Arxiv:1806.05346V4 [Math.AG]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
How many zeroes? Counting the number of solutions of systems of polynomials via geometry at infinity Part I: Toric theory Pinaki Mondal arXiv:1806.05346v4 [math.AG] 26 Mar 2020 Preface In this book we describe an approach through toric geometry to the following problem: “estimate the number (counted with appropriate multiplicity) of isolated solutions of n polynomial equations in n variables over an algebraically closed field k.” The outcome of this approach is the number of solutions for “generic” systems in terms of their Newton polytopes, and an explicit characterization of what makes a system “generic.” The pioneering work in this field was done in the 1970s by Kushnirenko, Bernstein and Khovanskii, who completely solved the problem of counting solutions of generic systems on the “torus” n (k 0 ) . In the context of our problem, however, the natural domain of solutions is not the torus, but the \{ } n affine space k . There were a number of works on extension of Bernstein’s theorem to the case of affine space, and recently it has been completely resolved, the final steps having been carried out by the author. The aim of this book is to present these results in a coherent way. We start from the beginning, namely Bernstein’s beautiful theorem which expresses the number of solutions of generic systems in terms of the mixed volume of their Newton polytopes. We give complete proofs, over arbitrary algebraically closed fields, of Bernstein’s theorem and its recent extension to the affine space, and describe some open problems. We also apply the developed techniques to derive and generalize Kushnirenko’s results on Milnor numbers of hypersurface singularities which in 1970s served as a precursor to the development of toric geometry. Care was taken to make this book as elementary as possible. In particular, we develop all the necessary algebraic geometry (modulo some explicitly stated basic results). This book should be accessible to a second year graduate student. Contents Chapter I. Introduction 1 1. The problemand the results 1 2. Prerequisites 7 3. Organization 8 Chapter II. A brief history of points of infinity in geometry 10 1. Points at infinity 10 2. Homogeneous coordinates 11 3. Projective space 12 Part 0. Preliminaries 14 Chapter III. Quasiprojective varieties over algebraically closed fields 15 1. Overview of classical results from algebra 15 2. Quasiprojective Varieties 16 3. Affine varieties 18 4. (Ir)reducibility 20 5. Rational functions and rational maps on irreducible varieties 21 6. Product spaces, Segre map, Veronese embedding 22 7. Completeness and compactification 23 8. Dimension 25 9. Constructible sets 28 10. Zariski closure of the image of a morphism 29 11. Tangent space, singularities, local ring at a point 31 12. Completion of the local ring at a point 35 13. Degree of a dominant morphism 37 Chapter IV. ∗Intersection multiplicity 40 1. Introduction 40 2. Closed subschemes of a variety 41 3. Possibly non-reduced curves 44 4. Intersection multiplicity at a nonsingular point of a variety 47 5. Intersection multiplicity of complete intersections 51 Chapter V. Convex polyhedra 53 1. Basic notions 53 2. Characterization of convex polyhedra 57 3. Basic properties of convex polyhedra 61 4. Normal fan of a convexpolytope 68 5. Rational polyhedra 70 6. ∗Volume of convex polytopes 72 7. ∗Volume of special classes of polytopes 75 Part 1. Toric Varieties and classical results 79 Chapter VI. Toric varieties over algebraically closed fields 80 CONTENTS 1. Algebraic torus 80 2. Toric varieties from finite subsets of Zn 81 3. Examples of toric varieties 82 4. Structureof XA 83 5. Toric varieties from polytopes 85 6. Nonsingularity in codimension one on XP 88 7. Extending closed subschemes of the torus to XP 89 8. Branches of curves on the torus 92 9. Points at infinity on toric varieties 93 10. ∗Weighted projective spaces 95 11. ∗Weighted blow up 97 Chapter VII. Number of solutions on the torus: BKK bound 99 1. Introduction 99 2. Mixedvolume 99 3. Theorems of Kushnirenko and Bernstein 100 4. Proof of Bernstein-Kushnirenko non-degeneracy condition 102 5. ProofoftheBKK bound 106 6. Applications of Bernstein’s theorem to convex geometry 109 7. Some technical results 113 8. The problem of characterizing coefficients which guarantee non-degeneracy 114 9. Notes 116 Chapter VIII. (Weighted) B´ezout theorems 117 1. Weighted degree 117 n n 2. P (ω) as a compactification of k when the ωj are positive and ω0 =1 117 3. Weighted B´ezout theorem 118 4. Products of weighted projective spaces 119 5. Weighted multi-homogeneous B´ezout theorem 121 6. Notes 122 Part 2. Extension of Bernstein-Kushnirenko Theorem to the affine space and other applications123 Chapter IX. Intersection multiplicity at the origin 124 1. Introduction 124 2. Generic intersection multiplicity 124 3. Characterization of minimal multiplicity systems 128 4. Proof of the non-degeneracy condition 130 5. Proofofthebound 133 6. The