ASBMB ANNOUNCES 2008 AWARD WINNERS
September 2007
ASBMB GOES TO CHINA
American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Scientists helping scientists… It costs no more to choose the very best for your custom peptides and antibodies…
Ac-C T P R Q I pS F N F K-OH All peptides are made in our laboratories 1461.640
with the most rigorous QC in the industry – pSFNFK-H3PO4 -98 623.245 We sequence every purified -H PO peptide we manufacture! 3 4 PhD scientists with over 70 years of 623.0 626.5 combined experience in Chemistry, Mass 293.141 72 Cell Biology and Immunology 1218.599
1169.510 1347.658 536.784 740.405 809.426 1317.591 6 246.072 499.227 972.531
400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 Mass
Complete antibody protocols and no hidden charges. Phosphospecific antibody experts!
Custom peptides up to 100 AAs in length and at purities up to >98%. Peptides for epitope mapping as low as $4/AA.
Modifications include phosphorylated amino acids, dye-labeling, cyclic peptides, and peptides with stable isotopes.
Experience for yourself why research scientists around the world trust 21st Century Biochemicals for their custom peptides and antibodies!
Come speak with our scientists at: Biomedical Research Equipment and Supplies Exhibit at Harvard Medical School Sept. 19 – 20 Society for Neuroscience, San Diego, CA Nov. 3 – 7 American Society for Cell Biology, Washington, DC Dec. 1 – 5
www.21stcenturybio.com 260 Cedar Hill Street, Marlboro, MA 01752 Made in the P: 508.303.8222 Toll-free: 877.217.8238 F: 508.303.8333 E: [email protected] U.S.A. contents SEPTEMBER 2007
ON THE COVER: A delegation of seven representa- tives from ASBMB recently visited society news Beijing, Guangzhou, and Shanghai 2 President’s Message where they met with Chinese sci- entists, students, and members of 6 Washington Update the Society’s counterpart in China. 7 New JBC Minireview 12 Compendium on Interferons 10 Retrospective: Daniel E. Koshland Jr. special interest 12 ASBMB Delegation Tours China 14 Early Medical Research Funding and the Evolution of Modern American Biochemistry 2008 meeting overview 16 Systems Biology: a shared goal with diverse views 18 The Diverse Aspects of Protein Synthesis and Degradation 20 A Renaissance for Metabolism Research compendium. 7 22 RNA: From Atom to Organism 23 ASBMB Taps 8 Scientists and 1 Politician for Top Awards science focus 27 Maurice Swanson: Finding New Cures for Muscular Dystrophy 30 Matthias Mann: Using Proteomics to Understand Protein Interactions departments 4 News from the Hill 8 Member Spotlight 24 Career Insights 26 Education and Training 32 BioBits resources 34 For Your Lab 35 Career Opportunities 36 Scientific Meeting Calendar e transcription cttor two-step. 32
September 2007 ASBMB Today 1 president’smessage
A monthly publication of The American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Peer Review Front Officers Heidi E. Hamm President and Center Gregory A. Petsko President-Elect BY HEIDI HAMM Mark A. Lemmon Secretary Merle S. Olson Treasurer Council Members Alan Hall Kuan-Teh Jeang Suzanne R. Pfeffer Linda J. Pike John D. Scott Joan A. Steitz Kevin Struhl James A. Wells t’s great to be back from a very Groups (IRGs). (More information is Ex-Officio Members Iproductive and interesting trip to given at cms.csr.nih.gov/AboutCSR/ Ellis Bell China with our ASBMB delegation. We OpenHouses.htm.) The open house on Chair, Education and Professional met our goals of establishing a closer Biomolecular IRGs, which is particu- Development Committee Laurie S. Kaguni relationship with Chinese scientists in larly relevant to ASBMB, will be held on Chair, Meeting Committee biochemistry and molecular biology, December 18. George Hill and we were delighted with the warm The Panel on Scientific Boundaries Chair, Minority Affairs Committee Kendall J. Blumer and enthusiastic welcome we received. for Review, headed by Bruce Alberts, Anna Marie Pyle I am sure you have been hearing undertook the latest reorganization Co-chairs, 2008 Program Committee about the many calls for information of study sections. I have been work- Mary J. C. Hendrix Chair, Public Affairs Advisory Committee from the National Institutes of Health ing closely with Bruce for a couple of Robert E. Rhoads (NIH) on many topics. One which is years on the issue of how to influence Chair, Publications Committee dear to our hearts is peer review. It’s the CSR to have more ongoing input Herbert Tabor Editor, JBC good to see that the NIH is making a from extramural scientists on how study Ralph A. Bradshaw major effort to examine the peer review sections are functioning. This ongoing A. L. Burlingame process. This critical reexamination fo interaction has led to a proposal for the Co-editors, MCP Edward A. Dennis the peer review system has been a high two societies to work together to provide Editor, JLR priority of ASBMB, prompted by the our input to the CSR. Thus, the two
ASBMB Today crisis in funding and resultant doubling societies will jointly analyze the makeup Editorial Advisory Board of NIH grant applications over recent and scope of the study sections that are Alex Toker years. A key reason for this reassessment of most interest to the two societies, Chair is to be sure the system is operating as it determine whether there is sufficient Mike Autry Greg P. Bertenshaw Craig E. Cameron A. Stephen Dahms was meant to after the last major over- breadth, expertise, and balance between Irwin Fridovich Richard W. Hanson haul instigated by the Panel on Scientific basic and clinical investigators, etc. Our Elizabeth A. Komives Bettie Sue Masters Luke A. O’Neill Boundaries for Review almost 7 years analysis will be provided to the CSR at Duanqing Pei Carol C. Shoulders ago. Of course, we hope that completely this open house. If you are willing to be Robert D. Wells new ideas will emerge from this reex- involved in this analysis, please let me ASBMB Today amination to help us overcome the real or Mary Hendrix, chair of the Public Nicole Kresge Editor crisis in peer review that has resulted Affairs Advisory Committee, know of [email protected] from the lack of investment in biomedi- your interest! In particular, we need Pat Pages Science Writer [email protected] cal research over the last 5 years. ASBMB members who have served on Nancy J. Rodnan Director of Publications A number of activities to assess these study sections recently, as they are [email protected] Barbara Gordon Executive Director peer review are underway. Toni Scarpa, the real experts on how well the study [email protected] director of the Center for Scientific sections are working. Magazine design & production: Amy Phifer Review (CSR), announced a series of Additionally, a Working Group of
For information on advertising contact open houses to give the extramural the NIH Advisory Committee to the FASEB AdNet at 800-433-2732 ext. 7157 or community a chance to voice their views Director, focusing on a review of the 301-634-7157, or E-mail [email protected]. on the quality and expertise of various current peer review system at NIH, met study sections and Integrated Review in Washington, D.C. on July 30 to hear www.asbmb.org
September 2007 comments from the scientific com- Working Group co-chairs Lawrence We hope all of you with an inter- munity. ASBMB President-Elect Greg Tabak, director of the National Institute est in the NIH peer review system will Petsko delivered ASBMB’s comments, of Dental and Craniofacial Research, bookmark this site and visit it regularly which covered 4 main points: and Keith Yamamoto, University of to keep abreast of what is going on. Oversight of study sections should California, San Francisco, noted in The Working Group will be accepting be ongoing. The Center for Scientific their July 12 letter to the commu- comments from concerned members Review must monitor the IRGs and nity about the group that “With the of the biomedical research community; study sections to ensure that they are increasing breadth and complexity of the NIH also currently has a request functioning as they should, and make science, along with the rising number for information on the NIH System to changes as appropriate based on feed- of research grant applications, we are Support Biomedical and Behavioral back from both members of the study Research and Peer Review (grants.nih. sections and those whose proposals are gov/grants/guide/notice-files/NOT- reviewed there. Critical OD-07-084.html). Senior researchers should continue reexamination In his opening remarks, Yama- to serve on study sections. ASBMB moto noted that there had been many also recommended that assistant of the peer review changes in peer review since he became professors not serve on study sections. involved in the mid-1980s. In 1987, Petsko recommended that senior system is a high there were only 1,800 people serving researchers be compelled to serve on priority of ASBMB on study sections. Now, that figure has study sections, similar to serving on grown by an order of magnitude— juries