Minutes of the 4.91th VC Meetings of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), (Raj.), held on28, 29th and 30th June, 2021.
The 4.91th VC Meeting of the members of State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), Rajasthan constituted for considering environmental clearance projects (B-category) under GoI Notification 18.12.19 was held on 29th, 30th June and 01st July, 2021 at 10:30 AM through video conferencing under the Chairmanship of Sh. Manoj Kumar Agrawal. The names of the members who attended the meeting are as follows:-
S. No. Name Designation 29.06.2021 30.06.2021 01.07.2021
1 Sh. Manoj Kumar Chairman Attended Attended Attended Agrawal 2 Dr. Suja George Vice - - - Chairman 3 Sh. Pushakar Singh Member Attended Attended Attended Shekhawat 4 Sh. Mukesh Behari Member Attended Attended Attended Sharma 5 Sh. Laxmi Kant Member - - Attended Dashora 6 Sh. Buddhi Prakash Member Attended Attended Attended Pareek 7 Sh. Vikram Singh Member Attended Attended Attended Chauhan 8 Sh. Nand Kumar Co-opted - - - Khare Member, SEAC
The Secretary welcomed the members.
The SEAC considered the following 41 projects and 4 Additional Agenda. With the permission of Chairman, SEAC.
S.No File Subject Project Proponent Name & Consultant No Name 1. 18476 Validity extension of TOR granted to Name of Proponent: - M/s S.R. Stone and Crusher chandpur Masonry Stone Mine (Area- Industries, Add.- Vill.- Chandpur, Distt.- Dholpur 53.8383 ha., M.L. No.- 20/97) with (Raj.) proposed production capacity of 1327500 Email – Not Given TPA (ROM) along with Crusher by M/s Name of Consultant – Not Given S.R. Stone and Crusher Industries, at Vill.- Chandpur, Tehsil & Distt.- Dholpur (Raj.) (Proposal No.-167113) 2. 18392 EC for Marble Quarry lease (Q.L.No-2/4), Name of Proponent:- M/s Abdulla Marble Mines Quary Area-0.5806ha.At near Village-Mata Makrana,Add-R/o-Guljarpura, Tehsil-Makrana,Dist- Bhar,Tehsil-Makrana,Dist- Nagaur,Rajasthan,[email protected] Nagaur,Rajasthan,Proposal No-166039) Name of Consultant:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). email:- [email protected] 3. 19031 Environmental Clearance for Project Proponent Name- M/s Ramjani " Marble Quarry Lease (Bapi Quarry Gesawat & Sans, Add.- Makrana, Tehsil- No.- 165) Area-0.11 ha (40*300sq. Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.), Email- ft.)., Near Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati [email protected] Range) Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Consultant of Name:-MANTRAS GREEN Nagaur (Raj.) of M/s Ramjani Gesawat RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1, NICE & Sans. (Proposal No.-191689) Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). [email protected] 4. 17871 Environmental Clearance for Sand Name of Proponent: - Reenu Gehlot (1755) Stone Mining Project (Q.L. No.- 1755, W/o Late Shri Rameshwar Lal Gehlot, Add.- Area- 0.18 ha., Khasra No.-1755) with Rupawaton Ka Bera, Kaliberi, Soorsagar, Distt.- Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
production capacity of 1710 TPA Near Jodhpur (Raj.)Email- – Village- Fidusar, Tehsil & Distt.- [email protected] Name of Jodhpur (Raj.) by Smt. Reenu Gehlot Consultant: - MANTRAS GREEN W/o Late Shri Rameshwar Lal RESOURCES LTD, Add.- Hall No.- 1 NICE Gehlot.(Proposal No.-142440) Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik).email:[email protected], 5. 17874 Environmental Clearance for Sand Name of Proponent: - Smt. Reena Gehlot W/o Stone Mining Project (Q.L No.- Late Shri Rameshwar Lal Gehlot, Add.- 1760, Area- 0.18 ha., and, Khasra No.- Rupawaton Ka Bera, Kaliberi, Soorsagar, Distt.- 1760) with production capacity of 1710 Jodhpur (Raj.)Email- TPA Near Village- Fidusar, Tehsil &, [email protected] of Distt.- Jodhpur(Raj.) by Smt. Reena Consultant: - MANTRAS GREEN Gehlot W/o Late Shri Rameshwar Lal RESOURCES LTD, Add.- Hall No.- 1 NICE Gehlot.(Proposal No.-142803) Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik).email:[email protected], 6. 18371 E C for Limestone Mining Project Name of Proponent:- Shri- Dhokal Ram, Add.- (M.L. Area 4.50 ha and M.L. No.28/98) Chidhani, Tehsil-Bilara, District- Jodhpur with Production Capacity of 1,49,460, (Raj.) [email protected] TPA (ROM) Khasra No. Not Given, Name of Consultant:- MANTRAS GREEN Add.- Village- Bayad, Tehsil- Metra, RESOURCES LTD, Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.), By Shri Dhokal Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Ram S/o Shri Baluram, (Proposal Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). No.- 165997) Email: [email protected] 7. 18563 E C for Masonry Stone Mining Project Name of Proponent:- Smt. Damyanti W/o Shri (M.L. No. - 184/07, M.L. Area- 1.00 Shyam Singh Charan, Add.- Chavrada Ki Hect., Production Capacity of 1,99,375 Dhani, Vill.- Roopawas, Tehsil & District- Pali, Khasra No.- 512, Near Village- (Raj.) Email- [email protected] Bhanwari, Tehsil- & District- Pali, Name of Consultant:- MANTRAS GREEN (Raj.) of Smt. Damyanti W/o Shri RESOURCES LTD, Shyam Singh Charan, (Proposal No.- Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. 166526) Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). email:- [email protected] 8. 19462 ToR for Seeking Environmental Name of Proponant : - M/s Narayan Minerals Clearance for Quartz & Feldspar ,Add- Near Village-Buchara, Tehsil-Kotputli, Mining Lease (ML. No-32/04, Area- District-Jaipur,Rajasthan,Email- 4.73ha.) at Khasra No-746Near Village- [email protected] Buchara, Tehsil-Kotputli, District- Name of Consultant-Mantras Green Resources Jaipur,Rajasthan,by m/s Narayan ltd. (NABET/EIA/1619/SA 066) hall no- 1 Minerals ,(Proposal No-62103) ,Nice Sankul Plot no - A-9 opp, Nasik Marchant co op bank ltd. iti signal, MIDCSatpur,Nasik,Email- [email protected] 9. 18847 ToR for E C for Quartz, Feldspar Name of Proponent:- Smt. Kanta Jain W/o Late Mining lease (M.L. No. - 06/80 – Shri- Mahavir Chand Jain, Add.- H.No. 75, 22/01(R), M.L. Area- 19.0 Anupam Ashok Marg, Ajmer, Distt.- Ajmer, Hect., Khasra No.- ………, Near (Raj.) Email- [email protected] Village- Kishanpura, Tehsil- Beawer, Name of Consultant:- MANTRAS GREEN District- Ajmer, (Raj.) of Smt. Kanta RESOURCES LTD,Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Jain W/o Late Shri- Mahavir Chand Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Jain, (Proposal No.- 43246) Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik).email:- [email protected] 10. 17120 Regarding submission of Final Cluster Project Proponent Name- 1.Sh. Mohan lal Jangid, EIA/EMP report for Quartz, Feldspar & Partner- 2. Smt. Sugnidevi Jangid, 3. Sh. Hemant Marble Mining Project (ML. NO.- 60/18 Kumar Add.- 166, Near PHED Tank, Distt.- (New) & 14/18 (Old), Khasra No.- 717, Kishangarh (Raj.) [email protected], 718, 719, 720, having mine lease Area- Consultion of Name:-Fulgro Environmental & 2.1665 ha., falling in cluster of area- Engineering Services India Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 27, 6.1713 ha. With production capacity - Ashok Vatika, Khatipura Road, Jhotwara, Jaipur, 15611856 TPA (ROM) and carrying (Raj.).Email:- [email protected], capacity of the cluster- 26359856 TPA, Near Vill.- Makreda, Teh.- Pisangan, Distt.- Ajmer (Raj.) (Proposal No.-60135 ) 11. 18000 EC for our Proposed Mining "Silica Sand Project Proponent Name-Naresh kumar Saxena, Mine Area-4.06ha,Khasra No- Add-F-28 Ghiya Marg, Jaipur, Rajasthan,Email- 281,282,283,372,(ML No-23/2008)" Near [email protected] Name-Shri Village-Karola, Tehsil-Tonk, District-Tonk, Naresh Kumar Sexena, (mining Engineer & Rajasthan, promoted by Shri N.K.Saxena. RQP),Reg.No.RQP/SME/JP/04/2013Add-G-4 Nand (Proposal No-132687) Puri Swaj Farm Sodala, Near Gayatry Public School Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Jaipur 12. 17436 E C of Our Kunwar Granite Mining Project Name of Proponent :-M/s RANKA MINES, Add.- M.L No. 118/2018, Area 1.1453 E-6, Rajhans Colony, Madanganj, Tehsil – Ha.) Khasra No. 682/5, 697/5, Near Village Kishangarh, Distt.- Ajmer, (Rajasthan) Email- – Kunwar, Tehsil - Kareda, District – [email protected] Bhilwara, (Rajasthan). (Proposal Name of Consultant:- M/s Ramji Mine Envirotech, No. 131838) Plot No. 21, First Floor, Aarna-2 Tower, Kartarpura Industrial Area, Jaipur, (Raj.).Email: - [email protected], rme. [email protected] 13. 16980 EC for Sand Stone Mine, (Q.L. No. Name of Proponent: Shri Parasmal Lasod S/o Shri 05/2018)of Applicant Shri Parasmal Lasod Bapu Lal LasodR/o-185, Jain Colony, Kansya, Situated, area 2.33370 ha, Near Village Bijoliya, Bhilwara, (Raj.).Email – Katbada, Tehsil Bijoliya, District Bhilwara, [email protected] (Raj.) Khasra No. 260, 260/1, 260/2, 260/3, Name of Consultant:- M/s. Aseries Envirotek 261, 262(Proposal No. 44211) india Pvt. Ltd.B-107, First Floor, Sector-6, Noida, Uttar Pradesh (Raj.). Email:- [email protected], 14. 19129 ToR for Seeking E C for Proposed Name of Proponant :- M/s Shrinath Mining, Quratz & Feldspar Mining Project" Add.- Neelkanth, 209-210, 2nd Floor, Bhawani M.L. Plot No. 86, Area 4.0566 Ha., Singh Road, Jaipur, Distt.- Jaipur, (Raj.) Khase No. 34, Add.- Rama, Tehsil- Email- shrinathmines086@gmail. com Raipur, District- Bhilwara, (Raj.)M/s Name of Consultant:- MANTRAS GREEN Shrinath Mining, Cat. B1 as Per Cluster RESOURCES LTD Certificate (Proposal No.- 60317) Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). email:- [email protected] 15. 19130 ToR for Seeking E C for Proposed Name of Proponant :- Smt. Shruti Agarwal Quratz & Feldspar Mining Project" W/o Shri Vinay Agarwal, Add.- 131, Barkat M.L. Plot No. 82, Area 4.2632 Ha., Nagar, Tonk Phatak, Jaipur, Distt.- Jaipur, Khase No. 28, Add.- Rama, Tehsil- (Raj.) Email- shrutiagarwal0086@gmail. com Raipur, District- Bhilwara, (Raj.) Smt. Name of Consultant:- MANTRAS GREEN Shruti Agarwal, Cat. B1, as Per Cluster RESOURCES LTD Certificate, (Proposal No.- 60313) Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). email:- [email protected] 16. 18714 Environmetal Clearance for Sand Stone Name of Proponent:- Smt. Mohani Devi W/o Mining Project (Q.L. Area-0.18 ha, and Shri Pabu Ram, Add.- Baba Ramdev Mandir Ke Q.L. No.- 1635 with Production Pas Buurtiya, Sur Sagar, Distt.- Jodhpur Capacity of 1800 TPA (ROM) Near (Raj.)[email protected] Vill.- Fidusar, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Name of Consultant: - MANTRAS GREEN Jodhpur (Raj.) by Smt. Mohani Devi RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1 NICE W/o Sh. PaburamProposal No.- Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co 178680) Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik)[email protected] 17. 14956 Sub., of Final EIA/EMP Report for E C Name of Proponant :- M/s Salasar of Sand Stone Mining Project, M. L. Minerals, Add.- Flat No. 306, Elanza No. 4/1987, Area 5.20 Ha., Production Apartment, Shreenathpuram-Block-C, Capacity 48402.5 TPA, (Mineral Kota, Distt.- Kota, (Raj.) Email- 33622.5 TPA, O.B./Waste 14,780 salasarminerals487 TPA), Khase No. 318, 319 & 320 TPA), @gmail.com Add.- Parana, Tehsil- Talera & Distt.- Name of Consultant:- M/s Overseas Min- Bundi, (Raj.) M/s Salasar Minerals for" Tech Consultans 501, 5th Floor, Apex Tower, (Proposal No. 59074) Tonk Road, Jaipur Raj. Email:- [email protected], 18. 15455 E C to Enhancement the Production for Name of Proponent:- Shri – Narendra Malik, Add.- existing Ball Clay, China Clay, Red & VPo- Diyatara, Tehsil- Kolayat, Distt.- Bikaner, ( Yellow Ocher & Silica Sand Mine, M.L. Raj.) No. -10/98, M.L. Area- 33.03 Hect.) with Email- [email protected] Production Capacity- 99,999.9 TPA (clay), 3,00,000 TPA (Silica sand), Khasra No.- Name of Consultant:- M/s Overseas Min- Tech 154, 786, 789, 801, 802, 819, 1005/784, Consultans, Add.- 501, 5th Floor, Apex Tower, 796, 155, 156, 783, 784, 800, 803, 818, 785, Tonk Road, Jaipur (Raj.) Email:- 790, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 157, 158, [email protected] 255, 264, 265, 266, 267, Add.- Village- Mudh, Tehsil- Kolayat, District- Bikaner, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 54461) 19. 18813 TOR for Environmental Clearance of Soap Project Proponent Name:- M/s Mahadev Mining Works, Stone & China Clay Mining Project Add.- Near Bus Stand, Jahazpur, Tehsil- Jahazpur, Distt.- (1500000 TPA), ML. No.- 443/2010, Old Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
