American Fisheries Society • Exploring The
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
VOL 34 NO 6 JUNE 2009 Fish News Legislative Update Journal Highlights Fisheries Calendar FisheriesAmerican Fisheries Society • www.fi sheries.org Job Center EXPERIENCE THE DIVERSITY OF NASHVILLE Exploring the Peer Review Process: What Is It, Does It Work, and can It Be Improved? Abdicating Responsibility: The Deceits of IFQ Fisheries Policy Fisheries • v o l 34 n o 6 • j u n e 2009 • w w w .f i s h e r i e s .o r g 261 Biomark 262 Fisheries • v o l 34 n o 6 • j u n e 2009 • w w w .f i s h e r i e s .o r g VOL 34 NO 6 JUNE 2009 285 AmericANFisheries FiSherieS Society • www.FiSherieS.org EDITORIAL / SUBSCRIPTION / CIRCULATION OFFICES 5410 Grosvenor Lane, Suite 110 • Bethesda, MD 20814-2199 301/897-8616 • fax 301/897-8096 • main@fi sheries.org The American Fisheries Society (AFS), founded in 1870, is the oldest and largest professional society representing fi sheries scientists. The AFS promotes scientifi c research and enlightened management of aquatic resources for optimum use and enjoyment by the public. It also encourages comprehensive education of fi sheries scientists and continuing on-the-job training. AFS OFFIcERS FISHERIES STAFF EDITORS PRESIDENT SENIOR EDITOR SCIENCE EDITORS Contents William G. Franzin Ghassan “Gus” N. Rassam Madeleine Hall-Arber Ken Ashley COLUMN: COLUMN PRESIDENT ELECT DIRECTOR OF Doug Beard Donald C. Jackson PUBLICATIONS Ken Currens 264 PRESIDENT’S HOOK 304 GuEST DIREcTOR'S lINE Aaron Lerner William E. Kelso The AFS Annual Meeting: Field Biologists and Fighter Pilots, Unite! FIRST Deirdre M. Kimball what’s in it for you As a Fisheries VICE PRESIDENT Robert T. Lackey Take every opportunity possible to actually get Wayne A. Hubert mANAgiNg editor professional and what’s in it for your Beth Beard Dennis Lassuy into the fi eld to experience the natural context Allen Rutherford Agency? SECOND of where your data were measured. PRODUCTION EDITOR The 2009 AFS Annual Meeting in Nashville, VICE PRESIDENT book review Edward J. Peters William L. Fisher Cherie Worth EDITORS is the single best venue on the continent to Francis Juanes accomplish vital information exchange. PAST PRESIDENT Ben Letcher Mary C. Fabrizio Keith Nislow William G. Franzin COLUMN: EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR ABSTRACT TRANSLATION Ghassan“Gus” N.Rassam Pablo del Monte Luna 305 STuDENTS’ ANGlE NEWS: the role of the Student member in the AFS Fisheries information and technology Dues and fees for 2009 are: 266 FISHERIES $76 in North America ($88 elsewhere) for regular members, Section $19 in North America ($22 elsewhere) for student members, Michael E. Colvin and Jeff Kopaska and $38 ($44) retired members. Fees include $19 for Fisheries subscription. JOURNAL HIGHLIGHTS: Nonmember and library subscription rates are $132 ($127). 268 JOuRNAl OF AQuATIc OBITUARY: Price per copy: $3.50 member; $6 nonmember. ANIMAL HEALTH AND Fisheries (ISSN 0363-2415) is published monthly by the 307 NIcHOlAS F. HuGHES American Fisheries Society; 5410 Grosvenor Lane, JOuRNAl OF AQuAculTuRE Authority on Salmonid Behavior Suite 110; Bethesda, MD 20814-2199 ©copyright 2009. Periodicals postage paid at Bethesda, Maryland, and at an additional mailing offi ce. A copy of Fisheries Guide for UPDATE: CALENDAR: Authors is available from the editor or the AFS website, www.fi sheries.org. If requesting from the managing editor, 269 lEGISlATION AND POlIcY 308 FISHERIES EVENTS please enclose a stamped, self-addressed envelope with Elden Hawkes, Jr. your request. Republication or systematic or multiple reproduction of material in this publication is permitted only ANNOUNCEMENTS: under consent or license from the American Fisheries Society. Postmaster: Send address changes to Fisheries, American FEATURE: 309 JOB CENTER Fisheries Society; 5410 Grosvenor Lane, Suite 110; Bethesda, 270 PROFESSIONAL ISSUES MD 20814-2199. Exploring the Peer Review Process: What Is Fisheries is printed on 10% post-consumer It, Does It Work, and Can It Be Improved? recycled paper with soy-based printing inks. Despite its importance to our fi eld, peer review has been little studied. In this paper, we summarize the literature concerning peer review. Dennis R. DeVries, Elizabeth A. Marschall, Advertising Index and Roy A. Stein Advanced Telemetry Systems . 311 Biomark. 262 PERSPECTIVE: Emperor Aquatics, Inc. 305 280 SOCIOECONOMICS Floy Tag . 291 Abdicating Responsibility: Frigid Units . 289 The Deceits of Fisheries Policy Hallprint. 298 Fisheries managers have been deceived by HallTech. 291 fi sheries economists who use false economic Hydroacoustic Technology, Inc. 312 arguments to justify the free and perpetual Juniper Systems . 267 gifting of quota shares under IFQ programs. Kentucky State University . 277 Daniel W. Bromley CORRECTIONS: The list of authors on the Table of Lotek . 