Discoglossus Sardus and Euproctus Montanus During the Breeding Season
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HERPETOLOGICAL JOURNAL, Vol. 9, pp. 163-167 (1999) FEEDING HABITS OF SYMPATRIC DJSCOGLOSSUS MONTALENTII, DISCOGLOSSUS SARDUS AND EUPROCTUS MONTANUS DURING THE BREEDING SEASON SEBASTIANO SALYIDI01 , ROBERTO SINDAC02 AND LlVIO EMANUELl3 'Istituto di Zoologia, Universita di Genova, Via Balbi 5, I- I6126 Genova, Italy 2Istituto per le Piante da Legno e Ambiente, Corso Casale 476, 1- 10I 32 Torino, Italy 1Acquario di Genova, Area Porto Antico - Ponte Sp inola, I- 16128 Genova Italy The diets of three Corsican amphibians, Discoglossus montalentii, Discoglossus sardus and Euproctus montanus, were studied in the Ospedale region during the breeding season. Adult specimens were collected in or around breeding pools and were stomach flushed in the field. Prey taxa included a large variety of terrestrial and aquatic prey items of variable size, indicating opportunistic predation. All species were able to catch their prey both on land and in water, but varied in the proportions of aquatic and terrestrial prey consumed. E. montanus fed largely upon benthic macroinvertebrates, suggesting predation in deep water; D. sardus mainly captured terrestrial prey; and D. montalentii showed a mixed fe eding strategy, preying upon both terrestrial and aquatic prey categories in similar proportions. Discoglossus sardus showed the highest standardized value of niche breadth (D, = 0. 769), compared to D. montalentii and E. montanus (D, = 0.544 and D, = 0.523 respectively). When prey size frequency distributions were compared, no specific differences were observed. These results indicated that, at least during the breeding season, trophic segregation among sympatric amphibians was maintained by different foraging strategies, and that the three species exploited contiguous microhabitats in different ways. Key words: Corsica, Discoglossus, Euproctus, foragingstrategy, sympatry INTRODUCTION STUDY AREA AND METHODS On the Mediterranean island of Corsica seven am Samples were collected in the Ospedale forests phibian species, including three endemic forms (Southern Corsica, 20 km NW of Portovecchio) from (Euproctus montanus, Discoglossus montalentii and April to June, both in 1996 and 1997. The study area, a Salamandra corsica), are known to occurr (Delaugerre Pinus laricio forest ranging from 700 to 1000 m a.s.l., & Cheylan, 1992; Gase et al., 1997). The Corsican was located between the villages of Ospedale and painted frogD. montalentii was the last species to have Zonza, which are separated by a linear distance of been described on the basis of biochemical and mor about 12 km. Although very similar morphologically, phological characters (Lanza et al., 1984 ), and -due to D. montalentii and D. sardus were identifiedin the fi eld its confusion with the congeneric Tyrrhenian painted mainly on the basis of their hind limb length, which is frog D. sardus - little is known about its biology and relatively greater in D. montalentii (Clarke & Lanza, ecology. Discoglossus montalentii is mainly a moun 1990; Salvidio et al., unpublished data); in some cases, tain species living in pristine or semi-pristine forest fieldid entification was confirmed by dissection and by streams, while D. sardus breeds from sea level to about chromosomal analysis (Gaetano Odierna in litteris). 1300 m, in a variety of aquatic habitat types (Clark & With the exception of Salamandra corsica (see be Lanza, 1990; Lanza, Vanni & Brizzi, 1992a, b). The low), all amphibians were captured in or near (i.e. less altitudinal distribution of the two species overlaps than I metre from) water. All specimens were meas broadly, and in several areas they are found together ured from thetip of the snout to the posterior end of the (Clarke & Lanza, 1990; Salvidio et al., unpublished vent (SVL) to the nearest mm, and toe clipped at first data). During a two year field study on the distribution capture; thus, stomach contents were analyzed only and ecology of D. montalentii and D. sardus, we col once for each individual. Diet composition was ob lected data on their fe eding habits together with those tained by stomach flushing (Fraser, 1976; Joly, 1987), of the sympatric Corsican brook salamander E. and stomach contents were preserved in the field in montanus. This gave us the opportunity to analyse their 70% ethanol. Stomach flushing was performed at least feeding behaviours and to compare their foraging twice on each specimen and, if no prey was obtained, modes in order to investigate whether they were parti the stomach was considered empty. Where possible, tioning food resources when they coexist. food items were identified to order or family, and meas ured to the nearest 0.1 mm under a dissecting Correspondence: S. Salvidio, Istituto di Zoologia, Universita microscope. Aquatic invertebrates were classified us di Genova, Via Balbi 5, 1-16126 Genova, Italy. E-mail: [email protected] ing Sansoni's (1988) identification keys of freshwater 164 S. SAL VIDIO, R. SINDACO