View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Repository of the Academy's Library Journal of Insect Science, (2018) 18(3): 6; 1–8 doi: 10.1093/jisesa/iey046 Research Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jinsectscience/article-abstract/18/3/6/5001952 by MTA Wigner Research Centre for Physics user on 17 September 2018 The Only Blue Mimeresia (Lepidoptera: Lycaenidae: Lipteninae) Uses a Color-Generating Mechanism Widely Applied by Butterflies Zsolt Bálint,1,5 Szabolcs Sáfián,2 Adrian Hoskins,3 Krisztián Kertész,4 Antal Adolf Koós,4 Zsolt Endre Horváth,4 Gábor Piszter,4 and László Péter Biró4 1Hungarian Natural History Museum, Budapest, Hungary, 2Faculty of Forestry, University of West Hungary, Sopron, Hungary, 3Royal Entomological Society, London, United Kingdom, 4Institute of Technical Physics and Materials Science, Centre for Energy Research, Budapest, Hungary, and 5Corresponding author, e-mail: [email protected] Subject Editor: Konrad Fiedler Received 21 February 2018; Editorial decision 25 April 2018 Abstract The butterflyMimeresia neavei (Joicey & Talbot, 1921) is the only species in the exclusively African subtribal clade Mimacraeina (Lipteninae: Lycaenidae: Lepidoptera) having sexual dimorphism expressed by structurally blue- colored male and pigmentary colored orange–red female phenotypes. We investigated the optical mechanism generating the male blue color by various microscopic and experimental methods. It was found that the blue color is produced by the lower lamina of the scale acting as a thin film. This kind of color production is not rare in day-flying Lepidoptera, or in other insect orders. The biological role of the blue color of M. neavei is not yet well understood, as all the other species in the clade lack structural coloration, and have less pronounced sexual dimorphism, and are involved in mimicry-rings. Key words: Africa, Lycaenidae, mimicry, thin film, wing scale The late John Nevill Eliot in his fundamental work on Lycaenidae blue dorsal wing surface, whilst the female with its bright orange classification subdivided the family into sections, tribes, and sub- appearance is a typical mimeresine. This Lycaenidae clade mimicks families (Eliot 1973, 1990). Subsequently, in co-authorship with the the poisonous African members of the subfamily Acraeinae (Larsen British microscopist John Tilley, he examined the color-generating 2005, D’Abrera 2009). Even their denomination ‘mimacraeina’ scales of various subfamilies, investigating whether the microstruc- reflects this mimicry. This paper is dedicated to explore the blue col- ture characteristics reflect the phylogeny of Lycaenidae (Tilley and oration of this outstanding species with the following aims: 1) to Eliot 2002). The authors extensively sampled the family and sug- document and describe the wing scales, 2) to study and model the gested that the color-producing structures found in the majority of optical properties related to the wing coloration, and 3) to briefly examined species represent the Urania (pepper-pot)-type. They also annotate the results in the light of our present knowledge regarding discovered that some color-generating scales are ‘undifferentiated’ the structural coloration of Lycaenidae. and some species have Morpho-type scales. Tilley and Eliot did not sample species from the Afrotropical Materials and Methods region, where the Lycaenidae fauna is distinctive, especially regard- ing the endemic subfamily Lipteninae (alternatively classified as a Species tribe of Poritiinae by Vane-Wright 2003) and the optically highly Classification: M. neavei: Mimacraeina: Liptenini: Lipteninae: interesting African taxa of the Old-World groups Liphyrinae and Lycaenidae. The genus Mimeresia Stempffer, 1961 (type species: Miletinae. Among the representatives of these assemblages, there are Liptena libentina Hewitson, 1866) has been documented with a many species obviously possessing structural coloration (D’Abrera detailed morphological description by Larsen (2005) and was cata- 2009). Subsequent studies elaborating the structural coloration of loged by D’Abrera (2009). Lycaenidae also lack information on the African taxa (Ingram and The species M. neavei (Joicey and Talbot 1921) (Pseuderesia Parker 2008, Wilts et al. 2009). Among the African mimeresine neavei holotype male, Uganda: ‘West Semliki river, near Lesse’) lycaenids, Mimeresia neavei (Joicey and Talbot 1921) is the only one belongs to the subtribe Mimacraeina (forewing veins 6 and 7 that displays strong sexual dimorphism, having a male with unusual stalked, male genitalia without brachia and brush organ, imagines © The Author(s) 2018. