J Ornithol (2007) 148 (Suppl 2):S455–S458 DOI 10.1007/s10336-007-0159-8

REVIEW

The renaissance of avian and its bearing on the higher-level phylogeny of

Gerald Mayr

Received: 12 February 2007 / Revised: 24 May 2007 / Accepted: 24 May 2007 / Published online: 20 June 2007 Dt. Ornithologen-Gesellschaft e.V. 2007

Abstract Recent phylogenetic analyses provide strong by only a few specialists and, unlike the situation in evidence for some previously undetected clades of mor- mammalogy (e.g., Novacek 1992; Asher et al. 2003; phologically very divergent avian groups. Also, within the Boisserie et al. 2005), taxa are usually not considered past decades, palaeornithology has experienced a renais- in analyses of and discussions on the phylogeny of extant sance and the Paleogene fossil record of birds is avian taxa, other than calibrations of molecular clocks approaching that of mammals in the number of recorded (e.g., Cracraft et al. 2004; Livezey and Zusi 2007). Livezey higher-level taxa. However, there is still little mutual ex- and Zusi (2007, p. 4) even went as far as to note that fossil change between students of these different data, as birds ‘‘typically provide only substandard anatomical molecular systematists are often unfamiliar with the fossil material or incomplete specimens’’. Certainly, this is not record of birds, whereas palaeornithologists only recently true. Many Paleogene taxa are known from complete started to interpret their in the light of modern skeletons which are often complemented by three-dimen- phylogenetic analyses. Here, this deficiency is remedied in sionally preserved isolated bones, and sometimes even a brief overview of some fossil ‘‘missing links’’ between exhibit remarkable soft-tissue preservation (e.g., Mayr extant higher avian groups, which combine derived char- 2005a, 2006). acters of a certain taxon and plesiomorphic characters of its The significance of fossils as ‘‘missing links’’ (transi- sister group. tional forms) between morphologically disparate clades of extant birds has been vilified as the ‘‘most prevalent idio- Keywords Fossil birds Á Missing links Á syncracy [sic] of paleontological perspectives’’ by Livezey Palaeornithology Á Phylogeny and Zusi (2007, p. 49). Indeed, fossils are not mandatory for a reconstruction of the phylogeny of extant organisms. However, stem group representatives of a certain clade Introduction may support existing phylogenetic hypotheses on widely divergent taxa, if they exhibit old bauplan characteristics In the past few decades, the Paleogene (pre-) fossil which were reduced or transformed in the crown group. In record of birds has approached that of mammals, at least in the following, three examples of such ‘‘missing links’’ are terms of the recognized higher-level taxa (e.g., Mayr given, which provide independent evidence for recently 2005a). However, the avian fossil record is still overseen established phylogenetic hypotheses.

