March 1918: Azerbaijan Without Azerbaijanis Aslan Khalilov Ph.D

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

March 1918: Azerbaijan Without Azerbaijanis Aslan Khalilov Ph.D As it happened March 1918: Azerbaijan without Azerbaijanis Aslan KHALIloV Ph.D. in History AFTER THE RUssian REVOLUTIONS OF THE EARLY 20TH CENTURY, THE SOUTH CAUcasUS was ENGULFED IN ANARCHY AND ARBITRARiness. TAKING ADVantaGE OF that, ARMENIANS staRTED TO IMPLEMENT THEIR MUCH-COVETED DREAM OF CReatinG A “GReat ARMENIA FROM THE SEA TO THE SEA”, PRIMARILY at THE EXPENSE OF AZERbaiJANI LANDS WHERE A SIGNIFicant ARMENIAN POPULatiON APPEARED ONLY at THE dawn OF THE 19TH CENTURY. THIS IDEA became THE MAIN SLOGAN FOR ALL ARMENIAN POLiticaL PARTIES AND ORGANIZatiONS - FROM Dashnaks TO THE BOLSHEVIKS. s is known, Soviet power was established in and around ABaku on 2 November 1917. The Baku Council was headed by Armenian activists who called themselves Bolsheviks - Shaumyan, Mikoyan, Amiryan, Kamo and oth- ers. After seizing power, they used it as an instrument in exterminating the Muslim population. The anti- Azerbaijani policy of S. Shaumyan and the likes climaxed in the early 1918: from March to July, acting on behalf of Soviet power, Armenians Building of the Achig Soz newspaper unleashed genocide against the 22 www.irs-az.com Building of the Kaspiy newspaper on Nikolayevskaya Street Muslim population of the entire crushed. Dashnaktsutyun also and three bayonet wounds on Baku province. had three to four thousand na- the body... In another place, he The heavily armed Armenian tional units at its disposal. Their found a young Muslim woman units dealt the first blow to Baku. A participation lent the civil war the with a slit throat. The woman’s member of the Emergency Investi- nature of an ethnic massacre, but one-year-old baby was slaugh- gation Commission, lawyer A. Kluge it was unavoidable. We did that tered with a dagger and placed confirms in his report “On violence on purpose. Muslim paupers suf- on top of his killed mother. There against the Muslim population of fered greatly...” were numerous bodies of Muslim Baku”, based on numerous witness Kluge says in his report that the women with cut off breasts, nose, accounts and examination of massa- Muslim population was massacred ears... In one place he discovered cre sites, that over 11,000 of innocent in most horrific ways, while help- a child burned on the stove, in an- Azerbaijanis were killed by armed Armenian gangs in late March and accORDING TO EYE-witnesses, THERE WERE MUTILated BODIES THROUGH- early April 1918 alone. Most of those OUT THE CITY killed were extremely poor. Some background to the massacre was ac- less old men, women and children other there was a boy pinned to knowledged by Shaumyan himself suffered the worst. “According to the ground with wooden stakes in a report to the Council of People’s Heydar Gulyiev, he found terribly pierced through his stomach.” Commissars on 13 April 13 1918: “... mutilated corpses when visiting As if these atrocities against There was a fierce battle in Baku Muslim homes in different parts Azerbaijanis weren’t enough, Arme- for three days – 30, 31 March of the city. He found the body of nian units burned and destroyed and 1 April... The results are bril- his nephew Bashir Jafarov with the best buildings owned by the liant for us. The enemy has been his head cut off, a severed hand Muslims. Kluge’s report suggests www.irs-az.com 23 As it happened The Ismayilliye Palace that the I smailliye building, the ments of the early 1918, Kluge pro- ans. As confirmed by the events Kaspiy newspaper where 5,000 vides witness accounts and numer- that unfolded in the aftermath of copies of the Koran were stored, ous documents confirming that the 17 (30) March 1918, the killing of hotels Islamiye, Dagestan, Iskend- campaign was not spontaneous, Muslims and the destruction of eriye and others were burnt out. but had been carefully prepared Muslim homes were carried out Armenian soldiers looted the prop- in advance. Along with political or- throughout the city according to erty of the killed Azerbaijanis and ganizations and armed Armenian a preexisting plan masterminded destroyed everything they could lay units, many ordinary Armenian resi- by Armenian troops and the Ar- menian population of Baku.” THE EVents OF MARCH 1918 HAD BEEN ON THE ARMENIAN AGenda FROM The mass killings of Azerbaijanis 1917 and the looting of their property continued until September 1918. their hands on. This is confirmed by dents of Baku were actively involved Baku resident Sadig Bey Mamed Rza Kluge’s report. “Breaking into Mus- in the massacre. “The events of Bey oglu left Baku for the Pirshaga lim homes, Armenians took over March had been on the agenda settlement in late August 1918. In all valuables, while the rest was of Dashnaktsutyun and the Ar- the