Governor Dunn of Tennessee
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RIPON APRIL, 1971 VOL VII, No. 4 ONE DOLLAR Why Revenue Sharing? by Murray L. Weidenbaum • Abolish the Independent Regulatory Commissions • Paul N. McCloskey on Ending the War • An Ex- DIA Agent Writes to Henry Kissinger Governor Dunn of Tennessee by Sam Williams SUMMARY' OF CQ,NTENTS THE RIPON SOCIETY INC. Is a Republican research and , po'ley organization whose mem- EDITORIAL POINTS bers are young business, acadamlc and professional men and women. It has national headquarters In Cambrldsa, Massachusetts, chapters In el8'l8ll On Thomas E. Dewey; looking at the SST votes; cities, National Associate members throughout the fifty states, and several and parting words from Ripon's president. -8 affiliated groups of subchapter status. The Society Is supported by chapter dues, individual contributions and revenues from Its publications and con tract work. The SOCiety offars the following options for annual contribu POLITICAL NOTES tion; Contributor $25 Or more; Sustalner $100 or more; founder $1000 or more. Inquiries about membership and chapter organization should be WASHINGTON VIEWPOINT addressed to the National Executive Director. Notes on, a frontrunner, or why Edmund-Muskie NATIONAL GO.VERNING BOARD should go all the way, even if he is a "Democratic Nixon." 0ffIC8/11 Also, Republican National Chairman Dole makes head 'Josiah Lee Auspltz, President lines by namecalling. Partisan political:- diatribe aside, 'Howard 1'. Gillette, Jr., Chairmen of the Board Ripon thinks we can do with less of that. -12 'Bruce K. Chapman, Chairman of the Executive Committee 'Michael F. Brewer, Vice-President OPEN LETTER TO HENRY KISSINGER 'Robert L. Beal, Treasurer 'Richard E. Beaman, Secretal'J An ~-Army intelligence agent who operated out of Boston Phlbdalphla Saigon tells why everything he did was not only worth 'Martha Reardon • Richard R. Block less, but counterproductive. It appears from the Cam Martin A. Linsky Robert J. Moss bodia invasion and the POW raid that Dr. Kissinger et Michael W. Christian Herbert Hutton al. are relying on intelligence reports to develop policy. Cambridge SeatHe The former DIA man details the whole inoredible process, 'Robert Davidson • Martin H. Sours David A. Reif Dick Dykaman how reports from Vietn,amese agents are channeled up Joel Greene Tom Alberg through the military hierarchy 'til the whole distorted Chicago Washington batch lands onsoine policymaker's desk in Washington. 'R. Quincy White, Jr. 'Dan. Swllllnger . -13 'Harold S. RuSsell Stephen Herbits George H. Walker III Albert Ely Dalles At Larsa WHY REVENUE SHARING? 'Neil D. Anderson ··Christopher T. Bayley Howard L. Abramson Thomas A. Brown Assistant . Secretary of the Treasury Murray L. Robert A. Wilson Richard M. Conley Weidenbaum. offers a very· succinct defense of the Admin Hartford Christopher DeMuth istration's revenue shariilg plan. This article should con 'Nicholas Norton Bruce D. fraser vince the doubtful and inform those who are confused Robert G. Smith Emil H. Frankel William J. McKinney, Jr. Ralph J. Heikklnan about how revenue sharing will actu811Y function. -15 Paul Leach Los Angeles •• Lee W. Huebner A NEW REGULATORY FRAMEWORK N8111 H81I8lI Philip C. Johnston 'Hayward L. Draper WlI!lam J Kilberg Peter J. Wallison, who was with the Ash' Commis Deke Karzun ..J. Eugene Marans sion, writes about the independent regulatory commis Thomas E. Patri Paul C. Capra •• John R. Price, Jr. sions and why they should be abolished. He reviews the New '(ark Howard L. Reiter Ash Commission's recommendations and adds some·· of 'Richerd Zimmer Clair W. kodgers. Jr. his own. If you don't know much about the FMC, the Werner Kuhn , 'John S. Saloma III SEC or the FTC, join the crowd; one reason the com Marianne Magocsl Frank E. Samuel, Jr. missions need reform is that they have no constituency and so tend to be sympathetic to the industries they reg Ex-OffIcio At Large 'Robert D. Behn, National Executive Director ulate instead of the public interest. -16 Evelyn F. Ellis, Editor of the RIpon FORUM Terry A. Barnett, Political Director ... ".. .. ." ..... ".. '. Christopher W. Beal. Policy Chairman GOVERNOR WINFIELD DUNN OF TENNESSEE "Peter I. Wallison, Finance Chalrm.n 'National Executive Committee Mamber A profile of Tennessee's new Republican governor "Past President, Chairman of the Board, or Chairman of tb. EucatIIe by fellow-Tennessean Sam Williams. Mr. Williams focuses Committee on Dunn's effect on the state budget, the legislature and strengthening the state Republican organization. -21 THE RIPON FORUM Is published monthly by the Ripon So- ciety, Inc., 14e Eliot Streat, Cambrldsa, Massachusetts 02138. Second cless postage rates paid at Boston Massa. chusetts. Contents are copyrighted © 1971 by the Ripon Society, Inc. PUBLICATIONS PAGE -26 Correspondence addressed to the Editor is welcomed • . In publls~lng this magazine the Ripon Society seeks to provide 8 14A ELIOT STREET -27 forum for fresh Ideas, well-researched proposals end for e spirit