DOCSLIB.ORG

WRAP THESIS Shuttleworth 1

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
WRAP THESIS Shuttleworth 1 University of Warwick institutional repository: http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap/4246 This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item for information to help you to cite it. Our policy information is available from the repository home page. The Poetics of Impurity: Louis MacNeice, Writing and the Thirties. Antony Shuttleworth. A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Department of English and Comparative Literary Studies University of Warwick. October 1991. Summary of Thesis. The Poetics of Impurity: Louis MacNeice, Writing and the Thirties. This thesis argues that the notion of 'impurity' may be taken as a model for paradigms in MacNeice's texts which are subjected to undercutting and transgression, by virtue of their presumed identity, their context, and by the workings of the text. This impurity challenges notions of MacNeice as an exponent of 'common-sense' empiricism. Chapter One examines notions of purity and impurity as promoted by MacNeice in the thirties. MacNeice's exposition in Modern Poetry is shown to be contradictory. Comparison with the figure of Orwell indicates that Modern Poetry, and its promotion of common-sense 'experience' or 'life', is an unreliable guide to MacNeice's thirties work. Chapter Two examines notions of 'History' in the thirties, and of MacNeice's treatment of time in a number of poems. MacNeice's poems demonstrate a conception of time-as-difference, which is shown to be historically constructed within 'static' or 'imaginary' frames of reference. These frames of reference are seen to be imperiled by historical circumstances Chapter Three analyses MacNeice's presentation of representation in, and of, society in the thirties. Attention is paid to poems dealing with problems of representation and of observation within a given social context, particularly that of consumer culture. Chapter Four examines MacNeice's examination of the subject or 'I' of the thirties. I argue that MacNeice evidences a scepticism towards the claims of the thinking, acting, subject, inhabited as it is by the dominance of text or 'writing' within history, and the indeterminacies this engenders. Chapter Five offers a reading of Autumn Journal which emphasises MacNeice's attention to the processes of the construction of 'unreliable' fictions. Rather than asserting the values of liberal humanism in the poem, it is seen to question the implications of such an act itself. The poem is shown to question the notion of the possibility of the 'honesty' of the subject which is often attributed to MacNeice. Chapter Six argues for the necessity of further re-examination of 'Louis MacNeice, writing and the thirties' and the wider implications of 'impurity'. Contents. 1. Introduction: Impurity and 1 The Thirties. 2. In Our Time: Temporality and 40 Representation in the Thirties. 3. The Look of the People: MacNeice, 81 Writing, and Society (1). 4. The Man of the People: MacNeice, 114 Writing and Society (11). 5. Everyday Writing: Impurity in 168 Autumn Journal. 6. A Poetics of Impurity: Louis MacNeice, 215 Writing, the Thirties. Bibliography 225 1 Chapter One Introduction: Impurity and the Thirties. 'My generation was brought up to regard luxury from an aesthetic standpoint. Since the War, people don't seem to feel that any more. Too often they are merely gross. They take their pleasures coarsely, *don't you find? At times, 'one feels guilty, oneself, with so much unemployment and distress everywhere'. Christopher Isherwoodl 'Oh I do hope they'll make a revolutionl' Isabel exclaimed. 'I should delight in seeing a revolution. ' 'Let me see, ' said her uncle, with humorous intention; 'I forget whether you're on the side of the old or on the side of the new. I've heard you take such opposite views. ' 'I'm on the side of both. I guess I'm a little on the side of everything. In I I be high, loyalist. One a revolution ... think should a proud sympathizes more with them, and they've a chance to behave so exquisitely. I mean so picturesquely. ' Henry JameS2 4 My friends had been writing for years about guns and frontiers and factories, about the 'facts' of psychology, politics, science, economics, but the fact of war made their writing seem as remote as the pleasure dome in Xanadu. For war spares neither the poetry of Xanadu nor the poetry of pylons... both these kinds of poetry stand or fall together. Louis MacNeice3 2 In 1938 Louis MacNeice made, a plea for impure poetry, that is, for poetry conditioned by the poet's life and the world around him'. 