DOCSLIB.ORG

Sealand, Havenco, and the Rule of Law James Grimmelmann Cornell Law School, [email protected]

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Sealand, Havenco, and the Rule of Law James Grimmelmann Cornell Law School, James.Grimmelmann@Cornell.Edu Cornell University Law School Scholarship@Cornell Law: A Digital Repository Cornell Law Faculty Publications Faculty Scholarship 2012 Sealand, HavenCo, and the Rule of Law James Grimmelmann Cornell Law School, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/facpub Part of the Internet Law Commons, Jurisdiction Commons, and the Rule of Law Commons Recommended Citation James Grimmelmann, "Sealand, HavenCo, and the Rule of Law," 2012 University of Illinois Law Review 405 (2012) This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Scholarship at Scholarship@Cornell Law: A Digital Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Cornell Law Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of Scholarship@Cornell Law: A Digital Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. SEALAND, HAVENCO, AND THE RULE OF LAW James Grimmelmann* In 2000, a group of American entrepreneursmoved to a former World War I antiaircraftplatform in the North Sea, seven miles off the British coast. There, they launched HavenCo, one of the strangest start-ups in Internet history. A former pirate radio broadcaster,Roy Bates, had occupied the platform in the 1960s, moved his family aboard, and declared it to be the sovereign Principality of Sealand. HavenCo's founders were opposed to governmental censorship and control of the Internet; by putting computer servers on Sealand, they planned to create a "data haven" for unpopularspeech, safely beyond the reach of any other country. This Article tells the full story of Sealand and HavenCo-and examines what they have to tell us about the nature of the rule of law in the age of the Internet. The story itself is fascinating enough: it includes pirate radio, shotguns, rampant copyright infringement, a Red Bull skateboarding special,perpetual motion machines, and the Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of State. But its implicationsfor the rule of law are even more remarkable. Previous scholars have seen HavenCo as a straightforwardchallenge to the rule of law: by threat- ening to undermine national authority, HavenCo was opposed to all law. As the fuller history shows, this story is too simplistic. HavenCo also depended on internationallaw to recognize and protect Sealand, and on Sealand law to protect it from Sealand itself. Where others have seen HavenCo'sfailure as the triumph of traditionalregulatory authoritiesover HavenCo, this Article argues that in a very real sense, Haven Co failed not from too much law but from too little. The "law" * Associate Professor of Law, New York Law School. I presented earlier versions of this Arti- cle at the Bits Without Borders conference at Michigan State University, to the Information Society Project at Yale Law School, and to faculty workshops at New York Law School and Fordham Law School. My thanks for their comments to the attendees there, to the readers of the Volokh Conspiracy blog, and to Aislinn Black, Claude Aiken, David Auerbach, Robert Blecker, Andrea Casillas, Michael Froomkin, Jean Galbraith, Nathaniel Gleicher, Peter Hirtle, Molly Land, Jan Lewis, Dominic Mauro, David Post, Harry Surden, Berin Szoka, and Christopher Wong. Nate Anderson generously shared the Sealand-related fruits of his research for his forthcoming book, The Internet Police. William Mills at the NYLS library helped track down numerous sources. Geoffrey Weg and Katie Baxter provided research assistance. This Article is available for reuse under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 U.S. license, http://creativecommons.org/licensesby/3.0/us/. 406 UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS LAW REVIEW [Vol. 2012 that was supposed to keep HavenCo safe was law only in a thin, for- malistic sense, disconnected from the human institutions that make and enforce law. But without those institutions,law does not work, as HavenCo discovered. TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRO DUCTION ............................................................................................. 406 II. S EA LA ND ...................................................................................................... 4 12 A . 1942: R oughs Tow er........................................................................... 413 B . 1966-1967: R oy B ates ........................................................................ 414 C. 1967: Roy Bates vs. The United Kingdom .......................................... 418 D. 1967-1968: The Principalityof Sealand............................................ 421 E. 1968-1978: GrandSchemes ................................. 424 F. 19 78: Civil W ar .................................................................................. 427 G. 19 78-1990: PirateBroadcasting Redux ............................................. 430 H. 1987-2011: Recent Developments...................................................... 434 I. L ife on Sealand................................................................................... 437 J. Other Sealands ................................................................................... 439 K. Th em es ................................................................................................ 4 4 3 III. H AVEN C O..................................................................................................... 44 5 A . "Data Haven ..................................................................................... 