DOCSLIB.ORG

Fat Activism: a Queer Autoethnography

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Fat Activism: a Queer Autoethnography Fat Activism: A Queer Autoethnography Charlotte Rachel Mary Cooper BA(Hons) PGCert PGDip MA MBACP PhD University of Limerick Supervisor: Dr Lee F. Monaghan Submitted to the University of Limerick, December 2012 2 Table of contents ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................................................. 5 DECLARATION ...................................................................................................................................... 7 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ........................................................................................................................ 9 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................................... 11 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 13 SIMPLICITY, COMPLEXITY AND THE KILLJOY ................................................................................................... 15 WHY THIS STUDY MATTERS ............................................................................................................................... 20 STRUCTURE OF THE THESIS ................................................................................................................................ 21 CHAPTER TWO: FAT ACTIVIST LITERATURE .......................................................................... 25 GO CHUB CRAZY WITH THE CHUBSTERS! ...................................................................................................... 25 EXPLANATORY LITERATURE .............................................................................................................................. 28 Popular fat activism ...................................................................................................................................... 28 Fragmented fat activism ............................................................................................................................. 31 Feminist proxies for fat activism .............................................................................................................. 32 Disengaged fat activism ............................................................................................................................... 35 CRITICAL LITERATURE ........................................................................................................................................ 39 Marginalised fat activism ........................................................................................................................... 40 The threat of fat activism ............................................................................................................................ 43 Using obesity to explain fat activism ...................................................................................................... 44 Fat activism that fails ................................................................................................................................... 47 LOCATING THE THESIS ........................................................................................................................................ 51 What is fat activism? ..................................................................................................................................... 52 Where is my fat activism discursively located? ................................................................................. 54 How can fat activism be theorised productively? ............................................................................. 56 CONCLUSION: MY CONTRIBUTION TO THE LITERATURE ............................................................................... 62 CHAPTER THREE: FAT ACTIVIST METHODOLOGY ................................................................ 65 CONTEXTUALISING FAT ACTIVIST RESEARCH ................................................................................................. 66 Researching obesity ....................................................................................................................................... 66 Who is allowed to know about fat? ......................................................................................................... 67 Research justice ............................................................................................................................................... 69 REFLEXIVITY AND ACCOUNTABILITY ................................................................................................................ 71 Who am I to do this work? .......................................................................................................................... 71 Why who I am matters ................................................................................................................................. 73 CUSTOMISING QUALITATIVE METHODOLOGY .................................................................................................. 75 Critical ethnography ..................................................................................................................................... 75 Autoethnography ............................................................................................................................................ 77 Queering and scavenging autoethnography ...................................................................................... 81 THE FIELD ............................................................................................................................................................. 82 The archive as autoethnographic field ................................................................................................. 83 DOING QUEERED AND SCAVENGED AUTOETHNOGRAPHY ............................................................................. 85 Being an activist .............................................................................................................................................. 86 Generating data .............................................................................................................................................. 88 Access ............................................................................................................................................................................................... 