ML. No.- 1/90, Area- 67.875 ha, Near Vill.- Bhilwara (Raj.)Email-Not Given Consultant Name- Nathun, Tehsil- Jahazpur, Distt.- Bhilwara, M/s Overseas Min- Tech Consultans , Add.- 501, 5th (Raj.) of M/s Mahadev Mining Works. (Proposal No.- 58568) Floor, Apex Tower, Tonk Road, Jaipur Raj.Email:- [email protected], 20. 18199 Environmental Clearance for” Bhankri Name of Proponent:- Sh. Narayan Lal Meena Masonry Stone Mine” M.L. No.- S/o Sh. Ratan Lal Meena, Add.- Aam Ka 23/99,Production Capacity- 111873 Jhahera, Tehsil- Nadhoti, District- Karoli, (Raj.) (ROM) TPA, Area- 1.00 ha., Khasra Email- [email protected] No.- 253, Near Village- Bhankri, Name of Consultant: M/s. N.S. Enviro-Tech Tehsil- Dausa, District- Dausa (Raj.) Laboratories & Consultant, Add.- Corpo Office- Proposal No.- 161170) P No 69/318, V.T. Road Chouraha, Madhyam Marg, Mansarovar Jaipur, (Raj.) Email- [email protected], [email protected] 21. 18579 Environmental Clearance for “ Koliya Name of Proponent:- Shri Kamlesh Kumar Masonry Mine, M.L. No.- 37/1993, Panwar, Add.- Near Railway Station, Tehsil- Area- 1.00 ha., Khasra No.- Didwana, District- Nagaur (Raj.)Email- 2034, Production Capacity-100360 [email protected] TPA (ROM ) Near Vill.- Koliya, Name of Consultant: - M/s. N.S. Enviro-Tech Tehsil- Didwana, Distt.- Nagaur Laboratories & Consultant, Add.- Plot No- (Raj.)(Proposal No. -168207) 51,Ganeta House, Shiv Colony,Near Patrakar Colony Road,Mansarovar,Jaipur (Raj.)Email- [email protected], [email protected] 22. 16313 Environmental Clearance (EC) for Our Name of Proponent M/s. 20 Microns Limited Moras Calcite Mine (M.L.No. 01/80), R/o.-9-10, Gidc Industrial Estate Waghodia- Near Village Moras, Tehsil Pindwara & 391760 District Vadodara (Gujarat).E. mail- District Sirohi (Raj.), and Lease Area- [email protected] Environment 49.25 hect.(Proposal No. 33357) Consultant-M/s. N.S. Enviro- Tech Laboratories & ConsultantReg.Office Address-:A-8, Neha Medical Building, Opposite ESI Hospital, Hasanpura Road, Sodala, Jaipur- (Raj.).E. mail- [email protected] 23. 16217 Environment Clearance f or "Panchota Name of Proponent Shri Mahesh Kumar, S/o. Masonery Stone & Quartzite Mines, Sh. Lala Ram Meena R/o Panchota, Tehsil Production Capacity- 56000 TPA Nawa, District Nagaur (Raj.). E. mail- (ROM) Area-1.00 Ha, Near Village [email protected] Environment Panchota, Tehsil- Nawa, District- Consultant-M/s N.S. Enviro-Tech Nagaur Rajasthan.(Proposal Laboratories& ConsultantCorp. Office: Applied No. 35415) No. 69/318, V.T. Road Chouraha, Madhyam Marg, Mansarovar, Jaipur Rajasthan.E. mail- [email protected] 24. 18198 E C for “Bhankri Masonry Stone Name of Proponent:- Smt. Usha Sharma W/o Mine” M.L. No. 33/95 and Area 1.00 Shri Banwari Lal Sharma, Add.- Behind Roy Ha.) with Production capacity of Nursing Home, Opp. P.G. Collage, Distt.- 1,07,715 (ROM) TPA, Khasra No.- Dausa (Raj.), 253, Add.- Village- Bhankri, Tehsil- Email- [email protected] Dausa, District- Dausa, (Raj.) (Proposal Name of Consultant:- M/s. N.S. Envro- Tech No.-161108) Laboratories & Consultant, Corpo OFFICE Add Plot No. 69/318, V.T. Road Chouraha, Madhyam Marg, Mansarovar, Jaipur (Raj.). Email:- [email protected] 25. 15673 EC for Mevda Kalan Granite Mining Project Proponent Name- M/S Shri Mahi Project, M.L.No 48/2018, Production Minerals,R/o-A-93 Talwandi Kota, Dist-Kota, Capacity -62832 TPA (Marketable), Area- (Raj),[email protected] 1.6231 ha,Near village-Mevda Kalan, Name of the Consultant :- Vardan Environet Add:- Tehsil-Kekri, Dist-Ajmer,(Raj) M/S Mahi 142, Sushant Lok-III,sec.57, Gurgaon (Haryana) E- Minerals Mail:- [email protected] 26. 18463 ToR for E C for China Clay (Minor Name of Proponent:- Shri Shivji Ram, Add.- Pateli, Mineral) Mining Project, M.L. No. - Tehsil- Jayal, District- Nagaur (Raj.) 26/2018, Area- 3.5926 Hect.) with Email- [email protected] Production Capacity- 69,900 TPA (ROM) Name of Consultant:- VARDAN ENVIRONET, {Saleable Mineral 62,910 TPA & Waste- Add: Plot No.-82-A, Sector- 5, IMT Manesar, 6,990 TPA} Khasra No.- 258, 259, Add.- Gurgaon-122003 (Haryana). Village- Pateli, Tehsil- Jayal, District- email:- [email protected] Nagaur, (Raj.) By Shri Shivji Ram S/o Shri Sanwata Ram Jat., (Proposal No.- 56080) 27. 19309 E C for Masonry Stone Mining Name of Proponant :- Smt. Ratni Devi W/o Project" M.L. No. 174/06, Area 1.00 Shri- Gopi Siloniya, Add.- Bhagwati Bhawan,
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Ha., Production Capacity 1, 50, 000 Fatehpur Road, Sikar, Distt.- Sikar, (Raj.) TPA to 2, 99, 998 TPA, Khase No. Email- [email protected] 1430, Add.- Tal Ki Dhani, Rasulpur, Name of Consultant:- MANTRAS GREEN Tehsil- Khetri, District- Jhunjhunu, RESOURCES LTD (Raj.) By Smt. Ratni Devi W/o Shri- Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Gopi Siloniya, (Proposal No.- Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, 200535) MIDCSatpur, Nasik). email:- [email protected]
28. 19268 E C for Existing Masonry Stone Name of Proponant :- M/s Shri- Balaji Stone Mining Lease M.L. No. 471/06, Area Crusher, Add.- R/o -9, Leela Mention, Raj 1.00 Ha., Production Capacity 99,000 Bhawan Road, Civil Lines, Jaipur, Distt.- Jaipur TPA 2,90,000 TPA (ROM) Khasra (Raj.) Email.- [email protected] No. 376/1/1, 373/1, Add.- Kundala Ki Name of Consultant :- MANTRAS GREEN Dhani, Tehsil- Neem Ka Thana, RESOURCES LTD, Add.- Hall No.- 1 NICE District- Sikar, (Raj.) By M/s Balaji Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Stone Crusher, (Proposal No. 60776) Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). email:- [email protected]
29. 19102 Enviornmental Clearance for Sand Project Proponent Name- Smt. Kamla W/o Sh. Stone Mining Project (QL. Area-0.18 Jagdish Ram, Add.- N/v- Keru, Tehsil & Distt.- ha, and QL No.- 2318) with Production Jodhpur(Raj.) Capacity of 1697 TPA (ROM) Near [email protected], Vill.- Keru, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Consultant Name-MANTRAS GREEN Jodhpur, (Raj.) by Smt. Kamla W/o Sh. RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1 Jagdish Ram (Proposal No.-192493) NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). [email protected] 30. 19103 Project Proponent Name- Sh. Laxmi Narayan, Add.- Raiko Ka Baas, Birai, Tehsil- Bhopalgadh, Distt.- Jodhpur(Raj.) Enviornmental Clearance for Sand [email protected], Stone Mining Project (QL. Area-1.00 Consultant Name-MANTRAS GREEN ha, and Plot No.- 42, Khasra No.- 543) RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1 with Production Capacity of 77777 TPA NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik (ROM) Near Vill.- Kasti, Tehsil- Baori Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, Distt.- Jodhpur, (Raj.) by Sh. Laxmi MIDCSatpur, Nasik). Narayan (Proposal No.-192840) [email protected] 31. Cluster/ Final EIA Cluster for proposed Clulster Name of Proponant :- Nagaur cluster Mining Nagaur- No.6 ,Cluster area-406.7523ha,China project,Shri Gunsai Baba Society ,Jhunjhala,Add-Jat 6/No.of Caly,Bajri,Keolin & Masonry stone Samaj Bhawan ,Jhanjhala, Post-Borwa, Kuchera, lease- ,Number of Lease 107, Cat.B-1,of Tehsil –Jayal, Dist-Nayaur,Email- 107 predominant Mineral China Caly,(Proposal [email protected],me.nagour.rajast No-57305) han.gov.in. Name of Consultant:- SITU ENVIRO CARE PVT. LTD.,Add-E-7/829,Shahpura, Area Colony ,Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh,Email- [email protected] 32. 18639 Environmental Clearance For Bodki Quartz Name of Proponents: - Shri Simardeep Singh, Add.- & Feldspar Mining Project (Plot No- House No.-7, Shiv Shakti School, Vishal Nagar, 17/2018, Area- 4.0744 ha.) at Vill.- Bodki, Jagadhri, Yamuna Nagar, Haryana (Raj.)Email – Tehsil- Lasadiya, Distt.- [email protected] Udaipur (Raj.)(Proposal No. -37301) Name of Consultant:- Cognizance Research India Private Ltd., Add.-Office GT-20, Sec 177, Noida- 201301 (U.P.)email:- [email protected] 33. 18921 Environmental Clearance for our existing Project Proponent Name-M/s Rama Devi Sharma, mining project Mudh Kotri Ball Clay and Add.- 99-100, RIICO Road No.-9 Industrial Area, Fire Clay Mine (M.L. No.- 09/1993, Area- Rani Bazar, Bikaner (Rajasthan), Email- 89.3645 ha., Khasra No.- 868, 873, 867, [email protected], 871, 878, 4, 133, 134) Near Vill. Mudh- [email protected] Kotri, Tehsil- Kolayat, Distt.- Bikaner Consultant Name-(EGCIPL) (Raj.) with production capacity of -375290 Envirogreen Consultans (India) Private Limited, 1- TPA of Mineral Ball Clay and Fire Clay B, Machhla Magra, Near Patel Circle, under EIA Notification, 2006, and its Udaipur.Email- [email protected], subsequent amendments and MoEF & CC Notification dated- 06.04.2018, 14.08.2018 & NGT order, (Proposal No. - 45488). 34. 19255 E C for Granite Mining Ref. No. Name of Proponant :- Smt.- Suman Bhambi W/o 20201000028740, mine lease Area Shri- Chhagan Lal, Add.- Gulab Villa, Near Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
1.0435ha., Khasra No. 332 and 333, Jagdamba Mata Ji Ka Mandir Brij Lal Nagar, Add.- Bijwar, Tehsil – Deoli, Distt.- Tonk, Malpur, Distt.- Tonk, (Raj.) Email- (Raj.) By Smt. - Suman Bhambi W/o Shri- [email protected] Chhagan, (Proposal No. 198909) Name of Consultant:- Envirogreen Consultants (India) Private Limeted, Add.- 1-B, Machhla Magra, Near Patel Circle, Udaipur. Email- [email protected]
35. 19253 E C for Granite Mining M.L. No. Name of Proponant :- Shri- Shankar Lal Jat S/o 25/2020, mine lease Area 1.3161 ha., Shri- Kishan Jat, Add.- Jat Maholla, Vill- Baghera, Khasra No. 563, Add.- Baghera, Tehsil – Tehsil- Kekri, Distt.- Ajmer, (Raj.) Email- Kekri, Distt.- Ajmer, (Raj.) By Shri - [email protected] Shankar Laljat S/o Shri- Kishan Jat, Name of Consultant:- Envirogreen Consultants (Proposal No. 198714) (India) Private Limeted, Add.- 1-B, Machhla Magra, Near Patel Circle, Udaipur. Email- [email protected]
36. 18375 E C Masonry Stone mining Project Name of Proponent:-Shri – Kishan Ram Choudhary, (M.L.No.82/209, M.L. area 1.00 Ha) with Add.- Karnu, Tehsil- Khimsar, District- Nagaur, Production Capacity 22,406.8 MT Khasra (Raj.) [email protected] No. 1906, Add.- Village- Karnu, Tehsil- Name of Consultant :- OCEAO-ENVORO Khinwsar, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) By Shri Management Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd., Kishan Ram Choudhary, (Proposal No.- Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara, 137034) Ghaziabad, U.P 201012 email:- www.oceaoenviro.com [email protected] 37. 18374 E C Masonry Stone mining Project Name of Proponent:-Shri – Omprakesh, Add.- (M.L.No. 84/209, M.L. area 1.00 Ha) with Karnu, Tehsil- Khimsar, District- Nagaur, (Raj.) Production Capacity 22,407 MT Khasra No. [email protected] 1906, Add.- Village- Karnu, Tehsil- Name of Consultant :- OCEAO-ENVORO Khinwsar, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) By Shri Management Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd., Omprakash, (Proposal No.- 138640) Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P 201012 email:- www.oceaoenviro.com [email protected] 38. 18372 E C Masonry Stone mining Project Name of Proponent:-Shri – Kishan Ram Choudhary, (M.L.No. 83/209, M.L. area 1.00 Ha) with Add.- Karnu, Tehsil- Khimsar, District- Nagaur, Production Capacity 20,583 MT Khasra No. (Raj.) [email protected] 1906, Add.- Village- Karnu, Tehsil- Name of Consultant :- OCEAO-ENVORO Khinwsar, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) By Shri Management Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd., Kishan Ram Choudhary, (Proposal No.- Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara, 139310) Ghaziabad, U.P 201012 email:- www.oceaoenviro.com [email protected] 39. 18749 Environmental Clearance for “Marble Name of Proponent: - M/s Gulam Suleman & Sons, Add.- Near Quarry of Gunawati Range, QL. No.- Vill.- Bordiya Bada Makrana, Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- 157, Khasra No.- 157, Area- 0.2491 Nagaur(Raj.) [email protected] of ha., Production Capacity- 4500 TPA/ROM, Consultant:-OCEAO-ENVORO Management Solutions (India) Vill.- Makrana, Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.-179375 ) Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara,Ghaziabad, U.P 201012, Email:-www.oceaoenviro.com, [email protected] 40. 18753 Environmental Clearance for “Marble Name of Proponent: - M/s Salauddin S/o Shri Gulam Suleman, Quarry of Gunawati Range, QL. No.- Add.- Near Vill.- Guljarpura Makrana, Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- 157/A, Area- 0.4907 ha., Production Nagaur(Raj.) [email protected] Capacity- 4500 TPA/ROM, Vill.- Makrana, Name of Consultant:-OCEAO-ENVORO Management Solutions Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.-179393 ) (India) Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara,Ghaziabad, U.P 201012, Email:- www.oceaoenviro.com, [email protected] 41. 19104 Project Proponent Name- Sh. Sugna Ram, Add.- Vill.- Keru, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Jodhpur,(Raj.) Enviornmental Clearance for Sand [email protected], Stone Mining Project (QL. Area-0.18 Consultant Name-MANTRAS GREEN ha, and QL No.- 2317) with Production RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1 Capacity of 1677 TPA (ROM) Near NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Vill.- Keru, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, Jodhpur, (Raj.) by Sh. Sugna Ram MIDCSatpur, Nasik). (Proposal No.-193196) [email protected]
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
After examining the documents, information provided and deliberations, the committee decided to 1. Recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to proposals listed at serial no. 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 23, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38 with appropriate conditions as recommended in the detailed minutes of the respective agenda items. 2. Recommend to SEIAA to close & delist the proposals listed at serial no. NIL. 3. Recommend to SEIAA for amendment in EC/ToR granted/change in name for proposals listed at serial no. NIL with appropriate conditions as recommended in the detailed minutes of the respective agenda items. 4. Recommend to SEIAA for grant of ToR to the proposals listed at serial no. NIL as recommended in the detailed minutes of the respective agenda items. 5. Defer the proposals listed at Serial no. 20 to be consider in subsequently proposed meetings after receipt of the request from Project Proponent /Consultant 6. Issue query/seek additional information with respect to the proposals listed at serial no. 2, 21, 22, 24, 25, 27 to be reexamined in the forthcoming meetings of the SEAC upon receipt of the reply from PP/consultant. 7. Issue the warning letter to Project Proponent/ Consultant of the proposals listed at Serial no. NIL. 8. Issue the ToR letter to Project Proponent/ Consultant of the proposals listed at Serial no. 12, 26.
