Early American Marxism (14-12)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
H-HOAC Early American Marxism (14-12) Discussion published by Tim Davenport on Tuesday, March 25, 2014 Early American Marxism website • www.marxisthistory.org/ Weekly Update no. 14-12 • March 23, 2014. A full bushel of 20 new files. Three main clusters of articles: a small group of mostly short news pieces about the little-known Sept. 4, 1918 bombing of the Chicago Federal Building in the aftermath of the great IWW trial; several articles on the factional machinations behind the 1924 Farmer-Labor Party convention and LaFollette for President efforts; and a sampling of material from 1926 including fisticuffs over a controversial article in The New Leader which drew an official denunciation of the "most complete and ignorant forgery" by Soviet leader Joseph Stalin. Debsiana includes a 1918 dance on capitalism's grave, a letter declining nomination as an Indiana Congressional candidate in 1918, a remembrance of Ohio pioneer socialist Allen Cook, and C.E. Ruthenberg's defense of the Communist decision to honor the recently-deceased Debs as a member of the revolutionary socialist pantheon. Also worthy of mention is an official obituary of former youth leader turned Daily Worker editor Harry Gannes from 1941. All of these files are available for free download and non-commercial reproduction at the following URL: http://www.marxisthistory.org/subject/usa/eam/14-12.html Thanks for your interest, Tim Davenport, Corvallis, OR [email protected] ================ NEW FILES ON EAM ================ (1) "The Terror," by James Oneal [event of June 1908] Although perhaps slightly fictionalized for the allegorical telling, this short work by Socialist Party activist James Oneal detailing a June 1908 lynch mob which he witnessed stands as his most compelling piece of writing. First published in 1909, this powerful story was reprinted by the New York Call's Sunday magazine in September 1918. (2) "Farewell, Capitalism!" by Eugene V. Debs [May 24, 1918] The slaughter of millions on European battlefields, the tottering of war-stressed economies, and the emergence of the Bolsheviks in defeated Russia combined to create a sort of mass hysteria among revolutionary socialists in America, in which prospects were exaggerated and grim political realities minimized. This short piece by Socialist icon Gene Debs is a gleeful grave dance upon a grave site not yet even dug. "The system in which capitalists and profiteers so long have fattened while working people and their families starved, body and soul, is in the throes of collapse and dissolution. The war has broken its backbone and ripped it into shreds and patches," Debs enthusiastically declares. "Farewell, capitalism! We have waited long and patiently for your end, and it finally has come. The frightful war of your own making shall be your funeral dirge. (3) "Debs Refuses Nomination: Physical Condition and Busy Months Ahead Given as Causes." (Truth) [event of July 9, 1918] Although a candidate for Congress in his home state of Indiana in 1916, Eugene Debs chose not to run in the subsequent 1918 election. His letter of declination was made public and widely printed in the Socialist press. While stating that he appreciated the honor of being made the SPA's candidate in the Indiana 5th District, Debs Citation: Tim Davenport. Early American Marxism (14-12). H-HOAC. 03-25-2014. https://networks.h-net.org/node/6077/discussions/16532/early-american-marxism-14-12 Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 1 H-HOAC announces "there are reasons in my present situation, physical and otherwise, which make this absolutely impossible. The coming months promise to be very busy ones for me, and I have already more in hand than I can well manage, and am, therefore, compelled, much to my regret, to decline the nomination." * * * (4) "Bomb Explosion Kills 4 in Federal Building in Chicago; Arrests Reported."(NY Call) [event of Sept. 4, 1918] Terse initial report of the Sept. 4, 1918 Chicago Federal Building bombing as published the next morning in The New York Call, Socialist daily newspaper. The event is (apparently wrongly) reported as resulting from a thrown bomb. A correct casualty count of 4 killed and "more than 75 injured" is provided, with the reporter adding the detail "a majority of them slightly." "The bomb fell just outside the door of the north corridor. The material damage done was not great," the unsigned report notes. This appears to be the only coverage of the attack which The Call published. (5) "Chicago Federal Building Bombed: Four Persons Killed, 75 Injured: Haywood There at Time: Structure Containing Landis’ Courtroom Damaged." (Morning Oregonian) [event of Sept. 4, 1918] Apparently a national wire news report of the Sept. 4, 1918 bombing of the Chicago Federal Building. Four were killed