DOCSLIB.ORG

Developing Municipal Wireless Infrastructure

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Developing Municipal Wireless Infrastructure Developing Municipal Wireless Infrastructure Catherine A. Middleton Ryerson University digital.library.ryerson.ca/object/61 Please Cite: Middleton, C. A. (2009). Developing municipal wireless infrastructure. Public Sector Digest, Summer, 37-41. library.ryerson.ca TECHNOLOGY PARIS , France, is a leader in providing free Wi-Fi access to both residents and visitors. Developing Municipal Wireless Infrastructure BY CATHERINE MIDDLETON In the middle of this decade, there was great interest in the municipal service delivery, and improving citizens’ access to the development of municipal wireless networks. Recognizing that web. Large-scale, high profile projects were planned in cities like internet access was becoming an essential service, Toronto, San Francisco, and Philadelphia. In 2007, the municipalities considered building wireless networks as a means website muniwireless.com estimated that there were more than of fostering economic development, improving efficiency of 400 ‘muni Wi-Fi’ projects planned, under development or www.publicsectordigest.com Summer 2009 Public Sector Digest 3 7 The early hype and excitement has been replaced with a “” much more realistic outlook on what wireless networks can and cannot do for municipalities. actually operational in the United States. By late 2007, however, because the private company could generate revenues by it became evident that the espoused benefits of municipal providing internet access to local residences. wireless networks were not as easy to achieve as initially anticipated. Networks were abandoned, scaled back or delayed, It is now clear that, to be viable, this approach requires an as Earthlink, Google, MetroFi and other corporate partners ongoing financial commitment from the municipality as an exited the municipal wireless sector. Toronto’s network, anchor tenant, but the municipality does not receive any share of OneZone, was not a municipal wireless project, but its network revenues. Some networks are developed in partnership developer, Toronto Hydro Telecom, initially proposed covering with private sector companies, with costs and revenues shared a 630 km 2 area to blanket Toronto with wireless internet access. between municipalities and their technology providers It was anticipated that dividends from network revenues would (Québec’s Xittel has been active in many such partnerships). flow to the City through its ownership of Toronto Hydro. A six Additionally, in a number of Canadian cities, non-profit km 2 pilot zone was developed in Toronto’s downtown core, but community wireless networking groups operate free Wi-Fi the larger network was never built. networks serving public spaces. Examples include Île Sans Fil in Montréal, ZAP Québec, and Wireless Toronto. Their In 2008, the company and its assets were sold to Cogeco Cable, objectives include increasing connectivity in neighbourhoods effectively privatizing the OneZone network, which continues to and fostering community engagement. operate today on a fee-for-service basis. San Francisco’s proposed municipal network was cancelled, replaced by an Regardless of the operational model adopted by municipalities, initiative from a company called Meraki that is slowly extending wireless networks can be public or private. Public networks are Wi-Fi coverage throughout that city. Wireless Philadelphia has built with the intention of providing internet access to members become the Digital Impact Group, retaining its focus on of the community, and also provide service to anyone who is bringing internet connectivity to underserved communities but within range of the network (that is, there is no requirement that no longer committed to wireless as its primary networking a network user be a taxpayer in the municipality). Public technology. networks are not necessarily free networks, but they are open to the public. Today, the municipal wireless landscape is much different from what it was just a few years ago. The early hype and excitement Private networks are not open to community members, and are has been replaced with a much more realistic outlook on what used to support municipal operations. For instance, municipal wireless networks can and cannot do for municipalities. There wireless networks can be used to provide internet connectivity are fewer projects under development, but those that are being to mobile workers, to support voice-over-IP (VoIP) telephone planned are now generally based on solid business cases. Project service, to allow for remote monitoring (e.g. cameras, meters), leaders are often willing to share their successes and failures, to provide access to maps and geographical data, and to support and it is understood that building municipal networks is not a public safety applications. Hybrid networks can serve public and simple task. private users, with the two types of usage managed separately. I. II. FORMS OF WIRELESS INFRASTRUCTURE UNMET EXPECTATIONS Municipalities have engaged with wireless networks in a variety In the early days of municipal wireless networking, it was the of different ways. In some instances, municipalities own and public networks that generated the most attention and interest. operate the entire network infrastructure (e.g. Fredericton, New The idea of public networks was appealing. Wireless networks Brunswick’s Fred-eZone). Others engage a private company to could be set up using ‘free’, licence-exempt spectrum, build, own, and operate the network. Initially, some believed that minimizing the cost and complexity of providing service. this model could provide cities with free network services, Municipalities