Ashley Johnson

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Ashley Johnson I give permission for public access to my thesis and for any copying to be done at the discretion of the archives librarian and/or the College librarian. _________________________________________ MOUNT HOLYOKE COLLEGE HEALING THE WOUNDS OF FASCISM: THE AMERICAN MEDICAL BRIGADE AND THE SPANISH CIVIL WAR AN UNDERGRADUATE THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT FOR THE DEGREE OF BACHELOR OF ARTS WITH HONORS DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY BY ASHLEY JOHNSON MAY 1, 2007 SOUTH HADLEY, MASSACHUSSETTS TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION…………………………………………………………1 CHAPTER ONE Why Spain?..............................................................................................11 CHAPTER TWO Hospital Life: Optimism, Trauma, and the Daily Grind……………..39 CHAPTER THREE The Journey Home………………………………………………………78 CONCLUSION……………………………………………………………107 APPENDIX Medical Brigade Photographs………………………………………...111 BIBLIOGRAPHY…………………………………………………………116 To my mother, Melanie Johnson, for instilling me with a love of history. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank the following people, who helped make this project a reality: To the staff of the Tamiment Labor Archives at NYU, for organizing papers, finding audio guides, and suggesting new material. To the History Department of Mount Holyoke College for generously giving me two Almara grants to carry out my research in New York. To Fredericka Martin, for working on a history of the Medical Brigade until her dying day, and for generously leaving all the material to ALBA. To my grandmother, Nanette Campbell, for trekking off to the Palo Alto library to find me microfilmed back issues of the San Francisco Chronicle. To Joy, Jessie, and Leslie, for reading drafts, listening attentively, and at times, taking me out of the library by force. And of course to Professor Daniel Czitrom, an amazing advisor, for handing me my first book about the Abraham Lincoln Brigade my sophomore year, and seeing me through it to the end. I could not have completed this project without his support, enthusiasm, and unfailing honesty. I leave Mount Holyoke not only with a passion for history but the desire to pass it on to others— thank you. Areas of American Soldiers and Medical Personnel in Spain Courtesy of Peter Carroll. The Odyssey of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade ( Stanford: 1994). 1 INTRODUCTION THE AMERICAN MEDICAL BRIGADE AND THE SPANISH CIVIL WAR “Stem the blood of Spanish Democracy!”1 In the middle of the 1930s, while the worst economic crisis in capitalist history plagued the United States, the government of a small country cried out for help against the fascist forces of General Francisco Franco. In response, the United States Left banded together, sending aid, American soldiers, and the American Medical Brigade, a group of doctors, nurses, and ambulance drivers who held one goal: the defeat of fascism in Spain. The well-known Abraham Lincoln Brigade joined the ranks of the International Brigades established out of Moscow, and quickly became the cause that unified the Popular Front of the 1930s. As of yet, no one has taken the time to tell the lesser known story of the American Medical Brigade. Nonetheless, it was equally important to the American Left at a time when Communists, Socialists, idealists, and simple anti-fascists united no matter what their nationality, color or gender to help the legitimate government of Spain. The Spanish Civil War exemplified the fight between democracy and fascism, opened the scene for World War II, and created a specific goal which joined the Popular Front during the 1930s. 2 American Medical Brigade members came from all walks of life. Dr. Edward Barsky was a graduate of Columbia’s College of Physicians and Surgeons. He was tall, charismatic, and regarded by his fellow nurses as extremely handsome. He held a respectable position as assisting surgeon on the staff of Beth Israel Hospital in New York City and had studied in Vienna, Berlin, and Paris before joining the Communist Party in 1935. Evelyn Hutchins was a spunky blonde woman of twenty-seven, who was a fervent feminist and eager to counter any man who denied her equality. She grew up in Washington with a step-father who was a militant stevedore and a suffragist mother. At age eighteen she left home to become a professional dancer but the crash of the stock market in 1929 cancelled any hopes of a career. Consequently, she turned to politics, and more specifically, the Communist Party.2 Dr. Leo Eloesser was a world famous thoracic surgeon based out of Stanford University. He spoke at least six languages, including Chinese, and had recently returned from medical service in World War I. His only political affiliation noted was that of an anti-fascist. At age fifty-nine, when Franco began his Spanish coup, he simply stated, “I hate dictators and if I hate them enough I should be doing something about it.”3 In early 1936, Salaria