L'.3350 Deposmon and DISSOLUTION of the MIDDLE DEVONIAN PRAIRIE FORMATION, Williston BASIN, NORTH DAKOTA and MONTANA By
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
l'.3350 DEPOsmON AND DISSOLUTION OF THE MIDDLE DEVONIAN PRAIRIE FORMATION, WilLISTON BASIN, NORTH DAKOTA AND MONTANA by: Chris A. Oglesby T-3350 A thesis submined to the Faculty and the Board of Trustees of the Colorado School of Mines in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science (Geology). Golden, Colorado Date f:" /2 7 /C''i::-- i ; Signed: Approved: Lee C. Gerhard Thesis Advisor Golden, Colorado - 7 Date' .' Samuel S. Adams, Head Department of Geology and Geological Engineering II T-3350 ABSTRACf Within the Williston basin, thickness variations of the Prairie Formation are common and are interpreted to originate by two processes, differential accumulation of salt during deposition, and differential removal of salt by dissolution. Unambiguous evidence for each process is rare because the Prairie/Winnipegosis interval is seldom cored within the U.S. portion of the basin. Therefore indirect methods, utilizing well logs, provide the principal method for identifying characteristics of the two processes. The results of this study indicate that the two processes can be distinguished using correlations within the Prairie Formation. Several regionally correlative upward-brining, and probably shoaling-upward sequences occur within the Prairie Formation .. Near the basin center, the lowermost sequence is transitional with the underlying Winnipegosis Formation. This transition is characterized by thinly laminated carbonates that become increasingly interbedded with anhydrites of the basin-centered Ratner Member, the remainder of the sequence progresses up through halite and culminates in the halite-dominated Esterhazy potash beds. Two overlying sequences also brine upwards, however, these sequences lack the basal anhydrite and instead begin with halite and culminate in the Belle Plaine and Mountrail potash Members, respectively. A fourth sequence is indicated by several feet of halite capping the Mountrail Member in some parts of the basin. Subsequent erosion or dissolution prior to burial may have removed the upper portion of this sequence. Cross-sections show that the Lower Prairie gradually decreases in thickness from the basin to its margins. This thickness variation is most simply explained by decreasing accommodation potential due to decreased basin topography away from the basin ill T-3350 depocenter and by depositional onlap of the Prairie toward the basin margins. A depositional onlap pattern is characteristic of the basin's southern margin. In this case, there is a progressive increase in areal extent of the formation from the base to the top. By correlating the four sequences within the Prairie, some local thickness variations are shown to originate by depositional onlap onto Winnipegosis reefs. Other thickness variations occur in response to minor vertical movements across basement faults. Inparticular the Brockton-Froid fault zone and the Nesson anticline have affected deposition of the Prairie and Winnipegosis Formations. In other areas, such as along the western and eastern basin margins, the basal parts of the formation are more extensive and completely preserved, but upper parts are progressively diminished in areal extent from the top down. This pattern is explained by progressive dissolution of Prairie evaporites from the top downward, suggesting that the aquifers contributing to the dissolution overlie the Prairie Formation. Although no distinct linear pattern emerged, the coincidence between tectonic features such as the Brockton- Froid fault system, the Nesson anticline and the Superior/Churchill contact and major dissolution areas suggests that dissolution is controlled primarily by tectonic fracturing. Dissolution was also recognized over several Winnipegosis pinnacle reefs. This dissolution preferentially removed the overlying potash horizons and resulted in partial dissolution of the Prairie. These observations suggest that dissolution resulted from an upward-directed flow of waters localized by the reeffacies. IV T-3350 TABLE OF CONTENTS lli!@ ABSTRACT iii TABLE OF CONTENTS v LIST OF FIGURES vii LIST OF PLATES x ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS xi IN1RODUCTION I STRUCTURAL SETTING 4 DEPOSITIONAL SETTING 7 rv1E1HOOOLOGY 22 Genetic Stratigraphy 22 Deposition of thick evaporite sequences 27 CAUSES OF PRAIRIE FORMATION THINNING 29 Depositional thinning by onlap 29 Temporal Relationship between the Prairie Formation and Winnipegosis Formation Pinnacle Reefs 36 RECOGNmON OF SALT DISSOLUTION 39 Presence of collapse breccias 39 Isopach and isochron patterns 39 Geophysical methods 43 DISSOLUTION MODELS 46 Dissolution thinning by groundwater flow 46 Compaction and dewatering model 46 v T-3350 Surface water model. 