidence of dose-response interpreted the study to show a dose-response would tend to show a stronger causative relationship relationship based on the comparison of never-users between talc use and ovarian cancer. However, based and users of talc." (Id. at 888-91.) Dr. McTiernan further on epidemiological principles, a strong dose-response is testified that it is "appropriate to include non-users when not necessarily required for an expert to find a casual you are looking at a dose-response effect, unless there nexus. See, e.g., Ferguson v. Riverside Sch. Dist. No. is some other reason non-users are so different they 416, No. 00-0097, 2002 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 28851, 2002 should be excluded. I liken it to if you are testing a dose WL 34355958, at *6 (E.D. Wash. Feb. 5, 2002) ("The for effectiveness in a randomized trial, you would Court determines that the lack of a model for compare it to a placebo." (Id. at 890-91.) In fact, the determining causation based on a 'dose-response' Terry study also concluded, "[t]aken together, these relationship does not undermine the reliability of [the observations suggest that the significant trend test expert's] testimony."). Even so, the causation experts largely reflects the comparison of ever regular use with have pinpointed studies that demonstrate evidence of never use." Terry, supra at 817. dose-response, i.e., meta-analyses, and adequately explained why the studies, themselves, are reliable. See Based on the parties' arguments, I find that both sides Green, supra at 603. offer different interpretations of the Terry study, which did not wholly rule out a dose-response relationship, but Next, Defendants argue that, contrary to the causation instead found the data inconsistent. See Terry, supra at experts' opinions, only a limited number of studies show 819. Admittedly, while the body of evidence with respect a dose-response relationship between talc use and to dose-response is inconclusive, the experts' ovarian cancer, and even in those studies that do show conclusions drawn from such evidence do not constitute a dose-response, the relationship tends to be weak. an "unsupported [*582] scientific leap," as the experts Thus, Defendants submit that the Court must find that have explained the bases for their findings. See the causation experts' opinions are unreliable. I disagree Roundup, 390 F. Supp. 3d at 1134. Distilled to its for two reasons. First, as I already explained, the dose- essence, the dispute between the parties as to whether response factor [*580] need not be significant in order the studies support the experts' opinions appears to be for an expert to, nevertheless, find a causative based on competing interpretations of the studies' relationship, so long as there is reliable epidemiological results and whether those results support a dose- evidence of a dose-response. See Green, supra at 603 response relationship. But, it is not the Court's position (observing that "a dose-response relationship is strong, as gatekeeper to determine whose interpretation of the but not essential, evidence that the relationship between studies is correct, as long as the competing an agent and disease is causal"). interpretations are each rooted in some sound ground. Second, as indicated above, Plaintiffs' experts relied See Stecyk, 295 F.3d at 414-15 ("A party confronted upon certain meta-analysis and pooled studies, which with an adverse expert witness who has sufficient, they interpreted as having demonstrated a dose- though perhaps not overwhelming, facts and assumptions as the basis for his opinion can highlight Page 196 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *582 those weaknesses through effective cross- Defendants may disagree with the experts' conclusions examination."). That is an issue for cross-examination. as to specificity, but that is fodder for cross-examination and not exclusion under Daubert. e. Specificity f. Temporality The next Bradford Hill factor, specificity, provides that "[a]n association exhibits specificity if the exposure is The Court next considers the parties' arguments with associated only with a single disease or type of respect to temporality. It is well-established that "[a] disease." Green, supra at 605. While "evidence of temporal, or chronological, relationship must exist for specificity may strengthen the case of causation, lack of causation to exist," i.e., the exposure must have specificity does not necessarily undermine it where occurred before the disease develops. Green, supra at there is a good biological explanation for its absence." 601. Plaintiffs' general causation experts weighed this Id. Each of Plaintiffs' experts [*583] found this factor to factor highly because "it's been shown that talcum weigh in support of causation, but did not place powder exposure [occurs] before the onset of [*585] significant weight on the factor. Dr. Clarke-Pearson ovarian cancer." (See Clarke-Pearson Daubert Hr'g Tr., explained that "the epidemiologic studies appear[] that at 1542; Carson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1312; McTiernan this is specific for ovarian cancer, not other cancers, Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 799.) Defendants, however, vaginal cancer, uterine cancer." (Clarke-Pearson maintain that "the notion that talc use precedes the Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1542.) Dr. Carson similarly opined onset of ovarian cancer is unremarkable given that that ovarian cancer typically develops late in life, whereas [s]pecificity is a little less easy to define, but most women begin using talc by their mid-20s." (Defs.' essentially it means that this exposure causes a General Causation Br., at 93-94.) Both positions are specific disease and not other diseases, and that true. Talc use precedes an ovarian cancer diagnosis, there is not a lot of confounding. We know that and that fact is "unremarkable." The weight to be given ovarian cancer occurs at a particular rate in women. this factor is an issue for the fact-finder. Defendants' What we have shown through research is that it argument does not present a question of reliability—but occurs more often in women who use talcum scientific disagreement. Dzielak, 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS powder for hygienic purposes on a regular basis. 39232, 2017 WL 1034197, at *26. So based on that information, I believe the specificity consideration is satisfied. g. Coherence (Carson Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1311-12.) Defendants argue that the experts' findings "ignore[] the undisputed The coherence factor, as described by Dr. McTiernan, fact that ovarian cancer is not a single disease, but demonstrates that "[t]he cause-and-effect interpretation instead a number of different diseases, all with different of the data should not significantly conflict with the genetic origins, risk factors, and treatments." (Defs.' known facts about the natural history and biology of the Post-Hr'g Br., at 29.) Plaintiffs, however, maintain that disease." (McTiernan Expert Rep., at 29.) Dr. McTiernan Defendants' position ignores the body of did not weigh this factor heavily, explaining scientific [*584] evidence that demonstrates specificity with epithelial ovarian cancer, and more specifically, [t]he cause-and-effect interpretation of the data on serous ovarian cancer. (Pls.' General Causation Br., at talcum powder product use and risk of ovarian 179-81.) cancer clearly do not significantly conflict with the known facts about the natural history and biology of The testimony of Plaintiffs' experts demonstrates that the disease. Increase[d] [*586] inflammation has their opinions rest on good grounds and considered been linked to risk of ovarian cancer, and talc and scientific evidence to conclude that the association is other contents of talcum powder products elicit specific to ovarian cancer. The experts do not opine as inflammatory responses within areas of the body in to any link between talc use and any other genital which they have been found . . . . While these cancer. Their findings are limited to epithelial ovarian factors support a causal association and my cancer. While epithelial ovarian cancer may have opinions in this regard, I do not weigh them as various subtypes, Defendants have not sufficiently heavily as the strength and consistency of the demonstrated that Plaintiffs' findings are unreliable. association. Page 197 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *586