when called upon. As he noted, 18,000 scientists are currently serving. “holding a federal grant is a privilege, taking a comprehensive look at our Furthermore, the nature of science is not a right,” and thus those who hold review process to ensure its continued different; the scope of applications is them should be expected to pay back strength for applicants and reviewers much broader than 20 years ago. the system by study section service if alike. We would like you to participate Yamamoto went on to note that called upon. in this discussion.” NIH Director Elias the review process must evolve and Study section membership must fit Zerhouni was in attendance the entire adapt to these changes. For example, the charge of the study section. Care meeting. there is currently too much emphasis should be taken to ensure that indi- NIH formed the Working Group to on preliminary data and experimental viduals with all necessary expertise to gather information from the external detail. One way to deal with this might carry out the reviews the study section community to hear ideas on ways to be to move toward an “editorial board” is charged with are selected to serve. improve the process. The July 30 meet- model of peer review, with permanent Study section size should be ing was the first in a series of meetings panels that evaluate applications as they manageable. Under the reorganization, planned through the end of the year. A come in. The technical details would be many study sections have too many second meeting will be held in Wash- sent to panels of technical experts for areas of science under their purview. ington to hear comments from the vol- review and the editorial board/study ASBMB suggested that some of the untary health community; three more section would look at the proposal as sections should be broken down into meetings will be held in the fall—one a whole. This model would also avoid smaller groups. each in New York, Chicago, and San artificial competition. Petsko also recommended that the Francisco. ASBMB will work to ensure This was only one of a number of application package be redesigned so that a few of our members attend each ideas floated at the meeting; others will that it is only 15 pages long. of these sessions and offer comments fi no doubt emerge in coming months. As The comments were based on a possible. Petsko noted in his closing remarks, the survey conducted in March 2006 of A website has been established to NIH peer review system “is the jewel of ASBMB members on peer review. The keep the biomedical research com- American science,” and if it is going to above points synthesized the major- munity apprised of the activities of the be modified, it must be done deliber- ity of the more than 1,000 comments Working Group. It can be accessed at ately and thoughtfully to maintain its received. enhancing-peer-review.nih.gov/. luster.
September 2007 ASBMB Today 3 news from the hill
The Senate bill, passed in June, provides a $29.9 billion Congress Leaves (3.5%) increase for NIH. However the bill also increases the amount of the transfer from NIH to the Global HIV/ for August Recess AIDS fund from $99 million in FY2007 to $300 million in FY 2008. As a result, the actual increase for NIH programs in with Veto Threats FY 2008 is $799 million (2.8%), compared to $549 million (1.9%) in the House bill. Both the House and Senate bills Looming fall short of the projected 3.7% increase in the Biomedical Research and Development Price Index (BRDPI) for FY 2008. he 2008 appropriations bills currently being debated There may be some interesting discussions in confer- Tin Congress would provide $22 billion more in Federal ence about policy issues. First, the House approved a man- spending than President Bush proposed in his FY 2008 datory public access policy regarding scientific publications budget. On August 2, the President reaffirmed his intentions resulting from NIH-funded research. to veto spending bills if this money remains in them. The current NIH Public Access Policy asks researchers ASBMB Today has learned that Senate Majority Leader to submit their NIH-funded research articles to PubMed Harry Reid (D-NV) met with the Democratic caucus on Central for online availability within 12 months of publica- August 2 and told them he would not be scheduling a tion in a peer-reviewed journal. The House bill makes the floor vote for the Labor/Health and Human Services (HHS) submission mandatory. In recognition of copyright issues, appropriations bill, which funds NIH. With the looming however, a phrase was added requiring NIH to implement veto threat, expectation of another supplemental funding the policy “in a manner consistent with copyright law.” request in September for the Iraq war, and the likely need to Publishers are not happy with this language, however. respond to the report on progress in Iraq due in September, According to a statement by the Association of American Reid did not see an opportunity to devote time to the bill. Publishers, “mandatory submission of the final peer-re- Thus, Hill staff expects the bill to be wrapped into either a viewed manuscript cannot be implemented ‘consistent with giant omnibus appropriations bill or a copyright law’ because of its adverse “minibus” made up of two or three such impact on journal publishers’ copyright bills. This is not likely to occur until the interests in the version of the manu- late fall, if then, thereby necessitating a script published as a journal article.” continuing resolution, if not a series of them until final agreement is reached. NSF Also Under the Gun Therefore, it is very likely that most On July 26, the House voted to pass of the major science agencies, includ- the FY 2008 Commerce, Justice, Sci- ing NIH and NSF, will be on a continu- ence and Related Agencies Appropria- ing resolution once October 1, 2007, tions Act, which funds NSF and other arrives. How long they will remain in this science agencies as well as a host condition is anyone’s guess. of other programs. The $53.8 billion bill provides NSF with $6.51 billion, a NIH Spending and Policy Issues $592 million increase over its FY 2007 On July 19, the House passed the FY budget and $80 million more than the 2008 Labor/HHS Bill by a vote of 276- President proposed. House Com- 140. The bill provides NIH with a $750 merce, Justice and Science Appropria- million increase (2.6%) in FY 2008. How- tions Chairman Alan Mollohan (D-WV) ever, the actual NIH program increase is stated, “this increase would continue $549 million (a 1.9% increase) because the goal of doubling NSF’s funding in the House would require that NIH trans- 10 years.” fer $201 million of its increase to the However, the President has said Global AIDS fund. he will veto this bill as well, mainly
4 ASBMB Today September 2007 because of what the White House terms “an irresponsible The Senate Appropriations Committee approved an and excessive level of spending” as well as “other objec- increase for NSF of $637 million or 10.8%, to $6.55 billion tionable provisions.” These comments were made in a in FY 2008. The full Senate is expected to vote on the bill Statement of Administration Policy issued on July 24. within the next two months, and then a conference commit- Regarding the NSF, the Statement of Administration Pol- tee will be appointed to reach a compromise between the icy says, “the Administration supports neither the additional House and Senate versions of the bill. $72 million above the [President’s budget] request allocated to NSF education programs that lack proven effectiveness, nor [Appropriations Committee] report language that seeks to allocate funds away from the NSF research programs Go Visit Your Congressman that most directly contribute to America’s economic com- Congress left Washington on August 3 for the traditional petitiveness.” August recess. They spend this time taking both vacations This is an apparent reference to report language and the pulse of their constituents. In this latter capacity, instructing NSF to fund Biology, Behavioral, Social and please try to arrange to visit with your member this summer Economic Science, and Geosciences at the agency while he or she is home. Contact the ASBMB Public Affairs at “comparable” levels to those enjoyed by the other Office if you would like assistance. In addition, you might research directorates. ASBMB supported this language consider watching the training DVD the ASBMB Public when we became aware of it. It is highly unusual for the Affairs Advisory Committee produced this spring, called White House to single out such report language as a rea- “Meeting with Your Congressman: A Guide for the Grass son to veto an appropriations bill. Unfortunately, although Roots Advocate.” You can watch this DVD on the ASBMB the House passed the bill by a large majority, the margin of website (the link is on the home page at www.asbmb.org victory was several votes short of the two-thirds number under “What’s New”) needed to override the threatened veto.
