Victorian Bar News
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
162 VICTORIAN BAR NEWS BAR VICTORIAN ISSUE 162 SUMMER 2017 Slow boat to Shanghai VICTORIAN Ingrid Braun Teaching advocacy BAR far away NEWS Campbell Thomson Everything is orange: my year in Amsterdam Morgan Brown The Travel Issue SUMMER 2017 162 Meet the new Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria Our Corporate Programme rewards are engineered around You. Mercedes-Benz vehicles are the choice of those who demand the best. Our Corporate Programme is designed to make ownership easier for you. As a privileged member the rewards available to you include: • Reduced dealer delivery fee^ • Complimentary scheduled servicing* • Total of 4 years Mercedes-Benz roadside care Take advantage of the benefits today. Call 1800 888 170 or visit www.mercedes-benz/corporate Corporate Programme is subject to eligibility. * Up to 3 years or 75,000km from new (whichever comes first). AMG (excluding V12 vehicles) 3 years or 60,000 km from new (whichever comes first). All V12 vehicles 3 years or 50,000km from new (whichever comes first). ^ Not applicable to all models. ISSUE 162 SUMMER 2017 VICTORIAN BAR NEWS Editorial News and Views Big shoes to fill 7 42 Winemakers at the Bar THE EDITORS CAMPBELL THOMSON Letters to the editors 9 44 Teaching Advocacy far away CAMPBELL THOMSON President’s report 10 JENNIFER BATROUNEY QC 47 Barristers on the move: Is a change as good as a holiday? CEO’s report 15 JENNIFER BATROUNEY QC 47 Perth is where the heart is HELEN TIPLADY Welcome — The Hon. 17 Anne Ferguson 10 48 Moving to Amsterdam BANJO MCLACHLAN MORGAN BROWN 50 Slow boat sabbatical Around town INGRID BRAUN Warren CJ farewell dinner 18 52 Moving to the Brisbane Bar MARK COSTELLO BEN GARDINER Victorian Bar Legends 20 53 A view of Sydney — Dress Codes SIOBHÁN RYAN ED HEEREY Farewell to the Hon. Chief 22 54 The ‘start-up’ that questioned Justice Diana Bryant AO Victoria’s corruption innocence FIONA MCLEOD SC STEPHEN O’BRYAN QC Please, Continue (Hamlet) 24 56 In Conversation with Helen Garner EVELYN TADROS 8 VBN Right Brain vs Left Brain 29 58 A Kimberley Homicide (aka the Master and the Emissary) JOHN KELLY HAROON HASSAN 61 Bar indigenous mentee graduates Rick Amor’s Portrait 31 PAUL DUGGAN of Peter O’Callaghan QC 56 SIOBHÁN RYAN 62 A big year for BCL: eight new floors and major refurbishment project Victorian Bar V. Law Institute 32 begins Of Victoria Football Match MARY HAYES DUGALD McWILLIAMS Opening of Brian 34 Back of the Lift Bourke Chambers 64 Adjourned Sine Die JUSTIN WHEELAHAN 66 Silence all stand The ICJ Victoria annual 36 68 Vale fund raising dinner 78 Gonged CAMPBELL THOMSON 78 Victorian Bar Council CIArb Australia Annual Dinner 37 GIANNA TOTARO 58 79 Victorian Bar Readers Dublin ABA Conference 38 79 New Silks Q&A JUSTIN WHEELAHAN Boilerplate Criminal Bar Dinner 40 85 Judge & Junior VBN 87 Book Reviews CommBar Drinks 41 88 Verbatim VBN 2018 ON SALE JOIN TODAY EXCLUSIVELY TO MEMBERS BELLSHAKESPEARE.COM.AU ISSUE 162 SUMMER 2017 VICTORIAN BAR Editorial NEWS Editors: Natalie Hickey and Justin Wheelahan. Victorian Bar News Editorial Committee: Natalie Hickey, Justin Wheelahan (Editors), Maree Norton, Annette Charak (Deputy Editors), Georgina Schoff QC, Georgina Costello, Catherine Pierce, Brad Barr, Jesse Rudd, Campbell Thomson, Georgie Coleman, Justin Hooper, Denise Bennet, Amanda Utt and Sarah Harrison Gordon. Contributors: (In alphabetical order) Paul Anastassiou QC, Jennifer Batrouney QC, Ingrid Braun, Morgan Brown, Mark Costello, Lisa De Ferrari SC, Craig Dowling SC, Paul Duggan, Paul Ehrlich SC, Garry Fitzgerald SC, Sally Flynn SC, Sarah Fregon, Ben Gardiner, Mark Gibson SC, W Guy Gilbert SC, Ross Gillies QC, Michael Gronow SC, Claire Harris SC, Haroon Hassan, Mary Hayes, Paul Hayes SC, Robert Heath SC, Ed Heerey, Natalie Hickey, Will Houghton QC, Mark Irving SC, Ben Jellis, Scott John SC, Theo Kassimatis QC, John Kelly, Catherine Kusiak, Stewart Maiden SC, Banjo McLachlan, Fiona McLeod SC, Julian McMahon AC SC, Dugald McWilliams, Lisa Nichols SC, Stephen Big shoes to fill O’Bryan QC, Stephen Parmenter SC, David Purcell SC, Warwick Rothnie, Siobhan Ryan, NATALIE HICKEY & JUSTIN WHEELAHAN, EDITORS Suresh Senathirajah SC, Scott Stuckey SC, Evelyn Tadros, Campbell Thomson, Helen Tiplady, Gianna Totaro, Minal Vohra SC, Justin Wheelahan, Michael Wise SC. aking over as editors from Georgina Schoff QC and Photo contributors: Peter Bongiorno, Nicola Georgina Costello is a daunting task. Gina and Georgie Bell, David Cook, Tom Gyorffy, Emma-Jane have been Bar News’ fearless leaders for a number of Johnston, Simon Moglia,Les O’Rourke, Neil years. They have an eye for a story and an endless capacity Prieto, Nicholas Purcell, Josh Robenstone, to know the right person to tell it. As committee