345 Riesling Auslese - Vintage 1976

______418 Vega Sicilia Unico - Vintage 1960 gsl, lwrl, cuc, outstanding color and condition 345 Riesling Auslese - Vintage 1976 (Wines Located in New York) Schloss Vollrads "Very sweet, more earthy."(4 stars MB) 4bsl, 1tl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $500-700 4 bottles per lot $480-600 ______

384 Château Malartic La Graviere - Vintage 1975 434 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2008 Graves cuvée Jules, Lignier-Michelot 3bn, 5ts, 12bsl, 12htal, 4sdc, 2scc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $300-400 ______12 bottles per lot $350-480 450 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1990 385 Château Paveil de Luze - Vintage 1986 Altesino Margaux (Wines Located in New York) 3bn, 6ts, 1vhs, 12lbsl, 5ltl, 3nl, 3lstl, 1tl, 4sdc, "...intense perfumes of jammy cherry fruit, tobacco, 2spc, 1x12 bottle owc, excellent color and smoke, herbs, and licorice, immense richness and condition (Wines Located in New York) extraction of flavor, full body, and gobs of glycerin and alcohol. The single vineyard Montosoli possesses a 12 bottles per lot $350-500 thicker, richer texture, more depth and length, and a ______slightly more focused personality."(90pts)

393 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2009 2 bottles per lot $200-280 ______Clos des Porrets, H. Gouges (Wines Located in New York) PARCEL LOTS 464-465 6 bottles per lot $450-600 ______464 Musigny - Vintage 1961 J. Hudelot 396 Corton - Vintage 1948 5.5cm bc, lbsl, stl, lscl, sdc, outstanding color L. Violland (Wines Located in New York) bsl, lwisl, stc, outstanding color and condition 1 bottle per lot $650-900 (Wines Located in New York)

1 magnum per lot $600-800 465 1 bottle per lot $650-900 lbsl, stl, lscl, tl, sdc, outstanding 397 Vosne Romanée - Vintage 1988 color (Wines Located in New Les Suchots, M. Noellat York) bsl, nl, scc (Wines Located in New York) ______1 bottle per lot $150-200 467 Château Ksara - Vintage 2003 410 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1970 cuvée 3eme Millenaire Jaboulet-Vercherre (Wines Located in New York) 1-3cm bc, 1-3.5cm bc, 1-3.75cm bc, 1-4cm bc, 2- 8 bottles per lot $320-400 4.5cm bc, 1-5cm bc, 7bsl, 7lstl, 7scc, 1ssos, 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 468 Château Ksara - Vintage 2008 7 bottles per lot $350-480 Reserve du Couvent 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 411 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 1970 12 bottles per lot $320-450 Brune et Blonde, Jaboulet-Vercherre 1-3cm bc, 2-3.5cm bc, 1-3.75cm bc, 4-4cm bc, 1- 469 Château Ksara - Vintage 2009 4.5cm bc, 1-5cm bc, 10bsl, 10scc, 2ssos, 1x12 Reserve du Couvent bottle ocb, excellent color (Wines Located in New (Wines Located in New York) York) 5 bottles per lot $240-320 10 bottles per lot $500-650 470 Château Ksara - Vintage 2010 Bordeaux Superieur Reserve du Couvent 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $300-400 9 bottles per lot $200-280 PARCEL LOTS 489-491 471 Château Ksara - Vintage 2011 Reserve du Couvent 489 12 bottles per lot $300-400 3lscl, 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in York) New York) 12 bottles per lot $350-500 490 12 bottles per lot $300-400 472 6 bottles per lot $180-240 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in (Wines Located in New York) New York)

474 Château Bellevue du Galvesse - Vintage 2009 491 12 bottles per lot $300-400 Lalande a Pomerol 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in (Wines Located in New York) New York) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 498 Riesling Beerenauslese - Vintage 2005 Schloss Schonborn 475 Château Blanchon - Vintage 2010 (Wines Located in New York) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 2 half-bottles per lot $150-200 11 bottles per lot $220-300

499 Alvear Solera - Vintage NV 480 Château L'Arrosee - Vintage 2000 1927 St. Emilion 1x12 half bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 3vlscl (Wines Located in New York) "Powerful and decadent young red. Lots of smoky, berry 12 half-bottles per lot $500-700 and cherry character. Full-bodied and very chewy, with loads of fruit. This always impresses me, with its rich 502 Las Rocas - Vintage 2003 and decadent character."(92pts WS) Vinas Viejas 3 bottles per lot $200-280 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $140-200 482 Château L'Arrosee - Vintage 2005 St. Emilion 508 B.V. Reserve Pinot Noir - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Somewhat reminiscent of a Burgundy, the deep ruby/purple-tinged 2005 offers up sweet raspberry and 12 bottles per lot $190-240 forest floor characteristics along with a hint of toasty oak. It hits the palate with beautiful finesse, elegance, 511 Pepperwood Grove Pinot Noir - Vintage 2007 and sweetness. Medium to full-bodied with loads of black currant and raspberry fruit, substantial but sweet (Wines Located in New York) tannin, zesty acidity, and a long finish, this beauty is 12 bottles per lot $120-160 filled with purity, symmetry, and balance. It should hit ______its plateau of maturity in 7-8 years, and last for three decades."(93pts) 547 Corton - Vintage 1985 12 bottles per lot $750-1000 Bonneau du Martray 2ltl, 2wasl, 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) 484 Château la Croix Taillefer - Vintage 2010 2 bottles per lot $300-420 Pomerol ______6lscl (Wines Located in New York) 559 Château Cadillac - Vintage 1982 6 bottles per lot $150-200 6hbsl, 6hwasl, 6htal (Wines Located in New York) 487 Moulin D'Issan - Vintage 2005 6 bottles per lot $150-200 3bn, 6bsl, 6sdc (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $600-800 560 Château Cadillac - Vintage 1983 ______5hbsl, 5hwasl, 5tal (Wines Located in New York) 692 Axios Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 5 bottles per lot $100-130 (Wines Located in New York)

562 Clos de l'Obac 3 bottles per lot $180-240 - Vintage 2000 Costers del Siurana 2bsl, 1tal (2) (Wines Located in New York) 694 Bialla Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) Conca de Barbera 4 bottles per lot $200-280 - Vintage 2000 Abadia de Poblet 2lbsl, 2wasl, (2) 2ltal (Wines Located in New 720 D'Arenberg Shiraz - Vintage 2002 York) The Dead Arm Above 4 bottles per lot $110-150 (Wines Located in New York) ______3 bottles per lot $130-180 ______616 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1997 Castelgiocondo (Frescobaldi) 736 Corton - Vintage 1947 (Wines Located in New York) Bressandes, Piat 2 bottles per lot $180-240 7cm bc, ltl, spc, sos, good color (Wines Located in New York) 619 Brunello di Montalcino 1 bottle per lot $200-280 Riserva, Fornacina - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (2) 737 Riesling Auslese Wehlener Sonnenuhr, Bergweiler-Prum - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 1971 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) Above 4 bottles per lot $150-200 York) - Vintage 1982 scc, sos (Wines Located in (1) 651 Dalla Valle Cabernet Sauvignon New York) - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 2 bottles per lot $130-180 (95pts) - Vintage 1993 lstl (Wines Located in New (1) 738 Riesling Auslese - Vintage 1983 York) (94+pts JK) Wehlener Sonnenuhr, J.J. Prum - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (1) spc (Wines Located in New York) (92-94pts) (91pts WS) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 (93pts WS) ______

768 Diamond Creek Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1985 Dalla Valle Red Gravelly Meadow - Vintage 2005 Casa 1nl (Wines Located in (2) hcrc, ssos, 1x1 9 liter owc (Wines Located in New New York) York) Above 6 bottles per lot $350-450 ______1 9 liter per lot $1200-1800 ______

672 Château Haut Bages Averous - Vintage 1986 PARCEL LOTS 771-773 Pauillac 1vhs, 6bsl, 3wisl (Wines Located in New York) 771 Billecart Salmon Champagne - Vintage NV 6 bottles per lot $300-400 150th Anniversary, 1818-1968 lbsl, tc, outstanding color and condition (Wines 673 Château Langoa Barton - Vintage 1982 Located in New York) St. Julien "Exciting notes of red wine, spices, old wood, ashes, and mushrooms combined with roasted almonds, toffee, 787 4 bottles per lot $95-120 and golden syrup."(94pts RJ) 3vhs, 1hs, 4bsl, 4lstl, 4lscl, 4sdc, 1 bottle per lot $400-500 excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 772 1 bottle per lot $400-500 lbsl, tc, outstanding color and 788 4 bottles per lot $90-120 condition (Wines Located in New 4hs, 4bsl, 4lstl, 2ltl, 1sdc, York) 2excellent color, 2lwrl, 1spc (Wines Located in New York) 773 1 bottle per lot $400-500 lbsl, tc, outstanding color and 803 Rioja - Vintage 1970 condition (Wines Located in New Reserva, Marques de Caceres York) 2bn, 8ts, 2vhs, 12bsl, 12lstl, 11vlscl, 1ltl, ______excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 781 Rioja - Vintage NV 12 bottles per lot $420-600 ______Clarete Crianza, 3 ano, CVNE 1ts, 6vhs, 5hs, 12bsl, 12lscl, 10lstl, 2wisl, 4sdc, 814 Hine Cognac - Vintage NV excellent color (Wines Located in New York) Triomphe, Extra Rare 12 bottles per lot $300-420 (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 782 10 bottles per lot $240-350 ______2ts, 3vhs, 3hs, 2htms, 10bsl, 10lstl, 10ltl, excellent color (Wines 822 Wild Duck Creek Reserve Shiraz - Vintage 2009 Located in New York) 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $300-420 783 8 bottles per lot $180-260 1ts, 4hs, 3htms, 8bsl, 8stl, 3tl, 825 Wild Duck Creek Shiraz - Vintage 2007 2ltl, 3sdc, excellent color (Wines Duck Muck Located in New York) 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $1800-2400 784 Rioja - Vintage NV ______Clarete Crianza, 3 ano, CVNE 1ts, 1hs, 2bsl, (2) 2lwrl, 2ltl, excellent color (Wines Located in New 830 Château Caillou - Vintage 1959 York) Sauternes ts, vlstl, vlwrl, sdc, light amber color (Wines Clarete, 3 ano, CVNE 2vhs, 1hs, 3bsl, 2lscl, 2stl, (3) Located in New York) 1lstl, 1sdc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 Above 5 bottles per lot $120-160 831 Château de Fargues - Vintage 1980 Sauternes 785 Rioja - Vintage NV 2bn, 1wc (Wines Located in New York) Clarete, 3 ano, CVNE 2ts, 1vhs, 2hs, 5bsl, 5stl, 5tl, 1wisl, 2sdc, 1scc, 2 bottles per lot $100-140 ______excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $120-160 848 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1990 Les Fontenys, J. Roty PARCEL LOTS 786-788 ltl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $120-160 786 4 bottles per lot $95-120 ______1ts, 2vhs, 1hs, 4bsl, 4stl, 4lscl, excellent color (Wines Located in 914 Chapelle Chambertin - Vintage 2006 New York) L. Jadot lstl (Wines Located in New York) 1002 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 "...2006 Chapelle-Chambertin from very old vines RBS displays an alluring nose of rose petal and red fruits. In (Wines Located in New York) the mouth, pure, sweet red berry fruit is superbly (91pts) transparent to nuances of an herbal and mineral (peat, iodine, chalk) elements, as an apparently direct result 1 bottle per lot $400-600 of which the finish here is dynamically interactive, a ______virtue reinforced by the wine's vintage-typical sense of buoyancy."(92pts) 1048 Château Angelus - Vintage 2010 1 bottle per lot $110-150 St. Emilion ______(Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $600-800 953 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 2010 Caveau de la Tour 1053 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 1966 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac 2 magnums per lot $420-550 ______ms, lbsl, lgsl, sdc, outstanding color (Wines Located in New York) 992 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 1 bottle per lot $200-260 T6 (Wines Located in New York) 1055 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 2008 1 bottle per lot $350-500 Pauillac 7lscl, 1nc (Wines Located in New York) 997 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 "...exhibits a dark ruby/purple color, more minerality than the 2010 and hints of cedarwood, black currants, Beckstoffer To-Kalon Vineyard underbrush and forest floor. This round, generous blend (Wines Located in New York) of 66.5% Cabernet Sauvignon and 33.5% Merlot should 1 bottle per lot $350-500 easily last for two decades or more."(91pts) 7 bottles per lot $1000-1400 999 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2009 CCS 1056 Château Coutet - Vintage 2009 (Wines Located in New York) Sauternes (96+pts) 1x1 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $400-600 1 bottle per lot $60-80

1000 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2010 PARCEL LOTS 1057-1058 RBS (Wines Located in New York) 1057 Château de Fargues - Vintage 2003 "Super-ripe plums, cassis, mint, mocha and violets Sauternes caress the palate as the 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon RBS (Wines Located in New York) vineyard opens up in the glass. The RBS stands out for its gorgeous inner perfume, sweetness and plushness. 6 bottles per lot $300-400 Layers of fruit build effortlessly as this gracious, highly expressive wine flows through to its plush, generous 1058 6 bottles per lot $300-400 finish. The minerality of the vintage comes alive on the vibrant, beautifully delineated finish laced with sensual 3lbsl (Wines Located in New York) crushed flower overtones. This is another striking wine. "(97pts) PARCEL LOTS 1060-1061 1 bottle per lot $350-450 1060 Pommard - Vintage 2011 1001 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 Les Chanlins, Tres Vieilles Vignes, Domaine Clos de la Chapelle CCS (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) (95pts) 2 bottles per lot $170-240 1 bottle per lot $400-500

1061 2 bottles per lot $170-240 (Wines Located in New York) 1075 Côteaux du Layon - Vintage 2000 SGN, Delesvaux 1062 Volnay - Vintage 2009 (Wines Located in New York) Clos de la Chapelle, Domaine Clos de la Chapelle 6 500 mls per lot $200-300 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $400-500 1079 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 CCS PARCEL LOTS 1064-1065 (Wines Located in New York) (95pts) 1064 Volnay - Vintage 2011 1 bottle per lot $400-500 En Carelle, Domaine Clos de la Chapelle (Wines Located in New York) 1080 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 2 bottles per lot $170-240 CCS 1x4 bottle custom owc (Wines Located in New (1) York) (95pts) 1065 2 bottles per lot $170-240 LPV (Wines Located in New York) (93pts) (1) (Wines Located in New York) RBS (Wines Located in New York) (91pts) (1) PARCEL LOTS 1070-1072 T6 (Wines Located in New York) (93pts) (1) 1070 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2005 Above 4 bottles per lot $1300-1800 cuvée Tradition, Vieilles Vignes, Monpertuis wisl (Wines Located in New York) 1081 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 "Ruby-red. Explosively perfumed, utterly seductive Old Sparky bouquet of raspberry, blackberry, garrigue and 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) minerals. Deep flavors of sweet dark berry liqueur "...reveals lots of cassis, spring flower, graphite and buttressed by vibrant minerality. Silky tannins add spice characteristics along with good minerality. gentle grip to this suave midweight. Deftly combines Medium to full-bodied and strikingly rich, it, too, is a power and finesse, finishing with outstanding sappy great success for the vintage."(95pts) length."(95pts IWC) 1 magnum per lot $800-1000 1 magnum per lot $280-350

1082 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 1071 1 magnum per lot $280-350 RBS (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) (91pts) 1072 1 magnum per lot $280-350 1 bottle per lot $400-500 (Wines Located in New York)

1087 Olivet Lane Estate Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 1073 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2000 Pellegrini Family Vineyard Reserve des Deux Freres, P. Usseglio (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Its inky purple color is accompanied by succulent 4 bottles per lot $80-110 aromas of blackberry, cherry, and raspberry liqueur ______interwoven with licorice, mineral, and acacia flower characteristics. Fabulously concentrated and full- 1089 Matanzas Creek Merlot - Vintage 1979 bodied, with a voluptuous texture, sweet tannin, and a vhs, bsl, hwasl, ssos (Wines Located in New flamboyant and accessible personality, this prodigious, York) majestic Châteauneuf-du-Pape needs to be tasted to be believed."(98pts) 1 bottle per lot $50-70 ______5 bottles per lot $600-800

1090 Château Teyssier - Vintage 2001 1074 Côteaux du Layon - Vintage 1999 3vlscl (Wines Located in New York) SGN, Delesvaux 3 bottles per lot $60-80 (Wines Located in New York) 3 500 mls per lot $120-160 1091 La Chapelle d'Ausone - Vintage 2005 St. Emilion - Vintage 2003 Les Jarollieres, J.M. Boillot (5) (Wines Located in New York) 5bsl, 5nl (Wines Located in 2 bottles per lot $350-500 New York)

1097 The Colonial Estate Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage Volnay 2003 - Vintage 1995 Le Ronceret, J.M. Boillot bsl, (1) Etranger wasl, tl (Wines Located in New 3vlscl (Wines Located in New York) York) 3 bottles per lot $70-90 Above 7 bottles per lot $300-400

1098 The Colonial Estate Shiraz - Vintage 2003 1120 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2005 Explorateur La cuvée du Papet, Clos du Mont Olivet 3vlscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $60-80 3 bottles per lot $240-350 ______

1126 Desiderio - Vintage 1997 1099 Château Ducru Beaucaillou - Vintage 1998 Avignonesi St. Julien 6bsl (Wines Located in New York) 5bsl (Wines Located in New York) "...a blend of 70% Cabernet Sauvignon and 30% 6 bottles per lot $240-320 Merlot. An excellent wine... Classically proportioned with plenty of plum and cassis fruit intermixed with 1127 Desiderio - Vintage 2000 toasty oak as well as minerals, it possesses good power, Avignonesi medium body, excellent richness, and a concentrated, firm, angular finish. It has been well-made."(91pts) (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $500-700 5 bottles per lot $160-220

1104 Château Pontet Canet - Vintage 1999 1128 Sangioveto - Vintage 2004 Pauillac Badia a Coltibuono 3bsl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $170-220 6 bottles per lot $180-240

1107 Vougeot - Vintage 2003 1129 Lupicaia - Vintage 1998 Clos de la Perriere, Bertagna Castello del Terriccio 6bsl, 2tl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $350-500 2 bottles per lot $160-200

1111 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 2005 1131 Valpolicella - Vintage 1994 Chantal Lescure Dal Forno 6bsl, 6wasl (Wines Located in New York) 6bsl (Wines Located in New York) "Most Amarone-like that fragrant, creamy, Amarony 6 bottles per lot $500-700 thing happening nice spice - pepper, caramel, and candle wax combo subtle yet still intoxicating more 1112 Vosne Romanée - Vintage 2004 meaty flavors, and much more alcohol and tannin on Les Suchots, Confuron-Côtetidot palate great length with an alcoholic spice white pepper flavors and someone tasted a 'rubber/tar-like wuality' (Wines Located in New York) best balance of the three within itself."(93pts JK) 12 bottles per lot $900-1200 6 bottles per lot $500-700

1115 Pommard 1136 Messorio - Vintage 2003 - Vintage 2002 Les Jarollieres, J.M. Boillot (1) Le Macchiole bsl, lwasl, lscl, sdc, nc (Wines (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $450-600 1139 Gabbro - Vintage 2004 Kiedricher Grafenberg, R. Weil Montepeloso lbsl, nl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) 1 half-bottle per lot $60-80 3 bottles per lot $300-450 ______

1190 Riesling Auslese - Vintage 1976 1142 Toscana - Vintage 2005 Bernkasteler Doctor, Dr. Thanisch Podere Il Carnasciale lbsl, sdc, scc (Wines Located in New York) 3bsl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $100-140 3 bottles per lot $150-200 ______

1150 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1995 1207 Foxen Cabernet Sauvignon Vasco Sassetti - Vintage 1988 2lwisl, 2nl, 1lwrl, 1nc (2) 3lwrl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $120-150 - Vintage 1989 lscl, lwisl (Wines Located in (1) 1152 Rioja - Vintage 1999 New York) Grandes Anadas, Artadi Above 3 bottles per lot $50-70 12hbsl, 4ltl, 2tl, 2nl (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $750-1000 1210 Castle Rock Pinot Noir - Vintage 2003 Mendocino 2cuc with no top, 4sdc (Wines Located (6) 1155 Clos de l'Obac - Vintage 2003 in New York) Costers del Siurana Carneros 1cuc with no top (Wines Located in New (5) 10bsl (Wines Located in New York) York) 10 bottles per lot $400-600 Landmark Pinot Noir - Vintage 2007 Grand Detour (Wines Located (1) 1157 Gran Vinya Son Caules - Vintage 2003 in New York) M. Gelabert 12lbsl (Wines Located in New York) Above 12 bottles per lot $75-100 ______12 bottles per lot $240-320 1216 Herb Lamb Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1158 3 bottles per lot $60-80 2010 3bsl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $180-240 1159 Mas la Plana Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1990 ______Gran Reserva, M. Torres 1218 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2002 6bsl, 2tl (Wines Located in New York) Hirsch Vineyard 6 bottles per lot $260-350 lwasl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $120-160 1160 Cims de Porrera - Vintage 1997 Mas Martinet 1219 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2002 6bsl, 6lwasl (Wines Located in New York) Sonoma Coast 6 bottles per lot $200-280 lwasl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 1165 Ribera del Duero - Vintage 2003 Regina Vides, Vina Sastre (Bodegas Hermanos Sastre) 1220 Mr. K - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) Nobleman, Sine Qua Non 1x3 half bottle custom half- 3 bottles per lot $180-240 bottle (1) ______owc (Wines Located in New York) (98pts) 1170 Riesling Auslese - Vintage 2001 Strawman, Sine Qua Non (Wines Located in New half- bottle (1) Pauillac York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 2 half-bottles per lot $240-320 "A solid, well-built '95. Lovely chocolate, berry and ______tobacco aromas, with a hint of vanilla. Full-bodied, with velvety tannins and a long, flavorful finish. The 1223 Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese - Vintage 2003 best second label of Pauillac?..."(91pts) wehlener sonnenuhr, #12, S. A. Prum 1 bottle per lot $150-200 ______(Wines Located in New York)

1 half-bottle per lot $120-180 1360 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2011 ______Vieilles Vignes, Lignier-Michelot 1225 Château Magdelaine - Vintage 2007 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) St. Emilion 12 bottles per lot $500-700 (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $90-120 1362 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 2009 Lignier-Michelot 1226 5 bottles per lot $200-280 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $900-1200 ______

1241 Heidseick & Co Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1979 1382 Château Belle Vue Diamant Bleu - Vintage 2000 2lscl (Wines Located in New (2) outstanding color and condition (Wines Located York) in New York) 1 bottle per lot $450-600 Château Calon Segur - Vintage 2000 St. Estephe (Wines Located in (1) 1242 Pommery Champagne New York) (94pts) - Vintage NV Brut Royal 1lscl, 2x1 bottle (2) ocb's (Wines Located in New Château Cormeil Figeac York) - Vintage 2005 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (2) New York) Brut Dargent Sparkling Wine Above 5 bottles per lot $190-240 - Vintage 1984 Methode Champenoise (Wines (1) Located in New York) 1388 Château du Tertre - Vintage 2005 Above 3 bottles per lot $80-110 Margaux 1x6 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) 1243 Valpolicella - Vintage 1996 6 magnums per lot $600-800 La Grola, Allegrini (Wines Located in New York) 1389 Château Ducru Beaucaillou - Vintage 1982 2 magnums per lot $220-300 St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) "...the 1982 Ducru-Beaucaillou is unquestionably the 1247 Fetzer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1986 best wine made at this estate since 1961. The Barrel Select concentrated, viscous, dark ruby/purple color is scc (Wines Located in New York) followed by explosive aromas of spring flowers, blackcurrants, minerals, and toast. It is fuller-bodied 1 double magnum per lot $70-90 than normal, with remarkable delineation, great richness, and that wonderful sweetness that is a 1248 Brick House Pinot Noir - Vintage 1994 hallmark of this vintage."(94pts) 6sdc, 2scc (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 9 bottles per lot $200-280 ______1390 Château Gigault - Vintage 2000 cuvée Viva, Côtes de Blaye (3) 1259 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) Château Grand Ormeau - Vintage 2003 1nl (Wines Located in New (6) - Vintage 2000 Lalande a Pomerol (Wines (3) York) Located in New York) Above 9 bottles per lot $160-220 Above 6 bottles per lot $240-300 1433 Rasteau - Vintage 2000 1394 Château Roc de Cambes - Vintage 2000 Domaine Gourt de Mautens Côtes de Bourg (Wines Located in New York) 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 9 bottles per lot $220-280 6 bottles per lot $240-300 1440 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 1396 Les Plantiers du Haut-Brion - Vintage 2000 cuvée du Papet, Mont Olivet Graves (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 3 bottles per lot $150-200 1449 Taittinger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1964 1402 Vougeot - Vintage 1999 Comtes de Champagne Clos Prieur, Domaine de la Vougeraie vhs, lstl, sos, outstanding color (Wines Located in 4lscl, 1ltl (Wines Located in New York) New York) 6 bottles per lot $350-500 "Comtes at its best, with its lively, deep yellow appearance. Full bodied, fat, oily, and creamy. Packed with aromas from dried fruits, magnificently rich and 1424 Morey St. Denis Blanc - Vintage 2000 smooth with the same softness and sweetness in the long Les Larrets, F. Magnien aftertaste." (96pts RJ) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $600-900 6 bottles per lot $200-280 1457 Riesling 1428 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1997 Senftenberger Hochacker, Nigel (2) - Vintage 1998 Château Cabrieres nl (Wines (1) Urgesteins (Wines Located in Located in New York) New York)

Tete de Cru Prestige, Château (1) Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese Cabrieres nl, sdc (Wines - Vintage 2005 Trittenheimber Apotheke, half-bottle (2) Located in New York) Clusserath-Weiler 2lbsl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2007 Beaurenard (Wines Located in (1) Above 2 half-bottles per lot $170-240 New York) and 2 bottles cuvée Boisrenard, Beaurenard (1) (Wines Located in New York) 1462 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1999 Le Fonti, Molinari Carlo Côtes du Rhône 1sdc, 2spc (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2009 Pian De Dieu, Calendal (Wines (3) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 Located in New York) 1471 Conn Creek Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1976 Côtes Du Ventoux 1vhs, 1hs, 2lbsl, 2lscl, 2scc, 2ssos (Wines Located - Vintage 2001 Les Terrasses, Château Pesquie (1) in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $120-160 Above 8 bottles per lot $220-300 1481 Stanton Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 1430 Rasteau (Wines Located in New York) La Ponce, Domaine des Escaravailles 3 bottles per lot $150-180 - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (3) 1482 Behrens & Hitchcock Syrah Arrowood Reserve Chardonnay - Vintage 2001 Hommage to Ed Oliveira, Alder (2) - Vintage 1997 cuvée Michel Berthaud 1lscl (2) Springs Vineyard 1nl (Wines (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) Hollywood and Vine Chardonnay Brewer-Clifton Pinot Noir - Vintage 2000 2480 (Wines Located in New (2) - Vintage 2003 Melville (Wines Located in New (1) York) York) Pride Mountain Viognier Buzzard Tree Meritage - Vintage 2003 vlscl (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (7) York) Above 10 bottles per lot $240-300 Saintsbury Chardonnay 1483 Dumol Pinot Noir - Vintage 2001 - Vintage 2009 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (2) Finn (Wines Located in New York) Above 2 half-bottles per lot $200-260 and 7 bottles 2 bottles per lot $140-180

1492 Newton Chardonnay - Vintage 1997 1485 Dumol Pinot Noir 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2002 Russian River Valley (Wines (1) Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $140-180

Ryan (Wines Located in New (2) 1493 Patrius Chardonnay - Vintage 2000 York) Keefer Ranch Vineyard - Vintage 2005 Ryan (Wines Located in New (1) 6sdc (Wines Located in New York) York) 12 bottles per lot $180-240

Dumol Syrah 1496 Highbank Red - Vintage 2001 Eddie's Patch (Wines Located (2) - Vintage 1997 Coonawarra (Wines Located in (2) in New York) New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $280-400 R.L. Buller Muscat 1487 Lewis Cellars Reserve Merlot - Vintage NV Fine (Wines Located in New half-bottle (3) - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (1) York)

Rosenblum Petite Syrah Schwarz Rose - Vintage 1999 Pickett Vineyard 1nl (Wines (3) - Vintage 1999 The Butcher (Wines Located in half- Located in New York) bottle (2) New York) Rosenblum Zinfandel Above 5 half-bottles per lot $110-150 - Vintage 2001 Alegria Vineyard (Wines (1) and 2 bottles Located in New York) Above 5 bottles per lot $110-150 1498 Trevor Jones Reserve Shiraz - Vintage 1997 Wild Witch 1489 Whitethorn Winery Pinot Noir - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $150-200 4 bottles per lot $90-120 ______

1490 Alban Vineyards Viognier 1508 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1999 - Vintage 2004 1lscl, 1lwrl (Wines Located in (2) C. Dugat New York) 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) "The medium to dark ruby-colored 1999 Gevrey- "Semillon-dominated aromas of dried apricot, wet stone Chambertin reveals lovely red cherry, sweet oak and earth. Fatter and richer than the 2002, but less aromas. This pure, lush, medium-bodied wine is velvety- tightly wound and gripping today. But this has lovely textured and filled with violets and candied cherries. It underlying sweetness and really spreads out and lingers is plush, opulent, and reveals sweet, supple tannins in on the finish."(90+?pts IWC) its fresh, long finish."(90pts) 4 bottles per lot $800-1000 3 bottles per lot $300-400 ______1563 Montepulciano D'Abruzzo - Vintage 1998 1515 Château Belair - Vintage 1995 Emidio Pepe St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) 3lscl, 1nl, 1spc (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 12 bottles per lot $400-600 ______

1517 Château Belair - Vintage 1998 1564 Dehlinger Pinot Noir - Vintage 2004 St. Emilion Goldridge Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (3) (Wines Located in New York) Russian River Valley (Wines Located in New York) (3) 2 bottles per lot $80-110 Above 6 bottles per lot $200-260 ______1519 Château Monbousquet - Vintage 2000 St. Emilion 1569 Veuve Clicquot Vintage Champagne 1nl (Wines Located in New York) Trilogy (93pts) - Vintage 1988 1x3 bottle custom owc (1) 6 bottles per lot $500-700 (Wines Located in New York) ______- Vintage 1989 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 1526 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2012 Colesworthy - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New (1) 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) York) (94pts RJ) "This is deep, rich, full, backward and not quite as easy Above 3 bottles per lot $500-700 to access as its sibling, although at some point the ______Schraders and Thomas Brown thought these were the best barrels from Las Piedras. It seems to share much of its siblings opaque purple color, lots of coffee, 1577 Mr. K - Vintage 2000 blackberry and cassis fruit, charcoal and graphite, but Vin de Glace, Sine Qua Non seems to also require more bottle age to round into 1x3 half bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) shape."(95pts) 3 half-bottles per lot $350-500 1 magnum per lot $600-800 ______1581 Château Bellevue - Vintage 2003 1538 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1975 St. Emilion Sauternes 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) lbsl, lstl, nl, amber color (Wines Located in New "This 15+ acre estate, situated on a south/southwest- York) facing slope, has been making sensational wines since "The nose has it all - a Marilyn of a wine the nose is so 2000, when the management of the vineyard and thick it exudes richness so many things going on, winemaking were taken over by Nicolas Thienpont and adjectives would do it a disservice honey, baked Stephane Derenoncourt. The 40-year-old, bio- something, Crème brulee, grilled almonds, orange dynamically farmed vineyard is planted with 80% peel/flowers loads of caramel and full of structure Merlot and 20% Cabernet Franc. The 2003 possesses fabulous spice and alcohol on the finish honey flavors superb ripeness as well as a stony, mineral liqueur-like and hints of apricots outstanding, huge, intensity, a reticent but promising perfume of black lingering."(99pts JK) raspberries, sweet kirsch, and blacker fruits, a full- bodied, powerful, concentrated attack and mid-palate, 1 bottle per lot $600-800 and a blockbuster, long, powerful, moderately tannic finish. It is an infant..."(93+pts) 1541 Château Laville Haut Brion - Vintage 2001 12 bottles per lot $500-700 Graves 1lwisl, 2lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 1585 Château Lynsolence - Vintage 2000 Clos de los Siete St. Emilion - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Above 5 bottles per lot $130-180 (90pts) 12 bottles per lot $400-600 1617 Marilyn Merlot ______- Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 1596 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1970 - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Grande cuvée, A. Ogier et Fils 6lbsl, 6lwasl, 3nl, excellent color and condition - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1998 nl (Wines Located in New (1) 10 pints per lot $550-700 ______York) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 1598 Château Puy Blanquet - Vintage 2005 Above 5 bottles per lot $350-480 St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) 1618 Marilyn Merlot 35 bottles per lot $500-700 - Vintage 2000 lscl (Wines Located in New York) (1) 1607 Amarone - Vintage 2001 - Vintage 1997 Lamberti (Wines Located in (1) (Wines Located in New York) (1) New York) - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Brunello di Montalcino Norma Jeane (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1995 Il Marroneto lscl (Wines (1) Located in New York) - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Cepparello - Vintage 2004 - Vintage 2000 Isole e Olena (Wines Located in (1) (Wines Located in New York) (1) New York) Norma Jean (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 7 bottles per lot $260-350 Toscana ______- Vintage 2000 IL Borro (Wines Located in (2) New York) 1622 Mr. K - Vintage 2006 Nobleman, Sine Qua Non Above 5 bottles per lot $130-180 (Wines Located in New York)

1614 Montevetrano - Vintage 2000 1 half-bottle per lot $120-160 S. Imparato wisl (Wines Located in New York) 1623 Mr. K - Vintage 2006 Strawman, Sine Qua Non 1 bottle per lot $60-80 (Wines Located in New York) 1 half-bottle per lot $120-160 1616 Flowers Pinot Noir ______- Vintage 2001 Keefer Ranch 2nl (Wines (2) Located in New York) 1640 Musigny - Vintage 1999 C. Confuron Saintsbury Pinot Noir (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1998 Brown Ranch (Wines Located (1) 2 bottles per lot $750-1000 in New York) 1649 Pommard - Vintage 2009 Rex Hill Reserve Pinot Noir Les Rugiens, Domaine de Montille - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 2 bottles per lot $70-90 ______

1650 Pommard - Vintage 2010 1788 Salon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1982 Les Rugiens, Domaine de Montille Le Mesnil (Wines Located in New York) lscl (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $900-1200 "It took a few years before the '82 really found itself. Now it is wonderfully harmonious, if a little uneven 1656 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 2003 from bottle to bottle. A classic Salon with brilliant acidity and an exceptionally dry aftertaste of lanolin Forey and butter."(96pts RJ) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $550-850 1 bottle per lot $120-160 ______

1726 Cepparello 1791 Château de Bellevue - Vintage 1998 Isole e Olena St. Emilion - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $120-160 - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) (3) Above 4 bottles per lot $220-300 1792 Château de Chantegrieve - Vintage 2009 ______Graves PARCEL LOTS 1771-1772 1wrl, 1lll (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $260-350 1771 Jameson Whiskey - Vintage NV Rarest Reserve PARCEL LOTS 1794-1795 bottled in 2007, 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) 1794 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 cuvée Marie Beurrier, H. Bonneau 1 bottle per lot $300-400 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "Shows the roasted, slightly burly edge of the vintage, 1772 1 bottle per lot $300-400 but the grilled chestnut, dark bittersweet cocoa, maduro bottled in 2009, 1x1 bottle ogb tobacco, licorice root and black currant paste notes are (Wines Located in New York) still defined and distinctive, delivering iron and roasted apple wood notes that pound through the long, tannic finish. A gloriously old-school style."(95pts WS) 1774 Saxum Syrah - Vintage 2011 12 bottles per lot $2400-3200 Bone Rock (Wines Located in New York) 1795 12 bottles per lot $2400-3200 3 bottles per lot $500-700 ______6wc (Wines Located in New York)

1776 Château Faizeau - Vintage 2005 1796 10 bottles per lot $2000-3000 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) ______6 bottles per lot $120-160 1798 Château Latour a Pomerol - Vintage 1982 1777 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1959 Pomerol Sauternes 2ts, 2bsl (Wines Located in New York) ts, bsl, ltl, mahogany color (Wines Located in "...offer a dark ruby/garnet-colored wine, with an New York) intensely fragrant, forceful, spicy, sweet, pain grillee, "Richly coloured from the start, a deep, somewhat black-cherry, mocha, and herb-scented nose. Lush, musky nose, soft ripe and luscious..."(5 stars MB) opulent flavors cascade across the palate with no astringency or tartness. It is a plump, fleshy, delicious 1 bottle per lot $1300-1700 wine that can be drunk now or held for another ______decade."(93pts) 1780 Volker Eisele Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 2 bottles per lot $500-650 (Wines Located in New York) 1799 Château Latour a Pomerol - Vintage 1983 1814 Merlot/Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 Pomerol Iugum, P. Dipoli 1ts, 1vhs, 6bsl, 2tl (Wines Located in New York) 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $600-900 23 bottles per lot $280-380 ______

1804 Almansa Red 1817 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2005 - Vintage 2000 Crianza, Bodegas Tintoralba (9) Domaine & Selection, M.L.V. 1nl (Wines Located in New (Wines Located in New York) York) 4 bottles per lot $300-400 ______St. Francis Zinfandel - Vintage 1997 Old Vines tl (Wines Located in magnum 1851 MX Wines Zinfandel - Vintage 2004 (1) Amnesia New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 9 bottles per lot $70-100 4 bottles per lot $160-220 ______and 1 magnum ______1873 Brillet Cognac - Vintage NV 1806 Napoleon Cognac - Vintage NV V.S.O.P Reserve Tres vieille fine cognac, Canonnier (Wines Located in New York) 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $40-60 ______1 bottle per lot $150-200 ______1878 Château Clarke PARCEL LOTS 1807-1811 - Vintage 2003 Listrac (Wines Located in New (1) York) 1807 Merlot - Vintage 2001 Fihl, P. Dipoli Côtes du Rhône Blanc 2x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2003 St. Cosme (Wines Located in (5) 24 bottles per lot $300-400 New York)

1808 24 bottles per lot $300-400 Côteaux d'aix en Provence - Vintage 2003 2x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in Commanderie de la Bargemone (Wines Located in (6) New York) New York) Rose, Commanderie de la Bargemone (Wines (8) 1809 24 bottles per lot $300-400 Located in New York) 2x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) Keller Chardonnay - Vintage 2002 La Cruz Vineyard (Wines (3) 1810 24 bottles per lot $300-400 Located in New York) 2x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in Above 23 bottles per lot $160-220 New York) ______PARCEL LOTS 1889-1890 1811 24 bottles per lot $300-400 2x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in 1889 Rioja - Vintage 1976 New York) Reserva Especial, Martinez Lacuesta 12scc (Wines Located in New York) 1812 Merlot/Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 12 bottles per lot $1200-1600 Alto Adige, P. Dipoli 3x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 1890 12 bottles per lot $1200-1600 36 bottles per lot $450-600 12cc (Wines Located in New York) 1892 12 bottles per lot $1000-1400 St. Julien 1bsl, 1tl, 12cc (Wines Located in (Wines Located in New York) New York) "...reveals an impressively saturated black/purple color, ______followed by a sweet, chocolatey, cassis-scented nose with hints of hickory smoke, toast, and charcoal. The 1899 Charles Melton Red - Vintage 1999 wine is low in acidity, with excellent, possibly outstanding concentration, a layered feel in the mouth Nine Popes which adds to the appealing texture, and a long, thick, (Wines Located in New York) sumptuous, tannic finish."(90pts) 6 bottles per lot $180-240 2 bottles per lot $220-300 ______

1921 Château Margaux - Vintage 1982 1907 Saxum Red - Vintage 2010 Margaux James Berry Vineyard (Wines Located in New (1) ts, lstl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) York) (96+pts) "We transitioned to the remaining four First Growths in Terry Hoage Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (1) the next flight, beginning with a phenomenal bottle of Above 2 bottles per lot $240-320 1982 Margaux (sourced from Château). The Margaux ______had a pungent nose, and its t n a jumped out at first. It also had cinnamon, iron, rock and gorgeous perfume. It 1915 Château Clerc Milon - Vintage 1970 was beyond licorice according to Dan, and Australian John admired its cherry liqueur. The palate was rocky Pauillac without the horror but with the picture show, not its 3ts, 3vhs, 6lwrl, 6lstl, outstanding color and usual feminine self, Ray observed. Though spiny and condition (Wines Located in New York) long, the Margaux was still stylish with a touch of that Margaux elegance. This was a great bottle of this wine, 6 bottles per lot $600-800 and it ended up being wine of the flight, outshowing all the other First Growths."(97pts JK) 1916 Château Haut Brion - Vintage 1999 1 bottle per lot $800-1100 Graves 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) 1922 Château Palmer - Vintage 1990 "Great nose - has an Italian quality of tar, leather, and Margaux saucy fruit...loads of cassis and dark undertones of leather, earth, cherry, plum, yeast, chocolate...great 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) balance and definition...long finish with nice "A beauty. Seductive, with currant, berry, tobacco, spiciness...flavors of peanut oil, black fruits, chocolate cedar and flowers on the nose. Full-bodied, with silky and cedar...my wine of the night, nosing out the tannins and a long, caressing finish. A joyous Margaux...wish I could have tasted them side by side, Palmer."(92pts WS) but it was not my tasting."(94+pts JK) 3 bottles per lot $650-850 3 bottles per lot $1000-1400 1923 Château Pavie Decesse - Vintage 2000 1918 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1995 St. Emilion St. Julien 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The wine is full-bodied, rich, with striking purity, "Exceptionally ripe cassis fruit, the judicious use of fabulous delineation, immense body and extract, and toasty new oak, and a thrilling mineral character sweet but high levels of tannin in the finish, which goes intertwined with the high quality of fruit routinely on for nearly one minute. This is undoubtedly the obtainedby Las Cases, make this a compelling effort greatest Pavie Decesse ever produced and a modern- The finish is incredibly long in this classic."(95pts) day Bordeaux legend. At one-half the price of its sibling, Pavie, it should be obvious what readers should 2 bottles per lot $350-500 do!..."(96pts) 5 bottles per lot $550-750 1919 Château Leoville Poyferre - Vintage 1970 St. Julien 1924 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 2001 1bn, 1hs, 1stl, 1gsl, 1nl, 1sdc, 1spc, outstanding Sauternes color (Wines Located in New York) removed from owc (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $180-240 "...with airing, it offers up honeyed tropical fruit, orange marmalade, pineapple, sweet creme brulee, and 1920 Château Leoville Poyferre - Vintage 1995 buttered nut-like scents. In the mouth, it is full-bodied with gorgeously refreshing acidity as well as massive concentration and unctuosity. Everything is uplifted and "...emerges from the glass with an exotic array of tar, given laser-like focus by refreshing acidity. This large- smoke, licorice and grilled herbs. There is wonderful scaled, youthful Yquem appears set to take its place intensity to the fruit and plenty of structure. The tannins among the most legendary vintages of the are still a touch young and the wine is only now past..."(100pts) beginning to enter the early part of what looks to be a long drinking window!"(95pts) 8 bottles per lot $4200-5500 2 bottles per lot $550-750 1925 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2008 La Combe d'Orveau, Faiveley 1938 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1990 3tl (Wines Located in New York) Mastrojanni "The detailed, fresh and racy middle weight flavors 8sdc, 3ssos, 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in however are cool, pure, defined and exude a fine stony New York) character that also suffuses the long and palate staining "Big, ripe and full-bodied, this tannic monster still finish. This is unmistakably Chambolle."(91pts BH) manages to show a lot of class. Offers tons of earth, red 3 bottles per lot $260-350 berry and black cherry notes. It's like a volcano waiting to erupt..."(94pts WS) 1928 Romanée St. Vivant - Vintage 2002 9 bottles per lot $950-1200 N. Potel 1lstl (Wines Located in New York) 1939 Barolo - Vintage 2004 "Good full red. High-toned, superripe aromas of La Villa, Seghesio raspberry, cocoa powder, flowers and underbrush. Very (Wines Located in New York) dense and distinctly high-toned, with leafy and menthol notes to go with the raspberry flavors. Conveys a strong 10 bottles per lot $600-800 impression of terroir..."(90pts IWC) 3 bottles per lot $550-750 1941 Perlato del Bosco - Vintage 1997 Tua Rita 1932 Ermitage Blanc - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) de l'Oree, M. Chapoutier 3 bottles per lot $260-350 2tl, different importers (Wines Located in New York) 1942 San Martino - Vintage 1997 "...this wine flirts with perfection. It is a compelling Villa Cafaggio white Hermitage. Made from 100% Marsanne, it is as 5lscl (Wines Located in New York) rich and multidimensional as the fullest, most massive Montrachet money can buy. It is unctuously textured, 8 bottles per lot $450-600 yet extraordinarily and beautifully balanced. I suspect it will drink well early in life, and then shut down for a 1943 Abreu Red - Vintage 2010 few years. It should last for 4-5 decades. The 1996 possesses some of the most amazing glycerin levels I Rothwell Hyde have ever seen in a dry white wine. In short, this wine (Wines Located in New York) must be tasted to be believed."(99pts) 3 bottles per lot $480-600 2 bottles per lot $350-500 1944 B.R. Cohn Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1996 1933 Ermitage Blanc - Vintage 2003 Olive Hill de l'Oree, M. Chapoutier (Wines Located in New York) lscl (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $320-450 1 bottle per lot $180-240 1945 Blankiet Red - Vintage 2011 1934 Krug Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1976 Rive Droite scl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Loads of Krug aromas and voluptuousness, gigantic 6 bottles per lot $650-850 body, and warm fruit."(95pts RJ) 1 bottle per lot $700-900 1946 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 Beckstoffer To-Kalon Vineyard 1936 Barbaresco - Vintage 1990 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) Gaja "Exotic spicy, toasty, cedary oak turns taut, with firm, 2lscl, 2lgsl (Wines Located in New York) chewy, loamy earth, currant, anise, sage and mineral flavors that are tightly wound. Finishes with full-bodied Vineyard comes from clone 337, from a Beckstoffer- tannins"(94pts WS) owned vineyard in Rutherford. Its dense purple color is followed by a big, sweet nose of black cherries, black 2 bottles per lot $700-900 currants, cedar, spice box, and subtle oak. Enormously concentrated and full-bodied with superb minerality as 1948 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2007 well as tannic structure, it will benefit from 4-5 years of Beckstoffer To-Kalon Vineyard bottle age, and should evolve for three decades. "(97+pts) 1x2 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "The 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Beckstoffer To-Kalon 1 bottle per lot $350-500 Vineyard Schrader, which comes from clone 4 and clone 6, from two separate blocks, is another prodigious 1954 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 Cabernet. It boasts stunning concentration, a dense purple color, plenty of crushed rock, floral, black GIII currant, pain grille, and spice box notes, and (Wines Located in New York) outstanding ripeness as well as richness. Forget it for 3- (97pts) 4 years, and enjoy it over the following 25+."(96+pts) 1 bottle per lot $350-500 2 bottles per lot $750-1000 1955 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2009 1949 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 GIII Beckstoffer To-Kalon Vineyard nl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) (95pts) 1 bottle per lot $500-700 1 bottle per lot $300-400

1950 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 1956 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2010 Beckstoffer To-Kalon Vineyard 1x4 bottle custom (1) GIII owc (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $400-600 CCS 1x4 bottle custom owc (Wines Located in New (1) York) (95pts) 1959 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 RBS (Wines Located in New York) (91pts) (1) RBS lscl (Wines Located in New York) T6 (Wines Located in New York) (93pts) (1) (97pts) Above 4 bottles per lot $1300-1900 1 bottle per lot $300-400

1951 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 1960 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2010 CCS RBS (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon CCS, which is clone 4 "Super-ripe plums, cassis, mint, mocha and violets from block C1, displays a bit more depth and tannic caress the palate as the 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon RBS structure. Its inky/ruby/purple color is accompanied by vineyard opens up in the glass. The RBS stands out for sensational aromas of creme de cassis, scorched earth, its gorgeous inner perfume, sweetness and plushness. acacia flowers, licorice, cedar, and grilled meats. Pure, Layers of fruit build effortlessly as this gracious, highly full-bodied, and powerful."(95pts) expressive wine flows through to its plush, generous 1 bottle per lot $750-1000 finish. The minerality of the vintage comes alive on the vibrant, beautifully delineated finish laced with sensual crushed flower overtones. This is another striking wine. 1952 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 "(97pts) CCS lstl, ltl, 1x2 bottle custom owc (Wines (1) 2 bottles per lot $700-900 Located in New York) (100pts) RBS (Wines Located in New York) (99pts) (1) 1961 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 Above 2 bottles per lot $950-1300 RBS (Wines Located in New York) 1953 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2007 (91pts) GIII 4 bottles per lot $1200-1600 (Wines Located in New York) "The 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Beckstoffer George III 1963 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 T6 1982 Paul Lato Pinot Noir - Vintage 2010 (Wines Located in New York) Lancelot Pisoni Vineyards (93pts) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $320-450 1 bottle per lot $140-180

1964 Boar's View Pinot Noir - Vintage 2012 1985 Paul Lato Pinot Noir - Vintage 2010 The Coast Seabiscuit, Zotovich Vineyard 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $1200-1600 1 bottle per lot $180-240

1965 Booker Vineyard Red - Vintage 2008 1987 Paul Lato Pinot Noir - Vintage 2011 Vertigo The Prospect, Sierra Madre Vineyard 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $450-600 1 bottle per lot $180-240

1966 Booker Vineyard Red - Vintage 2009 1989 Penfold's Shiraz - Vintage 2007 Vertigo Magill Estate Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $200-280 2 magnums per lot $650-850 ______1969 Booker Vineyard Syrah - Vintage 2008 1994 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1970 Fracture Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) vhs, hwasl, nl, outstanding color (Wines Located 1 bottle per lot $100-140 in New York) "Deep garnet; fragrant tar and black truffle nose; 1971 Booker Vineyard Syrah - Vintage 2010 extremely concentrated; big and mouth-filling, with very Fracture dense cassis flavor; enormous, generous fruit; a (Wines Located in New York) voluptuous claret."(96pts WS) 4 bottles per lot $300-400 1 bottle per lot $350-500

1973 Booker Vineyard Syrah - Vintage 2008 1996 Barolo - Vintage 1967 Fracture 24 Riserva del Centenario, G. Contratto (Wines Located in New York) bn, wasl, bsl, ltl, sdc, outstanding color (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $120-160 1 bottle per lot $180-240 ______1974 Booker Vineyard Syrah - Vintage 2007 Fracture 28 2007 Hine Vintage Cognac - Vintage 1982 (Wines Located in New York) Grande Champagne 1 bottle per lot $90-120 4x1 bottle ogb's (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $800-1100 1975 Booker Vineyard Syrah - Vintage 2007 ______Vertigo (Wines Located in New York) 2012 Saxum Red - Vintage 2010 Paderewski Vineyard 1 bottle per lot $90-120 (Wines Located in New York)

1977 Paul Lato Pinot Noir - Vintage 2008 3 bottles per lot $300-400 ______Duende, Gold Coast Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 2016 Terlato Red 1 bottle per lot $110-150 - Vintage 2002 Episode (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) Episode (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2007 Torbreck Red Galaxy (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2001 Woodcutter's Red lscl (Wines (1) Above 3 bottles per lot $190-260 Located in New York) ______Above 19 bottles per lot $100-150

2018 Château de Callac Blanc - Vintage 1996 2037 Grant Burge Red - Vintage 1998 cuvée Prestige, Graves The Holy Trinity (Wines Located in New York) 2nl (Wines Located in New York) 11 bottles per lot $110-150 10 bottles per lot $150-200 ______2019 Hess Select Chardonnay - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) 2039 Charles de Fere Sparkling Wine - Vintage NV 10 bottles per lot $40-60 cuvée Jean Louis, Blanc de Blancs ______1ltl (Wines Located in New York) 30 bottles per lot $150-200 2024 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 1975 Pauillac 2040 Aetna Springs Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 12bn, 12lbsl, 4lgsl, 2nl, 12sdc, 2scc, excellent (Wines Located in New York) color and condition (Wines Located in New York) 30 bottles per lot $300-400 12 bottles per lot $1500-2000

2043 Rosemount Cabernet Sauvignon 2025 9 bottles per lot $1100-1500 - Vintage 2000 Show Reserve (Wines Located (1) 4bn, 1ts, 3vhs, 1hs, 9bsl, 9lgsl, in New York) 3ltl, 1lwrl, 6sdc, 7scc (Wines Located in New York) ______Rosemount Estate Shiraz - Vintage 1998 Mountain Blue (Wines Located (1) 2026 Château Belle Vue - Vintage 1999 in New York) 2lstl, 6 bottles different importer (Wines Located - Vintage 2001 Hill of Gold (Wines Located in (1) in New York) New York) 12 bottles per lot $260-350 Rosemount Estate Syrah 2028 Joseph Phelps Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 Balmoral 2lbsl (Wines Located (3) - Vintage 1994 Napa Valley (Wines Located in (1) in New York) New York) Rusden Red Stonestreet Red - Vintage 2002 Ripper Creek (Wines Located in (1) - Vintage 1994 Legacy (Wines Located in New (2) New York) York) Tahbilk Shiraz Villa Mt. Eden Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 8 bottles per lot $200-280 ______Above 4 bottles per lot $160-220 ______2084 Querciabella - Vintage 1997 2034 Arrowood La Rose Camartina, Querciabella - Vintage 2003 1lwisl, 3sdc (Wines Located in (3) (Wines Located in New York) New York) 1 bottle per lot $100-130

Edwards Vineyard Sauvignon Blanc 2089 Finca Villacreces - Vintage 2001 - Vintage 2004 Margaret River 4lscl, 2nl (15) Nebro New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $130-180 2 bottles per lot $300-400 ______

2137 Deutz Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1975 2103 Frazier Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 2ts, 1vhs, 5lbsl, 2ltl, 3ssos, outstanding color Napa Valley (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $600-800 1 magnum per lot $60-80 ______

2108 Amon-Ra Shiraz - Vintage 2006 2148 Scharffenberger Brut - Vintage NV Barossa Valley 1nl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $100-150 (95pts) 4 bottles per lot $280-320 2150 Amarone - Vintage 1986 Due Torri 2109 Blackstone Merlot 4nl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 8 bottles per lot $260-350

Brown Brothers Shiraz 2152 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1990 - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Castelgiocondo 6bn, 1ts, 12lbsl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) Rolf Binder Shiraz 12 bottles per lot $700-950 - Vintage 2003 Hanisch Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) 2154 Solengo - Vintage 1997 Above 3 bottles per lot $80-100 Argiano 6lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 2110 Clarendon Hills Grenache - Vintage 2003 "The profound 1997 Solengo vino da tavola (a blend of Romas Vineyard Sangiovese and Cabernet Sauvignon with a tiny dosage (Wines Located in New York) of Syrah) is spectacular. Opaque purple-colored, it displays a fabulously sweet nose of creme de cassis, 4 bottles per lot $140-190 new saddle leather, toasty new oak, licorice, and flowers. This wine boasts amazing richness, a huge, 2111 Clarendon Hills Syrah - Vintage 2003 full-bodied impact on the palate (yet no sense of heaviness), low acidity, gorgeous ripeness, and a finish Brookman Vineyard that lasts for 35+ seconds. I predict a brilliant future (Wines Located in New York) for this compelling proprietary red wine."(94pts) 3 bottles per lot $150-200 6 bottles per lot $600-800

2119 Torbreck Shiraz - Vintage 1999 2155 Toscana - Vintage 1999 The Factor La Togata Azzurreta, Tenuta Carlina lscl (Wines Located in New York) 6vlscl, 6lwrl (Wines Located in New York) "Deep garnet in color, the 1999 The Factor shows an 6 bottles per lot $150-200 earthy, meaty and gamey nose that is a little musky. Full-bodied and rich, it has medium levels of velvety tannins that hold up the concentrated and long, spicy 2160 Greenwood Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage finish."(93pts) 1995 1 bottle per lot $90-120 Anderson Valley ______6lscl, 1lwasl, 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $120-160 2129 Château Boutisse - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) (2) 2161 Leonetti Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) Château Rollan de By - Vintage 2008 Haut Medoc (Wines Located in (4) 2 bottles per lot $100-140 2171 Rosemount Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1993 3 bottles per lot $900-1200 Show Reserve ______9bn, 3ts, 4lscl (Wines Located in New York) 2202 Château Pavie - Vintage 1989 12 bottles per lot $300-420 St. Emilion ______3sdc (Wines Located in New York) 2172 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2012 "A lovely, balanced Bordeaux, with elegant berry, coffee and fruit aromas and flavors and very silky T6 tannins. Shows an extremely firm structure."(90pts WS) (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $850-1200 2 bottles per lot $800-1200 ______2204 Château Sicard-Charlus 2180 Moulin de Carruades - Vintage 1979 - Vintage 1990 Bordeaux Superieur 3lscl (6) Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) bsl, ltl, excellent color and condition (Wines Located in New York) Pommard - Vintage 1993 Les Charmots, A. Girardin (1) 1 bottle per lot $120-160 ______(Wines Located in New York) Above 7 bottles per lot $120-160 PARCEL LOTS 2184-2185 2205 Barbaresco - Vintage 1979 2184 Wild Duck Creek Shiraz - Vintage 2007 Gaja Duck Muck 1-4cm bc, 1-4.5cm bc, 3bsl, 3lscl, 1nl, 1sdc, 1spc, 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) excellent color and condition (Wines Located in 6 bottles per lot $1800-2400 New York) 3 bottles per lot $500-650 2185 6 bottles per lot $1800-2400 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in 2210 Toscana - Vintage 1999 New York) ______Tenuta di Trinoro 1lscl, 1wc (Wines Located in New York) 2193 Château D'Angludet - Vintage 1976 6 bottles per lot $500-700 Margaux ______3bn, 1vhs, 1hs, 5lbsl, 5sdc, 2scc, excellent color 2215 Château Angelus - Vintage 1971 (Wines Located in New York) St. Emilion 5 bottles per lot $120-160 1bn, 2vhs, 3bsl, 2nl, 1lstl, 1ltal, excellent color and condition (Wines Located in New York) 2197 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1979 3 bottles per lot $400-600 Mont Redon 4lbsl, 4sdc, excellent color and condition (Wines 2217 Château Beychevelle - Vintage 1971 Located in New York) St. Julien 4 bottles per lot $400-600 ______2ts, 7vhs, 1hs, 2htms, 12bsl, 3lstl, 6sdc, 2spc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 2199 Jim Beam Bourbon Whiskey - Vintage NV 12 bottles per lot $400-600 Bowling Pin, 6 year lscl, sos (Wines Located in New York) 2222 Château Simard - Vintage 1969 1 bottle per lot $240-320 St. Emilion ______6bn, 2ts, 8wrl, 5 taped labels, 4ll, 4ltl, 1pc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 2201 Taylor Fladgate Port - Vintage MV 8 bottles per lot $150-200 Vinha Velha Collection 1 bottle each vintage 1995, 2000 & 2009, 1x3 2223 Château St. Georges - Vintage 1990 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) St. Emilion Château Calon Segur lgsl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1989 St. Estephe vhs, nl, sdc, scc (1) 1 bottle per lot $20-30 (Wines Located in New York) ______Château Clinet 2243 Château Belair - Vintage 1994 Pomerol (Wines Located in (1) - Vintage 1996 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (1) New York) (93ptsWS) New York) Château de Pez Château Grate Cap - Vintage 1986 St. Estephe lscl, ltl (Wines (1) - Vintage 1993 Pomerol lstl, lwrl (Wines (1) Located in New York) Located in New York) Château de Sales Château Roland La Garde - Vintage 1996 Pomerol nl (Wines Located in (1) - Vintage 1999 Graves 2lscl, 1ll (Wines (3) New York) Located in New York) Above 5 bottles per lot $220-300

Château St. Georges 2363 Château Monbrison - Vintage 1995 - Vintage 1993 St. Emilion lbsl (Wines Located (1) Margaux in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $110-170 5 bottles per lot $150-200

2244 Château de Reignac - Vintage 1997 2375 Château Rauzan Gassies cuvée Prestige - Vintage 1995 2nl (Wines Located in New (2) (Wines Located in New York) York) 7 bottles per lot $140-200 Château Simard 2246 Hautes Côte de Nuits Blanc - Vintage 1995 - Vintage 1990 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (4) Charles de Valliere New York) 8lbsl, 1nl, 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) 8 bottles per lot $80-110 Château Siran - Vintage 1995 Margaux (Wines Located in (2) 2257 Joseph Phelps Winery - Vintage 1997 New York) (93pts WS) Napa Valley 4sdc, 3wc (Wines Located in New York) Château St. Pierre 4 magnums per lot $900-1200 - Vintage 1989 St. Julien sdc (Wines Located (1) in New York) 2263 Cloudy Bay Sauvignon Blanc - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) Les Tourelles de Longueville 2 bottles per lot $50-70 - Vintage 1995 Pauillac (Wines Located in (1) ______New York) Above 10 bottles per lot $280-380 2281 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1945 St. Julien 2379 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 1989 htms, wasl, sdc, Nicolas bottling, oustanding Pauillac color (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $400-500 ______1 bottle per lot $150-200

2323 Château Cadet Piola 2418 Joseph Phelps Winery - Vintage 1987 - Vintage 1990 St. Emilion ts (Wines Located (1) Insignia in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Magnificent. Dark, ripe, dense, chewy and enormously 1 bottle per lot $150-200 concentrated, it's clearly one of the stars of the vintage. Packed with rich currant, mineral, earth, cedar, spice, anise and coffee notes, it turns plush and thick on the 2488 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 1998 finish, where the flavors are young and vibrant. A Les Pavots wonderful aftertaste keeps pumping out the (Wines Located in New York) flavors."(96pts WS) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 1 bottle per lot $240-320 ______2495 Kosta Browne Pinot Noir - Vintage 2004 2436 Château Brane Cantenac Cohn Vineyard - Vintage 1982 Margaux bn, sdc (Wines (1) scl (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) (90pts "A remarkable Pinot. Broad, rich and opulent, with a firm tannic backbone supporting ripe black cherry, WS) blackberry, mineral, sage, herb and tea notes that border on syrupy. Tightens up on the finish, with ripe Château Langoa Barton tannins giving it a rich, complex aftertaste."(97pts WS) - Vintage 1982 St. Julien lbsl, sdc (Wines (1) 1 bottle per lot $180-240 Located in New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $190-240 2496 Martinelli Pinot Noir - Vintage 2000 Three Colts Vineyard 2438 Château Larcis Ducasse bsl, tl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1979 St. Emilion 2lgsl, 2sdc (Wines (2) 1 bottle per lot $40-60 Located in New York) 2497 Martinelli Pinot Noir - Vintage 2000 Château Latour a Pomerol Zio Tony Ranch - Vintage 1970 Pomerol bn, lbsl, excellent (1) (Wines Located in New York) color and condition (Wines "...is a beautiful, complex example made from all of the Located in New York) (93pts) new French Dijon clones. It offers aromas of cherry liqueur, cola, plums, Asian spices, and earth."(90pts) Above 3 bottles per lot $180-240 1 bottle per lot $35-45 ______2461 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2007 GIII 2522 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) Sauternes "The 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Beckstoffer George III 2bn, 2lscl, 1sdc (Wines Located in New York) Vineyard comes from clone 337, from a Beckstoffer- owned vineyard in Rutherford. Its dense purple color is 2 bottles per lot $450-550 followed by a big, sweet nose of black cherries, black ______currants, cedar, spice box, and subtle oak. Enormously concentrated and full-bodied with superb minerality as 2527 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 well as tannic structure, it will benefit from 4-5 years of RBS bottle age, and should evolve for three decades. (Wines Located in New York) "(97+pts) (91pts) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 ______1 bottle per lot $350-500

