DOCSLIB.ORG

Universidad Autónoma De Madrid Facultad De Derecho

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Universidad Autónoma De Madrid Facultad De Derecho UNIVERSIDAD AUTÓNOMA DE MADRID FACULTAD DE DERECHO TESIS DOCTORAL CONSPIRACY. A CONCEPTUAL GENEALOGY (THIRTEENTH TO EARLY EIGHTEENTH CENTURY) Autor Víctor Manuel Saucedo Maqueda Directores Carlos Petit Calvo Jesús Vallejo Fernández de la Reguera Madrid, 2017 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................... 2 Abbreviations ................................................................................................................................ 8 Introducción ................................................................................................................................ 11 Getting Ready for Work ............................................................................................................. 13 The Mystery of Conspiracy ....................................................................................................... 13 Frames ...................................................................................................................................... 16 Prototype Theory ...................................................................................................................... 19 Mappings, Mental Spaces and Blends ...................................................................................... 21 The Law of Conspiracy ............................................................................................................. 31 1. The Historiography of the Law of Conspiracy .................................................................... 33 1.1 The Codification of Conspiracy .......................................................................................... 33 1.1.1 The Trade Unions Issue ............................................................................................... 33 1.1.2 Codification Ideas and Ideals ....................................................................................... 37 1.1.3 The Instrumental Theory of Conspiracy and the Wide Rule ....................................... 44 1.1.3.1 The History of the Wide Rule ............................................................................... 46 1.1.3.2 Special Conspiracies ............................................................................................. 50 1.1.3.3 Restraint of Trade ................................................................................................. 51 1.1.3.4 The Repeal of Conspiracy ..................................................................................... 54 1.1.4 The Attempt Theory of the Law of Conspiracy ........................................................... 55 1.1.4.1 ATTEMPT by Conspiracy .................................................................................... 56 1.1.4.2 The Wider Rule ..................................................................................................... 58 1.2 Conceptual Continuity of the Law of Conspiracy ............................................................... 64 1.3 The Medieval Conspiracy ................................................................................................... 67 1.3.1 The Stationary Thesis: Conspiracies Against the State ............................................... 71 1.4 Superseding Thesis.............................................................................................................. 74 2. Conspiracy in the Middle Ages .............................................................................................. 79 2.1 Legislating the Corruption of Justice ................................................................................. 79 2.1.1 Corruption of Royal Officers ....................................................................................... 79 2.1.2 Corruption of Jurors ..................................................................................................... 81 2.1.3 Barratry and Corruption ............................................................................................... 84 2.1.4 The Ordinance of Conspirators .................................................................................... 87 2.2 The Writ of Conspiracy in Action ....................................................................................... 94 2 2.2.1 Disturbance of Right by Judicial Corruption and Barratry .......................................... 95 2.2.2 Extortion and Wrongdoing by Judicial Corruption and Barratry .............................. 101 2.2.2.1 Extortion ............................................................................................................. 102 2.2.2.2 Wrongdoing ........................................................................................................ 103 2.2.2.3 Disturbance of Right, Extortion and Wrongdoing .............................................. 108 2.2.2.4 Genealogy of the Writ of Conspiracy as Applied to Wrongdoing ...................... 109 2.2.2.5 Wrongful Prosecution and Justification .............................................................. 110 2.2.2.6 Homicide in Will................................................................................................. 116 2.2.3 Sole Defendant ........................................................................................................... 119 2.3 The Definition of Conspirators ......................................................................................... 119 2.3.1 The Trailbaston in Action .......................................................................................... 