The detailed minutes with respect to the agenda items are as annexed. The meeting ended with thanks to the Chair.
S. No. Name Designation
1 Manoj Kumar Agrawal Chairman 2 Suja George Vice Chairman 3 Pushakar Singh Shekhawat Member 4 Mukesh Behari Sharma Member 5 Laxmi Kant Dashora Member 6 Buddhi Prakash Pareek Member 7 Vikram Singh Chauhan Member 8 Nand Kumar Khare Co-opted Member 9 Rajneesh Jain Member Secretary
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Agenda no. 01. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(18476)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Validity extension of ToR granted to Chandpur Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 20/97, Area-53.8383 ha., with proposed production capacity of 1327500 TPA(ROM) along with Crusher by M/s S.R. Stone and Crusher Industries, at khasra no- 414 ,430, 447, 448, 499, 500, 516/413 & 519/498 Vill.- Chandpur, Tehsil & Distt.- Dholpur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 167113)
Project Proponent Name- M/s S.R. Stone and Crusher Industries, Add.- Vill.- Chandpur, Distt.- Dholpur (Raj.).
Consultant Name- Terracon Ecotech Pvt. Ltd. Add-202,kingstone tejpal road ,vile parle(E) Mumbai.
Observations and Resolutions of the committee:-
Neither the PP nor his EIA coordinator was present during presentation. The PP has also not circulated complete documents to the members. The SEAC, therefore, decided to issue warning letter to the PP/Consultant and asked him/them to get all the requisite documents pertaining to the project circulated to all the members in advance and to be present in the meeting as per notice issued in this regard upon receipt of request from PP for consideration of the project, failing which the case shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment of the matter.
Agenda no. 02. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18392)/ 2019-20
Project Name:- EC for Marble Quarry Lease, Q.L. No.- 2/4, Area- 0.5806 ha., (250*250/ 250*212 Sq.ft), Production Capacity- 2080 TPA (ROM){Marble- 1248 TPA & Reject- 832 TPA}, near Village-Mata Bhar, Tehsil-Makrana, Dist-Nagaur, Rajasthan (Proposal No.- 166039).
Project Proponent Name:- M/s Abdulla Marble Mines Makrana, Add-R/o-Guljarpura, Tehsil- Makrana,Dist-Nagaur, Rajasthan, [email protected].
Consultant Name :- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD,Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik).email:- [email protected]
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
S.NO Category / Item 1(a)B2 no.(in Schedule): 1. Location of Project QL No.- 2/4, at / near village- Mata Bhar, Tehsil: Makrana, District – Nagaur (Rajasthan). 2. Project Details Marble Quarry Lease {Q.L No.2/4, Quarry Area- 0.5806 Ha. (250*250/250*212 sq. ft.)} M.L. No. /Production Production capacity: 2080 TPA (ROM) (Marble: 1248 TPA & mineral reject: 832 TPA) capacity at / near village- Mata Bhar, Tehsil: Makrana, District – Nagaur (Rajasthan). 3. Project Cost: Rs 35/- lacs 4. Water Requirement 3.0 KLD (Source : Water will be purchased from nearby villages) & Source Dust Suppression: 1.0 KLD, Greenbelt/Plantation: 1.0 KLD, Drinking & Sanitation: 1.0KLD 5. Fuel & Energy: Mine will be operated in day time only. 6. Application No. & SIA/RJ/MIN/166039/2020 Date & documents submitted :- 7. Information about Aravalli letter in prescribed format dated 07.08.2020. Aravalli Certificate. 8. Date of 02/08/2020 to 03/08/2020 Air/Water/Noise Monitoring 9. Information about Cluster certificate dated 29.06.2021. 500 mtr composite map Cluster map is enclosed.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
10. Environment Annual Amount allocated for EMP measures Management Plan 1. Pollution monitoring – Air, Water, Noise and Soil 40,000/-
2. Dust Suppression 30,000/-
3. Greenbelt / Plantation including maintenance 50,000/- Plant saplings purchase, digging of pits , Watering, Weeding and bowing
4. Haul road and other roads repair and maintenance 20,000/- Total Rs 1,40,000/-
11. Green Belt/ Inside Dump Govt. School, Waste Dump Top Soil Plantation Year (Reclaimed Total Shaympura (Outside) Dumps Area) Area No. Area No. Area No. Area No. Area No. (Ha.) of Ha.) of (Ha.) of (Ha.) of (Ha.) of Trees Trees Trees Trees Trees Existing ------I 0.0384 38 ------0.0384 38
II 0.0384 39 ------0.0384 39
III 0.0384 39 ------0.0384 39 IV 0.0384 38 0.0384 38
V 0.0384 38 0.0384 38
Total 0.192 192 ------0.192 192 Note*- As per O.M. dated 16.01.2020 “The Mining lease holders shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc. . Plantation will be done in Govt. Sec. School, Shyampura (Nagaur). . Species proposed are Alstonia, Phaneravariegata(kachnar), Kusum tree (Schleicheraoleosa), Karanj (PongamiaPinnata), Arjun tree (Terminalia arjuna), Alstonia scholaris, Neem (Azadirachtaindica), etc. Cost for Greenbelt / Plantation including maintenance (Plant saplings purchase, digging of pits, Watering, etc.) is Rs50,000/ - 12. Budgetary Breakup Budgetary breakup for labours for Labour S.No. Health and Facility provided to labours Recurring safety issues cost (In Rs.)
1. Drinking water Safe drinking water, sanitation facility. 10,000 and Sanitation
2. Rest shelters Rest shelters will be provided. 10,000
3. Medical Periodical medical examination once in three years 5,000 Examination
4. Occupational Insurance of workers 5,000 Health
5. Safeguards Provision for Personal protective equipment's viz. 5,000 face mask, ear plug, ear mask helmet shoes, etc. and sanitizer. 6. First aid facility Fully-equipped with first aid boxes & Conveyance 5,000 arrangements to hospitals or dispensaries from mine site.
Total amount allocated for labours 40,000/- Total amount allocated for labour welfare is Rs 40,000/- . 13. Present Status :- ExistingQuarry lease of B2 Category. Presently Non Operational. Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant. Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
This is an existing QL. Initially the QL was issued in favour of Smt. Hajjan Batun for 0.5806 ha. (250*250/ 250*212 Sq.ft area) for mineral Marble. QL was then transferred to M/s Abdulla Marble Mines Markrana vide order dated 17.07.2020.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 0.5806 ha. (250*250/ 250*212 Sq.ft, came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificate dated 07.08.2020 of ME, Makrana, production of mineral from 2012-13 (base year) to 2020-21 has been nil. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Marble Quarry Lease, Q.L. No.- 2/4, Area 0.5806 ha., (250*250/ 250*212 Sq.ft), Production Capacity- 2080 TPA (ROM){Marble- 1248 TPA & Reject- 832 TPA}, near Village-Mata Bhar, Tehsil-Makrana, Dist-Nagaur, Rajasthan (Proposal No.-166039). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining scheme has been approved by the ME, Makrana vide letter dated 24.07.2020 and (corrigendum regarding rectification of lease area was issued on 22.03.2021). ME, Makrana in his certificate dated 07.08.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Nagaur in his certificate dated 18.08.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The SEAC considered the certificate dated 07.08.2020 issued by ME, Makrana. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to M/s Abdulla Marble Mines Makrana for Marble Quarry Lease, Q.L. No.- 2/4, Area 0.5806 ha., (250*250/ 250*212 Sq.ft), Production Capacity- 2080 TPA (ROM){Marble- 1248 TPA & Reject- 832 TPA} near Village- Mata Bhar, Tehsil- Makrana, Dist-Nagaur, Rajasthan (Proposal No.-166039), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent:- M/s Abdulla Marble Mines Makrana, Add-R/o-Guljarpura, Tehsil- Makrana, Dist-Nagaur, Rajasthan, [email protected], Consultant Name:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDC Satpur, Nasik).email:- [email protected].
Agenda no. 03. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(19031)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environmental Clearance for "Marble Quarry Lease, (Bapi Quarry No.- 165), Area- 0.11 ha. (40*300 sq.ft), Production capacity- 1500 TPA (ROM){Marble: 600 TPA & Mineral Reject- 900 TPA} at Near Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil-Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.-191689).
Project Proponent Name- M/s Ramjani Gesawat & Sons, Add.- Makrana, Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.), Email- [email protected].
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1, NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDC Satpur, Nasik). [email protected].
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
S.NO Category / Item 1(a)B2 no.(in Schedule): 1. Location of Project At/ near village- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil: Makrana, District – Nagaur (Rajasthan). 2. Project Details Marble Quarry, Q.L No. 165, Quarry Area 0.11 Ha (40*300 Sq. Ft.). Production capacity 1500 M.L. No. /Production TPA (ROM) (Marble: 600 TPA & mineral reject: 900 TPA) at/ near village- Makrana (Gunawati capacity Range), Tehsil: Makrana, District – Nagaur (Rajasthan). 3. Project Cost: Rs 25 lacs /- 4. Water Requirement 3.0 KLD (Source : Water will be purchased from nearby villages) & Source Dust Suppression: 1.0 KLD, Greenbelt/Plantation: 1.0 KLD, Drinking & Sanitation: 1.0 KLD 5. Fuel & Energy: Mine will be operated in day time only. 6. Application No. & SIA/RJ/MIN/191689/2021 Date & documents submitted :- 7. Information about Aravalli letter in prescribed format issued dated 20.08.2020. Aravalli Certificate. 8. Date of 02/08/2020 to 03/08/2020 Air/Water/Noise Monitoring 9. Information about Cluster certificate issued dated 24.06.2021. 500 mtr composite Cluster map enclosed. map 10. Environment Annual Amount allocated for EMP measures Management Plan 5. Pollution monitoring – Air, Water, Noise and Soil 20,000/-
6. Dust Suppression 20,000/-
7. Greenbelt / Plantation including maintenance 50,000/- Plant saplings purchase, digging of pits , Watering, Weeding and bowing
8. Haul road and other roads repair and maintenance 10,000/- Total Rs 1,00,000/-
11. Green Belt/ Govt. Sr. Sec. Inside Dump Waste Dump Top Soil Plantation Year School, (Reclaimed Total (Outside) Dumps Makrana Area) Area No. of Area No. of Area No. of Area No. of Area No. of (Ha.) Trees Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Existing ------
I 0.007 7 ------0.007 7 II 0.007 7 ------0.007 7 III 0.007 7 ------0.007 7 IV 0.007 7 ------0.007 7 V 0.008 8 ------0.008 8 Total 0.036 36 ------0.036 36 Note*- As per O.M. dated 16.01.2020 “The Mining lease holders shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc. . Plantation will be done in Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Makrana. . Species proposed are Alstonia, Phanera variegata (kachnar), Kusum tree (Schleichera oleosa), Karanj (Pongamia Pinnata), Arjun tree (Terminalia arjuna), Alstonia scholaris, Neem (Azadirachta indica), etc. Cost for Greenbelt / Plantation including maintenance (Plant saplings purchase, digging of pits, Watering, etc.) is Rs 50,000/ -
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
12. Budgetary Breakup Budgetary breakup for labours for Labour S.No. Health and Facility provided to labours Recurring safety issues cost (In Rs.)
1. Drinking Safe drinking water, sanitation facility. 10,000 water and Sanitation 2. Rest shelters Rest shelters will be provided. 10,000
3. Medical Periodical medical examination once in 5,000 Examination three years 4. Occupational Insurance of workers 5,000 Health 5. Safeguards Provision for Personal protective 5,000 equipment's viz. face mask, ear plug, ear mask helmet shoes, etc. and sanitizer. 6. First aid Fully-equipped with first aid boxes & 5,000 facility Conveyance arrangements to hospitals or dispensaries from mine site. Total amount allocated for labours 40,000/- Total amount allocated for labour welfare is Rs 40,000/- . 13. Present Status :- Existing Quarry lease of B2 Category. Presently non Operational. Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
The PP has submitted application for Environmental Clearance for "Marble Quarry Lease, (Bapi Quarry No.- 165), Area- 0.11 ha. (40*300 sq.ft), Production capacity- 1500 TPA (ROM){Marble: 600 TPA & Mineral Reject- 900 TPA} at Near Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil-Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 191689). The project is covered under B2 category. The ME, Makrana has granted LOI on 25.10.2019 for mining of Marble. ME, Makrana vide letter dated 11.06.2021 has issued extension of LOI up to 24.02.2022. The mining scheme has been approved by the ME, Makrana vide letter dated 21.01.2020. ME, Makrana in his certificate dated 20.08.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Nagaur in his certificate dated 07.02.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by ME, Makrana on 20.08.2020, the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster having area of 0.11 ha.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to M/s Ramjani Gesawat & Sons, for Marble Quarry Lease, (Bapi Quarry No.- 165), Area- 0.11 ha. (40*300 sq. ft), Production capacity- 1500 TPA (ROM) {Marble: 600 TPA & Mineral Reject- 900 TPA} at Near Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil-Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 191689), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent M/s Ramjani Gesawat & Sans, Add.- Makrana, Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.), Email- [email protected], Consultant Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Name:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1, NICE Sankul Plot No.- A- 9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). [email protected].
