Stakeholder Events and Attendance Registers

APPENDIX 3

Stakeholder events and attendance registers

1. NATIONAL 1.1. Stekeholder events . . . . . 100 1.2. List of attendees ...... 102 1.3. List of stakeholder invited that did not attend . . . 106

2. KWAZULU-NATAL 2.1. Stekeholder events . . . . . 109 2.2. List of attendees ...... 111 2.3. List of stakeholder invited that did not attend . . . 115

3. MPUMALAMGA & LIMPOPO PROVINCE 3.1. Stekeholder events . . . . . 118 3.2. List of attendees ...... 120 3.3. List of stakeholder invited that did not attend . . . 127

4. EASTERN CAPE & WESTERN CAPE 4.1. Stekeholder events . . . . . 130 4.2. List of attendees ...... 133 4.3. List of stakeholder invited that did not attend . . . 137

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 99 1. NATIONAL 1.1. Record of national consultation events DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS 15 October 2001 Mike Howard National Case Study English DEAT None Stephen Berrisford CSIR 15 October 2001 Mike Howard National Case Study English Dept Land Affairs None Stephen Berrisford 15 October 2001 Mike Howard National Case Study English SANPARKS None Stephen Berrisford 15 October 2001 Mike Howard National Case Study English DWAF None Stephen Berrisford 16 October 2001 Mike Howard National Case Study English AGRI-SA None Stephen Berrisford 31 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell National Case Study English Forestry SA Environmental None Fonda Lewis Committee Mike Howard 5 November 2001 Dominic Mitchell Workshop with National English SAAPAWU None Stephen Berrisford Labour sector CEPPWAWU Khulile Mavundla (Trainer) DWAF AUBTW CSFM 17 November Mike Howard National case Study English Timberwatch Objected to the merging 2001 Dominic Mitchell of natural forests and plantation forests 17 November Mike Howard National Case Study English Forestry SA None 2001 Dominic Mitchell 6 December 2001 Mike Howard Technical stakeholder English Forestry South Africa None Cathy Dzerefos workshop for forestry Global Forest Products practitioners and Hans Merensky environmental Mondi managers to review the Sappi desired conditions – SAFCOL Held at the Barnyard Theatre, White River 11 December Mike Howard Technical stakeholder English ICFR None 2001 Cathy Oelofse workshop for forestry Masonite Hylton Adie practitioners and Mondi

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 100 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS environmental Sappi managers to review the Singisi desired conditions – UNP – Forestry school Held at Ascot Conference Centre, Pietermaritzburg. 15 January 2002 Fonda Lewis Meeting with Natural English DWAF None Hylton Adie Forest Specialists to KZN Wildlife Coert Geldenhuys review desired NBI Dominic Mitchell conditions. Held at the UND University of Natal, UNP Durban. WESSA 16 January 2002 Fonda Lewis Meeting with Senior English DANCED None Myles Mander Govt Stakeholders. DEAT Dominic Mitchell Held in Pretoria. DTI DWAF NFAC NDA SANPARKS 17 January 2002 Dominic Mitchell Report back Meeting English CEPPWAWU Started late. Several did Stephen Berrisford with Labour Sector. NEHAWU not turn up. Held in Johannesburg. SAAPAWU 18 January 2002 Dominic Mitchell Meeting with Senior English DWAF None Jenny Mander Govt Stakholder 20 February 2002 Dominic Mitchell Government Key English DEAT None Stephen Berrisford Informant Review DWAF Meeting CSIR 22 February 2002 Fonda Lewis Industry Key Informant English Sappi More time required to Dominic Mitchell Meeting Global Forest Products discuss everything. Mike Howard Mondi Second meeting Stephen Berrisford SAFCOL scheduled for 12 March SAWGU 2002. Hans Merensky Mason Farms Forestry SA 25 February 2002 Fonda Lewis Natural Forest Key English WESSA None

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 101 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS Dominic Mitchell Informant Meeting KZN Wildlife Hylton Adie 12 March 2002 Fonda Lewis Industry Key Informant English Sappi None Dominic Mitchell Follow up Meeting Global Forest Products Stephen Berrisford Mondi Mike Howard SAFCOL SAWGU Hans Merensky Mason Farms Forestry SA 12 March 2002 Fonda Lewis Key Informant Meeting English KZN Wildlife None

1.2. List of attendees of national consultation events

Event Name Position in Organization Organization National Case Study Lisa Grobler PCIS Coordinator DEAT (15/10/2001) Liz Muller Consultant CSIR

National Case Study Sipho Sibanda Chief Director Dept Agric & Land Affairs (15/10/2001)

National Case Study Peter Novellie Scientific Services SANPARKS (15/10/2001)

National Case Study Linda Swanepoel Chief Director DWAF (15/10/2001) National Case Study Nick Opperman Portfolio Manager Water and Forestry Agri-SA (16/10/2001)

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 102 Event Name Position in Organization Organization Forest Industry Environment MBP Edwards Executive Director Forest Owners Association Committee National Case Study R Pott Environment manager Mondi (31/10/2001) L van Zyl Forestry Manager Hans Merensky S Meikle Enviromental Manager SAPPI G Marais Environmental Manager SAFCOL D Dobson Director SAWGU S McCartney Environmental Manager Forest Owners Association JW Hunt PAMSA D Everaad Environmental Manager SAPPI J Scotcher SAPPI D Pepler Stellenbosch University Workshop with National Pelelo Magane CEPPWAWU Labour Sector Thamsanqa Myeza SAAPAWU (05/11/2001) Witness Mulandana AUBTW Mathapo Mathapo SAAPAWU Mafu Nkosi DWAF Motsamai Nkosi DWAF

National Case Study Wally Menne Committee member Timberwatch (17/11/2001)

National Case Study Roger Grafton Editor Forestry SA (17/11/2001) Technical stakeholder workshop Stewart Meikle Enviromental Manager SAPPI for forestry practitioners and Steve Reynolds Business Manager SAPPI environmental managers to Shaun McCartney Environmental Manager GFP review the desired conditions – Roger Godsmark Assist Director FOA Held at the Barnyard Theatre, Gerrit Marais Environmental Manager Komatiland (SAFCOL) White River Louis van Zyl Forestry Manager Hans Merensky (06/12/2001)

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 103 Event Name Position in Organization Organization Technical stakeholder workshop Grant Rowe Masonite for forestry practitioners and David Everard Sappi environmental managers to Andrew Morris Sappi review the desired conditions. Carol Rolando ICFR Held in Pietermaritzburg John Swaine Mondi (11/12/2001) Chris Burchmore KZN Wildlife Stuart Charlton Singisi Craig Norris NCT Forests Ricky Pott Mondi Janusz Zwolinsky University of Natal Natural Forest Specialist Meeting Keith Cooper WESSA to review desired conditions. Held Neil Crouch National Botanical Institute in Durban (15/01/2002) Di Dold WESSA Hennie Gwanya DWAF Rynhardt Kok DWAF Mike Lawes UNP Steve McKean KZN Wildlife Armien Seydack DWAF Helen Watson UND Wiseman Yako DWAF Senior Government Stakeholder Paddy Abbot DWAF/DiFD Meeting. Held in Pretoria MJ Botha NDA (16/01/2002) P Botha DEAT T Demana DTI J Diederiks DANCED Liza Grobler DEAT S Kelatwang DWAF Ronny Madula DWAF Mmakomo Moloto DEAT A Myeni NFAC Mafu Nkosi DWAF D Nomshongwane DWAF Peter Novellie SANPARKS Devan Pillay Dept Labour Sipho Sibanda NDA T J van der Merwe DWAF T Vorster DWAF