(McTiernan Expert Rep., at 67.) Similarly, Dr. Carson disease (ovarian cancer) in question. On this issue, opines that Plaintiffs' general causation experts have presented the theory that talc use causes inflammation, which leads to [t]he proposal that talcum powder product use ovarian cancer. Defendants' arguments do not question results in the occurrence of ovarian cancer is whether this particular opinion [*588] was reached in an entirely consistent with what is known about other unreliable manner. Rather, Defendants argue that the factors related to ovarian cancer, i.e. early experts' theory is implausible because "there are menarche, late menopause, pregnancies, numerous subtypes of ovarian cancer," and that it would breastfeeding history, oral contraceptive use, etc. be incoherent to suggest that talc causes all of them, All are factors that influenced the local inflammatory particularly since, according to Defendants, some types environment of the ovary and its surroundings and of ovarian cancer are developed as a result of genetic have the potential to promote existing mutations. However, whether a plaintiff's ovarian cancer transcriptional errors and mutations. is caused by genetic mutations or use of talc, is a question of specific causation that each plaintiff would (Carson Expert Rep., at 10.) Dr. Clarke-Pearson have to separately prove. Rather, in assessing likewise opines that the "[e]pidemiological data, in vitro coherence, it is sufficient that the causation experts and in vivo research are consistent in explaining the examined generally known facts regarding inflammation pathogenesis of [epithelial ovarian cancer] through . . . and cancer, and opined that these facts are coherent inflammatory mechanisms," as well as the causes of with their theory that talc, which may contain other cancers." (Clarke-Pearson Expert Rep., at 9.) carcinogens, can inflame epithelial cells resulting in Defendants present three arguments as to why the cancer. That there are different types of ovarian cancer experts' opinions on coherence [*587] are unreliable: does not undermine the experts' opinion on this factor. (1) "there are numerous subtypes of ovarian cancer, and the notion that talc would cause all of them is Defendants' remaining arguments merely show incoherent"; (2) no animal studies have shown that use disagreement with the conclusion on coherence drawn of talc causes ovarian cancer; and (3) the experts do not by the causation experts. On one hand, the experts reconcile their opinions "with studies that have point to scientific knowledge on the potential for talcum investigated the use of talcum powder on diaphragms powder to cause cellular inflammation, which may lead to cancer. [*589] In that connection, the experts opine and condoms and have found no increased risk."45 that it is entirely coherent with known scientific fact for (Defs.' General Causation Br., at 84-88.) Plaintiffs the studies upon which they rely to show a causative maintain that coherence is demonstrated by the relationship between talc use and ovarian cancer. observational studies which "are long enough to account Notwithstanding this scientific knowledge, Defendants for the development of ovarian cancer and the biologic insist that the experts failed to consider the lack of evidence relied on is consistent with the natural course animal studies of talc use and ovarian cancer, and the of ovarian cancer." (Pls.' General Causation Br., at 186.) studies based on condom and diaphragm usage. Under Bradford Hill, the coherence factor ensures that However, the experts did consider the studies cited by the association (talc use and ovarian cancer), does not Defendants, though they interpreted the studies conflict with other known scientific facts, i.e., coherent differently. For example, with respect to the condom and with existing knowledge of the development of the diaphragm studies, Dr. McTiernan acknowledged the studies' findings, but criticized the studies' lack of clarity as to the amount of talc exposure that results from 45 The condom and diaphragm studies evaluated whether diaphragm application. (See id.) Indeed, Dr. McTiernan application of talcum powder to condoms and diaphragms, found that they were flawed because they did not which are inserted directly into the genital tract, increased the consider "whether "the woman rinsed the diaphragm risk of a woman developing ovarian cancer. (See Defs.' before putting spermicidal jelly and before inserting. So General Causation Br., at 87 & n.206.) For example, case- we don't know about the amount of real exposure." (Id. control studies and meta-analyses that considered the risk of at 906-07.) With respect to the relevant animal studies, ovarian cancer resulting from application of talc to diaphragms Defendants fault the experts for not considering the before insertion did not show a positive association. (See 2009 Keskin study46 or the 1984 Hamilton study.47 McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 904-08.) Dr. McTiernan acknowledged the studies' findings, but criticized the studies' lack of clarity as to the amount of talc exposure that results from diaphragm application. (See id.) 46 In the 2009 Keskin study, researchers treated rats with Page 198 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *589

(Defs.' General Causation Br., at 86.) Again, briefs and do not address the factors in their Post- Plaintiffs' [*590] experts, in fact, considered these Hearing briefing because the factors "were not covered studies. Notably, they rely on these studies to support extensively at the hearing." (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 29 their opinion that application of talc causes n.89.) inflammation, which may lead to cancer. (See McTiernan Expert Rep., at 62-63 (opining that the First, with respect to the experiment factor, which animal studies "demonstrate that talcum powder considers whether there is experimental evidence to products and its attendant inflammation can induce support the association, Defendants posit there is "no carcinogenesis"); Clarke-Pearson Expert Rep., at 4 reliable support for [P]laintiffs' experts' causation ("Talcum powder is known to elicit an inflammatory opinions." (Defs.' General Causation Br., at 92-93.) The response in animals and humans."); Carson Expert experts generally did not afford this factor great weight Rep., at 5 ("When implanted under the skin or into because of the ethical implications for conducting a tissues of laboratory animals, talcum powder induces an randomized trial on women to explore the relationship inflammatory response.").) That these studies only between talc use and ovarian cancer. (See McTiernan showed inflammation as a result of the talc application, Expert Rep., at 67; Clarke-Pearson Expert Rep., at 9). and not neoplastic transformation, i.e., formation of Nevertheless, [*592] the experts reference certain in cancer cells, does not undermine the experts' vitro experiments and animal studies as support for coherence analysis which only refers to the scientific causation. (See McTiernan Expert Rep., at 67; Clarke- knowledge that talc can cause inflammation. Pearson Expert Rep., at 9.) To the extent Defendants Importantly, Defendants do not dispute the known fact assert that contradictory animal and in vitro studies do about the link of cellular inflammation to cancers in not otherwise support causation, that is a question of general, (see Defs.' Bio. Plausibility Br., at 49), which is weight for the jury to decide. As the Court has reiterated the basic premise of the experts' opinion on coherence. throughout this Opinion, the fact that experts may Defendants, instead, raise issues on this Daubert disagree as to how to interpret the relevant studies at motion beyond whether the experts' opinions were issue does not indicate one expert is more reliable than reached using sound methodology; because Plaintiffs' the other. See, e.g., Stecyk, 295 F.3d at 414-15. general causation [*591] experts have presented Moreover, to the extent there are competing studies scientific grounds for their opinion on coherence, that relied upon by the parties' experts, a weighing of those opinion and its bases must be explored on cross- studies is reserved for the factfinder at trial. examination. See Daubert, 509 U.S. at 596. Second, the analogy factor of Bradford Hill provides that "[s]ubstantiation of relationships similar to the putative h. Remaining Bradford Hill Factors causal relationship increases the likelihood of causation." In re Mirena Ius Levonorgestrel-Related Finally, Defendants argue that Plaintiffs' general Prods. Liab. Litig. (No. II) ("Mirena II"), 341 F. Supp. 3d causation experts' analysis of the final two Bradford Hill 213, 243 (S.D.N.Y. 2018); see also Carson Expert Rep., factors—analogy and experiment—are unreliable. at 10 (framing analogy criteria as considering whether Defendants raise these arguments only in their moving "there [have] been other environmental exposures that have been associated with ovarian cancers that act via similar mechanisms."). On this factor, the general intravaginal and perineal talc. Nadi Keskin, et al., Does Long- causation experts compare the relationship between talc Term Talc Exposure Have a Carcinogenic Effect on the and ovarian cancer [*593] to the relationship between Female Genital System of Rats? An Experimental Pilot Study, asbestos and the development of ovarian and lung 280 Archives Gynecologic Obstet. 925, 925 (2009). The study concluded that "[t]alc has unfavorable effects on the female cancer. (See McTiernan Expert Rep., at 67; Clarke- genital system," but that "this effect is in the form of foreign Pearson Expert Rep., at 9; Carson Expert Rep., at 10.) body reaction and infection, rather than being neoplastic." Id. Dr. McTiernan explains that "a similar mechanism has been reported by which asbestos causes ovarian 47 The 1984 Hamilton study involved exposing rat ovaries to cancer. These mechanisms are consistent with one talc by intrabursal injection. T.C. Hamilton, et al., Effects of another and the accepted understanding of the role of Talc on the Rat Ovary, 65(1) J. Exp. Pathol. 101 (1984). The inflammation in carcinogenesis." (McTiernan Expert Hamilton study found that the talc injection "was followed by Rep., at 67.) The experts do not weigh this factor changes in the ovary and its associated tissues" and observed heavily. (See id.) "papillary changes . . . in the surface epithelium of a proportion of the injected ovaries." Id. at 105. Page 199 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *593

