CERNCOURIER
- March/April 2021 cerncourier.com
- Reporting on international high-energy physics
W E L C O M E
CERN Courier – digital edition
Welcome to the digital edition of the March/April 2021 issue of CERN Courie r. Hadron colliders have contributed to a golden era of discovery in high-energy physics, hosting experiments that have enabled physicists to unearth the cornerstones of the Standard Model. This success story began 50 years ago with CERN’s Intersecting Storage Rings (featured on the cover of this issue) and culminated in the Large Hadron Collider (p38) – which has spawned thousands
of papers in its first 10 years of operations alone (p47). It also bodes well for a
potential future circular collider at CERN operating at a centre-of-mass energy of at least 100TeV, a feasibility study for which is now in full swing.
Even hadron colliders have their limits, however. To explore possible new physics at the highest energy scales, physicists are mounting a series of experiments to search for very weakly interacting “slim” particles that arise from extensions in the Standard Model (p25).
Also celebrating a golden anniversary this year is the Institute for Nuclear Research in Moscow (p33), while, elsewhere in this issue: quantum sensors target gravitational waves (p10); X-rays go behind the scenes of supernova
1987A (p12); a high-performance computing collaboration forms to handle the
big-physics data onslaught (p22); Steven Weinberg talks about his latest work (p51); and much more.
- HA
- DR
- ON
- CO
- LL
- IDE
- RS
- 50 y
- ear
- s of
- dis
- cov
ery
To sign up to the new-issue alert, please visit:
http://comms.iop.org/k/iop/cerncourier
To subscribe to the magazine, please visit:
https://cerncourier.com/p/about-cern-courier
EDITOR: MATTHEW CHALMERS, CERN DIGITAL EDITION CREATED BY IOP PUBLISHING
ATLAS spots rare Higgs decay Weinberg on effective field theory Hunting for WISPs
V o l u m e 6 1 N u m b e r 2 m a r c h / a p r i l 2 0 2 1
CERNCOURIER.COM
Your DIGITAL
POWER ELECTRONICS
Partner
Volume 61 Number 2 march/april 2021
IN THIS ISSUE
It’s ALL
about the
DETAILS
Dalitzdecay ATLA S s pot s r ar e d eca y o f t h e H igg s b oson
UniversalsearchBaikal-GVD will continue the
StaffsearchCERN’s efforts to attract
- to a photon and a low-mass electron or muon pair. 17
- astrophysical neutrino search. 33
- non-physicists into ke y r oles. 61
- NeWS
- people
- ANALYSIS
- ENERGY FRONTIERS
- FIELD NOTES
- CAREERS
- OBITUARIES
AEgIS on track to test antimatter free fall
First evidence for rare
Higgs-boson decay
Tooling up to hunt dark
Jack Steinberger
Martinus Veltman Günther Plass
Acceleratingtalent at CERN
The challenge of attracting engineers, technicians
and others who build and
maintain CERN’s complex
infrastructure. 61
•••••••
matter Computing
•
NICA sees first beam
CLOUD and Arctic sea
Supersymmetry
collaboration kicks off
- •
- •
searches Precision
Quark-matter fireballs
in Protvino. 21
André Martin
- •
- •
- •
- ice Quantum sensing
- leap for B0s Light shines
Stephanie Zimmermann Stephen Reucroft Jean-Claude Berset. 69
- •
- •
- Farewell Daya Bay
- inside lead nuclei. 17
•
The core of SN1987A. 7
•
FeaTureS
- WISPS
- INR RAS
- HADRON COLLIDERS
- LHC
Insearchof WISPs
New experiments will expand the search for axions and other weakly interacting ‘slim’ particles that could hail from far
above the TeV scale. 25
Discoverymachines
Lyn Evans and Peter Jenni look at the lessons learned from 50 years of experience with hadron colliders and
their detectors. 38
A decadeinLHC publications
Alex Kohls, Jens Vigen and Micha Moskovic
look back on the
Russia’sparticle- physicspowerhouse
The Institute for Nuclear Research in Moscow continues to leave its mark on neutrino and high-energy physics. 33
first 10 years of LHC
publications. 47
DeparTmeNTS opiNioN
- VIEWPOINT
- INTERVIEW
- REVIEWS
FROM THE EDITOR
5
15
Power Supply Systems
Connectingphysics withsociety
We must communicate the applications and
impact of our field, argues Barbora Bruant
Gulejova. 49
Stillseeking solutions
Steven Weinberg reflects on effective field theory
and his latest attempt to understand the fermion
mass hierarchy. 51
Thehitchhiker’s guidetoweakdecays
An expedition to
NEWS DIGEST
Precision Current Measurements Beamline Electronic Instrumentation FMC and MicroTCA
APPOINTMENTS &AWARDS
62
new physics summits
RECRUITMENT BACKGROUND
64 74
Onthecover: CERN’s
Intersectin g S torag e R ings,
the firs t h adron collider. 38
The science of
learning physics. 57
•
CERN COURIER MARCH/APRIL 2021
3
V o l u m e 6 1 N u m b e r 2 m a r c h / a p r i l 2 0 2 1
CERNCOURIER.COM
edwardsvacuum.com
FROM THE
EDITOR
ENABLING RESEARCH IN UHV
Edwards are able to supply a total vacuum package from UHV through to atmospheric pumping from a range of products including:
• Primary pumps nXDS dry scroll
pumps and RV oil sealed rotary vane
pumps for excellent ulꢀmate and
superior vapour handling With our advanced modelling
Therewardsof boldthinking
• Ultra-high vacuum Gamma Ion
pumps for low cost and vibraꢀon free operaꢀon capabiliꢀes and years of experience in scienꢀfic research, rest assured Edwards has the vacuum experꢀse to meet your applicaꢀon requirements.
