I Have a Horrid Cold, & So Cannot Do Better Than Write to Thank You for Yours of 8Th, &

Fe[bruar]y 23/[18]86

Dear [Asa] Gray

I have a horrid cold, & so cannot do better than write to thank you for yours of 8th, & for Synopt[ical]. Flora Suppl[ement].

Well, it is good news that you have gone back to Ranunculaceae, you will I hope be able to gallop through the Thalamiflorae.

I am still on Laurineae, but nearly done. The 1--celled anthered Litsaeaceae I have followed Bentham in bringing under one genus Lindera -- though I feel satisfied that they should make 3 or 4 by habit & inflorescence. The latter is very curious & often difficult to make out. Bentham did not attempt to understand it -- had he attempted it the Gen[era] Plant[arum] would not now be finished! Laurineae is one of those orders that he would have wished me to do, not because I could do it better, but because I have more patience with that sort of analysis that is required & which is necessary, even if I do not make so good a use of it. I did

[[2]] however suppose that Bentham had done generically the S[outh]. American ones for [Robert] Schomburgk & [Richard] Spruce. You never I think tried your hand at such a job of exotic plants as classifying [1 word crossed out, illeg.] any of these obscure arborescent tropical orders. They are a great strain, but I prefer such work to such jerky work as Bot[anical]. Mag[azine]. But you have your full share of troubles in your own Compositae & other Orders.

I am now printing Indian Polygonums 70 species!

By the way I was staggered in looking into your Man[ual]. [of the] Bot[any]. [of the Northern United States] for a Willow[?], to find, p. 461 that you were waiting for Andersson[']s Monograph in D[e].C[andolle]. Prodr[romus] published in 1868, whilst your issue is dated 1880 on the title page but 1868 in the Note at the back of the dedication -- surely this is Hocus--pocus.

I have received [John Merle] Coulter's Rocky Mt Flora, a curiously unequal book, but I suppose a very serviceable one. What a pity that he gives no elevations & hardly ever distinguishes alpine plants as such. But how do you define an alpine plant? I can't except as Tom defined an

[[3]] Archdeacon. I asked Ball & he couldn't.

We are in a fix for a P[resident]. L[innean]. S[ociety]. which [John] Lubbock is about to resign. I know no fit man but [William Thiselton] Dyer. Lubbock & others press me to accept, but I cannot trisect myself. The Camp & Kew are all I can manage -- it tires me so to add London that I shall take no more Society work after this year of the Royal -- besides the frightful loss of time. If Dyer won't take it[,] it must I suppose be [William] Carruthers, who has neither Scientific nor Social position for it, & whose conduct to Bentham, & action in joining a secret conspiracy to overthrow the P[resident]. & Council in the matter of Dyer's election to the Sec[retar]yship, & then putting an utterly unknown & ignorant man into the Secretary's place [1 word crossed out, illeg.] were simply shocking.

Ball won't take it. He wants to go abroad every year. No one but Dyer could get the new school of Botanists to rally round the Society.

By the way I have been good 2 hours over D. Jackson's Biog. Biograph[ical] notice of Bentham for the Linnean, which won't do at all -- he can't write English to begin with, & is utterly incompetent even with your & my notices to help him to do it.

I wrote to Madam Wallon *1 urging her paying up the Legacies to the Linnean & the Relief fund of the Royal, -- she answered asking to buy the portrait "if she could afford it", & making no allusion to

[[4]] the legacies -- I have sent her a stinger in return & if she does not come down with the money (only about £300 out of her £15000) I shall send her a concluder.

There is a very fine Botanical Library to be sold that did belong to a friend of mine, a Mr Watson Taylor, an amateur Botanical Artist, whose drawings I thought equalled Bauers. He belonged to a wealthy family -- died some 15 years ago or more & left his Bot[anical]. books to his brother a wealthy swell[?] who wants to part with them. Is there a chance of St Louis buying them? There are 140 works, 345 vols including Boltons Fungi; Bulliard &c & CavanillesIcones; Crantz Stirp[iu]m; De Prodr[omus] XIV vols; Deless[ert] Icones; Grevilles Scot[tish] Crypt[ogamic] Flo[ra]; HBH [Humboldt, Bonpland and Kunth] Plant Equnots[?]; Hook Exot[ic] Fl[ora]; Brit[ish]. Junger[mmani]a Folio Ed[ition]!; Bot[anical] Misc[ellany]; Comp[anion to the] Bot[anical] Mag[azine]; Muscol[ogica] Brit[tanica].; Hort. Gran.; Jacquin Obs[ervationum Botanicarum]; Fl[ora] Austr[iaceae]; Plant[arum] Rar[iorum]; Stapel[iarum]; Miscell[anea]. Austr[iaca].; Collect[anea]; Oxalis; Select[arum] Stirp[ium]; Hort[us]. Bot[anicus]. Vindob[onensis].; Redouté Rosa & Lilia[cées].; R[uiz] &P[avón] Fl[ora] Peru; Scopoli; Sowerby's Fungi; Turner's Fici; Vaillant Fl Dauph; Wallich Pl[antae] As[iaticae]. Rar[iores]; Waldst[ein] & Kit[aibel]; -- all in splendid order I believe, Russia[?] board & gilt.

The owner a comparative stranger to me does not know what to ask, or I what to advise, but it is a rare chance. What would you say? £500? I think I shall ask Wheldon.

Ever aff[ectionatel]y y[our]s J.D. Hooker [signature].

*2 Is Sargent right in styling you one of the "immortal 8" of the French Academy? If so I should have congratulated you. I always thought you should have been chosen before A[lphonse] D[e] C[andolle] a very long way. ENDNOTES

1. Mary Louisa Wallon, George Bentham's great niece who, on his death, inherited the bulk of his estate.

2. The text which runs from here until the end of the letter is written vertically up the left margin of page 1.

Please note that work on this transcript is ongoing. Users are advised to study electronic image(s) of this document where possible.