125 2.3.2 The Articles of the Eyre in Action ............................................................................. 126 2.3.2.1 The Formula De Mutuis Sacramentis ................................................................. 126 2.3.2.2 Malfeasance by Corrupt Officers ........................................................................ 127 2.3.2.3 Barratry ............................................................................................................... 128 2.4 Making Good Friends ....................................................................................................... 132 2.4.1 The Fraternizing Model of Mutual Protection and Aid ............................................. 132 2.4.2 Fraternal Agreement and Litigation ........................................................................... 136 2.4.3 Bastard Feudalism and the Management of Litigation .............................................. 138 2.5 The Narrowing of Conspiracy .......................................................................................... 142 3. The Will for the Deed ........................................................................................................... 145 3.1 Homicide in Coke .............................................................................................................. 146 3.1.1 The Frame of Homicide ............................................................................................. 147 3.1.1.1 Malice Aforethought ........................................................................................... 147 3.1.1.2 Voluntariness ...................................................................................................... 148 3.1.1.3 Sound Memory and Age of Discretion ............................................................... 148 3.1.1.4 Feloniousness ...................................................................................................... 149 3.1.1.5 Consummation .................................................................................................... 149 3.1.2 Structure of the Category of Homicide ...................................................................... 150 3.1.2.1 Manslaughter....................................................................................................... 150 3.1.2.1.1 Chancemedley .............................................................................................. 150 3.1.2.1.2 The Periphery of Manslaughter ................................................................... 151 3.1.2.2 Murder ................................................................................................................. 152 3.1.2.2.1 The Periphery of Murder ............................................................................. 153 Murder by Malice Implied ...................................................................................... 153 Murder of Misfortune ............................................................................................. 153 Murder by Abetment ............................................................................................... 154 Murder by False Accusation ................................................................................... 155 3.1.2.2.2 The Ancient Law of Conspiracy .................................................................. 155 3.2 High Treason in Coke ....................................................................................................... 159 3 3.2.1 Coke’s Analysis of The Treason Act 1351 ................................................................ 159 3.2.2 Attempt Theory of the Treason of Compassing the King’s Death ............................ 161 3.2.2.1 Will as the Intended Effect of the Action ........................................................... 161 3.2.2.2 The Action as Failed Execution .........................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Conceptualizing Inchoate Complicity: the Normative and Doctrinal Case for Lesser Offenses As an Alternative to Complicity Liability
    Document1 (Do Not Delete) 5/10/2016 8:15 PM CONCEPTUALIZING INCHOATE COMPLICITY: THE NORMATIVE AND DOCTRINAL CASE FOR LESSER OFFENSES AS AN ALTERNATIVE TO COMPLICITY LIABILITY DENNIS J. BAKER* TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................... 504 II. HISTORY AND DOCTRINE .............................................................. 509 III. THE LETTER OF THE LAW UNDER THE SERIOUS CRIME ACT 2007 .......................................................................................................... 514 IV. RECKLESSLY ENCOURAGING AND ASSISTING SEVERAL AND ALTERNATIVE CRIMES ........................................................................ 532 V. ENCOURAGING AND ASSISTING AN INNOCENT AGENT .................................................................................................................. 537 VI. CAUSATION, ACT CAPABLENESS, AND IMPOSSIBILITY ....... 540 VII. IMPOSSIBILITY AND CAPABILITY ............................................ 552 VIII. WHEN IS TRIVIAL ENCOURAGEMENT CAPABLE OF ENCOURAGING? ................................................................................... 557 IX. ATTEMPTS TO ATTEMPT AND THE SERIOUS CRIME ACT 2007 .................................................................................................................. 566 X. REMOTE ENCOURAGEMENT ........................................................ 575 XI. CONCLUSION .................................................................................. 586 * (M.Phil., Ph.D.