Mammadli village, he and 20 broken and set alight. In the low- menian National Council from other Azerbaijanis were captured by er part of the city, there was no 1917. They repeatedly tried to 17 Armenian soldiers and taken to Muslim home left intact except provoke the Muslim population the Zabrat village where they were for the house of Haji Zeynalabdin to stage an uprising only to phys- tied together with a rope and fired Tagiyev... The Muslim population ically destroy it first in Baku and on from rifles. When the victims col- of Baku suffered losses of at least then around the city, capture all lapsed, they were stabbed with bay- 400 million rubles in old prices.” of its property and pass the po- onets, daggers and swords. While describing the develop- litical dominance on to Armeni- Also attacked by Armenians 24 www.irs-az.com Scores of Muslims fell victim to Armenian atrocities were Shamakhi and Guba districts. stormed the Muslim (lower) part of Shamakhi Muslims was stopped In late March 1918, Shaumyan sent the city and began to burn houses only with the arrival of a detach- Armenian units to Shamakhi alleg- and kill men, women and children. ment of Azerbaijani troops. Arme- edly to establish Soviet rule there. A member of the Emergency In- nians hurriedly left the crumbling Instead, they teamed up with local vestigation Commission under the city, retreating towards the Molokan Armenians and unleashed a mas- Azerbaijan government, A. Novatski, village of Kozlichay (Hilmilli). But sacre in the province, killing tens of said in a report on the destruction the Azerbaijani unit had to leave thousands of civilian Muslims with- of Shamakhi and the violence un- the town soon, and Armenian of- out heeding much attention to their leashed against the Muslim popula- fensive resumed with fresh feroc- gender, age or political affiliation. tion: “Every step of their advance ity. The chairman of the Emergency On 31 March 1918, the center of the was accompanied by the burning Investigation Commission, Alekper province, Shamakhi, was destroyed. of houses, killing of civilians and Bey Khasmammadov, wrote in a In the early hours of the day, local looting. The fire spread through- message to the commander of al- residents were awakened by the out the city and there was noth- lied troops in Baku on 9 December 1918: “... On orders from S. Lalayev, EVERY steP OF THEIR ADVANCE was accOMPANIED BY THE BURNING OF his soldiers seized young Muslim HOUSES, KILLING OF CIVILIANS AND LOOTING. women, took them to his house in Shemakha, stripped them, forced thunder of machine guns. It turned ing left of it by the next morning. them to drink alcohol and then out that armed Armenians attacked People were killed in their houses raped them. Some were then killed, the city from the Armenian village and on the street. The killings others were thrown from a high bal- of Matrasy and sealed it from all were incredibly cruel. Valuable cony onto the street.” sides. Led by G. Korganov, T. Amirov, property was plundered…” During the Armenian attack on S. Lalayev and others, the attackers The blood-bath against the Shamakhi, a number of prominent www.irs-az.com 25 As it happened The inside of the Ismayilliye Palace was in complete ruins representatives of the local popula- September 1919: “I witnessed the cut off his tongue, ears and nose...” tion were killed, including mayor murder of well-known and high- S. Lalayev (Lalayan), acting to- Teymur Bey Khudaverdiyev, a mem- ly respected mullah Jafar Gulu gether with local Armenian leaders ber of the first State Duma Mamed Akhund and about 400 women Gyulbandyan, Arzumanyan, Doliyan, Tagi Aliyev, Haji Baba Abbasov, Ashraf and children. They were hiding Petrosyan, Karapetyan, etc., ordered Hajiyev, Haji Jafar Gulu Akhund, who in a local mosque but Armenians to encircle all 13 mosques that shel- was tortured to death. Here is a wit- stormed it and killed them all. Be- tered women, children and the el- ness account of Nasrulla Haji Sul- fore killing Akhund, they knocked derly in Shamakhi. The Armenians tan oglu from his testimony on 29 out his teeth, pulled off his beard, set fire to the mosques, killing eve- ryone trying to escape... A total of several thousand peo- ple were killed in the first and sec- ond Armenian attacks on Shamakhi. The Muslim part of the town was razed to the ground. Killings and violence continued in many villages of the Shamakhi Province. In mid- April 1918, Armenians attacked the village of Navagi where they mas- sacred local civilians – those fleeing were shot, those who fell into their hands were killed with bayonets and daggers, while women were raped. A total of 555 men, 260 women and 140 children were killed. 26 www.irs-az.com joined forces, irrespective of politi- cal and social standing, to eradicate the Muslim population of Shamakhi and Guba provinces.