Communicated by F. Bairlein. () and (Podicipediformes) G. Mayr (&) Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg, Sister group relationship between flamingos (Phoenicop- Sektion Ornithologie, Senckenberganlage 25, 60325 Frankfurt am Main, Germany teriformes) and grebes (Podicipediformes) was first pro- e-mail: [email protected] posed in a molecular study of van Tuinen et al. (2001), who 123 S456 J Ornithol (2007) 148 (Suppl 2):S455–S458 analyzed mitochondrial and nuclear DNA sequences as extremitas sternalis of the coracoid which forms three well as DNA–DNA hybridization data, and also resulted pointed projections, the absence of pneumatic foramina in from sequence analyses of the nuclear ZENK gene (Chubb the fossa pneumotricipitalis of the humerus, the presence of 2004), the RAG-2 exon (Cracraft et al. 2004), RAG-1 gene a tuberculum on the os carpi ulnare at the insertion area of (Ericson et al. 2006: Fig. ESM 2), the myoglobin intron 2 the ligamentum humerocarpale, and the fact that the fourth (Ericson et al. 2006: Fig. ESM 3), and combined sequences phalanx of the fourth toe is shorter than the third phalanx of ADH5, GPD3–5, FGB7, 12S rDNA, 16S rDNA, and (Mayr and Knopf 2007). Charadriiform affinities of the tRNA Valine (Fain and Houde 2007). Derived morpho- Turnicidae are further supported by the osteology of the logical characters shared by flamingos and grebes were first early fossil taxon Turnipax, which is known identified by Mayr (2004) and augmented by Manegold from skeletons from Ce´reste in France and Frauenweiler in (2006). Germany. The two of Turnipax are small birds and A flamingo– clade is strongly supported by the combine derived characteristics of crown group Turnicidae fossil , which have an abundant fossil record (including a highly peculiar morphology of the coracoid) in the Paleogene and Neogene of Europe (Mayr 2004, with a plesiomorphic ‘‘charadriiform’’ overall morphology 2005a; note that Livezey and Zusi 2007, p. 50, misquoted (Mayr 2000, Mayr and Knopf 2007). Before any molecular Mayr (2005a) in stating that the ‘‘intermediacy of two evidence for charadriiform affinities of the Turnicidae was skeletal features between Juncitarsus […] and the Pal- available, the striking character mosaic of this fossil taxon aelodidae […] provides a morphological link between raised the question whether ‘‘buttonquails are highly Phoenicopteriformes and Podicipediformes’’; the com- modified which evolved from a Turnipax- ments in that study pertained to only). Pal- like ancestor’’ (Mayr 2000, p. 629). aelodids are unanimously considered stem lineage representatives of the Phoenicopteriformes and possess a deep lower jaw which suggests the existence of a Owlet-nightjars (Aegothelidae) and apodiform birds ‘‘primitive filter-feeding apparatus’’ (Cheneval and Escuillie´ 1992, p. 209). However, they have much shorter It has recently also been suggested that the ‘‘Caprimulgi- hindlimbs than crown group Phoenicopteriformes and the formes’’ (nightjars and allies) are not monophyletic, and tarsometatarsi in particular ‘‘show many similarities with that owlet-nightjars (Aegothelidae) are the sister group of those of a foot-propelled diving such as swifts and (). The owlet- [Podicipedidae]’’ (Cheneval and Escuillie´ 1992). In the nightjar–apodiform clade was first proposed from an light of the new phylogenetic hypotheses, it is reasonable analysis of morphological characters, and apomorphies of to consider the similarities between Palaelodidae and this clade include a derived morphology of the quadrate Podicipedidae to be plesiomorphic. Because grebes and and the splenius capitis muscle (Mayr 2002a). A clade palaelodids are aquatic birds which use their hindlimbs (Aegothelidae + Apodiformes) is supported by an indel in for propulsion, it is thus most parsimonious to assume the c-myc gene (Mayr et al. 2003) and resulted from all that the stem species of the Phoenicopteriformes was also subsequent molecular analyses (Cracraft et al. 2004; Eric- an aquatic bird which used its hind limbs for propulsion son et al. 2006; Barrowclough et al. 2006). in the water (Mayr 2004; contra Storer 2006). Species on Nevertheless, the extant representatives of this clade are the stem lineage of the Phoenicopteridae then entered a morphologically very different, and owlet-nightjars, for new ecological zone, as filter feeders in shallow waters example, differ markedly from apodiform birds in their (see Mayr 2007a). feathering. In the light of the novel phylogenetic hypothesis, it is thus notable that the Middle Parargornis messel- Buttonquails (Turnicidae) and shorebirds ensis, a stem group representative of the Trochilidae, (Charadriiformes) exhibits an owlet-nightjar-like feathering with short and rounded wings and a long tail (Mayr 2005b). Parargornis Molecular analyses provide strong evidence that button- messelensis further has an owlet-nightjar or swift-like quails (Turnicidae), traditionally most often considered and certainly was an insectivorous bird. It is most parsi- aberrant ‘‘gruiform birds’’, are representatives of the monious to assume that the feathering of Parargornis is Charadriiformes (shorebirds and allies) (Paton et al. 2003; plesiomorphic for the total group of Trochilidae (stem Cracraft et al. 2004; Fain and Houde 2004, 2007; Paton and group + crown group); the narrow wings of the crown Baker 2006; Ericson et al. 2006). Derived morphological group representatives are functionally correlated with the features which are shared by crown group Turnicidae and highly specialized hovering flight of the nectarivorous other charadriiform birds include a derived shape of the crown group representatives. 123 J Ornithol (2007) 148 (Suppl 2):S455–S458 S457

