403 WlttenAnstNtS APRIL 10,1992 WritrenAnswers 404 would Ike to I'8CJ.I8Sl the G9vemment to lat [Translation) this august House know the steps It Is going to take to solve water crisis in Deihl. This Is SHRI BRISHIAN PATEL: He has been not the problem merely In those areas where arrested. Arrests have been made. They the hon. Mermers of Par1Iament or the Min- hav~ been nabbed. * is related to the leader isters live, but for the common man who face of the opposition in Bihar, Dr Jagannath the water problem. The Goveml'l'J8nt should Mishra. Because thls is a case of political take some concrete steps to supply them vendena. Shri J)e.vendra Prasad Yadav's water and make a statement in the younger brother was killed deliberately. It is House ..•..• ( Int8fl1Jptions). because Shri Lalu Prasad Yadav was about to inaugurate the Phulparas Sub-division. SHRI KALKA' tiAs (KaroIbagh): Mr. Those people did not want it and resented It. Speaker, SIr, we have drawn the attention of They thought that because of initiative being the House towards this many times. This Is taken by Janata Dal Phulparas has been the factual position that Delhi is going to face made a sub division and later this credit will acute water crisis, as stated by the hon. go to them only. That is why quite deliber- Member. This has created a lot of tension In ately a conspiracy was hatched and hon. the minds of people. W. have been drawing Member, Shri Devendra Prasad Yadav's the attention of the administration for many youngerbrotherwas killed. There is a planned years towards this, but the Government has conspiracy in it. That is why I would like to not done anything. This august House should request you to get it probed. The assailants apprise the Deihl Administration of acute should be punished. This is the only request shortage of water Delhi is going to face. that I would like to make to There is a doubt that people might die of you ...... (Intemiptions) ...... thirst. The administration should be directed to attend to it and solve the problem. SHRI NITISH KUMAR (Barh): Mr. Speaker sir, one person has been arrested SHRI BRISHIN PATEL (Slwan): Mr. In connection with the murder" ...... Speaker Sir, an hon. Member of this House, Shrl Devendra Prasad Yadav's younger [English) brother, Shrl Surendra Yadav was killed on 9.4.92 at 5.00 a.m. in the morning in Phul- MR. SPEAKER: Don't mention the paras market in Madhubanl district by a names. They are not here to defend them- bullet. Duty conscious and brave police in- selves. spector of Phulparas nabbed the three CUl- prits on the spot. The name of one of the ( Interruptions) assailant's Is * - - - - who in the Bihar Vidhan Sabha ...... [Translation 1

[English) SHRI NITISH KUMAR: Congress (I) candidates in the assembly elections· MR. SPEAKER: The name is not form- (lnterruptions) ...... This is a political ing part of the record. mUrder ...... ( Interruptions)