The Court finds the weighing of this factor by Plaintiffs' Defendants further challenge the experts' conclusion experts to be reliable. There is no dispute that asbestos that [*595] talc and asbestos are comparable minerals. is carcinogenic and that asbestos has been shown to Defendants assert that it is improper to compare talc cause cancer. In that connection, it is not unreliable for and asbestos because "asbestos and talc are distinct the experts to opine that because asbestos has been minerals with distinct chemical structures and found in talc, it can similarly cause ovarian cancer. morphology, and talc lacks the unique chemical and Defendants, nevertheless, argue that because the physical properties that make asbestos harmful." (Defs.' asbestos mineral that has been most associated with General Causation Br., at 89.) Putting aside that the ovarian cancer—crocidolite—was not found in its talcum experts assumed, by relying on certain studies, that talc powder products, this analogy is inappropriate.48 To contains asbestos, it is, nevertheless, apparent that the better understand Defendants' argument, the Court experts' comparison of asbestos and talc is based on reiterates that crocidolite is in the same family as the these minerals' tendency to cause inflammation, which types of asbestos (anthophyllite and tremolite) that were could lead to carcinogenesis. (See McTiernan Expert found in talc—amphibole asbestos; all of these Rep., at 67.) I cannot find that such a comparison is not asbestoses are regulated. See Int'l Agency for supported by science, such that it was unreliable or Research [*594] on Cancer, World Health Org., 100 inapt. Defendants may disagree with the experts' Monographs on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to findings, but that, in and of itself, is not grounds for Humans: Arsenic, Metals, Fibres, and Dusts 220 (2012) exclusion. (defining as "the five amphibole minerals - actinolite, amosite . . ., anthophyllite, crocidolite, . . ., and tremolite"). Based on that science, the general iii. Consistency with Public Health Agencies causation experts analogize that the asbestos present in talc, like crocidolite, may cause ovarian cancer. Indeed, Finally, Defendants argue that the opinions of Plaintiffs' the purpose of the analogy factor is to compare the general causation experts should be excluded as causal association at issue to other similarly known unreliable because "they are generally inconsistent with causative relationships. See Mirena II, 341 F. Supp. 3d the scientific consensus that a causal relationship at 243. The factor does not require an expert to prove between talc use and ovarian cancer has not been causation, i.e., that anthophyllite or tremolite indeed established." (Defs.' General Causation Br., at 108.) cause ovarian cancer, as Defendants have suggested; Defendants [*596] assert that the opinions of the in fact, to adopt Defendants' argument would turn the causation experts are contrary to the findings of the analogy factor on its head. Rather, it is sufficient, under FDA, NCI, and IARC which have declined to find any this factor, that the causation experts compared the association between ovarian cancer and perineal known relationship between a similar carcinogen application of talc. (See id. at 110.) For example, (crocidolite) and ovarian cancer to the putative Defendants highlight that in 2014, the FDA conducted a carcinogenic effect of anthophyllite and tremolite on the review of the literature available at that time and "did not ovaries. find that the data submitted presented conclusive evidence of a causal association between talc use in the perineal area and ovarian cancer." (Id. (quoting FDA Denial Letter).)

48 The studies to which Defendants referred specifically Plaintiffs counter that the scientific community has not examined the effect of occupational exposure to asbestos. "reached any consensus that talcum powder does not (See Defs.' Longo Br., at 88-89.) For example, Defendants cause ovarian cancer." (Pls.' General Causation Br., at point to the 2011 Reid meta-analysis, which identified three studies that associated occupational exposure to crocidolite 197.) At the outset, I note that Defendants overstate asbestos with ovarian cancer. Reid, et al., Does Exposure to IARC's position on this issue. IARC, in their 2006 Asbestos Cause Ovarian Cancer? A Systematic Literature Monograph, concluded that talc is "possibly Review and Meta-Analysis, 20(7) Cancer Epidemiol carcinogenic." See IARC, 93 Monographs on the Biomarkers Prev. 1287, 1289-90 (2011). While Defendants Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans: Carbon rely on this study to suggest that only crocidolite asbestos has Black, Titanium Dioxide, and Talc 412 (2010). In that been associated with ovarian cancer, (see Defs.' Asbestos Br., regard, IARC made no definitive pronouncement that at 89), the Court notes that the Reid meta-analysis also talc use is not linked to ovarian cancer. See id. (noting highlights four studies that found an association between that "[t]here is limited evidence in humans for asbestos and ovarian cancer, that did not indicate what type of carcinogenicity of perineal use of talc-based body asbestos to which the women were exposed. See id. Page 200 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *596 powder"). [*597] In fact, Plaintiffs argue that IARC's Daubert, weigh the findings of the public health groups categorization of talc as a possible carcinogen supports against those of Plaintiffs' general causation experts and their position. (See Pls.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 24.) In the various scientific, peer-reviewed, studies on which addition, Plaintiffs point to Health Canada's 2018 report they rely. See, e.g., In re Testosterone Replacement on talc, which examines the association between talc Therapy Prods. Liab. Litig. Coordinated Pretrial and ovarian cancer and concluded, after applying the Proceedings, MDL No. 2545, 2017 WL 1833173, at *13 Bradford Hill criteria, that "available data are indicative (N.D. Ill. May 8, 2017) (finding that expert's of a causal effect" and that "[g]iven that there is potential disagreement with FDA report did not undermine for perineal exposure to talc from the use of various self- reliability of testimony and instead was issue of weight care products . . ., a potential concern for human health for jury to resolve). has been identified." Health Canada, Draft Screening Assessment: Talc, at iii (Dec. 2018). Plaintiffs' general In conclusion, what remains clear from the general causation experts maintain that the Health Canada causation evidence relied on by the experts on both report is generally supportive of their findings. (See sides in this matter, is that there is scientific evidence McTiernan Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 721.) Indeed, Dr. supporting each side's opinion. At best, that [*599] the McTiernan testified that Health Canada's analysis body of relevant scientific evidence is inconclusive and differed slightly from her own, but that overall its may be open to different interpretations—does not conclusion is consistent with her conclusion on the mean one side's interpretation is more reliable than the association between talc and ovarian cancer.49 other. See Roundup, 390 F. Supp. 3d at 1126 (finding that "[t]he upshot of all this is that the epidemiology The Court agrees with Plaintiffs—there does not appear evidence is open to different interpretations"). to be scientific consensus on the issue of the Ultimately, the question of whose experts are correct is association between talc use and ovarian cancer. The a question for the jury; it would be erroneous for this case law cited by Defendants [*598] to support their Court to make those factual findings on a Daubert argument that the lack of consensus renders the motion. See Mitchell, 365 F.3d at 244 ("Daubert does experts' opinions unreliable present a very different not require that a party who proffers expert testimony picture than the case at hand. For example, Defendants carry the burden of proving to the judge that the expert's rely on Norris v. Baxter Healthcare Corp., 397 F.3d 878, assessment of the situation is correct" (quoting Ruiz- 885-86 (10th Cir. 2005), in which the expert's opinion Troche, 161 F.3d at 85); In re Processed Egg Prods. was "flatly contrary to all of the available epidemiological Antitrust Litig., 81 F. Supp. 3d 412, 416 (E.D. Pa. 2015) evidence." That is simply not the case here. The public ("Proponents of expert testimony do not 'have to prove health agencies have not reached any consensus that their case twice—they do not have to demonstrate to talc does not cause ovarian cancer. Indeed, the groups the judge by a preponderance of the evidence that the identified by Defendants have simply interpreted and assessments of their experts are correct, they only have weighed the relevant epidemiological evidence to demonstrate by a preponderance of evidence that differently than Plaintiffs' experts and other agencies. their opinions are reliable.'" (citation omitted)). The Court cannot, in its capacity as a gatekeeper under Accordingly, the Court finds that the opinions of Plaintiffs' general causation experts are admissible 49 In arguing that the Plaintiffs' general causation experts under Daubert, subject to the limitations on certain improperly rely on Health Canada's report, Defendants testimony as set forth above. The experts reliably highlight differences between the experts' Bradford Hill applied each factor of [*600] the Bradford Hill analysis analyses and those of Health Canada. (See Defs.' Post-Hr'g as required under Zoloft, even if their conclusions in the Br., at 7-9.) However, the question of whether Health Canada context of some of these factors demonstrate a and the general causation experts identically applied the relatively minimal causal relationship between talc use Bradford Hill factors does not affect the reliability of the and ovarian cancer. 