2477 Ermitage - Vintage 1998 2529 Saxum Red - Vintage 2010 Le Meal, M. Chapoutier James Berry Vineyard tl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The 1998 Ermitage Le Meal rouge represents the "...is endowed with serious energy and tension, dark red essence of Hermitage - a wine of elegance, power, fruit, flowers and spices. Rose petals and a hint of sweet symmetry, and extraordinary purity. Aromas and spices add lift on an energetic, intense finish layered flavors of black and red fruits as well as liquid granite with huge dark red fruit."(96+pts) emerge in this superb, multi-layered wine of fabulous 1 bottle per lot $140-180 intensity and length. The finish lasts for nearly a ______minute. The tannin is high, and a decade of cellaring is warranted. This 1998 will last for half a century."(96pts) 2534 Vougeot - Vintage 1999 Clos du Prieure, Domaine de la Vougeraie (Wines Located in New York) 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $90-120 3 bottles per lot $240-320 2571 Dumol Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 2545 Bonnes Mares - Vintage 1999 Aidan V. Girardin (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $60-80 "Austere but intense with brooding power and superb ______underlying material to go with tremendous finishing complexity. The length here is simply phenomenal and PARCEL LOTS 2576-2577 the intensity of the flavors is almost painful. This slowly builds in intensity from start to finish."(92-95pts BH) 2576 Château Quinault L'Enclos - Vintage 2005 2 bottles per lot $160-200 St. Emilion 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 2554 Villa Pillo Red (94pts) - Vintage 1997 Vivaldaia (Wines Located in (2) 12 bottles per lot $500-700 New York) 2577 12 bottles per lot $500-700 Villa Pillo Syrah 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (2) New York) Above 4 bottles per lot $100-140 2578 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1998 2556 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2003 cuvée du Papet, Clos du Mont Olivet Castello Tricerchi (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $180-240 2 bottles per lot $85-110 2579 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 2558 San Roman - Vintage 1998 Reserve Secrete, Domaine de la Solitude Toro, Bodegas y Vinedos Maurodos 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $450-600 4 bottles per lot $170-220 2584 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2007 2560 Abreu Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 Poggio Alle Mura, Castello Banfi Rothwell Hyde (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $600-800 2 bottles per lot $240-320 2588 Montevetrano - Vintage 2010 2561 Oakford Cabernet Sauvignon S. Imparato - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) (90pts) 6 bottles per lot $350-500

Alder Syrah 2591 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2007 - Vintage 2002 Alisos Vineyard lscl (Wines (1) Valdicava Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $500-700 Pride Mountain Sangiovese - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 2592 Flor de Pingus - Vintage 2003 Above 1 500 ml per lot $85-110 (Wines Located in New York) and 2 bottles 1 bottle per lot $80-110 ______2566 Vinoce Red - Vintage 1997 2596 Château Certan de May - Vintage 1971 (92pts RJ) Pomerol 3 bottles per lot $750-1000 1hs, 1htms, 2bsl, 2ltl, 2lwrl, 2sos, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 2610 Philipponnat Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1989 2 bottles per lot $260-350 Reserve spéciale (Wines Located in New York) 2597 Château Certan de May - Vintage 1979 3 bottles per lot $450-600 Pomerol ______4bn, 1ts, 5gsl, 1nl, 5sdc, outstanding color and 2621 Guado Al Tasso - Vintage 1990 condition (Wines Located in New York) Antinori "Increasingly the 1979 Certan de May appears to be one of the top five or six wines of the vintage. It exhibits (Wines Located in New York) a deep, dark ruby, saturated color, and a blossoming (93pts JK) yet still unevolved bouquet of black fruits, fruitcake, 3 bottles per lot $380-500 toasty new oak, and cedar. Full-bodied and massive, this broad-shouldered, expansively-flavored wine still has some tannin to lose."(94pts) 2629 Solengo - Vintage 1997 5 bottles per lot $500-700 Argiano 2nl, 1bsl (Wines Located in New York) "The profound 1997 Solengo vino da tavola (a blend of 2599 Château La Conseillante - Vintage 1971 Sangiovese and Cabernet Sauvignon with a tiny dosage Pomerol of Syrah) is spectacular. Opaque purple-colored, it vhs, lbsl, lgsl, ltl, excellent color (Wines Located displays a fabulously sweet nose of creme de cassis, in New York) new saddle leather, toasty new oak, licorice, and flowers. This wine boasts amazing richness, a huge, 1 bottle per lot $150-200 full-bodied impact on the palate (yet no sense of heaviness), low acidity, gorgeous ripeness, and a finish 2600 Château La Mission Haut Brion - Vintage 1962 that lasts for 35+ seconds. I predict a brilliant future for this compelling proprietary red wine."(94pts) Graves vhs, lbsl, sdc, Nicolas, outstanding color and 3 bottles per lot $300-400 condition (Wines Located in New York) "Medium ruby, with a garnet edge; raspberry and 2631 Montevetrano - Vintage 1997 tobacco aromas; medium- to full-bodied, with plenty of S. Imparato raspberry and tobacco flavors and a soft 1lwasl (Wines Located in New York) mouthfeel."(90pts WS) "...is a beguiling wine. Amazingly, the tannins remain a 1 bottle per lot $400-600 touch hard! There is wonderful integrity to the dark fruit. This is a decidedly virile and powerful Montevetrano, even if floral and spice notes add a sense 2602 Château Mondot - Vintage 1990 of lift to the finish."(95pts) 3lbsl, 1lwrl (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $420-600 3 bottles per lot $500-700 2632 Montevetrano - Vintage 2000 2608 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1961 S. Imparato htms, lscl, outstanding color (Wines Located in 1nl (Wines Located in New York) New York) 4 bottles per lot $260-400 "Very fleshy and toasted, with a long, oaky aftertaste that has several nuances and coffee is the strongest one. A classic that seams to be a little tired in regular 2638 Percarlo - Vintage 1995 bottles. coffee, as usual, is the most distinct. One of the San Giusto a Rentennano jury's real favorites at the Millennium Tasting. "(97pts 1nl (Wines Located in New York) RJ) "Hints of truffle, tobacco and earthiness add 1 bottle per lot $800-1200 complexity."(92pts) 3 bottles per lot $240-320 2609 Dom Ruinart Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1976 Blanc de Blancs 2642 Il Carbonaione - Vintage 1995 outstanding color and condition (Wines Located Scalette in New York) 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $240-320 5 bottles per lot $260-350 ______

2644 Giusto dei Notri - Vintage 1997 2668 Puligny Montrachet - Vintage 1996 Tua Rita Les Combottes, Sauzet (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...exhibits a dark ruby/purple color, and excellent aromatics consisting of toasty new oak, lead pencil, 1 bottle per lot $70-90 black currants, chocolate, and smoke. Layered and rich, ______but backward and unevolved, with copious tannin in the finish, this wine should improve with further 2672 Musigny - Vintage 1985 cellaring."(90pts) Vieilles Vignes, Comte de Vogue 4 bottles per lot $240-320 4cm bc, lbsl, lwasl, ltl, scc (Wines Located in New York) 2651 Martinelli Zinfandel "Showing well, fully mature, very rich and Jackass Vineyard attractive..."(4 stars MB) - Vintage 2000 nl (Wines Located in New (1) 1 bottle per lot $500-700 York) ______- Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New (1) 2683 Rieslaner Trockenbeerenauslese - Vintage 1998 York) (90-3pts) Gimmeldinger Schlossel, Muller-Catoir Above 2 bottles per lot $90-130 lstl, nl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) ______1 half-bottle per lot $120-160 2654 Gewurztraminer - Vintage 1983 Jubilee, Reserve Personelle, (1) 2686 Barolo Hugel scc, sos (Wines Located - Vintage 1978 La Serra, Marcarini 5.5cm bc, (1) in New York) lscl, ssos (Wines Located in New York) Riesling - Vintage 1976 Hugel, Hugel lbsl (Wines (1) Brunello di Montalcino Located in New York) - Vintage 1970 Altesino lbsl, nl, sdc (Wines (1) Above 2 bottles per lot $110-150 Located in New York) Above 1 bottle per lot $200-280 2655 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 and 1 720ml ______RBS (Wines Located in New York) 2701 Carruades de Lafite - Vintage 1989 (91pts) Pauillac 1 bottle per lot $350-500 ______(Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $500-700 2660 Château Clinet - Vintage 2009 Pomerol 2702 Carruades de Lafite - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac "...boasts an opaque, moonless night inky/blue/purple (Wines Located in New York) color in addition to a gorgeous perfume of blueberry "Wonderfully ripe and decadent, with tobacco, meat pie, incense, truffles, black raspberries, licorice and and ripe berry aromas, with hints of currants. Full- wood smoke. Viscous and multi-dimensional with silky, bodied, and very velvety, with unctuous fruit flavors. sweet tannin, massive fruit concentration and full- Long and exotic aftertaste. Terrific wine."(93pts WS) bodied power..."(100pts) 8 bottles per lot $1600-2200 6 bottles per lot $1500-2000 ______

2716 Meursault - Vintage 2000 2666 Glaetzer Shiraz - Vintage 2012 Narvaux, Mestre-Michelot Anaperenna (Wines Located in New York) 7 bottles per lot $240-300 owc (Wines Located in New York) (95pts JK)

2719 Piaceri Wines Pinot Noir - Vintage 2007 Rose (Wines Located in New York) (93pts) (1) DXG, Rochioli & Allen Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) Krug Vintage Champagne 12 bottles per lot $260-350 - Vintage 1982 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (96pts RJ) 2721 Patz & Hall Chardonnay Above 3 bottles per lot $850-1200 - Vintage 2008 Sonoma Coast (Wines Located (3) in New York) 2750 Louis Roederer Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1979 Cristal Tandem Chardonnay excellent color, outstanding condition (Wines - Vintage 2004 Porter Bass Vineyard (Wines (6) Located in New York) Located in New York) "Its nose oozed butterscotch city. There were some secondary gingerbread cake aromas, along with toast, Above 9 bottles per lot $150-200 melted butter and caramel. The palate was razor sharp at first, fresh and zippy though mellowing over time, but 2723 Scott Paul Chardonnay - Vintage 2001 a lot of time, like an hour. Bad Boy hailed it as a perfect bottle,' and its vim and vigor seconded that Kent Ritchie Vineyard emotion. One of the Botrytis Brothers hailed it as the (Wines Located in New York) best Champagne I ever had'."(97pts JK) 12 bottles per lot $180-240 1 bottle per lot $900-1200 ______2727 Valdez Family Winery Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 2753 Williams Selyem Chardonnay - Vintage 2010 Silver Eagle Vineyard Allen Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 10 bottles per lot $150-200 1 bottle per lot $50-70 ______2728 Brick House Chardonnay - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) 2757 Laurel Glen Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1994 12 bottles per lot $180-240 nl (Wines Located in New York) "...reveals an opaque purple color, and a tight but 2729 11 bottles per lot $160-220 promising nose of jammy black fruits, spice, earth, and a whiff of Provencal herbs. Full-bodied, with layers of (Wines Located in New York) chewy, fleshy, ripe fruit, this highly-extracted, ______moderately-tannic, blockbuster Cabernet should prove to be accessible when released."(92-94pts) 2733 Kongsgaard Syrah - Vintage 2008 1 bottle per lot $70-90 (Wines Located in New York) ______2 bottles per lot $260-350 ______2760 Bonnezeaux - Vintage 1997 cuvée Zenith, R. Renou 2735 Messorio - Vintage 2003 6lbsl, 2scrc (Wines Located in New York) Le Macchiole "Aromatically revealing spicy yellow fruits of exquisite lwisl, lwrl, nl (Wines Located in New York) ripeness, this is a medium-to-full-bodied, powerful, and explosive wine. Copious quantities of spicy bergamots, 1 bottle per lot $100-140 ______flowers, almonds, perfume, caramelized minerals, and tropical fruits can be found in its layered, velvety texture. Renou was somehow able to marry 1997's 2739 Arietta Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 awesome density and depth of fruit with virtually perfect vlstl, nl (Wines Located in New York) levels of acidity, creating a blockbuster-sized wine of great equilibrium and freshness. Bravo!..."(97pts) 1 magnum per lot $150-200 ______6 500 mls per lot $300-400

2749 Krug Champagne - Vintage NV 2761 Agharta Syrah - Vintage 2007 Grande cuvée La Famille Krug, 1x3 bottle custom (1) (Wines Located in New York) 2 magnums per lot $200-280 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) "A truly wonderful wine from the start. As usual, they 2762 Kongsgaard Syrah - Vintage 2008 succeed particularly well in warm, acid-weak vintages, when the neighbors' wines often appears flat and (Wines Located in New York) publicly simplistic. Despite the fact that the acid is not 3 bottles per lot $350-800 particularly accentuated here either, the vineyards aromatic citrus fresh touch, manage to leave a fresh uplifting side to the creamy fat smoothness."(94pts RJ) 2763 1 bottle per lot $120-160 6 bottles per lot $500-700 (Wines Located in New York) ______

2764 Torbreck Shiraz - Vintage 1999 2806 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1983 The Factor Pauillac 1wasl (Wines Located in New York) bn, lbsl, lscl (Wines Located in New York) "Deep garnet in color, the 1999 The Factor shows an "Finally, the 1983 Lafite is beginning to shed its tannin. earthy, meaty and gamey nose that is a little musky. The wine exhibits a deep ruby/garnet color with only a Full-bodied and rich, it has medium levels of velvety slight lightening at the edge. The intoxicatingly tannins that hold up the concentrated and long, spicy perfumed nose of lead pencil, pain grille, red and black finish."(93pts) fruits, minerals, and roasted herbs is provocative. In the 4 bottles per lot $300-400 mouth, this wine displays considerable body for a ______Lafite, plenty of power, and a fleshy, rich, sweet mid- palate. Long, elegant, plump, and surprisingly fleshy, this outstanding example of Lafite seems largely 2767 Musigny - Vintage 1990 forgotten given the number of high quality vintages Vieilles Vignes, Comte de Vogue during the golden decade of the eighties."(93pts) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $500-700 "The Bordeaux-like, saturated dense ruby/purple color ______is followed by a tight-fisted nose and flavors of black fruits, underbrush, minerals, smoke, and new oak... This 2807 Secondo Viaggio - Vintage 1997 loaded effort should prove to be one of the longest-lived red Burgundies made in the last twenty years."(96pts) La Quadratura del Cerchio, La Fiorita 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $600-800 ______1x6 magnum ocb (Wines Located in New York) 2792 Chambertin - Vintage 2011 Above 12 bottles per lot $350-450 Clos de Bèze, A. Rousseau and 8 magnums 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "A potently expressive nose blends both wood and PARCEL LOTS 2808-2809 natural spice together with distinctly cool, pure and ripe wild red berries, earth and underbrush. The palate 2808 24 bottles per lot $300-400 impression is a gorgeous combination of power and refinement along with flat out superb complexity on the 2x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in explosively long, focused and beautifully well-balanced New York) finish. The supporting structure is dense but fine and this should prove to be a moderately long-lived example."(95ps BH) 2809 24 bottles per lot $300-400 2x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in 2 bottles per lot $1700-2200 New York) ______2801 Morey St. Denis - Vintage 2008 Clos de la Bussiere, G. Roumier 2810 Rochioli Pinot Noir - Vintage 1999 1nl (Wines Located in New York) West Block "... is sweet, sensual and totally beguiling, Dark (Wines Located in New York) cherries, herbs, violets and white flowers are some of "The opaque ruby/purple-colored 1999 Pinot Noir West the nuances that emerge from this precise, striking Block (a vineyard planted in 1969 and 1970) boasts a wine."(93pts) sumptuous nose of allspice, blackberries, cherries, and 1 bottle per lot $110-150 toast. This multi-layered Pinot Noir exhibits uncanny balance and purity, an unctuous texture, and a 40- second finish. It is a dazzling effort."(94-96pts) 2805 Taittinger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2005 Comtes de Champagne 4 bottles per lot $400-600 2811 Rochioli Pinot Noir - Vintage 2000 2832 7 bottles per lot $220-300 Barrel Select (Wines Located in New York) (3) 7bsl, 3nl, 3wasl, 2tl, excellent color (Wines Located in New Estate Grown (Wines Located in New York) (2) York) Above 5 bottles per lot $150-200 ______2833 Anderson's Conn Valley Reserve Cabernet 2812 Sine Qua Non White - Vintage 2012 Sauvignon - Vintage 1994 In The Abstract 7lwrl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "It sports a slightly darker color than the Chardonnay 12 bottles per lot $500-700 and offers up incredible notes of caramelized peaches, poached apples, white flowers and crushed rock that 2836 Dover Canyon Syrah - Vintage 1997 flow seamlessly to a full-bodied, decadent, yet classy and graceful feel on the palate. It's a classic effort that 1nl (Wines Located in New York) doesn't pull any punches, yet also never seems hot, 10 bottles per lot $150-200 heavy or puts a foot wrong. Enjoy this beauty over the coming decade or more."(97pts) 2837 Nichols Pinot Noir - Vintage 1996 3 bottles per lot $500-700 Pisoni Vineyard ______3nl, 3sos, 1lwisl (Wines Located in New York) 2817 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1972 14 bottles per lot $280-380 Reserve des Celestins, H. Bonneau 6cm bc, lbsl, sdc, wc, excellent color (Wines 2838 Qupe Reserve Syrah Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 Bien Nacido Vineyard (Wines (6) 1 bottle per lot $400-600 Located in New York) ______Qupe Syrah 2826 Two Rivers Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 - Vintage 1997 Hillside Estate, Bien Nacido (5) Château Deux Fleuves Vineyard (Wines Located in (Wines Located in New York) New York) 1 bottle per lot $20-30 Above 11 bottles per lot $190-260 ______

2828 Abreu Red - Vintage 2009 2839 Hugh Hamilton Shiraz/Viognier - Vintage 2005 Rothwell Hyde Jekyll & Hyde 2nl (Wines Located in New York) 4nl (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $400-600 12 bottles per lot $240-320 ______

2829 Bianco Amabile - Vintage 1988 2842 Carruades de Lafite - Vintage 1989 G. Quintarelli Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) 6lbsl, 2ltl, 1lscl, 1 taped label (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $900-1200 6 bottles per lot $1100-1500 2830 5 half-bottles per lot $500-700 5lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 2843 Château Haut Nadeau - Vintage 2000 ______Bordeaux Superieur (Wines Located in New York) 2831 Rioja - Vintage 1966 6 bottles per lot $90-120 Carta de Oro, Berberana 1-4cm bc, 12bsl, 6ltl, 4wasl, 1tal, excellent color 2847 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) La Crau de Ma Mere, Domaine du Pere Papes 12 bottles per lot $400-600 1nl (Wines Located in New York) (92pts) 9 bottles per lot $260-350 2864 Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese - Vintage 1990 ______Ruppertsberger Nubbien, A. Christmann lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 2850 A. Hardy Cognac - Vintage NV Noces de Diamant 1 half-bottle per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) 2865 Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese - Vintage 1998 1 bottle per lot $2400-3200 Forster Ungeheuer, Reichsrat Von Buhl nl (Wines Located in New York) 2851 Marilyn Merlot - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) 1 half-bottle per lot $100-140 12 bottles per lot $500-700 2867 Turriga - Vintage 1997 Isola DeI NuraghI, Argiolas 2852 Marilyn Merlot - Vintage 2003 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $260-350 12 bottles per lot $400-600

2869 Schidione - Vintage 1998 2853 Marilyn Merlot - Vintage 2004 Biondi Santi 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 3nl (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $400-600 6 bottles per lot $300-400

2854 Marilyn Merlot - Vintage 2005 2870 Chianti Classico - Vintage 1993 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) Vigneto Bellavista, Castello di Ama 12 bottles per lot $400-600 12ts, 2x6 bottle ocb's (Wines Located in New York)

PARCEL LOTS 2855-2856 12 bottles per lot $750-1000

PARCEL LOTS 2871-2872 2855 Marilyn Merlot - Vintage 2004 Norma Jean 2871 Chianti Classico - Vintage 1994 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) Vigneto Bellavista, Castello di Ama 12 bottles per lot $300-400 1bn, 7ts, 3vhs, 1hs, 2x6 bottle ocb's (Wines Located in New York) 2856 12 bottles per lot $300-400 12 bottles per lot $900-1200 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 2872 12 bottles per lot $900-1200 5bn, 2ts, 1vhs, 6lbsl, 1nl, 1ssos 2857 Marilyn Merlot - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) Norma Jean 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 2873 Chianti Classico - Vintage 1994 12 bottles per lot $300-400 Vigneto La Casuccia, Castello di Ama 4ts, 1vhs, 1hs, 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in 2858 Marilyn Merlot - Vintage 2007 New York) Norma Jean 6 bottles per lot $400-600 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York)

12 bottles per lot $300-400 2874 Vigna L'Apparita - Vintage 1994 ______Castello di Ama 2862 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2011 1bn, 3ts, 2vhs, 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in RBS New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $500-700 (91pts) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 2875 Vigna L'Apparita - Vintage 1996 ______Castello di Ama - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $600-800 Smeriglio Merlot PARCEL LOTS 2876-2878 - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) 2876 Saffredi - Vintage 1995 Le Pupille Smeriglio Sangiovese 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) "...is an excellent choice for drinking today, as it is (Wines Located in New York) fairly mature. Dried flowers, menthol, licorice and plums are some of the elements that come together. Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 Early tertiary, gamy notes are beginning to creep in, while the fruit is drying out, both of which suggest the 2883 Ardito Red wine is best enjoyed sooner rather than later."(91pts) - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) 6 bottles per lot $400-600 (Wines Located in New York)

2877 6 bottles per lot $400-600 Smeriglio Merlot 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) New York) (Wines Located in New York)

2878 6 bottles per lot $400-600 Smeriglio Sangiovese 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 2879 Saffredi - Vintage 1999 Le Pupille 2884 Ardito Red 5bn, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) "The 1999 Saffredi is an immensely gratifying wine. It (Wines Located in New York) could almost be mistaken for a Burgundy, so pure and sweet is the bouquet. The 1999 is a decidedly understated, graceful Saffredi that impresses for its Smeriglio Merlot elegance and finesse rather than for its heft. Hints of - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) French oak, smoke, autumn leaves, tar and tobacco add (Wines Located in New York) the final layers of complexity."(92pts WA) 12 bottles per lot $800-1100 ______Smeriglio Sangiovese - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) PARCEL LOTS 2881-2890 (Wines Located in New York) Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 2881 Ardito Red - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) 2885 Ardito Red (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) Smeriglio Merlot - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) Smeriglio Merlot (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) Smeriglio Sangiovese - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) Smeriglio Sangiovese (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 (Wines Located in New York) Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 2882 Ardito Red 2886 Ardito Red 2890 Ardito Red - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York)

Smeriglio Merlot Smeriglio Merlot - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York)

Smeriglio Sangiovese Smeriglio Sangiovese - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350

2887 Ardito Red 2892 Ardito Red - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (11) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York)

Smeriglio Sangiovese Smeriglio Sangiovese - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 Above 35 bottles per lot $200-350

2888 Ardito Red 2893 Ardito Red - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 2005 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York)

Smeriglio Sangiovese Smeriglio Sangiovese - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 ______

2889 Ardito Red 2901 Prieure Blaignan - Vintage 2004 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 1995 Medoc lbsl (Wines Located in (1) (Wines Located in New York) New York)

Smeriglio Merlot Côteaux du Layon - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) - Vintage 1995 cuvée de la Tour, Château (1) (Wines Located in New York) Soucherie lscl (Wines Located in New York) Smeriglio Sangiovese - Vintage 2006 Baracchi 1x12 bottle ocb (12) Above 1 500 ml per lot $35-55 (Wines Located in New York) and 1 bottle ______Above 36 bottles per lot $180-350 2902 Riesling Feinherb - Vintage 2010 2984 Concannon Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1966 Hofberg, A. J. Adam Limited Bottling (Wines Located in New York) hs, bsl, hscl, htal, cc, excellent color (Wines 3 bottles per lot $150-200 Located in New York) ______1 bottle per lot $60-80

2906 Musigny - Vintage 1990 2985 Sanford & Benedict Pinot Noir - Vintage 1977 Vieilles Vignes, Comte de Vogue (Wines Located in New York) different importers (Wines Located in New York) "The Bordeaux-like, saturated dense ruby/purple color 6 bottles per lot $160-200 is followed by a tight-fisted nose and flavors of black ______fruits, underbrush, minerals, smoke, and new oak... This loaded effort should prove to be one of the longest-lived 2990 Château Belair - Vintage 1997 red Burgundies made in the last twenty years."(96pts) St. Emilion 2 bottles per lot $1200-1600 12vlbsl, 1x12 bottle owc, 7lbsl (Wines Located in ______New York) 19 bottles per lot $350-480 2940 Reserve de la Comtesse - Vintage 2000 Pauillac 2992 Château Mazeris - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) Canon-Fronsac 6 bottles per lot $300-400 ______1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $240-320 2956 Barolo - Vintage 1997 Rocche dell'Annunziata, Riserva, P. Scavino PARCEL LOTS 2993-2994 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "...is a deep garnet. Its full-barreled aromas of 2993 Château Mazeris - Vintage 2003 cinnamon, plums, and cedar announce flavors of Canon-Fronsac superior ripeness and sweetness."(93pts) 2x12 bottle owc's (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $900-1200 24 bottles per lot $350-480

2959 Maremma - Vintage 2006 2994 24 bottles per lot $350-480 Rocca di Frassinello 2x12 bottle owc's (Wines Located 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) in New York) 6 bottles per lot $150-200 PARCEL LOTS 2995-2997 2965 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2004 Valdicava 2995 Château Plince - Vintage 2003 1x12 half bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) Pomerol "Firm but silky tannins frame a core of ripe dark fruit 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) as this powerful yet elegant Brunello opens up in the glass. Smoke, cured meats, earthiness and graphite 12 bottles per lot $300-400 develop in the glass, adding further complexity. Sweet roses and spices linger on the long, refined 2996 12 bottles per lot $300-400 finish."(94pts) 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in 11 half-bottles per lot $950-1200 New York)

2977 Opus One - Vintage 1992 2997 12 bottles per lot $300-400 lbsl, ltl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...offers a beautiful dark ruby/purple color, a big, spicy nose of cassis, lead pencil, and smoky oak, round, full- bodied, broad, fat flavors crammed with black fruits, 3000 Château Rouget - Vintage 2005 soft tannin, low acidity, and a fleshy, full-bodied Pomerol finish."(92pts) 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $240-300 ______12 bottles per lot $500-700 3001 Château Siaurac (Wines Located in New York) Lalande a Pomerol 1 magnum per lot $200-280 - Vintage 2000 1x12 bottle owc (Wines (12) Located in New York) 3039 HdV Red - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 1x12 bottle owc (Wines (12) 6 bottles per lot $180-240 Located in New York)

Above 24 bottles per lot $320-450 3040 Monticello Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1989 3002 Château Siaurac Jefferson cuvée Lalande a Pomerol (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2002 1x12 bottle owc (Wines (12) 11 bottles per lot $220-300 Located in New York) 3041 Monticello Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage - Vintage 2005 1x12 bottle owc (Wines (12) 1991 Located in New York) Jefferson cuvée Above 24 bottles per lot $280-380 Etched 5 liter (Wines Located in New York) ______1 5 liter per lot $180-240 3017 Sammarco - Vintage 2006 3042 Morgan Manor Red - Vintage 2004 Castello Dei Rampolla Anagram 2nl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $550-750 24 bottles per lot $240-320 3021 Sammarco - Vintage 2009 3043 Swanson Red - Vintage 1994 Castello Dei Rampolla Alexis (Wines Located in New York) nl (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $300-400 1 5 liter per lot $180-240 PARCEL LOTS 3022-3023 3044 Alexander Valley Pinot Noir 3022 Percarlo - Vintage 1994 - Vintage 2000 Wetzel Family Estate (Wines (1) San Giusto a Rentennano Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Andrew Murray Syrah 2 bottles per lot $200-280 - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (3)

3023 2 bottles per lot $200-280 - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (3) (Wines Located in New York) Above 7 bottles per lot $70-100

3025 Priorat - Vintage 2008 3046 Black by Black Red La cuvée Riu, Combier Fischer Gerin Associes - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (2) (Wines Located in New York)

9 bottles per lot $180-240 Brewer-Clifton Pinot Noir - Vintage 1996 Santa Maria Hills tl (Wines (1) 3026 Rioja - Vintage 2004 Located in New York) Reserva, Marques de Riscal (Wines Located in New York) Clos du Val Merlot 12 bottles per lot $300-400 - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (1) ______

School House Pinot Noir 3038 Arietta Red - Vintage 2005 - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Hudson Vineyard, 'H Block' Above 5 bottles per lot $80-120 3064 Le Baron de Brane - Vintage 2000 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 3047 Saintsbury Pinot Noir - Vintage 1998 12 bottles per lot $260-350 Brown Ranch (Wines Located in New York) 3065 12 bottles per lot $260-350 3 bottles per lot $90-120 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 3048 Steele Pinot Noir ______- Vintage 1993 Dupratt Vineyard lbsl, cc, sos (1) 3067 Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese - Vintage 1966 (Wines Located in New York) Langenloiser Speigal, Brundlmayer lbsl, sdc, sos (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1995 Dupratt Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 ______

Steele Syrah 3069 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2000 - Vintage 1996 Parmalee Hill Vineyard writing Vieilles Vignes, E. Texier magnum (1) 6lscl, 1ltl (Wines Located in New York) on magnum (Wines Located in 6 bottles per lot $200-280 New York)

Above 1 bottle, 1 magnum per lot $160-220 3073 Groth Cabernet Sauvignon and 1 5 liter - Vintage 1986 bsl (Wines Located in New (1) York) 3049 Steele Zinfandel - Vintage 1987 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Dupratt Vineyard - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) magnum - Vintage 1988 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (6) - Vintage 1989 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1997 1lscl (Wines Located in New magnum (3) - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New York) (1) York) (90-92pts) Above 9 magnums per lot $260-350 - Vintage 1991 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (87-91pts) 3050 Au Bon Climat Reserve Chardonnay - Vintage 1995 - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Talley Vineyard (91pts) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1996 1nl (Wines Located in New (3) 5 bottles per lot $120-160 York)

3051 Simi Reserve Chardonnay - Vintage 1990 Groth Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon lscl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1989 (Wines Located in New York) (2) 1 5 liter per lot $100-140 Above 12 bottles per lot $420-550 ______

3079 Laurel Glen Cabernet Sauvignon 3061 Château Martinens - Vintage 2000 - Vintage 1996 2nl (Wines Located in New (3) Margaux York) 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "Vibrant aromas of crushed berries, cherries and licorice. Full-bodied, with super well-integrated tannins Le Ducq Red and a long, caressing finish. Very fine indeed.(91pts - Vintage 1996 Le Ducq (Wines Located in (6) WS) New York) 12 bottles per lot $300-400 - Vintage 1997 Le Ducq (Wines Located in (2) New York) PARCEL LOTS 3064-3065 Leducq Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 3094 Clarendon Hills Grenache - Vintage 1996 Sylviane (Wines Located in (2) - Vintage 2003 Clarendon Vineyard (Wines (1) New York) Located in New York) Above 13 bottles per lot $280-400 Clarendon Hills Old Vines Grenache 3080 Lewis Cellars Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Clarendon Hills Shiraz Moss Creek Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 Liandra (Wines Located in (2) - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (4) New York) (91pts) Above 6 bottles per lot $180-260 D'Arenberg Shiraz - Vintage 1998 The Dead Arm (Wines Located (1) 3085 Behrens & Hitchcock Syrah in New York) - Vintage 1998 4lscl (Wines Located in New (4) York) Elderton Shiraz - Vintage 1995 Command (Wines Located in (1) Beringer Cabernet Franc New York) - Vintage 1996 Third Century (Wines Located (2) in New York) (92pts WS) Above 7 bottles per lot $240-320 ______Above 6 bottles per lot $110-150 3106 JC Cellars Syrah 3087 Hartley Ostini Pinot Noir - Vintage 2004 Fess Parker's Vineyard (Wines (1) - Vintage 1996 Hitching Post 4lbsl (Wines (4) Located in New York) Located in New York) Laetitia Estate Pinot Noir Keegan Pinot Noir - Vintage 2001 Les Galets nl (Wines Located (1) - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (2) in New York)

- Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Laird Family Merlot Above 8 bottles per lot $110-160 - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 3 bottles per lot $50-80 3092 Sarah's Vineyard Pinot Noir ______- Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (3) 3108 Killerby Cabernet Sauvignon Sarah's Vineyard Reserve Pinot Noir - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (13) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Killerby Shiraz - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (6) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (4) Above 17 bottles per lot $170-240 Sarah's Vineyard Pinot Noir ______- Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (3) Above 14 bottles per lot $190-260 3111 Chablis - Vintage 2002 Les Vaillons, Fevre (Wines (2) 3093 Mr. K - Vintage 2003 Located in New York) Nobleman, Sine Qua Non (Wines Located in New York) Lewis Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon "While deep golden-hued and honeyed, with brilliant - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) unctuosity, thickness, and richness, it takes third place when ranked against its two sweet siblings. Readers Robert Mondavi Cabernet Sauvignon should think of it as a Chardonnay - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Trockenbeerenauslese."(94pts) Above 5 bottles per lot $180-220 2 half-bottles per lot $180-240 ______3123 Château Beaulieu Comtes de Tastes - Vintage 2000 3140 Grace Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1994 Bordeaux Superieur Vineyard 29 10bsl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 10 bottles per lot $150-200 3 bottles per lot $450-600

3127 Château Gigault - Vintage 2000 3141 Ristow Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 cuvée Viva, Côtes de Blaye Quinta de Piedras Vineyard, Pauillac 2gsl, 1nol (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $120-160 6 bottles per lot $150-200

3132 Sangioveto 3142 Schweiger Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 - Vintage 1994 Badia a Coltibuono (Wines (1) 4nl (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $180-240 ______Valpolicella - Vintage 1993 La Grola, Allegrini 1nl (Wines (3) 3143 Château Beausejour Becot - Vintage 1995 Located in New York) St. Emilion bsl, nl (Wines Located in New York) Vino Nobile di Montepulciano 1 bottle per lot $45-60 - Vintage 1986 Avignonesi vhs, nl (Wines (1) Located in New York) 3144 Château Beychevelle - Vintage 1986 Above 5 bottles per lot $100-150 St. Julien bsl, stl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) "Remarkably complex with rich, concentrated, tannic 3133 St. Clement Cabernet Sauvignon currant, spice and anise flavors, wrapped in smoky, - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New York) (4) cedary oak that gets tastier with every sip."(93ptsWS) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 A. Rafanelli Zinfandel - Vintage 2003 Dry Creek Valley 2nl (Wines (4) 3147 Château Martinens - Vintage 2000 Located in New York) Margaux 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Alexander Valley Merlot "Vibrant aromas of crushed berries, cherries and - Vintage 1994 Wetzel Family Estate (Wines (5) licorice. Full-bodied, with super well-integrated tannins Located in New York) and a long, caressing finish. Very fine indeed.(91pts WS) Above 13 bottles per lot $190-260 12 bottles per lot $300-400

3138 Penfold's Cabernet Sauvignon/Shiraz - Vintage 1993 3148 Château Montrose - Vintage 1986 Bin 389 St. Estephe 6lbsl (Wines Located in New York) ts, bsl, stl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $240-350 "... is a big, brawny Montrose, with gobs of fruit, a ______boatload of tannin, and enough muscle and depth to remind the league of classic Montrose fans of such 3139 Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese - Vintage 2005 great vintages such as 1970, 1964, 1959, and #7, Grande cuvée, Kracher 1953."(91pts) 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 "...offers impressive aromatic complexity, suggesting brown-spiced apple and quince jellies, glazed 3149 Pavillon Rouge du Château Margaux - Vintage 1990 pineapple, dried apricots, honey, musk, and truffle. Tactile spice and surprising fresh fruit character derive Margaux contrast in the mouth from creamy, oily textural bsl, scl, spc, scc (Wines Located in New York) richness and suggestions of nut brittle and 1 bottle per lot $110-150 chocolate."(94pts) ______6 bottles per lot $400-600 ______3153 Louis Roederer Champagne 3160 Alentejano - Vintage 1996 - Vintage NV (Wines Located in New York) (1) Reserva, Tapada do Chaves 1x3 bottle ocb, 2lwrl, 2x6 bottle ocb's (Wines Pouilly Fume Located in New York) - Vintage 1993 S. Daganeau lbsl, sdc, sos (1) 9 bottles per lot $130-180 (Wines Located in New York) ______

Riesling 3161 Ficklin Port - Vintage NV - Vintage 1997 Schmitt Sohne (Wines Located double htms, bsl, dc, sos (Wines Located in New York) magnum 1 bottle per lot $10-20 in New York) (1) 3162 Marilyn Merlot - Vintage 1996 Gran Duque D'Alba (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage NV Gran Reserva, Ruiz-Mateos 1x1 (1) 1 bottle per lot $70-90 bottle ogb (Wines Located in ______New York) 3163 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 1978 Grand Empereur Brandy Pauillac - Vintage NV Napoleon vhs, 1x1 bottle ocb (1) 1vhs, 1hs, 3dc, 1sos (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $240-320 ______Above 4 bottles per lot $180-260 and 1 double magnum 3168 Château La Clusiere - Vintage 1999 ______St. Emilion 3154 Carruades de Lafite - Vintage 1989 6lbsl (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac 6 bottles per lot $800-1100 2lbsl, 2lwasl, 2ltal (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $350-500 3169 Château Magdelaine - Vintage 2003 St. Emilion 3155 Carruades de Lafite - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac 8 bottles per lot $400-600 2lbsl, 2ltl, 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) ______"Wonderfully ripe and decadent, with tobacco, meat and ripe berry aromas, with hints of currants. Full- 3171 Château Bouscaut Blanc - Vintage 1967 bodied, and very velvety, with unctuous fruit flavors. Graves Long and exotic aftertaste. Terrific wine."(93pts WS) 3bn, 7ts, 9lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $350-500 9 bottles per lot $220-300 ______

3156 Château de Laussac - Vintage 2001 3184 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1997 Côtes-de-Castillon Sauternes 9lbsl, 6wasl, 6tl (Wines Located in New York) 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) 9 bottles per lot $150-200 "A sensational Yquem, 1997 may be this estate's finest effort since 1990 (although I would not discount the 1996 turning out to be nearly as good). The 1997's light 3158 Turley Zinfandel - Vintage 1996 gold color is accompanied a gorgeous perfume of Old Vines caramel, honeysuckle, peach, apricot, and smoky wood. 4scl, 3tl, 3nl (Wines Located in New York) Full-bodied and unctuously-textured, with good underlying acidity as well as loads of sweetness and 10 bottles per lot $240-320 glycerin, it looks to be a great vintage for this renowned Sauternes estate."(96pts) 3159 Mitolo Shiraz - Vintage 2002 2 half-bottles per lot $280-400 Reiver 5lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 3209 Châteauneuf du Pape 5 bottles per lot $180-240 Roussanne Vieilles Vignes, Château de Beaucastel out nose of black fruit (cassis and black-raspberries), this wine hits the palate with phenomenal concentration - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) that brilliantly manages to be neither heavy nor overbearing. Plenty of velvety tannin is concealed - Vintage 2005 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) behind the fruit's remarkable intensity. The wine's York) (95pts JK) purity, presence, and finish are unbelievable. I predict Above 2 bottles per lot $220-300 this wine will turn out to be a legend!"(98pts) 1 bottle per lot $350-450 ______3215 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2004 cuvée de Mon Aieul, P. Usseglio 3269 Barbera d'Asti - Vintage 1993 4lscl (Wines Located in New York) Camp du Rouss, Coppo 4 bottles per lot $180-240 2bn, 1ts (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $50-70 3223 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2001 Pertimali (Livio Sassetti) (Wines Located in New (2) 3271 Matanzas Creek Merlot - Vintage 1995 York) Estate Salvioni sdc (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York)

Siro Pacenti (Wines Located in New York) (1) 6 bottles per lot $150-200 Above 4 bottles per lot $240-320 3272 Matanzas Creek Merlot - Vintage 1994 3224 Rioja - Vintage 2004 Journey (Wines Located in New York) (1) Remirez de Ganuza - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) (3) 4 bottles per lot $120-160 - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (3) 3232 Verite Red - Vintage 2010 Above 7 bottles per lot $170-240 La Joie 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 3273 Matanzas Creek Merlot - Vintage 1997 3 bottles per lot $750-1000 Estate (Wines Located in New York) 3245 Betz Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 9 bottles per lot $180-240 Pere de Familie 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 3274 Matanzas Creek Merlot - Vintage 1997 5 bottles per lot $240-320 (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $120-160 3247 Betz Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 Pere de Familie 3275 Rochioli Pinot Noir (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2000 Barrel Select (Wines Located in (3) 4 bottles per lot $200-260 New York)

3249 Betz Syrah - Vintage 2005 Sanford Pinot Noir Chapter 3 - Vintage 1993 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $160-200 - Vintage 1997 Barrell Select (Wines Located (2) ______in New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $160-220 3265 Bryant Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1994 vlscl (Wines Located in New York) 3277 Château St. Michelle Meritage - Vintage 1994 "... is one of those rare wines that possesses awesome aromatic, flavor, and texture dimensions. Totally dry, it Artist Series comes across as sweet because of its highly extracted, 1x4 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) ripe fruit. Opaque purple/black-colored, with a knock- 4 bottles per lot $80-110 (Wines Located in New York) ______1 6 liter per lot $300-400 3279 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1985 PARCEL LOTS 3301-3302 Mongeard-Mugneret 2-3.5cm bc, 6lbsl, 3sos, 3scc, 6wc (Wines Located 3301 Clos du Bois Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1983 in New York) Briarcrest Vineyard 6 bottles per lot $1200-1600 ______2bn, 5ts, 5vhs, 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 3282 Château Lafaurie Peyraguey - Vintage 2003 12 bottles per lot $180-240 Sauternes 6lwrl, different importers (Wines Located in New 3302 12 bottles per lot $180-240 York) 4bn, 3ts, 5vhs, 1x12 bottle ocb 6 bottles per lot $260-350 (Wines Located in New York)

3285 Clarendon Hills Old Vines Grenache - Vintage 2003 PARCEL LOTS 3304-3305 Romas Vineyard lscl (Wines Located in New York) 3304 Inglenook Reserve Cask Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1983 1 bottle per lot $60-80 Reunion ______bsl, lwasl, nl, 1x1 double magnum owc with no 3291 Hermitage - Vintage 1994 lid (Wines Located in New York) La Chapelle, P. Jaboulet 1 double magnum per lot $200-280 11vlbsl, 11lscl, 7sdc (Wines Located in New York) "...shows balance and refined tannins, but the finish is a 3305 1 double magnum per lot $200-280 bit chewy and hard now. Beautifully fresh and clean, lbsl, scc, 1x1 double magnum owc with subtle vanilla, blackberry, spice, mocha and chocolate."(90pts WS) (Wines Located in New York) 11 bottles per lot $900-1200 3306 Iron Horse Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1982 8vhs, 4hs, 12cc, 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located 3292 Robert Mondavi Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1979 in New York) lbsl, lscl (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $240-320 "Mature and complex, with supple, elegant cherry, currant, mint and coffee notes, holding its elegance and 3308 Rutherford Hill Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1985 finesse on the finish."(90pts WS) cc, 1x1 Imperial owc (Wines Located in New 1 magnum per lot $140-180 ______York) 1 Imperial per lot $200-280 3296 Marsala - Vintage NV Dry, Cantine Florio 4lwisl (Wines Located in New (5) 3309 Sebastiani Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1985 York) Cherry Block Vineyard Sweet, Cantine Florio lwisl, nl (Wines Located in (1) ts, bsl, ltal, scc, 1x1 Imperial owc (Wines Located New York) in New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $60-100 1 Imperial per lot $260-350

3298 Campaccio - Vintage 1995 3310 Sequoia Grove Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1987 Millenium 2000, Terrabianca Allen Vineyard ts, wisl, sos (Wines Located in New York) sdc (Wines Located in New York) 1 18 liter per lot $500-700 1 5 liter per lot $200-280

3299 Torres - Vintage 1995 3311 Steltzner Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1987 Mas La Plana, M. Torres SLD ts, bsl, nl, sdc, nc, signed by Richard Steltzner, 3317 Hermitage - Vintage 1995 1x1 Imperial owc (Wines Located in New York) La Chapelle, P. Jaboulet 1 Imperial per lot $220-300 2bsl, 2nl (Wines Located in New York) "...boasts a deep ruby/purple color, and a complex set of aromatics including scents of cassis, minerals, lead 3312 Sterling Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1995 pencil, and spice. The wine possesses good acidity, full nl (Wines Located in New York) body, outstanding richness, and a tight 1 Imperial per lot $150-200 personality."(90pts) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 ______3313 EOS Zinfandel - Vintage 1996 1x1 double magnum owc double 3321 Château Ducru Beaucaillou - Vintage 1983 magnum St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York)

Robert Mondavi Sauvignon Blanc 1 bottle per lot $100-130 - Vintage 1983 Botrytis 2lbsl (Wines Located half- bottle (2) 3322 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1982 in New York) St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) Robert Pepi Sauvignon Blanc "Exhibits an explosive nose of new saddle leather, - Vintage 1986 Botrytised (Wines Located in half-bottle plums, prunes, black cherry jam, chocolate, steak tartar, and roasted espresso. Unbelievably powerful, (1) thick, and intense, with full body, mouth-searing tannin New York) levels, a grilled steak-like flavor, and a huge, intense finish..."(96pts) Rodney Strong Late Harvest Johannisberg Riesling 1 bottle per lot $300-400 - Vintage 1985 Le Baron Vineyard (Wines half-bottle (5) 3325 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1983 Located in New York) Pauillac 3bn, 3lstl, 1spc (Wines Located in New York) Hogue Cellars Reserve Merlot "Finally, the 1983 Lafite is beginning to shed its tannin. - Vintage 1991 scrc (Wines Located in New (1) The wine exhibits a deep ruby/garnet color with only a York) slight lightening at the edge. The intoxicatingly perfumed nose of lead pencil, pain grille, red and black fruits, minerals, and roasted herbs is provocative. In the Powers Merlot mouth, this wine displays considerable body for a - Vintage 1997 sos (Wines Located in New (1) Lafite, plenty of power, and a fleshy, rich, sweet mid- York) palate. Long, elegant, plump, and surprisingly fleshy, this outstanding example of Lafite seems largely Above 8 half-bottles, 1 double per lot $220-300 forgotten given the number of high quality vintages magnum, 1 Imperial during the golden decade of the eighties."(93pts) and 1 5 liter 3 bottles per lot $1500-2000 ______3314 JC Cellars Syrah - Vintage 2004 California cuvée 3330 Château Angelus - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) St. Emilion sdc (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $120-160 ______"A massive, powerful Angelus, this wine exhibits a saturated black/ruby/purple color as well as an impressively-endowed nose of dried herbs, roasted 3316 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 1995 meats, new saddle leather, plum liqueur, and cassis. In Pauillac the mouth, olive notes make an impression. This sweet, (Wines Located in New York) full-bodied, exceptionally concentrated wine is "A solid, well-built '95. Lovely chocolate, berry and atypically backward and ferociously tannic."(91pts) tobacco aromas, with a hint of vanilla. Full-bodied, 1 bottle per lot $200-300 with velvety tannins and a long, flavorful finish. The best second label of Pauillac?..."(91pts) 3331 Château Balestard La Tonnelle 5 bottles per lot $700-1000 - Vintage 1994 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (1) - Vintage 2001 Luenzo, Cesani Vincenzo (1) New York) (Wines Located in New York)

Château Certan de May Vitiano - Vintage 1998 Pomerol nl (Wines Located in (1) - Vintage 2001 Falesco lscl (Wines Located in (1) New York) (93pts WS) New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $95-130 Above 7 bottles per lot $50-90

3332 Château de Maison Neuve - Vintage 1990 3348 Estancia Meritage - Vintage 1997 Montagne-St. Emilion Alexander Valley 2nl, 1lstl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 8 bottles per lot $100-140 9 bottles per lot $60-80

3335 Clos Fourtet 3351 Frick Red - Vintage 2002 - Vintage 1982 St. Emilion bn, lbsl, lgsl (1) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 16 bottles per lot $180-240

cuvée de la Commanderie du Bontemps 3352 Paso Creek Merlot - Vintage 1982 Medoc 4bn, 6bsl, 1lbsl (Wines (6) - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) (13) Located in New York) Above 7 bottles per lot $140-190 - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) (27) Above 40 bottles per lot $200-260 3336 Château d'Ardennes Blanc - Vintage 1979 Graves 3354 Grand Cru Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 3bn, 5ts, 1vhs, 9lstl, 9bsl, 1pc (Wines Located in - Vintage 1987 Stanford Wine Program lwrl, (1) New York) nl (Wines Located in New 9 bottles per lot $120-160 York)

3339 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1989 Clos Pegase Chardonnay Château La Nerthe - Vintage 2000 Mitsuko's Vineyard 1nl (Wines (2) 2nl, 1novl (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $600-800 Far Niente Chardonnay - Vintage 2002 tvl (Wines Located in New York) (1) 3344 Barbera d'Asti - Vintage 1998 Riserva della Famiglia, Coppo (1) Monthaven Chardonnay (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1994 2lbsl, 2sdc (Wines Located in (2) New York) Chardonnay - Vintage 1998 Riserva della Famiglia, Coppo (1) Peter Lehmann Cabernet Sauvignon (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1993 The Barossa lbsl, lscl (Wines (1) Located in New York) Chianti Classico - Vintage 2002 Carpineto (Wines Located in New York) (1) Peter Lehmann Shiraz Nando (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1992 The Barossa (Wines Located in (3) New York) Chianti Rufina - Vintage 2005 Nipozzano Rufina, Riserva, (1) Quinta dos Penassais Red Marchesi de Frescobaldi - Vintage 1995 Garrafeira taped label (Wines (1) (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York)

Toscana Above 11 bottles per lot $120-190 3357 Joseph Phelps Chardonnay - Vintage 1996 lbsl (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 1998 Ovation (Wines Located in New (4) York) York) Trileka Chardonnay Ramey Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1999 Hyde Vineyard 2nl (Wines (2) Above 22 bottles per lot $50-80 Located in New York) (93pts ______JK) 3363 Bonarda - Vintage 2012 Raymond Reserve Chardonnay Dell' Oltrepo, Castello di Luzzano - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (3) (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $30-40 ______Seresin Sauvignon Blanc - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 3364 Château Belair - Vintage 1998 Above 10 bottles per lot $110-160 St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) 3359 Stony Hill Chardonnay 2 bottles per lot $80-110 - Vintage 1987 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

- Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (4) 3367 Solengo - Vintage 1997 Argiano Villa Mt. Eden Chardonnay 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) "The profound 1997 Solengo vino da tavola (a blend of - Vintage 1994 4lbsl (Wines Located in New (4) Sangiovese and Cabernet Sauvignon with a tiny dosage York) of Syrah) is spectacular. Opaque purple-colored, it Above 9 bottles per lot $160-220 displays a fabulously sweet nose of creme de cassis, new saddle leather, toasty new oak, licorice, and flowers. This wine boasts amazing richness, a huge, 3360 Paringa Shiraz full-bodied impact on the palate (yet no sense of - Vintage 2001 1lscl (Wines Located in New (11) heaviness), low acidity, gorgeous ripeness, and a finish York) that lasts for 35+ seconds. I predict a brilliant future for this compelling proprietary red wine."(94pts)

Penfold's Cabernet Sauvignon/Shiraz 3 bottles per lot $300-400 - Vintage 2005 Koonunga Hill 5wrl, 4wasl (11) (Wines Located in New York) 3368 Barbaresco - Vintage 1997 Bricco de Neueis, Dante Rivetti Above 22 bottles per lot $180-240 magnum (2) (Wines Located in New York) 3361 Rosemount Estate Shiraz - Vintage 1998 L'Insieme Show Reserve 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) (8) - Vintage 1997 F. Grasso 1lgsl (Wines Located (4) - Vintage 2005 in New York) Diamond Label 1nl (Wines Located in New York) (26) Montiano Above 34 bottles per lot $240-320 - Vintage 1997 Falesco (Wines Located in New (2) York) (95pts) 3362 Monkey Bay Chardonnay - Vintage 2004 1nl (Wines Located in New (9) Above 6 bottles per lot $280-380 York) and 2 magnums

Monkey Bay Sauvignon Blanc 3373 Anderson's Conn Valley Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) (11) - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

Los Vascos Sauvignon Blanc Carmenet Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1987 2lwrl (Wines Located in New (3) New York) York) Above 2 half-bottles per lot $160-240 and 11 bottles Château Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1993 bn, lbsl, ltl (Wines Located in (1) 3385 D'Arenberg Cabernet Sauvignon New York) (94+pts JK) - Vintage 1998 Copper Mine Road (Wines (3) Located in New York) (95pts) Duckhorn Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1985 bn, lscl, ltl (Wines Located in (1) D'Arenberg Grenache/Shiraz/Mourvedre New York) - Vintage 1998 Ironstone Pressings (Wines (1) Located in New York) Durney Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1982 (Wines Located in New York) (1) D'Arenberg Shiraz - Vintage 1998 Dead Arm (Wines Located in (2) Far Niente Cabernet Sauvignon New York) (96pts) - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 8 bottles per lot $190-260 D'Arenberg Shiraz/Viognier - Vintage 2005 The Laughing Magpie (Wines (1) 3377 Monticello Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Located in New York) - Vintage 1989 Corley Reserve 2nl (Wines (2) Above 7 bottles per lot $240-320 Located in New York) 3387 Galah Shiraz Mount Veeder Reserve Red - Vintage 1998 1bn (Wines Located in New (4) - Vintage 1997 4lscl (Wines Located in New (4) York) York) Above 6 bottles per lot $150-200 Gender's McLaren Park Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) 3383 Chambers Special Muscat York) - Vintage NV nl (Wines Located in New half-bottle - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (3) (1) York) J.J. Hahn Shiraz - Vintage 1998 Block 1914 ts, ltl (Wines (1) Chambers Special Tokay Located in New York) - Vintage NV lscl (Wines Located in New half-bottle (1) Jasper Hill Shiraz York) - Vintage 1995 Georgia's Paddock lscl (Wines (1) Located in New York) Christa Rolf Shiraz - Vintage 1998 4lscl, 1ltl (Wines Located in (4) Jeanneret Cabernet Sauvignon New York) - Vintage 1998 Clare Valley (Wines Located in (1) New York) Classic McLaren Grenache - Vintage 1998 La Testa (Wines Located in (1) Above 11 bottles per lot $170-240 New York) (91pts) 3388 Kangarilla Road Shiraz - Vintage 1999 La Testa (Wines Located in (3) - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (2) New York)

Kay Brothers Shiraz Craiglee Shiraz - Vintage 1998 Block 6 (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (2) York) (98pts)

Dalwhinnie Shiraz Hillside (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 1994 Victoria lscl (Wines Located in (1) York) - Vintage 2000 Block 6 (Wines Located in New (3) Located in New York) York) Parker Coonawarra Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Kay's Amery Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 Terra Rossa (Wines Located in (5) - Vintage 1998 spc (Wines Located in New (1) New York) York) Ralph Fowler Shiraz Kay's Amery Shiraz - Vintage 1997 Limestone Coast (Wines (1) - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (5) Located in New York) Above 13 bottles per lot $350-480 - Vintage 1998 Limestone Coast (Wines (1) Located in New York) 3389 Jim Barry Shiraz Above 15 bottles per lot $280-400 - Vintage 1994 McCrea Wood (Wines Located (1) ______in New York) 3396 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 1989 Pauillac Killibinbin Shiraz bn, lbsl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1998 Langhorne Creek (Wines (2) Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $140-180

Leasingham Shiraz - Vintage 1994 3397 Balifico Clare Valley (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 1997 Volpaia (Wines Located in New (1) York) Classic Clare (Wines Located in New York) (2) Brunello di Montalcino Classic Clare 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in - Vintage 1997 Riserva, Martinozzi (Wines (1) magnum (1) Located in New York) New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $70-100 Above 7 bottles per lot $200-280 ______and 1 magnum 3403 Mr. K - Vintage 2006 3390 Lengs & Cooter Reserve Shiraz Nobleman, Sine Qua Non - Vintage 1998 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) (Wines Located in New York) York) 2 half-bottles per lot $260-350

Lengs & Cooter Shiraz 3404 Mr. K - Vintage 2006 - Vintage 1995 Old Vines (Wines Located in (2) Strawman, Sine Qua Non New York) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1996 Swinton (Wines Located in (2) 1 half-bottle per lot $120-160 New York) - Vintage 1998 Swinton (Wines Located in (1) 3406 Kilikanoon Shiraz - Vintage 2004 New York) Testament - Vintage 1999 Old Vines (Wines Located in (3) 3lscl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) New York) 4 bottles per lot $160-220 ______Above 9 bottles per lot $190-260 3407 Barton & Guestier Bordeaux - Vintage 1975 3391 McAlister Red St. Estephe - Vintage 1994 1bn, 1nl (Wines Located in (4) 6vhs, 6hs, 12bsl, 2ltl, 12sdc, outstanding color New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $120-160 Oddfellows Shiraz - Vintage 1998 Langhorne Creek (Wines (4) 3408 11 bottles per lot $110-150 11hs, 11lbsl, 11sdc, outstanding 1 bottle per lot $550-750 color (Wines Located in New York) 3424 Château Margaux - Vintage 1975 Margaux 3409 10 bottles per lot $100-140 3ts, 3bsl, 3hwasl, 3cc, excellent color (Wines 2ts, 4vhs, 4hs, 10lbsl, 10sdc, Located in New York) outstanding color (Wines Located 3 bottles per lot $1000-1400 in New York) PARCEL LOTS 3425-3426 3410 7 bottles per lot $70-90 6hs, 6htms, 7bsl, 6dc, excellent 3425 1 bottle per lot $260-350 color (Wines Located in New hs, bsl, scc, excellent color (Wines York) Located in New York)

3411 8 bottles per lot $80-110 3426 1 bottle per lot $260-350 3vhs, 4hs, 8bsl, 1nl, 8sdc, vhs, bsl, nl, excellent color and 1excellent color, 1ts, 1wol, condition (Wines Located in New 1outstanding color (Wines Located York) in New York) 3428 Château Margaux - Vintage 1999 3412 Château Belgrave - Vintage 1986 Margaux Haut Medoc wasl (Wines Located in New York) 2lbsl, 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) "The wine reveals the vintage's flamboyant side in its sweet, blackberry, and cassis-scented nose. With airing, 2 bottles per lot $60-80 spicy vanillin and toast notes also emerge. Soft and full- bodied, there is admirable density behind the wine's 3417 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1975 superficial display of charm. The vintage's high sugars Pauillac have resulted in nearly 13% alcohol."(94pts) 1ts, 2hs, 3lstl, 1nl, 1sdc, 1pc, excellent color 1 bottle per lot $350-50 (Wines Located in New York) "...is a powerful Lafite, and troublesome bottles tend to 3430 Château Pavie reveal more tannin and funkiness than others, which - Vintage 1975 St. Emilion hs, lgsl, wol, (1) have a roasted character, combined with a gravelly, excellent color (Wines Located mineral underpinning. As this wine has aged, it appears to be less of a sure bet. In most cases, it has been an in New York) outstanding wine, as the bottle tasted in December suggested."(92pts) Château Vieux Robin 3 bottles per lot $1100-1500 - Vintage 1972 Medoc 1ts, 2vhs, 1hs, 1htms, (6) 4lscl, 2cc, 2excellent color, 1bn, 3418 1 bottle per lot $600-800 2lbsl, 2lwrl, 1nl (Wines bsl (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) Above 7 bottles per lot $80-120 3422 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1999 Pauillac 3431 Château Pontet Latour - Vintage 1975 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac "both elegant and intensely flavored, and almost vhs, bsl, ltl, wc, ssos, outstanding color (Wines diaphanous in its layers that unfold with no heaviness. An opaque ruby/purple color is accompanied by a Located in New York) complex bouquet of lead pencil, graphite, cedar, creme 1 Imperial per lot $240-350 de cassis, toast, and vanilla. It is medium-bodied, with extravagant layers of richness yet little weight, and a finish that is all sweetness, ripeness, and harmony. This 3432 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1989 extraordinary Lafite increasingly appears to be a Sauternes modern day clone of the majestic 1953. A mere one- (Wines Located in New York) third of the crop made it into the grand vin!"(95pts) "...extremely alcoholic and rich, with a huge nose of smoky, honey-covered coconuts and overripe pineapples and apricots so highly extracted and rich yet York) approachable."(97pts) 1 half-bottle per lot $180-240 Notarpanaro - Vintage 1988 Taurino wisl, sos (Wines (1) 3434 Beaujolais Nouveau Located in New York) - Vintage 2000 G. Duboeuf (Wines Located in (1) New York) Orvieto - Vintage 1980 Secco, Ruffino bn, lbsl, wc (1) Beaujolais Villages (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1979 L. Latour 3stl, 3sdc, gold color (3) Above 5 bottles per lot $85-130 (Wines Located in New York)

3474 Rioja Bourgogne Pinot Noir - Vintage 1964 - Vintage 1994 L. Jadot lbsl (Wines Located in (1) Sangre de Toro, M. Torres stl, ltl, outstanding color (1) New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 5 bottles per lot $25-50 - Vintage 1994 3448 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 1995 Vina Lanciano, Reserva, Bodegas LAN 2lbsl (Wines (2) M. Niellon Located in New York) 4lgsl, 4lwrl (Wines Located in New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $70-100 4 bottles per lot $160-200 3475 B.V. Cabernet Sauvignon 3468 Côteaux du Languedoc Ermitage du Pic St.-Loup - - Vintage 1997 Coastal lbsl (Wines Located in (1) Vintage 1999 New York) Pic St. Loup, Ravaille Freres B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1971 vhs, bsl, excellent color (Wines (1) 5 bottles per lot $100-130 Located in New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $75-100 3469 Riesling - Vintage 1967 3476 B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage Wehlener Sonnenuhr, J.J. Prum (Wines Located in (1) 1972 New York) 2ts, 1vhs, 3hs, 5stl, 1lstl, 1wol, 1sos, good color - Vintage 1978 (Wines Located in New York) Qualitatswein Grungold, Schloss Vollrads 4cm bc, (1) 6 bottles per lot $480-650 wisl, sos (Wines Located in New York)