Science Policy Fellow to Join Staff Welch Foundation Pre-doctoral Fellowship in July 2005. She has a long record of academic and community service, including a Angela Noel Hvitved, a Ph.D. candidate in biochemistry and cell term as president of the Biochemistry and Cell Biology Graduate biology at Rice University, Houston, Texas, has been selected by Student Association at Rice. the Public Affairs Advisory Committee as ASBMB’s first science “Science literacy for all Americans,” Hvitved says, “is critical policy fellow. Ms. Hvitved, who defended her thesis in August, will for the health of our national science policy. A 2004 National be joining the ASBMB staff no later than October 1 after moving Science Foundation (NSF) report on scientific literacy indicated here from Houston. that almost half of Americans believe that humans coexisted with As Hvitved told ASBMB Today, “Science and scientists should dinosaurs and did not develop from earlier species. Each and exert a much greater influence on our public policy than they every scientist should consider this a serious concern, not only currently do. One of my goals for this fellowship is to learn how because that 50% can elect policy makers with funding and over- career scientists can become actively involved in policy making. sight responsibilities, but also because it contradicts everything I wholeheartedly believe in the concept of the ‘civic scientist’ and we spend our lives trying to accomplish—expanding the pool of hope to help scientists appreciate the civic responsibilities that human knowledge.” accompany scientific training.” During her year-long fellowship, Hvitved wants to work on Hvitved received twin bachelor’s degrees in Biochemistry and lifting the ban on federal funding for most human embryonic stem Philosophy from Iowa State University in 2000 and has been a cell research, restoring funding increases to the National Insti- graduate student at Rice since 2001. She notes that her degree in tutes of Health (NIH), and raising awareness of the critical lack philosophy provided her with an extensive background in political of scientific literacy among Americans. In addition, Hvitved will theory and ethics and helped her cultivate a broader interest in be helping the staff and Public Affairs Advisory Committee with the intersection of science and society. various research projects, writing regularly for ASBMB Today, and She has worked as a teaching and research assistant at Rice generally helping to advance the ASBMB’s policy goals. . and has received two training awards, including a Robert A. —Peter Farnham
September 2007 ASBMB Today 5 washington update FA S E B FASEB Calls on Scientific Community to Endorse Common Guideline for COI, Unveils Toolkit BY CARRIE D. WOLINETZ
ASEB has issued a call to the scientific community Delivering the keynote address, House Energy and Fto adopt more consistent policies and practices for Commerce Committee Vice-Chair Diana DeGette (D-CO), disclosing and managing financial relationships between applauded FASEB’s efforts and stated, “By creating a academia and industry in biomedical research. This sum- more consistent standard to the extent possible we are mer, FASEB unveiled a framework for a national guideline more likely to avoid ambiguity and confusion. Without and held a meeting of more than 75 representatives of such standards, we run the risk of further confusing the scientific societies and other key stakeholders to discuss public about the integrity of research and exacerbating the process of implementation. Participants in the meet- their distrust.” ing included industry leaders like Gail Cassell of Eli Lilly; The FASEB framework is based on three guiding government officials such as Norka Ruiz-Bravo, of the principles: investigators must conduct research activities National Institutes of Health; and institutional groups rang- objectively, operate with transparency, and be account- ing from the Association of American Medical Colleges able to all stakeholders. To promote practices to achieve (AAMC) to the National Association of State Universities these principles, FASEB developed the COI Toolkit and Land Grant Colleges (NASULGC) as well as more website containing recommendations to improve the than two dozen scientific societies. In conjunction with the management of academic-industry relationships and conference, FASEB launched the COI Tookit, a website promote investigator education. Many of the recommen- designed to help researchers, institutions, publications, dations were derived from guidelines FASEB published and industry put into practice FASEB’s recommendations. in 2006 (opa.faseb.org/pdf/FASEB_COI_paper_7x06. Leo T. Furcht, immediate past president of FASEB pdf). The Toolkit provides a platform for the community to and chair of the committee that developed the program, share resources with the goal of moving toward a national described the challenge before the community: “FASEB guideline. is concerned that the lack of clarity and consistency in Participants in the meeting expressed enthusiasm for current conflict-of-interest policies may cause confu- a set of common principles and guidelines that they could sion by investigators and ultimately inhibit their ability to use to help better manage financial relationships between protect the integrity of research.” According to Laura academia and industry. “It is essential that the various Brockway, FASEB’s lead staffer on the project, “FASEB’s stakeholders work together to study the effectiveness of recommendations articulate the issue from the investiga- policies and practices and strive to balance the need for tors’ perspective because they, as a group, determine the more common standards with preserving case by case effectiveness of policies and practices.” analysis and situational driven decision making, when warranted,” said Brockway. “While flexibility is needed, operating under more broadly agreed upon guidelines Your Congress—Your Health will benefit the public and ensure future public support for Research!America, the Albert and Mary Lasker Foundation, biomedical research.” and several other partners recently released the results of a The work was funded by a grant from the Association new Your Congress–Your Health public opinion poll. A similar of American Medical Colleges–Office of Research Integrity poll was sent to all members of Congress. Responses from Responsible Conduct of Research Program for Academic both polls can be found at www.yourcongressyourhealth.org/. Societies. The FASEB COI toolkit may be viewed online at If your members of Congress have not yet submitted their opa.faseb.org/pages/advocacy/coi/toolkit.htm. responses to the Your Congress–Your Health questionnaire, please send them a message asking them to participate. Carrie D. Wolinetz is with the FASEB Office of Public Affairs.
6 ASBMB Today September 2007 firstasbmbsecondnews words New JBC Minireview Compendium on Interferons
nterferon (IFN), the first cytokine discovered, was identi- Montreal, Canada) focuses Ified by the British virologist Alick Isaacs and the Swiss on the centrally important researcher Jean Lindenmann in 1957 during their seminal interferon regulatory factors studies on virus interference. They found that influenza (IRFs) involved in transcrip- virus-infected cells produced a secreted factor that trans- tional activation of the type ferred a virus-resistant state to previously uninfected cells. I interferon gene promoters. The factor was designated interferon because of its ability Next, Sidney Pestka to interfere with virus growth. (Robert Wood Johnson To celebrate the 50th anniversary of the discovery Medical School, Piscat- of interferons, the Journal of Biological Chemistryy (JBC) away, New Jersey) provides an account of the discovery will release a compendium of eight Minirevieww articles of interferons, their purification and molecular cloning, and published in the journal on this topic. The compendium the biologic activities of IFNs. is available for $22.00 on the JBC Web site (www. In the fifth Minireview, Nicole de Weerd, Shamith jbc.org/), and a summary of the compendium is avail- Samarajiwa, and Paul Hertzog (Monash University, able for free at www.asbmb.org/asbmb/site.nsf/main/ Melbourne, Australia) focus on recent developments in publications?opendocument. understanding the biochemical properties and functional The compendium will also be distributed to the attend- activities of the type I IFN receptor proteins. ees of the Annual Meeting of the International Society for The combined biochemical and genetic studies of the Interferon and Cytokine Research, September 16—19, in mechanisms by which interferons induce transcriptional Oxford, United Kingdom. activation of new cellular gene expression led to the “The JBC is pleased to provide this thematic compen- discovery of the Janus tyrosine kinase (JAK)-signal trans- dium of Minireviews on interferon signal transduction and ducers and activators of transcription (STAT) signaling antiviral innate immunity,” says Charles E. Samuel, editor pathway by the Darnell and Stark laboratories. In the sixth of the Minirevieww section and associate editor of the JBC. Minireview, Christian Schindler (Columbia University, New “Much knowledge about interferons has been gained York), David Levy (New York University School of Medi- during the past 50 years, so it is important to assess the cine), and Thomas Decker (University of Vienna, Austria) depth of that knowledge with a focus on recent advances provide an overview of the JAK family of protein kinases and the new questions that yet need to be addressed.” and the STAT family of transcription factors. Seven of the articles highlighted in the compendium Keiko Ozato, Prafullakumar Tailor, and Toru Kubota were published in 2007 and were part of two Minireview (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland) then series. The first series consisted of three articles on innate describe the mechanisms by which the IRF family of immunity and was published in the May 25 issue of the transcription factors plays critical roles in both innate and JBC. The second was composed of four articles on signal adaptive immunity, including the induction and action of transduction and was part of the July 13 issue of the the IFNs. JBC. An eighth article from the January 9, 2004, issue of In the final Minireview of the compendium, Samuel the JBC was added to these articles. Wormald and Douglas Hilton (Walter and Eliza Hall The first two Minireviews in the compendium, by Institute of Medical Research and Cooperative Research Mitsutoshi Yoneyama and Takashi Fujita (Kyoto University, Centre for Cellular Growth Factors, Parkville, Australia) Japan) and Satoshi Uematsu and Shizuo Akria (Osaka describe the biochemical properties and mechanisms University, Japan), provide updates on two kinds of of action of three families of proteins that inhibit cytokine nucleic acid sensors and the biochemical pathways by signal transduction, the SH2-containing phosphatases which they signal the production of interferon. (SHP), the protein inhibitors of activated STATS (PIAS), In the third Minireview, John Hiscott (McGill University, and the suppressors of cytokine signaling (SOCS).
