A Carlow Tribute to Walt Disney. Carlow Connections from a New Book Book Review"A Journey Along the the Emergence of the Clergy in Borris

Carlow Historical and Archaeological Society Cumann Staire agus Seandd/afochta Cheatharloch

, :·.,-~·. ' . ' . . .

•

A Carlow Tribute to Walt Disney. Carlow connections from a new book Book Review"A Journey along the The Emergence of the Clergy in Borris. 'The Villain of Steam'. Carlow Corridor~ Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Here's to the 32! Growth and Decline: the changing Demesne. Involvement of the Catholic Clergy fortunes of Carlow Town. Captain Bill Murphy ofTullow, with the Republican Struggle. Saint Fiacc, the Steve Jobs of Unsung hero of the Somme. History of the RTC/ ITC Fifth Century Ireland. Cumann na mBan in Carlow. 'Corpse Watching': Fr James Cullen, Founder of the Pioneer The Bagenals of !drone Chronology. a macabre practice in the l 830's Total Abstinence Assoc. Property Owners in County Carlow in Leighlin. Hare-slips in the walls of the Deerpark in the year 1307. Book Review'Michael O'Hanrahan'. on Ballintemple Estate. PR comes to Carlow. Bishop Daniel Delaney and the Irish women carried goods on their heads. Dunleckney Post Bagenal 1802 - 2015. Presentation Sisters {1718-1813). "Carlow - A Journey to the Past"; ~ounty Statistics 2002. Bishop James Keefe and the foundation Heritage Week 2015. ' 4 A Carlow Folly. of Carlow College. CHAS history Prize Competjtj'on , Memories of life on the Edmund Dwyer Gray JI: for National Schools. Barrow/ Grand Canal his life to two h~f!!ispheres. Gradam an Phiarsaigh 2015. Robert Hartpole, Constable of Carlow. Kildart & leighlin Roman Catholi~ The Red lad and Blunt - Hacketstown Wi\tiam DesmondTa~lor, Chaplains in WW1. Poachers ofthe 20th Century. Ca ow's forgotten Celtuloid King. Qua1

Kilkenny Road Leighlinbridge P.J. BYRNE & CO. SOLICITORS INCORPORATING SAMUEL ROCHE & CO Co. Carlow Athy Road. Cadow. arbO;;lum T: 059 9721558 • Phone: 059-9141888 •Fax: 059-9132391 •Email:~ •Web: www.pjbyme.ie & E: [email protected] lifestyle garden centre W: www.arboretum.ie DX No: 18 009 Carlow CARLOW CORNICE & MOULDINGS LTD. q[arloiu leistrirt ~rtbit fflnion JLtb. Tinryland, Carlow CREDIT UNION HOUSE, ASKE.A, CARLOW. Tel: 059 9143930 Mob: 087 2632329 Fax: 059 9133258 Cornice, Centrepieces, Arches, Panelling, Corbels, Niches, Phone: 059 91319949131643. Fax: 059 9134288 Supplied and Fitted Email: info@cadowcreditunio!Lie Web: www.carlowcreclitunion.ie Specialists in Fibrous Plaster Restoration & Design

$;2fl~,/~_,.1 ,,,,, / ENGAGEMENT & WEDDING TULLY'S TRAVEL LTD ~;:.;;_,;;;:;r.,. RINGS MADE TO YOUR DESIGN 137 TULLOW STREET, CARLOW, IRELAND 62-64 DUBLIN ST., CARLOW. · IN OUR WORKSHOP Tel: 059 9136100 Fax: 059 9136180 JEWELLERS Dublin OI 6767777 T: 059/91 31346 E: [email protected] _W: irelandjewellers.com Web: www.tullys.ie SEVEN OAKS HOTEL KEHOE AUCTIONEERS ATHY ROAD, CARLOW. • Sumptuous Food • Exquisite Banqueting Suite PROPERTY AND ESTATE AGENT 57 DUBLIN STREET, CARLOW. &MlnOaks • Contemporary Conference Facilities ~ • State of the Art Heahh and Leisure Centre Tel: 059 9131678 Fax: 059 9141818 · KEHOE Tel: 059 9 131308 Email: [email protected]. Web: www.sevenoakshotel.com Email: [email protected] Web: www.kehoe.ie JONES BUSINESS SYSTEMS • Carlow 059 9132595 Clogrennane Lime Ltd • Kilkenny 056 7763655 O ogrennane, Carlow, Ireland. • Waterford 051 37 4896 Tel: 059 91 31811 I Fax: 059 9131607 Total Office Solutions Email: [email protected] I Web: www.irishlime.ie www.officestuff.ie Glanbia Agribusiness Graiguecullen, Topline M.P. DOYLE LTD Co. Carlow, Ireland. Shamrock Business Park, Telephone: +353 59 9131639 LOTS_ !;!!!j Graiguecullen. Carlow ~ Facsimile: +353 59 9142054 glanbift AGRIBUSINl!S-5 1 Web: www.glanbia.com Ph: 059 913 18471 Fax: 059 914 3008 Carlow Property Management EBSLimited LETTINGS & SALES 135 Tullow Street, Carlow 6 0 Dub lin Street, C arlow. Tel: 059 9142203 I Fax: 059 9130003 Tel: +353 59 9 135 800 Web: www.ebs.ie E m a il: [email protected] EBS Umited is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland Micron Filtration Abbey Murphy (Carlow) Ltd. ~~PRODUCTS LIMITED~~ - General Insurance Brokers - QUINAGH, CARLOW, IRELAND 48, Tullow Street, Carlow. Tel: 059-9131129 I Fax: 059-9131017 T: 059 9132547/9132580 F: 059 9132111 W: www.elitequote.ie E: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Abbey Murphy (Carlow) Limned is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland. Swans Electrical TV and Video LEINSTER CO-OP MARTS Strawhall, Carlow. Killeshin Road, Carlow. T: 059-91 31 617 E: [email protected] Tel: (059) 9 131530. Fax: (059) 9143342. expert SPECIALISTS IN LIVESTOCK SALES Email: [email protected]. (1) Farm & Property Sales Farm Leases & Valuations Licence No. 001191 P.S.R.A. Web: www.swanselectrical.ie I I LORD BAGENAL Main Street, Leighlinbridge, Co. Carlow, Ireland ~~ Tel: +353 (0) 59 9721668 Fax: +353 (0) 59 9722629 5 Tullow Stree~ ~ Email: [email protected] Web: www.lordbagenal.com Phone: (059) 9131254. Email: [email protected] Xevin Xe([y Pli.annacy ~t ' VALE OIL CO. LTD. KENNEDY AVE. CARLOW CASTLEMEADOWS, THURLES, CO. TIPPERARY Tel: 059 91 43007 Fax 059 9 43319 STAPI.ESTOWN ROAD CARLOV\ DEPOTS Tel'Fai -- . " Carlow 059 91 31814 Clonmel 052 6121828 OUNNES STORES GRA : Kilkenny 056 7722.067 New Ross 051 422168 Portlaoise 057 8621811 Waterford 051 358000

Carlmiana 2016 Page 1 Edited_Layout 1 29/10/2015 15:22 Page 1

Front cover picture CARLOVIANA The first and only female name on the 2016 Edition Roll of Honour of Carlow Brigade 1916- 1924 is Margaret Kehoe, Orchard Leighlinbridge. She nursed in the South No. 64 Dublin Union, now St James’s Hospital. During Easter Week I,S.S.N. 0790-0813 1916 the premises were occupied by 42 volunteers of the 4th battalion, Dublin Brigade Articles under the command of Eamon Ceannt A Carlow Tribute to Walt Disney, ...... 4 and Cathal Brugha as 2nd in command. The Emergence of the Clergy in Borris ...... 11 On Easter Monday intense fighting took Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne ...... 20 place when the British forces attacked Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow. Unsung Hero of the Somme ...... 37 the building. During a period of quietness Cumann na mBan in Carlow ...... 45 word was passed to Nurse Kehoe that a The Bagenals of Idrone Chronology ...... 51 volunteer lay wounded. Without hesita- Property Owners in County Carlow in the Year 1307 ...... 54 tion she rushed outside. Within minutes PR comes to Carlow ...... 56 guns opened fire again and Nurse Kehoe Dunleckney Post Bagenal 1802-2015 ...... 59 lost her life. In doing so, she displayed a County Statistics 2002 ...... 65 great devotion to duty and an extraordi- A Carlow Folly ...... 66 nary sense of heroism. The wounded Memories of Life on the Barrow/Grand Canal ...... 68 volunteer was Dan McCarthy who sub- Robert Hartpole, Constable of Carlow ...... 72 sequently became President of the GAA, William Desmond Taylor, Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King ...... 85 1921-1924 A plaque to her memory was Carlow connections from a new book ‘The Villain of Steam’ ...... 95 unveiled at St Kevin’s Hospital, Dublin Here’s to the 32! ...... 98 on Easter Monday, 1965 by the National Involvement of the Catholic Clergy with the Republican Struggle .....100 Graves Association. She was buried History of the RTC/ITC ...... 105 within the grounds of the Union but aftrr ‘Corpse Watching’: a macabre practice in the 1830s in Leighlin ...... 122 the surrender the remains were exhumed Book Review “Michael O’Hanrahan” ...... 126 and reinterred in Ballinabranna grave- Bishop Daniel Delaneyand the Presentation Sisters (1718-1813) ...... 127 yard in the Parish of Leighlin. Bishop James Keeffe oand the foundation of Carlow College ...... 133 Edmund Dwyer Gray Jr: his life in two hemispheres ...... 141 Kildare & Leighlin Roman Catholic Chaplains in WWI ...... 145 Michael O’Hanrahan, a New Quakers in County Carlow ...... 153 Ross born Wexford man who Book review “A Journey along the Carlow Corridor” ...... 160 had come to Carlow when his Growth and Decline: the changing fortunes of Carlow Town ...... 161 father transferred his busi- Saint Fiacc, The Steve Jobs of Fifth Century Ireland ...... 167 ness to Tullow St. in Carlow Fr James Cullen, Founder of the Pioneer Total Abstinence Assoc...... 172 Town. He had been a very prominent Hare-slips in the walls of the Deerpark on Ballintemple Estate ...... 173 man in the town before moving to Irish women carried goods on their heads ...... 175 Dublin. He founded the Workman’s Club “Carlow - A Journey to the Past”; Heritage Week 2015 ...... 179 in Browne’s St, Carlow and was a teacher CHAS History Prize Competition for National Schools ...... 183 in the Gaelic League classes. He was the Gradam an Phiarsaigh 2015 ...... 184 author of Swordsman of the Brigade and The Red Lad and Blunt - Hacketsown Poachers of the 20th Cent ...... 185 When the Normans Came. He was 77M, The McMillan Boat ...... 190 executed for his role in the Easter Rising Officers and members ...... 193 1916. Back Cover Brown and Crosthwaite Lodge Mill lorry Bagenalstown, c. 1920s. This was the first lorry bought second hand by Brown and Crosthwaite and the first letters on the number plate were IK (issued 1903- 1927) and this denotes that it was first registered in Dublin. Note the four wheels have brushes attached to prevent gravel and stones from flying up and hitting people while lorry was on the move. Tommy Comerford, at side of engine, was the driver and obtained that position because he had previously worked on engine boats on the canal. George Darcy is the tall man who worked with him and both hailed from Bagenalstown.The photo was taken in Regent Street Bagenal- stown. Courtesy: Jim Murphy, St Brigid’s Cresent, Bagenalstown.

Carloviana 2016 Page 2 Editorial Page Edited_Layout 1 29/10/2015 16:08 Page 1

Editor: Martin Nevin CARLOVIANA 2016 Edition

No. 64

I,S.S.N. 0790 - 0813

Editor: Jim Shannon Editorial

Editorial Committee: Once again we are delighted to present another bumper edition of our annual Journal. The editorial team expresses our thanks to our contributors who continue year after Martin Nevin year to come forward with varied and interesting articles relating to our area. They Pat O’Neill are the backbone of this Journal and without them it would simply not exist, never Padraig Dooley mind attain the degree of recognition and respect that, we are happy to say, it enjoys. Nial O’Neill We note that two of the regulars among these contributors attained the degree of Ph.D. during the year. Congratulations to Dr. Ann Power of Bagenalstown and to Dr. Published by: Shay Kinsella of Milford. Carlow Historical th and Archaeological Society November 2015 sees the 1400 anniversary of the death of St. Columbanus, who P.O. Box 162 tradition tells us, was born in this area, the founder of monasteries at Luxeuil, Bobbio Carlow. and many other places in Europe. He was described by the late Cardinal Tomás Ó Fiaich as “Ireland’s first European,” and certainly his impact on the history of the continent was a very significant one in that he and his companions made a major Email: contribution to the re-Christianisation and re-civilisation of Western Europe in the [email protected] wake of the collapse of the Roman Empire.

Website: The coming year brings the centenary of the 1916 Rebellion. Like other events during www.carlowhistorical.com this Decade of Commemoration this, we expect, will inspire renewed interest in researching the events of that period in our local area. Our society, in co-operation Carlow Historical and Archaeological with the History Department of St. Patrick’s College, Carlow, is endeavouring to Society is affiliated to the Federation of foster such interest by sponsoring a prize for original research into the local history Local History Societies. of the period, open to all third and fourth year students of History or Humanities in the College. This, it is hoped, will result in new and exciting insights into the events of the time in Carlow. We confidently expect that next year’s edition of “Carloviana” All articles in this journal are the will feature some of the fruits of this research. copyright of the Carlow Historical and Archaeological Society and may not be The centenary of the Rising has already given rise to some obvious attempts by var- reproduced in any form without the ious politically interested groups and individuals to impose upon the public con- permission of the editor. sciousness their own particular agenda and their own particular interpretation of what happened. It is important that we do not let a mythologized and biased version of Views and opinions expressed in this the events of Easter Week become accepted as truth. Neither would it be desirable to journal are not those of the editor or of the allow “the men with the keen long faces” to convince us that it was all a mistake. It Carlow Historical and Archaeological happened, and in the words of Yeats “all changed, changed utterly/ a terrible beauty is born.” The events of that week were the catalyst that led to a totally changed Society. political landscape in Ireland and it behoves us to understand that period and how it affected our people at the time and for long after. To that end we welcome any Printed by: research by our members on this period and we will be glad to publish in future Carlow Advertiser & Printing, editions any articles of suitable standard.The Society will mark the actual centenary Strawhall Industrial Estate, in April 2016 by presenting a lecture on Micheál Ua hAnnracháin, the 1916 leader Carlow. with closest Carlow connections. This lecture will be given by Dr. Conor Kostik, the author of a biography of Micheál Ua hAnnracháin which is reviewed in this Journal. SPONSORS Inside the front and back covers of our journal This Decade of Commemoration also recalls the experiences and sacrifices of those we list the local businesses who, each year, who took a different road and followed the advice of John Redmond to “go wherever support us in producing Carloviana. We wish the firing line extends.” Ann Power’s article on chaplains in World War I is a welcome to thank them sincerely for their assistance, contribution to remind us all of an almost forgotten group of dedicated men and of without which it would not be possible to do the service they gave. this. Just as these businesses support us we ask our members, in turn, to support them wherever possible. Sílimíd go bfhuil cnuasacht suimúil, eagsúil, bríomhar d’ailt bailithe againn arís i mbliana, agus tá súil againn go mbainfidh ár léitheoirí taithneamh astu. Gabhaimid Bertie Watchorn buíochas le gach éinne a chabhraigh linn i rith na hoibre. Nollaig Shona agus athbh- President lian fé mhaise dhaoibh go léir.

Carloviana 2016 Page 3 Message from the Pres. Edited_Layout 1 29/10/2015 18:49 Page 1

Message from the President

This year has been an eventful one for Society paid us a very enjoyable visit Sadly—we are losing Deirdre as she has our society, breaking new ground on a 22nd to 24th May when Martin Nevin left for Australia. She was an excellent couple of occasions. We started the year spoke on Walt Disney and the Carlow secretary and spearheaded the develop- with our three lectures which were very connection. During Heritage week we ment of our website; she will be greatly well attended. The society entered into a had three excellent mini lectures in missed. I would like to thank our editor conservation agreement with the Leighlinbridge Parish Centre on the 26th Jim Shannon and Martin Nevin for their museum to fund some restoration work August, unstinting work on the production of on museum artifacts. We also co- Carloviana. Where they source the purchased two items for the museum. Reflections on Keenan's of Bagenal- material to fill it is amazing. I would also stown by Michael Keenan like to thank Pat O'Neill for his help and Rathmichael Historical Society paid us a Milletts — Coachbuilders of Borris the huge volume of work he does for the visit from the 24th to 26th April and by Ned Moran society. Also I would like to thank all the Martin Nevin gave them a talk on Carlow Blue Limestone by Phil Meaney. members of the committee for their help County Carlow. and commitment to the Society during Also during Heritage week on the 22nd the year. We had an enjoyable outing to Hillsbor- August we had one of our biggest ough Castle and Lisburn Linen Museum projects. The re-enactment was spear- Finally I want to thank all those both on May 9th. headed by three of our youngest members and sponsors who continue to members, Seamus Ó Murchú, Gary make a vital contribution to our society. Our Schools History Prize was presented Hughes and Deirdre Kearney and took at a function in the museum on the 20th place in the Town Park, Graiguecullen. Thank You of May; we had four very good projects They did an excellent job and deserve our from four separate schools. thanks. Our thanks also to Carlow Co. Bertie Watchorn Council for the use of the park. Shannon Historical and Archaeological

The 70th Winter Lecture Series 2015-2016

All lectures start at 8pm.

Date Lecturer Topic Venue 21 October, 2015 Charles Doherty St Columbanus& the earliest churches Talbot Hotel, Carlow U.C.D. School of History in the Carlow area 8 November, 2015 Felix Larkin “Dublin Opinion” magazine - Seven Oaks Hotel, Academic the safety valve of a nation Carlow Director, Parnell Summer School 20 January, 2016 Dr Elaine Byrne Carlow and the Famine Girls Mount Wolseley Hotel, Academic, Tullow Journalist and Consultant 17 February, 2016 Christopher Power, Visitation of Vengeance - the killing Seven Oaks Hotel, Historian of D.I. Percival Lee-Wilson Carlow 16 March, 2016 Prof. Tagh O’Keeffe, U.C.D. Ballymoon Castle Credit Union House, School of Archaeological Bagenalstown 20 April, 2016 Dr Conor Kostic Micheál UahAnnracáin - Institute of Technology, Gaelic League, I.R.B. and Novelist Carlow

Carloviana 2016 Tribute to Walt Disney edited 1 Collected - Copy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:03 Page 1

A CARLOW TRIBUTE TO WALT DISNEY.

‘A DREAM, A PENCIL, AND A MOUSE’.

Mary Stratton Ryan

In July 1923, Walt Disney (1901- 1966) Walt Disney went to live with his Uncle boarded a train bound for the movie Robert Disney, who had retired to Mecca of Hollywood. He had forty Los Angeles. dollars in the pocket of his threadbare jacket. He was carrying a brown Disney’s French ancestry cardboard suitcase, which contained one shirt a change of socks, underwear, a The Disney Family originated in France, bundle of sketchbooks filled with it may be traced back to the 11th century drawings, a few drawing materials and a to Normandy and Hughes Suhart, from the reel of film entitled Alice’s Wonderland. village of Isigny. He was a vassal of Duke Guillaume of Normandy and had received Two months earlier Disney had written several strongholds including the village to several New York film distributers; of Isigny for his military services. Hughes We have just discovered something new Suhart now Hugh of Isigny [Hugh and clever in animated cartoons! The d’Isigny] and his son Robert travelled with first subject of this distinctly different William the Conquer in 1066 to fight in series is now in production. It is a new the battle of Hastings England. William idea that will appeal to all and is bound became King of England and the d’Isigny to be a winner, because it is a combina- Walt Disney family settled in Lincoln, known today as tion of live characters and cartoons, Born December 5th, 1901at 12.35 Norton Disney, 10mls from Lincoln on the using a cast of live child actors who Died December 15th, 1966 at 9.30 river Witham. carry on their action on cartoon scenes 1 with cartoon characters. The center of the animation industry was The Disney family was well established New York. It was 17 years since James in Lincolnshire by the 1150 and the Lewis Carroll’s classic Alice Adventures Stuart Blackton had made the first film Church of St Peter’s Norton Disney, was in Wonderland inspired the story for this using drawn animation, Humorous founded by the family, it has five Disney innovative cartoon, however this time, Phases of Funny Faces, and in the mean- monuments. Carved in stone and set in a Alice goes to Cartoonland for her many time the medium had been advanced by low arched recess is an effigy of Joan film adventures.On his arrival in Holly- pioneers such as Winsor Mc Cay, Earl d’Isigny, she is dressed in a coif and wood, there were no animation studios. Hurd, Walter Lantz, and Paul Terry, and wear’s a costume of the 1300s. A second It was a hive of industry; Cecil B. De by the Fleischer brothers with their Out lady also named Joan and Sir William Mille was filming The Ten Command- of the Inkwell series. The top cartoons of d’Isigny, son of William the church’s ments and Douglas Fairbanks was build- the period were Mutt and Jeff and Pat founder are also carved in stone, Sir ing a monumental set for The Thief of Sullivan’s Felix the Cat who, animated William is dressed in full knights armor. Bagdad. Charlie Chaplin wrote, by Otto Messmer made his debut in 1921 On the mortuary floor is the effigy of a produced and directed A Woman of Paris. and was hugely popular. late 14th century lady robed in a long

Carloviana 2016 Tribute to Walt Disney edited 1 Collected - Copy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:03 Page 2

5 A Carlow tribute to Walt Disney. ‘A dream, ‘A pencil, and a mouse

close fitting tunic, she lies with her head Charles 11 and was a power struggle be- resting on two diagonally set cushions tween the Duke and his Uncle the future and her hands are clasped together. King James 11. It ended with the Battle of Sedgemoor on 6th July 1685. The An inscription on one side reads; Duke was captured and cruelly Here lies Hautacia, daughter of William beheaded.] Disney, Lord of Norton. The fifth monument is a framed brass plaque dating Clonmelsh cemetery, Ballyloo, from the 17th century its purpose was to Garryhunden commemorate two generations of Disney’s and is engraved with the Disney There are three Disney tombs in Clon- coat of arms.2 The family lived in this melsh cemetery Co. Carlow, that of area until the 17th century when they Robert Disney born in Carlow 1746 who sided with the Duke of Monmouth in his married Mary Kepple (1750-1815) also attempt to overthrow King James 11. born in Carlow. They married on 2nd After the rebellion failed the Disney Feb. 1775 at St Mary’s Church, Carlow lands were confiscated and most of the town. He died aged 62 on August 28 3 family fled to Ireland. Walt Disney the film maker 1808. Robert Disney died at the home of his son Kepple Disney at Sweethill, On the 30th July 1949 Walt Disney made Permission granted by: Clone, Co. Kilkenny and was buried in a private visit to Norton Disney, he The Walt Disney Co. Clonmelsh cemetery, Garryhunden, filmed and photographed all these Carlow. Mary Disney nee Kepple, his monuments and church registers. The wife, erected the tombstone.6 local parish magazine only recorded this Strabanne and died there in 1692, quiet visit. [Central Library Lincoln.] Thomas [? moved to Carlow], and Robert Disney 1746-1808 Disney around the same time, also Eccles, became High Sheriff of Water- visited, the birthplace of Robert Louis ford in 1757 and lived in Churchtown A closer look at Robert Disney’s origin Stevenson in Edinburgh, while he was Dysert/ Carrick-on-suir [from 11th Nov. will unravel much of the mystery, which making the film Treasure Island in 1743] he died there in 1758. Elizabeth has surrounded the Carlow connection England, which was released on July 19, and Darkis both lived and died in Stra- with Walt Disney’s roots. Until very recent 1950. [See rare photograph taken on banne. research there was no evidence as to the October 15, 1949 by freelance photogra- origin or ancestry of Robert, the great, pher George Konig ] William and Elizabeth [Fowles] Disney great, great grandfather of Walt Disney. had three sons their 3rd son John was Disney’s Carlow ancestry born c1662 and on Feb. 26th 1703 he Robert Disney was born in Carlow in married Jane Brabazon eldest daughter of 1746. He was the son of Richard and By the mid 1600s at least two members James and Mary Brabazon. On 29th Sept. Elizabeth Disney, Richard was born in of the Disney family were living in 1742 John Disney was appointed Mayor 1723 in Sudbury, Suffolk, as was his Carlow. Both Thomas Disney who died of Galway City he died in 1749.5 wife, Richard and Elizabeth died in in Carlow in 1658 and John Disney who Clonmelsh. died in Carlow in 1666, are recorded in These early dated wills of Thomas and the Index to the Act and Grant books and John Disney who died in Carlow in 1658 Richards father was Edward Disney born the Original Wills of the Dioceses of and 1666 prove that the Disney family in 1689 in Brent, Eleigh, Suffolk. He Dublin 1272-1858. [26th, 30th, 31st were settled in Carlow long before the married Elizabeth Lingwood also born in Reports 1894,1899.] Location, Carlow, Monmouth Rebellion which took place 1680 Suffolk. They both died in Suffolk. Ireland.4 in 1685. Records indicate that the Carlow Disney’s were established before the Edwards parents were Mechisodech and On 22nd Nov. 1666, a Patent was passed Kilkenny branch and were in fact ances- Mary [Disnie] Disney both from Brent granting lands in Co Waterford, Co. tors of the Kilkenny branch. The Carlow Eleigh, Suffolk. Louth, and Westmeath to William Disney Disney’s predate the Galway branch, and of Strabanne, Co. Louth and his son were established before, but closer to the Mechisodech died on 21st July 1660, and William. The Strabanne Disney family Louth branch! his wife Mary on 6th Dec.1712 in Brent were living there until 1732. The elder Leigh, Suffolk. branch included Captain Thomas Disney, Whether there is any family connection his brother Lieut. George Disney, his between the Louth branch, and the Although the Parish Register for St. wife Susanna Disney, also in the same Carlow branch needs further research. Mary’s Carlow records the marriage of family were Ebenezer Disney, Mary Robert Disney and Mary Capel [ Kepple, Disney and Benoni Disney. Their [The Monmouth rebellion was led by the the name is of Dutch, Huguenot origin] children were William, who married dashing but doomed James Scott, Duke on 2nd Feb. 1775, it does not give any Elizabeth Fowles of Dublin, they lived in of Monmouth an illegitimate son of King indication as to where they lived or their Carloviana 2016 Tribute to Walt Disney edited 1 Collected - Copy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:03 Page 3

A Carlow tribute to Walt Disney. ‘A dream, ‘A pencil, and a mouse

occupation. However further research in Kepple Disney of Sweethill, Clone, the Public Record Office, Dublin gives Kilkenny this information, it is to be found in Kepple Disney is a key figure in weaving abstracts from the list of Grants of Mar- together the Disney family story. riage Licences for the Diocese of Leighlin. Amongst these documents is a Kepple Disney was the eldest son of the grant to Robert and Mary Disney, which afore mentioned Robert [1746-1808] and states that Robert was a farmer from Mary Disney [Kepple] 1750-1815. He Ratibendonin Co. Carlow [Rathvinden] was born in Aharney parish, Co Laois in close to Leighlinbridge and also 1776. He married Frances Best, daughter to Clonmelsh. of Arundel Caulfield Best10 who was born in Bestville, Carlow 1776 she died Robert Disney and Mary Kepple had in Sweethill, Clone Kilkenny. They nine children; Kepple born 1775, John married on 17th Feb. in 1795 at St. Marys born 1780, George born 1783, Thomas Church, Carlow. born 1786 Mary born 1788 Elinor born 1790, James born 1793, Elizabeth born They had 8 children. 1795 and William born in 1800.7 1. The eldest was Mary Anne born 1795 The other two Disney headstones in in Clone, Kilkenny. Died Nov. 1875 in Clonmelsh Cemetery are to the memory Louisville, St. Lawrence New York. She of Abigale Pain (alias Disney) who died Walt Disney inventer of Mickey Mouse married William Powers [born 1790 in November 29, 1746, aged 28, and Permission granted by: Garrentaggart, Laois] on 20th April George Disney, baker of Dublin who The Patent Office, U.S.A. 1815.in Ireland. died May 9, 1736 aged 53. [address; 10 2. Robert was born on 9 July 1797 in Mill St. Dublin] Clones, Kilkenny. He died on 18 April In 1932, Walt Disney travelled to Leigh- 1872 in Goderich, Huron Co. Ontario. He Thomas Disney of Garryhunden linbridge, Carlow for a private visit to married Jane Cook in 1829 in Kilkenny. Another Carlow Disney was Thomas meet his Disney cousins, still living, in She was born 4 Nov1810 in Ireland, and Disney of Garryhundon who died in Coolnaskisha, Rathornan, and 2 mls from died in 1893 in Goderich, Ontario. 9 1762; he farmed the lands of Garryhun- Old Leighlin. 3. Charlotte was born in 1801 in Clone, den/Clonmelsh. He is possibly related to Kilkenny and died in Jan. 1882 in Lon- Roberts branch, an uncle or cousin, Several documents clarify the Carlow – don England. perhaps.? [Further research on him is Kilkenny Disney connection. 4. Arundel Elias was born in 1803 in required]. He married Elizabeth daughter Clone, Kilkenny. He died on 31May of Samuel Leonard of Garryhunden. On February 17, 1857 the sale of 33 acres 1880 in Goderich Huron Co. Ontario. He Mary Disney, a daughter of Thomas and of land in Clone, Barony of Galmoy, Co married Maria Swan on 1 Sept.1832 in Elizabeth Disney of Garryhunden, Kilkenny owned by the Disney family Clone Kilkenny. She was born in 1816 in married William Warren who was a took place in the Court of the Commis- Ireland. She died 26Sept. 1896 in Ellis, cousin of the Butler family through the sions for sale of Incumbent Estates of Ire- Kansas, USA. marriage of Arrabella Butler, sister of Sir land. The names in which the deeds were 5. Kepple was born 5Sept. 1806 in Thomas Butler 3rd Bart. Knight of held included Henry, Kepple, Arundel Clone, Kilkenny. And died in 1875. He Garryhunden, who married John Warren Elias and Robert Disney, John Swan and married Mary E.B.? in 1830 in England. MP for Carlow 1689.8 William and Mary Power. [court 14, 6. James born 1807 in Clone, Kilkenny. Heneretta St. Dublin.] Died in 1840. George Disney of Tullowcreen, Wells, 7. Frances born 1816 in Clone, Leighlin Further documents related to the Kilkenny. Kilkenny connection of the family may 8. Henry the youngest, was born There is also a George Disney recorded be found in Griffiths Valuation and the on10May 1816 in Sweethill, Clone, as living in Carlow born in 1794 died Electoral Division of Rathbeagh; Kilkenny and died 12April 1877 New 1870. The Parish Register of Old Leigh- York. He married Christina Furney born lin 1794-1802 records members of the Kepple Disney was farming at Sweethill, 17 Feb. 1822, Kildare, Ireland who died Disney family for example September 4, Rathbeagh, this was a union parish of 29 April 1891 New York. They had 5 1797 George Disney son of George and Clomantagh, Freshford, Closhcrow, children born in Ireland, and 5 in New Mary Disney both of the parish of Rathbeag and Sheffin. The census for York.11 Tullowcreen, Wells and Richard Disney 1841 also shows Kepple Disney still baptized on 3rd January 1800 son of the alive and farming at Sweethill, Rathbeag. Disney’s move to America same couple, George and Mary Disney Kepple Disney died in Sweethill, Clone, of the parish of Tullowcreen, Wells. Co. Kilkenny in 1857. In 1834 seven members of this branch of the Disney family sailed on a ship Carloviana 2016 Tribute to Walt Disney edited 1 Collected - Copy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:03 Page 4

A Carlow tribute to Walt Disney. ‘A dream, ‘A pencil, and a mouse

Disney married Lillian Bounds who was employed at their studio as an ink and paint artist. On the strength of Oswald’s success, all seemed to be going well for what was now called Walt Disney Studios. Then a death blow was delivered by Charles Mintz his distributer when he announced that not only had he taken almost all of his animators except his friend Ub Iwerks to work for him but that under the terms of his contract his creation Oswald the Rabbit was the sole property of Universal Pictures and Disney had no rights to the character his studio had created.

Things could not have been worse, on that day in March 1928 when Walt and Lilly left New York for Hollywood. He had lost his film distributor, his cartoon star, and most of his animators. However, he was about to be rescued by a most unlikely hero!.

Walt Disney the story teller Disney recalled in 1948, that Mickey Mouse had first popped out of his mind unto his drawing pad at a time when leaving Liverpool called the ‘New eldest sons Elias (Walt Disneys father) disaster seemed just around the corner. Jersey’ and arrived in New York on 3rd and Robert set out for Southern Calfornia October. An extract of the passenger in search of gold in 1878. They settled for Disney said that on his train journey he sat manifest from this vessel records the a while into farming in Ellias, Kansas. doodling on his sketchpad, hoping for following; Elias Disney married Flora Call on 1 inspiration and a solution to his problems; Seven Disney’s from Sweethill, Clone, January 1888. They had four sons, Her- Out of the trouble and confusion stood a Kilkenny; bert, Raymond, Roy, Walt and one mocking, merry little figure. Vague and 12 Robert Disney aged 36 occupation daughter, Ruth Flora. indefinable at first. But grew and grew. Farmer. And finally arrived----- a mouse.! Arundal Elias Disney aged 33 occupation The Disney brother’s Farmer. The idea completely engulfed me. The Jane Disney [nee Cook] aged 21 wife. When Walt Disney arrived by train, in train- wheels turned to the tune of it. Maria Disney [nee Swan] aged 20 wife. Los Angeles in July 1923, to stay with his Kepple Disney aged 2. uncle Robert his brother Roy was also When Disney was a struggling young Frances Disney aged 4. there, they rented a small apartment near artist, so the tale runs, he befriended a Elias Disney aged 3. the site of their new Hollywood Studio, family of mice that took up residence in an unused storage space where the his waste paper basket. One particular Arundel Elias Disney Disney Brothers officially launched their mouse had become very tame and would Arundel Elias Disney was Walt Disney’s company in 1923 with the help of a loan climb up onto Disney’s Drawing board to great- grandfather. His son Kepple Elias of $500 from their Uncle Robert. Work be fed. Disney (1832-1891) born in Clone [aged began on the first picture animated 2 when he sailed to America], married in entirely by Walt inked and painted by At first this imaginative Mouse was called 1858 Mary Richardson (1838-1909) an two girls hired for $15 a week and Mortimer. Lilly Disney disliked the name Irish emigrant from Aghaboe Co. Laois. photographed by Roy on a second-hand and suggested that he should call him Their son Elias Charles Disney 1859- camera which he had bought for $200. Mickey Mouse and he did. Disney ‘s 1941 was Walt Disney’s father. The completed film was, Alice’s Day at irrepressible optimism was one of his the Sea, after which there were more that strongest attributes. Disney viewed the Arundel and Maria settled on the shores 50 Alice in Cartoonland adventures blow that fate had dealt him as a positive of Lake Huron, in Canada and set up a between 1924-27. Their next film was opportunity; a chance to create a new sawmill. He cleared and farmed 149 Oswald the Rabbit 1926-28. cartoon character. Mickey was neither acres beside his brother Robert who mouse nor man but rather a symbol of farmed 93 acres. They had sixteen Roy Disney married Edna Francis on 7 youth, optimism and adventure. children, the eldest Kepple with his two April 1925 and on 13 July 1925 Walt

Carloviana 2016 Tribute to Walt Disney edited 1 Collected - Copy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:03 Page 5

A Carlow tribute to Walt Disney. ‘A dream, ‘A pencil, and a mouse

In the first Mickey Mouse film entitled Plane Crazy, Disney and Ub Iwerks who was drawing up to 700 drawings a day, worked in secret on it. The scenario they devised was inspired by the exploits of Charles Lindberg who in 1927, had made the first solo, non–stop flight across the Atlantic. This set the trend for many of Mickey Mouse’s earliest escapades.

The next major development was the first sound cartoon, Steamboat Willie, it was a triumph. It was estimated that, in just one year, no fewer than 468 million cinemagoers saw a Mickey Mouse movie. Mickey and I are firm friends Disney once said we have weathered the storms together and indeed for many years life was anything but plain sailing for Walt Disney Studio.

Walt Disney was the first to add synchro- nized sound and, later, full colour to cartoons. He was the first in the age of Walt Disney and the Seven Dwarfs talkies, to produce a feature length animated film. The first animator to exper- He replied: built a company that overcame numerous iment with stereo sound, 3-D, Cinema vicissitudes; initial uncertainties, indus- Scope and Technirama. He was also the Over at our place we’re sure of just one trial unrest, economic slumps, constantly first and only cartoonist to make a success- -thing everybody in the world was once shifting market conditions and eventu- ful break into live-action film–making. a child. We grow up, our personalities ally, even the death of its founder. By the change, but within every one of us sometime of his death on 15 December 1966 The characters from the Disney movies- thing remains of our childhood. It knows in Burbank, Los Angeles, California, whether animated like Mickey Mouse and nothing of sophistication and distinction; Disney’s enterprises had brought him Pinocchio; portrayed by actors and it’s where all of us are simple and trust- respect, admiration, honors, and Oscars actresses in roles such as Long John Silver ing. So, in planning a new picture, we but he will always be remembered as the and Mary Poppins; or inanimate objects don’t think of grown-ups and we don’t man who invented Mickey Mouse.14 like Herbie the Volkswagen-are known think of children, but just of that fine, throughout the world. The creative and clean unspoiled spot down deep in every- The Disney Studio during Walt Disney imaginative use of sound, music, and folk one of us, that the world has maybe made career had produced 21 full-length material made Disney successful and his us forget and maybe our pictures can animated films, 493 short subjects, 47 studio expanded rapidly. help recall. live action films7 true life adventure features 330 of Mickey Mouse Club TV At this point he set up a training school It was a philosophy that was to provide programs 78 half hour Zorro TV adven- where a whole new generation of artists the Studio with a formula that would earn tures and 280 other TV shows. developed and this made possible the it success for decades to come. production of the first feature length car- 13 On18 July, 1957 Disney opened Disney- toon Snow White 1937. Other animated features followed, land in Anaheim, California, the most including Pinocchio, Bambi, and Fanta- successful amusement park in history. In This was a well-timed animated feature sia, and many more. Wild life films 1971 Disney World opened in Orlando, although it was dubbed by the movie began with Seal Island in 1948. Treasure Florida and since then Disney theme industry as Disney’s folly. Few believed Island in 1950 led to the studios major parks have opened in Tokyo Japan and that an audience would sit through a 90 - production of live-action films, which Paris. Walt Disney created and funded a minute cartoon.! This film set the Disney cornered the traditional ‘family market’. new university the California Institute of style. Disney’s folly turned out to be an Disney’s hit Mary Poppins was one of the Arts, known as Cal Arts. enchanted castle. Snow White and the his most successful films, which used Disney once commented; Seven Dwarfs was proof, beyond any occasional animation. doubt, of the genius of Walt Disney and It’s the principal thing I hope to leave his artists. Later in a radio interview With the dedicated help of his brother when I move on to greener pastures. If I Cecil B. de Mille asked Disney to explain Roy and a highly creative staff Disney can help provide a place to develop the the secret of Snow White’s appeal. Carloviana 2016 Tribute to Walt Disney edited 1 Collected - Copy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:03 Page 6

A Carlow tribute to Walt Disney. ‘A dream, ‘A pencil, and a mouse

Lawton also in 2014. In the year 2000 Fr. Lawton’s entire portfolio of music was stolen, he was devasted and had to start writing from the beginning again. After a Jerusalem pilgrimage he produced an album Bethlehem Sky inspired by that journey. One song on his album Under a Thousand Stars focuses on the humanitarian plight of the people of Syria.

Disney Studios shortly afterwards, asked the Irish writer to pen a song to be used in a special retrospective for film classics such as Snow White and Cinderella. The result was the song ‘Beyond Belief’ arranged by Mark Cahill, performed by the Prague Philharmonic Orchestra and sung by the Longford born soprano Emer Barry of Affiniti. It has been chosen as the voice of Disneyland Paris latest campaign. A dream comes true for both a talented and deserving writer and singer.! The song Beyond Belief represents the positivity of life and especially believing in our dreams, that all things are possible if we believe in ourselves.

What a wonderful legacy Walt Disney has left us.!

Acknowledgements

I am grateful to Peter Furney a cousin of the Disney family and to genealogist Paul Gorry from Baltinglass who corre- Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs sponded with me on the Disney Family History. Also to sources, Carlow roots, talent of the future, I think I will have ac- ‘Frozen’, has become the highest gross- Ancestry.com, Find my past, and The complished something.15 ing Disney film of all time. On 13th De- National Library of Ireland Archives. cember 2014 Carlow Childrens Choir ‘Aspiro’ led a Frozen Sing Along to a sell Author’s note. ‘Beyond belief’. out audience in the National Concert When you wish upon a star. Hall, Dublin for a total of three shows. The first film the author saw was Snow . The story ‘Frozen’ was inspired by the White, when aged 3. In the world of Irish film animation, Hans Christian Anderson fairy tale. Its Kilkenny based Cartoon Saloon, estab- music with many classic hits for example ‘My father took me to see it at the Ritz lished by Tom Moore and Paul Young in ‘Let it Go’ has made it an outstanding Cinema, Carlow, it was Christmastime 1999 has grown into a multi-award win- success. Mary Amond O’Brien estab- and I travelled the 2 miles from ning Animation Studio. It received Oscar lished the Carlow Children’s Choir in Kilmeaney to Carlow, as a passenger on Academy Award nominations for The 1997 and it was a dream comes true for fathers James Motorbike ZL 880, sitting Secret of Kells in 2010 and Song of the her and the children to perform to such on a cushion on the front seat, wearing Sea in 2014. Film animation has come a packed and appreciative audiences in the my best clothes, father wore an aviator’s long way worldwide, thanks to Walt Dis- National Concert Hall. helmet and goggles. I was enchanted and ney’s dream, a pencil and a mouse. spellbound by the film, however, I hid Disney’s magic touched the life of under my seat when the witch arrived. One of Disney Studios recent films Carlow Music Director Rev. Fr. Liam For four decades I have been privileged Carloviana 2016 Tribute to Walt Disney edited 1 Collected - Copy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:03 Page 7

A Carlow tribute to Walt Disney. ‘A dream, ‘A pencil, and a mouse

to work in Art Education. Throughout that time film animation and especially the Walt Disney characters have proven to be a source of joy and inspiration for my students. What a wonderful gift imagination is. I am honored that several of my students both in Carlow and Wexford have happily followed careers in film animation. It is with the greatest joy that I write this small tribute to Walt Disney to say thank you to him, and his Studio for all the hours of happiness and laughter he has given us.’

Endnotes:

1 Richard Holliss and Brian Sibley, The Disney Studio Story. Octopus Book Ltd. London. 1988. P12.

2. Jan Winter, Uncle Walt’s Ancestors, Travel Section, The Independent, Sat. 12th April. 1997.

3. Jimmy O’Toole, Carlow’s Interna- tional Achievers. The Leinster Leader, Naas, Kildare, Ireland. 1999, p7-14. Walt Disney visits the birthplace of Robert Louis 4. Index to the Act and Grant books and Stevenson with J.W. Wherries, Vice President of the R.L.S. the Original Wills of the Dioceses of Clubin Edinburgh, rare photograph, October 15th, 1949, Dublin 1272-1858. [26th, 30th, 31st taken by Geoarge Konig. Disney photo Library A 13 Reports 1894,1899.] Location, Carlow, Mounted on linen. 8*10ins. Ireland. The Index to Prerogative Wills of Ireland 1536-1810 and Supplement neglected. Castle in Ring, Cork\ Waterford boarder. 1914 by Sir Arthur Vicars is a useful source. He indexed all wills up to 1810. 7 Peter Furney, Disney Family History, 11 Peter Furney, cousin of Christine This index deals with 40,000 Irish Wills. 2010. Private coll. Furney, who married Henry Disney, [see Almost all destroyed in the 1922 explo- 8 Turtle Bunbury, ref. to the Butler and tree]. Disney Family, 2010, private coll. sion at the Public Record Office in Warren Family, in Disney of Straban- Dublin. Vicar’s publication was based on non, see web. site. 12 Disney Family Tree. Web site. Disney the transcripts and notes taken from the Museum archives. original wills by Sir William Bertham, 9 Martin Nevin, local information and Ulster King of Arms. 1779-1853. Disney archives. The census for Leighlin 13 Richard Holliss and Brian Sibley, The

5 in 1911 records James and Bridget Dis- Disney Studio Story. Octopus Book Ltd. Turtle Bunbury, Disney of Strabannon. ney living in Coolnaskisha, Rathornan, London. 1988. P15. ch2. Enter The the Brabazon connection see web site. Carlow. Aged 42 and 48, and a niece Mouse.

6 Cathleen Mallon aged 16 from America. The Cemetry of Clonmelsh is aban- 14 Ibid. p. 6-7 The House that Walt Built. doned and overgrown, Mrs Dorothy 10 Arundel Caulfield Best, was Frances Leonard of Woodlands, Castledermot Bests father and this is where the unusual 15 Ibid. p.82. ch.12. Practically perfect in while researching the roots of another name of ‘Arundel’ came into the Disney every way. family there, was the first to rediscover family. The name is of Norman-French the Disney tombs. origin it comes from the old French (h) arondel a diminutive of ‘aroud’, a swal- The present author of this article is low. The name is strongly associated with researching the possibility of restoration the Munster Co. of Cork. Arundel Mills and care of the Disney family tombs, for a village in south Cork and also Arundel it is a great shame that they should be so Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 1

The emergence of the Catholic Clergy as a political force was certainly evident in Borris. Here three very strong minded and outspoken priests, Rev John Walsh Snr. PP, his nephew Rev John Walsh Jnr. CC and Rev Buggy CC, opposed Tory The emergence of candidates at every opportunity.7 Fr. John Walsh Snr. was born in Graigna- managh and was the first student to enrol the clergy in Carlow College.8 He was appointed PP of Borris in 1805 and set about repair- ing the local church in Ballymurphy and in building the churches in Rathanna and Tom Joyce Borris. The latter church is on record in Slater’s Leinster Directory of 1881 as Borris costing £2000. He also built the school house in Borris with monies donated Many of the extracts for this article are give the 40-shilling freeholder the right from his political opponents, the taken from the well-researched book by to vote, Catholic or Protestant. This Kavanaghs of Borris House. Fr. John the late Tom Murphy of Borris Co. resulted in the doubling of the number of Walsh Jnr was appointed curate at Borris Carlow. His Book, The Fathers Walsh of registered freeholders in Ireland between in 1823. He was a nephew of John Walsh Borris : Political Intrigue, Murder & 1795 and 1803 to 100,000 as landlords Senior and was also born in Graiguena- Transportation in the 1830s, is an franchised their tenants in order to se- 1 managh. Fr. Buggy was appointed curate extremely valuable source of information cure votes. There is no evidence that in Borris sometime before 1835.9 The on Borris and the surrounding areas Thomas Kavanagh the main landlord in political battle between clergy and during this period. Murphy minutely the Borris area manipulated the tenants politicians was fought out locally but also examines each article in the Tory for electoral advantage. This can be seen publicly in the Tory newspaper, The (Carlow Sentinel) and Liberal (The when comparing two adjoining town Carlow Sentinel and also the Liberal Carlow Morning Post and The Leinster lands in the Parish of Clonagoose (Bor- Carlow Morning Post and indeed from Independent) newspapers, among others, ris), Coonogue and Rathgeran. Coonogue the pulpit when necessary. The two that documents the strengthening control was in the possession of the Earl of Cour- Walsh priests were denigrated and of the clergy in Borris over their congre- town and by 1826 there were forty-seven insulted shamefully by the Sentinel but gation. The account covers a period of tenants listed, forty of them on less than also described quite rightly as turning the rampant sectarianism from both sections ten acres, some as little as one. In the ad- locals of Borris against their landlord of the community. Newspapers of the joining towns land of Rathgeran under Thomas Kavanagh. John Walsh Jnr. in time were careless or worse with the truth the control of the Kavanaghs, the average 2 particular was not afraid to use the press if it suited their agenda. What Murphy acres per tenant was thirty-two. At the to get his point across and sent many achieved was the critical analysis of the time this act looked to have increased the letters to the Sentinel defending his information from each article coupled power of the landlord as they could actions. While the Tory newspaper used with the ability and knowledge to point effectively enfranchise their tenants and almost exclusively biased journalism in out the truth and inaccuracies that were control their votes. As it would turn out their reporting of the disturbances in contained within. This gives the reader this would change when the Catholic Borris, the clergy it seems were also not an excellent feeling for the mood of the clergy realised that controlling these afraid to use any means to convince their day while also maintaining a jaundiced votes could change things in their 3 congregation to oppose Kavanagh. The eye on the vitriol that was contained in a favour. The Catholic clergy in Carlow Church in Borris was used for political large percentage of the reports. Murphy’s were not slow to realise this opportunity meetings, and parishioners were threat- attention to detail is extraordinary and by 1818 there was evidence of 4 ened from the altar, if they voted for throughout the book. Any error is distinct Catholic electoral interest. A Kavanagh or Bruen. referenced back to reliable sources such House of Commons Report on The State as the National Library or Government of Ireland in 1825 would back this up, as Tom Murphy’s book The Fathers Walsh papers of the time. Any contradictory evidence is given of clergy preaching 5 of Borris: Political Intrigue, Murder & stories are exposed and referenced. discontent from the altar. Dr. Doyle, Transportation in the 1830s, details the then professor of Theology at Carlow different meeting and rallies organised in The passing of The Catholic Relief Act College urged Catholic voters to cast Borris and the outlying area around this of 1793 would prove to be a seminal their votes for Robert Latouche, a Whig 6 period. A meeting was held, according to moment in Irish politics and eventually supporter of Catholic Emancipation. He The Carlow Post, in Borris on November its effects would filter down to villages was unsuccessful in this attempt but it 1830 organised by the Borris clergy, like Borris. This act did not allow was only to be the start of a battle be- petitioning Parliament for a repeal of the Catholics access to parliament but did tween the clergy and landlord. Union. Another was held on the follow-

Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 2

12 The emergence of the clergy in Borris

ing April and was again reported in the at the Tithe meetings as the Fr. Walshes.16 with a letter expressing their attachment Post. The first instance of an anti Tithe The Morning Post goes on to describe to him as their landlord and how they organisation is reported in the Carlow two other huge meetings held over the would look to him for advice and Sentinel on the 11th February 1832 when summer of 1832 in St. Mullins and The support. They also indicated that they a meeting was called for the 19th in Cross of Skeough respectively, where the wished to exercise their rights (which Borris.10 This was a replication of a Walsh priests and Thomas Cloney spoke must be presumed their right to vote), and meeting organised in Graiguenamanagh for repeal of the Union.17 The numbers they would look to Kavanagh to ensure under the stewardship of Fr. Martin given for the second meeting were even that they were allowed to do so. Sixty-two Doyle.11 The Sentinel and Post both wel- more extraordinary at 20,000. At the names signed this letter which they comed this meeting with the Sentinel de- Cross of Skeough the tone of John Walsh requested be published in the provincial scribing the priests who called it as Jnr. took on much more political tone as papers.22 Kavanagh wrote back a letter, exemplary and patriotic.12 This would be he used his speech to disparage Henry which was also published in the Sentinel, one of the few compliments bestowed on Bruen, Thomas Kavanagh’s Tory running thanking his tenants for their support. He the priests of Borris over the next few mate and son in law from Carlow, for the assures them of their right to exercise their years from that paper. The numbers re- way he voted for the people of Carlow at elective franchise and his willingness to ported at this meeting are extraordinary parliament. He also highlights how support this right by force if necessary. In with between 7000-8000 people esti- Bruen, after the last election treated his this letter he takes a swipe at the men of mated in the Post. The Post also reported tenant, Mr. Sinnot of Kiledmond Borris. peace who ought to know better, who are the amount of Tithe paid by the locals as After Sinnot had voted against him he inciting.23 This is undoubtedly a reference £385 in the Parish of Kiltinnel and £235 immediately looked for arrears and then to the clergy of Borris but he also declares in the parish of Clonagoose, quite a sum served him with a letter for non-payment. that he will bring to justice the hired ruffi- of money at the time. The Sentinel also Fr. Walsh also highlights Kavanagh’s ans who nightly disturb the peace. The fol- describes how several Protestant gentle- conversion as he describes how once they lowing week the Sentinel carried a letter men attended this meeting and both pa- were hereditary friends of the people but from the Trades People and persons em- pers record the speeches as ecumenical, that a “blasting simoom [sic] has swept ployed by Thomas Kavanagh endorsing encouraging good relations with their them from us.”18 Interestingly although the letter from his tenants and expressing neighbours.13 Bruen resided in Carlow, some thirty similar sentiments. This was signed by miles away, and Kavanagh in the same sixty-five names but as before they are not What is interesting about this meeting is parish his only criticism of Kavanagh is given so it cannot be calculated if these the power that the clergy clearly felt they in relation to his conversion. If Kavanagh were the same people as the first.24 Con- had with the locals. Rev. Walsh Snr.'s had been practising any ill treatment of his sidering that the number of engaged in speech is reported in the Sentinel as tenants then this would have been an ideal trade in Borris in the 1831 Census is given beginning with the line, “I shall address opportunity to highlight this fact. It was as sixty-three then this was a serious en- a few words to you and as Catholic rector not an endorsement of Kavangh but nei- dorsement. There are also twenty-eight of this parish I will expect you to pay ther was it as bitter towards him as that of families listed as engaged in farming of attention to what remarks I am about to Bruen in Carlow. The Kavanaghs’ reputa- which Kavanagh undoubtedly some as his make.” Fr. Walsh Jnr. advised the tion as landlords may have had something records show upwards of fifty people audience on how to frustrate the Tithe to do with this, while Bruen on the other employed on any given day.25 It is little proctor by secreting their cattle and hand had by his own admission a reputa- wonder some of the people of Borris were hiding everything of value.14 This was tion as a severe and grinding.19 coming out in favour of their landlord. sound advice as this very system of preventing Tithe Proctors from securing The first sign of a counter point to the The clergy were not long in responding livestock had begun in the neighbouring priests of Borris came not from Thomas to this barrage from the Sentinel. On the parish of Graiguenamanagh in 1830 and Kavanagh but in the form of a letter to first Sunday of November The Post had been spectacularly successful. One the editor of the Sentinel in November reports that a meeting was held in Borris stipulation of the Tithe collection was 1832 from one of Kavanagh’s tenants. Chapel to propose resolutions to counter- that livestock could not be taken at night- This published letter described how act the address presented to Mr. time and could not be taken from under “most base and dishonest efforts are Kavanagh. Kavanagh responded by lock and key.15 Fr. Doyle in Graiguena- being made to separate Mr. Kavanagh ordering placards erected in the town managh used these loopholes and from his tenants”.20 This was followed a supporting Blackney, his political advised the locals to only allow their week later by a notice of a meeting of opponent, to be torn down, deeming livestock out to graze at night and to lock tenants in support of Thomas Kavanagh. them a trespass on his property.26 The them up during the day. He had also This meeting was held on the 19th Post reports on this meeting: “After last offered to store the cattle prior to sale and October and a resolution was passed that mass Rev Walsh Snr. stated that all who this had brought matters to a head when an address be presented to Kavanagh were attached to their religion and priests one hundred and twenty yeomanry expressing respect and firm attachment should remain in the chapel and all those arrived to take the cattle from the priest’s to him as landlord. Edmond Hagarty, who could not repose confidence in their house. The priests in Borris were not Charles Corcoran and Daniel Kelly were priests he begged withdraw”. After a slow to use their fellow clergy’s methods. appointed to write up the same.21 They considerable pause he drew up three Indeed Fr. Doyle was as regular a speaker completed this task and presented him resolutions that he stated would display Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 3