Above 2 bottles per lot $80-110 3480 B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1973 3470 Riesling - Vintage 1978 1bn, 4bsl, 3gsl, excellent color (Wines Located in Qualitatswein Grungold, Schloss Vollrads New York) 1-3.5cm bc, 1-5.5cm bc, 3lbsl, 2lstl, 3sdc, 2sos 5 bottles per lot $500-700 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $90-120 3481 2 bottles per lot $200-300 2bn, 1ts, 3lstl, good color (Wines 3471 Brunello di Montalcino Located in New York) - Vintage 1998 Castello Banfi (Wines Located (1) in New York) 3483 B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1975 stl, excellent color (Wines (1) Gattinara Located in New York) - Vintage 1975 Travaglini 2ts, 2lstl, excellent (2) color (Wines Located in New - Vintage 1993 bsl (Wines Located in New (1) York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $90-120 10 bottles per lot $240-320

3486 Beringer Cabernet Sauvignon 3508 Sterling Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1974 - Vintage 1994 Knights Valley (Wines Located (3) 4bn, 4vhs, 2hs, 12lbsl, outstanding color (Wines in New York) Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $500-700 Ernest & Julio Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage NV (Wines Located in New York) magnum 3512 ZD Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1991 (1) 5lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $100-140 Gallo of Sonoma Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 3lscl (Wines Located in New (3) 3513 Andrew Murray Syrah York) - Vintage 1996 Hillside Reserve 1lbsl (Wines (2) Above 6 bottles per lot $120-170 Located in New York) and 1 magnum

Atlas Peak Sangiovese 3487 Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) "The opaque plum/purple color is followed by a superb Franus Pinot Noir nose of smoked herbs, melted licorice, and black - Vintage 1996 Beau Terroir Vineyard (Wines (1) currant jam. Full-bodied, with a silky texture, and an Located in New York) opulent personality."(94pts) Above 5 bottles per lot $65-100 2 bottles per lot $160-220 3514 Beringer Private Reserve Merlot 3491 Charles Krug Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 Bancroft Ranch (Wines Located (1) - Vintage 1968 vhs, wol, lstl, excellent color (1) in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Clos Pegase Merlot Chimney Rock Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1996 2wol (Wines Located in New (2) - Vintage 1994 2lbsl (Wines Located in New (2) York) York) Above 3 bottles per lot $90-120 Above 3 bottles per lot $120-170 3519 Freemark Abbey Petite Syrah - Vintage 1975 3497 Napa Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1995 York Creek 2lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 1bsl, 1outstanding color and condition, 1-4cm bc, 14 bottles per lot $280-350 1stl, 1sos, 1outstanding color (Wines Located in New York) 3502 Rubissow-Sargent Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2 bottles per lot $70-100 1994 (Wines Located in New York) 3520 Geyser Peak Merlot 12 bottles per lot $300-400 - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (2)

3503 Rubissow-Sargent Cabernet Sauvignon Hacienda Merlot - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (8) - Vintage 1997 Clair de Lune (Wines Located (1) in New York) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Above 10 bottles per lot $240-300 Havens Reserve Merlot - Vintage 1996 2lbsl (Wines Located in New (2) 3504 Rubissow-Sargent Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage York) 1997 Kendall Jackson Merlot mint is thrown in for complexity. They are full-bodied, gorgeous, highly extracted wines with sweet - Vintage 1996 Vintner's Reserve lbsl (Wines (1) tannin."(90pts) Located in New York) 9 bottles per lot $450-600

Makor Zinfandel 3528 Sean Thackrey Orion - Vintage 1995 - Vintage 1995 nl, pc (Wines Located in New (1) 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) York) "This dark ruby/purple-colored wine reveals intense aromas of licorice, peppery black cherry and currants, Marilyn Merlot with smoky, earthy notes in the background. On the - Vintage 2003 Norma Jean (Wines Located in (1) palate, the wine is seamlessly-textured, with medium to New York) full body, outstanding concentration, and oodles of personality."(91pts) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 Ojai Syrah - Vintage 1995 Roll Ranch vlscl, wc (Wines (1) 3530 Sean Thackrey Pleiades Located in New York) (90pts) - Vintage NV Old Vines (Wines Located in (1) Above 9 bottles per lot $130-200 New York)

3523 Pine Ridge Merlot St. Francis Merlot - Vintage 1996 Crimson Creek Vineyard lbsl (1) - Vintage 1995 lbsl (Wines Located in New (1) (Wines Located in New York) York)

Qupe Syrah Staglin Family Sangiovese - Vintage 1996 Hillside Estate, Bien Nacido (2) - Vintage 1997 Stagliano 2lbsl (Wines Located (2) Vineyard (Wines Located in in New York) New York)

Steele Pinot Noir Robert Mondavi Red - Vintage 1997 lbsl (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage NV bsl, dc (Wines Located in New magnum York) (1) York) Stellenzicht Syrah - Vintage 1994 1lstl, 1vlscl (Wines Located in (2) Rubissow-Sargent Merlot New York) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (9) Above 12 bottles per lot $130-190 Baron Herzog White Zinfandel and 1 magnum - Vintage 1992 bn, lbsl (Wines Located in New (1) York) 3524 Saintsbury Reserve Pinot Noir - Vintage 1995 Above 8 bottles per lot $65-110 1-4cm bc, 1lwisl, 1sos (Wines Located in New York) 3531 Freemark Abbey Chardonnay - Vintage 1977 12 bottles per lot $380-480 4-4cm bc, 2-4.5cm bc, 1-5.5cm bc, 1-6.5cm bc, 12bsl, 3wisl, 1nl, 2sos (Wines Located in New 3525 5 bottles per lot $160-200 York) (Wines Located in New York) 2-3.5cm bc, 1-4cm bc, 1-5cm bc, 5lbsl, 1ltl (Wines Located in New York) 3526 2 bottles per lot $60-80 (Wines Located in New York) 17 bottles per lot $320-450

3527 Sean Thackrey Orion - Vintage 1993 3532 Dolce Late Harvest 9sdc (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1994 Far Niente (Wines Located in half- bottle (1) "The 1992 and 1993 Orion are made from a vineyard planted in 1905 and believed to be Syrah. Both wines New York) exhibit intense, blackberry/cassis characters. A touch of Pastene Chablis Eden Valley Riesling - Vintage NV bsl, nl (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 1995 Heggie's Vineyard (Wines half-bottle York) (7) Located in New York) Beaux Freres Pinot Noir Above 7 half-bottles per lot $100-170 - Vintage 1996 Beaux Freres Vineyard (Wines (2) and 9 bottles Located in New York) 3537 Galway Pipe Tawny Port - Vintage NV Glogg Red (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage NV Boyden Valley (Wines Located (1) 11 bottles per lot $160-220 in New York) 3539 Jasper Hill Shiraz - Vintage 1996 Redhawk Pinot Noir Georgia's Paddock - Vintage 1994 1lscl, 3stl (Wines Located in (6) (Wines Located in New York) New York) 5 bottles per lot $200-300 Above 1 half-bottle per lot $160-220 and 10 bottles 3540 Maxwell Shiraz - Vintage 1997 Ellen Street (Wines Located in (1) 3534 Glen Fiona Syrah - Vintage 1997 New York) 1lscl, 1tl (Wines Located in New York) (2) Bacchus Vineyard 9lscl (Wines Located in New (9) Mount Horrocks Shiraz York) - Vintage 1996 lbsl (Wines Located in New (1) Above 11 bottles per lot $220-320 York)

3535 Riverbend Red Pirramimma Shiraz - Vintage NV Boyden Valley (Wines Located (1) - Vintage 1997 4lbsl (Wines Located in New (4) in New York) York)

Château Morisette White Preece Merlot - Vintage NV Our Dog Blue lwrl, lstl, wol, (1) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) sdc (Wines Located in New York) Rosabrook Shiraz - Vintage 1998 Abattoir Block 1nl (Wines (2) Ausvetia Shiraz Located in New York) - Vintage 1994 lbsl (Wines Located in New (2) York) Taltarni Shiraz - Vintage 1978 bn, bsl, lstl, outstanding color (1) Banrock Station Shiraz (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 10 bottles per lot $170-220

Chapel Hill Shiraz 3542 Penfold's Shiraz/Mourvedre/Grenache - Vintage - Vintage 1996 lbsl (Wines Located in New (1) 1997 York) Old Vine lbsl (Wines Located in New York) Coriole Shiraz 1 bottle per lot $260-350 - Vintage 1998 2lbsl (Wines Located in New (2) York) (90pts) 3543 Rosemount Estate Shiraz - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (3) Ebenezer Shiraz - Vintage 1995 lbsl (Wines Located in New (1) Rosemount Estate Shiraz/Cabernet Sauvignon York) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Rosemount Estate Syrah 3569 Livingston Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1995 Balmoral lbsl (Wines Located (1) - Vintage 1997 Moffett Vineyard 2nl, 2wol (2) in New York) (Wines Located in New York)

Seaview Shiraz Viader Red - Vintage 1987 6lbsl, 1lscl (Wines Located in (7) - Vintage 1998 V (Wines Located in New York) (1) New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $110-150 Above 12 bottles per lot $100-160 ______

3571 Château Suduiraut - Vintage 1959 3544 Vasse Felix Cabernet Merlot Sauternes - Vintage 1996 5lbsl (Wines Located in New (5) 2bn, 1vhs, 3lbsl, 2stl, 1sos, 1 bottle different York) importer, beautiful amber color (Wines Located in New York) Waninga Reserve Shiraz (5 stars MB) - Vintage 1997 Skilly Hills lbsl (Wines Located (1) 2 bottles per lot $900-1200 in New York) ______

Wolf Blass Shiraz 3578 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1982 - Vintage 1990 President's Selection 2lbsl (2) St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) bn, nl (Wines Located in New York) Above 8 bottles per lot $95-130 "Exhibits an explosive nose of new saddle leather, plums, prunes, black cherry jam, chocolate, steak tartar, and roasted espresso. Unbelievably powerful, 3547 Egri Bikaver Red thick, and intense, with full body, mouth-searing tannin - Vintage 1994 Vivamus Bull's Blood (Wines (1) levels, a grilled steak-like flavor, and a huge, intense Located in New York) finish..."(96pts) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 ______Concha Y Toro Merlot - Vintage 1996 Sunrise (Wines Located in New (10) 3583 Château Ducru Beaucaillou - Vintage 1998 York) St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) Concha Y Toro Cabernet Sauvignon "...a blend of 70% Cabernet Sauvignon and 30% - Vintage 1976 bn, hstl, wc, excellent color (1) Merlot. An excellent wine... Classically proportioned (Wines Located in New York) with plenty of plum and cassis fruit intermixed with toasty oak as well as minerals, it possesses good power, medium body, excellent richness, and a concentrated, Concha Y Toro Sauvignon Blanc firm, angular finish. It has been well-made."(91pts) - Vintage 1979 lwrl, wc, excellent color (Wines (1) 1 bottle per lot $100-140 Located in New York)

Above 13 bottles per lot $80-120 3585 Château La Mission Haut Brion - Vintage 1982 ______Graves 3558 Riesling - Vintage 1971 bn, nl, wol (Wines Located in New York) Raventhaler Baiken, Von Simmern "A thick, unctuously-textured wine with massive richness as well as abundant notes of black fruits, 3.5cm bc, lbsl, lscl, sdc, sos (Wines Located in truffles, creosote, scorched earth, smoke, and camphor, New York) a colossal mouthfeel, a layered texture, incredible depth of fruit and glycerin, and copious, but well-integrated 1 bottle per lot $90-120 tannins that are largely concealed by the incredible amount of fruit. An old school La Mission, it is a tour de 3560 Vino Nobile di Montepulciano - Vintage 1997 force that should continue to age effortlessly for another Grande Annati Riserva, Avignonesi 40+ years."(100pts) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $800-1100 2 bottles per lot $90-120 3590 Château Margaux - Vintage 1978 Margaux 3625 Switchback Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2hs, 2lstl, 1nl, 2cc, outstanding color (Wines 2001 Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The 1978 s nose has moved from one of ripe fruit and "...to die for! Given its quality, the price is surprisingly spicy oak, to tarry, truffle, earthy aromas that come realistic, considering how many California North Coast across as slightly too masculine and meaty. mediocrities fetch three digit prices. This opaque Nevertheless, this is a rich, full-bodied, concentrated purple-colored Cabernet exhibits wonderfully sweet Margaux it remains one of the few great wines from the aromas of melted licorice intermixed with cedar wood, 1978 vintage."(92pts) black currant liqueur, chocolate, and spice box. This full-throttle, unctuously-textured, dense, broad, pure, 2 bottles per lot $650-900 impeccably balanced, expansive 2001 is mouth-coating in its richness and intensity."(98pts) 3592 Château Palmer - Vintage 1982 1 bottle per lot $150-200 Margaux ______ts, lwrl (Wines Located in New York) "Full, deep red. Spicy aromas of cassis and rose petal, 3633 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2011 with a whiff of meat. Then wonderfully penetrating and Les Échézeaux, J.L. & E. Burguet classy, with bright acidity giving the wine superb clarity (Wines Located in New York) and thrust. This has terrific structure. Finishes very long and fine, with excellent grip. By far the finest bottle 7 bottles per lot $350-500 I've tasted to date of this wine, and one of the real surprises of the tasting."(93pts IWC) 3636 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2008 1 bottle per lot $240-320 R. Bouvier (Wines Located in New York) 3606 Andrew Will Merlot 6 bottles per lot $500-700 - Vintage 1995 Pepper Bridge (Wines Located (2) in New York) 3645 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2006 Reserve, Domaine de la Vieille Julienne Andrew Will Reserve Merlot (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (1) "This extraordinary offering boasts an opaque purple Above 3 bottles per lot $110-150 color as well as awesome aromatics consisting of ______ground pepper, blueberry and blackberry jam, and kirsch liqueur. It is full-bodied, with multiple layers, a seamless integration of acidity and tannin, and a finish 3610 Château Clinet - Vintage 1989 that lasts over a minute."(100pts) Pomerol 1 bottle per lot $180-240 1lbsl, 2sdc, 1scc (Wines Located in New York) "...offering up pure scents of flowers, black-raspberries, currants, vanillin, and truffles. Full-bodied, with a 3651 Billecart Salmon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2002 seamless texture, fabulous concentration, a massive Rose, cuvée Elisabeth Salmon degree of richness, but no heaviness or awkwardness, 2x6 bottle ocb's (Wines Located in New York) this remains one of the most profound young wines I have ever tasted. Its sweetness of fruit and layers of 12 bottles per lot $2400-3200 flavor, combined with its remarkable texture are the stuff of legends..."(100pts) 3652 4 bottles per lot $800-1100 2 bottles per lot $1000-1400 (Wines Located in New York)

3611 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1982 3663 Testamatta Red - Vintage 2007 Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) ts, lscl, scc, nc, cuc (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $200-280 "...Still backward with a deep ruby/plum color revealing only a touch of lightening at the edge, the wine offers up an extraordinary nose of caramelized herbs, smoke, 3666 Vin Santo di Montepulciano - Vintage 1999 cedar, pen ink, black currants, and earth. The gorgeous Le Casalte aromatics are followed by a full-bodied, plump, rich, 1lwisl (Wines Located in New York) fleshy wine with low acidity."(97+pts) 11 half-bottles per lot $220-300 1 bottle per lot $2000-2600 ______3669 Clos Mogador - Vintage 2009 1x1 5 liter owc (Wines Located in New York) 9 bottles per lot $260-350 ______1 5 liter per lot $1800-2400 3704 St. Aubin - Vintage 2009 3671 Clos Mogador - Vintage 2010 En Remilly, M. Colin 1x1 5 liter owc (Wines Located in New York) sos (Wines Located in New York) 1 5 liter per lot $1800-2400 1 bottle per lot $25-30

3673 Pedro Ximenez Red - Vintage NV PARCEL LOTS 3705-3706 Gran Barquero (Wines Located in New York) 3705 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2006 7 bottles per lot $260-350 Clos de la Maltroie, M. Niellon (Wines Located in New York) 3675 Monsant 1 bottle per lot $60-80 - Vintage 2009 Les Pujoles, Orto Vins (Wines Located in New (6) 3706 1 bottle per lot $60-80 York) (Wines Located in New York) Les Tallades, Orto Vins 2lscl (Wines Located in (5) New York) PARCEL LOTS 3707-3708 Palell, Orto Vins 1x6 bottle ocb, 2lstl (Wines (9) Located in New York) 3707 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2008 Teixar, Vinyes Domenech (Wines Located in New (2) Clos de la Maltroie, M. Niellon York) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2010 1 bottle per lot $60-80 La Carrerada, Orto Vins 2lscl (Wines Located in (6) New York) 3708 1 bottle per lot $60-80 Above 28 bottles per lot $650-900 (Wines Located in New York)

PARCEL LOTS 3709-3710 3686 Linne Calodo Cellars Grenache - Vintage 2011 Rising Tides 3709 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) Les Champs Gains, M. Niellon 6 bottles per lot $350-500 (Wines Located in New York) "This is also quite ripe but stops short of being overtly PARCEL LOTS 3691-3692 exotic with notes of resin oil and orchard fruit aromas that introduce rich, full and delicious medium-bodied 3691 Brewer-Clifton Chardonnay - Vintage 2011 flavors that possess very good length and I like the textured and sappy mouth feel."(90pts BH) 3d (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $70-90 6 bottles per lot $300-400 3710 1 bottle per lot $70-90 (Wines Located in New York) 3692 6 bottles per lot $300-400 (Wines Located in New York) PARCEL LOTS 3711-3712

3696 Diatom Chardonnay - Vintage 2011 3711 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2008 Kazaoto (Wines Located in New York) (8) Les Champs Gains, M. Niellon Hamon (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) Above 9 bottles per lot $500-700 1 bottle per lot $80-110

3698 Arterberry Maresh Chardonnay - Vintage 2009 3712 1 bottle per lot $80-110 Dundee Hills (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) PARCEL LOTS 3713-3714 "A ripe and beautifully layered nose offers up light spice notes as well as a mix of both red and blue pinot fruit aromas that introduce rich and full-bodied flavors 3713 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2006 that display a hint of crushed leaf along with plenty of Les Chaumees, Clos de la Truffiere, M. Niellon dry extract that does a commendable job of buffering (Wines Located in New York) the moderately firm tannins on the long, serious and mouth coating finish."(92pts BH) 1 bottle per lot $70-90 1 bottle per lot $70-90 ______3714 1 bottle per lot $70-90 (Wines Located in New York) 3722 Château Brane Cantenac - Vintage 1928 Margaux 3715 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2008 hs, lstl, scc, Nicolas, excellent color (Wines Les Chaumees, Clos de la Truffiere, M. Niellon Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Great nose - very young - anise, plums, stones, 1 bottle per lot $70-90 minerals...real cherry fruit to the nose with an earthy backbone...excellent finish - huge tannins."(94pts JK)

3716 Meursault - Vintage 2006 1 bottle per lot $350-600 En Luraule, R. Jobard 3723 Château Brane Cantenac - Vintage 1970 (Wines Located in New York) Margaux 1 bottle per lot $20-25 hs, excellent color and condition (Wines Located in New York) 3717 Riesling Auslese - Vintage 2003 Braunberger Juffer Sonnenuhr, Dr. Pauly Bergweiler 1 bottle per lot $50-70 lscl (Wines Located in New York) 3724 Château Haut Brion - Vintage 1953 1 bottle per lot $25-30 Graves htms, stl, lscl, cuc, sdc, outstanding color (Wines 3718 Ravenswood Red - Vintage 1993 Located in New York) Pickberry "Haunting nose - big, sweet, coffee cake aroma, touch sdc (Wines Located in New York) of gravel, a little smoke and tobacco gets more earthy 1 magnum per lot $30-40 and gravelly in the glass initially, but it comes full circle towards a core of brown sugared fruit more alcohol, tannins, and gravel on the finish than any other wine so 3719 Taylor Fladgate Vintage Port - Vintage 1978 far was neck and neck with the Palmer but the Haut Quinta de Vargellas Brion exerted itself more as it stayed in the glass while vhs, lstl, lscl, ltl, sos (Wines Located in New York) the Palmer did not."(95pts JK) 1 bottle per lot $25-35 1 bottle per lot $800-1200 ______3725 Château La Mission Haut Brion - Vintage 1989 3720 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 2005 Graves Domaine de la Vougeraie (Wines Located in New York) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "I am certainly not going to argue with anyone who "Moderate wood spice and a pretty if serious mix of red believes La Mission-Haut-Brion's 1989 is every bit as berry, black pinot and plenty of earth influence can be profound as the 1989 Haut-Brion. It is a spectacular found on the round, rich and very suave full-bodied wine, and as it ages in the bottle, it is quickly becoming flavors that possess ample volume and excellent one of my all-time favorite La Mission-Haut-Brions, underlying material though the finish is perhaps not ranking alongside the 1982, 1975, 1961, 1959, and quite as precise and delineated as the very best in the 1955. The 1989 boasts a dense, thick, purple color, range. Still, this offers plenty of character and superb followed by a sweet, roasted cassis, chocolatey-scented length plus it's less youthfully austere than most nose with whiffs of tobacco, tar, and minerals. The wine examples at this very early stage."(92pts BH) is extremely full-bodied, unctuously-textured, sweet, jammy, and rich. Although it is still a youthful, 2 bottles per lot $200-280 unformed wine, it is already delicious to drink."(100pts) 1 bottle per lot $750-1000 3721 Rivers Marie Pinot Noir - Vintage 2008 Summa Old Vines 3726 Château Latour - Vintage 1943 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac edge. The nose offered up that explosive Mouton perfume of mint, leather, cassis, black olives, and lead htms, lbsl, outstanding color (Wines Located in pencil. In the mouth, there was stunning concentration, New York) magnificent extraction of fruit, and plenty of tannin in "I thought its bouquet was as good as the 45 beautifully the long finish. The wine tasted remarkably young and developed , delicate yet concentrated . Rich, crisp and could easily last another 20-30 years. Amazing!"(97pts) flavoury..."(4 stars MB) 1 bottle per lot $1000-1300 1 bottle per lot $850-1200 3731 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1959 3727 Château Latour - Vintage 1947 Pauillac Pauillac htms, stl, nl, outstanding color (Wines Located in hs, bsl, nl, spc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) New York) "I was blown away by this Mouton, which to me is one "We finished this glorious evening with a strong pocket of the three greatest Moutons made in the last thirty- pair, beginning with the 1947 Latour. The 47 has never five years (1982 and 1986 being the others) This been considered one of the top-tier wines of this particular bottle was astonishingly young and legendary vintage, but this bottle shattered that myth. unevolved, with a black/purple color, a huge, yet still The '47 was creamy and nutty with a sweet, open nose. youthful nose of cassis, minerals, and new oak. Aromas of grape and broth were present in this rich, Exceptionally powerful and super-extracted, with the saucy and sexy wine. The palate was lush and chunky, fruit supported by high levels of tannin and some lusty grapy again due to the youthfulness of the bottle, but quantities of It may well be a 100-year there was a kiss of toughness to its finish. Its secondary wine!..."(100pts) acidity was impressive, and the wine got longer and zippier in the glass. This was another great Latour, 1 bottle per lot $1600-2200 undervalued in the market."(96pts JK) 1 bottle per lot $1000-1500 3732 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1970 Pauillac 3728 Château Margaux - Vintage 1961 hs, stl, ltl, scc (Wines Located in New York) "Deep garnet; fragrant tar and black truffle nose; Margaux extremely concentrated; big and mouth-filling, with very htms, scc, excellent color (Wines Located in New dense cassis flavor; enormous, generous fruit; a York) voluptuous claret."(96pts WS) "Great nose - forward and leathery with a carob, sweet 1 bottle per lot $320-500 caramel profile...nice tannins...delicious! I think that both the '59 and '61 Margaux are both severely underrated and appreciated when it comes to the First 3733 Château Talbot - Vintage 1947 Growth-odometer - probably the best first growth to St. Julien drink in both vintages right now."(95pts JK) hs, lstl, lscl, excellent color and condition (Wines 1 bottle per lot $900-1200 Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 3729 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1952 Pauillac 3734 Barons de Rothschild - Vintage 2006 hs, lbsl, ltl, outstanding color and condition Reserve spéciale (Wines Located in New York) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "Six notes but none in the 1990s. Nevertheless. Looking at these notes I am left with the impression that this has 4 bottles per lot $160-220 the vivid colour, fragrance and flavour to more then make up for the hard tannins. Worth looking out for". 3735 Hermitage - Vintage 1952 (Last tasted April 1986**** MB) La Chapelle, P. Jaboulet 1 half-bottle per lot $350-500 stl, ll, excellent color and condition (Wines Located in New York) 3730 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1955 "...was no slouch, either. Showing more animal and Pauillac game and smoother and softer in style, it was another hs, hstl, outstanding color and condition (Wines beauty."(94pts JK) Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $800-1200 "This should be a vintage to buy at auction as I suspect the price is more reasonable than what such acclaimed 3736 Martini & Rossi Vino Vermouth - Vintage NV vintages as 1959 and 1961 fetch. The color revealed no Gran Medaglia D'Oro amber or rust, only a slight lightening of intensity at the lbsl, ltl, excellent color and condition (Wines 3741 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2006 Located in New York) Rancia Riserva, Felsina 1 bottle per lot $40-60 (Wines Located in New York) ______"The 2006 Chianti Classico Riserva Rancia is another of the truly great wines... It is most similar in style to 3737 Chianti Classico - Vintage 1999 the 2001 for its power, but also has some of the aromatic finesse and complexity of the 2004. Layers of Rancia Riserva, Felsina fruit build to the explosive, huge finish."(96+pts) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $120-150 "The 1999 Chianti Classico Riserva Rancia is an introspective wine that appears to still be stuck in its adolescence. Over time the fruit begins to emerge, but 3742 3 bottles per lot $120-150 only with great reluctance. This is a complex, broad- (Wines Located in New York) shouldered wine with tons of power and big tannins. Hints of dried roses, licorice and rich, expansive fruit saturate the palate on the finish. Readers cellaring the 3743 3 bottles per lot $120-150 1999 will need to be patient, but this is a magnificent (Wines Located in New York) wine that will be even more compelling as the tannins soften a bit more and the fruit fleshes out."(94pts) PARCEL LOTS 3744-3745 2 bottles per lot $90-120 3744 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2007 3738 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2000 Rancia Riserva, Felsina Rancia Riserva, Felsina (Wines Located in New York) 2tl (Wines Located in New York) "The 2007 Chianti Classico Riserva Rancia is another "The 2000 Chianti Classico Riserva Rancia is dazzling wine. This is a vintage of overt, sumptuous impressive. It comes across as a larger scaled version fruit and pure sexiness. Despite its richness, the 2007 of the 1995, with all of the elements beautifully in place never loses its sense of structure, but in this vintage the and aging in pure harmony. Hints of spices, licorice and tannins are nearly buried by the huge fruit. Today the tobacco are layered into the finish."(94pts) 2007 comes across as a hypothetical blend of the 2004 and 2006, with the finesse of the former and the size of 2 bottles per lot $90-120 the latter. Not a bad combination, to put it mildly. In the glass the wine is alive, vibrant and totally 3739 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2001 captivating."(96pts) Rancia Riserva, Felsina 3 bottles per lot $100-120 (Wines Located in New York) "The 2001 Chianti Classico Riserva Rancia has all of 3745 3 bottles per lot $100-120 the ingredients to be a modern-day legend. Aromatic complexity, vibrant fruit and firm yet well-integrated (Wines Located in New York) tannins are all present. This is a vintage that stands out for its exceptional overall balance. Everything that 3746 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2008 makes Rancia a great wine is found in the 2001. The Rancia Riserva, Felsina 2001 remains incredibly young, and the tannins need time to soften. Readers who bought the 2001 are going (Wines Located in New York) to be thrilled. This is a great showing."(95pts) "Silky tannins frame a core of black cherries, plums, licorice and tobacco through to the vibrant finish. The 3 bottles per lot $110-150 2008 speaks of textural finesse and silkiness first and foremost. I will not be surprised if the 2008 blossoms 3740 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2004 further with more time in bottle. Today it is immensely Rancia Riserva, Felsina beautiful."(93+pts) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $100-120 "The 2004 Chianti Classico Riserva Rancia is pure silk on the palate...Sweet roses, spices and licorice are all 3747 2 bottles per lot $70-80 woven together beautifully on the impossibly fine, (Wines Located in New York) dazzling finish. This is a wine of unbelievable harmony. ______Proprietor Giuseppe Mazzocolin and longtime oenologist Franco Bernabei have elevated Sangiovese to a level of sophistication rarely seen."(96pts) 3748 Château Brane Cantenac - Vintage 1971 Margaux bn, bsl, nl, sdc, (1) 3 bottles per lot $120-150 excellent color and condition PARCEL LOTS 3741-3743 (Wines Located in New York) Aloxe Corton 3756 Vosne Romanée - Vintage 2010 - Vintage 1978 Clos du Chapitre, Remoissenet (1) Les Beaux Monts, B. Clavelier (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $80-110 3 bottles per lot $260-350

3749 Château Cantenac Brown - Vintage 1979 3757 Meursault - Vintage 1975 Margaux Faiveley 1bn, 1ts, 2bsl, 1ltl, 1nl, 1scc, excellent color and 1-3.5cm bc, 1-4cm bc, 2-4.5cm bc, 7bsl, 4stl, condition (Wines Located in New York) 3wisl, 1lscl, 1nl, excellent color (Wines Located 2 bottles per lot $70-90 in New York) 7 bottles per lot $140-190 3750 Château Dassault - Vintage 1955 St. Emilion PARCEL LOTS 3758-3759 vhs, bsl, lstl, scc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 3758 Corton Charlemagne - Vintage 1988 L. Max 1 bottle per lot $80-110 12bsl, 7stl, 6hscl, 6htl, 5lstl, 4scl, 4tl, 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) 3751 Château Haut Brion - Vintage 1964 Graves 12 bottles per lot $500-700 5cm bc, bsl, stl, nl, scc, ssos (Wines Located in New York) 3759 12 bottles per lot $500-700 "1964 was a very good year for the Graves Châteaux. 9scl, 8tl, 7bsl, 5lbsl, 5lstl, 5stl, Haut-Brion's 1964 is fully mature as evidenced by the 3lscl, 2hstl, 2htl, 1ltl, 2scc (Wines amber edge to its color, and has a splendidly rich, Located in New York) earthy, tobacco-and-mineral-scented bouquet. Ripe, deep, supple, voluptuous flavors are present on the palate."(90pts) 3760 Chassagne Montrachet Blanc - Vintage 2008 1 bottle per lot $320-420 Le Cailleret, Marc Colin (Wines Located in New York) 3752 Château La Fleur Pétrus - Vintage 1970 6 bottles per lot $300-400 Pomerol 1bn, 1ts, 2bsl, 2lstl, outstanding color (Wines 3761 Chassagne Montrachet Blanc - Vintage 2009 Located in New York) Le Cailleret, Marc Colin 2 bottles per lot $350-480 (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $300-400 3753 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1973 Pauillac 3762 Chassagne Montrachet Blanc - Vintage 2010 bn, htal, bsl, cuc, excellent color (Wines Located Les Champs Gains, Marc Colin in New York) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 6 bottles per lot $300-400

3754 Corton - Vintage 2009 3763 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1975 Rognets, B. Clavelier 1x1 bottle ogb, outstanding color and condition (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $300-400 "A pure Dom Pérignon with everything in its rightful place."(93pts RJ)

3755 Vosne Romanée - Vintage 2009 1 bottle per lot $400-600 Les Beaux Monts, B. Clavelier (Wines Located in New York) 3764 Veuve Clicquot Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1973 Carte d'Or 3 bottles per lot $260-350 bsl, nl, outstanding color and condition (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York) ______"A candidate for the wine of the vintage, this blend of 80% Merlot and 20% Cabernet Franc is a big, 3765 Château Ausone - Vintage 2006 concentrated effort of extraordinary intensity and St. Emilion richness. A sensational bouquet of sweet blueberry, black raspberry, and black currant fruit interwoven (Wines Located in New York) with scents of charcoal, incense, graphite, and pain "Boasting an inky/blue/purple color as well as an grille is followed by an extraordinarily intense, full- extraordinary, precise bouquet of minerals, flowers, bodied, amazingly concentrated wine displaying blueberry liqueur, and black currants, this wine elevated tannins in the finish."(97pts) possesses fabulous fruit and great intensity, but what makes it so special is its precision, focus, and almost 3 bottles per lot $350-480 ethereal lightness despite substantial flavor intensity and depth. It is a ballerina with density and power. The 3771 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1988 abundant noticeable tannin is sweet and, not surprisingly, very finely grained."(98pts) Pauillac bn (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $900-1200 "The 88 had a wonderful nose, very smoky in addition to the usual cedar, mineral and tobacco. It has nice vim, 3766 Château Faugeres - Vintage 2005 but I wouldn t call it vigor. There was also some exotic St. Emilion chestnut on a secondary bed of cassis. Pencil was there, along with good spice. Long and hearty, the 88 Lafite (Wines Located in New York) had good intensity without being intense. Carob, earth, 6 bottles per lot $200-300 tobacco and a kiss of wood flavors rounded out this excellent wine."(94pts JK) 3767 Château Fombrauge - Vintage 2005 1 bottle per lot $500-700 St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) 3772 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1996 6 bottles per lot $180-240 St. Julien 2vlgsl (Wines Located in New York) "...a spectacular nose of cassis, cherry liqueur, pain 3768 Château L'Evangile - Vintage 1990 grille, and minerals. It is powerful and rich on the Pomerol attack, with beautifully integrated tannin, massive 2bn, 2lscl, 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) concentration, yet no hint of heaviness or disjointedness "The 1990 L Evangile was classic, very expressive with It is a remarkable, seamless, palate-staining, and lots of tannins and alcohol in the nose. It also had extraordinarily elegant wine - the quintessential St.- luscious fruit, a plum, cassis and black olive trifecta. Julien."(98pts) There were secondary brick, wheat and nut aromas. Its 2 bottles per lot $420-550 fruit was meltingly sweet, and red mixed in with purple and a splash of black. It was quite explosive on the finish with its tannins and acidity, yet it was still 3773 Château Lynch Bages - Vintage 1985 balanced with a wealth of a fruit rainbow. Green olive Pauillac flavors graced its finish. It was just flat-out delicious 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) wine, still sturdy, long and fine. Some food toned down "A fastball of a nose...pinch of green/wet hay but still the (positive) aggressive nature of its t n a qualities, but nice, ripe, and round...cherry, allspice, and wet stones its acidity stayed long and scintillating."(96pts JK) develop...gets more and more complex in the 3 bottles per lot $750-1000 glass...tastes very young and has a liqueur-like cassis quality on the palate...I was sure this was the 1982, but it was the 1985 - good show!..."(94pts JK) 3769 Château La Fleur de Bouard - Vintage 2000 Lalande a Pomerol 3 bottles per lot $400-500 (Wines Located in New York) "A saturated purple color is followed by a gorgeous 3774 1 bottle per lot $130-170 perfume of ink, plum, cassis, licorice, smoke, and ts, vlscl, nc (Wines Located in espresso. Dense, full-bodied, and opulent, offering a New York) hedonistic as well as intellectual turn-on, it should drink well for 10-15 years."(91pts) 3775 Château Lynch Bages - Vintage 1988 6 bottles per lot $180-240 Pauillac 1lstl (Wines Located in New York) 3770 Château La Mondotte - Vintage 2006 "... is one of the best efforts of the vintage. Although the St. Emilion bouquet is still reserved, it reveals attractive herbal, cassis, smoky aromas. In the mouth, there is 6 bottles per lot $1800-2400 considerable richness and weight, a full-bodied, powerful feel on the palate, and a long, moderately tannic finish."(92pts) 3784 Savigny les Beaune - Vintage 1986 Maison Leroy 3 bottles per lot $350-500 (Wines Located in New York) 3776 Château Lynch Moussas - Vintage 2000 6 bottles per lot $420-500 Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) 3785 Chevalier Montrachet - Vintage 2005 M. Niellon 6 bottles per lot $190-300 (Wines Located in New York) "A very deft touch of wood frames the understated and 3777 Château Marquis de Terme - Vintage 2000 backward nose of white flower and pear aromas that St. Julien lead to mineral-infused and stunningly intense and (Wines Located in New York) precise medium full flavors that culminate in a hugely long yet focused and explosive finish. As one would 6 bottles per lot $300-400 expect, this scintillates with minerality and this liquid stone quality defines the character of this wine from 3778 Château Troplong Mondot - Vintage 2006 start to finish. In a word, harmonious. Note that St. Emilion patience will be required." (94pts BH) 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $500-700 "...is an impressive, powerful, broad, surprisingly masculine and deep effort. Its inky/blue/purple color is 3786 Corton Charlemagne - Vintage 2006 accompanied by an exceptional bouquet of powdered Coche-Dury rock, blackberries, blueberries, spring flowers, and hints of camphor as well as espresso roast. The wine is vlscl (Wines Located in New York) full-bodied with a layered, multidimensional texture, "This is also quite restrained yet strikingly pure and sensational purity and structure, and elevated levels of highly complex with a nose of white flower, green fruit tannin, concentration, and richness."(93pts) and discreet spice aromas that complements perfectly the delicious, intense and stony big-bodied and overtly 12 bottles per lot $750-1000 muscular flavors that are wonderfully vibrant and gorgeously detailed on the transparent and explosive 3779 Château Doisy Daëne - Vintage 2003 finish that really coats the palate with extract. This is Sauternes beautifully balanced and understated with a youthfully austere finale."(94pts BH) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $1300-1600 3 bottles per lot $110-150

3787 Meursault - Vintage 2002 3780 Château Monbousquet Blanc - Vintage 2006 Blagny, Maison Leroy St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $600-800 6 bottles per lot $180-240

3788 Montrachet - Vintage 2005 3781 Bourgogne Pinot Noir - Vintage 2006 Sauzet Coche-Dury (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...offering up notes of anise, peach, pear, citrus, 6 bottles per lot $500-700 orange blossom and honey that also merges seamlessly into textured, sweet, powerful and robust full-bodied flavors that possess a seductive mouth feel yet excellent 3782 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 2006 precision and cut as well."(96pts BH) Arlaud 1 bottle per lot $350-500 (Wines Located in New York)

6 bottles per lot $600-800 3789 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 1991 La Landonne, E. Guigal 3783 Hospices de Beaune, Mazis Chambertin - Vintage lstl, ltl, tvl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) 2005 "...huge, smoky, new saddle leather, licorice, Asian cuvée Madelaine Collignon, La Gibryotte spice, meaty, and cassis scents. Black in color, with (Wines Located in New York) layers of richness, huge body, massive extraction, and a phenomenal finish, it is another legend from Marcel 3795 Kapcsandy Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage Guigal."(99pts) 2005 1 bottle per lot $500-700 Estate cuvée, State Lane Vineyard 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) PARCEL LOTS 3790-3791 "...reveals a dense ruby/purple color as well as a gorgeous nose of chocolate-covered black cherries and 3790 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 2003 hints of cedar and licorice, medium to full body, superb richness and weight, and moderate tannins."(94pts) La Mouline, E. Guigal 12 bottles per lot $1200-1600 (Wines Located in New York) "The 2003 Côte-Rotie La Mouline is by far the most delicate and elegant wine but the enormous aromatics 3796 12 bottles per lot $1200-1600 of spring flowers intermixed with Crème de cassis, 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in black raspberry, mocha, caramel, and cola, and New York) enormous full-bodied opulence and striking velvety, ______seamless texture make for one of the most memorable wines anyone could every drink."(100pts) 3797 Vieux Château Certan - Vintage 2011 1 bottle per lot $450-600 Pomerol 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 3791 1 bottle per lot $450-600 "...offers a beautiful bouquet of plums, black cherries, (Wines Located in New York) cassis and hints of graphite as well as spice, an excellent texture and medium body."(91pts) 3792 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1973 6 bottles per lot $500-700 Oenotheque 1x1 bottle owc, outstanding color and condition 3798 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1993 (Wines Located in New York) A. Rousseau "I was in the mood for a refresher, and did those 1973s 2lbsl, 2lscl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) ever qualify and then some. It was one of the greatest Champagne experiences of my life. I don t know if it 2 bottles per lot $300-400 was just that point in time and space where bottles undress themselves right in front of your very own lips 3799 Latricieres Chambertin - Vintage 1996 and show incredibly due to circumstance and the theory Camus of relativity, wine-wise of course. This champagne was incredible, so delicious and incredibly balanced, racy, 2x3 magnum ocb's (Wines Located in New York) bready, nutty - it had it all."(98pts JK) 6 magnums per lot $1400-1800 1 bottle per lot $1200-1600 3800 Clos de Tart - Vintage 1995 3793 Krug Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1990 Domaine du Clos de Tart (Wines Located in New York) 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) "An aristocrat. Big-boned and intense, yet with finesse "Displaying a medium-to-dark ruby color and a lovely and complex flavors of coconut, whole-grain bread, nose of spicy red berries, cracked black pepper, Asian ginger, citrus and honey. Waves of flavor saturate the spices, and distinctive notes of cedar, this is a medium- palate and the long finish picks up a mineral and smoke to-full-bodied, velvety-textured, and complex wine. Its note. Very harmonious from start to finish."(97pts WS) enthralling flavor profile offers layers of rich black pepper-laced blueberries and blackberries that are 5 bottles per lot $1600-2200 intensely spiced with cinnamon, juniper berries, and hints of eucalyptus."(92pts) 3794 Louis Roederer Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2000 1 magnum per lot $600-800 Cristal (Wines Located in New York) 3801 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 2009 "A leaner, more elegant vintage for Cristal which plays G. Raphet right into the style of the Champagne very well. I have had about a dozen bottles of this over the past year and (Wines Located in New York) always find it to be excellent, fresh and racy. It s a good 3 bottles per lot $300-350 Cristal to drink young."(93pts JK)

1 bottle per lot $200-280 3802 2 bottles per lot $200-260 (Wines Located in New York) PARCEL LOTS 3795-3796 3803 1 bottle per lot $100-120 1 bottle per lot $450-600 (Wines Located in New York) 3812 Moet & Chandon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 3804 Échézeaux - Vintage 2006 1981 L. LeMoine Brut Imperial, Rose 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 3bsl, 3nl (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $900-1200 3 bottles per lot $500-700

3805 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 1959 3813 Rene Brun Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1971 Ligeret Grande Reserve 1-5cm bc, 2bsl, 2nl, excellent color (Wines lbsl, nl, outstanding color and condition (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $650-850 1 magnum per lot $300-400

3806 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1966 3814 Taittinger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1978 Ligeret Artist Series 2-4cm bc, 4lbsl, 2ltl, excellent color (Wines 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $350-500 ______4 bottles per lot $700-1000 3815 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1982 3807 Chablis - Vintage 1996 St. Julien Fourchaume, Fevre 1bn, 1lscl, 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) 1wrvl (Wines Located in New York) "Exhibits an explosive nose of new saddle leather, 6 half-bottles per lot $170-240 plums, prunes, black cherry jam, chocolate, steak tartar, and roasted espresso. Unbelievably powerful, thick, and intense, with full body, mouth-searing tannin 3808 Chablis - Vintage 1996 levels, a grilled steak-like flavor, and a huge, intense Les Clos, Fevre finish..."(96pts) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $600-800 6 half-bottles per lot $320-420 3816 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1990 3809 Chevalier Montrachet - Vintage 1991 St. Julien M. Niellon (Wines Located in New York) 2lbsl, 2nl (Wines Located in New York) "The 1990 reveals a dense, dark purple color, followed "There are gobs of sweet fruit, as well as a tremendous, by a sweet, pure nose of black fruits, minerals, lead almost oily thickness to it."(91pts) pencil, and vanillin. Broad, expansive flavors come across as rich, pure, and concentrated, but never heavy 2 bottles per lot $700-900 or coarse. Beautifully integrated tannin and acidity are barely noticeable in this classic, full-bodied, velvety- 3810 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1959 textured, youthful yet exceptional St.-Julien."(96pts) L. Julian 4 bottles per lot $900-1200 4cm bc, bsl, spc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 3817 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1996 1 bottle per lot $260-300 St. Julien 1vlscl, 1sdc (Wines Located in New York) "...a spectacular nose of cassis, cherry liqueur, pain 3811 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1986 grille, and minerals. It is powerful and rich on the Rose attack, with beautifully integrated tannin, massive 1x1 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) concentration, yet no hint of heaviness or disjointedness "One of this vintage's foremost Champagnes. As always, It is a remarkable, seamless, palate-staining, and seductively soft and exotic with a wonderful bouquet of extraordinarily elegant wine - the quintessential St.- roasted coffee beans, nougat, and orange chocolate. A Julien."(98pts) wine that can be compared to the kiss of an 2 bottles per lot $420-550 angel."(93pts RJ) 3818 Château Margaux - Vintage 1996 3823 Sassicaia - Vintage 1988 Margaux Tenuta San Guido lscl (Wines Located in New York) ltl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) "...the paradigm for this estate, combining measured "The brute power of the '88 brings to mind Château power, extraordinary elegance, and admirable Latour in top vintages. Full-bodied, it's firm and rock- complexity. I tasted the wine on three separate solid yet tastes very silky thanks to sensational occasions in January, and in short, it's a beauty! The concentration of fruit."(97pts WS) color is opaque purple. The wine offers extraordinarily 1 bottle per lot $300-400 pure notes of blackberries, cassis, pain grille, and flowers, gorgeous sweetness, a seamless personality, and full body, with nothing out of place."(99pts) 3824 Sassicaia - Vintage 1990 1 bottle per lot $500-700 Tenuta San Guido (Wines Located in New York) 3819 Château Montrose - Vintage 2000 "Very good wine - aromatic...creamy, chocolaty, nutty, cassis-y...excellent balance between fruit and St. Estephe finish...black fruits but medium-bodied...hint of lscl (Wines Located in New York) licorice...a touch prune-y on the palate...came right out "This estate has frequently hit the bull's eye over recent of the cellar so it was a little too cold not sure if it vintages, and the 2000 Montrose is the finest effort helped or hurt the wine!"(93pts JK) produced since the compelling 1990 and 1989. This 1 bottle per lot $300-400 gigantically sized, tannic, backward effort boasts a saturated inky purple color followed by a huge nose of acacia flavors, crushed blackberries, creme de cassis, 3825 Clos Erasmus - Vintage 2003 vanilla, hickory smoke, and minerals. Extremely full- 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) bodied, powerful, dense, and multi-layered, this unreal "Deep purple, the wine releases an ethereal nose of Montrose should last for 30+ years."(96pts) smoke, crushed stone, pencil lead, cassis, kirsch, black 1 bottle per lot $140-180 cherry and wild blueberry. On the palate the wine is liquid minerality, opulent, rich, yet focused and well- delineated. The finish lasts for over one minute."(99pts) 3820 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1988 Pauillac 3 bottles per lot $600-800 1bn, 2vlscl (Wines Located in New York) "...it has always been classic in quality. It's rich and 3826 Clos Erasmus - Vintage 2004 fruity, with loads of currant, tobacco, smoke and new (Wines Located in New York) wood on the nose and palate. Full-bodied, with silky "The aromatic profile is similar but more expressive tannins and an elegant finish."(94pts WS) and soars from the glass. It is somehow richer, broader, 2 bottles per lot $600-800 and more sexy with amazing complexity and length. Think of your wildest fantasy coming true and you may be able to conjure up the pleasure this wine delivers 3821 Château Pichon Baron - Vintage 1990 now and will continue..."(100pts) Pauillac 1 bottle per lot $320-450 1lstl, 1sdc (Wines Located in New York) "The wine is opulent and flamboyant, with lower 3827 Vega Sicilia Unico - Vintage 1991 acidity, and noticeably less tannin than the 1989. It is equally concentrated, with a more evolved nose of 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) cedar, black fruits, earth, minerals, and spices. On the "The 1991 is a gorgeous, deep ruby/purple-colored, palate, the wine offers sensational quantities of jammy remarkably youthful effort offering sweet vanilla notes fruit, glycerin, wood, and sweet tannin."(96pts) intertwined with black currants, cherry liqueur, flowers, spice box, and tobacco leaves. Full-bodied and intense, 2 bottles per lot $500-700 with sweet tannin, outstanding density as well as purity, and a layered mouthfeel..."(95pts) 3822 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 1996 2 bottles per lot $700-900 Pauillac 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 3828 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 1997 "The nose suggests sweet, nearly overripe Cabernet (Wines Located in New York) Sauvignon, with its blueberry/blackberry/cassis scents intermixed with high quality, subtle, toasty new oak. "The 1997 Harlan Estate is one of the greatest Cabernet Deep and full-bodied, with fabulous concentration and Sauvignon-based wines I have ever tasted. A blend of a sweet, opulent texture, this wine was singing in full 80% Cabernet Sauvignon, with the rest Merlot and harmony..."(96pts) Cabernet Franc, this enormously-endowed, profoundly rich wine must be tasted to be believed. Opaque purple- 2 bottles per lot $350-450 colored, it boasts spectacular, soaring aromatics of vanilla, minerals, coffee, blackberries, licorice, and cuvée Madelaine Collignon, Dujac cassis. In the mouth, layer after layer unfold powerfully (Wines Located in New York) yet gently. Acidity, tannin, and alcohol are well- balanced by the wine's unreal richness and singular 1 magnum per lot $800-1100 personality. The finish exceeds one minute."(100pts) 1 bottle per lot $800-1100 3834 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2005 J. Drouhin 3829 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) lscl (Wines Located in New York) "A pungent nose combines notes of menthol, moderately "...a dark ruby/purple color, silky tannin, and abundant toasty wood, warm earth and bright crushed berry quantities of licorice, graphite, chocolate, espresso, aromas where the sweetness of the nose can also be black currant, truffle, and earthy characteristics, it found on the rich, generous and notably powerful big- comes across like a hypothetical blend of a top-notch boned flavors yet the finish is refined, pure and while Pauillac and Graves. Superb texture, low acidity, and not delicate, it's certainly built more along the lines of gorgeous purity as well as richness..."(95pts) finesse..."(93pts BH) 1 bottle per lot $350-450 3 magnums per lot $750-1000

3830 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 2004 3835 Bollinger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1995 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) RD "...probably the most precocious and accessible Harlan 1x1 Jeroboam owc (Wines Located in New York) Estate that this perfectionist team has made. Already "...whole-grain bread, ginger, roasted hazelnut and compelling, the wine has notes of roasted coffee, yeast notes lending complexity."(95pts WS) charcoal, blackberry, spring flowers, and some 1 Jeroboam per lot $750-1000 background sweet, toasty notes. Dense, fleshy, exuberant, even flamboyant by the standards of Bill Harlan, this wine exhibits no jaggedness or rough 3836 Lanson Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1971 edges, has relatively high tannins, but they melt away outstanding color and condition (Wines Located on the palate. The wine is sensationally well-endowed, in New York) long, and rich a tour de force in winemaking. They can do no wrong at Harlan..."(98pts) "Sometimes pure and honeyed. Light to medium-bodied with a charming apple character that reminds me of 1 magnum per lot $900-1200 Cox's Orange apples. More full-bodied other times."(95pts RJ) 3831 Sine Qua Non Grenache - Vintage 2009 2 bottles per lot $350-500 Upside Down (Wines Located in New York) PARCEL LOTS 3837-3838 "Seventy-two percent came from the 11 Confessions estate vineyard, 22% from the Cumulus estate vineyard 3837 Fonseca Vintage Port - Vintage 1995 (the source for Next of Kyn) and the balance from the Bien Nacido Vineyard. It is a big wine at 15.7% alcohol Guimaraens and seems to show surprising amounts of tree bark and 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) mushroom notes for the tiny quantity of 12 bottles per lot $350-500 Mourvedre."(94-96pts)

4 bottles per lot $800-1100 3838 12 bottles per lot $350-500 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in 3832 Sine Qua Non White - Vintage 2009 New York) On the Lam (Wines Located in New York) 3839 6 bottles per lot $180-240 "...is a blend of 48% Roussanne, 34% Chardonnay and 18% Viognier from the Eleven Confessions and Bien (Wines Located in New York) Nacido vineyards. Tangerine peel, white peaches, mango, lychee and passion fruit are some of the 3840 3 bottles per lot $90-120 nuances that emerge from this beautifully layered white. (Wines Located in New York) Weekly lees stirring gives the wine much of its depth."(93pts) 3841 1 bottle per lot $30-40 2 bottles per lot $240-320 ______(Wines Located in New York)

3833 Hospices de Beaune, Mazis Chambertin - Vintage 3842 Graham's Vintage Port - Vintage 1977 2009 2bsl (Wines Located in New York) flavors, culminating in a potent, intense, serious and (93pts) driving finish."(91pts BH) 2 bottles per lot $150-200 3 magnums per lot $350-500 ______

3843 Taylor Fladgate Vintage Port - Vintage 1963 3850 Château Pontet Canet - Vintage 1995 hbsl, hwasl (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac "A big wine with superb balance, a shining example of lscl (Wines Located in New York) this exuberantly fruity vintage. Deep ruby, with violets "An old style Pauillac, yet made with far more purity and coffee on the nose, full-bodied, with dried cherry and richness than the estate's ancient vintages, this flavors and plenty of tannin, balanced and long on the broad-shouldered, muscular, classic wine exhibits a finish."(97pts WS) saturated purple color, and sensationally dense, rich, 1 bottle per lot $240-350 concentrated, cassis flavors that roll over the palate with impressive purity and depth. The wine is tannic 3844 Taylor Fladgate Vintage Port - Vintage 1977 and closed, but powerful and rich. It appears to possess length and intensity similar to the 1996. This is a great 3lbsl, 2sos (Wines Located in New York) young Pauillac."(92pts) "It is a mammoth, opaque, statuesque vintage port of remarkable depth and power."(96pts) 1 bottle per lot $70-90 3 bottles per lot $260-350 3851 Château Climens - Vintage 1988 Sauternes 3845 1 bottle per lot $90-120 bn, lstl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...reveals layer upon layer of honeyed pineapple-and orange-scented and -flavored fruit, vibrant acidity, high 3846 Taylor Fladgate Vintage Port - Vintage 1994 levels of botrytis, and a fabulously long, yet well- 3lbsl (Wines Located in New York) focused finish. It is a great wine."(96pts) "This classically made, opaque purple-colored wine is 1 bottle per lot $100-130 crammed with black fruits (blueberries and cassis). It reveals high tannin and a reserved style, but it is enormously constituted with massive body, a formidable 3852 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1990 mid-palate, and exceptional length."(97pts) Sauternes 3 bottles per lot $260-350 bn, vlscl (Wines Located in New York) ______"An extraordinary effort, Yquem s 1990 is a rich and fabulously superb, sweet wine. This wine also possesses 3847 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 1983 lots of elegance and finesse. The wine s medium gold color is accompanied by an exceptionally sweet nose of Pauillac honeyed tropical fruits, peaches, coconut, and apricots. 2bn, 4stl, 2nl, 1lwrl, 4sdc (Wines Located in New High quality, subtle toasty oak is well- York) integrated..."(99pts) "...one of the great wines of the vintage. The color is an 1 bottle per lot $320-450 impressive opaque dark ruby with only a hint of amber at the edge. The powerful nose of jammy blackcurrants, cedar, and roasted herbs is followed by a broad- 3853 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1994 shoulderedstyle of Pichon, with superb concentration, Sauternes soft tannins, below average acidity, and a spectacularly wisl (Wines Located in New York) rich, explosive finish."(94pts) 1 bottle per lot $160-220 4 bottles per lot $600-800

3854 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1999 3848 Chevalier Montrachet - Vintage 2001 Sauternes M. Colin (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) (92pts) 3 magnums per lot $1200-1500 1 half-bottle per lot $110-140

3849 Puligny Montrachet - Vintage 2004 3855 Corton La Garenne, M. Colin - Vintage 1989 Capitain Gagnerot sdc (Wines (1) (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) "...perfumed nose of floral, spice and green fruit aromas and rich, detailed and superbly fresh and vibrant Santenay - Vintage 1995 Les Charmes, R. Monnier lstl (1) 3863 1 bottle per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) wisvl, nl (Wines Located in New York) Gigondas - Vintage 1998 Les Hauts de Montmirail, (1) 3864 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1996 Brusset (Wines Located in New Clos St. Jacques, L. Jadot York) lscl (Wines Located in New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $70-100 "Very saturated red-ruby. Bright, sweet black raspberry and cassis nose. Very sweet and intensely flavored, but bracing acidity gives the wine great dynamism and cut. 3856 Volnay - Vintage 2008 Really explosive in the mouth. Very long, vibrant finish. Comte Lafon Grand cru quality."(91-4pts IWC) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $100-130 2 bottles per lot $120-160 3865 Chambertin - Vintage 1993 3857 Volnay - Vintage 2008 Clos de Bèze, P. Damoy Les Lurets, Comte Lafon 10lscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Elegant, extremely pure and spicy with austere black fruit notes and understated, powerful, densely 2 bottles per lot $160-220 concentrated and superbly well focused flavors that deliver superb mid-palate punch and terrific finishing 3858 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1996 complexity."(93pts BH) Les Poissenots, Geantet-Pansiot 10 bottles per lot $1100-1400 lscl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $60-80 3866 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1996 Les Perrières, R. Chevillon 3859 Richebourg - Vintage 1985 lstl (Wines Located in New York) Gros Frere et Soeur 1 bottle per lot $60-80 wisvl, stl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $450-600 3867 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1996 Les St. Georges, R. Chevillon 3860 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 1989 lstl (Wines Located in New York) Les Baudes, H. Lignier 1 bottle per lot $90-120 lscl, wrl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $100-140 3868 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1996 Les Vaucrains, R. Chevillon 3861 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 1997 lstl (Wines Located in New York) "This dark-colored wine aromatically displays cassis H. Lignier liqueur, road tar, blackberries, and dried prunes. This lscl (Wines Located in New York) backward, austere, muscular, broad-shouldered "Huge ripeness of fruit, exquisite definition, opulence, behemoth is velvety-textured (but don't be fooled by this and the required structure for cellaring. Immensely youthful trait - it will demand patience!), gorgeously sweet, black fruits, chocolate, cumin, and cinnamon focused, full-bodied, and packed to the gills with black seemingly expand on the palate, saturating the mouth, fruits, metal shavings, minerals, and stones."(91-94pts) and lingering for up to 45 seconds."(94pts) 1 bottle per lot $100-130 1 magnum per lot $650-850 3869 Batard Montrachet - Vintage 1998 PARCEL LOTS 3862-3863 Baron de la Charriere (Wines Located in New York) 3862 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1993 Clos St. Jacques, L. Jadot 5 bottles per lot $500-700 wisvl, wisl (Wines Located in New York) 3870 Puligny Montrachet - Vintage 2008 1 bottle per lot $150-200 Champ Gain, Comte Lafon (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $240-320 3880 2 bottles per lot $130-180 (Wines Located in New York) 3871 Vire Clesse - Vintage 2008 Comte Lafon 3881 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) cuvée des Cadettes, Château La Nerthe 3 bottles per lot $70-90 2x6 bottle owc's (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $650-900 3872 Bienvenue Batard Montrachet - Vintage 1997 L. Latour 3882 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1989 stl (Wines Located in New York) La cuvée du Papet, Clos du Mont Olivet 1 bottle per lot $80-120 lscl, spc, wxc (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $120-160 3873 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2006 Vieilles Vignes, A. Jaume 3883 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1998 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) La cuvée du Papet, Clos du Mont Olivet 12 bottles per lot $300-420 (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $70-90 3874 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 Vieilles Vignes, A. Jaume 3884 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2005 2x6 bottle owc's (Wines Located in New York) Deus Ex Machina, Clos St. Jean 12 bottles per lot $350-480 (Wines Located in New York) "Saturated purple to the rim, with an extraordinary nose of incense, fruitcake, blackberry and black cherry 3875 Cornas - Vintage 1996 notes with some subtle roasted herbs, roast beef, smoke, Vieilles Vignes, A. Voge and licorice, massive fruit concentration, extraordinary 3bsl (Wines Located in New York) intensity, unreal purity and harmony, and a seamless integration of acidity, tannin, and alcohol, this is a tour 3 bottles per lot $180-240 de force in winemaking and certainly one of the most compelling Châteauneuf du Papes I have ever 3876 Hermitage - Vintage 2001 tasted."(100pts) Betts & Scholl 1 magnum per lot $650-850 (Wines Located in New York) 11 bottles per lot $350-550 3885 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2009 Vieilles Vignes, Clos St. Jean 3877 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1983 (Wines Located in New York) Château de Beaucastel 1 bottle per lot $1200-1500 lscl (Wines Located in New York) "A full-bodied wine, with black cherry, charcoal and 3886 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 light earth aromas and tons of flavor. Has super-firm Vieilles Vignes, Domaine de la Janasse tannins and a tight structure."(90pts WS) vlscl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $70-100 "One of the vintage s most compelling wines, the huge, dense purple-colored 2003 Châteauneuf du Pape cuvée 3878 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1998 Vieilles Vignes offers aromas of creme de cassis, Château de Beaucastel creosote, and flowers along with immense concentration, body, and tannin. The finish is 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) reminiscent of a first-growth Bordeaux, meaning it is "The 1998 is unquestionably one of the great modern well-delineated and tannic."(97pts) day Beaucastels, but because of its high Grenache content, it is different from some of the other 1 bottle per lot $80-110 classics."(96pts) 6 bottles per lot $400-550 3887 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 1999 Jamet 3879 4 bottles per lot $260-350 1nl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...possesses a striking perfume of roasted meats, violets, graphite, blackberries, raspberries, and cherry liqueur. The wine is smoky, intense, full-bodied, L'Ermite, M. Chapoutier muscular, concentrated, layered, and dominated by ripe 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) fruit, with the tannin well-hidden by the wealth of extract, glycerin, and fruit."(96pts) 6 bottles per lot $950-1500 6 bottles per lot $1800-2400 3893 4 bottles per lot $650-1000 3888 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) Les Cailloux, cuvée Centenaire, L. & A. Brunel 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 3894 3 bottles per lot $480-750 "...a dense ruby/purple-tinged color to the rim, a (Wines Located in New York) strikingly pure nose of kirsch liqueur, creme de cassis, and hints of vanilla and espresso. Hitting the palate 3895 St. Joseph Blanc - Vintage 2004 with full-throttle opulence, superb concentration, fabulous purity, and striking multiple levels of Les Granits, M. Chapoutier raspberries and black cherry jam, this is a beautifully 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) full-bodied, brilliantly concentrated and structured wine 6 bottles per lot $240-320 that reveals sweet but abundant tannin and a finish that goes on for close to a minute."(96pts) 3896 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 1999 12 bottles per lot $900-1200 Les Rochains, P. & C. Bonneford 3889 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) Barbe Rac, M. Chapoutier 3 magnums per lot $320-480 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "...shows classic garrigue notes intermixed with ground 3897 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 pepper, lavender, and sweet black currant and black Reserve des Deux Freres, P. Usseglio cherry notes with hints of raspberry and olive. The wine (Wines Located in New York) is fullbodied has a boatload of tannin, fabulous concentration, and a finish of close to 50 "Dense purple to the rim, with a huge nose of scorched seconds."(96pts) earth, blackberry and blueberry liqueur, Crème de cassis, roasted meat juices, and a hint of Provencal 6 bottles per lot $450-600 herbs interwoven with licorice and a touch of balsamic, it is voluptuously textured, with striking body, low 3890 Ermitage Blanc - Vintage 1991 acidity, and amazing concentration. This fabulous bottle of Châteauneuf-du-Pape should drink well for 20+ de l'Oree, M. Chapoutier years."(98pts) 2bsl (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $500-600 "The wine is full-bodied and stunningly rich, with a honeyed, peach blossom, Acacia flower, mineral- scented nose, and unctuously-textured, thick, rich, 3898 Guado Al Tasso - Vintage 1997 chewy flavors. The acidity provides zest and vibrancy. Antinori The finish lasts for up to a minute."(96pts) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $180-240 "A balanced and harmonious young red. Dark ruby color, with loads of grape, berry, mineral and violet 3891 Ermitage Blanc - Vintage 1993 aromas. Full-bodied, with loads of blackberry and cherry character, fine tannins and a medium finish. de l'Oree, M. Chapoutier Gorgeous wine."(96pts WS) 4bsl (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $600-800 "Five thousand bottles of the cuvée de l Or e are produced from frightfully tiny yields from a parcel of 70-year old vines near the Meal vineyard on Hermitage 3899 Chianti Classico Hill. The wine is barrel-fermented in Francois Freres - Vintage 1996 Riserva Ducale, Ruffino (Wines (1) barrels and aged in tank prior to being bottled Located in New York) unfiltered. It is a wine of extravagant richness, and in some vintages it seems almost too thick, unctuous, and concentrated to be believed. It is the single greatest La Braccesca white Hermitage being made, but with just over 400 - Vintage 1998 Antinori (Wines Located in (1) cases, not many people get the opportunity to New York) experience it."(94pts) 4 bottles per lot $320-500 Le Volte - Vintage 1997 Tenuta dell' Ornellaia bsl (1) 3892 Ermitage Blanc - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) Napa Valley 2wisl (Wines Located in New York) Salice Salentino "A seductive style, with lots of spicy, vanilla-scented oak - Vintage 1999 Leone de Castris (Wines (1) that leads to a rich, complex core of currant, black cherry, olive and plum. The tannins are smooth and Located in New York) polished; supple enough to drink now, yet substantial enough to cellar short-term."(92pts WS) Toscana 2 bottles per lot $100-140 - Vintage 1995 Castelrapiti, Fattoria (1) Montellori (Wines Located in PARCEL LOTS 3906-3907 New York) Above 5 bottles per lot $100-160 3906 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1995 Special Selection 3900 Tignanello - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) Antinori "Wow. This '95 Special Selection is a classic. Amazingly complex, it displays a wide range of flavors--including (Wines Located in New York) currant, wild berry, herb, sage, coffee and tobacco-- "A fabulous Tuscan red, young and racy. Deep dark gains in nuance, delicacy, elegance and finesse, and ruby in color, with focused aromas of blackberries, unveils pretty oak shadings on the finish."(97pts WS) wood and very ripe fruit. Full-bodied, with loads of velvety tannins and a long, long finish."(95pts WS) 1 bottle per lot $130-170 4 bottles per lot $480-600 3907 1 bottle per lot $130-170 3901 Amarone - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) Dal Forno (Wines Located in New York) 3908 Cardinale Red "Great aromatics - more nutty, great cream, less pepper - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) a little fruitier and less chocolaty most classic in the nose of the first three better balance of fruit and finish - Château Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon still huge alcohol and spice pepper really comes - Vintage 1985 Calistoga cuvée (Wines (1) out."(97pts JK) Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $320-450 - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (90pts) 3902 El Nido - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) Clos du Val Cabernet Sauvignon "...is a selection of the best grapes from the same vineyards. Opaque purple-colored, it has even better - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) perfume than Clio. Already complex, it offers up a toasty aromatic array of violet, lavender, espresso, Franciscan Estate Cabernet Sauvignon chocolate, blueberry compote, and blackberry liqueur. Smooth-textured and dense, the wine is rich and mouth- - Vintage 1996 Oakville Estate (Wines Located (1) filling."(98pts) in New York) 3 bottles per lot $240-320 Pezzi King Cabernet Sauvignon 3903 Aquilon - Vintage 2005 - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Bodegas Alto Moncayo (Wines Located in New York) Vinoce Red - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 12 bottles per lot $950-1200 Above 7 bottles per lot $160-240 3904 Numanthia - Vintage 2004 Numanthia 3909 Colgin Red - Vintage 2004 2x6 bottle ocb's (Wines Located in New York) IX Estate (98pts) (Wines Located in New York) "Flamboyant, super-fragrant aromas of graphite, 12 bottles per lot $650-900 Crème de cassis, espresso roast, flowers, and the entire black and blue fruit spectrum jump from the glass of 3905 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1995 this gorgeous wine. In the mouth, silky tannin and a multi-dimensional, skyscraper-like mouthfeel are Morisoli Vineyard offered without heaviness or coarseness."(98pts) (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $1200-1600 4 bottles per lot $200-300