September 2007 ASBMB Today 7 asbmbfirstsecond member spotlightwords Please submit news about yourself to [email protected] Caruthers and Fedoroff Awarded Georgiou Is Amgen Biochemical National Medal of Science Engineering Awardee Marvin Caruthers, professor of Chemistry and George Georgiou of The University of Texas Biochemistry at the University of Colorado at (UT) at Austin has been honored with the 2007 Boulder, and Nina V. Fedoroff, the Verne M. Amgen Biochemical Engineering Award for his Willaman Chair in Life Sciences and Evan profound impact on protein therapy and other Pugh Professor at Penn State University and protein research. an external professor of the Santa Fe Institute, Georgiou received the award and delivered are the recipients of the 2006 National Medal a lecture on his research at the Biochemical CARUTHERS of Science, the nation’s highest award for Engineering IV conference in July in Quebec lifetime achievement in scientific research. City, Canada. The bi-annual award was given in recognition of They received their medals at a White House Georgiou’s research excellence and leadership in biomedical ceremony in July. engineering. Caruthers was recognized for his lifetime Georgiou holds the Cockrell Family Reagents Chair at the UT accomplishments as a chemistry professor, Austin, with a primary appointment in the Department of Chemi- researcher, and biotechnology innovator. He pio- cal Engineering and further appointments in the departments of neered research in nucleic acid chemistry result- Biomedical Engineering and Molecular Genetics and Microbiology FEDOROFF ing in new methods that are used worldwide for and in the Institute for Cell and Molecular Biology. the chemical synthesis of DNA and RNA. His research has had a profound impact in protein engi- Fedoroff received the medal for her pioneering work on plant neering, protein-based therapeutics, and on the fundamental molecular biology and for her being the first to clone and charac- understanding of protein biogenesis. His biochemical engineering terize maize transposons. She has also contributed to education contributions include the invention of numerous commercially and public policy pertaining to recombinant DNA and genetic important technologies for facilitating the discovery and manu- modification of plants. U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice facturing of protein therapeutics, and in particular therapeutic also recently named Fedoroff as her new science and technology antibodies. He has also made seminal discoveries in the areas of adviser. oxidative protein folding and protein secretion.
Jordan Awarded Pincus Medal Raines Receives Rao V. Craig Jordan, Alfred G. Knudson Chair of Makineni Lectureship Cancer Research and vice president of the Ronald T. Raines, Henry Lardy Professor of Medical Sciences Division at the Fox Chase Biochemistry and Professor of Chemistry at the Cancer Center, Philadelphia, is the co-recipient University of Wisconsin-Madison, has won the with Angela Brodie of the 2007 Gregory Pincus 2007 Rao Makineni Lectureship award from the Prize and Medal from the Worcester Founda- American Peptide Society (APS). tion for Biomedical Research at the University The award, one of only three bestowed by of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester. the APS, is given every other year to recognize The international award recognizes outstanding research “an individual who has made a recent contribu- in endocrinology and honors Gregory Pincus, a co-founder of tion of unusual merit to research in the field of peptide science.” the Worcester Foundation in 1944 and the scientist responsible Raines was honored for his “self-assembly of synthetic collagen for the development of the oral contraceptive. Jordan is being triple helices, which provides new strategies for developing honored for his pioneering research in developing the antiestro- biomaterials for use in medicine and nanotechnology.” His award genic drug tamoxifen for the treatment and prevention of breast address was delivered at the 20th APS symposium in June 2007 cancer as well as the recognition of selective estrogen receptor in Montréal, Canada. modulators that lead to the subsequent development of the drug Raines has made notable contributions to the exploration and raloxifene for the prevention of both osteoporosis and breast exploitation of proteins. He demonstrated that mammalian ribo- cancer. Jordan started his research on tamoxifen at the Worces- nucleases can become potent cytotoxins and potential cancer ter Foundation in the early 1970s. Currently, Jordan is exploiting chemotherapeutics. Raines discovered fundamental attributes of his discovery of the new biology of estrogen action that causes the collagen triple helix, enabling him to assemble triple helices apoptosis in antihormonally resistant breast cancer cells. that are stronger and longer than any found in nature. He and Laura L. Kiessling developed the traceless Staudinger ligation as a means to couple synthetic peptides and thus synthesize proteins.
8 ASBMB Today September 2007 Wells Presented with Borchardt Wins Biomolecular Medal of Friendship Science Award Robert D. Wells, past president of the Ronald Borchardt, Solon E. Summerfield American Society for Biochemistry and Distinguished Professor of Pharmaceutical Molecular Biology and of the Federation of Chemistry at the University of Kansas School of American Societies for Experimental Biology Pharmacy, is the recipient of the PolyPops (FASEB), received the Medal of Friendship Development Foundation Award. He shares the (Universitatis Lodziensis Amico Medal) from award with Ismael J. Hidalgo, chief scientist the Rector (President) Professor Wojciech and cofounder of Absorption Systems. Katner of the University of Lodz, Poland, in The researchers are being recognized for June. This medal is provided to special friends of the university their discovery and development in the late 1980s and early who have made substantial contributions to the education and/ 1990s of Caco-2 cells, a human colon carcinoma cell line that is or well being of the institution. widely used today in in vitro assays to predict the transport rate of Wells has trained a number of postdoctoral research associ- drug candidates across the intestinal epithelial cell barrier. ates at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, the University of The award is presented annually by the Society for Biomo- Alabama at Birmingham, and the Institute of Biosciences and lecular Sciences to members of the scientific community who Technology, Texas A&M University System Health Science Center have shown innovation in the design and application of plastics since 1979. At that time, Wells’ first research associate joined his and polymers in microplate development and design. The prize team to investigate non-B DNA structures in gene expression. includes a $2,500 honorarium. This was quickly followed in 1986 by a second research associ- ate, Adam Jaworski. Jaworski has been instrumental helping IN MEMORIAM: Wells identify young scientists to work in his laboratory as well as new professors to hire at the latter two institutions. Approximately Harry Rudney 1918–2007 20 scientists have been hosted in the U.S. Furthermore, the Harry Rudney, chairman emeritus of the Department of Bio- total number of Polish citizens educated or trained in the U.S. in chemistry and Molecular Biology at the University of Cincinnati technical or scientific pursuits due to the Jaworski-Wells collabo- College of Medicine, died on May 30, 2007. rations is 46. Born in Toronto, Canada, on April 14, 1918, Rudney was a member of a struggling Jewish immigrant family. Although he Lefkowitz Lauded with Shaw Prize couldn’t afford college, he attended public lectures offered by the University of Toronto. Among the lectures he heard was one Robert J. Lefkowitz, Howard Hughes Medical given by Bruno Mendel, who worked at the Banting Institute. Institute investigator at Duke University Medical Rudney wrote to Mendel and suggested an experiment that he Center, has received the Shaw Prize in Life could do. Mendel was so impressed that he offered Rudney a Science and Medicine for 2007 for his research job in his lab, which helped him pay his way through the Univer- into understanding the receptor system that sity of Toronto. controls the body’s response to drugs and Rudney went on to receive a master’s degree from the hormones. Lefkowitz will receive the award, University of Toronto in 1948 and a Ph.D. from Western Reserve which includes a $1 million prize, during a University in Cleveland in 1952. He joined the faculty at Western ceremony in Hong Kong in September. Reserve before being recruited by the University of Cincinnati The annual prize, which was first granted in 2004, was estab- to be the chairman of the Department of Biochemistry and lished by Run Run Shaw, a Chinese native who founded the film Molecular Biology. He was the Andrew Carnegie Professor of company Shaw Brothers Limited in Hong Kong in the 1950s. Biological Chemistry from 1967 until 1989. After his retirement, Shaw also serves as executive chairman of Television Broadcasts he returned to serve as interim chairman of the Department of Limited, also in Hong Kong. Pharmacology for three years. He later served as chairman of Lefkowitz received the award for his “relentless elucidation” the institutional review board. of seven-transmembrane-spanning receptors. These receptors Rudney was elected to the Fellows of the Graduate School are the targets of almost half of the drugs on the market today, at the University of Cincinnati in 1976 and received the George including antihistamines, ulcer medications, and beta blockers for Rieveschl Jr. Award for distinguished research. He served as heart disease. Lefkowitz first cloned the receptors in the 1980s. president of the Association of Medical School Chairmen of “I am so deeply honored to be recognized like this,” Lefkowitz Biochemistry and was on the editorial board of the Journal of said. “I am also proud that all I have accomplished happened Biological Chemistry. while I was here at Duke. It is a very fulfilling feeling to have years of hard work recognized like this.”