858 F.3d at 795-96; see Mathis v. experts' opinions. Each of the experts, here, has conducted Exxon Corp., 302 F.3d 448, 461 (5th Cir. 2002) his or her own analysis under Bradford Hill by examining the (explaining that the Daubert analysis was never available epidemiological evidence to reach his or her own intended to supplant trial on the merits). Where, as here, conclusions on the association between talc use and ovarian the causation experts' opinions are based on facts, a cancer. That Health Canada may have assessed certain reasonable investigation (including documented Bradford Hill factors differently or come to a slightly different conclusion as to each factor does not undermine the reliability findings), and traditional technical/mechanical expertise, of the experts' opinions. and the experts provide a reasonable link between the Page 201 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *600 information and procedures they use and the Defendants proffer Dr. Gregory Diette as an expert in conclusions reached, the Daubert requirements are met. epidemiology. Dr. Diette is a professor of medicine at See id.; Bigelow v. N.Y. Lighter Co., Inc., No. 03-340, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and holds 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 47871, 2005 WL 67424971, at joint appointments in the Departments of Environmental *1-*3 (W.D. Tex. June 27, 2005); see also Tassin v. Health Sciences [*601] and Epidemiology at the Johns Sears, Roebuck & Co., 946 F. Supp. 1241, 1248 (M.D. Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. (Diette La. 1996). To the extent any of the causation experts' Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1005.) In that capacity, Dr. Diette analyses are "shaky but admissible," Defendants ought has three major roles: (1) evaluate patients at the clinic; to raise these issues on cross-examination before the (2) educate medical students, residents, fellows, and fact finder. It is the role of the adversarial system, not other trainees; and (3) conduct research. (Id.) He the Court, to highlight weak evidence. See Primrose received his M.D. from Temple University School of Operating Co. v. Nat'l Am. Ins. Co., 382 F.3d 546, 562 Medicine. (Diette Expert Rep., at 1.) The doctor also (5th Cir. 2004).50 holds an M.H.S. in epidemiology and clinical epidemiology from the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. (Id.) His areas of clinical III. DEFENSE EXPERTS51 expertise include internal medicine, pulmonary medicine, and critical care medicine. (Id.) While Plaintiffs imply in their briefing that Dr. Diette is not A. Dr. Gregory Diette qualified to provide an epidemiological opinion as to the relationship between talc use and ovarian cancer, because the primary focus of his research is pulmonary disease, (see Pls.' Mem. Of Law in Supp. of Mot. To Exclude Opinions of Defendants' Epidemiology Experts 50 In addition to challenging the reliability of the methodology ("Pls.' Epidemiology Br."), at 6), the Court is satisfied employed by Plaintiffs' general causation experts, Defendants that Dr. Diette is qualified to testify on epidemiology. assert that these experts should be excluded because they Daubert's qualification requirement is liberally "are not employing the same level of rigor in the courtroom construed, and the Third Circuit has instructed that an that characterizes their activities in the field." (Defs.' Post-Hr'g Br., at 76.) Specifically, Defendants fault Dr. Clarke-Pearson expert should not be excluded "merely because the for not advising patients of the dangers of talc, (id. at 76-78); court feels that the [*602] expert is not the best Dr. McTiernan for previously acknowledging a hierarchy of qualified or that the expert does not possess the most epidemiological evidence, (id. at 78-79); and Dr. Carson for appropriate specialization." In re Human Tissue, 582 F. contradicting his previous statement made clinically that even Supp. 2d at 655. I find that Dr. Diette has extensive some exposure to a carcinogen, i.e., benzene, does not training and experience in epidemiology and, further, necessarily raise a health concern. (Id. at 79-80.) Unlike in that his medical training affords him the expertise to other cases where experts have been excluded because their interpret epidemiological studies. As such, to the extent litigation opinions on an ultimate issue contradicted other of Plaintiffs seek to exclude Dr. Diette based on a lack of their published opinions, see In re Zoloft (Sertraline qualifications, I decline to do so. Hydrochloride) Prods. Liab. Litig, 26 F. Supp. 3d 449, 460 (E.D. Pa. 2014) (excluding expert whose testimony Dr. Diette opines that "[t]he body of relevant contradicted her own peer-reviewed publications), the so- epidemiological evidence does not support a causal called contradictory statements suggested by Defendants connection between perineal use of talcum powder appear to be more akin to credibility issues that may be raised products (whatever constituents those products may on cross-examination. contain in addition to talc) and ovarian cancer." (Diette 51 Like Defendants, Plaintiffs have filed motions to exclude Expert Rep., at 2.) Dr. Diette, like Plaintiffs' general various defense experts. Unlike, for example, Drs. Longo and causation experts, performed a Bradford Hill analysis Saed, Defendants' experts, for the most part did not conduct and explains that, most notably, the strength of their own individual testing, i.e., testing the components of talc association, consistency, dose-response, and biological or the effect of talc exposure on ovarian cells. Instead, plausibility factors did not demonstrate a causal Defendants' experts rebut the opinions offered by Plaintiffs' relationship. (Id. at 3.) In sum, Dr. Diette opines experts. In this regard, Plaintiffs' briefing on their motions to exclude repeat many of the arguments already raised in their 1. The epidemiological literature shows a non- opposition to Defendants' motions to exclude. I note that existent association or, at most, a small association neither Plaintiffs nor Defendants address the arguments raised between perineal talc use and ovarian cancer that in Plaintiffs' motions to exclude in their Post-Hearing briefing. Page 202 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *602

constitutes only weak epidemiological evidence. the consistency of association, dose-response, and Because any purported association demonstrated biological plausibility criteria. (See Pls.' Epidemiology in the literature [*603] is weak, it may well be Br., at 7-57.) First, with respect to the consistency of attributed to factors such as confounding, bias or association, Plaintiffs contend that [*605] Dr. Diette's chance. methodology is flawed as he conducted statistical 2. Studies have not consistently shown an significance testing and erroneously applied a association. The prospective epidemiological "'hierarchy of the evidence' principle to assess the talc studies (cohort studies) do not show a statistically studies by generic design or category of study," as significant association; the hospital based case- opposed to considering the specific strengths and control studies do not show a statistically significant weaknesses of each individual study. (Id. at 20-47.) association; and only a subset of the population- Second, as to dose-response, Plaintiffs argue that Dr. based case-control studies show a statistically Diette incorrectly requires, against the Bradford Hill significant association. If consistency could be principles, that there be consistent findings of dose- drawn from these inconsistent results, it would be a response across the studies. (See id. at 52-53 & n.110.) consistency of null results because case-control Finally, Plaintiffs contend that Dr. Diette similarly studies, which are more easily subject to certain misdefined and misapplied the biological plausibility biases and confounding facts, are not the best factor by conflating biological plausibility with biological evidence for proving causation. proof. (Id. at 57-61.)

