DOCSLIB.ORG

ABC Board - Trustees for the People Chairman, Donald Mcdonald

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

Quarterly Newsletter: Autumn 2000 Vol.2 No.1 Friends of the ABC Australia Sell-out of the ABC by its trustees? In this issue There has been an outcry in the media about plans to join the ABC's future to Telstra's, and an outcry about Senator Alston's Independence leaked directive re ABC management in a letter to board ABC Board - trustees for the people chairman, Donald McDonald. Little by little, the ABC dies A moral minefield At the same time good news about the ABC abounds. We Media monitor Media Watched know that 92% of Australians rate the value of the ABC to the Challenge to the Federal Government Australian community as valuable. We know that average ABC tops the list of public broadcasters production costs for both radio and television are around Cash for Content 0.4% of those of the commercial stations and networks. We Valuing our ABC know that there are twice the number of Australians who rate Whose products? the quality of ABC television programs 'good' as for their commercial rivals - 87% to 43%. And we also know that while Thus the ABC is becoming increasingly dependent on a variety of the cost of the BBC per day per person is the equivalent of 33 commercial sources. The ABC is built on trust. If the foundations cents a day, we pay 7.7 cents. are eaten away and the building begins to crumble, it will be only It was sad therefore to hear the minister responsible for the a question of time before what we have is only a facade. funding and well-being of the ABC, Senator Alston, tell Paul The ABC has to be properly funded from the public purse. It is Barry on Media Watch 21/2, 'I think in terms of modern held in such high regard by the Australian people - remember management practices the ABC is languishing badly with that 92% - that paying for it from taxes must be a proper measure comparison with people like the BBC, I don't think it has the for any government. same efficiency ethos that others do.' Note that while Senator Alston is responsible also for commercial radio, we have not We are riding high economically and are told we can look forward observed him judging those 'ranting for reward'. to a more efficient tax system. We are not living in a third-world country. Strange, isn't it, how the private sector is self-regulated, ill- supervised, exploitative and shielded from competition, while We cannot afford not to have a robust and fearless public the public broadcaster is to be hog-tied in its planning and broadcaster wholly funded by the Parliament to which it is performance by boards of 'independent experts' and thrown accountable. This is a message every one of us must send - by to the commercial wolves for its funding. letter or phone - to our federal MPs and to the Prime Minister and Cabinet before it is too late. The ABC is built on trust background briefing The ABC is still thought to be free of the influence of editor: Joan Laing corporations and not in the business of tailoring its programs GPO Box 203 Adelaide 5001 for sponsors. But one-fifth of its operating expenses now phone & fax: 08 8271 [email protected] comes from sources other than parliamentary appropriations, unattributed text is by the editor and the submission from ABC management and Board for the next deadline: May 8 next triennium includes an offer to raise a further $40 million, which would bring the total operating revenue from 'independent sources' to $180 million. The ABC Board - trustees for the people of Australia We must go back to May 1970, and the Gorton government. The ABC had sent its budget request to Alan Hulme, the David Bowman comments on Senator Alston's leaked letter to relevant minister. He told the ABC chairman, Robert Madgwick, Chairman Donald McDonald. that he would pass this on to the Treasurer with the advice that This is taken from an article in The Adelaide Review 2/2000 it be reduced by $500,000, at least half the sum to be taken out of television current affairs. The account that follows here is There is another reference to which the minister points. He based on This is the ABC, Ken Inglis's indispensable history says that this ... published in 1983. specifically allows the minister to furnish the board with a The ABC commissioners (predecessors of today's board statement of government policy 'on any matter relating to members) are under no illusions about the implications in the broadcasting or any matter of administration', and the board minister's action and were resolute. They prepare a reply telling is then required to give it proper consideration. Mr Hulme that while they recognise the government's right to make the ABC live within whatever overall budget is granted, it So, he