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 104 Event Name Position in Organization Organization Reportback Meeting with Labour P Mogane CEPPWAWU Sector. Held in Johannesburg S Myaluza NEHAWU (17/01/2002) Thami Myeza SAAPAAWU S Nqata SEPPAAWU M Xulu SEPAAWU Govt Meeting. Held in Pretoria N Ncapaya DWAF (18/01/2002) M Warren DWAF Govt Key Informant Meeting Obed Baloyi DWAF (20/02/2002) Liza Grobler DEAT Linda Mossop Acting Director Forest Regulations DWAF Liz Muller CSIR Noxolo Ncapaya DWAF Mafu Nkosi DWAF RJ Sebola DWAF National Key Informant Review Dave Dobson SAWGU Meeting (22/02/2002) Marius du Plessis Mondi Mike Edwards Forestry SA Dave Everaad Sappi Peter Gardiner Mondi Roger Godsmark Forestry SA Ian Henderson Masonite Gerrit Marais SAFCOL Murray Mason Independent Farmer Shaun McCartney Global Forest Products Stewart Meikle Sappi Ricky Pott Mondi John Scotcher Sappi Louis van Zyl Hans Merensky Natural Forest Key Informant Keith Cooper WESSA Meeting (25/02/2002) Steve McKean KZN Wildlife Industry Key Informant Follow Up Dave Dobson SAWGU Meeting (12/03/2002) Marius du Plessis Mondi Mike Edwards Forestry SA Dave Everaad Sappi Peter Gardiner Mondi Roger Godsmark Forestry SA Gerrit Marais SAFCOL

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 105 Event Name Position in Organization Organization Murray Mason Independent Farmer Shaun McCartney Global Forest Products Ricky Pott Mondi John Scotcher Sappi Louis van Zyl Hans Merensky Brian Aitken Forestry South Africa Key Informant Meeting Pete Goodman KZN Wildlife (12/03/2002) Bill Howells Steve McKean Rob Scott Shaw Peter Thomson

1.3. List of invitees who did not attend consultation events

Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Workshop with National Sthembiso Myaluza General Secretary NEHAWU Called to urgent management Labour Sector Sylvester Sithole NEHAWU meeting (05/11/2001) Allistair Charles NEHAWU No reason provided Stanley Nqata SAAPAWU No reason provided Vorster Mbethe SAAPAWU No reason provided Mamane Xulu SAAPAWU No reason provided Thomas Mkala CEPPWAWU No reason provided Glen Mpufane NUM No reason provided Josephilda Nhlapo- COSATU Hlope No reason provided Jacqueline Mpolokeng COSATU Natural Forest Specialist Div Devilliers Dept Ec Affairs & Tourism Apologies Meeting to review desired Peter Goodman KZN Wildlife Apologies conditions. Held in Durban Ed Granger UNP Apologies (15/01/2002) Welile Kedama DWAF Sent representative Wally Menne Timberwatch Nicky Michelle Unizul Retiring

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 106 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Pat Reavell DWAF Apologies Rob Scott Shaw KZN Wildlife Apologies Peter Thomson KZN Wildllife Apologies Wessel Vermeulen DWAF Apologies Senior Government RM Adam Dept Arts & Culture No reason provided Stakeholder Meeting. Held in L Bethlehem DWAF Sent representative Pretoria (16/01/2002) M Msimang SANPARKS Apologies M Muller DWAF Sent representative N Nduli NDA Sent representative B Njobe NDA Sent representative A Ntsaluba Dept Health No reason provided S Nogxina Dept Energy & Mineral Affairs No reason provided C Olver DEAT Sent representative H Pienaar DWAF R Ramashia Dept Labour Sent representative A Ruiters DTI Sent representative B Shreiner DWAF Sent representative W Smit DWAF Sent representative F von Krosigk DWAF Sent representative Reportback Meeting with Allistair Charles NEHAWU Sent representative Labour Sector. Held in Glen Mpufane NUM No reason provided Johannesburg (17/01/2002) Witness Mulandana AUBTW Apology Josephilda Nhlapo- COSATU No reason provided Hlope National Key Informant Review Brian Aitkin FOA Apology Meeting (22/02/2002) Kevin Cazalet Mondi Apology Philip Day Apology Vince Erasmus Hans Merensky Apology Craig Norris NCT Forests Apology David Pepler University of Stellenbosch Apology Grant Rowe Masonite Apology John Swaine Mondi Apology Peter Viljoen Ecoserve Apology Rob Wilson Hall Moon Apology Natural Forest Key Informant Neil Crouch National Botanical Institute Apology – other commitment Meeting (25/02/2002) Fikile Dilika DWAF Apology

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 107 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Ed Granger University of Natal Apology – other commitment Peter Thomson KZN Wildlife Apology Rick van Wyk Apology Helen Watson University of Natal

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 108 2. KWAZULU-NATAL CONSULTATION EVENTS

2.1. Record of consultation events in kwaZulu-Natal

DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS 02 October 2001 Mike Howard KZN Case Study English Land Claims Commission None 02 October 2001 Mike Howard KZN Case Study English Dept Land Affairs None 03 October 2001 Mike Howard KZN Case Study English DWAF None 10 October 2001 Isaiah Mahlangu Bulwer Case Study English Singisi Forests None Fonda Lewis Independent small timber St gower representative Non-grower representative 11 October Isaiah Mahlangu Kwambonambi Case English KZN Wildlife None Fonda Lewis Study DWAF Steven Ngubane 11 October 2001 Isaiah Mahlangu Kwambonambi Case English Mondi An urgent Sappi Fonda Lewis study Sappi management meeting Steven Ngubane was called just before we were due to hold the workshop and therefore some of the more senior management staff from the area was not able to attend the case study. 15 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell Harding Case Study English South African Wattle Growers None Fonda Lewis Association representatives 16 October 2001 Steven Ngubane (Translator) Umzimkulu Case Study Xhosa Sizamimphilo muthi market None Dominic Mitchell and Bark harvester Fonda Lewis representatives Umzimkulu Tribal Authority DWAF Singisi 19 October 2001 Fonda Lewis KZN Provincial Case English NCT None Study Satga Independent Certification Consultant/Auditor