Agenda no. 04. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(17871)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environmental Clearance for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L. No.- 1755, Area- 0.18 ha., with production capacity-1710 TPA at Khasra No.-1755, Near Village- Fidusar, Tehsil & Distt.- Jodhpur (Raj.).(Proposal No.-142440)
Project Proponent Name- Smt. Reenu Gehlot W/o Late Shri Rameshwar Lal Gehlot, Add.- Rupawaton Ka Bera, Kaliberi, Soorsagar, Distt.- Jodhpur (Raj.), Email- [email protected].
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add.- Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik).email:- [email protected],
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal submitted by the PP and also the presentation made by him through VC/Electronic media in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan.
This is an existing QL. The ME, Jodhpur vide order dated 31.12.1988 has issued quarry licence to the Smt. Jhumri Devi w/o Shri Kashi ram. The QL was later on transferred to Sh. Rameshwar Lal s/o Kashi Ram vide order dated 21.03.1996. The QL was again transferred to Smt. Reenu Gehlot vide order dated 01.03.2013. The QL is valid up to 31.03.2025.
The DEIAA, Jodhpur vide letter dated 02.09.2016 had granted EC to Smt. Reenu Gehlot for mining of Sand stone having production capacity of 1710 TPA, Q.L. No.- 1755, Area- 0.18 ha.. The DEIAA, Jodhpur vide order dated 03.07.2018 revoked the said EC on the ground that total no. of 22 LOI’s were sanctioned after 09.09.2013, within the periphery of 500 meters. As per Notifications dated 15.01.2016 and 01.07.2016 of the MoEF & CC all these 22 mining leases formed a cluster which had total mining lease area of more than 25.0 ha. and being so the project comes within the jurisdiction of SEIAA.
The cluster certificate and cluster map dated 05.11.2019 issued by ME, Jodhpur state that the held area of QL No. 1755 (applied lease) is 0.18 ha. and they also indicate that the total area of quarry licenses sanctioned after 09.09.2013 is 0.2347 ha. The cluster map does not show any other mining lease or QL within 500 meters periphery of the applied lease area. The cluster certificate further states that the cluster has been formed as per Notification dated 15.01.2016 and 01.07.2016 of the MoEF & CC. As per the cluster certificate and map prepared by ME, Jodhpur the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster is less than the 5.0 ha. and being so the project is B2 category project and has to be dealt with accordingly.
The PP has submitted application for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L. No.- 1755, Area- 0.18 ha., with production capacity-1710 TPA at Khasra No.-1755, Near Village- Fidusar, Tehsil & Distt.- Jodhpur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 142440). The simplified mining scheme has been approved by the AME, Jodhpur vide letter dated 05.11.2019. ME, Jodhpur in his certificate dated 26.10.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF (WL), Jodhpur in his certificate dated 07.11.2019 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of W.P. (Civil) No. 114.2014 Common Cause Vs Union of India in its judgment dated 02.08.2017 has directed that in case mining activity has
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
been carried out or its expansion has been affected without obtaining Environmental Clearance of the regulatory authority, such activities are illegal and 100% penalty has to be levied in such cases. Since the project is less than 5.0 ha., it came under the purview of the EIA Notification on 09.09.2013, therefore, the PP is required to submit production figures from the base year i.e. 2012-13 onwards in order to secure compliance of the mandate of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The SEAC, therefore, in view of the above asked the PP to submit certified production figures from 2012-13, within a period of 45 days failing which project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Agenda no. 05. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project/Cat.B2(17874 )/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environmental Clearance for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L No.- 1760, Area- 0.18 ha., with production capacity of 1710 TPA at Khasra No.-1760, Near Village- Fidusar, Tehsil &, Distt.- Jodhpur(Raj.) (Proposal No.-142803).
Project Proponent Name- Smt. Reena Gehlot W/o Late Shri Rameshwar Lal Gehlot, Add.- Rupawaton Ka Bera, Kaliberi, Soorsagar, Distt.- Jodhpur (Raj.)Email- [email protected]
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add.- Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik).email:- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing QL. The ME, Jodhpur vide order dated 16.09.1969 has issued quarry licence to Smt. Jhumri devi w/o Shri Kashi Ram. Later on QL was transferred to Sh. Rameshwar Lal s/o Sh. Kashi Ram vide order dated 21.03.1996. The lease was again transferred to Smt. Reenu Gehlot vide order dated 01.03.2013. The QL is valid up to 31.03.2025.
The DEIAA, Jodhpur vide letter dated 02.09.2016 had granted EC to Smt. Reenu Gehlot for mining of Sand stone having production capacity of 1710 TPA, Q.L. No.- 1760, Area- 0.18 ha.. The DEIAA, Jodhpur vide order dated 03.07.2018 revoked the said EC on the ground that total no. of 22 LOI’s were sanctioned after 09.09.2013, within the periphery of 500 meters. As per Notifications dated 15.01.2016 and 01.07.2016 of the MoEF & CC all these 22 mining leases formed a cluster which had total mining lease area of more than 25.0 ha. and being so the project comes within the jurisdiction of SEIAA.
The cluster certificate and cluster map dated 26.10.2020 issued by ME, Jodhpur state that total- 0.4147 ha., area falls in 500 meter periphery of QL No. 1760 having area of 0.18 ha., (applied lease area). They further state that three QL strip land area of 0.2347 ha., has been sanctioned after 09.09.2013 in 500 meter periphery of applied QL No. 1760. The cluster map does not show any other mining lease or QL within 500 meters periphery of the applied lease area. The cluster certificate further states that the cluster has been formed as per Notification dated 15.01.2016 and 01.07.2016 of the MoEF & CC. As per the cluster certificate and map prepared by ME, Jodhpur the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster is less than the 5.0 ha. and being so the project is B2 category project and has to be dealt with accordingly.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L No.- 1760, Area- 0.18 ha., with production capacity of 1710 TPA at Khasra No.-1760, Near Village- Fidusar, Tehsil &, Distt.- Jodhpur(Raj.) (Proposal No.- 142803). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining scheme has been approved by the AME, Jodhpur vide letter dated 19.11.2020. ME, Jodhpur in his certificate dated 26.10.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF (WL), Jodhpur in his certificate dated 07.11.2019 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of W.P. (Civil) No. 114.2014 Common Cause Vs Union of India in its judgment dated 02.08.2017 has directed that in case mining activity has been carried out or its expansion has been affected without obtaining Environmental Clearance of the regulatory authority, such activities are illegal and 100% penalty has to be levied in such cases. Since the project is less than 5.0 ha., it came under the purview of the EIA Notification on 09.09.2013, therefore, the PP is required to submit production figures from the base year i.e. 2012-13 onwards in order to secure compliance of the mandate of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The SEAC, therefore, in view of the above asked the PP to submit certified production figures from 2012-13, within a period of 45 days failing which project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Agenda no. 06. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18371)/ 2019-20
Project Name: - EC for Limestone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 28/98, Area- 4.50 ha., Production Capacity- 1,49,460 TPA (ROM), at Village- Bayad, Tehsil- Metra, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 165997)
Project Proponent Name:- Shri Dhokal Ram, Add.- Chidhani, Tehsil-Bilara, District- Jodhpur (Raj.) [email protected]
Consultant Name:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). Email: [email protected]
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
1. Category / Item B2 no.(in Schedule):
2. Location of Near Village-Bayad, Tehsil- Merta, District-Nagaur State-Rajasthan Project
3. Project Details ML No.-28/98
M.L. No. production capacity of 1,49,460 TPA (ROM) /Production capacity
4. Project Cost: Rs. 50 Lakhs
5. Water Total Water Required- 2.0 KLD Requirement Drinking & Domestic Use- 1.5 KLD & Source Dust Suppression & Plantation- 1.5 KLD
6. Fuel & Energy:- Fuel will be required for mining machineries and No electricity will be required because mining activities will operate in day shift only
7. Application No. Proposal No. SIA/RJ/MIN/ 165997 /2020 & Date &
documents submitted :-
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
8. Information AME/Gotan/Map/ML No-28/1998/1338 dated 16.07.2020 about Aravalli
Certificate.
9. Date of Monitoring was conducted by Noida Testing Laboratories., Approved by NABL, Noida Air/Water/Noise Monitoring
10. Information AME/Gotan/DRG/dated 16.07.2020 about 500 mts Area falling within 500 m is 4.50 ha composite map
11. Environment Annual expenditure of in Rs.- 2,50,000 per year Management Plan (EMP) S. No. Description of Item Cost Per Year (in Rs.) 1 Air Pollution Control –Water Sprinkling 1,00,000 3 Environmental Monitoring and Management Occupational 1,00,000 Health and Safety 4 Green Belt Development 50,000 Total 2,50,000
12. Corporate Annual expenditure of in Rs.- 1,00,000 per year Environment Responsibility (CER)
13. Green Belt/ Annual expenditure of in Rs.- 50,000 per year Plantation Year Un-worked Area Waste Inside Dump Top Soil Total Dump (Reclaimed Dumps (Outside) Area) Area No. Area No. Area No. Area No. Area No. (Ha.) Of (Ha.) Of (Ha.) Of (Ha.) Of (Ha.) Of Trees Trees Trees Trees Trees
Existing ------I 0.205 164 - - 0.289 231 - - 0.494 395 II 0.205 164 - - 0.289 231 - - 0.494 395 III 0.205 164 - - 0.287 230 - - 0.492 394 IV ------V ------VI years ------onwards
Total 0.6150 492 - - 0.865 692 - - 1.48 1184
Note:- As per O.M. dated 16.01.2020 “The Mining Lease holders shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc.
Note:-At the end of third year Green Belt /Plantation will be done in 1.48ha. Area i.e. (1184trees) (0.87.) out of which 0.6150ha.( 492 Plants) area will be covered under green belt on around the mine periphery & remaining i.e. 0.865ha. (692 Plants) Plantation will be done on backfilled area. Native specie which are more suitable to the local environment are preferred to be planted such as like Neem (Azadiracta indica), Pipal (Ficus religiosa), Babool (Acacia nilotica), Kher (Acacia catechu) etc.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Source-Approved Mining Plan with Progressive Mine closure plan
14. Budgetary Annual expenditure of in 55,000 per year Breakup for Labour S. No. Facilities Provided For Labourers Cost (in Rs.) 1. Shelter, Supply of PPE equipment's 25,000 (Earplugs, Masks, Safety shoes) 2. Supply of fuel for cooking 15,000 3. Drinking Water & Sanitation Facility- Mobile Toilets 15,000 Total 55,000
15. Present Status : This is an existing mining lease of Limestone Mining Project, located near Village-Bayad, Tehsil- Merta, District-Nagaur (Rajasthan) over an area of 4.50 hectares, ML No.-28/98. Mining Lease Area of 4.50 Ha was granted in favour of Shri Dhokal ram S/o Sh. Balu ram vide Letter No- SME/Aj/Mining Plan/F-N-36/2015/15416 on dated-25/11/2016. As per EIA Notification dated 14.09.2006, as amended from time to time this mining project comes under ‘B2’ Category. Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing lease. The mining lease was granted over an area of 4.50 ha. for mineral Limestone in favour of Sh. Abdul Majid S/o.- Sh. Basir Khan vide order dated 27.05.1999. The lease was registered on 19.08.1999 for 20 years. Later on lease was transferred to Sh. Dhokal Ram S/o Sh. Babu Ram vide order dated 13.03.2003. The transfer agreement was executed on 29.03.2003 and registered on 16.04.2003.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 4.50 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificate dated 25.01.2021 of ME, Makrana, production of mineral in the year 2012-13 (base year) was 3150 MT. Thereafter, production of mineral has either been less than the base year’s production level or nil, in the subsequent years up to 2019-20. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Limestone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 28/98, Area- 4.50 ha., Production Capacity- 1,49,460 TPA (ROM) at Village- Bayad, Tehsil- Metra, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 165997). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 25.11.2016. AME, Gotan in his certificate dated 16.07.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Nagaur in his certificate dated 21.07.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by AME, Gotan on 16.07.2020, there is no other mining lease and the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster having area of 4.50 ha.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Dhokal Ram, for Limestone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 28/98, Area- 4.50 ha., Production Capacity- 1,49,460 TPA (ROM) at Village- Bayad, Tehsil- Metra, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 165997), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent- Shri Dhokal Ram, Add.- Chidhani, Tehsil-Bilara, District- Jodhpur (Raj.), [email protected], Consultant Name:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). Email: [email protected].
Agenda no. 07. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18563)/ 2019-20
Project Name:- E C for Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 184/07, Area- 1.00 ha., Production Capacity- 1,99,375 TPA(ROM) at Khasra No.- 512, Near Village- Bhanwari, Tehsil- & District- Pali, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 166526)
Project Proponent Name:- Smt. Damyanti W/o Shri Shyam Singh Charan, Add.- Chavrada Ki Dhani, Vill.- Roopawas, Tehsil & District- Pali, (Raj.) Email- [email protected]
Consultant Name:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A- 9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik), Email- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 01.07.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting.
Agenda no. 08. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(19462)/ 2019-20
Project Name- ToR for Quartz & Feldspar Mining Lease, (ML. No- 32/04, Area- 4.73 ha.) Production capacity- 2,78,460 TPA (ROM){Quartz & Feldspar: 2,22,770 TPA and waste: 55,690 TPA} at Khasra No- 746, Near Village- Buchara, Tehsil-Kotputli, District-Jaipur, Rajasthan, (Proposal No-62103).
Project Proponent Name- M/s Narayan Minerals, Add- Near Village-Buchara, Tehsil- Kotputli, District-Jaipur, Rajasthan, [email protected].