asks innocently, what is all the present fuss about? is they, the commissioners, who have to decide how the budget He knows well enough. It is about his motives and intentions. will be divided up. It is, to repeat, the duty of the ABC board to preserve the The six commissioners who can get to Canberra wait on Mr Corporation's independence. The managing director, Brian Hulme. The ABC staff back them up; the Leader of the Johns, who is to retire next month, says it is vital (his word) to Opposition, Gough Whitlam, raises the matter in parliament; the independence of the ABC that programming and internal newspapers in several states defend the ABC. Five days after budget decisions continue to be the preserve of the the meeting between minister and commissioners, ABC staff broadcaster itself. hold a mass meeting of protest. On the same day, the minister And it is just such decisions that the minister is trying to capitulates. Sir Robert Madgwick issues a statement that the encroach upon. He is acting for a government which, as the reduction proposed would have been completely unacceptable ominous words of a leaked cabinet document showed two to the commission. 'The time had come when we had to dig in years ago, seeks changes: our toes', he said later. 'to give us the ability to influence future ABC functions and And all those ABC commissioners who stood up to the Liberal activities more directly.' minister had been appointed by Liberal-Country Party governments. Well, if the ABC board members remember that they are trustees for the public, they will be wary indeed of Senator DAVID BOWMAN Alston's Trojan horse. There is a previous case of a minister barging into this no-go area of ABC but it remains relevant. Little by little, the ABC dies This thin-end-of-the-wedge approach to commercialising the ABC is only one aspect of what has become common practice in Stewart Fist, Information Technology journalist with The government and political circles, and in many public and mutual Australian, examines how politicians and executives manage organisations (notably AMP and NRMA). unpopular change in an age in which they have lost public trust. In the last week alone I could point to stories about CARE workers in Somalia and Serbia who were asked to help with ... the thin-end-of-the-wedge approach when something military monitoring. It compromised all international nasty is being introduced, and salami-slicing when good humanitarian missions -- but only a little! things are being taken away. Incrementalism is a well-understood technique of governance SBS also revealed that for almost a year AustAid told the that is effective when executives and politicians need to force Australian government Indonesian militia were incrementally through change against public opposition. Incrementalism has murdering Timor's opposition. Indonesia correctly judged that two subdivisions: the thin-end-of-the-wedge approach when daily massacres of 10 to 20 people would be below Australia's something nasty is being introduced, and salami-slicing when threshold for action. We have a remarkable tolerance for small good things are being taken away. massacres among non-European people. The whole point of incrementalism is to be unobtrusive so, Then there's the Australian Broadcasting Authority's cash-for- when a story hits the front pages of the newspaper, the tactic comment report on John Laws and Alan Jones -- an example of has partly failed. Then there is a need to go public, a system finally reaching the thick end of the wedge, where it is characterise objectors as zealots, purists, or fanatics, and say impossible to pretend it hasn't been noticed. everyone is overreacting. This last claim has the uncommon When the wedge has been driven in far enough to be widely virtue of truth. noticed and bought to public attention, there are a number of Opponents of incremental change have no choice but to over- standard and predictable defences. react. Increments always increase when the first change has been adopted. The only successful tactic is to cut off Globalisation and world's best-practice are always good lines to trot out. We are told Australia must follow the pattern of other incrementalism at the earliest possible moment. countries or be left behind. Communications Minister Richard Bureaucrats and politicians know most people have a high Alston used this line to claim the ABC is only following the BBC's threshold of annoyance, and require attacks on their personal lead in flogging its online material. well-being before they respond and participate in counter measures. So the whistleblower can always be isolated and (continued on next screen) labelled difficult, or someone with a bee in their bonnet.
Recommended publications
  • Media Locks in the New Narrative