445 B . R ise .....................................................................................................44 9 C. F all ..................................................................................................... 4 5 3 IV . THE R ULE OF LAW ........................................................................................ 457 A . N ationalL aw ...................................................................................... 459 1. Haven Co and NationalLaw ...................................................... 460 2. The Rule of Law As Self-Government........................................ 463 B . InternationalLaw ............................................................................... 465 1. Sealand and InternationalLaw ................................................. 465 2. The Rule of Law As FormalLegality ......................................... 473 C . Sealand L aw ....................................................................................... 476 1. The Rule of Law As Restraint on Government........................... 476 2. HavenCo and SealandLaw ....................................................... 477 D . C onnections ........................................................................................ 479 V . C ONCLU SIO N ................................................................................................48 1 I. INTRODUCTION Sealand is stranger than fiction. A pair of concrete legs supporting a 120-foot by 50-foot platform, 60 feet above the North Sea, this "small- est country on earth" sits 7 miles off the British coast. Built during World War II for antiaircraft defense, it was occupied in the 1960s by Roy Bates, a former pirate radio operator who declared himself ruler of the new Principality of Sealand. Boosting his claim, a British court ac- quitted him in 1968 on firearms charges because Sealand stood outside of British territorial waters. He made Sealand into his family's home: No. 2] SEALAND, HAVENCO, AND THE RULE OF LAW promulgating a constitution; issuing stamps, coins, and passports; and generally adopting the trappings of nationhood. Sealand has even had a coup and countercoup: in 1978 a German lawyer seized control of the platform, only to be taken prisoner by Bates in a daring helicopter land- ing a few days later. Sealand's moment of greatest fame came in 2000, when it offered the ultimate in literally offshore data hosting. The Internet startup HavenCo built out Sealand as a data center, moving in computer servers and connecting them to the Internet. The idea was that HavenCo would be a data haven, which would store content that was illegal in other coun- tries. Online casinos, subpoena-proof corporate records, good old- fashioned pornography-HavenCo would host it all, safely beyond the reach of any other country's courts. The company launched to massive press coverage (including a cover story in Wired'), promising unfettered free speech to the masses while extending a raised middle finger to cen- 2 sors and control freaks around the world. This much is familiar to scholars.3 Talk to any Internet-law scholar 1. See Simson Garfinkel, Welcome to Sealand. Now Bugger Off, WIRED, July 2000, at 230. 2. See, e.g., Around the Globe, 27 COMPUTER L. & TAX REP. 16, 16 (2000); Mara D. Bellaby, An Internet "Mouse that Roars" Pops up off Britain, Hous. CHRON., June 25, 2000, at 10; Steve Boggan, Americans Turn a Tin-Pot State off the Essex Coast into World Capital of Computer Anarchy, INDEP. (Eng.), June 5, 2000, at 3; David Canton, Creating a Country to Avoid Jurisdiction, LONDON FREE PRESS, June 16, 2000, at D3; David Cohen, Offshore Haven: Cold Water Poured on Sealand Se- curity, GUARDIAN, June 6, 2000, at 24; Anne Cornelius, Legal Issues Online Firms Set to Take Refuge in Offshore Fortress, SCOTSMAN, June 15, 2000, at 26; Peter Ford, Banned on Land, but Free at Sea?, CHRISTIAN SCI. MONITOR, June 23, 2000, at 1; Dan Gillmor, Data Haven May Be a Step in the Right Direction, SAN JOSE MERCURY NEWS, June 6, 2000, at IC; Carlos Grande, Island Fortress's "Data Ha- ven" to Confront E-Trade Regulation,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • DR HOGGART' S FAREWELL Peter Smith
    DR HOGGART' S FAREWELL Peter Smith Although Richard Hoggart is upset at hav- Hoggart had served six years. The last two ing been dropped as vice-chair of the Arts were served as vice-chair. It was expected Council he is deriving comfort from the fris- that Hoggart would be asked to stay on a son of martyrdom that comes from the year or so more because in a few months' knowledge that the decision to axe him was time chairperson Kenneth Robinson (and taken by Margaret Thatcher. Why should now a member of the SDP) retires. It was she be bothered about the vice-chair of the thought that all the powers that be would Arts Council? recognise the expediency of keeping Hog- The Arts Council proper consists of a gart on to give a continuity of leadership. chairperson, currently Kenneth Robinson, And, irrespective of what one thinks of Hog- and twenty members. These twenty-one gart's political or artistic views, he has had people are allegedly appointed by the Minis- the guts to lead with his chin: he was the Arts ter for the Arts in the name of the Secretary Council's 'hit man'. He wrote many articles of State for Education and Science. The defending the Council's work and policy vice-chairperson of the Council is filled' and has been publicly critical of the manner from among the members of the Council — in which the press deals with the issue of in other words, they vote one of themselves public funding for the arts.
