Rank Can Democracy Be Devoid of Morality?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FOREWORD he Albert Barrow Memorial All – India Inter - School Creative Writing Competition held every year by the Council for the Indian School Certificate Examinations, is Ttestimony of its efforts to foster creativity, independent thinking and communicative ability among the students of the schools affiliated to the Council. The competition becomes the touchstone of the Council’s goals and efforts. We wish to create articulate, thinking individuals who are not merely bound by bookish knowledge, but are able to process the world that they find themselves in and develop their own values and attitudes. It was with this aim in mind that the theme of this year’s competition was ‘Democracy’. The contributions of students from classes XI and XII in category 1 and classes X and below in category 2 reflect their maturity levels. Not only are today’s students alert and aware, but they are also able to voice their opinions with great clarity. Schools should take part in these competitions in greater number as in addition to giving their students much needed exposure, they are showcasing the talents being nurtured in the schools. The range and variety of interpretation of the topics and the felicity of style revealed through the writings of the students have left the judges quite impressed. In some cases, the compositions show rare sensitivity to the burning topical issues. It was very difficult for the judges to come to a decision about the best writing. I would like to express my gratitude to the Heads of Schools for encouraging their students to participate in this competition, as well as the teachers who motivated and trained them. I wish to commend all the participants for their effort and their clarity of thought. I take this opportunity to put on record my appreciation of the hard work put in by the team in the Council office in making this edition of the volume of essays of the Albert Barrow Memorial All - India Inter - School Creative Writing Competition 2019, possible. (Gerry Arathoon) Chief Executive & Secretary 51 C O N T E N T S CATEGORY - 1 CATEGORY - 2 Vaishnavi Prasad st Siya Elizabeth Jacob Class XII 1 Class X 04 04 26 St. Xavier’s School Vidyashilp Academy Bokaro, Jharkhand Bengaluru, Karnataka Akshansh Kumar Meera Mothilal nd Class XII 2 Class IX 06 28 Hari Sri Vidya Nidhi School Hill Top School Thrissur, Kerala Jamshedpur, Jharkhand Arkajyoti Banerjee rd Mayukhi Khan Class XII 3 Class X 08 30 Garden High School Calcutta Girls’ High School Kolkata, West Bengal Kolkata, West Bengal Vrinda Sharma th Harini Vijayakumar Class XII 4 Class X 10 32 Hiranandani Foundation School The Bishop’s Co-Ed. School Powai, Mumbai, Maharashtra Undri, Pune, Maharashtra Siya Manoj Gupta th Juzer Malbari Class XI 5 Class X 12 34 Smt. Sulochanadevi Singhania School Christ Church School Thane, Maharashtra Mumbai, Maharashtra Sanjana Shetty th Ananya Mukerji Class XII 6 Class X 14 36 Podar International School Dhirubhai Ambani International School Nerul, Mumbai, Maharashtra Mumbai, Maharashtra Arunima Sengupta th Avanie Joshi Class XII 7 Class X 16 38 Modern High School For Girls St. Mary’s Convent College Kolkata, West Bengal Nainital, Uttarakhand Ananya Katyal th Arnav Mishra Class XI 8 Class X 18 40 The Bishop’s Co-Ed. School Don Bosco Academy Kalyaninagar, Pune, Maharashtra Patna, Bihar Anuj Khare th Rishi Tiwari Class XII 9 Class X 20 42 Cathedral & John Connon School St. George’s College Mumbai, Maharashtra Mussoorie, Uttarakhand Veena Venugopal th Shane Rebelo Class XI 10 Class X 22 44 G. D. Birla Centre For Education Wisdom World School Kolkata, West Bengal Wakad, Pune, Maharashtra CATEGORY 1 "An educated, enlightened and informed population is one of the surest ways of promoting the health of a democracy." -Nelson Mandela CATEGORY - 1 St. Xavier’s School, Bokaro 1st RANK Vaishnavi Prasad St. Xavier’s School, Bokaro steel city was established by the Society of Jesus in 1966 at the invitation of the Bokaro Class XII steel plant. The School envisions the holistic growth of the St. Xavier’s School students to become persons of Competence, Consciousness, Compassion and Commitment. It revamps its students into Bokaro people, courageous enough to make mistakes and ingrains in Jharkhand them the humility to learn from these mistakes. The School accentuates on the idea, “In order for the pupils to liberate the energy of their strength, their weakness must have a chance to reveal itself”. I HAVE THE POWER - I CAN VOTE enerally a