Designwrites Welcome to the Sixth Edition Focus on Fashion – Clothing of Designwrites Design Cases Sashay Through
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
July 2015 July & DesignWrites Welcome to the sixth edition Focus on fashion – clothing of DesignWrites design cases sashay through At Bird & Bird we’re passionate about design. DesignWrites the UK courts will unravel and explore the seemingly complex world of design Unregistered design rights are an important IP protection, offering practical advice by looking at recent design right in the fashion industry, given that the lives By Hilary Atherton cases, hearing from industry experts and sharing stories from the of clothing designs are often short and may not London wider design community. justify the cost of design registration. [email protected] Get in touch If you would like advice on how best to protect your designs or take action There has been a recent flurry of cases before the UK to stop copycats, please contact Ewan Grist via [email protected] courts concerning rights in fashion designs, specifically unregistered design rights: G-Star Raw v Rhodi Ltd; Superdry v Animal (DKH Retail Ltd v H Young (Operations) Ltd); John Kaldor Fabricmaker UK Ltd v Lee Ann Fashions Ltd; and Dalco v First Dimension (see following pages). Of these four cases (decided between late 2014 and early 2015), three were heard in the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC). Established in 2013, IPEC was intended to provide a less expensive and more streamlined alternative to intellectual property actions in the High Court. Employing strict cost recovery caps of £50,000 and taking In this edition... a proactive approach to case management to reach a swift resolution, IPEC is widely considered to be meeting this aim. Focus on fashion – unregistered design cases Innovation and challenges in architectural sashay through the UK courts ......................................... 01 and community design – Q&A with Hello Wood ................16 The increasing importance of international design Registered Community designs for a plastic fork registrations under the Hague system .............................06 found to be valid and infringed in France ........................20 3D printing & Intellectual Property Lego takes action against copycat – what you need to know ................................................08 toy figures in Poland ....................................................... 23 Blocking validity in The Netherlands – minor variations UK Government announces policy for extension of of earlier designs and the thin line between practicality copyright term for industrially manufactured works ....... 24 and mere functionality ................................................... 10 Designs of the year 2015 ................................................. 27 UK: copyright in tableware surface designs ......................12 Industry news .................................................................31 General Court looks at design freedom Upcoming industry events & awards ............................... 32 in Argo v. OHIM ...............................................................14 Focus on fashion – clothing design cases sashay through the UK courts & 01 Unregistered Rights in the fashion industry Practical tips • There are two categories of unregistered design 1. Keep a design trail. The alleged infringer in John Kaldor right (UDR) in the UK; UK and Community UDR. Fabricmaker UK Ltd v Lee Ann Fashions Ltd was able • Both UK and Community UDR arise automatically and to show credible evidence from its print designer as protect the whole or part of its appearance arising to how, stage-by-stage, she came to design Lee Ann’s from its shape or configuration. However, Community ‘tribal print’ fabric independently of John Kaldor’s UDR also provides protection for the appearance of a tribal fabric design. Conversely, in G-Star Raw v Rhodi product resulting from its colour, texture, materials Ltd, the absence of a paper trail showing how Rhodi and/or ornamentation, and has effect throughout came up with its jeans design contributed to a finding the EU. of infringement. Likewise, in Dalco v First Dimension, an absence of evidence showing that First Dimension’s • Unlike registered designs, in order to succeed in a design pre-dated Dalco’s was fatal to its defence. claim for infringement of UDR (Community or UK), it is Accurate and contemporaneous records of how, when necessary to show that the relevant design was copied and by whom the design was created by are essential. by the alleged infringer. 