September 2007 ASBMB Today 9 asbmbnews
RETROSPECTIVE: Daniel E. Koshland, Jr. (1920-2007)
aniel E. Koshland, Jr., former friends and family. Below, as a tribute, DASBMB president and a tireless we offer thoughts and reflections from booster of the biological sciences, died several of Koshland’s friends and former on July 23 following a massive stroke. colleagues: A long time professor of Molecular and I knew of Koshland’s fame before I came to Cell Biology at the University of Califor- Berkeley, yet he was never intimidating even nia, Berkeley and a resident of Lafayette, as he cast an imposing scientific presence. California, Koshland was 87. He made graduate school a thoughtful, Koshland graduated from the Univer- rewarding and—importantly—enjoyable sity of California, Berkeley in 1941 and experience with his innovative ideas and promptly joined the Manhattan Project, charming wit. I am very proud to have purifying plutonium for the atomic bomb. passed through his lab, and I frequently He received his Ph.D. from the Univer- reflect on his teachings as I develop my own sity of Chicago in 1949. After a two- scientific perspectives. year postdoctoral fellowship at Harvard — Gideon Bollag, vice president, Plexxikon, University, he accepted an appointment former Koshland graduate student at the Brookhaven National Laboratory, where he remained Dan loved to write limericks, and he would always write one for for 14 years. He then joined the faculty of the University of the students/postdocs on the occasion of their departure from the California, Berkeley, where he also served as chair of the lab. He and I communicated in limericks after I left the lab. On Molecular and Cell Biology Department from 1973 to 1978. the occasion of the ASBMB symposium in his honor, I presented him Koshland became editor-in-chief at Science magazine in with the following limerick: 1984. He held the post for 10 years, during which time he There once was a man named Koshland, D. E. was best known for his incisive and witty editorials. This was Who thought about things like enzymes with glee most evident in the character he created, “Dr. Noitall,” who From fits induced was intended to represent the many scientists who took nar- To mechanisms deduced He enraptured us all with his chemistry row, overly simplistic views of important issues. — Alexandra Newton, University of California at San During his lifetime Koshland made major contributions to Diego, former Koshland postdoc the fields of enzyme action, short- and long-term memory, and science education. In the 1950s, he proposed that the With the death of Dan Koshland, biochemistry has lost a giant. then popular lock-and-key theory of enzyme action was inad- He was a brilliant scientist whose research was characterized by equate to explain all forms of enzyme action. To augment that its originality and boldness. As a teacher, he was outstanding— theory, he proposed an induced-fit theory of enzyme action. combining insight, rigor, and wit. He was a superb citizen devoting In the 1970s, his interest turned to the mechanism by which his energy and wisdom to problems in education and public policies cells “remember” situations and events. He demonstrated affecting science. His contributions are inestimable. — Howard K. Schachman, University of California at that bacteria have short-term memory and that purified mam- Berkeley, friend malian cell lines show rudimentary memory.1 An heir to the Levi Strauss fortune, Koshland endowed While working in the Koshland lab, I learned from a great scientist the National Academy of Sciences with a $25 million gift to how to dare. He pushed us to think outside the box, to follow up on establish the Marian Koshland Science Museum, named for wild guesses and hunches and not worry about sticking our neck his late wife, an immunologist who did ground breaking work out with a speculation—as long as we label it as a speculation. This on a cholera vaccine and the behavior of antibodies. advice has guided me well throughout my career. We extend our sympathy and thoughts to Koshland’s — Daria Mochly-Rosen, Stanford University, former Koshland postdoc
10 ASBMB Today September 2007 Dan loved to play with names and puns, both to promote the Dan always said that his ambition was to die young as old as research and to promote his postdocs. This story is one he used to possible. He succeeded: very few people, of any age, have had a tell on the lecture circuit in the early 1970s. A series of experiments younger heart or a more open mind. He went the way we should were published on enzyme mechanisms that he would refer to as the all go: suddenly, while still sharp and having fun. He managed to “Neet-Koshland” experiments that were done in conjunction with combine a gift for theorizing with a talent for clever but rigorous Ken Neet. Shortly later he published studies on receptors (with Pete experiments—a feat that few have done so well. And throughout Lovely) that he referred to as the “Lovely-Koshland” experiments. He it all he gave the impression that he was just a kid playing with his would laugh and say that he had to quit this approach when one day favorite toy. a new postdoc walked into his lab—Phil Strange. — Greg Petsko, Brandeis University and Harvard — Kenneth Neet, Rosalind Franklin University of Medical School, friend Medicine and Science, former Koshland postdoc Dan used to say when we caught him with a Snickers bar that he Dan and I were both past presidents of the American Society for ate as many preservatives as he could so that he could live as long Biochemistry and Molecular Biology. At the most recent meeting in as possible. My favorite Dan joke was about isocitrate dehydroge- Washington, D.C. we had a chance to visit for about half an hour nase crystals—that they were so beautiful that he wanted to make before our past president’s meeting started. I recall thinking to a ring for his wife. She refused when she found out she had to sit in myself as we talked, what a wit he still has and what a sharp mind. AmSO4 every time she wore it. He was an icon when I was a student in the 1960s, so just to see — Susan Tsutakawa, Lawrence Berkeley National him functioning at such a high level at the ASBMB meeting was a Laboratory, former Koshland graduate student real inspiration for an aging biochemist like myself. Dan was a true giant in the field of biochemistry. He will be missed. FOOTNOTES: — Jack E. Dixon, University of California More information on Koshland’s research can be found in his Journal of Biological at San Diego, friend Chemistry Classics article (2007, 37, e29). specialinterest ASBMB Delegation T
12 Tours China
13 specialinterest Early Medical Research Funding and the Evolution of Modern American Biochemistry BY SEYMOUR S. COHEN