13 The emergence of the clergy in Borris

that his congregation would not be sepa- troublesome tenants. The land was set to church during this period. A full blown rated from their priests by the machina- four Protestants for the purposes of win- riot was reported in the February 7th tions of any bad Catholics or those who ning subsequent elections according to edition of the Sentinel. Edward Mulligan were their enemies. The first resolution the Kilkenny Moderator. The individual who had apparently opposed the priests stated that they viewed with detestation who took up Walsh’s land apparently be- during the previous election was dragged those who presented the address to Mr. came ashamed of his actions and gave up from the gallery and beaten outside. Kavanagh as it cast measured censure on the land. Walsh again took possession of Some of Mulligan’s friends intervened the conduct of the clergy. The second the land. This story was carried in other outside which prevented him from, resolution simply expressed confidence papers such as the Morning Register, receiving a more severe beating. Three in their priests. The third resolution was Evening Mail, Evening Packet and the witnesses, a Constable Patrick Roach, in regard to the interference of the land- Dublin Evening Post. On the 28th Sep- Richard Kelly and Patrick Holden swore lords with the tenantry and as none of the tember the Sentinel carries an article de- evidence of this incident. Information signatories of the address to Mr. tailing how Fr. Walsh Jnr. had his turf was lodged against all these incidents and Kavanagh were in attendance their ricks torn down and destroyed. Fr. Walsh nine cases were handed over for the names were read from the altar. A Mr. responds to this article on the 5th Octo- Quarter Sessions. One man was found Nolan expressed the belief that some of ber, by vehemently denying that a single guilty and the others were referred to a those who signed the address were now rick of turf had been destroyed mali- later sitting as the jury could not agree. sorry, to, which Rev Walsh replied that ciously. Instead he details how the locals At this sitting Edward Mulligan refuted the people would know how to deal with had come and saved his turf and carried the evidence he had given previously and them.27 Fr. Walsh also stated that who- it back to his house. The Sentinel com- all charges were dropped.34 ever voted for Kavanagh had ceased to mented on this letter stating that Fr. be a member of his Church and was Walsh was more acquainted with the col- In January 1835 the Sentinel has the handed over to Satan.28 lection of his dues rather than with facts. following editorial which is a good Luke Hagarty of Kilcoltrim Borris on the example of the view point taken by “THE CLERICAL AGITATORS” was 26th October wrote a letter to the paper that newspaper. the headline in the Sentinel on March taking exception to Fr. Walsh’s letter in 30th 1833. The paper urges the govern- the Sentinel regarding his turf. He ques- “It appears, that restless and mischievous ment to impose martial law following a tions Fr. Walsh’s facts and states that Fr. politician, the Rev. John Walsh and a few particularly fiery sermon given by Fr. Walsh had, from the altar in Borris, as- of his vulgar satellites, are determined at John Walsh in Ballymurphy. 29 Unfor- serted that his turf had been destroyed all hazards to keep up a system of agita- tunately no detail is given of the homily. maliciously and charged the people in the tion in his parish, in order to preserve his On May 4th it followed up its criticism townsland of Moulon (sic) with the act. popularity and retain some shadow of of Fr. Walsh describing him as “an igno- Fr. Walsh responded to this letter on the authority over the unthinking rabble. A rant agitator, a man possessing less 5th November 1833 and makes a very meeting, we perceive by the Carlow Post knowledge of Latin or polite Literature, poor attempt to divert attention from will take place on tomorrow after last than one of our office messengers, a vul- Hagarty’s letter. His letter veers in sev- mass, for various legal and constitutional gar imperious demagogue…”.30 Obvi- eral tangents but does not adequately purposes and thus after 'prayer', this ous from the article is the fact that address Hagarty’s points. Hagarty again meek and pious pastor will indulge his Thomas Kavanagh had finally had writes in the Sentinel on the 30th Novem- parishioners with a long catalogue of enough of the political interference and ber when he effectively calls Fr. Walsh a Irish grievances and the piety and ardent had moved against some of his tenants, liar and again points out the contradic- attachment of their ancestors to the enforcing arrears and following that up tions in the original letter.32 This goes to priesthood. The altar will once more with eviction. This included Fr. John show that although the Catholic clergy become a proper place to discuss the Walsh Snr., whom Kavanagh moved to was emerging as a strong political force merits of popular representatives and we evict for non-payment of rent according in the Borris area there were Catholic suppose much of the 'recusant Catholics' to the Kilkenny Journal of 22nd October parishioners who were unafraid to take as are attached to their benefactor will be 1883.31 There was also an ejectment them on. denounced as the enemies of the priests order against the parish priest of St. and therefore to all intents and purposes, Mullins. This priest, Fr. Martin Doyle The Carlow Sentinel in the early part of heretics who should be carefully avoided, was the organiser of the Tithe protest in 1835 details several instances of violence for, according to modern demagogues, no Graignamanagh. It reported that the land against people who had voted for the man can be a good Christian nor a sincere was property of Mr. Carroll of Wicklow Tory candidates at the recent election.33 Roman Catholic if he obey not the and Fr. Walsh has been in possession for There are several alleged instances of mandate of the priest with the same pious 20 years. Although Walsh had paid his people being accosted and “hooted at” as defense he would the canons of a general rent he held the land with others who had they were on their way to and from Mass council. The people of Borris have had not. Kavanagh again demanded arrears during this period. The instances were re- opportunities of profiting by the lessons and as a result all were ejected, about ported to have occurred at the chapels in of experience - and if they suffer a wily sixty in number. If the clergy had their Rathanna and also at the parish church in agitator, who cares not one farthing for loopholes to avoid the Tithe Proctor the Borris. A woman was reported to have the people, provided he pockets his dues landlords also had theirs to get rid of been thrown from the gallery in Borris to sever the connection between them Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 4

14 The emergence of the clergy in Borris

and Mr. Kavanagh, they and not the Walsh of Borris. The article is written and the topics which the print has usually priest, will be answerable for the conse- under the heading “The Priest Murdering selected have been of such a lying and quences. By agitation the priest keeps up Faction”, which emotively sets the tone inflammatory character, as to contribute, a sort of artificial excitement to browbeat for the rest of the article:- in no small degree, to swell the tide of and intimidate industrious traders who Conservative odium against these two are attached to a resident gentry; by "The priest murdering factions are terri- Reverend Gentlemen. We all recollect the agitation the priest rouses the bad passion bly annoyed by the verdict given in the distorted tirade of calumnies poured forth of the vulgar and the ignorant and like the case of Mr. Walsh and are consequently against the present venerable Parish dexterous juggler, he turns their credulity straining every point to impugn the deci- priest of Borris, as well as against the to his own advantage, little regarding sion of the jury. The Sentinel is at its old Roman Catholic priests of the county in their temporal or spiritual welfare trade of falsification and misrepresenta- general, by Colonel Bruen. The gallant provided he be regarded as the great idol tion. Its first exception is grounded on the Colonel, not content with misrepresent- of popular worship as a politician. It circumstance of the jury being comprised ing on the hustings, amidst the savage therefore behoves Mr. Kavanagh to look of Roman Catholics: without, however, yells of demi-barbarous Protestants, to the peace of that district and we should even intimating to his readers, that Chief thought proper to repeat, in the British respectfully suggest to him the propriety Constable Hawkshaw had furnished the House of Commons, his unfounded of carefully marking out his dependents coroner with a list of names, indiscrimi- calumnies. The good sayings of the and tenantry as attend those mob assem- nately Catholic and Protestant - that the Colonel were re-echoed all over the blies at his own gate; he will be thereby coroner had called over this list in the county and the low devils of the action be enabled to distinguish the turbulent order of which it had been presented to believe what emanated from his lips and disaffected from the peaceable and him - that of the first twelve names much sooner than they would any one industrious people of that neighbourhood called, five were Protestants - that these portion of the gospel. We mention these and treat them according to their merits. five Protestants did not answer and that, things to show the state of religious feel- The Whitefoot have not latterly disturbed of course the coroner supplied their ing in the County of Carlow and to point that district, after a few agitation meet- places with persons who happened to be out to strangers the deadly hate with ings we shall see how matters will stand; Roman Catholics of such respectability which the Conservative faction pursued but it is, at all events, important that the and integrity, as to defy the imputations the Catholic priesthood. The Sentinel rep- public should know those who cause the so adroitly insinuated by the Sentinel.” resented them as demons incarnate, ruin of our population. Mr. Kavanagh whose extermination from society would resides constantly among his people, The editorial continues in this vein for be a work of piety. Every week the same encouraging industry, opening fresh another page before becoming even more doctrine was inculcated and sent abroad sources of wealth, clothing the poor, emotive and accusatory in its tone gratis to every Conservative in the whilst his amiable family are occupied in county. Damiens confessed that he had administering relief to the sick, educating “No; not all the water which the River been induced to stab Louis the Fifteenth, the children of the poor - in fact, blessing Barrow shall pour into the ocean till the from hearing the harangues of the Parlia- and being blessed; and yet, at such a day of eternity, will ever be able to wash ment of Paris; and as human nature is gentleman's gates do a gang of heartless out the conviction that the Rev. John everywhere the same, may we not easily political incendiaries meet for the Walsh fell a victim to Conservative suppose, that some of the ignorant and purpose of abuse, misrepresentation and hatred and fury. The Sentinel well knows enthusiastic Conservatives in the. region sheer opposition to his known wishes. that Mr. Walsh was murdered by some of Slyguff, by constantly reading or hear- Mr. Kavanagh, we trust, will have a strict person or persons of the faction: he has ing read to them the extravagant and high watch on their proceedings and such as too much sagacity not to foresee the wrought declamation of the Sentinel repay his kindness by joining in those consequences to his party and therefore against the Catholic clergy, were led to conventions, we hope he will take care to is he so anxious to remove the perpetra- perpetrate the atrocious murder, which, afford them sufficient leisure to repent tion of the horrid act to some other quar- at the moment cries to Heaven for hear- for their ingratitude. Peace and content- ter. But in vain! The murder was ing read to them the extravagant and high ment, there can be none, until such Conservative - exclusively Conservative; wrought declamations of the Sentinel persons are brought to a sense of Conservatives have the sole and entire against the vengeance? For vengeance their duty.” merit of the execrable deed; and be the did we say? Yes, but the only vengeance blood of the victim upon them and upon we seek is that warranted by the laws of This article would indicate that despite their children's children. the country. We desire no lex talionis, no the bluster the Tory press was concerned law of private retaliation, or revenge; we with the emerging influence of the Mr. Walsh had, by his zeal and activity, disclaim the right of any individual to Catholic clergy in Carlow. Although the been long obnoxious to the bloodstained arrogate to himself the vindication of the Carlow Sentinel was biased, bigoted and faction. Of all the priests in the diocese, laws; but we hope, we trust, we confide, at times simply untruthful it did not have perhaps himself and his venerable uncle, that before long some clue will be given a monopoly on these characteristics. The the venerable Parish priest of Borris, to lead to the conviction of the miscre- following is an extract from the Leinster were most detested by the murdering ants, who imbued their hands in the Independent on August 15th 1835. It is crew. The Sentinel has constantly blood of a priest of the living God, with- an editorial on the death of Fr. John directed its virulent attacks against both out any provocation having been given Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 5

15 The emergence of the clergy in Borris

on his part, save his endeavors to stem K.T. Hoppen describes Carlow as one of Doyne, a magistrate of Carlow and the torrent of squireen despotism and to Ireland’s leading contenders in the under-agent of Thomas Kavanagh, who, guide the people, not merely in the duties corruption stakes, declaring that it was they alleged, was stationing a company of religion, but in their social relations, unambiguously up for sale to the highest of soldiers at the entrance to the church by exhorting them to make a proper use bidder.35 The highest bidder in fact in in Borris. This prevented the priests from of the elective franchise, which had been this election was on the Tory side. Henry being able to say Mass for two Sundays given them by the Reform Bill, for the Bruen expended £5000 on expenses on in a row. The three priests who signed the common benefit of us all and not to serve one of the 1835 elections.36 Lack of letter stated that if they allowed the the isolated purposes of a faction, whose political leadership would only fuel the parishioners to attend then the most de- darling object is the overthrow of liberty, unrest on both sides. To give an idea of plorable consequences would follow. The the establishment of oligarchical despot- how much Borris was split during this following correspondence which carries ism and the perpetration of abuses in both period, one troop of Dragoons and one on for several months shows in stark de- Church and state. Such was the course company of the 51st Regiment were tail the level of suspicion and detesta- pursued by the Rev. John Walsh and for stationed in Borris during the elections of tion between the two parties. this was he marked out for destruction. 1835.37 Desmond Keenan in his book In a former number of the Independent Ireland 1800-1850 writes of bitter in- To His Excellency Lord Haddington, we styled the Orangemen "Children of fighting in Carlow in January 1835 be- Lord Lieutenant, General Governor and Blood," and so indignant did the Sentinel tween Catholics who wished to vote for Governor of Ireland. affect to feel on the occasion, that the the local landlord and the priests who fellow worked himself up into one of wished to support O Connell. The new We, the undersigned Roman-catholic those ranting fits so characteristic of him. bishop , Dr. Edward Nolan who had suc- clergy, officiating in the parish of Borris, We now repeat the epithets, careless to ceeded Doyle allowed political priests to county of Carlow, most respectfully beg whom they may give offence. We shall canvass Catholic voters.38 It was also leave to solicit your Excellency's protec- never forget the blood-thirsty disposi- during this 1835 election that Kavanagh tion for the free and peaceable exercise tions manifested by the Orangemen at the was accused of cooping his freeholders of our religion. On the last and the late Carlow election; we well remember at Borris House. This was reported in the preceding Sunday we were obliged to their dirks and daggers and loaded butts Sentinel just before the second election close our chapel and refrain from the and pistols, as well as their wicked, of 1835. At a meeting in St. Mullins os- public exercise of the rites of our although unsuccessful attempt to deal de- tensibly to protest against the Tithes but religion. We have been induced to adopt struction among their Catholic country- really to drum up support for the Liberal this extraordinary and unprecedented men. All these were acts which well candidates, Fr. Walsh and Thomas course by the conduct of Robert Doyne, became children of blood and were but a Cloney, leader of the 1798 attack on Bor- Esq., a magistrate of this county, and warning prelude to the awful tragedy ris House were addressing the gathering. under-agent to Thomas Kavanagh, Esq., enacted on the Bridge of Kilgreany. Kavanagh had obviously prior notice of one of the representatives for this county. the meeting and he arrived with a troop On Sunday the 8th instant, Mr. Doyne We have suffered ourselves to be borne of military from Goresbridge. He seems went to Goresbridge, in the county of along much further in these observations to have persuaded them to travel with Kilkenny, and brought with him a than we had either intended or wished; him to Borris House where they were company of soldiers, to have them but when we find such bold sophisticated “protected” until polling day. Lady stationed at the entrance to the chapel of statements put forth by the lying Sentinel, Kavanagh describes in her diaries how Borris, for the purpose of preventing for the purpose of misleading public opin- over sixty of the freeholders were some voters for Mr. Kavanagh being ion, the blood boils within our veins and brought to stay by Charles Doyne, hooted by the people, and, in case they we feel more than ordinary difficulty to Kavanagh’s agent, in July 1835 before met any opposition, to force an entrance restrain ourselves from launching forth the second election. The Chapel was for them into the House of God. On last into execrations against the diabolical prepared as their dormitory. There is Sunday the military and all the police faction, who never were content until they mention of ale and dancing and she attended for the same object. We are spilt the blood of the priesthood and of- recounts that she was “without sleep informed that they are to attend on next fered it up, as a libation at the shrine of yesterday”.39 If this was the reception Sunday, for the same purpose. We are Toryism. The Sentinel may as well desist; they received at Borris House it might convinced that if we permitted the the public have decided - and that deci- not have taken much persuasion in St. people to assemble on either of these sion is - that the Rev. John Walsh has been Mullins to get them to come. Both sides days, the most deplorable consequences murdered by some person or persons in the elections carried out this cooping would most probably have followed. We belonging to the Conservative faction.” of voters and the tenants did not seem too were obliged to have the chapel closed, bothered it.40 and not permit the people and the This is but one sample from both papers military to come in collision. The excite- of how the clergy in Borris were revered There is also detailed correspondence ment usually following a contested and reviled in equal measure. It also between the clergy of Borris and The election was, previous to this occurrence, shows that a real struggle was emerging Lord Lieutenant of Ireland during 1835 gradually subsiding, and would before between the Tory politicians and the available.41 This details the complaints this have entirely ceased, had not the clergy for control of the people. of the clergy of Borris about Robert military been ordered to attend under Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 6

16 The emergence of the clergy in Borris

arms at the chapel. their wives and families inhumanly not take up their quarters within a quarter beaten. These occurrences took place in of a mile of the chapel, although stated We most respectfully and earnestly some instances in the presence of the by the Messrs. Walsh and Buggy they beseech your Excellency to give direc- priests, without the slightest exertion on were stationed at the entrance to the tions for the military to discontinue ap- their parts to prevent those outrages and chapel, or, as they pray, in their memo- pearing armed at the entrance of our scandalous violation of the public peace, rial, "We beseech your Excellency to place of religious worship, for whilst they as will appear by the enclosed copy of give directions for the military to discon- continue to do so, we cannot assemble sworn information, marked No. 1. tinue appearing armed at the entrance of the people to worship their God, fearing our place of religious worship," being that murder would follow. In the chapel of Borris, one man, named stationed in the Sessions-house at the end Edward Mulligan, was assaulted, of the town, the chapel being at the other We humbly conceive that the ordinary dragged out into the yard, where he was extremity. So far I trust I have, to the course of administering the law is quite knocked down, pelted with stones, and satisfaction of his Excellency, refuted the sufficient to punish any violation of it, but for the humane interference of some statements made by the memorialists, which might arise from the causes we of his friends, he most probably might and on a perusal of the enclosed informa- have mentioned. have been killed. As a resident magis- tions, I confidently hope he will find that trate, I was called upon by several I acted in my official capacity with as We look to your Excellency's impartiality Roman-Catholics to afford them the much prudence as the circumstances of to remove the pretext of exciting the protection of the laws, and in the impar- the case required. The memorialists religious feelings of the people. tial discharge of my duty, I advised the further state, that the " ordinary course of persons upon whom assaults were administering the laws was quite Whilst we remain, &c. committed to summon the parties to the sufficient to preserve the peace;" in reply petty sessions of Borris, on the 6th of to which I have only to observe, that (signed) John Walsh, P. P. February, upon which occasion there where the Roman-catholic clergymen Richard Buggy, R.C.C. were nine magistrates upon the bench, had been mainly instrumental in produc- John Walsh, 11.C.C. among whom were Messrs. Blackney ing the fierce excitement which led to and Vigors; four men were ordered to breaches of the peace, and where men's This letter was obviously passed on to find bail to appear at the next quarter lives were openly threatened, some Robert Doyne and he quickly sessions for trial, for the assault upon beaten, and a young female thrown from responded;- Mulligan as above referred to. Before the the gallery of the chapel of Borris, I had court rose, the said Edward Mulligan no alternative but to call upon the Borris, Goresbridge, 5th March 1835. asked for protection on the following military ; and I here solemnly state, that Sir, Sunday; and as Messrs. Walsh and in no instance did I directly or indirectly I have the honour to acknowledge the Buggy, by the most inflammatory make any invasion on the religious receipt of your letter, dated 26th ult., speeches from the altar, had kept the feelings of the people, but on the enclosing a memorial of the Rev. Messrs. people in a state of great excitement; contrary, my object was to protect the Walsh and Buggy, Roman-catholic fearing a breach of the peace, I ordered respectable Roman-Catholics in the due clergymen of Borris, complaining, as the military to attend from Goresbridge. exercise of their right as British subjects, they state, of my having, upon two On their arrival they occupied the inn, to attend their place of worship without successive Sundays, placed a military which is so situate as not to be even in molestation. party at the entrance to their place of view of the chapel, nor within I suppose religious worship, and requesting that I 600 yards of it; and I have the honour to I have now the honour to inform you, that would furnish, for the information of his assure you, for the information of his since the excitement ceased, the military Excellency the Lord Lieutenant, a state- Excellency, that so far from appearing at have not been called upon; and I cannot ment of the circumstances under which I the entrance to the chapel, which is the help here stating, that the Roman- ordered the troops to attend on the whole complaint of the memorialists, the catholic clergymen, in refusing to say occasions in question. military never made their appearance in Mass, on pretence of having the military the streets after they took up their quarters in the town, intended by this subterfuge In reply I beg to state, that for three on their arrival. The memorialists assert, to keep up excitement to serve their own weeks after the election, the parish of that I intended to force an entrance into the purposes, by intimidating those electors Borris was in a state of total insubordina- chapel in case any opposition were given who voted contrary to their mandates, so tion. At every chapel throughout that to the electors; this I deny in the most as to prevent their doing so upon any extensive district, large masses of the unqualified terms; for my object was to future occasion; in fact it was their mode peasantry assembled at the chapels and preserve the peace, and in doing so, as will of commencing a new canvass, upon in the public roads on each successive appear by the accompanying documents, which principle they have acted since the Sabbath-day, and savagely ill-treated 1 adopted the best course to prevent the close of the poll at the late election, by a such of the Roman-catholic electors as possibility of a collision between the total prohibition from their presence of voted for Colonel Bruen and Mr. military and the populace. those of their miscreant flock, as they Kavanagh. Their pews were entered, the termed those who disobeyed them; and electors dragged out of the chapels, and On the second Sunday the military did one priest, within my hearing, went so far Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 7

17 The emergence of the clergy in Borris

as to say, in reply to an elector (who a your Excellency, that they did not state Mr. Kavanagh, entering their pews, and few moments before had been dragged (as Mr, Doyne asserts*) that the military dragging them out of the chapels, &c. out of the chapel), on his appealing to were placed at the chapel, but that he &c, without the slightest exertion of the him if he (the elector) had not as much brought a company of soldiers from clergy to prevent these outrages.“ Your right to go to his devotions as another, Goresbridge to have them stationed at the memorialists most positively and "that he had no business in the house of entrance of the chapel, and that the mili- solemnly assure your Excellency that the God," or in his own words, "What tary came for that purpose: one of your above statement is unfounded and false, brought you there?" memorialists as informed by Lieutenant and they most earnestly solicit the most King, of the 89th, who, when memorial- rigid inquiry into its truth. Memorialists They have also preached the doctrine of ist waited on him to know if he came to take this opportunity of informing your exclusive dealing, and for the people to town for the purpose of attending with Excellency, that the only voter who was hold no communion whatever with the his men at the chapel on that day, he ever taken out of any chapel in this supporters at the election of the represen- informed memorialist that he was parish, or so assaulted, was a person tatives for this county. brought for that purpose, when called on named Mulligan, and that he came into by the magistrate. the chapel at the conclusion of Mass, and I have, &c. that he was accompanied by several other (signed) Robert Doyne, J.P. This interview took place half an hour persons in the employment of Thomas before the usual time for first Mass; and Kavanagh, Esq., who assaulted the Doyne also enclosed several statements immediately after Mr. Hawkshaw, the people in the chapel-yard before Mulli- from two constables, an army officer, a police chief, with his men, with fixed gan was taken out of the chapel; they local labourer and a local farmer which bayonets, marched up and down the street were convicted of this offence, and fined refuted the accusation of preventing before the chapel; under these circum- by the magistrates, which fine memorial- Mass from taking place. The Lieutenant stances, your memorialists determined not ists are ready to prove. Mr. Doyne prom- who controlled the army on the day in to have Mass in the chapel, and dispersed ised to pay. The persons who assaulted Borris also provided a letter stating that the people then assembled, and there Mulligan were two or three women and the army remained at the courthouse in being no persons at the chapel, the mili- children, strangers, and in no way con- Borris and never came in sight of the tary had no pretext for appearing there. nected with this parish. Chapel. This information is forwarded from the Lord Lieutenant back to the In reply to Mr. Doyne's first assertion, " Memorialists beg to state, that no outrage clergy in Borris. The clergy replied back that for three weeks after the election, the occurred in the presence of any one of to this letter with the following:- parish of Borris was in a state of total them, and whenever they perceived the insubordination," we beg leave to assure slightest disposition to disturbance, they your Excellency, that this is not the truth; immediately suppressed it. And on the day To His Excellency Lord Haddington, on the two Sundays next after the elec- that Mulligan was assaulted, the parish Lord Lieutenant, General Governor, and tion, the people attended at and retired priest declared, before commencing Mass, Governor of Ireland. from the different chapels in this parish that if there was any disturbance or without manifesting the slightest disorder in the chapel he would not say The Memorial of the undersigned symptoms of disturbance. Your memori- Mass. The same admonition was given at Roman-catholic Clergy of the Parish of alists beg leave to inform your Excel- first Mass, and in all the country chapels. Borris, County Carlow, humbly showeth, lency that the first cause of excitement in that your Memorialists feel grateful to this part of the county originated with Mr. Your memorialists feel much concern your Excellency for communicating to Doyne. He caused fireworks and illumi- that expressions so injurious to their them the substance of Mr. Doyne's nations to be got up to celebrate the characters should go before the public defence, forwarded to your Excellency in return of Colonel Bruen and Mr. through the medium of the press, before answer to the charges preferred against Kavanagh; numbers of the country they ever heard they were made, or him by your memorialists in their memo- people attended, and were conducting received your Excellency's answer to rial of the 17th of last February. We feel themselves most peaceably and orderly, their memorial. Your memorialists solicit happy in being able to furnish your when they were driven by Mr. Hawk- from your Excellency's impartiality an Excellency with such answers to Mr. shaw and the police out of the town, the opportunity of vindicating their charac- Doyne's statements as we are confident police acting as partisans by illuminating ters, and proving by the must incontro- will amply vindicate the character of the their barracks: this treatment so irritated vertible evidence, that the charges inhabitants of this part of the county from the people, that had one of your memori- preferred by Mr. Doyne against them are the charges brought against them by Mr. alists not interposed, the most deplorable literally untrue. Doyne, and also convince your Excel- consequences might have ensued. lency that your memorialists are inca- In reply to Mr. Doyne's assertion, that a pable of submitting to your Excellency's Mr. Doyne secondly states, " that at every young girl was thrown from the gallery consideration any statement not founded chapel in this district large masses of the of the chapel of Borris, or from the on truth. peasantry assembled and savagely gallery of any chapel in this parish, it is ill-treated such of the Roman-catholic false and unfounded, no such occurrence Your memorialists beg leave to inform electors as voted for Colonel Bruen and having ever taken place. Your memorial- Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 8

18 The emergence of the clergy in Borris

ists beg leave to inform your Excellency, saw the transaction, though the street was night. The Lord Lieutenant again that Kelly's Inn, where the soldiers full of people. forwards this information to the priests in stopped the first day, and the Court- Borris and plainly states that there is no house, where they were stationed the 4th. evidence of wrongdoing by the police. second Sunday, command a direct view That they never made at the time or He does admonish the action of illumi- of the chapel. Your memorialists solicit since, or thought of making, any com- nating of the barracks on the night but from your Excellency the most strict plaint or application for redress, either to notwithstanding this it makes the inquiry into the truth of the facts stated the police authorities, to the magistrates complainants seem somewhat foolish. by Mr. Doyne. And your memorialists of the district, to their own clergy, or to What is probably most interesting about shall ever pray. any other individual; and were not this correspondence is that the clergy of informed that any complaint of this na- Borris were comfortable enough to (signed) John Walsh, P. P. ture was to be preferred until Saturday publicly denounce Doyne, a Justice of John Walsh, R.C.C. last, the 4th instant. the Peace. They were also willing to Richard Buggy, R. C. C, publicly articulate their poor opinion of Borris, 19 March 1835. With regard to the 2d charge, " that the the police and their actions in Borris. The police acted as partisans in illuminating clergy clearly felt that they were now in The Lord Lieutenant replied to this letter their barracks," while I admit that it a position to be the voice of the Catholic stating that he felt that no good would would have been more discreet in Mr. parishioners in Borris. This despite some come from investigating this further. He Hawkshaw at once to have ordered the of the Catholics of Borris obviously not did indicate that an inquiry would be held few candles which the women had placed supporting this view. The priests were into the illuminating of the police bar- in some of the windows (to protect them unafraid to use both the public periodi- racks and driving the people of Borris out from being broken) to be extinguished, cals of the day but also to complain to the of the town on the same night. A Petty yet I trust his Excellency will make every political masters of Ireland at the time. Session was held in Borris to enquire into allowance for the circumstances in which What is also revealing is that these polit- these complaints on the 6th April 1835. this really humane and excellent officer ical leaders were willing to entertain Sir John Harvey was tasked with the was placed, in being suddenly called out these complaints and in this case order investigation and he swiftly drafted his from where he was at dinner to quell a enquiries when necessary. This would reply to the Lord Lieutenant. riot which, I think the evidence of Mr. have sent a clear message to the local Doyne and the sergeant of police, as well politicians and civil authorities that they “The Minutes of Evidence taken before as that of Mr. Charles Corcoran, a could not ride roughshod over the clergy me, 1 have the honour to enclose, and to respectable Roman-catholic inhabitant, without repercussions. submit as my opinion, and report, with proved was threatening to become very reference to them and to the facts then serious, the town being full of ‘strangers, These are but some samples of the elicited, and to those which have other- and others, not in Mr. Kavanagh's inter- opprobrium which was dished out in the wise come to my knowledge, that in est, armed with bludgeons, &c. &c.’ And local press at the time. It points to a clearing the streets of the town of Borris I also beg to draw his Excellency's atten- deeply divided parish in Borris where the on the evening referred to, the chief tion to the fact stated in Mr. Hawkshaw's landlords and the clergy fought out for constable and police acted under the letter, which appears to me to prove that the loyalty of the locals. The press was positive and repeated orders of the only police could not fairly be suspected of invariably biased and agitated in its own magistrate in the village, and that it has being partisans of the two Protestant right. No opportunity was missed to not been proved by any concurrent testi- candidates, viz. that six out of the nine of denigrate the opposition and promote mony that any act of intemperance or which the party was composed were divided feelings among the populace. violence on the part of the chief constable Roman-Catholics. Due to space constraints only a very or the police was committed against small sample of the newspaper coverage any individual. I have, &c, and the other information that Tom Murphy gathered is given here. His book Those who have sworn the contrary have (signed) J. is full of more examples that are well all been compelled to admit: Harvey, Inspector General. worth perusing. Sir William Gosset, K.C.H,” 1st That they sustained no bodily hurt Footnotes: or injury. Harvey supplied the testimony of all the 1 P.J. Jupp, ‘Irish Parliamentary Elections and the individuals involved and while it would Influence of the Catholic Vote, 1801-20’, in The Historical Journal, x, no.2 (1976), pp. 183-196. ; 2nd. appear that the police were heavy handed Whyte, ‘Landlord Influence at Elections in Ireland That they could not identify any one of on the night, a couple of hundred people 1760-1885’, pp. 740-760. the policemen by whom they were had gathered in Borris on this particular 2 Garrett Bolger, ‘Coonogue Evictions’, in Carlo- viana, no. 44 (1996), p 60. “charged with fixed bayonets." night so it may have been the case that 3 Whyte, ‘Landlord Influence at Elections in Ire- the police had to take control quickly. land 1760-1885’, pp. 740-760. 3rd. That being the case, there would also 4 Jupp, Irish Parliamentary Elections, pp. 183-196. That they are unable to bring forward a seem to be evidence of intimidation of 5 House of Commons, First Report from the Select single witness of their own party, who some of the inhabitants of Borris on the Committee on the State of Ireland 1825. Evidence Carloviana 2016 Emergency of clergy in Borris edited Colected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:51 Page 9

19 The emergence of the clergy in Borris

of Denis Browne, “Formally tenants would support 11-20. 34 Murphy, pp. 47-56. the landlord – latterly religious feelings frequently 18 Murphy, The Fathers Walsh of Borris, p 18. 35 K.T. Hoppen. Elections, Politics and Society in carry the tenants away from the landlord, particu- 19 Whyte, ‘Landlord Influence at Elections in Ire- Ireland, 1832—85, (Oxford, 1984), pp. 77-84. larly through the activity of the clergy”. Daniel O land 1760-1885’, pp. 740-760. 36 Malcolm, ‘'The Reign of Terror in Carlow', Connell in the same report questions the influence 20 Murphy, The Fathers Walsh of Borris, pp. 20-21 pp.64- 65. of the clergy. 21 Ibid, p 21. 37 Tom Murphy, The Fathers Walsh of Borris Po- 6 Jupp, ‘Irish Parliamentary Elections and the In- 22 Ibid. litical Intrigue, Murder & Transportation in the fluence of the Catholic Vote, 1801-20’, pp.740-760. 23 Ibid, pp. 21-22. 1830’s, Borris, p89 7 Murphy, The Fathers Walsh of Borris, pp. 11-45. 24 Ibid, p 38 Desmond Keenan, Ireland 1800-1850, Dublin, 8 Ibid, p 5. 25 Online Historical Population Reports University 2001, chapter 13. 9 Ibid, pp. 5-9 of Essex, 1831 Census, www.histpop.org, accessed 39 Diary of Lady Harriet Kavanagh, Borris, County 10 Ibid. on the 11th February 2011. Carlow, which makes a number of references to the 11 Joyce, Graiguenamanagh A Town and its People, 26 Murphy, The Fathers Walsh of Borris, p 23. elections in County Carlow, c1835-1839 (PRONI, p158. 27 Ibid, pp. 23-25. D/3235, 3617) 12 Murphy, The Fathers Walsh of Borris, p 11. 28 The London Quarterly Review, volume lxviii, 40 Bolger, Coonogue Evictions, p60 13 Ibid, pp. 11-16. June and September 1841. Fr. Walsh was also re- 41 Copies of a correspondence between the Roman 14 Ibid, p 13. puted to declare that anyone who voted for Ka- Catholic priests of the parish of Borris in the 15 Ibid, p 170. ; Patrick O’Donoghue, ‘Opposition vanagh would be refused all religious rites and County of Carlow, Robert Doyne a magistrate ... to the Tithe Payments in 1830-31’, in Studia Hiber- would suffer everlasting punishment. and the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland on the subject nica, no.6 (1966), pp.69-98. 29 Murphy, p 28. of the alleged attendance of the military at Roman 16 Joyce, Graiguenamanagh A Town and its People, 30 Ibid, p 29. Catholic chapel in Borris, available at pp. 157-73. ; Murphy, The Fathers Walsh of Borris, 31 Ibid, pp. 35-40. http://www.dippam.ac.uk/eppi/documents/10964/p pp. 11-20. 32 Murphy, pp 36-46 age/249103. Also available at Parliamentary Pa- 17 Joyce, Graiguenamanagh A Town and its People, 33 Carlow Sentinel, various publications from 01st pers, House o p144. ; Murphy, The Fathers Walsh of Borris, pp. January 1835- March 1835.

Courtesy: Tom Somers archives

Carloviana 2015 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 1

At one time known as“The Lodge”, which was or became a Bagenal prem- Eastwood House ises with an avenue, part of which grew into a town, Bagenalstown, in the and the townland of Moneybeg, Co. Carlow. Moneybeg Demesne

Myles Kavanagh

Wales circa 1556. They had 9 Children, 6 girls and 3 boys. The 3 boys were Henry, Dudley and Ambrose. Ambrose died without issue. Henry (1556 – 1598) a soldier and politician lived at Newry and Wales. He was killed in action in the Battle of the Blackwater on the 14 August 1598 when his army was cut to pieces by Hugh O’Neill his brother-in-law.

Sir Nicholas bought a large estate of lands for his son Dudley in Idrone, County Carlow in 1585 from the Carews who had ousted the Kavanaghs, the original owners of the land. Dudley married firstly Katherine Nangle and they had one child, Nicholas (1582 - 1607). He married secondly Mabel Fitzgerald and they had 3 children George (died 1625), Adam, and Eleanor Eastwood House pre-1968 (died November 1632). and town of Bagenalstown. The town- Introduction land in its early stages was the property Dudley lived in the Barony of Idrone, of the Kavanagh Dynasty. It then came County Carlow and held the office of Moneybeg is a townland of 366 acres, 1 into the hands of the Carews who Constable of the Castle at Leighlinbridge rood, 22 perches, on the east side of the managed to coexist in a civil manner with between 1585 and 1587. He started a river Barrow in the Civil Parish of the Kavanaghs until the arrival of feud with the Kavanaghs and in 1587 he Dunleckney, Barony of East Idrone in Dudley Bagenal. was killed by the Kavanaghs in an Co. Carlow. A townland is a small ambush at Ballymoon. Nicholas Bagenal, geographical division of land of Gaelic The Bagenals son of Dudley from his first wife Kather- origin predating the Norman invasion ine Nangle, on the 5th October 1602 was and most have names of Gaelic origin. In 1539 Nicholas Bagenal fled England appointed Constable of the Castle at The name Moneybeg was anglicised after killing a man in a brawl. He became Leighlinbridge. He married Anne from the Irish Muine Bheag which a mercenary under Con Bacach O’Neill, Colclough daughter of Sir Thomas translates as “Small Shrubbery/Thicket”. chief of the O’Neills of Tyrone. Through Colclough and Marta Loftus who lived at In a map of 1640 it is spelt Moniebegge the influence of O’Neill Nicholas got a Tintern Abbey Co. Wexford. Nicholas and described as “Arable and Heathy”; “General pardon of all murders and was killed in a duel in Dublin in 1607. He other variations of spelling also appear felonies by him committed” granted in appears to have been the last of the elsewhere e.g. Monyibegge, Moneybegg, Westminster, 2nd March 1543 by Bagenals that occupied the Castle Monybegge, Monibeg and Monabeg. Henry V111. at Leighlinbridge. The following article explores the origins of the establishment of two Lodges and Nicholas later circa 1552 was granted George Bagenal son of Dudley from his a Mill in this townland but in particular Newry Castle Co. Down with substantial second wife Mabel Fitzgerald married one Lodge which became known as East- lands and lived at Newry. He married Jane Fitzgerald, daughter of Garrett wood House in the latter half of the 19th Eleanor Griffith daughter of Edward Fitzgerald and married secondly, Joanne century from which grew the Demesne Griffith, Penrhyn, Caernarvonshire, Butler, daughter of Walter Butler 11th

Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 2

21 Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

Earl of Ormonde and inherited constructed road, firstly named New Moneybeg at various times included Nicholas’s estates. George it appears was Road and now known as Bachelors Walk. Thomas Payne, Daniel Keohler, Thomas the builder of the first family home at It was an extension of the then Main Singleton, Samuel Ward and Robert Dunleckney circa 1607 - 1612. He held Street, now known as Regent Street. The Brown to name but a few. the office of M.P. for County Carlow in New Road continued on and joined the 1613. A period of peace and prosperity northern entrance road to the town by the The dates of the construction of the two followed for the Bagenals until the river bank. lodges (Lodge alias Eastwood House and Catholic Rebellion of 1641 and the arrival of Cromwell’s army in 1649. The Bagenals in Ireland held on to the Catholic faith. Thomas Bagenal was deported to Connaught in 1641 and Colonel Walter Bagenal was executed in Kilkenny in October 1652. The Bagenals lost their entire estates following Walter’s execution. They were restored to Walter’s son Dudley in 1660.

At the battle of the Boyne in 1690, Dudley Bagenal commanded an Infantry Regiment for the army of King James 11 and in the wake of the Williamite victory the Bagenals once more forfeited their estates. Eastwood Estate as per Griffith’s Valuation Survey 1852 In exile in France, Dudley became Gentleman Usher to King James at the Court of St. Germain. King James ll died the Lodge Mill House) and the mill in the on the 6th September 1701 at St. The Two Lodges townland of Moneybeg is not clear. The Germain-en-Laye, near Paris. Dudley Lodge (Eastwood House) still exists and died at Bruges in 1712. The first construction that became the has been inhabited since its first recorded Lodge may have been inhabited by a time and perhaps its time of construction After another period of time Dudley’s Kavanagh or a Carew and then came a in one form or another. The building eldest son Walter Bagenal (c.1670– Bagenal, followed by the Vigors, Mercer itself conveys signs that additions of one 1745) became a Protestant and regained and Weld families. The following names kind or another have occurred during its the estates. Walter started the formal appear in early deed dealings and other time up to the present day e.g. workers at building of the town that became known communications of the Lodge and the estate uncovered evidence of the front as Bagenalstown. Walter’s second wife Demesne lands at intervals – Rev. of the building having extended a consid- was Eleanor Beauchamp of Ballyloughan Edward Vigors, Edward Mercer, Richard erable length westward in the past. Castle and they had a son, Beauchamp, Mercer, Luke Mercer, Simons Mercer, born in 1735, who would be remembered Michael Carter, William Chaigneau Therefore, one could assume that a as the most famous of all the Bagenals. Colville. The widow, Issamy Quinn’s Bagenal may have constructed the first In 1745 he succeeded to the Estate and name appears also holding land contain- Lodge or Lodges in the townland of his extravagant lifestyle led to the sale in ing 24 acres 2 roods or thereabouts of the Moneybeg prior to the residence at all of 32,000 acres. He died in 1802. He Demesne. Owen Murphy’s name appears Dunleckney or inhabited the premises was succeeded by his daughter Sarah in a deed as a Miller of the Lodge Mills already established there. In the Registry of Westrop wife of Philip Newton. The and holding land of eight acres and ten Deeds early records in Henrietta Street, Bagenal family graves are located in the perches. It may be that Owen Murphy Dublin, what we know as Regent Street in Dunleckney Cemetery Bagenalstown. was the one who built the first mill here the present town of Bagenalstown is as his name appears in several of the referred to as the “Main Street leading to Tradition has it that Walter got the idea deeds as “the Old Mill Quarters of Owen the Mill”. Beside the Mill entrance is the of recreating a Versailles on the banks of Murphy.” The records of Griffiths entrance to the avenue leading to the two the Barrow and began to lay out Bagenal- Valuation of 1852 show that property Lodges, and all are located in the same stown in that way in an attempt to estab- number 11 of Long Range consisting of compound. It is reasonable then to assume lish a profitable trading centre. The a house, malt house, corn stores, yard and that this main street led to the Lodge/s project failed, the only imposing archi- garden which were then vacant, records where the Bagenal family resided and tectural building that was completed is John Murphy as the Landlord. The therefore it is from the Lodge/s of the first the present library, once the courthouse. Queen of the Universe National School Bagenals the Demesne of Moneybeg It was built facing the river Barrow with now occupies that site. Others that had (Bagenalstown) grew. its entrance opening on to the then newly substantial properties in the townland of Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 3

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

A map of 1640 of Dunleckney Parish and Bagenal leased unto Owen Murphy the 22nd October 1770. part of Wells Parish by George Marshall Mill and Lands of the Lodge Demesne Notes: records the townland of Moniebegge as containing 8 acres 10 perches for 1) The above Leases 47&84 are contained in MS being part of the estate of Walter 31 years. 1096 of the Cliff-Vigors Papers of the Private Bagnall”. (See map in article “Bagenals Collections in the National Archives Dublin. of Idrone”) In a Memorial Deed of the 16th and The Landed Estates Court and Memorial of 17thof May 1763 Beauchamp Bagenal 2) Deed of Conveyance of the 13th July 1859 dealt The present library which was the Court leased unto Michael Carter City of with a lease dated 17th of May 1763 concerning all House was built according to Richard J. Dublin all Lands of Bagenalstown com- the properties of the Eastwood Demesne and an Butler (Carloviana 2015) “not c.1835 monly known by the name of Lodge and Indenture of Marriage Settlement bearing date 18th but almost a decade earlier, 1826”. The Demesne of Bagenalstown containing by March 1812 executed to the marriage of William C. Colville to Hester Lowry. The following people Court House faced the River Barrow and the survey of Messrs Frizile 40 acres 1 who had interests at various stages in the property a road was constructed in front of it rood 28 perches all and that of those of were listed in the case - Beauchamp Bagenal, called the New Road and is recorded with the Water Corn Mills holding being one Michael Carter, Robert Wybrants and John Barlow. its residents in Griffith’s Valuation of part of the lands of Bagenalstown The address of William C. Colville was given here as 10 Russel Street, Reading, Berkshire in England. 1852. This road later became known as containing by the said Frizile Survey 8 3) In Griffith’s Valuation of 1852 in Killinane Co. Bachelors Walk. This new road would acres 10 perches in as large and ample Carlow, two holdings with the family name Quinn seem to have been an extension of manner as Owen Murphy holds and i.e. Patrick Quinn with a holding of 35 acres 1 rood Regent Street which as mentioned previ- enjoy the said Mills Lands nevertheless 35 perches and Philip Quinn 66 acres 1 rood 29 ously, was referred to as the Main Street to the lease thereof made to the said perches, both with house, offices and land facing Bagenalstown on the opposite side of the river in the town that led to what once may Owen Murphy by the said Beauchamp Barrow. Perhaps Patrick and Philip may in some have been a Bagenal residence. The Bagenal for 31 years from 1st of May way be connected to the aforementioned Street of Long Range may have been 1758 and also that of the lands of Issamy Issamy Quinn! constructed at the same time along with Quinn said containing by Frizile Survey the New Road, both linking the Main 24 acres 2 roods or thereabouts. Edward Vigors Street to the Royal Oak Road and in keeping with Walter Bagenal’s plan of The following is a summary taken from The first member of the Vigors family to development for the town. A very popu- Indentures, dated the 22nd of October arrive in Ireland was the Rev. Louis lous street in the early 1800s was what 1770 Lease 47 and Lease 84 dated 10th Vigors from Holloden, North Devon who we now call Barrett Street and is January 1790 concerning - All the Lands arrived in Cork circa 1615. He had been recorded in Griffith’s Valuation as the of Bagenalstown commonly known by the ordained on the 5th of November 1603 Old Post Office Street, also linking Main name of Lodge or Demesne of Bagenal- by the Bishop of Exeter. In Ireland he Street with the Royal Oak Road. stown with the buildings and appurte- was beneficed in the Diocese of Ross nances containing 35 acres 1 rood and where he became Treasurer of the Cathe- The Bachelors Walk name may have 32 perches and plantation measure by the dral in 1631. He died in Devonshire in been introduced by William Chaigneau same more less situated in the Barony of 1642, as did his widow in 1651. Their Colville who had considerable interests Idrone and County Carlow, spread over son Urban Vigors was beneficed 1634-37 in the Canal, and adjoining lands; he is a period of time up to 1770:- in the Diocese of Cork and Ross, and in listed in Griffith’s Valuation (1852) as the 1645 was Chaplain to the 1st Earl of Landlord of the Lodge (Eastwood 1) Beauchamp Bagenal to Michael Ossory. He married circa 1635 Catherine House) for that period. He had consider- Carter of the city of Dublin. Boyle sister of Richard Boyle, Bishop of able flour business interests also at that Ferns (1667 – 1683) and Roger Boyle time in Bachelors Walk, Dublin and was 2) Beauchamp Bagenal and Michael Bishop of Clogher (1672-1687) and they a Director and Governor of the Bank Carter to Richard Cochran, his wife had a son called Urban. The Vigors were of Ireland. Elinor, his brother Robert Cochran, and granted estates in Co. Carlow during the William Fishburn of Carlow. reign of Charles 11 (1660-1685) which The Memorial Deed 125497 bearing date included Old Leighlin where Urban 23rd of August 1757 in the Registry of 3) Richard Cochran his wife Elinor and Vigors, son of Urban Vigors and Mary Deeds Dublin shows that Beauchamp Robert Cochran, (sons of Nicholas Boyle, established the first Vigors house Bagenal leased unto Issamy Quinn Cochran, Abbey Street, Dublin), and in Co. Carlow and later built Burgage widow of Bagenalstown all that part of William Fishburn to Peter Pidgeon House. Sometime after they arrived in Moneybeg otherwise Bagenalstown now (Pigeon) of Blackditch in the Co. Old Leighlin they acquired Malcolm in her possession containing by estima- Wicklow, Robert Carter (son of Henry Ville, the home of the Mulhallen family, tion 24 acres 2 roods plantation measure Carter, Nicholas Street, Dublin). in the townland of Clorusk near the situated in the Barony of Idrone Co. Royal Oak and changed its name to Carlow, aforesaid to hold to the said 4) Peter Pigeon to Edward Vigors and Holoden House. Urban was High Sheriff Issamy Quinn for 31 years from the 1st Samuel Carpenter. in Co. Carlow in 1700. He married Brid- of May last. get Tench daughter of Allen Tench, Sta- 5) Rev. Edward Vigors, the Lodge, Co. plestown, Co.Carlow and niece of John On the 1st of May 1758 Beauchamp Carlow to Richard Mercer of Killinane Tench of Mullinderry, Co. Wexford. Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 4

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

Urban and Bridget’s second son Thomas Note: of the Barrow. Vigors was born c.1685. They had estates The following people had shared lease interests in and houses in Derryfore and Rathevan, Lodge & Demesne, during the Beauchamp Bagenal The following has been extracted from period, prior to the tenure of Edward Vigors - Queen’s County (Laois) and Ballybar Samuel Carpenter, Peter Pigeon, Robert Carter, the travelogue of Arthur Young’s Tour of and Corries Co. Carlow (1729) and Richard Cochran, Robert Cochran, Elinor Cochran Ireland 1776-1779, first published in Seldon, Devonshire (1725). Thomas was and William Fishburn. 1780 – Captain in the Legion Regiment, “The Black Horse” and was Justice of the Peace for Queen’s County (Laois) and High Sheriff in 1714. Captain Thomas married twice, first to Margaret a widow and they had issue of three children Urban, Bartholomew, and Lucy. His second marriage was to Elizabeth Mercer daughter of Edward Mercer of Knock- ballystine Co. Carlow and they had issue of three children Richard, Edward and Elizabeth. It was at Burgage, Co. Carlow that the Rev. Edward Vigors was born in 1747 to Captain Thomas Vigors and Eliz- abeth Mercer. He graduated with a B.A. in Trinity College Dublin in 1767 and married Mary Low of Lissoy, Co. West- meath, daughter of Edward Low and Elizabeth Nelligan (daughter of the Rev. Maurice Nelligan) in December 1773. Lodge Mills Rev. Edward became Perpetual Curate of Old Leighlin, Co. Carlow in 1774 and Rector of Shankill, Co. Kilkenny 1783 Richard Mercer and he and his wife Mary lived at various Richard Mercer senior lived in Dublin “June 19th arrived at Hollyhead ……… times in Old Leighlin, Burgage and the and he had one son also called Richard ………………… July 9th left Brown- Lodge (Eastwood House). who lived with his uncle Luke at shill (Carlow) and taking the road to Killinane Co. Carlow. He married Ann Leighlinbridge called on Mr James They had three children:- Pigott. Richard was a merchant and he Butler at Ballybar ……………….. 1) Rev. Thomas Mercer Vigors born on and Ann lived at Killinane at first and Having taken a short walk with Mr the 23rd October 1775, and married Anne then at the Lodge Bagenalstown, Co. Butler passed on to Captain Mercer’s Cliffe daughter of John Cliffe of New Carlow. Edward Mercer of Knock- Mill at Laughlin-bridge (Bagenalstown). Ross Co. Wexford. He succeeded his ballystine Co. Carlow whose daughter I had been told that this was one of the father as Perpetual Curate of Old Leigh- Elizabeth married Thomas Vigors may most considerable in Ireland; and had a lin and same parishes, except Shankill have been another uncle of Richard and letter of recommendation to Mr Mercer, until he was appointed Rector of Rathas- also Simons Mercer of Knockballystine which through carelessness I had lost. I beck, Queen’s County (Laois) on the who was buried in Tullow on the 30th of did not care however to pass without 25th of November 1815 and promoted to January 1783. seeing the mill; drove down to it and was Powerstown, which he held until his in the awkward situation of explaining death on the 7th April, 1850. In April of 1770 the Rev. Edward Vigors myself to be a traveller – what I wanted formerly of the Lodge, Bagenalstown – from whence I came –and so forth; but 2) Elizabeth who died unmarried 30th leased unto Richard Mercer all lands of the good nature and politeness of Mr July, 1828 and was buried at Old Lodge and Demesne of Bagenalstown Mercer presently dissipated the agree- Leighlin, and which included the Owen Murphy ableness of the first explanatory Old Water Corn Mill, at the yearly rent moments. He showed me the mill and 3) Maria who married the Rev. George of £106 and renewable forever at a yearly explained everything with the utmost Alcock died in 1854 and is also buried at rent of £106.7 shillings. This mill was civility. It is a very large and convenient Old Leighlin. started in 1708. A committee had been one, 15,000 barrels a year, and if there appointed in 1703 in the Irish House of was a brisker demand could do yet more. The Rev. Edward died aged 51 years, on Commons to propose a bill to make the I found the same necessity of kiln-drying the 22th June 1797 and was buried in Old River Barrow navigable. However, work here as at Slaine Mill, and made the same Leighlin. Mary his wife died on the 12th did not start until 1761, and by 1800 ten observation that the wheat was none of it of April 1827 and was also buried in Old lateral canals had been cut. The building of a fine bright colour, like what is Leighlin. of the Bagenalstown Mill in 1708 may common in England. The farmers also have been prompted by the navigable bill dress their corn in so lovely a manner, Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 5