could generate goodwill in their communities by 38 Public Sector Digest Summer 2009 www.publicsectordigest.com providing free internet access. A municipal Wi-Fi network could not pay for the cost of provisioning municipal networks. For help in branding the municipality as progressive and municipalities considering building new wireless networks, it technologically savvy, and it could help to attract business and makes sense to plan for coverage in indoor locations (e.g., city tourists to the community and encourage local community hall, other municipal buildings, community centres, sports engagement and spur economic development. facilities, libraries, etc.) as well as selected high traffic outdoor locations. As part of the network planning exercise, consideration There was no doubt that citizens and visitors would appreciate should be given to lighting conditions, comfortable seating, and access to Wi-Fi networks in the community, but this did not the provision of power. translate into a willingness to pay for such service. Some plans to offer free service relied upon advertising revenues to cover As the excitement over municipal wireless networking fades, the municipalities’ costs, while others were dependent upon the more municipalities are investigating the development of their provider signing up sufficient numbers of paying subscribers to own fibre-optical network assets. By building their own fibre cover the costs of free service in specified public spaces. Neither networks (which offer reliable, high capacity, high quality of these proved terribly successful, and municipalities that were connectivity), or by leveraging existing networking assets intending to pay the costs themselves discovered that building within their communities (e.g., local utility companies may have wireless networks was not as cheap as initially expected. fibre-optical networks), the business case for both public and private wireless networks is improved. In addition to supplying Many problems were encountered in the initial network builds. reliable backhaul for the wireless network, access to municipal One challenge was negotiating access to utility poles in order to fibre offers several advantages: First, municipalities have much mount the Wi-Fi radios used to provide connectivity. Some more control and flexibility in provisioning their own municipalities could arrange access, but another issue was that communication networks. Second, coordinated planning of light poles did not have a 24-hour power supply. The tops of wired and wireless network coverage is possible. Finally, high fiberglass utility poles often collapsed when radio connections quality wired connectivity can be made available for municipal were tightened, and some poles needed to be reinforced to bear offices. the weight of networking equipment. Leaves on trees proved to be a barrier to Wi-Fi signals, meaning that networks that worked Indeed, the reason that the City of Fredericton is able to offer in the winter did not work so well in the summer. Additionally, free Wi-Fi through its popular Fred-eZone network is that the early estimates of the coverage areas of wireless radios were wireless network makes use of excess capacity available on the found to be too optimistic, meaning that more equipment was City’s community fibre network. Through its municipally needed to provide coverage to targeted areas. The need to owned company eNovations, Fredericton developed its own provide ‘backhaul’, which connects a wireless network to the fibre-optical network. This network not only provides backhaul internet, was not always well understood. for the Fred-eZone, but also provides affordable, high-quality broadband connectivity to local businesses and government. Another issue with public wireless networks was that many Wi-Fi networks were engineered to cover outdoor areas only. In The future of municipal broadband is in fibre networks. There
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Expand and Enhance Your Home Network with Gigabit Powerline
    Expand and Enhance Your Home Network with Gigabit Powerline • The HomePlug AV2 standard creates The ZyXEL PLA5405 1200 Mbps Powerline Gigabit Ethernet Adapter is based on the latest powerline networks with data HomePlug AV2 standard and features data transfer rates of up to 1200 Mbps*. The Powerline transfer rates of up to 1200 Mbps* adapter plugs into an existing power outlet and instantly enables high-speed network access • Enjoy high-speed networking through a home’s electrical lines. The device offers a perfect solution for streaming HD movies, and complete coverage through playing online games and enjoying other network-intensive applications—all without the hassle of Line-Natural/Line-Ground MIMO** installing cables throughout the residence. Featuring the latest HomePlug AV2 MIMO** technology, technology the PLA5405 utilizes multiple lines from your home’s existing electrical wiring, whereas non-MIMO • No extra wires or configuration based HomePlug AV technology uses a single line. This enables the PLA5405 adapter to perform at required up to twice the speed of existing 600 Mbps* Powerline products. • Perfect for connecting smart TVs and playing online games Benefits • QoS enhances media streaming Enjoy high-speed networking and increased coverage through MIMO quality capabilities** • Single push-and-secure button for With advanced HomePlug AV2 technology, the ZyXEL PLA5405 provides users with steady, high-speed easy security setup data transfer rates of up to 1200 Mbps* and is backward compatible with HomePlug AV and IEEE • Compliant with IEEE 1901 and 1901-based products. The new HomePlug AV2 Multiple Input Multiple Output (MIMO) feature increases HomePlug AV technology throughput and coverage.