    [Show full text]
  • Latin for Lawyers
    LATIN FOR LAWYERS The Language of the Law By LAZAR EMANUEL J.D., Harvard Law School Published by Latin For Lawyers, 1st Edition (1999) Emanuel Publishing Corp. • 1328 Boston Post Road • Larchmont, NY 10538 Copyright © 1999 by LAZAR EMANUEL _____________________ ALL RIGHTS RESERVED No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Printed in the United States of America. This book is not intended as a source of advice for the solution of legal matters or problems. For advice on legal matters, the reader should consult an attor- ney. ISBN 1-56542-499-9 PREFACE I have tried in this book to do several things. y To identify those words, phrases and axioms which still find their way in their original Latin into legal study and writing. y To identify all words and phrases in current English used by lawyers and derived from Latin y To trace the origin of the words and phrases by identifying and defining their Latin roots. y To define each entry in every sense in which it has meaning for lawyers. y To list in each definition appropriate references to such documents as the U.S. Constitution, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct, and other documents of concern to lawyers. My hope is that law students and lawyers will find this a useful tool for studying the origin, development and meaning of all legal words and terms which can be traced to Latin.
    [Show full text]
  • Analysis of the Contents of This Volume
    ANALYSIS OF THE CONTENTS OF THIS VOLUME. CHAPTER I. PAGE. OF THE REDRESS OF PRIVATE WRONGS BY THE MERE ACT OF THE PARTIES,............. 1-17 wrongs are divisible into private wrongs and public wrongs ................... 2 private wrongs or civil injuries are an infringement or privation of the private or civil rights belonging to individuals, considered as individuals ...... 2 for their redress courts of justice are instituted ...................... 2 the redress is effected, 1, by the mere act of the parties; 2, by mere ope- ration of law; 3, by suit or action in courts ........................ 3 redress by the mere act of the parties is, 1, that from the act of the in- jured party only; 2, that from the joint act of all the parties ......... 3 of the first sort are : 1. defence of one's self, and those who stand in the relation of hus- band and wife, parent and child, master and servant ........... 3 2. recaption of goods wrongfully taken, or wife, child or servant wrongfully detained ...................................... 4 3. entry on lands and tenements occupied by another without right, 5 4. abatement or removal of nuisance ........................... 5 5. distress for rent or other duties, or of cattle damage feasant ...... 6 which is a taking of a personal chattel of the wrongdoer into the custody of the party injured to procure satisfaction ...... 6 the things which may be distrained ....................... 7 distress should be made by day except in case of damage feasant, 10 and generally upon the premises ........................ 11 and for the whole duty at once ........................ 11 and must be reasonable in amount .....................
    [Show full text]
  • CHAPTER 10:01 CRIMINAL LAW (PROCEDURE) ACT ARRANGEMENT of SECTIONS PRELIMINARY 1. Short Title. 2. Interpretation. 3. Application
    LAWS OF GUYANA Criminal Law (Procedure) Cap. 10:01 3 CHAPTER 10:01 CRIMINAL LAW (PROCEDURE) ACT ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS PRELIMINARY SECTION 1. Short title. 2. Interpretation. 3. Application of the Act. PART I GENERAL PROVISIONS TITLE 1—BUSINESS OF THE COURT 4. Appointment of causes to be tried on each day of the sitting. 5. Time of trial of causes. 6. Adding cause after transmission of list. 7. Calendar of causes for trial. 8. State prosecutors. 9. Jurisdiction with respect to counties. 10. Bringing of prisoners before the Court for trial. 11. Discontinuance of proclamation against vice. Gaol Delivery 12. Prisons to be delivered at sittings of the Court. 13. Bringing of certain classes of prisoners before the court for delivery. 14. Right of prisoner in certain cases to be tried or bailed. 15. Prisoners entitled to be discharged. 16. Procedure of the Court in matters not provided for. L.R.O. 3/1998 LAWS OF GUYANA 4 Cap. 10:01 Criminal Law (Procedure) TITLE 2—LAW AND PRACTICE AS TO JURIES SECTION 17. Constitution of jury. 18. Abolition of jury de mediatate linguae. Qualification of Jurors and Jury Lists 19. Qualification of Jurors. 20. Disqualification of certain persons from jury service. 21. Exemption of certain persons. 22. Disqualification or exemption to be claimed on revision of jury list. 23. Information to Registrar for preparation of lists. 24. Publication of list by Registrar. 25. Revision of lists. 26. Appeal from decision of revising officer. 27. Jurors’ book to be true record of jurors. Summoning Jurors 28. Mode of selecting jurors to form panel.