Recommended publications
  • United Nations Code for Trade and Transport Locations (UN/LOCODE) for Azerbaijan
    United Nations Code for Trade and Transport Locations (UN/LOCODE) for Azerbaijan N.B. To check the official, current database of UN/LOCODEs see: https://www.unece.org/cefact/locode/service/location.html UN/LOCODE Location Name State Functionality Status Coordinatesi AZ ABN Agcabadi AGC Road terminal; Recognised location 4003N 04727E AZ AST Astara Multimodal function, ICD etc.; Recognised location 3827N 04852E AZ BAK Baku Port; Airport; Postal exchange office; Code adopted by IATA or ECLAC AZ DAM Dalimammadli GOR Road terminal; Recognised location 4041N 04634E AZ DJU Djulfa Rail terminal; Code adopted by IATA or ECLAC AZ GAN Ganja Multimodal function, ICD etc.; Recognised location 4040N 04621E AZ GYD Heydar Aliyev BA Airport; Recognised location 4028N 05002E International Apt. AZ IMI Imisli Road terminal; Recognised location 3952N 04803E AZ KAZ Qazax QAZ Rail terminal; Road terminal; Recognised location 4106N 04521E AZ KBD Kirovabad GA Rail terminal; Road terminal; Request under consideration AZ KHA Khanlar Road terminal; Recognised location 4020N 04949E AZ KMZ Khachmaz XAC Port; Multimodal function, ICD etc.; Recognised location 4159N 04735E AZ KVD Gyandzha Airport; Code adopted by IATA or ECLAC AZ LAN Lankaran Road terminal; Recognised location 3845N 04851E AZ MGC Mingechaur Road terminal; Recognised location 4045N 04703E AZ NAJ Naxcivan Road terminal; Recognised location 3912N 04514E AZ NK7 Nakhchivan Rail terminal; Recognised location 3912N 04524E AZ QDG Qaradag Port; Rail terminal; Road terminal; Recognised location 4015N 04936E AZ
    [Show full text]
  • World Bank Document
    ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT Public Disclosure Authorized AZERBAIJAN REPUBLIC MINISTRY OF TRANSPORT “AZERROADSERVICE” OJC Azerbaijan Highway Project II-Additional Financing IBRD Loan No. 7516 AZ Public Disclosure Authorized Upgrading of Baku-Shamakhi Road Section of Baku-Shamakhi- Yevlakh Road, preparation of Environmental Assessment and Environmental Management Plan Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized November 2013 Studi e Azerbaijan Republic – Ministry of Transport Pianificazione del Territorio “AZERROADSERVICE” OJC Table of contents 0 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................... 4 0.1 PROJECT BACKGROUND AND PREVIOUS STUDIES ....................................................................................... 4 0.2 SCOPE OF THE PRESENT REPORT ............................................................................................................. 4 0.3 REPORT STRUCTURE ............................................................................................................................. 5 0.4 DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT ............................................................................................................... 5 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................................... 7 1.1 PROJECT SUMMARY ............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The World Factbook Middle East :: Azerbaijan Introduction
    The World Factbook Middle East :: Azerbaijan Introduction :: Azerbaijan Background: Azerbaijan - a nation with a majority-Turkic and majority-Shia Muslim population - was briefly independent (from 1918 to 1920) following the collapse of the Russian Empire; it was subsequently incorporated into the Soviet Union for seven decades. Azerbaijan has yet to resolve its conflict with Armenia over Nagorno-Karabakh, a primarily Armenian-populated region that Moscow recognized in 1923 as an autonomous republic within Soviet Azerbaijan after Armenia and Azerbaijan disputed the territory's status. Armenia and Azerbaijan began fighting over the area in 1988; the struggle escalated after both countries attained independence from the Soviet Union in 1991. By May 1994, when a cease-fire took hold, ethnic Armenian forces held not only Nagorno-Karabakh but also seven surrounding provinces in the territory of Azerbaijan. The OSCE Minsk Group, co-chaired by the United States, France, and Russia, is the framework established to mediate a peaceful resolution of the conflict. Corruption in the country is widespread, and the government, which eliminated presidential term limits in a 2009 referendum, has been accused of authoritarianism. Although the poverty rate has been reduced and infrastructure investment has increased substantially in recent years due to revenue from oil and gas production, reforms have not adequately addressed weaknesses in most government institutions, particularly in the education and health sectors. Geography :: Azerbaijan Location: Southwestern