    [Show full text]
  • Approved Modem List
    Approved Modem List Internet Only Cable Modems* SMC Networks D3CM1604 This broadband modem supports downstream speeds up to 640Mbps and 120Mbps on the upstream. The extreme speed allows faster streaming HD videos, file downloads and high-speed gaming. The D3CM1604 is the ideal solution for your house or small home business. hitron CDA3-35 The CDA3-35 is the perfect choice for cable operators who want to offer high-speed broadband access to their customer base economically. It delivers speeds of up to 1.2Gbps (32×8) with thirty-two bonded downstream channels over its DOCSIS interface. Arris CM3200 The CM3200 is well-suited to the home user – offering the speeds to stream multimedia content to multiple devices and the responsiveness to keep you “in the game” for online gaming. However, the CM3200 is also a serious commercial solution, ready to meet the challenging demands of small business. Cable Modems with WIFI* Arris SURFboard® Modem & Wi-F® Router SBG6580 High-speed Internet and Wireless N at your fingertips. The SURFboard SBG6580 Wi-Fi Cable Modem is 3 products in one device: DOCSIS 3.0 Cable Modem, Dual-Band 802.11n Wi-Fi Access Point and 4-port Gigabit Ethernet Router. Arris DG2470 Wireless Gateway The Touchstone DG2470 is a DOCSIS3.0 home data gateway supporting 24 x 8 channel bonding for up to 960Mbps of broadband data. It combines a 4-port gigabit router, MoCA 2.0 over coax, and a dual band 802.11ac wireless access point. Arris TG2472 Wireless Gateway The Touchstone TG2472 is a DOCSIS3.0 home telephony gateway supporting 24 x 8 channel bonding for up to 960Mbps of broadband data.
    [Show full text]
  • Scanless Fast Handoff Technique Based on Global Path-Cache for Wlans
    Scanless fast handoff technique based on global Path-Cache for WLANs Wanalertlak, W., Lee, B., Yu, C., Kim, M., Park, S. M., & Kim, W. T. (2013). Scanless fast handoff technique based on global Path-Cache for WLANs. Journal of Supercomputing, 66(3), 1320-1349. doi:10.1007/s11227-012-0805-7 10.1007/s11227-012-0805-7 Springer Accepted Manuscript http://hdl.handle.net/1957/48745 http://cdss.library.oregonstate.edu/sa-termsofuse Journal of Supercomputing manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) Scanless Fast Handoff Technique Based on Global Path Cache for WLANs Weetit Wanalertlak · Ben Lee · Chansu Yu · Myungchul Kim · Seung-Min Park · Won-Tae Kim Received: date / Accepted: date Abstract Wireless LANs (WLANs) have been widely adopted and are more convenient as they are inter-connected as wireless campus networks and wire- less mesh networks. However, time-sensitive multimedia applications, which have become more popular, could suffer from long end-to-end latency in WLANs. This is due mainly to handoff delay, which in turn is caused by channel scan- ning. This paper proposes a technique called Global Path-Cache (GPC) that provides fast handoffs in WLANs. GPC properly captures the dynamic be- havior of the network and MSs, and provides accurate next-AP predictions to minimize the handoff latency. Moreover, the handoff frequencies are treated Weetit Wanalertlak and Ben Lee School of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science Oregon State University Corvallis, OR, 97331, USA Tel.: 1-541-737-3148 E-mail: {wanalewe,benl}@eecs.orst.edu Chansu
    [Show full text]
  • Best Practices for Keeping Your Home Network Secure1
    BEST PRACTICES FOR KEEPING YOUR HOME 1 NETWORK SECURE Don't be a victim; cyber criminals may leverage your home network to gain access to personal, private, and confidential information. Help protect yourself and your family by observing some basic guidelines and implementing the following mitigations on your home network. COMPUTING AND ENTERTAINMENT DEVICE RECOMMENDATIONS Electronic computing devices including computers, laptops, printers, mobile phones, tablets, security cameras, home appliances, cars and other “Internet of Things” devices must all be secured in order to prevent attack. Most home entertainment and utility devices, such as home monitoring systems, baby monitors, Internet of Things (IoT), Smart Devices, Blu-ray™2 players, streaming video players, and video game consoles are capable of accessing the Internet, recording audio, and/or capturing video. Implemented security measures can ensure these devices don’t become the weak link in your home protection. 1. Upgrade to a Modern Operating System and Keep it Up-To-Date The most recent version of any operating system (OS) inevitably contains security features not found in previous versions. Many of these security features are enabled by default and help prevent common attack vectors. Increase the difficulty for an adversary to gain privileged access by utilizing the latest available and supported OS for desktops, laptops, and other devices. Enable automatic update functionality inside the OS. If automatic updates are not possible, download and install patches and updates from a trusted vendor minimally on a monthly basis. 2. Exercise Secure User Habits To minimize ransomware threat, backup data on external drives and portable media. Disconnect external storage when not in use.