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 109 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS 21 October 2001 Steven Ngubane (Translator) Kwambonambi Case Zulu Nseleni small growers No problems reported Isaiah Mahlangu Study Kwambonambi small growers Khulile Mavundla (Trainer) Emphembeni small growers Fonda Lewis Port Durnford small growers Sokhulu small growers 19 November 2001 Dominic Mitchell KZN Provincial English SAPPI Process delayed by Fonda Lewis Workshop Mondi debate of process and Cathy Oelofse KZN Wildlife definitions – new date Steven Ngubane DWAF scheduled (3 UniZul December) to re- EJNF convene and complete Land Commission the workshop Masonite SAAPAWU NCT SAWGU FIA LIMA ICFR PAMSA Brousse-James 23 November 2001 Dominic Mitchell Mhlatuze Case Study English SATGA / NCT None Fonda Lewis representatives (small to medium timber producers) 3 December 2001 Dominic Mitchell KZN Provincial English SAPPI None Fonda Lewis Workshop Mondi Cathy Oelofse KZN Wildlife Steven Ngubane DWAF UniZul Masonite LIMA SAAPAWU Brousse-James 4 December 2001 Isaiah Mahlangu Kwambonambi Case English SAPPI None Fonda Lewis Study Feedback Mondi Steven Ngubane Workshop KZN Wildlife

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 110 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS DWAF 5 December 2001 Steven Ngubane (Translator) Kwambonambi Case Zulu Nseleni small growers None Fonda Lewis tudy Feedback Kwambonambi small growers Workshop Emphembeni small growers Port Durnford small growers Sokhulu small growers 6 December 2001 Dominic Mitchell Harding Feedback English SAWGU representatives None Fonda Lewis Workshop 7 December 2001 Steven Ngubane (Translator) Umzimkulu Feedback Xhosa Sizamimphilo muthi market None Dominic Mitchell Workshop and Bark harvester Fonda Lewis representatives Umzimkulu Tribal Authority DWAF Singisi

2.2. List of attendees of KwaZulu-Natal consultation events

Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Bulwer Case Study Koos Kotze Regional manager Singisi Forests (10/10/2001) Charles James Owner Private farmer Pat St Perne Farm Owner Private Farmer Kwambonambi Case Study P Connant KZN Wildlife (11/10/2001) S Lowe KZN Wildlife R Jones KZN Wildlife P Ngidi DWAF E Khanyile KZN Wildlife B Aitken CSFM Member Kwambonambi Case Study John Swaine Regional Manager Mondi (11/10/2001) Francois Retief Forester SAPPI Etienne Sander Forester SAPPI

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 111 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Umzimkulu/Harding Case Study D Jones Proprietors Private farmers (15/10/2001) R Rossler G Payn R Buhr K Wichmann D Willey K Bouverie G Jones J Payn M Galagher D Simpson B Lund R Miles Umzimkulu/Harding Case Study Alan Mathu Forester Singisi (16/10/2001) Sandiso Mabongo Forester DWAF Wiseman Rozani Forester DWAF Zodwa Khumalo Herbalist Herb Market Nkosi Nyandeni Traditional leader Nyandeni Tribal Authority Amos Dlamini Tribal Councillor Tribal Council Mr Mnguni Tribal Councillor Tribal Council Veronica Cwele Herbalist Sizamimpilo Virginia Hlengwa Herbalist Sizamimpilo Ms Mnguni Herbalist Sizamimpilo Patrick Ado Consultant Eesia Japhet Ngubane Consultant Eesia KwaZulu Natal Provincial Case James Perkins Water Aforestation DWAF – Water Study (19/10/2001) KwaZulu Natal Provincial Case Thabi Shange Commissioner Land Claims Commission Study (19/10/2001) KwaZulu Natal Provincial Case Mdu Shabane Provincial Director Dept Land Affairs Study (19/10/2001) KwaZulu Natal Provincial Case Vusi Dladla NCT Forests Study (19/10/2001) Craig Norris NCT Forests Bruce Ferguson SATGA Steven Germishuizen Assessor SGA Kwambonambi Case Study J Mthethwa Small grower KwaMbonambi (21/10/2001) M Mthethwa Forest worker KwaMbonambi

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 112 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Zeblon Mthiyane Induna KwaMbonambi Silwe Mtegu Dev. Forester NCT Ndumiso Zungu Small grower KwaSokhulu Sipho Ndunakazi Small grower Port Dunford Thoko Mkhonto Forest worker Port Dunford Boniswe Ndunakazi Forest worker Port Dunford Madodonke Zulu Small grower Enseleni Albert Ntshangase Small grower Enseleni Sipho Thusi Small grower Enseleni Joseph Mbokazi Small grower Empembeni RNB Shozi Forest worker Empembeni S Shozi Small grower Empembeni F Mkhize Small grower Empembeni SN Shandu Forest worker Empembeni KZN Provincial Workshop Barry James Brousse James & Associates (19/11/2001) Steve McKean KZN Wildlife Pete Conant KZN Wildlife John Swaine Mondi Ricky Pott Mondi Douglas McFarlane SAPPI Moses Ndlovu SAAPAWU Mark Clendennan NCT Forests Vusi Dladla NCT Forests John Feely SAWGU Peter Roberts Forest Industries Association Ian Felton Dept Agric & Enviro Affairs Marita Thornhill Dept Agric & Enviro Affairs Trudy Guma University of Zululand Japhet Ngubane EESIA Thabi Shange Land Claims Commission Zanele Mngoma EJNF Grant Rowe Masonite Rory Mack Lima Rural Development Mynah Dlamini Land Claims Commission Harald Witt Timberwatch Carol Rolando ICFR Fikile Dilika DWAF Tony leske PAMSA

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 113 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Hennie Gwanya DWAF Mafu Nkosi DWAF

Mhlatuze Case Study H Percival Proprietors Private Farmers (23/10/2001) S McMurray G Chandler D Leitch R McMurray B Aitken CSFM member KZN Provincial Workshop 2 Rory Mack Lima Development (03/12/2001) John Swaine Mondi Grant Rowe Masonite Moses Ndlovu SAAPAWU Trudy Guma University of Zululand Fikile Dilika DWAF Steve McKean KZN Wildlife Douglas Macfarlane SAPPI Barry James Brousse James & Associates Kwambonambi Case Study RW Jones KZN Wildlife Feedback Meeting S Louw KZN Wildlife (04/12/2001) DP Ngidi DWAF – IFM NH Ponoyi DWAF – IFM C Burchmore Mondi

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 114 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation T Netterville SAPPI T Rabie SAPPI C van Loggerenberg SAPPI Kwambonambi Case Study N Zungu Small grower KwaSohkulu Feedback meeting VA Mtshali Small grower KwaSokhulu (05/12/2001) S Ndunakazi Forest worker Port Dunford TD Buthelezi Small grower Enseleni T Ndunakazi Forest worker Port Dunford M Mjadu Induna Port Dunford I Maphumulo Induna Port Dunford NB Nene Forest worker Enseleni A Ntshangase Small grower Enseleni ZK Mlambo Forest worker Enseleni SM Mtshali Small grower Enseleni NS Mhlongo Co-op chair KwaDlangezwe RNB Shozi Forest worker Empembeni S Shozi Small grower Empembeni S Mbokazi Small grower Empembeni B Mbokazi Forest worker Empembeni Umzimkulu/Harding Feedback Ron Rossler Proprieters Farmers meeting (06/12/2001) D Willey Kim Bouverie M Gallagher D Simpson Bruce Lund Rodney Miles Mafu Nkosi Secretariat DWAF/CSFM Umzimkulu /Harding Feedback Johan de Beer Manager Singisi meeting (07/12/2001) Alan Mathu Forester Singisi Sandiso Mabongo Forester DWAF Wiseman Rozani Forester DWAF Zodwa Khumalo Herbalist Herb Market Mafu Nkosi DWAF