295 Contents omitted the names of the fi rst two authors OnSet Computer . 267 of the article “Risks of Introductions of Marine Oregon RFID . 297 LETTERS Fishes: Reply to Briggs” in the April issue (Fisheries O. S. Systems . 301 292 TO THE EDITOR 34[4]). The full list of authors is Walter R. Courtenay, Quantitative Fisheries Center . 299 Jr., Bruce B. Collette, Timothy E. Essington, Ray Sonotronics . 293 Hilborn, James W. Orr, Daniel Pauly, John E. Randall, Sound Metrics. 279 and William F. Smith-Vaniz. Also, Courtenay’s e-mail Vemco . 302 address was listed incorrectly in the article – it should read “[email protected].” tell advertisers you found them through Fisheries! COVER: Experience the diversity of Nashville at the 139th Annual Meeting of the American Fisheries Society, 30 August–3 September 2009. Fisheries • v o l 34 n o 6 • j u n e 2009 • w w w .f i s h e r i e s .o r g 263 COLUMN: William G. Franzin AFS President Franzin can be PRESIDENT’S HOOK contacted at [email protected]. The AFS Annual Meeting: What’s in It for You As a Fisheries Professional and What’s in It for Your Agency? I have been attending AFS research. You will meet fellow relevance to the fisheries science Annual Meetings since the 110th researchers, resource managers, of the day. AFS Annual Meetings meeting held in 1980 in Louisville, and authors face to face and provide a service to members and Kentucky. I make my own decisions begin or maintain your network others in our professions: excellent on which meetings to attend of fisheries professionals. These opportunities for learning, now, but having been a bench people, in a wide range of fields, networking, and professional scientist and a science manager in will provide that essential go-to development. They also offer a federal agency, I often was faced resource that will make your great venues for recruitment of with either answering or replying work more efficient, whether you new employees to federal and to those two questions. A third need some bits of data on some state agencies since the meetings question usually was why I should small endangered species or the attract young, talented graduating attend rather than any number of latest management techniques students to present their work. other scientists who might wish for those charismatic species of With technical and leadership to go (I will leave the answer to salmonids, basses, and percids. It workshops, symposia, and poster that one to you). Given that this is all will be there in your network, sessions, the AFS Annual Meeting about the time of year when these just an e-mail or phone call is an educational experience at a questions and answers are asked, away. Participating in AFS Annual relatively low cost. How better to I thought I would address them Meetings is important for your find potential new employees than from both sides. To set the stage, career in fisheries; knowing other to see them present their own your abstract has been accepted professionals that you can call and research at a scientific meeting? and you now have to find the for those people to know your Many states and provinces are travel funds and justify why you or work will help you to establish facing budgetary shortages this your staff member should go and your reputation as a fisheries year and, as a result, they have deliver the paper. professional. Finally, if you become put restrictions on travel and For me it has always been easy involved in Society governance, meeting attendance. But for your to justify why I should attend you will benefit from learning one of our meetings. It is the how to participate effectively in aquatic and fisheries professionals, biggest, best, broadest fisheries meetings of a professional society there is no more cost-effective meeting on the continent, the that will help you in meetings experience than attending the meeting where you will meet the in your workplace and in your AFS Annual Meeting. By allowing eminent fishery biologists from community. these professionals to attend our North America and beyond. You Why should your agency meeting, you are making a small will learn about the latest fisheries support your attendance to an investment with big returns in and aquatic research directly from AFS Annual Meeting? Fisheries terms of future efficiency and scientists long before it appears play an important part in the performance. The science forming in the journals. If you have a economy and diet of countries all the basis of fisheries management great piece of research that you over the world. The recreational in your state/province is dependent are contemplating publishing aspects of fisheries and the on your scientists and managers and you just want to float a taxes levied on that activity help being exposed to the most up-to- trial balloon first, the audience sustain preservation of the aquatic date information possible. Our in a meeting room will provide environment.