DOCSLIB.ORG

Why Only Women?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Why Only Women? Why only women? An interview study of individual members’ experiences and perceptions of the women-only online community Heja Livet! Malin Johnsson Media and Communication studies: Culture, Collaborative Media and Creative Industries Master thesis, One-year master 15 credits Spring 2021 Supervisor: Maria Brock Malmö University Abstract Why are women attracted to join women-only online communities and what are the affordances of these communities? This study is focusing on the signifier of the fourth-wave feminism – feminist activity online and the cultivation of online safe spaces. Sweden is often considered to be a gender-equal country but this study sheds light on the fact that women in Sweden still experience gender inequalities. Through interviews with members of the online community Heja Livet, this study aims to investigate why women choose to join women-only online communities, how they reflect on separatism and safe spaces, and the group’s possible contributions to women and society at large. The study is based on a feminist perspective and has a constructionist approach in the sense that it understands the individual members’ perceptions as constructions. The study found that the administrative work, a constant renegotiation of the binaries safe/unsafe and inclusion/exclusion together with the separation from men, creates a climate where women feel comfortable to interact with other women online. Issues of whether Heja Livet is inclusive of all women remain under discussion, and even though the members consider separatist groups to be important for both individual women and the feminist movement, it is also important to raise men’s consciousness of patriarchal structures. Heja Livet provides a space where women can come together with other women to discuss, share, support, find inspiration, empower each other and raise consciousness. It is difficult to determine whether the group can be defined as a safe space or not, both due to the incomplete and dynamic nature of safe spaces and also because of the interviewees’ low level of active participation exposing themselves and their personal life in the group. The perceptions of the interviewees were, however, that the group provides women with a safe space online. Keywords: Separatism, online safe spaces, consciousness-raising, empowerment, fourth-wave feminism 1 Table of Content Abstract ................................................................................................................................................. 1 List of tables ........................................................................................................................................ 3 1. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 4 1.2 Background about Heja Livet ............................................................................................... 5 1.3 Aim, purpose, and research questions .............................................................................. 6 2. Previous research and theoretical framework ....................................................................... 7 2.1 Feminist separatism ................................................................................................................ 7 2.1.1 The rise of separatism ..................................................................................................... 7 2.1.2 Theorizing separatism ..................................................................................................... 8 2.2 Intersectionality ........................................................................................................................ 9 2.3 Safe space ................................................................................................................................. 9 2.3.1 The construction of safe spaces .................................................................................. 9 2.3.2 The concept of safe space ........................................................................................... 10 2.4 Women-only online safe spaces ........................................................................................ 11 3. Research method ......................................................................................................................... 14 3.1 Choice of method ................................................................................................................... 14 3.2 Research paradigm ............................................................................................................... 14 3.3 Data collection method ........................................................................................................ 15 3.3.1 selection of respondents .............................................................................................. 15 3.3.2 Pilot interview .................................................................................................................. 16 3.3.3 Conducting the interviews ........................................................................................... 16 3.4 Data analysis method ........................................................................................................... 17 3.5 Method discussion ................................................................................................................ 18 3.6 Ethical considerations .......................................................................................................... 20 3.7 Validity and reliability ........................................................................................................... 21 4. Findings and analysis ................................................................................................................. 23 4.1 Why Heja Livet? ..................................................................................................................... 23 4.1.1 The members’ descriptions of Heja Livet ................................................................ 23 4.1.2 Why do women join the group? .................................................................................. 24 4.1.3 Why do women stay in the group? ............................................................................ 25 4.2 Feminism and separatism ................................................................................................... 28 4.2.1 Is the group feminist? ................................................................................................... 28 4.2.2 Separatism ....................................................................................................................... 29 4.2.3 Problematizing separatism .......................................................................................... 31 2 4.3 A safe space online? ............................................................................................................. 32 4.3.1 ‘Safety for’ ........................................................................................................................ 32 4.3.2 ‘Safety from’ ..................................................................................................................... 35 4.3.3 ‘Safety to’ .......................................................................................................................... 