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 115 2.3. List of invitees who did not attend KwaZulu-Natal consultation events

Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Kwambonambi Case Theunisen Rabie Regional manager – forestry Sappi Called to urgent management study (11/10/2001) operations meeting Kwambonambi Case Alson Mthembu Regional Manager – Eshowe DWAF Noreason provided Study (11/10/2001) Graham Keet Conservator KZN Wildlife Called away to family emergency KZN Provincial Workshop Dave Dobson SAWGU Unavailable (19/11/2001) Dave Everaad SAPPI Sent representatives Bruce Ferguson SATGA Sent representatives Theunissen Rabie SAPPI Sent representatives Colin Dyer ICFR/SATGA Sent representatives Craig Norris NCT Forests Sent representatives Peter Keyworth NCT Forests Sent representatives Di Dold WESSA Unavailable Keith Cooper WESSA On leave Wally Menne Timberwatch Requested remuneration Andy Blackmore KZN Wildlife Sent representatives Dave Balfour KZN Wildlife No reason provided Khulani Mkhize KZN Wildlife Another urgent engagement Roger Porter KZN Wildlife No reason provided Ian Rushworth KZN Wildlife No reason provided James Wakelin KZN Wildlife No reason provided Doggy Kewely Mondi Sent representatives Mdu Shabane Dept of Land Affairs Unavailable H Karodia Dept of Agric & Env Affairs Sent representatives Sipho Mtetwa EJN No reason provided Nick Swan FEDA No reason provided Dan Moagi EDA Apologies Eddy Russell Pondo Crop Unavailable Duncan Stuart Lima Sent representative Sandile Ndawonde Earthlife No reason provided Neville Brummer Siyaqubeka No reason provided Welile Kedama DWAF Sent representative James Perkins DWAF Apologies Roddy Ward Rward Ecological Consultancy Apologies

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 116 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance John Hunt PAMSA Sent representative Pat Reavell Unizul Apologies Colleen Downs UNP No reason provided Vanessa Weyer Independent Env Planner Apologies Ernest Mdletshe Unizul Sent representative Prince Dube CEPPWAAWU No reason provided Louw Dladla CEPPWAAWU No reason provided Petrus Khambule SAPAAWU No reason provided Linda Ambler Groundwork No reason provided Patrick St Pern Farmer Apologies Charles James Farmer Apologies Vince Erasmus Singisi Apologies John Ferguson Singisi No reason provided Kwambonambi Feedback John Swaine Mondi Sent representative Meeting (04/12/2001) Pete Conant KZN Wildlife Sent representative Dave Balfour KZN Wildlife Sent representative Graham Keet KZN Wildlife Sent representative Edward Khanyile KZN Wildlife No reason provided Johannes Ntsele KZN Wildlife No reason provided Francois Retief SAPPI No reason provided Ettienne Sander SAPPI No reason provided Adison Mthembu DWAF No reason provided Brian Aitkin CSFM Apologies Gideon Cele Mondi - Khulanathi No reason provided Umzimkulu/Harding Case Des Jones Proprietors Farmers No reason provided Study Feedback Meeting Guy Payn No reason provided (06/12/2001) RF Buhr No reason provided K Wichmann No reason provided Gavin Jones No reason provided JD Payn Apologies Umzimkulu/Harding Case Nkosi James Nyandeni Traditional Leader Tribal Authority No reason provided Study Feedback Meeting (07/12/2001) Mhlatuze Case Study Dudley Leitch Proprietors Farmers Apologies Feedback Meeting Rudy Schnetler Apologies (23/11/2001) Ralph Dobeyn Apologies

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 117 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Kwambonambi Small M Zulu Small grower Enseleni No reason provided Growers Feedback J Mbokazi Small grower Empembeni No reason provided Meeting Z Mthiyane Induna/Small grower KwaMbonambi No reason provided (05/12/2001)

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 118 3. MPUMALANGA & LIMPOPO PROVINCES

3.1. Record of consultation events in Mpumalanga and Limpopo Province

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 119 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS 08 October 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Mpumalanga Case English Mpumalanga Parks Board None Cathy Dzerefos Study 08 October 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Mpumalanga Case English Working for Water None Cathy Dzerefos Study 09 October 2001 Penny Geerdts Mpumalanga Case English, SeSotho Greenvalley/Boelang Held at Setihare TA Coert Geldenhuys Study community offices, where other Cathy Dzerefos activities were taking Khulile Mavundla (Trainer), place - distracting Sam Moropane (Translator) 09 October 2001 Penny Geerdts Mpumalanga Case English SATGA private plantation None Cathy Dzerefos Study grower Coert Geldenhuys 10 October 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Mpumalanga Case Afrikaans SATGA private plantation None Study grower 10 October 2001 Penny Geerdts Mpumalanga Case English, SeSotho DWAF Forestry, management None Coert Geldenhuys Study and forestry workers Cathy Dzerefos Khulile Mavundla (Trainer) Sam Moropane (Translator) 11 October 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Mpumalanga Case English Global Forest Products None Study 12 October 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Mpumalanga Case English SAFCOL None Study 16 October 2001 Penny Geerdts Limpopo Province Case English, Venda Small Plantation Growers, None Cathy Dzerefos Study SATGA Mafu Nkosi Khulile Mavundla (Trainer) Zeblon Mphaphuli (Translator) 17 October 2001 Penny Geerdts Limpopo Province Case English, Venda Tshivhase TA Communities No women represented Cathy Dzerefos Study Mafu Nkosi Khulile Mavundla (Trainer), Zeblon Mphaphuli (Translator) 17 October 2001 Penny Geerdts Limpopo Province Case English Practical Solutions None Cathy Dzerefos Study Khulile Mavundla (Trainer)

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 120 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS 18 October 2001 Penny Geerdts Limpopo Province Case English, Venda Tshivhase TA Executive None Cathy Dzerefos Study Council Mafu Nkosi Zeblon Mphaphuli (Translator) 19 October 2001 Penny Geerdts Limpopo Province Case English DWAF Forestry None Coert Geldenhuys Study Forestry Biodiversity Mafu Nkosi Programme Zeblon Mphaphuli (Translator) 14 November Penny Geerdts Mpumalanga Provincial English Mondi Forests Labour Unions, DWAF 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Workshop SeSotho (on Sappi Water Affairs and some Miles Mander request) SAFCOL government Mafu Nkosi SAFCA departments did not Cathy Dzerefos DWAF Forestry attend the meeting Sam Moropane (Translator) Dpt of Mineral & Energy Affairs Dpt of Labour Dpt of Agriculture Dpt of Agriculture, Conservation & Environment Mpumalanga Parks Board Working for Water Global Forest Products NCT SATGA Hall & Sons Setihare Tribal Authority FFA WESSA Sabie River Co-ordinating Committee SA Water Crisis 14 November Coert Geldenhuys, Mpumalanga Provincial English Wits Rural Facility AWARD programme did 2001 Miles Mander Workshop not attend meeting but Cathy Dzerefos comments were sent 15 November Penny Geerdts Limpopo Province English University of Venda Tshivase Tribal 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Provincial Workshop Practical Solutions Authority or community

