Biosphere Reserves in Action: Case Studies of the American Experience
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Biosphere Reserves in Action: Case Studies of the American Experience D. Dean Bibles, Chair National Committee U.S. Man and the Biosphere Program 1995 The United States Man and the Biosphere Program (U.S. MAB) fosters harmonious relationships between humans and the biosphere through domestic and international cooperation in interdisciplinary research, education, biosphere reserves, and information exchange. U.S. MAB utilizes UNESCO designated biosphere reserves as sites for promoting ecosystem management by incorporating a program of ecosystem protection with sustainable human use and development; documenting global change and biological diversity through monitoring, inventorying, and scientific research; and organizing regional cooperative institutions for resolving complex issues of multipurpose land use. U.S. MAB is supported by the Agency for International Development, Department of Agriculture-Forest Service, Department of Commerce-National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Department of Energy, Department of the Interior-Bureau of Land Management, Department of the Interior-National Biological Service, Department of the Interior-National Park Service, Department of State, Environmental Protection Agency, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, National Institutes of Health, National Science Foundation, Peace Corps, and Smithsonian Institution. The opinions, conclusions and recommendations expressed in U.S. MAB publications are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the participating agencies and institutions. Inquiries concerning the U.S. MAB Program should be addressed to the U.S. MAB Secretariat U.S. Department of State OES/ETC/MAB SA-44C, Room 107 Washington, D.C. 20522-4401 The case studies presented here were written with contributions from managers and staff of the reserves. Nine of the studies were originally prepared by Partners in Parks in October 1993 and have been updated in 1995. The case study on "Virginia Coast Biosphere Reserve" was prepared by The Nature Conservancy in November 1994; "New Jersey Pinelands Biosphere Reserve" was written by The Pinelands Commission, September 1994; and "Land Between the Lakes Biosphere Reserve" was written by Tim Merriman, October 1994. Antoinette J. Condo of the U.S. MAB Secretariat staff brought the separate 12 case studies together into this one volume. Available from the National Technical Information Service (NTIS): U.S. Department of Commerce 5285 Port Royal Road Springfield, VA 22151 No. NTIS PB95-159877 _____________________________________________________ Department of State Publication 10241 Bureau of Oceans and International Environmental and Scientific Affairs Released June 1995 TABLE OF CONTENTS Foreword Preface Acknowledgments 1. Central California Coast Biosphere Reserve 2. Champlain-Adirondack Biosphere Reserve 3. Chihuahuan Desert Biosphere Reserve 4. Colorado Rockies Regional Cooperative 5. Crown of the Continent Biosphere Reserves 6. International Sonoran Desert Alliance 7. Land Between The Lakes Biosphere Reserve 8. Mammoth Cave Area Biosphere Reserve 9. New Jersey Pinelands Biosphere Reserve 10. Southern Appalachian Biosphere Reserve 11. Virgin Islands Biosphere Reserve 12. Virginia Coast Biosphere Reserve Afterword DEDICATION This volume is dedicated to those around the world interested in biosphere reserves and the study of land management issues. The biosphere reserves of the United States are diverse in origin, purpose, and management. U.S. MAB envisions every biosphere reserve as a catalyst for cooperation among various interests and people. The following 12 case studies give a glimpse of efforts in communication among the local community, scientists, managers, and policymakers toward solving issues of sustainable development, conservation of biological diversity, and scientific investigation. D. Dean Bibles, Chairman FOREWORD For nearly 20 years, biosphere reserves have offered a unique framework for building the knowledge, skills, and attitudes required for conservation and sustainable use of ecosystems. The 12 case studies in this volume chronicle many of the cooperative efforts to implement the biosphere reserve concept in the United States. Considered together, these efforts involve more than 20 types of protected areas, and the participation of all levels of government, and many private organizations, academic institutions, citizens groups, and individuals. Biosphere reserves are multipurpose areas that are nominated by the national committee of the Man and the Biosphere Program (MAB) and designated by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) to serve as demonstration areas for cooperation in building harmonious relationships between human activities and the conservation of ecosystems and biological diversity. Each biosphere reserve exemplifies the characteristic ecosystems of one of the world's biogeographical regions. It is a land or coastal/marine area involving human communities as integral components and including resources managed for objectives ranging from complete protection to intensive, yet sustainable development. A biosphere reserve is envisioned as a regional "landscape for learning" in which monitoring, research, education, and training are encouraged to support sustainable conservation of natural and managed ecosystems. It is a framework for regional cooperation involving government decisionmakers, scientists, resource managers, private organizations and local people (i.e., the biosphere reserve "stakeholders"). Finally, each biosphere reserve is part of a global network for sharing information and experience to help address complex problems of conservation and development. Natural resource policies in the U.S. and other countries increasingly encourage cooperation in conserving biological diversity and meeting the needs of human communities for social and economic development. Biosphere reserves help implement these policies by providing international recognition of important regional efforts and a focus for stakeholders to cooperate in developing the knowledge, technologies, and perspectives needed to solve complex resource problems. UNESCO designated the first U.S. biosphere reserves in 1976. These first reserves were properties managed by the National Park Service, the Forest Service, or the Agricultural Research Service. The parks served as strictly protected "core areas" for conservation and as benchmarks for monitoring ecological change against which to compare the effects of human activities in the surrounding region. The experimental research areas facilitated manipulations to improve understanding of these effects and develop ecologically sustainable management practices. Where possible, these separately designated biosphere reserves were paired to encourage cooperative research that could help regional interests formulate management goals. In 1984, UNESCO approved the Action Plan for Biosphere Reserves, based on the recommendations of the First International Congress on Biosphere Reserves held in Minsk, Belarus, in 1983. The plan clarified the concerns, characteristics and objectives of biosphere reserves, and recommended implementing actions for consideration by international organizations and National MAB Committees. Beginning in the early 1980s, U.S. MAB nominated multisite biosphere reserves to strengthen regional cooperation in implementing biosphere reserve concepts. In recent years regional cooperative biosphere reserve programs have been established involving many agencies, private interests, and participating sites. In 1993, the interagency U.S. National Committee for MAB approved convening a national workshop of biosphere reserve managers and stakeholders to develop recommendations for an integrated U.S. Biosphere Reserve Program that would take into account the many differences among U.S. biosphere reserves. The workshop, involving more than 80 participants, was held in Estes Park, Colorado, in December 1993. To help workshop participants evaluate the U.S. experience, the National Park Service amended its cooperative agreement with Partners in Parks to provide for preparation of a series of case studies as examples of efforts to implement biosphere reserve concepts. The case studies focus on U.S. biosphere reserves that are actively developing cooperative biosphere reserve programs. The case study areas represent many terrestrial and coastal/marine biogeographic regions illustrating a variety of resource issues; ecological, social, and economic conditions; and different types and patterns of ecosystem uses, management strategies, and land ownerships. Each case study includes a brief description of the natural and human environment of the biosphere reserve and the significant resource issues of regional concern; a history of the initial designation of the biosphere reserve and subsequent planning and implementation of the biosphere reserve concept; an overview of accomplishments; and an assessment of benefits, constraints, and the lessons learned. The initial nine case studies are based on information from the files of the National Park Service and from interviews of biosphere reserve managers and stakeholders conducted in mid-1993 by Dr. Sarah H. Bishop, President of Partners in Parks. These nine case studies prepared by Dr. Bishop and myself, were distributed to participants in the national workshop of biosphere reserve managers. Following the workshop, U.S. MAB convened a small working group to consider recommendations