By Salafi Manhaj
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Is Salafiyyah a Cause of Terrorism? ______________________________________________________________ SSAALLAAFFIIMMAANNHHAAJJ..CCOOMM RREESSEEAARRCCHH DDIIVVIISSIIOONN ˶ΏΎ˴Β˸γ˴˴Ϧ˶ϣϲϔϠ˴δϟΞ˴ϬϨ˴ϤϟϞ˴ϫ˶ΏΎ˴Β˸γ˴˴Ϧ˶ϣϲϔϠ˴δϟΞ˴ϬϨ˴ϤϟϞ˴ϫ ˮ˶ϑ͊ήτ˴Θϟ˴ϭ͋Ϯ˵Ϡϐϟ˴ϭ˶ΏΎϫ˸έϹˮ˶ϑ͊ήτ˴Θϟ˴ϭ͋Ϯ˵Ϡϐϟ˴ϭ˶ΏΎϫ˸έϹ IISS TTHHEE SSAALLAAFFII MMAANNHHAAJJ AANN IINNDDIICCAATTOORR OOFF TTEERRRROORRIISSMM,, PPOOLLIITTIICCAALL VVIIOOLLEENNCCEE AANNDD RRAADDIICCAALLIISSAATTIIOONN?? AA CCRRIITTIICCAALL SSTTUUDDYY OOFF TTHHEE NNYYPPDD DDOOCCUUMMEENNTT:: ‘RADICALIZATION IN THE WEST – THE HOMEGROWN THREAT’, BY MITCHELL D.SILBER AND ARVIN BHATT (SENIOR INTELLIGENCE ANALYSTS – NYPD INTELLIGENCE DIVISION)1 1 This is available Online at: http://www.nyc.gov/html/nypd/pdf/dcpi/NYPD_Report- Radicalization_in_the_West.pdf __________________________________________________________________ 1 © SalafiManhaj 2007 Is Salafiyyah a Cause of Terrorism? ______________________________________________________________ CONTENTS 3 Summary 7 Introduction 10 Well-Known Salafi Scholars and their Views on Terrorism, Radical Politicization and Violent Extremism 37 Key Observations about Silber and Bhatt’s Report 49 Salafi Mosques in the West that have Consistently Opposed Terrorism, Radical Politicization of Views and Violent Extremism: A Case Study of Brixton Mosque and Islamic Cultural Centre (aka Masjid Ibn Taymiyyah) in London 58 Conclusion __________________________________________________________________ 2 © SalafiManhaj 2007 Is Salafiyyah a Cause of Terrorism? ______________________________________________________________ SUMMARY Indeed, all praise is due to Allaah, we praise Him, we seek His aid, and we ask for His forgiveness. We seek refuge in Allaah from the evil of our actions and from the evil consequences of our actions. Whomever Allaah guides, there is none to misguide and whoever Allaah misguides there is none to guide. I bear witness that there is no god worthy of worship except Allaah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the servant and messenger of Allaah. ƂƊǹ Ȃ ĄǸ ÊǴ ąLj ČǷ Ƕ ĄƬ ǻ ƊƗ ăȁ ōȏ Êƛ ċǺ Ąƫ Ȃ ĄǸ ăƫ Ɗȏ ăȁ ÊǾ Êƫ Ƣ ƊǬ Ąƫ ċǪ ăƷ ăǾ ƐǴ dz ơ ƒơ Ȃ ƌǬ ċƫ ơ ƒơȂĄǼăǷƕăǺȇÊǀōdzơƢăȀČȇƊƗƢăȇƃ “O you who have believed, fear Allaah as He should be feared and do not die except as Muslims (in submission to Him).” {Aali-Imraan (3): 102} ơ ĆŚ Êư Ɗǯ Ɔȏ Ƣ ăƳ Êǁ Ƣ ăǸ ĄȀ ąǼ ÊǷ ōƮ ăƥ ăȁ Ƣ ăȀ ăƳ ąȁ ăǃ Ƣ ăȀ ąǼ ÊǷ ăǪ ƊǴ ăƻ ăȁ ÇƧ ăƾ ÊƷ ơ ăȁ Çdž ƒǨ ċǻ Ǻ ďǷ Ƕ ƌǰ ƊǬ ƊǴ ăƻ ȅ Êǀ ōdz ơ ĄǶ ƌǰ ċƥ ăǁ ƒơ Ȃ ƌǬ ċƫ ơ ĄDž Ƣ ċǼ dz ơ Ƣ ăȀ Čȇ ƊƗ Ƣ ăȇ ƃ ƂƢĆƦȈÊǫăǁąǶƌǰąȈƊǴăǟƊǹƢƊǯăǾƐǴ dz ơ ōǹ Êƛ ăǵ Ƣ ăƷ ąǁ Èȋ ơ ăȁ ÊǾ Êƥ Ɗǹ Ȃ ƌdz Ɣ Ƣ ăLj ăƫ ȅ Êǀ ōdz ơ ăǾ ƐǴ dz ơ ƒơ Ȃ ƌǬ ċƫ ơ ăȁ Ɣ Ƣ ăLj Êǻ ăȁ “O mankind, fear your Lord, who created you from one soul and created from it its mate and dispersed from both of them many men and women. And fear Allaah through whom you ask things from each other, and (respect) the wombs. Indeed Allaah is ever, over you, an Observer.” {an-Nisaa (4): 1} ơ Ćƾ ȇ Êƾ ăLJ Ƣ Ɔdz ąȂ Ɗǫ ơ Ȃ ƌdz Ȃ ƌǫ ăȁ ăǾ ōǴ dz ơ ơ Ȃ ƌǬ ċƫ ơ ơ Ȃ ĄǼ ăǷ ƕ ăǺ ȇ Êǀ ōdz ơ Ƣ ăȀ Čȇ ƊƗ Ƣ ăȇ ƃ ƂƢĆǸȈÊǜăǟ ơ Ćǃ ąȂ Ɗǧ ăǃ Ƣ Ɗǧ ąƾ ƊǬ Ɗǧ ĄǾ Ɗdz Ȃ ĄLJ ăǁ ăȁ ăǾ ōǴ dz ơ ąǞ Êǘ Ąȇ Ǻ ăǷ ăȁ ąǶ ƌǰ ăƥ Ȃ Ąǻ ƌƿ ąǶ ƌǰ Ɗdz ąǂ ÊǨ ąǤ ăȇ ăȁ ąǶ ƌǰ Ɗdz Ƣ ăǸ ąǟ ƊƗ ąǶ ƌǰ Ɗdz ąƶ ÊǴ ąǐ Ąȇ “O you who have believed, fear Allaah and speak words of