he United States did not develop an official national regularly to Warm Springs, Georgia, to attempt to regain T policy of financial support for medical research some muscular strength. In 1934, his legal partner, Basil for almost a decade after World War II. Here I will O’Connor, who led the Warm Springs Foundation since describe how some financial support was developed in 1928, had begun fundraising to generate research funds to that period, i.e. 1946–1956, for what subsequently became find a cure for the disease, and in 1938 President Roosevelt the basis of the now large structure of American medi- and O’Connor announced the formation of the National cal research. To do so it seems desirable to describe some Foundation for Infantile Paralysis. In that year O’Connor personal experiences in developing a career in biochemistry appointed Tom Rivers, a leading virologist at the Rockefeller before, during, and after American entrance into that War. Hospital, to lead a Scientific Research Committee. One of In 1937, I began graduate study in the Department of the first decisions of the research committee was to expand Biochemistry at Columbia University’s College of Physi- knowledge in the field of virology by developing variously cians and Surgeons and worked as a bottle washer for $40 a trained younger scientists, and this decision resulted in the month. My fellowship in the last year of my graduate work announcement in Science to which I had responded. was $800. Salaries for academic positions for new Ph.D.s In 1934 and 1935 Stanley published on the crystallization were about $1,800 per year. of tobacco mosaic virus, and very soon thereafter Bawden The Columbia Department of Biochemistry at that time, and Pirie discovered RNA in the virus. Having read these chaired by Professor Hans T. Clarke, has been described as papers and the book of Bawden on plant viruses, I began one of the best in the country. Many of the faculty had been my work at the Princeton laboratories in the spring of 1941. relatively recent European refugees, some of whom had Early in 1942, shortly after the U. S. entered the war, Stanley obtained positions or consultative connections in clinical and I were able to report on the isolation and existence of a departments. Both postdoctoral fellows and graduate stu- viral RNA much larger than a tetranucleotide. dents were supported on absolutely minimal fellowships. Soon after 1941, Rivers and many members of the After receiving my Ph.D. early in 1941, I sought a Scientific Research Committee of the Polio Foundation postdoctoral position. Offers of a Naval position at Point went off to the armed forces until about 1947. Stanley’s Barrow, Alaska, and one at Peiping Union Medical College laboratory turned to the study of influenza vaccine, and I in China were not appealing. Curiously, pharmaceutical became involved in attempts of the Army and an academic companies were not interested in my information on blood Committee of Medical Research to improve the typhus clotting. However an issue of Science in 1940 had pointed vaccine, whose rickettsial antigens comprised less than to new fellowships in virology for the National Foundation 1% of the total protein in the vaccine. This work led me to for Infantile Paralysis, and I applied for one of these to work the Childrens Hospital of Philadelphia and the University with Wendell Stanley at the Rockefeller Institute in Princ- of Pennsylvania. By the end of the 1940s the rickettsia of eton. I was interviewed by Homer Smith for the adminis- typhus proved to be of bacterial structure and composi- tering National Research Council and by Stanley, who was tion, but the discovery and use of antibiotics had revealed $pleased by the notion of exploring the nature of the nucleic an inability of both penicillin and the known sulfa drugs to acid in tobacco mosaic virus. The awarded fellowship paid control infections by this fastidious microbe or indeed true $2,100 per year, and I was excited at my good fortune. viruses. In 1945 and 1946 the need for chemotherapeutic In 1924 Franklin D. Roosevelt had been hit by disabling agents to control virus infections led me to begin to work poliomyelitis and after a very difficult illness had traveled on the biochemistry of bacteriophage multiplication. 14 ASBMB Today $September 2007 It is important to realize that the National Institutes of well as new useful analytical reagents. Also the application Health (NIH) did not develop a system of funding medical of isotopic techniques had created new techniques of chem- research before 1955. In the period of 1946 to 1949 my work ical discovery in the many microbial systems. The decade on phage was supported by remnants of funds through the was also marked by the extraordinary enzymology in the Office of Naval Research to the Childrens Hospital. After American laboratories of a few European refugees, such my early studies on the biochemistry of phage multiplica- as the Coris, Lipmann, Szent-Gyorgi, and Ochoa, which tion appeared in 1946 to 1948, financial support was devel- revealed that phosphorylated intermediates were important oped through the good offices of the Commonwealth Fund, in the metabolism of cells generally. and this was maintained until 1963, when this fund decided The relevance of these biochemical advances to the not to compete with NIH research funds. growth of knowledge in phage and other virus systems was In 1946 and 1947, the donation of funds through the accepted enthusiastically by the members of the research March of Dimes had been sufficiently successful to encour- committee of the National Foundation for Infantile Paraly- age the Polio Foundation to renew the activities of its sis who wanted to develop these new findings in animal cell research committee, and under the systems. These scientists also contrib- O’Connor and Rivers leadership this uted in major ways to the develop- body reviewed the status of virology. A The National ment of the structural biochemistry key meeting of virologists in Madison, Institutes of Health of the nucleic acids and proteins. The Wisconsin, in 1948 was held under the foundation was particularly active in auspices of the research committee. In (NIH) did not develop encouraging and financing the study these few post-war years it had become a system of funding of the growth, cytology, and composi- clear that the phage systems permit- tion of animal cells that might serve as ted studies of the interaction of viruses medical research hosts for the polio virus and produce and separate host cells, and these had before 1955 enough virus to serve as a vaccine for included my own findings on the exag- poliomyelitis by 1956–57. This devel- gerated synthesis of virus nucleic acids opment had been highlighted in 1953 and proteins in infected bacteria as well as the dependence of by the Cold Spring Harbor Symposium on Viruses, which such synthesis on host cell metabolism. After that meeting, was supported by the National Foundation for Infantile the research committee pointed to the importance of similar Paralysis. A major section on the phages included the first experiments on virus-infected animal cells. The commit- American report of Watson and Crick on DNA structure, tee then attempted to encourage the development of animal while the reports of Wyatt and Cohen described a new DNA tissue culture systems and of establishing virus-infection on pyrimidine whose synthesis required phage infection. The plated tissue cultures as well as the isolation and character- symposium concluded with a section on the multiplication ization of several strains of polio virus from infected tissue of animal viruses in tissue culture, including the detection cultures, etc. In addition to these steps, which became the of phage-like polio virus-induced plaques in monolayers of basis of providing the killed virus in the Salk vaccine used in animal cells by Dulbecco and Vogt. 1957, the research committee encouraged financially much of In a very few years, i.e. the post-war decade from 1947 the work on the cytology, genetics, and composition of ani- through 1956, the work on animal cells, stimulated by the mal cells generally as well as on the structure, isolation, and National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis, had produced enzymatic synthesis of the nucleic acids. It will be clear that new data and directions in the study of their growth, the work and financial support via the Scientific Research behavior, and composition. These studies now pointed to Committee of the Polio Foundation in the decade from 1948 approaches to the curbing of pathological cells, as in the to 1956 functioned as essential anticipants of the NIH. growth of human cancers, and provided major incentives The Cold Spring Harbor International Symposium in to research which might be undertaken by the American 1946 had stimulated the study of the growth, heredity, and Cancer Society and the National Cancer Institute and other metabolism of microbial cells. Those studies then occurred institutes of the NIH. in a decade-long period in which American laboratories had been newly stocked with centrifuges, spectrophotom- REFERENCE 1 Chargaff, E., and Cohen, S. S. (1939) On Lysophosphatides. J. Biol. Chem. 129, eters, and the crude apparatus of paper chromatography as 619–628 $ September$ 2007 ASBMB Today 15 2008 annual meeting Systems Biology: A Shared Goal with Diverse Views BY FREDERICK P. ROTH AND BRENDA ANDREWS