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 121 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS Miles Mander DWAF Forestry representatives and Mafu Nkosi Dpt of Agriculture (National & commercial Cathy Dzerefos Provincial) organisations did not Zeblon Mphaphuli (Translator) Dpt of Finance, Environmental attend; there were many Affairs & Tourism apologies Dpt of Labour SAAPAAWU 10 December Penny Geerdts Limpopo Province English Small Plantation Growers, No nominated 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Feedback Workshop SATGA community Mafu Nkosi Tshivhase TA Executive representatives Zeblon Mphaphuli (Translator) Council attended 10 December Penny Geerdts Limpopo Province English Steven’s Lumber Mill None 2001 Coert Geldenhuys Feedback Workshop Afrikaans Small timber growers from Cathy Dzerefos Agatha and Georges Valley, SATGA 11 December Coert Geldenhuys Limpopo Province English Kruger to Canyons Water & None 2001 Feedback Workshop Nature Project 11 December Coert Geldenhuys Limpopo Province English Kruger National Park None 2001 Feedback Workshop Afrikaans 11 December Coert Geldenhuys Limpopo Province English SATGA private plantation None 2001 Feedback Workshop grower 21 February 2002 Fonda Lewis Limpopo Province key Tshivenda Small growers None Dominic Mitchell informant review English meeting

3.2. List of attendees of Mpumalanga and Limpopo consultation events

Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Mpumalanga Case Study Mervyn Lötter Scientist Mpumalanga Parks Board (08/10/2001) Charles Ngobeni Conservation Auditing Manager Mpumalanga Parks Board Kevan Zunckel General Manager Mpumalanga Parks Board

Quinton Pretorius Senior Project Manager Working for Water Fiona Ross GIS & Data Co-ordinator Working for Water

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 122 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Willie Lekhuleni Project Manager Working for Water Mpumalanga Case Study E Moropane Tribal Authority Greenvalley/Boelang Community, (09/10/2001) J Malabe Setihare Traditional Authority F Motabatse E Maatjie O Chiloane Inkosi A Bango Small Farmers H Chiloane J Maleke S Mohlabiwa Forest neighbour W Sabashe P Malope P Mahlake E Masitile T Malebe E Mohlaba A Maatjie B Dilebe M Moeng R Morale S Moshego B Masuvle T Phale E Mohlolo S Sakoene M Masope M Kewedi H Phale R Theko S Shubane E Sakoene E Maatjie E Modipane S Bulebo G Sebashe C Mokoena F Bulebo P Kgwedi

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 123 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation S Komane D Mokome C Moripa Private Plantation Grower, SATGA Clive Leyland Mpumalanga Case Study Kobus Visser Private Plantation Grower, SATGA (10/10/2001) P Reyneke Regional Director Forestry DWAF Management (regional office & P Ntabeni Assistant Director, Community Forestry Salique, Onverwacht, Welgevonden, Hebron, I Setshoane Foresters Mariepskop Plantations Plantations) S Nkosi J Le Roux M Aphane A Kgatla M Shilakwe P Kgomo L Nemakonde S Phala M Maepa N Ximba B Mashego W Mashego W Mathe E Mashao N Malatsi P Pamalepe A Seoke F Dilebo S Ngwempama ASO M Mhlanga ASO M Du Toit Forest Scientist R Green Principal Scientist DWAF Forestry Workers FD Mahlake (Salique, Onverwacht, Welgevonden, Hebron, E Nonyane Mariepskop Plantations) E Gemedze L Maule N Shilelewe F Chiloane E Monanang NE Malumane

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 124 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation E Moritse E Phokane S Mashego J Maromane E Mokoni B Malatja F Dibakeva M Mahlake L Mokome E Maunye F Monaneng A Seleki D Mohlala L Sekatane S Chiloane L Maholodele Mpumalanga Case Study D Lawrie Forest Engineer & Fire Protection Global Forest Products (11/10/2001) S McCartney Environmental Manager L McNamara Silviculture Manager Mpumalanga Case Study G Marais Environmental Manager SAFCOL (11/10/2001) Limpopo Province Case Study 24 representatives Small Plantation Growers, SATGA (16/10/2001) Limpopo Province Case Study R Tshivhase Community members resident around Thathe (17/10/2001) M Musiwalo Vondo, Tshivhase Traditional Authority S Tshivhase R Sikhuevhela A Nemakivhemani W Muvhango F Tshivhase L Tshivhase R Mathoho N Netshiavha N Nemurangeni W Mukhaninga G Ramulongo V Nevhutanda

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 125 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation E Tsiku T Sididzha P Mugwena D Nevondo P Tshieteshe R Vondo T Tshikhovhokhovho F Mogube A Rathogwa S Makhado N Tshivhase M Philly J Netshirovha D Ralinalo M Masikhwa M Singo J Nemaranzwe O Ramulongo T Nemakamba S Mmbadi N Nyamande M Nemudzivhadi M Themeli A Thanyani M Masikhwami Practical Solutions Fiona Nicholson Co-ordinator Limpopo Province Case Study S Tshivhase Executive Councillor Tshivhase Traditional Authority Executive (18/10/2001) M Mulavakazi Council Secretary Council B Sikhwivhilu Executive Councillor F Tshivhase Executive Councillor Limpopo Province Case Study L Legodi Chief Forester DWAFLetaba (19/10/2001) E Mavhungu Chief Forester DWAF Voorspoed D Mavhungu Chief Forester DWAF Soutpansberg D Raunge Chief Forester DWAF Thathe Vondo B Neluonbe Chief Forester DWAF Phiphidi C Ndou Forester DWAF Louis Trichardt E Nemakhavani Forester DWAF Thathe Vondo T Manyaga Driver DWAF Thathe Vondo

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 126 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation M Tshivhase Clerk DWAF Thathe Vondo S Venter Forestry Scientist DWAF Louis Trichardt A Matshiphephe Control Forester DWAF Louis Trichardt N Olemukule Forester DWAF Rossbach J Swaye Researcher, Student Forest Biodiversity Programme, University of D Forbes Researcher, Student Natal (PMB) Mpumalanga Provincial S Meikle Environmental Manager Sappi Forests Workshop S McCartney Environmental Manager Global Forest Products (14/11/2001) R Pott Environmental Manager Mondi Forests A Marais Environmental Manager Mondi Forests V Lascelles NCT D Peoples Chair SATGA R Wilson Hall & Sons J Steenkamp General Manager South African Forestry Contractors Association R Moshile Community representative Setihare Traditional Authority M Dilebo Community representative Greenvalley/Boelang Community M Brunduyn Assistant Director: IFM DWAF Forestry W Mashego Forester: IFM DWAF Forestry S Maepa Forester: Community Forestry DWAF Forestry L Nemakonde Forester: Community Forestry DWAF Forestry M Lizamore Stream flow Reduction Activity DWAF Water Affairs Q Pretorius Senior Project Manager Working for Water G Marais Environmental Manager SAFCOL D Du Plessis Dept of Mineral & Energy Affairs F Mashabela Provincial Dept of Agriculture F Moatshe Dept of Agriculture, Conservation & R Stroebel Environment (DACE) G Smith General Manager Dept of Labour K Zunckel Mpumalanga Parks Board S Evered General Manager WESSA J Heine Forest Fire Association P Owen Chair South African Water Crisis F Weir Sabie River Co-ordinating Committee Wayne Twine Wits Rural Facility Limpopo Province Provincial E Netshiungani Dept of Finance, Environmental Workshop Affairs & Tourism