and 75 wounded when a high explosive bomb concealed in a suitcase and hidden behind a radiator blew out the Adams Street entrance of the building. Many injuries resulted from flying glass generated by windows of the lowest three stories of two buildings across the street being blown in on their occupants. The IWW -- 95 members of which had recently been sentenced in the building -- was immediately blamed for the terrorism and raids and arrests proceeded at once. For his part, IWW Secretary-Treasurer Big Bill Haywood, who was present in the building at the time of the blast, quickly "deplored the outrage" and vehemently denied an IWW connection. "I know that the IWW will be blamed," said Haywood, "but I am convinced in my own heart that no man of my organization was in any way connected with this matter. It would be insane for an IWW to commit such an act at this time." An effort by an IWW attorney to win low bail for convicted members pending appeal was summarily denied in the aftermath of the blast. (6) "Bomb Explosion Blamed on IWW: Many Fellow Workers Arrested and Held Following Explosion in Federal Building, Chicago, which Killed 4 and Injured Many." (Defense News Bulletin) [event of Sept. 4, 1918] In the afternoon of Wednesday, Sept. 4, 1918, a bomb ripped through the entrance of the Chicago Federal Building, in which recently convicted IWW Secretary-Treasurer William D. Haywood was appearing in the office of the US Federal Marshal. Four people were killed and about 30 injured in the powerful blast, which rocked the building and was heard and felt for a considerable distance. The IWW was immediately blamed for the blast, with Haywood's "private secretary" J.W. Wilson targeted by authorities as responsible for the fatal bomb. This article from the IWW's weekly Defense News Bulletin denounces the "fiendish crime" and details the series of arrests which followed the blast. Lack of motive is made clear: "Looking at the matter from the standpoint of organization and defense work, nothing worse for us could have happened at this time. It was our intention, after filing appeals in behalf of our fellow workers who have been sentenced to Leavenworth, to make an attempt to get a number of them out on bonds pending the appeal. The explosion made it simply impossible for us to do anything further along this line at the present." (7) "A Terrible Deed." (St. Louis Labor) [event of Sept. 4, 1918] Short snippet covering the Sept. 4 bombing of the Chicago Federal Building from the pages of the Socialist Party of Missouri's weekly newspaper. Buried on page 5, the coverage is in the form of a summary of published news accounts, even-handed in tone despite the considerable antipathy to the IWW felt by many in the Missouri party - - which was closely connected to the local AF of L unions. "The blast occurred directly beneath the courtroom of Federal Judge K.M. Landis, where 95 IWW leaders were recently convicted and sentenced for obstructing the government’s war program," the report notes. It adds that "William D. Haywood, who was on the 8th floor of the building when the explosion happened, deplored the crime and expressed the fear that the IWW would be Citation: Tim Davenport. Early American Marxism (14-12). H-HOAC. 03-25-2014. https://networks.h-net.org/node/6077/discussions/16532/early-american-marxism-14-12 Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 2 H-HOAC blamed for it." (8) "4,000 Listen to Socialists on Russian Affairs: War on Soviet Government Would Mean War on People, Says Speaker," (NY Call) [event of Sept. 13, 1918] Throughout 1918 the ongoing situation in Soviet Russia remained a topic of keen interest among the Socialists of New York City, as reflected in this short news item about a mass meeting from the pages of the New York Call. On Sept. 13, some 3,000 people were turned away at the door and another 4,000 gained admittance to hear speeches by journalist John Reed (recently back from Soviet Russia), representative of Red Finland Santeri Nuorteva, Louis Fraina of the newspaper The New International, and Gregory Weinstein, editor of the Russian- language Socialist weekly Novyi Mir (The New World). All the speakers seem to have discounted reports appearing in the bourgeois press of widespread civil disorder in Moscow and Petrograd. Socialist Assemblyman Ben Gitlow, chair of the meeting, brought the crowd to its feet for a raucous ovation when he mentioned the name of party leader Eugene V. Debs, currently awaiting sentencing in Ohio. (9) "Reed Held Under Spy Act; Bail is $5,000: Hearing Set for Tuesday on Charge of Violating Law in Recent Speech." (NY Call) [event of Sept. 14, 1918] One day after speaking before 4,000 New Yorkers at Hunts Point Casino, Liberator journalist John Reed was arrested for alleged violation of the so-called Espionage Act for remarks made during the course of his speech.