4. This study seeks to analyse the implications of such a declaration, its consequences for the reading of MacNeice's texts, and for the assessment of his response to the thirties. In particular, it will examine how different notions of 'impurity' can be found in, and applied to, MacNeice's work. As a consequence, it will examine how different meanings can be assigned to the notion of literature 'writing', and how this may modify our sense of, the of the thirties. ,I ---,. Perhaps the most obvious meaning which is suggested by 'a poetry conditioned by the poet's life and the world around him' is an attitude which distrusts various kinds of artifice, style or form in preference to a poetry which is in vivid contact with the real via communication or reference. This is a poetry fully informed by the importance of experience'; it is relevant, above all, to 'fife'.,, Here, 'purity'- is associated with form, its opposite with 'content' and by extension 'the world'. As we shall see, these categories of purity and impurity are not as stable as one might think or, perhaps, wish. Moreover, this association of the categories of 'purity' and 'form', 'impurity' and 'content' only complicates such categories further. In examining these various complications this study does not aim to recuperate some notion of 'purity' in the reading of MacNeice's texts. In fact it seeks the reverse, in arguing for the continuing importance of the category of 'impurity' in an understanding of MacNeice's work of the thirties. However, in making this extension I will argue for the importance of aspects of the text which might be associated with 'purity' of various kinds, which have been underrated in existing studies of MacNeice's work. This project will necessarily involve consideration of certain areas which MacNeice is often thought to have ignored or rejected. One consequence of this examination, I will argue, is the problematization of a sense of impurity as a kind of unmediated formlessness which can be easily equated with raw 'experience'. Equally, the notion of MacNeice as a writer who unequivocally embraces the role of 'ordinary-man-in-the-street', and endorses the perspective of commonsense- empiricism will be questioned. Such an identity, I will argue, significantly damages our understanding of MacNeice's involvement in the thirties. However, since it is this 3 persona which is most often associated with 'impurity' in MacNeice's work, this is the identity with which we will begin our examination. Perspectives: Writing the Thirties. Perhaps the best way of understanding the various meanings of 'impurity' is through what may be meant by 'purity' and its implications for attendant notions of 'artifice', 'style', or most productively 'form', and their opposites. Immediately, however, we run into difficulties, as the following remarks by Christopher Norris indicate: Except in the most obvious aspect - the shape of the words on the page - it is hard to attach any clear meaning to the idea of poetic 'form'. This concept may indeed be a species of enabling fiction, having more to do with the interpretative rage for order than with anything objectively be 'dialectic 'there' in the text. Or it may the product ... of a close interplay' between poem and reading, such that the poem takes on a precarious unity of form in answer to the subtle teasing-out of unifying themes and figures. Criticism would then be caught up in a process of aesthetic mystification whereby its own desire for unity and closure was ceaselessly confirmed in the act of reading. 5 To this one should add that the elusive 'idea of poetic form' is itself subject to change over literary periods. 