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 127 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation (15/11/2001) G Engelbrecht Director: Agricultural Land Resource National Dept of Agriculture Management E Kganyago Senior Manager Provincial Dept of Agriculture C Ndou Forester DWAF Forestry S Venter Forestry Scientist DWAF Forestry B Homewood Community Forestry DWAF Forestry L Ndleve Dept of Labour D Shirindza Dept of Labour D Tshilande Regional Secretary SAAPAAWU F Nicholson Co-ordinator Practical Solutions C Todd School of Mathematics & Natural Sciences, University of Venda B vd Waal School of Environmental Sciences, University of Venda S Foord L Ndou K Steyn Mpumalanga Feedback C Clarke Environmental Specialist Intact; Kruger to Canyons Water & Workshop Nature Programme (11/12/2001) A Van Wyk Kruger National Park C Leyland Private Plantation Grower, SATGA Limpopo Province Feedback B Sikhwiyhiluba Small Plantation Growers, SATGA Workshop W Lirumo (10/12/2001) F Muthala D Khakhu N Netshiavha M Marahoa Limpopo Province Feedback P Henning SATGA Committee, plantation owner SATGA Workshop N Human SATGA committee, plantation owner SATGA (10/12/2001) C Morgan SATGA committee SATGA, Steven’s Lumber Mill Limpopo Province Key Informant A S Khakhu Small grower Small growers Thathe Vondo area Review Meeting (21/02/2002) M E Khakhu Small grower W Lirumo Small grower M P Marahdu Small grower M N Masikhwa Small grower N G Masikhwa Small grower S Muothe Small grower

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 128 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation M P Musetsho Small grower L Neluvade Small grower P T Ngislanda Small grower R B Tembulu Small grower A Thanyani Small grower S Thobone Small grower T P Tshikambu Small grower F Tshivhase Small grower

3.3. List of Mpumalanga and Limpopo invitees who did not attend consultation events

Event Name Position in Organisation Reasons Organisation provided for non-attendance Limpopo M Sneyders Area Manager Working for Water No reason Province provided Case Study (19/10/2001) Mpumalanga D Black General Mondi Timber Recommended Provincial Manager, Sabie Mondi Workshop K Visser SATGA Forests (14/11/2001) C Leyland Private SATGA instead P Visser plantation SGS Time constraints A vd Merwe grower DWAF Water Affairs Time constraints Private No reason L Yeatman plantation DANCED CF Project provided M du Toit grower No reason T Poulter FSC Auditor Working for Water provided G Batchelor Assistant Dept of Agriculture, R Naidoo Director: Water Conservation & Project AGM N Zwane Quality Environment No reason T Mabelane Management Dept of Land Affairs provided M Madlamini Dept of Arts & Sent Culture representative L Foxcroft Director: Dept of Health; No reason

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 129 Event Name Position in Organisation Reasons Organisation provided for non-attendance S Mofokeng Directorate of Traditional Healers provided A Thobelane Environmental Association S Mkhewebane Management Kruger National No reason Parks provided S Pollard Director CEPPWAWU No reason T Mhlanga Alien Biota SAAPAWU provided Manager South African No reason G Deall Independent provided J Newenham Allied Workers E Koch Regional Union No reason Secretary Save the Sand provided Branch Environmental No reason Organiser Justice provided General Networking No reason Secretary Forum provided Ecorex No reason Kruger to Canyon provided Representative Biosphere No reason provided No reason Co-ordinator provided

Moved to Johannesburg Out of town No reason provided Limpopo P Henning Chair, Limpopo SATGA Timber auction Province F Terrink Province Mondi Timber No reason Provincial K Moldenhauer Sawmill Mondi Forests provided Workshop R Tshivhase Manager CSFM No reason (15/11/2001) (+ others) Forestry Area Small Plantation provided Manager Growers, No reason Committee SATGA provided member Tshivhase TA No reason

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 130 Event Name Position in Organisation Reasons Organisation provided for non-attendance Members Executive provided Council L Nel Council Tshivhase TA No reason members communities provided

F Hlungani Community Dept of Finance, No reason members Environmental provided Affairs & No reason T Dlamini Head, provided V Mongwe Biodiversity Tourism Dept of No reason M Sneyders Finance, provided W Hollestein Management Environmental E Letsoalo Affairs & R Semenya Tourism No reason W Nkwashu Tourism provided K Nkgapelo DWAF Forestry M Galane Community DWAF Water Affairs Forestry Working for Water No reason W Tuhna Deputy Director: SAFCOL provided Prof Nkatini Water Affiars Dept of Land Affairs No reason Area Manager Dept of Arts & provided P Winter Culture No reason Provincial CEPPWAWU provided Director NEHAWU No reason MEC, NP Environmental provided Regional Justice No reason Organiser Networking provided Forum No reason Streamflow provided Reduction Activity No reason Chair Great Limpopo provided Transfrontier Park No reason Haenertsburg provided Co-ordinator Environmental Requiring Management & Dvt permission from Fourm Head

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 131 Event Name Position in Organisation Reasons Organisation provided for non-attendance Office No reason provided Attending workshop out of the

country Time constraints

Mpumalanga M Tinker-Uys Southern African Sent C Clarke Feedback Wildlife College as alternate Workshop Chief Chiloane Chief Setihare Traditional (11/12/2001) Greenvalley/Boelang Community Authority Chief’s mother Community representatives Greenvalley/Boelang passed away the representatives Community morning of the workshop (C Nxumalo, the Chair of the TA, K Visser Private plantation to organise an grower alternative meeting after the period of mourning) No time Limpopo Tshivhase Community Tshivhase Traditional No reason Province Community representatives Authority provided Feedback Representatives SAFCOL Workshop W Hollestein All (10/12/2001) representatives on leave

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 132 Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 133 4. EASTERN CAPE & WESTERN CAPE

4.1. Record of consultation events in the Eastern Cape and Western Cape DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS 4 October 2001 Tony Barbour Tokai Case Study English Friends of Tokai None Cori Ham Nceba Ngcobo 5 October 2001 Tony Barbour Tokai Case Study English Cape Peninsula national Park None Cori Ham Nceba Ngcobo 11 October 2001 Mike Howard Western Cape English Dept Economic Affairs None Stephen Berrisford Provincial Case Study 11 October 2001 Cori Ham Western Cape English Ukuvuka None Stephen Berrisford Provincial Case Study Working for Water 11 October 2001 Mike Howard Western Cape English DWAF None Stephen Berrisford Provincial Case Study 12 October 2001 Mike Howard Western Cape English SAFCOL None Stephen Berrisford Provincial Case Study 12 October 2001 Mike Howard Western Cape English Stellenbosch University None Stephen Berrisford Provincial Case Study 12 October 2001 Tony Barbour Tokai Case Study English Department of Forest Science, None Cori Ham University of Stellenbosch Nceba Ngcobo 12 October 2001 Tony Barbour Tokai Case Study English SAFCOL Boland Region None Cori Ham Nceba Ngcobo 15 October 2001 Tony Barbour Tokai Case Study English Working for Water None Cori Ham Ukuvuka Nceba Ngcobo 16 October 2001 Tony Barbour Storms River Case English DWAF None Cori Ham Study DEAT Nceba Ngcobo Western Cape Nature Conservation SAN Parks P.E. Technikon - Saasveld 16 October 2001 Tony Barbour Storms River Case English Eco tourism sector None Cori Ham Study Storms River Adventures