35 4.4 Contribution of the group .................................................................................................... 36 4.4.1 Is there a need for this group? .................................................................................... 37 4.4.2 Community and support ............................................................................................... 37 4.4.3 Raised consciousness .................................................................................................. 38 5. Discussion ..................................................................................................................................... 40 5.1 “What are the individual members’ motivations for joining and participating in the online community Heja Livet?” ......................................................................................... 40 5.2 What can a gender separatist online community such as Heja Livet contribute with to women’s everyday life and society at large? .......................................................... 41 5.3 What are the possibilities and limitations of Heja Livet to provide a safe space for women to share and interact with other women? ............................................................... 42 6. Conclusion and further research ............................................................................................. 43 7. References ..................................................................................................................................... 45 8. Appendices .................................................................................................................................... 49 Appendix I ...................................................................................................................................... 49 Appendix II ..................................................................................................................................... 50 Appendix III ...................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Strategies for Sexual Subversion: Informing the Future of Sexualities Research and Activism
    STRATEGIES FOR SEXUAL SUBVERSION: INFORMING THE FUTURE OF SEXUALITIES RESEARCH AND ACTIVISM ANDREA P. HERRERA University of Oregon Abstract In this paper, I review, analyze, and evaluate the myriad ways early canonical and more recent high-profile scholarship in the field of sexualities envision a liberatory sexual politics and the most fruitful modes of achieving it. Due to theorists’ diverging interpretations of the causes and forms of sexual oppression as well as their differing visions of liberated sexuality, I find that prescriptions for dismantling the “ethnosexual regime” (Nagel 2000) vary widely. The strategies suggested by scholars can be categorized into: 1) radical lesbian-feminist separatism, 2) identity politics, 3) the redeployment of gender, which encompasses trans and intersex bodies, gender play (e.g., butch-femme, drag, and shifting constructions of masculinity), and non-binary identities, 4) micro-level individual and interpersonal solutions, 5) changes in educational institutions, and 6) sexualities research itself. I conclude by making suggestions for sociologists who seek to further theorize and effect the subversion of normative systems of sexuality. Introduction Implicit in much sexualities research is the belief that another world is possible, one free from sexual regulation, oppression, persecution, and violence. While nearly all scholars of sexualities identify problems in the contemporary social organization of sexuality, they differ in their estimations of the causes and solutions to these issues. This paper is a qualitative meta-analytic review of the ways early canonical and more recent high-profile scholarship in Andrea P. Herrera ([email protected]) is a PhD candidate and sociologist at the University of Oregon specializing in gender, sexuality, embodiment, and new media.
    [Show full text]
  • Feminism and Pragmatism
    Feminism and Pragmatism Richard Rorty When two women ascended to the Supreme Court of Minnesota, of the reasonable rapist on women's employment opportunities' .3 Catherine MacKinnon asked: 'Will they use the tools of law as 'The conditions that create women's rapeability as the definition women, for all women?' She continued as follows: of womanhood were not even seen as susceptible to change. '4 MacKinnon thinks that such assumptions of unchangeability will only be overcome once we can hear 'what women as women I think that the real feminist issue is not whether biological would have to say'. I take her point to be that assumptions males or biological females hold positions of power, become visible as assumptions only if we can make the although it is utterly essential that women be there. And I contradictories of those assumptions sound plausible. So injus­ am not saying that viewpoints have genitals. My issue is tices may not be perceived as injustices, even by those who suffer what our identifications are, what our loyalties are, who them, until somebody invents a previously unplayed role. Only if our community is, to whom we are accountable. If it somebody has a dream, and a voice to describe that dream, does seems as if this is not very concrete, I think it is because we what looked like nature begin to look like culture, what looked have no idea what women as women would have to say. like fate begin to look like a moral abomination. For until then I'm evoking for women a role that we have yet to make, in only the language of the oppressor is available, and most oppres­ the name of a voice that, un silenced, might say something sors have had the wit to teach the oppressed a language in which that has never been heard .
    [Show full text]
  • THE MARGINALITY of the AMERICAN LEFT: the LEGACY of the 1960S
    THE MARGINALITY OF THE AMERICAN LEFT: THE LEGACY OF THE 1960s Barbara Epstein By virtually any definition of the term, the US left is not doing well. In the sixties the left was intertwined with a series of progressive social movements; these movements and the left within them attracted enormous numbers of young people, many of whom changed not only their ideas but the way they led their lives through this experience. A vibrant left politics and culture flourished in every major city in the North and in many in the South; few college or university campuses were untouched by it. The left was a major presence in national politics and in intellectual life, outside as well as within academia. The left brought a freshness, honesty and moral integrity to national discussion that compelled attention and respect. Today this is virtually all gone. Though there are many organizing projects concerned with specific social problems, there are only the remnants of a left able to link these issues and call for systematic social change. In national politics the left has little if any influence. There is a subculture that identifies itself as left, but it is insular and dispirited, and too often preoc- cupied with policing the attitudes and language of those in or close to the left. The staleness of the left's perspective and its political marginality in the nineties stand in sharp contrast to its attractiveness and influence in the sixties. The mistakes of the left are only one reason for its decline: the left has also been undermined by the rising power of global corporate capital and discouraged by the collapse of the Soviet Union and the apparent victory of capitalism over socialism.