3. Evidence of a dose-response relationship is Defendants maintain, however, Dr. Diette reliably lacking. None of the cohort studies reveals a dose- applied the Bradford Hill criteria. Defendants reason response relationship, and only a handful of case- that, in addition to considering statistical significance in control studies, including those analyzing addressing the consistency factor, Dr. Diette also "cumulative" talc use, have purported to find one. "considers and rejects Plaintiffs' experts' arguments Moreover, study authors and plaintiffs' experts all criticizing the cohort studies," and addresses other agree that there are major challenges to inconsistencies in the epidemiological studies. (Defs.' interpreting the study findings on dose-response Opp. To Pls.' Mot to Exclude Defs.' Epidemiology because there can be no assurance that any Experts ("Defs.' Epidemiology Br."), at 18-20.) With estimates of talc use are accurate or valid. Indeed, respect to dose-response, [*606] Defendants maintain there is not a single [*604] epidemiologic study that that Dr. Diette correctly found that the studies do not has used, or purports to have used, a validated present evidence of a dose-response and "that even the measure of talcum powder use. Without a validated studies plaintiffs' experts believe provide the strongest measure of talcum powder use, it is impossible to indication of a dose-response instead refute [their] correctly determine whether or not an exposure theory." (See id. at 41-50.) Finally, as to the biological occurred or the quantity of purported exposure, plausibility factor, Defendants contend that Dr. Diette casting considerable doubt on any purported applied the correct standard for biological plausibility causative relationship between perineal talcum and reliably opines that a plausible biological powder use and ovarian cancer. mechanism has not been shown by the relevant studies. 4. The theories as to how talc or asbestos would (Id. at 50-55.) reach the ovaries have not been validated, and the scientific community has repeatedly expressed the Where, as here, the parties have offered competing opinion that the potential mechanism by which expert testimony, the testimony of each expert is talcum powder is associated with ovarian cancer admissible so long as it is reliable and meets the other remains speculative. Daubert requirements. See Perry v. Novartis Pharms. 5. Additional Bradford Hill factors-temporality, Corp., 564 F. Supp. 2d 452, 464 (E.D. Pa. 2008). coherence of the association and analogy-are not Indeed, "[t]hat two different experts reach opposing satisfied based on the available epidemiologic conclusions from the same information does not render evidence and do not support the allegation that their opinions inadmissible." Walker v. Soo Line R.R. talcum powder use can cause ovarian cancer. Co., 208 F.3d 581, 589 (7th Cir. 2000); see also (Diette Expert Rep., at 3.) Pritchard, 705 F. Supp. 2d at 483 (noting that "it will be left to the jury to establish the relative credibility of the Plaintiffs contend that Dr. Diette's opinions are parties' competing experts" (citing Perry, 564 F. Supp. unreliable and specifically challenge his assessment of 2d at 464)); Allapattah Servs, Inc. v. Exxon Corp., 61 F. Page 203 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *606

Supp. 2d 1335, 1340-41 (S. D. Fla. 1999) ("Merely studies) do not show a statistically significant because two qualified experts reach directly opposite association, while only a subset of the population- conclusions using similar, if not identical, data bases or based case-control studies do. This [*609] disagree over which data to use or the manner in which disparity reflects inconsistent results across the data should be evaluated, does not necessarily different types of studies, undermining the mean [*607] that, under Daubert, one opinion is per se conclusion that cosmetic talc use causes ovarian unreasonable."). Instead, such a situation presents a cancer. The fact that none of the cohort studies classic "battle of the experts" scenario which is for the found a statistically significant association between jury to resolve. In re Asbestos, 714 F. Supp. 2d at 547 talc use and ovarian cancer is critical in this regard, (observing that "[t]he ultimate determination of whether because it calls into doubt even the modest expert testimony is correct and 'reliable' in this sense association in some of the population-based case- remains with the jury" (quoting Cook v. Rockwell Int'l control studies. Corp., 580 F. Supp. 2d 1071, 1085 (D. Colo. 2006))); see also Abilify, 299 F. Supp. 3d at 1336 ("To the extent (Diette Expert Rep., at 24 (footnotes omitted).) Dr. Defendants' experts draw a different conclusion from Diette goes on to criticize the consistency findings of those same facts, this presents a proverbial 'battle of the Plaintiffs' general causation experts, notably disagreeing experts,' which appropriately should be decided by a with their assessment of the cohort studies. (See id. at jury."); Dzielak, 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 39232, 2017 WL 24-25.) At the Daubert hearing, the doctor elaborated on 1034197, at *26 ("What is presented here is a classic his methodology for this analysis, explaining that battle of the experts over disputed facts, to be settled by I'm not saying that the entire consistency criterion is the finder of fact; it does not affect admissibility."). fulfilled by whether things are statistically significant or not. What I really focused on primarily was that The Court finds that Dr. Diette's opinions are reliable the different [study] designs produce different and admissible pursuant to Daubert. Dr. Diette's answers, and it is not because of something that testimony at the Daubert hearing and his expert report looks like that. It's because there is a null effect demonstrate that his opinions reasonably flow from the from the cohort studies and not the case-control. epidemiological studies and that he followed a reliable methodology in reaching his conclusions. As to Dr. (Diette Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1160.) The Court finds this Diette's analysis of consistency, the parties, again, analysis to be reliable. It is evident that Dr. Diette dispute the role of significance testing, or statistical considered the totality [*610] of the studies and that his significance, in assessing the consistency of an assessment of the studies is based on "good grounds." association. Plaintiffs' arguments related [*608] to Dr. That Dr. Diette interprets the studies' results differently Diette's analysis of the consistency factor restate the than Plaintiffs' experts is not a ground for exclusion. arguments raised by the parties with respect to Plaintiffs' general causation experts' assessment of the same Next, as to his findings on a dose-response relationship, factor. As the Court discussed above, the parties Dr. Diette explained that "none of the prospective cohort fundamentally disagree as to the weight that should be studies showed a dose-response," and "[w]here the given to the cohort and case-control studies, case-control studies that had some estimate of dose- respectively, and, further, what role statistical response, the results were highly variable." (Id. at 1051.) significance should play in the assessment of the Dr. Diette read these results as "highly inconsistent" and consistency of association. These disputes, based on possibly demonstrative of a lack of a causal relationship. each experts' interpretation of the relevant studies' (See id. at 1052-53.) While Plaintiffs assert that Dr. results and trends, cannot be resolved in the context of Diette unreliably required consistency in doseresponse this Daubert motion. Rather, pursuant to Daubert, my results, Plaintiffs overstate Dr. Diette's analysis. It is review of Dr. Diette's testimony and his expert report is apparent from his hearing testimony that Dr. Diette's only confined to whether Dr. Diette's methodologies in finding of a lack of dose-response is not because of the interpreting the studies are reliable, and on the issue, I inconsistent dose-response results, but instead, based find that his opinion is based on a fair interpretation of on his opinion that the inconsistent results demonstrate the relevant epidemiological studies and is not the lack of a clear dose-response trend. This is a fair methodologically flawed. In his expert report, Dr. Diette reading of the epidemiologic studies. Dr. Diette explains in detail his consistency findings: reviewed the results of the studies and assessed whether they were sufficient to show a dose-response the prospective epidemiologic studies (cohort relationship. Based on the inconsistent [*611] data, Dr. Page 204 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *611