efficient version of the non-degeneracycondition 136 7. Other formulae for generic intersection multiplicity 138 8. Monotonicity of generic intersection multiplicity 141 9. Notes 142 Chapter X. Number of solutions on (open subsets of) the affine space 143 1. Introduction 143 2. Thebound 143 3. Derivation of the formuale for the bound 146 4. Other formulaefor the bound 148 5. Examples motivating the non-degeneracy conditions 150 6. Non-degeneracy conditions 153 7. Proof of the non-degeneracy conditions 155 8. Weighted B´ezout theorem: general version 161 9. Weighted multi-homogeneous B´ezout theorem: general version 165 10. Open problems 166 CONTENTS Chapter XI. Milnor number of a hypersurface at the origin 168 1. Introduction 168 2. Milnornumber 168 3. Generic Milnor number 169 4. Classical notions of non-degeneracy 171 5. Newton number: Kushnirenko’s formula for the generic Milnor number 173 6. Open problems 176 Chapter XII. Beyond this book 180 1. Toric varieties 180 2. Newton-Okounkov bodies 180 3. B´ezout problem 180 Appendix A. Notation 182 Appendix B. Miscellaneous commutative algebra 183 1. Fundamental theorem of finitely generated modules over a PID 183 2. Prime and Maximal ideals, Noetherian rings, Zero-divisors 183 3. Nakayama’s lemma 184 4. Localrings 184 5. Discrete valuation rings 185 6. Krull dimension 185 7. Primary Decomposition 185 8. Length of modules 187 9. Gradedrings 188 10. Macaulay’s Unmixedness Theorem 188 11. Properties of order at a point on a possibly non-reduced curve 191 12. The power series ring and monomial orders 195 13. Primitive elements of Zn 198 14. Symmetric multiadditive functions on a commutative semigroup 199 Appendix. Bibliography 203 CHAPTER I Introduction 1. The problem and the results This book is about the problem of computing the number of solutions of systems of polynomials, or equivalently, the number of points of intersection of the sets of zeroes of polynomials. In this section we formulate the precise version of the problem we are going to study and give an informal description of the results. One natural observation that simplifies the problem is that intersection multiplicity should be taken into account, e.g. even though a tangent line intersects a parabola at only one point, it should be counted with multiplicity two (see fig. 1). As secants approach the tangent at O more and more closely, both of the two points of intersec- tion move arbitrarily close to O. O FIGURE 1. A tangent line intersects a parabola at a point with multiplicity two The geometric intuition for intersection multiplicity is the “principle of continuity,” the principle that continuous perturbations of systems result in continuous changes of associated metrics or invariants1. Since the number of points of intersection is a discrete invariant of a system, it follows that it must not change under continuous perturbation. However, over real numbers points of intersection may disappear upon an infinitesimal deformation (see fig. 2). On the other hand, this problem disappears if one also counts “imaginary” solutions (this is why the intersection theory over complex numbers, or, more generally, an algebraically closed field, is easier than the intersection theory over real numbers). In this book we will consider polynomial systems defined over algebraically closed fields2. y = x2 y = ǫ intersects the parabola at two real points with multiplicity one. (0, 0) y = 0 intersects the parabola at one real point with multiplicity two. y = −ǫ intersects the parabola at two imaginary points with multiplicity one. FIGURE 2. Disappearance of real points of intersection If there are infinitely many solutions of a system of polynomials, then the solution set has positive di- mensional components, and assigning multiplicity to these components is trickier; we bypass this problem 1“Consider an arbitrary figure in general position . Is it not obvious that if . one begins to change the initial figure by insensible steps, or applies to some parts of the figure an arbitrary continuous motion, then is it not obvious that the properties and relations established for the initial system remain applicable to subsequent states of this system provided that one is mindful of particular changes, when, say, certain magnitudes vanish, change direction or sign, and so on—changes which one can always anticipate a priori on the basis of reliable rules.” – J. V. Poncelet, the foremost exponent of the principle of continuity, in the introduction of Trait´edes propri´et´es projectives des figures (1822), as cited in [Ros05]. 2. which Poncelet probably would not have approved of, given his attitude towards consideration of complex solutions; see [Gra11, Section 4.2] for a most interesting account of this history. 1 2 I. INTRODUCTION in this book and compute only isolated3 solutions. This implies in particular we do not consider “under- determined systems,”4 since an underdetermined system over an algebraically closed field can only have either positive dimensional or empty sets of solutions.