47 Depositional facies controls on dissolution 49 Tectonic controls on dissolution 51 DIFFERENTIATING BETWEEN DEPOSmONAL AND DISSOLUTION THINNING 57 INTERPRETATION OF ISOPACH MAPS 59 PETROLEUM GEOLOGy 62 CONCLUSIONS 69 FUTURE WORK 71 REFERENCES CITED 73 APPENDIX 79 Winnipegosis Pinnacle Reef wells 79 Vl T-3350 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Stratigraphic column of the Devonian in the Williston basin. 2 2. Map of the study area showing major structural features and the Prairie Formation subcrop within the Williston Basin. 3 3. Map of the major lineaments within the U.S.A. portion of the Williston Basin and location of the contact between the Churchill and Superior Precambrian provinces. 6 4. Map of the Elk Point Basin (Middle Devonian) showing facies within the Prairie Formation. 9 5. Type well log (gamma ray - sonic) for the Prairie Formation. 10 6. Colored photograph of core showing laminated carbonate facies of the Winnipegosis Formation. (Sunray-Gagnum #1, sw/nw, 13-169n-89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=8,322). 11 7. Colored photograph of core showing laminated carbonate and anhydrite transitional facies .(Sunray-Gagnum #1, sw/nw, 13-169n-89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=8,302) 12 8. Colored photograph of core showing enterolithic anhydrite facies (Ratner member) (Sunray-Gagnum#l, sw/nw, 13-169n-89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=8,300.4). 13 9. Colored photograph of core showing, nearly pure, bedded (laminated) anhydrite facies (Ratner member) (Sunray-Gagnum #1, sw/nw, 13-169n- 89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=8,286). 14 10. Colored photograph of core showing transition of anhydrite facies into halite facies (lower Prairie Formation) (Sunray-Gagnum #1, sw/nw, 13- 169n-89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=8,282). 16 11. Colored photograph of core showing milky halite facies (chevron crystals) (Sunray-Gagnum #1, sw/nw, 13-169n-89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=8,261). 17 12. Colored photograph of core showing clear halite facies (hopper crystals) (Sunray-Gagnum #1, sw/nw, 13-169n-89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=8,152). 18 va T-3350 13. Colored photograph of core showing thin anhydrite beds in Lower Prairie Formation, "jahresringe", (Sunray-Gagnum #1, sw/nw, 13-169n-89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=8,233). 20 14. Colored photograph of core showing potash (sylvite and carnallite) facies, (Sunray-Gagnum #1, sw/nw, 13-169n-89w, Burke Co., N.D., Depth=7,971). 21 15. Stratigraphic and time stratigraphic sections showing correlation of genetic ~~. ~ 16. Idealized evaporite sequences from deep basin to basin margin. 25 17. Sequences within the Prairie Formation. 27 18. Paleogeography of the Elk Point Basin during Winnipegosis time. 29 19. Aggradational evaporite deposition within basin displaying onlap geometry. 30 20. Log cross-section showing onlap of Prairie Formation onto the Winnipegosis Formation shelf (depositional thinning). 32 21. Wheeler diagram of Prairie Formation through time. 33 22. Log cross-section showing onlap of the Prairie Formation onto Winnipegosis Formation pinnacle reefs. 34 23. Seismic section showing the Prairie Formation onlapping a Winnipegosis reef. 36 24. Depositional model of Prairie and Winnipegosis Formations, indicating two separate of carbonate and two stages of salt deposition. 38 25. Colored photograph of core near contact of Winnipegosis with overlying collapse breccia showing large clasts which occur near the base of the breccia, (California Company, 1 Blanche Thompson, 31-160n-81w, Depth=6,351). 40 26. Colored photograph of core near the middle of the collapse breccia showing less deformation and a decrease in fragment sizes, (California Company, 1 Blanche Thompson, 31-160n-81w, Depth=6,299). 41 27. Colored photograph of core near the top of the collapse breccia showing vertical fractures filled with anhydrite, (California Company, 1 Blanche Thompson, 31-160n-81 w, Depth=6,266). 42 VUI T-3350 28. Model of Winnipegosis mound showing groundwater flow and slumping due to dissolution and collapse. 44 29. Hypothetical model for groundwater flow in the presence of reefs (Leduc and Ireton Formations. 46 30. Model of vertical fractures and lineaments developed over basement fault blocks. 48 31. Model (two-dimensional) showing various flow paths in a fractured media. 53 32. Model (three-dimensional) showing various flow paths in a fractured media. 55 33. Log cross-section across the Roosevelt Co., Montana salt void showing top down nature of dissolution thinning. 56 34. Schematic diagram illustrating development of two-stage salt dissolution and the subsequent formation of a "turtle structure". 58 35. Distribution of oil fields related to two-stage salt dissolution, Roosevelt County, Montana. 64 36. Map showing location of Wiley field, Bottineau County, N.D. and its relationship to the underlying Prairie subcrop. 68 IX T-3350 LIST OF PLATES 1. Isopach map of Winnipegosis Formation, eastern Montana, scale 1:20000