    [Show full text]
  • A Unified List of Political Prisoners in Azerbaijan
    A UNIFIED LIST OF POLITICAL PRISONERS IN AZERBAIJAN A UNIFIED LIST OF POLITICAL PRISONERS IN AZERBAIJAN Covering the period up to 25 May 2017 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION..........................................................................................................4 DEFINITION OF POLITICAL PRISONERS...............................................................5 POLITICAL PRISONERS.....................................................................................6-106 A. Journalists/Bloggers......................................................................................6-14 B. Writers/Poets…...........................................................................................15-17 C. Human Rights Defenders............................................................................17-18 D. Political and social Activists ………..........................................................18-31 E. Religious Activists......................................................................................31-79 (1) Members of Muslim Unity Movement and those arrested in Nardaran Settlement...........................................................................31-60 (2) Persons detained in connection with the “Freedom for Hijab” protest held on 5 October 2012.........................60-63 (3) Religious Activists arrested in Masalli in 2012...............................63-65 (4) Religious Activists arrested in May 2012........................................65-69 (5) Chairman of Islamic Party of Azerbaijan and persons arrested
    [Show full text]
  • World Bank Document
    The World Bank Report No: ISR5276 Implementation Status & Results Azerbaijan Second National Water Supply and Sanitation Project (P109961) Operation Name: Second National Water Supply and Sanitation Project Project Stage: Implementation Seq.No: 8 Status: ARCHIVED Archive Date: 05-Jul-2011 (P109961) Public Disclosure Authorized Country: Azerbaijan Approval FY: 2008 Product Line:IBRD/IDA Region: EUROPE AND CENTRAL ASIA Lending Instrument: Specific Investment Loan Implementing Agency(ies): State Amelioration and Water Management Agency of Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic (SAWMA), State Amelioration and Water Management Company Key Dates Public Disclosure Copy Board Approval Date 27-May-2008 Original Closing Date 28-Feb-2013 Planned Mid Term Review Date Last Archived ISR Date 05-Jul-2011 Effectiveness Date 13-Jul-2009 Revised Closing Date 28-Feb-2013 Actual Mid Term Review Date Project Development Objectives Project Development Objective (from Project Appraisal Document) To improve the availability, quality, reliability and sustainability of water supply and sanitation (WSS) services in selected regional (rayon) centers in Azerbaijan. Has the Project Development Objective been changed since Board Approval of the Project? Yes No Public Disclosure Authorized Component(s) Component Name Component Cost Component A: Rayon Investments 392.00 Component B: Institutional Modernization 15.80 Component C: Project Implementation and Management 1.60 Overall Ratings Previous Rating Current Rating Progress towards achievement of PDO Moderately Satisfactory Moderately Satisfactory Overall Implementation Progress (IP) Moderately Satisfactory Moderately Satisfactory Public Disclosure Authorized Overall Risk Rating Implementation Status Overview This information is based on recent implementation support mission led by Manuel Marino and composed of Hadji Huseynov, Deepal Fernando, Gulana Hajiyeva and Norpulat Daniyarov and carried out through October 31- November 4, 2011.