    Media Locks in the New Narrative

    7. Influences on a changed story and the new normal: media locks in the new narrative It was the biggest, most powerful spin campaign in Australian media history—the strategy was to delay action on greenhouse gas emissions until ‘coal was ready’—with geo-sequestration (burying carbon gases) and tax support. Alan Tate, ABC environment reporter 1990s On 23 September 2013 the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) program Media Watch explored a textbook example of why too many Australians and their politicians continue to stumble through a fog of confusion and doubt in regard to climate change. The case under the microscope typified irresponsible journalism. Media Watch host Paul Barry, with trademark irony, announced: ‘Yes it’s official at last … those stupid scientists on the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [IPCC] got it wrong’, in their latest assessment report. He quoted 2GB breakfast jock Chris Smith from a week earlier saying the IPCC had ‘fessed up’ that its computers had drastically overestimated rising temperatures. ‘That’s a relief,’ said Barry, and how do we know this? ‘Because Chris Smith read it on the front page of last Monday’s Australian newspaper. When it comes to rubbishing the dangers of man-made global warming the shock jocks certainly know who they can trust.’ But wait. The Australian’s story by Environment Editor Graham Lloyd—‘We got it wrong on warming says IPCC’ was not original either. According to Media Watch, Lloyd appeared to have based his story on a News Limited sister publication from the United Kingdom. Said Barry: ‘He’d read all about it in the previous day’s Mail on Sunday,’ which had a story headlined ‘The great green con’.
  • Apo-Nid63005.Pdf

    Apo-Nid63005.Pdf

    AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING TRIBUNAL ANNUAL REPORT 1991-92 Australian Broadcasting Tribunal Sydney 1992 ©Commonwealth of Australia ISSN 0728-8883 Design by Media and Public Relations Branch, Australian Broadcasting Tribunal. Printed in Australia by Pirie Printers Sales Pty Ltd, Fyshwick, A.CT. 11 Contents 1. MEMBERSIDP OF THE TRIBUNAL 1 2. THE YEAR IN REVIEW 7 3. POWERS AND FUNCTIONS OF THE TRIBUNAL 13 Responsible Minister 16 4. LICENSING 17 Number and Type of Licences on Issue 19 Grant of Limited Licences 20 Commercial Radio Licence Grant Inquiries 21 Supplementary Radio Grant Inquiries 23 Joined Supplementary /Independent Radio Grant Inquiries 24 Remote Licences 26 Public Radio Licence Grants 26 Renewal of Licences with Conditions or Licensee Undertaking 30 Revocation/Suspension/Conditions Inquiries 32 Allocation of Call Signs 37 5. OWNERSHIP AND CONTROL 39 Applications and Notices Received 41 Most Significant Inquiries 41 Unfinished Inquiries 47 Contraventions Amounting To Offences 49 Licence Transfers 49 Uncompleted Inquiries 50 Operation of Service by Other than Licensee 50 Registered Lender and Loan Interest Inquiries 50 6. PROGRAM AND ADVERTISING STANDARDS 51 Program and Advertising Standards 53 Australian Content 54 Compliance with Australian Content Television Standard 55 Children's Television Standards 55 Compliance with Children's Standards 58 Comments and Complaints 59 Broadcasting of Political Matter 60 Research 61 iii 7. PROGRAMS - PUBLIC INQUIRIES 63 Public Inquiries 65 Classification of Television Programs 65 Foreign Content In Television Advertisements 67 Advertising Time On Television 68 Film And Television Co-productions 70 Australian Documentary Programs 71 Cigarette Advertising During The 1990 Grand Prix 72 Test Market Provisions For Foreign Television Advertisements 72 Public Radio Sponsorship Announcements 73 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 74 John Laws - Comments About Aborigines 75 Anti-Discrimination Standards 75 Accuracy & Fairness in Current Affairs 76 Religious Broadcasts 77 Review of Classification Children's Television Programs 78 8.
  • PO, Canberra, AX.T. 2601, Australia