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur,Nasik). email:[email protected]
Observations & Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is existing lease. Lease granted in favour of Sh. Ashwani Kumar Bajaj S/o. Sh. Vidhyasagar Bajaj over an area of 4.73 ha. for Quartz & Feldspar mineral vide letter dated 27.05.2008. Lease was executed on 29.08.2008 & registered on 08.09.2008 for a period of 30 years. Lease was transferred to M/s Narayan Minerals vide order dated 01.04.2016. The period of lease validity was auto extended for period of 50 years i.e. from 08.09.2008 to 07.09.2058.
The DEIAA, Jaipur vide letter dated 14.10.2016 had granted EC to Sh. Ashwani Kumar Bajaj, ML. No- 32/04, Area- 4.73 ha., Production capacity- 1,04,730 TPA, at Khasra No- 746, Near Village- Buchara, Tehsil-Kotputli, District-Jaipur, Rajasthan.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The DEIAA, Jaipur, however, vide order dated 12.01.2017 revoked the EC in view of the observations of the WRD, GOR contained in the letter dated 13.12.2016 that the mining lease will affect the catchment area of the dam. These observations were based on the WRD circular dated 04.09.2013. The WRD vide letter dated 17.04.2018 later on modified its earlier circular dated 04.09.2013 and specified minimum distances. The minimum distance specified in the letter dated 17.04.2018 is 500 meter for different types of water bodies and dams. The proposed project is located at a distance of 525 meters i.e. outside the prohibited distance.
The project being one of major mineral before 10.02.2015 with respect to quartz & feldspar, having lease area of 4.73 hectare, came under the purview of the EIA notification dated 14.09.2006 vide notification dated 07.10.2014 of the MoEF & CC. The base year in such cases is 2013-14 in terms of Common Cause judgement pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. According to the certificate dated 18.03.2021 of AME, Kotputli production of Feldspar in the base year i.e. 2013-14 was 480 Ton. The PP, however, increased production of Feldspar to 2295 Ton in the year 2016-17 without valid prior environmental clearance from the regulatory authority. The production of mineral without obtaining prior environmental clearance from the competent authority was in violation of EIA notification.
The PP has applied for ToR as a fresh case for Quartz & Feldspar Mining Lease, ML. No- 32/04, Area- 4.73 ha., Production capacity- 2,78,460 TPA (ROM) {Quartz & Feldspar: 2,22,770 TPA and Waste: 55,690 TPA} at Khasra No- 746 Near Village- Buchara, Tehsil- Kotputli, District-Jaipur, Rajasthan (Proposal No- 62103). The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Jaipur vide letter dated 12.03.2021. AME, Kotputli in his certificate dated 22.11.2019 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Tiger Project Sariska & DCF (WL), Zoo Jaipur in their certificates dated 10.01.2020 & 20.12.2019 respectively stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine.
The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
It is a project having capital cost of Rs. 60 Lacs. The AME, Kotputli in his certificate dated 22.11.2019 has stated that total area of the mining lease in the cluster is 4.73 hectare.
During presentation the PP was asked to furnish NOC from the Water Resources Department at the time of submission of project for obtaining EC.
The SEAC examined the project in the light of OM dated 12.11.2020 of the MoEF & CC. This OM provides that while considering the application for EC under violation category as per Notification dated 14.03.2017 of the MoEF & CC, the SEAC may insist upon public hearing to be conducted only for those category of projects for which EIA Notification, 2006 itself requires public hearing to be conducted. The project, under consideration, is one of ‘B2’ category and being so does not require public hearing as per EIA Notification, 2006 read with various OM’s and guidelines issued by the MoEF & CC, from time to time.
The SEAC, in view of the project being one of violation of the EIA notification as also in terms of Common Cause judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, decided that the PP is required to conduct Environmental Impact Assessment Study and prepare Remediation Plan, Natural Resource Augment Plan and Community Resource Augmentation Plan.
Keeping in view the presentation made by the PP/ Consultant and examination of documents submitted by them, the SEAC resolved to recommend to SEIAA for prescribing the ToR mentioned at ‘Annexure B’, as a case of violation of the EIA notification, for preparing comprehensive EIA/EMP reports and Assessment of Ecological Damage, preparation of Remediation Plan and Natural Community Resource Augmentation Plan as a case of violation, of the EIA notification.
Agenda no. 09. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project/ Cat. 1(a)B1(18847)/ 2019-20 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Project Name- ToR for Quartz & Feldspar Mining project, M.L. No. 06/80-R-22/01, Area- 19.0 ha., Production capacity- 1,32,600 TPA(ROM) {Quartz & Feldspar: 1,06,080 TPA and waste: 26,520 TPA} at Khasra No. 201- 207, 1561, 1574,182,174,208,186,185,184,180,181, 179, 178, 189-196, 175-177, 200 & 173 Near Village- Kishanpura, Tehsil- Beawer, District- Ajmer, (Raj.), (Proposal No.- 43246)
Project Proponent Name- Smt. Kanta Jain W/o Late Shri- Mahavir Chand Jain, Add.- H.No. 75, Anupam Ashok Marg, Ajmer, Distt.- Ajmer, (Raj.) Email- [email protected] Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur,Nasik).email:[email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 01.07.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting.
Agenda no. 10. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(17120)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Regarding submission of Final Cluster EIA/EMP report for Quartz, Feldspar & Marble Mining Project (ML. NO.- 60/18 (New) & 14/18 (Old), Khasra No.- 717, 718, 719, 720, having mine lease Area- 2.1665 ha., falling in cluster of area- 6.1713 ha. With production capacity - 15611856 TPA (ROM) and carrying capacity of the cluster- 26359856 TPA, Near Vill.- Makreda, Teh.- Pisangan, Distt.- Ajmer (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 60135)
Project Proponent Name- Sh. Mohan Lal Jangid, Partner- 2. Smt. Sugnidevi Jangid, 3. Sh. Hemant Kumar Add.- 166, Near PHED Tank, Distt.- Kishangarh (Raj.) Email- [email protected].
Consultant Name- Fulgro Environmental & Engineering Services India Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 27, Ashok Vatika, Khatipura Road, Jhotwara, Jaipur, (Raj.).Email:- [email protected],
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 25.06.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting.
Agenda no. 11. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18000)/ 2019-20
Project Name- EC for Silica Sand Mining Project, M.L. No- 23/2008, Area- 4.06 ha., Production capacity- 80,500 TPA (ROM) {Silica sand- 64,220 TPA & Waste 16,280 TPA} at Khasra No- 292, 283, 382, 384, 387, 388, 397, 375, 396, 390, 393, 381, 383, 392, 395, 372 & 389, Near Village-Karola, Tehsil-Tonk, District-Tonk, Rajasthan. (Proposal No- 132687).
Project Proponent Name- Sh. Naresh kumar Saxena, Add-F-28 Ghiya Marg, Jaipur, Rajasthan,[email protected]
Consultant Name:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur,Nasik). email:- [email protected]
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
S.NO Category / Item 1(a)B2 no.(in Schedule): 1. Location of Project Khasra No. 292,283,382,384,387,388,397,375,396,390,393,381,383,392,395,372,389 at/near Village - Karola, Tehsil & District- Tonk (Rajasthan).
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
2. Project Details Silica Sand Mining Lease (M.L. No 23/2008, Area: 4.06 Ha) Production Capacity M.L. No. /Production (ROM): 80,500 TPA (Silica Sand: 64,220 TPA and reaming waste: 16,280 TPA) at capacity Khasra No. 292,283,382,384,387,388,397,375,396,390,393,381,383,392,395,372,389 at/near Village - Karola, Tehsil & District- Tonk (Rajasthan). 3. Project Cost: Rs 20 lacs /- 4. Water Requirement 5.0 KLD (Source : Water will be purchased from nearby villages) & Source Dust Suppression: 2.0 KLD, Greenbelt/Plantation: 2.0 KLD, Drinking & Sanitation: 1.0KLD 5. Fuel & Energy: Mine will be operated in day time only. 6. Application No. & SIA/RJ/MIN/132687/2019 Date & documents submitted :- 7. Information about Aravalli letter in prescribed format dated 22.06.2021. Aravalli Certificate. 8. Date of 02/08/2020 to 03/08/2020 Air/Water/Noise Monitoring 9. Information about Cluster certificate dated 22.06.2021 enclosed. 500 mtr composite map Cluster map is enclosed dated22.06.2021.
10. Environment Annual Amount allocated for EMP measures Management Plan 9. Pollution monitoring – Air, Water, Noise and Soil 15,000/-
10. Dust Suppression 15,000/-
11. Greenbelt / Plantation including maintenance 1,00,000/- Plant saplings purchase, digging of pits , Watering, Weeding and bowing
12. Haul road and other roads repair and maintenance 20,000/- Total Rs1,50,000/-
11. Green Belt/ Safety zone Unworked Waste Dump Top Soil Plantation Year along ML area within Total (Outside) Dumps Boundary ML Area No. Area No. of Area No. of Area No. of Area No. of (Ha.) of Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees Trees (Ha.) Existing 0.02 20 ------0.02 20 I 0.260 260 ------0.260 260 II 0.270 270 ------0.270 270 III 0.260 260 ------0.260 260 IV - - - - 0.260 260 - - 0.260 260 V - - - - 0.270 264 - - 0.270 264 Total 0.81 810 - - 0.530 530 - - 1.34 1340 Note*- As per O.M. dated 16.01.2020 “The Mining lease holders shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc. . Plantation will be done about 1.34 ha within the ML area. . Species proposed are Alstonia, Phaneravariegata(kachnar), Kusum tree (Schleicheraoleosa), Karanj (PongamiaPinnata), Arjun tree (Terminalia arjuna), Alstonia scholaris, Neem (Azadirachtaindica), etc. Cost for Greenbelt / Plantation including maintenance (Plant saplings purchase, digging of pits, Watering, etc.) is Rs1,00,000/ -
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
12. Budgetary Breakup Budgetary breakup for labours for Labour S.No. Health and Facility provided to labours Recurring safety issues cost (In Rs.)
1. Drinking water Safe drinking water, sanitation facility. 20,000 and Sanitation 2. Rest shelters Rest shelters will be provided. 10,000
3. Medical Periodical medical examination once in three years 10,000 Examination
4. Occupational Insurance of workers 10,000 Health
5. Safeguards Provision for Personal protective equipment's viz. 10,000 face mask, ear plug, ear mask helmet shoes, etc. and sanitizer. 6. First aid facility Fully-equipped with first aid boxes & Conveyance 10,000 arrangements to hospitals or dispensaries from mine site.
Total amount allocated for labours 70,000/- Total amount allocated for labour welfare is Rs70,000/- . 13. Present Status :- Existinglease of B2 Category. Presently Non- Operational. Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing lease. The mining lease was granted over an area of 4.06 ha. for mineral Silica Sand in favour of Sh. Naresh Kumar Saxena vide order dated 23.07.2009. The lease was executed on 26.11.2009 & registered on 01.12.2009 for 30 years. The lease is valid up to 30.11.2059.
The project being one of major mineral (before 10.02.2015) having lease area of 4.06 ha.(less than 5.0 ha.), came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 07.10.2014 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificate dated 08.01.2020 and 22.06.2021 of AME, Tonk the production of mineral from 2013-14 (base year) to 2020-21 has been nil. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Silica Sand Mining Project, M.L. No- 23/2008, Area- 4.06 ha., Production capacity- 80,500 TPA (ROM) {Silica sand- 64,220 TPA & Waste 16,280 TPA} at Khasra No- 292, 283, 382, 384, 387, 388, 397, 375, 396, 390, 393, 381, 383, 392, 395, 372 & 389, Near Village-Karola, Tehsil-Tonk, District-Tonk, Rajasthan. (Proposal No- 132687). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Jaipur vide letter dated 25.03.2021. AME, Tonk in his certificate dated 22.06.2021 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Tonk in their certificate dated 23.02.2021 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by AME, Tonk on 22.06.2021, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
Resolution:
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Sh. Naresh Kumar Saxena for Silica Sand Mining Project, M.L. No- 23/2008, Area- 4.06 ha., Production capacity- 80,500 TPA (ROM) {Silica sand- 64,220 TPA & Waste 16,280 TPA} at Khasra No- 292, 283, 382, 384, 387, 388, 397, 375, 396, 390, 393, 381, 383, 392, 395, 372 & 389, Near Village- Karola, Tehsil-Tonk, District-Tonk, Rajasthan. (Proposal No- 132687), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent- Sh. Naresh kumar Saxena, Add-F-28 Ghiya Marg, Jaipur, Rajasthan,Email- [email protected], Consultant Name:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur,Nasik). email:- [email protected].
Agenda no. 12. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(17436)/ 2019-20
Project Name- EC for Kunwar Granite Mining Project, M.L No.- 118/2018, Area- 1.1453 ha., Production capacity- 1,17,491 TPA (ROM) {Saleable mineral- 23,476 Tonnes & Waste- 94,015 Tonnes} at Khasra No. 682/5 & 697/5, Near Village – Kunwar, Tehsil - Kareda, District – Bhilwara, (Rajasthan) (Proposal No. 131838).
Project Proponent Name- M/s RANKA MINES, Add.- E-6, Rajhans Colony, Madanganj, Tehsil – Kishangarh, Distt.- Ajmer, (Rajasthan) Email- [email protected]
Consultant Name- M/s Ramji Mine Envirotech, Plot No. 21, First Floor, Aarna-2 Tower, Kartarpura Industrial Area, Jaipur, (Raj.).Email: - [email protected], rme. [email protected]
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
1. Category / B-2 Item no.(in Schedule): 2. Location of Near Villages- Kunwar, Tehsil- Kareda, Distt. – Bhilwara (Raj.)falls within the Survey Project of India Toposheet No.45G/01 3. Project ML. No. 118/2018 Details Area – 1.1453 Ha. M.L. No. Khasra No.- 682/5, 697/5 /Production capacity Proposed production of Quartz Mining Project 117491 TPA ROM ( 23476 Tones Saleable Minerals + 94015 Tones Waste)
4. Project 30.00 Lakh Cost: 5. Water 5.0 KLD from nearby villages (Kunwar) through tankers. Requirement & Source 6. Fuel & 400LPD Energy:- 7. Application Proposal No. SIA/RJ/MIN/131838/2019 dated 16/12/2019 No. & Date & documents submitted :- 8. Information ME/Bhil../Map /Kha. P. 118/2018/292 on dated 28/06/2019 about Aravalli
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Certificate.