ack in the early 1960s, as this month’s cover feature Europeanstrategyforparticlephysics, CERNisexploringthe describes (p38), discussion raged at CERN about the mostambitiouslong-termtechnologicalpathinundertaking nextbeststepforparticlephysics.Atthetime,thehigh- a feasibility study for a future circular hadron collider with a energyfrontierwascommandedbythegreatprotonsynchro- centre-of-massenergyofatleast100TeV. Ifbuilt, thesuccess trons, such as Brookhaven’s Cosmotron and, later, CERN’s ofthismotherofallhadroncolliderswillhaveeachgeneration
Proton Synchrotron, which drove fixed-target experiments. of previous machine and its detectors to thank.
Butanewtypeofmachinecapableofexploitingthefullenergy
• High vacuum nEXT and STP
turbomolecular pumps including versions for high throughput and
radiaꢀon hardened designs
B
Matthew Chalmers
Editor
of proton beams for the production of new particles – the Know your limits hadron collider – was revving up in the sidelines. In Decem- As productive as hadron colliders are in probing nature at ber 1965 the CERN Council approved the construction of the the highest energies, many current mysteries, such as dark more technologically innovative Intersecting Storage Rings matter and the origin of neutrino masses, may well origi(ISR) over a very high-energy proton synchrotron, although thelatterwouldmaterialise10yearslaterintheSuperProton
Synchrotron (SPS). The ISR’s first proton–proton collisions,
whichreachedacentre-of-massenergyof62GeV, tookplace on 27 January 1971, opening the era of hadron colliders. From the ISR came the ingenious conversion of the SPS nate from phenomena at energy scales inaccessible to any collider imaginable. Fortunately, models involving such scales can be tested nowandinthenearfuturebya seriesofexperiments–some using magnets from the LHC andHERAinfact–searching for very weakly interacting “slim” particles that arise in extensions of the Stand-
ardModel(seep25). Effective fieldtheoryisanotherpower-
fultooltopursuesuchsignals fromfarbeyondtheTeVscale, explains Steven Weinberg in this issue’s interview (p51).
–into a proton–antiproton collider (SppS), the demonstration
of large-scale superconducting magnet technology for the Tevatron at Fermilab, and the LHC, whose elegant magnet design has enabled the highest collision energies (13TeV) and luminosities to date. Each machine, and its increasingly complex detectors, was a step into the unknown, requiring the invention of new technologies and sharp political and organisational skills to build and operate ever larger facil-
ities. The payoff was the discovery of the Standard Model’s
–cornerstones: the W and Z bosons at the SppS, the top quark
at the Tevatron, and the Higgs boson at the LHC. Not to be Discovery machine The LHC. omittedfromthehadron-beamcollidersuccessstoryarethe leapsinunderstandingofstronglyinteractingmatterbrought
Meanwhile at CERN: ATLAS reports the first evidence for a
Eachmachine, andits increasingly complex detectors, was astepinto the unknown
aboutbyBrookhaven’sRelativisticHeavy-IonColliderandthe rare“Dalitz”decayoftheHiggsboson(p17);pulsed-modeantiLHC, andthedeep-inelasticscatteringexperimentsatDESY’s hydrogen paves the way to test antimatter in free fall (p7); and so-faruniqueelectron–protoncolliderHERA, whichrevealed the CLOUD experiment reveals a new mechanism that could
- the proton’s innards in full colour.
- acceleratethelossofArcticseaice(p9).Elsewhereinthisissue:
Half a century after the ISR’s first collisions, and with at least quantum sensors target gravitational waves (p10); X-rays go
15 years of LHC operations still to come, particle physicists behindthescenesofsupernova1987A(p12);ahigh-performance
once again find themselves debating the next best step for the computing collaboration forms to handle the big-physics data field. True to form, as recommended by the 2020 update of the onslaught (p22); new twists in the ATOMKI tale (p74); and more.