'Form' is defined and interpreted differently, awarded different degrees of importance, placed within different conceptual oppositions, as it figures within different frameworks of reading and writing. It is, perhaps, this instability, rather than its status as 'enabling fiction' which must lead always and necessarily towards notions of 'unity', 'coherence' and 'closure', as Norris suggests, which accounts for the elusive quality of the concept. In beginning our discussion, therefore, it is necessary to consider some of the ways in which such a concept was seen to operate within the literary context of the thirties. It seems almost inevitable that among the many features of the literary text, and its production, undergoing mo dification by new British writers in the thirties were ideas about literary form. Such changes appear all the more pronounced by the attention given to this issue by the period's immediate forbears. Comparing work in the thirties with the daring innovations of modernism would indicate that thirties writers began to grant 'form' a different status in their writing, moreover that they began to think of it 4 differently, perhaps less adequately., If an important aspect of modernism was a re- examination of the possibilities adhering in the formal properties of the text, thirties writers became concerned with what seemed to lie 'outside' it.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sharpe, Tony, 1952– Editor of Compilation
    more information - www.cambridge.org/9780521196574 W. H. AUDen IN COnteXT W. H. Auden is a giant of twentieth-century English poetry whose writings demonstrate a sustained engagement with the times in which he lived. But how did the century’s shifting cultural terrain affect him and his work? Written by distinguished poets and schol- ars, these brief but authoritative essays offer a varied set of coor- dinates by which to chart Auden’s continuously evolving career, examining key aspects of his environmental, cultural, political, and creative contexts. Reaching beyond mere biography, these essays present Auden as the product of ongoing negotiations between him- self, his time, and posterity, exploring the enduring power of his poetry to unsettle and provoke. The collection will prove valuable for scholars, researchers, and students of English literature, cultural studies, and creative writing. Tony Sharpe is Senior Lecturer in English and Creative Writing at Lancaster University. He is the author of critically acclaimed books on W. H. Auden, T. S. Eliot, Vladimir Nabokov, and Wallace Stevens. His essays on modernist writing and poetry have appeared in journals such as Critical Survey and Literature and Theology, as well as in various edited collections. W. H. AUDen IN COnteXT edited by TONY SharPE Lancaster University cambridge university press Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi, Mexico City Cambridge University Press 32 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10013-2473, USA www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521196574 © Cambridge University Press 2013 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press.
    [Show full text]
  • 1. Philip Larkin
    Notes References to material held in the Philip Larkin Archive lodged in the Brynmor Jones Library, University of Hull (BJL), are given as file numbers preceded by 'DPL'. 1. PHILIP LARKIN 1. Harry Chambers, 'Meeting Philip Larkin', in Larkin at Sixty, ed. Anthony Thwaite (London: Faber and Faber, 1982) p. 62. 2. John Haffenden, Viewpoints: Poets in Conversation (London, Faber and Faber, 1981) p. 127. 3. Christopher Ricks, Beckett's Dying Words (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993). 4. D. J. Enright, 'Down Cemetery Road: the Poetry of Philip Larkin', in Conspirators and Poets (London: Chatto & Windus, 1966) p. 142. 5. Hugo Roeffaers, 'Schriven tegen de Verbeelding', Streven, vol. 47 (December 1979) pp. 209-22. 6. Andrew Motion, Philip Larkin: A Writer's Life (London: Faber and Faber, 1993). 7. Philip Larkin, Required Writing (London: Faber and Faber, 1983) p. 48. 8. See Selected Letters of Philip Larkin 1940-1985, ed. Anthony Thwaite (London: Faber and Faber, 1992) pp. 648-9. 9. DPL 2 (in BJL). 10. DPL 5 (in BJL). 11. Kingsley Amis, Memoirs (London: Hutchinson, 1991) p. 52. 12. Philip Larkin, Introduction to Jill (London: The Fortune Press, 1946; rev. edn. Faber and Faber, 1975) p. 12. 13. Donald Davie, Thomas Hardy and British Poetry (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1973) p. 64. 14. Required Writing, p. 297. 15. Blake Morrison, 'In the grip of darkness', The Times Literary Supplement, 14-20 October 1988, p. 1152. 16. Lisa Jardine, 'Saxon violence', Guardian, 8 December 1992. 17. Bryan Appleyard, 'The dreary laureate of our provincialism', Independent, 18 March 1993. 18. Ian Hamilton, 'Self's the man', The Times Literary Supplement, 2 April 1993, p.