    [Show full text]
  • Baoguang Zhai Gisposter
    Mapping new FronƟers— Use Socioeconomic lenses to find the best coastal ciƟes for seasteading Introduction Seasteading means the creaon and growth of permanent, autonomous ocean communies, or “seasteads,” to promote greater compeon and innovaon in polical and social systems. Seasteads will give people the opportunity to peacefully test new ideas about how to live togeth‐ er. The most successful will become thriving floang cies—inspiring change around the world. Since the founding of the Seasteading Instute in 2008 by the partnership of Patri Friedman, grandson of renowned economist Milton Friedman, and Silicon Valley investor and philanthropist Peter Thiel, the seasteading movement has been geng more and more aenon and recogni‐ on both within the US and across the world. Therefore, it is natural for seasteaders to look around the enre oceans of the world and study the most promising locaons for seasteading communies. The country is poliƟcally and economically liberal. The first spots for seasteading City Country Seasteading Score need to be more polically liberal, otherwise the seastead faces the danger of its estate Phase 2 City selecƟon - A city needs to sasfy two standards for it to be suitable for being expropriated by the government. For a seastead to be autonomous and funcon‐ New York United States 91.41 seasteading: ing, it also requires that the countries where the seasteads are located at to have rela‐ Stockholm Sweden 86.12 vely less economic regulaon and less government and tax burdens. The city is considered to be an important node in the global economic system. It is Dublin Ireland 85.79 a crucial strategy to build a seastead as a site of Amsterdam Netherlands 85.42 The economy of the country is compeƟƟve at building innovaƟve products and ser- aracon and a showcase for new ideas and max‐ Sydney Australia 85.15 vices.
    [Show full text]
  • Houseboat Living on the Seine È
    HOUSEBOAT LIVING ON THE SEINE Lonely pénichards or strong communities? Sciences Po Master students – Urban School, program “Governing the Large Metropolis”: Paola Chapdelaine: [email protected] Emeline Dutheil: [email protected] Lorena Figueiredo: [email protected] Marissa Potasiak: [email protected] Paul Tristan Victor: [email protected] Working papers du Programme Cities are Back in Town [email protected] http://blogs.sciences-po.fr/recherche-villes/ Cahiers de recherche du Programme Cities are Back in Town n° 2015-1 Chapdelaine P., Dutheil E., Figueiredo L., Potasiak M. and Victor, P.T., « Houseboat living on the Seine ». Abstract: A stroll along the Seine will alert even the most casual observer to the unique presence of houseboats moored along the river’s banks, many of them clustered in small ports and canals. Examining closer, one might even feel a twinge of jealousy at the sight of normally hurried Parisians using the Seine as their own personal backyard — hosting family barbecues, making quick excursions down the river, or simply enjoying long, carefree conversations with their neighbors. However, a real understanding of the linkages between these houseboats — and the people who make their life on them, the houseboaters — requires a more structured process of investigation. We ask ourselves, then, the following research question: How might the conditions of houseboat living on the Seine shape relations between houseboat owners? We hypothesize that houseboaters share practices, produce a specific body of knowledge, and form a sense of common identity in a manner that creates houseboat communities on the Seine. Our paper is organized as follows.