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

that there is the same necessity of dress- Richard Weld. at 7 South Lotts (Ringsend Area) and ing it over again, for which very power- Coolock House, Dublin. He was a mem- ful machines are contrived. The whole is Richard was High Sheriff of Co. Carlow ber of the House of Parliament Commit- very well calculated for, saving labour in in 1782. tee on the 25th March 1788 to consider every operation, and only eight hands are the petition of the subscribers for the im- employed. After the mill was built, Mr Notes provement of the Barrow navigation Mercer made many alterations of his 1) A Bolting Mill is a separate building from the between the bridge at Athy, Co. Kildare own, to render it more ample and effec- Mill, in which flour is sifted. and the tide water at St. Mullins in tive, which have fully answered his ex- 2) The High Sheriff of Co. Carlow was the British County Carlow. Included at the meeting pectations.” Crown’s judicial representative in County Carlow. of the members of this Committee on The list of people that Arthur Young was 3) Friday the 10th of October 1788, in the indebted to for making him perfectly well informed Richard Mercer and his wife Ann ran into was long and included – Right Honourable William County Court House Carlow were, financial difficulties circa the late 1770s Barton Slaine Castle, Mr Brown Carlow, Mr. Butler William Colvill, Richard Mercer and and as a result lost considerable lands and near Carlow and Mr Richard Mercer. Beauchamp Bagenal. The Committee premises in Carlow, Cork and Dublin. decided that the next meeting of the Colvill & Weld Committee would be held at the same Summary from Memorials, Registry of Following the financial difficulties of venue on the 29th of November 1788. Deeds, Dublin:- Richard Mercer the Colvill and Weld families appear on the scene in the William died on the 5th July 1820 aged Richard Mercer to William Colvill City second half of the 1700s and early 1800s. 82 years. of Dublin, Matthew Weld and Richard Moneybeg Demesne and lands were Weld of Dublin 22nd May 1780, 22nd made over by Richard Mercer unto William Chaigneau Colville March 1783, 25th November 1784, William Colvill of the city of Dublin and William Chaigneau Colville (Colvill) son which shows; the same Lands, buildings Matthew and Richard Weld of Dublin, in- of William Colville and Hannah and appurtenances as above mentioned cluding Killinane lands of Mercer. Chaigneau was born at Bachelors Walk, of Lodge and Demesne of Bagenalstown Dublin on the 23rd May 1784 and along with “the house improvements At first William Chaigneau Colvill may baptised in St. Mary’s Church of Ireland thereon” and included also was “that part have been resident in the Lodge and the located on the corner of Mary Street and of the Lands of Lodge containing 4 acres Weld brothers Joseph, Matthew & Jervis Street. 3 roods 26 perches where” Richard Richard in the Lodge Mill House which Mercer “built a large Bolting Mill”, along they built but not long afterwards Joseph He married Hester Lowry daughter of with the existing Owen Murphy Old and family moved in to the Lodge (East- James Lowry, Rockdale, Co. Tyrone, on Corn Water Mill and Mill Quarters, all wood House) with William Chaigneau the 21st of March 1812. An indenture of being made over by Richard Mercer unto Colvill as the Land Lord. After the death Marriage Settlement bearing date 18th William Colvill of the city of Dublin, of Colvill the Weld family gained full March 1812 in the Registry of Deeds Matthew and Richard Weld of Dublin, possession of the entire Demesne. Dublin appears to include the Lodge, along with that part of the Lands of Lodge Mills and Demesne lands of Killinane formerly in the possession of William Colville (Colvill) Bagenalstown, which I fail to fully un- Simon (Simons) Mercer situated in the William Colville was born on the 6th of derstand. William and Hester had 11 parish of Killinane being part of the December 1737 to William Colvill and children. William Chaigneau Colville Lands of Lord Brereton of Old Leighlin Jane Thompson daughter of John was a flour merchant with premises at 7 and containing 112 acres, 3 roods and 4 Thompson, Blackabbey, Co. Down. He Bachelors Walk and 7 South Lotts, a perches, plantation measure be the same married Hannah Chaigneau daughter of director of the Bank of Ireland and more or less bounded as in the said deed John Chaigneau on the 18th of June Governor 1832-1834 and Director of the is set forth and also all that part of 1771. They lived at Newtownards, Co. Barrow Navigation Company. On the Kilturk, Co. Carlow containing by Down and at Clonsilla, Clontarf 16th October 1832 William was regis- estimation 37 acres 4 roods, also Richard Demesne, Dublin. They had 8 children. tered on the “Voters List of Idrone East” Mercer to William Colvill lands in William held the office of Member of with Place of Abode as Dublin and Dublin and also townlands – Rathellen, Parliament for Newtownards – Limavady Situation as Moneybeg. In 1833 he was Leighlinbridge, Cloruske and lands of and that of Killybegs. He was one of the High Sheriff of Co. Carlow. He was reg- Carlow and some were of the Demesne promoters of the Bank of Ireland in istered on the 31st December 1839 with of Charles Jackson Lord Bishop of which he was director in 1783 and g Place of Abode as Bachelors Walk, Leighlin (1761 – 1765). overnor in 1801-2. William was a mem- Dublin and Situation as Bagenalstown. ber of the Royal Dublin Society (R.D.S.) He retired in 1844 but was Chairman of Memorial Deed 243075 Book 363 Page and a founder and director of the Grand the Barrow Navigation Company and the 191 of the Registry Deeds Dublin shows Canal Company in 1772, in which he Great Southern and Western Railway that William Colvill did grant, bargain invested £25,000. He had premises also Company in 1845. In the 1851 Census of and sell all lands and premises mentioned at 7 Bachelors Walk Dublin including a England and Wales he was recorded at in Memorial Beauchamp Bagenal unto mill and Agency for the National Insur- Ivy Rock Cottage, Tidenham, Chepstow, Michael Carter, unto Matthew and ance Co. of Scotland and other premises Monmouthshire, Wales, at the age of 66 Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 6

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

years, along with his wife Hester age 61 Bagenalstown and it includes the town- which the village is furnished. It is also years, his son Thomas age 32 years, his land of Moneybeg. In the late 1700s the the seat of that famous flour mill of the daughter in-law Barbara age 26 years and brothers Matthew, Richard and Joseph, Messieurs Weld which we have already his granddaughter Louise Hester age grandchildren of Nathaniel were estab- noticed in our estimate of the establish- 4 years. lished in the two Lodge houses in the ments on this river. And beside those townland of Moneybeg. Matthew and advantages, it has a brewery the property In Griffith’s Valuation of 1852 William Richard were the proprietors of an exten- of a Mr. – Murphy; and Mr. Singleton a Colville was recorded as the Landlord of sive business at the Lodge Mills in 1780 respectable trader who resides here and the Lodge (Eastwood House) with Mrs and dwelt in the Lodge Mills House. manufactures some Marble quarries in Mary Weld as the Tenant. Joseph had been installed as Archdeacon the neighbourhood, has no less than of Ross, Co. Cork in 1777 and had a res- sixteen or eighteen boats on the river. William died at his residence in Reading, idence at the Lodge, Bagenalstown. England on the 11th of December 1864. This village, in addition to its picturesque The following relating to Co. Carlow is situation on the banks of the Barrow, and Notes: taken from The History and Antiquities the good many houses which compose it, 1) Bachelors Walk Dublin was named after a of Co. Carlow 1833, Chapter XXX Page receives considerable augmentation of builder by the name of Bachelor who built there 309 - “An account of the flour sent by beauty from the receptacle of a very after the Dublin quays were extended from Ormond land carriage and canal to Dublin from extensive flour-mill the property of Quay in the late 1600s. A water mill was located in the same area. The Colvill family had extensive the 24th June, 1784 to the 24th June 1785 Richard and Matthew Weld, above men- business premises in this area. distinguishing the names of the mills, the tioned, the mansion and demesne of Mr. 2) South Lotts was created following the embank- number of miles from the Castle of Newton (son-in- law and heir of the late ment of the River Liffey in 1711 between the city Dublin, the owners names, the quantities Mr. Bagnel). The handsome villa of Mrs. and Ringsend, thereby reclaiming the marshes as in hundreds weights, and the bounties Mulhallin beautifully elevated above the North and South Lotts. The Grand Canal Dock is paid for the same”:- river, and from several other neat lodges in the same area. 3) The present end of Lower O Connell Street (Carlisle Street) was located on lands that formed Names of Mills Miles Distance Owners of the FlourQuantities in Cwts. Bounties Paid part of Bachelors Walk, which was laid out as part for same of the Amory grant of 1675. In January 1675, the Burrin 40 Frances Byrne 2469 £165-17s-4d city granted Jonathan Amory, a merchant, a lease of 299 years “of that part of the Strand on the north Bridewell 39 Thomas Delaney 48 £003-03s-5d side of the Liffey” which had at one end the water Carlow 39 Thomas Delaney 538 £034-15s-1d mill built by Gilbert Mabbott, close to location of Carlow 38 James Hamilton 201 £013-00s-4d the Abbey Theatre. Clashganny 54 James Byrne 16 £001-08s-9d 4) Colvill House 24-26 Talbot Street Dublin is at Lodge 50 Matthew Weld 8266 £697-03s-4d present the Irish Water Private Company Ltd. Registered Office. The Rev. A. Atkinson on his journey in the immediate vicinity of the town – it The Rev. David Chaigneau was Minister of the 5) through Ireland in the early 1800s writes derives also from some monuments of French Church in Carlow in 1741 and was buried in Carlow on the 11th of July 1747, may have been the following in his travelogue “The Irish antiquity near it, an auxiliary influence a relative of John Chaigneau, father of Hannah Tourist” (published in 1815): of grandeur.” Chaigneau, wife of William Colvill. 6) The Chaigneau family were descendants of “From Carlow I proceeded to Bagenel- The Weld brothers Archdeacon Joseph, Protestant exiles or Huguenots from France, in the stown alias Monabeg a picturesque Matthew, Lieutenant Royal Navy and reign of Louis xiv (1643-1715), who came to Great village on the banks of the Barrow, about Richard, Army Captain and Magistrate in Britain and Ireland. 8 miles south of that town, and eleven Carlow, were established in Bagenal- north of Kilkenny. Though many of the stown and Callan, Co. Kilkenny in the The Weld Family Edmund Weld was the first member of houses have a respectable aspect and the late 1700s. They always gave their the Weld family to arrive in Ireland and village is composed of several streets, yet address as The Lodge or the Lodge Mills. he had answered Cromwell’s call for it is not a post town, nor has the patent Matthew died 1806/7 and bequeathed to puritan ministers to serve as chaplains in granted by government for two annual his nephew Matthew Weld Hartstonge the army in Ireland. He later set up a fairs and a weekly market, produced all (Poet, Author and Antiquarian) of Dublin ministry in Co. Cork and soon afterwards that benefit to the place, which might be all his property in Moneybeg, which moved to Dublin. It is from Dublin then expected from its situation on the banks included the Lodge Mills, the Lodge that the Weld family spread to other areas of a navigable river and a country re- Mills House and the Lodge (Eastwood) of Ireland and acquired substantial markable for its property and population. and Demesne of Bagenalstown. estates. The Rev. Edmund had a son ………………………………………… Nathaniel who was also in Holy Orders …………………………………… Daniel Keoghler (Keogh) merchant of and possessed considerable estates in But although the infant markets of this Bagenalstown on the 1st of July 1815 Ireland. A map of 1640 by George place are but thinly attended, yet we see leased unto Matthew and Richard Weld Marshall shows the Bagenal estates in the proofs of a tolerable home trade, in of Lodge Mills all the lands of Moneybeg the aspect of several good shops with in his possession for 999 years at a yearly

Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 7

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

rent of £15. The lands were “bounded on In Dunleckney Church cemetery on the Parliament in 1662, in the reign of the east by a park then in the possession east side of the Church of Ireland ruins Charles 11. John Crosthwait arrived in of Mr. Robert Brown divided by a partly are the graves of a number of the Weld Ireland shortly afterwards and settled at wall, on the south by the Main Street family except for Matthew Weld “The Phoenix in the Kings Port of leading to the Mill, on the west by a road Hartstonge who was interred in the vaults County Dublin” (Phoenix Park). The leading to the Barrow Canal and on the beneath St. Anne’s Anglican Church, baptism of an Elizabeth Crosthwait on north by a tracking of said Barrow Canal Dorset Street, Dublin. the 1st of February 1669 was recorded in and premises containing in length one St. Michan’s Church of Ireland, Dublin. hundred and sixteen feet from out to out Notes: Thomas Crosthwait son of John and at the rear of the tracking one hun- The “handsome villa of Mrs. Mulhallin” mentioned Crosthwait was married to Mary dred and twenty three feet from out to out by the Rev. Atkinson also known as Malcolm Ville Macquay on the 17th of January 1744 in and Holloden House, Clorusk, Royal Oak, Co. situated and lying in the town of Carlow with its 18th century estate of 40 acres of St. Andrew’s Church of Ireland Dublin. Bagenalstown otherwise Moneybeg, pastoral land was the setting on the 11th of Septem- Leland Crosthwait a son of Thomas and Idrone East, at yearly rent as stated, ber 2014 for the turning of the first sod by Bernard Mary born on the 17th of May 1746 payable on first day of May and first day and Rosemary Walsh of their 25 million euro craft became Governor of the Bank of Ireland. of November.” The witnesses were Irish whiskey distillery on the banks of the River He married Ann Darby daughter of Barrow. William Payne and Edward Wynne both Jonathan Darby. Leland and Ann’s son of Bagenalstown. On the 17th January Samuel, born circa 1769 became the first 1818 Philip and Sarah Newton sold 32 The Crosthwait Family Crosthwait to settle in Co. Carlow. He The family of Crosthwait that arrived in acres 2 roods and 23 perches of Clorusk was recorded in Killinane, Co Carlow in Ireland were descended from Thomas land known locally as the Millers Quarter the Tithe Applotment Books of 1828 and Crosthwait of Cockermouth in the which was located on the opposite side in Griffith’s Valuation of 1852 we find County of Cumberland, England. An of the Barrow in West Idrone to Matthew him recorded as a Landlord with 199 ordinance was made in the year 1654 for Weld Hartstonge. acres 3 roods 16 perches and as Landlord “settling £100, per annum in Ireland to Thomas Singleton with a holding of 11 upon Richard Uriel and Thomas Crosth- Richard Weld’s son Richard died in 1815 acres 3 roods 17 perches located in wait of Cockermouth Castle in the and Richard senior died in 1824.Matthew Rathellin. County of Cumberland in satisfaction for Weld Hartstonge was now the owner of their losses and services”. This ordnance the Lodge Mill and resided in the Lodge In 1830 Samuel married Elizabeth was confirmed by the Act and Declara- Mill House and at times in his house in Bolton, daughter of Cornelius Bolton tion made by Cromwell’s Parliament and Molesworth Street, Dublin. Other M.P. of Waterford, Sheriff of the County subsequently by an Act of the Irish members of the Weld family also in 1810 and Mayor of the City in 1816. continued to live in the two Lodges. Lodge Mill House 1901Census of Ireland

Samuel Crosthwaite took over manage- Surname Forename Age Relation Birthplace Occupation ment of the Mills in the early 1800s and to Head built a seven floor high extension to it in Crosthwait Samuel 62 Head Carlow Mill Proprietor 1824. He moved into the Lodge Mills Crosthwait Sarah 55 Wife England House as a tenant following Matthew Stoker Lucy 29 Daughter Co. Carlow Weld Hartstonge’s death in 1834. Crosthwait Eileen 20 Daughter Co.. Carlow Joseph’s only son Matthew Weld contin- Crosthwait Olive 13 Daughter Co. Carlow Scholar ued to live on in the Lodge (Eastwood) Crosthwait Mara Isac 8 Gr. Daughter Trinidad Scholar following his father’s death in September Keegan Katherine 32 Servant Co. Carlow Cook 1781. Matthew died in 1832 but his wife Mary continued to live in the Lodge. She Baggy Margaret 16 Servant Co. Kilkenny Parlour Maid moved to her son’s home at Bloomfield, Lodge Mill House 1911 Census of Ireland Co. Dublin in 1862 and she died there in 1864.She was buried in Dunleckney. Fur- Surname Forename Age Relation Birthplace Occupation ther information of the Weld family is to to Head be found in the article on Matthew Weld Crosthwait Samuel 77 Head Carlow Flour & Corn Hartstonge in the 2015 edition Mill Proprietor of Carloviana. Crosthwait Eliza Olive 23 Daugter Co. Carlow Crosthwait Arthur Samuel 27 Son Co. Carlow The representatives of the Weld family Burke Walter De Leger 38 Friend Roscommon remained as landlords of a large number of properties in the Monbeybeg McCann Mary 25 Servant Co. Kildare Servant Demesne, including all the west side of Dooley Bridget 20 Servant Co. Kilkenny Cook Regent Street until recent times.

Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 8

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

Samuel and Elizabeth had a number of children which included Leland Crosthwait born 29th of August 1831, Samuel Crosthwait born 21st of October 1833, Edward Crosthwait baptised 31st December 1835, Elizabeth Crosthwait baptised 15th of June 1837 and John Thomas Crosthwait baptised 9th of November 1839; all of these were baptised in Dunleckney. A Lucy Crosth- wait of Bagenalstown was married to George Beamish of 60 Sackville Street Dublin, son of John Beamish and Anabella Swayne, on the 30th of Novem- ber 1844, in Dunleckney. They lived at Mount Beamish, Boulteen, Co. Cork. Leland Crosthwait married on the 14th of May 1857, in Dunleckney Sophie Lodge Mill Workers 1939/1940 Richards (born September 1836) of Rathwade, Co. Carlow, daughter of Back Row:Jimmy Johnson, Dick Hughes, John Dargan, ? Clarke, ? O’Brien, Tom Captain Edwin Richards, Royal Navy, Lawlor, William Millbanks, Christy Pender, Unknown, John Doyle. and Mary Ann Kirwan. Middle Row: ? Murphy, Paddy McDonald, Richard Lawlor, Paddy Doyle, Mick Pur- In the early 1800s Samuel took over the cell, Jack Walsh, John Lillis, George Darcy (Snr), Jack Monaghan (Snr), William running of the Lodge Mills and in 1824 Watkins, Jack Monaghan (Jnr), Frank Corcoran, Unknown, Jim Geoghegan, Bill built on an extension, which included a Stephenson (White coat-miller) Peter Carton, Sam Jenkinson, Unknown, Billy seven story high building. The Ordnance Stephenson, Pat Sullivan, Paky Lawlor. Survey in 1837 wrote of “the very extensive flour mills of Samuel Crosthwait Front Row: Tom Kinsella (White coat-miller), Jim Dudley, Mr Harvey (White coat- Esq.” A medal dated 1850, was found in miller), *Walter Brown, Frank Brown, Mr Hicks, Emilly Jeffs (Office), Jim McDon- recent years on the Lodge Mills grounds ald, Jim Dargan. with the inscription “Presented by the Idrone Farming Society to Samuel * Walter S. Brown = member of the 1894 Irish Triple Crown Team. Crosthwait Esq for the best Short Horn Bull exhibited October 16 1850”. Eliza- Arthur Samuel and Leland George century but by 1919 it was in the hands beth Crosthwait wife of Samuel died on Crosthwait attended St.Nicholas of Brown and Crosthwait Ltd. During the 4th of February 1854 and is buried in College Lancing in England and they this period the Company reroofed the Dunleckney, Bagenalstown. Samuel died both entered the Royal Military College Old Rudkin Mill and put it into working 22nd of August 1863 aged 74 and is also at Sandhurst in September 1896 and sub- order and use. The Minister of Industry buried in Dunleckney. After Samuel’s sequently left in December 1897. Leland and Commerce Jack Lynch announced in death his son Samuel managed the Lodge George was gazetted 2nd lieutenant the Dail in 1963 that that nine flour mills Mills business. He had married Sarah unattached list for Indian Corps Staff had been closed in Ireland since the end Eliza Perry who was born in England 29th July 1900. of 1962; this included Brown & Crosth- circa 1846 and the following are the wait Ltd. with a quota of 52,119 barrels. names of their children, all born in The The Publication of List of Carlow Land The Lodge Mills House and surrounds Lodge Mills House and baptised Owners of 1871 shows Samuel Crosth- were demolished at some stage possibly in Dunleckney:- wait with a holding of 96 acres in Bage- in the 1930s to facilitate trucks entering Edith Elizabeth Crosthwait 1867 nalstown. In 1884 Samuel Crosthwait and turning within the Mill compound. Herbert Leland Crosthwait 1868 was recorded as a Town Commissioner. Lucy Eleanor Crosthwait 1869 Samuel and Sarah were both recorded in Robert Wybrants Cecil Henry Edward Crosthwait 1870 the National Census of 1901 at the Lodge Robert Wybrants was the eldest son of Edward Gerard Stewart Crosthwait 1871 Mills House but only Samuel was Robert Wybrants of Granby Row Dublin. William Sylvester Crosthwait 1873 recorded in the 1911 Census along with He was educated at Trinity College Leland George Crosthwait 1881 family members. Their daughter Eileen Dublin (T.C.D.) and Kings Inn. He was Evelyn Mary Crosthwait 1876 Elizabeth Crosthwait died on the 21st of admitted to the Irish Bar in 1811. He was Eileen Elizabeth Crosthwait 1880 March 1968. elected a member of the Royal Dublin Arthur Samuel Crosthwait 1883 Society (R.D.S) on the 28th of April 1836 Ernest Jevon Crosthwait 1886 The Lodge Mills remained in the hands – served on the Botany Committee 1842- Elsie Olive Crosthwait 1887 of the Crosthwait family into the 20th 1867 and on the Executive Council 1846

Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 9

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

– 1852.He died on the 28th August 1875. Captain Algernon Moreton married sec- Estate close to Tortwort Court the former seat of the He was resident in Eastwood House for ondly his first cousin Emilia Olivia Moreton family in Gloucester, England. Captain Moreton’s first wife was Anne Jane a short period of time circa 1859-62. Moreton McDonald daughter of the Hon. 2) Paget of Knockglass Co. Mayo. A member of the John Barlow was in some way connected Augustus Henry Moreton McDonald of Bourke family of Ballina married a Paget, a relative to Robert Wybrants in financial and busi- Largie and Mary Jane McDonald of Thomas Paget, father of Anne Jane. Mary Robin- ness matters. Lochhart on the 1st April 1875. They son (nee Bourke) former President of Ireland is de- lived at Eastwood. The List of Carlow scended from the Bourkes of Ballina. 3) Emilia Olivia second wife of Captain Moreton Captain Algernon Thomas Moreton. Land Owners of 1871 shows the Hon. A. descended from the Lady Anne sister of King Ed- Joseph Weld was established in the Moreton with a holding of 68 acres in ward 1V (Yorkist) 1461 – 1483 and King Henry Lodge (Eastwood House) in the 1700s Eastwood Bagenalstown. Captain Alger- V11 (Tudor) 1485-1509. and his family occupied it up to 1862 non Moreton died on the 18th January when it was purchased by Captain Alger- 1880 at the age of 50 years in Corfe Captain Arthur Henley non Thomas Moreton. Mullen, Dorset, England. Emilia died In June 1878 Captain Arthur Henley 17th February 1920 at Whitechurch, bought Eastwood House and estate at the In the early 1860s Thomas Paget, his Dorset, England. price of one thousand six hundred second wife Anne Emily Handy along pounds from Captain Algernon Thomas with their daughter Anne Jane and her The following are snippets from newspa- Moreton. Arthur Henley was born in husband Captain the Hon. Algernon per society columns of that time report- Waterperry, Oxfordshire to Joseph Thomas Moreton moved from Knock- ing on some activities of the Hon. Warner Henley and Georgina Fane glass, Co. Mayo to Dublin and soon Captain Moreton: daughter of John Fane and Lady Eliza- afterwards moved to the Lodge in 1862. beth Parker who lived at Wormsley, The following is taken from the Dublin 1) Freeman’s Journal July 1861- Oxfordshire. On the 27th October 1868 Evening Mail 28th October 1863: “The The Hon. Mrs. Algernon Moreton of a son. Arthur married Margaret Gore daughter Magistracy, Captain the Hon. Moreton of 2) Dublin Evening Mail 29th October of Joseph Gore and Margaret Bagwell of Bagenalstown, has been appointed to the 1862 – Hunting in Ireland -The Hon. Derrymore, Co. Clare at Saint James, Commission of the Peace for the County Algernon Moreton has sold his harriers, Westminister London. They had at least of Carlow, and was on Wednesday sworn with Kingsland, their whip, in the bar- three children, Margaret M. Henley born in by G. W. Bolton, Esq. of Coolbawn, in gain to Colonel Stronge. 1875, Walter E. Henley born 1877 and the Courthouse Bagenalstown.” 3) Dublin Evening Mail 1863 and 1864 Cecil Henley born 1881. They lived at Captain Algernon Moreton – at Preser- Eastwood, Bagenalstown, Co. Carlow The Hon. Algernon Thomas Reynolds - vation of the Barrow – Fishery Meeting. and Waterperry, Oxfordshire, England. Moreton was born 10th August 1829 to 4) Dublin Evening Mail 21 February Henry George Francis Reynolds – More- 1866 – Arthur served as High Sheriff in Carlow, ton, 2nd Earl of Ducie and the Hon. Eliz- Hon. Algernon Moreton, Secretary of the as a Justice of the Peace, was appointed abeth Dutton. He married firstly Anne Barrow Protection Society. Magistrate for Bagenalstown on the 5th Jane Paget daughter of Thomas Paget, 5) Freeman’s Journal 18 February 1875 of November 1878 and served as Resi- Knockglass, Crossmolina, Co. Mayo on – Fashion & Varieties – dent Magistrate there into at least the late the 10th October 1857 and they lived at Captain Algernon Moreton arrived at 1890s. In the 1881 Census he was listed Eastwood Bagenalstown. They had two Kingstown from England. at his sister’s (Grace Elizabeth De Salis) children, Algernon Paget Reynolds – 6) Freeman’s Journal 1st July 1876 – residence in Egham, Surrey, Berkshire, Moreton born 24th November 1858, died Fashion & Varieties – along with his wife Margaret and three 12th December 1861 and Reginald Percy Algernon Moreton and E. Mrs. Moreton children. It was seemingly a very large Reynolds – Moreton born 22nd July left Kingstown for London. household as listed also were other fam- 1861, died August 1861 and buried in St. 7) Freeman’s Journal 17th June 1878 – ily members and 14 servants male Mary’s Church Cemetery, Crossmolina, Sale of Eastwood to Arthur Henley of and female. Co. Mayo. Waterperry Oxfordshire and now of East- wood – also referred to as the Lodge and The Registry Deeds show that Arthur Algernon gained the rank of Captain in Demesne land. sold Eastwood to Colonel William the service of the 3rd Light Dragoons Barton Wade on the 3rd February 1902. also known as The Kings Own Hussars Other reports also referred to Captain Al- (a cavalry regiment in the British Army). gernon Moreton’s visits to his Hunting In the 1901 Census Arthur was listed as His wife Anne Jane Moreton died 27th Lodge in Knockglass, Co. Mayo. a lodger in St. George, Hanover Square, August 1873 aged 38 years and is buried London Middlesex and listed in the 1911 in Mount Jerome Cemetery Dublin. Notes: Census at the age of 77 years in Chel- Thomas Paget father of Anna Jane died 1) We may speculate as to why the Hon. Moreton tenham, Gloucestershire. He died on the in Dublin 8th March 1877 aged 81 years, choose the name Eastwood and put forward that a 19th September 1923 at the age of 90 his widow Anne E. Paget died 2nd April wood was situated on both sides of the Barrow and years in Cheltenham, Gloucestershire. He as his house was on the east side he called it East- 1892, both also buried in Mount Jerome wood House or that he took the East because it was is listed as a descendant of William 1 (the Cemetery, Dublin. located in the Barony of East Idrone, or that he Conqueror) King of England 1066 -1087 choose it perhaps from the name Eastwood Park in the Genealogy Tree “Descendants of Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 10

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

William the Conqueror” by Alan G. Freer Eastwood House 1901 Census of Ireland A.C.I.B. Surname Forename Age Relation Birthplace Occupation Adjutant Arthur Forbes-Gordon to Head Arthur Newton Forbes-Gordon was born Forbes-Gordon Arthur Newton 57 Head Scotland Retired Captain on the 22nd January 1844 at Rayne, 79 Homelanders Scotland to Arthur Forbes Gordon and Forbes-Gordon Penelope 53 Wife Scotland Charlotte Balfour. He gained the rank of Forbes Adeline 22 Daughter Dublin Captain and Adjutant in the service of the Forbes Amesbury 18 Daughter Co. Carlow 79th Highlanders. He held the office of Forbes Ida 17 Daughter Co. Carlow Justice of the Peace (J.P.) for County Forbes Helen 9 Daughter Scotland Scholar Carlow. On the 15th September 1870 Captain Forbes-Gordon was appointed to Swann Mary 24 Governess West Indies Governess the Court of Bagenalstown as Magistrate MacKenzie Mary 25 Servant Scotland Lady’s Maid and resided at Rathwade House and had Robb Mary 23 Servant Scotland Maid a residence also at Rayne, Aberdeenshire, Horsbourough Jane 23 Servant England Cook Scotland. Russel Annie 20 Servant Co. Kilkenny Kitchen Maid He married firstly Christian Dalrymple Barry Sarah 17 Servant Co. Carlow Housemaid on the 22nd of October 1872 and they Copland James 17 Servant Scotland Footman had one child – Major Arthur Dalrymple Day Martin 30 Servant Queen’s Co. Coachman Forbes-Gordon born the 29th September Copland George 16 Servant Scotland Stable Boy 1873, died 16th May 1931. He married secondly, Adeline Sarah Newton, born in 1849 to Philip Jocelyn Newton of Dunleckney and Henrietta Adjutant Arthur Newton Forbes-Gordon were married at St. James Piccadily Lon- Maria Kennedy on the 17th of April died on the 7th March 1930 aged 86. don on the 7th November 1878. They had 1876. They had 2 children- Alistair Hugh two children Gwendolen Ada, born at Forbes-Gordon born the 8th February, Colonel William Barton Wade Agra, North West Provinces, India and 1877, died 11th July 1961 and Adeline William Barton Wade, a retired Army married at Dunleckney, Bagenalstown, Winifred Forbes-Gordon, born 3rd Colonel moved from his temporary 20th July 1904, to Adjutant Willoughby February 1879. Philip’s second wife residence at St. Canice’s Cottage, Jones Fowler of the Waterford Royal Adeline Sarah died the 21st February Kilkenny into Eastwood House Bagenal- Garrison Artillery (Militia). Gwendolen 1879 at the age of 30 years and is buried stown in February 1902 after purchasing died 27th February 1952.The second child in Dunleckney cemetery. it from Captain Arthur Henley. Eric William Noel Wade was born at Aldershot, Co. Hampshire, 19th January He married thirdly, Penelope Christie William was born at Grove, Fethard, Co. 1886, and baptised at the Garrison daughter of Major Napier T. Christie in Tipperary the 11th of July 1840 and Church, Aldershot; educated at April 1881.They had 3 children – Ames- baptised there on the 29th of July. He Cheltenham College. bury Frances Mary, Forbes-Gordon, born entered the Army as ensign 26th (The on the 29th of September 1882; Alice Ida Cameronians) Regiment of Foot, 11 In 1890 on the 16th August at the proved Kathleen Forbes-Gordon, born the 17th March 1859, Lieutenant 14 January reading of his father’s will at Kilkenny of March 1884 and Helen Charlotte 1862, Captain 21 July 1875, Paymaster 1 William Barton Wade’s address is given Forbes-Gordon born on the 26th of May, April 1878, Chief Paymaster 12 Novem- as Newpark, Co. Kildare. 1891. ber 1897, Colonel 16 February 1899, retired 23 September 1901; served in William Barton Wade died in 1919. Abyssinian Expedition of 1868 (Medal); I found no record of Arthur Newton Notes: Forbes Gordon in the Registry of Deeds in Dublin but in the 1901 Census he was Chief Paymaster in South Africa 1899 - 1901. He was invested as a Companion, 1) John Wade, Father of William Barton Wade is recorded along with his wife Penelope listed in 1853 as High Sheriff of Kilkenny City; Order of the Bath (C.B.) 29 November; and family of 4 daughters, Adeline, 1854 as resident in St. Canice’s Cottage, as Land mentioned in despatches, London Gazette, Amesbury, Alice and Helen plus 8 ser- agent and Resident Magistrate, with his wife vants (5 male and 3 female) residing in 16 April 1901; Justice of the Peace (J.P.) registered as a member of the Kilkenny and South Eastwood. At this time the owner of East- for Co. Carlow. William was the son of East of Ireland Archaeological Society. wood according to the Registry of Deeds John Wade from the Clonebraney Estate, was Captain Henley but he had not sold Co. Meath and Deborah Barton of the 2) John Wade was born 1st February 1811 and it to Colonel Wade until February 1902 Barton Estate, Grove, Fethard, Co. Tipper- died aged 78, 13th May 1889 at Kilkenny. Deborah ary. He married Emily Ada Elwell born in his wife died 24th March 1895. Both are buried in and therefore Forbes-Gordon obviously the Churchyard at St. Canices. had rented Eastwood for that period from Bermuda 1852/3 to Henry Elwell and Captain Henley. Margaret Graham of Edinburgh. They Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 11

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

3) The Companion Order of the Bath (C.B.) was founded in 1725 by King George 1 and is conferred EastwoodHouse 1911 Census of Ireland on men and women for recognised services of national importance, mainly awarded to Officers of Surname Forename Age Relation Birthplace Occupation the Armed Services as well as to a smaller number to Head of civil servants. Briggs George Frank 55 Head England Retired Colonel Briggs Kathleen Mary 37 Wife Dublin JS YN Co. Carlow William Ernest Elwell, Merchant Eastwood House passed from retired Philips Barbara 3 Visitor Egypt Colonel William Barton Wade on the 3rd Philips Di Ann 1 Visitor England of September 1903 to William Ernest Borough Dora Kate 50 Nurse Co. Clare Lady Nurse Elwell formerly of Houghton Hill, Burland Marcella Ellen 42 Nurse Co. Dublin Hospital Nurse Huntingdon and later West Dean Cottage, Collins Margaeret 40 Servant C. Waterford Cook Chichester. William Ernest Well was a Gorey Margaret 28 Servant Co. Kildare Parlour Maid brother of Emily Ada Elwell, wife of William Barton Wade. Waton Kate 34 Servant Co. Louth Housemaid Rogers Alicia 28 Servant Co. Kildare Kitchen Maid William and his brother Robert John McLean Elizabeth 23 Servant Co. Carlow 2nd Housemaid Elwell of Birmingham, England, were in partnership with George Walrond George Ewbank Briggs died on the 2nd January 1834, Mary Brown born 1st Hutchinson and Henry Perry Leach, both of July 1940 aged 84 and is buried in April 1836. of Bridgetown, Barbados, in the West Whitechurch Cemetery at the foot of the Indies, and traded as Merchants under the Dublin Mountains in Co. Dublin. William and Walter Brown emigrated to firm of Elwell and Co. at London and Kathleen Mary, wife of George died on Belfast where they started a flour mill. Birmingham. The partnership was the 5th of May 1962 at the age of 89 William married and he and his wife had dissolved on the 26th of November 1878. years and is buried alongside her hus- 6 children 2 boys and 4 girls. Two of Both Robert John and William Ernest band, in the same grave in Whitechurch. these were Mary Brown who died in were born in Birmingham, John Chris- 1940 and Jane Brown born 1869, died tened 10th January, 1844 and William Notes: 1901. Jane married her first cousin Frank born 1847. William Ernest died at Bath 1) O.B. E. = Officer of the British Empire. Beveridge Brown, son of Walter Brown. Somerset, England, aged 77 in 1924. 2) K.C. = King’s Counsel (Counsel to the Crown William later moved to Dublin where he when the British Monarch is a King). 3) Kathleen Mary Swifte was the daughter of Sir founded the Dock Mills. He lived at Note: E.G. Swifte of the Swifte’s Heath, Kilkenny. Glencairn, Dalkey. Henry Elwell father of Emily, William and Robert George Swifte Ewbank Briggs was the last Swifte died on 30th of December 1872 and will proved in to reside at Swifte’s Heath. He took possession of the District Registry at Lichfield Court of Probate Sometime soon after arrival in Belfast it in 1957 and sold it in 1971. He was buried in on the 30th May, 1873, by Robert John Elwell of Castlecomer in 1990. Walter Brown moved to Dublin where he Birmingham, Merchant and William Ernest Elwell founded Walter Brown & Co., a milling of the same place, Merchant, the executors named in the same will. The Brown Family business in Hanover Street. He lived at The Browns were descended from John Rockville, Newtown Park Avenue Black- Colonel George Ewbank Briggs Stewart Brown who came from near rock. Walter married Margaret Forbes George Ewbanks Briggs retired Army Montrose, a Scottish coastal town situ- Watson on the 29th of June 1859 in Aber- Officer “residing at 18 Fitzwilliam ated between the mouths of the North lemno, Angus, Scotland. They had 8 Square, Dublin purchased lands and build- and South Esk Rivers in Angus, children; John Hastings Brown born ings at Bagenalstown commonly called by Scotland, 38 miles north of Dundee. John 1860, Jessie Brown born 1861,Effie the name of Lodge or Demesne of Bage- Stewart Brown married Nicholas Hast- Brown born 1863,the aforementioned nalstown” from William Ernest Elwell “of ings who came from Moniaive, Dum- Frank Beveridge Brown born 1st October the Cottage of West Dean Chichester on frieshire, in 1820 and they had 12 1864, Mary Susan Brown born 9th May the 7th of September 1904”. children, 6 boys and 6 girls which 1866, Walter Stewart Brown born 29th included the following children born in October 1867,William Brown born 14th George Ewbanks Briggs was born to Moniaive in the Parish of Glencairn July 1870 and Margaret Watson Brown George Briggs and Letitia Fanny Dumfries and christened in the United born 30th May 1872, all born in Dublin. Egginton on the 10th February 1856 in Presbyterian Church:- William Brown Walter’s wife Margaret died in 1878 and Yorkshire. He married Kathleen Mary born 26 January 1821, Jenet Brown (Fe- he then married her sister Euphemia Swifte at St. George, Hanover Square, male) born 11th April 1822, Nicolas Watson in Switzerland because in Ireland London on the 1st of June 1898. He Brown (Female) born 17th April 1824, it was illegal to marry a deceased wife’s joined the Royal Fusiliers in which he Margaret Brown christened 23rd August sister. There were no children from the reached the rank of Colonel. He was 1826, Robert Brown born 14th Septem- second marriage. awarded the O.B.E. by the King. In 1919 ber 1827, Jane Brown born 11th Septem- Colonel Briggs sold Eastwood to Frank ber 1829, Walter Stewart Brown born 8th The first recording of the Brown family B. Brown. October 1831, Helen Brown born 7th in Bagenalstown that I have located

Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 12

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

comes from the Montrose Standard 1901 Census of Ireland No 1 Long Range Newspaper Scotland in 1885 and is as follows:- Surname Forename Age Relation Birthplace Occupation to Head Marriage. Brown Frank B. 36 Head Dublin Flour Merchant & At Panmure Place, on the 30th July, 1885 Miller by the Rev. W. Douglas Mackenzie , J. Brown Jane 30 Wife Dublin Hastings Brown, Bagenalstown, Ireland, Brown Brian S. 4 Son Co. Carlow to Jessie Mary only daughter of Comerford Julia 25 Servant Co. Carlow Cook James Johnston. McArdle Comerford Lizzie 22 Servant Co. Carlow Nurse Therefore John Hastings and Frank Beveridge Brown may have arrived in 1911 Census of Ireland N0.1 Long Range Bagenalstown in the early 1880s and lived in the Long Range. Surname Forename Age Relation Birthplace Occupation to Head Frank B. Brown purchased Eastwood Brown Frank 46 Head Dublin Fl. Mill Proprietor and lands of the Demesne of Bagenal- & Corn Merchant stown on the 19th of August 1919 from Brown Stewart 9 Son Carlow Scholar George Ewbank Briggs. Brown Mary 50 Sister-in-Law Kildare --- Brown Eric 24 Nephew Carlow Visitor Frank B. Brown was born on the 1st of Ryan Rose 31 Servant Carlow Gen. Servant October 1864 to Walter Stewart Brown Kealy Bridget 24 Servant Carlow Nurse and Margaret Watson at 16 Creighton Street, Dublin. Margaret Watson was the daughter of Frank Watson and M. Janet and was killed on the 5th April 1918 land of Bagenalstown commonly called Forbes (Fife) who lived in Farm, Black- while serving with the 1/28th London Lodge and Demesne of Bagenalstown hall, Breckin, Scotland. Regiment, Artists Rifles. He is buried at with buildings and appurtenances of 71 the Hamel Military Cemetery (Beaumont acres 2 roods 24 perches statue measure, Frank Beveridge Brown married his first Hamel - Somme France) along with 409 to Brown and Crosthwait Ltd., registered cousin Jane Brown in Dublin in 1896. other casualties, his inscription reads – office Lodge Mills. They moved to Bagenalstown where he BROWN BRIAN STEWART United went into partnership of the Lodge Mill Kingdom Rifleman B/201487 Rifle In later life Frank and Alice lived at with Samuel Crosthwait. Frank and Jane Brigade 05/04/1918 Age: 21 11 F. 33/37. Garryduff. Frank died in 1993 and Alice lived at the Long Range and had 2 sons, The second son of Frank and Jane died in 1996; both are buried in Bagenal- Brian Stewart born 1897 and Frank Brown, Frank Stewart Brown (1901- stown cemetery on the Fenagh road. Stewart born the 1st of November 1901. 1993) was born at Long Range on the 1st Jane died one month after the second of November 1901. He developed an eye John Hastings Brown (1860-1930) eldest birth, on the 3rd of December 1901 aged disease (Irises) while in his teens at son of Wallter Stewart Brown and Mar- 31 years. Jane’s, sister Mary who lived Campell College, had to leave school and garet Watson married Jessie Mary John- next door in Long Range helped to bring was blind by 21. Nevertheless, in 1930 ston from Montrose, Scotland at up the two boys and remained there until he married Alice Isabella Badham (1904- Panmure Place Montrose, Angus, Scot- she died in 1940. In the 1901 Census 1996) from Warwickshire England who land on the 30th of July 1885. Frank is recorded in the Long Range, was born with a stump in place of a right Bagenalstown, along with his wife Jane arm. Her aunt Christina Alice Bell was The following news item appeared in the and son Bryan Stewart Brown. He is married to Frank Beveridge’s younger Montrose Standard July 31, 1885:- recorded in the 1911 Census in the Long brother Walter Stewart Brown. Frank Handsome Bride’s Cake. Range as a widower. In the house with Stewart and Alice farmed at Eastwood him is his son Stewart Brown (age 9 (Apples, Bees, Pigs), then later at Rath- There was exhibited this week in the years) and his nephew Eric Brown (age wade (milking herd, horses, chickens), window of Mr. A. C. Burnett, baker, High 24 years). Frank is recorded in both cen- and Oldtown (arable, horses, sheep, Street, a bride’s cake which for size and suses as a Flour Mill Proprietor and Corn turkeys,). They had 3 boys and 3 girls; finish, has scarcely been surpassed in Merchant. Frank Beveridge Brown died another boy died as a baby. The follow- Montrose. The cake was prepared on the on the 21st of October 1922 aged 58 ing are the children of Frank and Alice:- occasion of the marriage of Miss John- years and was buried alongside his wife Robin (1931 – 2006), Sheelagh born ston, daughter of James Johnston, Esq., Jane in Mount Jerome cemetery 1932, Terrance died 1933, Denis born of the firm of Messrs Joseph Johnston & in Dublin. 1934, Jane (1936 -2001), Susan born Sons, fish curers and reflects much credit 1939, and Rory born 1940. On the 17th on the maker, Mr. Burnett. Frank’s eldest son Brian joined the army November 1943 Frank Stewart Brown after leaving Campell College Belfast sold Eastwood and all that parts of the John and Jessie had 6 sons and 2 daugh- Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 13

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

on the 12th of May 1886 at Bagenal- stown. His father’s occupation is stated as Miller. At the age of 24 years he is recorded in the 1911 Census at his Uncle Frank’s house in the Long Range Bagenalstown. He married the 3rd of June, 1912 Margaret Winifred Tibbits daughter of Frederick and Mary Tibbits at Aldridge Staffordshire. Eric and Mar- garet had one son Christopher Tibbits Brown born at Cedar Court, Aldridge on the 28th of October 1920. Eric emigrated to Canada and went in to the mining business which was not a successful enterprise. On the 6th of January 1917 he joined the Canadian Over-Seas Expedi- tionary Force, the 15th Canadian Battal- ion 48th Highlanders and his wrist band number was E.J.B. 3689 M.T. - C.A.S.C. and previous to that he had spent 3 months in the Canadian Militia. In his At- testation Paper he states his date of birth Lodge Mill workers 1947/48 as the 12th of May 1866 born at Bagenal- Front Row seated on ground:Jimmy Johnston, Paddy O’Brien, Ger Clarke, Peter stown, Co. Carlow and states his next-of- Carton, Mick Purcell, Jim Comerford, Paddy Lawlor, Dick Sheehan. kin as Mrs. M.W. Brown (wife) and her address as Cedar Court, Aldridge, Middle Row Seated: Tom Kinsella (Jnr), Tommy Kinsella (Snr), Jim Dargan, Bill Staffordshire and his occupation as Real Stephenson (Jnr), Eric Brown with son, Jim on his lap, Mr Harvey, Frank Brown, Estate Agent. The declaration made by Walter Brown, Billy Stephenson, Emilly Jeffs (Office), Cecil Stephenson, Eric Lewis. him states I Eric Johnston Brown do solemnly declare that the above answers Middle Row Standing: Dick Hughes, Paddy Doyle, Conor McDonald, Jim McEvoy, made by me to the above questions are Richie Lawlor, Johnny Lillis, Sean Walsh, Paddy Kelly, George Darcy (Jnr)Paddy Mc- true and that I am willing to fulfil the en- Donald, Tommy Lawlor, Willy Millbanks, Johnny Dargan, Ted Dargan, Dick Gregory. gagements by me now made, and I hereby engage and agree to serve in the Back Row: George Watkins, Christy Pender, John Monaghan (Snr), Jack Walsh(Snr), Canadian Over-Seas Expeditionary Peter Hughes, John Doyle, George Darcy (Snr), John Michaels, Jim Geoghegan, Force, and to be attached to any arm of Billy Watkins, John Boyle, Frick Doyle, Willy Kinsella, Jack Monaghan (Jnr) the service therein, for the term of one year, or during the war now existing between Great Britain and Germany and ters; Eric Johnstone Brown (1886-1959), to Jessie and John Hastings Brown who should that war last longer than one year, William Kenneth Brown (1888-1973), lived at Bagenalstown. He was the sec- and for six months after the termination Nan Brown (1889-1968), John Brown ond of 8 children. He married Bessie of that war provided His Majesty should (1892-1968), Harold Malcolm Brown Mitchell from Montrose Scotland. They so long require my services, or until (1899—1947), Madge Brown 1899- lived at Enniscorthy, Co. Wexford and legally discharged. 1967), Jerry Brown (1901-1969 and had no children. Ken took over S. and A. Date 6th January 1917. Frank McDonald Brown (1901-1975). G. Davis’s Mill which was located on the Frank spent some time in Natal, South banks of the Urin, a tributary to the River After the end of WW1 and the breakup Africa and when he returned home lived Slaney at Enniscorthy. S. & G.Davis (En- of his marriage with Margaret Tibbits, in a small house on the estate but later niscorthy) Ltd. was set up on Saturday Eric returned to Ireland. Sometime after- had a bungalow built part way up the av- 31st of July 1915 in Co. Wexford. The wards Marjory Stirton from Winnipeg enue to Eastwood House on the left hand Company was dissolved and closed on left Canada on board a ship and arrived side and lived there. He suffered from se- Tuesday 10th of December 2002. The in England. Eric was expecting her but vere arthritis and died on the 2nd of July mill operated for just over one year more did not know the port of arrival and so he 1975. Frank is buried alongside his as Cooney Grain and finally closed on visited a number of ports until he even- brother Eric in Bagenalstown cemetery Friday the 7th of May 2004. William tually succeeded in finding her. They on the Fenagh Road. Kennet Brown died in 1973. were married and spent their honeymoon in Bray Co. Wicklow. William Kenneth Brown was born on the Eric Johnston Brown eldest son of John 11th of June 1888 at Montrose Scotland Hastings and Jessie Johnston was born James Stirton lived in Forfarshire, Angus Scotland. He married Janet Crichton. On Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 14

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

the 13th of June 1816 Janet gave birth to their first son whom they called David. When David Stirton was about 11 years old he emigrated with his father and mother to Canada. The family settled in the bush about 5 miles from the present city of Guelph. David’s brother William Stirton was the first male child born in Guelph. David first toiled as a farmer in the townships of Guelph and Pulslinch, South Wellington, Nova Scotia. He had long connections with municipal affairs in Pulslinch ending in 1867. He then represented South Wellington in the Old Canadian Parliament and for 9 years after Confederation retained a seat in the House of Commons. He retired from Par- liamentary life in in 1876 upon his appointment to the office of Postmaster of Guelph. David Stirton was twice mar- Three generations of the Brown Family. ried, in 1842 to Mary Beattie of Pulslich Walter Brown, John Hastings Brown and Eric Brown. and in 1847 to Henrietta (unknown) and had children by both marriages. In the 1901 Census in Canada he is recorded in wife Alice continued to live on East Wellington, Ontario at the age of 84 in Eastwood. 1) Walter Stewart Brown, younger brother of Frank Beveridge, was a member of the Ireland rugby team years , widowed along with his daughter that won the Triple Crown for the first time in 1894. Mary J. Barlelay age 55 years (born the Eric and Marjory had one son Jim Brown At that time also he was a member of the Dublin 19th of April 1845 in Ontario). He died who was born on the 7th of May 1945. University Club. on the 15th of August 1908 at Guelph, Eric died on the 4th January 1959 aged 2) John Hastings Brown was captain of the Carlow Rugby team at one stage. Wellington, Ontario. 83 years. Jim attended a boarding school 3) Eric Johnston Brown donated the Green Park away from home from an early age and (Fair Green) in the centre of Bagenalstown for the On the 9th of December 1847 James Stir- at 13 years of age while away at school use of the people. ton was born to David and Henrietta Stir- his father died. So, Jim’s early memories 4) Jim Brown’s half-brother Christopher Brown lived in England and when WW2 broke out he was ton near the city of Guelph Ontario. connect more with his mother. attending college and so he and two of his friends James farmed up to 1879 and then went decided to join the forces. One friend joined the in to the grain business in Manitoba until After the death of his father his mother army, the second friend joined the navy and 1892. James married firstly Maggie Mar- Marjory discussed with him, whether Christopher joined the R.A.F. Christopher took part in many important bombing missions and at the end tin of Dumfries Ontario in 1869 and they they should return to Canada or stay in of the war he was glad to return once more to had 3 children. Maggie died and James Ireland and his mother’s preference was college where he met up with his two former Stirton then married Elizabeth Lindsay to stay in Ireland and so it happened. friends, life continued on and Christopher became Barclay from Guelph Manitoba. Marjory a doctor. Stirton was born to James and Elizabeth Marjory died on the 26th of March 1983 Lindsay Stirton in the year 1900 at Man- aged 83 years. Eric and Marjory were Hans Jeffrey White itoba, Canada. James and Elizabeth had both buried in Bagenalstown cemetery Colonel William Flower commenced the a total of 7 children. James moved in to on the Fenagh road. construction of Castle Durrow in Co. the real estate and financial business in Laois in 1712. The Flower family as- Morden and in 1901 he was appointed Jim Brown married Margaret Blenner- sumed residency in 1716 and continued Morden Postmaster. On the 3rd of June hasset from Beaufort, Co. Kerry and they to expand and improve their Estate on 1927 James Stirton died at Morden. had 4 children, Judy, Eric, Diane, and various occasions. The family were Susan. Jim managed the farm business regarded as benevolent Landlords and Eric Johnston Brown and Marjory Stirton and continued to live on at the Long were the largest employers of Durrow settled in the Long Range at Bagenal- Range until 1971 when he and Margaret village. They had growing financial prob- stow.Eric and his younger brother Frank moved to live at Killinane Farm on the lems up to 1919 but kept their Mansions managed the Brown and Crosthwait west side of the river Barrow. of Castle Durrow, Cloonageera and Lodge Mill business. Eric’s Uncle, Frank Knocknatrina in decent condition. How- Beveridge Brown had bought Eastwood ever, in 1922 the banks foreclosed and House and all lands of the Demesne in Notes: some members of the family relocated 1919 and had moved in to Eastwood 1) Re "Nicholas" Hastings wife of John Stewart back to Britain. Castle Durrow was sold. House. Frank Beveridge died in 1922 and Brown; the "s" in her first name refers to a Robin Flower the inventor was born on his son Frank Stewart Brown and his family name. the 1st of April at Castle Durrow. He Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 15

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

Residents of Eastwood House Residents of the Lodge Mills House Hart, son in law of Hans Jeffrey and (The Lodge) Mary Catherine White, arrived in East- Bagenal Family Matthew and Richard Weld wood and now resides there along with Michael Carter Matthew Weld Hartstonge & Richard Weld his son Edmund. Edward Vigors Samuel Crosthwait (Senior) History and Folklore Richard Mercer Samuel Crosthwait (Son) In my recent retirement years I go walk- William Chaigneau Colville ing several times a week. One day in Joseph Weld early 2014 I set off as usual up Royal Matthew Weld (son of Joseph) Lodge Millers Oak Road, down the Long Range and Mary Weld (Wife of Matthew) Owen Murphy into Regent Street, my favoured Street of Robert Wybrants Edward Vigors Day Dreams. My eyes and mind were Captain Algernon Moreton Richard Mercer focused on Tom Singleton’s large home Captain Arthur Henley Matthew & Richard Weld (and later Bank of Ireland), as my feet Adjutant Arthur Forbes-Gordon M. W. Hartstonge & Richard Weld carried me along. I visualised the house Colonel William Barton Wade Samuel Crosthwait (Senior) as it would have been in the glory years of canal and milling. Behind the house William Ernest Elwell Samuel Crosthwait (Son) and forming a continuous building down Colonel George Ewbanks Frank Briggs Brown & Crosthwait to the quay and continuing south down Frank Beveridge Brown the quayside, grain stores and stables for Frank Stewart Brown horses. Tom was a respected and prosper- Hans Jeffrey White ous business man of the time with 18 Mary Catherine White boats working the canal to Dublin, Wa- John Hart terford and towns in between. The stables of course were for the horses that towed the canal boats. I was drawn back into remarried Gertrude Sophia daughter of became a renowned producer of herba- ality as a voice rang out “that’s a fine big Rev. Sewell Hamilton. They had five ceous plants. She died on the 1st of Feb- house there”. I spied on the other side of children. One of his daughters Frances ruary 2002 and her ashes were buried in the street Jimmy and Bridget Kelly, shop- Mary Flower married Henry Ernest Nicholastown Churchyard. Her husband ping bags in hand on the way home. I White and they lived at Knocknatrina Hans Jeffrey had predeceased her. After crossed the street and opened my mind to House, Durrow Co. Laois. From 1869 the death of Mary the White family ex- them of how I visualised the street in the Robin Flower lived at Knocknatrina. tended an invitation to John Hart to come past leading up to the gate entrance of Frances Mary was widowed in 1923. On and live in Eastwood. His wife Catherine Eastwood House. Jimmy then related to October the 2nd 1940 one of her sons had died previous to this and so John me a story he had heard from an elder of Hans Jeffrey White who lived at Knock- natrina married in Dublin, Mary Cather- King James’s Irish Army List 1689/90 ine (Reena)Brennan of Eden Hall, Colonel Dudley Bagenal’s Infantry Regiment (Men =515) Ballyragget, eldest daughter of Richard Captains Lieutenants Ensigns Brennan and Kathleen Mary Clare Mor- ris. Henry and Mary lived firstly at Cool- The Colonel William Bourke John Comerford more House, Thomastown and in 1945 James Power Thomas Meara Edward Butler moved to Eastwood House in Bagenal- Lieutenant Colonel stown. They had 6 children; Jeffrey, Major - Corbett ------Catherine, Ian, Robert, Richenda and -- Gaffney ------Roger. Catherine White married John Geffrey Prendergast Walter Prendergast James Prendergast Hart of Chichester, and they lived in Nicholas Power Richard Wadding Edmund Power Chichester, England. In 1968 Eastwood John Meagher Edmund Meagher Thomas Meagher House caught fire and extensive damage Daniel Hogan Richard Morris William Hogan was done to the front of the house and the Richard Fanning Edmund Connor Thomas Butler roof. The insurance was not sufficient to restore the front of the house and so it John Keating Robert prendergast Piers keating was demolished. A new front was created Richard Mansfield Edmund Roche David Roche at the remainder of the front building and Bryan O’Bryan Murtogh O’Bryan Edward Butler a new roof was added to the entire build- Thomas Purcell John Dwyer Nicholas Purcell ing. The basement of the knocked front John Moclare Edmund Tobin James Moclare building still exists under the front ap- Philip Dwyer Thomas Dwyer proach to the house but has been sealed Grenadier Edmund Butler off. Mary Catherine White established -----Doherty, Quarter Master -- Tobin, Surgeon Eastwood Nurseries and she eventually

Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:42 Page 16

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

in the Royal Oak. Some twenty or thirty houses and cabins formed a sort of a street there. This house may be where King James and his escort stayed in 1690. The house was in 1815 used by Bianconi’s coaches as an Inn, a stopover and for a change of horses. A signboard ornamented the front of the house in its early years, which depicted a Royal Monarch hidden in an oak tree. Perhaps this picture commemorated the visit of King James or it may be as claimed by some that it commemorated the famous escape of King Charles 11 (1630-1685) in England by concealment in an oak tree.