    [Show full text]
  • 'More Than Glass': Louis Macneice's Poetics of Expansion
    THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA ‘More than glass’: Louis MacNeice’s Poetics of Expansion A DISSERTATION Submitted to the Faculty of the Department of English School of Arts & Sciences Of The Catholic University of America In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree Doctor of Philosophy © Copyright All Rights Reserved By Michael A. Moir, Jr. Washington, DC 2012 ‘More than glass’: Louis MacNeice’s Poetics of Expansion Michael A. Moir, Jr., PhD Director: Virgil Nemoianu, PhD The Northern Irish poet and dramatist Louis MacNeice, typically regarded as a minor modernist following in the footsteps of Yeats and Eliot or living in the shadow of Auden, is different from his most important predecessors and contemporaries in the way he attempts to explode conventional ideas of place, presenting human subjects in transit and shifting, melting landscapes, rooms and buildings that tend to blend in with their sur- roundings. While Yeats, Eliot and Auden evince a siege mentality that leads them to build religious or political Utopias easily separable from the chaos of the contemporary world, MacNeice denies the validity of any such imaginary constructs, instead taking apart the boundaries of imaginary private worlds, from rooms to islands to pastoral landscapes. Mac- Neice’s representations of space favor what Fredric Jameson terms ‘postmodern space’: his poems and radio plays operate outside of ideas of ‘home,’ ‘church,’ or ‘nation,’ opposing the rigidity of such places to the fluidity of travel. MacNeice has been much misunderstood and underestimated, and a reappraisal of his career is due, particularly given the amount of material that has been published or reis- sued since his centenary in 2007.
    [Show full text]
  • THE UNIVERSITY of HULL Philip Larkin's Textual Identities Being a Thesis Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in T
    THE UNIVERSITY OF HULL Philip Larkin’s Textual Identities being a Thesis submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the University of Hull by James Underwood, BA (Hons) (Dunelm), MA (Hull) September 2015 Contents List of Abbreviations 2 Introduction 3 Part I – The Letters 30 1 Introduction: Letters and Letter-Writing 31 2 James Ballard Sutton 48 3 Colin Gunner 63 4 Monica Jones 80 5 Conclusion: Will the Real Philip Larkin Please Stand Up? 102 Part II – The Brunette Coleman Heteronym 106 6 Introduction: What To Do With Brunette Coleman? 107 7 Genre 117 8 Gender 134 9 Camp 160 10 Conclusion: Why Brunette Disappears 169 Part III – The Poems 179 11 Introduction: History, Identity and Interpretation in ‘An Arundel Tomb’ 180 12 Down Cemetery Road: The Public Larkin Persona 198 13 Larkin’s Persona Poems 218 14 Larkin’s Impersonal Poems 267 Conclusion 310 Bibliography 317 1 List of Abbreviations References to the works of Philip Larkin are incorporated in the text using the following abbreviations: AGW A Girl in Winter AWJ All What Jazz CP Collected Poems (1988) EPJ Early Poems and Juvenilia FR Further Requirements J Jill LM Letters to Monica OBTCEV The Oxford Book of Twentieth Century English Verse RW Required Writing SL Selected Letters TCP The Complete Poems (including Archie Burnett’s commentary) TWG Trouble at Willow Gables and Other Fictions References to archived correspondences held by the University of Hull in the Larkin Estate Collection at the Hull History Centre are incorporated in the text as individual letters’ dates. The relevant reference numbers from this collection are: U DP/174 Letters from Philip Larkin to James Ballard Sutton U DP/179 Correspondence between Colin Gunner and Philip Larkin U DX/341 Photocopied letters from Philip Larkin to Monica Jones All unabbreviated references are given in full at their first appearance, and in short thereafter.
    [Show full text]
  • 50 Poems & the Fire of Belonging: the Life and Work of Mick Imlah
    50 Poems & The Fire of Belonging: The Life and Work of Mick Imlah and the influence of the work on my poetic development By Robert Edward Selby A Doctoral Thesis in Creative Writing Presented to Royal Holloway, University of London February 2015 Declaration of Authorship I, Robert Edward Selby, hereby declare that this thesis and the work presented in it is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, it is always clearly stated. Signed: ___________________________________________________________ Date: ____________________________________________________________ 2 Abstract This is the most sustained study to date of the late poet Mick Imlah. The close reading it makes of a number of his poems is informed and placed in context by biographical information gathered from archival research and interviews with his friends and colleagues. The study argues that Imlah’s first collection, Birthmarks, can be understood in the context of his predilection for the fictive potential of poetry being complemented by a contemporaneous, wider renaissance in interest in the Browningesque dramatic monologue and narrative. The study argues that his second collection, The Lost Leader, can be understood in the context of Imlah’s increased identification with his Scottish heritage, triggered by creative and personal crises and encouraged by Scotland’s growing sense of nationhood towards the end of the twentieth century. The implication is that Imlah’s oeuvre, contrary to the perception that it is sui generis, can be regarded as in dialogue with changes that took place within and without British poetry towards the end of the twentieth century and into the twenty-first: the re-appreciation of Victorian verse, for instance, or the emergence, from the 1980s, of a more confident Scottish voice.
