Chemoorganotrophic Bacteria Isolated from Biodeteriorated Surfaces in Cave and Catacombs Filomena De Leo1, Agnese Iero1, Gabrielle Zammit2, and Clara E
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
International Journal of Speleology 41(2) 125-136 Tampa, FL (USA) July 2012 Available online at scholarcommons.usf.edu/ijs/ & www.ijs.speleo.it International Journal of Speleology Official Journal of Union Internationale de Spéléologie Chemoorganotrophic bacteria isolated from biodeteriorated surfaces in cave and catacombs Filomena De Leo1, Agnese Iero1, Gabrielle Zammit2, and Clara E. Urzì1 Abstract: De Leo F., Iero A., Zammit G. and Urzì C. 2012. Chemoorganotrophic bacteria isolated from biodeteriorated surfaces in cave and catacombs. International Journal of Speleology, 41(2), 125-136 Tampa, FL (USA). ISSN 0392-6672. http://dx.doi.org/10.5038/1827-806X.41.2.1 The main objective of this work was the comparative analysis of a large number of bacterial strains isolated from biodeteriorated surfaces in three different sites, namely the catacombs of St. Callistus in Rome, Italy, the catacombs dedicated to St. Agatha in Ra- bat, Malta and the Cave of Bats in Zuheros, Spain. Our results showed that even considering only culturable chemoorganotrophic bacteria the variability is very high, reflecting the great variety of microhabitats present. Hence any strategies to prevent, control or eliminate the biofilm-embedded microbiota from an archeological surface should take into account a number of considerations as stipulated in our study. Keywords: biofilm; catacombs; caves; chemoorganotrophic bacteria; clustering; 16S rDNA sequencing Received 20 October 2011; Revised 2 January 2012; Accepted 10 January 2012 in most cases, strains that grow in culture can prove INTRODUCTION to be metabolically active microorganisms, if the en- Any study of microbial communities colonizing bi- vironment provides the required conditions. This is odeteriorated surfaces should involve a combination particularly true in the conservation of indoor Cultur- of several analytical techniques such as microscopy, al Heritage monuments where most of the dangerous culture techniques, biochemical tests and molecular microorganisms for the artefact itself (biodeteriogens) tools, which are designed to give complementary re- are those that grow epilithically on the surfaces; they sults. Each individual technique while having its own form a biofilm and cover areas that are the most valu- limitations, contributes the necessary information to able because are sculptured or painted. provide a better understanding of the microbial com- Very often, in fact, stone surfaces are hidden by munity as a whole and its role in the deterioration of unaesthetic colonization due to phototrophic and inorganic and/or organic substrata (Urzì et al., 2003). chemoorganotrophic biofilms (Roldán & Hernández- Culture-based techniques are selective due to the Mariné, 2009), and it is a common practice to treat limited choice of media used for the cultivation of mi- those surfaces with biocides in order to eradicate the croorganisms, and because the viable and culturable biodeteriogens present (Nugari et al., 2009). microflora (VCM) may be restricted to 1 to 5% of the However, biocides commonly applied on valuable whole population (Amann, 2000). However, the cul- surfaces are not always completely successful to erad- ture-based approach offers the possibility to isolate icate the complex community within the biofilm (Sal- and thus analyze a great number of strains (Donachie vadori & Charola, 2011). Thus it is important to study et al.,2007). It is then possible to study the isolated the culturable fraction of microorganisms in order strains, to cluster them into operational taxonomic to test in the laboratory if the chemical compounds units (OTUs), to compare different microbial commu- used are effective against the deteriogenic microflora. nities on the basis of types of cultivable bacteria iso- For this reason, when dealing with a large number lated in term of richness and the frequency of isolates, of strains, it is imperative to use a reliable and easily distribution or relative abundance of types. Further- implemented technique to group the strains into ho- more, cultivation-based techniques in association mogeneous clusters and reduce the amount of work with other complementary molecular techniques give to be carried out to characterize the isolates. a good idea of the “microorganisms in action” because, In this research study a large number of cultiva- ble bacteria isolated from three sites were analyzed 1Department of Life Sciences, “M. Malpighi” University of Messi- through a multi-step approach that included the fre-fre- na, Viale F. Stagno d’Alcontres 31, 98166 Messina, Italy;����� Cor- quency of types of colony, preliminary description of responding author: Clara Urzì ([email protected]) their micro-morphology,������������������������������� clusterization of all the iso- 2Department of Physiology and Biochemistry, University of Mal- lates via ITS-PCR, and the identification of selected ta, Biomedical Sciences Building, Msida, MSD2620, Malta. strains within each cluster. 