mother who gives birth to a new us. The cruel gods delight in withholding some of life is considered an incarnation of the their favours. So my parents, traditional GAlmighty and when the birth actually conformists, got a beautiful baby with some takes place, there is celebration all around. imperfections. However, this was not the same in my case. A pall Of course they dealt with the problem in their own of gloom descended upon my family. My way. After contemplation and analysis, it was grandmother wept as if my mother had given birth decided that my parents had borne a daughter and to a still born child. My mother, instead of being the school they admitted me to, remained congratulated and pampered, was cursed. The c o m p l e t e l y c l u e l e s s a b o u t m y g r i e v o u s world regretted my existence from the moment I imperfections. I grew up as the most captivating was born. No, I was not a physically challenged and accomplished girl of St. Mary’s School. It was person, who might have given a family sleepless in eighth grade that our teacher for Political nights. From what I can make out from my baby Science, Mrs. Munroe, read these lines from our pictures, I was outright beautiful and flawless. I Civics text book: had ten fingers and ten toes. What then was wrong you might ask? This universe does not have the ‘Any person who is more than eighteen years of habit of showering all the blessings that we seek on age will be allowed to vote without any 4 CATEGORY - 1 discrimination on the basis of caste, creed, sex or outraged and as I picked myself up to leave, I felt a religion, according to the Universal Adult hand over my mouth. Before I could react, I was Franchise.’ A smile escaped my lips. I lived in a stripped, kicked and thrown into the bushes. democracy, and my country would acknowledge I do not remember what happened next. When I me as I am. I could hardly wait to be eighteen. gained consciousness, I felt violated, humiliated The year I turned eighteen was also the year for and outraged. We feel so relieved when we wake fresh elections to the Lok Sabha. I got my name up from a nightmare. But it seemed as though I registered through the online portal and on the had woken up into one. I realized that in a few specified date, I joined the queue to cast my vote. minutes, the world had drained me of all that I After an hour and a half, my turn came. The officer had. asked me, “What is your name Madam?” Suddenly all those seminars and talk shows that “Vishwa Mishra,” I replied. were meant to espouse and motivate our kind, felt hollow and meaningless. All the speeches that I “What is your father’s name?” had heard and which had buoyed me up during “Chandan Mishra.” my moments of confusion and struggles with my identity seemed fake. The idea of a democracy with The man gave me a paper with the details printed its high sounding ideals, its promise of equality on it. Its top right hand corner stated: Sex- F and a voice for all, the words, ‘rights’ and ‘powers’ There was another man guarding the electronic lost relevance. Suddenly, this life felt pointless. voting machine. I approached him and said, “Sir, I Was it really my fault? Does a transgender not am not a female.” Instantly the man’s head jerked have a right to live, to decide who is going to up and he began staring at me. After a moment of represent him and his concerns? Weren’t we astonished silence, he said,” Sorry Sir, You look so supposed to be the biggest democracy in the much like a lady.” world? I had really thought I had the power- the Without further interrogation, he struck off the ‘F’ power of the ballot. I had felt that my vote counted. and wrote an ‘M’ in its place. Was I wrong? I again stopped him. “Sir, please tick the ‘Others’ box. I am a transgender. In the blink of an eye, the attitude of the man changed. He rose up and began shouting. “Who let you in? What are you doing here? Just get out.” Abased and humiliated more than I had ever been, I cried out, “According to the Universal Adult Franchise, all the citizens of this democracy are permitted to vote without any discrimination, if they are at least eighteen years old. I have the power to vote!” But not a single officer present, the protectors and upholders of the law and the Constitution, came to my rescue. I was pushed out of the room through the rear door to jeers and sniggering among all the people present. The doors were slammed shut. An inexpressible anger held me in its grip and I cursed long and loud. After all, supposedly, that is the only power that we possess.