of criticism, Innovation, and Independent thinking within the Republican Party. ArtIcles do not necessarily rapresent the opinion of the National Governing Board LETTERS -27 or the Editorial Boerd of the Ripon Society, unless they are explicitly 10 labelled. GUEST EDITORIAL SUBSCRIPTION RATES ara $10 a year, $5 for students, servlcamen, and for Peace Corps, Vista and other volunteers. Overseas air mail, $10 Congressman Paul N. McCloskey was one of the extra. Advertising rates an request. authors of the move to repeal the Gulf of Tonkin reso tion in the House. Since that repeal, McCloskey feels Editor: Evelyn F. Ellis that the President has exceeded his constitutional war Contributing Editor: Howard L. Reiter making powers, lind he discusses what the Congress can Tacbnlcal Editor: John Woodman do now to terminate the American presence in Indo china. -28 Contributors: Christopher. W_ Beal, Duncan K. Foley, Douglas Matthews, WIlliam D. Phelan, Jr., David Omer White. Circulation Dept.: Judith D. Behn. QUQTE OF THE MONTH Correspondents William Harding. Nebraska Mrs. Barbera Mooney, Conn. Charles O. Ingraham, New York :/~4.(rf/pting the Am?rican Legion's Distinguish Maggie Nichols, California Deryl Howard, North Carolina Alax M. Hehmayer. No. Calif. Henri Pell Junod, Ohio ed Service Medal last week, President Nixon called James F. McCollum, Jr., florida William K, Woods, Ohla Michael McCrery, Idaho Stephen Jones, Oklahoma for support of the President of the United States, Ben Violette. illinoiS Eric R. Blackledge. Oregon J. Kenneth Doka, Indlane Richard Ober, Jr .• Pennsylvania regardless of party, on important matters of national C.R. Connall, 1_ Donato Andre D'Andrea, R. I. Eric Kames, Kentocky Bruce M. Selya, Rhode Island defense . ..." Henry Bernstein, louisiana Herris Beach, Jr., So. Carolina William A. Marrill, Mass. Slanford M. Adelstein, S. D. Monday, publication of the Republican James Harrington, MaIne Dru Smith, Tann_ Terrence Dwyer, Michigan W, Stuart Persons, Wisconsin National Committee, February 22, 1971. Arthur F. McClure, II, Missouri Robert R. Murdoch, Virginia EDITORIAL POINTS THOMAS E. DEWEY without a subsidy; if a subsidy is needed, When Thomas Edmund Dewey first announced the SST should not be built. for President in 1940, the New York Herald A leader in the business and labor coalition Tribune prophetically remarked, "Whatever the re supporting the SST, George Meany exemplified the solve of the convention may ultimately be, the New Deal, liberal view citing the number o.f jobs vigor, the integrity, the candid mind of Thomas that the project would provide for America's work- E. Dewey are certain to count as a constructive in ers. fluence upon the party's future and a powerful force The Republicans in Congress for and against for its good." federal support of the SST as recorded in the House Grandson of a founder of the party, Governor of Representatives vote on March 18 and the Sen Dewey always fought for a Republican Party that ate vote on March 24 are listed below. would be equipped to meet the challenges of our Obviously, the traditional definitions of con century. In 1950, he derided "impractical theorists servative and liberal have been strained by the de with a 'passion for neatness'" who wanted to put velopment of new industries - aero-space is only all conservatives into the GOP and make all liberals one example - which are highly dependent upon Democrats: "The results would be neatly arranged, taxpayer support. Thus the pejorative phrase "so too. The Republicans would lose every election and cial engineering" can be used not only to describe the Democrats would win every election." Medicare and legal assistance for the poor; it is Using New York State as a base, he built a equally valid for farm supports, defense industries national political network that, though it did not and other governmental subsidies of private in elevate him to the Presidency, has had a lasting im dustry. Republicans who would purge the party of pact on American politics. It was Dewey men who those who are not sufficiently "conservative" might nominated Eisenhower and staffed his administra best reexamine their own positions first. tion. It was Dewey men who chose Richard Nixon "TRADITIONAL CONSERVATIVES" and then helped him win nominations in 1956 VOTING AGAINST THE SST and 1960. And paradoxically, it was disillusioned THE HOUSE Dewey men who helped lead the conservative move Andrews (N. Dak.) McCollister (Neb.) ment that in 1964 overthrew what Dewey had built Brotzman ( Colo.) McDonald (Mich.) Brown (Mich.) McKevitt (Colo.) nationally and who in 1970 dealt a severe blow to Broyhill (N.C.) McKinney (Conn.) what he had built in New York State. Broyhill (Va.) Mayne (Iowa) Burke (Fla.) Michel (Ill. ) After his third term as governor, Mr. Dewey Byrnes (Wis.) Miller (Ohio) left a revitalized state party and retired to private Cleveland (N.H.) Minshall (Ohio) Collier (TIL) Morse (Mass.) life. He had won his battles against crime in the Conable (N.Y.) Mosher (Ohio) courtroom, not on the podium.