    [Show full text]
  • Sibility of Entering Into
    PRACTICE of the COURTS. 253 It is agreed in the Books, that a wife may, without her husband, execute a naked authority, whether given before or after coverture, and though no special words are used to dispense with the disability of coverture; and the rule is the same where both an interest and an authority pass to the wife, if the authority is collateral to, and doth not flow from the interest; because then the two are as unconnected, as if they were vested in different persons. Finch Refi. 346. As too, a feme covert may without her husband convey lands in execution of a mere Power or authority, so may she with equal effect in performance of a condition where land is vested in her on condition to convey to others. W. Jones 137, 8. The reason why in these instances the wife may convey without her husband, seems to be, that he can receive no prejudice from her acts, but a great one might arise to others, if his concurrence should be essential. 1 Inst. 1 12. a. in n. See title Baron and Feme. As to the Suspension and Extinction of Powers, see 1 Inst. 342. b. in n.: and as to the rules by which the creation and execution of Powers in general are governed; see Powell on Powers: and further with respect to subjects connected therewith, this Dictionary, titles Authority; Estate; limitation of Estate; Lease; Remainder; Trust; Use, isfc. Power of the County; See Posse Comitates , Power of the Crown; See title King. Power of the Parent; See Parent.
    [Show full text]
  • Anti-Constitutionalism: Frontiers Sans Frontiers
    Anti-Constitutionalism: Frontiers sans Frontiers By Jack Edward Jackson A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Wendy Brown, Chair Professor Kathryn Abrams Professor Steven Shiffrin Professor Paul Thomas Fall 2012 Abstract Anti-Constitutionalism: Frontiers sans Frontiers by Jack Edward Jackson Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science University of California, Berkeley Professor Wendy Brown, Chair Anti-Constitutionalism: Frontiers sans Frontiers, maps and critiques a revitalized “rule- of-law” discourse in contemporary American politics, a discourse that cuts across and binds traditional ideological differences. I argue that this discourse generates a logic whereby the “law” is rendered a per se good threatened by two primary antagonists: lawlessness and politicization. All territories and persons, according to this vision, must be brought within the bounds of the rule-of-law and simultaneously the law must resist the temptations of politics. Drawing upon a variety of critical political and theoretical traditions that have witnessed the law as something other than synonymous with “justice” or “freedom,” including feminist legal theory and critical race studies, the dissertation argues that law void of political value is an impossibility. Thus, the very desire for a depoliticized legality is always a desire tethered to and through a particular political ordering of things. In advancing this argument, I look to several recent events in U.S. law and political life that have incited this flight of hope to legality: the Supreme Court decision in Bush v.
    [Show full text]
  • And Glad of It
    GODLESS AND GLAD OF IT Fifty years of militant secular humanism David Tribe President of the National Secular Society, 1963-1971 CONTENTS Introduction .............................................................................................................................3 Section 1: Republicanism .......................................................................................................7 Section 2: Abolition of the House of Lords ..............................................................................8 Section 3: Disestablishment and Disendowment of the Church of England............................9 Section4: Universal Affirmation .............................................................................................10 Section 5: Secular Education ................................................................................................11 Section 6: Secular Broadcasting ...........................................................................................13 Section 7: Penology ..............................................................................................................14 Section 8: Suicide .................................................................................................................16 Section 9: Euthanasia ...........................................................................................................17 Section 10: Moral Education .................................................................................................18 Section 11: Contraception.....................................................................................................20
    [Show full text]
  • Memorandum Concerning the National Symposium (2Nd Series)--The Law of Homicide Rollin M
    Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume 36 | Issue 6 Article 1 1946 Memorandum Concerning the National Symposium (2nd Series)--The Law of Homicide Rollin M. Perkins Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/jclc Part of the Criminal Law Commons, Criminology Commons, and the Criminology and Criminal Justice Commons Recommended Citation Rollin M. Perkins, Memorandum Concerning the National Symposium (2nd Series)--The Law of Homicide, 36 J. Crim. L. & Criminology 391 (1945-1946) This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology by an authorized editor of Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. MEMORANDUM CONCERNING THE NATIONAL SYMPOSIUM (2nd Series) The Journal, in this issue, is printing articles from the national Symposium series dealing with "Scientific Proof and Relations of Law and Medicine" (2nd series). The Symposium contains fifty or more studies prepared by legal and scientific writers on problems of joint interest; it is one phase of a program directed to the cor- relation of law and science. The papers will be published in the pages of participating legal and medical journals during the Spring and Summer of 1946. The intent of the effort is to muster up legal and scientific learning relevant to various type problems which need illumination from both sources for their proper solution. The sci- entific writers have undertaken, under editorial direction, to pre- pare their studies in a basic style comprehensible to lawyers, with- out, however, any sacrifice of scientific authority.