(lntetnJptions) MR. SPEAKER: Such an allegation can

*Not recorded. 405 WrlltBnAnswtB CHAITRA21,1g14(SAKA) Writt9nAnswers 406 be made against you as well...... (/nterrup- House. It is about the murder of an 000. tJons).. ..•. . Member's brother. During the lastfew days, especially all through the last week a furore SHRI NITISH KUMAR: You catTdelete over the murder of Shri Hemant Shahl was the name. I would IIYadavs and many people shall not go into that, but a discussion on the belonging to weaker sections. Such inci- life an hon. Member of the House is neces- dents have been continuously faking place sary. The Bihar Government has been at· in thls area. Pojijical murders are' being tacked in the :ast few days and a demand committed. A few days back the question of was made that the Government should be murderofanM.L.Aandmassacrewasralsed dismissed and President's Rule should be here. AU these things are happening, quite ifTlJOsed. This word was uttered in this House deliberately in Bihar and the Congress(l) is many times in the lastfewdaysbythe people dOing It. The stable Government in the State sitting on that side. I am not going to say is sought to be destablized. That is why I anything about them I have already saidthat would like you to get this matter probed by some ofthemwill raise Biharissuetoday and the Home Minister. We shall request you to at your instance they would attack Bihar and send a Parliamentary delegation to get all then some day they will go against you also these incidents probed. All these murders and no body shall be left here to speak. and the law and order situation which is rapidly deteriorating should be probed by the That is why I shall not go into that. I shall Parliamentary delegation so that the truth not go into those controversies. I would like may emerge. Thls is the conspiracy of the to make a special request to you that I would Congress(I). It will be proved and made like to thank the police official who nabbed public. Through you, I would like to present those culprits in the above murder case. I these facts before the House ..... , (/nmrrup- would like to thank him through you. This tlons) ...... incidenttook place at 5.00 a.m. in the mom- ing and the police station was adjacentto the SHRtGEORGE'FERNANDES (Muzaf- House. As soon as they came to know, they farpur): Mr. Speaker, SIr, 'wish to say two came there and arrested 3 people on the things In thl8connectionforthe lasttew.days spot. But those people who have been ar- the Bihar Govemmef1t is under attack and It rested have links with political leaders and Is going on inside as well as outside the are their relatives. They are among the rela· House. One such thing came before the tives of those people who are taking leader---- 407 WJ#ten AnsW9f$ APRIL 10, 1992 . shlpinBlhar.lamnotnaminganyparty. The sues. nshould be ~ In the meeting function was to take place there on the 14th. as to how growing c'1mlnallsatlon of politics They were running away after murdering the and polltlca/lsatlon of criminals could be Chief organiser of the function. The honour- checked. All the political parties should col- able Prime Ministe,. is not here at the mo- lectively evolve acode 01 condout to check ment. I would like to know from him and the this malice, of which Bihar is a giaring ex· hon. Home Minister whether they. would ample. This .malice is not restricted to Bihar reassure this House regarding this matter State only, but It Is spreading to other areas that their party was not involved in any way also. Legislative measures may also be taken in It. But it is clear and well known that their in this regard. Will we helplessly keep on party had a hand in it. Then, are they willing watching the growing tendencies in this to take up this matter and clarify it in the regard for want of soiution. House. Because I feartha: tho work of engi- neering this kind of incidents shall take place Mr. Speaker, Sir, there was a time when every day and then they would say that our criminals used to influence roliticians from Government can not protect the life and behind the curtain. But gradually the crimi- property of our owr. ,.:eople. So, we have no nals entered the legislature and even be· right to continue in power in the State. The came Ministers and are also noticeble in all Issue can go upto this extent. First, these the spheres of life. Is the Hon. Prime Minister people talked about the murder of their own prepared to take the initiative to check such man. Now the murder issue of our man is a tendency? I think this question has wider being talked about in the State. We people ranlfications and will also have a big ilTllact have experienced all these things and that is on the political future of the country. In this why Mr. Speaker, Sir, it is my most humble regard collective thinking and collective request to you that either the Prime Minister decision of some sort orthe other is essen· orthe Home Minister should make it clear as tial. to who are inVOlved in this murder, who are their political relatives and who are their SHRI RAM NAG INA MISHRA (Pa· leaders. They should not say that these kind drauna): Mr. Speaker, Sir, I am also con- of incidents keep happening. As such it need nected with Bihar. Therefore, I may also be not be discussed here. given an opportunity to say something on this issue. SHRJLAL K AOVANI (Gandhi Nagar): Mr. Speaker, Sir, so far as the Issue of killing is concerned, i am of the view that this Issue Mr. Speaker, Sir, I would also like to say . just concerns Bihar. therefore, in this matter something on what the leader of the opposi- whateverthe State Govemment wants to do tion has just now said. I would also like to to and whosoever has been identified for the make a submission that Bihar like situation is commission of crime should be arrested by .~ developing in the districts of Eastern the State Police. I would like to associate Uttar Pradesh especially in the district of myself with the concern expressed by Shri Deoria. All this I am saying because I hail George Fernandes. I would like to request from the area bordering Bihar. Sir, it Is also the Han. Prime Minister, who is also the correct that when any leader speaks like th is Congress(l) President, to call an all party it definitely has some bearing. Sir, in my area meeting for discussions in view of this inci· Shri Lalu Prasad paid a visit and said in his dent and other recent incidents as he had speech that .. :... is to be done away done in the past to discuss many such is· with.( Interruptions)

-Not recorded. • a·...... CHAITRA21.1914(SA/CA) Writt811 AMINI'S 410 IE9IrhJ hended the cu~ and this pICture has emerged on that basis. The issue becomes MR. SPEAKER: 11ds is not going on a matter of serious concern when the per- racon1 sons active In poIItlcsare associaledwllhthe crIm8. The Issue is not merely that of law and (TMT .....) order. but It Is also the question of public r.fe. Our responsibility does not end with giving SHAI GEORGE FERNANDES: It It is explanations or making arguments and eslll:l,"d,.1Mn'_" prepared to un- counter arguments. In my opinion anyone deqJo.,p.acIII• ...,t (InIenvptions) with poItIcaI background connected with such an incident. especially if his association is SHRI StWtAD VADAV (Madhepura): with the ruling party. then the Ruling party Ifwhat...... 8SIabI1shed. then we has got a special responsibility to act fast. are Pilip • red 1D Uftdrrgo any punishment to Sir. through you. we strongly condemn this be ct.cidad upon Oy'JOU. (Interruptions)· incident. The effective steps taken by the Bihar Government· were in wider perspec- (EtIgIMJ tive. I think definitely there are evil designs behind levelling of many aHegations and URSPEAl

