RBWF Burns Chronicle 2014
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Robert Burns World Federation Limited www.rbwf.org.uk The digital conversion of this Burns Chronicle was sponsored by Jane Brown, Past President of the Robert Burns World Federation The digital conversion was provided by Solway Offset Services Ltd by permission of the Robert Burns World Federation Limited to whom all Copyright title belongs. www.solwayprint.co.uk The mission of the Chronicle remains the Burns Chronicle furtherance of knowledge about Robert Burns and 2014 its publication in a form that is both academically responsible and clearly communicated for the broader Burnsian community. Bill Dawson EDITOR Making Teacakes for your Thomas Tunnock Ltd., 34 Old Mill Road, Uddingston G71 7HH Tel: 01698 813551 Fax: 01698 815691 Email: [email protected] enjoyment www.tunnock.co.uk ISBN 978-1-907931-31-4 22208_OTM 297x210 1205.indd 1 12/05/2011 14:18 Price www.rbwf.org.uk BURNS CHRONICLE BURNS CHRONICLE 2014 £30.00 ISBN 978-1-907931-31-4 9 781907 931314 The annual Burns Chronicle founded 1892 The Robert Burns World Federation www.rbwf.org.uk ©Burns Chronicle 2014, all rights reserved. Copyright rests with the Robert Burns World Federation unless otherwise stated. The Robert Burns World Federation Ltd does not accept responsibility for statements made or opinions expressed in the Burns Chronicle, contributors are responsible for articles signed by them; the Editor is responsible for articles initialled or signed by him and for those unsigned. All communications should be addressed to the Federation office. The Robert Burns World Federation Ltd. Dower House Dean Castle Country Park Kilmarnock KA3 1XB 0153 572259 Email [email protected] Web www.rbwf.org.uk Editorial Contacts & addresses for contributions; [email protected] [email protected] Books for review to the office address above ISBN 978-1-907931-31-4 Printed in Scotland by Solway Offset the Printers, Dumfries 2014 Burns Chronicle Editor Bill Dawson The Robert Burns World Federation Kilmarnock www.rbwf.org.uk The mission of the Chronicle remains the furtherance of knowledge about Robert Burns and its publication in a form that is both academically responsible and clearly communicated for the broader Burnsian community. In reviewing, and helping prospective contributors develop, suitable articles to fulfil this mission, the Editor now has the support of an Editorial Advisory Board. Articles submitted for consideration will normally be read both by the Editor for general suitability and by a relevant Advisory Board member or other specialist, who can provide any needed feedback about the submission. Academic contributors whose institutions require that publications be formally refereed should notify the Editor at the time of submission so he can ensure the regular review procedure is appropriately implemented. To allow time for appropriate feedback, contributors are asked to submit articles before June 30 each year for the forthcoming volume. The Editor is always pleased to discuss proposals for articles with potential contributors. The preferred length for full articles is between 1500 and 5000 words, and the Editor also welcomes shorter notes, especially when based on primary source materials. References should be kept simple, and as far as possible included in the text. Contributors are asked to contact the Editor ahead of submission if their proposed article differs significantly from these guidelines. Editorial Advisory Board Dr. Corey Andrews Prof. Liam McIlvanney Prof. Murray Pittock Bill Dawson, Editor Burns Chronicle 2014 1 CONTENTS Editorial ............................................................................................................................... 4 G. Ross Roy: His Contribution to Scottish Literature .......................................... 6 Professor Gerard Carruthers, University of Glasgow My Friendship with Ross Roy ...................................................................................... 8 Bill Dawson A Canadian Burns Collector: W. Ormiston Roy ....................................................11 as Remembered by his Grandson Professor G. Ross Roy Robert Burns, James Johnson, and the Manuscript..........................................18 of “The German Lairdie” Professor Patrick Scott Robert Burns’ Second Commonplace Book .........................................................23 Bill Dawson The Second Commonplace Book ............................................................................28 The Glenriddell Manuscripts;- John Gribbel’s Gift to Scotland .....................55 Bill Dawson “Born at a Ploughtail” Ploughing and Robert Burns .........................................59 Professor Craig Sharp BURNS- The Allusive, The Abstruse & The Assiduous .......................................70 Ronnie Crichton Wraiths, Rhetoric, and “The Sin of Rhyme”: The Shaping of Poet Burns .........79 Dr Kenneth Simpson A Dream Interpreted ....................................................................................................87 Cameron Goodall Epistle to J Lapraik, An Old Scotch Bard ................................................................92 Jim Thomson The Poet and The President .................................................................................... 