90 Sampling ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 91 Interviewing .................................................................................................................................................................................. 93 Data analysis ................................................................................................................................................................................. 95 Ethics and Quality .......................................................................................................................................... 95 Methodological limitations ........................................................................................................................ 96 CONCLUSION: RESEARCH ACTIVISM .................................................................................................................. 98 3 CHAPTER FOUR: WHAT IS FAT ACTIVISM? ............................................................................ 101 POLITICAL PROCESS .......................................................................................................................................... 103 Defining ............................................................................................................................................................ 103 The appeal of political process .............................................................................................................. 105 Limitations ..................................................................................................................................................... 107 ACTIVIST COMMUNITIES AND CULTURES ...................................................................................................... 112 What is community? ................................................................................................................................... 112 Community-building and capital .......................................................................................................... 113 Using community to generate cultural capital ............................................................................... 119 Existing cultural forMs .......................................................................................................................................................... 119 New cultural forMs ................................................................................................................................................................. 123 MICRO FAT ACTIVISM ........................................................................................................................................ 126 AMBIGUOUS FAT ACTIVISM .............................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sasquan Convention Guide
    Sasquan Convention Guide The 73rd World Science Fiction Convention Spokane, Washington, USA, Earth • August 19–23, 2015 See inside back cover for Doubletree map. CONTENTS 1 Sasquan The 73rd World Science Fiction Convention Spokane, Washington, USA, Earth • August 19-23, 2015 2 ...................... Quick Reference 27 ......................... Wednesday 39 ...........................Thursday 67 ............................. Friday 96 ........................... Saturday 124 ...........................Sunday 136 ...............Participant Schedules Credits: Chair: Sally Woehrle Program Division Head: Laurie Mann Convention Guide Editor: Paul Selkirk Proofreader: Kaye Tornbrugh Content Organizers: Phyllis Eide, Laurie Mann Cover: Brad W. Foster “World Science Fiction Society,” “WSFS,” “World Science Fiction Convention,” “Worldcon,” “NASFiC,” “Hugo Award,” and the distinctive design of the Hugo Award rocket are service marks of the World Science Fiction Society, an unin- corporated literary society. 2 QUICK REFERENCE Greetings from the Chair Greetings and Welcome to Sasquan! All the staff and I are happy that you have made the trek to beautiful Spokane. We are working on making this an experience that you will remember for years. Inside this book is most everything that you need to know about Sas- quan. Tere are policies so that you know what is expected. Tere are lists of where everything in the Convention Center and Hotels are located. By everything I mean items such as: t Where are the Exhibits and specific exhibits? t Where is the Art Show, Dealers Room, Programming Rooms, and the Office? t Where and when are certain Events? t What are the hours of operation for all of these places? So please take a few minutes to look through this book. Ten go out and have a wonderful exciting and informative time.
    [Show full text]
  • AIDS/ART/WORK Conference at CLAGS, CUNY, New York City
    The Newsletter of the Queer Caucus for Art Vol. 21, No. 1 January 2009 The Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender Caucus for Art, Artists & Historians AIDS/ART/WORK the Graduate Center of CUNY (CLAGS), Visual AIDS, and the Australian Conference at CLAGS, Research Council. The short synopsis CUNY, New York City, above does no justice to the value of the conference. I would personally like to May 30, 2008 thank the conference sponsors for a day The AIDS/ART/WORK conference that was not only informative, but well held Friday, May 30, brought together organized (plus the food was good!). a distinguished group of pro fessionals The important work of AIDS awareness from the art world, queer world, and and prevention, much of which has been AIDS activist/prevention world. a result of AIDS art, must go on. The first session presented a historical Larry Schulte, NYC artist overview of AIDS, including art that was made in response to the AIDS crises. As Tee A. Corinne Exhibition one who lived in NYC in the 80s, the history was not only thoroughly presented, and Celebration at but was also a moving remembrance of University of Oregon “Beverly”, 2006, SCARS Project, © Tee Corinne those years. There is a Tee Corinne Exhibition/ Papers, University of Oregon Libraries The second session dealt with art and Celebration at the University of Oregon University faculty and graduate students activism in the age of AIDS ranging Libraries in Eugene! I know she would and others on the topic of lesbian culture from militant art to art that expresses have been profoundly happy about the and representation.