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Entomological Society of America. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/ 1 licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected] 2 Journal of Insect Science, 2018, Vol. 18, No. 3 mimicking other lepidopterans), which comprises 13 recognized at a constant height with a tip velocity of 20 μm/s over the blue wing genera with ~120 species (Eliot 1973: Mimacraea section). In this scale. Decreasing the distance between the tip and surface, we were subtribe, the only species with blue dorsal coloration is M. neavei able to remove the ridges and cross ribs from the scale making visible (D’Abrera 2009). As control species, we examined the congeneric the lower lamina. Mimeresia libentina (Hewitson, 1866). Both species occur in the Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jinsectscience/article-abstract/18/3/6/5001952 by MTA Wigner Research Centre for Physics user on 17 September 2018 Guineo–Congolian forest zone but with different distribution pat- Spectroscopy terns. Caterpillars of all the species of the subtribe are strongly sus- We measured reflectance spectra of the wings with a modular pected to feed on blue–green algae (Bampton 1995). Avantes (Apeldoorn, Netherlands) fiber optic spectrophotometer (HS 1024*122TEC) and a light source (AvaLight DH-S-BAL). All Specimens spectra were recorded against a white reference standard WS-2 The specimens were curated in the Hungarian Natural History (Avantes). For the measurement of the reflected specular component, Museum, Budapest with the following data: M. neavei: ‘Uganda, we used a bifurcated probe oriented normally (perpendicular) to the radio Hill, Mabira Forest, 2010.IV.2–15, leg. Sáfián Sz. and Ward wing. P.’ (male) (Fig. 1), ‘Mpanga Forest, Uganda, Sz. Sáfián’ (female). M. libentina: ‘Ghana, Eastern Region, Asuom Amanfrom, Amanfrom Modeling Forest, Kade district, 2005.III.20–24, leg Sáfián Sz., Csontos G. and The lower laminae of the wing scales were modeled as chitin thin Kormos B. (male)’, ‘Ghana, New-Debiso, Bia NP, 2001. I. 21–23, leg. films using a transfer matrix method (Pendry and MacKinnon 1992, Sáfián Sz’. (female). Yeh 2005). The thickness of the lower lamina of the scales was meas- ured on the cross-sectional TEM images in multiple points. These Optical Microscopy values were averaged and used as input in the simulations. We sim- Optical imaging of the wing scales was carried out using a Zeiss ulated reflectance spectra for normally incident light and compared (Jena, Germany) Axio Imager A1 microscope in reflected light. The the results with the measured spectra. The calculated and measured wing scales stand at an angle of approximately 15° respective to results were transformed into the CIE 1931 chromaticity diagram, the wing membrane, so for better visibility we used focus stacking which represents the human color vision and can be used for the to compensate for the narrow depth of field of the high-resolution comparison of reflectance spectra and for comparing the visual microscope objectives. Single scale images were inspected in reflected impression of color experienced by a human observer. and transmitted light. Scanning and Transmission Electron Microscopy Results (SEM and TEM) Microscopy SEM images were taken using an LEO (Jena, Germany) 1540 XB. The scales of M. neavei are typical of lycaenids: both of the wing Wing pieces were cut and mounted on the sample holder with dou- surfaces are densely covered by two layers of scales. There is one ble-sided conductive tape; also, single scales were placed on con- layer of cover scales and another one of ground scales, both scale- ductive tape. To ensure that the original structure of the wing scales types being shovel-shaped. The wing margins possess narrower and was preserved, no other treatment was applied. For TEM, a few longer scales called fringes (Bálint et al. 2006). However, there are millimeter size wing pieces were embedded in a special resin and some notable differences or specificities. 70 nm thick slices were cut with an ultramicrotome. For better con- Androconia, as the name suggests, are restricted to male individ- trast, the sections were stained, and then inspected, using a Philips uals. It is a well-documented characteristic of the Mimeresini clade (Hillsboro, OR) CM20 TEM apparatus operated at 200 keV accel- (Eliot 1973) that the dorsal forewing veins are swollen and sparsely erating voltage. covered by minute splinter-like scales with ~50 µm in length and 1 µm in width (Fig. 2A). These scales are not present on the hindwing Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) dorsum, or