    [Show full text]
  • U DP181 Correspondence Between Philip Arthur 1958-1985 Larkin and Anthony Thwaite
    Hull History Centre: Correspondence between Philip Arthur Larkin and Anthony Thwaite U DP181 Correspondence between Philip Arthur 1958-1985 Larkin and Anthony Thwaite Historical Background: Anthony Simon Thwaite was born in Chester in 1930 and spent the years of the Second World War with an aunt in Washington DC where he went to school. On his return he was boarded at Kingswood School, Bath, before studying at Christ Church Oxford. While there he edited Isis and co-edited Trio and Oxford Poetry 1954. From 1955 to 1957 he was Visiting Lecturer in English Literature at Tokyo University. On his return to England he became a producer of features for the BBC Third Programme and then, from 1962 to 1965 was literary editor of the Listener. From 1965 to 1967 he was Assistant Professor of English at the University of Libya, Benghazi. Later he became editor of The New Statesman, co-editor of Encounter and Director of Andre Deutsch Ltd. He had a sabbatical year as writer in residence at the University of East Anglia in 1972. Thwaite and Larkin met in 1951 when Thwaite invited Larkin to contribute to a series for the European Service called Younger British Poets of Today. They quickly became good friends, their friendship deepening over the years. Larkin often stayed with the Thwaites in Richmond and later in Norfolk. As well as supporting Larkin’s writing, Thwaite built a reputation as a poet himself. Thwaite published his first book of poems with the Fantasy Press in 1953 and his second Home Truths with the Marvell Press two years after Philip Larkin's The Less Deceived in 1957.
    [Show full text]
  • 2017 Conference, University of Dallas, October 26-29 Hosts: Baylor University and University of Dallas
    ALSCW Association of Literary Scholars, Critics, and Writers 2017 Conference, University of Dallas, October 26-29 Hosts: Baylor University and University of Dallas Thursday, October 26 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 4-7:15 PM AN EVENING OF READINGS Dean Lee Nordt, Dean, Baylor College of Arts and Sciences; Haggar Auditorium and Thompson Loggia, Beatrice M. Haggerty Gallery (Building 20) Baylor's Beall Poetry Festival; Dr. Kevin Gardner, Chair, Baylor English Department; Cash bar and hors d’oeuvres beginning at 4 PM, followed by readings from con- ference participants Lois Avey, Administrative Assistant, Baylor English Department; Registration table open in Thompson Loggia. Dr. Meg Tyler, Boston University; 5:00-5:15: Gregory Fraser, Meringoff Award in Poetry Drs. Andrew Osborn and Steven Stryer, University of Dallas; 5:15-5:30: Chad Davidson, Meringoff Essay Award Dr. Ernest Suarez, ALSCW President; 5:30-6:00: Greg Delanty, “A short reading and signing from the new Selected Delanty, a book introduced by and selected by Archie Burnett” Dr. Meg Tyler, for bringing Peter McDonald to America; 6:00-6:15: Carolyn Jack, Meringoff Award in Fiction 6:15-7:15: Supper on your own (UD cafeteria has meals on campus) Dr. Matt Spangler, for bringing Declan Gorman to America; Katie Tjerrild, for designing the conference program; 7:15 PM Father Thomas More Barba, Chaplain of the Church of the Incarnation, for use WELCOME ADDRESS of the church for Professor Ricks's lecture; Haggar Auditorium (Building 20) Lee Nordt, Dean, College of Arts and Sciences, Baylor University Karen Gempel and Kelly O’Neal of the University of Dallas, and Anita Johnson of the University of Dallas Bookstore; 7:30-8:30 PM J.J.
    [Show full text]