The satirist poet and author Makepeace Thackeray made a journey through Ireland in the first half of the 19th century and wrote of his visit to the Royal Oak in his journal “The Irish Sketch Book.” He did not stay overnight but he and his party journeyed on to a farmer’s house situated between Royal Oak Front of Eastwood House 2015 and Gowran where they stayed the night. The original Royal Oak Inn building was demolished the town in his boyhood days. The story sisted of 36,000 men and James’s 25,000 in 1974. goes somewhat like “There was a king in men. James showed no courage at the trouble in Dublin and he had to flee from battle and at first intimation of defeat fled Some 500 metres east of the Royal Oak Walter Bagenal built the first bridge across the River Bar- there. He travelled down through Wick- to Dublin with a small escort and it is row to Bagenalstown and before that time some 50 low and was expected to stay overnight most likely that this small escort included metres below the bridge was the ancient ford. When in Eastwood House. There was great ex- Dudley Bagenal. They stayed overnight Walter Bagenal commissioned the building of the citement in the big house and great in Dublin and set out next morning bridge at Royal Oak he placed a wager with a contemporary of his that a horse and carriage would preparations were being made to receive through Wicklow for the south (Kinsale) cross it within a specific period of months. The time the Royal visitor. However, then came or south east coast (Duncannon). They of the wager was almost up and it became clear that the disappointment, the King and his crossed the river Barrow at Leighlin- the bridge would not be completed in time. Walter companions crossed the bridge at Leigh- bridge and stayed at a large house in the ordered that planks be placed across the bridge structure and he drove his carriage across and won lin and stayed in a house at the townland of Clorusk. The plan may have the wager. Royal Oak.” been to stay at the Lodge, a house of the 2) Juliana Carew daughter of Robert Carew (Bally- Bagenals that we now know as Eastwood boro, Co. Wexford) married secondly Thomas Way Later on that evening I recalled having in the townland of Moneybeg but accord- in 1707. 3) Other County Carlow electors who were mem- heard a similar story from another man ing to legend that did not happen. The bers of the King James Parliament: – Burrough of that had heard it from the same source as next morning they set out for their desti- Carlow: Mark Baggott, John Warren. Burrough of Jimmy Kelly. It was relayed to me that the nation in Ireland and eventually boarded Old Leighlin: Darby Long, Daniel Doran. original source had recorded quite an a ship that took them to Brest, Brittany, House of Lords – Cheevers, Viscount Mount Leinster (a new creation amount of local folklore that was left in France. King James set up Court at St. of King James). his house when he died. He was not a man Germain-en-Lay near Paris with Dudley Lord William Brereton, of Old Leighlin that had published any of his material. Bagenal as Gentleman Usher to him. (not present). James died there on the 6th September Richard Ogle, Viscount Carlow (not present). I have weaved fact, history and folklore 1701. Dudley Bagenal died at Bruges, together and have placed the above re- Belgium in 1712. Sources and Gratitudes lated story in what I believe is its histor- Clerical & Pastoral Records, Cork, ical background. I start with when Perhaps King James and his group did Cloyne & Ross by W. Maziere Brady Dudley Bagenal recruited and com- cross the bridge at Leighlin, travelled on Volumes 1,2,3 manded an Infantry Regiment for the to the Royal Oak, re-crossed the Barrow Asssociation for the Memorials of the army of King James 11, first at the Siege at the Royal Oak ford, stayed in East- Dead of Ireland. of Derry 18th April – 28th July 1689 and wood House and that it was from these Visitation of Ireland by Frederick Arthur then at the Battle of the Boyne 1st July events came the names - Royal Oak, Crisp. 1690 and at stake was the British throne. Royal Oak Road and Regent Street and The Irish Tourist by Rev. A. Atkinson Dudley Bagenal and Henry Luttrell that it was from Eastwood House in the representing County Carlow had townland of Moneybeg grew the town 1815. attended the King James Parliament in of Bagenalstown. Arthur Young’s Tour of Ireland. Dublin that sat from the 7th May until the Ulster Journal of Archaeology, January 20th July. The battle at the Boyne was Notes: 1900, Volume 6. between William 111 and his father-in- 1) On the estate of Major Boyle Heuson of The Memoirs (Chiefly Autobiographical) law the deposed King James 11. It took Kilkenny circa 1640 a big house was built in the from 1798 to 1886 of Richard Malden. townland of Clorusk, Co. Carlow. On his demise place on the 1st of July 1690 on the banks The Liffey in Dublin by J.de Courcy, the Major left the estate to the Way family in the Dublin 1996. of the River Boyne. William’s army con- first half of the 1800s. The house was located where the present car park is across the road from the pub Dictionary of National Biography 1885-

Carloviana 2016 Eastwood edited Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 16:43 Page 17

Eastwood House and the Moneybeg Demesne

1900. The Antiquary Volume X1 January – The Irish Almanac & Official Directory Cliffe Vigors Papers, National Archives June 1885. 1884. Dublin. Mac Donald’s Iris Directory & Gazetter Pigot & Co’s Provincial Directory of Registry of Deeds Dublin. 1929 Edition. 1824. History and Antiquities of Carlow by Soldiers of the First World War Canada. Susan Stoney John Ryan. Griffiths Valuation 1852. Denis Brown The Carlow Gentry by Jimmy O Toole. Tithe Applotment Book 1825. Jim Brown. A Genealogical & Heraldic Dictionary The Peerage Compiled by Daryl Lundy. John Hart. of the Landed Gentry by Sir Bernard Census of Ireland 1901 & 1911. Martin Nevin. Burke. Irish Genealogy.ie Jim Murphy Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquar- Family Search.org. Tommy Lawler ies of Ireland Volume 31. Mocavo.co.uk King James’s Irish Army List 1689 by The Origins and Development of Bage- Slaters Directory of Ireland 1894. John Dalton nalstown 1680-1900 by Catherine Ann The London Gazette 20th October 1874. Power. The London Gazette 18th February 1879.

Bachelors Walk and Regent Street showing what was the Photo of G. Bernard Shaw old Court House, now the Library found among Brown family photo collection.

The bridge to bog field 2015

Carloviana 2016 Capt Murphy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:13 Page 1

Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow

Unsung hero of the Somme

John O’ Donovan

In the view of one highly-acclaimed war The success at Ginchy was achieved at a the boys followed their father into busi- correspondent, the capture of Ginchy high price, with hundreds of casualties ness but there was also a diocesan priest deserved to be written ‘not in journalist’s among the six battalions of the 16th Irish and a medical doctor, while one of his prose, but in heroic verse’ and the same Division that participated in the attack. daughters entered the local convent, reporter went on to claim that the The 9th Battalion, Royal Dublin Fusiliers becoming a Brigidine nun. victorious Irish had added ‘a very noble – a battalion whose contribution proved episode to the history of the Celtic race’.1 crucial to the success of the operation – As the 19th century drew to a close, the Meanwhile, another prominent news- suffered heavily during the bloody Murphy family was not just the dominant paper praised the determination and encounter, losing six officers and sixty- force in the commercial and business life valour of the soldiers, suggesting that one men with countless others wounded. of the town, but they were also substantial ‘the narrative of the battle should be told The elation of victory was short-lived as landowners in the wider Tullow area. in Irish homes for centuries’.2 In addition, the decimated battalion struggled to Trading under the name W. Murphy & an eye-witness account from a Jesuit come to terms with the scale of the Son, Edward, the eldest, operated a chaplain who accompanied the troops as casualties that had been inflicted. grocery and licensed premises, located at they overwhelmed enemy forces in the Among those that lay dead on the battle- the junction of Market Square and Barrack village of Ginchy, on 9 September 1916, field was the battalion’s commanding St. This establishment, with a spirit bar maintained that ‘the wild rush of our Irish officer, thirty-six year old Captain W J ‘counted as one of the finest in the lads swept the Germans away like Murphy, a grocer’s son from Tullow, provinces of Ireland’, was destroyed by chaff’.3 These accounts, overstated or County Carlow. fire in 1898, but it was immediately rebuilt embellished as they may well have been, to the highest specifications. The ‘colos- are but a sample of the many glowing Background sal’ new building boasted a counter fifty- reports that chronicled the undisputed six feet in length, had ceilings panelled courage displayed by the Irish battalions, William Joseph Murphy came from a with Norfolk pine and featured an exterior whose fighting spirit at Ginchy won prominent business family, long assoc- faced with red Bridgewater brick.7 Across widespread praise and admiration. iated with the town of Tullow. His grand- the street on the other corner – also at the father – also William Murphy – had been junction of Barrack St and The Square – Probably the shortest battle of the a local shopkeeper who first opened his his brother Joseph carried on a successful Somme offensive, Ginchy was, nonethe- doors to the public in the 1840s. Trading hardware business. Meanwhile another less, a significant victory as it deprived from premises on the Market Square in brother, John George, – better known as the Germans of strategic observation Tullow, he established a successful busi- Jack – who lived at Belmont on New posts overlooking the entire combat ness, catering for a variety of local needs Chapel Lane, was an extensive farmer and zone. ‘The strongest of all the many as a butcher, grocer, wine merchant and his standing in the town was further en- fortified villages in the German line’, the ironmonger.5 As William Murphy’s retail hanced by an appointment as a local jus- Irish were said to have broken through interests continued to expand, so also did tice of the peace. Apart from their ‘the intricate defences of the enemy as a the size of his family with eight boys and individual business interests, Edward and torrent sweeps down rubble’.4 Its capture three girls surviving to adulthood. It was Joe Murphy were also involved in a joint – after a number of earlier assaults by a measure of his growing prosperity that enterprise, Murphy Brothers Auctioneers, British regiments had been repulsed – not no fewer than five of his sons attended a business that operated from premises on only boosted morale but opened the way boarding school at St Vincent’s College, Bridge St with branch offices in Carlow for further advances along the front. Castleknock.6 Career wise, a number of and Bagenalstown.

Carloviana 2016 Capt Murphy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:13 Page 2

38 Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow - unsung hero of the Somme

residence, Kilmagarvogue House, about three miles north of the town.

Gentleman and Sportsman

With the transition to country life, Bill Murphy became something of a gentleman farmer, indulging in various leisure activities, not least of which was a keen interest in horses and horsemanship. Along with his sister Tess, he was a regular on the hunting circuit and was also a frequent participant in jumping competitions; it was not unusual, at that time, to read in the Nationalist or the Sen- Early 20th century Tullow with W. Murphy & Son premises extreme left of picture tinel that ‘Mr W J Murphy, Kilmagar- vogue House, Tullow’ had taken the Each of the three Murphy brothers that attending school locally. As a young man honours at one or other jumping event. remained in Tullow made a contribution he was ‘extremely popular with the pub- Murphy kept several horses at Kill, his to public life. Edward was the unanimous lic owing to his amiability and other good most successful being a mare named Bit choice of local Nationalists when they qualities’ and it was said that he ‘enjoyed o’Skirt, on which he dominated in the gathered in 1899 to select a representa- the goodwill and esteem of all classes of jumping arena at the County Carlow tive to sit on Carlow’s first County Coun- the community’.11 Bill Murphy’s second- Agricultural Society’s Annual Show for cil.8 A strong supporter of Home Rule, he ary education was entrusted to two four successive years, beginning in 15 also had a genuine concern for the disad- different religious congregations and in 1903. At one of these shows, he jumped vantaged and was well-known for his two highly contrasting establishments. on five different horses in the various generosity towards that particular section From May 1893 until March 1896 he events and while, as usual, Bit o’Skirt of society; given his charitable disposi- attended the Patrician Brothers’ took the top award, he also collected tion, it was not surprising that he also Monastery Day School in Tullow, there- prizes with the more mundane sounding played a leading part in the Tullow St after transferring to the more prestigious Michael and Little Bill. The Carlow and Vincent de Paul Society. Following Clongowes Wood College.12 In this Island Hunt Sportsman’s Meeting was Edward’s untimely death, his seat on the County Kildare boarding school, under another annual event where Bill Mur- County Council passed to his brother the tutelage of the Jesuits, he spent the phy’s equestrian skills were displayed to Jack who went on to represent the area final two years of his formal education. good effect. for a number of years. Joe Murphy was During his short period at Clongowes, his involved in municipal affairs, becoming name does not appear to have come to the The description of Bill Murphy as being a member, and first chairman, of Tullow fore in the academic, sporting or extra ‘full of pluck and daring and a good Town Commission when that body was curricular spheres. all-round sportsman’ was clearly not just established in 1902. a reference to his horsemanship, as he Early in 1900, Bill Murphy was forced to was actively involved in a number of 16 In January 1879, Edward Murphy had take on additional responsibilities when other sports as well. Rugby – at the married Mary Joseph Farrelly, a grocer’s his father died unexpectedly at the age of time, still the preserve of the wealthier daughter from the Coombe area of fifty-two. Edward Murphy had been to classes – was another interest and, in his Dublin and, the following year, they Kingstown to see-off his daughter Teresa early twenties, he regularly lined out for celebrated the birth of a son and heir.9 Jane, who was returning to England the County Carlow Football Club. He Born in Tullow on 16 April 1880, he was where she was completing her education. had, no doubt, first encountered the game christened William Joseph Murphy, a He contracted influenza that quickly during his teenage years when he was a name that seemed destined to loom large developed into pneumonia and, despite student at Clongowes Wood College, a in the business life of Tullow but would, the best efforts of doctors at a Dublin school with a strong rugby tradition. The instead, feature in the footnotes of First hospital, he did not respond to treat- claim that he was ‘probably one of the World War history.10 An only son with ment.13 Although still under the age of best players in the United Kingdom’ may just one younger sister, he was in line for twenty, Bill – along with his mother – well have been an exaggeration, but he a considerable inheritance and it was took over the management of the grocery was highly regarded on the playing field taken for granted that he would, in time, in Tullow but, after a couple of years, the and he served as vice-captain of the 17 follow in the footsteps of his father and family decided to step back from front- Carlow club for the 1905-06 season. grandfather. Bill, as he was generally line shopkeeping.14 Having installed a known, grew up in a well-to-do family, manager and a number of live-in employ- Cricket was yet another game that helping out in the shop and learning the ees to operate the business, the Murphys appealed to the young Bill Murphy. In grocery trade from his father, while moved permanently to their country 1905, he was included in the Carlow XI,

Carloviana 2016 Capt Murphy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:13 Page 3

39 Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow - unsung hero of the Somme

early 1900s, Jack Murphy took leave of his family and Murphy married headed for the wheat belt of Western Mary Angela O’Con- Australia.22 nor and, a few years later, her brother Wilgie Hills Bernard wed Tess Murphy of Kilma- One of the first settlers to arrive in the garvogue House. Dalwallinu area, Bill Murphy found that turning a vast wilderness into arable Encouraged – or farming land was no easy task, so it was perhaps, persuaded – a couple of years before wheat could be by his Australian grown. The Murphy property, which friends, Bill Murphy came to be known as Wilgie Hills, Kilmagarvogue House set out on an amounted, in total, to about four-thou- exploratory trip to sand acres, an enormous holding by any perhaps the highlight of his cricket the colony, landing at the port of Freman- standards. A clearing programme to rid career, and he was also involved in the tle towards the end of 1906. First impres- the land of bush and scrub was com- local Tullow club.18 During August of sions must have been favourable for he menced, fencing was erected and a well that year – alongside his uncle Jack – he quickly applied to the Lands Department to provide fresh water was dug. The was on the Tullow team that defeated to lease a considerable amount of bush- operation was overseen from a camp that Kildare by one run. In addition, he land in a remote region about one-hun- Murphy had established and it was here, occasionally took part in matches with his dred-and-sixty miles north of Perth. This in a canvas tent, that he had his own own selection, known appropriately isolated area was completely untamed, accommodation; living conditions were enough as the ‘W J Murphy XI’. But as had no towns and, at that time, a railway extremely basic, in stark contrast to the the 1906 sporting seasons came to an end, was only at the planning stages. Follow- comfortable existence that he had pre- so also did Murphy’s association with ing a survey, he was issued, in October viously enjoyed in Tullow. By 1910, the local sporting organisations and events; he 1907, with a Crown lease for an area de- first crops had been planted and with the was coming to a decision on a major life- scribed as Ningham Location 55; this completion of the railway, together with change that would take him far from the one-hundred-and-sixty acre holding was the growth of the town of Dalwallinu, playing fields and jumping arenas of south of Wilgie Hill and close to the em- County Carlow. bryonic towns of Dalwallinu and Pithara, settlements that would develop at stations Australian Adventure on the new rail line. The official survey of the block indicated that the land was Murphy was planning to emigrate to bounded on the west by a road and it was Australia where vast tracts of land were also noted that York gums grew on the available for leasing by European settlers loamy soil.20 That was only the first with a view to starting farming enter- acquisition, as later, several other leases prises. It is not clear why he opted for such would be granted in his own name as a drastic change in his way of life, well as those of his mother and a certain although one source suggests that he did Thomas Murphy, assumed to be a rela- so for unspecified health reasons.19 There tive in Ireland. Meanwhile, Bill Murphy is every likelihood, however, that it was had returned home to Ireland to make the the Murphys close ties with the O’Connor necessary arrangements for a more family from Western Australia that permanent move to Australia. prompted consideration of such a move. The O’Connors were a prosperous family In November 1907, he was on hand to that lived in, and around, the Western ‘give away’ his sister Tess when she Australian city of Perth. Their Kerry-born married Bernard Maurice O’Connor at father had been an involuntary immigrant University Chapel, St Stephen’s Green, but went on to become a highly successful the ceremony being followed by a recep- businessman, acquiring several extensive tion in the Shelbourne Hotel.21 O’Connor, rural estates as well as investing in prop- a man with extensive land, business and erty and land in the city. A number of his mining interests in Australia, chose to Murphy during his years as an sons attended Clongowes Wood Jesuit spend the early years of his married life Australian wheat farmer College in Kildare and it was during these living and farming at Kill House, while years that they made the acquaintance of his brother-in-law embarked on a very some type of normality descended on the the Murphys. A friendship developed and different kind of adventure; and so it was area. His isolation from family also eased the bond between the families was further that, in the summer of 1908, having in 1912 when his sister Tess, with her strengthened by two marriages: in the settled his affairs and made a will, husband and two young sons, moved to Carloviana 2016 Capt Murphy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:13 Page 4

40 Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow - unsung hero of the Somme

vate with the 7th Battalion, Leinster Reg- iment, being given the service number 1425. Signing up for three years, or the duration of the war, he gave his national- ity as British, described his occupation as rancher and, for whatever reason, understated his age by some five years.25 His period as a private soldier, however, was short, as he quickly became a sergeant- major and, within weeks, joined the regiment’s newly established cadet corps, formed to address the dire shortage of officers; given Murphy’s background and education – not to mention his maturity and life experiences – he would have The Camp at Wilgie Hills with unfinished H-shaped building in centre of picture been seen as ideal officer material at the time. After what appears to have been a cursory training, he was gazetted a lieu- Australia, settling on an O’Connor estate Joining the Colours tenant on Christmas Day 1914, and then near Toodyay, about one-hundred miles transferred to the 9th Battalion, Royal south of Wilgie Hills. Holidaying with his mother at Kill House Dublin Fusiliers, at Buttevant Barracks. in the autumn of 1914, Bill Murphy kept It was said to be ‘the regiment of his In a history of Dalwallinu, compiled sev- up-to-date with the progress of the war, liking’ but his home address may well eral decades after his death, Murphy’s took note of the prevailing political have been a factor, as Carlow was one of tenure at Wilgie Hills is recalled thus: discourse and, eventually, opted to volun- the four counties that traditionally sup- ‘Neighbours remembered Bill Murphy as teer for service. He was said to have plied recruits to the Royal Dublin being a charming, generous person who ‘entered the army from purely national Fusiliers.26 did most things on a grand scale. Whereas motives’ and that ‘he believed in the wis- they would buy an axe handle or a Against the backdrop of a peaceful hammer, he would purchase a crate of County Cork countryside the 9th them. He welcomed many callers who Dublins, along with the other battalions asked for water from his well or who of the 48th Brigade, began preparing for wanted to borrow a spade, a pick or a war. (The 48th, together with the 47th water bag’. Wheat-growing was always and 49th Brigades comprised the 16th the dominant enterprise at Wilgie Hills but Irish Division) Lieutenant Murphy obvi- the Dalwallinu history records one attempt ously impressed his superior officers at diversification: ‘Several people also with the result that, in April 1915, he was recalled that he attempted to run sheep promoted to the rank of temporary cap- about 1911. The venture was not a success tain, being assigned to the battalion’s D for most of the mob died after eating Company. Two months later, he moved poisonous plants while being taken by with his battalion from Buttevant to an road from Moora to Wilgie Hills’.23 army camp at Ballyhooly near Fermoy, for further training exercises. In Septem- Bill Murphy clearly intended to remain ber 1915, after some ten months of mili- in the area for some time and, as soon as tary manoeuvres in north County Cork, the land was cleared and planted, he Bill Murphy in the uniform of Captain Murphy accompanied the 9th turned his attention to the construction of the Royal Dublin Fusiliers Battalion, Royal Dublin Fusiliers to permanent buildings at the camp. Work Blackdown Barracks in Aldershot where began on an H-shaped complex with ma- final preparations for active service chinery and feed stores at one end and dom of Mr Redmond’s policy, and acted would begin. As the countdown to war living quarters at the other, these two accordingly’.24 The fact that Murphy’s continued, Bill Murphy made one last blocks to be connected by a row of sojourn at Kill coincided with John Red- visit home to Tullow in November be- stables. The building progressed to roof- mond’s Woodenbridge speech calling for fore, as the local press report put it, ‘start- level but, unfortunately, it was never Irish participation in the war – ‘in defence ing to take his place with his company of finished. As the world powers prepared of right, of freedom and of religion’ – un- Dublin Fusiliers in the trenches’.27 for war in 1914, Murphy decided to visit doubtedly influenced his decision his mother in Ireland, hardly realising, as to enlist. To the Front he set out on that long journey, that he would never return to Wilgie Hills. In early November, he presented at Fer- Just days before Christmas 1915, nine- moy Barracks where he enlisted as a pri- hundred-and-nineteen men and thirty-

Carloviana 2016 Capt Murphy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:13 Page 5

Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow - unsung hero of the Somme

three officers of the 9th Battalion, Royal then little more than a pile of rubble but trenches that the men had dug over the Dublin Fusiliers, landed at Le Havre with the 19th Bavarian Regiment was two previous nights. With the assault the 48th Brigade.28 After arriving in entrenched in cellars and underground timed for 4.45 pm, the massed troops France, the battalion was constantly on fortresses with a vast array of machine- spent most of the day on standby in the the move and, as well as trench training, gun emplacements ready to repel all trenches while British artillery pounded it liaised with other units and was attacks. As the 48th Brigade was tasked the enemy lines and the Germans replied involved in some engagements, in a sup- with the capture of Ginchy, Captain with a counter-barrage that caused sev- porting role. Between March and August Murphy and his fellow battalion com- eral casualties among the ranks waiting 1916, the 16th Irish Division was intro- manders finalised the strategy to be to go into action. At zero hour Captain duced to trench warfare in the Loos area employed for the offensive, fixed for Murphy gave the signal and led his of north-eastern France, with the 9th Saturday, 9 September. It was arranged battalion out of the trenches, following Dublins sustaining heavy casualties, par- that the brigade would attack from the the 7th Royal Irish Rifles into battle, with ticularly during the German gas attacks south-west of the village with four the 8th Dublins moving forward on their at Hulluch. Captain Murphy came battalions, the 7th Royal Irish Rifles and right. Advancing with four companies, through these hostilities unscathed, but the 1st Royal Munster Fusiliers in the the 9th Dublins leap-frogged the 7th he was hospitalised for ten days at St front trench with the 8th and 9th Dublins Rifles, who had reached their objective Omer, the complaint being nothing more in the second line.31 and consolidated, before facing into the serious than a bout of measles.29 The war titanic struggle that lay ahead of them. of attrition in the Loos area dragged on The storming of Ginchy was one of the Daylight was fading and rain was falling but, towards the end of August, the forces notable successes of the Somme offensive as Murphy’s battalion rushed headlong of the 16th Irish Division were diverted but victory came at a high price. Contem- towards Ginchy, to be met with a storm elsewhere, being ordered to relocate to porary reports tended to romanticise the of artillery and machine-gun fire.33 With the valley of the Somme. battle, with references to the ‘dash and fierce determination, and despite mount- daring of the Irish troops’ and suggestions ing casualties, the 8th and 9th Dublins led During the first week of September some that ‘men wrestled for the privilege of the assault through Ginchy, reaching their units of the 16th Division played a sig- sharing in the glory’; another account told objective – a German supply line north nificant part in the capture of the village how the Irish ‘swept on triumphantly of the village – and managing to round of Guillemont. The 9th Battalion, Royal through the village of Ginchy’, displaying up two-hundred prisoners. But, as the 9th Dublin Fusiliers was not directly ‘irresistible dash’ on the field of battle.32 Dublins consolidated and dug-in, they involved but, in the support trenches on The reality, of course, was quite different did so without their commanding officer the periphery of the hostilities, it was and, despite the undoubted courage and who had fallen during the final stage of subjected to a sustained German bom- determination of the Irish, the enemy the assault, killed-in-action as his battal- bardment, resulting in heavy casualties. inflicted a heavy death toll. ion battled its way to victory and into the The battalion’s CO, Lt Colonel Thack- history books.34 eray – along with a major and two cap- Before day-break on 9 September, a tired tains – was among the wounded, and depleted 9th Battalion, Royal Dublin The exact circumstances of Captain resulting in the command of the 9th Fusiliers was already in the assembly Murphy’s death are unclear but it was Dublins passing to the most senior remaining officer – Captain W J Murphy.30

Ginchy

Fate had propelled Bill Murphy into a leadership role that he had hardly aspired to and, given the temporary nature of his commission, one for which he was probably ill-prepared. Within hours of taking command of the battalion on 6 Septem- ber 1916, he received orders to prepare for an assault on the village of Ginchy and, for this action, the entire operation was being entrusted to the 16th Irish Division with the 47th and 48th Brigades to the fore. He must have realised that the attack would be particularly hazardous for the commanders, who were forced to lead by example, exposing themselves to great danger in order to keep their soldiers moving. On an elevated site at the Map showing the formation for the Battle of Ginchy (Arrow indicates confluence of six roads, Ginchy was by the position of Murphy’s battalion) Carloviana 2016 Capt Murphy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:13 Page 6

Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow - unsung hero of the Somme

afterwards reported that he had been ‘hit beginning of the end of the Murphy fam- During the Second World War, all four of in the head by a rifle bullet’ and was seen ily’s involvement in the business life of Tess O’Connor’s sons served in the falling into a trench.35 The official record Tullow. At the time of her son’s death, British Armed Forces and, once again, states that ‘9th RDF advanced to the sec- Mary Murphy was already in Western tragedy would be visited upon the family. ond objective at 5.25 pm but suffered Australia on an extended visit with her Kevin O’Connor, a graduate of Jesus very heavy officer casualties in doing so. daughter Tess. Kill would never again be College, Cambridge, where he read eco- Captain W J Murphy (commanding) her permanent home, and she would nomics and – like his uncle – excelled on being killed as the battalion reached spend the rest of her life living with, or the sports field, was killed-in-action in Ginchy’.36 His former commanding near to, her daughter. Despite her ab- Italy in October 1943.40 A major in the officer later acknowledged Murphy’s sence, W. Murphy & Son continued to King’s Own Yorkshire Light Infantry, he heroic contribution to the capture of trade in Tullow but the business was dealt died as the Allies fought their way up the Ginchy, when he wrote: ‘he met his death a serious blow in September 1920 when Adriatic coast and he is buried in Sangro in a gallant and victorious charge at the Crown Forces torched the premises in a River War Cemetery. head of his battalion’.37 That courage and mindless and wanton act of retaliation for gallantry was afterwards officially recog- the murder of two RIC members in the A woman of considerable wealth with nu- nised when Bill Murphy was posthu- town.39 The grocery and bar were re- merous business interests, Tess O’Connor mously Mentioned in Despatches. stored but, while the business continued moved to live in Perth and it was there that to operate for some years, it eventually she spent her final years, residing in the The 9th Battalion, Royal Dublin Fusiliers ceased trading and the premises was sold affluent suburb of Peppermint Grove. She suffered up to two-hundred casualties and in the early 1930s; at that stage the house died, at the age of eighty-seven, in lost more than sixty men during the storm- and lands at Kill had already passed from October 1968, and is buried along with her ing of Ginchy. Six officers were killed family ownership, having been acquired husband and her two Tullow-born sons in and, with twice that number wounded, just by the Bolger family in 1925. the city’s Karrakatta cemetery.41 There is, two young lieutenants remained to take however, no such certainty as to the charge of the shattered battalion. One Tess O’Connor had, years earlier, opted for precise whereabouts of her only brother’s noteworthy individual who paid the ulti- the Australian way of life, raising her four final resting place. mate price on that day was Lieutenant boys near the small town of Toodyay, about Tom Kettle, poet, Irish nationalist, former fifty miles north-east of Perth. In 1925 she In Memoriam Member of Parliament and university moved temporarily to London while her professor, who had joined the 9th Dublins sons boarded at Downside, the exclusive Captain Bill Murphy has no known grave at the front just weeks earlier. Kettle, who Benedictine school in Somerset. Living, but he is believed to be buried in Guille- would have crossed paths with Bill along with her mother at an address in Hen- mont Road Cemetery, about a mile from Murphy at Clongowes, enlisted mainly don, it appears that her husband Bernard di- the scene of the battle where he died.42 In because of German outrages in Belgium, vided his time between England and the immediate aftermath of the Battle of and was in charge of the battalion’s B Australia. When Bernard O’Connor died in Ginchy in September 1916, the dead Company when he fell mortally wounded. 1932, the family returned to Toodyay but were buried in temporary graves, close to Because of his national profile, Kettle’s retained business and personal links with where they fell. It was recorded that role at Ginchy is generally highlighted, the United Kingdom. Captain Murphy’s body was found and while the likely more significant part buried and his identification disc was played by Murphy remains understated.

Bill Murphy was not the only Tullowman to perish on the battlefield at Ginchy. Forty-two year old Edward Wall, a sergeant in the 9th Battalion, Royal Dublin Fusiliers, lost his life during that deadly encounter on 9 September. It was a remarkable coincidence that, not only did they come from the same town, but the Wall family also lived in Barrack St where the young Bill Murphy had grown up.38 Despite an age gap of almost six years, they would previously have known each other on the streets of Tullow and surely that acquaintance was renewed in the trenches of the Somme before they both went to their deaths.

Disengagement Telegram from War Office informing family of Bill Murphy’s death, The tragic outcome at Ginchy marked the

Carloviana 2016 Capt Murphy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:13 Page 7

Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow - unsung hero of the Somme

included with other personal effects for removed. All the indications are that Bill return to his next-of-kin.43 Meanwhile, Murphy is buried at Guillemont Road, a the War Office telegram had arrived in cemetery where two-thirds of the two- Tullow and, with Mary Murphy absent in thousand-two-hundred grave-stones do Australia, it was the manager of W. not have a name. However, one of eight Murphy & Son that took delivery; special memorials located along the back Stephen Somers then had the unenviable wall of the cemetery is dedicated to his responsibility of forwarding the tragic memory and carries the inscription: and distressing news to the Murphy family in Toodyay. CAPTAIN W J MURPHY Captain Murphy’s death was acknowl- ROYAL DUBLIN FUSILIERS edged by religious and civic leaders in 9TH SEPTEMBER 1916. AGE 36 his native County Carlow. At the begin- REQUIESCAT IN PACE ning of October, a month’s mind Requiem Mass and Solemn Office took Closer to home, an inscription on Edward place in Tullow parish church with Murphy’s headstone in Grange church- Bishop Patrick Foley of Kildare and yard refers to his only son who ‘fell at Bill Murphy’s portrait that hangs in Leighlin in attendance, and with the Ginchy’ and he is also listed among Tullow museum deceased’s uncle, Fr Arthur Murphy, Tullow’s war dead on the Leighlinbridge officiating.44 Carlow Urban District Memorial. One of ninety-five Old Clon- the town and district of Tullow’. At the Council extended sympathy to the gownians to die in the Great War, he is time, still displaying a palpable sense of Murphy family with local MP, Michael remembered on a brass plaque inside the loss, Mary Murphy wrote: ‘I am glad to Molloy, remarking that ‘he gave his life porch of the boys’ chapel at Clongowes say both my daughter and I think it would for Ireland’ and ‘a finer type of Irishman Wood while, on the other side of the be fulfilling the wishes of my dear son, we could not find’.45 world, the Murphy name appears on the who always took such an interest in the Dalwallinu War Memorial in Western Club, to make a gift of the lease for the After the war ended, the Imperial War Australia. But surely the most tangible benefit of the young men of Tullow and Graves Commission began the grim task memorial to Bill Murphy is the town hall district. My husband built the hall solely of clearing the battlefields, a process that in Tullow that bears his name. for the purpose of providing them a continued into the early 1920s. In a means of recreation and rest during their painstaking exercise, bodies were In June 1929, his mother and sister gifted leisure time, and I’m sure it is what he exhumed and re-interred in war cemeter- the Commercial Club building in Barrack and Bill would wish, and we shall love to ies but, at that stage, identification was Street, to be used for ‘the advantage, think there is somewhere in Tullow in 46 difficult, particularly if discs had been welfare and benefit of the young men of memory of them’. The Captain Mur- phy Memorial Hall, extended and rede- veloped over the years, is an important part of the fabric of Tullow and stands as an enduring monument to a native of the town who gave his life on a foreign battlefield. For many years a gilt framed portrait of Bill Murphy looked down on Tullow audiences but, during a refur- bishment of the hall, it was removed and is now on display in the town’s museum. In Tullow, one further reference to Bill Murphy can be found on the altar in the Church of the Most Holy Rosary, the place where he worshipped as a boy and young man; on the tabernacle door – presented to the parish by the Murphy family – an inscription reads: In memory of Capt. W. J. Murphy. Killed-in-action 9th Sept. 1916

Bill Murphy’s death was no greater, or no less, a tragedy than that of any other soldier that perished in the Great War. In and Captain Murphy Memorial Hall, Tullow around his home town of Tullow, where he was the most prominent and probably

Carloviana 2016 Capt Murphy_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:13 Page 8

Captain Bill Murphy of Tullow - unsung hero of the Somme

2. Ibid.: Article quoting William Beach 35. Clongownian: Letter from Major General Thomas of the Daily Mail. September 1916. W B Hickie to Fr Arthur Murphy. 1917 edi- 3. O’Rahilly, Alfred: Father William Doyle, tion. S.J. (London 1922). Quote from Fr Doyle, 36. Battalion War Diary: Entry recording Cap- Chaplain 8th RDF. (London, 1922) tain Murphy’s death. 4. Buchan, John: Nelson’s History of the Great 37. West Australian: Article reporting Captain War. (London, 1916) Murphy’s death, January 1917. 5. Murphy, Martin: Captain Bill Murphy and 38. Tullow Parish Register: Baptismal records. his Kinsfolk. (unpublished) 39. Nationalist and Leinster Times: Report on 6. Castleknock College Archives. fire, September 1920. 7. Nationalist and Leinster Times: Restoration 40. Jesus College Cambridge Archives: Stu- of premises, July 1899. dent records for A P K O’Connor. 8. Ibid.: Tullow meeting to select County 41. Metropolitan Cemeteries Board, Perth: De- Council candidate. February 1899. tails from O’Connor headstone. 9. Marriage Certificate: Married in Church of 42. Commonwealth War Graves Commission: St Nicholas, Francis St, Dublin. Details of Captain Murphy’s memorial. 10. Birth Certificate and Baptismal Records for 43. War Office File: Details of personal ef- Tullow Parish. fects returned to family. 11. Carlow Sentinel: Obituary, September 44. Nationalist and Leinster Times: Report of 1916. Mass in Tullow, October 1916. 12. Delany Archive and Clongowes Wood 45. Ibid.: Carlow UDC report, September Special memorial to Capt. Murphy in Archive. 1916. Guillemont Road Cemetery 13. Nationalist and Leinster Times: Edward 46. Counsel’s opinion, May 1944. Murphy’s obituary, February 1900. 47. War Office File: Details of payments to 14. Census of Ireland (1901): Return for House Captain Murphy’s estate. the highest ranking fatality, some sixty No. 1, Barrack St, Tullow. 48. Myers, Kevin: Ireland’s Great War. other households also mourned the loss 15. Nationalist and Leinster Times: Reports (Dublin, 2014) of a family member. He joined the war and results of sporting events 1903-06. effort out of a sense of duty, hardly fore- 16. Carlow Sentinel: Obituary, September seeing the terrible slaughter and carnage 1916. 17. Acknowledgements: that would unfold and not expecting the Nationalist and Leinster Times: Obituary, Christie Andrews, Shire of Dalwallinu Office seriously flawed military strategies that September 1916. Rose Bolger 18. Ibid.: Sports reports 1905. would be employed by those in overall 19. Anna Crutchley, Jesus College Cambridge. Crake, Hellen Antonio: A History of Dal- Catriona Curry, Tullow Parish Office. command. And yet, when duty called in wallinu – A Place To Wait A While. (WA, a remote corner of Picardy, he readily Bernie Deasy, Delany Archive, Carlow. 1985) Margaret Doyle, Clongowes Wood College. stepped into the breach and assumed 20. Ibid. 21. Jenny Edgecombe, Toodyay Historical command of a war-weary battalion that Times, Nationalist and Sentinel: Announce- Society. was facing an immediate and formidable ment and wedding report, Nov.1907. 22. Argyro Francis, Commonwealth War Graves challenge. A novice in military terms, this State Records Office, WA: Copy of will, Commission. shopkeeper’s son turned Australian dated June 1908 – M. Cartan O’Meara, Solic- Jim Healy itors, Kildare St, Dublin. wheat-farmer, was only twenty-two 23. Brendan Kealy Crake, Hellen Antonio: A History of Dal- John Keogh months in uniform and just three days in wallinu – A Place To Wait A While. (WA, command of his battalion – a responsibil- Tim Lethorn, State Records Office of WA. 1985) Declan Mc Devitt, Castleknock College. ity that afterwards merited the payment 24. Nationalist and Leinster Times: Obituary, Al McDonell, Metropolitan Cemeteries of the grand sum of eighteen shillings to September 1916. 47 25. Board, Perth the late officer’s estate. But despite that War Office File: Short Service Attestation Christopher McQuinn lack of experience, it has been claimed Form, November 1914. 26. Tim Madden that Murphy’s display of leadership and Nationalist and Leinster Times: Obituary, Steven Parsons, Downside Abbey. September 1916. courage at Ginchy has ‘marked him out 27. Paul & Melissa Sutherland, Wilgie Hills. as one of the finest Irish soldiers of the Ibid.: Report of home visit, November Billy Wright 48 1915. Cella Dawson war’. With the passage of time, how- 28. Battalion War Diary: Landed in France, ever, the victories, defeats and sacrifices Carlow Central Library. December 1915. National Library of Ireland. of the Great War have faded from public 29. War Office File: Telegrams informing fam- The National Archives, Kew. consciousness, but the existence of the ily of illness and discharge. Tullow Museum. Captain Murphy Memorial Hall ensures 30. Battalion War Diary: Assumption of CO that, in Tullow at least, Bill Murphy’s duties. 31. name will never be forgotten. Ibid.: Record of formation of battalions. 32. Irish Times: Report on the ‘dash and daring’ of the Irish, September 1916. 33. Johnstone, Tom: Orange, Green & Khaki Endnotes: 1. progress of battle. (Dublin, 1992) Irish Times: Report quoting Philip Gibbs of 34. Battalion War Diary: Report on the capture the Daily Telegraph. September 1916. of Ginchy.