    [Show full text]
  • State Report Azerbaijan
    ACFC/SR(2002)001 ______ REPORT SUBMITTED BY AZERBAIJAN PURSUANT TO ARTICLE 25, PARAGRAPH 1 OF THE FRAMEWORK CONVENTION FOR THE PROTECTION OF NATIONAL MINORITIES ______ (Received on 4 June 2002) _____ TABLE OF CONTENTS PART I............................................................................................................................................ 3 II. Aggression of the Republic of Armenia against the Republic of Azerbaijan..................... 9 III. Information on the form of the State structure.................................................................. 12 IV. Information on status of international law in national legislation .................................... 13 V. Information on demographic situation in the country ...................................................... 13 VI. Main economic data - gross domestic product and per capita income ............................. 15 VII. State’s national policy in the field of the protection of the rights of persons belonging to minorities ...................................................................................................................................... 15 VIII. Population awareness on international treaties to which Azerbaijan is a party to........ 16 P A R T II..................................................................................................................................... 18 Article 1 ........................................................................................................................................ 18 Article
    [Show full text]
  • History of Azerbaijan (Textbook)
    DILGAM ISMAILOV HISTORY OF AZERBAIJAN (TEXTBOOK) Azerbaijan Architecture and Construction University Methodological Council of the meeting dated July 7, 2017, was published at the direction of № 6 BAKU - 2017 Dilgam Yunis Ismailov. History of Azerbaijan, AzMİU NPM, Baku, 2017, p.p.352 Referents: Anar Jamal Iskenderov Konul Ramiq Aliyeva All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form by any means. Electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the copyright owner. In Azerbaijan University of Architecture and Construction, the book “History of Azerbaijan” is written on the basis of a syllabus covering all topics of the subject. Author paid special attention to the current events when analyzing the different periods of Azerbaijan. This book can be used by other high schools that also teach “History of Azerbaijan” in English to bachelor students, master students, teachers, as well as to the independent learners of our country’s history. 2 © Dilgam Ismailov, 2017 TABLE OF CONTENTS Foreword…………………………………….……… 9 I Theme. Introduction to the history of Azerbaijan 10 II Theme: The Primitive Society in Azerbaijan…. 18 1.The Initial Residential Dwellings……….............… 18 2.The Stone Age in Azerbaijan……………………… 19 3.The Copper, Bronze and Iron Ages in Azerbaijan… 23 4.The Collapse of the Primitive Communal System in Azerbaijan………………………………………….... 28 III Theme: The Ancient and Early States in Azer- baijan. The Atropatena and Albanian Kingdoms.. 30 1.The First Tribal Alliances and Initial Public Institutions in Azerbaijan……………………………. 30 2.The Kingdom of Manna…………………………… 34 3.The Atropatena and Albanian Kingdoms………….
    [Show full text]
  • The National Emblem
    Administrative Department of the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan P R E S I D E N T I A L L I B R A R Y NATIONAL EMBLEM Contents National Emblem ........................................................................................................................... 2 The emblems of provinces ............................................................................................................ 3 The emblems of Azerbaijani cities and governorates in period of tsarist Russia ................... 4 Caspian oblast .............................................................................................................................. 4 Baku Governorate. ....................................................................................................................... 5 Elisabethpol (Ganja) Governorate ............................................................................................... 6 Irevan (Erivan) Governorate ....................................................................................................... 7 The emblems of the cities .............................................................................................................. 8 Baku .............................................................................................................................................. 8 Ganja ............................................................................................................................................. 9 Shusha .......................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Phonosemantic Research of Azerbaijani and Turkish in the Aspect of Literary Language and Dialect
    International Academy Journal Web of Scholar ISSN 2518-167X THE PHONOSEMANTIC RESEARCH OF AZERBAIJANI AND TURKISH IN THE ASPECT OF LITERARY LANGUAGE AND DIALECT PhD. Teymurlu Z. M. Department of the Azerbaijani Language and Literature Baku Engineering University, Azerbaijan, Baku DOI: https://doi.org/10.31435/rsglobal_wos/28022020/6915 ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT Received: 14 December 2019 Discovering and categorizing phonetic, morphological and lexical units Accepted: 19 February 2020 related to different languages in any language, studying the factors and Published: 28 February 2020 forms of language connections are still among trending issues nowadays. Special importance has been attached on dialect lexicon of languages, KEYWORDS historical-comparative study of literary language and finding out various language elements in the paper. Some researchers support that as Turkic the Azerbaijani language, peoples have been formed as independent or semi-independent nations the Turkish language, completing ethnosocial differentiation process since the late Middle literary language, Ages, their languages differ from one another to some extent. The dialect, emergence of different Turkic states has led to the appearance of phonosemantics common and various features in the peoples and their languages who experienced public-political differentiation. In this case if the existing analogical features are proof for the closeness of these languages, distinct features are indeed the confirmation of peculiar development direction of each language. The research work provides some vision about common and distinctive features of the Azerbaijani language dialects and the Turkish language. The characteristics of languages’ mutual influence are reflected in language material. Citation: Teymurlu Z. M. (2020) The Phonosemantic Research of Azerbaijani and Turkish in the Aspect of Literary Language and Dialect.