Diette determined there is not such a relationship. That court to make ultimate [*613] conclusions as to the determination rests on "good grounds" and is reliable. persuasiveness of the proffered evidence"). The Court, That Plaintiffs disagree with that interpretation is a in its capacity as a gatekeeper under Daubert, cannot question for cross-examination. See Roundup, 390 F. determine whose opinions or conclusions are more Supp. 3d at 1150-51 (finding that "different sound. To do so would usurp the role of the jury. For interpretations of [epidemiology] studies are not these reasons, Plaintiffs' motion to exclude Dr. Diette is necessarily evidence of unreliability" so long as each denied. interpretation is "sufficiently grounded in scientific principles"). B. Dr. Cheryl Saenz And, finally, with respect to biological plausibility, Dr. Diette in his expert report assessed the studies relied Dr. Saenz has been presented as an expert in upon by Plaintiffs' experts as to their theory that it is gynecologic-oncology. She received her M.D. at the biologically plausible that talc can travel from the University of California, Irvine, and completed her perineal area to the ovaries, where it causes residency in obstetrics and gynecology at the University inflammation that can lead to ovarian cancer. (See of California, San Diego. (Saenz Daubert Hr'g Tr., at Diette Expert Rep., at 36-42.) Dr. Diette opines that the 1799.) Following her residency, Dr. Saenz completed a there is "insufficient" scientific evidence to support that fellowship in gynecologic oncology at Memorial Sloan theory. (See id.) Again, the record demonstrates that Dr. Kettering Cancer Center. (Id.) The doctor is currently a Diette reliably reached this opinion based on his clinical professor in gynecologic oncology at the interpretation of the available data. Simply because Dr. University of California, San Diego, in the Department of Diette and Plaintiffs' experts "reach directly opposite Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Reproductive Sciences. conclusions using similar, if not identical data bases, or (Id. at 1800.) In that position, Dr. Saenz testifies that she disagree over which data to use or the manner in which frequently teaches medical students and trainees risk the data should be evaluated, does not factors for developing ovarian cancer. (Id.) Plaintiffs do necessarily [*612] mean that, under Daubert, one not dispute that Dr. Saenz is qualified to act as an opinion is per se unreliable." Allapattah Servs., 61 F. expert in gynecologic-oncology.52 Supp. 2d at 1341. In this proceeding, Dr. Saenz opines that "perineal Indeed, the dispute over the reliability of Dr. Diette's application of talcum powder does not cause ovarian testimony mirrors the dispute over the admissibility of cancer." (Saenz Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1807.) Dr. Saenz the opinions of Plaintiffs' general causation experts. The parties fundamentally disagree as to which experts' opinion and interpretation is best and, further, which 52 Plaintiffs argue that Dr. Saenz's critique of the opinion of Dr. experts reached the correct conclusions. Where the Rebecca Smith-Bindman, another of Plaintiffs' epidemiology Court has determined that the experts on both sides experts, should be excluded because Dr. Saenz's criticisms have applied a reliable methodology in reaching their are unfounded. In that connection, Plaintiffs contend that conclusions, "it is up to the jury to decide whether the because Dr. Saenz is not an epidemiologist she "lacks the expert used the best or most reliable methodology, what basic qualifications to critique Dr. Smith-Bindman's epidemiological assessment." (Pls.' Br. in Supp. Mot. to weight to accord to his testimony and which of [the] Exclude Defs.' Gynecology-Oncology Experts ("Pls.' competing experts' opinions should be credited." In re Gynecology-Oncology Br."), at 32.) The Court will not Asbestos, 714 F. Supp. 2d at 547 (alteration in original) disqualify Dr. Saenz on these grounds. As the Court has (quoting Cook, 580 F. Supp. 2d at 1085). That is explained, it is well-established that medical doctors are because "[t]he ultimate determination of whether expert qualified to opine as to epidemiology studies. See, e.g., In re testimony is correct and 'reliable' in this sense remains Mirena IUD Prods. Liab. Litig. ("Mirena [*614] I"), 169 F. with the jury." Id.; see also Phillips v. Cohen, 400 F.3d Supp. 3d 396, 426 (S.D.N.Y. 2016) ("[M]edical doctors do not 388, 400 (6th Cir. 2005) (observing that "competing need to be epidemiologists in order to testify regarding expert opinions present the 'classic battle of the experts' epidemiological studies."); Wolfe v. McNeil-PPC, Inc., 881 F. and it [is] up to a jury to evaluate what weight and Supp. 2d 650, 659 (E.D. Pa. 2012). Indeed, the Third Circuit credibility each expert opinion deserves" (alteration in has cautioned that a court may not exclude an expert's original)); Quiet Tech. DC-8, Inc. v. Hurel-Dubois UK, testimony because he or she does not have the particular degree that the court views to be "most appropriate." In re Ltd., 326 F.3d 1333, 1341 (11th Cir. 2003) (noting that Paoli, 916 F.2d at 855. Accordingly, the Court does not find it on a Daubert motion, "it is not the role of the district appropriate to exclude Dr. Saenz on this basis. Page 205 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *614 came to that opinion using the following methodology: purported strength of association or any evidence I went about researching this question as to of a dose-response curve. whether or not talc is a risk factor for the (Saenz Expert Rep., at 17.) development of ovarian cancer, much like I would go about asking any other question in the field of Plaintiffs raise two key arguments as to why Dr. Saenz's gynecologic oncology. I did a very extensive testimony in this matter should be excluded. First, literature search. I reviewed somewhere around 30 Plaintiffs posit that Dr. Saenz did not properly consider case-control studies. I reviewed the four published the "totality of the evidence" because she gave greater cohort studies. I reviewed seven meta-analyses weight to the cohort studies than the case-control and one pooled analysis. studies. (Pls.' Gynecology-Oncology Br., at 6-22.) I went back and looked at the literature surrounding Notably, Plaintiffs assert that Dr. Saenz dismissed what are the known established risk factors for statistically significant case-control studies simply ovarian cancer, and put together a report based on because they had a relative risk of less than 2.0 and that research. I also relied very heavily upon my that she relies on no epidemiologic authority for her experience in the field practicing in the subspecialty dismissal of the case control studies. (Id. at 14-22.) of gynecologic oncology for almost 25 years . . . , and considered all of the patients that I first address the contention that Dr. Saenz unreliably weighed the case-control and cohort studies. At the I have taken care of that have had the diagnosis of Daubert hearing, Dr. Saenz explained that she placed ovarian cancer, as well as the women that are in greater weight on the cohort studies because she my practice and that I have taken care of that are at "think[s] they are more scientifically credible because high risk for developing ovarian cancer, including all they are not as subject to the biases of the case-control of the slides that I [*615] have looked at from their studies." (Saenz Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1912.) In her surgeries, all of the findings that I find when I'm expert report, Dr. Saenz provides detailed reasons as to operating. I relied upon the breadth and depth of why [*617] she placed more weight on the cohort my experience. studies than the case-control studies. (See Saenz Expert Rep., at 9-13.) Indeed, Dr. Saenz identifies (Id. at 1308-09.) While Dr. Saenz did not complete a full certain internal inconsistencies of the case-control Bradford Hill analysis as part of her methodology, she studies and highlights the high risk of recall bias "that is considered certain of the Bradford Hill criteria in inherent not just in the case-control studies on talc and rendering her opinion and criticized the Bradford Hill ovarian cancer, but all case-control studies." (See id.) analyses conducted by Plaintiffs' experts. (See id. at The Court is satisfied that Dr. Saenz has provided "good 1974-76.) Dr. Saenz specifically considered the grounds" for her opinions with respect to the weight she following Bradford Hill factors: (1) strength of placed on the varying case-control and cohort studies. association, (2) consistency, (3) coherence, (4) dose- Plaintiffs may disagree with Dr. Saenz's assessment of response, and (5) biological plausibility. (Id. at 1974.) In the epidemiology studies, but, as this Court has stated sum, Dr. Saenz found that repeatedly, "Daubert neither requires nor empowers trial courts to determine which of several competing the epidemiologic literature on the association scientific theories has the best provenance." Mitchell, between the use of talc in the genital area and the 365 F.3d at 244 (quoting Ruiz-Troche, 161 F.3d at 85. It development of ovarian cancer does not support a is clear from the extensive briefing in this matter that the causal role for talc. The case-control studies are experts disagree about how to assess and weigh the inconsistent, both between studies and within relevant epidemiological studies related to the question individual studies and they are unable to of whether talc use causes ovarian cancer. Resolution demonstrate a dose-response curve; the cohort of that disagreement is reserved for the finder of fact. studies do not demonstrate any statistically significant associations across the tens of Next, Plaintiffs challenge Dr. Saenz's testimony as to thousands of women studied over decades and biological plausibility. In this regard, Plaintiffs raise two they undermine the hypothesis of biologic[al] arguments: (1) Dr. [*618] Saenz incorrectly requires plausibility; and lastly the meta-analyses bring proof of a mechanism, and (2) Dr. Saenz's testimony on nothing new