3910 Dalla Valle Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1991 3917 Araujo Estate Syrah hwisl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1998 Eisele Vineyard (Wines Located (1) 1 bottle per lot $70-100 in New York)

3911 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 1997 Blockheadia Zinfandel The Maiden - Vintage 1998 Ringnosii nl (Wines Located in (1) (Wines Located in New York) New York) "Readers should not overlook the dense purple-colored 1997 Maiden, a creamy-textured, full-bodied, unctuously thick, rich wine. Jammy cassis, new oak, Rubicon Estate/Niebaum-Coppola Zinfandel smoke, and espresso notes explode from the glass of this - Vintage 1994 Edizione Pennino (Wines (1) blockbuster."(94pts) Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 Steltzner Merlot PARCEL LOTS 3912-3913 - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 4 bottles per lot $90-140 3912 Kapcsandy Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 3918 Hundred Acre Shiraz - Vintage 2004 State Lane Vineyard Summer's Block, Ancient Way (Wines Located in New York) 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "Another perfect wine (identical to the 2007) is the 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Grand Vin State Lane Vineyard. (91pts ST) Composed of 87% Cabernet Sauvignon and the rest 6 bottles per lot $500-650 Merlot, Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot (430 cases produced), this is an exquisite wine of great precision and profound concentration and complexity. It 3919 3 bottles per lot $260-320 possesses an inky/purple color in addition to an (Wines Located in New York) ethereal nose of cassis, chocolate, burning embers, espresso and forest floor. Sweet tannins, a PARCEL LOTS 3920-3921 multidimensional mouthfeel, full-bodied power and good structure as well as freshness make for a prodigious example of wine that will benefit from 4-5 3920 Marcassin Pinot Noir - Vintage 2001 years of cellaring, but will keep for 25-30 Blue Slide Ridge Vineyard years."(100pts) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $240-320 "A sensational Pinot that caresses the palate. Ultra rich and deeply flavored, with an easygoing and delicious range of ripe, spicy blackberry, black cherry, fresh 3913 1 bottle per lot $240-320 earth and herbal spice and nutmeg flavors."(97pts WS) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $180-240

3914 Matriarch Red - Vintage 2005 3921 1 bottle per lot $180-240 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) (93pts) 3 bottles per lot $240-320 3922 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2009 Larry Hyde & Sons 3915 Morlet Family Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon - (Wines Located in New York) Vintage 2009 Passionnement 2 bottles per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $450-600 3923 George Pinot Noir - Vintage 2006 Marta Ella Vineyard (Wines (3) 3916 Whitehall Lane Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Located in New York) Vintage 1994 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay 1 bottle per lot $70-100 - Vintage 2003 Lauren Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) (94-96pts) 3932 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2009 Above 4 bottles per lot $190-260 UV-SL Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 3924 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 1 bottle per lot $80-110 Lauren Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 3933 Dumol Chardonnay 1 bottle per lot $100-130 - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) (7) PARCEL LOTS 3925-3927 - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 3925 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2009 Isobel (Wines Located in New York) (95pts) (1) Lauren Vineyard Above 9 bottles per lot $190-240 (Wines Located in New York) (95pts) 3934 Guenoc Chardonnay 1 bottle per lot $100-130 - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

3926 1 bottle per lot $100-130 Hyde & De Villaine Families Chardonnay (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 Los Carneros (Wines Located (1) in New York) 3927 1 bottle per lot $100-130 (Wines Located in New York) James Henry Cellars Chardonnay - Vintage 2000 Gold Ridge Vineyard 2bsl (2) 3928 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) Reuling Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) Kalin Cellars Chardonnay "...tastes like liqueur of stones. Reminiscent of an old - Vintage 1990 cuvée CH (Wines Located in (1) vine white Hermitage from Michel Chapoutier or a top New York) Burgundy from Meursault-Perrières, Montrachet, or Chevalier-Montrachet, it exhibits wonderful stone Above 5 bottles per lot $100-150 fruit/smoky notes, huge body, and crisp acidity to buttress the enormous power and wealth of 3935 Kongsgaard Chardonnay concentration. This is an extraordinarily singular expression of Chardonnay that must be tasted to be - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (2) believed."(95-97pts) (94pts) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 Kongsgaard White 3929 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 - Vintage 2007 Vio Rous (Wines Located in (1) Reuling Vineyard New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $160-220 1 bottle per lot $110-150 3936 Kongsgaard Chardonnay - Vintage 2003 3930 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2009 The Judge Reuling Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...what a remarkable wine! Tightly-wound as well as super-concentrated, it represents the essence of a (94pts) terroir and varietal character. Sadly, there are only 100 1 bottle per lot $100-130 cases of this remarkable effort."(99pts) 1 bottle per lot $180-240 3931 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2009 Ritchie Vineyard 3937 Kongsgaard Chardonnay - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) The Judge (95pts) (Wines Located in New York) "The Judge represents a selection of the finest barrels Evening Land Vineyards Chardonnay and is an homage to Kongsgaard's father. It exhibits - Vintage 2007 La Source 7 Springs (Wines (1) more white peach, pineapple, and tropical fruit characteristics as well as a steely minerality, full body, Located in New York) and more power than the regular cuvée."(93pts) Above 5 bottles per lot $130-180 5 bottles per lot $600-850 3944 Greenock Creek Shiraz - Vintage 1998 3938 Kongsgaard Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 Seven Acre The Judge (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Very rich, sexy nose, chock full of ripe fruits...black, "...is exquisite. Full-bodied with layer upon layer of ripe purple, blackberry, bosyenberry, cassis...you name it stone fruits, crushed rocks, and floral notes, it is a stylishly rich and meaty palate of chewy purple fruits honeyed, super-rich Chardonnay displaying a hint of with a touch of stone to keep it balanced decent length tropical fruits in the long, 40-second finish (a but it closes down a bit."(92pts JK) remarkable length for a Chardonnay). This brilliant 8 bottles per lot $480-600 effort should last for 8-10 years."(97pts)

1 bottle per lot $150-200 3945 Noon Eclipse - Vintage 1998 Eclipse 3939 Lewis Cellars Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) Napa Valley (Wines Located in New York) (5) 1 bottle per lot $50-70 Russian River Valley (Wines Located in New York) (3) PARCEL LOTS 3946-3947 Above 8 bottles per lot $190-260 3946 Penfold's Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1996 3940 Marcassin Chardonnay - Vintage 1997 Bin 707 Hudson Vineyard, 'E Block' bsl, tl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $180-240 "...displays an evolved light gold color as well as an exotic nose of smoked tropical fruit intermixed with orange marmalade and roasted coffee scents. Layered, 3947 1 bottle per lot $180-240 rich, and boisterous this is a full-throttle, exuberant, (Wines Located in New York) flamboyant Chardonnay."(91pts) ______1 bottle per lot $200-280 3948 Château Clinet - Vintage 1989 3941 Marcassin Chardonnay - Vintage 1999 Pomerol Upper Barn sdc (Wines Located in New York) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "...offering up pure scents of flowers, black-raspberries, currants, vanillin, and truffles. Full-bodied, with a 3 bottles per lot $600-750 seamless texture, fabulous concentration, a massive degree of richness, but no heaviness or awkwardness, 3942 Newton Chardonnay - Vintage 2005 this remains one of the most profound young wines I have ever tasted. Its sweetness of fruit and layers of (Wines Located in New York) flavor, combined with its remarkable texture are the 9 bottles per lot $260-350 stuff of legends..."(100pts) 1 bottle per lot $450-600 3943 Paul Hobbs Chardonnay - Vintage 2005 Walker Station Vineyard (1) 3949 Château Couhins Lurton - Vintage 2009 (Wines Located in New York) Graves 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Ramey Chardonnay 12 bottles per lot $350-500 - Vintage 2005 Ritchie Vineyard (Wines (2) Located in New York) 3950 Château Gruaud Larose St. Julien Walter Hansel Chardonnay - Vintage 1975 ts, gsl, sdc, outstanding (1) - Vintage 2008 The North Slope (Wines (1) color (Wines Located in Located in New York) New York) - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New (2) Pere et Fils (Wines Located in York) (90pts WS) New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $220-320 Gevrey Chambertin 3951 Château Haut Bages Averous - Vintage 2000 - Vintage 2002 Bouchard, Pere et Fils (Wines (2) Pauillac Located in New York) 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Above 5 bottles per lot $140-200 12 bottles per lot $400-600 3958 Beaune Rouge - Vintage 2005 3952 Château La Couspaude - Vintage 1996 Clos des Mouches, J. Drouhin St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $900-1200 5 bottles per lot $120-170 3959 Nuits St. Georges 3953 Château Lanessan - Vintage 1997 Les Charmois, J. Grivot (Wines (3) - Vintage 1975 Haut Medoc 2bn, 2gsl, 2lwasl, (2) Located in New York) 2outstanding color, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) Pommard - Vintage 2002 Les Noizons, J. Garaudet (2) Château Meyney (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1975 St. Estephe bsl, outstanding (1) Above 5 bottles per lot $110-160 color and condition (Wines Located in New York) (90pts) 3960 Chambertin - Vintage 1998 Above 3 bottles per lot $90-120 J. Prieur 2nl (Wines Located in New York) 3954 Château Larrivet Haut Brion - Vintage 2006 4 bottles per lot $320-420 Graves 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 3961 Échézeaux - Vintage 1998 12 bottles per lot $500-700 J. Prieur 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 3955 Château Meyney - Vintage 1995 3 bottles per lot $150-200 St. Estephe 6vlwrl (Wines Located in New York) 3962 Pommard - Vintage 2005 6 bottles per lot $240-320 Les Jarollieres, J.M. Boillot (Wines Located in New York) 3956 Château Rauzan Segla 12 bottles per lot $400-600 Margaux - Vintage 1989 (Wines Located in New (1) 3963 Beaune Bressandes - Vintage 2009 York) (90pts WS) Domaine des Heritiers, L. Jadot - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New (1) 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) York) (94pts) 12 bottles per lot $500-700 Above 2 bottles per lot $200-280 3964 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2006 3957 Beaune Greves Les Pruliers, N. Potel - Vintage 1999 Vigne de L'Enfant Jesus, (1) 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) Bouchard, Pere et Fils (Wines 9 bottles per lot $260-350 Located in New York) 3965 Savigny les Beaune - Vintage 2006 Beaune Rouge Vieilles Vignes, N. Potel - Vintage 1999 Clos de la Mousse, Bouchard, (2) 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $180-240 "What a great wine. Full-bodied, with crushed berry, smoke and grilled aromas, all presented quite subtly. Stands out for its natural, down-to-earth taste of clean, 3966 Montrachet - Vintage 1998 pure, shining fruit. A pleasure to drink. Tempting now. Sauzet Best from 2003 through 2015."(96pts WS) 2lscl, 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) 11 bottles per lot $800-1100 "Sauzet's 1998 Montrachet is a superb wine. Lovely anise, almond, hazelnut, and mineral aromas lead to a medium to full-bodied, compelling character. This 3973 Moet & Chandon Champagne - Vintage NV supple, soft, extremely flavorful, and harmonious wine Les Champs des Romont 1x3 bottle custom owc (1) is filled with layers and layers of spiced pears, candied (Wines Located in New York) apples, minerals, and toast."(94pts) 2 bottles per lot $600-800 Les Sarments d'Ay (Wines Located in New York) (1)

3967 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 1998 Les Vignes de Saran (Wines Located in New York) (1) Les Morgeots, Vieilles Vignes, V. Girardin Above 3 bottles per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $100-150 3974 Château Miraval Rose - Vintage 2009 (Wines Located in New York) 3968 Côtes du Rhône - Vintage 1998 2ltl, 2lwrl (Wines Located in New York) Coudoulet de Beaucastel, Château de Beaucastel Above 2 double magnums per lot $60-100 3nl (Wines Located in New York) and 2 Jeroboams 12 bottles per lot $180-240 3975 Barolo - Vintage 1995 3969 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1998 Bussia, A. Conterno Le Vieux Donjon lscl (Wines Located in New York) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $80-110 "Displays gorgeous, savage aromas and flavors, with crushed juniper berry, hot tar, sage leaf, roasted 3976 Barolo - Vintage 1996 chestnut and grilled beef notes that scorch across the palate. Still rugged on the finish, though the color at the Bussia, A. Conterno rim and the intensity and range of the aromas show that 4lscl (Wines Located in New York) this is evolving."(97pts WS) 4 bottles per lot $300-400 5 bottles per lot $300-400 3977 Barolo - Vintage 1997 3970 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1978 Bussia, A. Conterno Mont Redon 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) lbsl, sdc, outstanding color and condition (Wines "The dense ruby/garnet-colored, tightly-knit 1997 Located in New York) Barolo Bussia Soprana offers notions of earth, cherries, and balsam wood. Full-bodied, with good acidity 1 bottle per lot $70-100 (particularly for the vintage), moderately high tannin, and a firm finish, it possesses plenty of power."(91pts) 3971 Châteauneuf du Pape 2 bottles per lot $130-180 - Vintage 1998 P. Autard 3vlscl (Wines (3) Located in New York) 3978 Valpolicella Palazzo della Torre, Allegrini Gigondas - Vintage 1994 2lbsl (Wines Located in (2) - Vintage 1998 Pierre Aiguille, P. Jaboulet 1stl (2) New York) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 vlscl (Wines Located in New (1) Above 5 bottles per lot $120-170 York) Above 3 bottles per lot $60-90 3972 Hermitage - Vintage 1998 La Chapelle, P. Jaboulet 3979 Chianti Classico 5lbsl, 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New Riserva, Antinori York) - Vintage 1997 1nl (Wines Located in New (5) York) (92pts) 2 bottles per lot $220-300 - Vintage 1998 2lscl, 1nl (Wines Located in (5) New York) 3989 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2007 Above 10 bottles per lot $170-220 Vigneto La Casuccia, Castello di Ama (Wines Located in New York) 3980 Guado Al Tasso - Vintage 2006 2 bottles per lot $200-260 Il Bruciato, Antinori (Wines Located in New York) 3990 Brunello di Montalcino 8 bottles per lot $160-220 Vigna di Pianrosso, Ciacci Piccolomini d'Aragona - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 3981 Guado Al Tasso - Vintage 2009 - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New (1) Il Bruciato, Antinori York) (93pts) 1lstl, 2x6 bottle ocb's (Wines Located in New Above 2 bottles per lot $160-200 York) 12 bottles per lot $240-320 3991 Vino Nobile di Montepulciano - Vintage 2004 Antica Chiusina, Fattoria del Cerro 3982 Guado Al Tasso - Vintage 2012 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Il Bruciato, Antinori 6 bottles per lot $140-190 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $120-160 3992 Vino Nobile di Montepulciano - Vintage 2005 Antica Chiusina, Fattoria del Cerro PARCEL LOTS 3983-3984 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York)

3983 Desiderio - Vintage 1999 6 bottles per lot $150-200 Avignonesi 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) PARCEL LOTS 3993-3994 6 bottles per lot $180-240 3993 Colline Lucchesi - Vintage 2009 San Gennaro, Fattoria di Fubbiano 3984 6 bottles per lot $180-240 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $200-300

3985 Desiderio - Vintage 2000 3994 12 bottles per lot $200-300 Avignonesi 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in (Wines Located in New York) New York) 3 bottles per lot $90-120 PARCEL LOTS 3995-3997 3986 Ilatraia Red - Vintage 2005 Brancaia 3995 Galatrona - Vintage 2010 (Wines Located in New York) Petrolo 12 bottles per lot $350-500 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $300-400 3987 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1997 Caparzo 3996 6 bottles per lot $300-400 (Wines Located in New York) 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in 9 bottles per lot $350-500 New York)

3988 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2007 3997 6 bottles per lot $300-400 Vigneto Bellavista, Castello di Ama 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in 1x6 bottle custom owc (Wines Located in New New York) York) 3998 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1995 Tenuta dell' Ornellaia Poggio Antico (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...bursts from the glass with dark red berries, "Poggio Antico's superb 1995 Brunello di Montalcino is blackberries, flowers, licorice and tar. It shows lovely forward and soft, with a deep ruby/plum/garnet color, up-front juiciness and expressive inner perfume in a and a sweet bouquet of licorice, smoke, and jammy surprisingly accessible style for this wine. Like the cherry fruit. Rich and full-bodied, with excellent Ornellaia, the 2009 Masseto has quite a bit of concentration..."(90pts) freshness, although it, too, is medium-bodied in structure."(94+pts) 6 bottles per lot $300-400 1 bottle per lot $420-550

3999 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1997 4006 Guidalberto - Vintage 2007 Poggio Antico Tenuta San Guido 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) "Pretty aromas of plums, berries and cherries follow (Wines Located in New York) through to a full-bodied palate, with a lovely balance of 5 bottles per lot $150-200 ripe fruit and refined tannins. Long and caressing finish."(93pts WS) 4007 Sassicaia - Vintage 2007 10 bottles per lot $500-700 Tenuta San Guido 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 4000 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2000 "...explodes onto the palate with masses of rich, opulent Poggio Antico fruit that caress the palate with gorgeous length and a (Wines Located in New York) seamless beauty that is hard to fully capture. Dark wild cherries, plums, spices, minerals and herbs develop in 10 bottles per lot $300-400 the glass. This is an especially bold, perhaps slightly uncharacteristic Sassicaia in its extroverted personality, 4001 Chianti Classico - Vintage 2009 but it is beautiful all the same. The inner perfume and sweetness carries through the long finish, where the Il Grigio Riserva, San Felice sheer weight and glycerol of the fruit leaves a lasting 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) impression."(95pts) 12 bottles per lot $240-320 6 bottles per lot $800-1100

4002 Le Volte 4008 Campaccio - Vintage 1997 Tenuta dell' Ornellaia Riserva, Terrabianca - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (3) (Wines Located in New York) 8 bottles per lot $300-400 - Vintage 2008 1x1 double magnum ocb double magnum (1) (Wines Located in New York) 4009 3 bottles per lot $120-160 Above 3 bottles per lot $100-140 (Wines Located in New York) and 1 double magnum 4010 Barbera d'Alba 4003 Masseto - Vintage 2008 - Vintage 1998 Tenuta dell' Ornellaia Scarrone, Vietti 1lscl, 1ltl, 1lwisl (Wines Located in (6) 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) New York) "Freshly cut flowers, crushed rocks, spices and black - Vintage 2002 cherries are some of the aromas and flavors that Tre Vigne, Vietti 4lscl (Wines Located in New York) (6) emerge from the 2008. This is an exceptionally beautiful Masseto that impresses for its elegance."(96pts) Above 12 bottles per lot $180-240 1 magnum per lot $1000-1400 4011 B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1974 1lbsl, 1lwrl, 1lwasl, (2) 4004 3 bottles per lot $1300-1700 excellent color and condition 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in (Wines Located in New New York) York) - Vintage 1982 (Wines Located in New (1) 4005 Masseto - Vintage 2009 York) (90pts) Above 3 bottles per lot $350-450 "Earthy, elegant and refined Cabernet blend, delivering layers of currant, tar, black cherry, cedar, coffee and anise, all sharply focused and framed by just the right 4012 Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon amount of tannin."(91pts WS) - Vintage 1984 (Wines Located in New (1) 1 bottle per lot $70-100 York) (93pts JK) - Vintage 1987 (Wines Located in New (1) 4019 Dominus - Vintage 2001 York) (93pts) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1993 (Wines Located in New (1) "The impeccably made 2001 Dominus boasts a dense York) (92pts) plum/purple color in addition to a fragrant, promising perfume of cocoa, cedar, coffee, roasted herbs, and Above 3 bottles per lot $180-240 copious quantities of black fruits..."(95pts) 4 bottles per lot $600-800 4013 Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New (2) 4020 Dominus - Vintage 2003 York) (94pts) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1995 lwisl (Wines Located in (1) "A big, sweet nose of roasted coffee, Provencal herbs, New York) (93pts) black currants, cherry jam, plums, allspice, and forest floor is followed by a spicy, rich, full-bodied, fragrant, Above 3 bottles per lot $220-300 intense wine. The tannins are sweet, but noticeable in this beautifully complex, strikingly aromatic 4014 Château St. Jean Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1994 2003."(95pts) Cinq Cepages 4 bottles per lot $400-500 (Wines Located in New York) 7 bottles per lot $280-350 4021 Grace Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1985 scc (Wines Located in New (1) 4015 Château St. Jean Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 York) (96pts) Cinq Cepages - Vintage 1986 lbsl, scc (Wines Located in (1) (Wines Located in New York) New York) (93pts) "It boasts a super-complex bouquet of licorice, dried herbs, black currants, spice box, and cherry liqueur. In - Vintage 1988 (Wines Located in New (1) the mouth, notes of chocolate, new oak, and red and black fruits caress the palate in a medium to full- York) (92pts WS) bodied, succulent style. Aged in 50% new and 50% one- - Vintage 1989 (Wines Located in New York) (1) year old French barrels, it is bottled with no fining or filtration. Fleshy and complex, this is California's - Vintage 1990 lwisl, scc (Wines Located in (1) answer to a big, rich St.- milion."(94pts) New York) (94pts WS) 12 bottles per lot $700-950 - Vintage 1991 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 4016 Château St. Jean Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 Cinq Cepages - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1993 (Wines Located in New (1) "...offering a mix of ripe, rich, fleshy currant and blackberry fruit, with hints of herb, olive and sage. York) (91pts) Finishes with a firm, structured backbone and ripe Above 8 bottles per lot $900-1200 tannins giving it depth and richness."(96pts WS)

9 bottles per lot $220-300 4022 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 1995 The Maiden 4017 Corison Cabernet Sauvignon gsl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1987 lwasl (Wines Located in (1) "...possesses a dense, murky ruby/purple color, and an New York) expressive, cedary, leathery, spicy nose with plenty of - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New York) (2) black fruits. Some minerality comes through, but this complex, evolved yet structured, full-bodied wine is an Above 3 bottles per lot $100-140 amazing second wine."(90pts) 1 bottle per lot $110-150 4018 Dominus - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) 4023 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 2003 St.-Julien/Pauillac."(91pts) The Maiden 1 bottle per lot $120-160 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "Made in the Harlan Estate style, but more supple and 4029 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 1995 evolved, the 2003 The Maiden exhibits plenty of Les Pavots caramel, black currant, and espresso roast characteristics, a fleshy mid-palate, and a long, supple (Wines Located in New York) finish."(91pts) "A wine of enormous intensity, concentration and complexity, it's packed with crisp, firm currant, spice, 3 bottles per lot $260-350 cedar, tar and wild berry flavors, and the finish just goes on and on. Best on the aftertaste, where the flavors 4024 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 2004 fold together ever so nicely. A blend: 73 percent Cabernet Sauvignon, 14 percent Merlot, 13 percent The Maiden Cabernet Franc. Best from 2001 through 2010. 2,851 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) cases made."(93pts WS) "I was blown away by the 2004 The Maiden, which out of bottle is even better than it was from barrel. This 2 bottles per lot $200-280 wine exhibits a rather flamboyant scorched earth, lead pencil, incense, licorice, and blackberry and cassis- 4030 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 1996 scented nose and flavors. The wine has superb Les Pavots concentration..."(95pts) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $400-600 "The nose offers up blackberry, licorice, cassis, and pain grille aromas. The superb extract, well-defined 4025 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 2005 personality, and smoky, licorice, Asian spice, and blackberry flavors provide a thrilling tasting The Maiden experience. It was bottled with neither fining nor 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) filtration."(96pts) (93pts) 1 bottle per lot $130-170 6 bottles per lot $750-1000 4031 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 1997 4026 Paul Hobbs Cabernet Sauvignon Les Pavots Hyde Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1991 (Wines Located in New York) (1) "A blue/black/purple color is followed by an extraordinary bouquet of toast, blackberries, creme de - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (1) cassis, licorice, and cedar. Full-bodied, with silky Above 2 bottles per lot $100-140 tannin, low acidity, and layers of concentrated, pure black fruits judiciously wrapped in subtle toasty oak..."(96pts) 4027 Peter Michael Red 1 bottle per lot $120-160 Les Pavots - Vintage 1988 (Wines Located in New York) (2) 4032 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 1999 - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New (1) Les Pavots York) (94pts) (Wines Located in New York) "Deliciously rich, smooth and polished. Deeply Above 3 bottles per lot $170-220 concentrated, with layers of currant, blackberry, mocha and vanilla. Beautifully focused and deftly balanced, the 4028 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 1992 flavors run on and on. Best from 2004 through 2013."(96pts WS) Les Pavots (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $500-650 "...is the first vintage that has begun to exhibit some complex cedar, lead pencil, and cassis aromas. Medium 4033 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 2005 to full-bodied, with impressive richness, It is a wine that Les Pavots will last for at least 20+ years. The blend for Peter Michael's Les Pavots proprietary red wine varies year (Wines Located in New York) to year, but the composition usually includes at least "...is a sensational wine, with a style that suggests a 70% Cabernet Sauvignon, 5%-15% Merlot, and 5%- hypothetical blend of a great St.-Emilion and Pomerol. 15% Cabernet Franc. Sixty percent new French oak Chocolatey cassis notes intermixed with incense, casks are utilized. The result is a wine that comes as licorice, and a hint of black olive are present in this close as any other California Cabernet Sauvignon- wine. When it hits the palate, it comes across as very based wine to resembling a structured, rich, complex Pomerol-like, with lushness, full body, and opulence. The tannins are sweet, the pH high, and the wine (Wines Located in New York) gorgeously full, pure, dense, and long."(95pts) 1 magnum per lot $240-320 4042 Ristow Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1996 Quinta de Piedras Vineyard, Pauillac 4034 7 bottles per lot $750-1000 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $40-60

PARCEL LOTS 4035-4036 4043 Ristow Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 Quinta de Piedras Vineyard, Pauillac 4035 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) Les Pavots (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $180-240 (96pts) 1 magnum per lot $220-300 4044 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1987 Hillside Select 4036 1 magnum per lot $220-300 (Wines Located in New York) "This was the first Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon (Wines Located in New York) to spend 30 months in oak casks. It is an intriguing wine with a muted bouquet that is attractiv. In the mouth the 4037 Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1981 wine is superb, exhibiting far greater richness, intensity, Monte Bello and complexity than the shy, backward aromatics suggest. The youthful, opaque dark purple color is gsl, bsl, wasl (Wines Located in New York) followed by a restrained nose (due to sterile filtration?), (90pts) and a pure, rich, intense wine with adequate acidity, 1 bottle per lot $55-75 moderate tannin, and layers of ripe, highly-extracted fruit in the finish. Nevertheless, it is an impressive Cabernet Sauvignon that should last for another 15-20 4038 Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1984 years."(90pts) Monte Bello 2 bottles per lot $160-220 bsl (Wines Located in New York) "While this wine is not as reserved and tight as most 8- year old Ridge Cabernets, it still needs another 5-10 4045 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1988 years of cellaring. It should prove to be a 30-year wine. Hillside Select The color is dark ruby with no signs of age. With airing (Wines Located in New York) the reticent nose reveals attractive floral, mineral, and blackcurrant aromas. This full-bodied, powerful, 1 bottle per lot $100-140 structured wine has high tannins and ample evidence of rich, gamey fruit."(95pts) 4046 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1990 1 bottle per lot $150-200 Hillside Select (Wines Located in New York) 4039 Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1991 1 bottle per lot $120-160 Monte Bello (Wines Located in New York) 4047 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1992 "Rich, with currant, mineral, spice, sage, leather and Hillside Select black cherry. Supple in texture, graceful in style and long, persistent and focused on the finish. Tannins are (Wines Located in New York) fine-grained defines the complexity, weight, style, flavor "Possesses an opaque dark purple color, and a and nuance of this vineyard in its best years."(93pts profoundly complex nose of minerals, ripe cassis fruit, WS) cedar, chocolate, and subtle herbs. Full-bodied yet silky, with layers of concentrated, highly extracted fruit, 1 bottle per lot $180-240 this wine is exceptionally well-balanced, beautifully pure, and already delicious. It is still an infant in terms 4040 Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 of development, but I would not fault anybody for wanting to drink it."(95pts) Santa Cruz Mountains (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 6 bottles per lot $140-180 4048 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1989 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 4041 5 bottles per lot $120-160 - Vintage 1991 (Wines Located in New (1) 4055 12 bottles per lot $600-800 York) (93pts) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1992 1wisl (Wines Located in (2) New York) 4056 Brown Estate Zinfandel - Vintage 1999 - Vintage 1993 3wisl (Wines Located in (3) (Wines Located in New York) New York) (92pts) 6 bottles per lot $90-150 Above 7 bottles per lot $320-450 4057 Bryant Family Red - Vintage 2010 4049 Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Bettina Fay Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1991 (Wines Located in New York) (1) "...exhibits abundant notes of graphite, charcoal, blackberries and espresso roast along with fabulous fruit concentration and an unctuously textured, full- - Vintage 1992 2bsl (Wines Located in New (3) bodied mouthfeel with great definition and York) richness."(95pts) - Vintage 1995 3lbsl (Wines Located in (3) 1 magnum per lot $650-850 New York) Above 7 bottles per lot $350-450 4058 6 bottles per lot $1800-2400 (Wines Located in New York) 4050 Verite Red - Vintage 2001 La Joie 4059 Bryant Family Red - Vintage 2011 (Wines Located in New York) Bettina "71% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Merlot, and 9% (Wines Located in New York) Cabernet Franc. Aromas and flavors of roasted "Dark red cherry, plum, licorice, smoke and tobacco espresso, grilled herbs, scorched earth, blackberries, emerge over time. Today the 2011 is a bit compact, and cassis liqueur are accompanied by an unctuously- which is not surprising considering the vintage. With textured, full-bodied, expansive, dense, phenomenally time in the glass, the 2011 starts to find its typical concentrated, pure blockbuster."(96pts) explosive, dark personality, but today some slightly 12 bottles per lot $1500-2000 angular contours remain."(92+pts AG) 1 magnum per lot $400-600 4051 Verite Red - Vintage 1999 La Muse 4060 Bryant Family Red - Vintage 2011 (Wines Located in New York) DB4 12 bottles per lot $1100-1500 (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $1000-1400 4052 Waterstone Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) 4061 Hendry Zinfandel 12 bottles per lot $150-200 Block 7 - Vintage 1998 1tl (Wines Located in New (16) 4053 Waterstone Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 York) 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (5) 12 bottles per lot $180-240 Above 21 bottles per lot $140-260

4054 Blankiet Merlot - Vintage 2002 4062 Joseph Phelps Syrah Paradise Hills Vineyard - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) (1) nl (Wines Located in New York) "The deep, rich 2002 Merlot is not up to the level of the - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) (2) 2003, although it does possess fabulously complex notes of scorched earth, chocolate, espresso roast, and meaty - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) (2) black cherries, currants, and plums. A broodingly backward, concentrated, full-bodied, dense, and super- - Vintage 2008 1tc (Wines Located in New (2) rich Merlot."(94pts) York) 1 magnum per lot $120-160 - Vintage 2009 (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 2010 (Wines Located in New York) (2) 3wasl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2011 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 12 bottles per lot $240-350 4071 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2012 Ritchie Vineyard 4063 Ridge Zinfandel - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) Geyserville 1wisl (Wines Located in New York) (2) 3 bottles per lot $400-550

Lytton Springs (Wines Located in New York) (1) 4072 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2012 Above 3 bottles per lot $60-70 UV-SL Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 4064 Roar Pinot Noir - Vintage 2006 1 bottle per lot $80-110 Santa Lucia Highlands (Wines Located in New York) 4073 Fantesca Chardonnay 11 bottles per lot $190-280 - Vintage 2011 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

4065 Robert Biale Zinfandel Jordan Sparkling Wine - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (5) - Vintage 1987 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

Robert Pecota Merlot Joseph Phelps Eisrebe - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (1) Rosenblum Zinfandel - Vintage 1993 Maggie's Reserve (Wines (1) - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (1) Located in New York) Above 7 bottles per lot $120-180 Kesner Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 Hudson Vineyard (Wines (2) 4066 Roshambo Zinfandel - Vintage 2001 Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 2 half-bottles per lot $85-140 11 bottles per lot $110-140 and 4 bottles

4067 Seghesio Zinfandel - Vintage 1998 4074 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 2000 Home Ranch Belle Côte 2bsl (Wines Located in New York) 3wisl (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $120-170 7 bottles per lot $350-480

4068 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2012 4075 1 bottle per lot $50-70 Larry Hyde & Sons (Wines Located in New York) 1tl (Wines Located in New York)

3 bottles per lot $450-600 4076 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 2001 Belle Côte 4069 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) Ritchie Vineyard 2 bottles per lot $100-140 (Wines Located in New York) "...is a rich, full-bodied, textured, powerful, smoky effort that tastes like a Meursault premier cru on steroids. It 4077 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 2002 possesses ample layers, excellent underlying acidity for Belle Côte balance, and plenty of leesy, hazelnut, and tropical fruit 6wisl (Wines Located in New York) notes."(91pts) "...is a big offering. Filled with pure tropical fruit 5 bottles per lot $300-420 characteristics, it is a full-bodied, exotic Chardonnay offering up tremendous notes of smoky hazelnuts as well as lychee nuts presented in a ripe, gorgeously balanced 4070 3 bottles per lot $180-260 style with a decidedly California personality, but with to the complexity of this gorgeous, full-bodied effort more definition than most California Chardonnays of with zesty acidity. It emerges from the volcanic ash this size and intensity. It is made primarily from the old (tufa) soils of this site. Look for this wine to drink well Wente clone of Chardonnay planted on clay-dominated for 5-7 years."(95-97pts) soils."(95-8pts) 5 bottles per lot $320-450 6 bottles per lot $350-480 4085 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 2003 PARCEL LOTS 4078-4079 Ma Belle Fille (Wines Located in New York) 4078 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 1994 2 bottles per lot $85-110 cuvée Indigene (Wines Located in New York) 4086 1 bottle per lot $40-55 1 bottle per lot $80-110 (Wines Located in New York)

4079 1 bottle per lot $80-110 4087 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 2004 tl (Wines Located in New York) Ma Belle Fille (Wines Located in New York) 4080 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 1999 "...good richness and fatness, it is a firm-structured, cuvée Indigene stony/mineral-dominated, closed effort..."(94pts) 2wisl, 2tl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $120-160 "...exhibits distinctive aromas of smoky tropical fruit intermixed with peaches, apricots, and pears. Long, full-bodied, and layered, with terrifiCôtexture, gorgeous 4088 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 1998 purity, and loads of fruit, this effort can stand up Mon Plaisir against the finest Burgundy grand crus."(93pts) 3nl (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $280-400 6 bottles per lot $300-420

4081 Peter Michael Chardonnay 4089 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 1999 - Vintage 1998 Mon Plaisir Mon Plaisir wasl (Wines Located in New York) (1) 2tl (Wines Located in New York) 7 bottles per lot $380-500 - Vintage 1999 cuvée Indigene (Wines Located in New York) (1) 4090 Archery Summit Pinot Noir - Vintage 1999 (93pts) (Wines Located in New York) Le Caprice (Wines Located in New York) (1) "Only 2,604 bottles of the magnificent, medium to dark Above 3 bottles per lot $140-200 ruby-colored 1999 Pinot Noir Archery Summit Estate were produced. Its spice, rose, and black cherry-scented nose leads to a full-bodied, hugely concentrated 4082 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 2000 personality. This expansive, cherry, chocolate, plum, La Carriere and licorice-flavored wine is opulent, possesses loads of 2wisl, 2tl (Wines Located in New York) depth, and yet remains refined, fresh, and exceedingly well-balanced. Its sweet, lush fruit carries through its 4 bottles per lot $140-180 admirably long, impressive finish."(94pts) 6 bottles per lot $130-190 4083 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 2002 La Carriere 4091 Archery Summit Pinot Noir - Vintage 1997 3wisl (Wines Located in New York) Premier cuvée 3 bottles per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $150-200 4084 Peter Michael Chardonnay - Vintage 2003 La Carriere 4092 Beaux Freres Pinot Noir - Vintage 1997 3nl, 1tl (Wines Located in New York) Beaux Freres Vineyard "The 2003 La Carri re tastes like a grand cru from Corton-Charlemagne, with yeasty, earthy, mineral notes (Wines Located in New York) that are present in liqueur-like levels. Some heady, 4 bottles per lot $120-170 honeyed citrus and orange blossom characteristics add 4093 Beaux Freres Pinot Noir - Vintage 1999 4102 Glaetzer Shiraz - Vintage 2006 Beaux Freres Vineyard Amon-Ra 3nl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $90-120 6 bottles per lot $300-400

4094 Domaine Drouhin Pinot Noir - Vintage 1998 4103 Grant Burge Red Laurene - Vintage 2000 The Holy Trinity (Wines (2) 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $240-350 Henschke Red 4095 Panther Creek Pinot Noir - Vintage 1998 - Vintage 1996 Keyneton Vineyard (Wines (2) Bednarik Vineyard Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 4 bottles per lot $100-140 9 bottles per lot $180-240 4104 Jim Barry Shiraz - Vintage 1997 4096 Panther Creek Pinot Noir - Vintage 1998 The Armagh Freedom Hill Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $200-260 7 bottles per lot $180-240 4105 Kilikanoon Shiraz - Vintage 2005 4097 Ponzi Pinot Noir - Vintage 2011 Killerman's Run 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $120-160 12 bottles per lot $240-320

4098 Quilceda Creek Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1993 4106 Kilikanoon Shiraz - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) M "Smoky, toasty flavors and firm tannins almost mask the (Wines Located in New York) pretty berry tones that emerge gradually in the glass, 12 bottles per lot $500-700 growing polished and almost plush."(91pts WS)

2 bottles per lot $160-200 4107 Mollydooker Shiraz - Vintage 2005 Carnival of Love 4099 Quilceda Creek Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) Galitzine Vineyard, Red Mountain "Gorgeous notes of blackberry liqueur, camphor, and (Wines Located in New York) smoke, and an enormous voluptuousness that would (96pts) make even Pamela Anderson jealous."(99pts) 3 bottles per lot $350-500 1 bottle per lot $160-220

4100 Clarendon Hills Shiraz - Vintage 1998 4108 Mollydooker Shiraz - Vintage 2006 Liandra Carnival of Love (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The dark ruby/purple-colored 1998 Shiraz Liandra "The 2006 Shiraz "Carnival of Love" was sourced from Vineyard (1,800 cases) exhibits beautiful, sweet, a single vineyard. The sensational nose, consisting of blackberry fruit intertwined with pepper, saddle leather, violets, lilacs, meat, game, leather, blueberry, and and spice. Rhône-like in its aromatics, this rich, full- chocolate, leaps from the glass. On the palate this full- bodied, compelling Shiraz displays low acidity as well bodied wine somehow manages to combine power with as a fleshy, succulent mouth-feel."(91pts) elegance. The sweet tannins are well-concealed and the finish lasts for at least one minute. It will provide 5 bottles per lot $200-280 pleasure for 25 years but who will be that patient?"(97pts) 4101 D'Arenberg Shiraz - Vintage 2000 6 bottles per lot $350-500 The Dead Arm (Wines Located in New York) 4109 Peter Lehmann Shiraz - Vintage 1996 5 bottles per lot $160-220 Eight Songs 8bsl (Wines Located in New York) 4115 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 2000 "...is an exuberant, concentrated effort sold only in Pauillac eight-bottle cases. A dense opaque purple color is (Wines Located in New York) accompanied by flamboyant scents of roasted coffee, "...has an opaque ruby/purple color, followed by an cedar wood, cassis, blackberries, and sweet new French extraordinary aromatic expression of liquid oak. In the mouth, flavors of prune liqueur and black minerals/stones interwoven with the tell-tale graphite currants are backed up by abundant glycerin, extract, notes, mulberry, black currants, caramel, and tobacco. and sweet tannin, giving the wine a weighty yet pure, In the mouth, it is remarkably light on its feet, but concentrated impression. The French oak provides somehow seems to pack intense flavors into layer upon some restraint in this forward, super-concentrated layer of fruit and richness that cascade over the palate. Shiraz."(93pts) A compelling wine, with extraordinary precision, great 8 bottles per lot $220-300 intensity, and a seamlessness..."(100pts) 1 bottle per lot $1100-1600 4110 Peter Lehmann Shiraz - Vintage 1997 Eight Songs 4116 Château Latour - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac 6 bottles per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York) "A young wine that electrifies every taste bud in your 4111 Cockburn Vintage Port - Vintage 1975 mouth. Compacted aromas of crushed currants and minerals, with roses and lilacs. Full-bodied, with 3hbsl, 3hwasl, 2tal (Wines Located in New York) masses of silky, refined tannins and a finish that lasts 3 bottles per lot $60-90 for minutes. Stunning. Best Latour since 1990."(100pts WS) 4112 Taylor Fladgate Vintage Port - Vintage 1985 1 bottle per lot $800-1100 4bsl, 2tl (Wines Located in New York) "Extremely understated and closed, it starts out slowly 4117 Château Lynch Bages - Vintage 2000 but finishes quickly. Deep ruby-purple, with berry and Pauillac cherry aromas and flavors, full-bodied, very tannic and (Wines Located in New York) hard."(90pts WS) "This is a superstructured wine with loads of plum, 4 bottles per lot $200-280 blackberry and licorice. Full-bodied, with chewy tannins and a long finish. Gorgeous. Tight. Needs 4113 Taylor Fladgate Vintage Port - Vintage 2000 time."(96pts WS) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $160-220 "Among the most saturated blue/purple/black-colored examples of the vintage, Taylor's 2000 tastes like a 4118 Château Margaux - Vintage 1995 young vintage of Château Latour on steroids. Aromas of Margaux graphite, blackberry liqueur, Crème de cassis and smoke jump from the glass. Spectacularly concentrated (Wines Located in New York) and enormously endowed, with sweetness allied to ripe "Dark color. Black licorice, coffee, currants and black tannin, decent acidity, and layer upon layer of fruit and olives. Complex nose. A full-bodied, chewy blockbuster extract, this is the leading candidate for the port of the of a wine that is not giving anything at all away. It is vintage."(98pts) like buried treasure still; you have to search for the gold. And it's there. Fabulous."(100pts WS) 4 bottles per lot $260-350 ______3 bottles per lot $1100-1500

4114 Château Haut Brion - Vintage 2000 4119 Château Margaux - Vintage 2000 Graves Margaux (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Yet, like a great diplomat, it is a wine of intensity, "The 2000 possesses a saturated ruby/purple color to authority, and measured restraint. A supremely elegant the rim as well as an extraordinarily promising nose of offering, its dense ruby/purple color, and burgeoning creme de cassis intermixed with white flowers, licorice, perfume of scorched earth, liquid minerals, plums, and hints of espresso and toasty oak. There is great black currants, cherries, lead pencil, and subtle spicy intensity, compelling purity, a multi-layered, full-bodied oak are followed by a delicate yet powerfully flavorful, palate, and a finish that goes on for nearly 70+ multi-layered, highly nuanced, and extraordinarily pure seconds. Bottled naturally, with no filtration, it is a and seamless wine."(98pts) monumental example of the elegance and power that 1 bottle per lot $550-750 symbolize this extraordinary vineyard. A tour de force in winemaking, many of my colleagues predicted, far earlier than me, that it would be the wine of the vintage."(100pts) crushed flowers and berries. Full-bodied, with a solid core of ripe fruit and silky tannins. Long and delicious. 1 bottle per lot $650-900 A very fine and pretty wine. Best Talbot in years..."(93pts WS) 4120 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 2000 1 bottle per lot $75-100 Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) 4125 Château Trotanoy - Vintage 1995 "The wine offers a saturated ruby/purple color in addition to reticent but promising aromas of toast, Pomerol coffee, licorice, Crème de cassis, and roasted nuts. (Wines Located in New York) Dense, chewy, and backward, with tremendous purity "Dried flowers, with chocolate and hints of fruit. and density in addition to obvious toasty oak, it is full- Quickly opens and gives you more on the nose if you bodied, powerful, tannic, and backward. Twenty-four to look for it. Full-bodied, with velvety tannins and a long, 48 hours of aeration only hints at its ultimate potential. caressing finish. Builds on your palate. Still needs time. This blockbuster will be exceptionally long- Racy and refined. Fantastic."(96pts WS) lived."(97pts) 3 bottles per lot $500-700 1 bottle per lot $1300-1700 4126 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2000 4121 Château Pavie - Vintage 2000 Reserve des Deux Freres, P. Usseglio St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Its inky purple color is accompanied by succulent "...the color is an opaque purple, and the bouquet offers aromas of blackberry, cherry, and raspberry liqueur up notes of liquid minerals, blackberries, cherries, and interwoven with licorice, mineral, and acacia flower cassis intermixed with spice box, cedar, and white characteristics. Fabulously concentrated and full- flowers. On the palate, it exhibits a massive display of bodied, with a voluptuous texture, sweet tannin, and a richness and extract, yet with pinpoint delineation and flamboyant and accessible personality, this prodigious, vibrancy as well as a 60+ second finish, this is the kind majestic Châteauneuf-du-Pape needs to be tasted to be of phenomenal wine that Perse's critics were afraid he believed."(98pts) might produce - a no-compromise, immortal wonder 3 bottles per lot $450-600 that represents the essence of one of Bordeaux's greatest terroirs. Life is too short not to own and consume the 2000 Pavie.."(100pts) 4127 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2001 1 bottle per lot $420-550 cuvée de la Reine de Bois, Domaine de la Mordoree (Wines Located in New York) 4122 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 2000 "... the 2001 even surpasses the extraordinary Reine des Bois produced in 2000, 1999, and 1998 ... and that s Pauillac saying something! An inky/purple color is followed by a (Wines Located in New York) heady perfume of graphite, blackberries, kirsch, "In short, I find this to be a spectacular Pichon licorice, truffles, and charcoal. This full-bodied effort Lalande. Dense purple in color, with loads of coffee, displays endless concentration in its pure, dense, mocha, creme de cassis, and chocolate notes, this is a generous flavors. It is broadly flavored, with beautifully somewhat unusual blend of 50% Cabernet Sauvignon, integrated acidity, tannin, and alcohol..."(100pts) 34% Merlot, and a whooping 10% Petit Verdot, with a 3 bottles per lot $600-800 little bit of Cabernet Franc."(96pts) 1 bottle per lot $180-220 4128 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) 4123 Château Rauzan Segla - Vintage 2000 "The 1997 Harlan Estate is one of the greatest Cabernet Margaux Sauvignon-based wines I have ever tasted. A blend of (Wines Located in New York) 80% Cabernet Sauvignon, with the rest Merlot and "...still reveals a certain sternness in addition to tough Cabernet Franc, this enormously-endowed, profoundly tannin, it is sweeter and more expansive and flavorful. rich wine must be tasted to be believed. Opaque purple- The dark ruby/purple color is saturated and colored, it boasts spectacular, soaring aromatics of impressive."(90pts) vanilla, minerals, coffee, blackberries, licorice, and cassis. In the mouth, layer after layer unfold powerfully 1 bottle per lot $80-110 yet gently. Acidity, tannin, and alcohol are well- balanced by the wine's unreal richness and singular 4124 Château Talbot - Vintage 2000 personality. The finish exceeds one minute."(100pts) St. Julien 1 bottle per lot $800-1100 (Wines Located in New York) "Beautiful aromas of raspberries, Indian spices, 4129 Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) 4135 Torbreck Shiraz - Vintage 2003 "It boasts an opaque purple color along with Les Amis gorgeously pure, intense aromas of Crème de cassis, (Wines Located in New York) subtle smoke, and the ever-present licorice. Opulent, "It is extraordinarily elegant for a wine of such power, full-bodied, and extraordinarily rich, yet somehow richness, and intensity. Amazingly delineated, with a remaining light on its feet, this Cuvée always stands out dense ruby/purple color as well as a gorgeously sweet for its glorious purity and fragrance."(98pts) nose of smoke, spice box, black cherry liqueur, Crème 1 bottle per lot $1800-2400 de cassis, licorice, and lavender, it offers impressive balance, purity, opulence, and persistence. This phenomenal wine is both powerful and refreshingly 4130 Clarendon Hills Shiraz - Vintage 2002 elegant."(98pts) Astralis 1 bottle per lot $80-110 (Wines Located in New York) ______"...rivals the greatest wines Roman Bratasiuk has made in his 15-year career. This compelling, black/blue-hued 4136 Château Angelus - Vintage 1990 offering from 75-year-old Syrah vines tastes like blood of the vine."(99pts) St. Emilion lwasl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 "...boasts an exceptional nose of subtle licorice, menthol, creme de cassis, blackberries, and hints of 4131 Glaetzer Shiraz - Vintage 2002 coffee and charcoal. Full-bodied, flamboyant, and Amon-Ra opulent, with low acidity and sweet tannin, it still seems (Wines Located in New York) young at age 19. Expansive and full, wine lovers will argue for decades to come which is better, the 1 bottle per lot $50-70 sensational 1990 or the equally terrific 1989."(96pts) 1 bottle per lot $350-500 4132 Greenock Creek Shiraz - Vintage 2002 Alice's 4137 Château Cos d'Estournel - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) St. Estephe "Flamboyant as well as focused, with laser-like lscl (Wines Located in New York) precision, the 2002 Shiraz Alice s was produced from 7- year-old vines. Dense, with remarkable intensity and "Saturated deep ruby. Ineffable aromas of black fruits, wonderful freshness, it is a cool climate Barossa Shiraz minerals, licorice and Havana tobacco. Rich, dense and with good acidity, enormous concentration, and a thick; powerful but harmonious. Layered texture over a backward style that promises to be ethereal with 4-5 strong backbone. Very long on the palate, with more years of bottle age."(96pts) thoroughly ripe, noble cabernet tannins. Superb."(94pts IWC) 1 bottle per lot $50-60 1 bottle per lot $150-200

4133 Torbreck Shiraz - Vintage 2002 4138 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1998 Run Rig St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) lbsl, wrl, ll (Wines Located in New York) "...may be even more awesome than the 2001. It boasts a blackberry liqueur-like intensity with chocolatey "...boasts an opaque black/purple color as well as a richness intermixed with blackberries, raspberries, and classic L oville-Las-Cases display of lead pencil, cherries. The unctuous texture, refreshing acidity, and gorgeously pure black raspberries and cherries, smoke, sweet tannin frame-up this magnificent wine"(99pts) and graphite. A broad yet focused entry on the palate reveals firm tannin, medium to full body, superb 1 bottle per lot $110-150 concentration and purity, as well as a totally symmetrical mouthfeel."(93pts) 4134 Torbreck Shiraz - Vintage 2003 1 double magnum per lot $450-600 Descendant (Wines Located in New York) 4139 Château Margaux - Vintage 2002 "A spectacular perfume of flowers, blackberries, cassis, Margaux licorice, and honeysuckle is followed by an unctuously lstl (Wines Located in New York) textured, full-bodied red displaying a seamless integration of wood, tannin, acidity, and alcohol. With "This wine reveals a dense ruby/purple color in a style elegance, power, richness, and just about everything somewhat reminiscent of the 1988 but with more power, one could want in a full-throttle, beautifully balanced concentration, and volume. It has a beautifully elegant dry red wine..."(96pts) nose of black fruits intermixed with truffle, flower, and oak. The wine is medium to full-bodied, dense, with 1 bottle per lot $40-60 wonderful precision, freshness, and a long, full-bodied finish with impressive levels of concentration."(93pts) Full-bodied, opulent, and rich with outstanding depth, purity, and harmony, sweet tannin, and a long finish, it 1 bottle per lot $280-400 is approachable now, but will easily last for 20 years."(94pts) 4140 Château Montrose - Vintage 2003 6 bottles per lot $700-900 St. Estephe 5lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4146 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 "The enormous 2003 Montrose is built along the lines of the 1989 rather than the 1990. It boasts a dense Hillside Select black/purple color in addition to an extraordinary (Wines Located in New York) bouquet of scorched earth, blackberries, and cassis, "...one of the finest wines of the vintage. A saturated fabulous purity, a skyscraper-like texture, and opaque purple color is followed by scents of vanilla, substantial tannin in the finish. This superb, huge, ripe blackberry liqueur, crushed minerals, and a hint of wine is one of the vintage s most prodigious white flowers. There is stunning intensity, tremendous offerings."(97pts) purity, full body, and a remarkable, seamless finish..."(97pts) 5 bottles per lot $750-1000 1 magnum per lot $400-600 4141 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 2004 Pauillac 4147 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 lscl (Wines Located in New York) Hillside Select "...reveals a deep ruby/purple hue, classic evolved (Wines Located in New York) cedary, lead pencil, and cassis characteristics, medium " is a big wine (14.9% natural alcohol), but the alcohol body, beautiful sweetness of fruit, and a more forward, is buried beneath an avalanche of creme de cassis, evolved character than its big sibling."(90pts) wood smoke, toast, licorice and spring flower characteristics. Super full-bodied with fabulous fruit 1 bottle per lot $130-180 purity, a broad, expansive mouthfeel, lots of glycerin and a huge upside, this 2001 is still an infant at age ten, 4142 Bonnes Mares - Vintage 1996 but it is approachable as well as compelling to smell Comte de Vogue and taste. It has at least another three decades of aging potential ahead of it and is one of the great young, (Wines Located in New York) legendary classics from Napa Valley."(100pts) "Flamboyant nose combines blueberry, blackberry, licorice and Cuban tobacco; distinctly blacker aromas 1 magnum per lot $500-700 than the '97. Great sweetness and penetration on the palate."(93+pts IWC) 4148 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2003 1 bottle per lot $240-320 Hillside Select 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 4143 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 1995 "One of the great so-called "first growths" of Napa is Vieilles Vignes, Ponsot Shafer's 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon from their Stags Leap vineyard known as Hillside Select. This has been lgsl, htl (Wines Located in New York) one of the top dozen or so wines in every vintage for 1 bottle per lot $200-280 over 15 years. A big wine at 14.9% alcohol, it is aged an atypically long time of 32 months in 100% new French oak, but at ten years of age, no oak is present. It 4144 Verite Red - Vintage 2001 is an utterly perfect wine, surpassing almost everything La Joie else made in 2003! It possesses everything one could (Wines Located in New York) desire in a Cabernet Sauvignon minerality, flowers, "71% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Merlot, and 9% creme de cassis, blackberries, velvety tannins, a Cabernet Franc. Aromas and flavors of roasted skyscraper texture, perfect balance and integration espresso, grilled herbs, scorched earth, blackberries, between the acidity, tannin, alcohol and wood, all well- and cassis liqueur are accompanied by an unctuously- concealed by the luxurious nature of this great wine. textured, full-bodied, expansive, dense, phenomenally The finish is endless in this prodigious offering from a concentrated, pure blockbuster."(96pts) great family of grape growers and winemakers. It proves the point that good guys can finish first."(100pts) 1 bottle per lot $120-160 ______6 bottles per lot $1200-1600

4145 Joseph Phelps Winery - Vintage 2003 4149 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 Insignia Hillside Select 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...it offers up attractive aromas of licorice, black "...is one of those rare wines that looks like it will be currants, espresso roast, and background toasty oak. absolutely delicious pretty much at any point in its life. Super-refined and silky, the 2008 caresses the palate 4154 Échézeaux - Vintage 1969 with layers of deeply expressive dark fruit. The 2008 is Maison Leroy a wine of exceptional textural finesse and pedigree. According to Doug Shafer, cool weather in the spring lstl, lscl, excellent color and condition (Wines resulted in small clusters with high skin to juice ratios, Located in New York) always a plus for high quality wines."(96pts) 1 bottle per lot $700-900 1 magnum per lot $400-600 4155 Morey St. Denis - Vintage 2003 4150 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2009 cuvée des Grives, Ponsot Hillside Select 1x6 magnum ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 magnums per lot $600-800 "...is deep, racy and layered from the very first taste. A large-scaled, sumptuous wine, the 2009 impresses for its exceptional balance and pure pedigree. There is 4156 Volnay - Vintage 1998 plenty of flesh here, but also more than enough tannin M. Lafarge to help balance some of the wine's more overt 1lwrl (Wines Located in New York) tendencies."(98pts) 3 bottles per lot $100-140 1 magnum per lot $450-600

4157 Volnay - Vintage 1999 4151 Sine Qua Non Grenache Taillepieds, Marquis d'Angerville - Vintage 2007 To The Rescue 1x4 half bottle half- bottle (2) 1ssos (Wines Located in New York) custom owc (Wines Located in "Dark red. Deep, sappy aromas of red fruits, minerals, chocolate and smoke. Fat, sweet and full; wonderfully New York) (96pts) lush, layered Volnay, with impressive richness and depth. Very long finish coats the palate with ripe fruit Sine Qua Non Roussanne and fine tannins. Superb."(93pts IWC) - Vintage 2006 To The Rescue (Wines Located half- 3 bottles per lot $300-420 bottle (2) in New York) 4158 Lanson Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1996 Above 4 half-bottles per lot $480-650 Gold Label ______3lscl (Wines Located in New York)

4152 Ruchottes Chambertin - Vintage 2001 3 bottles per lot $180-240 Georges Mugneret (Wines Located in New York) 4159 Ornellaia - Vintage 2008 "...half of this holding was pulled up after the '98 Tenuta dell' Ornellaia harvest and then replanted; this 2001 is entirely from (Wines Located in New York) 60-year-old vines) Bright ruby-red. Sappy, precise "...graced with exquisite finesse in its dark fruit, mocha, aromas of cherry, spices and smoked meat. At once licorice, tar and spices. I especially like the minerality creamy-sweet and complex in the mouth, with intense, and focus. There is a fabulous balance between the highly perfumed flavors of red fruits, minerals and tannins of this structured, powerful vintage, but with spices. This boasts sneaky old-vines intensity and gorgeous fleshiness and pliancy that makes the wine terrific verve. A firmly structured, youthfully austere very attractive, even at this early stage."(96pts) wine with lovely lift and superb backbone. A great showing today."(92-4pts IWC) 1 bottle per lot $130-180 1 bottle per lot $300-400 4160 Tignanello - Vintage 2007 Antinori 4153 Pahlmeyer Merlot - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) lscl (Wines Located in New York) "...is wonderfully ripe and seductive in its dark cherries, "It is one of the most amazingly rich and intense flowers, spices, tobacco, sage, cedar, mint and Merlots I have yet tasted - from anywhere! The color is minerals. This is as opulent a Tignanello as I have ever a remarkable opaque black. The aromatics offer a tasted but there is just enough acidity and structure decadent display of jammy red and black-cherries, from the Sangiovese to keep things from going over the smoke, chocolate, licorice, and herbs. Extraordinarily top."(95pts) rich, this full-bodied, multi-layered wine is nicely framed by toasty oak and pain grillee."(95pts) 5 bottles per lot $400-550 1 bottle per lot $60-80 ______4161 Numanthia - Vintage 2005 1nl (Wines Located in New York) shavings, and sensationally sweet, ripe black currant "Opaque purple, it has a superb perfume of violets, and cedar notes. A wine of extraordinary intensity, mineral, wood smoke, blueberry, and blackberry. This texture, and depth with silky tannins as well as awesome leads to a firm, very structured wine with questionable concentration, this has turned out to be a remarkable balance. The finish is long but tannic."(92?pts) Lafite Rothschild that should be drinkable much earlier than the 2005, but age for three decades."(97pts) 6 bottles per lot $300-420 1 bottle per lot $500-650