    [Show full text]
  • CONSPIRACY a Conceptual Genealogy
    VÍCTOR SAUCEDO CONSPIRACY A Conceptual Genealogy CONSPIRACY A Conceptual Genealogy The Figuerola Institute Programme: Legal History The Programme “Legal History” of the Figuerola Institute of Social Science History –a part of the Carlos III University of Madrid– is devoted to improve the overall knowledge on the history of law from different points of view –academically, culturally, socially, and institutionally– covering both ancient and modern eras. A number of experts from several countries have participated in the Programme, bringing in their specialized knowledge and dedication to the subject of their expertise. To give a better visibility of its activities, the Programme has published in its Book Series a number of monographs on the different aspects of its academic discipline. Publisher: Carlos III University of Madrid Book Series: Legal History Editorial Committee: Manuel Ángel Bermejo Castrillo, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid Catherine Fillon, Université Jean Moulin Lyon 3 Manuel Martínez Neira, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid Carlos Petit, Universidad de Huelva Cristina Vano, Università degli studi di Napoli Federico II More information at www.uc3m.es/legal_history CONSPIRACY A Conceptual Genealogy (Thirteenth to Early Eighteenth Century) Víctor Saucedo ORCID ID: 0000-0002-5820-1898 Dykinson 2017 Historia del derecho, 59 ISSN: 2255-5137 © 2017 Víctor Saucedo Primera edición 2017, reimpresión Editorial Dykinson c/ Meléndez Valdés, 61 – 28015 Madrid Tlf. (+34) 91 544 28 46 E-mail: [email protected] http://www.dykinson.com Preimpresión: TALLERONCE ISBN: 978-84-9148-494-3 Versión electrónica disponible en e-Archivo http://hdl.handle.net/10016/26095 Licencia Creative Commons Atribución-NoComercial-SinDerivadas 3.0 España CONTENTS ABBREVIATIONS .