to the discussion, [*616] again biological plausibility is unreliable because she rehashing the same data many times over and still admittedly did not review all the relevant studies cited by being unable to demonstrate any changes in the Plaintiffs' experts with respect to this Bradford Hill Page 206 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *618 criteria. (See Pls.' Gynecology-Oncology Br., at 22-31.) there needs to be "enough science to make sense and Plaintiffs specifically take issue with Dr. Saenz's failure extend it." (Saenz Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 1827-28.) Dr. to review five in vitro studies which they allege Saenz disagrees with both the aspects of biological demonstrate Plaintiffs' theory of biological plausibility: plausibility theory put forth by Plaintiffs' general (1) the 2007 Buz'Zard study, (2) the 2009 Shukla study, causation experts—migration and inflammation—based (3) the 2010 and 2014 Ahktar studies, and (4) Dr. on her clinical experience as a gynecologic-oncologist Saed's 2019 in vitro study. (See Saenz Daubert Hr'g Tr., and her review of the epidemiological literature. (See id. at 1936-37.) Dr. Saenz explained that she "knew about at 1828-32.) Based on her testimony, Dr. Saenz the studies, and [she] knew from reading the expert questions the scientific basis of the biologic mechanism reports that none of these studies actually showed presented by Plaintiffs' general causation experts. malignant transformation," and thus, she determined Where those experts purport to present a supported they were not important to her analysis. (Id. at 1938, hypothetical mechanism, Dr. Saenz asserts that they 1976.) Dr. Saenz further testified that she did, in fact, have proffered a guess that is not based on sufficient read and consider Dr. Saed's 2019 study as set forth in scientific evidence. Again, resolution of that question his expert report in this matter. (See id. at 1937.) would require the Court to weigh the credibility or reliability of each expert's theory to determine which is It is axiomatic that "[w]here an expert ignores evidence more correct; that is not within the province of a judge that is highly relevant to [her] conclusion, contrary to on a Daubert motion. See Gutierrez, 2006 U.S. Dist. [her] own stated methodology, exclusion of the LEXIS 80834, 2006 WL 3246605, at *8. expert's [*619] testimony is warranted." Mirena II, 341 F. Supp. 3d at 241. There is not, however, any In what has become a repeated refrain in this Opinion, I requirement that an expert review every single study in again note that the dispute between the parties [*621] the relevant body of literature. See, e.g., In re C .R. on the admissibility of various causation experts, here, Bard, Inc. v. Pelvic Repair Sys. Prods. Liab. Litig., MDL boils down to which experts are more accurate in their No. 2187, 2018 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 151670, 2018 WL opinions based on competing interpretations of the 4220616, at *5 (S.D. W. Va. Sept. 5, 2018) (observing relevant studies. While Plaintiffs attempt to undermine that "nothing in Daubert requires an expert to consider the reliability of Dr. Saenz's testimony, the Court finds every single article on a topic in order to be admitted as that Dr. Saenz's opinions are admissible under Daubert. an expert"); In re Testosterone Replacement Therapy Accordingly, Plaintiffs' motion to exclude Dr. Saenz is Prods. Liab. Litig. Coordinated Pretrial Proceedings, also denied. MDL No. 2545, 2018 WL 4030585, at *6 (N.D. Ill. Aug. 23, 2018) (finding that simply because an expert did not consider all studies deemed relevant by the opposing C. Dr. Benjamin Neel party or overlooked a study "does not mean that he Dr. Neel is proffered by Defendants as an expert in unreliably applies his methodology"). Here, Dr. Saenz's cancer biology. Dr. Neel is currently the Acting-Director deliberate choice to not review these articles identified of the Laura and Issac Perlmutter Cancer Center at by Plaintiffs, does not render her opinion inadmissible. NYU Langone Health. (Neel Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 279- Dr. Saenz explained that because the studies referred 80.) He is a Professor of Medicine at NYU School of to, but did not reveal, any malignancy from talc, she did Medicine, where he also runs a 13-person research not view them as relevant on the question of biological laboratory. (Id. at 280.) The focus of Dr. Neel's research plausibility. While Plaintiffs dispute Dr. Saenz's opinion, laboratory is "cell signaling in normal cells and how that that disagreement is better explored on cross- is regulated in cancer" and "on generating new models examination. of ovarian cancer and the cell of origin of ovarian As to Dr. Saenz's opinion on biological plausibility, cancer. (Id. at 282.) Dr. Neel received a Ph.D. in viral Plaintiffs submit that Dr. Saenz unreliably requires that oncology at the Rockefeller University in 1982 and his there be "proof" that talc can migrate from the perineum M.D. from Cornell University Medical School in 1983. to the ovaries, notably in the form of a mechanistic (Neel Expert Rep., at 2.) study. (Pls.' Gynecology-Oncology Br., at 22-23.) Dr. Neel opines that "[t]alc is not genotoxic, does not However, at the Daubert hearing, [*620] Dr. Saenz cause mutations, does not cause inflammation [*622] in testified that biological plausibility does not require the female genitourinary tract and has not been shown "proof positive, nor does it need to be an exact to cause ovarian cancer." (Neel Expert Rep., at 14.) The representation of whatever is your hypothesis," but that Page 207 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *622 core of Dr. Neel's opinions are focused on the Washing Machine Class Action Litig., No. 08-51, 2013 experiment conducted by Dr. Saed, and in that U.S. Dist. LEXIS 96070, 2013 WL 3466821, at *4-5 connection, Dr. Neel opines that Dr. Saed's in vitro (D.N.J. July 10, 2013) (admitting testimony of rebuttal study was "flawed on multiple levels" and that the expert where he reliably reviewed testing conducted by results of his study do not support his conclusion that other experts in the proceeding). In short, there is no Defendants' products can cause ovarian cancer. (Neel basis for the Court to find that Dr. Neel's opinions in this Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 303.) Dr. Neel additionally reviewed specific context are unreliable under Daubert. the epidemiological literature and, based on his interpretation of the relevant studies and his weighing of What Plaintiffs argue is that Dr. Neel's opinion is the Bradford Hill criteria, he concludes that there is no unreliable because he did not consider the components evidence to support Plaintiffs' claim that perineal use of of talc. In other words, Plaintiffs fault Dr. Neel for not talcum powder can cause ovarian cancer. (Id. at 296; analyzing whether talc contains known carcinogens, see also Neel Expert Rep., at 14-28.) such as asbestos or other heavy metals, because, they argue, knowledge of the components of talc is essential Plaintiffs attack Dr. Neel's opinions on two grounds. to any opinion as to whether talc causes ovarian cancer. First, Plaintiffs argue that Dr. Neel's opinion with respect (See Pls.' Molecular Biology Br., at 12-14.) Defendants to biological plausibility is not reliable because he is argue Plaintiffs ignore the "core" of Dr. Neel's report and unaware of the constituent components of talc products, opinion—that is, to critique the methodologies employed i.e., whether such products are fibrous, contain by Plaintiffs' experts. (Defs.' Molecular Biology Br., at asbestos, or contain heavy metals. (Pls.' Br. in Supp. 12.) Defendants maintain that "the alleged Mot. to Exclude Defs.' Molecular Biologists ("Pls.' contamination of talc with other substances is utterly Molecular Biology Br."), at 13.) Second, Plaintiffs irrelevant to" Dr. Neel's opinion. (See id. at 15.) The contend that Dr. Neel is not qualified [*623] to testify Court agrees. There is no requirement that Dr. Neel "regarding the strengths and weaknesses of the opine as to the components of talc; indeed, Dr. Neel has epidemiological studies," nor is he qualified to conduct a been proffered [*625] as an expert to rebut the Bradford Hill analysis, as he did here. (Id. at 28.) methodology employed by Dr. Saed in conducting his in Defendants maintain that Dr. Neel need not consider the vitro study. That study does not make any finding as to components of talc in his opinion because his report is whether any component of talc is carcinogenic, but focused on criticizing the methodologies of Plaintiffs' instead opines that talc itself can cause inflammation experts and, to the extent he offers an opinion on and oxidative stress. The issue of the composition of biological plausibility, his testimony is focused on in vitro talc is, thus, irrelevant to Dr. Neel's testimony, and his studies that considered the carcinogenic effect of talc, silence as to those components does not render his notwithstanding talc's components. (Defs.' Br. in Opp. testimony unreliable. Pls.' Mot. to Exclude Defs.' Molecular Biologists ("Defs.' Molecular Biology Br.")