    [Show full text]
  • PRIME MINISTER Lunch for Collea Ues You Were Concerned About The
    PRIME MINISTER Lunch for Collea ues You were concerned about the list of colleagues which I put to you last night as possible guests for 18th April. 1 As you know, almost ail the Ministers of State and the Parliamentary Under Secretaries have now been included in a Monday lunch, and we are getting through the outstanding ones quite quickly. Three of the outstanding PUSSs are from the Scottish, Irish and Welsh Offices, and because they are not often in London on Mondays, I have liaised with their Private Offices for a suitable date_„ I know that James Douglas Hamilton and Peter Vidgers- are able to come on 18th April, and Ian Grist is available on 25th April. I know you are worried about the Senior/Junior mix. The last lunch was rather unbalanced because both John Wakeham and David Waddington were not present. This would not normally be the case, and I know that your invitations to senior backbenchers and to Parliamentary Private Secretaries have been very well received. However, you mav prefer to go through the list of Ministers of State again. Overleaf are two bossible lists for 18th April, and also two possible lists for 25th April (reserves in brackets). One set of lists includes senior backbenchers and PPSs, and one set reverts to Ministers of State. Please would you indicate which you prefer? • Page Two i8th APRIL John MacGregor (Lord Mackay) James Douglas-Hamilton Peter Viggers Mark Lennox-Boyd (Tristan Garel-Jones) Geoffrey Johnson-Smith (John Hannam or John MacGregor (Lord Mackay) David Mellor (Chris Patten) Tim Renton (John Patten)
    [Show full text]
  • Signal Issue 37
    Signal Issue 37 Tricks of the Trade Dave Porter G4OYX and Alan Beech G1BXG By 25th September 1965, Radio 390 was on the air and 31st December 2015 marks the fiftieth anniversary of the start of the offshore station Radio Scotland. The only remaining station to launch with RCA 10 kW Ampliphase transmitters was Radio 270 from 4th June 1966, on-air some three months later than originally planned. Member’s contribution understood that, whilst CE was used to these T-K arrangements, mainly for Government contracts, the need After reading the last three ToTT, VMARS Member Tony to effect a quick turn-around with minimal delays was not Rock G3KTR/AD1X contacted the author (DP) with the quite their norm. With time slipping by, the decision was following information on the 1965 build of Radio Scotland. made to leave the USA without the systems being totally commissioned and to complete en-route. Also, during this Tony writes; I read with interest the article you and Alan trip, it was discovered that one of the planned operating put together on Ampliphase transmitters. In the mid-1960s frequencies, namely 650 kHz, was actually occupied in the I was working out of the RCA Broadcast & UK by a certain high-power station on 647 kHz, the Communications Division at Sunbury-on-Thames. At this 150 kW BBC Third Programme. It was understood that an time RCA had sold several transmitters to offshore ‘pirate’ early ‘recce’ by the Americans to the UK to check for ‘spare radio stations. While Marconi and other European channels’ resulted in a monitoring time when the Third companies could be subjected to sanctions by the Programme was not scheduled on air.
    [Show full text]
  • Houseboats and Floating Houses
    Houseboats and Floating Houses Houseboats and floating houses are built elements that lie on top of the water surface, and therefore have there sensations depicted by the moving water below and views surround them. They are unique places to live due to these sensations. Houseboats and floating houses are very different. The major difference is in the fact that houseboats move themselves whilst floating houses are located in primarily the one spot. Living on the water can create a strong sense of community though floating houses, or it can provide privacy through houseboats, both however give the occupant a strong understanding and appreciation of the natural environment. http:// popularmechanics.com Differences between houseboats and floating houses- The major difference between houseboat and floating house design is the amount of manoeuvrability required. The typical houseboat for example has as hull that is submerged below the waves which allows the boat to move in the water with ease and direction. There are two major types of houseboats, the first has one hull that is curved to move through the water quickly, and it is designed for speed and to move though rough waters. The other has a pontoon base that is wider in the water and contains at least two hull extrusions into the water. This houseboat style is for slow cruising through waterways as it has less speed and manoeuvrability. The living area above or within the hull is therefore designed to maximise the space below and above the water level. In faster single hulled boats sleeping and living quarters are included in the hull of the boat, an example of which is a yacht.