    PO, Canberra, AX.T. 2601, Australia

    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 056 303 AC 012 071 TITLE Handbook o Australian h'ult Educatial. INSTITUTION Australian Association of AdultEducati. PUB DATE 71 NOTE 147p. 3rd edition AVAILABLE FROMAustralian Association ofAdult Education, Box 1346, P.O., Canberra, AX.T. 2601,Australia (no price quoted) EDRS PRICE Mr-$0.65 HC-$6.58 DEsCRIPTORS *Adult Education; Day Programs;*Directories; *Educational Facilities; EveningPrograms; *Professional Associations;*University Extension IDENTIFIERS Asia; Australia; New Zealand;South Pacific ABSTRACT The aim of this handbookis to provide a quick reference source for a number ofdifferent publics. It should be of regular assistance to adult andother educators, personnelofficers and social workers, whoseadvice and help is constantlybeing sought about the availability ofadult education facilities intheir own, or in other states. The aim incompiling the Handbook has been tobring together at the National and Statelevels all the major agencies--university, statutory body,government departments and voluntary bodies--that provide programsof teaching for adults open to members of thepublic. There are listed also thelarge number of goverrmental or voluntary bodi_eswhich undertake educationalwork in special areas. The Handbook alsolists all the major public institutions--State Libraries, Museums,and Art Galleriesthat serve importantly to supplement thedirect teaching of adults bytheir collections. New entries includebrief accounts of adult educationin the Northern Territory andin the Territory of Papua-NewGuinea, and the
  • Department of Tutorial Classes, Sydney University, 1919 to 1963 Darryl Dymock and Ann Kelly Griffith University

    Department of Tutorial Classes, Sydney University, 1919 to 1963 Darryl Dymock and Ann Kelly Griffith University

    24 Meeting diverse expectations Meeting diverse expectations: Department of Tutorial Classes, Sydney University, 1919 to 1963 Darryl Dymock and Ann Kelly Griffith University The University of Sydney has offered some form of organised adult education since the late 19th century. In 1914, that provision was formalised through the establishment of a Department of Tutorial Classes, the appointment of a Director, and a partnership with the Workers’ Educational Association (WEA). Right from that time, however, there was ambivalence and sometimes direct opposition to the role and sometimes to the existence of the department. As a result, successive directors of the department had to tread for extending the academy into the adult community, while also satisfying the demands of the WEA. This paper reviews the period of three directorships of the Department of Tutorial Classes, between 1919 and 1963, and argues that the liberal adult education approach adopted by the university from its earliest days was sustained over those 45 years mainly because ongoing disagreement within the university about the purpose of the department and the status of the director, as well as continuing external pressure from the WEA, ensured that the status quo prevailed, even when there were innovative adult education developments elsewhere, and opportunities for change presented themselves. Darryl Dymock and Ann Kelly 25 Introduction University adult education was introduced into Australia more than a century ago as a means of extending the knowledge and expertise of the academy to the general public, through means other than formal tertiary courses. All the sandstone universities and others such as adult education programs.
  • Australian Historians Networking, 1914–1973 Geoffrey Bolton1

    Australian Historians Networking, 1914–1973 Geoffrey Bolton1

    10 Australian Historians Networking, 1914–1973 Geoffrey Bolton1 TheOxford English Dictionary defines networking as ‘the action or process of making use of a network of people for the exchange of information, etc., or for professional or other advantage’.2 Although recently prominent in management theory, the art of networking has been practised over many centuries in many societies, but its role in the Australian academic community has been little explored. This essay represents a preliminary excursion into the field, raising questions that more systematic researchers may follow in time, and drawing unashamedly on the resources of the Australian Dictionary of Biography. Beginning on the eve of the First World War, the essay is bounded by the formation of the Australian Historical Association in 1973, at which date the profession provided itself with 1 This essay is a lightly edited version of the paper prepared by Geoffrey Bolton for the ‘Workshop on Biographies and Autobiographies of Historians’ held at The Australian National University in July 2015. Professor Bolton had intended to make further revisions, which included adding some analysis of the social origins of the Australian historians who participated in the networks he had defined. In all essential respects, however, we believe that the essay as presented here would have met with his approval, and we are very grateful to Carol Bolton for giving permission to make the modest editorial changes that we have incorporated. For biographical information and insights, see Stuart Macintyre, Lenore Layman and Jenny Gregory, eds, A Historian for all Seasons: Essays for Geoffrey Bolton (Melbourne: Monash University Publishing, 2017).
  • Master 260 April ABR Final