., at 14-17.) Defendants Plaintiffs additionally argue that Dr. Neel is not qualified additionally argue that Dr. Neel, as a medical doctor, is to provide an opinion as to the strengths and qualified to opine as to the epidemiologic evidence. (Id. weaknesses of the epidemiological studies, because he at 19-22.) is not an epidemiologist. (Pls.' Molecular Biology Br., at 32-33.) In so arguing, Plaintiffs concede that "the law At the outset, it appears that Plaintiffs do not move to recognizes that 'most arguments about an expert's exclude Dr. Neel's rebuttal opinion to Dr. Saed's qualifications relate more to the weight to be given the testimony. Indeed, Plaintiffs' briefing makes no mention expert's testimony than to its admissibility." (Id. at 28 of Dr. Neel's testimony in this regard, or otherwise (quoting Holbrook v. Lykes Bros. S.S. Co., 80 F.3d 777, suggests it to be unreliable or inadmissible under 782 (3d Cir. 1996).) Nevertheless, Plaintiffs state, Daubert. The Court, after hearing Dr. Neel's testimony without support, that because Dr. Neel is not an at the Daubert hearing and reviewing his expert report, epidemiologist, he cannot reliably opine as to causation finds that Dr. Neel can reliably serve as a rebuttal [*624] expert as to Dr. Saed's opinion that talc causes cellular inflammation.53Cf. In re Front Loading above, Dr. Saed's testimony is limited to his finding that talc causes inflammation and oxidative stress. Dr. Saed will not be permitted to opine as to whether such inflammation leads to 53 The Court notes that to the extent Dr. Neel is called to rebut ovarian cancer. Correspondingly, Dr. Neel will not be the expert testimony of Dr. Saed, his opinions must be limited permitted to rebut any portion of Dr. Saed's report that has to Dr. Saed's admissible opinions. As the Court determined been excluded by the Court. Page 208 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *625 determined by epidemiological grounds. Again, I Testimony of Dr. Saed is GRANTED in part and disagree. The Third Circuit has made clear that an DENIED in part. Specifically, Dr. Saed's testimony expert should not be excluded because he or she does is limited to his opinion and testing that talcum not have "a certain kind of degree or powder causes inflammation and oxidative stress. background." [*626] In re Paoli, 916 F.2d at 855; see Dr. Saed is not permitted to opine as to any also Pineda, 520 F.3d at 244 ("[I]t is an abuse of connection [*628] between talcum powder use and discretion to exclude testimony simply because the trial ovarian cancer. court does not deem the proposed expert to be the best 2. Defendants' Motion to Exclude the Testimony of qualified or because the proposed expert does not have Dr. Longo is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. the specialization that the court considers most Dr. Longo is permitted to opine as to his findings of appropriate." (alteration in original) (quoting Holbrook, asbestos in Defendants' talcum powder products 80 F.3d at 782)). Dr. Neel has extensive medical based on his TEM analysis; however, any opinions training, which establishes his qualifications to interpret based on his PLM analysis are excluded. Further, the relevant epidemiologic literature. In addition to being his opinion that women who used talcum powder a cancer biologist, Dr. Neel holds an M.D. This is products were exposed to asbestos is excluded as sufficient to qualify him to render an opinion with respect unreliable. to the epidemiological studies under Daubert. See, e.g., Wolfe, 881 F. Supp. 2d at 659; Mirena I, 169 F. Supp. 3. Defendants' Motion to Exclude the Testimony of 3d at 424. Plaintiffs' General Causation Experts—Drs. McTiernan, Carson, and Clarke-Pearson, is Finally, Plaintiffs argue that Dr. Neel incorrectly applies GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. Plaintiffs' the Bradford Hill criteria as he places too much weight General Causation Experts will not be permitted to on biological plausibility. Defendants, in response, testify as to their secondary theory of biological maintain that Plaintiffs' position distorts Dr. Neel's plausibility—i.e., that ovarian cancer may be testimony on this issue to make it appear that Dr. Neel, caused by inhalation of talcum powder that travels in his opinion, requires proof of biological plausibility as through the lymphatic system to the ovaries. They "essential." (Defs.' Molecular Biology Br., at 23-24.) may otherwise testify as to their opinions on all Plaintiffs' argument relies on Dr. Neel's deposition other Bradford Hill factors. testimony in which he explained that where "a series of 4. Plaintiffs' Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Dr. epidemiological associations . . . are conflicting and Diette is DENIED. weak, the biological [*627] plausibility becomes 5. Plaintiffs' Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Dr. essential." (Neel Dep. Tr., at 148.) Dr. Neel expanded Saenz is DENIED. on this testimony at the Daubert hearing, explaining that 6. Plaintiffs' Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Dr. biological plausibility is "particularly important when the Neel is DENIED. other evidence is relatively inconsistent or weak." (Neel Daubert Hr'g Tr., at 294.) The doctor elaborated further DATED: April 27, 2020 that he understands biological plausibility to require /s/ Freda [*629] L. Wolfson "some credible scientific evidence supporting the hypothesis." (Id. at 295.) This is an issue that goes to Freda L. Wolfson the weight of Dr. Neel's testimony. Dr. Neel presented good grounds for his opinion that, where an association Chief U.S. District Judge is weak and inconsistent, biological plausibility may become more important in the overall Bradford Hill analysis. While Plaintiffs disagree, that is not a reliability ORDER issue for this Court to decide. For these reasons, the Court denies Plaintiffs' motion to exclude Dr. Neel. THIS MATTER having been opened to the Court by P. Leigh O'Dell, Esq. and Michelle A. Parfit, Esq., counsel for individual consumer-plaintiffs ("Plaintiffs"), on various IV. CONCLUSION motions to exclude defendants' experts, and by Susan M. Sharko, Esq., counsel for Johnson & Johnson, For the foregoing reasons, the Court rules as follows: Johnson & Johnson Consumer Inc. f/k/a Johnson & Johnson Consumer Companies, Inc., and Thomas P. 1. Defendants' Motion to Exclude the Expert Locke, Esq., counsel for Personal Care Products Page 209 of 209 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76533, *629

Council (collectively, Defendants"), on competing ORDERED Plaintiffs' Motion to Exclude the Testimony motions to exclude plaintiffs' experts; it appearing that of Dr. Diette is DENIED; it is further both parties filed opposition briefs to the motions; it further appearing that the Court held a Daubert hearing ORDERED that Plaintiffs' Motion to Exclude the on July 23, 2019 through July 31, 2019, wherein Testimony of Dr. Saenz is DENIED; it is further Plaintiffs' experts, Dr. Ghassan Saed, Dr. William ORDERED that Plaintiffs' Motion to Exclude the Longo, Dr. Arch Carson, Dr. Anne McTiernan, and Dr. Testimony of Dr. Neel is DENIED; and it is further Daniel Clarke-Pearson, provided testimony, and defense experts, Dr. Benjamin Neel, Dr. Gregory Diette, ORDERED that the reasoning in the Court's Opinion and Dr. Cheryl Saenz, also appeared; it appearing that filed herewith, applies with equal force to the remainder instead of calling every expert challenged by the of the pending Daubert motions; and, in that regard, the motions, the parties selected these experts as parties are directed to confer and raise any issues, in a representatives of each field of science involved in this joint submission, with respect to specific experts, e.g., case; it appearing that after the hearing, the [*630] qualifications, that are not covered by this Opinion, parties submitted post-hearing briefs; it appearing that within 45 days of the date of this Order. the Court having considered the parties' extensive submissions and counsel's arguments in connection /s/ Freda L. Wolfson with the motions, the Court renders its decision only with respect to the motions to exclude concerning each of Freda L. Wolfson [*632] the experts who testified; accordingly, for the reasons U.S. Chief District Judge set forth herein, and for good cause shown,

IT IS on this 27th day of April, 2020, End of Document ORDERED that Defendants' Motion to Exclude the Expert Testimony of Dr. Saed is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. Dr. Saed's testimony is limited to his opinion and testing that talcum powder causes inflammation and oxidative stress. Dr. Saed is not permitted to opine as to any connection between talcum powder use and ovarian cancer; it is further

ORDERED that Defendants' Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Dr. Longo is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. Dr. Longo is permitted to opine as to his findings of asbestos in Defendants' talcum powder products based on his TEM analysis; however, any opinions based on his PLM analysis are excluded. Further, his opinion that women who used talcum powder products were exposed to asbestos is excluded as unreliable; it is further

ORDERED that Defendants' [*631] Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Plaintiffs' General Causation Experts— Drs. McTiernan, Carson, and Clarke-Pearson, is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. Plaintiffs' General Causation Experts will not be permitted to testify as to their secondary theory of biological plausibility—i.e., that ovarian cancer may be caused by inhalation of talcum powder that travels through the lymphatic system to the ovaries. They may otherwise testify as to their opinions on all other Bradford Hill factors; it is further