    [Show full text]
  • The Philadelphia Story Learning from a Municipal Wireless Pioneer
    The Philadelphia Story Learning from a Municipal Wireless Pioneer Joshua Breitbart, Author Naveen Lakshmipathy, Appendices Sascha D. Meinrath, Editor NEW AMERICA FOUNDATION 1 The Philadelphia Story Learning from a Municipal Wireless Pioneer Joshua Breitbart, Author Naveen Lakshmipathy, Appendices Sascha D. Meinrath, Editor Washington, DC Contents Executive Summary ...........................................................................................................................................1 Introduction..........................................................................................................................................................3 Keys To Successful Municipal Wireless Network Deployment......................................................................4 Welcome To Philadelphia ............................................................................................................................................7 About This Report ..........................................................................................................................................................8 Philadelphia A Case Study..........................................................................................................9 Pilot Project.......................................................................................................................................................................9 The Executive Committee .........................................................................................................................................10
    [Show full text]
  • In Blue Are the Updates Since the Last 1 June 2007 Summary)
    Muniwireless.com 1 August 2007 list of US cities and regions (in blue are the updates since the last 1 June 2007 summary) Region and citywide networks Tempe AZ MobilePro Chandler AZ MobilePro Pleasanton CA Network Anatomy Concord CA MetroFi, phase 1 rolled out Marina del Rey CA Planet Halo Foster City CA MetroFi Pacifica CA Veraloft Galt CA Softcom Anaheim CA EarthLink Mountain View CA Google Cerritos CA Cupertino CA MetroFi Sunnyvale CA MetroFi Santa Clara CA MetroFi Lompoc CA Hermosa Beach CA free Internet access San Diego Indian tribal villages CA West Hollywood CA Riverside CA AT&T, MetroFi - only a downtown hotzone for now Vail CO CenturyTel Longmont CO MobilePro St. Cloud FL Deployed and managed by Hewlett Packard Monticello FL Winter Park FL outdoor only Kissimmee FL Motorola, Scientel Adel GA Rome GA GTS Linton IN Scottsburg IN Brownsburg IN Moving Target Marion IN Western Kansas KS Lexington KY Owensboro KY Vivian LA Princeton MA Cape Cod MA Brookline MA Galaxy, Strix, multi-use network including public safety Rockland ME Redzone Wireless Thomaston ME Redzone Wireless Annapolis MD Annapolis Wireless Allegany County MD Coldwater MI operated by Coldwater Board of Public Utilities Bronson MI operated by Coldwater Board of Public Utilities Quincy MI operated by Coldwater Board of Public Utilities Tekonsha MI operated by Coldwater Board of Public Utilities Grand Haven MI Azulstar Ferrysburg MI Spring Lake MI Gladstone MI Washtenaw County MI 20/20 Communications Buffalo MN Chaska MN Moorhead MN Nevada MO Southaven MS Los Lunas NM Rio
    [Show full text]
  • High-Speed Internet Connection Guide Welcome
    High-Speed Internet Connection Guide Welcome Welcome to Suddenlink High-Speed Internet Thank you for choosing Suddenlink as your source for quality home entertainment and communications! There is so much to enjoy with Suddenlink High-Speed Internet including: + Easy self-installation + WiFi@Home availability + Easy access to your Email + Free access to Watch ESPN This user guide will help you get up and running in an instant. If you have any other questions about your service please visit help.suddenlink.com or contact our 24/7 technical support. Don’t forget to register online for a Suddenlink account at suddenlink.net for great features and access to email, billing statements, Suddenlink2GO® and more! 1 Table of Contents Connecting Your High Speed Internet Connecting Your High-Speed Internet Your Suddenlink Self-Install Kit includes Suddenlink Self-Install Kit ..................................................................................... 