    [Show full text]
  • A Strategy of Seclusion: Cavarero's Feminist Decentering of Arendt's
    ISSN 1393-614X Minerva - An Internet Journal of Philosophy 12 (2008): 1-18 ____________________________________________________ A Strategy of Seclusion: Cavarero's Feminist Decentering of Arendt’s Political Theory Mark Kingston Abstract Through her reading of The Odyssey, Adriana Cavarero proposes a strategy for feminist action based on the creation of small communities as a means of disconnection from patriarchal society. On the face of it, her argument may seem like a straightforward appeal for feminist separatism, but it is in fact intended as a critique of the political theory of Hannah Arendt. In arguing that the public space is inherently patriarchal, and proposing that women therefore abandon the public space in favour of small communities that can provide islands of freedom from patriarchy, Cavarero rejects Arendt’s valorisation of action in a central public realm. This makes Cavarero’s work interesting in the context of contemporary debates on Arendt, in which several commentators have attempted to ‘decenter’ Arendt’s political theory. Cavarero’s ‘small-community’ model of action also unsettles the traditional dichotomy between models that locate action within a central, public space and models that construe action as the individualistic transgression of social norms. Her work is therefore important in the context of the growing interest in small-community models of action. However, Cavarero’s gendering of Arendt’s concept of political action as masculine leads her to engage in identity politics, and this renders the strongest version of her argument unsound. Nonetheless, a slightly weaker version of Cavarero’s argument can support her thesis that Arendt’s political theory must be decentered by the inclusion of a small-community model of action.
    [Show full text]
  • Abstract LAMONICA, LAURA TRIPP. Becoming A
    Abstract LAMONICA, LAURA TRIPP. Becoming a Worker-Mother: Understanding the Transition. (Under the direction of Dr. Julia Storberg-Walker.) There has been a dramatic increase in the number of women who both work and mother into the workforce in recent years. The patriarchal structure of the typical U.S. organization is based on rational-economic models and the “economic man” model of worker. This structure systematically disadvantages women who work and mother. The HRD function within organizations can feed the patriarchal status quo of the organizations within which it exists by adopting the rational decision making model to formulate and develop policies that require performance at all costs. There are few studies that look specifically at women’s transitions in becoming worker-mothers. Literature typically has focused on perceptions of workplace policies and programs designed to assist work-life balance and of those who use those programs. The purpose of this exploratory, grounded narrative inquiry is to examine the experiences of primiparous (pregnant for the first time) women as they negotiate pregnancy and exit of and planned re-entry to the workplace around the birth of a first child. The conceptual framework for the study is radical feminist theory. The framework has at its core a belief in patriarchy as the basic system of power on which all human relationships are structured and arranged. Male oppression and dominance are recognized as the most fundamental form of inequality, superseding and preceding both classism and racism. Radical feminism recognizes that only the elimination of patriarchal structures will end the oppression of women.
    [Show full text]
  • Exorbitance and Queer Futurities in the Well of Loneliness, Lesbian Pulp Fiction, and Radical Feminist Manifestos
    FEET DOWN, NEW PLANET: EXORBITANCE AND QUEER FUTURITIES IN THE WELL OF LONELINESS, LESBIAN PULP FICTION, AND RADICAL FEMINIST MANIFESTOS A Thesis submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of Georgetown University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in English By Sally Baker, B.A. Washington, DC March 19, 2018 Copyright 2018 by Sally Baker All Rights Reserved ii FEET DOWN, NEW PLANET: EXORBITANCE AND QUEER FUTURITIES IN THE WELL OF LONELINESS, LESBIAN PULP FICTION, AND RADICAL FEMINIST MANIFESTOS Sally Baker, B.A. Thesis Advisor: Jennifer Natalya Fink, Ph.D. ABSTRACT “Feet Down, New Planet” explores exorbitance and queer futurities in The Well of Loneliness, lesbian pulp fiction, and radical feminist manifestos. It extends queer theory to the texts as a way to expand them beyond the limits of their original sociocultural publication contexts. This thesis examines models of reproduction, queer embodiment, and world-building in The Well of Loneliness, lesbian pulp fiction, and radical feminist manifestos in order to examine how the authors write worlds beyond the limits of liberal feminist propriety, and imagine radical queer futures through oozing poetic sensibilities. “Feet Down, New Planet” contributes to queer theories of excess by mapping a cartographic and affective history of queer literary excess, and curates the exorbitant world-building frameworks Radclyffe Hall, Valerie Taylor, Jill Johnston, and Valerie Solanas imagine. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction: Feet Down…………………………………………………………………...... 1 Chapter I: Flesh Temporalities: Womb as Queer Counterpublic in The Well of Loneliness… 4 Introduction: The Well of Loneliness………………………………………………….. 4 Situating the Womb………………………………………………………………….