4162 Termanthia - Vintage 2004 4167 Château Latour - Vintage 1995 1x2 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac "On the palate the wine is an infant developmentally with densely packed ripe fruit, sensational balance, and lbsl (Wines Located in New York) a seamlessness that must be tasted to be believed. It "A beauty, the opaque dense purple-colored 1995 should age like a great vintage of Lafite or Latour and exhibits jammy cassis, vanillin, and minerals in its have at least a 50 year life span. If you have a soul, sell fragrant but still youthful aromatics. Medium to full- it to the devil for a few bottles of this extraordinary bodied, with exceptional purity, superb concentration, liquid."(100pts) and a long, intense, ripe, 40-second finish, this is a magnificent example of Latour."(96pts) 2 bottles per lot $400-500 ______1 bottle per lot $450-600

4163 Sine Qua Non Rose - Vintage 2013 4168 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 2009 And an Eight Track St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 "...boasts an inky/purple color, monumental ______concentration and lots of sweet, jammy black currant, black cherry and kirsch fruit intermixed with crushed 4164 Château Cos d'Estournel - Vintage 1986 rock and mineral notes."(98+pts) St. Estephe 3 bottles per lot $700-900 lbsl (Wines Located in New York) "This is the most powerful and tannic Cos d'Estournel 4169 Château Margaux - Vintage 1995 made during the decade of the eighties. The color is still Margaux an impressive, nearly opaque dark ruby/purple. Except for some subtle aromas of toasty vanillin oak and lscl (Wines Located in New York) cassis, the nose is closed and unevolved. In the mouth "Dark color. Black licorice, coffee, currants and black this full-bodied wine, which exhibits no signs of olives. Complex nose. A full-bodied, chewy blockbuster evolution, is firmly structured with medium to full-body, of a wine that is not giving anything at all away. It is outstanding depth, and a hard, though not abrasive, like buried treasure still; you have to search for the exceptionally long finish."(95pts) gold. And it's there. Fabulous."(100pts WS) 1 bottle per lot $130-180 1 bottle per lot $300-400

4165 Château Cos d'Estournel - Vintage 2009 4170 Sassicaia - Vintage 2006 St. Estephe Tenuta San Guido (Wines Located in New York) 1x3 magnum banded owc (Wines Located in New "A remarkable effort from winemaking guru Jean- York) Guillaume Prats and owner Michel Reybier, this blend "...may very well go down as one of the all-time great of 65% Cabernet Sauvignon and the rest Merlot (33%) recent vintages for this Tuscan thoroughbred. The year and a touch of Cabernet Franc (2%) was cropped at 33 started off very warm but by August evening hectoliters per hectare. It boasts an inky/black/purple temperatures had moderated, leaving the fruit with a color along with an extraordinary bouquet of white stunning combination of ripeness, perfume, acidity and flowers interwoven with blackberry and blueberry tannin. The wine is simply glorious, that s all there is to liqueur, incense, charcoal and graphite."(100pts) it. Layers of dark fruit meld into smoke, leather, violets, menthol, earthiness and tar as this profound wine opens 3 bottles per lot $750-1000 up in the glass. The creamy, silky finish lasts an eternity, as waves of fruit caress the tannins with 4166 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 2006 breathtaking elegance."(97pts) Pauillac 3 magnums per lot $1100-1500 (Wines Located in New York) ______"Lafite's severe selection process (42% made it into the grand vin) resulted in a full-bodied wine boasting an 4171 Château Cos d'Estournel - Vintage 1982 extraordinary perfume of charcoal, truffles, lead pencil St. Estephe 1wasl, 1sdc (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac "Cos d Estournel s 1982 exhibits a dark ruby/purple 2lwasl, 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) color with light pink at the rim. Sweet aromas of jammy "Gorgeous aromas of currants, berries and minerals. black fruits intermixed with roasted espresso and Full-bodied, with juicy tannins and a long, long fininsh. vanillin jump from the glass of this young, concentrated, Same as ever. This will age for decades to full-bodied, succulent effort."(96pts) come..."(98pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $600-800 2 bottles per lot $350-480

4172 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1989 4178 Bollinger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1990 Pauillac Grande Annee (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Wonderful berry and tobacco character, with "A sense of opulence marks this highly concentrated, chocolate and cedar. Full-bodied, yet elegant and silky. creamy-textured 1990 Champagne, with its ripe, Beautifully long. This is always outstanding..."(94pts generous fruit flavors complementing the toasty, WS) honeyed nuances acquired from aging on the lees. 1 bottle per lot $550-750 Lingering finish."(95pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 4173 Château Latour - Vintage 1989 Pauillac 4179 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1988 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Firm and solid. Dark ruby color. Mint, cassis, berry "Beautiful. Offers great toasty, earthy aromas, lively but and cherry. Intense. Full-bodied, racy and fine. mellow fruit flavors and a lingering finish. Seems suave Tobacco, cherry and berry."(92pts WS) and sophisticated, even better than when reviewed earlier. Tempting now, but should improve. "(93pts WS) 1 bottle per lot $400-600 1 bottle per lot $180-260 4174 Château Margaux - Vintage 1989 Margaux 4180 Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 2nl, 1lwasl, 1sdc (Wines Located in New York) 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "Nice nose - nutty, cedary, caramelized cassis...iron fist "...notes of crushed rock, Crème de cassis, cedar wood in velvet glove thing happening...has that distinctive as well as some licorice and tobacco leaf. This is a Margaux breed and elegance."(94pts JK) beautiful wine of superb purity, depth, and broad, concentrated flavors that are full-bodied but in seamless 2 bottles per lot $700-900 harmony..."(94-97pts) 3 bottles per lot $900-1200 4175 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1985 Pauillac 4181 Sloan Red - Vintage 2000 bn, lscl, nl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The rich, complex, well-developed bouquet of oriental "This is a beautiful young Cabernet blend, ripe and spices, toasty oak, herbs, and ripe fruit is wonderful. On floral, dark-hued and rich yet elegant in its mouthfeel, the palate, the wine is also rich, forward, long, and with pure, fleshy currant, cassis, blackberry and toasty sexy."(90pts) vanilla scents from oak. Impeccably balanced, complex 1 bottle per lot $350-500 and concentrated, the finish keeps pumping out subtle flavor nuances that have remarkable staying power."(93pts WS) 4176 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1990 Pauillac 3 bottles per lot $450-600 1lwasl (Wines Located in New York) "Full, deep red. Knockout smoky nose of cedar, leather, 4182 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2004 earth, truffle and game. Then rather tightly coiled and cuvée Catherine far less pliant than the nose would suggest. Strong acids (Wines Located in New York) contribute to this wine rather powerful structure. But I "Aromas of crushed rocks, violets, raspberries, sweet don't find the flesh shown by the best wines from this cherries, and a distinctive terroir character are present vintage. Finishes quite firm, youthfully backward and in this full-bodied effort. With oodles of vivacious fruit persistent."(90+?pts IWC) as well as wonderful freshness and palate 2 bottles per lot $600-800 penetration..."(94-95pts) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 4177 Château Pichon Baron - Vintage 1989 4183 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2007 lime, tangerine and menthol. Deep, chewy and rich, with bright acids throwing the spicy cinnamon toast and cuvée Catherine mineral flavors into sharp relief.Impressively oily, ripe (Wines Located in New York) and full, but still painfully young, with truly three- "Following the brilliant success of Kistler's 2007s, Steve dimensional texture and superb thrust. This should Kistler and his sidekick, Mark Bixler, deserve kudos for evolve in bottle for years."(93pts IWC) what they have achieved in the more challenging 2008 12 bottles per lot $900-1200 vintage. This is the first vintage in which 100% of the ______fermentations were indigenous, and, fortunately, all their Sonoma Coast vineyards were far enough south that they were not tainted by any of the smoke from the 4190 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 2003 ferocious fires that spread through Mendocino. The D. Laurent 2008s appear to be slightly more fruit-forward, with a (Wines Located in New York) touch less minerality than the 2007s. "(95-97pts) (92-96pts IWC) 2 bottles per lot $350-450 6 bottles per lot $500-700 ______4184 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2004 Kistler Vineyard 4191 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 1969 (Wines Located in New York) Les Amoureuses, Bertheau "Violet, cranberry, cherry, pomegranate, and rose petal 7.5cm bc, lbsl, ltl, sos (Wines Located in New aromas jump from the glass of the tangy, medium- York) bodied 2004 Pinot Noir Kistler Vineyard. Fresh and lively with good acidity and not the weight or intensity 1 bottle per lot $350-500 of the cuvée Catherine, it is a beautifully fragrant, complex Pinot Noir to drink over the next decade." (92- 4192 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 1997 94pts) Dujac 2 bottles per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York) "The first-rate 1997 Clos de la Roche has exuberant 4185 1 bottle per lot $90-120 aromas of red fruits and licorice. This is a wine that combines Dujac's trademark elegance with power, (Wines Located in New York) density, and jammy, super-ripe flavors. Candied berries, chocolate-covered cherries, and red currant 4186 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 liqueur are found in this medium to full-bodied, Kistler Vineyard complex, and mouth-coating offering."(93pts) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $350-500 "...deep ruby/purple-hued 2005 Pinot Noir Kistler Vineyard possesses sweet blueberry, raspberry, and 4193 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2000 forest floor notes, zesty acidity, elegance, and finesse, and a medium-bodied finish."(93-95pts) Aux Combottes, Dujac (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $200-280 2 bottles per lot $240-320 4187 1 bottle per lot $100-140 (Wines Located in New York) 4194 Morey St. Denis - Vintage 2000 Dujac 4188 Penfold's Grange - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $120-160 "A massive wine, majestic in its proportions, combining power and grace in equal measure. Flavors of plum, 4195 Chambertin - Vintage 2001 blackberry, chocolate and pepper, with hints of cedar, Clos de Bèze, Faiveley licorice and mint, swirl through the exotic finish. Tannins swarm but don't overwhelm the finish, which (Wines Located in New York) echoes all day and night."(97pts WS) "Deep, bright red. Subtle, soil-inflected aromas of raspberry, minerals, tobacco and rose petal. Lush, thick 3 bottles per lot $650-850 ______and fat, with compelling flavors of musky, sappy berries. The silkiest of these young 2001s today. Finishes with chewy but very smooth tannins and slow- 4189 Gosset Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1996 mounting, palate-saturating flavor."(91-4pts IWC) Grand Millesime 1 bottle per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) "Cool, youthful aromas of wet stone, cinnamon bread, 4196 Bonnes Mares - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) G. Roumier 2 bottles per lot $280-350 (Wines Located in New York) "Displaying a dark ruby color and a fabulous nose of 4202 Meursault - Vintage 2002 candied red fruits and cookie dough, this wine is an immensely rich, multi-dimensional masterpiece. This Genevrieres, Bouchard, Pere et Fils broad-shouldered, ample, oily-textured, masculine, (Wines Located in New York) structured, and medium-to-full-bodied wine is 3 bottles per lot $170-220 formidably concentrated and complex. Highly-focused blackberries, violets, lilies, stones, earth, and cassis flavors are intermingled with grilled and spiced new 4203 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2001 oak. Its prodigiously long finish is expansive, rendering Dent de Chien, Château de la Maltroye its copious and supple tannins invisible."(93-95pts) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $850-1100 6 bottles per lot $180-240

4197 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2000 PARCEL LOTS 4204-4205 Les Cras, G. Roumier (Wines Located in New York) 4204 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2001 2 bottles per lot $160-220 La Romanée, Château de la Maltroye (Wines Located in New York) 4198 Musigny - Vintage 1999 2 bottles per lot $80-110 J. Drouhin (Wines Located in New York) 4205 2 bottles per lot $80-110 "Magnificent complexity, superb flavor detail and a (Wines Located in New York) penetrating minerality that culminates in a finish that lasts for minutes. As I commented in the Musigny vertical report, the Drouhin Musigny is a seriously 4206 Puligny Montrachet - Vintage 2004 underrated wine and all of the immense potential the '99 Les Enseigneres, Coche-Dury displayed in cask has been captured here. It would not (Wines Located in New York) surprise me if my score was ultimately found to be overly conservative as the picture perfect balance 2 bottles per lot $600-800 should permit this to age for 30 years or more."(94pts BH) 4207 Corton Charlemagne - Vintage 2002 1 bottle per lot $550-750 M. Colin (Wines Located in New York) 4199 Chambertin - Vintage 1993 6 bottles per lot $750-1000 Clos de Bèze, L. Jadot lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4208 Batard Montrachet - Vintage 2002 "...this is wonderfully expressive and complex with abundant earth and spice notes followed by big, M. Morey structured, still sappy if slightly austere flavors that (Wines Located in New York) offer excellent density and plenty of character. 3 bottles per lot $300-380 Impressively scaled and finishes with striking length."(92pts BH) 4209 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2000 1 bottle per lot $180-240 Les Champs Gains, M. Niellon (Wines Located in New York) 4200 Chambertin - Vintage 1999 Clos de Bèze, L. Jadot 4 bottles per lot $260-350 (Wines Located in New York) "Beautiful black fruit aromatics with rich, relatively 4210 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 1998 forward flavors that are not especially dense but offer La Crau, Vieux Telegraphe an amazing range of earth nuances."(91-94pts BH) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 "...is the greatest Vieux Telegraphe that was produced. It has taken a good decade for this wine to shed its tannins and come out of a dormant, closed period. It 4201 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1996 has finally emerged, and notes of iodine, seaweed, black Les Boudots, Méo-Camuzet currants, incense, and sweet cherries as well as hot rocks jump from the glass of this full-bodied, powerful 4216 2 bottles per lot $2000-2800 wine. It possesses considerable elegance and purity, (Wines Located in New York) along with loads of raspberries and incense, in a round, juicy, rich style that is just emerging from the closet."(95pts) 4217 2 bottles per lot $2000-2800 4 bottles per lot $300-400 (Wines Located in New York) ______

4211 Château Pontet Canet - Vintage 2003 4218 Château Calon Segur - Vintage 1996 Pauillac St. Estephe 3vlscl (Wines Located in New York) spc (Wines Located in New York) "Deep purple to the rim with a glorious nose of "The 1996, a 60% Cabernet Sauvignon, 40% Merlot scorched earth, black currant jam, smoke, licorice, and blend, made from very low yields of 35 hectoliters per roasted meats, it is full-bodied, incredibly hectare (just over 2 tons of fruit per acre), appears to be powerful..."(95pts) a dazzling, traditionally made, uncompromising, classic Bordeaux..."(92pts) 8 bottles per lot $650-900 1 bottle per lot $80-110 4212 Dominus - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) 4219 Château Grand Puy Lacoste "The deep, saturated purple-colored 2002 boasts an - Vintage 1978 Pauillac lgsl, scc, excellent (1) extraordinary perfume of roasted coffee intermixed with color and condition (Wines black currants, cherries, cocoa, cedar, cigar smoke, and Located in New York) (90pts) new saddle leather. A classic, full-bodied palate possesses great structure, tremendous depth, loads of tannin, and a multilayered, concentrated yet elegant Château Gruaud Larose finish. It is difficult to predict when this beauty will - Vintage 1981 St. Julien bn, wc (Wines (1) plateau in terms of maturity."(96pts) Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $850-1100 Above 2 bottles per lot $90-130

4213 Turley Petite Syrah 4220 Château Haut Brion - Vintage 1990 Hayne Vineyard Graves - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New (1) (Wines Located in New York) York) (93-95pts) "1990: In terms of the brilliant complexity and nobility - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New (2) of the aromatics, scorched earth, black currants, plums, York) (96-98pts) charcoal, cedar, and spices, the 1990 offers an aromatic explosion that is unparalleled. It is always fascinating Above 3 bottles per lot $160-220 to taste this wine next to the 1989, which is a monumental effort, but much more backward and denser, without the aromatic complexity of the 1990. 4214 Turley Petite Syrah The 1990 put on weight after bottling, and is currently - Vintage 2003 rich, full-bodied, opulent, even flamboyant by Haut Library Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (1) Brion's standards. It is an incredible expression of a noble terroir in a top vintage."(98pts) - Vintage 2004 1 bottle per lot $550-750 Library Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (96- (1) 98pts) 4221 Château La Tour Haut Brion - Vintage 1970 Rattlesnake Ridge (Wines Located in New York) (1) Graves Above 3 bottles per lot $130-190 lgsl, outstanding color and condition (Wines ______Located in New York)

PARCEL LOTS 4215-4217 1 bottle per lot $200-280

4215 Old Rip Van Winkle Bourbon Whiskey - Vintage NV 4222 Château Latour a Pomerol - Vintage 1986 Pappy Van Winkle 15 Year, Family Reserve Pomerol (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $2000-2800 1 bottle per lot $70-90 4223 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 1986 "This spectacularly sweet, opulent wine exhibits a stunning nose of coconuts and pineapples. In the mouth, Pauillac there is phenomenal richness, as well as enough acidity bn, gsl (Wines Located in New York) and botrytis to give it the extra dimension that is "The wine shows notes of cedar, black currants, earth, missing in so many 1990s. The finish is all fruit, spice box, and licorice, followed by a medium to full- glycerin, and moderately high alcohol."(95pts) bodied, very concentrated, intense palate with a still noticeable tannic structure, a relatively big, muscular 1 bottle per lot $50-65 style for Pichon-Lalande."(94pts) 1 bottle per lot $180-240 4230 Château Rieussec - Vintage 2001 Sauternes 4224 Domaine de Chevalier - Vintage 1982 (Wines Located in New York) "Like lemon curd on the nose, turning to honey and Graves caramel. Full-bodied and very sweet, with fantastic gsl, lwrl (Wines Located in New York) concentration of ripe and botrytized fruit, yet balanced 1 bottle per lot $75-100 and refined. Electric acidity. Lasts for minutes on the palate. This is absolutely mind-blowing. This is the greatest young Sauternes I have ever tasted."(100pts 4225 Château Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage WS) 1984 6 bottles per lot $650-850 (Wines Located in New York) "Nutty, plummy nose - cassis, cream, and a pinch of lavender lots of class - an excellent nose with a 4231 1 half-bottle per lot $65-85 chocolaty core good, meaty flavors with carob and (Wines Located in New York) leather and caramel excellent balance - beautiful."(94pts JK) 4232 Château Tirecul La Graviere - Vintage 1995 1 bottle per lot $75-100 cuvée Madame, Monbazillac 1ltl (Wines Located in New York) 4226 Dunn Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1987 "...there is no doubt in my mind that the 1995 cuvée Howell Mountain Madame is as profound a sweet wine as I have ever crc (Wines Located in New York) tasted. Made from 80-year old vines, harvested grape "A powerful, young wine, even at age 10. Dark, ripe, by grape, and with yields of 12 hectoliters per hectare intense and deeply concentrated, this one is years from (under one ton of fruit per acre), this wine boasts a peaking. Packed with a rich, earthy core of currant, glorious nose of apricot jam, tangerine essence, and mineral, anise, sage and cedar. Quite tannic in this subtle spicy oak. With its profound richness, blazingly tasting, the fruit poured through on the finish."(97pts vivid definition, huge body, viscous thickness (with no WS) heaviness), and finish that lasts for nearly a minute, this nectar constitutes one of the most extraordinary sweet 1 bottle per lot $100-140 wines I have ever tasted."(100pts) 4 500 mls per lot $420-600 4227 Joseph Phelps Winery - Vintage 1992 Insignia 4233 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New York) Vieilles Vignes, Château de la Tour "Starts with a slight earthiness but then quickly shows a lscl (Wines Located in New York) ripe, plush, generous core of complex currant, black cherry, anise, sage and blackberry that's youthful, "...the wine's weight, as well as massive length and vibrant and remarkably complex. Aging very intensity are admirable. The tannins are significant and gracefully."(94pts WS) the extraction of fruit is mind-boggling."(94pts) 1 bottle per lot $100-140 1 bottle per lot $160-220 ______4234 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 2003 4228 Château Doisy Daëne - Vintage 1983 Dujac Sauternes sdc (Wines Located in New York) 2lbsl, 1ll, 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) "Medium bright, deep red. Highly nuanced nose 2 bottles per lot $100-140 combines red fruits, minerals and flowers. Silky-sweet, thick and sappy, with outstanding richness and volume; this has fruit of steel. A perfect example of a 2003 that's 4229 Château Raymond Lafon - Vintage 1990 superripe without being cooked. One to buy and to Sauternes cellar."(93pts IWC) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $350-500 4235 Meursault - Vintage 1995 fruit, butter and mineral flavors. Full-bodied and harmonious, it cascades to a long, smoky Goutte d'Or, Comte Lafon finish..."(96pts WS) (Wines Located in New York) "Displaying a nose reminiscent of a vine's flower in the 1 bottle per lot $300-400 springtime (beautifully sweet with hints of cream and spice), the silky-textured Meursault Goutte d'Or exhibits 4242 Chassagne Montrachet - Vintage 2002 an explosive flavor profile packed with flavors of spices Les Blanchots Dessus, V. Girardin and sweet fruit."(90-92pts) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $100-120 4 bottles per lot $90-110

4236 Chevalier Montrachet - Vintage 2002 4243 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2001 Domaine Leflaive Château Rayas (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Gorgeous aromas of minerals, gravel, and spices are found in the big, rich, opulent 2002 Chevalier- "...reveals aromas of raspberries and sweet kirsch as Montrachet. Medium-bodied and velvety-textured, this well as a medium-bodied, vigorously fresh, lively style. lush, spicy wine coats the palate with layers of toasted There is also good flavor authority."(92pts) minerals, honey, and pears."(93-96pts) 3 bottles per lot $700-950 1 bottle per lot $500-700 4244 1 bottle per lot $240-320 4237 Chablis - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) Valmur, Fevre (Wines Located in New York) 4245 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2000 "Decidedly more austere with simply incredible purity cuvée de la Reine de Bois, Domaine de la Mordoree and focus plus outstanding intensity. This is a dramatic 1wisl (Wines Located in New York) wine yet perfectly composed with a pronounced stony "...boasts an inky purple color in addition to a ravishing quality that permeates the character of this from the perfume of wood smoke, Crème de cassis, blueberries, opening notes to the firm, powerful, wonderfully long plums, figs, and a hint of graphite. Full-bodied, with finish. Sappy, dense and palate staining in its intensity, sweet tannin, a layered richness, staggering ripeness, this is a real stunner and not to be missed."(94pts BH) and a finish that lasts for nearly 50 seconds, this 1 bottle per lot $60-80 monumental Châteauneuf du Pape continues the unbelievable succession of superstar wines that began in 1998."(97pts) 4238 Beaune Blanc - Vintage 1997 Clos des Mouches, J. Drouhin 6 bottles per lot $500-700 lbsl (Wines Located in New York) "This is a big white Burgundy, with lots of pear, 4246 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 tropical, vanilla bean, smoke and toast notes. There is Domaine du Pegau great balance here as the lemony acidity holds its own (Wines Located in New York) against the oak and ripe fruit."(90pts WS) 3 bottles per lot $220-300 1 bottle per lot $50-70

4247 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 1999 4239 Batard Montrachet - Vintage 1995 Brune et Blonde, E. Guigal L. Latour (Wines Located in New York) 2lbsl, 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) (91-93pts) 2 bottles per lot $130-180 1 bottle per lot $50-70

4240 Bienvenue Batard Montrachet - Vintage 1996 4248 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 2003 P. Pernot Château d'Ampuis, E. Guigal lwisl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $80-110 "A wine worth filling up the trunk of the car with is the 2003 Côte-R tie Château d Ampuis. This is staggering 4241 Montrachet - Vintage 1994 wine and as profound as most of the single vineyard Côte-R ties are in some other vintages. The wine has a Sauzet deep ruby/purple color and an extraordinary nose of (Wines Located in New York) smoky bacon fat and roasted meats, tapenade, black "This opulent wine offers tons of toasted oak, spice, ripe raspberry, cherry, and cassis. The intense aromatics are followed by equally thick, unctuous flavors with huge PARCEL LOTS 4254-4255 body, a voluptuous texture, and yet wonderful freshness, purity, and length..."(96pts) 4254 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1990 1 bottle per lot $65-90 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) "...is a creamy-textured, full styled offering that loses 4249 Ermitage - Vintage 2000 none of its elegance in spite of its flavor Le Meal, M. Chapoutier authority."(96pts) 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $240-320 "Offering up honeysuckle characteristics, gobs of fruit and glycerin, and more fat than the cuvée de l Or e, it is 4255 1 bottle per lot $240-320 huge in the mouth, very buttery, and is a total hedonistic (Wines Located in New York) turn-on. I suspect additional nuances will develop as it ages. It will provide an enormous mouthful of wine over the next 4-5 years, and should keep for 40-50 4256 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1996 years."(97pts) 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $280-350 "Notes of crushed rocks, honeysuckle, lemon oil, orange marmalade, and white pear provide a stunning aromatic display as well as palate impression. Great 4250 Ermitage Blanc - Vintage 2000 acidity and huge flavor intensity backed up by vibrant Le Meal, M. Chapoutier acidity make this an exquisite Champagne."(98pts) 3ltl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $200-280 5 bottles per lot $500-600 4257 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1998 4251 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2001 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) cuvée de Mon Aieul, P. Usseglio "An enticing blend of red berries, butter and toast on (Wines Located in New York) the nose; this settled down to an earthy, smoky "The 2001 Châteauneuf-du-Pape cuvée de Mon Aieul character that reminded me of B tard-Montrachet. Full (85% Grenache and equal parts Syrah, Mourv dre, and and rich, with flavors of musky yellow plum and ripe Cinsault) tips the scales at a prodigious 15.8% alcohol. pear accented by crisp mineral notes."(93pts IWC) Half of the wine is aged in neutral wood foudres and the 1 bottle per lot $150-200 other half in tank prior to being bottled unfined and unfiltered. The sources for Mon Aieul are three vineyard parcels with vines averaging between 75 and 4258 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2000 87 years of age. The 2001 is much more structured and 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) backward than the 2000, 1999, or 1998."(97pts) "...is a gorgeous, seductive wine that floats on the 2 bottles per lot $160-220 palate with remarkable grace. Toasty aromas meld into freshly cut flowers, apricots and pears, with sweet notes of mint and licorice that linger on the long finish. This 4252 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 perfumed, inviting Dom Pérignon is elegance cuvée de Mon Aieul, P. Usseglio personified, and in this vintage the wine fully merits its lofty reputation."(94pts) (Wines Located in New York) "Has a dense purple color as well as a glorious nose of 1 bottle per lot $100-130 blackberries, licorice, smoke, and some roasted meats and dried herbs. Amazingly opulent, even voluptuous, 4259 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2002 with extraordinary purity, a huge tactile impression on the palate, but not heavy by any means, this is a 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) stunning Châteauneuf-du-Pape from ancient vines made "...is at first intensely floral, with perfumed jasmine that with 95% Grenache and the rest Cinsault and Syrah. dominates the bouquet. With time in the glass the wine Production is about 8,000 bottles, and the wine is gains richness as the flavors turn decidedly riper and bottled after spending its entire life in epoxy-lined tanks, almost tropical. Apricots, passion fruit and peaches so what one gets is the essence of the three separate emerge from this flashy, opulent Dom Pérignon."(96pts) terroirs it comes from Les Serres, Guigasse, and La 1 bottle per lot $130-200 Crau."(97pts)

5 bottles per lot $300-400 4260 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2000 Rose 4253 Billecart Salmon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1997 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) cuvée Elisabeth Salmon "...is a flashy, ripe Champagne that screams Pinot to a (Wines Located in New York) degree I have never encountered in another vintage of this wine. A dark, intense color leads to a 1 bottle per lot $140-180 Chambollelike nose followed by endless red berries, (Wines Located in New York) flowers and spices, all backed up with plenty of muscle, "...boasts an opaque purple color as well as intense richness and density."(96pts) aromas of pepper, black cherries, blackberries, asphalt, 1 bottle per lot $320-450 and truffles. Extremely full-bodied, with lavish concentration, great stuffing, and well-concealed alcohol (15.5%)..."(95pts) 4261 Louis Roederer Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1997 Cristal 1 bottle per lot $60-80 (Wines Located in New York) "Honey, vanilla, exotic fruit and cakes sound so trivial 4269 Barbaresco - Vintage 2004 for a wine with this complexity and elegance - so let's Rabaja, B. Giacosa just enjoy this delicious tidbit without analyzing its (Wines Located in New York) beauty to death..."(95pts RJ) "...is off the charts. It boasts phenomenal richness and 1 bottle per lot $200-280 complexity in its dark, brooding aromatics and powerful structure, with suggestions of roses, tar, menthol, coffee beans and baking spices that emerge from the glass in 4262 Riesling Eiswein - Vintage 2001 an endless display of elegance married to sheer Hochheimer Kirchenstuck, F. Kunstler force."(97pts) 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $450-600 3 half-bottles per lot $180-240 4270 Amarone - Vintage 2001 4263 Welschriesling Trockenbeerenauslese - Vintage 1999 TB, Bussola #6, Grande cuvée, Nouvelle Vague, A. Kracher lscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $50-65 1 half-bottle per lot $50-70 4271 Amarone - Vintage 2001 PARCEL LOTS 4264-4265 Dal Forno (Wines Located in New York) 4264 Welschriesling Trockenbeerenauslese - Vintage 1999 "The 2001 Amarone is on another level entirely. It ZDS, #8, A. Kracher exudes notable warmth and ripeness, with profound (Wines Located in New York) layers of Venezuelan bitter chocolate, herbs, licorice, smoke, dark fruit and toasted oak. Made in an explosive 3 half-bottles per lot $150-200 style, this palate-staining Amarone possesses remarkable detail and nuance for such a big wine. It 4265 3 half-bottles per lot $150-200 has been phenomenal on the two occasions I have tasted it so far."(97pts) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $700-950 4266 Riesling Eiswein - Vintage 2001 4272 Amarone - Vintage 2004 Hochheimer Holle, F. Kunstler Dal Forno 6lscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 4 half-bottles per lot $200-280 2 bottles per lot $500-650 4267 Amarone - Vintage 1996 4273 Recioto della Valpolicella - Vintage 1993 Allegrini G. Quintarelli (Wines Located in New York) "Very impressive, an unquestionably fine dry red. The lscl (Wines Located in New York) outstanding, dark purple-colored 1996 Amarone offers 1 bottle per lot $200-260 a knock-out nose of wood charcoal intermixed with black truffles, melted asphalt, blackberries, and roast beef. Amazingly rich and full-bodied, but not heavy, this 4274 Bryant Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2010 chewy, thick, exceptionally pure, harmonious offering (Wines Located in New York) should drink well for 10-15+ years."(95pts) "Teasing the taster with a possible three-digit perfection 1 bottle per lot $50-70 is the 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon Pritchard Hill. This beauty shows lots of creme de cassis, blueberry liqueur, spring flower and forest floor notes in an opulent, full- 4268 Amarone - Vintage 1998 bodied, powerful, dense, rich style buttressed by Allegrini significant ripe tannins and decent acidity. Again, the striking purity and singular character of this Bryant Cabernet Sauvignon oozes potential as well as that boasts layers of fruit. Admirable purity, fine pedigree. This spectacular, young Cabernet should turn underlying acidity, and considerable sweet, ripe tannin out to be one of the all-time great Bryant Cabernet make this another compelling effort."(94-97pts) Sauvignons, rivaling their 1997, but slightly more 3 bottles per lot $380-500 structured."(99pts) 3 bottles per lot $900-1200 4280 Rudd Estate Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 Oakville 4275 Futo Red - Vintage 2010 (Wines Located in New York) 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "Intensely mineral and pointed, the 2010 is endowed 1 bottle per lot $50-70 with stunning minerality, energy and tension. This is a huge wine with little of the early appeal of many other 4281 Rudd Estate Red - Vintage 2001 vintages."(97+pts) Oakville 3 bottles per lot $600-800 2ltl, 1lll (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $130-180 4276 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 1996 The Maiden 4282 1 bottle per lot $65-90 1lbsl, 1lwisl, 1ltl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The 1996 Maiden was performing even better this year. The dark saturated plum/purple color is followed by aromas of prunes, coffee, black fruits, and espresso 4283 Rudd Estate Red - Vintage 2003 beans. With an opulent personality, low acidity and a Oakville plush texture, it is a sexy, well-endowed wine. (Wines Located in New York) Anticipated maturity: now-2015. Tel. (707) 944-1441; Fax (707) 944-1444"(91pts) 2 bottles per lot $60-80 4 bottles per lot $400-600 4284 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2009 4277 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 1997 Beckstoffer To-Kalon Vineyard (Wines Located in (1) The Maiden New York) (95pts) 1lbsl (Wines Located in New York) CCS (Wines Located in New York) (96+pts) (1) "Readers should not overlook the dense purple-colored 1997 Maiden, a creamy-textured, full-bodied, RBS 1x3 bottle custom owc (Wines Located in New (1) unctuously thick, rich wine. Jammy cassis, new oak, York) (95pts smoke, and espresso notes explode from the glass of this blockbuster."(94pts) Above 3 bottles per lot $1000-1400 2 bottles per lot $300-400 PARCEL LOTS 4285-4286

4278 Quintessa - Vintage 1994 4285 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2012 (Wines Located in New York) CCS 1x4 bottle custom owc (Wines Located in New (1) "Rich, supple and forward, this drinks well now but is worthy of cellaring. The core of currant, anise, cedar, York) (100pts) vanilla and spice flavors are smooth and polished, as LPV (Wines Located in New York) (94pts) (1) are the tannins."(91pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $100-130 RBS (Wines Located in New York) (98pts) (2) Above 4 bottles per lot $1100-1600 4279 Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1992 Monte Bello 4286 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2012 (Wines Located in New York) CCS 1x4 bottle custom owc (Wines Located in New (1) "When I tasted this wine early in its life I felt it had York) (100pts) outstanding potential. With another year of cellaring it LPV (Wines Located in New York) (94pts) (1) has gained considerable weight. It now looks to be one of the greatest examples of Monte Bello Cabernet Sauvignon Ridge has produced. Only 40% of the crop RBS (Wines Located in New York) (98pts) (2) made it into the final blend, which consists of 75% Above 4 bottles per lot $1100-1600 Cabernet Sauvignon, 11% Merlot, 10% Petit Verdot, and 4% Cabernet Franc. The wine offers a black/purple color, a profound nose of minerals, cassis, licorice, and 4287 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2010 spices, spectacular richness, and a great mid-palate RBS 1x2 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) and honeysuckle along with medium to full body and a "Super-ripe plums, cassis, mint, mocha and violets pure, nicely textured, long finish."(90pts) caress the palate as the 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon RBS 6 bottles per lot $300-400 vineyard opens up in the glass. The RBS stands out for its gorgeous inner perfume, sweetness and plushness. Layers of fruit build effortlessly as this gracious, highly 4292 Kistler Chardonnay expressive wine flows through to its plush, generous Vine Hill finish. The minerality of the vintage comes alive on the - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New (1) vibrant, beautifully delineated finish laced with sensual York) (90pts JK) crushed flower overtones. This is another striking wine. "(97pts) - Vintage 2001 4lbsl, 2lscl (Wines Located (4) 2 bottles per lot $650-850 in New York) (95pts) Above 5 bottles per lot $160-200 4288 Sloan Red - Vintage 2006 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 4293 Clarendon Hills Shiraz - Vintage 1997 "The wine's dense ruby/purple color is followed by Astralis notes of white chocolate, burning embers, creme de (Wines Located in New York) cassis, coffee, and scorched earth (think Haut-Brion or "The essence of vineyard and the varietal, the 1997 La Mission Haut-Brion). It possesses terrific structure, Astralis has a saturated purple color and is just melted, well-integrated tannins, full body, and is beginning to show more nuances, such as the tell-tale already bursting with complexity. A great success, it is Syrah characteristics of pepper, melted asphalt as well one of the vintage's most thrilling wines."(98+pts) as a wealth of blackberry and Crème de cassis fruit. The 3 bottles per lot $800-1100 new oak seems to have been sucked up completely, and the wine shows softness and evolution. Nevertheless, it is still a very youthful, backward, spectacular wine that 4289 Sloan Red - Vintage 2007 has surreal levels of richness and potential 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) complexity."(98pts) "A world-class, perfumed nose of charcoal, espresso 3 bottles per lot $320-450 roast, white chocolate, black currants, sweet plums, Asian soy and a Grave-like scorched earth aroma soars from the glass of this dense purple-colored wine. Full- 4294 Elderton Shiraz - Vintage 2004 bodied and seamlessly constructed with a Command multidimensional mouthfeel as well as a phenomenal 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) finish, this 2007 carries considerable tannin, but at present it is concealed by the wine's luxurious levels of 6 bottles per lot $260-350 fruit, glycerin and intensity."(100pts) 3 bottles per lot $1600-2200 4295 Greenock Creek Shiraz - Vintage 2001 Apricot Block 4290 Bacio Divino - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...represents a spectacular example of Barossa Shiraz. "The second awesome release from this tiny winery Made from 10-year-old vines cropped at 1-1.5 tons per dedicated to producing intriguing wines, the 1995 Bacio acre, it is a dense, full-bodied Shiraz possessing Divino (a blend of 66% Cabernet Sauvignon, 22% fabulous intensity, great purity, and a multi-tiered, Sangiovese, and 12% Petit Sirah) is a formidable wine skyscraper-like mid-palate."(99pts) of exceptional richness, layers of flavor, and a multi- 2 bottles per lot $240-350 dimensional personality. The color is a deep saturated ruby/purple. The nose offers up juicy/jammy strawberry, black currant, and blackberry notes wrapped with 4296 Torbreck Shiraz - Vintage 1999 subtle toasty oak. Full-bodied, with outstanding Run Rig ripeness and purity, a silky texture, and an explosive (Wines Located in New York) finish, this is a sumptuous example of what can be done "...is a structured, muscular effort with phenomenal with three grapes rarely blended together in such density, dry vintage Port-like concentration, and proportions."(94pts) magnificent notes of smoke, blackberries, cassis, 3 bottles per lot $90-120 leather, and coffee. A hint of Viognier's sweet marmalade character comes through as the wine sits in the glass."(97pts) 4291 Kistler Chardonnay - Vintage 2001 McCrea Vineyard 2 bottles per lot $180-240 6lbsl, 2nl, 1tl (Wines Located in New York) "The light gold-colored 2001 Chardonnay McCrea 4297 Torbreck Shiraz - Vintage 2001 Vineyard offers a perfumed nose of buttered popcorn Run Rig (Wines Located in New York) 4305 Guidalberto - Vintage 2007 "Constantly flirting with perfection, the 2001 Run Rig is Tenuta San Guido a worthy successor to the blockbuster, surreal 1998. A (Wines Located in New York) blend of 97% Shiraz and 3% Viognier, this is Torbreck's flagship offering. Sadly, there are only 1,500 cases 2 bottles per lot $140-180 produced. Sourced from old vines, some close to 140 years of age, it is fashioned from four sectors of 4306 Le Serre Nuove - Vintage 2005 Barossa Marananga, Koonunga Hill, Moppa, and Greenock. It spends 30 months in 60% new French oak Tenuta dell' Ornellaia before being bottled without fining or filtration. The (Wines Located in New York) powerful, full-bodied 2001 exhibits aromas of creme de 11 bottles per lot $350-500 cassis, blackberry liqueur, ink, espresso, graphite, and apricot marmalade. The impression on the palate is one of marvelous richness, expansive texture, a multi- 4307 Le Serre Nuove - Vintage 2006 layered skyscraper soaring across the palate with no Tenuta dell' Ornellaia heaviness. It is a tour de force in winemaking,..."(99pts) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 ______1 bottle per lot $30-50

4298 Château Moulin Riche - Vintage 2000 4308 Sassicaia - Vintage 2008 St. Julien Tenuta San Guido (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...is a rich, deep wine imbued with notable class in its 4 bottles per lot $120-160 black cherries, plums, grilled herbs, minerals and smoke. The 2008 is a decidedly buttoned-up, firm 4299 Château Moulin Rouge - Vintage 2000 Sassicaia that is currently holding back much of its (Wines Located in New York) potential, unlike the 2006 and 2007, both of which were far more obvious wines."(96pts) 2 bottles per lot $60-80 1 bottle per lot $180-240 ______4300 Château Moulin St. Georges - Vintage 2005 St. Emilion 4309 Château Leoville Poyferre (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1987 St. Julien vhs, bsl, nl (Wines (1) 2 bottles per lot $80-110 Located in New York)

4301 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2003 Château Pichon Lalande Talenti - Vintage 1987 Pauillac lbsl (Wines Located in (1) (Wines Located in New York) New York) 3 bottles per lot $120-160 Clos des Jacobins - Vintage 1987 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (1) 4302 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2003 New York) Tenuta Nuova, Casanova di Neri (Wines Located in New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $100-140 (92pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $100-140 4310 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1971 (Wines Located in New York) 4303 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2004 "All the older vintages of Dom Pérignon develop a clear tone of roasted coffee beans. The '71 is full of such Talenti aromas. The taste is slightly thinner than the '73 and (Wines Located in New York) without its walnut tones, but the aftertaste is actually 1 bottle per lot $60-80 longer. Better and more impressive almost every time I taste it."(96pts RJ) 1 bottle per lot $500-700 4304 Guidalberto - Vintage 2006 Tenuta San Guido 4311 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1982 1lwrl, 1lwisl (Wines Located in New York) ltl (Wines Located in New York) 7 bottles per lot $220-300 (96pts) 1 bottle per lot $420-600 1x6 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $600-800 4312 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1985 (Wines Located in New York) 4322 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2002 1 bottle per lot $300-400 Andy Warhol Label 3x1 bottle ogb's (Wines Located in New York) 4313 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1990 3 bottles per lot $480-650 Oenotheque disgorged in 2003 (Wines Located in New York) 4323 J.L. Vergnon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2006 "It seems obvious that the quality of the 1990 Confidence Champagne vintage is going to be remarkable, and the world-wide demand will be unprecedented."(96pts) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $1100-1500 2 bottles per lot $100-140

4314 Guado Al Tasso - Vintage 1999 4324 Pol Roger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2000 Antinori cuvée Sir Winston Churchill (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $60-80 1 bottle per lot $120-160

PARCEL LOTS 4315-4317 4325 Pol Roger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2002 Extra cuvée de Reserve 4315 Barolo - Vintage 2007 2scc (Wines Located in New York) Reversanti "White flowers, lemon, slate and chamomile are some of the notes that burst from the glass in Pol Roger's 2002 (Wines Located in New York) Brut Blanc de Blancs Extra cuvée de Reserve. A bright, 12 bottles per lot $240-320 tightly coiled wine, the 2002 comes across as quite fresh and vibrant, especially within the context of the year. Sweet floral and minty notes run through the precise, 4316 12 bottles per lot $240-320 crystalline finish."(94pts) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $450-600

4317 12 bottles per lot $240-320 PARCEL LOTS 4326-4327 (Wines Located in New York) ______4326 Ulysse Collin Vintage Champagne - Vintage NV 4318 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2012 Les Maillons Deus Ex Machina, Clos St. Jean degorgee March 5th 2011 (Wines Located in New (Wines Located in New York) York) 3 bottles per lot $350-500 1 bottle per lot $60-80

4319 Chartogne Taillet Champagne - Vintage NV 4327 1 bottle per lot $60-80 Heurtebise degorgee March 7th 2013 (Wines 1tl, degorgement September 2013 (Wines Located Located in New York) in New York) PARCEL LOTS 4328-4329 3 bottles per lot $100-140

4328 Ulysse Collin Vintage Champagne - Vintage NV 4320 Chartogne Taillet Vintage Champagne - Vintage Les Perrières 2006 Fiacre degorgee March 5th 2011 (Wines Located in New degorgement August 2012 (Wines Located in New York) York) 1 bottle per lot $60-80 3 bottles per lot $90-120 4329 1 bottle per lot $60-80 4321 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2004 degorgee July 3rd 2013 (Wines Located in New York) 4337 Barolo - Vintage 2007 Ciabot Mentin, Clerico PARCEL LOTS 4330-4331 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $200-300 4330 Ulysse Collin Vintage Champagne - Vintage NV Les Roises 4338 Barolo - Vintage 2004 degorgee March 10th 2012 (Wines Located in Percristina, Clerico New York) 2lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $60-80 2 bottles per lot $110-160

4331 1 bottle per lot $60-80 4339 Barolo - Vintage 2006 degorgee July 3rd 2013 (Wines Casa Mate Ginestra, E. Grasso Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 magnum per lot $160-220 4332 Barolo - Vintage 2001 Cicala, A. Conterno 4340 Barolo - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) Casa Mate Ginestra, E. Grasso "...suggests new oak and spices on the nose, then opens to reveal a very complete and multi-dimensional wine (Wines Located in New York) that offers sensations of ripe dark cherries, minerals, 3 bottles per lot $150-200 menthol, tar, licorice and violets wrapped around a structured, masculine frame."(93pts) 4341 Barolo - Vintage 2010 1 magnum per lot $240-320 Casa Mate Ginestra, E. Grasso 2x1 magnum owc's (Wines Located in New York) 4333 Barolo - Vintage 2009 "The 2010 Barolo Ginestra Casa Mate is a more B. Mascarello muscular and layered expression with a softer quality of (Wines Located in New York) fruit and a good amount of power and muscle at the back. Its aromatic delivery is constant and steady with 1 bottle per lot $70-90 an ever-changing array of red fruit, dark spice, cola and anisette. The tannins are particularly well defined 4334 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2006 and silky."(95pts) Tenuta Nuova, Casanova di Neri 2 magnums per lot $300-400 (Wines Located in New York) "The 2006 Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Nuova is an 4342 Barolo - Vintage 2010 explosive, heady wine endowed with considerable Gavarini Vigna Chiniera, E. Grasso richness in its dark wild cherries, licorice, tobacco, herbs and cedar. This generous, exuberant Brunello 2x1 magnum owc's (Wines Located in New York) shows awesome depth and richness in a style that "The 2010 Barolo Gavarini Chiniera is an amazing captures the essence of the warmth of the southern wine born 430 meters above sea level from white reaches of Montalcino. The Tenuta Nuova dazzles with limestone and sandy soils. The elegance expressed by its stunning depth, textural polish and captivating, the wine is unforgettable. It opens to a pretty garnet sensual personality. A round, inviting finish has the last color with ethereal tones of licorice and balsam herb say in this majestic Brunello. The 2006 is easily the best with sharp, delineated contours. This vineyard is vintage I have tasted of the Tenuta Nuova. "(95pts) usually harvested later than the others, so the growing cycle is extra long and steady. The wine is silky, 1 magnum per lot $150-200 finessed and profound."(98pts) 2 magnums per lot $300-400 4335 Corbaia - Vintage 2008 Castello di Bossi 4343 Barolo - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) Runcot, Riserva, E. Grasso 6 bottles per lot $170-220 (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $150-200 4336 Barolo - Vintage 2008 Bricotto Bussia, Clerico 4344 Barolo - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) Sori Ginestra, Fantino-Conterno 1 magnum per lot $100-140 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $150-200 patience will be required."(95pts) 1 magnum per lot $150-200 4345 Barolo - Vintage 2007 Sori Ginestra, Fantino-Conterno 4353 Barolo - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) Bric del Fiasc, P. Scavino 1 bottle per lot $50-65 (Wines Located in New York) "...is another awesome wine. Initially linear on entry, it explodes on the palate with a compelling array of dark 4346 Barolo - Vintage 2006 fruit, smoke, tar, licorice, new leather, plums and Cascina Francia, G. Conterno baking spices. Although Bric del Fiasc is typically a (Wines Located in New York) wine that relies on power, the 2004 is notably refined and elegant, with sweet silky tannins that support the 1 bottle per lot $75-100 fruit from start to finish."(96pts) 1 magnum per lot $180-240 4347 Barolo - Vintage 2007 Monprivato, G. Mascarello 4354 Barolo - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) Cannubi, P. Scavino "...is stunningly beautiful. Monprivato is seldom this rich when it is young. It is most often intensely (Wines Located in New York) aromatic, mid-weight and frequently out of balance, 6 bottles per lot $400-550 especially right after bottling. The 2007 is none of those things. It is a rich, dramatic wine endowed with tons of fruit and a sweeping, enveloping personality."(97pts) 4355 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2007 Uccelliera 2 magnums per lot $450-600 (Wines Located in New York)

4348 Barolo - Vintage 2001 1 bottle per lot $50-70 Le Vigne, L. Sandrone (Wines Located in New York) 4356 Barolo - Vintage 2004 Lazzarito, Vietti 1 bottle per lot $75-100 (Wines Located in New York)

4349 Barolo - Vintage 2010 3 bottles per lot $220-300 Le Vigne, L. Sandrone (Wines Located in New York) 4357 Barolo - Vintage 2008 Lazzarito, Vietti 6 bottles per lot $700-900 2nl (Wines Located in New York)

4350 Paleo - Vintage 2010 4 bottles per lot $170-220 Le Macchiole (Wines Located in New York) 4358 Barolo - Vintage 2008 Rocche, Vietti 9 bottles per lot $450-600 6lbsl, 3nl (Wines Located in New York)

4351 Eneo - Vintage 2010 6 bottles per lot $500-700 Montepeloso (Wines Located in New York) 4359 Barolo - Vintage 2010 Rocche di Castiglione, Vietti 4 bottles per lot $100-140 (Wines Located in New York)

4352 Barolo - Vintage 2001 6 bottles per lot $600-800 Bric del Fiasc, P. Scavino (Wines Located in New York) 4360 Ribera del Duero - Vintage 2003 "Is a massive and strapping Barolo with an exciting Seleccion de Vinedos de la Familia, Bodegas Felix nose of sweet ripe fruit, licorice, tar and mint. This Callejo deeply colored, masculine, full-bodied Barolo is packed (Wines Located in New York) with layers of dense backward dark fruit, prune, plum and macerated cherry flavors, with a distinctly 1 magnum per lot $120-160 mentholated note that gives it a sense of freshness and balance. It finishes with huge tannins which suggest 4361 Rioja - Vintage 2001 Imperial, Gran Reserva, CVNE 4371 Lindstrom Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2010 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $90-120 3 bottles per lot $180-240

4362 Rioja - Vintage 2005 4372 Philip Togni Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2009 Imperial, Gran Reserva, CVNE (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $130-180 3 bottles per lot $90-120 4373 Copain Syrah - Vintage 2007 4363 Rioja - Vintage 1998 Eaglepoint Ranch Gran Reserva '904', La Rioja Alta (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $30-40 1 bottle per lot $30-40 4374 Saxum Red - Vintage 2011 4364 Rioja - Vintage 2001 Heartstone Vineyard Gran Reserva '904', La Rioja Alta (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $120-160 8 bottles per lot $280-400 4375 Saxum Red - Vintage 2011 4365 Rioja - Vintage 2004 James Berry Vineyard Gran Reserva Especial, Castillo Ygay, Marques de (Wines Located in New York) Murrieta (94-96pts) 4 bottles per lot $500-700 (Wines Located in New York)

3 bottles per lot $140-190 4376 Saxum Red - Vintage 2011 Paderewski Vineyard 4366 Rioja - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) Gran Reserva Especial, Castillo Ygay, Marques de Murrieta 1 bottle per lot $110-150

(Wines Located in New York) 4377 Saxum Red - Vintage 2011 4 bottles per lot $160-200 Terry Hoage Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 4367 Priorat - Vintage 2007 1 bottle per lot $100-140 Costers de Vinyes Velles, Mas Doix (Wines Located in New York) 4378 Saxum Syrah - Vintage 2011 2 bottles per lot $100-130 Broken Stones (Wines Located in New York) 4368 Gemstone Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 4 bottles per lot $450-600 Facets (Wines Located in New York) 4379 Skipstone Red - Vintage 2005 1 bottle per lot $30-40 Oliver's Blend (Wines Located in New York) 4369 Lindstrom Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 8 bottles per lot $420-600 (Wines Located in New York) (92pts) 4380 Skipstone Red - Vintage 2009 1 bottle per lot $50-65 Oliver's Blend (Wines Located in New York) 4370 Lindstrom Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2009 2 bottles per lot $100-130 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $150-200 4381 Walter Hansel Chardonnay - Vintage 2011 The North Slope Beautifully-textured as well as expansive, this may be the most developed and forward Pavie made by Perse (Wines Located in New York) since his acquisition of the property in 1998."(95+pts) 6 bottles per lot $120-160 ______1 bottle per lot $150-200

4382 Marcassin Chardonnay - Vintage 2005 4387 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1999 Marcassin Vineyard Il Greppone Mazzi Riserva, Ruffino (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "White flowers, white currants, crushed rock, quince, 2 bottles per lot $40-60 lemon butter, nectarine are all present in this wine, which has exceptional minerality and always reminds me of a grand cru white Burgundy such as Chevalier- 4388 Hundred Acre Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 Montrachet or a Coche-Dury Mersault Perrières Deep Time because of its liquid stone and floral notes. The wine 1x2 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) has a gorgeous backbone of acidity to buttress the (98pts) concentrated, rich flavors."(99pts) 2 bottles per lot $600-800 2 bottles per lot $600-800 ______4389 Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 4383 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 2002 1x3 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac "...displays a silky, velvety personality. Although not as (Wines Located in New York) nuanced or complex as the 2005, it is a brilliant wine offering generous levels of black currant fruit "Bubbling over with crushed berries, currants and intermixed with graphite, scorched earth, and a hint of spices, with tobacco notes. Beautiful. Full-bodied, with underlying smoke. It will be surprisingly delicious early gorgeously velvety tannins and a long finish of pretty in its life but capable of lasting two-plus decades. fruit. This is a racy yet elegant Lafite."(95pts WS) "(94+pts) 1 bottle per lot $450-600 3 bottles per lot $900-1200

4384 Château Pavie - Vintage 1999 4390 Alban Vineyards Syrah - Vintage 2006 St. Emilion Reva Estate (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...a candidate for "wine of the vintage". It boasts an "...coming from parcels of dark, volcanic soil, has off- opaque ruby/purple color in addition to gorgeous the-chart richness and intensity. This thick, opaque- aromas of crushed minerals, smoke, licorice, cherry purple colored wine offers up notes of scorched earth, liqueur, and black currants exceptionally pure and ground pepper, and blackberry liqueur intermixed with multilayered, with stunning texture and overall cassis, licorice, camphor, and tar. The wine is balance."(95pts) spectacular in every sense."(100pts) 1 bottle per lot $160-220 3 bottles per lot $450-600 ______4385 Château Pavie - Vintage 2003 St. Emilion 4391 Château Figeac - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) St. Emilion "Its dense plum/purple color is accompanied by an (Wines Located in New York) extraordinary perfume of charcoal, Crème de cassis, "Wild, expressive aromas of black raspberry, cedar, melted licorice, espresso roast, and blackberries. The lead pencil, mocha, coffee and animal fur. Fat, silky and wine, which hits the palate with a dramatic minerality, lush yet dry; a thick, round Figeac with impressive comes across like a hypothetical blend of limestone volume. Even the merlot in 2000 showed solid structure. liqueur intermixed with black and red fruits."(98pts) Like the 2001, this shows an intriguing burnt note. 1 bottle per lot $200-280 Finishes with big but suave tannins and lingering notes of cherry, chocolate and black olive."(91pts IWC)

4386 Château Pavie - Vintage 2004 4 bottles per lot $450-600 St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) 4392 Château Lynch Bages - Vintage 2000 "...exhibits an inky/ruby/purple color, a surprisingly Pauillac soft, forward style for this hallowed terroir, full-bodied, (Wines Located in New York) and concentrated creme de cassis flavors intermixed "This is a superstructured wine with loads of plum, with cherries, truffles, and subtle smoky wood notes. blackberry and licorice. Full-bodied, with chewy tannins and a long finish. Gorgeous. Tight. Needs 4400 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2011 time."(96pts WS) Les Amoureuses, Bertheau 4 bottles per lot $650-900 (Wines Located in New York) "A highly perfumed mix of red currant, spice and blue 4393 Le Petit Cheval - Vintage 2000 pinot fruit gives way to intensely mineral-driven, St. Emilion delicious, round and supple medium weight flavors that possess moderately firm tannins and excellent balance (Wines Located in New York) on the solidly lasting finish."(91pts BH) "...this exceptional effort offers sweet, concentrated, plush flavors, wonderful opulence, and lovely density. 3 bottles per lot $450-600 This beauty will be drinkable upon release, and will last for 12-15 years. Believe it or not, the 2000 Le Petit 4401 Latricieres Chambertin - Vintage 2010 Cheval is better than some vintages of Cheval Blanc C. Giroud have been over the last two decades."(90pts) (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $450-600 3 bottles per lot $350-500 4394 Ferrari Carano Reserve Red - Vintage 1997 4402 Savigny les Beaune - Vintage 2010 (Wines Located in New York) Les Peuillets, C. Giroud 4 bottles per lot $100-140 (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $180-240 4395 Niebaum Coppola Red - Vintage 1996 Rubicon 4403 Corton - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) Les Bressandes, Chandon de Briailles 2 bottles per lot $80-120 (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $350-500 4396 Robert Mondavi Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) 4404 Pernand Vergelesses - Vintage 2007 "...a rich, dark ruby/purple-colored wine with very Ile des Vergelesses, Chandon de Briailles complex aromatics, medium to full body, tight structure (Wines Located in New York) and plenty of tannin in the finish."(92pts) 8 bottles per lot $240-320 5 bottles per lot $350-450 4405 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2011 4397 Robert Mondavi Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - J. Roty Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $160-220 1 bottle per lot $40-60 ______4406 Marsannay - Vintage 2010 4398 Château Bellevue - Vintage 2005 cuvée de Clos de Jeu, J. Roty St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $300-400 "The 2005, a blend of 80% Merlot and 20% Cabernet Franc, is a wine for true connoisseurs. It possesses a dense purple color to the rim along with a huge perfume 4407 Meursault - Vintage 2010 of camphor, charcoal, graphite, blackberries, cassis, Les Tessons, Fichet raspberries, and a liqueur of rocks-like (Wines Located in New York) component."(94+pts) 6 bottles per lot $200-280 1 bottle per lot $50-70

4408 Meursault - Vintage 2000 4399 Beaune Rouge - Vintage 2010 Perrières, P. Matrot Teurons, A. Morot (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The class of this group today with its racy, stylish, 6 bottles per lot $240-320 wonderfully subtle aromas of liquid rock, fresh citrus and green apple that combine seamlessly with medium weight, chiseled, taut flavors that also burst with minerality. This is almost painfully intense and quite - Vintage 2012 Descendientes de Jose Palacios (5) linear today. Solid potential here that will require (Wines Located in New York) several years of bottle age to realize."(91pts BH) Above 6 bottles per lot $100-140 5 bottles per lot $320-420

4418 Corison Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 4409 Muscadet Sevre et Maine - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) Sur Lie, Château de Chasseloir (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $100-140 14 bottles per lot $70-80 4419 Littorai Pinot Noir - Vintage 2012 Platt Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (1) 4410 Chinon - Vintage 2010 Domaine de Pallus Savoy Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $60-80 11 bottles per lot $55-75

4420 Columbia Crest Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - 4411 Vouvray - Vintage 1990 Vintage 2007 Clos Baudoin, Prince Poniatowski (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $45-60 5 bottles per lot $100-140 4421 Tokaji - Vintage 2012 4412 Riesling Spatlese - Vintage 2011 Furmint Sec, Kiralyudvar Molitor (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $180-240 5 bottles per lot $80-110 ______