Kee, described by the poet Langston Hughes as “…a slender chocolate colored girl,” offered her services as a nurse to the American Red Cross to help flood victims in her home state, Ohio. On 3 account of her race, the organization turned her away. Upset, a friend mentioned volunteering in Spain. “Fascism is very well understood in America where millions of people oppose it. What else is Jim Crow but part of Fascism?”4 Henceforth, Kee resolved to be firmly anti-fascist, even if it meant risking her life for it. At first glance, these men and women may not seem to have much in common, but they shared a strong social spirit and in January of 1937, they were comrades in American Medical Brigade. Barsky was the Brigade’s head doctor, Eloesser a surgeon, Kee a nurse, and Hutchins the only female ambulance driver on the Spanish front. They journeyed to Spain in an effort to change foreign and domestic policy against Spain, and to change the course of history. The Spanish Civil War pitted a democratically elected republic, against a fascist uprising actively supported by Hitler and Mussolini. It was a complex history of insurrection and rebellion, democracy and tyranny. In 1931 the “Segunda Republica” of Spain was the first ever democratically elected government in Spanish history.5 In the spring of 1936 the government suffered from severe instability under President Azaña. Consequently, on July 17 General Francisco Franco led a right wing military insurrection against the legitimate government of Spain, declaring a military coup against the Republic. On July 18, the Insurgents moved to Seville and successfully took the city but were defeated by the Republic at Barcelona. After this defeat, the 4 Insurgents appealed to Germany and Italy for support as Franco took control of the forces and on July 26, German and Italian planes, the first of many supplies and troops, landed in Morocco to help the insurgent forces. What might have remained an internal struggle turned into a worldwide symbol of democracy against fascism.6 The Spanish Republic was one of the first nations to directly oppose fascism, a form of politics that rose to the world’s attention at the hand of Benito Mussolini, who displayed his contempt for the masses, emphasizing the need for elite leadership. It holds an emphasis on voluntarism rather than communalism. In the fascist state, the fundamental unit is the nation, one is either part of it or not. One either has national values or has none at all. The nation-state, and therefore the elite dictator, (Mussolini, Hitler, and later Franco) is the ultimate authority in all matters.7 The Spanish Republic knew it was unable to measure up to the firepower of Franco, who was backed by Mussolini and Hitler. The Republic appealed to the democracies of the world but did not receive the help it had wished for. The French provided the Loyalist government with a small number of planes before proposing a world-wide non-intervention policy, which was ignored by both Italy and Germany. The British government refused to act, and in the United States, under Roosevelt’s urgings, Congress embargoed both sides of the war. In refusing to sell arms to the Republic, the US, France, and Britain in effect sided with the Nationalist Insurgents.8 The embargo did not merely 5 prevent supplies from being given to the Spanish Republic; it denied them the right to buy firearms with which to defend themselves, and medical supplies to tend their wounded. Gradually, while watching the Spanish Republic struggle against the fascists, an international base of volunteers began to form. They started with the refugees of fascist Italy and Germany, many escapees from concentration camps. The International Brigades became a reality when the Communist party of Moscow formed official brigades to aide the Spanish Republic. In early 1937 large numbers of soldiers began to join the brigades from England, Belgium, France, Italy, Germany, Canada, along with the Abraham Lincoln Brigade of the United States. For many idealistic defenders of democracy, Madrid represented “the heart of a civilization, of a world, and of an ideal, that 35,000 men from 53 foreign lands would put their lives on the line to protect.”9 In the International Brigades, there remained the sense that one was part of a cause rather than a country. In a letter home, female Brigade nurse Dorothy Fontaine commented, “…it is wonderful to be part of an international movement. I’ve met wonderful people from all nations…”10 This international brotherhood stretched to the United States, and became the trademark of the American Popular Front. During the 1930s, the Popular Front represented the union of all Leftist groups with one common goal. Communists, Socialists, 6 liberals, and the like put aside their differences in the name of one thing: anti- fascism. Though American volunteers went overseas to serve in Spain for a plethora of reasons, over eighty percent represented the Popular Front as members of the Communist Party and still more had significant affiliations with Communist organizations.
