Powering ’s Economy with Offshore Wind

1 The Foundation - NorTech - Cleveland - Ashtabula - Lake - Lorain - Cuyahoga US Electric Power Sources

2 Regional Jobs

Public/Private Offshore Epicenter

Private Investment 20 MW Pilot Project

Turbine Supplier “Freshwater Wind” Research Partners Strategic Advisors

GREAT LAKES DEVELOPMENT TASK FORCE A Cuyahoga County Initiative

Timeline

Task Force proposes offshore wind as a Geotechnical, 1000 MW in regional economic fisheries, historic LEEDCo is formed preservation, & Cleveland Foundation development engine, as the vehicle to permitting analysis, Ohio becomes funds anemometer on calling for a advance Ohio’s power purchase hub for a Great the water intake crib Feasibility Analysis. offshore wind agreement. Lakes offshore offshore Cleveland. energy initiative. wind industry.

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2020

Feasibility Analysis is GE selected as Commence Cleveland Foundation completed, confirming turbine supplier construction on 20 environmental and MW wind project. vision for an Ohio Cuyahoga County technical viability of /GLWE/Cavallo driven Lake Erie forms Great Lakes offshore wind in selected as developer offshore wind to Lake Erie. industry. promote advanced Economic Impact Study energy in Ohio. by Kleinhenz Associates Avian Radar/Bat Survey Cleveland Foundation funds the Great Lakes Geophysical Survey Science Center Wind Turbine Basic Fisheries Survey Shipwreck Survey 4 Mission

Beyond generating power, LEEDCo seeks to maximize Ohio’s offshore wind energy potential by capturing the emerging Great Lakes industry – dubbing Ohio as the epicenter.

Vision: 2013 – 20 MW 2020 – 1000 MW 2030 – 5000 MW

5 Mission

Nuclear - 1957

$0.50 12,000 $0.45 11,000 10,000 $0.40 9,000 $0.35 8,000 5000 MW $0.30 7,000 $0.25 20 MW 6,000 $0.20 5,000 4,000 $0.15 5000 MW 3,000 $0.10 Lower 2,000 $0.05 1,000 20 MW $0.00 Costs 0 Cost/kWh Lake Erie 68,000 MW Capacity Great Lakes 250,000 MW 6 Ohio & Wind Energy History

• Charles F. Brush • Born in Euclid, Ohio • 1887 - world's first wind-powered electric generator in Cleveland. • 144 blades, 50-ft. Rotor = 12 kilowatts • Brush’s company eventually became GE.

• NASA • Located in Brook Park, Ohio • Led U.S. Wind Energy Program between 1974-1980 • Turbine development paved the way today • Program eventually divested.

Question: “Where did Ohio’s turbines go?” 3.2 MW turbine in Hawaii Learning Curve vs. Economic Urgency

Europe: Asia: • 3,185 MW in operation •$30 BB Investment in Wind

• $100 BB planned •Using European experience & • Manufacturing is growing dramatically driving costs down • Ports revitalized/Jobs created Competitive Landscape

The Right Mix To Develop First Select Great Lakes Projects* MI – Scandia Wind – 150 MW NY – NYPA – 100-500 MW WI – Aquilo Wind – 50 MW Very A Good Mix IL – Evanston – 200 MW Deep OH – LEEDCo/Freshwater Wind – 20 MW Water Low Energy OH – LEEDCo/Freshwater Wind – 1,000 MW Prices Select East Coast Projects* MA – Hull - 15 MW MA – Cape Wind – 468 MW RI – Deepwater Wind/Block Island – 30 MW Low Energy Prices RI – Deepwater Wind/RI Sound – 385 MW Low Wind Resources NY – Con Ed/LIPA – 350/700 MW NJ – Fishermens Energy Atlantic City – 20 MW High Hurricane Risk NJ – Fishermens Energy Federal Waters – 350 MW NJ – Garden State Offshore Energy – 350 MW What does this mean for Ohio? NJ – NRG Bluewater Wind – 350 MW • Sputnik moment… DE – NRG Bluewater Wind – 300-450 MW VA – APEX Wind – 1,200 MW • Ready or not: Offshore wind industry is coming VA – Seawind Renewable Energy – 1,000 MW • Urgency: Race is on to capture economic benefits • Utilize momentum to be first in the water Ohio Currently…

 Ohio a leader onshore  7,500 wind manufacturing jobs  World Class Manufacturing Strengths

10 …But There’s More in Offshore

11 Ohio Ports to Dominate

Lake Erie Activity • - 4,500 MW o 1500 Turbines

• - 500 MW o 150 Turbines

• PA - 1000 MW o 300 Turbines

• 50% Canadian content = Ohio component/job exports • LEEDCo as a model

12 Scale of Deployment

• Revitalize Ohio’s Ports/Shipyards • Initial fabrication & staging to be in Cleveland or Lorain. • Commercial scale projects could utilize most ports. Initial Project:

• Big enough to capture attention

• Small enough to do fast and position Ohio as first

• Small enough to limit rate impact

• Target dates:  Iconic  Begin 2012  7 Miles offshore  COD late 2013  5-8 turbines producing 20-30 MW 20 MW Catalyst… Industry to coalesce where 1st projects are built. Claim stake • Demonstrate • Capture new investment • Supply Chain

Jobs • Manufacturing, construction, installation, maintenance, research, and innovation.

Infrastructure • Ports, Shipbuilding, Grid-System 15 Join us….

Sign up for monthly e-newsletter!

www.LEEDCo.or g Contact: Donny Davis [email protected] (216) 965-0612 www.leedco.org