3 Connecting your computer to a Suddenlink modem ....................................... 4 the following items: Connecting a wireless router or traditional router to Suddenlink ................. 5 Getting Started Microsoft Windows XP or Higher ......................................................................... 6 Cable Modem Power Adapter Mac OS X ................................................................................................................. 6 Register Your Account Online ................................................................................7 Suddenlink WiFi@Home
    [Show full text]
  • The Future of Personal Area Networks in a Ubiquitous Computing World
    Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. The Future of Personal Area Networks in a Ubiquitous Computing World A thesis presented in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Information Sciences in Information Systems at Massey University, Auckland New Zealand Fei Zhao 2008 ABSTRACT In the future world of ubiquitous computing, wireless devices will be everywhere. Personal area networks (PANs), networks that facilitate communications between devices within a short range, will be used to send and receive data and commands that fulfill an individual’s needs. This research determines the future prospects of PANs by examining success criteria, application areas and barriers/challenges. An initial set of issues in each of these three areas is identified from the literature. The Delphi Method is used to determine what experts believe what are the most important success criteria, application areas and barriers/challenges. Critical success factors that will determine the future of personal area networks include reliability of connections, interoperability, and usability. Key application areas include monitoring, healthcare, and smart things. Important barriers and challenges facing the deployment of PAN are security, interference and coexistence, and regulation and standards. i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Firstly, I would like to take this opportunity to express my sincere gratitude to my supervisor – Associate Professor Dennis Viehland, for all his support and guidance during this research. Without his advice and knowledge, I would not have completed this research.
    [Show full text]
  • Computer Networking 101 (HH – Rev1)
    Computer Networking 101 (HH – rev1) Henrietta Hankin Library 215 Windgate Drive Chester Springs, PA 19425 Phone: (610) 321-1700 [email protected] www.ccls.org/hankin https://www.facebook.com/HankinBranchLibrary Computer Networking 101 Page 1 Computer Networking 101 (HH – rev1) Workshop Topics: Fundamentals Network Protocols Home Network Components Diagnostics Outline of Workshop: 1. Fundamentals a. What is a computer network? b. Local Area Networks (LANs) c. Wide Area Networks (WANs) d. Virtual Private Network (VPN – AKA Tunneling) e. The Internet f. Peer-to-Peer Networks g. Server-based Networks h. Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs) 2. Network Protocols a. TCP/IP b. Ethernet c. Ethernet Standards (802.3, 10BaseT, 100BaseT) d. Wireless Protocols (802.11xxx) 3. Home Network Components - Hardware a. PC/Laptop with Network interface Card (NIC) b. Cable Modem c. Router, Switch, Hub d. LAN Cabling e. Network Printer 4. Home Network Components – Software a. Peer-to-peer b. Domain Name Server (DNS) c. Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol (DHCP) d. Firewall 5. Network Diagnostics a. ipconfig command b. ping command c. Command to identify all active network components d. Wireshark Page 2 Computer Networking 101 (HH – rev1) Fundamentals What is a computer network? A computer network consists of a collection of computers, printers and other devices that are connected together so that they can talk to each other. Local Area Networks (LANs), Wide Area Networks (WANs) and Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) are all examples of computer networks. Local Area Networks (LANs) LANs connect computers and other devices that are located physically close to each other. A computer network in a house or office is an example of a LAN.