Recommended publications
  • Norman Bethune: Un Cirujano En Las Revoluciones
    NORMAN BETHUNE: UN CIRUJANO EN LAS REVOLUCIONES Eduardo Monteverde ENERO 2016. © Eduardo Monteverde Esta publicación es financiada con recursos de la RLS con fondos del BMZ y Para Leer en Libertad A.C. www.rosalux.org.mx [email protected] www.brigadaparaleerenlibertad.com Cuidado de la edición: Alicia Rodríguez, Óscar de Pablo y Ezra Alcázar. Diseño de interiores y portada: Daniela Campero. A Rolf Meiners- Guadalajara, Jalisco1939 - México DF, 2015. Médico revolucionario en las ideas, guerrillero en la acción, preso político. In memoriam Agradecimientos: Participaron Fernanda de la Cueva y Paco Ignacio Taibo II, con la paciencia de las Moiras, el escudo de Medusa, el telar de Penélope, y la infinitud, si es que existe, del Infinito. Eduardo Monteverde Gangrena, el fantasma de los médicos, la devoradora de los pacientes, el enemigo de todos, la peste de los comba- tes. Gangrena, ya descrita en el siglo V a.c. en el Corpus Hipocraticum, como el principio de la muerte que se anun- cia en los tejidos que fueran sanos, la primera dentellada a la que seguirá el esfacelo, esa descamación pútrida de la piel, de los músculos, los huesos y hasta el cerebro. Necrosis, la muerte que viste de negro al cadáver. “Heridas de bordes cuarteados, coronadas de gangrena negra”. Así describió en un poema la muerte, el cirujano Norman Bethune, que falleció de gangrena en el escenario quirúrgico de la invasión de Japón a China. Año 1939, en el bando comunista del Octavo Ejército de Ruta. El hom- bre curtido a la intemperie muere en un hospital aldeano de campaña.
    [Show full text]
  • December 1976
    The Volunteer Published As A Public Service By The VETERANS OF THE ABRAHAM LINCOLN BRIGADE 799 Broadway, N Y. C. 10003 DECEMBER, 1976 The Political Future of Spain: Is Francoism Dead? Reunion In Florence By Alvah Bessie. By BILL WATSON (Nov. 29, 1976) Watching Spanish politics from a articles on police torture) and FLORENCE, October 10 - On the distance used to be a relatively determined to get out the important face of it, it was incredible. Here simple process. There were rarely news. were about 1,000 veterans of the any fundamental changes in the The “opening” of the press itself International Brigades from over 20 Franco regime, and the few changes reflects the most astonishing nations, including 68 of our own there were did not challenge the development since Franco’s death – from all over the United States, repressive character of the political life is quickly resuming its meeting in Italy over an October dictatorship or the firm grip - former vitality to the point that Spain weekend to commemorate the 40th stranglehold would be a better word - is becoming the most politically anniversary of the Brigades. General Franco maintained over conscious country in Europe. It was so long ago! Franco had political life. In fact, watching In virtually every region of Spain been dead almost 11 months, but his Spanish politics from the outside was preparations are underway for a regime was far from dead, and all the even an advantage, because one different kind of political future. veterans we saw - some for the first could learn more from IA Monde, Political parties are being organized; time in 37 or 38 years - all looked The New York Times, and Spanish the free trade union movement is anywhere from 10 to 20 years exile publications than one could gaining momentum; there is talk younger than they actually were.