9. Date of 10.12.19 Air/Water/N oise Monitoring 10. Information ME/Bhil./Map /Cluster/Kha.P.118/2018/293 on dated 28/06/2019 about 500 mts composite map 11. Environmen COST PER S.NO. DESCRIPTION OF ITEM t YEAR (IN RS.) Managemen 1. Air, Water, Noise & Soil Pollution Monitoring 45,000 t Plan Green Belt Development(Fencing, Tree Guard, 2. 40,000 Manuring, Mulching & Pitting) 3 . Water Sprinkling on Haul Roads 30,000 4. Maintenance of Haul Road 35,000 Total 1,50,000
Safety Barrier Survi 12. Green Belt/ Backfilled Zone (Inside ved Total Replacem Area Replace Plantation Lease Area) Survi Plant Surviv Sr. ent Surviv ment val al No. & ed & No. Rate No. Rate Area of Maintena Area of Plant Mainten Area No. of (%) (%) (Ha.) Tree nce (Ha.) Tre ance (Ha.) Trees s es
Existin - - (70%) (30%) - - 70% (30%) - - g I 0.1158 116 70% 81 35 70% 0.1158 81 II 0.1158 151 70% 106 45 70% 0.1158 106 III 0.1159 161 70% 112 49 70% 0.1159 112 IV - - - 49 ------49 Repla Replace ced d Vth - - - - - 0.27 273 70% 191 82 0.2736 191 Onwar 36 ds - - - - - 82 82 Replac (Replac ed ed) Total 0.3475 348 - 0.27 - - 273 - 0.6211 621 36 The 33% plantation of the total lease area i.e. 0.6211 Ha will be carried out inside the lease area, Total 621 Plants will be planted (On Safety barrier Zone 348 Plants and on Backfilled area 273 Plants ) Plant species will be adopted as per suggested by forest department like Neem, Mango and other species.
13. Budgetary S. No. Labour Welfare Amenities For Workers Amount (in Rupees) Breakup for 1. Rest Shelter 15,000 Labour 2. Health Facility 15,000 3. Drinking water 10,000 4. Sanitation Facility 8,000 5. Fuel for cooking 7,000 6. Education for Children 15,000 Total 70,000
14. Present This is a fresh LOI of Granite Stone Mining Project. vide letter no. SME/Bhil-Circle/C.C Status :- 2/Bhil/M.L. 118/2018/1608, dated 21/05/2019.
Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The PP has submitted application EC for Kunwar Granite Mining Project, M.L No.- 118/2018, Area- 1.1453 ha., Production capacity- 1,17,491 TPA (ROM) {Saleable mineral- 23,476 Tonnes & Waste-94,015 Tonnes} at Khasra No. 682/5 & 697/5, Near Village – Kunwar, Tehsil - Kareda, District – Bhilwara, (Rajasthan). (Proposal No. 131838). The project is covered under B2 category. The SME, Bhilwara vide order dated 21.05.2019 has issued LoI to the PP for mining of granite for a period of 18 months. The SME, Bhilwara vide letter dated 28.06.2021 has extended the period of LOI up to 20.08.2021. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Bhilwara vide letter dated 16.07.2019. ME, Bhilwara in his certificate dated 28.06.2019 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Bhilwara in his certificate dated 03.10.2019 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. DCF (WL), Rajasamand in its certificate dated 07.10.2020 has stated that Todgarh Raoli WLS is situated at a distance of 20.60 Km and Kumbhalgarh WLS is situated at a distance of 42.20 Km from the applied lease area.
The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by ME, Bhilwara on 28.06.2021, the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster having area of 4.1453 ha.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to M/s Ranka Mines for Kunwar Granite Mining Project, M.L No.- 118/2018, Area- 1.1453 ha., Production capacity-1,17,491 TPA (ROM) {Saleable mineral- 23,476 Tonnes & Waste- 94,015 Tonnes} at Khasra No. 682/5 & 697/5, Near Village – Kunwar, Tehsil - Kareda, District – Bhilwara, (Rajasthan) (Proposal No. 131838), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent M/s RANKA MINES, Add.- E-6, Rajhans Colony, Madanganj, Tehsil – Kishangarh, Distt.- Ajmer, (Rajasthan) Email- [email protected], Consultant Name:- M/s Ramji Mine Envirotech, Plot No. 21, First Floor, Aarna-2 Tower, Kartarpura Industrial Area, Jaipur, (Raj.), Email:- [email protected], [email protected].
Agenda no. 13. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project/Cat. B2(16980)/ 2019-20
Project Name:- EC for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L. No.- 05/2018, Ref. No. 2018100001073, Area- 2.33370 ha., Production Capacity- 2,79,693 TPA (ROM) {Saleable 70,164 TPA, Waste 46,776 TPA and OB 1,62,754 TPA}, at Khasra No. 260, 260/1, 260/2, 260/3, 261 & 262, Near Village Katbada, Tehsil Bijoliya, District Bhilwara, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 44211).
Project Proponent Name:- Shri Parasmal Lasod S/o Shri Bapu Lal Lasod R/o-185, Jain Colony, Kansya, Bijoliya, Bhilwara, (Raj.).Email – [email protected]
Consultant Name:- Gaurang Environmental Solutions Pvt. Ltd. Add-102, SNG, Shree Ratna, Apartment, Near Tambi Petrol pump, Teetal factory, Jhotwara road, Jaipur,Email- [email protected]
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
S.N Particula Details/Information o. rs 1. Cat./ Item 1 (a)-B2 no. (in schedule): 2. Location Near village –Katbada, Tehsil: Bijoliya, District: Bhilwara (Rajasthan) Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
of the Project 3. Project Q.L. No. : 05/2018 Details Khasra No. : 260,260/1, 260/2, 260/3, 261,262 M.L No./ Area : 2.3337HECT. Productio Production : 279693TPA(ROM) n (TPA) (Saleable Mineral- 70164 TPA, Waste- 46776 TPA & Overburden Capacity - 162754 TPA) Details are given in cover page of Proposal obtaining of Environmental Clearance (Page No.: 1)
4. Project Project Cost: Rs 30.0 lacs/-(in Rs.) Cost Details are given in cover page of Proposal obtaining of Environmental Clearance (Page No.: 1) 5. Water 3.0 KLD (Source : Water will be sourced from nearby villages) requireme Details are given in Slide no. 19 of Power Point Presentation. nt & Source 6. Fuel & No electricity will be required in mining operations as mining will be carried out in Energy day time only. Details are given in Slide no. 19 of Power Point Presentation 7. Applicati Category : B2 on no., SEAC FILE NO. : 16980 Date of Date of documents Submitted :18/09/2019 Documen SEAC Meeting No. :4.91thMeeting ts Agenda Sr. No. :13 Submitted Date of Presentation : 28/06/2021 8. Informati Aravalli Certificate has been issued byMining Engineer, Bhilwara (Raj.) vide letter on about No.ME/BIJJO/MAP/Aravalli/2019/120 dated 27/08/2019 as Page No.: 99 Aravalli certificate 9. Date of Monitoring was conducted byNoida Testing Laboratories., Approved by NABL, Air, Noida as Page No.: 114-117 Water, Noise, monitorin g 10. Informatio 500 mts composite map has been issued byMining Engineer, Bijoliya (Raj.) vide n about letter No. ME/BIJJO/MAP/CLUSTER/2021/112dated 10/03/2021 as Page No.: 100- 500 mts 101 composite Area falling within 500 mts 2.33370ha. map 11. CER Environment Management Plan Expenditures: Capital Cost : Rs. 0.80 lacs Recurring Activities Cost : Rs. 1.10 lacs per annum. Sr. Particulars Capital Cost Recurring No. (in Rs. Lac) Cost (in Rs. Lac) 1. Pollution monitoring – Air, Water, - 0.20 Noise and Soil 2. Pollution control (Water Sprinkling 0.80 0.40 &Green Belt development including providing tree guards, plantation and its maintenances) 3. Distribution of 10 Sets of chairs & - 0.30 benches 4. Maintenances of approach road - 0.20 after consultation of Gram panchayat. Total 0.80 1.10
12. Greenbelt Year Un-worked Charagaah Backfilled Top Soil Total & Area Land (Reclaimed Dumps Plantation Khasra No. Area) 183/185 Area No. Area No. Are No. Are No. Area No. (Ha.) of (Ha.) of a of a of (Ha.) of Tre Tre (Ha Tre (Ha Tre Tre es es .) es .) es es
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Existi ------ng 1st 0.142 0.114 0.256 142 114 ------256 6 2 8 2nd 0.142 0.114 0.256 142 114 ------256 5 2 7 3rd 0.142 0.114 0.256 142 114 ------256 5 1 6 4th Maintenance 5th Maintenance 0.427 0.342 0.770 Total 426 342 ------768 6 5 1 Note:- As per O.M. dated 16.01.2020 “The Mining Lease holders shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc. Note:-At the end of third year Green Belt /Plantation will be done in 0.7701 ha. area i.e. (768 trees) (0.4276 ha + 0.3425 ha.) out of which 0.4276 ha.(426 Plants) area will be covered under green belt on around the mine periphery & remaining i.e. 0.3425 ha. (342 Plants) Plantation will be done outside the lease area in village panchayat Mogarwasa in charagah land falling under Araji number 183/185, Native specie which are more suitable to the local environment are preferred to be planted such as like Neem (Azadiracta indica), Pipal (Ficus religiosa), Babool (Acacia nilotica), Kher (Acacia catechu) etc. Source-Approved Mining Plan with Progressive Mine closure plan 13. Budgetar The information regarding Budgetary breakup for labour has been given in PFR & y breakup Power Point Presentation (Slide No.: 30) for labour Sr. Facility provided for Labour Capital Cost in Recurring cost in No. Rs. Rs.
1. Shelter, Safe Drinking, Water , 50,000/- Maintenances Cost Sanitation Facility :7,000/- 2. Periodic Medical Examination once - 10,000/- in three years @500 workers 3. Group insurance @ Rs. 1500 per 30,000/- - worker 4. Provision for personal protective 8,000/- equipment (PPEs) like ear plugs, dust masks, helmet, shoes for 20 workers 5. First Aid Box - 4,000/- Total 80,000/- 29,000/-
14. Present Proposed Mine site. Status Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L. No.- 05/2018, Ref. No. 2018100001073, Area- 2.33370 ha., Production Capacity- 2,79,693 TPA (ROM) {Saleable 70,164 TPA, Waste 46,776 TPA and OB 1,62,754 TPA} at Khasra No. 260, 260/1, 260/2, 260/3, 261 & 262, Near Village Katbada, Tehsil Bijoliya, District Bhilwara, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 44211). The project is covered under B2 category. The SME, Bhilwara has granted LOI of mineral on 27.06.2019. ME, Bijoliya vide letter dated 23.02.2021 has extended validity of LOI for 06 months. The LOI was again extended for a further period of 2 months vide order dated 24.06.2021. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Bhilwara vide letter dated 01.07.2019. ME, Bijoliya in his certificate dated 27.08.2019 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF Bhilwara and DCF Neemuch (M.P) in their certificates dated 20.09.2019 and 09.06.2020, respectively have stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. DCF, MNP, Kota in his certificate dated 19.01.2021 has stated that MHTR/ Jawahar Sagar Sanctuary is at a distance of 8.0 Km from the applied lease area and National Chambal Ghariyal Sanctuary is at a distance of 33.95 Km from the applied lease area. The ESZ of MHTR has been notified.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The SEAC also went through para 4 (i)/ (ii)/ (iii) and (iv) of the OM dated 08.08.2019 of the MoEF & CC which requires that the Expert Appraisal Committee would examine the proposal from environmental angle including impact of developmental activity/ project on the Wildlife and its habitat, if any, and recommend appropriate protection and conservation measures and that these recommendations shall be explicitly mentioned in the EC letter. Since the project falls within a distance of 10 Km from the boundary of National Park/ Wildlife Sanctuary and outside notified ESZ, the following specific conditions shall also be applicable in terms of OM dated 08.08.2019 of the MoEF & CC: 1. The mining activity should be carried out in a manner so that the water regime/system of the sanctuary is not disturbed. The mining activity should not adversely affect any existing water course, water body, catchment etc. The PP shall while carrying out mining activity ensure compliance of the provisions of Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1981, Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1974 and the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 so that the wildlife in the area is not adversely affected. 2. The processes like blasting, drilling, excavation, transport and haulage resulting into noise, should be carried out in such an manner so that such activities do not disturb wild animals and birds particularly during sunset to sunrise. The level of noise should be kept within the permissible limits. 3. The mining activity should not create any obstacle in the way of free movement of wildlife and adversely affect wildlife corridors. 4. The mineral waste/ slurry should be dumped only at the designated places only and such waste dumps should be reclaimed in accordance with the conditions of the mining plan/ consent issued by the RSPCB under the Water and Air act. 5. The PP shall cooperate with the concerned DCF, Wildlife in their efforts towards protection and conservation of wildlife in the Sanctuary/ Park. 6. The PP shall ensure that the transporter and labor employed by him should not damage flora and fauna in the ESZ and the Wildlife Sanctuary/ National Park.
The SEAC considered the certificate dated 10.03.2021 issued by ME, Bijoliya. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Parasmal Lasod S/o Shri Bapu Lal Lasod for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L. No.- 05/2018, Ref. No. 2018100001073, Area- 2.33370 ha., Production Capacity- 2,79,693 TPA (ROM) {Saleable 70,164 TPA, Waste 46,776 TPA and OB 1,62,754 TPA} at Khasra No. 260, 260/1, 260/2, 260/3, 261 & 262 ,Near Village Katbada, Tehsil Bijoliya, District Bhilwara, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 44211), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. The PP shall also abide by the special conditions as mentioned in OM dated 08.08.2019 and as noted in the above mentioned observations. Name of Proponent:- Shri Parasmal Lasod S/o Shri Bapu Lal LasodR/o-185, Jain Colony, Kansya, Bijoliya, Bhilwara, (Raj.).Email – [email protected], Consultant Name:- Gaurang Environmental Solutions Pvt. Ltd. Add-102, SNG, Shree Ratna, Apartment, Near Tambi Petrol pump, Teetal factory, Jhotwara road, Jaipur, [email protected].
Agenda no. 14. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(19129)/ 2019-20
Project Name- ToR for Quratz & Feldspar Mining Project, Plot No. 86, Area 4.0566 ha., Production capacity- 1,67,100 TPA(ROM) {Quartz and Feldspar-1,00,250 TPA Waste 66,850 TPA} at Khasra No. 34, N/v.- Rama, Tehsil- Raipur, District- Bhilwara, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 60317)
Project Proponent Name- M/s Shrinath Mining, Add.- Neelkanth, 209-210, 2nd Floor, Bhawani Singh Road, Jaipur, Distt.- Jaipur, (Raj.) Email- shrinathmines086@gmail. com Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur,Nasik). email:- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 01.07.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting.