    Master 260 April ABR Final

    MEDIA Flip-flops Bridget Griffen-Foley N-AIR BANTER. It’s a staple of radio and television attacking somebody who has achieved something, then I shows seeking to project a friendly, accessible image. think that’s very sad.’ OThink of the chats between Steve and Tracy on Carlton was also sharply critical of Alan Jones, who was Today, and Mel and Kochie (and, increasingly, their viewers) now 2UE’s breakfast host. First he declared the rival on Sunrise. Chats between news, sports and weather present- programme ‘a direct photocopy of mine’, then he dismissed ers are routine. It helps if the weather presenter is gorgeous, Jones as ‘a fast-talking merchant of hype’. Carlton returned to zany or eccentric, such as Tim Bailey on Channel Ten’s 5 p.m. Australia in 1994, where he briefly presented a music-driven news in Sydney or the semi-retired Willard Scott on the NBC breakfast program on MIX 106.5 FM, promising ‘no dumb Today show. (There was never any evident warmth or banter talkback’ and advising listeners to tune in to Jones if they between Channel Nine’s Brian Henderson and Alan Wilkie, ‘want to be told what to think’. one of the few actual meteorologists on air.) The presenters Why recycle these old comments? Well, pretty soon are meant to seem ‘just like us’ as they yarn about their Carlton was back doing talk radio on ABC 702 and then 2UE; weekends, their birthdays and their children. Some of the after a time hosting the 2UE afternoon programme he began chats, particularly between radio hosts, are designed to including more talkback, assuring listeners that he wanted to personalise and promote interest in what’s coming up on the hear what they had to say; and his stablemates were Jones next programme.
  • Australian Radio Anecdotes

    Australian Radio Anecdotes

    AUSTRALIAN RADIO ANECDOTES * On 3XY, Keith Williams was interviewing a gynaecologist and asked “Which is best, oral contraception or the pill”? * Engineer Noel Serpell placed some rubber on a heater at night when closing. The morning announcer turned the heater on, creating a burning rubber smell. The Fire brigade was then called. * Ian McCrae once advised listeners that Telecom were about to clean out their telephone lines that were Full oF dust. He advised everyone to put their telephone receiver into a paper bag to collect the dust. * Jack Davey once bought a bunch of keys and attached tags reading “return to Buster Fiddes, room *, hotel **, $20 reward”. Buster was then a household name and felt obliged to pay up each time. * John Blackman sometimes telephoned a station to say that they were off the air. The announcer would then often say on air “A listener has told us that we are off the air. If you can’t hear us please telephone the station”. * 3AW arranged a special birthday surprise For Ormsby Wilkins. Students From the R.M.I.T. were given some equipment For their studio in return for a demonstration outside Ormsby’s house, including placards saying “Ormsby go home, Norman Banks forever”. * Perth breakfast announcer John Burgess Flew to Adelaide every Friday aFternoon to record Five episodes of “Wheel of Fortune”. * On 3XY, Bert Newton once had to present “Melbourne Speaks”, interviewing passers-by outside the Tivoli theatre. When they crossed to him, no one was passing. He kept changing his voice and pretended to interview a bus driver, policeman, housewiFe, and footballer.
  • Annual Report and Financial Statements

