Acoustics of Virtual Environments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THURSDAY MORNING, 27 MAY 2004 VERSAILLES TERRACE, 8:30 A.M. TO 12:00 NOON Session 4aAA Architectural Acoustics: Acoustics of Virtual Environments Elizabeth A. Cohen, Cochair Cohen Acoustical, Inc., California 90004 Mendel Kleiner, Cochair School of Architecture, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, 110 8th Street, Troy, New York 12180-3590 Chair’s Introduction—8:30 Invited Papers 8:35 4aAA1. Application-driven design of auralization systems. Durand R. Begault ͑NASA Ames Res. Ctr., MS 262-2, Moffett Field, CA 94035-1000, [email protected]͒ Acoustical environmental simulation ͑auralization͒ involves rendering a binaural signal that articulates simultaneously the posi- tional information of a sound source and the source’s acoustic and vibratory interaction with its environmental context. This places significant challenges on both the modeling and rendering components of such a system. Overcoming real-time limitations of processors can be accomplished by implementing rendering limits based on auditory threshold data for both early reflections and late reverberant energy. However, final assessment of system quality is dependent on the specific task or goal of the simulation. The use of auralization in accomplishing a telerobotic task requires head tracking and low latency, while environmental cues such as obstacles with acoustic reflections can be simplified and exaggerated beyond veridical representation. Contrasting this is the task of assessing speech intelligibility of an emergency public address system, or the quality of a space for musical performance, requiring a more accurate level of simulation of acoustical materials and sound-source characteristics. Modeling accuracy is complicated by such factors as the level of variance in the absorptive and diffusive properties of materials in terms of their real-world application. Assessment of auralization quality must therefore involve a best estimate of significant factors for a particular application. 8:55 4aAA2. The importance of perceived self-motion in experiencing convincing virtual acoustic rendering. William L. Martens ͑Faculty of Music, McGill Univ., Montreal, QC H3A 1E3, Canada, [email protected]͒ One factor that makes a virtual acoustic environment more convincing is the capacity to present information that enables a listener to answer questions about the geometry of the acoustical space in which they are immersed. This paper reviews the results of several studies in which virtual sound sources were presented to listeners via a loudspeaker array located in an anechoic chamber, and asked about details such as the location of a missing wall in a simulated rectangular room, and whether or not a reduction in the loudness of a virtual source was due to the interposition of a virtual wall between source and listener. When a listener was unaware of changes in the virtual listening position, such questions were difficult to answer; however, when listeners were informed of their path through the environment via computer graphic animation, performance improved significantly. The results of these perceptual experiments suggest that perceived self-motion may be an important determinant of how convincing virtual acoustic rendering may be. The identity of the sound source itself was also found to have a substantial impact, since listeners reported self-motion more often when presented with sound sources that were judged less likely to be in motion. Contributed Papers 9:15 pensate added absorption with the audience for a miniconcert. In the pre- sentation, these technologies will be presented, along with the acoustical 4aAA3. Active field control for piano room. Atsuko Ito and Yasushi data. Shimizu ͑Adv. System Development Ctr., Yamaha Corp., 10-1 Nakazawa-cho, Hamamatsu 430-8650, Japan, [email protected]͒ 9:30 ͑ ͒ Active field control AFC is an innovative system that employs elec- 4aAA4. Assessing the accuracy of auralizations computed using a troacoustic technologies enabling ‘‘natural changes’’ to major auditory im- hybrid geometrical-acoustics and wave-acoustics method. Jason E. pressions, such as reverberance, loudness, and spaciousness. This talk pre- Summers, Kengo Takahashi, Yasushi Shimizu, and Takashi Yamakawa sents typical design concept of AFC application for a piano room with a ͑Adv. Syst. Dev. Ctr., Yamaha Corp. of Japan, 10-1 Nakazawa-cho, low ceiling in architecture and with a miniconcert in program. The aim is Hamamatsu 430-8650, Japan, [email protected]͒ to accommodate a condition appropriate for both a solo piano performance and a miniconcert, regardless of the low ceiling height and significant When based on geometrical acoustics, computational models used for increase of absorption by the audience