    [Show full text]
  • |||GET||| a History of Modern American Criminal Justice 1St Edition
    A HISTORY OF MODERN AMERICAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE 1ST EDITION DOWNLOAD FREE Joseph F Spillane | 9781483342078 | | | | | Criminology & Criminal Justice The LRC also notes that Section 1A of the Broadcasting Authority Act inserted in [30] prohibited broadcasting of "anything which may reasonably be regarded as being likely to promote, or incite to, crime or as tending to undermine the authority of the State". This federal agency was created indeveloped a crime laboratory, began using fingerprinting as a large-scale method of identification, and provides training to law enforcement officers across the country through its National Police Academy. You Just Got Cheated. Archived from the original PDF on 2 June Drugs and Drug Policy. Terry v. Archived from the original on 18 January Views Read Edit View history. District Judge Victoria Roberts dismissed all serious charges against the remaining defendants, A History of Modern American Criminal Justice 1st edition sedition, and rebuked prosecutors for bringing the case. Learn about institutional subscriptions. Department of Veterans Affairs hospital in New Mexico was investigated for sedition in September [53] after writing a letter [54] [55] to the editor of a local newspaper, accusing several national leaders of criminal negligence. It is sometimes loosely translated as sedition, [61] although the law bans the incitement of hatred against a segment A History of Modern American Criminal Justice 1st edition the population such as a particular race or religion. Ans: Broken windows theory was introduced
    [Show full text]
  • Commentaries on the Laws of England; in Four Books. by Sir William
    ANALYSIS OF THE CONTENTS OF THIS VOLUME, CHAPTER I. PAOK. Os THE REDRESS OF PRIVATE WRONGS BY THE MERE ACT OF THE PARTIES 1-17 wrongs arc divisible into private wrongs and public wrongs, 2 private wrongs or civil injuries are an infringment or privation of the private or civil rights belonging to individuals, considered as individuals 2 for their redress courts of justice are instituted, 2 the redress is effected, 1, by the mere act of the parties ; 2, by mere opera- tion of law; 3, by suit or action in courts, 3 redress by the mere act of the parties is, 1, that from the act of the in- jured party only; 2, that from the joint act of all the parties, 3 of the first sort are: 1. defence of one's self, and those who stand in the relation of hus- band and wife, parent and child, master and servant, 3 2. recaption of goods wrongfully taken, or wife, child or servant wrongfully detained, 4 3. entry on lands and tenements occupied by another without right, 5 4. abatement or removal of nuisance, 5 5. distress for rent or other duties, or of cattle damage feasant,.... 0 which is a taking of a personal chattel of the wrongdoer into the custody of the party injured to procure satisfaction, 6 the things which may be distrained, 7 distress should be made by day except in case of damage feasant, 10 and generally upon the premises, 11 and for the whole duty at once, 11 and must be reasonable in amount, 1'2 the property must be impounded, 12 replevin of the property 18 6.
    [Show full text]
  • Suicide: a Constitutional Right?
    Duquesne Law Review Volume 24 Number 1 Article 3 1985 Suicide: A Constitutional Right? Thomas J. Marzen Mary K. O'Dowd Daniel Crone Thomas J. Balch Follow this and additional works at: https://dsc.duq.edu/dlr Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Thomas J. Marzen, Mary K. O'Dowd, Daniel Crone & Thomas J. Balch, Suicide: A Constitutional Right?, 24 Duq. L. Rev. 1 (1985). Available at: https://dsc.duq.edu/dlr/vol24/iss1/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Duquesne Scholarship Collection. It has been accepted for inclusion in Duquesne Law Review by an authorized editor of Duquesne Scholarship Collection. Duquesne Law Review Volume 24, Fall 1985, Number 1 Article Suicide: A Constitutional Right? Thomas J. Marzen Mary K. O'Dowd Daniel Crone Thomas J. Balch* TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION .................................... 3 II. CONTEMPORARY ADVOCACY OF SUICIDE ............... 4 III. THE ISSUE: A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO SUICIDE .... 8 A. Acts Versus Omissions ....................... 9 B. Is There A Constitutional Right to Autonomy? 13 C. The Basis of the Right to Privacy ............ 14 * Marzen: B.A., University of Illinois; J.D., Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago- Kent College of Law; General Counsel, National Legal Center for the Medically Dependent and Disabled. O'Dowd: B.S.; M.D. candidate, Northwestern University; Medical Consultant, Americans United for Life Legal Defense Fund. Crone: B.A., Ph.D. candidate in Philosophy, Loyola University-Chicago. Balch: B.A., Williams College; J.D., New York University; Staff Counsel, National Legal Center for the Medically Dependent and Disabled. The authors gratefully acknowledge the research assistance and writing assistance of Richard Coleson and Joel Tornari and the research assistance of Frank Melone, Keith Moore, Mary Anne Naso, Cathleen Perry, William Short, John F.
    [Show full text]