4413 Barolo - Vintage 2009 4422 Château La Mondotte - Vintage 1999 B. Mascarello St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The 1999 is a blockbuster offering. While it is 12 bottles per lot $900-1200 Bordeaux's most concentrated effort, readers should not think it is an overly extracted aberration that is all 4414 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2006 muscle, flesh, extract, and new wood. This wine possesses elegance, complexity, and, with time, a Poggio Al Vento Riserva, Col d'Orcia distinctive terroir character will emerge. The saturated (Wines Located in New York) black/blue/purple-colored 1999 exhibits unreal levels of 6 bottles per lot $300-400 concentration, high tannin, astonishing flavor extraction, and uncanny balance and precision for a wine of such proportions. This full-bodied, super- 4415 Collezione de Marchi Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage concentrated St.-Emilion offers plenty of prune, black 1998 cherry, cassis, and assorted berry flavors, all crammed Isole e Olena into a thick, structured, powerful format."(94pts) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 11 bottles per lot $320-420 4423 Château Leoville Barton - Vintage 2005 4416 Marsala - Vintage 2010 St. Julien Les Ouzeloy, J. Roty (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Delivers breathtaking aromas of blackberry, currant, licorice and flowers. Full-bodied, with a solid core of 12 bottles per lot $350-500 fruit and supersilky tannins. Dark chocolate, currant, berry and licorice follow through. This is racy and 4417 Barolo beautiful."(96pts WS) - Vintage 2007 Enrico, Serafino (Wines (1) 1 bottle per lot $85-110 Located in New York) 4424 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1995 Petalos de Bierzo St. Julien 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "Deep purple to the rim with a glorious nose of "Exceptionally ripe cassis fruit, the judicious use of scorched earth, black currant jam, smoke, licorice, and toasty new oak, and a thrilling mineral character roasted meats, it is full-bodied, incredibly intertwined with the high quality of fruit routinely powerful..."(95pts) obtainedby Las Cases, make this a compelling effort 2 bottles per lot $160-220 The finish is incredibly long in this classic."(95pts) 2 bottles per lot $350-400 4431 1 bottle per lot $80-110 (Wines Located in New York) 4425 Château Lynch Bages - Vintage 2008 Pauillac 4432 Château Rauzan Segla - Vintage 1990 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Margaux "Medium to full-bodied with an opaque dense purple (Wines Located in New York) color, notes of flowers and cassis, a layered texture that "A complex nose of subtle menthol intermixed with builds incrementally in the mouth and tremendous black currants, cherries, spice box, cedar, and herbs purity and depth, it can be drunk now or cellared for emerges from this fully mature 1990. It is a fleshy, two decades or more."(93pts) round, generously endowed Margaux with silky tannins, 12 bottles per lot $1000-1400 low acidity, and beautiful purity."(94pts) 3 bottles per lot $380-500 4426 Château Malescot St. Exupery - Vintage 2008 Margaux 4433 Château Talbot - Vintage 1978 (Wines Located in New York) St. Julien 6 bottles per lot $200-300 2nl, 2stl, 2sdc, outstanding color (Wines Located in New York) 4427 Château Pichon Baron - Vintage 2003 2 bottles per lot $80-120 Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) 4434 Domaine de Chevalier - Vintage 1978 "Wow. This shows so much ripe fruit and berry Graves character with just the right hint of lead pencil and spice. Full-bodied and very chewy. Big and powerful. vhs, lstl, excellent color and condition (Wines Beautiful wine. Superb."(95pts WS) Located in New York) (90pts) 3 bottles per lot $300-400 1 bottle per lot $50-70 4428 Château Pichon Baron - Vintage 2004 Pauillac 4435 Vieux Château Certan - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) Pomerol "An undeniable star of the vintage, Pichon-Baron s (Wines Located in New York) 2004 boasts an inky/ruby/purple color to the rim as well "...boasts a dense ruby/purple color along with a big, as a big, sweet nose of melted licorice, chocolate, black sweet bouquet of black cherries, licorice, roasted herbs, currant jam, truffles, and charcoal embers. Soft tannin, smoke, and cassis. Elegant, medium to full-bodied, pure full body, and abundant opulence and flesh are atypical flavors reveal moderately high tannin, but superb for the vintage character, but this wine is concentration and richness."(93pts) loaded."(93pts) 2 bottles per lot $180-240 2 bottles per lot $180-240 4436 Volnay - Vintage 2003 4429 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 2001 Premier Cru, Coche-Dury Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $420-500 "Seepy, sappy, grapy style...cassis and nuttyness dominate...tannins firm yet a touch bitter - gets more tannic as it opens."(93+pts JK) 4437 Montrachet - Vintage 2006 1 bottle per lot $90-120 Marquis de Laguiche, J. Drouhin (Wines Located in New York) "As good and refined as several of the foregoing wines 4430 Château Pontet Canet - Vintage 2003 are, this is the clear class of the cellar with moderate Pauillac wood notes framing a fresh, intense and airy nose that 2lbsl (Wines Located in New York) sports impressive aromatic breadth while merging into exceptionally rich and intense full-bodied flavors that 4443 Dunn Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1987 possess seemingly buckets of dry extract which gives the Napa Valley finish a textured and naturally sweet character. A wine of power yet excellent energy and focus and this too is lscl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) both quite primary and youthfully austere at present. A "...reveals an opaque dark purple color, and a strong potentially great Drouhin Montrachet."(94-6pts BH) yet unevolved bouquet of cassis, minerals, and toasty oak."(91pts) 1 magnum per lot $600-800 1 bottle per lot $110-150 ______4438 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2001 Château de Beaucastel 4444 Arrowood Reserve spéciale Cabernet Sauvignon - (Wines Located in New York) Vintage 1997 "This inky/ruby/purple-colored cuvée offers a classic Beaucastel bouquet of new saddle leather, cigar smoke, 1lwrl (Wines Located in New York) roasted herbs, black truffles, underbrush, and "It sounds preposterous, but when I put my nose in the blackberry as well as cherry fruit. It is a superb, earthy 1997 Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve spéciale, it reminded expression of this Mourv dre-dominated cuvée."(96pts) me of the 1996 Latour. California Cabernets are bigger, 5 bottles per lot $350-450 weightier efforts than most Bordeaux, so the comparison ends with the aromatics."(97pts)

4439 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 12 bottles per lot $600-800 Château de Beaucastel (Wines Located in New York) 4445 Joseph Phelps Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1989 "...has turned out even better out of bottle than I Eisele Vineyard predicted. An inky/ruby/purple color is followed by a (Wines Located in New York) glorious nose of blue and black fruits, truffles, pen ink, 2 magnums per lot $200-280 licorice, and meat juices as well as glorious levels of acidity and sweet tannin, buttressing the fruit s fabulous freshness and vibrancy."(96pts) 4446 Joseph Phelps Winery - Vintage 1998 1 bottle per lot $70-90 Insignia (Wines Located in New York) 4440 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 "A dark, deliciously rich and complex youngster, brimming with layers of curant, blackberry, plum, cuvée Reservee, Domaine du Pegau mineral, spice, chocolate and cedar. Finishes with a (Wines Located in New York) gush of flavors, yet maintains its finesse and "...stands out as one of the all-time great wines made by grace."(93pts WS) Laurence Feraud and her father, Paul. I remember first 12 bottles per lot $1200-1600 tasting it from a large tank as it was still fermenting and it was already impressive! It is a full-bodied, powerful wine that must tip the scales at close to 15.5% natural 4447 Joseph Phelps Syrah alcohol. I don't think this big, chewy, voluptuously - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) textured wine will ever close down. Dark plum/garnet with the classic Provencal display of garrigue, lavender, pepper, kirsch and Asian plum sauce, this full- Joseph Phelps Chardonnay throttle wine has splendid concentration, silky tannins, - Vintage 1999 Ovation (Wines Located in New (1) and a very voluptuous texture."(98pts) York) 6 bottles per lot $480-650 Joseph Phelps Semillon 4441 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2005 - Vintage 1995 Delice du Semillion (Wines half-bottle cuvée Exceptionelle, Domaine du Vieux Lazaret (1) (1) (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) domaine de Pere Caboche la Mirande, Jean-Pierre (1) Above 1 half-bottle per lot $35-55 Boisson lscl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) and 2 bottles Above 2 bottles per lot $80-100 4448 Archery Summit Pinot Noir - Vintage 1997 4442 Barbaresco - Vintage 1997 Premier cuvée Rabaja, B. Giacosa 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $180-240 ______2 bottles per lot $240-320 4449 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1997 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Vendemmia, Altesino 6 bottles per lot $350-500 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 4458 Barolo - Vintage 1999 Vigneto Arborina, Corino 4450 Solengo - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) Argiano 3 bottles per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 4459 Barolo - Vintage 1998 Vigneto Rocche, Corino 4451 Barolo - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) Bricco Fiasco, Azelia (L. Scavino) 3 bottles per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $120-180 4460 Barolo - Vintage 2000 Vigneto Campe, Vursu, La Spinetta 4452 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) Casanova di Neri 3 bottles per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) (90pts) 4461 Barolo - Vintage 2001 3 bottles per lot $150-200 Vigneto Campe, Vursu, La Spinetta (Wines Located in New York) 4453 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1999 3 bottles per lot $200-280 Tenuta Nuova, Casanova di Neri (Wines Located in New York) 4462 Barolo - Vintage 1999 "Delivers a wonderful concentration of crushed Bussia Vigna Fiurin, Parusso blackberry, raisin, treacle tart and dark chocolate. Full- bodied, with big, velvety tannins and loads of ripe fruit. (Wines Located in New York) A Porty, powerful wine. Superb. "(96pts WS) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 3 bottles per lot $200-260 4463 Barbaresco - Vintage 2000 4454 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1999 Vigneto Brich Ronchi, R. Albino (Wines Located in (1) Poggio all'Oro, Castello Banfi New York) 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) Vigneto Loreto, R. Albino (Wines Located in New (2) 6 bottles per lot $350-500 York) Above 3 bottles per lot $110-140 4455 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1997 Poggio Alle Mura, Castello Banfi 4464 Barolo - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) Ciabot Manzoni, S. Grasso (Wines Located in New (3) "This balanced red is built for aging. Loads of York) strawberry, cherry and red licorice aromas. Full-bodied and very tannic, yet refined and polished, with a Giachini, S. Grasso (Wines Located in New York) (3) caressing texture. Long, long finish. A Above 6 bottles per lot $180-240 masterpiece."(96pts WS) 3 bottles per lot $220-300 PARCEL LOTS 4465-4466

4456 Barolo - Vintage 1999 4465 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2003 Sori Ginestra, Conterno-Fantino Siro Pacenti (Wines Located in New York) 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $220-300 6 bottles per lot $300-400

4457 Barolo - Vintage 2000 4466 6 bottles per lot $300-400 Vecchie Vigne, Corino 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $80-120 4467 Barbaresco - Vintage 2000 Curra, Sottimano 4477 Dominus - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $100-140 "A big, sweet nose of roasted coffee, Provencal herbs, black currants, cherry jam, plums, allspice, and forest floor is followed by a spicy, rich, full-bodied, fragrant, 4468 Barbaresco - Vintage 2000 intense wine. The tannins are sweet, but noticeable in Fausoni, Sottimano this beautifully complex, strikingly aromatic 1bsl (Wines Located in New York) 2003."(95pts) 3 bottles per lot $100-140 6 bottles per lot $600-800

4469 Barbaresco - Vintage 2000 4478 Far Niente Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 Pajore, Sottimano Oakville (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $100-140 3 bottles per lot $150-200

4470 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2001 4479 Far Niente Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 Riserva, Uccelliera Oakville (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $240-320 6 bottles per lot $300-400

4471 Clio - Vintage 2002 4480 Far Niente Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2003 Bodegas el Nido Oakville (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $90-120 6 bottles per lot $200-260

4472 Numanthia - Vintage 2004 4481 Far Niente Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2004 Termes, Numanthia Oakville (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $120-160 6 bottles per lot $240-320

4473 Cain Five - Vintage 2002 4482 Philip Togni Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The color is an inky/black, and the nose offers up 6 bottles per lot $400-600 spectacular aromas of melted licorice intermixed with Crème de cassis, acacia flowers, roasted meats, 4474 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 tapenade, and subtle pain grille. Opulent and Special Selection voluptuous, with huge body brilliantly balanced by sweet tannin and adequate acidity, this Cabernet 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) possesses impeccable equilibrium, admirable purity, "Firm, intense and well-structured, with a mix of spicy and a 50-second finish. It is one of Togni s great oak, red and black currant, mineral, sage and dusty Cabernet Sauvignons, of which there have been many berry. Turns elegant and refined, yet shows a sturdy over the last quarter of a century."(96pts) backbone on the finish."(94pts) 3 bottles per lot $320-450 6 bottles per lot $700-900

4483 Philip Togni Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2003 4475 Corison Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $220-300 3 bottles per lot $90-120

4484 Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - 4476 D.R. Stephens Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 Vintage 2001 Moose Valley Cask 23 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $350-480 1 half-bottle per lot $100-150

4485 Two Hands Shiraz - Vintage 2002 4496 1 half-bottle per lot $100-150 Bella's Garden (Wines Located in New York) 1x3 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $120-180 4497 1 half-bottle per lot $100-150 (Wines Located in New York) 4486 Two Hands Shiraz - Vintage 2002 Lily's Garden 4498 Carruades de Lafite - Vintage 2004 1x3 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac 3 bottles per lot $90-120 nl (Wines Located in New York) ______1 bottle per lot $200-300

4487 Blason de L'Evangile - Vintage 1997 4499 Château Barrail du Blanc - Vintage 2003 lbsl (Wines Located in New York) St. Emilion 1 bottle per lot $30-40 1ltl, 1lwrl, 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $60-80 PARCEL LOTS 4488-4491

4500 Château Chantalouette - Vintage 2003 4488 Blason de L'Evangile - Vintage 1998 5lscl (Wines Located in New York) 3stl (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $50-70 3 bottles per lot $160-200 PARCEL LOTS 4501-4503 4489 3 bottles per lot $160-200 3stl, 1nl (Wines Located in New 4501 Pensees de Lafleur - Vintage 2002 York) Pomerol 1scl (Wines Located in New York) 4490 3 bottles per lot $160-200 1 bottle per lot $65-90 3stl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 4502 1 bottle per lot $65-90 1scl, sdc (Wines Located in New 4491 3 bottles per lot $160-200 York) (Wines Located in New York)

4503 1 bottle per lot $65-90 4492 Blason de L'Evangile - Vintage 1999 1scl, sdc (Wines Located in New 2lscl, 1stl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) York) 3 bottles per lot $90-120 PARCEL LOTS 4504-4509 4493 Blason de L'Evangile - Vintage 2001 3lscl, 1wc (Wines Located in New York) 4504 Nicolas Feuillatte Champagne - Vintage 1998 3 bottles per lot $100-140 cuvée Palms d'Or (Wines Located in New York) 4494 Blason de L'Evangile - Vintage 2002 2 bottles per lot $150-200 4lscl, 1sdc (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $100-130 4505 2 bottles per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) PARCEL LOTS 4495-4497 4506 2 bottles per lot $150-200 4495 Carruades de Lafite - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac 4507 2 bottles per lot $150-200 4520 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1988 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Beautiful. Offers great toasty, earthy aromas, lively but 4508 2 bottles per lot $150-200 mellow fruit flavors and a lingering finish. Seems suave and sophisticated, even better than when reviewed (Wines Located in New York) earlier. Tempting now, but should improve. "(93pts WS) 1 bottle per lot $200-280 4509 2 bottles per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) 4521 Louis Roederer Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1995 Cristal PARCEL LOTS 4510-4512 (Wines Located in New York) "Perfectly balanced, pure-bred finesse on the palate... 4510 Pineau des Charentes Blanc - Vintage NV classic Cristal... and a fabulous finish..."(97pts RJ) Brillet 1 bottle per lot $260-350 (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $40-50 4522 Brewer-Clifton Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 Cargasacchi Vineyard 4511 2 bottles per lot $40-50 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $90-120

4512 2 bottles per lot $40-50 4523 Brewer-Clifton Pinot Noir (Wines Located in New York) Cargasacchi Vineyard - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 4513 1 bottle per lot $20-25 (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2008 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) York) PARCEL LOTS 4514-4516 Above 2 bottles per lot $75-110

4514 Catena Red - Vintage 2002 4524 Brewer-Clifton Pinot Noir Caro - Vintage 2005 Mount Carmel (Wines Located (2) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) in New York) 3 bottles per lot $70-90 Williams Selyem Pinot Noir 4515 3 bottles per lot $70-90 - Vintage 2003 Flax Vineyard ll (Wines (1) (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $110-140 4516 3 bottles per lot $70-90 (Wines Located in New York) 4525 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 cuvée Catherine PARCEL LOTS 4517-4519 (Wines Located in New York)

4517 Catena Red - Vintage 2005 1 bottle per lot $150-200 Caro 1nl, 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) 4526 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 Kistler Vineyard 3 bottles per lot $85-110 5ltl, 1lwisl (Wines Located in New York) "...deep ruby/purple-hued 2005 Pinot Noir Kistler 4518 3 bottles per lot $85-110 Vineyard possesses sweet blueberry, raspberry, and (Wines Located in New York) forest floor notes, zesty acidity, elegance, and finesse, and a medium-bodied finish."(93-95pts) 4519 3 bottles per lot $85-110 5 bottles per lot $450-600 (Wines Located in New York) ______4527 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2006 Kistler Vineyard 1 bottle per lot $240-350 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) "Compelling perfume of raspberry, candied cherry, rose 4534 Château La Mission Haut Brion - Vintage 1975 oil and minerals. Buoyant red berry flavors boast Graves impressive depth and are complicated by suave cola and sassafras qualities. Becomes smokier with air and hs, taped label, dc, cc, excellent color (Wines finishes with excellent clarity, cling and nervy Located in New York) persistence."(92pts IWC) "The 1975 La Mission-Haut-Brion has been the most 2 bottles per lot $150-200 consistent wine of the vintage. Super-concentrated, and now beginning to shed enough tannin so that it can be fully appreciated, this enormously constituted La 4528 Kistler Pinot Noir - Vintage 2006 Mission-Haut-Brion has developed that fabulous Sonoma Coast Graves set of aromatics - tobacco, black fruits, minerals, roasted herbs, and cedar. Huge, massive, 2nl, 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) thick, and succulent, with moderate tannin, and some 3 bottles per lot $220-300 amber notes at the edge... it comes closest in style to resembling the 1945, with a hint of the sweet, ripe 1959."(100pts) 4529 Melville Pinot Noir Carrie's 1 bottle per lot $800-1100 ______- Vintage 2005 ltl (Wines Located in New (1) York) PARCEL LOTS 4535-4536 - Vintage 2006 3lscl (Wines Located in New (3) York) 4535 Leonetti Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 Above 4 bottles per lot $130-160 (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $800-1200 4530 Melville Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 High Density (Wines Located in New York) (93pts) (1) 4536 6 bottles per lot $800-1200 (Wines Located in New York) Indigene, Clone 115 nl (Wines Located in New (1) ______York) 4537 Château Pavie - Vintage 2000 Above 2 bottles per lot $80-100 St. Emilion different importers (Wines Located in New York) 4531 Melville Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 "...the color is an opaque purple, and the bouquet offers Terraces up notes of liquid minerals, blackberries, cherries, and 1nl (Wines Located in New York) cassis intermixed with spice box, cedar, and white 3 bottles per lot $100-130 flowers. On the palate, it exhibits a massive display of richness and extract, yet with pinpoint delineation and vibrancy as well as a 60+ second finish, this is the kind 4532 Penfold's Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1993 of phenomenal wine that Perse's critics were afraid he Bin 707 might produce - a no-compromise, immortal wonder that represents the essence of one of Bordeaux's (Wines Located in New York) greatest terroirs. Life is too short not to own and "...exhibits a huge, jammy, blackcurrant, vanilla, consume the 2000 Pavie.."(100pts) licorice, and earthy-scented nose, as well as massive concentration of fruit, glycerin, and body. Readers will 2 bottles per lot $850-1100 find plenty of sweet tannin in the awesomely-endowed finish."(94pts) 4538 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 2003 1 bottle per lot $180-240 Pauillac ______(Wines Located in New York) "Gorgeous aromas of blackberries, plum liqueur, sweet 4533 Château La Mission Haut Brion - Vintage 1966 cherries, smoke, and melted licorice. Fleshy, full- Graves bodied, and intense, displaying a seamless integration ts, bsl, wasl, excellent color (Wines Located in of wood, acidity, tannin, and alcohol..."(95pts) New York) 1 bottle per lot $110-150 "Very ripe, rich and fleshy, although still with a hard backbone. Deep ruby, brick-red color, ripe, intense 4539 Cornas - Vintage 2005 raspberry aromas, full-bodied, with ripe, rich raspberry flavors and cedar and tobacco notes."(93pts WS) cuvée Casimir, Balthazar nc (Wines Located in New York) Le Pavillon, M. Chapoutier 1 bottle per lot $50-70 nl, 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) 4540 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 "The black/purple-colored 1998 Ermitage Le Pavillon reveals a classic, inky, mineral, cassis, and licorice- cuvée Chaupin, Domaine de la Janasse dominated nose with no trace of the 100% new oak in (Wines Located in New York) which it is aged. The gorgeously pure wine possesses "A cold terroir and sandy/clay soils have given the wine fabulous intensity, layer upon layer of concentration, an extraordinary amount of acidity and freshness that high tannin, and a silky character that suggest full serve it well in buttressing the fabulously concentrated, physiological grape maturity was obtained. The finish massively extracted, old vine Grenache. This lasts for over a minute. As the wine sat in the glass, blockbuster wine possesses enormous richness and aromas of licorice, leather, and smoky black fruits density as well as an incredibly unevolved, young (primarily blackberry and cassis) emerged."(98pts) personality. Everything is there, including awesome 1 magnum per lot $350-500 aromatics, unbelievable layers of kirsch, raspberries, licorice, incense, and blacker fruits, and a finish that goes on for close to a minute."(98pts) 4545 Ermitage - Vintage 2000 1 magnum per lot $160-220 Le Pavillon, M. Chapoutier 2x1 magnum owc's (Wines Located in New York) 4541 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2001 "Notes of graphite, ink, licorice, lumy de cassis, and minerals jump from the glass of this syrup of Vieilles Vignes, Domaine de la Janasse Hermitage. Full-bodied, unctuously-textured, (Wines Located in New York) gorgeously rich, spectacularly concentrated and long, it "...is one of the monumental Châteauneuf-du-Papes of is a tour de force in winemaking."(98pts) the vintage. A saturated plum/purple color reveals a 2 magnums per lot $600-800 thick, rich appearance. The wine combines freshness, power, elegance, and great intensity, all wrapped into a full-bodied, concentrated personality with phenomenal 4546 Ermitage - Vintage 2003 persistence on the palate."(98pts) Le Pavillon, M. Chapoutier 1 bottle per lot $100-130 1nl, 1 bottle different importer (Wines Located in New York) 4542 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 "An inky/blue/purple color is followed by a subtle but Vieilles Vignes, Domaine de la Janasse impressively intense nose of barbecue smoke, creme de cassis, blueberries, blackberries, and white flowers. The (Wines Located in New York) wine cascades over the palate (15.8% natural alcohol) "Its inky/purple color is followed by a phenomenal nose with extraordinary richness, intensity, and silkiness. of spring flowers, creme de cassis, blackberries, This seamlessly constructed Hermitage is, analytically, boysenberries, licorice, truffles, and spice. Displaying high in tannin, but extremely low in acidity, with a massive body, incredible freshness, laser-like focus freaky accessibility (a vintage character)."(100pts) from the excellent acids, and a finish that goes on well past a minute, this prodigious Châteauneuf du Pape is 3 bottles per lot $750-1000 the most extraordinary wine yet made at this estate. "(100pts) 4547 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 3 bottles per lot $600-800 Clos des Papes, P. Avril 1nl, 2 bottles different importer (Wines Located in 4543 Ermitage - Vintage 2001 New York) L'Ermite, M. Chapoutier "The wine has a dense ruby/purple-tinged color and a nl, 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New wonderfully sweet nose of framboise, blackberry, and kirsch liqueur intermixed with Chinese black tea and York) licorice. The wine is full-bodied and voluptuous, but "The black-colored 2001 Ermitage l Ermite may be once past all the glycerin and beautiful, dense fruit of equal to the perfect 1996. Awesome levels of kirsch this full-bodied wine, there is striking purity, elegance, liqueur, licorice, and white flowers are followed by a finesse, and surprising freshness. Still primary, it looks superbly concentrated, etched, long, deep wine with set to have a long life of 20-25 or more years."(97pts) multiple layers, a fabulous texture, and virtually perfect balance as well as harmony. Possessing great stature 5 bottles per lot $400-600 and intensity, it is a monumental achievement."(98- 100pts) 4548 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2005 1 magnum per lot $400-600 Clos des Papes, P. Avril (Wines Located in New York) 4544 Ermitage - Vintage 1998 "...packed with dark fig, currant, espresso, licorice and chocolate notes. Superfleshy but seriously structured, York) there's layer after layer of sweet spice, fruit and minerality pumping through the finish, with lots of 1 half-pint per lot $700-800 latent depth and power. Far more backward than the 2003 or 2004 on release, but since this red typically 4554 Vintage Bourbon Whiskey - Vintage NV puts on weight as it ages, it should be a monster-- la the 17 Year 1990..."(98pts WS) lscl (Wines Located in New York) 1 magnum per lot $180-240 1 bottle per lot $600-800 4549 Taittinger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2002 4555 Brora Single Malt Whisky - Vintage 1981 Comtes de Champagne 21 Year (Wines Located in New York) "...is off the charts. I have tasted the 2002 now many The Un-Chill Filtered Collection, bottled July times, and it has never been less than thrilling. A vivid 30th 2003 (Wines Located in New York) kaleidoscope of pure Chardonnay aromas and flavors 1 bottle per lot $950-1100 opens up in the glass. The 2002 is at once incredibly ______rich yet also totally weightless and impeccable in its balance. All the classic Comtes notes are there, but with a level of detail and nuance I don't think I have ever 4556 Blanquette de Limoux Sparkling Wine - Vintage seen before."(98pts) 1995 Clos St. Hilaire 4 bottles per lot $600-800 2ltl (Wines Located in New York)

4550 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 2005 4 bottles per lot $40-60 ______1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) "...this cuvée, which seems to want to be both a Pauillac 4557 Château Cheval Blanc - Vintage 1966 and a ripe vintage of La Mission Haut Brion. Full- bodied, dense, pure, and revealing sweeter tannin than I St. Emilion remember, it can be drunk now, but it will no doubt ts, lstl, nl, outstanding color and condition display even greater complexity in 10, 20, and 30 (Wines Located in New York) years."(97pts) "No holding back on the bouquet , an immediacy about 3 bottles per lot $1200-1600 its fragrance yet opening up even more gloriously. Very sweet, a lovely cedary flavour, good flesh and weight."(5 stars MB) 4551 Harlan Estate Red - Vintage 2006 1 bottle per lot $350-500 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) "The 2006 Harlan Estate has turned out better than I originally predicted. Its dense ruby/purple color is 4558 Château Cheval Blanc - Vintage 1970 followed by classic aromas of creme de cassis, melted St. Emilion licorice, smoked meats, burning embers, and graphite. vhs, lbsl, outstanding color and condition (Wines It has thrown off some of the tannic clout it displayed last year, revealing great balance. A candidate for Located in New York) "wine of the vintage,""(96pts) "...the 1970 had a nice, pungent nose full of wintergreen, nut, roasted meat and cherry fruit pinches 1 magnum per lot $700-900 of pepper, anise and caramel alcohol still firm gamy quality but in a red, ripe way good flavors of nut, 4552 Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2010 caramel and older red fruits, mainly cherry good earth 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) and mild dust on the finish a very good, delicious Cheval that is lighter-bodied, fine, but complex won't "Vivid aromas and flavors literally jump from the glass get much better, probably, and light by Cheval in the 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon. All of the hallmarks of standards, but thoroughly enjoyable got saucy in a this great, historic site come through in the glass. Firm reduction way."(91pts JK) yet polished tannins support a core of expressive dark fruit, but ultimately it is the wine's textural finesse and 1 bottle per lot $240-350 polish that stand out most. The 2010 is all about delineation, balance and harmony. It is a terrific effort 4559 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1970 from the entire team at Scarecrow."(96+pts) Pauillac 3 bottles per lot $850-1100 ______bn, stl, nl, ltl, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 4553 Very Old Fitzgerald - Vintage 1953 1 bottle per lot $300-450 ls, lscl, bottled in 1961 (Wines Located in New 4560 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1975 12 bottles per lot $300-400 Pauillac ts, lbsl, nl, excellent color and condition (Wines 4565 Carruades de Lafite - Vintage 1997 Located in New York) Pauillac "...is a powerful Lafite, and troublesome bottles tend to 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) reveal more tannin and funkiness than others, which have a roasted character, combined with a gravelly, 12 bottles per lot $1800-2400 mineral underpinning. As this wine has aged, it appears to be less of a sure bet. In most cases, it has been an PARCEL LOTS 4566-4567 outstanding wine, as the bottle tasted in December suggested."(92pts) 4566 Château Lagrange - Vintage 1999 1 bottle per lot $400-500 St. Julien 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 4561 Château Latour - Vintage 1948 12 bottles per lot $450-600 Pauillac hs, bsl, nl, outstanding color (Wines Located in 4567 12 bottles per lot $450-600 New York) 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in "The 1948 Latour was much bigger and oakier in its nose, with lots of wood and green bean fruit behind it. New York) The palate was rich and heavy, fleshy and fresh with wonderful texture and a zippy finish. Its wood blew off 4568 Château Laroze - Vintage 1990 into a waterfall of cascading cassis and beef, and its 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) weight stood out in this flight. Coffee and chocolate flavors emerged with air, and the wine really started to 12 bottles per lot $300-400 sing after some time in the glass. I have had this vintage twice before and always been underwhelmed, but I 4569 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 2002 guess I didn't have them from the right cellar."(95pts JK) Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $1400-1800 "Tight nose hints at currant and smoky oak. Highly concentrated, densely packed and built to age. As young 4562 Château Mouton Rothschild - Vintage 1967 as it is, it also shows a lovely velvety texture rare for Pauillac this vintage. Finishes with terrific breadth, subtle hs, lscl, lbsl, scc, outstanding color (Wines minerality and noble tannins."(94pts IWC) Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $1100-1600 "There was big-time cocoa for sure. Its palate was rich, tasty and long with grit, definition and depth. There 4570 Château Palmer - Vintage 1990 were flavors of earth, tobacco and powdered sugar Margaux along with creamy bakery goodness. Someone noted, hazelnut,' ."(93pts JK) (Wines Located in New York) "A beauty. Seductive, with currant, berry, tobacco, 1 bottle per lot $200-280 cedar and flowers on the nose. Full-bodied, with silky ______tannins and a long, caressing finish. A joyous Palmer."(92pts WS) 4563 Château Montrose - Vintage 1970 1 bottle per lot $200-240 St. Estephe hs, bsl, tl, lwrl, scc, outstanding color (Wines 4571 Les Pagodes De Cos - Vintage 2002 Located in New York) St. Estephe "This is one 1970 that appears to possess the necessary components to develop into something special. It 3nl (Wines Located in New York) remains youthfully hard and astringent, but there is no 11 bottles per lot $260-350 doubting the high levels of concentration and intensity. Moreover, the wine exhibits a classy, complex bouquet, offering up scents of cedar, black fruits, minerals, and 4572 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2003 leather."(92pts) Boisrenard, Beaurenard 1 bottle per lot $140-180 2x6 bottle owc's (Wines Located in New York) ______12 bottles per lot $600-800

4564 Blason de L'Evangile - Vintage 2002 4573 Dom Ruinart Champagne - Vintage NV 1x12 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) l'Exclusive de Ruinart ts, nl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) 1x1 magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) "More my style - nice red fruits without the (94pts RJ) herbaceousness a hint of caramel and t 'n a varnish toffee as well great flavors - chalk and minerals 1 magnum per lot $550-750 wrapped around a core of cherry and cream gets drier ______and drier until it pulls its skirt back down over its knees still sexy."(93pts JK) 4574 Château Cheval Blanc - Vintage 1989 1 bottle per lot $50-70 St. Emilion lscl, vlwrl (Wines Located in New York) 4581 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1986 "Exotic. Fragrant spicy, roasted fruit and coffee aromas give way to very ripe fruit with toasty notes on the Pauillac palate good depth..."(95pts WS) nl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $320-420 "The 1986 possesses outstanding richness, a deep color, medium body, a graceful, harmonious texture, and superb length. The penetrating fragrance of cedar, 4575 Château Duhart Milon - Vintage 1989 chestnuts, minerals, and rich fruit is a hallmark of this Pauillac wine. Powerful, dense, rich, and tannic, as well as sdc (Wines Located in New York) medium to full-bodied, with awesome extraction of fruit, this Lafite has immense potential."(100pts) 1 bottle per lot $75-100 1 bottle per lot $750-1000

4576 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1982 4582 Château Trotanoy - Vintage 1989 St. Julien Pomerol lscl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) vlbsl (Wines Located in New York) "Exhibits an explosive nose of new saddle leather, plums, prunes, black cherry jam, chocolate, steak "All in elegance and finesse. Medium-ruby color at the tartar, and roasted espresso. Unbelievably powerful, center; a brick-red edge. Aromas of berries, raisins and thick, and intense, with full body, mouth-searing tannin sliced mushrooms. Full-bodied and chewy, with lots of levels, a grilled steak-like flavor, and a huge, intense round tannins and a tobacco, berry aftertaste..."(92pts finish..."(96pts) WS) 1 bottle per lot $260-350 1 bottle per lot $170-220

4577 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1986 4583 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1983 St. Julien Sauternes ts, lscl (Wines Located in New York) bn, sdc, light mahogany color (Wines Located in "It has a black/purple color, mammoth structure, a New York) fabulous wealth of fruit, and a finish that lasts for at "Super-intense and full-throttled, elegant and stylish. least a minute."(94pts) Dark amber in color and rich in complexity, this '83 coats your mouth with butterscotch, dried apricot, fig 1 bottle per lot $150-200 and spice flavors. Made to age for decades."(98pts WS) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 4578 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1989 St. Julien 4584 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1986 bn (Wines Located in New York) Sauternes "This has lovely lead pencil and berry character, with hints of tobacco. Medium body, with fine tannins and bn (Wines Located in New York) fresh finish. Still in a holding pattern. Delicious now." " Enthralling bouquet of pineapples, saut ed hazelnuts, (92pts WS) vanillin, and ripe apricots is breathtaking. Compellingly concentrated its breadth as well as depth of flavor 1 bottle per lot $65-85 seemingly know no limits."(98pts) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 4579 Château Haut Marbuzet - Vintage 1988 St. Estephe 4585 Hermitage - Vintage 1989 3bn, 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) La Chapelle, P. Jaboulet 3 bottles per lot $150-200 lbsl, nl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) "This fabulous, blockbuster has been totally unevolved 4580 Château L'Arrosee - Vintage 1986 since bottling, but at the Jaboulet tasting, it was St. Emilion beginning to reveal some of its formidable potential. A saturated opaque purple color is followed by aromas of sense of quality. Completely mature and this should be cassis, minerals, and hot bricks/wood fire. Super-ripe drank sooner than later. In short, remarkable period but and full-bodied, with a massive mid-section, teeth- especially so for the vintage."(90pts BH) staining extract, and mouth-searing tannin, it is a 1 magnum per lot $700-1000 monster-sized La Chapelle."(96pts) ______1 bottle per lot $200-280 4592 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1966 4586 Opus One - Vintage 1984 Pauillac lbsl, scc (Wines Located in New York) 2bn, 2wasl, excellent color and condition (Wines 1 bottle per lot $160-220 Located in New York) "It is like an exceptionally shy person who has to be gently courted to bring out his or her true qualities 4587 Opus One - Vintage 1987 lean, long distance runner Bouquet with the fragrance 2ts, 2lbsl, 1sdc, 2ssos (Wines Located in New that only Lafite can exude. Lovely flavor, lean, good York) length. A jolly good drink..."(4 stars MB) "Extra facets and dimensions abound in this 2 half-bottles per lot $300-400 deeplycomplex and flavorful wine. Impressive for its ______focus and finesse, though there's an underlyingfirmness and authority in the core of chewycurrant, herb and 4593 Sinskey Pinot Noir - Vintage 2007 anise flavors. Delicious."(96pts WS) Four Vineyards 2 bottles per lot $420-600 (Wines Located in New York) ______1 magnum per lot $60-80 4588 Jarvis Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1992 2x6 bottle owc's (Wines Located in New York) 4594 Castelnau de Suduiraut - Vintage 2009 10 bottles per lot $280-380 Sauternes ______(Wines Located in New York) 5 half-bottles per lot $100-140 4589 Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 vhs, sos (Wines Located in New York) 4595 Sitia - Vintage 2000 "The 2002 is reminiscent of the 1992, exhibiting a precociousness out of the gate, but capable of lasting Oikonomoy, Domaine Economou 20-25 years. Deep purple-colored to the rim, with a 1ltl (Wines Located in New York) gorgeously pure nose of Crème de cassis with a hint of 4 500 mls per lot $60-80 sweet cherry, licorice, and smoke, this wine is beautifully voluptuous, full-bodied, yet incredibly elegant, with a finish that goes on for close to a 4596 Chablis - Vintage 2012 minute."(99pts) Bougros, P. Piuze 1 bottle per lot $1800-2400 1lgsl, 1crc (Wines Located in New York) ______2 bottles per lot $80-100 4590 Corton - Vintage 1972 Confrerie des Chevaliers du Tastevin, Jaboulet 4597 Chablis - Vintage 2012 Vercherre Bougros, Côte de Bouqueyreaux, P. Piuze 4.5cm bc, sdc, sos, excellent color and condition (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $40-60 1 magnum per lot $100-140 4598 Valais Red - Vintage 2012 4591 Richebourg - Vintage 1973 Grain Sauvage, Marie-Therese Chappaz Domaine de la Romanée Conti (Wines Located in New York) 6cm bc, lbsl, sdc, scc, sos, excellent color (Wines lscl (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $40-60 "Surprisingly deeply colored for both the vintage and and 1 magnum for a 30 year old Burgundy with a ripe, elegant, complex nose that has evolved into mostly secondary aromas. The flavor profile is rich and still together 4599 Fiorano - Vintage 2011 though there is a slightly stewed quality to it though this B. Ludovisi is subtle and doesn't really detract from the overall (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $90-120 Richards Family Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 4600 Fiorano - Vintage 2012 11 bottles per lot $450-600 B. Ludovisi (Wines Located in New York) 4610 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 6 bottles per lot $180-240 Reuling Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 4601 Rioja - Vintage 1981 2 bottles per lot $220-300 Vina Tondonia, Reserva, Lopez de Heredia (Wines Located in New York) 4611 Aubert Vineyards Chardonnay - Vintage 2010 1 bottle per lot $90-120 Reuling Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 4602 Linne Calodo Cellars Zinfandel - Vintage 2011 (95+pts) Outsider 2 bottles per lot $200-280 2ltl (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $120-160 4612 Marcassin Chardonnay - Vintage 2010 Three Sisters Vineyard 4603 Sea Smoke Pinot Noir - Vintage 2011 (Wines Located in New York) Southing 3 bottles per lot $500-700 (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $50-75 4613 Leonetti Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) 4604 Sinskey White - Vintage 2009 5 bottles per lot $280-400 Abraxas Vin De Terroir lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4614 Leonetti Cellars Sangiovese - Vintage 2009 1 magnum per lot $60-80 (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $120-160 PARCEL LOTS 4605-4606 ______

4605 Cidrerie du Valcain - Vintage 2013 4615 Barolo - Vintage 1978 Transparente B. Giacosa (Wines Located in New York) 3lbsl, 3lstl, 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $120-160 3 bottles per lot $750-1000

4606 12 bottles per lot $120-160 4616 Barolo - Vintage 1979 (Wines Located in New York) B. Giacosa lbsl, lscl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) 4607 9 bottles per lot $90-120 1 bottle per lot $70-95 (Wines Located in New York) ______4617 Barolo - Vintage 1982 Bussia Soprana, A. Conterno 4608 Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 2lbsl, 2nl (Wines Located in New York) 1x3 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $480-600 "A hundred percent Cabernet Sauvignon (800 cases), ______this is still an outstanding wine, with classic graphite, creme de cassis, blueberry and floral notes all well- presented in the perfumed aromatics of this full-bodied, 4618 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1990 rich, concentrated wine."(93+pts) Sauternes 3 bottles per lot $750-1000 2sdc, 2 half bottles different importer (Wines ______Located in New York) "An extraordinary effort, Yquem s 1990 is a rich and 4609 Pax Syrah - Vintage 2006 fabulously superb, sweet wine. This wine also possesses lots of elegance and finesse. The wine s medium gold color is accompanied by an exceptionally sweet nose of 4624 Château Cos d'Estournel - Vintage 1995 honeyed tropical fruits, peaches, coconut, and apricots. St. Estephe High quality, subtle toasty oak is well- integrated..."(99pts) (Wines Located in New York) "A wine of extraordinary intensity and accessibility a 5 half-bottles per lot $900-1200 sexier, more hedonistic offering than the muscular, backward 1996. Opulent, with forward aromatics (gobs 4619 Barolo - Vintage 1996 of black fruits intermixed with toasty pain grille scents Cannubi Boschis, L. Sandrone and a boatload of spice), this terrific Cos possesses remarkable intensity, full body, and layers of jammy lwisl (Wines Located in New York) fruit nicely framed by the wine's new oak."(95pts) ""The 1996, one of the estate's best, takes things to another level. It shows an outrageous, well-delineated 1 bottle per lot $140-180 nose of fresh roses, minerals and menthol followed waves of dark fruit and licorice flavors that are just 4625 Château Ducru Beaucaillou - Vintage 1995 beginning to show the signs of early maturity, with St. Julien exceptional freshness, length, and harmony. This opens beautifully in the glass, taking on an almost Burgundian (Wines Located in New York) elegance. A wine to marvel over."(96+pts ) "Subtle yet aromatic character of Indian spices, currants and dried cherries. Full-bodied, with super 1 magnum per lot $320-450 well-integrated tannins and a long, caressing finish. Wonderful texture. Classy and structured. Long. This 4620 Barolo - Vintage 1996 was wine of the year in 1998; well deserved."(95pts WS) Le Vigne, L. Sandrone 4 bottles per lot $500-700 (Wines Located in New York) "An extremely fine and subtle Italian red, very classy. 4626 Château Grand Puy Lacoste - Vintage 1998 Emitting complex aromas of black licorice,berry, meat, Pauillac tobacco and mushroom, the wine isfull-bodied, with an amazing balance of ripefruit, fine tannins and a long (Wines Located in New York) finish. Hard towait, but do. Best after 2004. 400 cases "...reveals a classic creme de cassis-scented nose along made."(97pts WS) with powerful, tight, firmly-structured flavors. While moderate tannin is present, there is more than enough 1 magnum per lot $220-300 extract and depth behind the tannin to support the enthusiastic rating."(90pts) 4621 Le Pergole Torte - Vintage 1995 4 bottles per lot $180-240 Montevertine lwisl, ssos (Wines Located in New York) 4627 Château Grand Puy Lacoste - Vintage 2000 1 magnum per lot $180-240 Pauillac ______2lstl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "This large-scaled wine has a saturated ruby/purple 4622 Château Beychevelle - Vintage 1982 color and a big creme de cassis nose, with a hint of St. Julien licorice and tobacco. Still somewhat closed, this deep, (Wines Located in New York) full-bodied, luscious, muscular offering exhibits ripe "... remains unformed in its voluminous, chunky, rich, tannin, loads of fruit, and tremendous purity. This is a full-bodied, atypical style. The wine is loaded with black gorgeous example of one of the most popular wines in fruits, and the long, rich finish displays considerable the Medoc."(93pts) soft tannin. Low acidity gives the wine plenty of upfront 4 bottles per lot $320-450 appeal in that fleshy, flamboyant style of so many 1982s. The color remains a dense garnet/purple, and there is little evolution in the wine's bouquet."(94pts) 4628 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1982 St. Julien 1 bottle per lot $180-240 bn, lscl, sdc, scc (Wines Located in New York) "Exhibits an explosive nose of new saddle leather, 4623 Château Cos d'Estournel plums, prunes, black cherry jam, chocolate, steak St. Estephe tartar, and roasted espresso. Unbelievably powerful, - Vintage 1991 (Wines Located in New York) (1) thick, and intense, with full body, mouth-searing tannin levels, a grilled steak-like flavor, and a huge, intense - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New (1) finish..."(96pts) York) (91pts) 1 bottle per lot $260-350 Above 2 bottles per lot $150-200 4629 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1986 St. Julien 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4635 Château Lagrange - Vintage 2000 "It has a black/purple color, mammoth structure, a St. Julien fabulous wealth of fruit, and a finish that lasts for at (Wines Located in New York) least a minute."(94pts) "This ripe, dense, full-bodied St.-Julien is chewy, thick, 2 bottles per lot $300-400 high in tannin, large-bodied, and impressively long and dense..."(93pts) 4630 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 2000 4 bottles per lot $260-350 St. Julien 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4636 Château Larcis Ducasse - Vintage 2009 "Absolutely wonderful aromas of flowers, currants and St. Emilion citrus. Full-bodied, yet very, very refined, with a center 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) core of fruit that tastes like crushed raspberries and (96pts) goes on and on. Greatest wine from this estate since 1945."(95pts WS) 4 bottles per lot $240-320 3 bottles per lot $300-400 4637 Château Latour - Vintage 1978 4631 Château Haut Batailley - Vintage 1982 Pauillac Pauillac 2bn, 2lbsl, 2lgsl, 2sdc, excellent color and lbsl (Wines Located in New York) condition (Wines Located in New York) "From the owners of Grand-Puy-Lacoste; this is the "Huge nose (tannins and alcohol), yet still subtle (flavor best wine ever produced here. Wonderfully balanced, profiles)...lots of cedar and walnut...big finish with very with plenty of cedar, tobacco and fruit characteristics dry tannins...still enormous concentration, especially on the nose and palate and a fine tannin structure. considering the vintage."(94pts JK) Shows excellent elegance."(93pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $600-800 1 bottle per lot $75-100 4638 Château Latour - Vintage 1979 4632 Château La Conseillante - Vintage 1986 Pauillac Pomerol bn, lbsl, lgsl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 1 bottle per lot $90-120 4639 Château Leoville Barton - Vintage 1989 4633 Château La Dominique - Vintage 1989 St. Julien St. Emilion lwasl (Wines Located in New York) nl (Wines Located in New York) "A delicious, well-structured Bordeaux, with plenty of "The wine is typically forward, with an opaque purple ripe fruit, beautiful berry, green tobacco and cherry color, and an intense, sweet black-raspberry, cedary, character. Full-bodied, adding velvety tannins and a toasty-scented nose. In the mouth, the wine defines the long, caressing finish."(92pts WS) word opulence with its viscosity and superb levels of 1 bottle per lot $100-140 jammy black fruits nicely dosed with high quality wood."(93pts) 4640 Château Leoville Barton - Vintage 1996 1 bottle per lot $80-110 St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) 4634 Château La Lagune - Vintage 2005 "...more powerful, as it typically is, with a touch of Medoc game and exotic boysenberry in there."(93pts JK) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $80-110 "This is the finest wine made at this estate since 1982, and possibly the greatest La Lagune of all time. Its dense ruby/purple color is followed by an exquisite 4641 Château Leoville Poyferre - Vintage 1989 bouquet of spice box, incense, sweet unsmoked cigar St. Julien tobacco, black cherry liqueur, forest floor, and subtle (Wines Located in New York) toasty oak. Reminiscent of a Côte de Nuits grand cru "...outstanding. Dark ruby-colored center, verging on blended with a top-notch Bordeaux, this beauty purple. Superripe aromas of cassis, berry and mint. possesses silky tannins, a broad, savory, expansive Full-bodied, very sleek, with fine tannins and a long, mouthfeel, and intrinsic precision as well as long, caressing finish."(90pts WS) elegance."(95pts) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 4 bottles per lot $280-400 4642 Château Lynch Bages - Vintage 1978 4649 Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1985 Pauillac Monte Bello 2bn, 2lbsl, 2lwisl, excellent color and condition (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Along with the Dunn Howell Mountain and Château (92pts WS) Montelena 1985s, Ridge's Monte Bello is among the most backward wines of the vintage, but it is so 2 bottles per lot $200-260 promising. I do not intend to touch another bottle before 2005 - it is still that youthful and closed. It offers a good 4643 Château Pichon Baron - Vintage 1994 education in what great young wine is all about. The beautiful ruby/purple color exhibits no signs of age. The Pauillac sweet nose of cassis fruit, lead pencil, flowers, and (Wines Located in New York) minerals is followed by a full-bodied, opulent wine with 1 bottle per lot $60-80 a boatload of tannin. This huge, massive yet well- delineated and focused wine should prove to be uncommonly long-lived."(94pts) 4644 Château Pichon Baron - Vintage 1996 1 magnum per lot $240-320 Pauillac lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 4650 Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - "...it does exhibit an impressively saturated dark ruby/purple color, and plenty of new oak, earth, and Vintage 1985 spice in its tightly-knit nose. Very civilized for such a 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) young wine, it will doubtedly flesh out and exhibit more 2 bottles per lot $100-140 depth to its mid-palate."(91pts)

1 bottle per lot $110-150 4651 Verite Red - Vintage 2001 Le Desir 4645 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 1978 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac (50% Merlot, 40% Cabernet Franc, 9% Cabernet 1bn, 2lbsl, 2gsl, 1nl, different importers, excellent Sauvignon, and 1% Malbec) is an enormously color and condition (Wines Located in New York) concentrated, sweet yet elegant, medium to full-bodied "...displays an aromatic profile consisting of roasted effort revealing intense notes of red, black, and blue herbs, chocolate, cedar, tobacco, and ripe curranty fruit intermixed with camphor, lead pencil shavings, fruit. Medium-bodied, with low acidity, some tannin, and spice box characteristics. Rich and intensely and a round, attractive personality..."(92pts) flavored yet remarkably light on its feet for such power(95pts) 2 bottles per lot $200-240 4 bottles per lot $480-600

4646 Volnay - Vintage 2002 4652 D'Arenberg Shiraz - Vintage 2001 Santenots du Milieu, Comte Lafon The Dead Arm (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $350-480 6 bottles per lot $240-320

4647 Vosne Romanée - Vintage 1994 4653 Penfold's Grange - Vintage 1996 Les Beaux Monts, Domaine Leroy (Wines Located in New York) 1lscl, 1 bottle different importer (Wines Located "A massive wine, with cascades of potent plum, cherry in New York) and blackberry fruit swirling around wafts of black 4 bottles per lot $500-700 pepper, bay leaf and exotic spice, which last and last on the finish, hinting at smoky, meaty notes. It's all packed in tightly, suggesting this should evolve spectacularly 4648 Grands Échézeaux - Vintage 2006 with age."(97pts WS) J. Drouhin 3 bottles per lot $900-1200 (Wines Located in New York) ______"A wonderfully spicy and positively gorgeous nose features a m lange of red, blue and black fruits as well 4654 Bianco Amabile - Vintage 1988 as hoisin, clove, anise and warm earth, all of which are G. Quintarelli picked up by the rich, full and sweet flavors that possess excellent volume and real vibrancy on the strikingly 6wisl, 5ltl, 3nl (Wines Located in New York) long finish. This could actually deliver to the upside and 12 bottles per lot $1800-2400 it has that extra dimension of grand class."(92pts BH) ______4 bottles per lot $500-700 4655 Château Cap de Faugeres - Vintage 2005 4664 Fisher Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2007 Côtes de Castillon Unity (Wines Located in New York) signed by bottle maker (Wines Located in New 11 bottles per lot $260-350 York) 1 double magnum per lot $100-140 4656 Château Charmail - Vintage 2003 Haut Medoc 4665 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) CCS 7 bottles per lot $120-160 (Wines Located in New York) "Made from a particular block of Clone 4 planted in the Beckstoffer To-Kalon Vineyard, there is something just 4657 2 bottles per lot $35-50 broader, deeper, more multidimensional and more (Wines Located in New York) subtle without losing any of the great intensity, purity and richness these wines possess that gives the CCS an amazing character. Keep in mind, as my editor pointed 4658 Château de Francs - Vintage 2000 out to me, this is the third straight vintage of this cuvée Les Cerisiers to merit a perfect score, which must be the first of its (Wines Located in New York) kind in 32 years of critiquing wines. Blueberry pie intermixed with creme de cassis, licorice, subtle oak 7 bottles per lot $120-160 and forest floor notes are followed by an extraordinary wine of staggering richness, luxurious fruit and 4659 Les Pagodes De Cos - Vintage 2000 seamlessness."(100pts) St. Estephe 1 bottle per lot $500-700 lscl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $35-45 4666 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 ______Double Diamond, Amber Knolls Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 4660 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2011 Lavaux St. Jacques, C. Giroud 4 bottles per lot $120-160 (Wines Located in New York) 4667 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2007 6 bottles per lot $350-500 Double Diamond, Amber Knolls Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 4661 Pommard - Vintage 2009 Clos des Epeneaux, Comte Armand 6 bottles per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York) "...pure aromas of mocha, red currant, cassis, black 4668 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2008 cherry, warm earth, violets and subtle spice hints. There Double Diamond, Amber Knolls Vineyard is good energy to the intense and admirably rich full- (Wines Located in New York) bodied flavors that envelope the palate with velvety sap on the beautifully balanced and impressively persistent 6 bottles per lot $180-240 finish. I very much like the sense of underlying tension because despite this being a big wine with plenty of 4669 Schrader Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 concentration, the balance is impeccable and there is Double Diamond, Amber Knolls Vineyard (Wines (1) absolutely nothing ponderous about this complete effort."(94pts BH) Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $450-600 Double Diamond, Bomber X (Wines Located in (1) New York) 4662 Volnay - Vintage 2005 Above 2 bottles per lot $60-80 Les Fremiets, Comte Armand 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 4670 Kistler Chardonnay - Vintage 2008 6 bottles per lot $750-1000 Kistler Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) 4663 Vire Clesse - Vintage 2011 3 bottles per lot $150-200 Heritiers du Lafon 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 4671 Kongsgaard White - Vintage 2009 12 bottles per lot $200-280 Vio Rous (Wines Located in New York) Dujac 6 bottles per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York) "A completely different aromatic profile presents itself here with a wild mix of red berries, especially sour 4672 Schrader Pinot Noir - Vintage 2009 cherry and currant, along with lavender, rose petal and Aston Estate warm earth nuances. There is fine detail to the intense, (Wines Located in New York) cool and pure medium weight plus flavors that possess superb depth on the strikingly persistent finish."(93pts 11 bottles per lot $850-1100 BH) ______3 bottles per lot $750-1000 4673 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2012 La Combe d'Orveau, A. Gros 4682 Clos St. Denis - Vintage 2011 (Wines Located in New York) Dujac 3 bottles per lot $240-320 (Wines Located in New York) "Here too an adroit application of wood serves as a discreet foil for the more obvious floral aromas that 4674 Échézeaux - Vintage 2012 enjoy added scope from the presence of pure, spicy and Les Loachausses, A. Gros highly complex red and dark berry scents. There is an (Wines Located in New York) abundance of mouth coating extract that imparts a suave, even lush character to the very rich medium- 3 bottles per lot $400-600 bodied flavors that are an exercise in finesse and refinement while offering controlled power and 4675 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2012 outstanding length."(93pts BH) Les Corbeaux, Vieilles Vignes, D. Bachelet 3 bottles per lot $1400-1800 (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $600-800 4683 Morey St. Denis - Vintage 2012 Dujac 4676 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 2012 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) D. Mortet 6 bottles per lot $300-400 lstl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $260-350 4684 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2011 J.F. Mugnier 4677 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2012 (Wines Located in New York) D. Mortet 2 bottles per lot $140-180 (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $50-70 4685 Volnay - Vintage 2005 Champans, Marquis d'Angerville 4678 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2012 2lbsl (Wines Located in New York) Les Champeaux, D. Mortet "A raspberry liqueur nose with hints of spice and underbrush merges into fresh, ripe, round and sweet (Wines Located in New York) flavors of surpassing intensity and purity that tighten up 1 bottle per lot $150-200 in a flash to become tight and linear on the precise, even laser-like finish. There is a beautiful tension to this wine and while there is a serious tannic backbone, this 4679 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2012 seems supple on the mid-palate because the structure is Premier Cru, D. Mortet so well buffered." (93-5pts BH) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $220-300 1 bottle per lot $130-170 4686 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2010 4680 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2012 Vieilles Vignes, S. Esmonin Vieilles Vignes, D. Mortet 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $400-600 1 bottle per lot $90-120 4687 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2012 4681 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2011 Vieilles Vignes, S. Esmonin 1x12 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $300-400 12 bottles per lot $350-500 4695 Pommery Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1959 4688 Meursault - Vintage 1988 bsl, ltl, cc, excellent color, outstanding condition Charmes, Comte Lafon (Wines Located in New York) 6lgsl, 3sdc (Wines Located in New York) "It was time for some bubbly, and a magnum of 1959 Pommery was incredible. Honey, butterscotch, white 6 bottles per lot $750-1000 chocolate and a caramel toffee extravaganza per Gil, the 1959 Pommery was spectacular and practically a 4689 Meursault - Vintage 2010 sexual experience."(96pts JK) Perrières, Comte Lafon 1 bottle per lot $400-600 (Wines Located in New York) "An elegant, pure, cool and dazzlingly complex nose is 4696 Taittinger Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1970 comprised of white rose, acacia blossom, lemon zest Comtes de Champagne, Rose and plenty of mineral reduction character. There is 6nl, 6scc, excellent color and condition (Wines outstanding precision and almost painful intensity to the tautly muscular flavors that positively vibrate with Located in New York) underlying tension before culminating in a hugely long 6 bottles per lot $3000-4000 finish where a touch of wood is also in evidence. As the ______best examples of Perrières always are, this is a perfect blend of power and finesse."(95pts BH) 4697 Château Cos d'Estournel - Vintage 1994 4 bottles per lot $1000-1400 St. Estephe 6lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4690 1 bottle per lot $260-350 "The deep, saturated, dark ruby/purple color is followed 1lstl (Wines Located in New York) by gobs of toasty vanillin scents from new oak, a rich, sweet, pure nose of cassis, medium body, potentially outstanding concentration and definition, and a ripe, 4691 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1969 moderately tannic finish."(91pts) ts, lbsl, vlscl, excellent color and condition (Wines 6 bottles per lot $500-700 Located in New York) "The last vintage in oak barrels. A sensual acacia, 4698 Château Ducru Beaucaillou - Vintage 1999 honeyed nose and the usual hint of coffee. It dances in the mouth."(96pts RJ) St. Julien 1 bottle per lot $600-800 1sdc (Wines Located in New York) "Ducru-Beaucaillou is always elegant and complex. The 1999 exhibits an evolved character. This property has 4692 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1976 been making superb wines since the mid-nineties, and 1x1 bottle ogb (Wines Located in New York) the 1999 is a complete, open-knit offering that depends "Fabulously chewy and powerful with an indestructible more on its finesse, multiple aromatic dimensions, and power and a layered richness. Multifaceted nose with sheer delicacy than power. Ripe, medium to full-bodied, an elusive, almost flowery undertone and beautifully with excellent density, sweet tannin, and delicious nutty, toasted, and honeysuckle elements."(97pts RJ) symmetry..."(91pts) 1 bottle per lot $600-750 2 bottles per lot $180-240

4693 Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1978 4699 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1993 1ts, 2vhs, 3nl, excellent color (Wines Located in St. Julien New York) 3lscl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "An aroma of mushroom cream and bread-like taste, "Purity, balance, and super-concentration and intensity with well-rounded edges. Fine apricot opulence in the are hallmarks of this remarkable wine. Readers who middle taste gorgeously backed up by young gooseberry find it difficult to believe that the 1993 vintage could tones as well as the honey and chocolate of turn out wines such as this only need to pull the cork on maturity."(93pts RJ) a bottle of the 1993 L oville-Las-Cases."(90pts) 2 bottles per lot $800-1100 3 bottles per lot $300-400

4694 Louis Roederer Vintage Champagne - Vintage 1977 4700 Château Pichon Baron - Vintage 1990 Cristal Pauillac bsl, stl, nl, scc, outstanding color (Wines Located lscl (Wines Located in New York) in New York) "The wine is opulent and flamboyant, with lower acidity, and noticeably less tannin than the 1989. It is 1x6 bottle owc (Wines Located in New York) equally concentrated, with a more evolved nose of "The wine exhibits an opaque dark purple color, as well cedar, black fruits, earth, minerals, and spices. On the as an extraordinary penetrating fragrance of black palate, the wine offers sensational quantities of jammy fruits, roasted nuts, fruit cake, and allspice. Viscous, fruit, glycerin, wood, and sweet tannin."(96pts) rich, and full-bodied, with an unprecedented degree of 1 bottle per lot $240-320 opulence for a Cabernet Sauvignon-based wine, this dense, superbly concentrated, low acid, lush wine reveals layers of glycerin, fruit, and extract."(95pts) 4701 Château Troplong Mondot - Vintage 1998 St. Emilion 6 bottles per lot $650-850 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) "It boasts an impressively saturated purple color, as 4706 Philip Togni Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 well as a beautifully etched bouquet of cassis, 6lscl, 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) blackberries, and subtle new oak. The wine is medium- "...possesses a saturated purple color in addition to a bodied and stylish, with excellent concentration, dry thrilling but still reticent nose of blackberries, cassis, tannin in the finish, and a floral, finesse-styled minerals, dried herbs, and smoky oak. Full-bodied, personality."(93pts) pure, thick, and creamy-textured, this wine's superb 3 bottles per lot $240-320 concentration conceals its lofty, but sweet tannin."(94pts) 6 bottles per lot $800-1100 4702 Tignanello - Vintage 1999 ______Antinori 1lwrl, 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New 4707 Château Bellefont Belcier - Vintage 2000 York) St. Emilion "...exhibits rare elegance married to considerable flavor 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) intensity as well as power. Normally a blend of 80% "This dense ruby/purple-colored offering offers sweet, Sangiovese, 15% Cabernet Sauvignon, and 5% jammy black cherry fruit accompanied by notes of dried Cabernet Franc aged in French oak for 12 months, the herbs, cedar, licorice, and spice box. Medium to full- 1999 offers up aromas of new saddle leather bodied, with a sweet attack as well as excellent intertwined with black cherries, currants, creosote, concentration and symmetry, it will be drinkable vanilla, and spice box. Rich and medium-bodied, with between 2006-2016. This is a delicious, open-knit wine adequate acidity as well as sweet but noticeable tannin, from an up and coming estate. A sleeper."(90pts) it is the third consecutive exceptional vintage from this reference winery for modern, aggressively-styled 2 bottles per lot $60-100 Tuscan reds."(91pts) 6 bottles per lot $500-700 4708 Château Bellefont Belcier - Vintage 2003 St. Emilion 4703 Abreu Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) Thorevilos 3 bottles per lot $75-100 (Wines Located in New York) "...borderline perfection, an unreal wine with notes of 4709 Château Berliquet - Vintage 2000 crushed rocks, acacia flowers, blueberry pie, and Crème de cassis intertwined with a bit of smoke, St. Emilion espresso roast, and chocolate. The wine is 3lscl, 1lwrl (Wines Located in New York) phenomenally rich, has great nobility, purity, and a "More of a finesse-styled St.-Emilion than many other finish that goes on for just over a minute..."(98pts) wines from this hotbed of activity, the 2000 is the finest Berliquet yet produced. It exhibits an impressive 2 bottles per lot $500-700 saturated ruby/purple color as well as jammy cherry and cassis liqueur aromas, medium to full body, sweet 4704 Bryant Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2003 tannin, a multi-tiered mid-palate, and a long finish. An 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) elegant wine, it is a sleeper of the vintage."(90pts) "This broodingly dense opaque purple-colored wine 4 bottles per lot $160-220 offers an extraordinary nose of blueberries, smoky oak, chocolate, and licorice. Powerful, rich, and concentrated, with sweet tannin, a thick, juicy style, and 4710 Château Branaire Ducru - Vintage 1982 excellent delineation, this large-scaled Cabernet should St. Julien hit its peak in 4-5 years, and last through 2020."(96pts) 1bn, 1vhs, 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $450-550 "Wines tasted from my cellar have consistently been rich, well-colored, textbook St.-Juliens with less body and unctuosity than exhibited by the finest examples of 4705 Dominus - Vintage 1996 the vintage. Always seductively supple and precocious, the wine has opened beautifully, exhibiting classic PARCEL LOTS 4717-4718 cedar, mineral, and cassis aromas in a medium to full- bodied, supple, rich format."(90pts) 4717 Château Cos d'Estournel - Vintage 1983 2 bottles per lot $200-280 St. Estephe bn, vlbsl (Wines Located in New York) 4711 Château Branaire Ducru - Vintage 1985 1 bottle per lot $75-100 St. Julien 1bn, 2lbsl, 1nl, 1sdc, 1ltl, 1tc (Wines Located in 4718 1 bottle per lot $75-100 New York) bn, sdc (Wines Located in New 2 bottles per lot $85-120 York)