appropriate justice. He will amend for you your deeds and forgive your sins. And whoever obeys Allaah and His Messenger has certainly attained a great attainment.” __________________________________________________________________ 3 © SalafiManhaj 2007 Is Salafiyyah a Cause of Terrorism? ______________________________________________________________ {al-Ahzaab (33): 70-71} To proceed: Within the “war on terror” scenario the Salafi da’wah and tradition has been seen as a methodology which is the main cause, thrust and impetus for terrorism and political violence and as even promoting such radical views. A large body of research has been authored which seeks to claim that the Salafi way is indeed an extremist radical belief system which eventually manifests itself with political violence and terrorism.2 One such report which follows this rather simplistic and incorrect assertion is the latest report by the New York Police Department entitled Radicalisation in the West: The Homegrown Threat by two senior intelligence analysts for the NYPD, Mitchell D. Sibler and Arvin Bhatt. Even though they aimed to understand the process by which Muslim youth become attracted to more extreme understandings and interpretations of Islam, it fell far short of doing the subject any justice and greatly misunderstood much in this regard. One of the more glaring problems with the report is that it rather boldly holds the Salafi methodology as being the main catalyst for terrorism and then seeks to present examples of what they consider to be ‘Salafi’. Here is where the problem lies, as the two analysts Silber and Bhatt, make reference to samples which are not ‘Salafi’ in the slightest and are rather takfeeri, jihadi, ikhwaani (i.e. followers of the Muslim Brotherhood) and even at times Tablighi!? Yet all of it is placed under the poorly defined, by them, rubric of ‘Salafism’. This study hopes to critically assess some of the claims of the Sibler and Bhatt and explore the reality of the Salafi way in regards to issues related terrorism, political violence and extremism. We will actually quote from the leading and well-known Salafi scholars themselves who the Salafis hold to be their reference points – in order to assess 2 For example Marc Sageman in his book Understanding Terror Networks (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania, 2004) states on page 1: “The global Salafi jihad is a worldwide religious revivalist movement with the goal of re-establishing past Muslim glory in a great Islamist state...it preaches salafiyyah (from salaf, the Arabic word for “ancient one” [sic] and referring to the companions of the Prophet Muhammad),...” Sageman goes on to say about al-Qaeda that “Salafi ideology determines its mission, sets it goals, and guides it tactics.”!!? Then Sageman says: “What sets the global Salafi jihad apart from other terrorist campaigns is its violence against foreign non-Muslim governments and their population in furtherance of Salafi objectives.” __________________________________________________________________ 4 © SalafiManhaj 2007 Is Salafiyyah a Cause of Terrorism? ______________________________________________________________ the assertion that adopting Salafi Islam leads to political violence and terrorism. As a result, it will be evident that the Salafi da’wah and methodology