in a miniconcert. This can be real- auralization of auditorium sound fields are physically inaccurate at low ized by using an AFC system, which converts the room into different frequencies. To increase accuracy while keeping computation tractable, acoustical conditions as follows. One is that AFC alters acoustics of the hybrid methods using computational wave acoustics at low frequencies designed space, and makes it sound as if it has a higher ceiling, which have been proposed and implemented in small enclosures such as simpli- leads to a longer reverberation. The other is negative absorption to com- fied models of car cabins ͓Granier et al., J. Audio Eng. Soc. 44, 835–849 2514 J. Acoust. Soc. Am., Vol. 115, No. 5, Pt. 2, May 2004 147th Meeting: Acoustical Soceity of America 2514 Downloaded 19 Jul 2011 to 71.233.149.131. Redistribution subject to ASA license or copyright; see http://asadl.org/journals/doc/ASALIB-home/info/terms.jsp ͑1996͔͒. The present work extends such an approach to an actual 2400-m3 10:30 auditorium using the boundary-element method for frequencies below 100 4aAA7. Acoustical analysis and multiple source auralizations of Hz. The effect of including wave-acoustics at low frequencies is assessed charismatic worship spaces. Richard W. Lee ͑Rensselaer Polytech. by comparing the predictions of the hybrid model with those of the Inst., Prog. in Architectural Acoust., 110 8th St., Troy, NY 12180-3590͒ geometrical-acoustics model and comparing both with measurements. Conventional room-acoustical metrics are used together with new methods Because of the spontaneity and high level of call and response, many based on two-dimensional distance measures applied to time-frequency charismatic churches have verbal and musical communication problems representations of impulse responses. Despite in situ measurements of that stem from highly reverberant sound fields, poor speech intelligibility, boundary impedance, uncertainties in input parameters limit the accuracy and muddy music. This research looks at the subjective dimensions of of the computed results at low frequencies. However, aural perception room acoustics perception that affect a charismatic worship space, which ultimately defines the required accuracy of computational models. An al- is summarized using the acronym RISCS ͑reverberation, intimacy, gorithmic method for making such evaluations is proposed based on cor- strength, coloration, and spaciousness͒. The method of research is to ob- relating listening-test results with distance measures between time- tain acoustical measurements for three worship spaces in order to analyze frequency representations derived from auditory models of the ear-brain the objective parameters associated with the RISCS subjective dimen- system. Preliminary results are presented. sions. For the same spaces, binaural room impulse response ͑BRIR͒ mea- surements are done for different receiver positions in order to create an auralization for each position. The subjective descriptors of RISCS are 9:45 analyzed through the use of listening tests of the three auralized spaces. The results from the measurements and listening tests are analyzed to 4aAA5. A binaural Web-based tour of the acoustics of Troy Music determine if listeners’ perceptions correlate with the objective parameter Hall. Rendell R. Torres, James Cooney, and Yasushi Shimizu ͑Prog. in results, the appropriateness of the subjective parameters for the use of the Architectural Acoust., Rensselaer Polytech. Inst., Greene Bldg., 110 8th space, and which parameters seem to take precedent. A comparison of the St., Troy, NY 12180-3590, [email protected]͒ multi-source auralization to a conventional single-source auralization was done with the mixed down version of the synchronized multi-track For classical music to become more widely enjoyed, it must sound anechoic signals. exciting. We hypothesize that if people could hear examples of truly ex- citing acoustics, classical music would be perceived less as a rarefied delicacy and more as a viscerally engaging listening experience. The Troy Savings Bank Music Hall in Troy, New York, is a legendary 1200-seat 10:45 concert hall famous for its acoustics. Such landmarks are commonly docu- mented architecturally but with few attempts to document their acoustics 4aAA8. Sensitivity of room acoustic parameters to changes in in a way that it is listenable. Thus, the goal is to capture and sonically scattering coefficients. Jonathan Rathsam and Lily M. Wang disseminate the hall’s acoustics through a Web-based acoustical tour, ͑Architectural Eng. Prog., Univ. of Nebraska–Lincoln, Peter Kiewit Inst., where one can click on various seats to hear binaural auralizations of 1110 S. 67th St., Omaha, NE 68182-0681, [email protected]͒ different instruments and see corresponding views