4712 Château Branaire Ducru - Vintage 1989 4719 Château de Pez - Vintage 1990 St. Julien St. Estephe (Wines Located in New York) 1lbsl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "The wine is currently revealing more expansiveness, fuller body, and plenty of lusty richness, a sure-fire 3 bottles per lot $130-180 formula for producing a crowd pleaser. There are no hard edges to this opulently-textured, rich, ripe, 4720 Château Destieux - Vintage 2000 complex, savory style of wine."(92pts) St. Emilion 1 bottle per lot $65-85 (Wines Located in New York) "This beautiful wine, which is just hitting full maturity, 4713 Château Calon Segur - Vintage 1985 reveals plenty of truffle, forest floor, black cherry, black St. Estephe currant, plum, and soy aromas with hints of espresso and white chocolate in the background. The tannins bn, nl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) have fallen away in this medium to full-bodied St.- 1 bottle per lot $60-80 Emilion which offers a fleshy mid-palate in addition to lots of succulence."(90pts) 4714 Château Calon Segur - Vintage 1995 3 bottles per lot $90-120 St. Estephe (Wines Located in New York) 4721 Château Destieux - Vintage 2003 "Greatest Calon-Segur ever made. An absolutely St. Emilion amazing red layers of berry, violets and perfume. It's (Wines Located in New York) full-bodied and very velvety on the palate, with masses of character and an ultralong finish."(96pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $50-70 1 bottle per lot $80-110 4722 Château Ducru Beaucaillou - Vintage 1979 St. Julien 4715 Château Cambon La Pelouse outstanding color and condition (Wines Located - Vintage 2000 Haut Medoc (Wines Located in (3) in New York) New York) 1 bottle per lot $70-90 Château Cap de Faugeres - Vintage 2000 Côtes de Castillon (Wines (2) 4723 Château Grand Corbin Despagne Located in New York) - Vintage 2000 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (2) New York) (90pts) Above 5 bottles per lot $100-140

Château Jaugues Blanc 4716 Château Clerc Milon - Vintage 1995 - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Pauillac 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) "Like smelling a delicious raspberry sauce with hints of Château Quercy coffee and smoke, and the wine that follows is - Vintage 2000 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (1) wonderfully structured, muscular and well toned. Full- New York) bodied, with sleek and racy tannins and a long, characterful aftertaste. One of the top buys of the vintage. Best after 2001."(95pts WS) Château Quinault L'Enclos - Vintage 2000 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (1) 3 bottles per lot $200-300 New York) (94pts) St. Emilion 4lbsl (Wines Located in New York) Château Yon Figeac 4 bottles per lot $100-140 - Vintage 2000 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (1) New York) (91pts) 4731 Château La Croix Canon - Vintage 1998 Above 6 bottles per lot $170-240 Canon-Fronsac (Wines Located in New York) 4724 Château Grand Puy Lacoste - Vintage 1983 3 bottles per lot $65-90 Pauillac bn, lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4732 Château Lafite Rothschild - Vintage 1995 1 bottle per lot $40-60 Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) 4725 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1983 "It exhibits a dark ruby purple color, and a sweet, St. Julien powdered mineral, smoky, weedy cassis-scented nose. Beautiful sweetness of fruit is present in this medium- bn, ltl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) bodied, tightly-knit, but gloriously pure, well-delineated "Typical of the wines this property made in the late Lafite."(95pts) seventies and early eighties, it offers a full throttle style, an opaque dark ruby/purple color with no amber at the 2 bottles per lot $1200-1600 edges, and a huge nose of melted road tar, new saddle leather, grilled meats, and black fruits. It is sure to be 4733 Château Lafon Rochet - Vintage 1995 controversial among those tasters looking for only new St. Estephe oak and fruit aromas. Powerful, spicy, and full-bodied, with surprising viscosity for a 1983, this wine's low (Wines Located in New York) acidity allows it to be appreciated now, but there are "The best wine ever produced at this estate. So sexy, so still formidable quantities of sweet tannins in the wonderful now--but be patient. Dark in color, ruby, finish."(92pts) inky. Blueberries, cream and vanilla character. Full- bodied, with full yet fine tannins. It literally massages 1 bottle per lot $65-90 your palate."(93pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $70-100 4726 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1986 St. Julien 4734 Château Lagrange - Vintage 1990 1bn, 1ts (Wines Located in New York) St. Julien "It has a black/purple color, mammoth structure, a fabulous wealth of fruit, and a finish that lasts for at (Wines Located in New York) least a minute."(94pts) "This muscular, thick, unctuous, lavishly-oaked wine may cause raised eyebrows by those looking for 2 bottles per lot $300-400 something restrained and understated. There is no doubting the hedonistic appeal of this style of wine. The 4727 1 bottle per lot $150-200 1990 is another massive, highly-extracted, boldly- ts, vlscl (Wines Located in New wooded, spicy, dark purple-colored wine with high tannin, low acidity, and layers of jammy fruit. The huge York) glycerin and massive mouthfeel in this unctuously- textured wine are difficult to ignore. I suspect this wine 4728 Château Gruaud Larose - Vintage 1988 will become more defined after it loses its baby fat."(93pts) St. Julien 1nl, 1lwrl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $100-130 "This tight and powerful red has lots of tannin and fruit concentration. Full-bodied, with lovely violet and berry 4735 Château Leoville Barton - Vintage 1989 aromas and flavors."(92pts WS) St. Julien 5 bottles per lot $320-450 hwasl, lwrl, 1x1 double magnum owc (Wines Located in New York) 4729 Château Guibot la Fourvielle - Vintage 2000 "A delicious, well-structured Bordeaux, with plenty of St. Emilion ripe fruit, beautiful berry, green tobacco and cherry character. Full-bodied, adding velvety tannins and a 1nl (Wines Located in New York) long, caressing finish."(92pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $40-60 1 double magnum per lot $450-600

4730 Château Haut Brisson - Vintage 2000 4736 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1995 1 bottle per lot $350-480 St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) 4741 Château Margaux - Vintage 1995 "Exceptionally ripe cassis fruit, the judicious use of Margaux toasty new oak, and a thrilling mineral character lscl (Wines Located in New York) intertwined with the high quality of fruit routinely "Dark color. Black licorice, coffee, currants and black obtainedby Las Cases, make this a compelling effort olives. Complex nose. A full-bodied, chewy blockbuster The finish is incredibly long in this classic."(95pts) of a wine that is not giving anything at all away. It is 3 bottles per lot $450-600 like buried treasure still; you have to search for the gold. And it's there. Fabulous."(100pts WS) 4737 Château Leoville Poyferre - Vintage 2000 1 bottle per lot $380-500 St. Julien 2vlscl (Wines Located in New York) 4742 Château Milens - Vintage 2000 "Wow, this wine has really come on strong. A brilliant St. Emilion effort, it boasts an opaque purple color in addition to a 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) gorgeously sweet nose (make that explosive nose) of blackberries and creme de cassis intermixed with 4 bottles per lot $100-140 minerals, smoke, and earth. The 2000 is opulent, full- bodied, and much more accessible than either of its two 4743 Château Palmer - Vintage 1979 Leoville siblings, Leoville Las Cases or Leoville Barton, with low acidity, sweet tannin, and a layered, Margaux sumptuous finish. It continues to improve dramatically ts, lwrl, outstanding color and condition (Wines and looks to be a great success, rivaling the brilliant Located in New York) 1996 and 1990."(95pts) 1 bottle per lot $120-160 2 bottles per lot $260-400 4744 Château Palmer - Vintage 1985 4738 Château Lynch Bages - Vintage 1986 Margaux Pauillac 2bn, 2lwrl (Wines Located in New York) 1bn, 3lbsl, 1 bottle different importer (Wines "It was time to rock with the 80s, beginning with the Located in New York) 1985. The 85 had a charming nose with nice musk and a "It was drinking spectacularly, to be frank, and was in sweet, caramel glaze. Chocolate, honey and graham that just right, wine sweet spot that can last for many cracker emerged as sexy secondary aromas, all able to years, longer than the average American marriage, that speak on a platform of cassis underneath. The palate s for sure. There was great cedar, t n a and a long, had cassis and chocolate with twists of wood and kisses beefy Szechuan style about its aromas. Long and smooth of citrus. Gorky keenly observed, the style is so evident with cedar and mineral flavors, its palate was also in all these wines."(92pts JK) great."(95+pts JK) 2 bottles per lot $240-320 3 bottles per lot $400-550 4745 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 1979 4739 Château Margaux - Vintage 1983 Pauillac Margaux bn, lbsl, outstanding color and condition (Wines ts, lbsl (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) "Wine of the vintage. Massive, with exuberant aromas "A creamy, Fudgesicle thing going on - almost hay-like of cassis, lead pencil and fruit which follow through on as well but not quite hay unless you throw the the palate. Full-bodied and incredibly velvety. Long, Fudgesicle thing on it nice balance, round and richer long finish."(98pts WS) good balance and drinking well with a good, firm 1 bottle per lot $450-600 finish."(93pts JK) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 4740 Château Margaux - Vintage 1985 Margaux 4746 Château Pichon Lalande - Vintage 1985 lscl, nc (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac "...charming and the color is a healthy dark ruby/purple lbsl, spc (Wines Located in New York) offers copious quantities of lavishly ripe black berry "Still incredibly youthful. Exhibits fabulous aromas of and cassis fruit intermixed with toasty oak and floral fresh fruit, minerals and chocolate with a hint of spice. scents. It has always been a remarkably approachable Full-bodied and concentrated, with loads of fruit and and enjoyable wine, but it appears to be taking on more tannins."(96pts WS) character and quality than I ever imagined."(94pts) 1 double magnum per lot $600-800 4747 Château Prieure Lichine - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New York) Margaux 1 bottle per lot $100-130 (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $75-100 4754 La Romanée - Vintage 1993 Bouchard, Pere et Fils 4748 Château Siran - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) Margaux "...showing some nice concentration of red berry flavor (Wines Located in New York) and tannins that clamp down on the finish. Of medium body, with lovely rose petal and currant notes."(90pts "Château Siran - Vintage 1995 Margaux owc Massive WS) Margaux. Best Siran since the late 1920s. Bright currant and berry aromas, with hints of mushrooms and 1 bottle per lot $450-600 earth. Full-bodied, with big, velvety tannins and a long, long, fruity finish..."(93pts WS) 4755 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1983 3 bottles per lot $75-100 Château de la Tour 3wasl, 1ltl (Wines Located in New York) 4749 Château Sociando Mallet - Vintage 1990 3 bottles per lot $220-300 Haut Medoc 1bn, 3ts, 1lgsl (Wines Located in New York) 4756 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1988 "Amazing wine for the vintage. Black-ruby color. Stupendous aromas of crushed berries, currants, Château de la Tour cherries and minerals. Full-bodied, with nl (Wines Located in New York) superconcentration of fruit and wonderfully polished 1 bottle per lot $110-150 tannins. Goes on and on..."(96pts WS) 4 bottles per lot $300-420 4757 Vougeot - Vintage 1995 Les Petits Vougeots, Clerget 4750 Château Sociando Mallet - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) Haut Medoc 2 bottles per lot $120-160 (Wines Located in New York) "...offers gobs of sweet black-cherries, cassis, minerals, and toast in the nose. Sweet, fat, and rich, with 4758 Pommard - Vintage 1990 outstanding concentration and character."(90pts) Clos des Epenaux, Comte Armand 4 bottles per lot $200-280 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $320-500 4751 Château Sociando Mallet Haut Medoc 4759 Romanée St. Vivant - Vintage 1989 - Vintage 1995 vlscl (Wines Located in New (1) Domaine de la Romanée Conti York) (90pts) lscl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2003 1nl (Wines Located in New (1) "A really lovely wine, soft and sweet crisp, punchy York) (94pts) flavor and substantial tannins...still fairly deep, dark cherry; vegetal nose, broccoli , sweet, rich, high Above 2 bottles per lot $90-120 alcohol, assertive and more grip than the 1990."(3-5 stars MB) 4752 Château Talbot - Vintage 1982 1 bottle per lot $800-1100 St. Julien (Wines Located in New York) 4760 Bonnes Mares - Vintage 1988 "...exhibits considerable evolution, with super-ripe H. Roumier aromas of cassis, saddle leather, roasted black olives, (Wines Located in New York) and minerals. In the mouth, this voluptuous, concentrated wine displays no hard edges. There is still 1 bottle per lot $800-1100 plenty of tannin in evidence, but the low acidity and softness make for an opulent mouthful of claret."(93pts) 4761 Beaune Rouge - Vintage 1990 1 Imperial per lot $1200-1600 Clos des Mouches, J. Drouhin lstl (Wines Located in New York) 4753 Pavillon Blanc du Château Margaux - Vintage 1986 "A joy to taste. Gorgeous, smooth, round, supple and Margaux full of crisp, focused raspberry, earth and currant aromas and flavors."(93pts WS) mouthsearing tannins. At present, most of its quality can only be detected at the back of the mouth - usually a 1 bottle per lot $90-120 positive sign for a potentially long-lived wine. But readers should realize that this is one of the least 4762 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1990 flattering 1990s."(90pts) J.J. Confuron 1 bottle per lot $110-160 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $450-600 4771 Échézeaux - Vintage 1990 L. Jadot 4763 Beaune Rouge - Vintage 1988 (Wines Located in New York) Boucherottes, L. Jadot 1lscl (Wines Located in (3) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 New York) Clos des Ursules, L. Jadot lscl (Wines Located in (1) 4772 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1988 New York) (91pts WS) Clos St. Jacques, L. Jadot (Wines Located in New (1) Above 4 bottles per lot $160-220 York) Estournelles St. Jacques, L. Jadot (Wines Located (1) 4764 Beaune Rouge - Vintage 1989 in New York) Clos des Ursules, L. Jadot Above 2 bottles per lot $160-220 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $120-170 4773 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1990 Clos St. Jacques, L. Jadot 4765 Bonnes Mares (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1986 L. Jadot lscl (Wines Located in (1) "The nose explodes from the glass, offering a melange New York) of scents, including black-raspberries, toasty new oak, cloves, vanilla, and candy. In the mouth, there is astonishing richness, a thick, well-defined texture, and a Clos Vougeot flamboyant, moderately tannic finish that lasts well over - Vintage 1988 L. Jadot (Wines Located in (1) a minute."(96pts) New York) 1 bottle per lot $240-320 Above 2 bottles per lot $180-240 4774 Échézeaux - Vintage 1985 PARCEL LOTS 4766-4768 Lamarche (Wines Located in New York) 4766 Bonnes Mares - Vintage 1988 2 bottles per lot $300-400 L. Jadot (Wines Located in New York) 4775 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1988 1 bottle per lot $240-320 M. Mugneret 2lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 4767 1 bottle per lot $240-320 2 bottles per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York) 4776 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1990 4768 1 bottle per lot $240-320 Les Corvees Pagets, R. Arnoux (Wines Located in New York) lscl (Wines Located in New York) 1 magnum per lot $120-160 4769 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1988 L. Jadot 4777 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New York) Les Bousselots, R. Chevillon 2 bottles per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 4770 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 1990 L. Jadot 4778 Batard Montrachet - Vintage 1990 lscl (Wines Located in New York) L. Jadot "... reveal a wine with considerable power and lscl, spc (Wines Located in New York) 4785 Batard Montrachet - Vintage 1988 1 bottle per lot $150-160 Sauzet stl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) 4779 Chevalier Montrachet - Vintage 1989 1 bottle per lot $150-200 Les Demoiselles, L. Jadot lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4786 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 1990 "Less than 100 cases are made of the Chevalier- Jamet Montrachet-Les Demoiselles, which was the tightest, sdc (Wines Located in New York) most backward wine I tasted from Jadot. Even more unevolved than the Montrachet, it needs 5-10 years of 1 bottle per lot $200-300 cellaring and should last for 20-30 years. It is absolutely magnificent with its subtle yet authoritative 4787 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 1988 bouquet of minerals and super-ripe fruit. In the mouth, there is high acidity, formidable depth, and a texture Ogier that is oh, so chewy. It is the essence of lscl (Wines Located in New York) Chardonnay."(96pts) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 1 bottle per lot $350-500 4788 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 1991 4780 Corton Charlemagne - Vintage 1988 Ogier Domaine des Heritiers, L. Jadot (Wines Located in New York) sdc (Wines Located in New York) "... is a sensational Côte Rôtie. Ogier's style is one of 1 bottle per lot $50-70 exceptional elegance married to a velvety-textured, supple, rich fruitiness. His Côte Rôties are not as masculine or robust as others, relying more on 4781 Montrachet - Vintage 1989 complexity and finesse. The 1991 displays an ethereal L. Jadot bouquet of ripe cassis, bacon, vanilla, and violets. This (Wines Located in New York) deep, medium-weight wine with extraordinary finesse, fragrance, and length on the palate would embarrass 1 bottle per lot $350-500 many a Musigny from Burgundy."(93pts) 1 bottle per lot $100-130 4782 Batard Montrachet - Vintage 1989 L. Latour 4789 Hermitage - Vintage 1989 lscl (Wines Located in New York) La Chapelle, P. Jaboulet "The bouquet is bursting with flavors of oranges, smoky 2wasl, 2sdc, 1tc (Wines Located in New York) oak, toast, and butterscotch. In the mouth there is "This fabulous, blockbuster has been totally unevolved enormous richness, gobs of glycerin and extraction of since bottling, but at the Jaboulet tasting, it was flavor, and surprisingly high acidity in view of the beginning to reveal some of its formidable potential. A wine's massiveness and extract levels."(96pts) saturated opaque purple color is followed by aromas of 1 bottle per lot $120-160 cassis, minerals, and hot bricks/wood fire. Super-ripe and full-bodied, with a massive mid-section, teeth- staining extract, and mouth-searing tannin, it is a 4783 Corton Charlemagne - Vintage 1989 monster-sized La Chapelle."(96pts) L. Latour 2 bottles per lot $500-700 lscl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) "It will be potentially longer-lived than the 1983, but it is hard for me to believe that it will ever eclipse the 4790 Hermitage - Vintage 1991 great 1986. Stylistically, it reminds me of the opulent, La Chapelle, P. Jaboulet flamboyant 1979 Corton-Charlemagne. This is an (Wines Located in New York) outstanding white burgundy by any standard of "It is successful, with a personality not far removed measurement. Don't miss it!"(95pts) from the 1985. Soft and ripe, it reveals an excellent 1 bottle per lot $110-150 deep purple color, a rich, unformed but intense nose, medium to full-bodied flavors, excellent concentration, sweet tannins, and low acidity."(90pts) 4784 Meursault - Vintage 1989 Les Genevrieres, L. Latour 1 bottle per lot $260-350 lscl, cuc (Wines Located in New York) 4791 Bandol - Vintage 1989 1 bottle per lot $100-140 cuvée Vieilles Vignes, Château Pradeaux (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $45-50 - Vintage 1986 ltl (Wines Located in New (1) York) (96pts) 4792 B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage Above 2 bottles per lot $170-240 1985 (Wines Located in New York) 4798 Château Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1 magnum per lot $150-200 1987 (Wines Located in New York) 4793 Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon "The black/purple color, the extraordinary bouquet of - Vintage 1991 sdc (Wines Located in New (1) rich cassis, violets, and licorice, the massive extraction of flavors, sensational depth, super ripeness, and a York) (95pts) length that must last over a minute, suggest to me that - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New magnum (1) this is easily the most concentrated and potentially York) (96pts) longest-lived Cabernet Sauvignon that Château Montelena has ever made. The extract level is Above 1 bottle per lot $220-300 incredible, yet the balance is there."(98pts) and 1 magnum 1 bottle per lot $150-200

4794 Bryant Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2004 4799 Château Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage (Wines Located in New York) 1992 "...by far the strongest vintage at Bryant Family (Wines Located in New York) Vineyard, displaying the classic blueberry jam notes "...Château Montelena the Cal Ripken of Cabernet intermixed with cassis, smoke, underbrush, and spice. It producers"(95pts) is a full-bodied, opulent, fleshy wine that is beautifully pure, long, dense, and concentrated. Nevertheless, the 4 bottles per lot $320-450 forward style of this vintage argues for drinking this wine over the next 15+ years."(95pts) 4800 Château Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1 bottle per lot $260-350 1994 (Wines Located in New York) 4795 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1990 "The saturated black/purple color is followed by Special Selection aromas of gorgeously pure blackberry and cassis scents. Toasty oak notes are barely discernable given (Wines Located in New York) the wine's bombastic display of black fruits, huge, "...offers a saturated, dark purple color, and a rich, chewy glycerin level, and sensational finish."(95pts) spicy, oaky nose backed up by generous quantities of jammy blackcurrants. Ripe, highly extracted, and full- 2 bottles per lot $200-260 bodied, with copious amounts of sweet tannin and layers of fruit, this is a knock-out, flamboyantly-styled 4801 Clos Pegase Cabernet Sauvignon Cabernet for drinking over the next 15 or more - Vintage 1992 Hommage (Wines Located in (1) years."(94pts) New York) 1 bottle per lot $180-240 Clos Pegase Red 4796 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1994 - Vintage 1987 Hommage bn, scc, 1x6 bottle (1) Special Selection custom owc (Wines Located in (Wines Located in New York) New York) "This hedonistic Cabernet Sauvignon's saturated purple color is accompanied by an exuberant, sweet, enveloping fragrance of smoky new oak, and jammy - Vintage 1988 Hommage bn, scc (Wines (1) blackberry and cassis fruit. In the mouth, this lavishly Located in New York) wooded, black fruit-filled Cabernet is extremely full- bodied, with superb levels of fruit, glycerin, and extract - Vintage 1989 Hommage scc (Wines Located (1) extraordinary equilibrium, with the sweet tannin giving the wine considerable accessibility. The finish lasts for in New York) nearly 30 seconds."(95pts) - Vintage 1990 Hommage scc (Wines Located (1) 1 bottle per lot $160-220 in New York) - Vintage 1991 Hommage bn (Wines Located in (1) 4797 Château Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon New York) - Vintage 1983 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) Above 6 bottles per lot $240-350 York) (90pts JK) 4802 Colgin Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 - Vintage 1993 Napa Valley wc (Wines Located Tychson Hill magnum (1) (Wines Located in New York) in New York) (90pts) "A gorgeous wine, ripe, smooth and harmonious, rich Above 1 bottle per lot $120-160 and spicy, with tiers of currant, vanilla, cassis and black cherry flavors woven together. Long, thick, and 1 magnum persistent finish gushes with flavor. Plenty of smooth, ripe tannins add to its plush backbone..."(96 WS) 4808 Chalone Pinot Noir 1 bottle per lot $120-160 - Vintage 1990 1lscl (Wines Located in New (2) York) 4803 Dalla Valle Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley Rutherford Hill Merlot - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 1985 lscl (Wines Located in New magnum (1) York) - Vintage 1993 1lscl (Wines Located in New (2) Above 2 bottles per lot $100-150 York) and 1 magnum - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (3) Above 7 bottles per lot $420-600 4809 Sea Smoke Pinot Noir - Vintage 2006 Ten PARCEL LOTS 4804-4805 (Wines Located in New York) (92pts) 4804 Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1992 1 bottle per lot $80-110 Monte Bello lscl, sdc (Wines Located in New York) 4810 Sea Smoke Pinot Noir - Vintage 2007 "When I tasted this wine early in its life I felt it had outstanding potential. With another year of cellaring it Ten has gained considerable weight. It now looks to be one 1nl (Wines Located in New York) of the greatest examples of Monte Bello Cabernet 2 bottles per lot $150-200 Sauvignon Ridge has produced. Only 40% of the crop made it into the final blend, which consists of 75% Cabernet Sauvignon, 11% Merlot, 10% Petit Verdot, 4811 Clarendon Hills Old Vines Grenache - Vintage 2002 and 4% Cabernet Franc. The wine offers a black/purple Blewitt Springs Vineyard (Wines Located in New (1) color, a profound nose of minerals, cassis, licorice, and York) spices, spectacular richness, and a great mid-palate that boasts layers of fruit. Admirable purity, fine Hickinbotham Vineyard (Wines Located in New (1) underlying acidity, and considerable sweet, ripe tannin York) (92-94pts) make this another compelling effort."(94-97pts) Above 2 bottles per lot $95-130 1 bottle per lot $130-180 ______

4805 1 bottle per lot $130-180 4812 Montrachet - Vintage 1980 lscl, sdc (Wines Located in New Château de Beaune, Bouchard, Pere et Fils York) 7lbsl, 2nl, 5 bottles darker color (Wines Located in New York) 4806 Robert Mondavi Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - 7 bottles per lot $1000-1400 Vintage 1994 ______nl (Wines Located in New York) "I had the 1994 Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve a half- 4813 Rioja - Vintage 1942 dozen times this year, and it may be the finest Cabernet Vina Albina, Reserva, Bodegas Riojanas ever from Mondavi."(97pts) 3bn, 3ts, 2vhs, 3hs, 12bsl, 5wisl, 3hwisl, 3tl, 1 magnum per lot $180-240 2lstl, 2ltl, 2scl, 2lscl, 1htl, 3sdc, 1sos, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 4807 La Jota Cabernet Sauvignon 12 bottles per lot $1000-1400 - Vintage 1998 Howell Mountain lscl (Wines (1) Located in New York) 4814 Rioja - Vintage 1950 Monte Real, Reserva, Bodegas Riojanas Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvignon 1-3cm bc, 1-4cm bc, 4lbsl, 1lscl, excellent color, 4823 Rioja - Vintage 1964 outstanding condition (Wines Located in New Monte Real, Reserva, Bodegas Riojanas York) 1-3cm bc, 2-3.5cm bc, 1-4cm bc, 2-4.5cm bc, 4 bottles per lot $500-700 12lstl, 6nl, 2tl, 1lbsl, 3ssos, excellent color and condition (Wines Located in New York) 4815 Rioja - Vintage 1950 12 bottles per lot $1000-1400 Vina Albina, Reserva, Bodegas Riojanas 4ts, 8vhs, 12bsl, 12lstl, 2lscl, 1ltl, 1sdc, excellent 4824 Rioja - Vintage 1964 color and condition (Wines Located in New York) Vina Real Reserva Especial, CVNE 12 bottles per lot $1200-1500 1-3cm bc, 2-3.5cm bc, 1-4cm bc, 6bsl, 5stl, 3nl, 3tl, 1wisl, 1ssos, outstanding color (Wines 4816 Rioja - Vintage 1950 Located in New York) Vina Ramona Vieja, Reserva, Artacho 6 bottles per lot $900-1200 1bn, 6ts, 4vhs, 12bsl, 5nl, 2ltl, 1scl, 1lscl, 8sdc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 4825 Rioja - Vintage 1966 12 bottles per lot $600-800 Fuenmayor, Bodegas Montecillo 7bn, 1ts, 1vhs, 11bsl, 8stl, 3ltal, 2ltl, 3sdc, 4817 3 bottles per lot $150-200 excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 2ts, 1vhs, 3bsl, 3stl, 3lscl, 11 bottles per lot $650-850 excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 4826 Rioja - Vintage 1970 Prado Enea Gran Reserva, Bodegas Muga PARCEL LOTS 4818-4819 1-3.5cm bc, 1-4cm bc, 6bsl, 6lstl, 2tl, 2lscl, 2crwc, excellent color (Wines Located in New 4818 Rioja - Vintage 1951 York) Vina Real, Reserva Especial, CVNE 6 bottles per lot $650-900 hbsl, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $160-220 4827 2 bottles per lot $220-300 1-3.5cm bc, 2bsl, 2lstl, 1tl, 1twc, 4819 1 bottle per lot $160-220 1sos, excellent color (Wines 5cm bc, hbsl, excellent color Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 4828 Rioja - Vintage 1973 4820 Rioja - Vintage 1956 Vina Ardanza, La Rioja Alta Monte Real, Reserva, Bodegas Riojanas 1-3cm bc, 1-4cm bc, 12bsl, 12stl, 4ltl, 2nl, 2bsl, 2lstl, 2nl, excellent color and condition excellent color (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $500-700 2 bottles per lot $300-400 4829 Rioja - Vintage NV PARCEL LOTS 4821-4822 Vina Bosconia, 5 Ano, Lopez de Heredia 1-3cm bc, 3-3.5cm bc, 7-4cm bc, 12bsl, 12stl, 5nl, 4821 Rioja - Vintage 1964 1sdc, 12scc, 4ssos, excellent color (Wines Located Gran Reserva Especial, Paternina in New York) 3bn, 8ts, 1vhs, 12bsl, 12lstl, 3lscl, 1tl, 2spc, 8scc, 12 bottles per lot $600-800 4cc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) ______12 bottles per lot $900-1200 4830 Château Haut Batailley - Vintage 1961 4822 12 bottles per lot $900-1200 Pauillac 4bn, 7ts, 12bsl, 12lstl, 9lscl, 3ltl, htms, lgsl, lbsl, scc, excellent color (Wines 12scc, excellent color (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $140-180 4831 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1950 Château Boutisse Sauternes - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) (1) lbsl, lwasl, sdc, mahogany color (Wines Located in New York) Château Jean Faure 1 bottle per lot $800-1200 - Vintage 2005 2lscl, 2nc (Wines Located in half-bottle (2) New York) 4832 B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1982 Above 2 half-bottles per lot $200-280 bsl (Wines Located in New York) and 7 bottles "One of the finest examples of the 1982 vintage, this wine has been a reliable performer for over a decade 4839 Château Branaire Ducru - Vintage 2004 exhibits a saturated dark ruby color with only slight lightening at the edge. The nose offers copious St. Julien quantities of sweet, jammy, red and black fruits (Wines Located in New York) intertwined with plenty of spicy, toasty new oak. Ripe, 3 magnums per lot $240-320 full-bodied, opulent, and fleshy, this sumptuously-styled Private Reserve is drinking well."(90pts) 4840 12 half-bottles per lot $240-350 1 bottle per lot $50-70 (Wines Located in New York)

4833 Royal Oporto Vintage Port - Vintage 1917 4841 8 half-bottles per lot $160-240 York House (Wines Located in New York) vhs, crc, sos (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $200-300 4842 Château Calon Segur - Vintage 2004 St. Estephe 4834 Silval Port Noval - Vintage 1908 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) htms, lwisl, sos (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $150-200 1 bottle per lot $300-400 ______4843 Château Clinet - Vintage 1994 4835 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 2002 Pomerol N. Potel 1lscl, 1spc (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "Exotic aromas of violets, berry and toasted oak waft "Deep red. Superripe aromas of black raspberry, violet, from this full-bodied wine. Packed to the brim with fruit wild herbs and smoked meat; needs a racking. Sweet, and tannins and impressively long on the finish. Superb rich and succulent, but a bit youthfully unforthcoming. red from a producer known for opulence."(93ptsWS) Less detailed today than the Clos Saint-Denis but 2 bottles per lot $140-180 larger-scaled. Big, meaty, full and long. This should last longer than the Clos-Saint-Denis, but it does not come across as particularly austere today."(91-94pts IWC) 4844 Château Cos d'Estournel - Vintage 2005 St. Estephe 6 bottles per lot $600-800 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 4836 Échézeaux - Vintage 2002 "Black in color, with aromas of orange peel, new N. Potel leather, currant, berry and Christmas pudding. Full- (Wines Located in New York) bodied, with layers of velvety tannins and a long, long finish of fruit and spices. The cashmere texture is all 6 bottles per lot $600-800 ______there. 2003 plus 2000 equals 2005."(98pts WS) Above 1 half-bottle per lot $220-300 4837 Alter Ego de Palmer - Vintage 2004 and 1 bottle Margaux 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 4845 Château de Cruzeau - Vintage 2005 3 bottles per lot $150-200 Graves 6lscl (Wines Located in New York) 4838 Château Beau-Site 6 bottles per lot $120-180 - Vintage 2005 St. Estephe 1nl (Wines Located (6) in New York) 4846 Château du Tertre notes. Dense and fat, with low acidity, an opulent, chewy texture, medium to full body, superb power, and Margaux a seductive character..."(94pts) - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (3) 2 bottles per lot $750-1000 York) (90pts) - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) magnum 4852 Château Leoville Barton - Vintage 1982 (3) St. Julien Above 3 half-bottles per lot $220-300 1bn, 1stl, 1nc (Wines Located in New York) and 3 magnums "...exhibits a saturated, nearly opaque dark ruby/garnet color, as well as a tight but promising bouquet of 4847 Château Figeac - Vintage 2004 roasted nuts, dried herbs, and rich, jammy, curranty St. Emilion fruit. The most impressive components are the exceptional richness and textured feel. An opaque dark (Wines Located in New York) garnet color is followed by aromas of sweet cedar, old 1 bottle per lot $60-80 wood, truffles, smoke, and underbrush. Big, thick, juicy, black currant, and cherry flavors can be found in this muscular, monster-sized, exceedingly tannic, dense, 4848 Château L'Arrosee - Vintage 1985 backward wine. The finish must last for nearly a minute St. Emilion in this young, spectacularly rich, old style St.- 2ts, 2nl, 2sdc (Wines Located in New York) Julien."(92pts) "The deep ruby color reveals some amber/orange at the 2 bottles per lot $300-400 edge. The wine has always possessed a knock-out set of aromatics, consisting of nearly overripe black cherries and raspberries intermingled with high quality pain 4853 Château Leoville Barton grille notes. Supple, with a layered, richly fruity St. Julien textured imbued with plenty of glycerin and heady - Vintage 1985 bn (Wines Located in New (1) alcohol, this sumptuous, luxuriously-styled, fully mature York) (92pts) L'Arrosee should be drunk up."(93pts) - Vintage 1989 bsl (Wines Located in New (1) 2 bottles per lot $120-160 York) (92pts WS)

4849 Château L'Evangile - Vintage 1999 Above 2 bottles per lot $190-260 Pomerol (Wines Located in New York) 4854 Château Leoville Barton - Vintage 2006 St. Julien 2 bottles per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York) "There's a great dark color to this, with intense aromas 4850 Château Lascombes - Vintage 2004 of cedar, wood, new leather and crushed blackberry. Margaux Full-bodied, with loads of fruit and a firm, powerful 1nl (Wines Located in New York) palate. Long and mouthpuckering. A muscular baby. "Another brilliant effort from this estate, the 2004 Best after 2015."(94pts WS) Lascombes (a blend of 50% Merlot, 45% Cabernet 6 bottles per lot $300-420 Sauvignon, and 5% Petit Verdot) exhibits a deep blue/purple hue along with a sweet perfume of blueberries, black raspberries, cherries, incense, smoke, 4855 5 bottles per lot $240-350 and spring flowers. While opulent, underneath the full- (Wines Located in New York) bodied richness of fruit and depth is a structured wine. As it sits in the glass, an espresso roast character (no 4856 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 2006 doubt from new oak) also emerges."(93pts) St. Julien 3 bottles per lot $130-180 (Wines Located in New York) "...exhibits a personality that mimics the superb 1996. 4851 Château Latour - Vintage 1999 Classic aromas of sweet black raspberries, kirsch, Pauillac cassis, and subtle toasty oak are followed by a full- (Wines Located in New York) bodied, concentrated wine displaying moderately high tannin."(95pts) "Produced from yields of 39 hectoliters per hectare, the final blend was 70% Cabernet Sauvignon, 25% Merlot, 3 bottles per lot $350-450 4% Cabernet Franc, and 1% Petit Verdot. The opulent, rich, concentrated 1999 is atypically forward and 4857 Château Leoville Poyferre - Vintage 2000 luscious. The dense purple color is followed by precocious, sweet black cherry/cassis aromas backed up St. Julien by noteworthy liquid mineral and subtle smoky new oak (Wines Located in New York) "Wow, this wine has really come on strong. A brilliant Above 3 half-bottles per lot $80-110 effort, it boasts an opaque purple color in addition to a gorgeously sweet nose (make that explosive nose) of blackberries and creme de cassis intermixed with 4863 Château Monbousquet - Vintage 2005 minerals, smoke, and earth. The 2000 is opulent, full- St. Emilion bodied, and much more accessible than either of its two (Wines Located in New York) Leoville siblings, Leoville Las Cases or Leoville Barton, "A blend of approximately two-thirds Merlot, one-third with low acidity, sweet tannin, and a layered, Cabernet Franc and 8-10% Cabernet Sauvignon, the sumptuous finish. It continues to improve dramatically 2005 exhibits plenty of toasty oak, roasted herb, meat and looks to be a great success, rivaling the brilliant juice, blackberry, cherry, and spice characteristics 1996 and 1990."(95pts) along with a touch of incense. Full-bodied and opulent, 10 half-bottles per lot $420-650 with an atypically rigid structure, this is a remarkable achievement for such a humble terroir."(95pts) 4858 Château Lynch Bages - Vintage 1989 3 magnums per lot $420-500 Pauillac 1bsl, 1lbsl (Wines Located in New York) 4864 Château Monbrison - Vintage 2005 "The 1989 has taken forever to shed its formidable Margaux tannins, but what a great vintage of Lynch Bages! I (Wines Located in New York) would rank it at the top of the pyramid although the 1990, 2000, and down the road, some of the more recent 3 bottles per lot $100-150 vintages such as 2005, 2009 and 2010 should come close to matching the 1989's extraordinary 4865 Château Montrose - Vintage 1995 concentration and undeniable aging potential. Its dense St. Estephe purple color reveals a slight lightening at the edge and the stunning bouquet offers classic notes of creme de 2lscl, 2swc, 2ssos (Wines Located in New York) cassis, subtle smoke, oak and graphite. Powerful and "The wine exhibits an opaque black/ruby/purple color, rich with some tannins still to shed at age 22.."(99+pts) as well as a ripe nose of black fruits, vanillin, and licorice. Powerful yet surprisingly accessible (the 2 bottles per lot $500-650 tannin is velvety and the acidity low), this terrific example of Montrose..."(93pts) 4859 Château Lynch Bages 2 bottles per lot $200-280 Pauillac - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (1) 4866 Château Montrose - Vintage 2004 York) (91pts WS) St. Estephe - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New (7) 1lscl, 1tl (Wines Located in New York) York) (93pts WS) "Dark-colored, with beautiful spice, blackberry and Above 1 half-bottle per lot $850-1100 licorice aromas. Full-bodied, round and velvety, with wonderful balance and a long, long finish. This is a and 7 bottles Montrose that caresses your palate."(92pts WS) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 4860 Château Meyney - Vintage 2005 St. Estephe 4867 Château Montrose - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) St. Estephe 8 bottles per lot $260-400 (Wines Located in New York) "...is an undeniable success. A blend of approximately 4861 Château Monbousquet - Vintage 2000 two-thirds Cabernet Sauvignon, one-third Merlot, and a St. Emilion tiny dollop of Petit Verdot, the most dramatic difference between the 2006, and wines made by the previous (Wines Located in New York) administration is that Jean Delmas produces wines with (93pts) sweeter, silkier tannins, although analytically, they are 4 half-bottles per lot $150-200 as high as those found in the great Montrose vintages of the past."(94+pts) 4862 Château Monbousquet 3 bottles per lot $200-260 St. Emilion - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (1) 4868 Château Pape Clement - Vintage 2000 York) (93pts) Graves - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (2) (Wines Located in New York) York) (93pts) "...continues to put on weight. An opaque purple color is accompanied by stunning aromas of wood smoke, cocoa, black currant and cherry liqueur, coffee, 3 bottles per lot $220-300 scorched earth, and new oak."(95pts) 12 half-bottles per lot $700-950 4874 Château Quinault L'Enclos - Vintage 2005 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (2) 4869 Château Pape Clement - Vintage 2002 New York) (94pts) Graves 1lwrl (Wines Located in New York) Château Rauzan Segla 3 bottles per lot $150-200 - Vintage 2006 Margaux (Wines Located in (2) New York) 4870 Château Pavie Above 4 bottles per lot $200-260 St. Emilion - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 4875 Château Sociando Mallet - Vintage 2004 Haut Medoc (Wines Located in half- - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New (1) bottle (1) York) (95pts) New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $220-300 Haut Medoc nl, nc (Wines (1) Located in New York) 4871 Château Pavie Macquin - Vintage 2000 St. Emilion - Vintage 2005 Haut Medoc lscl (Wines (1) (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) "A wine of great density, concentration, and intensity, the opaque blue/purple 2000 Pavie Macquin needs Château Soutard considerable aeration, but with decanting the prodigious bouquet of graphite, camphor, blackberry, - Vintage 2005 St. Emilion (Wines Located in half- blueberry, mineral, coffee, and smoky oak finally makes bottle (4) an appearance. Persuasive, expansive, full-bodied, and New York) muscular, this enormously endowed, rich wine looks set Above 5 half-bottles per lot $160-220 for a long life, at least three decades. A terrific effort that rivals the compelling 1998."(95pts) and 2 bottles 10 half-bottles per lot $350-500 4876 Château Sociando Mallet - Vintage 2005 4872 Château Pontet Canet Haut Medoc Pauillac (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New (3) 9 bottles per lot $350-500 York) (92pts WS) - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (3) 4877 8 bottles per lot $320-450 York) (93pts WS) (Wines Located in New York) Above 3 half-bottles per lot $220-300 4878 Château St. Georges - Vintage 2005 and 3 bottles St. Emilion (Wines Located in New York) 4873 Château Pontet Canet - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) Pauillac 1nl (Wines Located in New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $280-400 "The 2006 is a wine to stockpile, especially for those in and 3 magnums their thirties and forties as it needs another decade to reach maturity, after which it should keep for 30+ 4879 Château Troplong Mondot years. This vineyard, just south of Mouton Rothschild, has produced an opaque bluish/purple-colored 2006 St. Emilion with an extraordinarily pure nose of graphite, charcoal, - Vintage 1989 lstl, nl (Wines Located in (1) sweet creme de cassis, and a hint of scorched earth. New York) (96pts) Incredible concentration, stunning richness, and a 60- - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (2) second finish result in a wine that transcends the vintage as well as this estate's 1855 classification. This York) (95pts) enormously endowed, modern day classic is a legend in Above 2 half-bottles per lot $260-320 the making."(95+pts) and 1 bottle 4880 Château Trotanoy - Vintage 1990 - Vintage 1973 bn, lbsl, ssos, beautiful (1) Pomerol amber color (Wines Located 1lwrl (Wines Located in New York) in New York) "Sleeping giant. Dark red color with a brick edge. Above 2 bottles per lot $220-320 Subtle aromas of mineral, berry and mint. Full-bodied and very closed, yet chewy and big. Grows and grows on the palate. Huge."(95pts WS) 4886 Château Climens - Vintage 1983 2 bottles per lot $400-600 Sauternes 1bn, 1lscl, 1lgsl, 5sos, 1ssos (Wines Located in 4881 Clos de L'Oratoire New York) - Vintage 2005 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (3) 6 bottles per lot $480-650 New York) 4887 Château Climens - Vintage 1998 Clos Fourtet Sauternes - Vintage 2004 St. Emilion (Wines Located in half- (Wines Located in New York) bottle (3) 3 bottles per lot $120-160 New York) 4888 Château Climens - Vintage 1999 Clos Rene Sauternes - Vintage 2005 Pomerol (Wines Located in half-bottle (Wines Located in New York) (1) New York) 4 bottles per lot $200-260 Above 4 half-bottles per lot $180-240 4889 Château Climens - Vintage 2004 and 3 bottles Sauternes (Wines Located in New York) 4882 Domaine de L'Eglise - Vintage 2005 Pomerol 3 bottles per lot $90-120 2nl (Wines Located in New York) 4890 Château Climens - Vintage 2005 3 bottles per lot $120-180 Sauternes 12nl (Wines Located in New York) 4883 Les Forts de Latour - Vintage 2004 Pauillac 12 bottles per lot $750-1000 (Wines Located in New York) "...reveals a deep ruby/purple hue, classic evolved 4891 5 bottles per lot $320-420 cedary, lead pencil, and cassis characteristics, medium 5nl (Wines Located in New York) body, beautiful sweetness of fruit, and a more forward, evolved character than its big sibling."(90pts) 4892 Château D'Arche Lafaurie 4 half-bottles per lot $240-320 - Vintage 2001 cuvée Madame, Sauternes nl (1) (Wines Located in New York) 4884 Château Caillou - Vintage 1983 Sauternes bn, lstl, ltl, sos (1) Château de Fargues (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 Sauternes (Wines Located in (2) New York) Château de Fargues - Vintage 1983 Sauternes bn, ssos (Wines (1) Château Graville Lacoste Blanc Located in New York) - Vintage 2007 Graves (Wines Located in New (2) Above 2 bottles per lot $120-160 York)

4885 Château Climens Château Lafaurie Peyraguey Sauternes - Vintage 2003 Sauternes lscl (Wines Located magnum - Vintage 1971 bn, lbsl, ssos, beautiful (1) (1) amber color (Wines Located in New York) in New York) Château Suduiraut Above 4 bottles per lot $140-190 - Vintage 1990 Sauternes lscl (Wines Located (1) in New York) (95pts WS) 4899 Château Doisy Daëne - Vintage 1990 L'Extravagance, Sauternes Domaine de Chevalier Blanc (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2004 Graves (Wines Located in New half- "In 1990 Doisy-Daene produced 100 cases of a bottle (1) sensational luxury cuvée called l'Extravagant. It York) possesses considerable botrytis, awesome extract levels and intensity, and despite massive power, remarkable Above 1 half-bottle, 6 bottles per lot $380-500 balance. Readers are unlikely to find any of this wine and 1 magnum (bottled in a heavy 375 ml bottle) outside Bordeaux. Its medium gold color and extraordinary richness and power suggest it will age effortlessly for another 20+ 4893 Château de Fargues - Vintage 1988 years."(95pts) Sauternes 1 half-bottle per lot $150-200 1nc (Wines Located in New York)

2 bottles per lot $140-180 4900 Château Guiraud Sauternes 4894 Château de Fargues - Vintage 1989 - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (3) Sauternes (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New (3) 2 bottles per lot $150-200 York) (97pts WS) Above 6 bottles per lot $240-350 4895 Château de Fargues - Vintage 1990 Sauternes 4901 Château La Tour Blanche - Vintage 1962 (Wines Located in New York) Sauternes "Fairly deep gold-tinged color. Superripe aromas of 1ts, 1ltal, 2spc, gold amber color (Wines Located pineapple, cooked apple, honey and white raisin. Huge, in New York) thick and three-dimensional; shows a powerfully honeyed character and deep peachy fruit in the mouth. 2 bottles per lot $320-420 Almost aggressively young today, with the chewy character and uncanny richness shown by a number of 4902 Château La Tour Blanche - Vintage 2005 these '90s. Slight heat and a note of mint on the very strong back end. This will require another five to seven Sauternes years to reach its full potential and should be long- (Wines Located in New York) lived."(92+?pts IWC) 3 bottles per lot $120-180 2 bottles per lot $160-220 4903 Château Raymond Lafon 4896 Château de Fargues - Vintage 1995 Sauternes Sauternes - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (3) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) (3) 1 bottle per lot $60-80 Above 6 bottles per lot $200-260 4897 Château de Fargues - Vintage 2005 Sauternes 4904 Château Raymond Lafon - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) Sauternes (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $600-800 5 bottles per lot $150-200 4898 Château Doisy Daëne Sauternes 4905 Château Sigalas Rabaud - Vintage 1988 - Vintage 1986 2bn, 2lbsl, 1lscl, 2sdc (2) Sauternes (Wines Located in New York) 2ts, 1stl, 1tl, 1nc, 1ssos (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1988 2lwrl, 2sdc (Wines Located (2) 2 magnums per lot $240-320 in New York) 4906 Château Suduiraut - Vintage 1959 Morey St. Denis Sauternes - Vintage 1998 Les Ruchots, Arlaud (Wines (3) 1ts, 2nl, 2lstl, 2sos, different importers, light Located in New York) mahogany color (Wines Located in New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $350-450 (5 stars MB) 2 bottles per lot $600-800 4913 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2006 Arlaud 4907 Château Tirecul La Graviere - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) cuvée Madame, Monbazillac 3 bottles per lot $260-350 (Wines Located in New York) 2 500 mls per lot $200-280 4914 Clos de la Roche - Vintage 2006 Arlaud 4908 Château Tirecul La Graviere - Vintage 1995 1lwrl (Wines Located in New York) cuvée Madame, Monbazillac 3 bottles per lot $320-450 (Wines Located in New York) "...there is no doubt in my mind that the 1995 cuvée 4915 Morey St. Denis - Vintage 2006 Madame is as profound a sweet wine as I have ever tasted. Made from 80-year old vines, harvested grape Les Ruchots, Arlaud by grape, and with yields of 12 hectoliters per hectare 1tl (Wines Located in New York) (under one ton of fruit per acre), this wine boasts a 3 bottles per lot $130-180 glorious nose of apricot jam, tangerine essence, and subtle spicy oak. With its profound richness, blazingly vivid definition, huge body, viscous thickness (with no 4916 Corton - Vintage 2005 heaviness), and finish that lasts for nearly a minute, this Le Rognet, B. Ambroise nectar constitutes one of the most extraordinary sweet wines I have ever tasted."(100pts) (Wines Located in New York) 2 500 mls per lot $220-300 2 bottles per lot $120-160

4909 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2005 4917 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1990 En Reniard, A. Burguet Vieilles Vignes, B. Dugat-Py (Wines Located in New York) 2lbsl, 2nl, 1lwisvl (Wines Located in New York) (90pts BH) 2 bottles per lot $170-220 1 bottle per lot $50-70 4918 Pommard - Vintage 2005 4910 Richebourg - Vintage 1990 Les Lavieres, Vieilles Vignes, B. Dugat-Py A. F. Gros (Wines Located in New York) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 "Amazingly rich, ripe and firm; the fruit just erupts like a volcano. Offers marvelous plum, currant and violet 4919 Bonnes Mares - Vintage 2004 aromas and flavors and a touch of toasted bread and vanilla on the complex, supple finish."(97pts WS) Bertheau 1lwisvl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $800-1200 10 bottles per lot $700-900 4911 Beaune Rouge - Vintage 2005 Les Bressandes, A. Morot (Wines Located in New (2) 4920 Bonnes Mares - Vintage 2005 York) Bertheau Les Teurons, A. Morot (Wines Located in New (2) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "Just as it was from cask, this is much more reserved York) and while not inexpressive, I had to again work the wine Above 4 bottles per lot $140-200 in the glass for it to grudgingly reveal a glimpse of the ripe earthy red and black pinot fruit nose that continues onto the rich, full, muscled and powerful flavors that 4912 Bonnes Mares offer excellent volume, particularly on the solidly - Vintage 2006 Arlaud (Wines Located in New (3) structured, indeed borderline chewy finish that offers York) exceptional persistence."(93pts BH) 6 bottles per lot $1000-1400 4921 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2004 Lavaux St. Jacques, C. Dugat Bertheau (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) 1er Cru, Bertheau (Wines Located in New York) (1) "...outstanding depth of sweet, ripe cherry, dried cranberry and peach preserves, impressive meatiness, Above 2 bottles per lot $50-70 and bracingly salty, bitter-sweet shrimp shell-like, as well as implacably chalky minerality. A certain not 4922 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2004 unpleasant tartness of fruit and chewy tannin creep into C. Dugat the finish, which exhibits the sort of youthful stamina and energy one anticipates just staring at the youthfully (Wines Located in New York) deep purple pool that is a glass of Claude Dugat "Good deep red. Wonderfully complex, scented nose Gevrey."(94pts) combines black cherry, rose petal, smoked meat, coffee and underbrush; a real essence of the village. Then 2 bottles per lot $400-600 densely packed and sweet, with beautifully integrated acidity and floral lift giving this silky wine a very suave 4928 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2006 impression."(93+?pts IWC) Lavaux St. Jacques, C. Dugat 1 bottle per lot $200-260 (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $300-420 4923 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2005 C. Dugat 4929 Griottes Chambertin - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) C. Dugat "...smells of cherry and black raspberry preserves along with herbal and almond extracts, stirs dark, faintly (Wines Located in New York) bitter notes of black chocolate and chalk dust into the "Good deep red-ruby. Darker on the nose than the pool of ripe black fruit that spreads out on the palate, Charmes but quite restrained at present, hinting at inky and finishes with more polish, glycerin-richness, and black cherry and violet. Then suave, sweet and fine- refinement..."(93pts) grained, with a higher pitch than the Charmes; more fruity and less animal. A lovely combination of power 2 bottles per lot $750-1000 and finesse."(93+?pts IWC) 1 bottle per lot $350-450 4924 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2004 4930 Corton - Vintage 2005 C. Dugat (Wines Located in New York) (2) Bressandes, Chandon de Briailles Premier Cru, C. Dugat (Wines Located in New York) (2) (Wines Located in New York)

- Vintage 2006 2 bottles per lot $140-180 Premier Cru, C. Dugat (Wines Located in New York) (1) 4931 Corton - Vintage 2005 Above 5 bottles per lot $300-400 Clos du Roi, Chandon de Briailles (Wines Located in New York) 4925 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2005 C. Dugat 2 bottles per lot $120-160 (Wines Located in New York) "Deep red-ruby. Superripe aromas of cherry, raspberry 4932 Corton - Vintage 2005 and licorice. Dense, lush and sweet, with superb depth Les Marechaudes, Chandon de Briailles of black raspberry and smoked meat flavor for a village (Wines Located in New York) wine. As ripe and rich as this rather massive wine is, sound acidity keeps it from going over the top. Finishes 3 bottles per lot $180-240 with serious tannins that are currently hidden by the wine's fruit. "It's a vintage that imposes itself," notes 4933 Volnay - Vintage 2005 Dugat."(91pts IWC) Les Caillerets, Chandon de Briailles 5 bottles per lot $400-550 (Wines Located in New York) 4 bottles per lot $160-240 4926 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2004 Lavaux St. Jacques, C. Dugat 4934 Chassagne Montrachet Rouge - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) Clos du Château de la Maltroye, Château de la 2 bottles per lot $200-280 Maltroye (Wines Located in New York) 4927 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2005 2 bottles per lot $80-120 4941 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2005 Dupont-Tisserandot 4935 Échézeaux - Vintage 2006 4nl (Wines Located in New York) En Orveaux, D. Mugneret 6 bottles per lot $600-750 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $260-350 4942 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2002 4936 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2006 Les Cazetiers, Dupont-Tisserandot (Wines Located (2) Les Boudots, D. Mugneret in New York) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 3 bottles per lot $120-180 La Petite Chapelle, Dupont-Tisserandot 1nl (Wines (3) Located in New York) 4937 Vosne Romanée - Vintage 2006 Lavaux St. Jacques, Dupont-Tisserandot 3nl (Wines (3) Les Chaumes, D. Mugneret Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 8 bottles per lot $380-500 3 bottles per lot $200-260 4943 Échézeaux - Vintage 1999 4938 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2005 E. Rouget Les Grandes Vignes, D. Rion (Wines Located in (3) 1lscl, 1lstl (Wines Located in New York) New York) "Heavy wood spice presently dominates the fruit and leads to round, sexy, seductive, earthy, nicely rich and Les Lavieres, D. Rion (Wines Located in New (1) detailed flavors of excellent intensity and fine length To York) be sure, there is good underlying material and certainly a fine track record behind the wine plus a demonstrated Vosne Romanée ability to age even in less than stellar vintages..."(91pts BH) - Vintage 2004 Les Chaumes, D. Rion (Wines (2) Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $1000-1400

- Vintage 2005 D. Rion (Wines Located in New (1) 4944 Blagny - Vintage 2005 York) La Piece Sous le Bois, F. Jobard Les Beaux Monts, D. Rion (2) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $120-180 Above 9 bottles per lot $380-550 4945 Chambolle Musigny 4939 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2006 Les Chabiots, F. Magnien (3) cuvée Les Petits Plets, Domaine de l'Arlot (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (3) Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2000 Vieilles Vignes, F. Magnien half-bottle - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (2) (1) (Wines Located in New York) Above 4 half-bottles per lot $100-130 Above 2 half-bottles per lot $180-240 and 3 bottles 4940 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2003 1er Cru, Domaine de l'Arlot (1) 4946 Corton (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2003 Clos des Cortons, Faiveley (1) (Wines Located in New York) Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 2006 Clos des Cortons, Faiveley 2lstl half- (95pts) bottle (3) Above 3 bottles per lot $200-260 (Wines Located in New York) Gevrey Chambertin aromas and flavors. Quite supple."(91pts WS) - Vintage 2006 Les Cazetiers, Faiveley (Wines half- 2 bottles per lot $400-500 bottle (2) Located in New York) 4953 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2005 J. Drouhin (Wines Located in half- Nuits St. Georges bottle (2) - Vintage 2002 Clos de la Marechale, Faiveley half- New York) bottle (4) (Wines Located in New York) Nuits St. Georges Above 9 half-bottles per lot $320-450 - Vintage 2000 Les St. Georges, H. Gouges (1) and 1 bottle (Wines Located in New York)

4947 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2001 Les St. Georges, H. Gouges (1) - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) Aux Échézeaux, Vieilles Vignes, Fourrier (Wines (2) Located in New York) Pommard - Vintage 2006 - Vintage 2005 Vieilles Vignes, J. Voillot (2) Vieilles Vignes, Fourrier (Wines Located in New half- (Wines Located in New York) bottle (1) York) Volnay Above 1 half-bottle per lot $170-220 - Vintage 2005 Vieilles Vignes, J. Voillot (1) and 2 bottles (Wines Located in New York) Above 2 half-bottles per lot $200-280 4948 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2005 and 5 bottles Les Beaux Bruns, G. Barthod (Wines Located in New York) 4954 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2006 3 bottles per lot $240-320 cuvée Unique, J. Raphet (Wines Located in New York) 4949 Chambolle Musigny - Vintage 2005 3 bottles per lot $260-350 Les Charmes, Gambal (Wines Located in New York) 4955 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1990 3 bottles per lot $150-200 Les Fontenys, J. Roty 1lstl (Wines Located in New York) 4950 Échézeaux - Vintage 2005 2 bottles per lot $240-320 Gambal (Wines Located in New York) 4956 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2004 3 bottles per lot $300-420 Clos de la Marechale, J.F. Mugnier (Wines Located in New York) 4951 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 2005 "This is more elegant still and slightly finer with detailed, expressive and pure aromas of earth, black Geantet-Pansiot fruit and plum that dissolve into beautifully complex, (Wines Located in New York) refined and balanced flavors that also display ample "...delivers a lovely meld of bright cherry, beef marrow, finishing minerality and better overall phenolic cocoa powder, and chalk. A typically sleek, polished, ripeness. A really lovely effort that should age long-lined performance for this appellation at its best, effortlessly."(89-91pts BH) this isn't a wine with lots of nooks and crannies."(94pts) 2 bottles per lot $100-140 4 half-bottles per lot $240-320 4957 Clos Vougeot - Vintage 2005 4952 Grands Échézeaux - Vintage 1990 J.M. Millot Gros Frere et Soeur (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $300-420 "Very delicate and refined, well balanced and offering plenty of pretty strawberry, violet, vanilla and chocolate 4958 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1990 Clos de Bèze, L. Jadot Les Hauts Poirets, Jayer-Gilles different importers (Wines Located in New York) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) "The color is a saturated dark ruby/purple, and the closed nose offers sweet, jammy aromas framed by 2 bottles per lot $150-200 noticeable smoky new oak. The magnificent richness, highly structured and delineated style, as well as the 4959 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1991 explosively rich finish, all make for a show-stopping Les Hauts Poirets, Jayer-Gilles impression."(96pts) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $420-550 2 bottles per lot $120-160 4963 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 1990 Estournelles St. Jacques, L. Jadot 4960 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) Les Hauts Poirets, Jayer-Gilles (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $200-300 2 bottles per lot $90-120 4964 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2006 Les Pruliers, Lecheneaut 4961 Gevrey Chambertin (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2004 La Perriere, L. Boillot (Wines (1) Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $120-160

Les Corbeaux, L. Boillot (1) 4965 Volnay - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New York) M. Lafarge 1nl (Wines Located in New York) Les Evocelles, L. Boillot (1) 2 bottles per lot $90-100 (Wines Located in New York) 4966 Échézeaux - Vintage 1990 - Vintage 2005 Les Cherbaudes, L. Boillot (2) Maniere-Noirot (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $180-240 - Vintage 2006 L. Boillot (Wines Located in half-bottle (2) New York) 4967 Volnay - Vintage 2006 Les Cherbaudes, L. Boillot half-bottle (3) Les Champans, Marquis d'Angerville (Wines (2) 2lscl (Wines Located in New Located in New York) York) Les Taillepeids, Marquis d'Angerville (Wines (1) Located in New York) Pommard Premier Cru, Marquis d'Angerville (Wines Located half- - Vintage 2005 Les Croix Noires, L. Boillot (2) bottle (4) (Wines Located in New York) in New York) Above 4 half-bottles per lot $320-420 Volnay and 3 bottles - Vintage 2004 Les Angles, L. Boillot (Wines (1) Located in New York) 4968 Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2004 Maume (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2006 Grand Poisots, L. Boillot half-bottle (3) Aux Etelois, Maume (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) Premier Cru, Maume (Wines Located in New York) (1) Les Grands Poisots, L. Boillot half-bottle (2) Above 3 bottles per lot $75-100 (Wines Located in New York) Above 10 half-bottles per lot $500-700 4969 Charmes Chambertin - Vintage 1990 and 8 bottles Mommessin (Wines Located in New York) 4962 Chambertin - Vintage 1990 2 bottles per lot $300-400 4970 Échézeaux - Vintage 1993 Clos de la Bousse d'Or, Pousse (2) Vieilles Vignes, Mongeard-Mugneret d'Or (Wines Located in New 2nl, 2sdc, 2scc, 1sos (Wines Located in New York) York) Clos des 60 Ouvrees, Pousse (2) 2 bottles per lot $350-480 d'Or (Wines Located in New York) 4971 Volnay Above 2 half-bottles per lot $650-850 - Vintage 2005 Vieilles Vignes, N. Potel half-bottle (3) and 8 bottles (Wines Located in New York) 4975 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2006 Vieilles Vignes, N. Potel half-bottle (12) - Vintage 2006 R. Arnoux (Wines Located in half-bottle (Wines Located in New York) (3) New York) Vosne Romanée - Vintage 2006 Vieilles Vignes, N. Potel half-bottle (12) Vosne Romanée (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 Les Chaumes, R. Arnoux (2) Above 27 half-bottles per lot $480-700 (Wines Located in New York) Above 3 half-bottles per lot $220-300 4972 Gevrey Chambertin and 2 bottles - Vintage 1990 Les Platieres, P. LeClerc (Wines Located in New (1) 4976 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 2007 York) Les Cailles, R. Chevillon (Wines Located in New (2) - Vintage 2005 York) La Combe Aux Moines, P. LeClerc (Wines Located (2) Les Vaucrains, R. Chevillon (Wines Located in (2) in New York) New York) (91-93pts BH) Above 3 bottles per lot $150-200 Above 4 bottles per lot $180-240

4973 Morey St. Denis 4977 Chambertin - Vintage 2002 - Vintage 1990 Clos de Bèze, T. Moillard 1vlstl (2) cuvée des Grives, Ponsot (Wines Located in New half- (Wines Located in New York) bottle (4) York) Gevrey Chambertin - Vintage 2004 - Vintage 1990 Vieilles Vignes, Serafin (Wines (2) cuvée des Alouettes, Ponsot (Wines Located in New (2) Located in New York) York) Above 4 bottles per lot $320-420 Above 4 half-bottles per lot $220-300 and 2 bottles 4978 Pommard - Vintage 2003 4974 Santenay Les Grands Epenots, Vieilles Vignes, V. Girardin (2) - Vintage 2005 Clos Tavannes, Pousse d'Or half-bottle (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) Les Rugiens, V. Guillemard (Wines Located in New (3) York) Volnay Above 5 bottles per lot $200-280 - Vintage 1990 Les Caillerets, 60 Ouvrees, (2) Pousse d'Or (Wines Located in 4979 Chablis New York) - Vintage 2006 Fourchaume, F. Gueguen half-bottle (2) - Vintage 2006 Clos d'Audignac, Pousse d'Or (2) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2007 Vaillons, C. Moreau (Wines half-bottle (2) 4983 Meursault Located in New York) Fichet - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle Meursault (9) - Vintage 2005 Genevrieres, Domaine Michelot (1) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (3)