    [Show full text]
  • Schedule for Receptıon of Citizens by Heads of Central Executıve Authorities in Cities and Districts in August 2018 Central Ex
    Schedule for receptıon of citizens by heads of central executıve authorities in cities and districts in August 2018 Central executive authority Reception The city Cities day where the and regions whose reception residents can attend the is held reception Jeyhun Bayramov Gazakh, Aghstafa, Tovuz 06 Gazakh Shamkir, Gadabay Minister of Education Maleyka Abbaszade Lerik, Lankaran, Astara, 10 Lerik Masalli, Yardimli, Jalilabad, Chairperson of the Board of Bilasuvar Directors of the State Examination Center public legal entity Arzu Rahimov Yevlakh, Barda, Tartar, Ujar, 16 Yevlakh Zardab, Aghdash, Goychay Chief of the State Service for Mobilization and Conscription Zakir Garalov Saatli, Shirvan, Hajigabul, 17 Saatli Salyan, Sabirabad Prosecutor General Sahil Babayev Ismayilli, Goychay, Aghsu, 17 Ismayilli Shamakhi, Gobustan Minister of Labor and Social Protection of Population Azad Rahimov Goygol, Ganja, Naftalan, 17 Goygol Goranboy, Samukh, Minister of Youth and Sports Dashkasan, Shamkir, Gadabay, Tovuz, Aghstafa, Gazakh Shahin Mustafayev Balakan, Zagatala, Gakh 17 Balakan Minister of Economy Kamaladdin Heydarov Gabala, Ismayilli, 24 Gabala Aghsu, Shamakhi, Gobustan Minister of Emergency Situations Inam Karimov Shamkir, Gadabay, Tovuz, Aghstafa, Gazakh Minister of Agriculture 24 Shamkir Karam Hasanov Aghsu,Shamakhi, Gobustan 24 Aghsu Chairman of the State Committee on Property Issues Ramil Usubov Shaki, Gakh, Zagatala, 25 Shaki Balakan, Oghuz, Gabala Minister of Internal Affairs Mikayil Jabbarov Sumgayit, Absheron, Khizi, 27 Sumgayit Siyazan,
    [Show full text]
  • Forced Displacement in the Nagorny Karabakh Conflict: Return and Its Alternatives
    Forced displacement in the Nagorny Karabakh conflict: return and its alternatives August 2011 conciliation resources Place-names in the Nagorny Karabakh conflict are contested. Place-names within Nagorny Karabakh itself have been contested throughout the conflict. Place-names in the adjacent occupied territories have become increasingly contested over time in some, but not all (and not official), Armenian sources. Contributors have used their preferred terms without editorial restrictions. Variant spellings of the same name (e.g., Nagorny Karabakh vs Nagorno-Karabakh, Sumgait vs Sumqayit) have also been used in this publication according to authors’ preferences. Terminology used in the contributors’ biographies reflects their choices, not those of Conciliation Resources or the European Union. For the map at the end of the publication, Conciliation Resources has used the place-names current in 1988; where appropriate, alternative names are given in brackets in the text at first usage. The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of the authors and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of Conciliation Resources or the European Union. Altered street sign in Shusha (known as Shushi to Armenians). Source: bbcrussian.com Contents Executive summary and introduction to the Karabakh Contact Group 5 The Contact Group papers 1 Return and its alternatives: international law, norms and practices, and dilemmas of ethnocratic power, implementation, justice and development 7 Gerard Toal 2 Return and its alternatives: perspectives
    [Show full text]
  • Economic Research Centre Strengthening Municipalities In
    Economic Research Centre Strengthening Municipalities in Azerbaijan Concept Paper This paper has been prepared within the framework of Oxfam, GB and ICCO, Netherlands co-funded project “The Role of Local self-governments in Poverty reduction in Azerbaijan” Expert group members working on the concept: Research Team Leader: Rovshan Agayev: Other Team Members: Gubad Ibadoglu Azer Mehtiyev Aydin Aslanov Translated by: Elshad Mikayilov Baku 2007 1 INTRODUCTION Democratic political system, creation of effective public management and eradication of socio-economic recession are the major challenges facing most of the world countries. The analysis of experience across highly developed countries reveals that the road to democratic and economic prosperity is quite clear. The matter has more to deal with the rejection of authoritarian type of management both in political and economic realms, establishment of market oriented relations and liberal economic environment. Liberal political and economic system in the country first and foremost presupposes deeper decentralization along with the autonomous strong municipal institutions from the perspectives of administration and financial capacity. However, a number of transition countries do not have any precise policy or concept for decentralization. They seem to be conservative towards any other external efforts or initiatives with that respect. The situation is even more complicated by a higher level of corruption in public administration and high-rank public officials preponderantly pursuing their own
    [Show full text]