n a well known Indian tale, blind men offer diverse descrip- the most likely hypotheses (e.g. unpublished work by Fred- Itions of the same elephant (“…seizing on the swinging tail erick Roth (Harvard Medical School) and colleagues). that fell within his scope, ‘I see,’ quoth he, “the Elephant is very like a rope!” (1)). Systems biology is the contemporary Global Systems Biology: Relationships elephant in the room, and it is easy to wonder whether the Before we can hope to simulate a global system, we must diverse scientific views operating under this name are of first have a general understanding of how the parts are the same beast. However, systems biologists do share a related to one another. Current challenges include protein common ultimate goal: to produce a dynamic model that networks, genetic networks, gene regulatory networks, and can predict the actions and internal workings of an entire chromatin networks. This area remains even less explored organism. than the parts list. For example, Marc Vidal (Dana-Farber Currently unachievable in any organism, a predictive Cancer Institute/Harvard Medical School) and colleagues dynamic model of an entire organism will require concerted have roughly estimated that only ~1% of all interactions effort on several fronts. Minimally, we must: 1) learn the between human proteins are known (4). We have only “parts list” for organisms of interest; 2) obtain a basic under- begun to learn about genetic interactions (cases in which standing of the relationships between all parts; 3) observe perturbations of two genes together yield a surprising system dynamics across time, space, and individuals; and result that often indicates a functional relationship). For 4) prepare for the global modeling challenge by first model- example, Brenda Andrews (University of Toronto), Charlie ing small subsystems. Boone (University of Toronto), and colleagues are using an automated genetics platform to create a complete map of Global Systems Biology: Parts double-mutant genetic interactions that lead to a significant Ultimate success in systems biology depends on the unfin- fitness defect in budding yeast. These groups have also ished task of defining the parts—genes, gene products, and begun to explore the effects of other genetic perturbations, their basic functional role. Current challenges include gene/ particularly gene overexpression, with the aim of reveal- protein definition, post-translational modifications, pheno- ing unappreciated functional connections in S. cerevisiae typing, epigenomics (e.g. heritable chromatin structure), (5). Furthermore, much of the dynamic control of biological and function annotation. It is clear that the parts list is far systems is affected through transcriptional regulation. Unfor- from complete. For example, recent work by Takashi Ito tunately, we do not yet have a complete map connecting (University of Tokyo) and colleagues has expanded the list transcription factors to their DNA binding elements in any of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (the most extensively studied species. Tim Hughes (University of Toronto), Martha Bulyk eukaryote) by dozens of introns, hundreds of new transcrip- (Harvard Medical School), and colleagues are systematically tion units in regions previously thought to be intergenic, identifying DNA-binding specificity of transcription factors in and hundreds of intragenic alternative transcriptional start mouse (unpublished work). In the meantime, it is clear that sites (2). The connection of genes to basic cellular roles, a comprehensive predictive model of any organism awaits e.g. determination of cell shape, also remains incomplete. a complete understanding of the relationships between In a single whole genome phenotyping screen in Droso- components. phila melanogaster, Amy Kiger (University of California, San Diego) and colleagues expanded the list of genes affecting Global Systems Biology: Dynamics cell shape by one-third (3). It is clear that our most basic We must also learn how the parts of an organism and their understanding of genes and gene functions remains vastly relationships change over time and space within an organ- incomplete. A current challenge is the integration of dispa- ism and between organisms and environmental stimuli. rate sources of data to roughly assign genes to functional Current areas of interest include gene expression, signaling, roles, which can focus limited experimental resources on development, genetic variation, and pathogenic systems.
16 ASBMB Today September 2007 For example, Jason Lieb (University of North Carolina, Cha- riz, G. F., Gibbons, F. D., Dreze, M., Ayivi-Guedehoussou, N., Klitgord, N., Simon, C., Boxem, M., Milstein, S., Rosenberg, J., Goldberg, D. S., Zhang, L. V., Wong, pel Hill) and colleagues are investigating how the occupancy S L., Franklin, G., Li, S., Albala, J. S., Lim, J., Fraughton, C., Llamosas, E., Cevik, S., Bex, C., Lamesch, P., Sikorski, R. S., Vandenhaute, J., Zoghbi, H. Y., Smolyar, and activity of human regulatory elements change in living A., Bosak, S., Sequerra, R., Doucette-Stamm, L., Cusick, M. E., Hill, D. E., Roth, F. P. & Vidal, M. (2005) Towards a proteome-scale map of the human protein- cells (6). One class of circuit that affects dynamics and protein interaction network. Nature 437, 1173-1178 homeostasis in living organisms is feedback, and our knowl- 5 Sopko, R., Huang, D., Preston, N., Chua, G., Papp, B., Kafadar, K., Snyder, M., Oliver, S. G., Cyert, M., Hughes, T. R., Boone, C. & Andrews, B. (2006) Mapping edge of the existence of such circuits is incomplete. Rachel pathways and phenotypes by systematic gene overexpression. Mol. Cell. 21, Brem (University of California, Berkeley) and colleagues are 319-330 6 Giresi, P. G., Kim, J., McDaniell, R. M., Iyer, V. R. & Lieb, J. D. (2007) FAIRE searching systematically for evidence of regulatory feedback (Formaldehyde-Assisted Isolation of Regulatory Elements) isolates active regula- tory elements from human chromatin. Genome Res. 17, 877-885 (unpublished work). A major challenge for systems biol- 7 Bao, Z., Murray, J. I., Boyle, T., Ooi, S. L., Sandel, M. J. & Waterston, R. H. (2006) Automated cell lineage tracing in Caenorhabditis elegans. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. ogy will be grappling with complexity and dynamics within U. S. A. 103, 2707-1272 multicellular organisms. As an example of current work in 8 Workman, C. T., Mak, H. C., McCuine, S., Tagne, J. B., Agarwal, M., Ozier, O., Begley, T. J., Samson, L. D. & Ideker, T. (2006) A systems approach to mapping this area, Robert Waterston (University of Washington) and DNA damage response pathways. Science 312, 1054-1059 colleagues have developed technology for tracking the 9 O’Dea, E. L., Barken, D., Peralta, R. Q., Tran, K. T., Werner, S. L., Kearns, J. D., Levchenko, A. & Hoffmann, A. (2007) A homeostatic model of IkappaB metabo- location and lineage of all cells in real time through the early lism to control constitutive NF-kappaB activity. Mol. Syst. Biol. 3, 111 10 Kaufmann, B. B. & van Oudenaarden, A. (2007) Stochastic gene expression: development of the worm Caenorhabditis elegans (7), which from single molecules to the proteome. Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev. 17, 107-112 they are now scaling up.
