Committee of the Whole Council

COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE COUNCIL

Supplement to Minutes Nos. 87, 88 and 89

Tuesday, 11 September 2012

1 RACING LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 2012

Clauses 1 to 8 — put and agreed to.

Clause 9 — Mr Pakula moved — 1. Clause 9, lines 25 to 26, omit all words and expressions on those lines. Question — That the amendment be agreed to — put. The Committee divided — The Deputy President in the Chair. AYES, 19 NOES, 21 Mr Barber Mr Atkinson Ms Broad Mrs Coote Ms Darveniza Ms Crozier Mr Eideh Mr Dalla-Riva Mr Elasmar Mr D.M. Davis Mr Jennings Mr P.R. Davis Ms Hartland (Teller) Mr Drum (Teller) Mr Leane Mr Elsbury Mr Lenders Mr Finn Ms Mikakos Mr Guy Mr Pakula Mr Hall (Teller) Ms Pennicuik Mr Koch Ms Pulford Mrs Kronberg Mr Scheffer (Teller) Ms Lovell Mr Somyurek Mr O’Brien Mr Tarlamis Mr O’Donohue Mr Tee Mr Ondarchie Ms Tierney Mrs Petrovich Mr Viney Mrs Peulich Mr Ramsay Mr Rich-Phillips Amendment negatived. Clause 9 — put and agreed to.

Bill reported without amendment.

2 EVIDENCE AMENDMENT (JOURNALIST PRIVILEGE) BILL 2012

Clauses 1 and 2 — put and agreed to.

Clause 3 — Ms Pennicuik moved — 1. Clause 3, lines 13 to 17, omit "engaged in the profession or occupation of journalism in connection with the publication of information, comment, opinion or analysis" and insert "who is engaged and active in 236 Legislative Council of Victoria

the publication of news and who may be given information by an informant in the expectation that the information may be published". Question — That the amendment be agreed to — put. The Committee divided — The Deputy President in the Chair. AYES, 3 NOES, 37 Mr Barber (Teller) Mr Atkinson Ms Hartland Ms Broad Ms Pennicuik (Teller) Mrs Coote Ms Crozier Mr Dalla-Riva Ms Darveniza Mr D.M. Davis Mr P.R. Davis Mr Drum Mr Eideh Mr Elasmar Mr Elsbury Mr Finn (Teller) Mr Guy Mr Hall Mr Jennings Mr Koch Mrs Kronberg Mr Leane Mr Lenders Ms Lovell Ms Mikakos Mr O’Brien Mr O’Donohue Mr Ondarchie Mr Pakula Mrs Petrovich Mrs Peulich Ms Pulford (Teller) Mr Ramsay Mr Rich-Phillips Mr Scheffer Mr Somyurek Mr Tarlamis Mr Tee Ms Tierney Mr Viney Amendment negatived.

Ms Pennicuik moved — 2. Clause 3, line 18, omit "a" and insert "any". Question — That the amendment be agreed to — put and negatived. Clause 3 — put and agreed to.

Clause 17 — Question — That Clause 17 stand part of the Bill — put. The Committee divided — The Deputy President in the Chair. AYES, 21 NOES, 19 Committee of the whole Council 237

Mr Atkinson Mr Barber (Teller) Mrs Coote Ms Broad (Teller) Ms Crozier Ms Darveniza Mr Dalla-Riva Mr Eideh Mr D.M. Davis Mr Elasmar Mr P.R. Davis Mr Jennings Mr Drum Ms Hartland Mr Elsbury Mr Leane Mr Finn Mr Lenders Mr Guy Ms Mikakos Mr Hall Mr Pakula Mr Koch Ms Pennicuik Mrs Kronberg Ms Pulford Ms Lovell Mr Scheffer Mr O’Brien Mr Somyurek Mr O’Donohue (Teller) Mr Tarlamis Mr Ondarchie Mr Tee Mrs Petrovich Ms Tierney Mrs Peulich (Teller) Mr Viney Mr Ramsay Mr Rich-Phillips Question agreed to.

Clause 18 — put and agreed to.

Clause 19 — Mr Pakula moved — 4. Clause 19, line 23, omit "does not apply" and insert "applies". Question — That the amendment be agreed to — put and negatived. Clause 19 — put and agreed to.

Clause 20 — Mr Pakula moved — 6. Clause 20, lines 9 to 20, omit all words and expressions on those lines. Question — That the amendment be agreed to — put and negatived. Clause 20 — put and agreed to.