AND L. EMANUELI macroinvertebrates. Prey volume (V)was calculated by Table 2 gives the complete data set of the diet com considering each item as a cylinder or a sphere, and was position by taxonomic group and by volume. In the expressed in mm3• Additionally, prey items were classi Ospedale forests, amphibians consumed a wide range fied as aquatic or terrestrial, with a third category of terrestrial and aquatic invertebrates. The Corsican comprising prey that dwell on land, in shallow water or brook salamander was the only species that preyed mud (e.g. metamorphosing anurans, mites, dipteran lar upon vertebrates: one unidentified urodelan larva and vae, earthworms), as well as unidentified preyitems. one postrnetamorphic froglet (Discoglossus sp.) were Simple correspondence analysis (CA), based on a found in the stomachs of two males, and a third male contingency table with predators as rows and prey taxa swallowed four eggs belonging to its own species. The as columns, was used to obtain a graphical representa distribution of prey items according to their life-style tion of the association between species and prey indicated that all species were able to feed both in categories. In this analysis, a small sample of the Corsi aquatic and terrestrial environments; however, E. can fire salamander S. corsica (four specimens montanus fe d mainly on benthic macroinvertebrates, in collected in the Ospedale region, and one from Haute particular Plecoptera, Ephemeroptera and Tricoptera Asco in Northern Corsica, all of them captured in ter larvae, while D. sardus primarily consumed terrestrial restrial habitats) was included for comparison, as this prey (Isopoda and Araneida). D. montalentii captured species feeds exclusively upon terrestrial invertebrates both freshwater, and terrestrial food items in similar (Kuzmin, 1994). The Corsican fire salamander sample proportions. These results suggest that the brook sala was used in the CA as a supplementary row element; mander was foraging mainly in deep water, while the thus, it was represented in the Euclidean space deter two discoglossids probably preferred surface or shal mined by the first two axes, but did not contribute to the low water. The frequencies of prey according to their calculation of the other species location (Greenacre, life-style (aquatic vs terrestrial) were overall signifi 1993 ). Correspondence analysis was performed using cantly different (x2=3 l.3, df=4, P<0.00 1), but when Minitab 11.12 statistical software (Minitab Inc., 1996). species were compared pairwise, the Corsican painted Prey volume frequency distributions were compared frogand the Corsican brook salamander showed similar with a Kolmogorov-Smimov two sample test (Siegel & feeding habits: D.montalentii - E. montanus, x2 =4.9, Castellan, 1988). The standardized version of Simp df=2; P=0.088; D. montalentii - D. sardus, x2 = 9.6, D (D )/(N D D. sardus - E. montanus, son's diversity index , = - 1 - 1 ), in which is df=2, P=0.008; x2=30.7, df=2, (D S N the Simpson's index = 11 P;2) and is the number P<0.001. The utilization of taxonomic categories by of prey taxa categories, was used to estimate trophic volume showed similar findings (Table 2), as D. niche breadth. This standardized index ranges from 0, montalentii and E. montanus were the species depend when only one resource category is exploited, to I ing the most upon aquatic food resources (58% and when all categories are exploited with the same fre 30% of the total ingested volume, respectively). The quency (Barbault, 1981 ). standardized Simpson index D, calculated on the basis of taxonomic categories, indicated that D. sardus had RESULTS the widest trophic niche breadth (D, = 0.769), E. During this study, 144 amphibians were stomach montanus the narrowest (D = 0.523), and D. , flushed(Table 1). The proportion of stomachs contain montalentii an intermediate value (D, = 0.544); but ing at least one prey item (inorganic and plant matter when prey volumes were considered, all species were excluded from data analyses) ranged from 100% showed similar - and relatively narrow values - ofniche in corsica to 63% in D. sardus, and a chi-square S. breadths (0.299 < D, < 0.356; see Table 2). analysis, based on the three largest samples (i.e. exclud The results of the CA based on the complete data set ing the S. corsica sample), indicated that there were no are shown in Fig. 1. The firstand second axes explained differences in the frequency of fasting animals (X2 = 38% and 24 % ofthe total variance, respectively. In this 4.4, df=2; P=0.1 08). plot, both Discoglossus sardus and S. corsica were pro The Euproctus montanus sample consisted of sexu jected in the bottom right quadrant of the plot, in strict ally mature individuals: 46 males and 6 females. The association with their terrestrial prey categories. sample ofD. sardus comprised 23 males, 6 females and Discoglossus montalentii and E. montanus were pro 2 subadults, and that of D. montalentii 2 males, 13 fe jected in different quadrants and their diets were males and 4 subadults.