    [Show full text]
  • Fogcon 9 Program
    FOGcon 9 Welcome to FOGcon 9!...........................................................................................2 Convention Committee...........................................................................................2 Honored Guest Becky Chambers..............................................................................3 Becky Chambers: Space Is a Place for Everybody...............................................................................................3 The Wayfarers Trilogy........................................................................................................................................4 Honored Guest Karen Joy Fowler.............................................................................5 Wonderful Person Writing Wonderful Books......................................................................................................5 Honored Ghost Ursula K. Le Guin.............................................................................6 Hotel...................................................................................................................8 Registration..........................................................................................................8 Consuite..............................................................................................................8 Dealers’ Room......................................................................................................8 Game Room.........................................................................................................8
    [Show full text]
  • Obesity Epidemic’
    Art & Activism in the Age of the ‘Obesity Epidemic’ by Pamela Grombacher A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in HISTORY OF ART, DESIGN AND VISUAL CULTURE Department of Art and Design University of Alberta © Pamela Grombacher, 2014 Abstract This thesis considers three contemporary artworks that open up new possibilities for size acceptance activism, a political movement that arose in the late 1960s to combat fat stigma and weight-based discrimination. Fatness is vilified in many parts of the world as an unhealthy, unattractive, and, most significantly, immoral embodiment. This is due, in part, to “healthism,” or the moralization of health, and to the perceived controllability of body size. In cultures where health is viewed as a moral obligation and size is viewed as a personal choice, fat people are discriminated against for supposedly choosing to be unhealthy. Fat stigma has worsened in the wake of the “obesity epidemic,” the alarmist rhetoric of which frames fatness as a lurking and deadly contagion that threatens to destroy public health. There are those within the size acceptance movement, however, who question the legitimacy of this “epidemic” as a true health crisis and suggest that it is instead a moral panic that reflects cultural anxieties about personal accountability. As politicians, medical practitioners and diet industrialists wage a “War on Obesity” to eradicate fatness and thus rid society of this alleged scourge, size acceptance activists resist weight-based discrimination by arguing that stigma, rather than fat, is the true enemy to be conquered. I suggest new possibilities for resistance by analyzing artworks that subvert hegemonic notions of fat in novel and nuanced ways.
    [Show full text]
  • Renewing Our Mission in New Orleans Innovative Interfaces Cover 3
    OPRAH WINFREY Bookwoman n FACEBOOK Fanning Friendships n 2015 ALA Strategic Plan May/JuNE 2011 THE MAGAZINE OF THE AMERICAN LIBRARY ASSOCIATION PLUS n Inspiring Library Advocacy n Creating Communities of Learning n The Best in Library Branding Renewing Our Mission in New Orleans Innovative Interfaces cover 3 FREEDOM IMAGINE WHAT YOU ALWAYS WANTED YOUR LIBRARY TO BE Introducing the Sierra Services Platform ALA 2011 Annual Conference, Booth #2234 www.iii.com Untitled-5 1 5/9/2011 2:47:02 PM CONTENTS A m e r i c A n L i b r A r i e s | m ay/June 2011 Features 47 38 Reading fOR Life: OpRah WinfRey The television talk-show host and media mogul has championed books and libraries By Leonard KniffeL facebOOk fOR LibRaRies 42 it’s easy to use social media’s most popular tool to connect with your community By david Lee King 46 LibRaRy advOcacy: One Message, One vOice Lessons from the 1991 rally for America’s Libraries By richard M. dougherty 56 pROfessiOnaL gROWth 56 thROugh LeaRning cOMMunities Knowledge comes with teamwork and fun— all across the organization By PauL SignoreLLi and Lori reed the best in LibRaRy bRanding 74 Winners of the 2011 John cotton Dana Library Public relations Award wow judges and their communities By Judith giBBonS 70 nOpL’s children’s cOveR stORies Resource center, before (on cover) ReneWing OuR MissiOn and after (left) 60 renovations. in neW ORLeans new combined opening session/exhibits kickoff, cover design by an extended film series, and a host of authors and taína Lagodzinski; speakers are on tap for 135th Annual conference photos provided By PaMeLa a.