126 Chemoorganotrophic bacteria isolated from cave and catacombs Cultural analyses MATERIAL AND METHODS For the isolation of chemoorganotrophic mi- Areas of study croorganisms samples were processed as de- Sampling campaigns were carried out in the scribed by Urzì et al. (2010). The following Ocean Cubicle (CSC13), inside the Catacombs of St. agarized media were used: BRII medium (Bunt Callistus (Rome, Italy), in the Cave of Bats (Z1 to Z8) and Rovira, 1955 modified as reported in Urzì close to the village of Zuheros (Córdoba, Southern et al., 2001), SC (Starch Casein KNO3 agar, Spain) in the frame of the research activity carried Kuster & Williams, 1964) and R2A (Reasoner and out during the European project CATS (EVK4-2000- Geldreich, 1985 Oxoid); in all media 0.05% cy- 00028), and in different areas of St. Agatha’s Crypt cloheximide was added to avoid/limit the growth and Catacombs (SA) in Rabat, Malta, during the activ- of unwanted fungal contaminants. Incubation ity carried out in the framework of a COST Action G8 was carried out at 28° C up to one month to allow scientific mission (COST-STSM-G8-1435) (Zammit et slow-growing strains. At the end of incubation al., 2009). time, enumeration of microorganisms as cfu/g In both catacombs the relative humidity (RH) was of sample was carried out and randomly chosen always above 90% while the Mediterranean climate of bacterial strains (10/20 colonies per sample) the areas did not influence the inner temperature of were isolated on Trypticase Soy Agar (TSA, Ox- the catacombs due to their deep location (range 15- oid). The bacterial isolates were maintained on 20°C) (Albertano et al., 2003; Zammit et al., 2009). TSA (Tryptone, Soy Agar) or GYM (Glucose, Yeast The Cave of Bats presented a RH variable from 95 extract, Malt extract, Agar). (inner part of the cave) to 56% (near the exit) and an Bacterial strains were preliminarily charac- average temperature between 8 and 14ºC, depending terized by their macro- and micro-morphology, on the area, at the time of sampling (Urzì et al., 2010). their Gram staining, catalase and oxidase activ- Samples were taken aseptically in correspondence to ity. The strains were then clustered on the basis alterations on rock surface described as black spots, of their ITS profiles. Randomly selected strains green patina, whitish/grey patinas with scalpel and/ belonging to the same profile were identified or adhesive tape as shown in Table 1. through 16S rDNA partial sequencing. Table 1. Samples, modality of sampling type of alteration, surface in three site studied. Presence and/or absence phototrophic organisms was also considered Type of substrate/ Presence of Sampling site Alteration type Sampling modality photototrophs Whitish/grey patina Tufa/Scalpel CSC13a, CSC13b, CSC13c N White patinas on top of CSC13i, CSC13f Fresco/Adhesive tape Y green biofilm Interface between green CSC13h Fresco/Adhesive Tape Y biofilm and white patina no apparent colonization CSC13d after 6 months from biocide Fresco/Adhesive tape Y treatment CSC13e, Dark Green biofilm Fresco/Adhesive tape Y CSC13g Black spots Tufa/Adhesive tape Y Limestone/Scalpel-Adhesive Z1a Dark grey spots Y tape Limestone/Scalpel-Adhesive Z1b Red spots Y tape Limestone/Scalpel-Adhesive Z3b, Z3c Black alteration Y tape Z2a, Z2b, Z3a, Z4a, Z4b, Z5a, Green patina Limestone/Scalpel-Adhesive Y Z5b, Z5d, Z6a, Z6b, Z7a, Z8a tape SA1, SA14, SA15, SA16, SA20 Reddish spots Limestone/Adhesive tape Y SA2, SA3, SA8, SA9, SA13, Limestone, Plaster/Adhesive Green patina Y SA17, SA18 tape Limestone/Scalpel-Adhesive SA4, SA7, SA19, SA23 Whitish/grey patina N tape SA10, SA12 Dark grey spots Plaster, Fresco/Adhesive tape Y SA6 Yellowish spots Plaster/Adhesive tape N International Journal of Speleology, 41(2), 125-136. Tampa, FL (USA). July 2012 Filomena De Leo, Agnese Iero, Gabrielle Zammit, and Clara E. Urzì 127 Plate 1. Graphic representation of distribution of bacteria isolated from St. Callistus catacombs (a, b), Cave of Bats (c, d), and St. Agatha catacombs (e, f). On the left the different classes of bacteria isolated (a, c and e); on the right are represented the different genera and the respective percentage of isolation (b, d and f). International Journal of Speleology, 41(2), 125-136. Tampa, FL (USA). July 2012 128 Chemoorganotrophic bacteria isolated from cave and catacombs Bacterial strains 180 strains were isolated and considered in this study. In particular, 59 bacterial strains were isolated from biofilm samples taken from the Ocean Cubicle (CSC13), in the St. Callistus Catacombs in Rome, Italy, 87 strains were isolated from 16 samples tak- en from the Cave of Bats in Zuheros, Spain and 34 strains were isolated from 19 samples taken from St. Agatha Crypt and Catacombs in Malta. ITS-PCR Genomic DNA was extracted from all the bacteria, as described by Rainey and co-workers (1996), after growth of the strains on TSA medium for 7 days. Amplification of ITS was carried out using the primer pair F1492 (5’AAGTCGTAACAAGGTAGCCG3’) and R188 (5’GGTACTTAGAGTTTTCAGTTC) (Gurtler & Stanisich, 1996) in a final volume of 50 µl contain- ing 2.5 U of Taq DNA polymerase (Pharmacia Biotech, Italy), 200 mM (each) deoxynucleoside triphosphates (dNTPs), 0.2 mM of each primer in 1X reaction buffer Fig.