    [Show full text]
  • Home Network System FAQ 20170202
    FAQ Home Network System As of February 2, 2017 FAQ for quick setup and easier use - Index STEP 1 Open the package and confirm the accessories Accessories Page 2-5 Basic Concept Page 7-11 & Operation STEP 2 Set up main unit (Hub) System Initial Setup Page 12-14 STEP 3 Install the Home Network app. Application Page 15-18 STEP 4 Make sure your mobile device is connected to Application Page 15-18 your Wi-Fi® network. STEP 5 Cordless Handset Page 19-28 Set up accessories HUB Page 29-33 Indoor Camera Page 34-41 Outdoor Camera Page 42-49 Motion Sensor Page 50-53 Window / Door Sensor Page 54-56 Water Leak Sensor Page 57 Class Break Sensor Page 58 Indoor Siren Page 59 Access Keypad Page 60 Keychain Remote Page 61 Backup Battery Page 62 Smart Plug Page 63-64 Full HD Camera Page 65-67 1 Accessories - What are the accessories for? HUB (KX-HNB600) Indoor Camera (KX-HNC200/210) • Full color camera with night vision and built-in microphone • Joins all system devices together for live monitoring and recording • Connects to your landline for making and receiving calls • Built-in motion sensor (visual detection), sound sensor, • Supports SD card connection for recording camera video and temperature sensor can be used to trigger other and audio. actions (camera recording, turning on a light, etc.) • Built-in microphone and speaker for two-way communication Outdoor Camera (KX-HNC600) Window / Door Sensor (KX-HNS101) • Full color camera with night vision and built-in microphone for live monitoring and recording • Detects when the corresponding window or door is • Built-in motion sensor (visual detection), sound opened.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 a Privacy Analysis of the Six Proposals for San Francisco
    A Privacy Analysis of the Six Proposals for San Francisco Municipal Broadband Six companies have proposed plans to bring municipal broadband to San Francisco. They range from approaches where users will pay monthly fees, to advertising-supported services and free services. Whatever the City's approach, we think it is important that the accepted proposal respect Californian's fundamental right to privacy. San Franciscans have the right to a network that respects privacy and autonomy, one that allows users to explore what the Internet has to offer, including information about medical conditions and the use of online banking, without fear of government or commercial surveillance and intrusion. In the summary below, we compare the six proposals against a model standard of privacy rights. This comparison only judges the proposals on privacy rights; other important interests, such as bridging the digital divide, reliability in service, and quality of service, are not considered. Again, we applaud City officials for their efforts to bring municipal broadband to San Francisco. This effort is an important experiment in public policy, one that we fully support. Our efforts are intended not to slow down or frustrate this important process, but rather to ensure that the network respects privacy rights. Background On October 19, 2005, the ACLU of Northern California, Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), and the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) submitted comments to TechConnect concerning the privacy implications of municipal broadband access. In that letter, the groups raised a series of privacy issues that sought to focus attention on whether uses of the municipal broadband network will have secure and private access to the Internet (see Appendix A).
    [Show full text]
  • Municipal Broadband: Challenges and Perspectives
    Federal Communications Law Journal Volume 59 Issue 1 Article 4 12-2006 Municipal Broadband: Challenges and Perspectives Craig Dingwall Mintz Levin Cohn Ferris Glovsky and Popeo Follow this and additional works at: https://www.repository.law.indiana.edu/fclj Part of the Administrative Law Commons, Antitrust and Trade Regulation Commons, Communications Law Commons, and the Legislation Commons Recommended Citation Dingwall, Craig (2006) "Municipal Broadband: Challenges and Perspectives," Federal Communications Law Journal: Vol. 59 : Iss. 1 , Article 4. Available at: https://www.repository.law.indiana.edu/fclj/vol59/iss1/4 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Law School Journals at Digital Repository @ Maurer Law. It has been accepted for inclusion in Federal Communications Law Journal by an authorized editor of Digital Repository @ Maurer Law. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Municipal Broadband: Challenges and Perspectives Craig Dingwall* I. INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY ................................................ 68 II. BROADBAND DEMAND ............................................................. 69 III. POSSIBLE JUSTIFICATIONS FOR MUNICIPAL BROADBAND ............. 76 IV. SPEED, FEATURE, AND PRICE CONSIDERATIONS ....................... 77 V. MUNICIPAL BROADBAND STATUS ............................................. 81 A. MunicipalBroadband Deployment ..................................... 81 B. State and FederalLegislation ................................................. 85 C. Nixon v.
    [Show full text]