“No Longer Objects of History:” American Indian Activism in the Late Twentieth Century
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“NO LONGER OBJECTS OF HISTORY:” AMERICAN INDIAN ACTIVISM IN THE LATE TWENTIETH CENTURY By JARED LEON EBERLE Bachelor of Arts in History University of Tulsa Tulsa, Oklahoma 2010 Master of Arts in History University of Tulsa Tulsa, Oklahoma 2012 Submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate College of the Oklahoma State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY July, 2018 “NO LONGER OBJECTS OF HISTORY:” AMERICAN INDIAN ACTIVISM IN THE LATE TWENTIETH CENTURY Dissertation Approved: Dr. Michael Logan Dissertation Adviser Dr. Douglas Miller Dr. Laura Belmonte Dr. Michael Smith Dr. Stephen Perkins ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Rather than being the last thing written, these were the first words I wrote. That is because the people below had as much, if not more, to do with this final product than I did. Had these people not been around this dissertation would not have come to fruition, at least not in the the form you see here. First, I need to thank the faculty and staff in the History Department, especially Exa von Alt and Diana Fry. My committee made up of Drs. Michael Logan, Douglas Miller, Laura Belmonte, Michael Smith, and Stephen Perkins also deserve special thanks, especially Dr. Perkins who stepped in at the last minute to resolve a scheduling conflict. They provided invaluable insight and advice during this project and expanded my academic horizons and I am forever grateful. In particular, I need to thank Dr. Miller, who came into the department and ended up working with a graduate student right off the bat who really had no idea what he was doing and he managed to prod me along over the last few years towards getting the bits of information I threw out in our meetings into something coherent and on paper. Additionally, he's not at Oklahoma State and I did not keep in touch nearly as much as I should have, a very special thanks to Dr. Brian Hosmer, who inspired by love for Native history during my Master's program and amazingly got this less than stellar student through the process of writing a thesis. iii Acknowledgements reflect the views of the author and are not endorsed by committee members or Oklahoma State University Finally, while she was never on my committee, I would be seriously remiss if I did not extend the biggest of thank yous to Dr. Laura Arata, for the years of putting up with my panic attacks and providing more mentorship and guidance than I could have ever expected. My fellow graduate students deserve thanks for all the support over the years and to everyone I could not fit in here I owe you a beer at some point. Thanks to Sam Jennings who regularly welcomed me into his home and provided ample conversation. Jake Cornwell also contributed wonderful conversations over the years. Last but not least special thanks to the late Gary Younger, who left our office far too early. You are still with us buddy. I need to thank my family because without my mother's undying support over the years of graduate school I would probably have gone crazy years ago. She was always there to talk me down when I let my brain go to the illogical extremes. Her cards, gift boxes, and visits gave me the support I needed to say, "Look Mom, I'm finally done!" Also, to my sister, who decided she wanted to follow in my footsteps and take the same path to grad school that I did, thanks for letting me pick on you all these years dork, love you. It saddens me every day that he is no longer here to receive this dedication, but my grandfather Leon Eberle, not only gave me my middle name, but served as a father for the first four years of my life and as a grandfather for forever. This is dedicated to him. Any errors, omissions, or typos are the sole responsibility of my cat, he’s a jerk. iv Acknowledgements reflect the views of the author and are not endorsed by committee members or Oklahoma State University Name: JARED LEON EBERLE Date of Degree: JULY 2018 Title of Study: “NO LONGER OBJECTS OF HISTOY:” AMERICAN INDIAN ACTIVISM IN THE LATE TWENTIETH CENTURY Major Field: HISTORY Abstract: Native American activism after the occupation of Wounded Knee in 1973 has been an understudied, yet critical period of twentieth century Indigenous history. The events in the two decades that followed the alleged zenith of the Red Power movement saw a significant shift by activists towards international activism that would allow them to work around the United States government and bring attention to issues concerning American Indians in the United States. Through the development of the International Indian Treaty Council, Native activists secured some of their greatest successes in the twentieth century and placed indigenous politics as an important part of international discourse. Yet, the movement never managed to sufficiently define itself, and by the 1980s that failure divided the movement over the conflict between the Sandinista government and Miskitu Indians in Nicaragua. The divide of the 1980s was never rectified, and the movement drastically declined in the 1990s with in-fighting and conflict over who had the legitimate ability to claim they represented the old Native rights organizations. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page I. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................1 Red Power Before AIM ...........................................................................................6 Red Power ..............................................................................................................13 Expanding Beyond Traditional Red Power ...........................................................19 Chapters Overview .................................................................................................24 II. WOUNDED KNEE ON THE PLAINS: THE FAILED UNDERSTANDING OF THE OCCUPATION OF WOUNDED KNEE .............................................................28 Overview of the Occupation ..................................................................................35 “Not just now, Mr. Wayne…perhaps later…” .......................................................54 Bury My Heart: The New Indian History ..............................................................73 Revisionist Westerns: Indians as the Vietnamese and Counterculture ..................77 The New Popular History and Wounded Knee ......................................................81 “We Have Been Destroyed Emotionally by the Incident:” Wounded Knee for Native Americans ..............................................................................................................84 Conclusion .............................................................................................................92 III. DISUNITY AT HOME, ALLIANCES ABROAD ...............................................94 The International Indian Treaty Council ................................................................99 Native Activism and the Realignment of the 1970s ............................................105 “Warrior Scholars” and the Response to Reagan ................................................115 The Scope of the American Indian International Tribunal ..................................121 Multi-National Corporations and Exploitations ...................................................126 Land and Relocations ...........................................................................................133 Conclusion ...........................................................................................................135 vi Chapter Page IV. “[DIS]-UNITING THE RED PEOPLE OF THE WESTERN HEMISPHERE:” INDIGENOUS ACTIVISTS IN NICARAGUA .................................................138 Roots of Rebellion: Miskitus and the Nicaraguan State ......................................143 Early Indigenous Support for the Sandinistas ......................................................153 Russell Means and the Divide Within AIM .........................................................158 The National Indian Youth Council’s Role in Nicaragua ....................................163 Conclusion ...........................................................................................................176 V. THE PAPER WARS: AIM AND THE QUESTION OF AUTHENTICITY ......180 V. CONCLUSION ....................................................................................................199 REFERENCES ..........................................................................................................205 vii LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page AIM 10th Anniversary Poster ....................................................................................95 Map of the Zelaya Department, which comprised the Mosquitia ...........................145 Flyers circulated during 1994 AIM Tribunal ..........................................................197 viii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION “That Wounded Knee was the last stand for the American Indian Movement is the unspoken fear at the…national convention….”1 - The New York Times, July 29, 1973 In April of 1973 residents of Pawnee, Oklahoma, a small town an hour west of Tulsa, were concerned about the impending American Indian Movement (AIM) annual convention to be held at the start of May. AIM, which caused tensions in town the previous year by occupying a BIA building, was currently in the latter stages of a seventy-one-day siege at Wounded Knee, South Dakota, and residents were concerned similar violence could erupt in Oklahoma.2 Pawnee’s mayor Glenn Wood argued