    [Show full text]
  • Alanis Obomsawin 2020 Glenn Gould Prize Laureate
    PRICELESS Vol 26 No 3 Alanis Obomsawin 2020 Glenn Gould Prize Laureate NOVEMBER 2020 Concerts, live & livestreamed Record reviews & Listening Room Stories and interviews 2603_Features_new.indd 1 2020-10-28 6:17 PM FOR WHAT IT’S WORTH • CIRC – keep up with reopenings, welcome new partners • SUBS CAMPAIGN – give (someone/yourself) the gift! • BACK ISSUES (ESP. LAST 4) – ask and ye shall receive • STILL IN PRINT!!!! – pass the word, PLEASE. • BUT MORE THAN PRINT – flip-through, HalfTones, blog, web, tweet, like, share • WEEKLY LISTINGS UPDATES – so keep sending them in!! • WE’RE WholeNote media 2603_Features_new.indd 2 2020-10-28 7:17 PM Volume 26 No 3 | November 2020 This picture of Alanis Obomsawin was taken in her office, at ON OUR COVER the National Film Board’s Montreal headquarters on Le Chemin PRICELESS de la Côte-de Liesse, just before they moved to Îlot Balmoral last Vol 26 No 3 summer. Having had the opportunity of working on a three-year project at the National Film Board of Canada, I had the chance to witness Alanis Obomsawin’s presence on an almost daily basis. If you would be passing by her office door you would witness a monumental intellect tirelessly rewriting our history for a better future for all. Unwavering from sunrise till sunset, she humbled ACD2 2736 us all. She is a true architect of change, winning her battles through the mind and heart, with more than fifty films in fifty years. — Stéphan Ballard Alanis Obomsawin “My office holds 50 years of archives, images, and text. I’m 2020 Glenn Gould Prize Laureate now finishing my 53rd film, so you can just imagine the number NOVEMBER 2020 Concerts, live & livestreamed Record reviews & Listening Room Stories and interviews of documents.
    [Show full text]
  • Takarazuka (All-Female Revues in Japan) by Laurie Toby Edison
    Takarazuka (All-Female Revues in Japan) by Laurie Toby Edison Encyclopedia Copyright © 2015, glbtq, Inc. Entry Copyright © 2002, glbtq, Inc. Takarazuka performers Reprinted from http://www.glbtq.com in 1936. During the twentieth century in Japan, Takarazuka, all-female musical and theater companies in which women play all roles, have thrived; and actresses playing males have generated large female fan clubs. The revues are elaborately costumed, flamboyant, and extravagant in execution. These commercially successful and mainstream theatrical enterprises generally present plays with safe, middle-of-the-road topics. During World War II, for example, the productions emphasized patriotic themes and the liberation of other Asians from European exploitation. Despite the mainstream subjects of Takarazuka, the revues have nonetheless spawned fringe activities that are gender-transgressive and that tellingly illustrate the construction and deconstruction of gender roles. It is important not to put a Euro-American imprint on Takarazuka. This is a Japanese theater in a Japanese context. It does not map well onto Euro-American concepts of desire, gender, and sexuality. Theater in Japan became mono-sexual in 1629, when the Tokugawa regime banned women (and later boys) from Kabuki. Men playing women (onnagata) in Kabuki are said to "embody" the ideal of femininity, while women playing men (otokoyaku) in Takarazuka only "represent" masculinity. The oldest and most successful of the all women groups is the Takarazuka Revue, founded in a hot-springs resort near Osaka in 1913 by Kobayashi Ichizo (1873-1957), a male industrialist, impresario, and politician. He called it "New Citizens' Theater" in contrast to the old and elitist Kabuki.
    [Show full text]
  • September 2002 CAA News
    NEWS NEWSLETTER OF THE COLLEGE ART ASSOCIATION Volume 27, Number 6 OCTOBER 2002 PHOTO CREDIT:JULIE GRABER/THE NEW MEXICAN Diane Karp, director of the Sante Fe Art Institute, created the Emergency Residency Relief Program NATIONAL STUDY OF ONE RESPONSE TO ART-HISTORY CAREER PATHS SEPTEMBER 11 Was the Ph.D. Worth the Effort? n September 11, 2001, Diane Karp, publisher of the art jour- nal New Observations, was driv- 4% 1% Oing to New Mexico to assume her new 1% 2% position as director of the Santa Fe Art 20% 14% Institute when she heard the catastrophic news about two planes crashing into the Women Men World Trade Center in New York. Soon after arriving at her new post, she 75% 83% responded by initiating the Emergency Residency Relief Program at the Art Institute, which provided living space and studios to artists in New York Definitely Probably Probably not Definitely not whose lives had been deeply affected by the devastation. According to Karp, Source: “Ph.D.s in Art History—Over a Decade Later,” study, University of California, Berkeley, and CIRGE, June 2002 “There was a crying need for these artists not only to have a place to work, ore than ten years after completing their doctorates, roughly three-quarters of the but also to find some emotional refuge.” respondents to a survey of art-history Ph.D. holders said the degree was “defi- She gathered conceptual and financial nitely” worth the effort. However, fewer women (75 percent) said that the art- support for her project from her depart- Mhistory Ph.D.