Discussion Gruppen vorgestellt, die als ,,missing links’’ (morpholo- gische Zwischenformen) zwischen heutigen ho¨herrangigen All of the clades discussed above: (1) can be established Vogeltaxa betrachtet werden ko¨nnen, und abgeleitete with morphological apomorphies found in the crown group Merkmale eines Taxons mit plesiomorphen Merkmale representatives; (2) result from independent analyses of a seiner Schwestergruppe kombinieren. fair number of different gene sequences; and (3) are further supported by the mosaic character distribution of fossil Acknowledgments I thank two anonymous referees for comments avian taxa. Remarkably, however, none is recovered in the which improved the manuscript. analysis of Livezey and Zusi (2007) which was based on 2,954 characters—probably the largest data set of mor- References phological characters analyzed so far. A discussion of this analysis is beyond the scope of the present paper (see Mayr Asher RJ, Novacek MJ, Geisler JH (2003) Relationships of endemic 2007b). However, the authors included hardly any fossil African mammals and their fossil relatives based on morpho- taxa in their study, and most of those that were considered logical and molecular evidence. J Mammal Evol 10:131–194 are nested within extant clades of lower taxonomic rank Barrowclough GF, Groth JG, Mert LA (2006) The RAG-1 exon in the avian order : phylogeny, heterozygosity, and (e.g., the columbiform ) and thus do not contribute to base composition. Mol Phylogenet Evol 41:238–248 a resolution of the higher-level phylogeny of neornithine Boisserie JR, Lihoreau F, Brunet M (2005) The position of the birds. Omission of fossils from Livezey and Zusi’s (2007) Hippopotamidae within Cetartiodactyla. Proc Natl Acad Sci analysis is so much the more regrettable, as it has been USA 102:1537–1541 Cheneval J, Escuillie´ F (1992) New data concerning Palaelodus shown that even very incompletely known fossil taxa in- ambiguus (Aves: Phoenicopteriformes: Palaelodidae): ecological crease the accuracy of phylogenetic analyses (e.g., Santini and evolutionary interpretations. In: Campbell KE (ed) Papers in and Tyler 2004). Avian Paleontology honoring Pierce Brodkorb. Nat Hist Mus Many Paleogene taxa exhibit a completely unexpected Los Angeles, Sci Ser, 36:208–224 Chubb A (2004) New nuclear evidence for the oldest divergence mosaic combination of characters found in extant birds among neognath birds: the phylogenetic utility of ZENK (i). Mol traditionally considered unrelated (e.g., Mayr 1999, 2001, Phylogenet Evol 30:140–151 2002b). Although phylogenetic interpretations of fossils Cracraft J, Barker FK, Braun M, Harshman J, Dyke GJ, Feinstein J, ´ with an all-too suggestive character combination can of Stanley S, Cibois A, Schikler P, Beresford P, Garcıa-Moreno J, Sorenson MD, Yuri T, Mindell DP (2004) Phylogenetic course be misleading (see, e.g., Livezey and Zusi 2007,p. relationships among modern birds (Neornithes): toward an avian 49, concerning the case of the long-legged anseriform tree of life. In: Cracraft J, Donoghue M (eds) Assembling the Presbyornis), fossil taxa may also be consulted a posteriori tree of life. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 468–489 to make sense of well-supported hypotheses based on Ericson PGP, Anderson CL, Britton T, Elzanowski A, Johansson US, Ka¨llersjo¨ M, Ohlson JI, Parsons TJ, Zuccon D, Mayr G (2006) molecular data which group together morphologically Diversification of : integration of molecular sequence disparate extant taxa. Eventually, fossils are the only direct data and fossils. Biol Lett 2:543–547 evidence of the ancient diversity of life, and it is about time Fain MG, Houde P (2004) Parallel radiations in the primary clades of that avian systematists raise their awareness of this often birds. 58:2558–2573 Fain MG, Houde P (2007) Multilocus perspectives on the monophyly neglected source of phylogenetic information. and phylogeny of the order Charadriiformes (Aves). BMC Evol Biol 7:35 Livezey BC, Zusi RL (2007) Higher-order phylogeny of modern birds Zusammenfassung (, Aves: Neornithes) based on comparative : II. Analysis and discussion. Zool J Linn Soc 149:1–94 Manegold A (2006) Two additional synapomorphies of grebes Neuere phylogenetische Analysen stu¨tzen bisher nicht er- Podicipedidae and flamingos Phoenicopteridae. Acta Ornithol kannte Monophyla, welche morphologisch sehr unter- 41:79–82 Pumiliornis tessellatus schiedliche rezente Vogelgruppen beinhalten. Innerhalb Mayr G (1999) n. gen. n. sp., a new enigmatic bird from the Middle Eocene of Grube Messel (Hessen, der letzten Jahrzehnte hat die Pala¨ornithologie zudem eine Germany). Cour Forsch-Inst Senckenberg 216:75–83 Renaissance erfahren und der pala¨ogene Fossilbericht der Mayr G (2000) Charadriiform birds from the early Oligocene of Vo¨gel na¨hert sich bezu¨glich der Anzahl der bekannten Ce´reste (France) and the Middle Eocene of Messel (Hessen, ho¨herrangigen Taxa demjenigen der Sa¨ugetiere an. Es gibt Germany). Geobios 33:625–636 Mayr G (2001) A new specimen of the tiny Middle Eocene bird jedoch noch wenig gegenseitigen Austausch zwischen den Gracilitarsus mirabilis (new family: Gracilitarsidae). Condor Bearbeitern dieser unterschiedlichen Daten, da Moleku- 103:78–84 larsystematiker ha¨ufig mit dem Fossilbericht der Vo¨gel Mayr G (2002a) Osteological evidence for paraphyly of the avian order nicht vertraut sind, wa¨hrend Pala¨ornithologen gerade erst Caprimulgiformes (nightjars and allies). J Ornithol 143:82–97 Mayr G (2002b). On the osteology and phylogenetic affinities of the beginnen, ihre Fossilien im Hinblick auf moderne phylo- Pseudasturidae: lower Eocene stem-group representatives of genetischen Analysen zu deuten. Hier werden einige fossile (Aves, Psittaciformes). Zool J Linn Soc 136:715–729 123 S458 J Ornithol (2007) 148 (Suppl 2):S455–S458