members, Megan Tittensor and Sarah Walker. we have always looked forward to our meetings during Publisher: The Victorian Bar Inc., Level 5, their time at the helm. Owen Dixon Chambers, 205 William Street, Melbourne VIC 3000. Registration No. A Gina and Georgie have presided over numerous debates about the 0034304 S. content of the next edition (which have from time to time been serious) The publication of Victorian Bar News may be with good humour and in an inclusive manner. The Victorian Bar is a cited as (2016) 159 Vic B.N. Opinions expressed Tbroad church, and the Bar News tries to reflect the views of its diverse are not necessarily those of the Bar Council or membership. Sometimes, these debates have been less serious but the Bar or of any person other than the author. no less intense. Advertising: Gina and Georgie have been fun and they have made Bar News relevant All enquiries including request for advertising and interesting. Their approach has been symbiotic. They have been so in rates to be sent to: harmony with each other that they would sometimes finish each other’s Sarah Harrison-Gordon sentences. They have also excelled at looking after the dark arts of the The Victorian Bar Inc. Level 5, Owen Dixon Chambers publication process. We are very grateful to Gina and Georgie for their 205 William Street, Melbourne VIC 3000 efforts, and for their continuing mentorship and patience as we take our Tel: (03) 9225 7909 first faltering steps down our own editorial path. We hope to live up to their Email: [email protected] editorial legacy. Particular thanks are also due to the Editorial Committee, to Guy Shield, to Peter Barrett and to members of our Bar Office such as Illustrations, design and production: Guy Shield and The Slattery Media Group; www. Denise Bennett, Amanda Utt, Sarah Harrison-Gordon and Ross Nankivell. slatterymedia.com We have called this edition ‘The Travel Issue’ because we appreciate that Contributions: Victorian Bar News welcomes the January court vacation is a time for reflection as we recalibrate and contributions to [email protected] consider the road ahead, personally and professionally. There is perhaps an enduring assumption that, by our membership of the Victorian Bar, VBN 7 Untitled-1 1 31/10/2017 7:51 am editorial we are more tied to the jurisdiction than those in other advocacy in places such as Vanuatu. Plainly, it is a pursuit professions. One can look wistfully at friends who say, that is confronting and fulfilling in equal measure. “my job involves a lot of travel”, or with envy at those The last six months have been significant for the legal An Apology editorial editorial who mention the travails of travelling to New York, profession in Victoria. In a milestone moment, we said London or Paris. farewell to one Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of to Cisco However, is the road less travelled really the lot of the Victoria and welcomed the next. The retirement of the n the last edition of Victorian Bar News 21st century barrister? After all, barristers have a great Hon. Marilyn Warren AC as Chief Justice was celebrated (VBN 161), in Silence All Stand, reference deal of autonomy. In our feature, ‘Is a change as good at a number of farewell functions hosted by the legal was made to the height of a certain horse as a holiday?’ we have brought together the stories of profession and by the Victorian Bar in an event at the called Cisco (majestic image attached). five barristers who have pursued personal odysseys in National Gallery of Victoria which is covered in this ICisco is owned by the Honourable Justice far flung places, taken a mid career break, or moved edition. We congratulate her successor, Chief Justice Anne David O’Callaghan, and gained special interstate for work for family or personal reasons. Our Ferguson, and look forward to providing insights from our mention in his Honour’s welcome as one objective is to promote reflection and inspiration over new Chief Justice in future editions of Bar News. of his ‘fast horses’. the holiday season. The year ahead can be geographically The legal profession and the Australian public also The article falsely reported that Cisco is a adventurous, if you so wish. saluted Sir Ninian Stephen KG, AK, GCMG, GCVO, mere 14 hands when, in fact, he is a lofty 17.3 Many barristers, of course, also travel on an ad KBE, QC, who passed away on 29 October 2017. Sir hands. The publishers reluctantly accept hoc basis for work, or to give back to the community. Ninian was a former member of our Bar who, amongst that egregious imputations have been cast Appearing in court in Melbourne’s CBD on one day, and his many achievements, was a Justice of the High Court upon Cisco’s manhood (even though he is appearing in Broome the next, might be daunting to some.