    [Show full text]
  • Norman Bethune: Un Cirujano En Las Revoluciones
    NORMAN BETHUNE: UN CIRUJANO EN LAS REVOLUCIONES Eduardo Monteverde ENERO 2016. © Eduardo Monteverde Esta publicación es financiada con recursos de la RLS con fondos del BMZ y Para Leer en Libertad A.C. www.rosalux.org.mx [email protected] www.brigadaparaleerenlibertad.com Cuidado de la edición: Alicia Rodríguez, Óscar de Pablo y Ezra Alcázar. Diseño de interiores y portada: Daniela Campero. A Rolf Meiners- Guadalajara, Jalisco1939 - México DF, 2015. Médico revolucionario en las ideas, guerrillero en la acción, preso político. In memoriam Agradecimientos: Participaron Fernanda de la Cueva y Paco Ignacio Taibo II, con la paciencia de las Moiras, el escudo de Medusa, el telar de Penélope, y la infinitud, si es que existe, del Infinito. Eduardo Monteverde Gangrena, el fantasma de los médicos, la devoradora de los pacientes, el enemigo de todos, la peste de los comba- tes. Gangrena, ya descrita en el siglo V a.c. en el Corpus Hipocraticum, como el principio de la muerte que se anun- cia en los tejidos que fueran sanos, la primera dentellada a la que seguirá el esfacelo, esa descamación pútrida de la piel, de los músculos, los huesos y hasta el cerebro. Necrosis, la muerte que viste de negro al cadáver. “Heridas de bordes cuarteados, coronadas de gangrena negra”. Así describió en un poema la muerte, el cirujano Norman Bethune, que falleció de gangrena en el escenario quirúrgico de la invasión de Japón a China. Año 1939, en el bando comunista del Octavo Ejército de Ruta. El hom- bre curtido a la intemperie muere en un hospital aldeano de campaña.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of the Surgical Service at San Francisco General Hospital
    THE HISTORY OF THE SURGICAL SERVICE AT SAN FRANCISCO GENERAL HOSPITAL William Schecter, Robert Lim, George Sheldon, Norman Christensen, William Blaisdell i DEDICATION This book is dedicated to our patient and understanding wives Gisela Schecter, Carolee Lim, Ruth Sheldon, Sally Christensen, and Marilyn Blaisdell. Their help and support not only made our careers possible but also ensured that they would be successful. ii PREFACE I was delighted and honored to be asked to assist in the publication of this landmark book on the History of Surgery in the San Francisco General Hospital. The authors are to be commended on their accurate, readable and historic portrayal of the evolution of this center of excellence in trauma and general surgical patient care. As I read through the manuscript, it brought back warm and clear memories of days spent here both as a junior medical student and later as a resident in the University of California, San Francisco surgical program. It presents an impressive timeline of surgeons who have taught here, a number of whom have moved on and become outstanding leaders in the field of surgery. After 40 years of practice as a surgeon, I look back on my training here at this hospital as one of the most important contributors to my overall surgical and medical education. This hospital and its surgical staff imbued me with the essential knowledge and technical skills necessary to be an accomplished general surgeon and, most importantly, they taught me the value of seeking advice from a more experienced specialist when the occasion arose. I feel certain that every surgeon, who during their training has passed through the portals of San Francisco General Hospital, will also find in this book a powerful reminder of how important it has been in their life.
    [Show full text]
  • Jenkins, Reed 2019 History Thesis Title: An
    Jenkins, Reed 2019 History Thesis Title: An American Surgeon, The Spanish Civil War, and the Faultlines of American Politics : Advisor: Jessica Chapman Advisor is Co-author: None of the above Second Advisor: Soledad Fox Released: release now Authenticated User Access: Yes Contains Copyrighted Material: No An American Surgeon, The Spanish Civil War, and the Faultlines of American Politics by Reed Jenkins Professor Jessica Chapman and Professor Soledad Fox, Advisors A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts with Honors in History WILLIAMS COLLEGE Williamstown, Massachusetts April 15, 2019 1 Table of Contents Introduction………………………………………………………………….. 5 Chapter One…………………………………………………………………...16 Chapter Two…………………………………………………………………...42 Chapter Three………………………………………………………………….74 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………..103 Bibliography…………………………………………………………………...108 2 Acknowledgements The completion of this thesis has been the culmination of a journey begun three years ago, when I was first introduced to Dr. Edward Barsky in Professor Fox’s Americans Abroad seminar. I would like to thank the many people who have helped make this project possible with their enduring encouragement and support. I will begin by thanking my advisors, who have been so helpful every step of the way. Professor Fox, thank you for inspiring me through your passion for Spanish Civil War history and for your dedication throughout the course of this project. I am also incredibly grateful to Professor Chapman for agreeing to take on this project, and for her help untangling the complex political currents of the McCarthyist period. Both my advisors were incredibly giving of advice, time, and expertise, and this project would not have come together without them.