Agenda no. 15. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(19130)/ 2019-20
Project Name- ToR for Quratz & Feldspar Mining Project, Plot No.- 82, Area 4.2632 ha., Production capacity- 167080 TPA(ROM) {Quartz and Feldspar-100260 TPA waste 66820 TPA} at Khasra No. 28, N/v.- Rama, Tehsil- Raipur, District- Bhilwara, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 60313)
Project Proponent Name- Smt. Shruti Agarwal W/o Shri Vinay Agarwal, Add.- 131, Barkat Nagar, Tonk Phatak, Jaipur, Distt.- Jaipur, (Raj.) Email- shrutiagarwal0086@gmail. com
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur,Nasik). email:- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 01.07.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting.
Agenda no. 16. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18714)/ 2019-20
Project Name: - Environmental Clearance for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L. No.- 1635, Area- 0.18 ha, Production Capacity- 1800 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No.- 119/736, Near Vill.- Fidusar, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Jodhpur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 178680).
Project Proponent Name- Smt. Mohani Devi W/o Shri Pabu Ram, Add.- Baba Ramdev Mandir Ke Pas Buurtiya, Sur Sagar, Distt.- Jodhpur (Raj.), [email protected].
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik)., Email- [email protected].
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 01.07.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing lease. The mining lease was granted over an area of 0.18 ha. for mineral Sandstone in favour of Sh. Rana Ram Meel S/o.- Sh. Bhoma Ram vide order dated 12.12.1974. The lease was transferred to Sh. Mohan Lal S/o.- Asu Lal Balai vide order dated 24.04.1991. The lease was further transferred to Sh. Pabu Ram vide order dated 22.12.1997. After death of Sh. Pabu Ram lease was transferred to Smt. Mohni Devi vide order dated 26.04.2007. The QL is valid up to 31.03.2023.
The PP has submitted application for Environmental Clearance for Sandstone Mining Project, Q.L. No.- 1635, Area-0.18 ha, Production Capacity- 1800 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No.- 119/736, Near Vill.- Fidusar, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Jodhpur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 178680).
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The project is covered under B2 category. The Simplified mining Scheme has been approved by the AME, Jodhpur vide letter dated 04.02.2019. ME, Jodhpur in his certificate dated 20.02.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF (WL), Jodhpur, in his certificate dated 18.06.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by ME, Jodhpur on 20.02.2020, there is no other mining lease and the total area of the mining lease in the cluster is 0.18 ha.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of W.P. (Civil) No. 114.2014 Common Cause Vs Union of India in its judgment dated 02.08.2017 has directed that in case mining activity has been carried out or its expansion has been affected without obtaining Environmental Clearance of the regulatory authority, such activities are illegal and 100% penalty has to be levied in such cases. Since the project is less than 5.0 ha., it came under the purview of the EIA Notification on 09.09.2013, therefore, the PP is required to submit production figures from the base year i.e. 2012-13 onwards in order to secure compliance of the mandate of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The SEAC, therefore, in view of the above asked the PP to submit certified production figures from 2012-13, within a period of 45 days failing which project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Agenda no. 17. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(14956)/ 2019-20
Project Name- EC for Sandstone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 4/1987, Area- 5.20 ha., Production Capacity- 48,402.5 TPA (ROM){Mineral- 33,622.5 TPA, O.B./Waste- 14,780 TPA} at Khasra No.- 130 mi, 130/1, 131, 138, 141, 129 & 137, near vill.- Parana, Tehsil- Talera & Distt.- Bundi, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 59074).
Project Proponent Name- M/s Salasar Minerals, Add.- Flat No. 306, Elanza Apartment, Shreenathpuram- Block-C, Kota, Distt.- Kota, (Raj.) , Email- salasarminerals487 @gmail.com.
Consultant Name- M/s Overseas Min- Tech Consultans 501, 5th Floor, Apex Tower, Tonk Road, JaipurRaj. Email:- [email protected].
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing mine. The PP has stated that the mining lease no. 4/1987, Near Village – Parana, Tehsil- Talera, District- Bundi was initially sanctioned in favour of Shri Gurubachan Singh for a period of 13.01.1972 to 12.01.1977 vide letter dated 03.02.1972. First renewal was made for a period 13.01.1977 to 12.01.1987 vide letter dated 31.08.1977 and second renewal for a period 13.01.1987 to 12.01.1997 vide order dated 23.06.1987. By order dated 23.08.2012, the period of Mining Lease was extended from 13.01.1987 to 12.01.2017, under Rule 16 (2). Due to death of Sh. Gurubachan Singh, the original lessee, the mining lease was allotted to Mrs. Sunder Kaur W/o Late. Sh. Gurubachan Singh. The mining lease was again transferred to M/s Salasar Minerals, Kota vide order dated 03.04.2013. The Mining Lease period was extended from 13.01.1972 to 31.03.2025 vide letter No. 5220 dated 01.12.2017.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 5.20 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification, 2006 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificates dated 26.10.2020 and 09.04.2021 of ME, Bundi, production of mineral from 2005-06 (base year) was nil and continued to do so up to 2020-21. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has stated that as per the RMCR, 2017 the lease period was auto extended from 13.01.1987 to 12.01.2037.
The PP has applied for EC for Sandstone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 4/1987, Area- 5.20 ha., Production Capacity- 48,402.5 TPA (ROM){Mineral- 33,622.5 TPA, O.B./Waste- 14,780 TPA} at Khasra No.- 130 mi, 130/1, 131, 138, 141, 129 & 137, near vill.- Parana, Tehsil- Talera & Distt.- Bundi, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 59074). The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Kota vide letter dated 15.07.2020. ME, Bundi- II in his certificate dated 08.04.2021 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF (WL), MNP Kota in his certificate dated 07.10.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. It is further stated in the certificate that Mukundara Hills Tiger Reserves is at a distance of 10.27 Km from the applied lease area. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The SEAC had considered the project in its 144th meeting and in pursuance to the decision taken their in, prescribe the ToR vide letter dated 28.12.2016 for undertaking EIA/EMP studies as per OM dated 12.08.2014, 08.10.2014 and 07.11.2014. The ToR was valid for a period of three years for submission of EIA/ EMP report after public consultation.
Since the PP failed to submit the said EIA/ EMP report within three years period of the validity of ToR, the PP again vide letter dated 30.11.2019 made application for extension of validity of ToR for a further period of one year.
The SEAC, considered the matter of extension of validity of ToR by further one year in its 4.44th meeting held on 28-31 July and 05.08.2020 and in pursuance of the decision in the meeting, extended period of validity of ToR by one year vide letter dated 31.08.2020.
The certificate dated 08.04.2021 issued by ME, Bundi- II states that, there is no cluster formation in terms of Notification dated 01.07.2016. The PP, however, during presentation in its 4.44th meeting had informed that the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster is 44.91703 ha. and in support of which shows composite map along with table showing details of other mining leases in 500 meter periphery prepared by AME, Bundi. On the submission of the PP the SEAC, therefore, asked the PP to conduct EIA study and prepare Environment Management Plan for the entire cluster in order to capture all the possible externalities.
In pursuance to issue of ToR vide letter dated 28.12.2016 the PP had collected one season post monsoon primary base line data of the ambient air quality PM2.5, PM10, SO2 and NOX, Water Quality, Noise level, Soil quality and Flora and Fauna were collected during October 2019 to December 2019.
The PP following the above decision got public notice published in 22.10.2019 editions of The Dainik Bhaskar and Rashtradoot for holding public hearing for the entire cluster for ascertaining material concerns for local affected persons and it such concerns into account in the EIA/EMP report.
Public hearing was accordingly held on 28.11.2019 at 03.00 PM in Rajiv Gandhi Seva Kendra, Gram Panchayat Bhawan, Panchayat Budhpura, Tehsil Talera, District Bundi, in reference to application for EC for mining activity by M/s Salasar Minerals, under the Chairmanship of Sh. Rajesh Joshi, Add. District Collector, Bundi and Sh. Vijay Sharma, Regional officer, RSPCB, Kota, was also present during public hearing.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
During public hearing public representative and also other persons belonging to the area did not raise any objection against the project and supported the project saying that it will bring about employment to the inhabitants of the area.
The PP has now submitted application for EC along with final EIA/ EMP reports, proceedings of public hearing and other documents of 12.12.2020. The SEAC in view of above passed the following resolution.
The PP has not submitted certificate from the DCF, WL, Kota regarding existence or otherwise of National Park or Wildlife Sanctuary from the applied lease area. The SEAC, therefore, decided to ask the PP to submit the same within a period of 45 days failing which the project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Agenda no. 18. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(15455)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Application for EC for Enhancement production capacity of mineral Ball clay and China Clay from 20,000 TPA to 3,99,999.9 TPA (ROM) {Ball Clay, China Clay, Red & Yellow Ochre- 99,999.9 TPA and Silica Sand- 3,00,000 TPA} and inclusion of mineral Red & Yellow Ochre and Silica Sand in the EC dated 26.07.2006 and 25.10.2016 granted by the MoEF & CC, with production capacity of 3,00,000 TPA, M.L. No.- 14/08, Area- 33.03 ha., at Khasra No.- 154, 786, 789, 801, 802, 819, 1005/784, 796, 155, 156, 783, 784, 800, 803, 818, 785, 790, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 157, 158, 255, 264, 265, 266, 267, Add.- Village- Mudh, Tehsil- Kolayat, District- Bikaner, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 54461).
Project Proponent Name- Shri Narendra Malik, Add.- VPo- Diyatara, Tehsil- Kolayat, Distt.- Bikaner, (Raj.) Email- [email protected]
Consultant Name- M/s Overseas Min- Tech Consultans, Add.- 501, 5th Floor, Apex Tower, Tonk Road, Jaipur (Raj.) Email:- [email protected]
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
1. Category /Item No.(In Schedule): 1(a) B1 2 Location of Project Mudh Ball Clay, China Clay, Red & Yellow Ocher & Silica Sand Mine, M.L. No. -10/98, M.L. Area- 33.03 Hect 3 Project Details ML. No. / Production Capacity Khasra No.- 154, 786, 789, 801, 802, 819, 1005/784, 796, 155, 156, 783, 784, 800, 803, 818, 785, 790, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 157, 158, 255, 264, 265, 266, 267, Proposed production capacity- 99,999.9 TPA (Ball Clay, China Clay, Red and Yellow Ochre) & 3,00,000 TPA (silica sand mineral) Total Proposed Production 99,999.9 + 3,00,000 = 3,99,999.9 TPA (ROM) 4 Project Cost: 1.10 Cr. 5 Water Requirement & Source: 6.58 KLD 6 Fuel & Energy:- 0.5 KLD (HSD) 7 Application No. & Date & Document Submitted:- Proposal No: SIA/RJ/MIN/54461/2019 8 Information About Aravalli Certificate. Aravalli letter was issued by ME Bikaner vide letter no. ME/Bikaner/Minor/M.L/10/98/1389 Dated on 14.11.2018 9 Date of Air/Water/Noise/Monitoring March 2021 to May 2021 10 Information About 500 mts Composite Map 500 Map was issued by ME/Bikaner/Minor/M.L/10/98/1389 Dated on 14.11.2018 11 Environment Management Plan EMP Cost :- Capital Cost is 12.95/- Lac Recurring cost is 9.45/- Lac per years. Recurring cost in S. No. Particulars Capital Cost in Lac. Lac per years 1 Pollution control ( water sprinkling for 0.50 0.90 dust suppression ) 2 Pollution monitoring (Air. Water ,Noise, -- 0.75 Soil) 3 Plantation & Green Belt Development 5.45 6.0 4 Fencing and Maintains 1.0 0.60 5. Fencing for Jojari Bandh (Token Money) 6.0 1.20 Total 12.95 Lac. 9.45 Lac/annum
12 Green Belt/ Plantation Capital Cost-5.45 Lac & Recurring Cost-6.0/- Lac/Annum Places of Plantation:- Plantation will be carried out during mining process by Narendra malik. Total 10890 planted at safety barrier zone area All the responsibility of plantation will be undertaking by
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
lessee of the mine and under guidance of mines manager and safety officer. Along the lease On Backfilled area Outside the lease area Inside Dumps Total Year boundary Area No. of Area No. of Area (Ha.) No. of Area No. of Area No. of (Ha.) (Ha.) Trees Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees Trees 2021 to 2021 2.178 2178 ------2.178 2178 2022 to 2023 2.178 2178 ------2.178 2178 2023 to 2024 2.178 2178 ------2.178 2178 2024 to 2025 2.178 2178 ------2.178 2178 2025 to 2026 2.178 2178 ------2.178 2178 onwards Total 10.89 10,890 ------10.89 10,890 Plantation will be carried out during mining process by Shree Narendra Malik. Total 10,890 plants will be planted at safety barrier zone during five year and backfilled area at the end of life of mine. As per Office Memorandum 16.01.2020: Commitment by PP The mining lease holders shall after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activates and restore the land to a condition which is for growth of fodder, Flora, Fauna etc.” 13 Budgetary Breakup For Labor Labor Welfare Capital Cost is 3.0/-Lac, and Recurring Cost is 2.72 lac/annum. Capital Cost Recurring Cost S. No. Facility Provided for Laborers Rs/- Lakh/year Rs/-Lakh/Year Drinking water provided by 1. --- 1,60,000 Tanker 2. First Aid Box -- 2,000 3. Rest Shelter 1,50,000/- 50,000 4. Washroom Facilities for laborers 1,00,000 25,000 Safety Shoes, hand gloves, Dust 5 50,000 20,000 mask, Ear plugs, Helmet 6 Insurance - 15,000 Total 3,00,000 2,72,000
Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing mine. Initially the project granted for mineral Ball Clay, China Clay, Red & Yellow Ocher & Silica Sand Mine, M.L.No.10/98 (OLD) 14/08 (New), production Capacity (99,999.9 TPA (clay)), 3,00,000 TPA (silica sand), M.L. Area- 33.03 ha., khasra No. 154, 786, 789, 801, 802, 819, 1005/784, 796,155, 156, 783, 784, 800, 803, 818, 785, 790, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 157, 158, 255, 264, 265, 266, 267, Near Village – Mudh, Tehsil- Kolayat, District- Bikaner (Raj.). The mining lease was initially granted Government order dated 17.1.1969 and lease agreement was registered on 17.6.1969 vide order dated 27/01/1990 in favour of M/s. Tahla Ram & Sons R/o Rathkhana Colony, Bikaner for a period of 10 years w.e.f.17/06/1989. The first renewal agreement was executed on 12/07/1994 and registered on 09/09/1994. M/s Tahla Ram & Sons had dissolved on 11/02/1985 and firm has requested that the mining lease sanctioned in their favour may please be mutated in between partners as per the agreement deed executed between them and whereas the State Government vide order dated 28/06/1994 had conveyed sanctioned of mutation of the aforesaid mining lease in favour of Shri Amar Nath Chandna S/o Late Shri Tahla Ram Chandna and mutation agreement in favour of Shri Amar Nath Chandna S/o Late Shri Tahla Ram Chandna R/o Rathkhana Colony, Bikaner executed on 12.1.1995 and registered on 28/04/1995. Shri Amar Nath Chandna S/o Late Shri Tahla Ram Chandna R/o Rathkhana Colony, Bikaner was transferred the above said mining lease to Shri Madhu Sudan Asopa S/o Shri Satya Narain Asopa R/o Bagree Mohalla, Napasar Ki Kothi, Goga-Gate, Bikaner. The State Government (Director, Mines & Geology Dept. Udaipur) was transfer the lease vide dated 21/10/1995 to Shri Madhu Sudan Asopa S/o Shri Narain Asopa R/o Bagree Mohalla, Napasar Ki Kothi, Goga-Gate, Bikaner. The mining lease transfer deed was executed and registered on 18.11.1995. Shri Madhu Sudan Asopa S/o Shri Narain Asopa was transferred the mining lease to Shri Narendra Malik S/o Late Shri Sultan Singh vide order dated 23.11.2007. The mining lease transferred deed was executed on 18.02.2008 and registered on 13.03.2008. As per Govt. of Rajasthan Rules RMMCR 2017 by which as per rule 9 (3) period of mining lease has extended up to dated 31/03/2025.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The MoEF & CC, vide order dated 26.07.2006 had granted EC to Sh. Madhusudan Asoopa for mineral Mudh China Clay and Ball Clay having production capacity of 20,000 TPA under the Notification of 1994, subject to the conditions mentioned there in. The MoEF & CC vide order dated 25.10.2016 transferred the said EC to Sh. Narendra Malik subject to additional conditions.