Petit Chablis Above 12 half-bottles per lot $120-240 - Vintage 2005 Dauvissat-Camus (Wines (2) Located in New York) 4984 Meursault - Vintage 2003 Above 4 half-bottles per lot $140-220 Les Perrières, Germain (Wines Located in New York)(1) and 3 bottles - Vintage 2005 4980 Puligny Montrachet - Vintage 2005 Germain (Wines Located in New York) (1) Les Pucelles, Domaine Leflaive Le Limozin, Germain 1nl (Wines Located in New (2) (Wines Located in New York) York) "A very discreet touch of brioche highlights the much more reserved honeysuckle, anise, honeysuckle and Les Charmes, Germain (Wines Located in New York) (2) apricot aromas that are elegant, pure and wonderfully Above 6 bottles per lot $200-300 refined and dissolve into sweet, intense and unusually precise flavors that also reflect more minerality than I typically find in this wine as well, culminating in superb 4985 Beaune Blanc punch and energy. A terrific vintage for Pucelles and - Vintage 2000 Clos des Mouches, J. Drouhin (1) one to consider closely."(93pts BH) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $200-260 (91pts IWC)

4981 Meursault - Vintage 2005 Clos des Mouches, J. Drouhin half- - Vintage 2005 bottle (1) En La Barre, F. Jobard (Wines Located in New half- (Wines Located in New York) bottle (4) (91pts BH) York) Clos des Mouches, J. Drouhin (1) En La Barre, F. Jobard (Wines Located in New (2) (Wines Located in New York) York) (91pts BH) Les Poruzots, F. Jobard (Wines Located in New (1) York) Meursault - Vintage 2006 - Vintage 2005 J. Drouhin (Wines Located in half- bottle (2) En La Barre, F. Jobard (Wines Located in New half- bottle (3) New York) York) Above 3 half-bottles per lot $180-240 Above 7 half-bottles per lot $240-380 and 2 bottles and 3 bottles 4986 Chablis 4982 Chablis Montmains, L. Tribut - Vintage 2002 - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Fourchaume, Fevre (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) (2) (92pts IWC) Above 3 bottles per lot $60-90 - Vintage 2008 Fevre (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (1) 4987 Meursault Fourchaume, Fevre (Wines Located in New York) half- bottle (2) - Vintage 2004 Blagny, T. & P. Matrot (Wines Located in New half- Above 3 half-bottles per lot $80-110 bottle (3) and 1 bottle York) - Vintage 2006 Les Chevaliers, T. & P. Matrot 2lscl (Wines half-bottle Above 6 bottles per lot $260-380 (8) Located in New York) 4993 Châteauneuf du Pape Above 11 half-bottles per lot $220-320 - Vintage 2005 Château de Beaucastel (Wines (6) Located in New York) (94+pts) 4988 Chablis - Vintage 2002 La Forest, V. Dauvissat (Wines Located in New half- - Vintage 2006 Château de Beaucastel 1nc magnum (3) bottle (5) (Wines Located in New York) York) Les Clos, V. Dauvissat 1nl (Wines Located in New (2) - Vintage 2007 Château de Beaucastel (Wines (5) York) (94pts) Located in New York) (96pts) Sechet, V. Dauvissat (Wines Located in New York) (2) Châteauneuf du Pape Blanc Vaillons, V. Dauvissat 1lscl (Wines Located in (2) - Vintage 2008 Roussanne Vieilles Vignes, (1) New York) Château de Beaucastel (Wines Above 5 half-bottles per lot $480-650 Located in New York) and 6 bottles Above 12 bottles per lot $1000-1300 and 3 magnums 4989 Corton Charlemagne - Vintage 2005 V. Girardin (Wines Located in half- 4994 Châteauneuf du Pape bottle (3) cuvée du Baron, Château Fortia New York) - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (3) Vougeot Blanc - Vintage 2001 Clos du Prieure, Vougeraie (1) - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (6) (Wines Located in New York) Above 9 half-bottles per lot $160-240 Above 3 half-bottles per lot $150-220 and 1 bottle 4995 Châteauneuf du Pape Clos des Brusquieres 4990 Cornas - Vintage 2005 lscl (Wines Located in New half-bottle A. Clape (1) - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) (6) York) - Vintage 2007 1nl (Wines Located in New (2) - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (3) York) (93pts WS) - Vintage 2008 1nl (Wines Located in New (2) Above 4 half-bottles per lot $95-130 York) (93pts WS) 4996 Hermitage Above 10 bottles per lot $550-750 - Vintage 2003 Marquise de La Tourette, Delas Freres (Wines half- 4991 Cornas bottle (3) Chaillot, Allemand Located in New York) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2005 Bessards, Delas Freres (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Above 3 half-bottles per lot $260-380 Above 3 bottles per lot $280-380 and 2 bottles 4992 Châteauneuf du Pape 4997 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2005 - Vintage 2006 Vieilles Vignes, Domaine de la (3) cuvée des Felix, Bois de Boursan (Wines Located in (3) Janasse (Wines Located in New New York) (92pts IWC) York) (93pts) - Vintage 2007 Bosquet des Papes (Wines Located in New York) (3) - Vintage 2007 Domaine du Marcoux (Wines (2) Les Cailloux, cuvée Centenaire, L. & A. Brunel (3) Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 3 half-bottles per lot $280-380 Vieilles Vignes, Domaine de la (2) and 3 bottles Côte de L'Ange (Wines Located in New York) 5003 Châteauneuf du Pape Le Vieux Donjon Hermitage - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2004 Domaine des Martinelles 1nl (3) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) (3) Above 10 bottles per lot $380-500 - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (5) 4998 Châteauneuf du Pape cuvée Reservee, Domaine du Pegau 2nl (Wines Located in New (11) - Vintage 2005 1lwrl (Wines Located in (5) York) New York) (94pts WS) - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (3) York) (95pts) - Vintage 2007 2lscl (Wines Located in New (11) (Wines Located in New (14) York) (95pts) York) (95pts) Above 16 bottles per lot $850-1100 Above 8 half-bottles per lot $1400-2000 and 29 bottles 4999 Gigondas - Vintage 2006 5004 Hermitage - Vintage 2005 Domaine les Paillieres (Wines Located in New York) Le Greal, M. Sorrel half-bottle (10) (Wines Located in New York) "A solid, muscular style, packed with dark fig paste, - Vintage 2007 black currant, bittersweet cocoa, coffee, grilled beef Les Racines, Domaine les Paillieres (Wines Located (3) and loam notes, all carried by loamy tannins. Yet stays in New York) juicy on the finish, thanks to well-buried acidity."(93pts WS) Above 10 half-bottles per lot $190-320 2 bottles per lot $160-220 and 3 bottles

5005 Châteauneuf du Pape 5000 Côte Rôtie - Vintage 2006 - Vintage 2004 Faury cuvée du Quet, Mas de Boislauzon (Wines Located (3) (Wines Located in New York) in New York) 6 bottles per lot $200-280 - Vintage 2007 Mas de Boislauzon 1nl (Wines Located in New (6) 5001 Hermitage - Vintage 2006 York) J.L. Chave Special cuvée Tintot, Mas de Boislauzon (Wines (3) (Wines Located in New York) "... reminds me of Chave s brilliant 1991. An incredibly Located in New York) subtle perfume of black raspberries, creme de cassis, Above 12 bottles per lot $450-550 camphor, and acacia flowers is followed by an elegant, concentrated wine with beautifully integrated acidity, tannin, wood, and alcohol. This seamless, gorgeously- 5006 Châteauneuf du Pape proportioned, large-framed wine represents the Clos des Papes, P. Avril definition of finesse, elegance, and terroir."(96pts) - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New (3) 1 bottle per lot $150-200 York) (95pts) - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (5) 5002 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 York) (98pts) Les Cailloux, L. & A. Brunel (Wines Located in half- Above 5 half-bottles per lot $320-420 bottle (3) and 3 bottles New York) (93pts) 5007 Châteauneuf du Pape Above 17 bottles per lot $900-1200 Clos des Papes, P. Avril - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New half-bottle (4) 5012 Châteauneuf du Pape York) (98pts) - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New (11) cuvée Prestige, R. Sabon (Wines Located in New half- York) (98pts) bottle (8) York) - Vintage 2008 1lwisl, 4sos (Wines Located (4) in New York) (91pts) - Vintage 2006 Secret de Sabon, R. Sabon (Wines Located in New (3) Above 4 half-bottles per lot $1000-1300 York) and 15 bottles - Vintage 2007 cuvée Prestige, R. Sabon (Wines Located in New (18) 5008 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 York) (95pts) Clos des Papes, P. Avril (Wines Located in New York) Above 8 half-bottles per lot $1200-1700 "It exhibits what is probably the deepest color I have and 21 bottles ever seen here, and the finished alcohol is a high (for Clos des Papes) 15.5%. Still slightly restrained because 5013 Cornas - Vintage 2006 of its recent bottling, but wow, what potential complexity, mind-boggling richness, and compelling Reynard, T. Allemand flavor profile are apparent. It is a sublime expression of (Wines Located in New York) the art of winemaking as evidenced by its dense purple 4 bottles per lot $350-480 color and big, sweet kiss of kirsch, framboise, blackberries, licorice, roasted herbs, and smoked meat. It hits the palate with a fascinating combination of 5014 Jean Milan Vintage Champagne substance, power, full-bodied authority yet - Vintage 2002 Terres de Noel (Wines Located (3) extraordinary freshness, elegance, and in New York) precision."(99+pts) 6 bottles per lot $700-950 L. Aubry Fils Vintage Champagne - Vintage 2002 La Nombre d'Or Campanae (1) 5009 16 half-bottles per lot $900-1200 Veteres Vites Brut (Wines (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) Above 4 bottles per lot $200-260 5010 Hermitage - Vintage 2004 La Chapelle, P. Jaboulet 2lscl (Wines Located in (2) 5015 Bonnezeaux New York) (92pts) - Vintage 1989 La Chapelle, Fesles lbsl (Wines (1) La Petite Chapelle, P. Jaboulet (Wines Located in (1) Located in New York) New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $240-320 - Vintage 1990 La Chapelle, Fesles 3lbsl, 1nl, (3) 3sdc (Wines Located in New 5011 Châteauneuf du Pape York) - Vintage 2005 cuvée de Mon Aieul, P. Usseglio (Wines Located in (1) Chinon - Vintage 2005 New York) (93-95pts) Clos de la Dioterie, C. Joguet (Wines Located in (1) - Vintage 2006 New York) cuvée de Mon Aieul, P. Usseglio (Wines Located in (7) Clos du Chene Vert, C. Joguet (Wines Located in (2) New York) (96pts) New York) - Vintage 2007 Côteau de Noire, Alliet 2lscl (Wines Located in (3) P. Usseglio (Wines Located in New York) (93pts) (3) New York)

cuvée de Mon Aieul, P. Usseglio (Wines Located in (3) Sancerre New York) (100pts) - Vintage 2007 Clos la Neore, E. Vatan 3crc (3) - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) P. Usseglio (Wines Located in New York) (3) Above 13 bottles per lot $320-480 5016 Vouvray (Wines Located in New York) cuvée Constance, Huet "...exhibits rare elegance married to considerable flavor - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New (1) intensity as well as power. Normally a blend of 80% Sangiovese, 15% Cabernet Sauvignon, and 5% York) (99pts WS) Cabernet Franc aged in French oak for 12 months, the - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (2) 1999 offers up aromas of new saddle leather intertwined with black cherries, currants, creosote, - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New (3) vanilla, and spice box. Rich and medium-bodied, with adequate acidity as well as sweet but noticeable tannin, York) (96pts) it is the third consecutive exceptional vintage from this Above 6 500 mls per lot $420-550 reference winery for modern, aggressively-styled Tuscan reds."(91pts) 5017 Barolo - Vintage 2004 2 bottles per lot $180-240 A. Conterno (Wines Located in New York) 5023 Barolo - Vintage 2005 5 bottles per lot $150-200 Falletto di Serralunga, B. Giacosa (Wines Located in New York) 5018 Barbaresco - Vintage 1997 "...offers up a gorgeous bouquet of red cherries, flowers, spices and menthol. This is a relatively Brich Ronchi, A. Rocca delicate, elegant Barolo Falletto yet it offers gorgeous (Wines Located in New York) balance, tons of inner perfume and a long, refined "...is a tour de force in winemaking. Its dark plum/ruby finish."(94pts) color is accompanied by explosive blackberry/cherry 2 bottles per lot $200-260 fruit aromas. In the mouth, its viscous texture, low acidity, and overripe Nebbiolo characteristics provide remarkable intensity, and extraordinary flavor richness 5024 Barolo - Vintage 1999 with notes of blackberries, cherries, coffee, smoke, B. Mascarello licorice, and earth."(97pts) (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $120-160 "Aromas of leather, berry and tobacco follow through to a full-bodied palate, with sweet and ripe fruit, silky 5019 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1997 tannins and a long finish. Beauty.The genuine deal here."(93pts WS) Altesino (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $180-240 "Wonderfully floral aromas, with plenty of ripe fruit and hints of minerals and spices. Full-bodied and chunky, 5025 Barbaresco - Vintage 2004 with well-integrated tannins and a long finish. Fresh Rabaja, B. Rocca and refined."(91pts WS) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 3 bottles per lot $450-600

5020 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1997 5026 Barolo - Vintage 2001 Spuntali, Angelini Monvigliero, Burlotto (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 3 bottles per lot $150-200

5021 Brunello di Montalcino 5027 Barolo - Vintage 2004 - Vintage 1997 Pian Delle Vigne, Antinori (1) Monvigliero, Burlotto (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) (97pts WS) 10 bottles per lot $500-700

Guado Al Tasso 5028 Amarone - Vintage 1995 - Vintage 1997 Tenuta Belvedere, Antinori (2) TB, Bussola (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $190-260 3 bottles per lot $160-200

5022 Tignanello - Vintage 1999 5029 Amarone Antinori TB, Bussola 2 bottles per lot $130-180 - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New (2) York) (92pts) 5037 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Vigna di Pianrosso, Ciacci Piccolomini d'Aragona Above 3 bottles per lot $220-300 - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

- Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5030 Amarone - Vintage 1999 Above 2 bottles per lot $240-320 TB, Bussola (Wines Located in New York) 5038 Barolo - Vintage 2004 3 bottles per lot $200-260 Ciabot Mentin Ginestra, Clerico 1lwrl (Wines (2) Located in New York) 5031 Amarone - Vintage 2000 Pajana, Clerico (Wines Located in New York) (2) TB, Bussola (Wines Located in New York) Above 4 bottles per lot $240-320 2 bottles per lot $160-220 5039 Barolo - Vintage 1997 Percristina, Clerico 5032 Amarone 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) Vigneto Alto, TB, Bussola - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 2 bottles per lot $200-280

- Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New (1) 5040 Barolo - Vintage 2004 York) (92pts) Sori Ginestra, Conterno-Fantino - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (3) (Wines Located in New York) (95pts IWC) Above 5 bottles per lot $420-550 4 bottles per lot $320-450 5033 Vigna d'Alceo - Vintage 2000 Castello Dei Rampolla 5041 2 bottles per lot $160-220 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $90-120 5042 Barolo - Vintage 2004 E. Altare (Wines Located in New York) (2) 5034 Barolo - Vintage 2001 Vigna Arborina, E. Altare (Wines Located in New (1) Bricco Boschis, San Giuseppe Riserva, Cavallotto York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $450-600 Roero - Vintage 2004 Roche D'Ampsej, Correggia (3) 5035 Barolo - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) Bricco Rocche, Ceretto Above 6 bottles per lot $170-240 (Wines Located in New York) This is very raisiny, almost meaty, with an ultrarich nose. Full-bodied, showing sultana and dried flowers 5043 Barolo - Vintage 2004 on the palate, with chewy tannins. Very long and Casa Mate Ginestra, E. Grasso powerful on the finish. Almost Port-like. Hints of vanilla (Wines Located in New York) and sultana. A top Bricco Rocche.(96pts WS) 10 bottles per lot $500-650 3 bottles per lot $180-240

5044 Barbera d'Alba 5036 Barolo - Vintage 2000 - Vintage 2006 Cascina Francia, G. Conterno (2) Bricco Rocche Brunate, Ceretto (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "So beautiful on the nose, with blackberries, fresh (93pts) mushroom and leather. Full-bodied, with ultravelvety tannins and decadent, ripe fruit on the palate. Long and - Vintage 2007 Cascina Francia, G. Conterno (2) opulent. Like eating foie gras."(94pts WS) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2008 Cerretta, G. Conterno (Wines (3) 5 bottles per lot $500-700 Located in New York) 5050 Barolo Barolo Sperss, Gaja - Vintage 2000 Cascina Francia, G. Conterno (1) - Vintage 1990 (Wines Located in New (1) (Wines Located in New York) York) (95pts) (94pts) - Vintage 1996 2nl (Wines Located in New (2) York) (94-6pts) Nebbiolo Above 3 bottles per lot $550-750 - Vintage 2008 Cerretta, G. Conterno 2novl (3) (Wines Located in New York) 5051 Barbaresco - Vintage 2004 Above 11 bottles per lot $400-550 Vicenziana, Giamello (Wines Located in New York) 5045 Barbera d'Alba 6 bottles per lot $150-200 - Vintage 2005 Codana, G. Mascarello (Wines (2) Located in New York) 5052 Barolo - Vintage 1998 Cannubi Boschis, L. Sandrone Barolo (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 Monprivato, G. Mascarello (3) "The deep ruby/purple-colored 1998 Barolo Cannubi (Wines Located in New York) Boschis boasts a spectacular bouquet of mineral- infused black cherry liqueur, new saddle leather, and Above 5 bottles per lot $240-320 pain grille. This powerful, ripe 1998 offers full-bodied flavors, silky tannin, low acidity, gorgeous levels of 5046 Barolo - Vintage 2001 glycerin, and a creamy mouthful of complex, layered, Ca' del Morissio, Monprivato Riserva, G. Mascarello superbly pure Nebbiolo fruit."(94-6pts) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $110-150 2 bottles per lot $500-700 5053 Barolo - Vintage 2004 5047 Barolo - Vintage 2004 Cannubi Boschis, L. Sandrone Monprivato, G. Mascarello (Wines Located in New York) "A translucent dark ruby, this weightless yet sumptuous (Wines Located in New York) Barolo bursts from the glass with layers of dark ripe "...is an explosive wine with an almost Pinot-like fruit that coat the palate with stunning grace and expression of purity in its fruit. This round, sweet elegance. As it sits in the glass notes of licorice, tar and Barolo is extremely primary at this stage, with tons of sweet toasted oak gradually emerge to complete this dense fruit that almost cover the wine's tannins magnificent wine."(98pts) completely. Subtle overtones of roses and tar develop in the glass, rounding out this majestic wine. Monprivato 3 bottles per lot $450-600 is one of the world's very finest values in collectible, age-worthy wine, and the 2004 is another classic in the 5054 Barolo - Vintage 1997 making."(96pts) Le Vigne, L. Sandrone 4 bottles per lot $350-480 (Wines Located in New York) "The 1997 Barolo Le Vigne's saturated ruby/purple 5048 Alzero color is accompanied by a terrific nose of blackberries - Vintage 1994 G. Quintarelli (Wines Located (2) and cherry fruit intertwined with minerals and spice. The wine possesses amazing levels of glycerin, low in New York) acidity, lofty alcohol, and good fatness. This powerful, concentrated Barolo should be at its finest between Secco Ca' Del Merlo 2003-2018."(94pts) - Vintage 2005 G. Quintarelli (Wines Located (1) 2 bottles per lot $240-320 in New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $600-850 5055 Barolo - Vintage 1998 Le Vigne, L. Sandrone 5049 Barolo - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) Brunate le Coste, G. Rinaldi "The multidimensional 1998 Barolo Le Vigne possesses (Wines Located in New York) huge layers of black cherry fruit infused with rose petals, tar, balsam wood, mineral, and subtle new oak 5062 Barolo notes. Full-bodied, awesomely concentrated, and - Vintage 2004 extraordinarily pure..."(95pts) Brunate, Marcarini 2nl (Wines Located in New York) (2) 2 magnums per lot $420-600 La Serra, Marcarini 1lscl (Wines Located in New (3) 5056 Barbaresco - Vintage 1997 York) Gallina, La Spinetta - Vintage 2005 2nl (Wines Located in New York) Brunate, Marcarini (Wines Located in New York) (3) 2 bottles per lot $140-180 La Serra, Marcarini 3lwrl (Wines Located in New (3) 5057 Barbaresco - Vintage 2004 York) Gallina, La Spinetta Above 11 bottles per lot $420-600 (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $170-220 5063 Le Pergole Torte - Vintage 1997 Montevertine 5058 Barbaresco (Wines Located in New York) Starderi, La Spinetta "Class in a glass. Dark ruby color. Aromas of blackberries, mineral, grilled meat follow through to a - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (2) full-bodied, very tight tannin structure, with a chewy finish."(93pts WS) - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (2) 2 bottles per lot $240-320 Above 4 bottles per lot $220-300

5064 Barolo - Vintage 2004 5059 Scrio Syrah - Vintage 1997 Mariondino, Parusso 3lscl (Wines Located in New (3) Le Macchiole York) (Wines Located in New York) Mosconi, Parusso (Wines Located in New York) (3) "You get it all here. Terrific. Black in color, with black licorice, blackberry, raspberry and mineral aromas. Above 6 bottles per lot $240-320 Full-bodied, with masses of polished tannins that coat the mouth, yet it's so fine and polished. Syrah."(96pts 5065 Barolo - Vintage 2004 WS) Pio Cesare (Wines Located in New York) (3) 2 bottles per lot $150-200 Bussia Darda le Rose, Podere Colla (Wines (3) Located in New York) 5060 Saffredi Above 6 bottles per lot $190-260 Le Pupille - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New (2) 5066 Barbaresco York) (96pts) - Vintage 2001 Bric Turot, Prunotto 2lscl (3) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (2) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New (2) York) (94pts WS) - Vintage 2004 Bric Turot, Prunotto 1nl (4) (Wines Located in New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $450-600

Barbera d'Alba 5061 Barbaresco - Vintage 2001 Costamiole, Prunotto 2lscl (2) - Vintage 1997 Martinenga, Camp Gros, (1) (Wines Located in New York) Marchesi di Gresy (Wines Located in New York) Barolo - Vintage 2001 Bussia, Prunotto (Wines (3) Barolo Located in New York) - Vintage 2001 Torriglione, M. Gagliasso (3) - Vintage 2004 Bussia, Prunotto 4nl (Wines (4) (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) Above 4 bottles per lot $140-220 Above 16 bottles per lot $600-900 5067 Barolo 5072 Barbaresco - Vintage 2004 - Vintage 2004 Curra, Sottimano (Wines Located in New York) (3) Conca, Ratti (Wines Located in New York) (6) Pajore, Sottimano 1nl (Wines Located in New York) (3) Marcenasco, Ratti 3lscl (Wines Located in New (6) Above 6 bottles per lot $260-380 York) - Vintage 2005 5073 Ornellaia - Vintage 1997 Rocche, Ratti (Wines Located in New York) (6) Tenuta dell' Ornellaia Above 18 bottles per lot $650-900 (Wines Located in New York) "This Tuscan gem is black in color, with complex aromas of black currants, minerals and wet earth. Full- 5068 Barbaresco bodied, with lots of tannins, but very polished. Long, - Vintage 2004 Montefico, Roagna (Wines (3) long finish."(96pts WS) Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $400-500

Montevetrano 5074 Ornellaia - Vintage 1998 - Vintage 1997 S. Imparato 2lscl (Wines (2) Tenuta dell' Ornellaia Located in New York) (95pts) (Wines Located in New York) "A cool and sleek Tuscan red, with tarragon and fresh - Vintage 1998 S. Imparato 2lscl (Wines (2) sage aromas, blackberry and cherry undertones. Full- Located in New York) (92pts) bodied, with a wonderfully silky palate of fine tannins and a long, fruity finish. Very sophisticated and reserved."(96pts, Wine of the Year, WS) - Vintage 2000 S. Imparato lscl (Wines (1) Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $320-420 Above 8 bottles per lot $420-550 5075 Sassicaia - Vintage 1999 Tenuta San Guido 5069 Barolo - Vintage 2004 2lscl (Wines Located in New York) Persiera, Saffirio "Complex aromas of minerals, berries, tobacco and (Wines Located in New York) shells. Full-bodied, with well-integrated tannins and a 8 bottles per lot $320-480 succulent, refined aftertaste. A pretty Sass."(92pts WS) 2 bottles per lot $350-480 5070 Percarlo - Vintage 1997 San Giusto a Rentennano 5076 Giusto dei Notri 2lbsl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1999 Tua Rita (Wines Located in (2) "Enormous in aromas, flavors, and persistence on the New York) (96pts) palate, it exhibits profound levels of concentration as - Vintage 2000 Tua Rita (Wines Located in (3) well as unbelievably dense, black currant, blackberry liqueur notes infused with new saddle leather, licorice, New York) (95pts) truffles, and toasty oak. Enormously thick and viscous, - Vintage 2001 Tua Rita (Wines Located in (2) with low acidity, and mouthcoating levels of extract, New York) (97pts) this wine's tannin level is high, but largely obscured by the wealth of fruit, glycerin, and extract. It is an amazing accomplishment!..."(98pts) Redigaffi 2 bottles per lot $300-400 - Vintage 2004 Tua Rita (Wines Located in (2) New York) (98pts WS) 5071 Barolo Above 9 bottles per lot $700-900 - Vintage 1999 Riserva, Schiavenza (Wines (3) Located in New York) (92pts) 5077 Brunello di Montalcino - Vintage 2001 Valdicava Brunello di Montalcino (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1995 Siro Pacenti 2lscl (Wines (2) "Black hued, with intense aromas of crushed berries Located in New York) and licorice with hints of oak. Full-bodied, with loads of fruit, velvety tannins and a long, long finish. Superb. Above 5 bottles per lot $160-220 One of the best Brunellos I have had in a long time."(98pts WS) 3 bottles per lot $300-420 - Vintage 1991 Torre Muga Reserva, Bodegas Muga nl (Wines (1) 5078 Barbaresco Located in New York) - Vintage 2005 Masseria, Vietti (Wines (2) Above 3 bottles per lot $220-300 Located in New York) 5085 Rioja - Vintage 1976 Barbera d'Alba Vina Real, Gran Reserva, CVNE - Vintage 2005 Scarrone, Vigna Vecchia, Vietti (1) 2stl, 1excellent color and condition (Wines (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $95-130 3 bottles per lot $350-480

5079 Dominio de Pingus - Vintage 2003 5086 Ribera del Duero - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) cuvée Janus, Reserva, Pesquera 1bn (Wines (2) "A candidate for perfection, the profound 2003 Pingus Located in New York) (97pts) possesses an awesome smoky, blackberry, and cassis- scented nose intermixed with hints of espresso roast, Reserva Especial, Pesquera 4ts, 2vltl, 4sos (Wines (4) lead pencil shavings, cedar, and subtle new oak. Located in New York) Sensational concentration, a seamless integration of Above 6 bottles per lot $420-600 acidity, tannin, alcohol, and wood, and a blockbuster finish lasting nearly a minute result in one of the most profound wines ever made in Spain. It should age 5087 B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage effortlessly for two decades or more."(96-100pts) 1985 1 bottle per lot $400-600 2lbsl, 2wrvl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $120-160 5080 Dominio de Pingus - Vintage 2005 Amelia 5088 Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1991 (Wines Located in New (2) 1 bottle per lot $220-300 York) (95pts) - Vintage 1992 (Wines Located in New (2) 5081 Dominio de Pingus - Vintage 2006 York) (96pts) Amelia - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New (2) 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) York) (94pts) 3 bottles per lot $700-950 - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New (2) York) (94pts) 5082 Dominio de Pingus - Vintage 2007 Above 8 bottles per lot $600-800 Psi (Wines Located in New York) 5089 Dominus 12 bottles per lot $280-400 - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New (2) York) (99pts) 5083 Castilla y Leon - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New (2) - Vintage 2003 Petalos, Descendientes de Jose (2) York) (95pts) Palacios (Wines Located in - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New (2) New York) York) (94pts) Above 6 bottles per lot $900-1300 Vega Sicilia Valbuena 5* - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5090 Joseph Phelps Winery - Vintage 1994 Above 3 bottles per lot $130-180 Insignia bn (Wines Located in New York) 5084 Rioja "...is spectacular. I have had the wine a half-dozen or - Vintage 1976 more times, and it is unquestionably opulent, sexy, flamboyant, explosively rich, concentrated, and a thrill Prado Enea Gran Reserva, Bodegas Muga excellent (2) to drink. Already gorgeous, it promises to evolve color (Wines Located in New York) gracefully for two decades or more. The color is a healthy saturated dark purple. The spicy nose offers 2 bottles per lot $150-200 aromas of black currants, allspice, pain grille, and soy, with scents of a burning wood fire thrown in for additional complexity."(96pts) 5096 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) 1 magnum per lot $350-500 "A dazzling wine, sleek and sophisticated, with beautiful ripe fruit purity. It has rich currant, Crème de cassis, 5091 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 light mocha and herb shadings and a silky-smooth Hillside Select texture that firms on the finish as the tannins make their (Wines Located in New York) presence more evident."(94pts WS) "...is a candidate for wine of the vintage. It continues to 2 bottles per lot $120-160 gain weight, and is better each time I retaste it. Its opaque purple color is accompanied by gorgeous 5097 Pahlmeyer Merlot - Vintage 2001 aromas of graphite, vanilla, black currant liqueur, and minerals. This rich, full-bodied Cabernet offers sweet 1x6 bottle ocb (Wines Located in New York) tannin, a layered texture, and a finish that lasts for 45- 6 bottles per lot $380-480 50 seconds."(95pts)

3 bottles per lot $320-450 5098 Domaine Drouhin Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) (3) 5092 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 Hillside Select - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) (3) (Wines Located in New York) Above 6 bottles per lot $120-180 "...one of the finest wines of the vintage. A saturated opaque purple color is followed by scents of vanilla, 5099 Domaine Drouhin Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 blackberry liqueur, crushed minerals, and a hint of white flowers. There is stunning intensity, tremendous cuvée Laurene purity, full body, and a remarkable, seamless (Wines Located in New York) finish..."(97pts) 5 bottles per lot $200-260 2 bottles per lot $350-500 5100 Domaine Drouhin Pinot Noir - Vintage 2005 5093 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1994 cuvée Louise (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...begins with a gush of pure blueberry, black- raspberry, cassis, and spicy, cinnamon-like aromas 3 bottles per lot $220-300 judiciously touched by toasty new oak. The wine's impeccable balance, fabulous ripeness, and well- 5101 Domaine Drouhin Pinot Noir - Vintage 1999 integrated acidity and tannin result in a sumptuous Laurene glass of vibrantly fresh, pure, youthful Napa Cabernet."(93pts) 2x1 magnum owc's (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $200-240 2 magnums per lot $160-220

5094 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1995 5102 Evesham Wood Pinot Noir (Wines Located in New York) cuvée J "...appears to cram everything into its suave, fabulously - Vintage 2002 2vlwisl (Wines Located in (3) concentrated, rich, intense personality. Although New York) (92pts BH) highly-extracted, the wine manages to avoid being a weighty or fatiguing style of Cabernet. The tannin is sweet, and the acidity offers vibrancy and delineation, - Vintage 2005 (Wines Located in New York) (3) but no sharpness."(92-95pts) Above 6 bottles per lot $160-220 3 bottles per lot $200-260 5103 Eyrie Reserve Pinot Noir - Vintage 2002 5095 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 3 bottles per lot $90-120 "The deep ruby/purple-colored 1997 Cabernet Sauvignon (4,800 cases) reveals a Bordeaux-like, lead 5104 Ken Wright Cellars Pinot Noir pencil and black currant-scented nose with nuances of spice, cedar, and minerals. Medium-bodied and elegant, - Vintage 2005 Carter Vineyard lscl (Wines (1) with graceful flavors and fine balance, this suave wine Located in New York) should age nicely for 15 or more years."(93pts) St. Innocent Pinot Noir 5114 Château Figeac - Vintage 2000 - Vintage 2008 Justice Vineyard (Wines (1) St. Emilion Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $50-70 "Wild, expressive aromas of black raspberry, cedar, lead pencil, mocha, coffee and animal fur. Fat, silky and lush yet dry; a thick, round Figeac with impressive 5105 St. Innocent Pinot Noir - Vintage 2008 volume. Even the merlot in 2000 showed solid structure. Shea Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (3) Like the 2001, this shows an intriguing burnt note. Finishes with big but suave tannins and lingering notes Temperance Hill Vineyard (Wines Located in New (3) of cherry, chocolate and black olive."(91pts IWC) York) 1 bottle per lot $110-150 White Rose Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (2) 5115 Nuits St. Georges - Vintage 1996 Above 8 bottles per lot $200-260 Clos des Corvees, Prieure Roch lscl (Wines Located in New York) 5106 Cockburn Port - Vintage 1983 8lbsl, 8nl (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $80-110 8 bottles per lot $300-400 5116 Chorey Côte de Beaune - Vintage 1996 Tollot-Beaut 5107 D'Oliveras Boal Reserva - Vintage 1977 1nl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $60-80 4 bottles per lot $400-550

5117 Châteauneuf du Pape 5108 D'Oliveras Madeira - Vintage 1957 - Vintage 1998 L. Bernard (Wines Located in (1) Terrantez Reserva New York) 2crc (Wines Located in New York) Trintignant 1vlstl, 1sdc (Wines (2) 2 bottles per lot $300-400 Located in New York)

5109 Quinta do Noval Vintage Port - Vintage 2003 - Vintage 1999 Les Sinards, Perrin & Fils (1) (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 8 bottles per lot $400-550 Côtes du Rhône 5110 Royal Oporto Vintage Port - Vintage 1944 - Vintage 1998 Coudoulet de Beaucastel, (1) Colheita Château de Beaucastel lgsl 6lbsl, 6lscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $700-950 Above 5 bottles per lot $150-200

5111 Taylor Fladgate Vintage Port - Vintage 2003 5118 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2001 1nl (Wines Located in New York) Vieilles Vignes, E. Texier 3 bottles per lot $170-220 2ll, 1stl (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $60-80 5112 Taylor Fladgate Vintage Port - Vintage 1968 Quinta de Vargellas 5119 Châteauneuf du Pape 2bn, 1wisl, 1hcrc, 1 rewaxed capsule (Wines - Vintage 2000 Located in New York) Marquis, P. Lesec (Wines Located in New York) (1) 3 bottles per lot $180-240 ______- Vintage 2003 Grande Garde, St. Benoit lscl (Wines Located in (1) 5113 Château Cantemerle - Vintage 1996 New York) Haut Medoc Above 2 bottles per lot $50-70 nl (Wines Located in New York)

1 bottle per lot $50-70 5120 Francois Montand Champagne - Vintage NV (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1991 Reserva Especial, Castillo (1) Ygay, Marques de Murrieta Avignonesi Merlot (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1998 Desiderio nl (Wines Located in (1) Above 3 bottles per lot $110-150 New York) 5125 Aetna Springs Cabernet Sauvignon Berlucchi Guido - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage NV Blanco Imperiale lscl (Wines (1) Located in New York) Altamura Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Brachetto d'Acqui - Vintage 2006 Rosa Regal, Castello Banfi half-bottle Amizetta Cabernet Sauvignon (1) - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York)

Above 1 half-bottle per lot $60-90 Barnett Cabernet Sauvignon and 3 bottles - Vintage 1999 Spring Mountain District (1) (Wines Located in New York) 5121 Pinot Grigio Above 4 bottles per lot $90-130 - Vintage 2004 Masianco, Masi (Wines (1) Located in New York) 5126 Amizetta Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 Sfursat 5 Stelle (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 Nino Negri (Wines Located in (1) 11 bottles per lot $240-320 New York)

Above 2 bottles per lot $25-40 5127 B.V. Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 5122 Barolo - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) Piccole Vigne, Parusso nl (Wines Located in New (1) "...boasts a dense ruby/purple color in addition to a York) beautifully sweet nose of spicy oak intermixed with black cherries and currants."(90pts) Vigneto Cerequio, Beni di Batasiolo (Wines (1) 5 bottles per lot $280-380 Located in New York) Above 2 bottles per lot $75-100 5128 Barnett Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 Spring Mountain District 5123 Brunello di Montalcino (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 Castello Banfi (Wines Located (1) 12 bottles per lot $600-800 in New York) (94pts WS)

5129 Bond - Vintage 2000 L'Insieme Melbury - Vintage 1997 La Morra, E. Altare (Wines (1) (Wines Located in New York) Located in New York) (90pts) Above 2 bottles per lot $120-160 2 bottles per lot $300-400

5124 Navarra 5130 Caldwell Red - Vintage 1994 Gran Feudo Reserva, Bodegas (1) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Julian Chivite lscl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2000 1nl (Wines Located in New (2) York) Rioja Above 3 bottles per lot $80-110 - Vintage 1990 Conde de Valdemar Reserva, (1) Valdemar (Wines Located in 5131 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon New York) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Chappellet Cabernet Sauvignon Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 Pritchard Hill (Wines Located (1) - Vintage 2000 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) in New York) York) Above 2 bottles per lot $90-120 Above 3 bottles per lot $65-95

5132 Château Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 5137 Darioush Cabernet Sauvignon 1998 - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (4) (Wines Located in New York) "...will disprove all the naysayers about how bad the - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (2) vintage was in the North Coast. It possesses an opaque ruby/purple color, a gorgeous perfume of loamy soil, - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New (1) new saddle leather, chocolate, and black cherry and York) (90pts) black currant fruit, full body, and ripe tannin in the finish."(93pts) Above 7 bottles per lot $170-220 7 bottles per lot $350-480 5138 David Arthur Cabernet Sauvignon 5133 Château St. Jean Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Cinq Cepages (Wines Located in New York) David Arthur Meritaggio "...offering a mix of ripe, rich, fleshy currant and - Vintage 2002 lwisl (Wines Located in New (1) blackberry fruit, with hints of herb, olive and sage. York) Finishes with a firm, structured backbone and ripe tannins giving it depth and richness."(96pts WS) Above 3 bottles per lot $75-100 5 bottles per lot $120-160 5139 Delectus Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 GIII (Wines Located in New (1) 5134 Clos Pegase Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1993 York) 2lscl, 1lwasl, 1nl (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $240-320 Duckhorn Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5135 Clos du Bois Red Above 2 bottles per lot $90-130 - Vintage 1997 Marlstone Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) 5140 Diamond Terrace Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 Clos Pegase Reserve Claret 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1996 Pegase Circle Reserve lscl (1) 7 bottles per lot $140-180 (Wines Located in New York)

5141 Egelhoff Cabernet Sauvignon Cloud View Red - Vintage 2001 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (4) York)

Constant Red Ehlers Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 Diamond Mountain Vineyard (1) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (2) (Wines Located in New York)

Above 7 bottles per lot $170-240 EMH Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 Black Cat (Wines Located in (2) 5136 Cornerstone Cabernet Sauvignon New York) - Vintage 1996 Black Sears Vineyard lbsl, nl (1) Above 5 bottles per lot $180-240 (Wines Located in New York)

5142 Far Niente Cabernet Sauvignon Crauford Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1991 - Vintage 2000 Tatto Marcon Vineyard (Wines (1) (Wines Located in New York) (1) Located in New York) - Vintage 1993 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5150 Hewitt Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage - Vintage 1994 2002 1ltl (Wines Located in New York) (2) 3lscl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 3 bottles per lot $180-240 Cave Collection (Wines Located in New York) (2) 5151 Honig Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 7 bottles per lot $300-420 J. Lohr Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 Hilltop Vineyard (Wines (1) 5143 Fisher Vineyards - Vintage 1999 Located in New York) Coach Insignia (Wines Located in New York) Jessandra Vittoria Cabernet Sauvignon 2 bottles per lot $120-160 - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

5144 Flora Springs Cabernet Sauvignon Joel Gott Cabernet Sauvignon Wild Boar Vineyard - Vintage 2001 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (1) York)

- Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Justin Cabernet Sauvignon Above 3 bottles per lot $80-110 - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 5 bottles per lot $80-130 5145 Frank Family Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) 5152 Ilsley Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 York) (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $100-130 Groth Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5153 Kamen Cabernet Sauvignon Above 2 bottles per lot $60-90 - Vintage 2001 4lscl (Wines Located in New (5) York) 5146 Groth Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) Kelham Cabernet Sauvignon 7 bottles per lot $160-220 - Vintage 1999 nl (Wines Located in New (1) York) 5147 Hall Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Kobalt Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 sdc (Wines Located in New (1) Hanna Cabernet Sauvignon York) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (5) Above 7 bottles per lot $130-200 Krupp Brothers Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2003 Stagecoach Vineyard (Wines (1) 5148 Hartwell Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 8 bottles per lot $280-380 4 bottles per lot $200-280 5154 L'Aventure Estate cuvée 5149 Heitz Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Bella Oaks Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (1) La Jota Cabernet Sauvignon Trailside Vineyard (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1999 Howell Mountain lwrl (Wines (1) Above 2 bottles per lot $100-140 Located in New York) Laird Family Cabernet Sauvignon 5159 Melka Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2001 CJ (Wines Located in New (2) York) Larkin Cabernet Franc - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Merryvale Cabernet Sauvignon Above 5 bottles per lot $100-150 - Vintage 1997 Beckstoffer Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) 5155 Lewis Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Merryvale Red - Vintage 1999 Profile (Wines Located in New (2) Lewis Cellars Red York) - Vintage 2000 Alec's Blend (Wines Located in (2) Above 5 bottles per lot $190-260 New York) Above 3 bottles per lot $95-130 5160 Merryvale Red - Vintage 1997 Profile 5156 Liberty School Cabernet Sauvignon (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1994 1nl (Wines Located in New (21) "Massive, with wonderful richness, depth and concentration, this Cabernet blend has layers of York) complex currant, black cherry, plum, vanilla and - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (4) blackberry and a long, detailed, firmly tannic finish."(97pts WS) Above 25 bottles per lot $350-500 12 bottles per lot $750-1000 5157 Liparita Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1996 Howell Mountain 1nl (Wines (2) 5161 Merryvale Red - Vintage 1999 Located in New York) Profile 10lscl (Wines Located in New York) Livingston Cabernet Sauvignon 12 bottles per lot $500-650 - Vintage 1999 Stanley's Selection (Wines (1) Located in New York) 5162 Merryvale Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Lockwood Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) Miner Family Cabernet Sauvignon York) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

Long Meadow Ranch Cabernet Sauvignon Moraga Red - Vintage 1998 nl (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 1998 Bel Air lscl (Wines Located in (1) York) New York) Above 4 bottles per lot $180-260 Longboard Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 Rochioli Vineyard (Wines (1) 5163 Mount Veeder Reserve Red Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 1lscl (Wines Located in New (3) York) Lynch Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Neal Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Mayo Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Neiman Red Above 8 bottles per lot $180-260 - Vintage 2000 Caldwell Vineyard 6lscl (Wines (6) Located in New York) 5158 Matriarch Red - Vintage 2000 Above 10 bottles per lot $200-280 (Wines Located in New York) 2 bottles per lot $120-160 5164 Oakford Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Regusci Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 2lscl (Wines Located in New (2) - Vintage 1998 1nl (Wines Located in New (5) York) York) Reynold's Family Cabernet Sauvignon Oakville Ranch Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1994 1lscl (Wines Located in New (2) Above 8 bottles per lot $170-240 York)

Above 8 bottles per lot $170-220 5169 Paul Hobbs Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 Napa Valley 5165 Opus One - Vintage 1998 1lscl (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 5 bottles per lot $150-220 1 bottle per lot $220-300 5170 Peter Michael Red - Vintage 1999 5166 Pahlmeyer Red - Vintage 1998 Les Pavots (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "...one of California's finest meritage wines. It is a "Deliciously rich, smooth and polished. Deeply blend of 74% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Merlot, and the concentrated, with layers of currant, blackberry, mocha rest small dollops of Cabernet Franc, Petit Verdot, and and vanilla. Beautifully focused and deftly balanced, the Malbec. There are limited quantities of the 1998 flavors run on and on. Best from 2004 through Proprietary Red...full-bodied, intense, and 2013."(96pts WS) concentrated...reveals greater richness, ripeness, and unctuosity...Dark purple-colored, with copious amounts 1 bottle per lot $90-120 of flashy coffee, black currant, prune, chocolate, and jammy notes, this multidimensional, full-bodied, highly- 5171 Ritchie Creek Cabernet Sauvignon extracted wine is beautifully balanced..."(91pts) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 8 bottles per lot $400-600 Robert Mondavi Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon 5167 Pahlmeyer Red - Vintage 2000 - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) (94pts WS) "Wonderful richness, complexity and concentration, with layers of mouthcoating dark fruits centered around currant, plum, blackberry and even a trace of prune. Robinson Family Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Finishes with a long gush of ripe fruit and ripe tannins - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) that ease into the elegant aftertaste."(92pts) 5 bottles per lot $300-400 Rubicon Estate Red - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5168 Paoletti Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) S. Anderson Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Paul Hobbs Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1996 Hyde Vineyard 1ltl (Wines (1) Salvestrin Cabernet Sauvignon Located in New York) - Vintage 1999 Salvestrin Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) Pine Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 SLD (Wines Located in New (1) School House Red York) - Vintage 1999 Mescolanza (Wines Located in (1) New York) Preston Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Schweiger Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Pride Mountain Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Sequoia Grove Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon (90pts) - Vintage 1996 nl (Wines Located in New (1) York) Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 Cask 23 (Wines Located in (1) Sherwin Family Cabernet Sauvignon New York) (93pts WS) - Vintage 2000 Spring Mountain District (1) (Wines Located in New York) Steltzner Red Above 10 bottles per lot $220-320 - Vintage 1999 Three Lab cuvée (Wines (1) Located in New York) 5172 S.P. Drummer - Vintage 2001 Blair Vineyard Tara Bella Cabernet Sauvignon (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (6) 12 bottles per lot $140-190 Tara Bella Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5173 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1991 The Terraces Cabernet Sauvignon SLD (Wines Located in New York) (2) - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Truchard Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 - Vintage 1994 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 1nl (Wines Located in New York) (3) Above 7 bottles per lot $260-350 - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (3)

5174 Showket Cabernet Sauvignon Turnbull Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 7lscl (Wines Located in New (12) - Vintage 1999 1lscl (Wines Located in New (3) York) York) - Vintage 1999 lwrl (Wines Located in New (1) York) V. Sattui Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 2lscl (Wines Located in New (2) - Vintage 1992 Suzanne's Vineyard (Wines (1) York) Located in New York) - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (6) Above 19 bottles per lot $380-500 Above 21 bottles per lot $550-750 5177 Viader Red 5175 Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 1994 York) (97pts WS) Napa Valley vlscl (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (93pts) - Vintage 1999 wc (Wines Located in New (1) - Vintage 1995 York) (94pts WS) Alexander Valley (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (94pts) - Vintage 1996 - Vintage 2001 1nl (Wines Located in New (9) Napa Valley (Wines Located in New York) (91pts) (2) York)

- Vintage 1997 Above 13 bottles per lot $600-800 Napa Valley (Wines Located in New York) (94pts) (2) 5178 Vineyard 29 Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Alexander Valley (Wines Located in New York) (6) Above 12 bottles per lot $700-950 Von Strasser Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 Diamond Mountain 2nl (Wines (2) 5176 Simi Cabernet Sauvignon Located in New York) - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2001 Post Vineyard (Wines Located (1) in New York) 5181 Clos du Bois Merlot - Vintage 1998 3sdc, 2lscl (Wines Located in (3) Whitehall Lane Cabernet Sauvignon New York) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Clos Pegase Cabernet Franc - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1996 Pegase Circle Reserve sdc (1) (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 8 bottles per lot $240-320 Clos Pegase Merlot - Vintage 1994 1lscl (Wines Located in New (8) 5179 Wing Canyon Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon - York) Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) Clos Pegase Pinot Noir 7 bottles per lot $140-190 - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 13 bottles per lot $260-350 5180 Wolf Family Red - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5182 Crauford Zinfandel Kilt Lifter - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) York Creek Meritage - Vintage 2001 2vlscl, 1nl (Wines Located in (5) Ferrari Carano Merlot New York) - Vintage 2009 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

Behrens & Hitchcock Syrah Franciscan Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 Homage to Ed Oliveira, Alder (1) - Vintage 1994 Magnificat (Wines Located in (1) Springs Vineyard (Wines New York) Located in New York)

Judd's Hill Red - Vintage 2003 Chien Lunatique (Wines (2) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (3) Located in New York)

Justin Cabernet Franc Bell Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 Justification (Wines Located in (1) - Vintage 1999 Reserve Clone 6 (Wines (1) New York) Located in New York)

La Crema Pinot Noir Bouchet Cellars Caberbet Sauvignon - Vintage 2006 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

La Jota Cabernet Franc Brown Estate Zinfandel - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (3)

Lamborn Family Zinfandel C.G. Di Arie Petite Syrah - Vintage 2001 The Cork Report (Wines (1) - Vintage 2004 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) Located in New York) York) - Vintage 2006 Serendipity (Wines Located in (1) Charter Oak Zinfandel New York) - Vintage 2000 Monte Rosso Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) Lewis Cellars Merlot - Vintage 1993 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Claudius Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Linne Calodo Cellars Red - Vintage 2005 Problem Child lbsl (Wines (1) Above 17 bottles per lot $320-500 Located in New York) Above 13 bottles per lot $220-350 Silver Ridge Merlot - Vintage 1995 Barrel Select (Wines Located in (1) 5183 Martinelli Pinot Noir New York) - Vintage 2006 Moonshine Ranch (Wines (1) Located in New York) Toasted Head Red - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Martinelli Zinfandel - Vintage 2002 Jackass Vineyard (Wines (1) Trinitas Zinfandel Located in New York) - Vintage 2002 Bigalow Vineyard (Wines (4) Located in New York) McKenzie-Mueller Merlot - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Truchard Pinot Noir - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Melka Red - Vintage 1999 Sand Hill lscl (Wines Located (1) - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) half-bottle (1) in New York)

Turley Zinfandel Nickel & Nickel Syrah - Vintage 2002 Dragon Vineyard (Wines (1) - Vintage 2001 Dyer Vineyard (Wines Located (3) Located in New York) in New York)

Walter Hansel Pinot Noir Page Cellars Red - Vintage 2005 The North Slope (Wines (1) - Vintage 1999 1nl (Wines Located in New (2) Located in New York) York) Above 1 half-bottle per lot $240-350 Paloma Merlot and 14 bottles - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (93pts WS) 5186 Alban Vineyards Viognier - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (1) (90pts WS) Cambria Chardonnay Above 11 bottles per lot $280-420 - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

5184 Novy Syrah - Vintage 2002 Duckhorn Sauvignon Blanc 1nl (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2001 1nl (Wines Located in New (4) 12 bottles per lot $350-500 York)

5185 Parador Red Dumol Chardonnay - Vintage 1999 ltl (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2004 Chloe (Wines Located in New (1) York) Provenance Merlot - Vintage 2003 Paras Vineyard (Wines Located (2) Martinelli Chardonnay - Vintage 2006 in New York) Three Sisters Vineyard, Sea Ridge Meadows lstl (1) (Wines Located in New York) Ramsay Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 Lot 3 (Wines Located in New (1) Zio Tony Ranch (Wines Located in New York) (1) York) Newton Chardonnay Robert Biale Zinfandel - Vintage 2002 Unfiltered lscl (Wines Located (1) - Vintage 2003 Black Chicken (Wines Located (1) in New York) in New York) Topaz Late Harvest Sauvigon Blanc/Semillion - Vintage 1989 Special Select (Wines Located half- - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (1) bottle (1) in New York) Woodward Canyon Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) Treana White York) - Vintage 2004 Mer Soleil Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) 3 Rings Shiraz Above 1 half-bottle per lot $170-260 - Vintage 2004 lscl (Wines Located in New (1) and 11 bottles York)

5187 Sokol Blosser Pinot Noir Blackstone Merlot - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (3)

Château Ste. Michelle Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1996 (Wines Located in New York) (3) - Vintage 1998 Cold Creek Vineyard (Wines (1) Located in New York) Branson Coach House Shiraz - Vintage 2003 Single Vineyard nl (Wines (1) - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (4) Located in New York)

Château Ste. Michelle Gewurztraminer Cat Amongst the Pigeons Shiraz - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (4) - Vintage 2006 Nine Lives (Wines Located in (6) New York) Colvin Vineyards - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Flinders Run Shiraz Chelle Den Pleasant (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2005 Southern Flinders Ranges (8) (Wines Located in New York) Long Shadows Syrah - Vintage 2003 Sequel (Wines Located in New (1) Hazyblur Shiraz York) - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Above 13 bottles per lot $170-240 Henry's Drive Reserve Shiraz - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (1) 5188 L'Ecole #41 Cabernet Sauvignon (97pts) - Vintage 1995 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2003 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) (2) Kangarilla Road Shiraz L'Ecole #41 Merlot - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (3) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (7) Marquis Philips Shiraz L'Ecole #41 Red - Vintage 2003 9 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 2002 Apogee Pepperbridge Vineyard (1) (93pts) (Wines Located in New York) Above 37 bottles per lot $550-800 Above 11 bottles per lot $150-200 5190 Mollydooker Cabernet Sauvignon 5189 Magnificent Wine Company Red - Vintage 2007 Giggle Pot (Wines Located in (6) - Vintage 2002 Lot 2 4lbsl, 1ltl (Wines (4) New York) Located in New York) Mollydooker Cabernet Sauvignon/Shiraz Matthews Cellars Red - Vintage 2005 Two Left Feet (Wines Located (6) - Vintage 1999 (Wines Located in New York) (2) in New York) - Vintage 2006 Two Left Feet 1x12 bottle ocb (22) Quilceda Creek Red (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 2007 Two Left Feet 2x12 bottle ocb (24) Above 6 bottles per lot $120-180 (Wines Located in New York) Above 58 bottles per lot $1200-1700 5197 Shirvington Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New (1) 5191 Mollydooker Merlot York) (94pts) - Vintage 2006 The Scooter (Wines Located in (6) - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (4) New York) Above 5 bottles per lot $220-300

Mollydooker Shiraz 5198 Shirvington Shiraz - Vintage 2003 - Vintage 2005 The Boxer (Wines Located in (4) (Wines Located in New York) New York) (95pts) "...reveals a seamless integration of tannin, acidity, wood, and alcohol, it boasts aromas of blackberry - Vintage 2006 The Boxer 1x12 bottle ocb (36) liqueur intermixed with violets."(96pts) (Wines Located in New York) 12 bottles per lot $600-800

- Vintage 2007 The Boxer (Wines Located in (12) 5199 9 bottles per lot $420-600 New York) (Wines Located in New York) Above 58 bottles per lot $1000-1400 5200 Angelique de Monbousquet 5192 R Wines Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2005 - Vintage 1995 St. Emilion (Wines Located in (1) Green Lion New York) (Wines Located in New York) Château Tire Pe 3 bottles per lot $600-800 - Vintage 2000 La Côte (Wines Located in (1) New York) 5193 R Wines Shiraz - Vintage 2006 The Wine Ebenezer Larkmead Cabernet Sauvignon (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1999 2lscl, 1nl (Wines Located in (4) 12 bottles per lot $1100-1500 New York)

5194 8 bottles per lot $750-1000 Spring Mountain Red (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1997 (Wines Located in New York) (1)

5195 2 bottles per lot $180-240 Château Montelena Red (Wines Located in New York) - Vintage 1996 St. Vincent 2vlscl (Wines (2) Located in New York) 5196 The Colonial Estate Red - Vintage 2002 Émigré (Wines Located in New (1) Reilly's Grenache York) (92pts) - Vintage 2003 Old Bush Vines (Wines Located (1) in New York) Two Hands Shiraz - Vintage 2003 Lily's Garden (Wines Located in New York) (1) Haras de Pirque Chardonnay - Vintage 2007 (Wines Located in New York) (1) Max's Garden (Wines Located in New York) (1)

Astica Malbec Egri Bikaver Red - Vintage 2008 (Wines Located in New York) (1) - Vintage 1992 Bull's Blood of Eger (Wines (1) Located in New York) Above 12 bottles per lot $180-260 ______

Whistling Eagle Shiraz 5201 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2007 - Vintage 2002 Eagle's Blood 1lscl (Wines (2) Telegramme, Vieux Telegraphe Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) 10 bottles per lot $300-400 5210 Moss Wood Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2004 ______Margaret River (Wines Located in New York) 5202 Château d'Yquem - Vintage 1949 Sauternes 6 bottles per lot $240-320 ______vhs, stl, sdc, sos, dark mahogany color (Wines Located in New York) 5211 Château Leoville Las Cases - Vintage 1989 "The 1949 was also great, a complete wine as St. Julien well..."(96pts JK) (Wines Located in New York) 1 bottle per lot $1800-2400 "Greatest Leoville-Las-Cases ever produced. Superb ______concentration with a great velvety texture and ripe fresh flavors. Coconut and vanilla notes and a burst of fruit 5203 Grosset Riesling at the end; wonderful backbone."(96pts WS) Polish Hill 1 magnum per lot $300-400 - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) (6) 5212 Château Pichon Baron - Vintage 1990 - Vintage 2001 (Wines Located in New York) (6) Pauillac - Vintage 2002 (Wines Located in New York) (6) lbsl, sos (Wines Located in New York) "The wine is opulent and flamboyant, with lower - Vintage 2004 (Wines Located in New York) (6) acidity, and noticeably less tannin than the 1989. It is equally concentrated, with a more evolved nose of Above 24 bottles per lot $240-320 cedar, black fruits, earth, minerals, and spices. On the palate, the wine offers sensational quantities of jammy 5204 Moss Wood Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 fruit, glycerin, wood, and sweet tannin."(96pts) Margaret River 1 magnum per lot $500-650 (Wines Located in New York) 6 bottles per lot $240-350 5213 Château Rauzan Segla - Vintage 1986 Margaux 5205 Moss Wood Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1998 (Wines Located in New York) Margaret River "OK, now we are talking - a step-up here in the nose fantastic balance between its cassis and slate (Wines Located in New York) components chocolate dancing around the edges 6 bottles per lot $240-320 penetrating minerals - about as intense as Margaux gets great breed in this explosive nose long palate with great dust flavors to the finish and big-time mirabelle."(94pts 5206 Moss Wood Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1999 JK) Margaret River 1 bottle per lot $130-180 (Wines Located in New York)

6 bottles per lot $240-320 5214 Châteauneuf du Pape - Vintage 2012 Sanctus Sanctorum, Clos St. Jean 5207 Moss Wood Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 (Wines Located in New York) Margaret River 1 magnum per lot $800-1100 (Wines Located in New York)

6 bottles per lot $240-320 5215 Hermitage - Vintage 1989 Le Greal, H. Sorrel 5208 Moss Wood Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2001 ltl, dc (Wines Located in New York) Margaret River 1 bottle per lot $120-170 (Wines Located in New York)

6 bottles per lot $240-320 5216 Ermitage Blanc - Vintage 1991 cuvée de L'Oree, M. Chapoutier 5209 Moss Wood Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2002 tl (Wines Located in New York) Margaret River 1 bottle per lot $150-200 (Wines Located in New York)

6 bottles per lot $240-320 5217 Bryant Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1997 nl (Wines Located in New York) should drink well for 10-15 years."(95pts) "One of the most awesome young reds I have ever 1 bottle per lot $80-110 tasted, it possesses a black/purple color, a seamless texture, and freakishly high levels of intensity (cassis, black and blueberries infused with espresso, chocolate, 5222 Alban Vineyards Syrah - Vintage 2004 and licorice) that are flawlessly presented in a full- Reva bodied, massive yet elegant wine. Nothing is out of 2ltl (Wines Located in New York) balance in this explosively rich, thick, highly-extracted "...boasts a blue/black/purple color in addition to Cabernet."(100pts) gorgeous aromas of blackberry liqueur, creosote, 1 bottle per lot $650-900 graphite, and a hint of smoky oak. It is an intense, dense, stunning effort with huge tannin as well as a full- bodied, long finish."(96pts) 5218 Bryant Family Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2000 2 bottles per lot $160-220 2nl (Wines Located in New York) "...amazing tour de force. Quality like this was rare, if not impossible to obtain in 2000. From bottle, the wine 5223 Alban Vineyards Syrah - Vintage 2005 is performing even better than it did from cask. The Reva color is an opaque black/ruby/purple, and the amazing tl (Wines Located in New York) aromatic concoction includes notes of melted licorice, minerals, smoky toast, and blackberry as well as cassis 1 bottle per lot $100-140 liqueur. Full-bodied, thick, and juicy, it is a voluptuous effort..."(95pts) 5224 Alban Vineyards Syrah - Vintage 2006 4 bottles per lot $800-1100 Reva 2nl, 1lwisl (Wines Located in New York) 5219 Joseph Phelps Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 1985 "...coming from parcels of dark, volcanic soil, has off- Eisele Vineyard the-chart richness and intensity. This thick, opaque- lscl (Wines Located in New York) purple colored wine offers up notes of scorched earth, ground pepper, and blackberry liqueur intermixed with "The backward 1985 Eisele Vineyard is marvelously cassis, licorice, camphor, and tar. The wine is concentrated, but extremely tannic and at least 5-10 spectacular in every sense. Full-bodied and certainly years away from full maturity. Impressively endowed, not for wimps, this is a remarkably concentrated yet well-focused, dense, powerful, thick, and tannic, this very nuanced and intense wine that should age for 20 wine leaves little doubt that the extract, ripeness, and more years."(100pts) quantity of fruit are more than sufficient to balance out the wine's tannic ferocity."(93pts) 5 bottles per lot $900-1200 1 bottle per lot $120-160 5225 Penfold's Cabernet Sauvignon/Shiraz - Vintage 1990 5220 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon - Vintage 2010 Bin 920 (Wines Located in New York) (Wines Located in New York) "The brilliant 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon boasts an 1 bottle per lot $180-240 inky/purple color as well as glorious aromas of spring flowers, lead pencil shavings, licorice and a multitude of wild mountain fruits, in particular black raspberry, blackberry and cassis reminiscent of a French Pauillac (although I always think of Spottswoode as the Château Margaux of Napa). With a flawless integration of tannin, wood and acidity, it comes across like a liquid version of haute couture from the house of Chanel."(100pts) 1 bottle per lot $200-280

5221 Alban Vineyards Syrah - Vintage 2002 Reva tl (Wines Located in New York) "There are 1,400 six-packs of the 2002 Syrah Reva Vineyard Estate. Tasted just after bottling, it was performing spectacularly well. Its opaque purple color is accompanied by a classic bouquet of creme de cassis, blackberries, and touches of new oak, tar, and sweet leather. It is a spectacular, dense, opulent, full-bodied effort with good minerality as well as structure. It