Bilingual Rhotics in Two Island Communities of the Archipelago of San Andres, Colombia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
LANGUAGE CONTACT AND CONVERGING PATHS OF VARIATION: BILINGUAL RHOTICS IN TWO ISLAND COMMUNITIES OF THE ARCHIPELAGO OF SAN ANDRES, COLOMBIA By FALCON D. RESTREPO-RAMOS A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2019 © 2019 Falcon D. Restrepo-Ramos Jezu, Ufam Tobie! ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to start by thanking my dissertation committee for believing in this project and for their invaluable support throughout all stages. My mentor, Dr. Aaron, for her insightful guidance and knowleadgeable comments and suggestions, which assured the successful completion of this dissertation. I hope I can carry on your example. Dr. Gillian Lord for being a beacon of light and hope through all these years. Dr. Valdés-Kroff for always looking forward to the success of this work. Your guidance will have a lasting impact on my career. Dr. Essegbey for being a voice of reason and being readily available for help. It goes without saying that I am greatly indebted to all the spectacular faculty, staff, and colleagues at the Department of Spanish and Portugues Studies for all their support and consideration. Five years ago, I arrived at the University of Florida with many dreams and barely enough to support myself, but I was welcomed with a smile and the opportunity to become part of the Department. It was there that I had a sense of the great things that were coming in my future. I look back and I can’t thank you enough Prof. Gillian Lord. It was in great part thanks to you that I was able to fulfill my dreams in a great place. Precisely through this academic setting, I met my lovely girlfriend, Nofiya Denbaum, whose priceless encouragement, confidence and support made these years even more wonderful. Those Thanksgivings with you and your family gave me the warmest memories throughout these years. Thanks for opening the doors of your house and heart. I also appreciate the help that I received from external faculty. Dr. Stefanie Wulff, for always being available to discuss how to improve the project. Dr. Aaron Broadwell for advising my own fieldwork. Dr. Andrew Lotto, who introduced me to phonetic analyses that were new to me. I would also like to thank the Center for Latin American studies for partially funding this project through a Tinker Foundation grant. Finally, I want to recognize the marvelous people of 4 the Archipelago of San Andres for whom this work has been done. I hope this project benefits these communities and that more scholars carry on what I and many others have started. Last but not least, my family and friends for their love, friendship and prayers. 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ...............................................................................................................4 LIST OF TABLES ...........................................................................................................................8 LIST OF FIGURES .......................................................................................................................12 ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................................16 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................18 1.1 Historical and Sociolinguistic Background ...................................................................18 1.1.1 The Archipelago Of San Andres Between 1618-1810 .......................................20 1.1.2 The Archipelago Of San Andres Between 1810 And 1886 ................................21 1.1.3 The Archipelago Of San Andres Between 1886 And The Present .....................22 1.1.4 The Past And Present Of Islander Creole ...........................................................28 1.2 The Current Study .........................................................................................................36 1.2.1 Identification Of The Linguistic Varieties Under Study .....................................37 1.2.2 Studying Sound Variation And Change In This Contact Scenario: Rhotics ......38 2 REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE ........................................................................................41 2.1 Language Contact and the Comparative Method in the Archipelago ...........................42 2.2 Rhotic Variation In Monolingual And Bilingual Settings ............................................53 2.2.1 Variable Production Of Rhotics In Contact Situations: How To Account For The Articulation And Distribution Of Non-Vibrant Rhotics In The Archipelago Of San Andres .........................................................................................59 2.2.2 Enhancing Our Understanding Of Contact Phonologies In Spanish Vibrant Rhotics .........................................................................................................................64 2.3 Summary .......................................................................................................................68 3 METHODOLOGY .................................................................................................................69 3.1 Data Collection..............................................................................................................69 3.1.1 Participants ..........................................................................................................70 3.1.2 Data Elicitation Tasks .........................................................................................71 3.2 Data Analysis ................................................................................................................72 3.2.1 Preparation Of The Datasets For The Speech Analysis ......................................72 3.2.2 Phonetic Analysis................................................................................................73 3.2.3 Variable Rule Analysis .......................................................................................74 3.2.4 Envelope Of Variation ........................................................................................75 3.2.5 Coding Of The Sociolinguistic Data ...................................................................80 4 A SOCIOPHONETIC ANALYSIS OF NON-VIBRANT RHOTICS IN THE ARCHIPELAGO OF SAN ANDRES ....................................................................................83 6 4.1 Acoustic Properties of the Non-Vibrant Rhotics in the Varieties of the Archipelago .........................................................................................................................86 4.1.1 The Non-Vibrant Rhotics In The Archipelago ...................................................88 4.1.2 Spectral Moments In The Non-Vibrant Rhotics Of The Archipelago ................89 4.1.3 Formant Frequencies In The Rhotics Of The Archipelago .................................94 4.1.4 Segmental Duration In The Rhotics Of The Archipelago ..................................98 4.1.4.1 A comparison of segmental duration in the rhotics of the Archipelago ...98 4.1.4.2 A comparison of segmental duration in non-vibrant taps and trills between Raizal and Continental Spanish ............................................................105 4.2 Discriminant Function Analysis ..................................................................................114 4.3 Correlation Analysis Between Generations Of Raizal Spanish And Continental Spanish/Raizal Creole. ......................................................................................................122 5 COMPARATIVE VARIATIONIST ANALYSIS OF RHOTIC VARIATION IN THE ARCHIPELAGO OF SAN ANDRES ..................................................................................140 5.1 Distribution Of Rhotic Variants ..................................................................................142 5.1.1 Distribution Of Rhotic Variants In Raizal Spanish...........................................143 5.1.2 Distribution Of Rhotic Variants In Continental Spanish ..................................147 5.2 Variable Rule Analysis ...............................................................................................150 5.2.1 Preparation Of The Datasets .............................................................................150 5.2.2 First Generation ................................................................................................155 5.2.2 Second Generation ............................................................................................166 5.2.3 Third Generation ...............................................................................................175 5.2.4 Continental Spanish ..........................................................................................185 5.3 A Tale Of Distant Stories: Bilingual Raizal Spanish And Monolingual Continental Spanish Compared ............................................................................................................198 6 DISCUSSION .......................................................................................................................209 6.1 Variation And Change In Non-Vibrant Rhotic Production.........................................209 6.2 Variation And Change In Vibrant Tap And Trill Production .....................................217 7 CONCLUSION.....................................................................................................................223