~) THE DEPUTY MINISTER IN THE ...INISTRYOF HOME AFFAIRS(SHRI RAM AN HON. MEMBER: A similar speech tAL RAHI): Mr. Speaker • Sir. the Ministry of was deJiwIf8d by Shri Vajpayee in Uttar Home Affairs is awattillg fuM report from the Pradesh{ tItenuptjons) Government ot B:har aoout the incident of killing of brother ot Shri Devendra Yadav. SHRI VISHWANATH PRATAP SINGH M.P. before arrj\ling ~;: any conclusion or (Fatehpur): Mr. Speaker, Sir, the way Shri taking any action. Something could be said SuAmdra Vadav, brother of Shri Devendra only after thaI. So far as the concern ex- Yadav, M.P. was murdered. is not only a prassed by Shri George Fernandes. the matter of sorrow, but also a matter of con- leader of the opposition and th former Prime cem. It is not s~ a law and order issue. Minister. Shri V.P. Singh on criminalisation Killings and other condemnable acts takes of politics is concemed. I would like to submit place and action is also taken on them. The that no particular individual or political party Police officers acted promptly and appre- is totally responsible. It is clearly evident that

·Not recorded. 411 WritrenAnswers APRIL 10, 1992 WdlMAnsINfS 412 no particular party Is Insulated from the ten- being made. DeItabIIIshaIiopropaganda Is dency of criminals joining its ranks from time being deliberately Iauncebd. Youdespatch a to time and also every party gives patronage team to investigate al the incidents con- to such elements ...... (/ntem.tptIons) I think ceming Bihar, so that ShrtAzaddoes not get the Uaader 01 the opposition has rightly said an opportunity to say anyIIing. Yesterday that all ~ political parties should sit to- candidate 01 his party was caught red- gether and think as to how politics could be handed...... (/ntsnuptJDns) freed from such forces. The criminals who eartler used to approach politicians for fa- SHRI SUAVA NARAYAN VADAV voUr to provide them protection from the (Saharsa): Sir, as pointed out dUMg the • oppression of Policed officials have them- discussion just now and as stated by Ghu- selves now unfortunately become Ministers, lam Nab! Aiadji, we have at along made a MLAs and MPs. I do not think in the prevail- demand that whether it be the murder of ing circumstances the administration can Hemanl Sahi or the incident that took place take action against these criminal elements. yesterday, you may cons1ltute and send a It is a sorry state of affairs and we must think Parliamentary Committee lei Bihar for mak- astohowwecouldgetridoftheseelements. ing an assessment. H we succeed In this endeavour then we will be able to provide good administration to the MR. SPEAKER: Matty incidents take country. place. Do you mean to saythataParliamen- lary Committee should be stond to each I think the Hon. Prime Minister is also place. worried abo",! it and he has been continuo ously watching the situation. He will defi· [English 1 nitely try to find out some solution. Coopera- tion of an the leaders and all the political SHRJ A. CHARLES (Tnvandrum): I parties is required in this task. would like to draw-the attentien-oi this House to a very serious matter. There is a very THE MINISTER OF PARLIAMENTARY disturbing news that a lady Member of this AFFAJRS(SHRIGHULAMNABIAZAD): Mr. Parli<'tmell1 has beel\ men1aJ1y tonured and Speaker, Sir, Jwould lQ(e to submit o"e more harassed because she beY;lOgS to a back-...j thing in this regard. , agree with the views ward community. We speak a lot about the expressed by Shrl V.P. Singh, the Leader of atrocities committed onwcmet\. We equally the opposition and Shrl George Fernandes. are vociferous whenW8'talkaboutthe atroci-:l. We are very much pained about such inci- ties committed on SC anc:t othaf ~ar3 dents In the country whether in the past or communities. But here. a case'" an eiel.1ed now. I totany agree that whosoever is behind lady Member oJ this aU{W5t HclJse; she is such incidents should be dealt with severely. being mentally tOr1wect she is narassed. A My party is IKNer in favour of giving protec- news item saysthatshe ha&even resigned tion to persons involved in such incidents. I As Speaker of this House you have th& would like to submit that killing of the son of responsibilltyfol1he ~cf.8\'ery Member Shri LP. Sah and the recen! Idlling of the of this House. brother of Shrl Oevendra Yadav should n01 be linked with any other pcl!llcai party to She is a promisinIg yOUflg:lady. There divert a!ter.tionfrom the happenings in Bihar. are party diff~ bUt as tat_ at three children J would say ...... a promising SHRI NlTISH KUMAR: .•. ,. (Int8fTup- young lady. A~ ..ustHousf.? lionsj .....• porpoganda of various types is is undergoir.g moRIa agony oecause she-