    [Show full text]
  • Adventurer Houseboat Manual
    WELCOME TO 53’ ADVENTURER HOUSEBOAT MANUAL TABLE OF CONTENTS Marine Radio .....................................................................................................1 Engines/Helm .................................................................................................. 3 Houseboat Batteries .......................................................................................6 Generator ..........................................................................................................8 Water Pressure ..............................................................................................10 Hot Water ....................................................................................................... 12 Holding Tanks ..................................................................................................13 Gas/Propane .................................................................................................. 15 Refrigerator ..................................................................................................... 17 Range ................................................................................................................ 19 Grill ................................................................................................................... 20 Heater ............................................................................................................... 21 Cooling .............................................................................................................22
    [Show full text]
  • Capitalism, Social Marginality, and the Rule of Law's Uncertain Fate in Modern Society
    University of Colorado Law School Colorado Law Scholarly Commons Articles Colorado Law Faculty Scholarship 2005 Capitalism, Social Marginality, and the Rule of Law's Uncertain Fate in Modern Society Ahmed A. White University of Colorado Law School Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.law.colorado.edu/articles Part of the Criminal Law Commons, Law and Economics Commons, Rule of Law Commons, and the Social Welfare Law Commons Citation Information Ahmed A. White, Capitalism, Social Marginality, and the Rule of Law's Uncertain Fate in Modern Society, 37 ARIZ. ST. L.J. 759 (2005), available at https://scholar.law.colorado.edu/articles/429. Copyright Statement Copyright protected. Use of materials from this collection beyond the exceptions provided for in the Fair Use and Educational Use clauses of the U.S. Copyright Law may violate federal law. Permission to publish or reproduce is required. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Colorado Law Faculty Scholarship at Colorado Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Articles by an authorized administrator of Colorado Law Scholarly Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. +(,121/,1( Citation: 37 Ariz. St. L.J. 759 2005 Provided by: William A. Wise Law Library Content downloaded/printed from HeinOnline Sun Apr 30 18:05:56 2017 -- Your use of this HeinOnline PDF indicates your acceptance of HeinOnline's Terms and Conditions of the license agreement available at http://heinonline.org/HOL/License -- The search text of this PDF is generated from uncorrected OCR text. -- To obtain permission to use this article beyond the scope of your HeinOnline license, please use: Copyright Information CAPITALISM, SOCIAL MARGINALITY, AND THE RULE OF LAW'S UNCERTAIN FATE IN MODERN SOCIETY Ahmed A.
    [Show full text]
  • Freewave Niet Toegestaan
    COLOFON VOORWOORD Exploitatie: Stichting Media Communicatie Beste lezers, Hoofdredacteur: Hans Knot In dit augustusnummer zullen de Radio Noord- Lay Out: Jan van Heeren zee-fans zeker aan hun trekken komen. In maar Druk: EPC liefst 3 artikelen wordt de kleurige zeezender belicht: in een artikel over Karel Prior, in een inter- Vaste Medewerkers: view met Hans Hogendoorn en Pieter Damave en Walter du Bateau, Michel van Hooff (Neder- tenslotte in de herinneringen van Marc van Amstel. land); Rene Burcksen, Jan Hendrik Kruidenier Verder gaat de nieuwe serie ‘Muziek- en media- (VS); Jelle Knot (Internationaal); Eric Wiltshire memories’ van start: Bert Bossink en Hans Knot (Satelliet); Ingo Paternoster (Duitsland); Gijs van wisselen herinneringen aan een bepaald jaar uit. der Heuvel (Caribisch Gebied); Howard Rose Met het jaar 1959 wordt het spits afgebeten. Ook (England); Etienne Kerremans (België) nieuw is de rubriek satellietnieuws. We verwel- komen Bert Jan Brinkman, die voortaan regelma- Verantwoordelijke Uitgever tig een bijdrage zal leveren voor deze rubriek. Stichting Media Communicatie Rob Olthof maakt in zijn artikel o.a. duidelijk dat Postbus 53121 het met de orkesten in Nederland slecht is ge- 1007 RC Amsterdam steld. Ook aandacht voor de eerste Engelstalige zender op de Noordzee: CNBC. Bijna vergeten, Correspondentieadres: maar gelukkig nog in het geheugen van de be- Hans Knot, Postbus 102, 9700 AC Groningen trokken deejay’s. Radio 270 was net als CNBC geen lang leven beschoren. Toch leverde de ge- Lidmaatschap: schiedenis van dit station genoeg stof op tot het Nederland: Euro 23,- schrijven van een nieuw boek, dat door Hans Europa: Euro 28,- Knot onder de loep wordt genomen.