    Annual Report and Financial Statements

    The Australian Elizabethan Theatre Trust Annual Report and Financial Statements 31st December, 1967 THE AUSTRALIAN ELIZABETHAN THEATRE TRUST NOTICE OF MEETING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the ANNUAL ORDINARY GENERAL MEETING of Members will be held at the office of The Australian Elizabethan Theatre Trust. 153 Dowling Street, Potts Point. N.S.W., on Monday, 24th June. 1968, at 5.30 p.m. BUSINESS 1. To receive and consider the Balance Sheet and Income and Expenditure Account made up to 31st December, 1967, and the Report of the Directors and Honorary ",/ Auditors thereon. {} 2. The President and Vice-Presidents retire in accordance with Article 69. fL / 3. To elect Directors. / The following Directors, who were appointed by the Board since the last Ordinary General Meeting at which Directors retired, retire in accordance with Article 43. They are eligible and offer themselves for re-election: q Sir Reginald Groom. Mr. C. J. Legoe, Mr. Bruce Macklin, Sir Robert Madgwick, O.B.E., Sir George Paton. Sir Ian Potter, Mr. N. R. Seddon, Mr. Kenneth von Bibra. The following Directors retire by rotation in accordance with Article 44, are eligible. and offer themselves for re-election: Emeritus Professor Frederick Alexander, CB.E., Sir Warwick Fairfax, Miss / Margaret Gillespie, Mr. Stanley Haviland, CB.E., Mr. N. F. Hopkins, Mrs. y F. Massy Burnside, Professor J. A. Passmore, Mr. J. B. Piggott, Miss M. E. Roper. Mr. F. E. Lampe, M.B.E., Sir Alexander Reid, CM.G., LS.0., and Sir Arthur Smithers, CB.E., retire pursuant to Section 121 of the Companies Ordinance.
  • Report to the Senate Inquiry Into Broadcasting

    Report to the Senate Inquiry Into Broadcasting

    REPORT TO THE SENATE INQUIRY INTO BROADCASTING Summary 1.This paper discusses the decline in programme standards for regional radio in inland N.S.W. with emphasis on the Dubbo region in particular. A list of suggestions is included that might remedy the situation. 2. Networking is outlined in the second part of this paper. I try to show that since the introduction of supplementary FM licences that networking has become the norm at the expense of the listener. Again a list of suggestions follow that would bring a satisfactiry compromise to the regrettable networking situation we have at the moment in country Victoria, N.S.W. and Queensland. Submitted by; Richard Mutton 1 Waverley Drive DUBBO 2830 phone 02 68 842124 [ah] fax 02 68 846778 mobile 0409 228 209 e mail [email protected] A DISCUSSION OF REGIONAL RADIO. PART A: RADIO IN THE CENTRAL WEST OF N.S.W. When I first came to Dubbo in 1989, there were 2 radio stations in this city, the ABC 2CR Orange transmitting from Cudal and commercial station 2DU transmitting from Eulomogo near Dubbo. Other stations with weaker signals could be picked up in Dubbo, but were hardly listenable. Now in 2000, we have 10 stations: Tourist Radio FM88; 2KY Racing Radio; Zoo FM; Star FM; Radio Rhema; ABC Triple J; ABC Classic FM; Local ABC 107.1; ABC Radio National all on the FM band and commercial station 2DU on the AM band. Frankly, the radio service for Dubbo was better in 1989 than it is now in 2000.
  • Howard's Decade

    Howard's Decade

    Lowy Institute Paper 15 howard’s decade AN AUSTRALIAN FOREIGN POLICY REAPPRAISAL Paul Kelly Lowy Institute Paper 15 howard’s decade AN AUSTRALIAN FOREIGN POLICY REAPPRAISAL Paul Kelly First published for Lowy Institute for International Policy 2006 PO Box 102 Double Bay New South Wales 2028 Australia www.longmedia.com.au [email protected] Tel. (+61 2) 9362 8441 Lowy Institute for International Policy © 2006 All rights reserved. Without limiting the rights under copyright reserved above, no part Paul Kelly is Editor-at-Large of The Australian. He was of this publication may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means (including but not limited to electronic, previously Editor-in-Chief of The Australian. He writes mechanical, photocopying, or recording), without the prior written permission of the on Australian and international issues and is a regular copyright owner. commentator on ABC television. Paul holds a Doctor of Letters from the University of Cover design by Holy Cow! Design & Advertising Melbourne and a Bachelor of Arts from the University of Printed and bound in Australia Typeset by Longueville Media in Esprit Book 10/13 Sydney. He has honorary doctorates from the University of New South Wales and from Griffi th University, and is National Library of Australia a Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences in Australia. Cataloguing-in-Publication data He has been a Shorenstein Fellow at the Kennedy School at Harvard University and a visiting lecturer at the Kelly, Paul, 1947- . Weatherhead Center for International Affairs at Harvard.
  • The Effects of Civil Hate Speech Laws: Lessons from Australia