    [Show full text]
  • The Heroine's Journey
    In the footsteps of the heroine The journey to Integral Feminism Figure 1: ‘Queen of the Night’, © Trustees of the British Museum A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctorate of Philosophy at the University of Western Sydney 2008 Sarah Nicholson To the women, known and unknown, who have forged the way, and those still to come. Acknowledgements I would like to thank: My first supervisors, Anne Marshall and Susan Murphy, and my co-supervisor Brenda Dobia, for sharing their expertise, critique and inspiration. The Writing and Society group at UWS for their support and assistance, particularly in funding editorial assistance. The School of Social Ecology and the School of Humanities for providing me with Student Project funding to make invaluable contacts, conduct crucial research and attend conferences overseas. The Visiting Scholar scheme of the Centre for Feminist Research, York University, Toronto for hosting me as a visiting postgraduate scholar. The international Integral community – particularly the inspirational Willow Pearson and fellow traveller Vanessa Fisher, for their inspiration, support and encouragement. The Sydney Integral group – particularly Simon Mundy, Tim Mansfield, Vivian Baruch, Helen Titchen-Beeth, and Luke Fullagar - who read and insightfully commented on chapters of this thesis. My parents, Eli, my aunty Joy, my grandparents, and my extended family, for offering me unfailing love, support and assistance. My friends, for supporting me being me, by being you. Rachel Hammond, Martin Robertson, Sarah Roberts, and Sarah Harmelink, Cartia Wollen and Edward Birt, for their assistance with child care in the final stages of this thesis. Particular thanks to Allison Salmon, who is always there when, and indeed before I realise, I need her.
    [Show full text]
  • What Happened to Peer Production?
    The Tyranny of Openness: What Happened to Peer Production? Nathan Schneider University of Colorado Boulder Feminist Media Studies (2021) https://doi.org/10.1080/14680777.2021.1890183 This paper examines a “culture war” underway among software peer-production communities through relevant blog posts, legal documents, forum discussions, and other sources. Software licens- ing has been a defining strategy for peer producers, and much of the conflict at hand revolves around whether licensing should more fully incorporate ethics and economics, respectively. Femi- nist analysis can aid in tracing the contours of discontent through its emphasis on social processes that enable and infuse productive activity—processes that peer producers have trained themselves to ignore. The emerging critiques, and the experiments they have inspired, gesture toward fuller understandings of what “free” and “open” might mean. keywords: feminist theory, peer production, commons, free software, open source, software licensing, intellectual property The author is grateful for feedback on earlier drafts from Michel Bauwens, Heather Meeker, Matthew S. Wilson, and extraordinary anonymous reviewers. According to a brief trend piece in Wired (Cohen 2018), people in Silicon Valley have been reading “The Tyranny of Structurelessness.” The classic essay’s author, Jo Freeman, challenged her fellow feminist activists to notice how their insistence on allegedly leaderless, open forms of organization were “becoming a goddess in its own right” (Freeman 1972). In the absence of explicit
    [Show full text]
  • Utopian Separatism
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by NORA - Norwegian Open Research Archives Utopian Separatism Feminism and Science Fiction Anette Myrestøl Espelid A thesis presented to The Department of Literature, Area Studies and European Languages The University of Oslo In partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Master of Arts Degree Spring Term 2012 II Utopian Separatism Feminism and Science Fiction © Anette Myrestøl Espelid 2012 Utopian Separatism: Feminism and Science Fiction Anette Myrestøl Espelid http://www.duo.uio.no/ Trykk: Reprosentralen, Universitetet i Oslo III IV Abstract This thesis deals with three works of feminist science fiction. The three novels I will examine are Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s Herland (1915), Joanna Russ’s The Female Man (1975) and Sarah Hall’s Daughters of the North (2007). My central question in this thesis will be: To what extent are these novels representing contemporary feminisms? My thesis will therefore set out to examine the political and social context in which these novels were written, and also the impact of the genre in itself. By using their different feminisms as a point of departure, I will also examine how they approach gender as a social construction in science fiction through using utopian and dystopian strategies. Starting from the assumption that one can approach “literary narrative as a place where theory takes place” (182), as Judith Butler argues in Bodies that Matter, I will examine the importance of feminism in the narratives and also approach the context in which these novels are written. V VI Acknowledgements First of all, I would like to thank my supervisor Nils Axel Nissen for his help and guidance, his patient and kind feedback has been invaluable throughout the process of writing my thesis.