Reporting on international high-energy physics
- Editor
- Laboratorycorrespondents
Argonne National Laboratory
Jefferson Laboratory
Kandice Carter
JINR Dubna B Starchenko KEK National Laboratory
Hajime Hikino
Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory Spencer Klein Los Alamos National Lab
Rajan Gupta
NCSL Ken Kingery Nikhef Robert Fleischer Novosibirsk Institute
S Eidelman
SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory
Melinda Baker
SNOLAB Samantha Kuula TRIUMF Laboratory
Marcello Pavan
Technical illustrator
Alison Tovey
Advertising sales
Tom Houlden
Recruitment sales
Chris Thomas
Advertisement production Katie Graham Marketing and circulation Laura Gillham,
Jessica Pratten
General distribution
CourrierAdressage, CERN, 1211Geneva23, Switzerland; e-mail courrier-
CERN Courier is distributed
to governments, institutes
and laboratories affiliated
with CERN, and to individual subscribers. It is published six times per year. The views expressed are not necessarily those of the CERN management.
Matthew Chalmers
Associate editor
Mark Rayner
Editorial assistant
Craig Edwards
Archive contributor
Peggie Rimmer
Astrowatch contributor
Merlin Kole
Tom LeCompte
Brookhaven National Laboratory Achim Franz Cornell University
D G Cassel
DESY Laboratory
Till Mundzeck
Published by CERN, 1211
Geneva 23, Switzerland
Tel +41 (0) 22 767 61 11
Produced for CERN by IOP Publishing Ltd
Temple Circus, Temple
Way, Bristol BS1 6HG, UK Tel +44 (0)117 929 7481
Fermilab Kurt
Riesselmann
Printed by Warners
(Midlands) plc, Bourne, Lincolnshire, UK
Forschungszentrum Jülich Markus Buescher GSI Darmstadt I Peter IHEP, Beijing Lijun Guo IHEP, Serpukhov
Yu Ryabov
Advertising
- Advisory board
- Orsay Laboratory
Anne-Marie Lutz
PSI Laboratory P-R Kettle Saclay Laboratory
Elisabeth Locci
Head of Media Jo Allen Head of Media Business Development
Ed Jost
Content and production manager Ruth Leopold
Tel +44 (0)117 930 1026 (for UK/Europe display advertising) or +44 (0)117 930 1164 (for recruitment
advertising); e-mail [email protected]
Peter Jenni, Christine Sutton, Claude Amsler, Philippe Bloch, Roger
Forty, Mike Lamont, Joachim Kopp
2021 CERN
©
ISSN 0304-288X
- INFN Antonella Varaschin
- UK STFC Jane Binks
SWISS OFFICIAL DISTRIBUTOR OF EDWARDS
Jambe-Ducommun 19 | 2400 Le Locle | CH
+41 32 926 26 06 | [email protected] www.plasmadiam.com
CERN COURIER MARCH/APRIL 2021
5
V o l u m e 6 1 N u m b e r 2 m a r c h / a p r i l 2 0 2 1
CERNCOURIER.COM
NEWS
ANALYSIS
AntimAtter
FOR
AEgISontracktotestfreefallofantimatter
PROFESSIONALS
- The AEgIS collaboration at CERN’s
- schemeallowsthetimeatwhich90%of
theatomsareproducedtobedetermined with an uncertainty of around 100 ns. Further steps are required before the measurement of g can begin, explains Doser. These include the formation of a pulsed beam, greater quantities of antihydrogen, and the ability to make it colder. “Withonlythreemonthsofbeam timethisyear,andlotsofnewequipment to commission, most likely 2022 will be the year in which we establish pulsedbeam formation, which is a prerequisite forustoperformagravitymeasurement.”
AntiprotonDecelerator(AD)hasreported a milestone in its bid to measure the gravitational free fall of antimatter – a fundamentaltestoftheweakequivalence principle. Using a series of techniques developed in 2018, the team demon-
strated the first pulsed production of
antiatoms, which allows the time at which the antiatoms are formed to be knownwithhighaccuracy. Thisisakey step in determining “g” for antimatter.
“This is the first time that pulsed for-
mation of antihydrogen has been established on timescales that open the door tosimultaneousmanipulation, bylasers
Targeted approach
or external fields, of the formed atoms,
as well as to the possibility of applying thesamemethodtothepulsedformation ofotherantiprotonicatoms,”saysAEgIS spokesperson Michael Doser of CERN. “Knowing the moment of antihydrogen formation is a powerful tool.” Generalrelativity’sweakequivalence
Followingaproof-of-principlemeasurementofgforantihydrogenbytheALPHA collaborationin2013, ALPHA, AEgISand a third AD experiment, GBAR, are all targeting a measurement of g at the 1% level in the coming years. In contrast to AEgIS’s approach, whereby the vertical deviation of a pulsed horizontal beam of coldantihydrogenatomswillbemeasured