    [Show full text]
  • Fat Medicine
    Size Matters: Imagery of the Fat Female Body in the Art of Lucian Freud, Jenny Saville, Joel-Peter Witkin, Laurie Toby Edison, Leonard Nimoy, and Laura Aguilar By Brittany Lockard Submitted to the graduate degree program in Art History and the Graduate Faculty of the University of Kansas in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. ________________________________ Chairperson David Cateforis, Ph.D. ________________________________ Marni Kessler, Ph.D. ________________________________ Charles Eldredge, Ph.D. ________________________________ Marta Vicente, Ph.D. ________________________________ Judith McCrea, M.F.A. Date Defended: April 10, 2012 Brittany Jean Lockard The Dissertation Committee for Brittany Lockard certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: Size Matters: Imagery of the Fat Female Body in the Art of Lucian Freud, Jenny Saville, Joel-Peter Witkin, Laurie Toby Edison, Leonard Nimoy, and Laura Aguilar ________________________________ Chairperson Dr. David Cateforis ii Abstract Since the early 1990s, a number of prominent artists have begun to produce images of the nude fat body. This dissertation looks at the works of several of those artists—Lucian Freud, Jenny Saville, Joel-Peter Witkin, Laurie Toby Edison, Leonard Nimoy, and Laura Aguilar—seeking to discover what meanings each individual artist layers onto the fat body. Asking why these artists might be interested in the fat body may seem an unnecessary question, as anxiety about fatness pervades Western culture. It is impossible to watch television, listen to the radio, or even read a magazine without being inundated by this unease; whether in the form of advertisements for various weight-loss programs and products, stories about the “obesity epidemic” facing the West, or human interest stories about life as an obese American.
    [Show full text]
  • Nexus: from Handmade to High Tech Secac 2014 October 8-11 | Sarasota, Florida Nexus: from Handmade to High Tech
    NEXUS: FROM HANDMADE TO HIGH TECH SECAC 2014 OCTOBER 8-11 | SARASOTA, FLORIDA NEXUS: FROM HANDMADE TO HIGH TECH From Etsy to Apple, letterpress to Wordpress, Guttenberg to Adobe, Patrick Dougherty to James Turrell, handmade possibilities across disciplines. SECAC 2014 explores this contemporary art and design. NEXUS: Handmade to High Tech years to come. CONTENTS 2 MAP OF HYATT 2-8 DAY AT-A-GLANCE 9 MAP OF RINGLING COLLEGE 10-11 WELCOME 12-13 SECAC GOVERNANCE | AFFILIATIONS 14 JURIED SHOW 15 KEYNOTE 16-23 SESSION PROGRAMS 26 SARASOTA TOURS 27-28 EAT | GO | DO 29 MAP OF SARASOTA HYATT CONVENTION CENTER CONVENTION CENTER 1 2 10 11 3 6 5 8 9 4 7 LOWER LOBBY LEVEL MAIN LOBBY LEVEL 13 14 12 KEY 21 1. SALON A 12. CURRENTS 15 16 17 18 2. SALON B RESTAURANT & BAR 3. SALON C 13. TROPICS A 20 19 4. SALON D 14. TROPICS B 5. SALON E 15. CASEY 6. SALON F 16. SIESTA 7. REGISTRATION 17. LIDO 8. PALM ROOM 18. LONGBOAT 9. BOARDROOM 19. THE KEYS 10. PALM TERRACE 20. LIBRARY 11. POOL 21. FRONT DESK WEDNESDAY,, OCTOBER 8TH 1:00-3:00 pm Executive Committee Meeting Hyatt: Boardroom, lower lobby level 4:00-7:00 pm SECAC Board of Directors Meeting Hyatt: The Keys, lower lobby level 7:00-9:00 pm Welcome Reception Hyatt: Poolside/Palm Terrace, lower lobby level Hyatt: Ballroom North Pre-function Area, 7:00-9:00 pm Registration and Online registration pick up convention center 2 THURSDAY, OCTOBER 9TH Stop. Collaborate & Listen? Hyatt: Longboat Key/Lido Key, main lobby level Chair: Valarie Powell, Sam Houston State University Open Session: Collaboration (Big Ideas) Hyatt: Salon D, convention center Chair: Naomi Falk, St.