    [Show full text]
  • Symposia on Gender, Race and Philosophy
    indifference which will reveal to him his being-a-Jew; and this being-a-Jew is nothing outside the free manner of adopting it” Symposia on Gender, Race and (677).1 Philosophy You might be tempted to think that captors who deem that a Volume 3, number 3. September 2007 man is a Jew, imprison him in a concentration camp, torture http://web.mit.edu/sgrp him, and provide him with no reason to hope for release are, to say the very least, oppressors. Not so, according to Sartre. For this prisoner’s experience, though ordered around his circumstances, is constituted by his attitude toward those circumstances; and this attitude, or consciousness, is entirely The Second Feminism free. We “assume” our circumstances, Sartre said; and in so Commentary on Noëlle McAfee’s “Two Feminisms” doing we make of them what we will. Sometimes we assume them in “bad faith,” which is to say that we tell ourselves lies about what is going on. We are addicted to cigarettes but NANCY BAUER Department of Philosophy refuse to call ourselves smokers. We say that we “are” Tufts University waiters, as though the fact of waiting on tables day in and day Medford, MA 02155 out constitutes a fixed and secure identity. We insinuate to USA underlings that they ought to torture prisoners and then [email protected] rationalize that we’re not responsible because we didn’t give flat-out orders.2 But the worst kind of bad faith comes when we imagine that we are trapped, that we have no choice about how to construe—to articulate—what is going on.
    [Show full text]
  • From a Hashtag to a Movement from Metoo to Being Rightless in 2020’S Sweden
    ISSN 1653-2244 INSTITUTIONEN FÖR KULTURANTROPOLOGI OCH ETNOLOGI DEPARTMENT OF CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY AND ETHNOLOGY From a hashtag to a movement From MeToo to being rightless in 2020’s Sweden By Klara Fröberg Supervisor: Dr Charlotta Widmark 2021 MASTERUPPSATSER I KULTURANTROPOLOGI Nr 104 Abstract This thesis investigates the continuance of the MeToo movement in the Swedish context via the digital platform Instagram, collective action and feminist organizations that are engaged to end sexual vio- lence. It illuminates how the sisterhood impacted by the practice of challenging the rape script a con- cept used to describe the discourse on how sexual violence should be like, and how victim-survivors should behave, how the engagement is made among the activists that engage to challenge the rape script and lastly, how since the MeToo movement started a discourse of rightlessness have been ex- posed through the sharing of experiences that the MeToo movement initiated. The ethnographic study is based on participant observation of feminist actions in real life and on Instagram as well as interviews with 13 activists from feminist organizations and with background as organisers of collective actions. It is found that the MeToo movement in Sweden is commonly practiced through an engagement in Feminist organizations that serve to keep the movement alive through continuous work to keep sexual violence on the agenda by keeping it visible, and that the engagement is driven by an experience of anger towards the societal discourse that sets the discourse on rape which affects the possibility to be recognized by the legal system. The thesis will overall suggest that there is a sisterhood built on a collective identity, and that the shared identity and oppression between non-men with an aspiration to support one another in the experience of oppression as well as organize safety nets for those who are sentenced for defamation as a consequence of speaking out.
    [Show full text]
  • Rare Books Lib
    RARE BOOKS LIB. The University of Sydney Copyright and use of this thesis This thesis must be used in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright Act 1968. Reproduction of material protected by copyright may be an infringement of copyright and copyright owners may be entitled to take legal action against persons who infringe their copyright. Section 51 (2) of the Copyright Act permits an authorized officer of a university library or archives to provide a copy (by communication or otherwise) of an unpublished thesis kept in the library or archives, to a person who satisfies the authorized officer that he or she requires the reproduction for the purposes of research or study. The Copyright Act grants the creator of a work a number of moral rights, specifically the right of attribution, the right against false attribution and the right of integrity. You may infringe the author's moral rights if you: • fail to acknowledge the author of this thesis if you quote sections from the work • attribute this thesis to another author • subject this thesis to derogatory treatment which may prejudice the author's reputation For further information contact the University's Director of Copyright Services Telephone: 02 9351 29911 e-mail: [email protected] FAIR GO. Cleo magazine as popular feminism in 1970s Australia M. J. Le Masurier A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Media and Communications School of Letters, Arts and Media University of Sydney December 2007 1 CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORSHIP jORIGINALITY I certify that the work in this thesis has not previously been submitted for a degree nor has it been submitted as part of requirements for a degree except as fully acknowledged within the text.
    [Show full text]