Carloviana 2016 Cumann na Mban edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:51 Page 1

VâÅtÇÇ Çt ÅUtÇ

|Ç VtÜÄÉã Marie Treacy

Write a biographical essay on a particular Ladies’ Land League I was originally antry. (McCallum, 2005). Unfortunately woman/group of women whose lives are tempted to write about that organisation. once Charles Stewart Parnell was understood within the framework of It was originally founded in America and released from Kilmainham Jail, the patriarchal constraint. motivated by ideas of humanitarianism Ladies’ Land League was disbanded, as and philanthropy, which gave many part of the terms of the Kilmainham It can be difficult for modern women women the freedom to move outside the Treaty. Publicly they were seen as too living in the Ireland of 2015 to relate to private sphere into the public sphere of militaristic, privately and more relevantly the patriarchal constraints that existed for respectable good works. In Ireland the land question had taken a back seat to women in the Ireland of 1914. Notwith- moreover in the public sphere, women Parnell’s aim of Home Rule for Ireland. standing writing an essay on a group of were involved in and contributed to the This example of the Ladies’ Land League women whose lives are understood growing climate of cultural nationalism and its demise illustrates the constraint of within this framework gives one some which was flourishing at the turn of the patriarchal organisations such as the considerable scope and choice. For century. Historically women have Church and government politicians. personal reasons I have decided to write always played a key yet background role They believed it was women’s domestic this paper on the Carlow branch of in political or revolutionary events in Ire- and mothering roles that should be Cumann na mBan, as my grandmother, land as evidenced in Brigid’s witness emphasised. (Helleiner, 1997, p275). In Jane Quigley was a member of that statement. She describes how ‘a woman spite of their disbandment, the Ladies’ branch. She received a Military Service walked all the way from Tullow and Land League highlighted the growing medal for her contribution during the planted three elm saplings on the Crop- contribution that women who took part War of Independence from 1919-1921 pies Hole, one for each of her sons’. in the movement for Irish national inde- when only 16. However, the main biog- (Ryan, 1957). That woman was the pendence made and whose lives should raphical focus of this paper will be mother of Ryan’s three great-grand be understood within the framework of concentrated on Brigid Ryan (nee uncles who were murdered by the patriarchal constraint. Brophy) who played multiple key roles Yeomen, and buried there. Therefore within the same branch from 1917-1923. Brigid Ryan’s own revolutionary history Notwithstanding despite these constraints The paper will also include some goes back at least as far as 1798. Despite Mary McAuliffe has noted that ‘the first reminiscences from talks with my grand- this however with Ireland and Cumann two decades of the 20th century had seen mother about that period. It will examine na mBan ‘women’s participation in mil- women emerge in great numbers from how these women’s lives can be under- itarism was mediated through their sex’. the domestic sphere and participate in the stood within the patriarchal constraint of (Ryan, 2000, p77). The fact that they hitherto male-dominated sphere of Irish the period. Indeed the women of Ireland were women impacted not only on how Politics’. (McAuliffe, 2014, p48). were not alone in these restraints. All they were represented […] but also on Women like Jenny Wyse Power who over Europe and further afield prior to the roles they played within the armed were involved in Cumann na mBan had World War I women were largely conflict. (Ryan, 2000, p77). been involved in or had been influenced confined to the home, the private sphere, by the Ladies’ Land League. Indeed carrying out household and childcare In her thesis Christi McCallum describes Brigid Ryan mentions in her witness duties with few exceptions. the Ladies’ Land League as ‘an excellent statement that her parents were Parnellite example of the skill of the women who supporters which no doubt influenced her A number of other groups of women are organised it, Anna and Fanny Parnell, beliefs and behaviours. Many women worthy of a brief mention here such as and was a remarkable organisation for its were involved in Cumann na mBan at an the Ladies’Land League, the Suffragettes time’. (McCallum, 2005). The women increasingly young age as evidenced by and the women of the Magdalen aided the men by raising funds, doing na- my own grandmother. Nationalist poli- laundries, as they were all subjected to tionalist women’s work, and had the tics had been gradually changing in constraints. In fact having studied The support of rural women and Irish peas- Ireland with the response to the Third Carloviana 2016 Cumann na Mban edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:51 Page 2

46 Cumann na mBan in Carlow

Home Rule bill, and the formation in resigned as president after this decision, in the public mind set, and generating an 1912 of the Ulster Volunteers. (McCoole, which freed the women from conserva- emotional connection to the revolution- 2000, p8). These events led to the tive leadership. In fact, the women who ary effort. (Knirck, 2006, p162). formation of the Irish Volunteers in 1913. left the organization during the split were Furthermore the catalyst for the setting mostly the conservative women who felt Mc Coole has done much to reconstruct up of Cumann na mBan, the first of its that their organisation should not choose the lives and activities of the women of kind exclusively for women, was a sides, but help both the Redmondites and Cumann na mBan in her books and consequence of the fact that when the the Irish Volunteers. The nationalist- articles. She believes that the women of Irish Volunteers were formed women feminist constituency of the group thus the organisation ‘brought together the were not allowed join the executive. won the battle against the most conserva- disparate elements under Sinn Fein in the Accordingly in April 1914 they formed tive members. (McCallum, 2005). months following the rising. […] and their own executive. Cumann na mBan soon began recruiting also took a leading role in the coordina- even larger numbers of women and these tion of relief and support to those According to Margaret Ward in April younger women were a lot more widowed and orphaned […] in the wake 1914 in her inaugural address to Cumann militaristic in outlook and belief. This of the Rising’. (McCoole, 1997, p37). na mBan, Agnes O’Farrelly highlighted militarism was evident in the first major Cumann na mBan members collected some of the reasons behind the setting up event in the run up to the 1916 Rising and distributed the monies which were of such a women’s organisation, as being involving Cumann na mBan which was for the aid of the families of the Volun- ‘due to the fears and turmoil of the the Howth Gun-running. They were teers who had lost their lives, were present moment [which has] brought already in charge of gathering the without a breadwinner or in need of here today women who until now were Defence of Ireland Fund to finish paying support. By 1917 as many as two only known as home-makers. They are off the guns; their major role here was in hundred branches of the organisation had here because they fear for the liberty of distributing and hiding the guns. Women been established all over the country. the home, and because they realise that also helped by storing ammunition and When the threat of conscription loomed the blow aimed at the freedom of the men guns as well as aiding the men by making they organised a Lá Na mBan and of Ireland strikes the women and children cartridges before the Rising. (McCallum, between 14,000 and 15,000 women as well; our cause is a common cause, 2005). signed an anti-conscription pledge at City our interests are inextricably bound Hall. (McCoole, 1997, p37). However together’. (Ward, 1995, p40). Although Historian Sinead McCoole has claimed more negatively historian Sarah Benton conservative women controlled the that the number of women who took part believes ‘the conscription crisis was a organisation in its early days other in the 1916 Rising is unclear as the major turning point […] the war was women agitated for a more militant majority of the women involved were not responsible for the marginalization of stance from the society. (McCallum, arrested, however it may be as many as women which […] in turn led them to 2005). Critically by September 1914 one hundred and fifty out of the one thou- use different arguments, […] a develop- according to Margaret Ward the organi- sand six hundred who took part. (Mc- ment which would have fateful repercus- sation was seen as ‘the most vigorous and Coole, 1997, p13). Their roles included sions for women during the Treaty enterprising of all the movements that first-aid, commandeering supplies, cook- debates’. (Benton, 1995, p163). have grown out of the idea of arming and ing, as well as gathering information and drilling the nation […] it is a force to be carrying dispatches. In the aftermath of Cumann na mBan in Carlow reckoned with […] for all the patriotic the 1916 Rising many of the key leaders energies of the women of the country are were dead, however Countess Post 1916 however there was a sense of rushing towards it’. (Ward, 1995, p44). Markievicz had her death sentence com- expectation and promise in the air for the In addition other key women such as muted since the authorities were fearful women of Cumann na mBan in Carlow, Constance Markievicz believed that ‘a ‘that the execution of a women would and throughout Ireland. Ryan (nee consciousness of their own dignity and bring about an emotional reaction from Brophy) was involved in the organisation worth should be encouraged in women, the people of Dublin’. (Kelly, 1988, from its Carlow inception in 1917 when they should be urged to get away from p106-7). Cumann na mBan were now it was set up by Brid Whelan, another wrong ideals and false standards of poised to become a widespread more formidable Carlow woman. At that time womanhood, to escape their domestic militaristic organisation. As noted by Irish women were idealised symbolising ruts, their feminine pens’. (Ward, 1995, historian Jason Knirck ‘revolutionary ‘all that is unique, pure and good within p47) and Cumann na mBan was perfectly times initially seemed to hold great the nation’. (Knirck, 2006, p165). As placed to assist women in this regard. promise for Irish women […] with gen- Louise Ryan has observed ‘the idealised der boundaries seemingly open for rene- Catholic woman was the Mother, Mary. During WW1 Redmond’s campaign to gotiation’. (Knirck, 2006, p160). The overlap between Mother Church, persuade Irish men to join the Irish Certainly after the 1916 Rising those Mother Ireland and Irish mother is appar- regiments during the war led to a split. women who were associated with ent’. (Ryan, 2000, p76). Furthermore The male majority sided with Redmond, deceased patriots were given a special patriarchal constraints extended to the but Cumann na mBan chose to side with position in Sinn Fein activities, keeping ‘representation of Ireland as both the the Irish Volunteers rather than vital links open, and the memory of the young vulnerable maiden (Róisin Dubh) Redmond’s group. Agnes O’Farrelly revolutionary struggle and sacrifice fresh and the motherly old woman (Shan Van Carloviana 2016 Cumann na Mban edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:51 Page 3

47 Cumann na mBan in Carlow

Vocht) enabling nationalists to enact a The Carlow Cumann’s district area against the military. Crucially her state- range of masculine roles; chivalrous hero corresponded to the Volunteer battalion ment also shows first-hand how the and devoted son. Such images also area, and similarly Carlow Cumann’s women of Cumann na mBan interacted helped to construct appropriate roles for brigade area was the same as the Volun- with the male revolutionaries in the Irish women; selfless assistants and caring teer brigade area. Crucially ‘there was Volunteers, albeit within the patriarchal mothers’. (Ryan, 2000, p88). close co-operation between the officers constraint of ancillary activities only. of both organisations’. (Ryan, 1957). Biographer Leeann Lane believes the In her thesis Christi McCallum outlines study of the life of an individual illumi- Ryan describes in some detail their ancil- how the nationalist women were often nates ‘social, economic, political and lary activities which included ‘carrying described by historians as puppets of the cultural change within a society’. (Lane, despatches, arms and ammunition, intel- male organisations. She disagrees with 2010, p1). My grandmother, Jane ligence work, cooking and supplying this description, maintaining they Quigley was born in 1905 and reared in food for I.R.A. men who were on the run, actually had a great degree of agency and times of great unrest and change, living and also for members of ambush parties. ‘were able to make more of an impact on through the Rising, the War of Independ- We also collected money for the Prison- the men than suffragists due to their ence and Civil war. She witnessed first- ers Dependents' Fund, visited the I.R.A. relationship with male revolutionaries’. hand these very social, economic, prisoners and supplied them with such (McCallum, 2005). Furthermore she political and cultural changes going on comforts as warm clothing, cigarettes, believes that Cumann na mBan used their all around her. Her stories of her youth tobacco, papers’. (Ryan, 1957). Brigid unique position to increase the visibility during those tumultuous times described herself was a 1st lieutenant of the Carlow of Irish women in the struggle for some of the activities she was involved town branch of Cumann na mBan from independence, and created a formidable in during the War of Independence - 1917-1921, and was the Commanding public persona that set them apart as moving small firearms about in prams, Officer of the Carlow Brigade of the women and revolutionaries’. (McCallum, carrying messages, passing through army organisation from 1921-1923. Her 2005). Historian Cal McCarthy agrees checkpoints, all requiring courage and no matter of fact description of how her with McCallum claiming that they were small amount of organisation by such home was the meeting place for the substantial players in the Irish Revolu- young women. Although older Brigid brigade after its formation, (and as a tion. (McCarthy, 2007, p1). He also Ryan (nee Brophy) would have experi- consequence it was continually under highlights the fact that many male enced the same unrest and change and enemy surveillance), is indicative of her revolutionaries acknowledged how much her witness testimony which I found in bravery and commitment to the cause. the women had contributed to the Irish the Military Archives is testament to her Indeed her home was the ‘first in Carlow Republican Army’s war effort. (Mc- involvement in Carlow Cumann na town to be raided by enemy forces, […] Carthy, 2007, p1). One witness testi- mBan at a very high level. This testi- it took place on a Sunday night and mony compiled in the 1940s from mony was compiled in 1957 some 34 caused a great deal of excitement’. Padraig O’Cathain (Kane) an IRA man years after her release from Kilmainham (Ryan, 1957). She also carried arms and from Kilkenny, and Adjutant in the Jail. Such a verifiable witness testimony ammunitions to Volunteers about to take Carlow Brigade of the Irish Volunteers, is hugely important for compiling both part in ambushes and barrack attacks; she confirms this, mentioning Cumann na historical and biographical accounts and even mentions an attack on the RIC mBan women in most glowing terms; ‘I records. Archivist Randall Jimerson be- Barracks in Baltinglass, Co. Wicklow, cannot resist naming the Mistresses, [… lieves that witness statements and docu- whereby afterwards she admits ‘some of ] Brophy, Doyle, Quigley and Woods ments ‘provide the most reliable the arms used in the attack were brought (Carlow). Some of them were better than evidence available for understanding the to me and I concealed them’. (Ryan, many of our men’. (O’Cathain, 1940). past’. (Jimerson, 2003, p89). 1957). This testimony shows that for He describes the ‘great-hearted women Brigid Ryan the personal was political of Cumann na mBan who could never Historian Lindsey Earner Byrne agrees, and the political was personal. (www.his- find enough to do, and were wonderful in highlighting the importance of witness tory.org). They were intertwined in her helping us to maintain communications’. testimony by noting that the ‘individual activities and would have been a huge (O’Cathain, 1940). in history can be resurrected to heighten influence in her life. our historical understanding of broader Nonetheless despite this positive analysis patterns’. (Earner-Byrne, 2015, p78). In The fact that Brigid was able to conceal by McCallum and McCarthy, Brigid her testimony Ryan outlines how the weapons, was largely due to the fact that Ryan’s statement conveys perfectly the Carlow Cumann na mBan branch was women were not under the same level of specific gendered roles at play within the organised territorially, on the same basis suspicion as men. Consequently they organisation, and crucially shows the as the Volunteers. As she explained ‘we were able to carry out their activities patriarchal constraints at play. In spite of had a branch, or at least a section, in without detection for longer periods. In- the fact that Cumann na mBan was the every area where there was a company of deed as Louise Ryan claims women were first ever solely women’s organisation the volunteers’. (Ryan, 1957). Indeed usually seen within the ‘conventional with their own executive, they were still from her testimony it is clear that Brigid narratives of grieving mothers or passive restrained by the patriarchal ideals of the was actively involved in organising nameless victims’. (Ryan, 2000, p74) day and were subordinate to the men, the branches in several parts of the country. rather than as revolutionaries working Irish Volunteers, because of their Carloviana 2016 Cumann na Mban edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:51 Page 4

48 Cumann na mBan in Carlow

exclusion from their executive. (Mc- blurred, and this can be seen in the nu- period 1900-1923 describes the women Coole, 1997, p13). Historian Margaret merous occasions that Brigid’s home was who played a major part in the fight for Ward concurs with this and claims ‘this raided and looted. As Sarah Benton Ireland’s freedom within Cumann na separate but equal formula gave rise to claims ‘the British Government wanted mBan, as originating ‘from every class in absolute inequality as women were re- to crush the wild men so that through the society and all walks of life; titled ladies garded as subordinates and excluded propriety of politics, it could reach a and shop assistants, doctors, housewives, from the decision making process’, settlement’. (Benton, 1995, p165). This laundry workers, artists and teachers. (Ward, 1995, p39) and indeed many is another important factor within the Some were married with children, some protested that they were not the auxil- context of patriarchal constraint and our were widowed, and some mere school- iaries or the handmaidens or the camp understanding of Brigid’s life within this children’. (McCoole, 2003, p1). followers of the Volunteers. (McCoole, framework. 1997, p13). I have no specific information on how my grandmother must have felt about the It was the Soloheadbeg ambush of 1919 I see it as hugely important to my grand- split after the signing of the Anglo Irish which ushered in the War of Independ- mother’s memory, that her depiction of Treaty in December 1921, however on a ence, a guerrilla war, and widespread the events and roles she undertook in personal level it must have caused a lot popular support was key to its success. such a traumatic period of Ireland’s of angst for her when considering the The women of Cumann na mBan were history were verified by Ryan and split in Cumann na mBan, as women crucial in supporting the men who were O’Cathain. Critically over long periods who had previously fought together on the run and away from home for large of time one’s awareness and memory of during the War of Independence, found periods of time. According to Margaret events can fade. Notwithstanding it themselves on opposite sides in the Civil Ward the organisation ‘attached a far should be noted that archival memory ‘is War. Anecdotal evidence appears to greater degree of importance to military a social construct reflecting power show my grandmother was a supporter of struggle than to political issues, […] their relationships in society […] thus the Treaty as her front parlour in primary loyalty was to the Volunteers and archivists and manuscript curators play Harcourt Lodge, Dublin gave pride of not to Sinn Fein’. (Ward, 1983, p132). an important role as mediators in select- place to two huge paintings, one of Indeed the militant women of the organi- ing records for preservation […] which Michael Collins in his army uniform, and sation ‘viewed Sinn Fein as the moderate can provide a more balanced perspective another on his death bed! This would wing of the nationalist movement’. (Ward, on the past’. (Jimerson, 2003, p89). This appear to confirm that Brigid’s stance 1983, p132). Furthermore O’Cathain’s is important as this period in Ireland’s and my grandmother’s stance differed, as witness testimony gives agency to the history still can provoke bitterness and during the Truce Brigid continued her women’s roles ‘particularly in the context ignite old feuds between groups even activities and was appointed as Receiver of a guerrilla war fought out in the coun- after a period of almost a hundred years. of Supplies for the brigade training camp tryside’. (Ryan, 2000, p78). at Duckett’s Grove, Co. Carlow. Recollecting those times with my grand- Lil Conlon in her memoir stated that more mother, together with consideration of Similarly during the Civil War Brigid attention had been focussed on the women Brigid’s testimony, has enabled me to was unstoppable. One of her many from 1919 by the authorities, as they had recognise the intersectionality between ‘ancillary’ activities included making all begun to realise that women were playing what my grandmother told me, and what the arrangements for the funerals of all a major part in the campaign. (Conlon, I have found out about the other ‘ordi- the IRA men killed in action. (Ryan, 1969). Certainly an atmosphere of vio- nary’ women who were involved in 1957). Many of her duties were highly lence and disorder exposed women in Cumann na mBan between 1919-1921. dangerous such as procuring guns and domestic settings to considerable fear, in- Little had been written about the women ammunition from Free State soldiers and timidation, gender violence and assault. of organisation up until more recently, as handing them over to the 1st battalion, (Earner-Byrne, 2015, p82). Women ‘who it is those who were in positions of ASU, IRA. Despite her activities it is in the isolated villages remained in the pri- authority, such as Countess Markievicz, clear that she took her orders from the vacy of the domestic sphere were easy tar- who have been eulogised. Nevertheless Volunteers so despite her bravery and gets for frustrated British soldiers and the huge numbers of ordinary rank and courage she was still subject to patriar- particularly vulnerable to attack’. (Ryan, file members, described by Lil Conlon chal constraint. 2000, p78). Attacks on women varied as‘mothers, wives, sisters, sweet-hearts, from sexual insults and other humiliations all were dragged into that cauldron of When the Civil War broke out in June such as cutting off their hair, or dragging self- sacrifice’, […] ‘those women who 1922 Kilmainham Gaol was taken over them from their beds in their night clothes. made diverse sacrifices in many different by the Free State Government. (Kelly, ways were ‘ordinary’ women’. (Conlon, 1988, p112), and many women were However these attacks can also be seen 1969, p3). imprisoned there, which is an indication as a way of getting to the male members of the role they had played in the War of of the population who were on the run Nevertheless McCoole disagrees with this Independence. A number of Carlow and weaken their resistance. In this way description, arguing that they were not members were imprisoned in Kilmain- the boundaries between the private home ‘ordinary women’ at all. Her own work ham including Brigid Ryan and Essie and the public battlefield become on Irish revolutionary women in the Snoddy, a young girl of only 16. Accord- Carloviana 2016 Cumann na Mban edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:51 Page 5

Cumann na mBan in Carlow

ing to historian Julian Stover those nationalist women and drastically bravery of these women and their contin- imprisoned ‘had been found guilty of a curtailed their role in post-revolutionary ued persistence in claiming their right to variety of crimes, ranging from the politics’. (Knirck, 2006, p163). Repub- a pension despite numerous delays and possession of seditious documents […] licanism became ‘feminized’, tarred with excuses put to them. In one letter written or for breaking curfew, no doubt commit- the brush of hysteria, irrationality and in 1937, signed by Brigid Ryan and ted in aid of military operations’. (Stover, undue emotion. (Knirck, 2006, p163). Nellie Woods, the letter concludes 2014, p97). This is another example of how the ‘kindly let me know at your earliest patriarchal society of the day was able to convenience when it will be possible for In her witness testimony Brigid claimed constrain the women, playing down their you to call a number of applicants from she was arrested on 16th March 1923 and role in events and removing them from this area […] as no member of Carlow released on the 27th of the same month. the limelight. Indeed according to Cumann na mBan has been called up to Whilst in Kilmainham she became historian David Fitzpatrick ‘after the the present’. (Ryan, Woods, 1937). involved in a project with Essie Snoddy, Treaty the search for respectability Furthermore their pensions, if awarded at making a tri-colour with the Cumann na displaced revolutionary enthusiasm, all, were at the lowest level payable, and mBan initials embroidered in the centre, imitation drove out imagination, the not on a par with a man’s pension despite and the flag can be seen in Kilmainham solemn trappings of familiar institutions their service and allegiance. This is yet Jail to this day. Prison crafts could be enveloped and began to stifle the another example of patriarchal constraint seen as an articulation of protest by the iconoclasts’. (Fitzpatrick, 1977, p232). at work, increasing our cognisance of women, as this tri-colour was used to how the women’s lives are understood drape over the coffins of Carlow activists In the post-Civil War era of the new Irish within that framework. killed in combat. Her previous role in Free State Irish, independence was this type of activity is recorded in her marked not only by the rise to power of This paper has shown how women’s lives witness statement where she describes the Catholic propertied classes, but also are understood within the framework of how she ‘was in charge of the firing party by the marginalisation of feminist patriarchal constraint. Despite Brigid over the grave of Commandant Seamus concerns that were part of the anti-colo- Ryan’s monumental participation, and O'Toole who was killed in an engage- nial movement. (Helleiner, 1997, p277). that of countless other women (including ment with the enemy in 1922’. (Ryan, The new State felt that the contribution my grandmother) in Cumann na mBan, 1957). Ryan was obviously rearrested as of women would be most acceptable in their efforts were indeed mediated by the she also claims to have been on hunger the domestic sphere. This reflected the fact that they were women. Subse- strike for nine days in June 1923, and growing influence of the Catholic Church quently this affected the types of roles whilst she was in prison her home was through the 1920s, which railed against that they performed during the period broken into by Free State forces who the moral deterioration of the world in 1914-1923. Patriarchal constraint also wrecked the interior of the café and general and Irish women in particular. dominated the treatment that they dwelling apartments, and looted the (McAuliffe, 2014, p49). However Irish received afterwards. Notwithstanding contents. (Ryan, 1957). Once again feminists contested this definition believ- Brigid Ryan’s participation is written political events in her life had personal ing that women could and should inhabit large in her witness testimony, yet it is repercussions. Brigid was released in the public and the private spheres, be only one woman’s account of her role in September, 1923. On a lighter note Essie mothers and wives but also citizens who historic events. Countless more women’s Snoddy was very productive whilst in added their talents to the new state. historic participation is to be found in the prison as ‘she brought home souvenirs (Valiulis, 1995, p118). Crucially despite Military Archives and other archives and such as tea cosies, golliwogs and dolls, the fact that the 1922 Constitution gave records. I have little tangible evidence of as well as a crocheted top’. (McCoole, women the right to vote, subsequent l my grandmother’s participation in these 2004, p113). egislation denied full political identifica- historic events with the exception of her tion for women and by 1937 women’s medal, a more tenuous link through Despite the connections the women political, economic and reproductive Padraig O’Cathain’s witness testimony, associated with the leaders of the 1916 rights had been severely constrained. and a mention of a J. Quigley in the Easter Rising had, it was these same (Valiulis, 1995 p120). Carlow member lists in handwritten connections that led to the women being applications for Pensions in the 1930s. cast out of politics in the Irish Free State. Consequently women perceived them- Regardless of this lack of evidence for The female TDs as well as most of the selves as forgotten by a state they my grandmother, without doubt she, more politically and militarily involved believed owed them recognition and Brigid and the other ‘ordinary’ woman of women had opposed the treaty, including material recompense for their participa- Cumann na mBan were heroines. They as mentioned above many Cumann na tion. (Lane, 2010, p2). This can be seen deserve to be recorded in more dominant mBan members. Consequently the asso- in the letters of Brigid Ryan representing narratives similar to the dominant narra- ciation of the women TDs with the Old Cumann na mBan in the late 1930s. tives of male patriarchy and heroes. sacrifices made by their loved ones in the Brigid Ryan and Nellie Woods were rising, now became unpopular within the instrumental in petitioning the govern- Currently the emphasis on these brave new Irish Free State government. ment for pensions for the women women is growing and more recently a According to Jason Knirck ‘the Free involved in the period 1919-1923. Their wider corpus of written work has Staters marginalised the contribution of letters are testament to the continued emerged. In this era of remembrance and Carloviana 2016 Cumann na Mban edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 17:51 Page 6

50 Cumann na mBan in Carlow

commemoration individual stories are State Senate 1922-1936’ in Fischer, C, http://www.bureauofmilitaryhistory.ie/re beginning to appear. It is evident the McAuliffe, M. (eds) (2014) Irish Femi- els/bmh/BMH.WS1572.POOCathain.dat Carlow women were a particularly active nisms: Past, Present and Future. Essays eaccessed21/4/2015. branch in the organisation and Brigid in honour of Mary Cullen and Margaret Ryan was an extraordinarily brave and Mac Curtain. Dublin: Arlen House. http://www.history.org.uk/resources/stu- capable woman. I am proud my grand- dent_resource.dateaccessed 21/4/2015. mother was a member of this group. The McCallum, C. (2005) ‘And they’ll march history of the women of Cumann na with their brothers to freedom; Cumann mBan, their contribution and courage, na mBan, Nationalism, and women’s which has for so long evaded historical rights in Ireland 1900-1923’. Unpub- record, (McCoole, 2000, is finally begin- lished MA Thesis. Florida State Univer- ning to get the recognition it deserves. sity, USA. Many more stories are waiting to be told. McCoole, S. (1997) Guns and Chiffon: Bibliography Women Revolutionaries and Kilmainham Gaol 1916-1923. Dublin: Stationary Benton, S. (1995) ‘The Militarisation of Office. Thomas J. Kennedy, managing editor Politics in Ireland 1913-1923’. Feminist of The Homiletic and Pastoral Review. No. 50, The Irish Issue: The McCoole, S. (2004) No Ordinary Review, 53 Park Place, a monthly British Question. (Summer, 1995). pp Women: Irish Female Activists in the magazine for Roman Catholic priests, 148-172. Revolutionary Period 1990-1923. died of a heart attack on Wednesday at Dublin: O’Brien Press. his home, 258 Riverside Drive. Conlon, L. (1969) Cumann na mBan and the Women of Ireland 1913-25. McCarthy, C. (2007) Cumann na mBan He was born in Ireland, was graduated Kilkenny: Kilkenny People. and the Irish Revolution. Cork: Collins from Carlow College and the National University of Ireland and studied lan- Earner-Byrne, L. (2015) ‘The Rape of Ryan, L. (2000). ‘Drunken Tans: Repre- guages at the Universities of Vienna Mary M: A Microhistory of Sexual Vio- sentations of Sex and Violence in the and Bonn. Then he worked in London lence and Moral Redemption in 1920s Anglo Irish War 1919-21. Feminist with the Rev. Herbert Thurston, S. J., Ireland’. Journal of the History of Sexu- Review, No. 66, Political Currents. on research projects until 1909, when ality, Volume 24, No 1, (January 2015) (Autumn, 2000). pp 73-94. he came to New York and joined the pp 75-98. editorial staff of the Catholic Stover, J. (2014) ‘Irish Political Prisoner Encyclopedia. Fitzpatrick, D. (1977) Politics and Irish Culture 1916-1923’. Crosscurrents. As- Life, 1913-1921: Provincial experience sociation for Religion and Intellectual Later for several years Mr. Kennedy of War and Revolution. Dublin: Gill & Life. 2014. pp 90-106. was editor of Letters and Arts Press, a MacMillan. religious book publishing concern. In Valiulis, M. (1995) ‘Power, Gender and 1824 he became managing editor of Helleiner, J. ‘Women of the Itinerant Identity in the Irish Free State’. Journal The Homiletic and Pastoral Review. Class: Gender and Anti-Traveller Racism of Women’s History. Volume 6, No. 4, For many years he supervised the in Ireland’. Women’s Studies Interna- Volume 7, No. 1 (Winter-Spring, 1995). publication and translation of eccleias- tional Forum, Vol 20, No. 2, (1997). pp pp 117-136. tical treatises, and he collaborated in 275-287. the preparation and publication of The Ward, M. (1993) Suffrage First – Above Catholic Biblical Encyclopedia. Jimerson, R. C. (2006) ‘Embracing the All Else: An Account of the Irish Suf- Power of the Archive’. The American frage Movement in Smyth. A. (ed) Irish Surviving are his widow, Mrs. Moira Archivist, Volume 69, No. 1 (Spring- Women’s Studies Reader (1993) Dublin: Coyle Kennedy; two daughters, the Summer, 2006). pp 19-32. Attic Press. Misses Sighle and Ethne Kennedy of New York; a brother, Brian of New Kelly, F. (1988) The History of Kilmain- Ward, M. (1995) Unmanageable Revolu- York, and a sister, Mother Mary St. ham Jail: The Dismal House of Little tionaries: Women and Irish Nationalism. John of Bangalore, India. Ease. Dublin: Mercier Press. Dingle: Brandon.

Knirck, J. (2006) Women of the Dail: Ward, M. (1995) In Their Own Voice: Gender Republicanism and the Anglo- Women and Irish Nationalism. Dublin: Irish Treaty. Dublin: Irish Academic Attic Press. Press. http://www.bureauofmilitaryhistory.ie/re McAuliffe, M. (2014) ‘The Unquiet Sis- els/bmh/BMH.WS1573.B.Ryan.dateac- ters: Women, Politics and the Irish Free cessed 21/4/2015. Carloviana 2016 Bagenals of Idrone Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:16 Page 1

1585 Nicholas bought the Barony of Idrone from George Carew for his son Dudley for £2,000. Dudley moved there and lived in Idrone, perhaps the Lodge (later to be known as Eastwood, located The Bagenals in the townland of Moneybeg). He was appointed Constable at Leighlinbridge Castle (Black Castle). Dudley was of a different temper and character from the Carew family and was immediately of involved in a feud with the Kavanagh Clan, previous owners who had been ousted by the Carews. Dudley had the elderly Clan chief Murtagh Kavanagh Idrone killed along with a servant at Garryhill. 1587 Dudley with followers was killed in an ambush at Ballymoon by the Kavanaghs.

Chronology 1598 Henry Bagenal son of Nicholas Bagenal was killed at the Battle of the Myles Kavanagh Yellow Ford by the Irish forces led by Hugh O Neill who was married to Henry’s sister Mabel Bagenal. 1509 Nicholas Bagenal was born in ship of Mourne. Newcastle-under-Lyme, Staffordshire, 1602 Nicholas Bagenal son of Dudley England where his father John Bagenal 1556 Nicholas Bagenal married Eleanor, and Katherine Nangle succeeded Dudley was Mayor of the town. 3rd daughter and heiress of Sir Edward as Constable at Leighlinbridge Castle. Griffith of Penrhy, North Wales, the cou- 1539 Nicholas Bagenal fled England ple had 9 children Henry, Dudley and 1607 Nicholas died as the result of a after killing a man in a brawl. He became Ambrose, and daughters Frances, Mary, duel in Dublin. George Bagenal son of a mercenary under Con Bacach O’Neill, Margaret, Isabel, Anne and Mabel. This Dudley Bagenal and Mabel Fitzgerald chief of the O’Neills of Tyrone. marriage brought Nicholas considerable succeeded Nicholas (half-brother). estates in Wales. 1607-1612 George Bagenal built the 1st 1543 Through the influence of O’Neill Nicholas got a “General pardon of all murders and felonies by him committed” granted in Westminster, 2nd March 1543 by Henry V111.

1544-1547 Nicholas served in the French wars where he gained a high reputation for his military prowess. Leighlinbridge Castle rebuilt by Edward Bellingham in 1547.

1548 He was back in Ireland serving under Sir Edward Bellingham and defeated a group from Laois, Carlow and Kildare led by Cahir O Connor, inflicting a crushing defeat on them in county Kildare.

1550 Nicholas Bagenal became a member of the Irish Privy Council and was appointed Marshall General of the Army in Ireland. He received a lease for 21 years on the Abbey lands of Newry, Newry Castle and was granted the Lord- Carloviana 2016 Bagenals of Idrone Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:16 Page 2

52 The bagenals of Idrone Cronology

Manor at Dunleckney.

1625 George Bagenal died.

1641 Colonel Thomas Bagenal (leader in Army of Confederate Catholics) and his brother Henry Bagenal, sons of George Bagenal and Lady Joanne Butler were banished to Connaught.

1652 Walter Bagenal son of George Bagenal and Lady Joanne Butler, was executed in the Parade Kilkenny by the Cromwellian forces. Walter was a member of Army of Confederate Chimney view of Dunleckney Manor Catholics. The Bagenal family lost their entire estates. stown. He married firstly Eleanor Bagenal’s natural daughter was born. She 1660 The Bagenal estates were restored Barnewall and they had 2 children, and became his favourite and eventual heiress to Dudley Bagenal, son of Walter Bage- secondly Eleanor Beauchamp and they of the Bagenal estate. nal and Elizabeth Roper, by King had 3 children. Charles 11. 1778 Bagenal refused to fire his gun at 1726 Walter Bagenal had the first bridge an opponent and neighbour Mathew 1689 Dudley Bagenal recruited and at the Royal Oak built across the river Weld in a duel and accused him of an commanded an Infantry Regiment that Barrow and drove a coach and horses assault. The judge Mr. Crookshank found fought at the Siege of Derry. across it before its completion to win a Mr. Weld guilty, imposed on him a fine wager. of £70 and ordered him to be imprisoned 1690 Dudley Bagenal and Henry for one month. Luttrell represented County Carlow and 1735 Beauchamp Bagenal is born to attended the King James Parliament in Walter Bagenal and Eleanor Beauchamp. 1778-1783 Beauchamp Bagenal, Mem- Dublin. Dudley Bagenal commanded his He became the most renowned and flam- ber of Parliament for Co. Carlow. Infantry Regiment for King James 11 at boyant member of the Bagenal family. Beauchamp fought as few as a dozen the Battle of the Boyne. King James 11 duels, the great duellists of his time loses the battle. King James and Dudley 1736 Katherine Bagenal (sister of Wal- fought many. One of his 12 was against Bagenal fled to France. King James set ter), the Poor Clare nun, died in France. his own cousin and godson Beauchamp up Court at St. Germain-en-Lay near Bagenal Harvey. Harvey fired first, but Paris with Dudley Bagenal as Gentleman 1745 Walter Bagenal died. missed, to Bagenal’s delight. “You damn Usher to him. young villain. Do you know you had like 1753 Beauchamp Bagenal entered Trin- to kill your own godfather? Go back to 1691 Mary Bagenal daughter of Dudley ity College, Cambridge and undertook a Dunleckney, you dog, and have a good Bagenal and Anne Mathew died in grand tour of European capitals. breakfast ready for us. I only wanted to France. She was a nun at the Poor Clares see if you were stout.” (Bagenal Harvey at Gravelines. 1761-1768 Beauchamp Bagenal Mem- later was hanged in the 1798 Rebellion ber of Parliament for Enniscorthy. in Wexford). 1701 King James 11 died. 1762 Walter Bagenal was born to 1785 Sarah Westropp at 15 years of age 1705 Katherine Bagenal daughter of Beauchamp Bagenal and his wife Maria married Colonel Philip Newton of Dudley Bagenal and Anne Mathew, a nun Ryan. They also had 2 daughters Cather- Bennekerry. at the Poor Clare Convent at Gravelines, ine and Emelia. France was appointed 7th Abbess of 1802 Bagenal died and as his son the convent. 1768-1776 Beauchamp Bagenal entered Walter had no male heir, in his will, politics as an M.P. for Carlow. He con- Beauchamp left his estate to Sarah. 1712 Dudley Bagenal died at Bruges, stantly supported Catholic Relief Bills. Belgium. As a politician, landlord, duellist, liber- 1817 Sarah’s eldest son Walter Newton tarian and bon viveur he became a inherited Dunleckney and 5,000 acres of 1710-1745 Walter Bagenal, son of legend in his own lifetime. The cost of land. He married Anne Jocelyn,. Sarah Dudley Bagenal and Anne Mathew his lifestyle was high as he sold 32,000 and Philip’s second son Philip changed became a Protestant and regained the acres of his estate. his name by Royal Licence to Bagenal family estates from the Crown. Walter and inherited the Newton seat at began the layout of the town of Bagenal- 1770 Sarah Westropp, Beauchamp Bennekerry. Carloviana 2016 Bagenals of Idrone Collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:16 Page 3

1818 Philip Jocelyn Newton was born to Walter Newton and Anne Jocelyn.

1832 Sarah Newton died.

1833 Sarah’s husband Philip Newton died.

1841 Philip Jocelyn Newton, Walter’s son, married Henrietta Maria Kennedy, Panoramic view of St Andrew’s Church daughter of John Kennedy, of Dunbrody, Co. Wexford and had 3 daughters. 1871 Anne Henrietta Newton daughter 1932 Sydney P.C. Vesey died. Walter Newton had plans for the present of Philip Jocelyn Newton and Henrietta Tudor-Gothic Manor, at Dunleckney, Maria Kennedy married William 1942Mrs. Blanche Edith Vesey sold the drawn up by Daniel Robertson. Philip’s Muschamp Vesey of Abbeyleix. They Dunleckney estate to Thomas Donnely, son, married Henrietta Maria Kennedy had 2 sons. of the Belfast distillery family, ending the daughter of John Kennedy, of Dunbrody, last Bagenal-Newton connection with Co. Wexford and they had 3 daughters. 1880 William Vesey died. Dunleckney.

1851 Philip Jocelyn Newton married his 1895 Philip Jocelyn Newton died. He Sources: second wife Emily Toler Osborne. had 5 daughters from his 2 marriages and The Carlow Gentry by Jimmy O’Toole he was succeeded by his eldest surviving Newry Journal 1853 Walter Newton died and he was daughter from his first marriage, Mrs. Famous People of Ireland succeeded by his son Philip Jocelyn Anne Henrietta Vesey. The Times of London 5th August 1778 Newton who changed his name to Bage- The Peerage Compiled by Darryl Lundy nal by Royal Licence. Philip was respon- 1902 Sydney Philip Charles Vesey son Wikipedia. sible for the completion of Dunleckney of Anne Henrietta Newton and William Manor. Muschamp Vesey married Blanche Edith Power.

Carlow Mart Founders

Courtesy: John Dowling

Carloviana 2016 Property owners in Carlow edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:24 Page 1

cÜÉÑxÜàç bãÇxÜá |Ç VÉâÇàç VtÜÄÉã |Ç à{x lxtÜ DFCJ Sean O’Shea

While a considerable area of County to the Lordship of Carlow. They had as follows: Carlow was under forestation in 1307, a three sons, Roger. Hugh and Ralph. On certain amount of information can be the death of Hugh, Roger, their first born, Yet of Common Pleas, at Dublin, be- gleaned regarding, property owners in inherited the titles of Earl of Norfolk and fore John Wogan, Justiciar, in the the county at the time, following an Lord of Carlow. Roger died without issue quinzaine of Easter. inquisition held in the town. The inquisi- in 1270, and his nephew, also called tion was ordered by King Edward 1, to Roger Le Bygod succeeded to his The King sends his writ: Edward etc. to ascertain the Irish possessions of Roger honours and possessions. Roger married Wogan etc. Because Roger le Bygod Earl Le Bygod, Earl of Norfolk, and Lord of twice without iss'ue, and as already stated of Norfolk, who held of the King in Carlow, who died without issue on the - by means of surrender made in 1302, capite, has died, Wogan is to take into the 11th December, 1306. In 1302 Roger had his estate passed to the King on his death. King's hand all lands and tenements in constituted King Edward his heir on This comprised his Earldom, Marshalcy Ireland, of which he was seised when he his death. and property, which included Carlow died, and cause them to be kept safely; castle, then in a state of disrepair. and to enquire how much land he held of Roger Le Bygod was a descendent of The King's writ directed Sir John Wogan the King in capite, and how much of William Marshal, Earl of Pembroke and Justiciar of Ireland "to take into the others, and by what service, and how Lord of Leinster. Marshal and his wife King's hands, all lands and tenements in much they are worth yearly, and who is Isobel, (daughter of Strongbow and Eve Ireland, the property of Roger Le Bygod, his heir and of what age, and return in- MacMurrough), had ten children, five and cause them to be kept safely". To quisition. Teste at Lanrecost, 8 Dec. sons and five daughters. Their five sons enable Wogan to comply with the King’s a. r. xxxv. died without issue, thereby Marshal's writ, Walter De La Haye, Escheator of daughters became co-heirs of his Ireland, was instructed to conduct an By pretext of which mandate Walter 'de holdings. Maud the eldest daughter was inquisition, to establish Roger's holdings, la Haye, escheator of Ireland, was allotted the Carlow County area, which which were mainly in County Carlow. directed to execute it, who made extent: comprised a much larger area than the The inquisition was held in Carlow in present county (the county boundary Apri1, 1307. Apart from insight into the Inquisition taken at Catherlach, on Sat- being re-defined in the mid fifteen- property owners at the time, some insight urday after the close of Easter a r xxxv. hundreds following the creation of Coun- is also gleaned as to the condition of the John Sweyn, Will. Baret, Roger the ties Laois and Offaly. Joan, the second castle and town. Another inquisition was Welshman, Ricard Rys, Will. Went, daughter was granted the Wexford area. also undertaken to establish the value of Thomas Rauf, Adam Leth, Thomas The third daughter, Isabel received the the Knights’ fees in the county. Borne, Peter Borne, Simon. Bryt, Robert Kilkenny area. Sibilla, a fourth daughter son of Ricard, Ric. Harpur, Johii was allotted the Kildare area, and Eve the The “Yet of Common Pleas”, relating to Fraunceys, Robert le Archer, John Cadel, youngest received the Laois area the inquisition, is recorded in the Calen- Stephen Cadel, John Tybaund, Robert (Dunroe in Ossory). der of Justiciar Rolls of Ireland (35- Cadel, James de Valle, John Balymor, Edward I) which as already stated gives Adam Mauncel, Gilbert Maceon, Peter Maud married Hugh Le Bygod, Earl of some insight into the property owners in Loppyn, David Cobrath, Thomas Carru, Norfolk, thus entitling the Earl to succeed County Carlow at the time, and is set out Robert Bremyl, Henry Wyce, Geoffrey Carloviana 2016 Property owners in Carlow edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:24 Page 2

55 Property Owners in County Carlow in the Year 1307

Galbarry, Ric. Galburry, Ric. le Bret, by the service of 10s.; the heir of chief lord of that fee 6s., to Robert John Marcel, Robert Bendeuill, Remund Reginald de Dene holds two knights' fees Mauncel 16d., and to Ric. son of Robert Cheure, Walter de Rupe, Will. Bendeuill at Kenles in Foth', by the service of 4ι. ; 20d. Sum; beyond this rent repaid 4s. and Ric. Graunger. Ric. Taloun holds an eighth part of a knight's fee at Balymakele, by the service And there are at Fynuagh 6 carucates 47 Who say that Roger Bygod held of the of 5s.; Robert Bremyl holds a third part caruc' (recte acres) and 1 stang, worth King in capite, the castle and county of of a knight's fee at Balyscandyl, by the yearly 38 marks 4s. 10d. (to wit 8d. an Catherlach which castle is not well service of 1 mark. Sum 44ι. 2s. 4d. acre), of which Douenald Mcmurwoth roofed, and opposite the castle is a hall in held for term of his life, two carucates 7 which pleas of the county and assises are They say that at Foth' there is a stone acres 1 stang; and there are 15a. of held, in which are many defects, as well chamber covered with shingles and meadow worth yearly 7s. 6d. The works in roofing as in walls; which are valued boards valued at nothing, and no one will of tenants in autumn worth yearly half a at nothing because no one would hire hire it, and a grange of ten principal mark; betaghs render yearly 6s. 8d for them, but they need roofing and care. beams (furcis), almost fallen, of no value suit which they were accustomed to There are there 68 acres of arable land, except the beams, and 368 acres of make to the mill, which mill is now waste of which 50 acres are worths 50s. yearly, demesne land, worth yearly 12ι. 5s. 4d., land prostrate. Sum 26ι. 12s. 4d. to wit, 12d. an acre, and 18 acres are to wit, 8d. an acre, 20 acres of meadow, worth 6s. (4d. an acre), 50 acres of worth yearly 13s. 4d., a pasture called The serjeants of the county of Ceather- meadow are worth 50s. yearly, a moor Oxsynles, containing 10a. worth 40d., a lach were accustomed to render 20 marks and an island containing 16 acres are pasture containing 10a. of no value, a for their serjeancies yearly. worth 16s. yearly. Sum 6ι. 2s. decayed water mill with 12 acres of pasture adjoining, worth yearly 5 marks. Also the perquisites of assises there are Ric. Taloun holds the barony of Tame- Sum 16ι. 16s. 8d. worth in common years, deducting the lyng, and renders for it 4s. yearly. Peter fees- of the Seneschal and other minis- Waas holds there 75 acres opposite the Ric. Taloun holds 2 carucates of land in ters, 40/ι. Also the county court there is castle, and renders 20s. yearly. Geoffrey Balymecolye and renders yearly 26s, 8d.; Wade junior holds there 20 acres, and worth yearly, clear, 5 marks. Also the William Traherne holds 1 carucate at le perquisites of the court of Fothered are renders yearly 12s. The burgesses of the Boly, and renders yearly 30s. 6d. Amicia town of Catherlach hold there 160 worth yearly half a mark. The perquisites Manecouena.unf[d] holds two caru- of the hundred of Catherlach are worth burgages, and render for them yearly 8l. cartes at the Drym and renders yearly 3s. 16½d. and do suit to the hundred. Sum Will., de Bencleuill and Eva his wife hold yearly 20s. Sum 45ι. 6/. 17s. 4½d. one carucate at the Kneiston, and render yearly 2s. The above “Yet of Common Pleas” is Also there is there an oven, which the confined as nearly as possible to the burgesses hold at will, and it is worth The burgesses of the town of Castle- present boundary of the County yearly 20s. The burgesses render yearly Foth' hold there 79 burgages, and render of Carlow. for the toll and farm (sensar') of said for them 69s., and there are there 29 town, 8s. 3d.; the prise of ale there is cottagers who render for their cottages worth yearly 40s.; and there are there 13s. 11½d. Also the burgesses render References: three water - mills worth yearly 8 marks, each Michaelmas 10 geese or 20d., and and three weirs worth yearly 5s. Sum for each smith’s house, four horse shoes, (1) The History and Antiquities of the 8ι. 19s. 11d. or 4d. yearly rent. Also they render 3d. County of Carlow by John Ryan MRSL yearly rent for one place in the head of Edmund le Botiller holds one barony of the town (1 plac’ in cap' ville). Tho. (2) Brophy Papers Tulagh Offelmyth, by the service of 8ι, Wade junior holds there 15 acres, and as often as it shall be proclaimed, and renders yearly 1lb. of pepper and 1½lb. (3) Carlow Sentinel does suit to the county court; Nich. de of cummin, or 16d. Will. Spynel holds Carru holds one barony in Odrone at there 12 acres for 12d. yearly rent. Adam (4) The Calendar of Justiciary Donlek', by the service of 10l. and does le Tanner holds there half a stang of land Rolls of Ireland, 1305-1307, 35th suit as above; John de Valle holds one and renders yearly ½lb. of cummin, or Edward I knight's fee at Ardbrystyn, by the service 1d. Sum 7ι. 19s. The toll there is worth of 40s. and does suit to the court of Foth'; yearly 8s. 6d. Thomas le Boteller holds one knight's fee at Gras by the service of 40s. and does And there are at Dunlek’ and Leghlyn 55 suit there; Adam Broun holds one acres, of which 14 are worth yearly 7s. knight's fee at Ardynhch, by the service and the rest lies waste for want of tenants of 40s.; Will. Traherne holds one knight's and poverty of the land; and 6 cottiers fee at Kilcloit, by the service of 40s., and who render for their cottages yearly 6s., a fourth part of a knight's fee at Kylbolet, of which there are paid to Nich. de Carru

Carloviana 2016 P R comes to Carlow Collected Edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:30 Page 1

was Mr. Campbell, in the unavoidable absence of Mr. Aston. There was a large attendance and deep interest was taken PR Comes to in the proceedings. Those who listened to the lecturer and followed the details of the model election afterwards, realised that after all the system is not so compli- Carlow cated as would seem at first sight, and Sean O’Shea the various societies and associations should take steps to supply information to their members. Proportional Representation (or P.R. as dissolved and replaced by a Town Com- it's referred to) was first introduced to mission. Unfortunately, the Town Com- Mr. Michael Governey presided, and at Carlow when the 1920 Local Elections mission of 1840 had a short innings and the close of the proceedings a hearty vote were held on the 15th January of that was succeeded by a new town commis- of thanks was passed to the lecturer. year. Sometime earlier, an order issued sion in 1855. by the Local Government Board in ac- The model election was most interesting." cordance with the Local Government This followed the adoption of the Towns (Ireland) Act 1919, brought the proce- Improvement (Ireland) Act 1854 by the Carlow Urban District was divided into dure into effect. householders of the town. three electoral areas (wards) namely:- Carlow North, Carlow South and In the town, eligible voters were some- Under the provisions of the 1854 Act, Graiguecullen. Carlow North to return 9 what apprehensive of the new system of property owners of at least £12.00 valu- members, Carlow South to return 6 mem- voting, as was the local paper, which ation qualified to go forward as candi- bers and Graiguecullen to return 3 stated "the election will be the most dras- dates for the office of Town members. tic test to which the single transferrable Commissioner and rate payers with prop- vote has been submitted in any part of the erty of £8.00 valuation and upwards, On Monday the 5th January 1920, world" were entitled to vote. Elections were held William A. Lawler returning officer at- annually with one third of commissioners tended at the Town Hall to receive nom- The system of electing members to local vacating office each year. Over time, inations from candidates for membership authorities had varied from early times. qualifications to hold office and right to of the Urban Council. While the borough of Carlow possessed vote became more liberal. a municipal or corporate existence from The election held on the 15th January the days of King John, when a charter The Local Government (Ireland) Act evoked considerable interest from the was granted to the town by William 1898 abolished the Town Commission opening of the polling booths at 8am Marshal, Earl of Pembroke, there is no and it was replaced by an Urban District until the close of poll twelve hours later. mention of a corporation or provision for Council. From that period onwards mem- All polling took place within the the election of members to a local author- bers held office for a three year period, precincts of the Town Hall, where six ity contained in the charter. The system when new elections were held. Voting booths were provided, and twenty seven for the election of members to Carlow was by way of a single vote with candi- candidates contested the eighteen seats. Corporation was not defined until King dates receiving the majority of votes de- At 10am on Friday 16th January the sort- James I granted a second charter to the clared elected. ing and counting of votes commenced in town in 1613. This charter established the Council Chamber. The returning of- "One Body Corporate and Politique" in In January 1920, the single transferrable ficer was W.A. Lawler, Town Clerk, with the town and decreed, "the corporate vote was introduced, unfortunately with- P.A. Lawler acting as deputy returning body consists of one portrieve and twelve out giving any clear government guid- officer, while P.J. Byrne Solicitor was the free burgesses" John Kerton was named ance to the electorate on the operation of assessor. T.R. Coyle, clerk of the union, the first portrieve and the twelve the system. The local papers were helpful acted as superintendent of elections and burgesses were also named. in explaining the new method of voting D. Fenlon N.T. and P.P Carbery B.S. as were the "Proportional Representation were calculators. The counters were J. Burgesses were elected by a majority of Society of Ireland". The following ex- White, P.C. Bergin, J. Lawler and F. Bol- the corporate members and held office tract from the Nationalist and Leinster ger. The count took place in the presence for their natural lives. The portrieve (later Times gives some indication as to the po- of the candidates and finished at 10am. sovereign) was elected annually by the sition at the time. Burgesses. While other charters were Following the completion of each count granted to the town, the procedure for Proportional Representation the returning officer declared the candi- electing members to the corporation re- dates elected in order of preference in the mained unchanged until the introduction Wednesday night last, a lecture was de- areas:- of the municipal corporation (Ireland) livered in the Town Hall, Carlow, on Pro- Act 1840 when Carlow Corporation was portional Representation. The lecturer

Carloviana 2016 P R comes to Carlow Collected Edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:30 Page 2

57 P R Comes to Carlow

Carlow North Area William Purcell Edward Duggan John Brennan Patrick Breen Sean O' Farrell Frederick J. Williams Catherine Mc Donnell Bridget Laffan Mary R. Bolger

Carlow South Area Patrick Comerford Robert C. Browne-Clayton James Leonard James J. Cuddy Thomas Kirwan Frederick G. Thompson

Graiguecullen Area Michael Governey John Byrne Ebenezer Shackleton

The Nationalist and Leinster Times reporting on the election stated that the P.R. system worked smoothly and the small percentage of spoiled votes (54) proved that the electorate grasped the principle, although the time for educating the public was rather short. The various officials did their work excellently from the viewpoint of routine, impartiality and administration, and showed that a careful study of the scheme had been made.

Interest had waned when the next Urban Council Elections were held in June 1925, with the Nationalist and Leinster Times reporting as follows:

The first Local Government Elections since 1920 were held on Tuesday, and were probably the quietest on record, Co. Carlow being no exception. About 55% seemed to be the average poll.

The only contest in Carlow Urban area was in the electoral division of Graiguecullen. There were four candidates for three seats, viz.: John Bolger (Maltster), D. Fenlon, N.T. (Labour); P. MacGamhna (Labour) and Ebenezer Shackleton. The latter, who was the defeated candidate, obtained 13 votes. The other three were elected on the first count. Mr. John Bolger headed the poll with 93 votes; Mr. D. Fenlon came second with 89 votes, and Mr. P MacGamhna received 68 votes. The result was announced about 10 o' clock on Tuesday night.

Carloviana 2016 P R comes to Carlow Collected Edited_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:30 Page 3

P R Comes to Carlow

Records of the North Area

Records of the South Area

Records of the Graiguecullen Area

Carloviana 2016 Dunleckney Post Bagenals_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:38 Page 1

WâÇÄxv~Çxç cÉáà @ UtzxÇtÄá DKCE@ECDH

Dunleckney Manor as featured in Helen and Derek Sheane’s Myles Kavanagh Christmas Card

Introduction mother and his grandfather from whom great grandfather of Richard Sheehan he thereby inherited the family estates. lived at Amore (Dunleckney field name) Beauchamp Bagenal of Dunleckney He lived at the Newton seat in Benne- and he and his family were located to a Manor died on the 1st of January 1802. kerry. During the Bagenal period in Dun- house on the opposite side of the road to He was buried in Dunleckney cemetery leckney some tenants lived in houses and the entrance of Rathwade House which next to his favourite grandchild Catherine mud cabins in close vicinity of the Manor belonged to the Newton family. Newton, daughter of Sarah and Philip and this was acceptable to the Bagenal Newton, who died at 14 years of age in family but the Newtons did not favour Anne Henrietta Newton daughter of 1800. this and gradually tenant residents that Philip Jocelyn Newton married William lived close to the Manor were located Muschamp Vesey of Abbeyleix on the Sarah Westropp (1770 – 1832) daughter elsewhere on the estate. Daniel Bryan 17th of October 1871. of Beauchamp Bagenal married Colonel Philip Newton. Walter Bagenal, son of Beauchamp, had no male heir and in his will Beauchamp Bagenal left his estate to Sarah.

Newton

Sarah & Philip’s son Walter Newton married Anne Jocelyn, daughter of the Hon. George Jocelyn, on the 22nd of March 1817. They had 2 children Thomasine Jocelyn Newton and Philip Jocelyn Newton. Walter inherited Dunleckney and plans for the present Tudor – Gothic Mansion were drawn up by Daniel Robertson (1770-1849). Walter died on 28th of August 1853 and his son Philip Jocelyn Newton (1818-1895) succeeded him and completed the building of Dunleckney Manor. Sarah and Philip Jocelyn Newton seated on the steps and his 2nd wife Emily standing, the Philip’s son Philip Newton (1796 – 1856) three older children, Adeline, Maria, Anne, from his first marriage and the 2 changed his name to Philip Bagenal by younger children, Harriett and Emily of Philip and Emily. Royal Licence and this was done in Children’s governess seated accordance with the express wishes of his

Carloviana 2016 Dunleckney Post Bagenals_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:38 Page 2

60 Dunleckney Post-Bagenal 1802-2015

In 1895 Philip Jocelyn Newton died. He the second Bore War in South Africa. He Tomduff and Rathanna along with local had 5 daughters from his 2 marriages and was awarded the C.B.E. i.e. Commander residents which included Michael Shiels he was succeeded by his eldest surviving of Order of the British Empire in 1918. of the Market Square Bagenalstown. The daughter from his first marriage, Mrs. Sydney Philip Charles Vesey married O Toole family from Tomduff rented the Anne Henrietta Vesey. Blanche Edith Power of Tramore House field known as the High Field. The Co. Waterford in 1902 and they lived at present Pairc Mhuire housing estate in Vesey Dunleckney Manor. She was the grand- Bagenalstown is located in Casey’s and daughter of Mr. Henry Denny who began Donald’s fields. Each field in Dunleck- William Muschamp Vesey was born to the the Denny bacon business. Blanche ney became known by the name of the Hon. Rev. Arthur Vesey Rector of Vesey had a cousin who was Catherine person who had it rented. During this Abbeyleix Co. Laois and Sydney John- Power, (Sister Alphonsus), a nun in the time also Richard Sheehan’s father stone on the 23rd of June 1827. William Presentation Order. She was Mother Robert worked at Dunleckney as herds- held the office of Justice of the Peace in Superior of the convent in Bagenalstown man caring for the sheep and animals in Co. Carlow and at first lived at Borris and at one stage of her life. Blanche Vesey all the fields, along with the maintenance then at Upton House Fenagh. William and would visit her cousin in the convent and and upkeep of all the fields, fences and Anne lived at Ballyellen and Upton House towards the end of the visit all the nuns ditches. He would round up the sheep before moving to Dunleckney Manor. in the community would join them. with his collie sheep dog and lambs that They at first had twins who died at birth Sydney inherited Dunleckney after his were motherless or delicate were nursed and later had two sons Sydney Philip mother died in 1927 and he died the 28th at his house, as pet lambs, until they were Charles Vesey born the 9th of March 1873 of October 1932 aged 59 years. His wife strong enough to return to the fields. He and Charles Vesey born the 10th of Blanche Edith Vesey died on the 10th of had started at 12 years of age in Dunleck- November, 1874 at Ballyellen House. January 1955 aged 82 years and both are ney Manor as Pantry Boy, later he moved to Marlfield, Clonmel as Footman, and he then moved to Kilkea Castle as Foot- man and once more returned to Dunleck- ney as Gardener and finally worked as Herdsman in Dunleckney.