Mayr G, Manegold A, Johansson U (2003) Monophyletic groups Novacek MJ (1992) Fossils, topologies, missing data, and the within ‘‘higher land birds’’: comparison of morphological and higher level phylogeny of eutherian mammals. Syst Biol molecular data. J Zool Syst Evol Res 41:233–248 41:58–73 Mayr G (2004) Morphological evidence for sister group relationship Paton TA, Baker AJ (2006) Sequences from 14 mitochondrial genes between flamingos (Aves: Phoenicopteridae) and grebes (Pod- provide a well-supported phylogeny of the charadriiform birds icipedidae). Zool J Linn Soc 140:157–169 congruent with the nuclear RAG-1 tree. Mol Phylogenet Evol Mayr G (2005a) The Paleogene fossil record of birds in Europe. Biol 39:657–667 Rev 80:515–542 Paton TA, Baker AJ, Groth JG, Barrowclough GF (2003) RAG-1 Mayr G (2005b) Fossil Hummingbirds in the Old World. Biologist sequences resolve phylogenetic relationships within Charadrii- 52:12–16 form birds. Mol Phylogenet Evol 29:268–278 Mayr G (2006) New specimens of the Eocene Messelirrisoridae Santini F, Tyler JC (2004) The importance of even highly incomplete (Aves: Bucerotes), with comments on the preservation of fossil taxa in reconstructing the phylogenetic relationships of the uropygial gland in fossil birds from Messel and the Tetraodontiformes (Acanthomorpha: Pisces). Integr Comp Biol phylogenetic affinities of Bucerotes. Pala¨ontol Z 80:390–405 44:349–357 Mayr G (2007a) The contribution of fossils to the reconstruction of the Storer RW (2006) The grebe–flamingo connection: a rebuttal. Auk higher-level phylogeny of birds. Species Phylogeny Evol 1:59–64 123:1183–1184 Mayr G (2007b) Avian higher-level phylogeny: well-supported clades van Tuinen M, Butvill DB, Kirsch JAW, Hedges SB (2001) and what we can learn from an analysis of 2,954 morphological Convergence and divergence in the evolution of aquatic birds. characters. J Zool Syst Evol Res (in press) Proc R Soc Lond B 268:1345–1350 Mayr G, Knopf C (2007) A stem lineage representative of button- quails from the lower Oligocene of Germany: fossil evidence for a charadriiform origin of the Turnicidae. Ibis (in press)

123