    The Effects of Civil Hate Speech Laws: Lessons from Australia

    Title Page Manuscript Title: The effects of civil hate speech laws: lessons from Australia Authors: Katharine Gelber & Luke McNamara* * We acknowledge funding from the Australian Research Council (DP1096721), and ethical clearance from the Univ. of Queensland (2011000341). We thank Jess Todhunter, Dave Eden, Sorcha Tormey and Ellyse Fenton for research assistance, and acknowledge the important work undertaken by Cultural and Indigenous Research Centre Australia (CIRCA). We are grateful also for the assistance of the relevant authorities and community organizations from whom we obtained data. Please direct all correspondence to Katharine Gelber ([email protected]). 1 The effects of civil hate speech laws: lessons from Australia Abstract This article examines the effects of hate speech laws in Australia. Triangulating data from primary and secondary sources, we examine five hypothesized effects: whether the laws provide a remedy to targets of hate speech, encourage more respectful speech, have an educative or symbolic effect, have a chilling effect, or create ‘martyrs’. We find the laws provide a limited remedy in the complaints mechanisms, provide a framework for direct community advocacy, and that knowledge of the laws exists in public discourse. However, the complaints mechanism imposes a significant enforcement burden on targeted communities, who still regularly experience hate speech. We find a reduction in the expression of prejudice in mediated outlets, but not on the street. We find no evidence of a chilling effect and we find the risk of free speech martyrs to be marginal. We draw out the implications of these findings for other countries. Introduction This article seeks to make a contribution to international debate about the legitimacy and efficacy of hate speech laws, by examining the effects of hate speech laws in practice.
  • Submission to the Senate Environment, Communications, Information Technology 1 and the Arts References Committee

    Submission to the Senate Environment, Communications, Information Technology 1 and the Arts References Committee

    Friends of the ABC Submission to the Senate Environment, Communications, Information Technology 1 and the Arts References Committee National Spokesperson P.O. Box 547 Stepney, SA, 5069 Phone 08 8362 5183 Mobile 0412 684 178 Fax 08 8363 7548 Email [email protected] August 11, 2001 Ms Andrea Griffiths Secretary, Senate Environment, Communications, Information Technology and the Arts References Committee Parliament House CANBERRA ACT 2600 Dear Ms Griffiths, Friends of the ABC Submission Thank you for allowing an extension of time for this submission. On behalf of Friends of the ABC I wish to make the following submission to the above committee in relation to: “The development and implementation of options for methods of appointment to the board of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) that would enhance public confidence in the independence and the representativeness of the ABC as the national broadcaster" I will be available to appear before the committee if required. Friends of the ABC also seeks permission to publish this submission. Yours sincerely, Darce Cassidy National Spokesperson Friends of the ABC Friends of the ABC Submission to the Senate Environment, Communications, Information Technology 2 and the Arts References Committee CONTENTS • Executive Summary • Friends of the ABC • Nearly all agree that the current appointment process has been abused. • Politicisation of the ABC Bord is damaging because it threatens ABC independence , because it is destabilising, and because it erodes public trust in the ABC • Politicisation of boards damages government. • Politicisation of the ABC board threatens funding. • A more open system • Conclusion and recommendations. Appendix 1. The Composition and Character of the ABC's Governing Body, 1932-2001, by Professor Ken Inglis Appendix 2 Criticism of the Appointment Process by former Chairmen Appendix 3.