106 James Davidson 2 Burns Chronicle 2014 Manuscript Acquired by The Mitchell Library .................................................. 108 A Short History of The Burns Chronicle and Editors ...................................... 110 Bill Dawson Robert Burns and Scottish Independence ........................................................ 114 Norman Paton Book Reviews ............................................................................................................... 122 The Man’s the Gowd, for a’ that The 4th Edition of The Burns Encyclopaedia Preview;- The Oxford Edition of Robert Burns, Robert Burns: Commonplace Books, Tour Journals, And Miscellaneous Prose. Our President and Directors ................................................................................... 126 2013 Conference ......................................................................................................... 130 Our Membership ........................................................................................................ 134 The Robert Burns World Federation Newsletter is available to all Burns enthusiasts free by email, every two months throughout the year. Register your email address at [email protected] to get your copy direct to your inbox. Burns Chronicle 2014 Advertisement 3 Follow Burns to Irvine for The 2014 Robert Burns World Federation Conference The North Ayrshire town of Irvine will play host to a prestigious event celebrating the life of Robert Burns this year. The Robert Burns World Federation Conference in September 2014 will provide a great opportunity to highlight the key role Irvine played in the development of Burns the poet. Despite spending just a single year in Irvine, there is little dispute that the town and the people he met there made a major impact on the young Burns. His friendship with sea Captain Richard Brown was of particular importance to his growth as a writer and poet. The Captain’s tales of the open sea, exciting voyages and a world with broad horizons were an inspiration to the fledgling writer. All the while, Captain Brown would cajole and encourage Burns to focus on his writing and poetry. The rest, as they say, is history. North Ayrshire Council is working with Irvine Burns Club – the oldest continuous Burns Club in the world – to organise an exciting programme of events to coincide with the Conference. The programme will be supported by Eglinton Burns Club and Irvine Lasses Burns Club. The event was last held in Irvine in 1981 to mark the 200th anniversary of Burns’ arrival in the town and hundreds of Burns enthusiasts from around the world are expected to attend the three-day 2014 conference. Councillor Alan Hill, Cabinet Member for Community and Culture, said: “We are extremely excited to host such a prestigious event. Despite being considered the catalyst for Burns’ creative development, his connection to Irvine is often overlooked. “Many people are unaware of the huge impact his time in Irvine had on Burns – to the extent that many claim he would not have become such an iconic figure had he not set foot in the town.” North Ayrshire Council has already started to bring together a fantastic array of Burns-related events to coincide with the 2014 conference. These will range from exhibitions of Burns-themed artwork from local and international artists to musical events and live performances of some of his works. Bringing the bard into schools provides an excellent opportunity to build on the work already taking place and to broaden Burns appeal to the next generation by teaching youngsters about the poet, his life and his work. 4 Editorial Burns Chronicle 2014 From the Editor It is with considerable honour that I write an Editorial for the first annual Burns Chronicle in over 12 years. Since 1892, the Burns Chronicle has provided Federation members and other subscribers with some of the most important and authoritative research on Robert Burns, his friends and contemporaries, and his influence, together with well-edited transcriptions or reproductions of many original Burns documents. The return to annual volume format allows the inclusion of more, and more substantial, research-based articles than has been possible in a quarterly magazine. Our Board have taken the decision to permanently