During the Vesey period in Dunleckney and up to the death of Captain Vesey in 1932 the tenant children arrived at the kitchen Manor door on a fixed date at Christmas time and from there they were escorted into the Servants Hall, the room where the servants sat, had their meals and relaxed. The children sat at the long table on which lay cakes, buns, jelly, custard and other goodies. Afterwards they were taken into the billiard room where they all sat on cushions on the Dr Hope Trant home on leave during WWI, visiting her aunt, Mrs Anne Vesey, on floor. There was a Christmas tree in the the 3 wheeled Dunleckney Parcel Bicycle with her friend, Ms Tiffeney from South room and Mr. and Mrs. Vesey sat at each Africa on the basket, in the stable yard in Dunleckney. side of the fireplace. The older children then individually entertained Mr and Mrs William Vesey died on the 24th of buried in Dunleckney. Vesey with a song, a recitation or some September 1880 aged 53 years at Aix- Charles Vesey lived in South Africa and Irish dancing. La-Chapelle, France and was buried died there on the 1st of November 1911 there. His wife Anne Henrietta Vesey from Blackwater Fever and was buried in When the entertainment concluded each aged 80 years died the 26th of February Johannesburg. child received a present from Mr. and 1927 and she is buried in Dunleckney Mrs. Vesey. The presents had been with her mother, Henrietta Maria Newton During Sydney’s time in Dunleckney he bought by Mrs. Vesey and each was who died at Dunleckney on the 14th of discontinued the farming business and wrapped up in paper with the child’s December 1849. leased out the fields on an annual basis name written on it. After the presentation for eleven months of each year. The 12th of presents the children departed for Sydney Vesey attended Rugby School, month (February) was left vacant so to home. Richard Sheehan was present only Warwickshire, England and Christ allow growth before the next renting once and that was in 1931 when he was Church University Oxford where he auction in March. The majority of people five years of age. He received a toy bugle graduated with a B.A and M.A. degree. that rented land at this time were sheep as his present that day at the Christmas He gained the rank of Captain in the farmers from around the foot of Mount party in Dunleckney. Kings Royal Rifle Corps and served in Leinster which included Coolasnaghta, Carloviana 2016 Dunleckney Post Bagenals_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:38 Page 3

Dunleckney Post-Bagenal 1802-2015

Richard recalls clearly seeing Mrs in a terrazzo floor in the entrance hall. All large Venetian hand mirror in her hand, Blanch Vesey’s big shining Armstrong the Vesey staff had gone to Dublin and so which later was hung from the wooden Siddeley black and blue car with gold the Donnelly family employed local staff panel on the halfway landing of the stairs lining around it and chrome headlamps. for the house and the estate in general. from the inner hall and it was visible to She sat up in it like a queen, he said and Richard Sheehan, Jim Monaghan, Pat all that entered the house. After the during cold days would place her feet in Curran and Paddy Finn to name but a few Donnelly family moved from Dunleck- a foot muff and wrap a rug around her body. Bill Foster her chauffer who hailed from Abbeyleix would pick her up at the front door of the Manor and take her to that day’s destination and at Christmas time that would be to Dublin’s Grafton Street where she would buy the Christ- mas presents. At Christmas each year Mrs. Anne Vesey visited the District Hospital in Bagenalstown and presented the female patients with toiletries and the male patients with tobacco and cigarettes. This custom was continued by Mrs. Blanche Vesey. Tenant houses Catherine Donnelly’s birthday party at Dunleckney. Tom Donnelly received a half hundredweight of coal seated on deck chair and nannie Sheehan by the seesaw. each Christmas.

Following the death of her husband, of the young boys. At one stage during ney to Glenageary the painting of Sydney Philip Charles, Mrs. Blanche the stay of the Donnelly family in Dun- Margaret was so large that it was put in Edith Vesey sold the Dunleckney estate leckney they employed over 30 workers to storage and was mislaid. Gaetano to Thomas Donnelly, spirit merchant and there in various positions i.e. house staff, enjoyed walking around the Dunleckney wine importer from Co. Antrim, in 1942, garden staff, farm staff, stables and estate and the general area of Bagenal- ending the last Bagenal-Newton connec- horses staff. The garden featured promi- stown especially along the banks of the tion with Dunleckney. nently with all kinds of produce been River Barrow. The background portrait grown and transported to the Dublin of each member of the Donnelly family Donnelly market as well as milk and butter. Flow- featured picturesque scenes of the local ers were grown and were available for countryside. The style and fashion of purchase at Dunleckney. One day of each Margaret Donnelly at Sunday Mass in week Richard Sheehan, the then house Bagenalstown caught the attention and garden boy, delivered to Mrs Don- of many. nelly a fresh lot of flowers from the garden, which were placed on display in Thomas and Margaret had 6 children, each room of the house and this added to Peggy, Anne, Geraldine, Jimmy, John the ambience. Hunting and horse racing and Catherine. Jimmy now manages the also played a prominent part in the life family wine importing business and spirit style at this time. The Donnelly family business in Belfast while John is based in were competent horse riders and bred Dublin involved in the same business well known thoroughbreds of the time along with additional businesses. Peggy which included Pink Larkspur and Draw- met a young Argentinian who was doing bridge. Thomas Donnelly at one time a post graduate course in Trinity College brought over from America the famous Dublin. They got married and settled in jockey, Johnny Longden (1907-2003) to Argentina and he was one of officers in ride one of the family horses in a race. the Argentinian army who occupied the Falkland Islands in the recent conflict The Italian artist Gaetano de Gennaro there in 1982. Geraldine carved out a Margaret Donnelly (nee Nugent) (1890-1959) worked in Ireland from career in the horse industry business and about to depart for the races, cap- 1940 to circa 1946 and prior to his depar- moved to America. Anne Donnelly tured in a quick sketch in Dunleck- ture for Sao Paulo, Brazil where he became an Artist. She studied first at the ney, by visiting artist,Gaetano de became professor of painting, he stayed College of Art in Dublin in 1953 and a Gennaro. at Dunleckney Manor with the Donnelly year later at the Escuela de Bellas Artes family. During his stay in Dunleckney he in Madrid. She then went to study at the painted portraits of each member of the Ecole Julienne in Paris in 1956 where she Thomas Donnelly and his wife Margaret family. He painted one large rectangular met her husband Carlo Mazzantini a modernized Dunleckney Manor and put portrait of Margaret Donnelly holding a renowned Italian writer. Ann lived and Carloviana 2016 Dunleckney Post Bagenals_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:38 Page 4

62 Dunleckney Post-Bagenal 1802-2015

and lived there until they built their own house not far from the Manor. They then left and lived in their new house. During the ownership period of the Keenan brothers the Manor also was unoccupied for a time and for a time was also let out in apartments. When the Keenan business firm in Bagenalstown was dissolved, the estate was divided up among the family with the Dunleckney Manor section passing to the Hughes family. Jim Hughes built a house for his family in a field on the farm, a short distance up from the entrance to the Manor House. Jim’s wife continues to live in the house while her son and family Jimmy Donnelly on horseback in the stable yard at Dunleckney live in what was once the Gardener’s house and at another time the Steward’s house. The house has since been redeco- rated and extended.

Colloton

In 1980 Mayler and Loretto Colloton from Wexford bought Dunleckney Manor. They carried out some restoration work on it and operated it as a Bed and Breakfast business.

Sheane

In 1988 Helen Sheane Wall Coverings Ltd. of London bought Dunleckney Geraldine competing at the R,D.S. in Dublin Manor for a reported £425,000.00 from the Colloton family, who returned to Wexford and now operate a Bed and worked in many parts of the world; of the 20th century. Catherine Donnelly Breakfast business at Healthfield Manor, France in 1956, Morocco 1958-61, was the youngest child of Thomas and Killurin, Co. Wexford. Michael Hopkins returned to Ireland1961-63 and from Margaret Donnelly. She spent her child- of Bagenalstown was appointed care- 1963-66 she Carlo and their family took hood in the grand 17th- century Dunleck- taker of Dunleckney Manor by the up residence in Tuscany and from there ney Manor stud farm in Co. Carlow, proprietors Helen and Derek Sheane. they moved to Tivoli. Today she lives and where she developed a lifelong fondness works close to the ruins of the Emperor for horses.” Jimmy Hickey and Christy Lawler of Hadrian’s Villa. She has had exhibitions Bagenalstown were employed in 1990 by in Dublin, London, New York and Rome. Keenan Derek and Helen Sheane to work at the Her works can be found in Collections in restoration of the house from roof to Ireland, Italy, France and the USA. In 1958 Thomas Donnelly put Dunleck- walls, windows and floor. Richard Shee- ney up for sale and many potential buyers han of Dunleckney who had started work The following extract is taken from the from Ireland and abroad came to view it in the garden at Dunleckney Manor as a Irish Times in October 2014 - “Obituary and there were reports of dissatisfaction young boy and had later emigrated to – Catherine Sheerin-Donnelly; April 29th as some people wanted the land divided England first and then America had 1948 – October 8th 2014. Writer, arts and that delayed the sale but eventually returned home, was approached by champion and captivating queen of Irish Thomas Donnelly sold the Dunleckney Michael Hopkins to work on the restora- Advertising. Catherine Sheerin - Don- estate to the Keenan Brothers (Richard, tion of garden and grounds and eventu- nelly who has died aged 66 after a short Patrick & John) of Bagenalstown. The ally was persuaded by Michael to take on illness, was widely regarded as one of the Keenan Brothers had a business in the work. Tommy McAssey was the gen- finest advertising copywriters of her Bagenalstown and then went into farm- eral workman at Dunleckney at this generation. Her campaigns for Bally- ing in Dunleckney which included sheep period of time. Jimmy and Christy gowan, the IDA and Barry’s Tea are farming. John Keenan and his wife stripped the roof of the house of all the among the most iconic Irish advertising Sheila moved in to Dunleckney Manor slates and among them found a slate lined Carloviana 2016 Dunleckney Post Bagenals_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:38 Page 5

63 Dunleckney Post-Bagenal 1802-2015

with names and boxes that showed all the workdays of March 1845 ticked off, which indicated that all those days had been worked at the time of the construction of the building and the roofing. The non -workdays had been left blank. The names on the slates were of men from Wales. On the visit to the house by a Welsh couple some years afterwards, Richard Sheehan showed the slate to them and queried the meaning of a Welsh word after one of the names as to what it meant, the lady pointed out to him that it was the name of a village and as two men had the same name on the slate, it distinguished one from the other.

Threshing Day at Dunleckney -1947 Jimmy Hickey sourced good quality L-R Top of rick of straw: Pat Curran, Percy Rogers, Jim Armstrong. second hand Bangor (Wales) blue slates Lower straw: Jack Sheehan, John Darcy, Bob Sheehan (hand on head), that had been discarded from houses and Lar Fleming (hat on & facing mill), the roof of the Manor was re-slated with these slates and thus restored to its original state. Cotton material to cover the walls rather than wallpaper was installed on the walls and this is the same method used in French historical houses. Behind the wall covering of one wall in the house was placed a white board which contained the names of the workers. The outdoor swimming pool was restored, walled, roofed and connected to the Manor building with an indoor access. Jimmy Hickey and Christy Lawler worked from January 1990 to June 2007 on the restoration of Dunleckney Manor as did Richard Sheehan on the garden and grounds.

On the farm at Dunleckney- The considerable works to the Manor L-R Robert Sheehan, Tom Sheehan, Jack Sheehan, William House, the garden, parkland and the Dreeland (Ballycrinnigan) and Joe Nolan (Acha). superb lime tree avenue complement the entire estate and landscape, giving us a true picture of its former glory.

The owners and the workers have done a memorable and praiseworthy job.

Notes

1) Some field names of Dunleckney:- Amore, Aughney Augh, Casey’s (Pairc Mhuire), Church Meadow, Crab Bush, Cricket, Donald’s (Pairc Mhuire), Doran’s (McGrath Park), Fourteen Acres, High Field (O’Tooles), Lower Well Field, Mill Field, Orchard Field, Pavilion, Pig Paddock, Pump Field, Railway Field, Square Field, Upper Well Field. The pleasure gardens at Dunleckney and Bridie Doyle, the parlour maid circa 1950s 2) The Italian artist Gaetano De Genaro Carloviana 2016 Dunleckney Post Bagenals_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:38 Page 6

64 Dunleckney Post-Bagenal 1802-2015

worked in Ireland from 1940 to c.1946. He exhibited regularly at the RHA from 1942. Predominantly a portrait painter, he painted many prominent figures in Dublin Society such as Dr Douglas Hyde (first President of Ireland 1938-45), Jerome Connor (Irish sculptor 1874- 1943), Jack Yates (Irish Artist & Olympic Medalist 1871-1957), and actor Rita Mooney.

Some paintings of De Genaro may be viewed at public collections in: a) Crawford Municipal Gallery, Cork b) Hugh Lane Gallery, Dublin c) National Gallery of Ireland, Dublin

Sources Luxurious and imposing , an Armstrong - Siddeley Richard Sheehan, Dunleckney, Bagenal- stown, Co. Carlow.

Carlow Historical and Archaeological Society outing to Hillsborough

Carloviana 2016 County Statistics reviewed 2_County Statistics.qxd 28/10/2015 18:43 Page 1

COUNTY STATISTICS 2002 Compiled by John Dowling and Martin Nevin Source: Encyclopaedia of Ireland - 2003 County County Area Population Place Motor car Number Plates of old (pre-1987) Town km2 Sq. Mls Size Antrim Belfast 2,838 (1,092) 642,000 9 Co: DZ, IA, KZ, RZ; Belfast AZ, CZ, EZ, FZ, GZ, MZ, OI,OZ, PZ, TZ, UZ, WZ, XI Armagh Armagh 1,254 (483) 119,000 28 IB, LZ, XZ Carlow Carlow 896 (347) 45,845 31 IC Cavan Cavan 1, 890 (730) 56,416 19 ID Clare Ennis 3,188 (1,231) 103,333 8 IE Cork Cork 7,459 (2,880) 448,181 1 IF, PI, ZB, ZF, ZT, ZK Derry Derry 2,108 (799) 187,000 15 City: UI; County: YZ, IW, NZ Donegal Lifford 4,830 (1,864) 13 7,383 4 IH, ZP Down Downpatrick 2466 (953) 63,828 11 BZ, IJ, JZ, SZ Dublin Dublin 922 (355) 1,122,600 30 IK, RI, SI, YI, Z, ZA, ZC, ZD, ZE, ZG, ZH, ZJ, ZL, ZO, ZS, ZU, ZV, ZZ Fermanagh Enniskillen 1,852 (648) 52,000 20 IG, IL Galway Galway 5,939 (2, 293) 208, 826 2 IM, ZM Kerry Tralee 4,701 (1, 814) 132,424 5 IN, ZX Kildare Naas 1,694 (652) 163,995 25 IO, ZW Kilkenny Kilkenny 2, 062 (795) 80,421 16 IP Laois Portlaoise 1,719 (664) 58,732 24 CI Leitrim Carrig-an-Shannon 1, 525 (591) 25,815 26 IT Limerick Limerick 2, 686 (1038) 175,529 10 IU, IV, TI Longford Longford 1, 034 (401) 31,127 29 IX Louth Dundalk 821 (317) 101,802 32 IY, ZY Mayo Castlebar 5, 398 (2, 084) 117,428 3 IS, IZ Meath Navan 2, 338 (903) 133,936 14 AI, ZN Monaghan Monaghan 1, 291 (498) 52,772 27 BI Offaly Tullamore 2, 000 (772) 63,702 18 IR Roscommon Roscommon 2, 463 (950) 53,803 12 DI Sligo Sligo 1,795 (695) 58,178 22 EI Tipperary Nenagh/Clonmel 4, 255 (1, 644 140,281 6 FI (North) GI, HI, (South) Tyrone Omagh 3, 263 (1, 220) 144,000 7 HZ, JI, VZ Waterford Dungarvan 1, 838 (710) 101,518 21 KI, WI Westmeath Mullingar 1,764 (679) 72,027 23 LI Wexford Wexford 2, 352 (907) 116,543 13 MI,ZR Wicklow Arklow 2, 025 (784) 114,719 17 NI

Carloviana 2016 A Carlow Folly Joe Feeley Eamonn Moore collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:48 Page 1

19th c. Most likely builder was;

1 Edward August Stratford who is said had a strong interest in architecture and urban development which manifested itself not only in follies and obelisks... Mr Stratford married into the O’Neill family, A Carlow Folly the landowners of the time. Historian, Paul Gorry; thinks the struc- J. M. Feeley ture served as an ice house for Mount- E. A. Moore neill House. Ice houses were a feature of most big houses up to the invention of freezers. The ice was harvested in winter In the townland of Mountneill is an earthen mound adjacent to the River Slaney. It is recorded as a ‘moatabower’ on an early ordnance map, but is not recorded in the Archaeological Inventory of Co Carlow (OPW). From the nearby road the observer sees a large grass grown mound encircled by several ma- ture larch trees. (see Fig 1).

However, when viewed from across the river one is surprised to see a romanesque entrance leading to a building within. (see Fig 2). Projecting from the entrance portal are the remains of a semicircular brickwork canopy. The left quadrant has since collapsed and lies on the grass nearby. The doorway and windows are of chiselled granite. Strangely there is no evidence for door hangings.

The building within is circular: 4.77M (15’-6”) diameter and topped by a brickwork dome 3.7M (12’-0”), above a stone flagged floor. On each side of the doorway are large niches in the wall of unknown purpose.The smaller niche is now used as a den by badgers who have spread loose clay nearby. The floor is also littered with animal bones and several sheeps’ skulls. The building is dry and cool within.

The whole scene reminds one of an Indi- ana Jones movie, without the snakes or giant spiders etc!

So what is the building for? Who built it and when?

The authors’ view is that it is a folly and was once attached to a big house nearby, probably Mountneill House. Folly building was in fashion during the 18th c in Ireland. Our best date estimate for its construction is the 18th c or very early

Carloviana 2016 A Carlow Folly Joe Feeley Eamonn Moore collected_Layout 1 28/10/2015 18:48 Page 2

67 A Carlow Folly

from the river nearby and stored therein. Neighbouring counties; Kildare,Wicklow 4. Technology & the Big House in Ire- Normally ice houses are of simple shape and Dublin have many well known fol- land c1800-1930. Charles John Thomas and mostly underground. This particular lies. Is this the only example for Carson. example is very elaborate for the pur- Co Carlow? 5. Moatabower. Short (Mp4) Movie. pose. It quite resembles in particular the http://glasnost.itcarlow.ie/~feeleyjm/ar- Fox’s Earth and the Feuillé at Larchhill Further Reading; chaeology/moatabower.mp4 Arcadian Gardens in Co Kildare. We agree that the structure served Mountneill 1 Alborough House Dublin; a construc- Sincere thanks to historians; Paul Gorry House but is rather distant from the tion history by Aidan O’Boyle & Richard.Lennon house, (which burned down in 1806 and Irish Architectural and decorative Stud- shown on early ordnance map as ‘in ies. Vol IV, 2001 Surveyed by; Eamonn Moore, John Kin- ruins’). Our view is that an earlier big 2 Wikipedia; Ice House (building). sella, & Gabriel Healy. house was once located in the same field 3. Storage,Preservation & Icehouses as the mound itself. (Laois Education Centre).

A forgotten Carlow landmark, the Sugar Factory Chimney.

Courtesy: Michael Keenan

Carloviana 2016 68

Memories of life on the Barrow/Grand canal

Memories of Life on the Barrow / Grand Canal

Mary Hoare

Just a small bit of history to set the scene. Waterford, the Boats were drawn at first In 1772 the Grand Canal Company was by Horses walking along the Tow Path. to build the Grand Canal of Ireland, after a lot of problems it reached Lowtown, in In places along the River where the water Co Kildare. This being junction for the was not deep enough for Boats to travel, Shannon and Barrow lines, as there was short Canals were dug, you will see them trading being carried out on the Barrow usually going to Locks along the system. by small boats already it was decided to The Locks are built to cope with rising or build to the Barrow as this would show a falling ground, on the Barrow all Locks profit quicker. In 1791 the Canal reached are lower as you go towards St. Mullins, Athy, and at the Lock below entered the from there on to New Ross and Water- River Barrow. Boats could then carry all ford the river is tidal. So Boats have to manner of cargo between Dublin and go out with the Falling Tide and come

Tommy and Jack Anderson coming down the canal on the 73M

back with the rising tide. The Scenery as you go down the Barrow is Beautiful, a little piece of Heaven

The Stables were on the area which is now the Town Park, Michael Mealia was in charge of the them and his son was as- sistant stable man and another son was store man in 1901. The Melia family lived in Bachelors Walk, close to the stables in Graigue. (The name Graiguecullen was much later)

This Boat a Horse Boat was owned by Martin Fennell, who was a native of The Boatmen of that era, and there was a Carlow and has many relatives still living in Carlow, as you can see she has a big lot of them in this Parish then, were load of timber on board. This Boat was called a Long Tailed Barrow Boat, the Tiller Dennis Fitzpatrick, Daniel Butler, Patrick which Martin is holding, as is the Rudder are made of wood and are used to guide Hogan, Terence Hoare, James Neill, John the boat as the Horse pulls it. Hennessy, Michael Hennessy, Martin Fennell, Edward Haughney, Michael Haughney, Thomas Hoare, James

Carloviana 2016 69

Memories of life on the Barrow/Grand canal

those people still have family here in Graiguecullen

The letter after the number on the Boats are M meaning the Boat has an engine as opposed to Horse drawn Boats," M' for Motor. `B 'is Bye trader or Hack boat privately or owned by a company and paying a toll to the Grand Canal Company. 'E' engineering boat doing repairs to Locks, River Banks, Weirs along the navigation system.

My own family were Boatmen for five or more generations, my great, great Grand- father George Hoare his son William was my great Grandfather, his son again my View from the Canal Store in 1908. Note the horse drawn barges, stabel on Grandfather Patrick my Father Michael the far side (now the Towmn Park) and the Church steeple on the Athy and all of their brothers and nephews and Roadwhich was removed stone by stone and reerected in Graiguecullen. cousins, so now you know where my interest in boats comes from. 1 was also born and reared at a Lock and remember Dobbyns, Patrick Farrell, John Farrell, Matt Duggan from Allenwood, Co. a lot of Boats and Boatmen. They were John Meaney, James Byrne, Michael Kildare, married Clare Walsh from Sleaty and still the salt of the Earth, Callinan, John Keating, Dennis Road, their oldest son Pete, whom a lot Gentlemen all Haughney, Thomas Begley, John Farrell, of people would know from Knockbeg, Thomas Moore, Patrick Haughney, boated with his Dad for a short time., Next time you visit the Town Park go to Francis Tobin, William Hoare, Patrick the Foot Bridge on the Park side of the Hoare, John Fennell. Some of the Boat Tommie Anderson also from Allenwood River, you will see just beside the bridge owners from this area I remember from also married down here, and his son Jack an inlet with stone walls coming in from later times than the above boated for a while before going to the Barrow, this is the Dry- Dock where America, where he joined the Army and Boats were brought in to be repaired, it The boatmen of that era, and there was a become a Paratrooper, Jack saw service would have had Gates like the Lock lot of them in this parish then, were Denis in all the hot spots of the world, that Gates, with racks to let water in or out. Fitzpatrick, Daniel Butler, Patrick America was involved in his time. All of Boats needing repairs were sailed in the Hohan, Terence Hoare, James Neill,John Hennessy, Martin Fennell, Edward Haughney, Michael Haughney, Thomas Hoare, James Dobbyns, Patrick Farrell, John Farrell, John Meaney, James Byrne, Michael Callinan, John Keating, Denis Haughney, Thomas Begley, John Farrell, Thomas Moore, Patrick Haughney, Francis Tobin, William Hoare. Patrick Hoare, John Fennell, Some of the boat owners from this area I remember from later times than the above list are Jack, Eddie and thomas Moore, They had 54B (the letter B after the after the number on the boat means she was privately owned and paid tolls to the Grand Canal Com- pany, they were also known as Hack Boats) Bill O'Neill had 120 B, Mick Fennell 107 B. They are just some in remember there were also a lot of people who would have worked drawing sugar beet to the factory. Several Boatmen 34B in Sallins Co. Killdare on her way back to base after delivering a load from other areas found wives in to Dublin Graiguecullen, Tom Bolger from Graignamanagh married Katie O'Brien.

Carloviana 2016 70

Memories of life on the Barrow/Grand canal

just reopening; left to right (1) Tom King, Deckhand and Cook, he worked all his life with Mick Fennell's Father on the Barrow and Canal (2) unknown (3) Jack Flynn, Canal Agent (4) unknown (5) Frank Mealia, Store man in the Canal Stores (6) Tommie Anderson, Engineman (7) Mick Fennell, Skipper and Owner of 107B

The Boats carried all manner of Cargo, from wheat as seen here sugar beet to the Sugar Factory and the finished product from there all over the Country, Coal, Guinness to name but a few items. They were the heavy goods vehicles of their time, the hold of a Boat held 50 ton. (Not tonne) From stem to stern they measured John Hoare, my uncle and his son, Pat 60feet, and 13feet across. There was a small cabin in the front about 12 feet by water let out, the boat was sitting on look at the writing at the back of the boat 12 feet with 3 beds that were tied up blocks, ready to be repaired. I know of at you will see M MOORE and a against the side during the day to leave a least one Boat 11B which was built there. Shamrock. Jack and his brothers Eddie bench to sit on, not that the men had a lot Tom Moore sen. brought a Shipwright and Tommie worked this Boat together of time for sitting around, and a stove in from Wexford to build her. She was later for years, and Jack kept her tied up in the the stem for heating and cooking. exchanged with the Barrow Mill Barrow for a long time and went over to Company for 348. her every day and sat on her before he The old Canal Stores where the Boats finally parted with her. loaded and unloaded is now the Boat Jack Moore is sitting to the front of her. Club and is a very attractive building; This was his Fathers Boat then passed to The Boat on the opposite page belonged Jack Flynn was the last Canal Agent Mary Moore nee Hoare on the death of to Mick Fennell of Sleaty Road, as you there. I believe he had a very grand title her husband, and later to Jack. If you can see the Mill had been closed and was " Agent of the Grand Canal Company, Superintendent of the Barrow Navigation and Collector of Tolls"

Boats approaching the Canal Stores from Dublin always turned and berthed with their bows facing up the River. The prevailing flow of the River meant that the boats coming down the River would be travelling quite fast even on reduced engine power. As the boat drew level with the Canal Store the Skipper would put the tiller hard to the right. For many years the Barrow opposite the Canal was divided into 2 channels by a long island. Bystanders watching canal boats turning would gasp with shock as the blunt round prow of the boat struck the island causing the vessel to stop dead in its tracks and then the southerly flow of the river would catch the boat now immobile across the channel and the boat would swing right First boat load of wheat delivered to the reopened Barrow around to face up river, a quick juggling Milling Company in february 11935. Similar baots were of the throttle control and the tiller again operated by the Grand Canal Company until 1960. In the hard over and the canal boat glided over early part of the 20th century boats were converted from to tie up. Yes those boatmen were horse drawn to being powered by diesel engine. extremely skilled in control of those Courtesy: Carlow County Museum. Donated by W. L. Duggan, seemingly awkward and hard to manage ccm74-286. canal boats. Carloviana 2016 71

Memories of life on the Barrow/Grand canal

together behind the tug. There are 4 locks between Carlow and the Barrow lock in Athy, at each lock the tug would come up to the lockpull over untie the boat behind go through the lock, pull in put the next boat through the lock and continue this until all the boats were through, as only 1 boat would fit in the lock at a time this had to be done at each lock. When they got through the Barrow Lock they were on the Canal and tug would go back to Carlow and do the same again until the floods subsided. The tug had a very strong engine.

Bill Dobson, Storeman Daigean, Co. Offaly; Matt Duggan, Mickie Connolly, Graiguenamanagh and Tommy Anderson

This is the wheel of the tug Paddy lock, must people will recognise Mikie's McGrath was not a member of that crew photo above. In fact there were 3 locks but I think the photo is worth seeing; the looked after by Webster families at crew of her were Mickie Connolly. Ardreigh near Athy and at St. Mullins Skipper, Matt Duggan. Engine man and Co. Carlow. At Clogrennan the Lock Tim Connolly, Deck man, I also remem- keeper was John Lanigan, the lock ber Paddy Connell as a member of that keepers were responsible for looking crew earlier. after the River banks and drains in their area as well as the locks. Next to the Lock Keepers; The locks nearest to Carlow are at Bestfield, on the A Boat that must be remembered is 6 M Paddy McGrath census of 1901 the Lock Keeper was the Barrow Tug she was the boat that was William Hickson, a later lock keeper was used to bring the other boats up the named Barron, at Carlow the lock keeper Barrow in the high water. Here is a photo was Michael Webster in fact 2 or 3 of boats, fully loaded being pulled generations of Websters minded that against the floods, 5 or 6 boats roped

The old canal stores in 1940s Paddy Gill The Tug boat at work

Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 1

Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

Life and afterlife: a 500 year saga

John Kelly

Introduction To quell the ongoing unrest a policy of tics to systematically eliminate the hard- ‘Surrender and Regrant’ meant to nosed English soldiers posted to defend The Tudor period is the point in time assimilate the Gaelic Irish by establishing the planter families’.6 One of these where sufficient records survive to their leaders as an English style gentry hard-nosed Englishmen was a young provide a coherent narrative of the was introduced. When this policy failed man from Canterbury in the County of pivotal place of Carlow in the struggle the concept of plantation took shape. This Kent and his name comes down through for control of Ireland between the aimed at introducing English language, history as Robert Hartpole. Gaelic Irish, the Old English and the law and culture through the ‘planting’ of New English planters. In this context English settlers on Gaelic Irish lands. A Origins Robert Hartpole is a key figure and he similar policy had previously been has left significant evidence of his life in proposed in February 1537 when Lord Writing in his memoirs, Sir Henry Sidney archives, physical artefacts and social Deputy Grey and the Privy Council of praises the ‘service of a faithful country- memory. His life provides a unique Ireland suggested to Henry VIII that man of mine, a Kentishman, I mean insight into the rise in social status and substantial farmers should be encouraged Robert Harpool, an inveterate soldier of rank of a colonial soldier/settler and the to 'inhabitie the countrie' and describes that country’.7 The Hartpole family establishment of an interesting and often 'the bridge of Leghlen' as 'a good place pedigree8 begins seven generations eccentric Anglo Irish dynasty. to buylde a towne, there is a house of before Robert with William Hartelepole, Friars there which will helpe well to that who on 10th October 1330 is mentioned Robert Hartpole’s1 service in various purpose. Lett another party of them be in a Charter of King Edward III. The State posts held in County Carlow assigned to Carlaugh being walled pedigree describes the ‘Harpoles of established his reputation and saw him already, another company to Castleder- England’ as of ‘very worthy and of long gain honours and rewards which enabled mot which is alsoo walled already'.4 In continuance’. His father John is recorded him to become a major landowner and 1556 the Tudor Administration acted in the family pedigree as having ‘lived in political figure in both Carlow and decisively to subdue the rebellious Gaelic the city of Canterbury’. The records of Laois2. He continued his association Irish to the west of Carlow and the Plan- the Irish branch of the family were main- with Carlow to the end of his life when tation of Laois and Offaly was estab- tained and it is possible to trace the male he was buried in the Parish Church of St lished ‘whereby the King and Queen's line from William Hartelepole to the Mary’s in October 1594. Majesties, and the Heires and Successors unfortunate George Hartpole of Shrule, of the Queen, be entituled to the Counties who died after a sad and unlucky life in This period saw Gaelic Irish clans of Leix, Slewmarge, Irry, Glinmaliry, and 1795, a period of over 450 years. engaged in a terminal struggle for Offaily, and for making the same cultural and political survival. The Irish Countries Shire Grounds.’5 The ensuing In his memoir 'Personal Sketches of His position was weakened by territorial and opposition to this strategy ensured that Own Times', Sir Jonah Barrington clan rivalry with the result that no real Carlow town remained on the front line describes the character of the Hartpoles unity existed on the Irish side. Loyalties and constantly under threat of attack as 'the hardest livers in the county'.9 He often changed and ‘in those disturbed from both its eastern and western flanks. makes reference to the legendary family times, the Irish chiefs opposed to each Bunbury writes that at this time the 'Eng- curse (or 'doom') which was supposed to other often took different sides, according lish “Counties” were plunged in a state haunt the family and he claims that the as interest or passion dictated’ .3 of perpetual war with native tribesmen 'fathers seldom survive the attainment of employing the time honored guerilla tac- the age of twenty three years by their

Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 2

73 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

elder sons, which circumstances gave 'HEARE LYETH VNDER THIS in the extant records of the period as ‘Sir’ rise to numerous traditionary tales of STONE, TOO BRETHEREN ALL IN and neither his effigy nor his Will make sprites and warnings'. Barrington attrib- ONE, BRITTIANES BORN, HART- reference to such an honour and his utes this a fondness for alcohol and states POOLES BY NACION, HEARE LIV- supposed ennoblement may result from the Hartpoles 'will never be found a ING GOTT GREAT COMENDACION, confusion with his grandson Sir Robert sturdy race'. In her book, ‘Ancient VALIANT THOMAS WITH HIS Hartpole. Hartpole had noble ancestry; legends, mystic charms, and superstitions SWORD, VIRTVOVS WALTER BY the family pedigree records that his of Ireland’, Lady Wilde attributes the THE WRITTEN WORD' grandfather John was married to Joane origin of this family curse to the execu- Littlebery, a descendant of tion of a priest named O’Moore by a Sir Humphrey Littlebery of Richard Hartpole.10 Before he was killed Lincolnshire. He was well the priest is said to have let out three respected and after his screams and laid down the curse that ‘So death the Lord Chancellor shall you scream, and all your (recommending his son descendants in your last agony, as a sign William for the post of of the doom upon your race. You have Constable of Carlow) murdered my people, you are now going refers to ‘his father's long to take my life ; but I lay the curse of God and faithful service’.20 So on you and yours — your property shall Walter and Thomas Hartpole’s Grave, Ballyadams, while he had a prosperous pass away; your race shall perish off the Co Laois career in the service of the earth ; and by the three death screeches John Kelly, 2015 State and died a wealthy all men shall know that you and your man, it is likely that Hart- posterity are accursed.’ While this story pole still retained some of is almost certainly apocryphal, it reflects The first official mention of Hartpole in the rough traits of a soldier and it may a reputation for cruelty and severity Ireland is on the 31st of December, 1556 therefore have fallen to the second which endured long after Hartpole’s when he is identified as a suitable settler generation of the family in Ireland to death in 1594 and was still strong enough for lands in Laois in the Act of Queen attain the honour of Knighthood when to result in a severe attack of vandalism Mary. His reputation as a reliable soldier his son, and successor as Constable, on his tomb when it was rediscovered appears well established at this point and William was knighted on ‘2 daye of in 1809. both he and Nicholas Malby are referred October 1603’21 by Sir George Carey, to ‘Malbie and Harpoole, two gentlemen Lord Deputy of Ireland. Early Life that can serve, and the one that had charge’.13 At this time he was resident in A man of property Using surviving information it is possible Leighlin, where he held the post of to make some reasonable deductions in Deputy Constable14 and is described as The selection of Hartpole to participate in relation to Hartpole’s early life. The ‘Robert Hartpole of Leighlin (County Queen Mary’s plantation of Laois and inscription on his tomb states that at his Carlow), gentleman and soldier’.15 Lord Offaly marked the beginning of a relent- death in 1594 he was 'septagenario Deputy Edward Bellingham had walled less campaign of land acquisition in both maoir'. This has been interpreted as a suppressed monastery and established Carlow and Laois which established meaning more than a septuagenarian (i.e. a fort at Leighlin in 1549 as part of his Hartpole as major landowner in both over 80).11 This was a major achievement campaign against the O’Moores and counties and ensured that he became a rich for a man whose role was central to the O’Connors.16 If Hartpole was part of and influential man. violent times he lived through and gives Bellingham’s force this may account for his year of birth as approximately 1514. Hartpole’s early connection with In 1563 he was granted ‘the lands of Leighlin and his official duties there. He Ballyrahene, Rossenalgan, Garroughe, A reference in the State Papers for remained associated with that part of Dormoyle and Cappoyle, in the lordship December 1567 to ‘Robert Harpoole, a Carlow and in 1567 is listed in a pardon of Slewmarge, Queen’s co’.22 As part of soldier for 18 years in Ireland’ 12 allows as ‘Robert Hrpoole, of Ballibar'.17 the conditions of the grant he was to his arrival in Ireland to be dated to 1549 maintain one English horseman. In the when he was about 35 years old. He was Ryan describes Hartpole as a 'strict, following year 1664, he received 'an old accompanied (or later joined) by two of vigilant and active officer' and that he castle in Colvanacre, alias Coolbana- his brothers; Walter and Thomas. Walter was 'recommended to the Queen (Eliza- hore, in the Queens County, and the was appointed Dean of Leighlin in 1588 beth) by the Lord Downy of the daye in lands of Colvanacre, Ballinabeg and and died in 1596. Thomas, described on very flattering terms, which probably Sheanbeg, containing 200 acres of the his tomb as 'of Catherlagh' and 'an officer procured him the honour of knighthood county measyre known as 'Irry acres;' in the army' died sometime after 1596. which he afterwards enjoyed'.18 He is and also Ballimolroney, together with a Both are buried in Ballyadams Church in also referred to as Sir Robert Harpole by parcel of land there of called Ballinas- Laois and their grave slab has the follow- a number of other authors including traghe'.23 On this occasion, perhaps ing inscription (parts of which are still Lodge,19 but none give any supporting reflecting the size of the grant, he was readable) around its edge. detail. Hartpole is not referred anywhere required to maintain six English horse- Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 3

74 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

men in the service of the Crown ‘and of and Rosseleaghanmore, the their attending all hostings and risings lands of Killehide, Ballehide, out when summoned and of their giving Garrenroe, Ballinecard, Far- a plough-day on their lands whensoever rinduf, Rossemore, and it should be required by the Constable of Ballin’-Kegane, in the lord- the Castle of Maryborough’.24 ship of Slemarge, the lands of Ballirahen, Rossenalgan, In 1565 Hartpole expanded his interests Garroughe, Dromoile, and to the Carlow side of the Barrow and on Cappoile, or Cappahoile, in the 13th of October 1565 he and Henry the same lordship; the Davells are recorded as having leased advowson of the rectory and lands at ‘Ballevare, Clonmolskye, vicarage of S. Fenton, of Kirrikegroghan, Chapelstown and Austin Cooper Sketch Monksgrange Castle 1782 Clowenenaghe, diocese of Powerstown, co Carlow, and the customs Pic: The National Library of Ireland Leighlen, all in Queen’s co. of the tenants, possessions of the late to hold forever, by the service monastery of Baltinglass, co. Carlow’25 Stone from Monksgrange Castle of a fourth part of a knights for 21 years. In accordance with the Journal Kildare Archaeological Society fee; rent £26 1s. 6d’.30 In policy of promoting English settlement keeping with his obligation they were instructed not to let land to any Shrule tenant who was not ‘English by both parents’. They were also not permitted to In 1576 Hartpole was ‘levy coyn or other extractions’. On the granted the 523 acres of the 27th of June 1568 Hartpole continued the Manor of Shrule in Slieve- expansion of his property with the margy. Associated with the acquisition of ‘lands, and half a wood, in Hartpole family for the rest Kynnaughe, and half of Tomegroghe, of their existence, the Shrule Castle county Carlow,' which were seized from Shrule estate was formerly Pic: John Kelly, June 2015 the attainted rebel Gerard McDonnoghe in the possession of John moyne Cavenaghe.26 Barre until his death allowed its transfer of service Hartpole was required to main- to Hartpole.28 On the 24th of May tain six English horsemen as part of the Monksgrange ‘Daniel, bishop of Laghlen, Roger terms of grant. Maneringe, esq., queen's remember- His acquisitions in Laois continued apace ancer, Robert Bice, of Dublin, and Shrule Castle, the ancestral seat of the and on the 24th of October of 1569 he Richard Gos, of Catherlagh, gent’ Hartpole family, stands on the Laois bank was granted ‘the advowson of the rectory accepted the surrender of lands from of the River Barrow near the point where and vicarage of S. Fenton of Clowne- ‘William Portas, of Blackord, Queen’s the River Lerr enters the Barrow. Located naghe, Queen’s co’.27 Five years later, in co., Robert Harpoll, of Colbanahore, at the confluence of the counties of August 1574, he was granted ‘the grange Thomas Myrrick, of Clonrigh, John Carlow, Laois and Kildare and at a tradi- of Kilmagobock alias the Mounkes Barre, of Shrowle, and Lishagh Mc tional fording point of the Barrow it Grange, with its tithes, Queen's co. To Conor, of Ballahide’. Hartpole was occupies a strategic position. Dating the Hold for ever, by the service of a regranted his property on the 2nd of structure is difficult but it certainly twentieth part of a knights fee’. August and his expanded holdings now existed by 1576 as an inscription on the included ‘the manor of Blackforde, a fireplace of the stateroom on the first Monksgrange castle was a tower house castle in Moniferick, Rathmadock alias floor reads: located approximately a mile from the the Blackforde, Kilteighan, Garrans, Hartpole seat at Shrule. Local legend has Kilgessin, Ballekilkavan, Dromlin alias 1576 ROBART HARPOL it that this was built for his wife Grainne Killiclery, Inche alias Ballicowley, and GRAIN HARPOL who would not sleep under the same roof Bavon an old castle in Colvanacre alias DONAGH O'LALOR as Robert when she discovered that he Colbanahore, the lands of Colvanacre had fathered a child by a serving maid alias Colbanahore, Ballarighan, Kill- (who the legend claims he subsequently genne, Ballenbeg, Shanebeg, Ballemol- killed). The tower had a stone above the rone, and Ballenestraghe, the lands of door inscribed with the year ‘1588’ and Shrowle, Ballyhormer, Ballecollin, Rath- the initials ‘RH’, which may have dated duf, Garribriken, Aghatenan, and the structure. An Austin Cooper sketch Cappescribedor, in the lordship of dated 1782 shows the building in poor Slemarge, a ruinous castle and land in condition and roofless. The remains of Clonrere29 alias Merrickstown, lands in this castle may have been subsequently Cultwerin, Killclonhoberd, Ballekilka- incorporated into a house on the site. raghe, Knockandiere, Rathnemanaghe, and Knockanbroghe, Rossleachanbege, Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 4

75 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

Standing four storeys high, Shrule Castle ber of rebellions involving both the Old castle and lands, now in the possession is a classic example of an Elizabethan English and the Gaelic Irish and resulted of Randolph's wife, by a lease for term of tower house and contains features typical in an increased military presence and the years yet to come. A good soldier, he to such structures of that period.31 These strengthening of centers of control (such deserves the same’.37 The letter refers to include stairs within the walls to the as Carlow) to enable a quick response to Hartpole as bearer and it’s possible that upper floors; a ground floor entrance rebel activity in their localities. he travelled to London to pursue his protected by a murder hole; stone vaulted case directly. roofs on the chambers of the ground floor Extreme measures were taken by all sides which also form the floor of the first floor in engagements. In May 1564 a protec- On the 17th of September the State stateroom; the other floors being tive pardon was granted to Hartpole and Papers record ‘Grant to Robert constructed of timber and the roof others (such as Davells and Cosby) for Harpoole, gent,; of the office of constable surrounded by a parapet with defensive ‘services against the Irish rebels, and in of the castle of Catherlaughe’.38 This castellations. Interestingly there is also a the execution of martial law, during entry is most likely a reminder that his carving of a Tudor style Rose on a lintel which they may have offended without claim remained to be decided because in which is now part of an adjoining wall malice, against the rigour of the laws’ 32 December of that year both Hartpole and but which may have been part of the In 1566 a general commission granted to Langham had suits before the Queen structure at some stage. execute martial law included Robert regarding the Constableship of Carlow.39 Hartpole for Carlow.33 These pardons and commissions gave their holders wide The issue seemed to be decided in ranging punitive powers, including sum- Langham’s favour on the 20th of April mary execution, and were a key tool used 1568 when Queen’s instructions to Lord by the Tudor administration to supress Deputy stated ‘Edmund Langham to have local resistance. custody of the castle of Carlow with allowance as constable with reservation By 1567 Hartpole’s military abilities of rent as in the lease. Robert Harpoole appear to have caught the notice of was appointed constable by the lord Plaque, Shrule Castle Sidney and he wrote to the Queen recom- deputy and after expiry of the lease he John Kelly, June 2015 mending Hartpole’s confirmation to the shall be constable there and have the oc- post of Constable of Carlow Castle, cupation of the said lands upon reserva- which he had temporarily been assigned tion of the like rent during pleasure’.40 The dimensions of the structure are 12 by to Hartpole following the death of the 11 metres and it is 14 metres high. The previous Constable, Francis Randolph. Sidney either did not receive the Queen’s upper floors and roof are gone but stairs, Sidney writes; ‘Robert Harpoole who decision regarding Langham or chose to walkways and the parapet remain. The was Constable, by our Deputy, of the ignore it because he appointed Hartpole castellation was removed at a date in the Castle of Carlo, shall have the determi- to lead the Ward of Carlow in September 17th century when the castle was con- nation of the lease made thereof to 156741 and in an entry dated the 20th of verted into a more comfortable residence. Edward Randolph,34 the same Constable- April 1568 titled ‘suits for lands in This was probably done by Sir Robert ship, with the lands thereunto belonging; Ireland’42 he records that ‘Robert Hartpole, grandson of the original Robert and in the meantime, he shall have the Harpoole sues for the same thing as and who died at the battle of Drogheda in pension which he enjoyed before he was Langham and is the most sufficient man 1649. He was married to Catherine appointed Constable, and also a grant of for the service’. By June Sidney finally (Katherine) Lutterell and a plaque the Constableship of the said castle, and had his way and he writes ‘Harpoole to located on the outside of the castle dated of the land therewith occupied’.35 The have his office’.43 1640 may date the renovation. Queen appeared to want more information on the character of Hartpole and A report dated the 31st of March 1572 Thanks to the great care and affection of responded on the of 22nd of July that she confirms that Langham was discharged the present owners, Trevor and Wendy ‘will not give Robert Harpoole a lease in as Constable on the 29th of September Fennell, Shrule Castle is now in good reversion for the castle of Carlow, but 1569 and later left for England. It states condition and it has been spared the fate will hear the matter on Sidney's ’Edward Langham entered 16 May 1565 of Hartpole’s other castle at Cool- coming over’.36 and was likewise one of the said number banagher and will continue to stand as an paid in England and yet continued in pay important monument for many years Sidney again set out the case for Hartpole until 20 March 1568 and then being to come. in a letter seeking the support of Sir appointed constable of Carlow was William Cecil, chief advisor to the Queen discharged of his pension and being after The Constableship of Carlow Castle and dated the 17th of August; ‘The discharged again from the ward on 29 bearer, Robert Harpoole, is the man to September 1569 then was entered into his The return of Sir Henry Sidney to Ireland whom Sidney has given custody of pension again and continued until his in 1568 saw the launch of a sustained prisoners in the castle of Carlow, on the going into England by passport since campaign by the Lord Deputy to pacify death of Francis Randolph. He has which time he remains checked’.44 and settle Ireland. This provoked a num- requested a lease in reversion of the Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 5

76 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

In April 1570 the State Papers record Clogrennane Castle. His father had they had only 28 horsemen and 30 kerne that‘Robert Harpoole to have Carlow for bought these lands from the Kavanaghs, against the Butlers’ 50 horsemen and 400 life’ 45 and Hartpole’s formal appointment who had held them without challenge footmen and that ‘Aid is needed quickly as Constable of Carlow is definitively since before the Norman Conquest. This from the counties of Dublin, Kildare and entered on the record on the 26th of changed in 1568 when Sir Peter Carew, Meath’.51 The letter also informed the October 1570. The grant reads; ‘to a native of Devon, travelled to Ireland to Council that Piers Butlers had attacked Robert Harpoole, gent.; of the manor of pursue claims to Irish lands (including Leighlinbridge while Carew was absent. Catherlaghe, and old strong castle with the Dullogh) which he believed were his Leighlinbridge at this time was the four towers on the east side of the inheritance through an ancestor’s posses- second largest town in Carlow, with its Barowe, one tower on the other side, the sion of the title ‘Lord of Idrone’ which own Constable and garrison. Butler’s fishing of the Barrowe, the demesne had been granted to the Carew family by attack on the town resulted in the burning lands in Barneglasse on the other side of a descendant of Strongbow. of 19 houses, killing 9 men and burning the Barrowe, Ardconeryan, Rathmore, four children.52 Coranmore, Farrancloigh, Heloighe, Carew’s claims were supported by Monesnekyll, Skeamragh and Rathwvll, Sidney, as they would assist his settle- On the 18th of August Hartpole and his Corranbegge, Burlooe on this side of the ment policy and reduce the holdings and associates again wrote to the Privy Coun- Barrowe, Knockanecroghe, the influence of the Ormond family. In 1568 cil that; ’Yesterday Edmund Butler made Erlesmodowe and a water mill there, on Carew’s case came before the Lord camp within three miles of Carlow and the demesne lands of the manor, Deputy and Privy Council and was de- burned Little Nowth in Co. Kildare. He messauges, and the land in the town of cided in his favour. This was a legally is now around Tullow which he also took Catherlaghe, and the customs of the questionable departure from the normal yesterday’. They stated they couldn’t tenants, lands of Mortelliston, parcel of process where such cases were heard by defend Carlow against him as their the manor, half of Dowganstown, Ballen- the Courts. Carew took legal possession company was too small and their locally raghe, Ahate, Kyllenore, the customs of of the Barony and was shortly afterwards raised kerne ‘have defected to the rebels, the tenants of Douganston, Paynston, also appointed as Constable of Leighlin. as have two of O’Byrne’s sons, Gerald Johnston and Pollardeston, and the In response Butler and his brothers, Piers Ore and Edmund O’Byrne, and Cahir prerequisites of the court of the manor. and Edward, rose in rebellion. mac Callough along with divers others’. To hold for 21 years, at a rent of £23 3s. The situation was desperate and they 1d. Lessee or his assign to reside in the The rebellion had heated up on the 22nd warned (with perhaps a hint of exagger- castle, and not to assign without license. of June 1569 and Edward Langham ation) ‘If they are not dealt with soon the As many of the tenants of the houses in wrote to the Lord Deputy warning him of rebellion will approach Dublin’.53 The Catherlaghe as the lord deputy shall rumours that the Queen and the Earl of crisis was averted, however, when the appoint to keep bedding and stabling for Ormond had been killed and that this was Earl of Kildare arrived at Tullow in mid- travellers. The castle and stable reserved the reason why Sir Edmund Butler was August and drove the Butlers back over for the use of the lord deputy when in rebellion. He also warned ‘they give the Barrow, relieving the situation required, lessee providing 100 loads of great threatenings to this poor town, in Carlow. hay, at 2s. sterling a load, 200 pecks of which Langham will to the uttermost oats, at 16 d., 24 loads of wheat straw, at defend’.48 Guided by Caher Kedagh In response to the rebellion, Thomas 12 d. And 100 loads of wood, at 12 d. For O'Moore, the Butlers raided planter Butler, Earl of Ormond, a favourite of the his use. Not to charge coyn’.46 This towns in Laois on the 29th of June. In Queen, returned to Ireland in August and position added considerably to Hartpole’s response Sidney ordered Carew to take immediately set about bringing his land holdings and influence. He retained the lands of the Dullogh and the Butler troublesome brothers back in line. The this prestigious position until his death, castle at Clogrennane. Following an rebellion, while sparked by Carew’s land following which both his son and grand- initial refusal by the garrison to surren- claims, was also part of a dispute within son held it successively. der, Carew misled the Chief Warder by the Ormond lordship and ‘from the very saying the Lord Deputy was present and start the rebels had striven to destroy The rebellion of Sir Edward Butler47 that safe conduct was guaranteed to the Earl Thomas’s power’.54 Accompanied garrison.49 He then took the Castle and by senior local notables including Hart- Among the instances of organised ‘all in it, men, women, and children, were pole, Ormond met his brothers outside opposition to Sidney’s Irish policies in put to the sword’.50 Kilkenny on the 1st of September. this period, the rebellion of Sir Edmund Edmund complained ‘about the cruelties Butler in 1569 is of particular interest The garrison at Carlow prepared to he had suffered at the hands of Lord from a Carlow perspective. Primarily a defend itself from imminent attack. Deputy Sidney and Sir Peter Carew, who dispute about land title, it also formed Viscount Baltinglass - Roland Eustace, wished not only to take his lands without part of the rebellion of the Earl of (who was Butler’s father in law), John any recourse to law, but to kill him as Desmond against the policies of the Eustace and Hartpole wrote to the Lord well. They declared him a traitor, the only Tudor government. Sir Edmund, second Chancellor and Privy Council on the 12th reason being that he had refused to come son of James Butler, Earl of Ormond, of August 1569 warning that Piers Butler to Sidney, who had made threats against held the Dullogh (the western part of the was on the borders of Carlow at the the life and property’.55 He also wrote to Barony of Idrone) with his seat at Dullogh and Slievemargy. They stated the Queen placing himself at her mercy. Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 6