    [Show full text]
  • Judith Jarvis Thomson on Abortion; a Libertarian Perspective
    DePaul Journal of Health Care Law Volume 19 Issue 1 Fall 2017 Article 3 April 2018 Judith Jarvis Thomson on Abortion; a Libertarian Perspective Walter E. Block Loyola University New Orleans, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/jhcl Part of the Health Law and Policy Commons Recommended Citation Walter E. Block, Judith Jarvis Thomson on Abortion; a Libertarian Perspective, 19 DePaul J. Health Care L. (2018) Available at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/jhcl/vol19/iss1/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Law at Via Sapientiae. It has been accepted for inclusion in DePaul Journal of Health Care Law by an authorized editor of Via Sapientiae. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Judith Jarvis Thomson on abortion; a libertarian perspective1 I. Introduction Abortion is one of the most vexing issues faced by society. On the one hand, there are those who favor the pro-choice position. In their view, the woman, and she alone (along with the advice of her doctor – but the final decision must be hers), should be able to legally determine on what basis, and whether, her pregnancy should be conducted. She should be as free to end her pregnancy at any stage of the development of her fetus, or give birth to it after the usual term of nine months. On the other hand, there are those who favor what is called the pro-life position. In this perspective, the fetus, from the moment of conception, is a full rights-bearing human being.
    [Show full text]
  • Mirrorshade Women: Feminism and Cyberpunk
    Mirrorshade Women: Feminism and Cyberpunk at the Turn of the Twenty-first Century Carlen Lavigne McGill University, Montréal Department of Art History and Communication Studies February 2008 A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Communication Studies © Carlen Lavigne 2008 2 Abstract This study analyzes works of cyberpunk literature written between 1981 and 2005, and positions women’s cyberpunk as part of a larger cultural discussion of feminist issues. It traces the origins of the genre, reviews critical reactions, and subsequently outlines the ways in which women’s cyberpunk altered genre conventions in order to advance specifically feminist points of view. Novels are examined within their historical contexts; their content is compared to broader trends and controversies within contemporary feminism, and their themes are revealed to be visible reflections of feminist discourse at the end of the twentieth century. The study will ultimately make a case for the treatment of feminist cyberpunk as a unique vehicle for the examination of contemporary women’s issues, and for the analysis of feminist science fiction as a complex source of political ideas. Cette étude fait l’analyse d’ouvrages de littérature cyberpunk écrits entre 1981 et 2005, et situe la littérature féminine cyberpunk dans le contexte d’une discussion culturelle plus vaste des questions féministes. Elle établit les origines du genre, analyse les réactions culturelles et, par la suite, donne un aperçu des différentes manières dont la littérature féminine cyberpunk a transformé les usages du genre afin de promouvoir en particulier le point de vue féministe.
    [Show full text]
  • Who Governs the Internet? the Emerging Policies, Institutions, and Governance of Cyberspace
    City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works All Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects 2013 Who Governs the Internet? The Emerging Policies, Institutions, and Governance of Cyberspace Robert J. Domanski The Graduate Center, City University of New York How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/gc_etds/1481 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] i WHO GOVERNS THE INTERNET? THE EMERGING POLICIES, INSTITUTIONS, AND GOVERNANCE OF CYBERSPACE by ROBERT J. DOMANSKI A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty in Political Science in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, The City University of New York 2013 ii © 2013 ROBERT J. DOMANSKI All Rights Reserved iii This manuscript has been read and accepted for the Graduate Faculty in Political Science in satisfaction of the dissertation requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Donna Kirchheimer 8/5/2013 Date Chair of Examining Committee Joe Rollins 8/5/2013 Date Executive Officer Stephen Brier Andrew Rich Charles Tien Sarah Zelikovitz Supervisory Committee THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK iv Abstract WHO GOVERNS THE INTERNET? THE EMERGING POLICIES, INSTITUTIONS, AND GOVERNANCE OF CYBERSPACE by Robert J. Domanski Sponsor: Professor Donna Kirchheimer There remains a widespread perception among both the public and elements of academia that the Internet is “ungovernable”. However, this idea, as well as the notion that the Internet has become some type of cyber-libertarian utopia, is wholly inaccurate.
    [Show full text]