is one of the main barriers to the spread of terrorism in the world today.3 Indeed, the more stricter and serious the Salafi, the less likely the person will fall into radicalisation or terrorism: Ironically, this means that the most “radical” of the salafis are the most immune to jihadist teachings, and the more “moderate”, those more open to other streams of thought, may provide slightly more fertile recruiting grounds for the jihadis.4 These are for the following reasons: 9Strict Salafis are religious and not entrenched in political activity, political involvement and rhetoric; let alone terrorism. Politics is not their first port of call, rather to educate and cultivate Muslims upon tawheed and adhering to the Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad (sallallaahu ’alayhi wassallam) along with purifying the beliefs of the Muslims is their focal emphasis. 9Salafis frown upon forming political parties and groups which are based on partisan loyalties. 9Salafis do not hold secret clandestine meetings in order to put into place a strategic political plan. 9Salafis do not pledge allegiance to heads of organisations, groups and political parties. 9Salafis hold it to be un-Islamic to stage a revolt or rebellion against the leader of a Muslim country regardless of how unjust and oppressive that leader it, and especially if the Muslims do not have the ability to remove a particular leader from power. 9Salafis take into account the benefits and harms of any action which is done in the name of advancing the religion. 9Salafis do not agree with the targeting of innocent people in warfare based on the evidences from the Qur’aan and Sunnah. 9Those who claimed to be Salafi and then began adopting the methodology of Ikhwaan ul-Muslimeen (i.e. the Muslim Brotherhood) were those who eventually 3 See for example the excellent study: Indonesia Backgrounder: Why Salafism and Terrorism Mostly Don’t Mix (International Crisis Group: September 2004). Online: http://www.seasite.niu.edu/Indonesian/Islam/83_indonesia_backgrounder_why_salafism_and_terro rism_don_t_mix_web.pdf 4 Ibid., p.ii __________________________________________________________________ 5 © SalafiManhaj 2007 Is Salafiyyah a Cause of Terrorism? ______________________________________________________________ avoided referring to themselves as being ‘Salafi’ and rejected its well known principles. Unfortunately then, these individuals did end up leaving the Salafi way and some began to support erroneous ideas of jihad which the Salafi scholars did not endorse whatsoever. For more on the above topics refer to the lecture series entitled ‘Politics in Light of Islam’ by Shaykh Khalid al-’Anbaree which is available on www.salafimanhaj.com As a result, this in itself indicates the Salafi way and tradition is quite clear in its emphasis and position but unfortunately all of this seemed to have escaped the NYPD analysts, Sibler and Bhatt. We will also critically assess the claim made by Sibler and Bhatt in their NYPD study that regular attendance at a Salafi Mosque is a factor that leads to terrorism. We support our refutation of this claim with reference to a case study of a Salafi Mosque in the heart of London and how it has been probably the most pivotal mosque in London in opposing extremist and terrorist beliefs and methodologies.