77 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

He was imprisoned by Sidney in Dublin sioned to ‘execute martial law in the co. form a taxation and a major grievance. It Castle for a short time but escaped. He Catherlogh; with power to search out, was generally taken in the form of food later surrendered under the Earl’s bond in after the order of martial law, all disor- because in Ireland’s largely agricultural February 1570 and was formally ders committed in the county, and on economy money or other tradable items pardoned in 1573. In September 1572 finding any persons to be felons, rebels, of value were rare. The Lord Deputy and Hartpole was among a number of gentle- enemies, or other notorious evil-doers, to the Privy Council ordered ‘For the better men requested ‘to make enquiry of the punish them by death or otherwise, ob- extirpation of the proclaimed rebels, the ancient bounds of the barony of odrone, serving however, in all points the instruc- O'Connors and the O'Mores, who co Carlow, the lawful inheritance of sir tions of the lord justice’.62 continue to annoy the queen's subjects in Peter Carewe, knt., and to certify to the Queen's County and County Carlow, we Chancery’.56 Nothing came of this Hartpole was particularly active in his have ordered that 100 kern with 50 boys inquiry and Carew continued to hold duties as Constable. In carrying out these for the next three months serve and be at Idrone in the name of the Queen until it duties (and in common with other the order of Henry Davells, sheriff and was eventually restored to Butler follow- officers of the colonial administration) he Robert Harpoole and to be divided as ing his pardon. exploited his position to increase his you think meet. Cess the kern and boys personal wealth. In 1571 a number of and receive and levy the entertainment The Carlow Garrison in the 1570s individuals from Forth O'Nolan (modern accustomed for the same. Take distress Myshall, Ballon & Kilbride), Clonegal from those who refuse to contribute and The main threat to Carlow in the 1570s and Rathvilly who had been subject to sell it if it is not redeemed within eight came from the activities of the Laois Hartpole’s extractions made a formal days. A third part of the land in the Forth chieftain Rory Óg O’Moore. O’Moore complaint against him.63 Bagwell O'Nolan appertaining to the earl of had been pardoned in the mid 1560s but describes how Hartpole ‘sheriff of Ormond has been stayed from cess by an following the departure of Sidney from Carlow and constable of the Castle, and order of the queen's letters. These lands Ireland in March 1571 he again became his sub-sheriff were accused upon oath of are not part of the lands which the earl active. In April it is recorded that ‘Feagh having seized a vast number of cattle on holds freed of antiquity and this service M'Hugh, son of the wily Hugh M'Shane, all sorts of pretences, of forcing labour- of defence, being a general service is joined with Rory Oge’57 and that they ers to work, and in general of every sort whereunto all such freed lands (of the had done '1,000l' of damage on the of violence and corruption’ and earl's and others) ought to bear cess and borders of the Pale. In November Rory is concludes that ‘No particular notice contribute to this charge. Therefore cess recorded as being ‘more peaceable’58 but seems to have been taken of the charges the third part’.71 Hartpole’s continued by July 1572 he was again active and against him’.64 service shows that any complaints being pursued by the Earls of Kildare and against his conduct brought to the atten- Ormond.59 His activities continued until On the 1st of January 1572 the Carlow and tion of the administration were not the return of Sidney in 1575 (who it ap- Leighlin garrisons again stood at 18 and treated seriously and he continued to be pears he feared as a much more danger- 32 men respectively. Hartpole is also a central figure in local military and ous adversary than the Seneschal of recorded as a pensioner in service ‘besides administrative structures. Queen’s County, Francis Cosby) and he his ward at Carlow’.65 He had entered was again pardoned by Sidney on the 4th service as a pensioner on 26 May 1567 ‘by 1577 and 1578: Rory Óg O’Moore and of June 1576. This pardon would not last the queen's special instruction to the lord Mullaghmast long and would be followed by the deputy and is ready to go to any place of violent and fateful events in 1577 service’.66 In March 1572 Hartpole 1577 and 1578 were to be momentous and 1578. received £191 4s and Davell’s, £85 19s in years in the life of Robert Hartpole and payments for the year ending 20 March their events cemented the fate of both the A commission to implement Martial law 1572.67 By this time the threat from Gaelic Irish opposition and the future of in Carlow was again issued to Hartpole O’Moore must have diminished and the the Tudor settlement in South Leinster. and Henry Davells (Constable of Leigh- Carlow garrison was reduced to 8 (losing Rory Óg O’Moore, in alliance with lin) in March 1570.60 The garrison of 6 horsemen and 4 footmen).68 Leighlin Connor MacCormac, leader of the Carlow was significantly strengthened in retained its strength of 32 men. In June O’Connors, had recommenced his response to the threat of O’Moore and on Carlow remained at 8 (2 horsemen, 6 foot- rebellion in earnest following his failure the 1st of April 157161 the ward of men) .69 The strength of both garrisons to be re-instated to the Chieftaincy of Carlow is recorded as having 18 men at remained the same in November70 and Leix. His claims were dismissed by arms. Interestingly the ward of Leighlin again in 1574, with the only change being Sidney in his memoir as 'that aspiringe under Davells had 32 men at this time. that Sir Peter Carew assumed command at imagination of tytle to the countrie'. This reflects its strategic position and Leighlin from Davells. jurisdiction as far as New Ross, as well In support of his claims to the chieftancy as the ever present threat of the In September 1573 the Lord Deputy and O'Moore attacked and burned Naas on Kavanaghs to the East and the O’Moores the Privy Council ordered Hartpole and the 3rd of March 1577. His men ‘ranne to the West. On the 28th of September Davells to impose a cess of one third on thorough the towne lyke hagges and Hartpole, now titled as ‘sheriff of Cather- Ormond’s lands for protection against the furies of hell, with flakes of fier fastned logh’, and Davells were again commis- O’Moores and O’Connors. Cess was a on poles ends’.72 He appears to have been Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 7

78 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

a bold and audacious leader, with a fear- Margaret Maol O’Byrne (sister of Feach who have cost the Crown of England some reputation. Unafraid to announce MacHugh O’Byrne) and possibly two of 200,000’. 79 his intention to attack; by day he led his O’Moore’s children were killed. Mac men with pipers and at night by lighted Rory’s wife was captured. Both O'Moore The most famous and controversial event torches. This must have had a devastating and Mac Rory escaped by creeping of this short period of intense warfare psychological impact on the determina- 'between the legs of the soldiers into fast- was the massacre of leaders of the Clans tion of his intended victims to resist. He ness of the plashes of trees'. O’Moore of Laois at the Rath of Mullaghmast, was also clever and the attack on Naas had a very close escape and Sydney in his close to Crookstown in Co Kildare.80 The took place at the end of a pattern day memoir claims that 'skirts of his shirt event most likely took place between the when the local men and troops of the were with an English sword cut from his end of 1577 and March 1578.81 garrison would not be in a fit state to bare body'. However, it wasn’t only the defend the town after the traditional rebels who suffered casualties; Sidney’s No direct reference to the event is identi- pattern celebrations. man, John Parker, was killed in the heat fiable in State Papers but number of Irish of the battle and Sidney describes Henry accounts survive. In an account of the Emboldened by this success and upping Harrington as 'being tied in chains, and massacre quoted by Fitzgerald, a local the ante in the hope of a favourable him most shamefully hacked and hewed source states ‘those who were chiefly settlement from Sidney he then attacked with my nephew’s own a number of towns, including Leighlin- sword, to the effusion of such bridge. He burned half the town and a quantity of blood as were nearly took the castle, before Sir Peter incredible to behold. He Carew (a cousin of the original Sir Peter) brake his arm with that blunt leading a much smaller force managed to sword and cut off the little fend off the attack. finger of one of his hands, and in the sundry parts of his Later in 1577 O'Moore carried out a head so wouned him, as I daring coup when he took Captain myself in his dressing did see Harrington and Alexander Cosby, son of his brains moving’.75 Har- Francis Cosby as prisoners. Sidney rington was carried away to From John Derricke's Image of Ireland, 1581. writing in his memoir with a measure of a safe place by Sydney’s The decapitated head of the lady on the right is embarrassment at the naivety of the pair men using their halberds and reputedly O’Moore’s wife (Quinn, 2006) says Harrington was persuaded by ‘some pikes as a stretcher and he about him, and his own credulity’ to meet later made a miraculous recovery from concerned with this horrid murder were O’Moore and discuss his submission and his wounds. the Deavils, the Grehams, The Cosbys, this had led to his capture. Sidney opened the Piggotts, the Bowens, the Hartpoles, ransom negotiations to free the prisoners The outcome of the rescue was recorded the Hovendens and the Dempseys…The (who were being moved about the on the 26th of November in a report by last four of them were at the time Roman country in chains and no doubt exhibited Sidney to the Privy Council; ‘Harpoll Catholics’.82 to the local Gaelic Irish as an example of has rescued Captain Harrington, Alexan- O’Moore’s bravery and skill as a war der Cosbye, and the other prisoners, The association of the New English leader) but it is likely this was an attempt killing all the rebels in the house where Settler families with the event has led to to buy time for Hartpole to locate the they were, save only Rory himself’.76 speculation that it was a local action prisoners and rescue them. Hartpole was carried out by them to remove Irish the ideal choice as both an experienced Enraged, O’Moore immediately attacked opposition to the plantation. While there soldier and a local landowner familiar and burned Carlow. Bagwell says ‘He en- is probably an element of truth to this with O’Moore’s territory. Hartpole’s tered Carlow through one of many view, the prior delivery of hostages to efforts were successful and a disgruntled breaches in the wall, and fired all the Sidney as a sign of good will by the Irish servant directed him to the hideout; ‘the thatched houses’.77 Carlow’s walls strongly indicates the Lord Deputy had at house of a ranger situated in the heart of appeared to be in constant disrepair least prior knowledge of the event. Given a large wood at the north side of throughout their existence. His attack his avowed determination to capture Carlow’.73 Sidney describes O’Moore as was unsuccessful and he only succeeded O’Moore, it is reasonable to assume his having twenty six of his best men with in burning ‘some haggards of corn and assent and possible active participation in him as well as his Marshall, Shane mac houses, after which he retired’. While the events about to unfold. Rory reagh. O'Moore’s and Mac Rory's withdrawing he was attacked by Hartpole wives were also present. Hartpole was at a ford in the Barrow where he lost The leaders of the Laois Clans, led by accompanied by a Captain Furse, Lieu- sixteen or seventeen men.78 Despite this Muircheartach O’Mordha, were invited tenant Parker and about 50 men.74 O’Moore again had escaped and a to Mullaghmast under protection to frustrated Sidney decided it was time to discuss alliances. When the parley had During the attack to free the prisoners a deal decisively with O’Moore and commenced they were surrounded and fierce battle occurred and all of ‘appointed a general hosting to extirp slaughtered by an English force led by O’Moore’s men, as well as his wife, Rory Oge, the O'Conors and O'Mores, Cosby. Sidney’s strongman Hartpole was Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 8

79 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

said to be 'responsible for the treachery county of Catherlagh; north-west, Kil- mended that lands of equivalent value be aforesaid in the fort of Mullamast’83 and dare; flat north, Dublin; east, the main given to the him. The Queen agreed, and apparently directed the carnage. In an sea; and south, the county of Wexford’.87 in September commanded the Privy insertion to the account of the Four Council ‘with convenient speed, to pass Masters Hartpole is reputed to have given Disputes over cess continued but this unto the Earl and his heirs as estate in as an excuse for his actions that 'Moris time Hartpole opposed its collection and fee simpleof such lands and reversions in had geven villanous wordes to the breach he was party to a petition from ‘Gentle- this our realm in exchange, as shall be of his protection'.84 Accounts vary as to men of the Queens co.’ to the Lord amswerable to like antiquity and good- the number of Gaelic Irish killed but it Deputy and Privy Council seeking an ness of the lands in Catherlaghe; for such would appear to be between 60 and 70.85 exemption of payments to support the lands as the Earl is to pass unto us, being Hartpole’s ruthless determination to Pale in compensation for cess they now annexed to the Fort of Catherlaghe’. achieve Sidney’s aim of ‘the totall had paid.88 Writing in the early 1900s94 Fitzgerald extirpacion of those rebells ' is further (a descendant of the Earl) wrote that he supported by O’Cadhla’s assertion that Hartpole’s star was still ascendant in had ‘not ascertained which property was Hartpole hanged the Irish hostages on the 1579 when he was appointed as High given to the Earl in exchange’. following day. Sheriff of Queen’s County, and in 1580 he was also appointed as High Sheriff of A document dated 1591 ‘Notes on the The massacre resulted in the elimination Carlow.89 In August of 1580 the next Provinces of Leinster and Meath’ lists of the leaders of the O’Moores, O’Kellys, generation of the Hartpole clan was also Hartpole as a ‘man of power.95 This O'Lalors, Devoys, McEvoys (Mav- emerging when his son William, appears document must have been compiled at a aboyd), O'Dorans, O'Dowlings and Keat- for the first time on record as a co-lessee much earlier date as it also mentions ings. O’Moore’s activities in 1577 and of the Manor of Carlow.90 William, living Carew and Davells, both of whom had 1578 ultimately proved fatal and he was at Coolbanagher, joined his father again died in the 1570s. Hartpole is said to be killed by Brian Og MacGillapatrick in an in 1586, when sitting on an Inquisition ‘matched with a Coultyeoman and a ambush on the 30th of June 1578. Fol- ‘to ascertain what lands Turlough mac maintainer of rebels’. This is a reference lowing his death the remaining Gaelic Alexander MacDonnell, of Gastlenocy to his wife Grainne, who was an Irish clans submitted to Crown authority. alias Newcastle, in the Barony of Slieve- O’Byrne. The Coultyeoman are As for Hartpole the impact is best maragy, Queen's County, held from the described as ‘notable knaves and rebels summed up by Walsh who states 'the Crown at the time of his death’.91 William pertaining to the Earl of Ormond’. The readiest way to enjoy these lands was to was also commissioned, along with his Coulteman O’Byrnes were a branch of murder the rightful Irish master of the father, Edmund Butler, Josua Mynce and the wider O’Byrne clan and centred on James Grace to take the muster and array Tullow. Piers Butler seized Tullow in of County Carlow in January 1588.92 1531 and thereafter, despite underlying clan allegiances, they became allies of Hartpole was at the pinnacle of his public the Butlers of Ormond.96 career (having been appointed as first member of Parliament for Queen’s On the 11th of October 1594 after a long County in Perrot’s Parliament of 1585) eventful life Robert Hartpole died. He when a serious threat to his Carlow must have known the end was near as his holdings and offices emerged. In January will was dated on the 12th of September of that year the Earl of Kildare wrote to and stated he was ‘sick in body but whole the Privy Council reminding them of his in mynde and in full and sound memory’. The Rath of Mullaghmast and claim for restitution of the Manor of He was buried in the Chancery of St. 93 Memorial to the Laois Clans Carlow. He claimed that the ‘the Mary's Church in Carlow and an elaborate John Kelly, 2015 auncient inheritaunce of the Earle of altar-tomb was erected to his memory. Kildare, have ben held from him these whole district'.86 xvijth yeares by Robert Harpoole, Con- When, on the 21st of October 1594, Declining Years stable of Catherlagh Castle, by vertue of Queen Elizabeth appointed his son a lease made unto him by Sir Henry William Harpole to the office of the Con- By 1578 Hartpole was at least 64 years Sidney, knight, then, Lord Deputye there, stable of the Castle of the Carlow, the old but remained an active servant of the and that thereuppon his Lordship's tytle family succession was secured. Robert Crown. In February of that year he was having ben brought in question before the Hartpole was dead but his story does not appointed as a commissioner with other Cheefe Justices of both the Benches, the end there. senior members of the ruling elite such Lord Cheife Baron and the Master of the as the Lord Chancellor of Ireland, Sir Rolles of Ireland, they yeelded their Family Nicholas Bagnal, Sir Theobald Butler, opinions of the insufficiencye of the lease, Richard Shee, Edmund Butler, Henry and favored his Lordship's tytle’. The Robert Hartpole was married to Grainne Davells and Francis Cosby) to survey the Council found that the castle and its lands O'Byrne and Fitzgerald states they ‘left issue prospective county of Wicklow. ‘This were too important to the defence of the five sons and at least three daughters’.97 county or country hath, by west of it the County to return to the Earl and recom- Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 9

Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

Sir William Hartpole; Coolbanagher, and sound memory doo make this my last Catholic family in Fitzgerald’s account succeeded his father as Constable of will and Testain in manner and fforme as of Mullaghmast. His wife, an O’Byrne, Carlow Castle and inherited the family ffolloweth. would almost certainly have retained her estates. He died in 1616 Catholic faith. The ‘Papist’ tag was also Ffirdt I bequeath my soule into the hands applied to both his son and grandson and George Hartpole; Monksgrange, second of Almightie God, and my body to be the family is only definitively recorded son and heir to his brother. After buryed and interred in the Church of as Protestant in the Down Survey in Williams’s death he succeeded to the Chancell of Our Blessed lady the Virgin where his grandson Robert is described family estates. His son, Robert succeeded Mary att Catherlogh. as Protestant in the surveys of 1641 William as Constable of Carlow and died and 1670. in the battle of Drogheda in 1649. Item, I doo by this my will and last Testamt, constitute and appoynte my Hartpole was placed in an altar tomb James Hartpole; not mentioned in lovinge wyfe Graine Hartepoole to be my made up of a slab (Mensa) mounted with Hartpole’s will and therefore likely dead full and whole executrix. an effigy and a chest to hold his remains. before 1594. The effigial slab was bevelled along one Itm. Idoo will yt therebe delyvered and side and at the two ends suggesting that Henry Hartpole; not mentioned in geeven as a ffree token and healpe to my the non-bevelled side was placed against Hartpole’s will and therefore likely dead lovinge soone-in-law Mr, John Hoven- a wall in the chancel of the church. The before 1594. den, or to his assignes,one halfe yeares chancel is the area of the church around warrante of myne entertaynmt due on her the altar and was a prestigious location Pierce Hartpole; referred to in the will as Maite contayninge ye some of threescore which reflected Hartpole’s place in local the youngest son and was left lands in Co pounds lawffull mooney of Irelande, for society. The choice of an effigial tomb Carlow (including Chaplestown) and to paye suche arrerages as he is behynde also reflects his status and wealth. In Queen’s County. Born in 1559, he died to her Matie in the tyme yt the countrey 1614 £230 was paid for the tomb of the on the 11th February, 1619. was waste in ye rebellion of ye O'Mores’ Earl of Ormond, and in 1620 the tomb of the Earl of Youghal cost £330.103 An unnamed daughter who was married The Will was witnessed by his son in law Hartpole’s tomb is apparently of similar to John Hovenden, of Ballyfoyle, John Hovenden, David Lea, Robert quality and would therefore have Queen's County. Bowen of Ballyadams and Piers White, incurred a similar cost. This demonstrates the Vicar of Carlow. the rising status of the new settler class Helen (or Ellen) Hartpole; married 1st, in relation to the Old English aristocracy. Francis Cosby and after his death in the As requested in his Will Hartpole was battle of Stradbally she married Sir laid to rest in the Church of the Blessed The effigy was of a knight in a suit of Thomas Loftus of Timahoe. Lady the Virgin Mary in Carlow. This plate-armour, with the head resting on a was the church associated with St Mary’s round helmet. The feet were supported by Margaret Hartpole, wife of Gerald Grace, Abbey which is placed by a number of a dog. The hands lay on the chest, fingers Ballylinch, Kilkenny. She died in 1619 sources on the hill where the castle stands joined in prayer. A sword was attached by and both are buried at Jerpoint Abbey. and was part of the medieval settlement a belt round the waist on the left side of around the castle. This location is the effigy. An inscription was carved into Will and Burial supported by a lease dated 1723 which the right hand side of the tomb: refers to a plot ‘bounding on the south Hartpole died in October 1594. His will with the Castle Churchyard, on the north ‘Hic jacet Robartus Hartpoole, was quickly proved after his death on the by Gaynor’s plot, on the west by the Conestabulrius de Catherlagh, 28th of October. The original of the will Castle Yard and on the east by the road Septuagenario maoir, interiit iii die appears to have disappeared at an early leading to the Barracks’100 and by Octobris 1594’ date and Vicar’s ‘Index of Prerogative Malcomson, who refers to ‘the remnant This was later translated (by Fitzgerald) Wills of Ireland, 1536-1810’ records only of the burial-ground attached to the to read: a copy existing in 1897.98 annihilated Abbey of St. Mary, on Castle- ‘Here lies Robert Hartpoole, Constable hill, in the town of Carlow’.101 Archaeo- of Carlow, he died on the 3rd day of The Will leaves his possessions to his logical digs carried out as part of the October, 1594, being more than a three sons William, George, and Pierce. Carlow Main Drainage Scheme in the septuagenarian [i.e. being eighty years A Queen's County inquisition99 mentions years 2010 to 2012 show that the grave- of age and over]’. two other sons, James and Henry, as yard associated with this church was living in 1579, but as they are not large and stretched north through Coal In the 1630s the churches in Ireland are mentioned in the will. No reference is Market to the present St Marys Church. described as ‘in a deplorable condition, made to his daughters. Curiously while Fennell102 notes that St the Cathedrals in many places destroyed, Mary’s Church passed to the new Protes- the parish Churches generally ruined, 'In the name of God Amen. I Robert Hart- tant faith in 1562 a number of sources unroofed or unrepaired, the houses of the pole of Catherlough, Esquier, though sick describe Hartpole as a Papist and the Clergy left desolate’.104 This was also the in body but whole in mynde and in full Hartpoles are stated to be a Roman case of the Church of the Abbey of St Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 10

81 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

Mary which fell into disrepair and traction. Ms Leadbetter continued; ‘I have it restored to its proper place some ‘became untenable in the sixteen thirties went to see it along with some other day’.114 Alice Hartpole-Bowen, daughter through decay’.105 A new church was young people, but we could not see it of Charles, was his lady correspondent constructed around the year 1635 at the satisfactorily, the crowd was so great. It and she had written to him in January location of the present St Mary’s Church. lies exposed where it was found for 1895 confirming that 'the head of the It is likely the old church was scavenged anyone to look at it. I wonder the man effigy, which rested on a helmet, was for building material and the site became who discovered it did not bring it home broken off at the neck, and, as a child, I overgrown and forgotten (although a and make something of showing it there. remember seeing it kept at a garden- local tradition indicates some ruins still It was no more than 5 feet below the house at Kilnacourt, but do not know remained as late as 1786).106 surface of the earth on Castle Hill’. what has since come of it'.115 She also Speculation began as to who the impres- gave him an etching of the tomb (a copy This part of Carlow was subject to extensive figure was. Initially it appears the of Hewetson’s conjectural representa- sive development in the late 18th and local people thought it was a long forgot- tion below). early 19th centuries. The construction of ten Gaelic Irish King or Chieftain but a new military barracks in Barrack St in eventually ‘an old friar visited the spot, the 1750s made the land of old Cavalry and pronounced it to be the effigy of Barracks along the River Barrow avail- Robert Harpol, and pointed out a Latin able for development. In addition the inscription which had escaped the notice development of the street of Castle Hill of those who had previously examined (the emergence of which can be seen on it.109 The knowledge of the identity of the Columbine’s map of 1735) resulted in effigy may have stirred latent memories extensive works in the area. These of Mullaghmast and aroused the fury of factors, while altering the landscape of the workmen. As a result ’discovering John Hewetson’s lithograph of the Castle Hill and obliterating the remains that it was not to the memory of an Irish effigy (From ‘Memoirs of the Family of of medieval settlement in the area, King, a labourer contemptuously Grace’ by Sheffield Grace, 1828). ultimately led to the re-discovery of knocked the head off. The head was Hartpole’s tomb. thrown into the Barrow. To save what This lithograph bears very little likeness remained, Mr Bruen has the slab to the remaining parts of the tomb and Discovery removed to Oak Park, and offered, must have been drawn from an oral or successfully, a reward for the recovery of written description . Hartpole’s effigy was rediscovered in the head’.110 The destruction of memori- 1809 when workers ‘engaged cutting als to persons seen as oppressors of the Local antiquary Lord Walter Fitzgerald away a portion of the graveyard for Irish was not unusual at this time. In also took an interest in the effigy and building purposes…….. discovered a Ballyadams Churchyard the effigies of wrote that ‘The effigy is at present placed stone effigy about four feet below the Robert Bowen and his wife Alice Hart- on a base of mason- work, built on a little surface, which they raised and placed pole (a daughter of Walter Hartpole) were hillock, under the trees near the lough at upright against a tombstone. The effigy destroyed by a funeral crowd in 1832.111 the back of Kilnacourt’.116 The following was in a perfect state of preservation, year he dealt with the effigy in more notwithstanding the long period it Move to Portarlington detail. Having been described at its remained buried beneath the surface of uncovering in 1809 as being in very good the churchyard’.107 The remnants of the tomb resided in the condition it had now badly deteriorated, walled garden of Oak Park House for a probably due to the damage caused by This dating is calculated from a diary number of years until Charles Hartpole- the workmen before Bruen’s rescue. entry of 18 year old Elizabeth Cole (nee Bowen, a descendant of Hartpole, got Fitzgerald notes ‘The head is broken off Leadbetter), who wrote the following; ‘I permission from Col. Bruen to relocate it and missing ; ……. finger-tips joined; was in Carlow last week, and the day to his family home at Kilnacourt, they are badly broken…….The legs, too, before I went there there was a tombstone Portarlington. 112 have met with bad treatment. The effigy- dug up in an old churchyard bearing the slab itself is broken into two parts, inscription ‘Robertus Hartpold. A.D. By the 1890s interest in the fate of the ef- 1594’ – 215 years ago. It is in high figy revived in Carlow and Col. Vigors preservation; about 7 feet long and three writes that he had got information from [illegible] wide. on the tomb is a man in ‘a lady….whose name led me to believe complete armour, as large as life, with his her to be a descendant of the family’, and head resting on his helmet; at his feet a that he had ‘traced the old warrior to his bloodhound. It is of grey marble, and as present resting place, under a grove of good as if it were done but three fine trees in the grounds of Kilnacourt 108 113 years ago'. House, Portarlington’. In a letter to the Photograph of effigy and rubbing of Editor of the Carlow Vindicator Vigors inscription, Lord Walter Fitzgerald, The find generated interest and excite- states that ‘the head, I am informed, is JPMDI, Vol. VI ment and immediately became a local at- also at Kilnacourt, and we may hope to Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 11

82 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

caused by a clean break just above the seems strangely modern in design and its knees’.117 stout proportions (particularly the large chest) is unlike the Ormond effigies in However, not all of the tomb had found Kilkenny and Tipperary .121 Its distinctive its way to Portarlington and in 1905 features include the helmet, armour (the Canon Ffrench identified a figure and a breastplate may be a late Peascod type) heap of debris in the walled garden at and in particular the sword, which is a Oak Park as the remains of the tomb. He British design and may be a Proto-Mor- describes the figure as made from black tuary type sword.122 The sword has a bas- marble and it details as ‘The present The Hartpole effigy in the People’s ket shaped handguard unlike the older gross width of the stone, from which the Park, Portarlington crossguard type on both the Ormond ef- figure stands in relief, is 2 feet 3 inches. John Kelly, 2015 figies and soldiers in Derricke’s illustra- The height of the stone figure, and the The effigial slab measures 193 x 71cm height of the pillar alongside it, is 21 (76 x 28 inches). The figure appears to be inches; the gross width of the figure is 13 unchanged since Fitzgerald’s examina- inches. It seems to be represented as tion but the inscription is badly damaged vested in a steel cuirass. Possibly it may and is now missing its central script on be a long-waisted, peaked, and close- the lower line. This piece is marked by fitting doublet; but it looks more like a ‘chip’ and ‘break’ in Fitzgerald’s rubbing cuirass, and over it, around the neck, there is a collar turned down. Some light open headpiece, probably the “salade” Features of effigy: Helmet, Sword, Dog and Inscription

tions. These features reflect the transition in military style and function from the medieval to the early modern period.

The Oak Park weeper also survives and takes a place of honour in the Oak Park museum. As can be seen in the picture below most of the backing slab has gone and the features have become less Hartpole Tomb Remnant, Oak Park, distinct since Ffrench’s discovery. The 1905, Canon Ffrench, JPMDI, Vol. VI pile of debris has unfortunately been lost. An extensive search in the 1980s did not or morion, was worn, which is now discover any more artefacts of the tomb greatly defaced. The face shows a short Grafitti on effigy at Oak Park and unless serendipity allows fringe of hair across the forehead’.118 some undiscovered or misplaced pieces and was always in danger of being to be uncovered in the future the weeper broken off. In its present location the The Effigy in 2015 will remain as the only piece of the tomb effigy is subject to graffiti, litter and extant in Carlow. vulnerable to vandalism.119 In the latter part of the twentieth century due to a change of ownership of Kilna- While described by some authors as court House the effigy ended up being being made of black marble, it appears stored in the yard of Laois County Coun- the effigy is carved from limestone. This cil at Portarlington. At this time Carlow is a type of black ‘marble-like limestone’ historian, Tommy Clarke made efforts to local to Kilkenny which when polished have the effigy returned to Carlow. He takes on the appearance of black mar- gained approval for the move but the ble.120 This effect can be seen in photo- emergence of some local opposition graphs of the effigy. The helmet on caused him to drop the matter. The effigy which the head rested is a Cabasset type was later moved to its present location in helmet and is very similar to helmets in the People’s Park, Portarlington where it Derricke’s illustrations. The belt, sword now lies on a platform covered by a and armour remain well defined and the canopy constructed of wood and dog (also headless) is well preserved. For Hartpole Tomb Weeper, Oak Park, 1905 metal sheeting. an artefact over 400 years old the effigy Pic: Canon Ffrench, JPMDI, Vol VII

Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 12

83 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

1 The name Hartpole is recorded in a num- 2014. More information see Chapple, R., SUMMARY ber of different forms. Among archival Demolition of 13th/14th Century Castle, sources it is found spelled as Hartlepool, Coolbanagher,Co.Laois,http://rmchapple.blog The Robert Hartpole that emerges from Harpol, Harpool, Harpoole, and in Robert’s spot.ie/2014/02/demolition-of-13th14th-cas- case most commonly as Harpole. This article tle.html history is rightly viewed as a rapacious 25 will use the modern spelling of Hartpole for 808, Fiants Elizabeth land grabber, a ruthless soldier of severe 26 the family, except where quotations are taken SP 63/25 f.25 27 temperament and having a single minded directly from sources. 1599, Fiants Elizabeth 28 ambition to climb to the top of the social 2 The territory of the modern county of Cosby, I., The English Settlers in Queen’s ladder. However Hartpole also had a Laois is referred to in original sources as Leix County, 1570-1603, Laois History and Soci- more enigmatic side. In common with or Queen’s County. In this article the modern ety, 1999, other figures of the period he had am- title of Laois is used except where quotations PP. 283-326 29 biguous loyalties; he may have retained are taken directly from sources. Clonreher castle is a four storey tower 3 his Catholic faith, he married a Gaelic O’Hanlon, J., & O’Leary, E., History of with a hall over a vaulted cellar and loft and its remains are located to the north of Port- Irish woman and in at least one account the Queen’s County,1907, P. 424 4 laoise. See Searle, M., Castles of Leinster: is said to be a ‘maintainer of rebels’. The Lord Deputy and Council of Ireland, Memorial for Winning Leinster, State papers Clonreher, Laois, of Henry VIII, Vol ii, 1537, p.413 http://www.geograph.ie/photo/2493938 Regardless of his personal nature and 30 5 3 & 4 Phil & Mar, c.2 (1556) 2838, Fiants Elizabeth activities in life he remains an important 31 National Monuments Service, Irelands 6www.turtlebunbury.com/history/history_iris figure in the history of Carlow and his Tower Houses, Country Living Section, Irish h/history_irish_mullaghmast.htm effigy is an important artefact in 7 Farmers Journal, 24 March 2012 Brady, C., A Viceroy’s Vindication? Sir 32 629, Fiants Elizabeth Carlow’s archaeological history. Its Henry Sidney’s Memoir of Service in Ireland, 33 present location has no historical 953, Fiants Elizabeth 2002, P. 97 34 This should read Edward Langham who connection with Hartpole and the familial 8 GO MS 177, National Library of Ireland had married the widow of Francis Randolph connection, the Hartpole-Bowens, who (NLI) 35 Patent and Close Rolls of Ireland, Eliza- 9 brought the effigy to Portarlington, no Is Barrington referring to their lifestyle or beth, 1567 longer reside there. The canopy covering their actual Livers? Perhaps a bit of lawyerly 36 499, Fiants Elizabeth the effigy is not aesthetically appropriate double entendre at play? 37 SP 63/21 f.181 10 to the artefact nor does not it provide any This is most likely referring to Robert 38 1125, Fiants Elizabeth 39 protection from weather or vandalism. about whom this story appears in various SP 63/22 f.176 40 Hartpole’s Will directs that he be buried guises in a number of sources SP 63/24 f.32 11 Fitzgerald, W., Journal of the Association 41 in St Mary’s Church in Carlow and as no SP 63/22 f.84 for the Preservation of the Memorials of the 42 SP 63/24 f.32 records exist of discovery of his body, it 43 Dead in Ireland (JPMDI), Vol. XXX, P137 SP 63/25 f.22 12 must be assumed his remains are still SP 63/22 f.176 44 SP 63/35 f.168 13 interred at Castle Hill. SP, Vol 1, P134 45 SP 63/30 f.94 14 Brady, 2002, P127 46 1600, Fiants Elizabeth 15 While two different Carlow historians 171, Fiants Philip and Mary 47 See Hughes, J., “Sir Edmund Butler of the 16 (Vigors and Clarke) made unsuccessful Ryan, J., The History and Antiquities of the Dullogh, Knight”. The Journal of the Royal 123 County of Carlow, 1833 P.101 Historical and Archaeological Association of attempts to have the effigy returned , it 17 1185, Fiants Elizabeth Ireland, Fourth Series, Vol. 1, No. 1, 1870 is this author’s opinion that a serious and 18 Ryan, 1833, P. 379 48 SP 63/28 f.106 sensitive attempt to return the effigy to 19 Lodge, J., The Peerage of Ireland, Vol III, 49 Butler regarded himself as loyal to the Carlow could be successful, particularly PP.183-184 Queen (who was his cousin) and refused to 20 if an assurance could be given it would SP 63/188 f.43 engage with troops which were led in her 21 be reunited with its surviving weeper and Official grants and confirmations of arms, name. This stance explains the chief warder’s a safe location was secured to ensure its GO103-111g, NLI apparent credulity. 22 preservation. The present St Mary’s 953, Fiants Elizabeth 50 Hughes, 1870 23 Church of Ireland would be an eminently 612, Fiants Elizabeth 51 SP 63/29 f.67 24 52 suitable location. The County Museum Home of William Hartpole, Roberts’s son John McLean, The Life and Times of Sir may also be suitable. As for the missing and successor, Coolbanagher castle was Peter Carew Kt, 1857, P221 constructed as part of a ring of towers 53 head perhaps some publicity may turn it SP 63/29 f.72 constructed to defend the Rock of Dunamase 54 Edwards, D., The Ormond Lordship in up in a rockery or on a shelf in the Por- complex. It was a tower house and has been County Kilkenny, 1515-1642, 2000, PP. 196- tarlington area. dated to the 13th century. The castle stood 3 199 stories high and castle contained a murder 55 SP 63/29 f.108 Thanks are due to the following for their hole in the doorway, a typical feature in this 56 2147, Fiants Elizabeth help and assistance in compiling this type of structure. Before its demolition three 57 SP 12 of 1571 Vol. xxxii article; Wendy and Trevor Fennell, walls of the original structure remained, the 58 SP 29 of 1571 Vol. xxxiv 59 Shrule; Ronnie Matthews, Portarlington; western wall having previously collapsed. SP 11 of 1572 Vol. xxxvii 60 Eric Donald and Connie Conway, Unfortunately Storm Darwin caused the 1505, Fiants Elizabeth collapse of the southern part of the structure 61 Teagasc, Oak Park; Pat Comerford and SP 63/32 f.1 on the 12th of February 2014 and the remain- 62 1829, Fiants Elizabeth Deirdre, Janet and the excellent and 63 der was demolished on the 24th of February This document entitled ‘The Book against patient staff of Carlow County Library. Carloviana 2016 Robert Harpole Jims_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:09 Page 13

84 Robert Hartpole Constable of Carlow

Robert Hartpole’ will be the subject of a 166 105 Fennell, 1986/87, P. 41 future article by this author 84 O’Donovan, J., Annals of the Kingdom of 106 Fennell, 1986/87 64 Bagwell, R, Ireland Under the Tudors, Ireland by the Four Masters, 1854, P. 1694 107 O'Neill, 1895, Carlow Vindicator Vol. II, 1885, P.229 85 O’Cadhla puts the dead at more than 58, 108 Barrington, A., The Barrington’s, 1917, 65 SP 63/35 f.2 Annals of Lough Ce at 70 and the Annals of P. 80 66 SP 63/35 f.168 Ireland at 40 109 O'Neill, 1895, Carlow Vindicator, 67 SP 63/35 f.2 86 Walsh, 1933, P. 172 reprinted in Vol III, JPMDI, 1895, P.P. 135- 68 SP 63/35 f.140 87 Document dated 1596 in Carew Mss 137 69 SP 63/36 f.154 88 SP 63/62 f.200 110 McCartney, D., W.E.H. Lecky, Carlo- 70 SP 63/38 f.46 89 3848 Fiants Elizabeth viana, 1966, P. 34 71 P 63/42 f.54 90 SP 63/62 f.200 111 Fitzgerald, W., JPMDI, Vol II, Part 2, 72 SP37, Vol LVIII, 1577 91 SP 63/117 f.127 1892-94, P. 536 73 O'Neill, J., letter to Editor of the Carlow 92 SP 63/123 f.44 112 Despite a search of Oak Park estate Vindicator, 16th February, 1895. 93 SP 59 of Vol. VII, 1588 records a date for this move cannot be estab- 74 Ryan, J., The History and Antiquities of 94 Fitzgerald, W., The Castle and Manor of lished but it was definitely before 1880 when the County of Carlow, 1833, P. 379 Carlow, JCKAS, Volume 6, 1909-1911, PP. Hartpole-Bowen died 75 Brady,2002, PP. 96-98 335-337 113 Vigors, P. JPMDI, Vol III, 1895, P.P. 134- 76 SP 63/59 f.128 95 SP63/213 f.33 Addenda, 587 145 77 Bagwell, 1885, P. 345 96 Byrne-Rothwell, D., The Byrnes and 114 Dated 6th March, 1895 and reprinted in 78 Ryan, 1833, P. 110 O’Byrne’s, Vol. II, 2010, P109 Vol III, JPMDI, 1895 79 SP57, Vol LVIII, 1577 97 Fitzgerald, E., JCKAS, Vol IV, PP. 305- 115 JKAS, Vol IV, 1905, P. 433 80 For a detailed examination of Mullagh- 306 116 See Fitzgerald, W., JKAS, Vol IV, 1905, mast see: Carey, Dr. V., John Derricke's 98 A search of the National Archives in 2015 P.P. 301-311 Image of Ireland, Sir Henry Sidney, and the failed to locate a copy of the will and it is 117 Fitzgerald, W., JPMDI, Vol VI, P.137 massacre at Mullaghmast, 1578, Irish Histor- likely that it was destroyed in the Civil War 118 Canon Ffrench, JPMDI, Vol VII, Part 2, ical Studies, Vol. XXXI No 123, Vincent P. destruction of State Records. It is possible to 1907-1909, PP. 521-522 Carey, 1999 piece together most of the terms of the will 119 See Barker, L.W., Gilligan, N. & Fegan, 81 While it is traditionally accepted as having from research carried out by Fitzgerald and G., Laois Burial Grounds Survey 2011, Vol- occurred on New Year’s Day 1577, Carey Vigors. ume 2: Gazetteer of Burial Grounds. October dates the massacre to March 1578. This dif- 99 Queens Co Chancery Inquisition, No 13 2011 ference may have resulted from the fact that of Charles 1 120 Loeber, 1981, P. 278 the administrative year until 1752 ran from 100 Hardy, C., www.excavations.ie, number: 121 For a detailed examination of these Lady Day (25th March) and not 1st January 2004:0090, Valerie J. Keeley Ltd effigies see Rae, E.C., “Irish Sepulchral Mon- and would have resulted in the 1st of January 101 Malcomson, R., The Carlow Parliamen- uments of the Later Middle Ages”, Journal of 1578 being dated using this notation as the 1st tary Roll, Dublin, 1872, P.61 the Royal Society of Antiquities of Ireland, of January 1577. This would be in line with 102 Fennell, H., “History of St Mary’s Parish Volume 100, 1970 the earliest Irish account by Corc Og O'- Church Carlow”, Carloviana, 1986/87, PP. 122 Thanks to Dave Swift of Claíomh, Irish Cadhla dated 22nd of March 1578 and the as- 41-44 Living History & Military Heritage, who gave sertion of its editor, Walsh, who states that 103 Loeber, R., Sculptured Memorials of the the author useful and thought provoking com- ‘our entry was made a few months after the Dead in Early Seventeenth-Century Ireland: ments on the effigy event took place’. A Survey from “Monuments Eblane” and 123 Past opposition to a return may have re- 82 Fitzgerald, W., Mullaghmast: Its History other Sources, Proceedings of the Royal Irish sulted from a misidentification of the effigy and Traditions, Journal of the Co. Kildare Ar- Academy Vol. 81C, 1981, with the destroyed effigy of Robert Bowen in chaeological Society (JCKAS), VI, P379-390 P. 269 Ballyadams. 83 Walsh, P., Editor, Corc Óg Ó Cadhla, 104 Carte, T., An History of the Life of James, Gleanings From Irish Manuscripts, , 1933, P. Duke of Ormonde, 1736, Book 2, P.68

Carlowman in the Charge of the Light Brigade

Daniel Dowling Rode In Famous British hundred without a wound, and not until many countries on his guest, which never Charge at Balaklava, Spector to The New the battle of Inkerman was he wounded. was successful. He had distant relatives York Times. After the Crimean War Dowling went to in this region and came here to live, many places, fighting for England. He taking up farming. Age coming on, he UTICA, July 15.—In the County Alms- saw service in Malta. Egypt, India, was compelled to seek the almshouse. house in Rome to-day died a survivor of Australia, and South America. He came the ‘Charge of the Light Brigade’ at to the United States with the intention of The veteran had all his discharge papers, Balaklava on October 25, 1854. He was entering the Union Army. When he was but he never received any assistance from Daniel Dowling, born in Carlow, on his way here the surrender of Lee was the British Government. Among the few Ireland. in 1832. He enlisted in the made. possessions he retained to the last were British Army, going at once into the the spurs he wore in the famous Charge Crimean Peninsula, where he was in Dowling's only sister had gone with her and a copy of Tennyson’s poem. many battles. He was one of the very few husband to South America. He began a who came out of the charge of the six search for her and for years traveled in Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 1

William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s Forgotten Celluloid King

Murder most mysterious - Hollywood February, 1922

Martin J. Lynch

William Desmond Taylor in 1921.

In Feb., 2012, on the 90th Anniversary of voice, his Beatle’s cap and his Courtesy of Bison Archives his death Carlow finally honoured its adventures! most glamorous son, who also was the the locals. The trimmed hedges and neat central figure of one of Tinsel Town’s Strawhall –The Gentry & Boyhood white-painted cottages nestling beside most enduring and infamous mysteries, the broad Barrow, Ireland’s second-great- fit to rank with all the Marilyn Monroe One views Strawhall now with its est river. The town’s only previous death conspiracies. vanished Sugar Factory, Gateway Enter- excitement had been the ambush/mas- prise Centre and across the Cannery Rd., sacre of the 600 insurgents on its small Carlow’s greatest cinematic celebrity Strawhall Industrial Estate’s half-aban- main street 100 years before in 1798. (only equalled in recent years by our own doned commercial units. Book-ended by beloved Seoirse Ronan) William the compassion and love of Holy Angels Family Roots in Strawhall/Carlow Cunningham Deane-Tanner known to at the top with Delta Centre at the Rifles/Early Fire Service history and filmdom as William bottom, it is difficult now to envisage the Desmond Taylor would henceforth be Tanner-O’Brien holdings ensconced Taylor’s father, Major Thomas Kearns remembered with an annual Taylor Fest. there at the end of the 19th Century. Deane-Tanner held his rank from the Poignant to reflect that of his astonishing Typical of the estates of the minor Anglo- militia body known as the King’s Royal corpus of 87 or so films only 6 Irish gentry it (and its non-absentee Rifle Corps or the Carlow Rifles as the perhaps survive. family) was justly respected in the town. locals called it. Two years before William Cunningham Deane-Tanner was William’s birth, the Major had returned He pioneered many film techniques we born there on April26th, 1872, second from active service in the ‘Opium Wars’ revere today, and these are surely his child and eldest son of the dashing Major and Britain’s cynical suppression of the second enduring legacy. Thomas Kearns Deane –Tanner and the T’ai Ping Rebellion when Peking fell to land-heiress, Jane O’Brien. The family the imperial forces. Plaudits are due to filmdom’s and name is now immortalized in a modern Carlow’s native-son Marc-Ivan O’Gor- housing estate, round the corner on the The Major’s maternal grandfather was man and the organizing committee for Athy Rd., called Tanner Hall, complete Sir Thomas Deane, the most influential their Trojan efforts. Likewise, Carlow with green board! architect of his time (pointer perhaps to Little Theatre’s accurate dramatization William’s future artistry?). The Major /synopsis of the complexities of a life William grew to young manhood in the quickly became founding head of such as Taylor’s was awesome! It was, then sleepy little hamlet and garrison- Carlow’s fledgling fire-service. Set-up in sadly to be the swan-song of that other town of Carlow which boasted a mere 1878, when members of the town council Carlow showman/writer/ actor/ director 880 souls. Then and now it was and locals banded together. Thirty volun- and fitting interpreter of this epic, dominated by the already-ruined 13th teers were enrolled with buckets and Sheamus O’Rourke. God rest his merry Century Castle of the Marshal. The helmets coughed up from council funds. twinkling cultivated and friendly soul. ‘insanity ‘(pun intended) of its 1814 Major Tanner and his merry men fought How we miss Sheamus, his beautiful destruction still causing sniggers among local outbreaks from a Merriweather- Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 2

86 William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

Paxton appliance requiring no –less than Women were plentiful including the Soon he unwisely married a great 22 men plus 2 horses! A long long way prospective gentile Irish and British debs pretender, like himself, called Ethel from our renowned World Champion slipped in for just that purpose to the (Effie) Hamilton in an ill-matched and Service of today! nearby Harper Township. He showed disastrous union. Her gloom and selfish- only a polite interest in all such, his ness matched by his indifference to The dashing Major had wasted no time repressed bi-sexuality probably first womanly perspective and female sexual in ‘nailing down the money’ by marrying surfacing in the all-male environment of demands. Nonetheless, they would the land-heiress, Jane O’Brien in 1870. the ranch. Later, he would in passing remain both at their bluebook address Their first-born was the beautiful Ellen refer to a ‘lost love’, either imagined/real and married at West 93rd St. for all of 7 who onto become ‘the most dominant, (or self-serving in Hollywood’s hedonis- years. This encompassed the birth of his powerful, trusted, best-married family tic birthing). Was this a man or a woman? daughter, Ethel Daisy on Nov.15th, 1902. member’. This attribute no little aided by her inheriting the many bequests of this The ranch closed in 1892 and Taylor His wife’s constant weeping and multi-branched family. William came began the life of an itinerant labourer and demanding female intimacy sent him next, being born in 1872, followed by railway yardman, even selling magazines during these strange years to seek the Lizzie(1874) or ‘Daisy’; then Denis door-to-door. Passing thru Missouri and company of the afore-mentioned young (1876); and finally Oswald(1878) who Fort Leavenworth he got a job as a bucks of Manhattan where at he main- died of whooping cough before his 15cents-a-plate waiter in St. Paul, tained a batchelor apartment. The great first birthday. Minnesota. He impressed many in this American financial crash of 1907 and heyday of immigrant-era America with suspicions about the provenance of some Their mother had inherited from her his fluent French, German and his of his antiques (his partner was the true father, Denis, the then enormous sum of doggerel verse. culprit) saw the rapid decline of £17,000 (£2 million today) supposed to his fortune. be held in trust for her children. Incred- Antique Dealer to the Wealthy ibly, this vast sum was to be nibbled Owing money to all his wealthy friends away by a lavish life-style including a Heading for the 1893 Chicago William abandoned backers, apartments, town-house in Dublin, then the ‘second Columbian Exposition he was taken on the great city and even his wife and child. city of Empire’. William never got a by the once-famous Fannie Davenport’s He deliberately drove them to Ethel’s penny of this birth right or any Tanner Theatrical Company by 1895. Here he favourite upstate New York retreat and inheritances to his eternal rightful anger. finally found solace from his American fled. The last she would hear of him was loneliness and poverty. The struggling a courier-delivered $500 draft. Eventu- However, he grew to manhood, highly- company and its ailing fading actress ally, belatedly she reported him to the strung, silent and removed but neither offered him relief on-stage but a hugely police, years later, as ‘losing reclusive nor a weakling. At 17 he was demanding schedule of constant touring. his memory’! handsome, striking, with dark brown hair When the dying Davenport in 1898 and eyes, on top of a lean, well-propor- collapsed onstage at the Chicago Grand In 1914, remarried by now to a wealthy tioned horseman’s body. An air of intrigu- Opera House he was already gone, tour- restaurateur, she took Daisy to the ing romantic mystery surrounded him. ing with other troupes. When he made it movies only to jump up in the middle of to Broadway’s Great White Way by 1900 his most famous acting-film ‘Capt. Cowboy Days he would be buoyed up by (his sole such Alverez’, screaming ‘ That’s your remembrance by family) his beloved father’! No further contact is recorded A year later he was packed off to Kansas, sister Lizzie’s bequest (d.1898) of £1092 between them. Daisy was spoiled by her by his family for nefarious reasons to a (£30,000 today). adoptive father and would die wealthy young gentlemen’s ‘finishing school’ but no thanks to the putative erstwhile dude ranch. This was run by a young He took over an elegant apartment on 5th Carlow man. Irishman Francis (Ned) J. Turnby and his Avenue among the rich and famous, partner. He arrived there, adept at many of whom he easily befriended. Shaving off his moustache for good languages, cultivated, an extremely fine With a slight knowledge of antiques and William joined a travelling Canadian horseman with many outdoor skills. All as an available English (?) batchelor with acting troupe to further cover his tracks. of which would stand him in good stead a purely imaginary Indian Army back- Henceforth he adopted the name he is as his varied life unfolded! Runnymede ground, he became a favourite of Long known to history by William Desmond Ranch became William’s final founda- Island hostesses. He even laid on mus- Taylor. His Carlow sense of irony tional-experience on his arrival in 1889 icals for the Astor’s and the Vanderbilt’s!! evidenced in the name Taylor which was as the Frontier was settled. He learned the surname of his cheating partner. carpentry, building, shooting from horse- Backed by wealthy male friends Taylor back (Carlow had already taught him opened an antique and interior-designer’s North to the Yukon static marksmanship). It became his store on 5th Ave. Thus opened up to him first attempt at acting in the ranch’s the demi-world of Manhattan’s wealthy He thereafter allowed himself to be ‘fit-ups’. homosexuals. He could also cast many- recruited by the goldmining offshoot of an-eye on the Precinct’s pretty girls. the fabulously wealthy Guggenheims to Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 3

William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

work their holdings for the Yukon Gold- subsequent movies for which filmdom Conscription/ Taylor Meets His mining Co. Onboard the Dolphin he owes him a debt. Nemesis/ Bisexuality & Obsession sailed for Scagway on May12th, 1909. He was appointed Timekeeper /Stores He was also his own stuntman before the Despite his age, identity cover-up, Controller thus assuring himself the term or the job was even thought of. neuroses, and genuine health problems as enmity of his fellow equally exploited These stunts involved in executing the the Great War hoovered up all available fellow-workers, under the stingy most dangerous sequences any movie manhood Taylor now felt the long arm of uncaring Guggenheims, working the men had seen up to that time, such as gallop- British desperation when he was com- to death on tiny rations in the ing down a precipitous slope at break- pelled to submit to conscription in early harsh conditions. neck speed and ‘hitting the mark’ in one 1918. Rising meteorically from private to shoot! God bless Carlow and the Yukon! major inside a year he nonetheless spent Riding from mine head to mine head his This film’s success finally persuaded the his service in pointless tomfoolery far supreme horsemanship, learned in Balboa (!) Studio heads to appoint him a from the Front. He was released from this Carlow and refined in Kansas to the long- full director and script consultant. This Purgatory in May, 1919. stirrup American style enabled him to was in spite of having NO such film or remain safe and in the saddle across the even stage experience. incredible terrain, over the Dismal Swamp with his time books in his saddle- Taylor’s ‘British’ appearance and accent bags. He thus gained the solitude he plus the tall tales surrounding him of a loved and the self-reliance for which lost Irish romance(stable boy and the he longed. lady stuff) imprisonment in Dublin (never of course happened). Gold-dig- The creative side of his gifted persona ging in the Yukon plus equally founda- showed when he even gained the friend- tionless vaquero adventures in South ship of the poet of the Yukon, Robert W. America guaranteed him acceptance, Service (‘Dangerous Dan McGrew’ etc. respect and even awe in the newly –born etc.). However, Taylor left Alaska before industry and its baby celeb magazines. winter closed it and him in. Meantime, He, of course, did nothing to dispel any his mother died in 1911 leaving him of the rumours strict truth about his past £5000 which he was never to know about never having troubled William before in despite his then desperate poverty. any case! Both the ladies and the gay set simply adored him encouraged by his An Actor’s Life for Me impeccable manners and bearing with time for nearly everyone. Arriving in San Francisco Taylor heard of the fledgling movie industry being He now embarked on a love-affair with born in New York and more significantly the female star Neva Gerber at the same in Los Angeles’ suburb, Hollywood. It time conducting a passionate sexual Taylor in army uniform was crying out for a new kind of actor, so relationship with the set designer, George gentleman -of-fortune as ever, he caught Hopkins. Both would love him to the end the Southern Pacific train stepping off at of his life. Taylor was able to cover up Long Mile Pier, Malibu in early 1912. much of his homoerotic involvement to Just before this severe prolonged disrup- his lover Gerber with lies and imagined tion to his film career, he attended the Round this time James Joyce was launch- stress-related illnesses. He claimed to be Club of Forty Halloween Dance with ing Ireland’s first purpose-built cinema in getting bad news from Ireland and New Hollywood’s elite. He was then halfway Dublin’s Mary Street! York while ‘over-working’. It helped that thru shooting his masterpiece ‘Tom like the Carlow man Gerber’s early life Sawyer’ in the book’s original settings of Going to work immediately for the bril- and birth were shrouded in mystery Hannibal and St. Petersburg, Missouri. liant irascible Thomas Harper Ince for and lies. the modest sum of $40 weekly. William Taylor would for the very first time at made his maiden appearance The Coun- Taylor added to his macho image when this dance meet the 15yr. old rising and terfeiters wherein he was both actor and he shot and directed Davy Crockett in the unstable star, Mary Miles Minter, sweet director. He then went on to complete 11 blizzard-prone San Bernardino Moun- and dimpled , she was being chapharoned films in 17 months for Ince. tains in 1916. After 4 years success as a by her equally volatile poisoned mother. director he was honoured by being Escorting this twosome was the corrupt He was headhunted by Vitagraph Studios elected President of the Motion Pictures and unscrupleless L.A. District Attorney, in 1914. He then created his most endur- L.A. Lodge, the fore runner of the future Thomas Lee Woolwine. Thus the 4 ing success, Captain Alverez. In this Oscar’s Academy of Film. He was now characters and the first act of the tragedy ground breaker he began the string of truly accepted by his fellow artists. 4 years hence, collided like the starry cinematic innovations for many of his portents foretelling that other murder of Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 4

William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

the Ides of March 44 B.C. reputation as a temperamental nightmare, He developed a revolutionary pioneering a romantic fantasist especially toward method of under-screen sub-titles rather His Last Home. older and sometimes gay men. She was than the tedious narrative-interrupting also aided and abetted by her viperous card-titles then the standard practice as William came back from his ‘War’ to a formidable interfering mother, Charlotte talkies already loomed. He also started to bisexual double welcome, from a cool Shelby. Both of their names and back- shock and titillate Hollywood and his George Hopkins and an overwrought grounds were murky. audiences with lurid sexually explicit weeping Neva Gerber. Emotional women filmic devices, such as naked men and tears always irritated and rendered Beginning with Taylor’s Anne of Green (especially) and women, writhing about Taylor insensitive. He used this disagree- Gables Minter entered his professional on set in such best-sellers as The Furnace able welcome as excuse to break off life. She was 30yrs. his junior. Born in in staid still puritanical WASP America! the engagement. Texas in 1902 on Apr.26th, as a child she Crowds rushed his sets to feast their eyes was so beautiful and naturally talented on Hollywood’s most beautiful bodies. However, before this rupture Gerber did she could have been a forerunner to He even went so far as to force his studio him the at-the-time enormous but Shirley Temple, 15yrs later. In fact, by publicists to concoct stories of his heroin fate-ridden service of finding for him a then, her film career had been dead for a addiction to improve his public persona fashionable stylish address, ready decade. She lived in a dual world of self- and box-office. Some tales were even furnished at upmarket 400B Sth. obsessed flighty sexual fantasy and steely true adding to his machismo. Alvarado St. Newly built the monthly mother-domination. rent would be a very steep $132. Here he But finally in March 1921 William would spend 4 happy and productive Taylor ignored all the advice and the Taylor tiring of Minter’s hysterics and years, surrounded by filmdom’s best, oil warnings of his friends, male and female, shameless sexual overtures, wrote to her and merchant princes. He would make even that of his lover and artistic collab- explicitly ordering her to never write, even more new friends. But here he orator, George Hopkins. Much of what phone or contact him in any form again. would also meet his obsessed killer and we know of this time has been recorded But was it all too little too late? come to his lonely and undeserved end. by Hopkins and proven by the testimony of others as to its veracity. Despite this after a short while she Enter Fatal ‘Romance’ blatantly phoned only to be wisely told Minter would, over the next 3 years, send Taylor was ill. However, at a perform- At this time already enduring screen-leg- almost childish letter after letter, many ance of the opera Othello Minter and her end Mary Pickford left Taylor’s studio, overt or explicitly sexual. Some still mother would spot the daring pair of Famous Players for a rival, First National secret have never seen the light of Taylor and his ‘friend ‘Hopkins. This Films. In her place the fatal (for Taylor) scrutiny. Her mother, aware of her daugh- finally woke her stupefied mind to decision was taken to build up the ter’s nymphomaniac obsession with older Taylor’s alternative lifestyle. From that image/career of the ingénue Mary Miles men would frequently wield a .38 Smith moment on the world-renowned former Minter. To begin this process studio and Wesson revolver at suitors she Carlovian would be doomed. heads paired her with Taylor their leading suspected. Mother and daughter would director and noted for his handling of hysterically conduct continuous scream- The stress of this odd incident at the actresses. Taylor would be warned by all ing matches with each other. Often these opera and a huge workload caused a his knowledgeable friends to refuse and would be over Taylor whom Shelby breakdown in his health. Undergoing steer clear of her. She already had a particularly loathed. surgery for a duodenal ulcer he then underwent a second and a third operation Some were even in front of Taylor him- in those pre-keyhole surgery days. All self but he seemed to treat all of this with this hospitalized him for a month. A long a dangerous off-handedness? All convalescence followed in Paris, oblivious of her mounting possessiveness London, and New York keeping him he meantime courted many lovers, male from work into the summer. and female. At home his two man-servants stole and The Director’s Chair. embezzled $7000, at least, from him. For good measure they also wreaked his top- Taylor’s output and quality of film of-the-range automobile. Both were fired throughout this period of 1920/21 and and disappeared but both would later be right up to his death was prodigious…… suspect’s further diverting attention from he was reaching the apogee of his art. His the investigations. studio, Famous Players even allowed him the then unheard-of accolade in June, Romance, Friendship and Insanity. Taylor with Mary Miles Minter 1921 of forming his own film unit and editing his own films!! When Mary Miles Minter returned to Courtesy of Bison Archives L.A. from filming late in 1921 she found Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 5

William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

the now recovered William Taylor had was away he besieged her with with a man and vagrancy in begun a new and rewarding romance telegrams. He wined and dined her, often Westlake Park. with the truly great (as an actress and a at Mack Sennett’s parties. He swopped genuine human being) Mabel Normand. books and constant presents with her. She The director, just shy of 50 was, at this She was everything Minter was not. enjoyed his erudition, he her vitality. Just stage of his exotic life, handsome in a Normand was amusing, sweet, unposses- before Christmas, 1921 while shopping patrician fashion, with attractive grey sive, fun-to-be-with, an adorable friend for gifts for her, he was disagreeably hair cut close to his high intellectual and lover with an even temperament. She spotted across an aisle by the odious brow. His blue-grey secretive eyes stared seemed to be able to ignore his gay Mary Miles Minter. Minter then turned intently over his Roman nose. His thin- friends, his odd ways and even the up at his door late on Christmas Eve. lipped mouth giving forth an air of fine irritating proclivities of his ever They exchanged what Taylor vainly breeding and silent solitude. Very much present houseman. hoped were farewell notes. Minter would in keeping with his actual background of relate this to an Asst. District Attorney Irish minor nobility, duty and service and after his murder. not the fictional one which he encouraged his multitude of admirers to pro- Mabel and Taylor later in that Christmas mulgate. Years of horseback riding and season would argue despite their earlier manual labour helped still maintain a exchange of expensive gifts. However, lean hard physique. he was immediately contrite and sent her a $1250 jewelled tassel! Throughout the He bathed and took from a drawer his whole of January he showered her with choice of monogrammed crisp shirts roses trimmed with heather daily. wherein also nestled a lady’s pink night- gown (?). He had just finished The Green Temptation. Yesterday he had driven into the San Gabriel Range seeking locations for his forthcoming adaption of Somerset Maugham’s society story The Ordeal. Already for this project his homosexual lover and artistic collaborator of 6 yrs.., George Hopkins had designed a brilliant ballroom set. Taylor and Hopkins had brilliantly cooperated on many such films before. They had thus given birth to a Mabel Normand, 1921 (inscribed whole new execution of the previously “Cordially Mabel Normand) ramshackle business of film set-design.