    [Show full text]
  • Jews in the Spanish Civil War – and in My Book “Fighting Back – the Contribution of British Jews in WW2”
    CLICK HERE FOR UPDATED VERSION This document is the copyright of M Sugarman and may not be reproduced in part or whole without his permission Against Fascism – Jews who served in The International Brigade in The Spanish Civil War (Note – This survey is available at the AJEX Archives of the Jewish Military Museum in Hendon, the Marx Memorial Library (MML) in Clerkenwell , The Imperial War Museum Library, The National Archives at Kew, The British Library, The SOAS Library at the University of London, the LSE Spanish Studies Library, the Jewish Historical Society of England Library, UCL Jewish Studies Library, and The Wiener Library – all in London; Manchester University Library, The Hebrew University Library in Jerusalem, The Virtual Jewish Library website, VALBA (Veterans of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade) web site and Brandeis University Library in the USA. As at 01/07/16 Spanjews.doc By Martin Sugarman, BA (Hons.), Cert. Ed. ( Archivist of the Association of Jewish Ex-Servicemen and Women, Jewish Military Museum) Introduction For reasons best known to themselves, most adherents of the Left - both old and new - and the mainstream Jewish community itself – have been, till recently, loathe to acknowledge and recall the dominant Jewish role in the International Brigade’s (IB) struggle against Fascism in the Spanish Civil War. Stereotyped as timid and submissive, the reality is that thousands of Jews from 53 countries went to fight and die opposing Franco, firing the first shots against Fascism. Some went openly as Jews, others took aliases; some fought in the battalions of their country of birth, others with other national groups; some went via a third nation, others went direct to Spain; some were refugees from anti-Semitism or political oppression already, others went freely from the 1 democracies.
    [Show full text]
  • Jews Who Served in the International Brigade in the Spanish Civil War
    MASTER COPY This document is the copyright of M Sugarman and may not be reproduced in part or whole without his permission Against Fascism – Jews who served in The International Brigade in The Spanish Civil War (Note – This survey is available at the AJEX Archives of the Jewish Military Museum in Jewish Museum, Camden; the Marx Memorial Library (MML) in Clerkenwell , The Imperial War Museum Library, The National Archives at Kew, the IBMT web site,The British Library, The SOAS Library at the University of London, the LSE Spanish Studies Library, the Jewish Historical Society of England Library, UCL Jewish Studies Library, and The Wiener Library – all in London; Manchester University Library, The Hebrew University Library in Jerusalem, The Virtual Jewish Library website, VALBA (Veterans of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade) web site and Brandeis University Library in the USA. As at 07/03/21 Spanjews.doc By Martin Sugarman, BA (Hons.), Cert. Ed. ( Archivist of the Association of Jewish Ex-Servicemen and Women, Jewish Military Museum) CONTENTS Introductions and opening Comments Page reference for National Batallions - p. 11 - UK p. 26 - Dombrowskis (Poland) p. 54 - USA p. 83 - Canada p. 87 - Latvia p. 93 - Franco-Belge p. 100 – Dimitrov – East Europe 1 p. 103 – Austria p. 112 – Italy p. 112 – Israel p. 118 - Morcco p. 119 – Romania p. 122 – Germany p. 130 – Misc. E and SE Europe p. 132 - Argentina Introduction For reasons best known to themselves, most adherents of the Left - both old and new - and the mainstream Jewish community itself – have been, till recently, loathe to acknowledge and recall the dominant Jewish role in the International Brigade’s (IB) struggle against Fascism in the Spanish Civil War.
    [Show full text]
  • RHYTHM, RIOTS and REVOLUTION by Rev
    RHYTHM, RIOTS AND REVOLUTION by Rev. David A. Noebel AN ANALYSIS OF THE COMMUNIST USE OF MUSIC — THE COMMUNIST MASTER MUSIC PLAN "Even music may be intoxicating. Such apparently slight causes destroyed Greece and Rome, and will destroy England and America/' Henry David Thoreau. Walden, The New American Library, 501 Madison Ave., New York, Eighteenth Printing, December, 1963, p. 147. First published in 1854. CHRISTIAN CRUSADE PUBLICATIONS Tulsa, Oklahoma 1966 Copyright ® 1966 by Christian Crusade Publications. All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from the publisher, Christian Crusade Publications, Box 977, Tulsa, Oklahoma 74102, except by a reviewer, who may quote brief passages in connection with a review. Manufactured in the United States of America DEDICATION To fhe young people of America who must ultimately cope with the problems set forth in this book, and par­ ticularly to six that I love and know so well: Brent David and Brenda Joy Noebel; Billy James //, Bonnie, Becky and Brenda Jo Hargis. "And Jesus called a little child unfo Him, and set him in the midst of them, and said , . whoso shall re­ ceive one such little child in my name receiveth me. But whoso she!! offend one of these little ones which believe in me, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in fhe depth of fhe sea " Matthew 18:2, 3, 5, and 6. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I wish to express my gratitude for the co-operation of the following publishing firms for granting permission to quote copyrighted material from their publications: Capricorn Books, 200 Madison Ave,, New York 16, New York: CONDITIONED REFLEX THERAPY by Dr.
    [Show full text]