Local Systems Biology: Systems Biology Thematic Meeting Subsystems and Simulation ORGANIZERS: On the path towards modeling and simulating entire organ- Brenda Andrews, University of Toronto isms, we can begin by modeling and simulating smaller Fritz Roth, Harvard Medical School modules and subsystems. For example, Trey Ideker Symposium: (University of California, San Diego) and colleagues have Global Systems Biology: Parts been assembling knowledge about individual physical and Unexpected complexity of the budding yeast genetic interactions to model cellular responses to DNA transcriptome, Takashi Ito damage (see Ref. 8 for an example). In an example of Functional genomic analysis of morphogenesis, Amy Kiger Systematic function annotation in microbes and mammals, dynamic subsystem modeling, Alexander Hoffmann (Univerr- Fritz Roth sity of California, San Diego) and colleagues are developing temporal models of inflammatory signaling pathways (see Symposium: Global Systems Biology: Relationships Ref. 9 for an example). A major challenge in the modeling Interactome networks and human disease, Marc Vidal of subsystems is that many of our experimental measure- Genetic interaction networks in yeast, Brenda Andrews ments of cellular systems are derived from the study of Cracking the second genetic code, Tim Hughes ensembles of cells rather than individual cells. Alexander Symposium: van Oudenaarden (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) Global Systems Biology: Dynamics and colleagues have been exploring stochastic phenomena, Genome-wide identification of active human regulatory (e.g. Ref. 10), for which measurements on the single cell elements by formaldehyde-assisted isolation of level will be critical. regulatory elements, Jason Lieb In summary, systems biologists have a shared vision for Expression variation and regulatory feedback, Rachel Brem where the field must ultimately go, but the scale of the chal- Title TBD, Robert Waterston lenge is immense and demands a diversity of vision as we Symposium: proceed. Local Systems Biology: Subsystems and Simulation REFERENCES An integrated physical and genetic interaction map of 1 Saxe, J. G. (1873) The POEMS of John Godfrey Saxe, James R. Osgood and Company, Boston, Massachusetts genotoxicity, Trey Ideker 2 Miura, F., Kawaguchi, N., Sese, J., Toyoda, A., Hattori, M., Morishita, S. & Ito, A temporal code to generate specificity in inflammatory T. (2006) A large-scale full-length cDNA analysis to explore the budding yeast signaling, Alexander Hoffmann transcriptome. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 103, 17846-17851 3 Kiger, A., Baum, B., Jones, S., Jones, M., Coulson, A., Echeverri, C. & Perrimon, Dynamics of signal transduction and gene expression N. (2003) A functional genomic analysis of cell morphology using RNA interferr- in single cells: feedback, inheritance and survival, ence. J. Biol. 2, 27 Alexander van Oudenaarden 4 Rual, J. F., Venkatesan, K., Hao, T., Hirozane-Kishikawa, T., Dricot, A., Li, N., Berr-
September 2007 ASBMB Today 17 2008 annual meeting The Diverse Aspects of Protein Synthesis and Degradation BY MARK HOCHSTRASSER AND RACHEL GREEN
iological systems devote considerable effort to the recent biochemical studies focusing Bsynthesis and subsequent folding of the enormous on the termination step of protein Mark Hochstrasser cellular repertoire of proteins. And, like all cellular pro- synthesis. Each talk will broadly focus cesses, protein synthesis and folding are subject to on the theme of protein synthesis many different levels of regulation to allow for the timely being a series of allosteric switches, production of needed functional proteins. An under- dictating the specificity of each standing of the basic molecular mechanisms of protein molecular event. synthesis and folding will be key for deciphering how The Protein-Assisted Folding these systems can be regulated. Just as overall pro- and Misfolding session will focus
tein synthesis is an enormously complicated and highly on discussion of diverse aspects of Rachel Green regulated process, so too is the controlled destruction of protein folding and misfolding. Judith cellular proteins. Many important regulatory proteins are Frydman (Stanford University) will talk about recent stud- subject to rapid degradation as this allows tight control ies on the organization of the chaperone machinery in of their concentrations in the cell. the eukaryotic cytosol and how it In addition, any protein made in the Just as overall protein promotes folding of newly trans- cell can suffer biosynthetic errors or lated polypeptides and clearance post-translational mishaps such as synthesis is an enormously of misfolded proteins. Jeff Kelly incorrect folding or improper assem- complicated and highly (The Scripps Research Institute) will bly. Accumulation of such defective regulated process, so too is discuss how the mechanisms of proteins can be toxic and is linked to the controlled destruction protein folding and misfolding are a variety of degenerative disorders related to normal physiology and such as Alzheimer and prion dis- of cellular proteins. disease. Art Horwich (Yale Univer- eases. Much of this regulatory and sity) will describe the mechanism of quality control proteolysis falls under the province of the a complex ring-shaped folding machine, the chaperonin ubiquitin-proteasome system. Four sessions focusing on GroEL, which together with its detachable lid cofactor diverse aspects of protein synthesis and degradation will GroES uses ATP to bind and fold proteins within its cen- comprise the Protein Synthesis, Folding, and Degradation tral cavity. Theme. In the Protein Turnover and Quality Control ses- In the Mechanisms of Protein Synthesis session, sion, Brenda Schulman (St. Jude’s Children’s Research the speakers will focus on the molecular mechanisms Hospital) will first describe the class of enzymes that of protein synthesis, principally in bacteria. Jamie Cate provide the gateway into the ubiquitin system and closely (University of California, Berkeley) will speak about recent related protein-conjugation systems. These so-called E1 structural advances detailing the interactions of the or E1-like enzymes use ATP to activate the C terminus of 70 S ribosome with ribosome recycling factor. These ubiquitin or ubiquitin-like proteins (Ubls) for amide bond studies will illuminate key interactions that facilitate the formation with target proteins. In the second talk, Randy poorly understood recycling step of protein synthesis Hampton (University of California, San Diego) will detail that follows completion of the polypeptide chain. Scott the fascinating mechanistic link between sterol-regulated Blanchard (Cornell University) will next discuss current degradation of HMG-CoA reductase and protein quality advances in defining the thermodynamic and kinetic control at the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). HMG-CoA is parameters of allosteric movements of the ribosome dur- a polytopic ER membrane protein and is the rate-limiting ing elongation using single molecule approaches. Finally, enzyme in the synthesis of cholesterol and related sterols. Rachel Green (Johns Hopkins University) will describe A specific ubiquitin-protein ligase (E3) functions both in
18 ASBMB Today September 2007 HMG-CoA degradation and quality control of a subset of aberrant ER proteins. Mark Hochstrasser (Yale University) Protein Synthesis and will describe another set of ubiquitin- and Ubl-dependent urnover Thematic Meeting reactions that occur at the ER membrane and inner ORGANIZERS: nuclear membrane. These include ubiquitin ligation to Mark Hochstrasser, Yale University specific abnormal ER membrane proteins and to certain Rachel Green, Johns Hopkins nuclear regulatory proteins. The Ubl known as SUMO is University School of Medicine also subject to attachment and removal at the nuclear Symposium: membrane, and a new link between SUMO dynamics Protein Turnover and Quality Control and RNA quality control will be described. Structural insights into ubiquitin-like protein transfer For the Protein Turnover in Cell Regulation session, cascades, Brenda Schulman Sterol regulation and protein quality control at the ER, a series of diverse regulatory mechanisms subject to Randy Hampton control by protein turnover will be outlined. The first SUMO and ubiquitin at the nuclear envelope and ER, speaker, Michael Rape (University of California, Berkeley), Mark Hochstrasser will describe the intricate control of cell cycle progres- Symposium: sion through mitosis by what is probably the most Protein Turnover in Cell Regulation complex E3 ubiquitin ligase, the anaphase-promoting Ubiquitin ligase machinery: from plant biology to human diseases, Ning Zheng complex (APC). How different substrates are targeted by The multiple roles of ubiquitin in orchestrating mitosis, the APC at defined stages of cell cycle progression will Michael Rape be a central topic. In the next talk, Ning Zheng (Univer- Structure and function of rhomboid intramembrane sity of Washington, Seattle) will lay out the remarkable proteases, Sinisa Urban story of how the simple plant hormone auxin regulates Symposium: plant growth by binding to a specific subunit of another Mechanisms of Protein Synthesis ubiquitin ligase. Crystallographic data from Zheng reveal Ribosome function is modulated by built in switches, Rachel Green an elegant mechanism by which auxin binding stimulates Single-molecule observations of allostery in translation, subsequent substrate binding. In the last talk, Sinisa Scott Blanchard Urban (Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine) will Structures of E. coli ribosome with ribosome recycling discuss the unusual ability of certain proteases to cleave factor, Jamie Cate transmembrane proteins within the plane of the mem- Symposium: Protein-Assisted Folding and Misfolding brane. How hydrolysis reactions can occur in the hydro- Chaperone-mediated protein folding in the eukaryotic phobic interior of lipid bilayers has been a long standing cytosol, Judith Frydman puzzle, but biochemical and structural data from Urban Amyloid diseases, Jeffery W. Kelly and others on the rhomboid proteases have now shed Chaperonin structure and function, Art Horwich considerable light on this problem.
TRAVEL AWARDS Join us for the ASBMB Annual Meeting !PRIL s 3AN $IEGO #! s 'RADUATE0OSTDOCTORAL s 'RADUATE -INORITY s 5NDERGRADUATE &ACULTY