Courtesy the Bison Archives His young chauffeur, Howard Fellows then drove him from his Alvarado Court She had experienced the great romance Apartment in his luxury $18,500 McFar- of her life with the immortal Mack lane to his tax-advisor, Juliet Berger. He Sennett before WW 1, which would 60 was then driven on a gift –buying spree yrs. hence be immortalized in the hit for his lover, star and part-protégée, Mabel musical Mack and Mabel. Henry Peavey, Taylor’s houseman. Normand. Taylor then swam and lunched at the L.A. Athletic Club. He then went But in that unique special way of her’s, Courtesy of Bison Archives. on to Famous Players Studio to discuss which she exhibited throughout her short with the rising mogul, Jesse E. Laskey, the life, she retained Mack’s friendship, till pending film and Taylor’s plans for other her tubercular death in 1929. Like Taylor future projects. and so many others in that early film The last Day. world she had invented her past for the Arriving home at 5.00pm Taylor phoned press. She was giddy, full of Irish The morning of Mon., 21st Feb., 1922 Mabel Normand inviting her to visit later mischief (a trait she transferred to the broke frostily and clear as the famed to receive her presents and render him screen), a tomboy. Like him she was Hollywood director, known to movie loving conversational company. Then he athletic and loved books. Millions of history as William Desmond Taylor was sat down to his bland ‘British’ supper working-class girls identified with her. awoken by his manservant, Henry before being involved in an annoying Peavey with a spoonful of milk of mysterious phone call (?). This distrac- In his bi-sexual way Taylor was, finally, magnesia, suffering as he did with severe tion for the chronically absent-minded truly in love with Mabel Normand. He digestive problems. This same Peavey director resulted in Mabel Normand would stare, in this his middle-age, at her had a chequered past being due to appear having to stand in the 32 degrees cold framed photo night after night. When she for trial 2 days hence for lewd conduct night for several minutes. She refused his Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 6

90 William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

offer of supper, being due on-set at Sen- cheap lodgings, as this dawn broke. Deputy Sherriff Francis J. Wallis and nett Studios very early next morning. But Before boarding the trolley-bus to head Sargent of Detectives, Thomas A. Zeigler she entertained him on his piano while for Alvarado Court he bought a bottle of compounded their late arrival by acting they drank 2 Orange Blossoms a milk of magnesia for his boss’s dyspep- like green rookies when they still failed favourite tipple for both of them. sia. As was stated he would not have to seal the area and secure it for the been allowed to sleep under his white Coroner. Now appears a never explained Because there was then a Black/Latino employer’s roof. or traced figure, posing as a doctor who curfew, which still exists today in certain proclaims the director had died of a select parts of L.A., the manservant, Opening the front-door he noticed the coronary or internal haemorrhage despite Peavey then left having locked the back still brightly-lit apartment had its blinds the blood on the Axminster carpet and the and side-doors. Taylor and Normand still down. But his workaholic boss was hole under his arm. Nobody stops this arranged to accompany each other to the perfectly capable of pulling an ‘doctor’ or enquires his bona fides! I Cameraman’s Ball that coming Saturday ‘all-nighter’ working on scripts so he speculate it may even have been a char- while he ushered her to her car. The thought nothing of this oddity. However, acteristic stunt of a certain hyper- couple were heard laughing by Taylor’s Peavey was surprized to find the front – imaginative Mary Miles Minter?!? neighbours the Lawrence family. As door locked as Taylor normally forgot. Mabel pulled away she blew a kiss to The Coroner continues this almost Key- William, little knowing she would never All was as the servant had left it the stonesque charade when he fails to note see him alive again. Nor would anyone previous evening, except for the prostrate the presence of the uncongealed blood, else except his murderer(s?). neatly laid-out body of the exiled Irish indicating a time-of-death of under 12 film-maker. Even his tan gabardine hours. Then in an incredible breach of Taylor then went back thru his door to jacket and slacks were uncreased! jurisprudence this same Coroner allows continue working on his tax-papers. A Taylor’s face was in repose, his hands by studio trouble-shooter, Charles Eton to man knocked but left after a few minutes his sides and his eyes were closed!? recommence an examination of the receiving no answer. Later around victim! Eyton then in a Chaplin parody 8.30p.m.Taylor’s driver left his The terrified boy ran into the street even goes on to instruct the medical man McFarlane limousine round the rear. shouting his head off. He was quickly on body-examination procedures! He Walking round he rang the bell but Taylor joined by the landlord, Myles Jessurum, was a mere studio manager with not even didn’t answer. So Fellows went home, ill from his bed. Mrs Jessurum rang a a background in security much less one remarking to himself on his bosses’ doctor. Then she incredibly rang Mabel in medicine! partial deafness and chronic addiction Normand, rather than the police. Thus to work. Famous Players were alerted and losing The bullet-hole was eventually found no time sent their trouble-shooter, under William’s armpit with burn marks Two days before these fateful happenings Charles F. Eyton for ‘damage-limitation’, around it indicating a point-blank close- Taylor told a lady friend of a most unwel- as we now refer to such cover-ups round up shot. Also, the killer wasn’t a profes- come midnight visit from the increas- celebrity’s activities. sional as a pro would realize the victim ingly unbalanced child-woman, Mary could have swung around and seized the Miles Minter. Such a visit would be char- Far too late to secure this crime-scene the gun. Rather the murderer held the victim acteristic of her erratic behaviour round police, late in the day, finally arrived. in a loving embrace given the angle and Taylor. Minter’s visits would often be They find the apartment swarming with place-of-entry of the bullet. interrupted by a pursuing hysterical tenants in night-attire nosing everywhere, vengeful Charlotte Shelby, Minter’s touching everything. By then even the Studio man Eyton now compounded his domineering dangerous and equally body was grossly disturbed with the right felonies, not that anybody was noticing, unbalanced mother. Shelby would even arm, originally straight by Taylor’s side, by removing vital evidence from the go so far as to petition Taylor’s gay lying at right angles with the clenched murder scene, thus becoming an acces- friends to find her daughter. But when fist now forced open (the Coroner’s sory after-the-fact to the killing. Under such help was offered Shelby would rightful sole duty). Thus time-of-death, the gaze of 5 police officers he further refuse it! rigor mortis, etc. would all be wrongly messed –up fingerprints, ransacked calculated. drawers and cupboards for anything Meantime, at her home Mary Minter damaging to his employers. Anything he returned from what she claimed had been The originally unrumpled body should found he piled into a wire basket still in a failed attempt to talk to Taylor. She then have indicated the killer had an plain view of the now dozen or read aloud to her mother and grand- emotional attachment to the deceased. If so officials. mother. Slowly the fatal dawn of Feb. a man falls in death, shot or not, he falls 22 approached. in an untidy heap. No death such as Forensics Fouled-up /Evidence Taylor’s, violent or not, was ever Evaded. Murder Most Mysterious? recorded where the body ends up almost lying-in-state as William’s corpse orig- When the police finally got around to Henry Peavey, William’s foppish and inally was found. So it had to have been searching the body and the crime scene effeminate man-servant was leaving his thus lovingly so arranged by his killer? themselves, they failed to wear rubber Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 7

William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

gloves for dusting Taylor’s effects for man-of-the-world to distraction. dispose of it till years later! This believed fingerprints, etc..... Mistakes and disposal happening, astoundingly, in the mishandling continued to pile upon each Various, sometimes conflicting witness middle of another unrelated criminal other. Still, bystanders were let stand accounts of Taylor’s last evening and the hunt! This weapon was never asked for around as more officials and reporters varied comings-and-goings at Alvarado or examined by the investigators. shoved in. Court were taken to no avail. Sightings of men asking for directions in the On Taylor’s jacket were found 3 long However, in a drawer was found a pink vicinity proved false. Following in this- strands of blond hair further indicating a nightie which Taylor was even rumoured now-established pattern of ineptitude the female with her head on his chest? These to wear? Also an initialled ladies hand- victim’s clothes were burnt without any were found to match Minter’s blond kerchief was found. This would be accu- analysis of forensic evidence or ballistic locks exactly. Brought in reluctantly for rately identified as belonging to Mary examination! questioning she lied consistently, oft Miles Minter. A pale lavender notepaper contradicting herself against known sheet from her, embossed with her The constant fixation with a male facts. Some facile excuse was offered by favourite butterfly motif fluttered to the fugitive was explained with the facile her for the presence of her locks on floor from the handkerchief. Written on excuse ‘a woman seldom uses a .38 (ref. Taylor’s coat. Given that William had it was: syndicated columnist Edward Doherty). rejected her and even thrown her out However, one female very definitely DID again and again, she could offer no Dearest, use one, frequently in public view, and in explanation for her presence in his prox- I love you ---I love you---I love you a bogus suicide attempt years before. imity. Neither had she any alibi to indi- That that woman was Mary Miles cate she had not premeditated the murder. xxxxxxx Minter!! X Innocents Suffer. Yours Always! Taylor’s death –wound when examined by police Chief Autopsy Surgeon Dr. A.F. Detectives did actually arrest Minter. Wagner was proven to have burn-marks Going to her mother Shelby’s house they around it in the side of his jacket. It indi- even questioned this possessive vindic- cated Taylor at the moment of his death tive old woman who plainly hated had his arms stretched out, in an embrace William Taylor. She gave every indica- (?). He had sustained the wound on his tion of an accomplice preparing to flee left-side, between his seventh and eighth and offered no help. rib, penetrating his left lung. In common with its initial upward directed entry the As previously written Shelby was a long- bullet passed up into the neck where it time close associate of the deeply corrupt deflected, before hitting the collarbone (remember L.A. Confidential?) and four and a half inches inside his flesh. ambitious L.A. District Attorney Thomas The angle indicated a much shorter per- L. Woolwine. He would use all his guile son (A woman?) than Taylor’s full and connections to avoid at every turn six foot. any attempt to implicate this terrible female twosome. Misguided hunts after The .38 Smith and Wesson death weapon any or all other suspects were demanded had been tilted up at the moment of the by him. fatal shot with William’s arms embracing his killer in affection or in struggle. The Subsequently, the investigative author facial composure indicated it was not in Charles Higham (who devoted a lot of a death defence. his life and his veteran Hollywood contacts to find the truth) was told by Ballistics established firmly it had been Mary Minter that her mother Charlotte a 10yr. old blue- steel break top 1911 Shelby had told Minter of Taylor’s death model Smith and Wesson .38. This type at 11.00 A.M. However, Shelby had that of revolver was most uncommon by morning already made a fatal incriminat- 1922. No official forensic time of death ing mistake. As early as 7.00 A.M. could be established but it circumstan- Shelby had phoned a friend advisor, tially could be assumed to be the early Mary Berger to say the studio had rung Surely this was proof enough of her hours of the morning (ref. Variety, issue to tell her of William’s murder. proximity to the put-upon Taylor at the April 10th, 1922). time –of-death?? Both items typical of But Peavey did not even open the apart- her self-centred schoolgirl loony fantasy Minter and her harridan mother were ment till 7.30 A.M. a time underwritten with him. Also,it was sure evidence of well-known to own such an unusual by his regular trolley bus ride. Actual why she would drive the fuss hating weapon but amazingly did not knowingly murder was not suspected for a further 20 Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 8

William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

minutes! Shelby thus had to know who Taylor percolated her narrative. She had The Funeral. killed William Taylor from the very the neck to claim William ‘had not an beginning! Thus the noose should have enemy in the world’, a fact she knew to St. Pauls, Pershing Square, a shabby tightened round both these unsavoury be patently false (at least Shelby and his cathedral marked for demolition, the site women way back in 1922. But………… murderer bore a grudge). All this ‘guff’ of the future Biltmore Hotel, sent ……! was to slip in her bogus alibi. The whole William Desmond Taylor to his eternal charade an opportunistic cheap shot at reward. A motley crowd of 10,000 sensa- If further convincing were needed, self-publicity. tion-seekers, idlers, and tourists were mother and daughter now initiated more barely kept in order by mounted and foot heartbreak and tragedy. Shelby disposed Mabel Normand, by contrast, always in police. To the undoubted disappointment of her innocent naïve cook, Belle Simp- her short remaining life, gave then and of this crew, none of Hollywood’s best son who had seen too much. Shelby had later, accurate, true and never changing and brightest bothered to attend. Only Belle arrested on a trumped-up charge accounts of her movements on that fate- Taylor’s tried and true friends braved the and sent quickly to a lunatic asylum in a ful evening and how she heard the notoriety in mourning. Hopkins, totally illegal manner (shades of D.A. morbid news on-set. Normand, Cecil B. DeMille (who would Woolwine). Poor Belle would spend the immortalize Taylor’s orgiastic cast style), rest of her life in solitary confinement, There is not sufficient space here to and Constance Talmadge were probably while her family for 7 decades vainly recount all the dubious and various the only notables. sought her release. The family were con- suspects who were used to cover the trail stantly told by the police to ‘not of clear evidence under the nose of the A rival mediocre despised (by Taylor) pursue it’. police. We make one set of observations director, Frank Lloyd devised a vulgar before summing up. tasteless self-promoting spectacle as if Another witness to much of the activity William was royalty or a distinguished in the Shelby-Minter house on that fate- Corruption Capitol---Why the Murder soldier, complete with Union flag on the ful night paid an equally high price. Man- Remains ‘Unsolved’. coffin, something the dead man would ley Earls Tiffany, healthy, young, and have hated. However, in the front pew well-connected, seized by a mystery Los Angeles in the ‘20s was a corrupt and were his true friends and lovers, of both illness, died 3 weeks later under an dangerous city, comprising as it still does sexes, behind wreaths sent by Mabel unnamed operation? 80 towns strung together in a metropolis Normand, Mary Pickford, Douglas Fair- of steaming heat and hedonism. This banks, Gloria Swanson, Rudolf Stories and Lies. unenviable image went back to its 1849 Valentino, etc... Gold Rush days. Opium was freely Minter’s version of the story, in 1922, available, brothels were rife, lynch mobs But even this awful service could not again 4 years later, subsequently in 1937 In this city of then barely three quarters drown out the screaming, pushing mob to her sister, Margaret and finally to of a million people 91,123 arrests were outside. A consolation for his friends was Author Charles Higham decades later, made in one bare year! Pickpockets Mary Miles Minter was a no-show. At would contain contradictions and facts at roamed freely. Policemen were killed the time she was spinning another of her variance with each other. Al Capone was with impunity. Police, for their part, tasteless fables to an Asst. District Attor- wise when he advised ‘A liar has to have failed to answer alarm calls. Thus ney. This worthy was helpfully steering a long good memory’! vigilantes usurped normal law and order. her away from any possible self-incrimi- One police chief resigned after only 3 nation in yet another example of the utter Shelby was not the only one on that weeks, only to be replaced by the corrupt complicity of the authorities in the Irish- awful morning to make basic mistakes, officer he himself had taken office from! man’s murder Minter made at least 2 further mistakes on arrival at Alvarado Court. She asked The D.A. Woolwine, we mentioned in Two Women and the Legend. for Taylor’s pinkie finger cabochon our narrative facing then into an election sapphire and diamond ring. She also he would lose, was already suffering One more myth of the William Desmond enquired if he had left a Will? Thirty nine from the cancer that, 3yrs. hence would Taylor tragedy needs to be cleared up. years later she would continue to regret kill him. Crooked as they come he would The killing was supposed to destroy the both serious lapses (ref. C. Higham). She spin web after web of lies and deceit to careers of both Mabel Normand and then went, she claimed, to where the his public. Ironically, it was he who had Mary Miles Minter. Both were rumoured body lay, again inventing fantasies originally introduced Taylor to Mary to have been dropped from all future resembling purple silent melodrama Miles Minter! Minter could not have had films. For a while the opposite was the round this sub-incident. a more ruthless and powerful ally. case for Minter began filming a lurid sex- drama South of Suva showing no grief Minter unbelievably called an actual The murder bungalow at 400B Alvarado nor missing a days filming. She then press conference on the evening of the Court was demolished in 1966 to make went on a holiday cruise to Hawaii mak- murder! Feigning an obvious bogus cold way for a supermarket of all things ing the maximum of all this ill-gained she remained calm throughout curled up attention and press interest. She would on a coach. Lies about her relations with have many love affairs even one with Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 9

William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

Charlie Chaplin. But by 1925 her film one-time great love Mack Sennett stood doned in New York, died in Florida in career was permanently washed up. by her and she was totally cleared. Her 1974. Her mother had passed away in Maybe even the uncaring film world increasing bad health required and 1928. Neither woman received a penny realized the truth but never announced it? received Sennett’s support but she died at from the director’s ravaged but originally She ballooned to an enormous size. She the Pottenger Sanatorium in Monrovia in substantial estate. But thanks to her would, in common with her crone mother 1929 at only 32yrs old. mother’s happy rich second marriage this live a very long contentious life buoyed ill-treated girl died wealthy. She would up by bequests, court settlements and The contention, repeated by the character finally receive recognition only on her fortuitous property deals. Both were Denis (Taylor’s brother) in the script of father’s tombstone. never far from controversy and some- Carlow Little Theatre’s ‘Life’, that Mabel times jail. Despite her many love affairs, was Hollywood’s ‘Queen of Druggies’ is So by the end of the Twenties all of the in keeping with her lifelong fantasies totally unfounded and I could not trace it main characters but one, excepting the especially in regard to Taylor, she died in any legitimate source. She was gifted, harpies’ twosome, were dead. The other claiming, somewhat outlandishly, to be funny, pretty, vibrant, and a beloved survivor was the gifted set-designer and still a virgin!! On her deathbed in 1984 incredible honest soul, a hero of working Taylor’s gay lover of 6 yrs., George Hop- she was rumoured to have made a con- girls. She was the Silent Screen’s Premier kins. His unpublished memoir would fession. But the nurse, Amanda Ryland’s Comedienne. point the finger of accusation in a long- disappeared for good immediately. overdue but accurate direction. Minter left $ 4million plus real estate. Her most enduring 2 memorials are due to two immortal film and stage produc- This gifted gentle man would go on to Unfortunately, the notorious Smith and tions. Firstly Billy Wilder’s central char- fame and renown at Warner Bros. Win- Wesson’s deadly story was far from acter in Sunset Boulevard is named ning many Oscars and other awards his finished. Minter incredibly kept it in her NORMA DESMOND, a conscious most well-known and loved creations possession until her mother stole it, meshing of Mabel’s surname and would be Rick’s Club in Casablanca and evidently fearing this paranoid selfish Taylor’s middle name. The character the magnificent chocolate box backdrops girl-woman might actually use it as relaunched the career of Mabel’s real life of My Fair Lady. One can be sure the lethally again! friend, Gloria Swanson and who would lovely George would not have realized create great roles until her death. the ironic connection of Shaw to his lost Shelby asked a friend, Chauncey Eaton friend’s birthplace. This latter was also to hide it. However, it would surface Later the great Andrew Lloyd Webber my own beloved Father’s last film! again in a 1937 family fall-out murder would relaunch the drama as an immortal Hopkins died in 1988. case. Police belatedly matched the ballis- musical. The storyline with its also tics to the Taylor bullet. Despite this unsolved body-in-the-pool, aka Taylor, Epilogue/ Appreciation. damning forensic proof unbelievably echoes the anarchic Wild West atmos- Minter was still not charged though phere of Taylor’s ‘20s L.A. Here lived What would have been Taylor’s potential murder has no Statute of Limitations. In still such legends as even Wyatt Earp, had he lived? Dying short of 50 he might some peculiar way it found its way back who only died at his typewriter in 1927! have gone on to, at least 20+ yrs. more of to the L.A. Police. Another corrupt-to- creativity. His already large corpus of 84 the-end D.A., Barren Fits who had The great love affair of Mabel’s life films or so showed great promise. Sadly, illegally closed the Taylor file in 1938, would be remembered in the hit musical only 6 perhaps survive so much can only used it to shoot himself in 1973. 51yrs Mack and Mabel. When this opened on be speculation but the positive contem- had passed since it had killed the great Broadway to rave revues in 1970 it porary critiques they elicited give us Carlow director. Generations of D.As had starred the great Robert Preston of Music good grounds for high expectations. kept it, quite improperly, rather than have Man fame and Bernadette Powers. It has it correctly stored in the secure police been seen there and in the West End Given his cultivation, learning, inven- property dept... many times since always to a fantastic tiveness and lovely speaking voice what reception. possibilities might Talkies (only 5yrs. But this close shave would never stop hence) have offered him? Remember, these two duplicitous women. In but one Other Players. with Alvarez Kelly he had been a pioneer example, Shelby was involved in another of the full length feature film. Directing court battles over money. She was William’s brother Denis in a stark and acting in so many films his progress accused of fraud. Her fellow swindler symbolism of that lost gentile family of was always on a rising trajectory. Leslie Henry went to jail. She as usual our town would disappeared in the Amer- walked away scot-free. Their lies went on icas in the year of the ‘Talkies’ 1927, He had been President of the Motion and on. having failed to make a breakthrough in Picture Directors Association (forerunner Hollywood, never to be seen again. of the Academy) for an impressive 3yrs. Mabel Normand his true and abiding Each of all his later films would demon- friend saw her career flourish. However, Ethel Daisy Deane-Tanner (she retained strate new innovations. true to her (half) Irish luck she would be her father’s Carlow name) Robins, involved in another murder case. Her Taylor’s only child whom he had aban- Born to gentility and relative rural Carloviana 2016 Taylor William_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:19 Page 10

William Desmond Taylor Carlow’s forgotten Celluloid King

obscurity he had, in a life of adventure, William C. Deane-Tanner Murder in Hollywood hardship, and ultimately glamour come Beloved Father of Ethel Deane-Tanner Solving a Silent Screen Mystery to stride the stage of the world with the Died February 22an, 1922. Charles Higham U. of Wisconsin Press great, the good and the very ungood. At Terrace Bks.2004 the apogee of his career he would die an References: Caught in the Act George James Hopkins innocent, violent, undeserved, and point- Author’s Note: Charles Higham’s contri- Unpublished less death. His murderers would go to bution to the vast and continuous 90 yrs. William Desmond Taylor’s Murder Earl their time –distant graves unpunished. on, body of literary investigation of this Stanley Gardner Duell, Sloane & Pearce He surely was a victim of his gentle infamous crime is definitive I feel. His L.A. & New York manners and sexually harmless masterful bio of Taylor’s oft mysterious William Desmond Taylor—A Dossier ambivalence. life stands head and shoulders above all Bruce Long The Scarecrow Press Inc. other attempts. It was my primary and Metuchen, N.J. & London But perhaps like Valentino or James principle source. Higham’s father knew Dean, Desmond Taylor’s greatest endur- Taylor and many of the protagonists. He Acknowledgements. ing legacy to the world was to die thus at also had access to written posthumous A very special thank you to Carlow man the height of his potential, fame, testimonies. He interviewed all of the Marc Ivan O’Gorman now of Holly- and influence!? surviving players just in time! wood, Los Angeles and New York who took time out from script-writing and Poignantly, his tomb would echo both Thus Highiam could draw on evidence many other T.V. and film projects to this lost legacy and the far-off repudiated and personal perceptions of all these, as encourage, guide and direct me to copy- (understandably by him) land of his birth. most others could not. With circumspec- right-sources regarding my elusive His Hollywood Cemetery’s (final home tion, forensic deduction, and painstaking subject. Marc is also the founding–father of many film and other luminaries) detective work he goes on to examine the of Taylor Fest so both William Desmond cathedral-like chapel now shelters the later actions of our participant players to Taylor and I have much to thank him for. bones of William Desmond Taylor. Iron- infer a bearing on their guilt or Thanks also, finally to Bison Studio who ically, his famed renowned nomencla- innocence. Having studied, over 3yrs. allowed the use of certain photos in ture, W, D. Taylor was not referred to on much that has been extensively written this study. his tombstone. It reads: on this abiding mystery I believe Higham’s conclusions are beyond doubt.

Polo in Carlow The Carlow Polo Club announced a tour- Mr. Deathe, Captain Loftus Bryan the N:ure, hut before the finish. Mr. Gro- nament, but as the dates clashed with (back). gan's mounts fell no less than three times. other fixtures, and as there were only Mr. Grogan continued to play after the three entries, it was decided to play a Mr. Stewart Duckett acted as umpire. two first falls, but. was obliged to retire Carlow Team v a Wexford team yester- after the third. though happily not much day, the winners to play Mr. J. J. Roark's TheWexford team were allowed a hand- hurt, when playing off the deciding goal, team to-day. Owing to the long-contin- icap of three goals, and the play through- both sides being six goals (in; eluding ued drought the ground was very bard, out was fast, and closely contested. Wexford's handicap). At this stage of the and partly, it not entirely, owing to this Daring the first two chukkars neither side game Wexford retired, leaving Carlow state of things. the play yesterday scored. Just after the commencement of to play Mr. Roark's team. Mr. Roark's resulted in a chapter of accidents, happily the third chukkar Carlow scored first team will be:— with no more serious result than a broken goal, and a few minutes later Captain Mr. Roark. Mr. Lakin, 11th Ilussars; collar-bone. Shortly after three o'clock Bryan's pony fell, throwing its rider Captain Rome, 11th Hussars; and Mr. D. the teams lined out as follow, before a heavily, and breaking his left collar-hone. J. Ross. goodly number of spectators:— After a short delay, during which he was attended by Drs. Mc Donald and The Irish Times (1874-1920; September Carlow - Mr. S. Slocock, Mr. B. Slocock, Rawson, who were spectators, Capt. 12, 1906; Mr. W. E. Grogan, Mr. W. Slocock Bryan's place was taken by Mr. D. Ross, (hack). and at, the end of the fourth chukkar the ProQuest Historical Newspapers; The play was WI goals each. Give and take Irish Times (1859-2012) and The Weekly Wexford - Mr. Jackson, Mr. Chambers, play followed, Carlow slowly adding to Iris! pg. 7

Carloviana 2016 Lardner_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:26 Page 1

Carlow connections from a new book “The Villain of Steam Life of Dionysius Lardner” By A.L. Martin

Norman McMillan and Martin Nevin opened up university education, while his school textbooks on science provided the Lardner’s story was not about a life “well is detailed by Anna Martin giving the full basis for the first ever school science lived” as he was a bit of a villain, but his salacious detail of the Captain adminis- courses in the mid-nineteenth century. is the story of a life packed full of tering some physical punishment to the Steam, scandal and the six shilling incidents, with dispute and developments small Dionysius and then throwing his sciences: Dionysius Lardner was an of the highest importance in 19th century wig in the fire. ‘The Villain’ is a page expert in all three. The most famous society. His affair and elopement with turner for sure at this point but these savant of his day, he rubbed shoulders Mrs Heaviside was an international scan- predictions populate his intriguing story with the rich and famous, commissioning dal that put the Irishman on the front starting from Denis’s early life in Dublin Sir Walter Scott, Mary Shelley and page of national papers. Lardner was and marriage to Cecelia Flood a member Robert Southey to write for his ency- already a household name by 1838 of the famous nationalist family and their clopaedia, and he supported Rowland having established a publishing empire eventual separation. The Provost of Hill in the campaign for a cheap postal that ‘literally’ touched the life of most Trinity, Patrick Prendergast recently service. He wrote also and lectured with middle-class of Victorians who proudly commented one of the first colourful prescience in Europe and the USA on the showed their educational credentials with aspects of Lardner’s tangled love life. importance of computers a century volumes of Lardner’s Cyclopaedias or Denis in Trinity adopted the moniker before they began their enormous trans- his derivate books on their bookshelves; Dionysius a name that even today almost formative role on our modern society. the first books to be within their price marks him out as being unique, but range in middle-class households. not quite. Anna Martin puts her finger on the very Upwardly mobile working class men and crucial moment for Lardner’s mass tradesmen were able to start to get To give an example of the surprises you’ll production of books when in 1824 the qualifications from pursuing course in uncover: Lardner’s liaison with a publisher Archibald Constable local Mechanics Institutes and Colleges married woman in Dublin produced the announced excitedly at a dinner with Sir but in 1850 these Institutes faced a threat only other ‘Dionysius’ in Irish history – Walter Scott “printing and bookselling, to their very existence but many trans- one who eventually became much more an instrument for enlightening and enter- formed themselves into famous universi- famous than his father. This is Dion taining mankind, as well, of course, as ties aided in no small part by the Boucicault, who was in fact christened making money, are yet in their infancy”. availability for the first time of suitable Dionysius Lardner Boursiquot so not Scott was inveigled into a publishing student textbooks streaming out of the much effort was made to hide his pater- project entitled ‘Constable’s Miscellany’ Lardner publishing empire. Carlow in the nity. Dion Boucicault inherited his which Lardner copied with his lster‘ 1840s had no less than two Mechanics father’s facility with words, but he was Cabinet Cyclopaedia’ volumes that ran Institutes, one Protestant and one more creative again – his plays are from 1829 until Thomas Moore’s History Catholic but despite this unique distinc- still performed. of Ireland which was the final volume in tion still awaits a university! 1846. After Lardner’s elopement with What is invariably forgotten is Lardner’s Mrs Heaviside the Cyclopaedia titles Lardner’s great celebrity was partly own leading role in educational in the were sold in 1851. Lardner had seized his based on his colorful and tangled love first half of the 19th century and his work opportunity when Constable’s empire ran life which culminated in him running was unquestionably culturally transfor- into trouble and Scott was left financially away to Paris with Mary the wife of mative. His university mathematics, distressed to be recruited by Lardner. The Captain Richard Heaviside. This scandal physics and steam engineering textbooks Cyclopaedias thus took the front line in

Carloviana 2016 Lardner_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:26 Page 2

96 Carlow connections from a new book “The Villain of Steam”

the commercial war for shelf space on the course with well-written mathematics, despite the outcry in the national papers frontrooms of Victorian middle-class. physics and philosophy textbooks. From as Britain fell disastrously behind Lardner was also to write the first of this launch pad, London by the end of Germany and France; only very late many serial monographs with his hugely that century became the largest ‘exami- indeed did Britain make any attempts to influential book ‘Treatise on Mechanics’ nation’ university in the world for such provide training facilities for working for the Library of Useful Knowledge external students. Lardner must there- men; and most embarrassingly, the (LUK) in in 1829. These monographs fore be placed at the very forefront of the British Establishment failed to reform sold in astonishing numbers and Lardner field of pedagogy in both second and their government of science as the Royal published an astonishing number of these third-level which is overlooked or Society scandalously remained a drink- written by himself and others! Some of forgotten because pedagogy was a ing club for aristocrats. The joke is that us are old enough to remember glass science that simply had no recognition in the British Establishment recieved an fronted bookshelves family homes which Victorian society. enormous jolt from this man abused as almost invariably had amongst them the ‘Irish Diddler’ and indeed across so selections of Encyclopaedias/Cyclopae- Anna Martin’s biography is about a man many key areas of British society that dias, smatterings of monographs and whose reputation is certainly diminished were all in need of such drastic reform. always classic novels usually including a in historical studies for various good couple of Scott volumes. reasons, but whose legacy in truth is A L Martin draws together original today still evident and one of incredible material from many sources to rebuild The book is a very welcome release and importance. Irish people’s self-deprecat- Lardner’s aston-ishing, triumphant and certainly enlivened this year’s Steam ing humour will enjoy the joke that is surprisingly hilarious story. This wonder- Festival where it was presented as it represented by Lardner’s life described ful book is the first ever biography of resurrects a knowledge of the now in this book as it is largely at the expense Dionysius Lardner, one of the most well- forgotten but in his day the foremost of the English establishment. The Brits known men of the Regency Age, whose international celebrity of steam. Lard- could not break free from the then scientific and cultural publications ner’s fame was from his acknowledged crippling intellectual restrictions of New- helped transform Victorian society as authority on steam engineering, steam- ton’s embrace which the analytical re- radically as the advent of Wikipedia car locomotion, steam railways, stream formers in mathematics called “the transformed the lives of our generation. navigation, steam economics and lastly ‘dot’age” until a reform led by Lardner Wonderfully, to end the story, Lardner and not least, his lecturing on steam. His that promoted the continental methods of “Saw Naples and died”. RDS lectures in 1826 on steam were a differential calculus; they refused to sensation as were his book on these allow the anachronistic dominance of Railways, Carlow and Lardner lectures coming before Ireland’s first rail- classics by any introduction of science The disgraced Lardner left from Europe way built by William Dargan of content in their school curriculums to set up tours (1840-1845) of American Laois/Carlow in 1831. Lardner was an Irish nationalist and Whig, and close to Thomas Moore.

Many criticized the idea of setting up a new university in London but Lardner’s role in Gower Street’s UCL was centrally important to the radical’s educational revolution. Let it not be forgotten Tories and enemies of this project where racing to establish their rival King’s College so it was not surprising that politically many were very rude about Lardner and his cheap publications (Calling the Univer- sity ‘StinkO’m Alley’ is racist but another term of abuse ‘The Old Lady of Gower Street’ today has become a term of endearment for UCL); it was in truth the birth of one of the world’s great universities. Lardner was the first super star academic of the new university delivering the opening lecture. He took directly from his own Trinity College Dublin to the new University College London a tradition of the external student studying in their own time for degrees A.L. Martin with Paddy Prendergast, Provost of Trinity College supported initially and uniquely for his Carloviana 2016 Lardner_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:26 Page 3

Carlow connections from a new book “The Villain of Steam”

cities having his lectures published in full was prescient in explaining the financial tion to the now much Nobel decorated in national and regional newspapers the limitations of this proposed Atlantic science of the USA is something Carlow day of the lecture, moving to lecturing in route. He was never forgiven for oppos- can be proud. This notable Irish contri- lecture halls rather than lecturing in large ing Brunel and still less for being right! bution to the USA detailed in McMillan’s auditoriums, thereby making science and Lardner’s greatest recognition came at book that was planned and edited with engineering lectures available to large the 1835 Dublin British Association for his friend Bill Brock 250th Anniversary numbers of both men and women. Anna the Advancement of Science (BAAS) Publication of the RDS “John Tyndall: Martin noted the historian Paul H Theer- meeting. The reform movement in Essays in a Natural Philosopher” and man has estimated Lardner could have Dublin had been led by Provost featuring Katherine Russell Sopka’s performed in front of “the equivalent of Bartholomew Lloyd from the start of the study in Chapter 15 of “John Tyndall: a quarter of the civilized America”. His 19th century and he was the only International Popularizer of Science” lecture performances radically extended academic leader at the founding of the pp.193 – 203. The International Tyndall the use educational props, but this BAAS in York in 1831 which was a School and the National Environmental dependence on props spelt the end of this development boycotted by the other Week in 1993 run by McMillan and his incredible tour when these were establishment church universities in son Douglas was opened by the President destroyed in 1844 in a theatre fire in Oxbridge and St Andrews. The reform of of Penn State University in a transatlantic Providence on Rhode Island. The books a mathematical curriculum in science and broadcast to acknowledge this debt to he published with Longmans were quick engineering was led by Lardner who Carlow and from this historic event run but beautifully edited transcriptions from introduced the analytical method for the in Carlow came the establishment of the newspaper articles that were full of first time in the science of economics. Tyndall Centre for Climate Change woodcut illustrations made Lardner Lardner was the man who wrote the Research was almost certainly named fabulously rich. He was already famous, books in the early 1820 that delivered from this event as the three founding or perhaps more accurately infamous, really this university reform in Britain universities East Anglia, Southampton touring America with Mrs Heaviside who because his books were written for the and Manchester were in attendance and was by then Mrs Lardner. He was able to student and at a level that could under- established their project after being in marry Mary as she had been divorced by stood by those who really needed profes- Carlow for that week’s events and her husband by an Act of the Westminster sionally to grasp these methods. The lectures on climate change and related Parliament after the couple’s scandalous importance of the books Ladner wrote on matters. This is a new legacy that flows elopement in 1839. mathematics cannot be over-exaggerated. out internationally from Ireland via These books were Central Forces (1820), Lardner and to Tyndall that should not The disputes Lardner had over Railways Algebraic Geometry (1823 and repub- be forgotten. came from his expert witness roles in lished 1831), Differential and Integral many Westminster Railway Bills. The Calculus (1825), Lines of Curvature of Lardner work is diminished and criti- English hero worship of Brunel has Ellipsoids, hyperboloids and Paraboloids cized as being simply “That of a popu- distorted this history badly. Brunel was (1825), Spherical Trigonometry (1926), larizer” but he was clearly an original employed by our wonderful entrepreneur not forgetting his Six Books of Euclid thinker and especially this aspect of his William Dargan on early pioneering rail (1830). He recycled these works and published works is most clearly constructions in Wicklow learning a lot indeed produced later mathematical presented in his ‘Railway Economy’ about tunneling and other engineering masterpieces in his Cyclopaedias articles published in New York by Harper Broth- matters. Lardner is constantly derided and monographs. Lardner did not need to ers in 1850. In this landmark work, he and misrepresenting for predicting recruit for some of his volumes authors introduced important graphical methods stream navigation across Atlantic was having written these wonderful and and most importantly analytical mathe- impossible. The truth is as Anna Martin hugely popular and influential studies. matics to economic analysis and predic- demonstrates that Lardner was objec- Lardner did howwever recruit specialists tion. This kind of superior analysis of tively explaining the advantage of using such as de Morgan works on recent data and presentation is seen here as Ireland (Foynes was established as the algebraic developments demonstrating ground breaking but is to be found every- hub by Dargan and later importantly led Lardner’s appreciation of his own where throughout his books and articles. to the seaplane connection that then limitations. presaged the Shannon Airport) as the This is an excellent book and indeed a point of departure for New York. Lardner Lardner established a lecture tour (1840- real-life thriller with lasting value as your was proved correct by warning of the 44) that enable Tyndall in 1872 working historical understanding of Victorian commercial failure of Bristol and Liver- again with Longmans in a year-long tour society will be much improved by this pool Atlantic Communications. He was of the Eastern Seaboard of the USA to well-researched biography. A good Xmas clear, as everyone in Ireland now knows raise enough funds (Billions in today’s stocking filler. that England’s connection with the New money) to actually establish the first World should be through Ireland. The research facilities in the USA’s premier great liners steamed to New York from Ivy League Universities. The venues Southampton with a stop at Cove. The initially established by Lardner were in Great Western Railway and Steam Navi- place and indeed primed for exploitation gation Bill evidence given by Lardner by Tyndall. The Carlowman’s contribu- Carloviana 2016 Here's to the 32!_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:33 Page 1

Here’s to the 32!

When you travel through Ireland work our way through and finish in the summer, you don't need with Wicklow? roadsigns to tell you which county you’re in. Flags attached to urban IT WASN'T even a question of starting gables and farmyard gates, or in Dublin and slowly spreading fluttering from little plastic flag outwards from the Pale with the poles clipped to car-windows, western being created last, as many leave you in no doubt. people understandably imagine. The immediate proof of this is the last of The Gaelic Athletic Association the thirty- two to be formed was Wick- season is in ftll swing and low - right on Dublin's doorstep. allegiances are proudly displayed in most of the thirty-two counties So, how did they go about it? An when on the island of Ireland - espe- did your county come into being? cially those counties which are in With a chance of winning some- Before the Normans, Ireland was thing, be it in football or hurling. divided into regions controlled by different groups of people, tuatha. The GAA justifiably boasts that it These were minor lordships and there reaches into every village and were about ninety of them. The old crossroads in the country. It has a tuatha structure didn't suit the presence in even the smallest business-minded Normans and they communities, but the county introduced the county system that had structure is the backbone of worked well for them in France the organisation. and England.

County allegiance is not confined to such As far as they were concerned, Prince matters. The Irish abroad have always b John - the baddie in all the Robin Hood laded together and in many instances Jim Rees examines films - was Lord of Ireland, and it was have formed county associations. the origins of our county under his command that the shiring of the system, introduced to country (the creation of c unties) began. Parts of cities like London and New York And some of them will appear odd to not only had 'Irish districts but many of Ireland by the Normans modern readers. these districts had particular streets pop- ulated by people from a particular county. As mentioned, the Normans first arrived in what is now County Wexford, but it Ask most Irish people where they are In fact, it is the least 'Irish' of our admin- wasn't long before they transferred their from and the chances are they will an- istrative divisions. seat of power to Dublin. Not surprisingly, swer with the name, not of their town, but the city and surrounding countryside for of their county. The county system was introduced by the several miles became the first Irish Normans and consolidated by the county. That was in 1190. We even go so far as to have our own English Tudor monarchs. It replaced the county anthems, such as The Rose cf native Irish divisions of townlands and Which was next - Meath, Kildare or Tralee; The Banks of my Own Lovely provinces in importance and-took over Wicklow? Not a bit of it. Try Cork and Lee; and 'The Rose of Mooncoin. I was four hundred years to complete. Waterford. going to say that the list is endless, but actually it ends at thirty-two and I can't Look at an alphabetical list of counties In fact, try both together, for the County think of quarter of them. and it all seems neat and logical, but of Waterford Cork came into being in getting them all in place was a long and 1211, with County Munster following ANYONE WOULD be forgiven for torturous process. The newly arrived hot on its heels. Yes, County Munster. thinking that the county structure was Normans didn't sit down dter securing a part of our DNA, a badge of identity we toe-hold at Baginbun and say: This 'Munstershire wasn't really anything can trace back to the time of Finn more than a label. It was so vast that it McCool’s granny. 'Right, lads, we'll start here with Antrim, might well have been called Carloviana 2016 Here's to the 32!_Layout 1 28/10/2015 19:33 Page 2

99 Here’s to the 32!

`Monstershire' and the Normans held WHEN WAS YOUR COUNTY FORMED little sway in ninety per cent of it, but it Different sources have slightly varying but looked good on parchment or vellum agree with the dates before back in London. Antrim c.1300 Galway c.1570 Monaghan 1604 Armagh 1604 Kerry 1233 Offaly 1557 AS NORMAN control increased, Carlow 1306 Kildare 1297 Roscommon 1292 however, particularly in urban areas, this Cavan 1579 Kilkenny c.1200 Sligo c.1570 massive 'county' was subdivided in Clare c.1570 Laois 1557 Tipperary 1254 Limerick (1251) and Tipperary (1254). In Cork 1211 Leitrim 1565 Tyrone 1579 the meantime, both Louth and Kerry had Derry 1579 Limerick 1254 Waterfors 1211 been established in 1233. Donegal 1604 Longford 1571 Westmeath 1543 Down c.1300 Louth 1233 Wexford 1247 But what of the vast area west of the Dublin c.1190 Mayo c.1570 Wicklow 1606 Shannon, another region in which the Fermanagh 1579 Meath 1297 Normans had made little headway, but on which they had nonetheless set their greedy little eyes? to shire the entire country, however, when Monaghan, Armagh and Donegal were put on hold in the 1300s and 1400s were shired in 1604, there was only one No problem, they simply did what they as the Irish started to regain some of their supposedly 'untamed' district left; the had done in Munster, and the virtually lost power. mountainous region on Dublin's southern fictitious County of Connacht came into doorstep which was controlled by being in 1247. Roscommon made its Then came the 1500s and the Tudor the O'Byrnes. debut in 1292, bringing the first stage of dynasty of English kings. Henry VIII was shiring to a close just as the thirteenth particularly anxious to bring the Irish to LOT has been said and written about the century came to an end. heel, and what we might call 'The Shiring O'Neills and the O'Donnells and their of Ireland Part II' got under way. resistance to English rule in the north- So, 120 years after the arrival of the west. Unfairly, outside his native Normans, large sections of Ireland had The counties of Dublin, Meath, Louth, Wicklow, little is known of the exploits been parcelled into nine administrative Kildare, Wexford, Limerick, Kerry and of Fiach MacHugh O'Byrne. regions called 'counties: Tipperary were consolidated and soon Carlow, Kilkenny, Cork and Waterford The remote and rugged valleys of The man in charge of each county was a were also smacked on the wrist, their Glenmalure and Glen Imaal afforded the shire-reeve, literally a custodian of the liberties taken away, told to be good boys O'Byrnes the terrain that made continued shire. Time has shortened this title to and to take their place in the fold. resistance possible. In the 1580s the sheriff. He was assisted by a coroner who English administration in Dublin sent an investigated sudden deaths with the main IT WAS also decided that Meath .„twas army under Lord Grey into the Wicklow purpose of seeing if the deceased's estate too big to control as a single unit, so mountains to rout the O'Byrnes. could be forfeited to the crown ('coroner' Westmeath was hived off in 1543, with comes from `crowner'). There was also King's and Queen's Counties (Offaly and But it didn't work out like that. an escheator, a clerk for markets and jus- Laois) coming into being in 1557. The 'Grey said victory was sure tices of the peace. County of Connacht was divided into That soon the firebrand he'd secure Galway, Mayo and Sligo. Clare was Until he met at Glenmalure Other areas under Norman rule were established at this time too, but as part of With Flack MacHugh O'Byrne' called 'liberties: the province of Connacht. Fiach's triumph over Grey was simply These were slightly different in that they Longford, Antrim and Down soon postponing the inevitable. In 1606, the were much more autonomous than followed and Leitrim was separated from `O'Byrne Countrie; as it was known, regular counties. They were controlled by Roscommon. Tyrone, Fermanagh and became the last of the thirty-two counties a major lord. The southern half of Cavan were formed in 1579. County to be shired, taking the name Wicklow. modern Leinster was a liberty, as was Coleraine was established the same year, Meath which included most of modern but this later became County Derry. Perhaps that's why Wicklow has never north Leinster. lifted the Sam Maguire or Liam Mac- The year 1601 saw the final tragic throw Carthy trophies - the other counties have In 1297, the Leinster liberty was sub- of the dice for the old Gaelic chieftains had more time to practise! divided into the liberties of Wexford, and land clivisions. The Battle of Kinsale Carlow, Kilkenny and Kildare. Bit by bit, was lost and within a few years the Flight the privileges that made them liberties of the Earls brought down the curtain. were eroded until they were eventually Reproduced here with thre permission reduced to the same subjugated state of There was still some land not yet of the author and “Ireland’s Own” ordinary counties. parcelled up and tied in neat ribbons, but Carloviana 2016