Clause 21 — Mr Pakula moved — 8. Clause 21, lines 3 to 11, omit all words and expressions on those lines. Question — That the amendment be agreed to — put. The Committee divided — The Deputy President in the Chair. AYES, 19 NOES, 21 Mr Barber Mr Atkinson Ms Broad Mrs Coote Ms Darveniza Ms Crozier Mr Eideh (Teller) Mr Dalla-Riva Mr Elasmar Mr D.M. Davis Mr Jennings Mr P.R. Davis Ms Hartland Mr Drum Mr Leane Mr Elsbury Mr Lenders Mr Finn Ms Mikakos Mr Guy Mr Pakula Mr Hall Ms Pennicuik Mr Koch Ms Pulford Mrs Kronberg 238 Legislative Council of Victoria

Mr Scheffer (Teller) Ms Lovell Mr Somyurek Mr O’Brien Mr Tarlamis Mr O’Donohue (Teller) Mr Tee Mr Ondarchie Ms Tierney Mrs Petrovich (Teller) Mr Viney Mrs Peulich Mr Ramsay Mr Rich-Phillips Amendment negatived. Clause 21 — put and agreed to.

Clause 22 — Mr Pakula moved — 10. Clause 22, line 6, omit "does not apply" and insert "applies". Question — That the amendment be agreed to — put. The Committee divided — The Deputy President in the Chair. AYES, 19 NOES, 21 Mr Barber Mr Atkinson Ms Broad Mrs Coote Ms Darveniza Ms Crozier Mr Eideh Mr Dalla-Riva Mr Elasmar Mr D.M. Davis Mr Jennings Mr P.R. Davis Ms Hartland Mr Drum (Teller) Mr Leane Mr Elsbury Mr Lenders Mr Finn Ms Mikakos (Teller) Mr Guy Mr Pakula Mr Hall Ms Pennicuik Mr Koch Ms Pulford Mrs Kronberg Mr Scheffer Ms Lovell Mr Somyurek (Teller) Mr O’Brien (Teller) Mr Tarlamis Mr O’Donohue Mr Tee Mr Ondarchie Ms Tierney Mrs Petrovich Mr Viney Mrs Peulich Mr Ramsay Mr Rich-Phillips Amendment negatived. Clause 22 — put and agreed to.

Bill reported without amendment. Thursday, 13 September 2012

1 RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES AND OTHER CONSUMER ACTS AMENDMENT BILL 2012

Clause 1 — Ms Mikakos moved — 1. Clause 1, page 2, line 20, omit "Act; and" and insert "Act.". Question — That the amendment be agreed to — put and negatived. Clause 1 — put and agreed to. Committee of the whole Council 239

Clause 26 — Question — That Clause 26 stand part of the Bill — put. The Committee divided — The Deputy President in the Chair. AYES, 20 NOES, 18 Mr Atkinson Mr Barber Mrs Coote Ms Broad Ms Crozier Ms Darveniza Mr Dalla-Riva Mr Eideh Mr D.M. Davis Mr Jennings Mr P.R. Davis Ms Hartland Mr Drum Mr Leane Mr Elsbury (Teller) Mr Lenders Mr Finn Ms Mikakos (Teller) Mr Guy Mr Pakula (Teller) Mr Hall (Teller) Ms Pennicuik Mr Koch Ms Pulford Mrs Kronberg Mr Scheffer Ms Lovell Mr Somyurek Mr O’Brien Mr Tarlamis Mr Ondarchie Mr Tee Mrs Petrovich Ms Tierney Mrs Peulich Mr Viney Mr Ramsay Mr Rich-Phillips Question agreed to.

Clause 27 — Question — That Clause 27 stand part of the Bill — put. The Committee divided — The Deputy President in the Chair. AYES, 20 NOES, 18 Mr Atkinson Mr Barber Mrs Coote Ms Broad Ms Crozier Ms Darveniza Mr Dalla-Riva Mr Eideh Mr D.M. Davis Mr Jennings Mr P.R. Davis (Teller) Ms Hartland (Teller) Mr Drum Mr Leane (Teller) Mr Elsbury Mr Lenders Mr Finn Ms Mikakos Mr Guy Mr Pakula Mr Hall Ms Pennicuik Mr Koch Ms Pulford Mrs Kronberg Mr Scheffer Ms Lovell Mr Somyurek Mr O’Brien Mr Tarlamis Mr Ondarchie Mr Tee Mrs Petrovich Ms Tierney Mrs Peulich (Teller) Mr Viney Mr Ramsay Mr Rich-Phillips Question agreed to.

Clause 28 — put and agreed to.

Bill reported without amendment.