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 134 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS Nceba Ngcobo 16 October 2001 Tony Barbour Storms River Case English DWAF regional office None Cori Ham Study Nceba Ngcobo 17 October 2001 Tony Barbour Storms River Case English SAFCOL Humansdorp None Cori Ham Study Nceba Ngcobo 17 October 2001 Tony Barbour Storms River Case English SAN Parks (Tsitsikamma) None Cori Ham Study Nceba Ngcobo 17 October 2001 Tony Barbour Storms River Case Afrikaans Thornham community None Cori Ham Study representative Nceba Ngcobo 18 October 2001 Tony Barbour Storms River Case English Working for Water None Cori Ham Study Plettenberg Bay Nceba Ngcobo Environmental Forum Botanical Society Natures Valley Trust 8 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell Port St Johns Case English DWAF None Cori Ham Study Nceba Ngcobo 8 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell Port St Johns Case English Tourism representative None Cori Ham Study Nceba Ngcobo 9 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell Port St Johns Case English WWF None Cori Ham Study Nceba Ngcobo 9 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell Port St Johns Case English Land surveyor None Cori Ham Study Nceba Ngcobo 9 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell Port St Johns Case Xhosa WWF None Cori Ham Study Green Trust Nceba Ngcobo Masters Farmers 10 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell Port St Johns Case English Eastern Cape Nature Started a bit late Cori Ham Study Conservation Nceba Ngcobo

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 135 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS 10 October 2001 Dominic Mitchell Port St Johns Case English University of Transkei – None Cori Ham Study Botany and Zoology Nceba Ngcobo 20 November Dominic Mitchell Eastern Cape Provincial English FGWU None 2001 Cori Ham Workshop STEP Project Nceba Ngcobo Unitra Fort Cox DWAF Stephen Keet Associates WESSA Buffalo City Municipality FARM Developers North East Cape Forests WCSDI Dept of Env Affairs 21 November Tony Barbour Southern Cape English Knysna Environmental Forum None 2001 Shona Young Provincial Workshop Knysna Municipality Cori Ham and case study WESSA Nceba Ngcobo feedback P.J. Van Reenen (PTY) LTD. NCT Forestry Cooperative SAFCOL PE Technicon – Saasveld DWAF MTO George Sawmill CEPPWAUU SAN Parks Tsitsikamma National Park Garden Route Trust Working for Water Geo Parks and Sons (PTY0 LTD. Cape Nature Conservation Plettenberg Bay Community Forum DEAT (DECAS) District Municipality

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 136 DATE FACILITATORS EVENT LANGUAGE GROUPS ATTENDING PROBLEMS & CONSTRAINTS 22 November Tony Barbour Western Cape English DWAF None 2001 Shona Young Provincial Workshop University of Stellenbosch Cori Ham and case study Stellenbosch Forestry Nceba Ngcobo feedback Students Association WWF Cape Metropolitan Council SAFCOL Friends of Tokai (WESSA) Department of Land Affairs Working for Water SAN Parks SAAPAWU 5 December 2001 Dominic Mitchell Port St Johns Case English Eastern Cape Tourism None Cori Ham Study Feedback Master Farmers Programme Nceba Ngcobo workshop DOA Pondo People DWAF

25 February 2002 Tony Barbour Key Informant Review English University of Stellenbosch None Cori Ham Meeting SAFCOL

4.2. List of attendees of Eastern Cape & Western Cape consultation events

EVENT NAME POSITION IN ORGANISATION ORGANISATION Tokai Case Study (04/10/01) John Green Chairman Friends of Tokai Tokai Case Study (05/10/01) Paul Britton Park Manager Cape Peninsula National Park Tokai Case Study (12/10/01) Pierre Ackermann Academic Stellenbosch University Prof. Gerrit van Wyk Academic Stellenbosch University Dr Andre Rozanov Academic Stellenbosch University Dr Eksteen Uys Academic Stellenbosch University Dr Isla Grundy Academic Stellenbosch Tokai Case Study (12/10/01) Braam Du Preez Regional Manager SAFCOL Boland Region Tokai Case Study (15/10/01) Val Charlton Senior researcher Ukuvuku

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 137 EVENT NAME POSITION IN ORGANISATION ORGANISATION Sandra Fowkes Manager Ukuvuku Brian van Wilgen Specialist Working for Water/CSIR Anban Padayachee Social researcher Ukuvuku Noluvuyo Mashologu Social researcher Ukuvuku Storms River Case Study (16/10/01) Wessel Vermulen Natural Forest Scientist DWAF (IFM) Danie Swanepoel Scientist DECAS Alistar MacDonald Scientist WCNCB Nick Hanekom Scientist SAN Parks Rod Randall SAN Parks Mike Cameron PE Technikon (Saasveld) Peet Joubert SAN Parks (Knysna) Steve Du Toit DECAS Storms River Case Study (16/10/01) John Wayland Proprietor Eco Tourism Sector Ashley Wentworth Proprietor Storms River Adventures Storms River Case Study (16/10/01) Carel van der Merwe Manager of the Tsitsikama DWAF (Tsitsikama) Forest Storms River Case Study (17/10/01) James Lukhof Manager SAFCOL Eastern Cape Karen Kirkman Environmental Manager SAFCOL Eastern Cape Storms River Case Study (17/10/01) Nico van der Walt Manager SAN Parks (Tsitsikama) Andre Riley Scientific Officer SAN Parks (Tsitsikama) Storms River Case Study (17/10/01) Pastor Henrico Bruiners Pastor Thornham Local Community Storms River Case Study (18/10/01) Pam Booth Local Manager Working for Water Elbie Burger Member Plett Enviro Forum Ian Dewar Member Plett Enviro Forum Peter Stratten Member Plett Enviro Forum Paul Falla Chairman Botanical Society PLett John Foord Natures Valley Trust

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 138 EVENT NAME POSITION IN ORGANISATION ORGANISATION Southern Cape Provincial Workshop Toni Tonim Chairman Knysna Environmental Forum and report back to stakeholders Ivan Van Wyk Knysna Municipality (21/11/01) Clive Nuns Knysna Municipality Ian Withers Member WESSA Warwick Van Reenen Proprietor P.J. Van Reenen (Pty) Ltd Willo Van Reenen P.J. Van Reenen (Pty) Ltd Marius Neser Marketing and Suppliers Co- NCT Forestry Co-operative ordinator Karen Kirkman Environmental Manager SAFCOL Larry Alcock Academic PE Technikon George Campus Mike Cameron Academic PE Technikon Saasveld Alistar Yardley DWAF Bruce Tu MTO George Sawmill Williams Johnson Organiser CEPPWAUU S.Cape Nick Hanekom Scientist SA National Parks Rynard Kok DWAF Andre Riley Scientific Officer Tsitsikama National Park Nico Van Der Walt Manager Tsitsikama National Park Peter Stratten Member Wildlife Society Plett Elzette Bester Manager – social ecology Tsitsikama National Park Jenny Lawrence Member Garden Route Trust Pamela Booth Local Manager Working for Water Carel Van Der Merwe Manager DWAF John and Anda Wayland Proprietors Tsitsikama Tourism Association Jim Parkes Managing Director Geo Parkes and Sons (Pty) Ltd Johan Huisamen Cape Nature Conservation Willie Louw Academic PE Technikon Henry Hill Indicator development District Municipality programme co-ordinator Elbie Burger Secretary Plett Community Enviro Forum Steve Du Toit DECAS Ian Dewar Community member Plett Community