2. Beware of over reliance on others’ designs. Fashion, • Copyright may also subsist in patterns on fabrics. by its nature, often involves the amalgamation of Copyright is again an unregistered right and arises different aspects of earlier designs. However, inG-Star automatically for original works. Raw, evidence that Rhodi had used a sample of G-Star Raw’s ‘Arc Pant’ to communicate design ideas to the manufacturers of its infringing pants was damaging to its case. 3. Don’t forget copyright. Copyright can sometimes be relied upon in addition to design rights. For example, in John Kaldor, the claimant’s tribal design was created on a computer. Therefore, the relevant computer file was protected by copyright and the design itself (i.e. the output of the computer file) was protected by Community UDR. 4. Don’t necessarily dismiss UK UDR. While Community UDR protects aspects of surface decoration which is not protected under UK design law and colour which will often be central to fashion designs, Community UDR only lasts for 3 years. UK UDRs have a longer life and last for at least 10 years. 02 & Focus on fashion – clothing design cases sashay through the UK courts Recent fashion cases G-Star Raw CV v Rhodi Ltd & Ors [2015] EWHC 216 (Ch) Superdry v Animal (DKH Retail Ltd v H Young John Kaldor Fabricmaker UK Ltd v Lee Ann Dalco v First Dimension [2015] EWHC 760 (IPEC) Date: (Operations) Ltd [2014] EWHC 4034 (IPEC) Fashions Ltd [2014] EWHC 3779 (IPEC) Date: February 2015 Date: Date: February 2015 Court: December 2014 November 2014 Court: High Court Court: Court: Intellectual Property Enterprise Court Rights: Intellectual Property Enterprise Court Intellectual Property Enterprise Court Rights: Unregistered UK design right Rights: Rights: UK & Community unregistered design rights Outcome: UK & Community unregistered design right Unregistered Community design right; copyright Outcome: Infringement Outcome: Outcome: Infringement (summary judgment granted) Rhodi’s nine separate styles of jeans infringed Infringement No infringement First Dimension’s ‘Daniel Rosso’ shirt infringed Dalco’s G-Star’s unregistered UK design rights in its ‘Arc Pant’ H Young’s Animal branded gilet infringed the A dress fabric supplied to Marks & Spencer by Lee unregistered design rights in its ‘Dalco’ shirt design. jeans design, which was characterised by a highly unregistered design rights in parts of DKH’s Superdry Ann did not infringe the copyright or unregistered The two were essentially identical, and First Dimension architectural cut with an asymmetric tapered leg that branded hooded gilet. However, only secondary Community design right in John Kaldor’s fabric as had no prospect of proving that its Daniel Rosso design turned around the human leg. The similarities were infringement by importing and selling was alleged copying could not be proven. Lee Ann’s evidence of pre-dated the Dalco shirt design, or any evidence of striking, there was evidence that Rhodi had used a (for which it must be shown that the alleged infringer independent design was credible, and the similarities independent design. sample of the Arc Pant to communicate design ideas knew or had reason to believe that the articles were between the two designs were not so compelling as to to its manufacturers, and it was unable to produce infringing). Therefore, while Superdry’s unregistered point to unconscious copying. evidence of independent design. Community design rights were found to have been infringed, its UK unregistered design rights were only infringed from the date of Superdry’s cease and desist letter to Animal, as Superdry had produced no evidence to show that those in the clothing industry would otherwise know that copying a garment would constitute an infringement of IP rights. JK Fabric LA Fabric Source: BAILII Database Source: BAILII Database 04 & Focus on fashion – clothing design cases sashay through the UK courts Focus on fashion – clothing design cases sashay through the UK courts & 05 For designs created in the USA, the applicant first needs to The increasing importance of obtain a license from the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) before filing a design registration outside of international design registrations the USA. Unlike many national offices and OHIM which only check for under the Hague system formalities, the national offices in the USA and Japan carry out a substantive examination of design applications, which Two of the world’s biggest economies, namely the USA might lead to correspondence with the examiner and a longer and Japan, recently joined the Hague System for the By Jana Bogatz registration process. International Registration of Industrial Designs. Munich While the registered Community design allows a protection [email protected] in the EU for up to 25 years (five-year terms of renewal), the maximum duration of design protection in Japan is 20 years and only 15 years in the USA. Comments Even though the Community design system is – with International Design Registrations The WIPO only verifies that the application meets all formal