Hunter S. Thompson and the American Carnivalesque
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Hunter S. Thompson and the American Carnivalesque Ellen Kristine Pedersen A Thesis Presented to The Department of Literature, Area Studies and European Languages UNIVERSITY OF OSLO In Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements of the MA Degree Autumn 2014 II Hunter S. Thompson and the American Carnivalesque III © Ellen Kristine Pedersen 2014 Hunter S. Thompson and the American Carnivalesque Ellen Kristine Pedersen http://www.duo.uio.no/ Trykk: Reprosentralen, Universitetet i Oslo IV Abstract In this thesis I look into the carnivalesque aspects in Hunter S. Thompson’s Hell’s Angels, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, and The Great Shark Hunt. I explore the ways Thompson challenges established views of agency and the self in modern times through his representation of otherwise ignored aspects of conventional society. I ground my comparative analysis of his texts on the rhetorical devices put in play by polyglossia, satire and the grotesque. I demonstrate how Thompson’s narrative strategy functions as a shock treatment on bourgeois sensibilities to contribute to a stagnant social discourse. Essential to the American Carnivalesque is how the performance of the self is affected by external influence and social aspirations, and Thompson enacts with self-reflexive humour his assessment of the state of modern civilization, in which people perform meaning to the extent of absurdity, the author included. In these three books Thompson engage into a celebration of the American Carnivalesque in its meaninglessness, by tearing down illusions and self-deceits, which in the end stands as a necessary acknowledgment of the post-modern social condition. V VI Acknowledgments There are many people to whom I am grateful after the long but rewarding process of my thesis writing. My supervisor, Rebecca Sherr, demonstrated patience and supportiveness along the way, and gave me constructive feedbacks which helped me to stay on track. For this I am very grateful. Also important has been the sense of community here at the University of Oslo, and while we worked hard to get to the end, the conversations with and support from my fellow students were priceless. Thanks especially to Maria Nedregård, Erik Holsvik Opsal and Kjetil Albertsen. Throughout this process I have received much help and feedback from my cousin, André Lauritzen, and it meant a lot. Last, but not least, I want to give my appreciation to my mother, Karin, my brothers, Bjørn Ivar and Geir Magnus, and my sister, Astrid. Your support has been a great comfort- and- you are great. Definitely last, I wish to express how challenging but very interesting and engaging it has been to write about Hunter S. Thompson and the American Carnivalesque, as I find his works to encourage afterthought on multiple levels, especially in their uncompromising rhetoric of grotesque humour. It has been a fun journey, and worth all the time it took. VII VIII Contents 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 1 1.1 The Works in Issue by Hunter S. Thompson............................................................... 3 1.2 Hunter Stockton Thompson's biography. .................................................................... 5 1.3 Covering reality and presenting it fictionally: New Journalism and Gonzo: .............. 7 1.3.1 Gonzo Journalism ................................................................................................. 8 1.4 The American Carnevalesque; Polyglossia, satire and grotesque realism: ............... 10 1.4.1 Polyglossia in the text. ....................................................................................... 11 1.4.2 The Rhetoric of Satire ........................................................................................ 13 1.4.3 The Grotesque as Mode of Communication ...................................................... 15 2 Hell's Angels – A strange and terrible saga...................................................................... 18 2.1 Employing polyglossia in the process of discourse. ................................................. 21 2.2 Satire counteracting flawed representation. .............................................................. 29 2.3 Grotesque enactments of social disturbance. ............................................................ 35 3 Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas – A Savage Journey to the Heart of the American Dream 42 3.1 Developing a dialogue challenging mechanical representation. ............................... 46 3.2 Satirical fear and loathing. ........................................................................................ 52 3.3 Enacting Grotesque resistance. ................................................................................. 57 4 The Great Shark Hunt- Strange Tales from a Strange Time ............................................ 65 4.1 In Dialogue with the social contexts in America ...................................................... 69 4.2 Satirising political strategies. .................................................................................... 75 4.3 Targeting grotesque conventions. ............................................................................. 81 5 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 89 Works Cited .............................................................................................................................. 93 IX 1 Introduction “He who makes a beast of himself gets rid of the pain of being a man” - Dr. Johnson These are modern times, and the world is full of contradictory voices and subcultures that have their own concept of standards and meaning. All these different cultural voices seek their ideal lives side by side, in the same block, in the same neighbourhood and in the same workplace, each with their own convictions and ideas of self-asserting truths. Capitalism has enabled men and women to gain material wealth based on hard work, and it is all up to the individual how he or she makes up her own life. Within this performative reality, everything should be attainable, and distinctions of high and low are in constant negotiation. There are many small narratives out there due to the global multicultural state of affairs, and the representation of all these smaller parts of the whole make up the mosaic of a nation of numerous voices, that all affect the totality of the everyday enactment of culture. There are channels of information that provide society with regular updates on events that take place, and these mediums have as a goal to inform citizens of who is doing what and who disagrees with whom in economical and power spheres. Jean Aitchison writes of news that “[it] is likely to be events which re-affirm accepted values in the society in which the readers live.”1 But whose ideology rules the day, and who is left out of the equation – being the paradigm in which socially acceptable behaviour is enlisted and tolerated? These questions are posed and performed by Hunter S. Thompson in his works by either telling the story of people who have either fallen out of the equation, or himself acting out the extremes of social boundaries, thus providing an incentive to take a look at the discourse of individual autonomy in the face of accepted social boundaries. The newsworthiness of Thompson's works reads more as a questioning of accepted values, and not a re-affirmation of them. In this thesis I will analyze and discuss how Hunter S. Thompson challenges traditional concepts of decency and the self in a society where narrow categorization compromises individual agency and spirit in order to promote and maintain a stable, productive and powerful state position. Thompson launches a new journalist shock treatment 1 Jean Aitchison.» The World Weavers- Newshounds and Wordsmiths.» Cambridge. Cambridge University Press: 2007., p198 1 onto bourgeois society's sensibilities, in order to shed light on the hilarious absurdities in the established cultural self-assertiveness. He demonstrates in his works both indirectly and directly how the greater society effects individuals, leaving them with few choices with which to act according to, and his works can criticise how these few choices make society into one that is dull and stagnant, thereby making individuals into passive consumers and not active participants on their own terms. Personal freedom holds a high position in American culture, and Thompson demonstrates an urge to preserve his, while at the same time making a social critique with his actions and behaviour, which I will look into further by discussing his narrative techniques. Thompson is dealing with these philosophical issues in different ways in the three publications of his that I will examine and analyze, Hell's Angels, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, and The Great Shark Hunt. The last publication is a book in which a majority of his published articles from different newspapers and magazines are gathered in one piece. Thompson wrote with the license of being a journalist, thus he acquired the authority to cover events, and he made use of fictional devices in order to create vivid descriptions of the experiences he had during his career, and of the people he met during his 'gigs', as he liked to call them. Not too many scholars have found Thompson's works to be of academic interest, as he has been labelled an author of entertainment rather than having something to