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 139 EVENT NAME POSITION IN ORGANISATION ORGANISATION Western Cape Provincial Workshop Mafu Nkosi DWAF and report back to stakeholders Pierre Ackerman Academic Stellenbosch University (22/11/01) Riaan Ferriera Chairman Stellenbosch Forestry Students Association Lisa Padfield Member WWF Elbrecht Oswald CMC Administration Braam Du Preez Regional Manager MTO Forestry (SAFCOL) Boland Cassie Carstens MTO Forstry (SAFCOL) E Cape John Green Chairman of Friends of Tokai WESSA and Friends of Tokai Forest Sue Middleton Dept of Land Affairs Megan Bradfield Working for Water Hester Lyons DWAF Chad Cheney South African National parks Irvin Shuma SAAPAWU Trevor Hufke SAAPAWU Andrew Wannenburgh Working for Water Eastern Cape Provincial Workshop – Mbulelo Jolisa Regional organiser FGWU East London (20/11/2001) Sharon Wilson Researcher STEP Project Rehema White Academic Unitra Mike Greenland Academic Fort Cox Wiseman Yako DWAF Avril Wilkinson WESSA Stephen Keet Consultant Stephen Keet Associates Suresh Sivai Buffalo City Municipality Gavin Koopman Buffalo City Municipality Reg Herapath Buffalo City Municipality Rolf Maier Buffalo City Municipality Brett Dustan Development consultant FARM Developers Graeme Harrison DWAF Fred Basset Manager North East Cape Forests Koli Mhlana WC SDI Gerry Pienaar Dept Env Affairs Port St Johns Case Study Feedback John Costello Tourism meeting (5/12/2001) Kathryn Costello Tourism Mbulelo Maqanqa Master Farmers Programme Marlene Powell Tourism Mtiyiseli Ntsabo DOA

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 140 EVENT NAME POSITION IN ORGANISATION ORGANISATION Sibabini Glanga DWAF Gail Sink Pondo People Mafu Nkosi DWAF Key Informant Review Meeting Prof R Bigalke Academic Univeristy of Stellenbosch (25/02/2002) Braam du Preez Regional Manager SAFCOL Dr E Uys Academic Univeristy of Stellenbosch Prof G van Wyk Academic Univeristy of Stellenbosch

4.3. List of Eastern Cape and Western Cape invitees who did not attend consultation events

Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Southern Cape Provincial Mr Callie Corbit Steinhoff southern Cape No reason provided Workshop and report back Danie Swanepoel DWAF No reason provided to stakeholders (21/11/01) Michael Peter Knysna Municipality No reason provided Wiekie Smit DWAF No reason provided Wessel Vermeulen George Tourism Bureau No reason provided Minnie Dreyer Plett Botanical Society No reason provided Paul Falla Chariman Plett Toursim Bureau No reason provided Lee Anne Le Roux Knysna Tourism Bureau No reason provided Joyce Ogilvie Wilderness Tourism No reason provided Ludrich Barnard SAFCOL No reason provided James Luckhof CNC No reason provided Ivan Donian Manager Tsitsikamma Tourism No reason provided Amanda Van Wyk DWAF No reason provided Susan Steyn SAASVELD No reason provided Peter De Wet SAFCOL No reason provided George Busshe Wildlife and Envir No reason provided Mr Carstens SAFCOL No reason provided Lorna Watt No reason provided Gerrit Niewoudt No reason provided

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 141 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Western Cape Provincial Fanie Bekker Cape Nature Conservation No reason provided Workshop and report back Ben Du Plessis DWAF No reason provided to stakeholders (22/11/01) Christo Marais Working for Water Project No reason provided Dumisani Sibayi SA heritage Resource Agency No reason provided Susan Steyn DWAF Sending a representative Patrick Dowling WESSA Sending John Green as a Andy Gubb WESSA representative Rob Little WWF Sending Lisa Padfield as a representative Thabanga Ngcozela EJNF Said he would send someone Leslie Richardson WWF from the EJNF Paul Britton Park Manager Cape Peninsula National Sending Lisa Padfield as a Parks representative Prof Gerrit Van Wyk Forestry Sciences, Stellenbosch University Did not rsvp Michael Shuttleworth Working for Water Did not rsvp Guy Preston WFW Unable to attend Brian Van Wigen Specialist Working for Water/CSIR Confirmed he would attend but never arrived Sandra Fowkes Manager UKUVUKU Unable to attend Gavin Bell Cape Peninsula National Did not rsvp Parks

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 142 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Eastern Cape Provincial Mkululi Siduna CEPPWAWU No reason provided Workshop – East Mlamleli Pokwana SAAPAWU No reason provided London Charlie Shackleton Env Science Program Apologies (20/11/2001) Travis Bailey Community Resource No reason provided Opt Programme Mr Kawa DWAF No reason provided Timbela Zwene CIMEC No reason provided Shadrack Ningiza DWAF No reason provided Dave Butt NE Cape Forests No reason provided Ashley Westaway Border Rural No reason provided Committee Des Hansell Ranch Timber Products No reason provided Craig Warren SATGA No reason provided Gabs Gabula Dept Economic Affairs No reason provided Sabelo Mgudlwa DWAF No reason provided Richard Bolus Master Farmers Prog No reason provided John & Kathryn Port St Johns Tourism Apologies Costello Malta Qathekhane WWF-SA Apologies Herman Timmermans PEOPLE Apologies Mcebisi Jonas E Cape Dev Corp No reason provided Sizwe Cawe Unitra No reason provided Ken Griffith Border Birding Club Apologies Ted Avis Coastal & Env Services No reason provided Michelle Cocks Rhodes University Away Danie Gouws SAFCOL No reason provided Christo Fabricius Saasveld No reason provided Sakiwo Zako CEPPWAWU No reason provided Baldwin EJNF No reason provided Mehlomakhulu Dr Siqwana-Ndulo Rural Research & Dev No reason provided Institute

Port St Johns Case Study Malta Qwathekhane WWF-SA on leave Reportback meeting Charlie Battle Surveyor work engagement (05/12/2001) Wiseman Yako DWAF work engagement Sabelo Mgudlwa DWAF work engagement

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 143 Event Name Position in Organisation Organisation Reasons provided for non- attendance Rehema White Unitra no reason provided Sizwe Cawe Unitra no reason provided Div de Villiers Dept of Env Affairs apologised Khaya Gqwabaza Port St Johns Municipality no reason provided

Section C: Draft principles, criteria, indicators and standards for sustainable forest management 144