    [Show full text]
  • Edison, Laurie Toby (B
    Edison, Laurie Toby (b. 1942) by Tee A. Corinne Encyclopedia Copyright © 2015, glbtq, Inc. Entry Copyright © 2002, glbtq, Inc. Reprinted from http://www.glbtq.com A photograph of Laurie Toby Edison by Carol Laurie Toby Edison is best known for three collections of photographic work featuring, Squires. Courtesy Laurie Toby respectively, fat nude women, nude men, and women in Japan. Each collection is Edison. characterized by the diversity of individuals pictured. Identifying as a bisexual, she has been active with queer activist organizations, including Queer Nation, and queer history groups. Born on March 5, 1942 into an upper-middle-class Jewish family in New York City, she grew up in Manhattan and Queens. During her childhood, her father was a businessman, her mother a dress designer, and her grandmother a Greenwich Village jeweler. Edison grew up among people who had concentration camp numbers tattooed on their arms and remembers being deeply affected by newspaper and magazine photographs of the piled-up naked bodies of Holocaust dead. In her teens, Edison was influenced by her involvement in the beat world in New York City, by Abstract Expressionist art, and by jazz music. She attended Wellesley college for one year (1958-1959). Edison married twice and has a daughter from each marriage. During the 1960s, Edison co-owned The Waverly Shops in Provincetown and Sarasota, selling hand-crafted jewelry. Since 1969, she has concentrated on crafting sculptural jewelry (for example, tide pools of precious stones surrounded by tiny ocean creatures). This work is especially prized by science fiction aficionados and continues to be her primary source of income.
    [Show full text]
  • Edison, Laurie Toby (B. 1942) by Tee A
    Edison, Laurie Toby (b. 1942) by Tee A. Corinne Encyclopedia Copyright © 2015, glbtq, Inc. Entry Copyright © 2002, glbtq, Inc. Reprinted from http://www.glbtq.com A photograph of Laurie Toby Edison by Carol Laurie Toby Edison is best known for three collections of photographic work featuring, Squires. Courtesy Laurie Toby respectively, fat nude women, nude men, and women in Japan. Each collection is Edison. characterized by the diversity of individuals pictured. Identifying as a bisexual, she has been active with queer activist organizations, including Queer Nation, and queer history groups. Born on March 5, 1942 into an upper-middle-class Jewish family in New York City, she grew up in Manhattan and Queens. During her childhood, her father was a businessman, her mother a dress designer, and her grandmother a Greenwich Village jeweler. Edison grew up among people who had concentration camp numbers tattooed on their arms and remembers being deeply affected by newspaper and magazine photographs of the piled-up naked bodies of Holocaust dead. In her teens, Edison was influenced by her involvement in the beat world in New York City, by Abstract Expressionist art, and by jazz music. She attended Wellesley college for one year (1958-1959). Edison married twice and has a daughter from each marriage. During the 1960s, Edison co-owned The Waverly Shops in Provincetown and Sarasota, selling hand-crafted jewelry. Since 1969, she has concentrated on crafting sculptural jewelry (for example, tide pools of precious stones surrounded by tiny ocean creatures). This work is especially prized by science fiction aficionados and continues to be her primary source of income.
    [Show full text]