The PP has submitted compliance report, vide letter dated 25.09.2019, of the MoEF & CC. The report states that minor non compliance have been detected (not of immediate danger to health and safety of the people). It is further stated in the report that the letter has been issued to the project authorities for taking corrective measures.
The project being one of major mineral (before 10.02.2015) having lease area of 33.03 ha, came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 27.01.1994 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificates dated 09.08.2019 and 28.06.2021 of ME, Bikaner the production of mineral in the year 1993-94 (base year) was 689 Ton. Production of mineral exceeded in comparison to base year’s production level in the years 1995-96 (2800 Ton), 1996-97 (4750 Ton), 1997-98 (4800 Ton), 1998-1999 (6500 Ton), 1999-2000 (5159 Ton), 2000-01 (6000 Ton), 2001-02 (7100 Ton), 2002-03 (6850 Ton), 2003-04 (12550 Ton). Increase in the production of mineral, in comparison to base year’s production level, during these years, was affected without obtaining prior EC in violation of the provisions of the EIA Notification 1994. The production of mineral, thereafter, has however, being either less than to base years production level or as per the quantity specified by the MoEF & CC in its letter dated 26.07.2006. The project, therefore, is one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that the activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The OM dated 13.05.2018 of the MoEF & CC provides that the following additional conditions in ToRs/ ECs to be issued for mining projects under the Provisions of Notification dated 14.03.2017 of the MoEF & CC. i. The PP shall give an undertaking by way of affidavit to comply with all the statutory requirements and judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others before grant of ToR/EC. The undertaking inter-alia include commitment of the PP not to be repeat any such violation in future. ii. In case of violation of above undertaking/ affidavit, the ToR/EC shall be liable to be terminated forthwith. iii. The environmental clearance will not be operational, till such time the project proponent complies with all the statutory requirements and judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others. iv. The department of Mines & Geology shall ensure that the mining operations shall not commence till the entire compensation levied, if any, for illegal mining, is paid, by the project proponent through the Department of Mines and Geology, in strict compliance of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others. The Common Cause judgment has ruled that if any mining operation is carried out in violation of the EP Act, 1986, FC Act, 1980, Water Act, 1974 and Air Act, 1986 than that mining operation is illegal or unlawful. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has further held that any person who raises, without any lawful authority, any mineral from any land in that event such person is liable to pay 100% price of the mineral as compensation. The SEAC has thus appraised the project in the light of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The PP has now applied for EC for Enhancement production capacity of mineral Ball clay and China Clay from 20,000 TPA to 3,99,999.9 TPA (ROM) {Ball Clay, China Clay, Red & Yellow Ochre- 99,999.9 TPA and Silica Sand- 3,00,000 TPA} and inclusion of mineral Red & Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Yellow Ochre and Silica Sand in the EC dated 26.07.2006 and 25.10.2016 granted by the MoEF & CC, with production capacity of 3,00,000 TPA, M.L. No.- 14/08, Area- 33.03 ha., at Khasra No.- 154, 786, 789, 801, 802, 819, 1005/784, 796, 155, 156, 783, 784, 800, 803, 818, 785, 790, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 157, 158, 255, 264, 265, 266, 267, Add.- Village- Mudh, Tehsil- Kolayat, District- Bikaner, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 54461). The DMG, Udaipur vide letter dated 28.08.2017 issued LOI for inclusion of mineral Silica Sand in the said mining lease. The validity of LOI has been further extended, vide order dated 27.01.2021, for a period of six months from 27.01.2021. The mining scheme and progressive mine closure plan for mineral Ball Clay, China Clay, Red & Yello Ochre and Silica Sand has been approved by the SME, Bikaner vide letter dated 22.12.2017. ME, Bikaner in his certificate dated 14.11.2018 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Bikaner in his certificate dated 20.08.2019 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site. The SEAC considered the certificate dated 19.08.2019 issued by ME, Bikaner. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
The SEAC had considered the project in its 4.19th meeting held on 19-22 August, 2019. In pursuance to the decision taken in the meeting ToR was issued vide letter dated 03.09.2019 for undertaking Environment Impact Assessment and preparation of Environment Management Plan and also Ecological damage, Remediation plan and Natural and Community Resource Augmentation Plan.
The PP following the above decision got public notice published in 04.02.2020 edition of Rajasthan Patrika and 04.02.2020 edition of Dainik Yugpaksh.
Following issue of ToR by SEAC the PP collected the base line data during the period from March, 2019 to May, 2019 and got the public hearing conducted on 06.03.2020 in the Office of Gram Panchayt Kotdi, Tehsil Kolayat, District Bikaner under the Chairmanship of Smt. Sunita Choudhary, Addl. District Magistrate, (City) Bikaner. Sh. Prema Lal Regar, RO, RSPCB, Bikaner was also present during public hearing.
The issues raised by the local in habitants, commitments made by the PP and action plan for fulfilling these commitments are as follows:
S.No Name and Address Point Represented Replies from Project Proponent 1. No complaint and Shri Kalu Ram As per Public welfare regular health checkup Resident of Village- works shall be is arranged time to Mudh undertaken in union time. with DMFT and Mining Association. The Budget for welfare is cost is 6.0 Lacs.
2. Benefit is not going to As per this regard the Shri Faujiram local people of the tax Employment ship given to Resident of Village- taken by the govt. from local villagers told by Mudh the mines. Project Proponent.
The D.M.F.T. Fund Due to mines we are contributed by the facing the problems of lessees is used by the Allergy and asthma. District Central Committee as per rules. Local people Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
shall be employed in the mine so as to benefit the local people.
The Budget for CER is Capital Cost is 6.0 Lacs.
3. Shri Kishan Lal Roadside proposed for Gram Sevak, Kotri plantation shall plantation and be undertaken. plantation shall be undertaken under this Water Pond of head. As regards Jogeri Dham plantation by the side should be of roads, plantation be develop. undertaken when proposal is received by D.M.F.T.
Water Pond shall be developed in co-ordination with Mining Association . The Budget for Plantation is 4.54 Lac. 4. Shri Durga Lal No complaint is As per Public welfare Meghwal there. Treatment works shall be Gram Kotri facility is also undertaken in union extended apart with DMFT and from medical Mining Association. The Budget for welfare is checkups. cost is 6.0 Lacs.
5. Shri Parmaram Gram Kotri The lessee has Public welfare works been doing public shall be undertaken in welfare works and union with DMFT and providing drinking Mining water facility etc. Association. to villagers in The Budget for welfare is summers. Lessee cost is 6.0 Lacs. should ensure implementation of public
The PP in the report regarding damage assessment and Remediation Plan stated that the total budget for Remediation Plan, Natural Resource Augmentation Plan, Community Resource Augmentation Plan and plan for upgradation of environment against Economic benefit derived due to violation of the EIA notification is Rs. 5,40,000/.
The SEAC also noted the provisions of para 13(3) of the EIA Notification dated 14.03.2017 and 08.03.2018 of the MoEF & CC which provide that in cases of violation, action will be taken against the PP by respective State or State Pollution Control Board under the provisions of section 19 of the Environment (Protection), Act, 1986 and further no consent to operate or occupancy certificate will be issued till the project is granted EC.
Resolution:
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The SEAC after taking into consideration the documents & additional documents submitted by the PP, outcome of public hearing, final EIA/EMP reports, reports of Remediation Plan - Natural Resource Augmentation Plan - Community Resource Augmentation Plan - Economic Benefit derived due to violation, clarification by the PP during presentation and after detailed deliberations, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Narendra Malik for Enhancement production capacity of mineral Ball clay and China Clay from 20,000 TPA to 3,99,999.9 TPA (ROM) {Ball Clay, China Clay, Red & Yellow Ochre- 99,999.9 TPA and Silica Sand- 3,00,000 TPA} and inclusion of mineral Red & Yellow Ochre and Silica Sand in the EC dated 26.07.2006 and 25.10.2016 granted by the MoEF & CC, with production capacity of 3,00,000 TPA, M.L. No.- 14/08, Area- 33.03 ha., at Khasra No.- 154, 786, 789, 801, 802, 819, 1005/784, 796, 155, 156, 783, 784, 800, 803, 818, 785, 790, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 157, 158, 255, 264, 265, 266, 267, Add.- Village- Mudh, Tehsil- Kolayat, District- Bikaner, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 54461), after finalization, by SEIAA, of the amount recommended by the SEAC, in the observations for Remediation Plan and Natural & Community Resource Augmentation Plan and after deposition of Bank Guarantee of finalized amount with the RSPCB as per the Provisions of the Notification dated 14.03.2017 and 08.03.2018 by the PP, subject to the conditions mentioned in the EC letter dated 26.07.2006 and transfer of EC letter dated 25.10.2016 of the MOEF & CC and subject to the conditions mentioned at Annexure ‘A’ and the conditions mentioned hereinbelow:
The SEAC further resolved to recommend to SEIAA to endorse a copy of EC to the RSPCB for taking action against the PP in terms of the Notification dated 14.03.2017 and 08.03.2018 of the MoEF & CC, in accordance with the provisions of section 19 of the Environment (Protection), Act, 1986.
Specific Conditions in terms of Notifications dated 14.03.2017 and 08.03.2018 of MoEF & CC:
1. The PP shall allocate and spend an amount of Rs. 5,40,000/- towards remediation plan, environmental upgradation plan and natural & community resource augmentation plan within a span of three years, as per the details given below:
Remediation Plan and Budgetary Provision: S. No. Particulars Remediation Budget (INR)
1. Air Environment 1. Regular watering of transport road using water tanker = Rs.35,000/- 2. Covering of loaded tippers with tarpaulins = Rs. 15,000 /- 3. Plantation around periphery= Rs.30,000/-
2. Soil Plantation and stabilization of top soil= Rs. 25,000/- Environment
3. Noise Earplugs for labour= Rs. 15,000/- Environment
4. Socio-Economic Organizing health check-up camps in village Mudh- Rs. 30,000/- Environment
5. Water Construction of septic tank & soak pit = Rs. 40,000/- Environment
6. Biological Plantation and green belt development within premises = Rs.20,000/- Environment
Total Rs. 2,10,000/-
Year wise Remediation Plan and Budgetary Provision: S. Activity Year – Wise Implementation Budget Total No. (INR) Budget 1st year 2nd year 3rd year (INR) Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
1. Air Environment 50,000 15000 15000 80,000
2. Soil Environment 10,000 7,500 7,500 25,000
3. Noise Environment 10000 2500 2500 15,000
4. Socio-Economic Environment 10,000 10,000 10,000 30,000
5. Water environment 20000/- 10000/- 10000/- 40,000
6. Biological Environment 10000 5000 5000 20,000
Total 2,10,000/-
Year Wise Natural Resource Augmentation Plan:
Year – Wise Implementation Budget Total S. Activity (INR) Budget No. 1st year 2nd year 3rd year (INR) 1. Avenue Plantation (650 m) – 65 10,000 10,000 10,000 30,000 plants on each side of the road.
2. Maintenance of Avenue 5000 5000 5000 15,000 Plantation. 3. One rain water harvesting in the 40,000 5000 5000 50,000 Govt. middle School Mudh. along with maintenance. Total 95,000
Year Wise Community Resource Augmentation Plan: Year – Wise Implementation Budget S. Total Budget Activity (INR) No. (INR) 1st year 2nd year 3rd year 1. Construction One Room with 50,000 50,000 50,000 1,50,000 Baramda in Govt. Middle School Mudh. 2. Toilet facilities in Govt. Middle 25,000 5,000 5,000 35,000 School Mudh.
Total 1,85,000
Economic Benefit derived due to violation: Cost of environment protection measures and other activities is approximately Rs 50,000 to be spent for Furniture (100 set), inverter double battery, fan-10 sets, in Govt. Middle School in Mudh. i.e. Govt. school / building in village Mudh.
NET SUMMARY OF THE PLAN: S. Particulars Proposed Budget (INR) No. 1. Remediation Plan 2,10,000/- 2. Natural Resource Augmentation Plan 95,000/- 3. Community Resource Augmentation Plan 1,85,000/- 4. Economic Benefit Derived due to violation 50,000/- Total INR 5,40,000/-
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
2. The said plan shall be completed in three years whereas the Bank Guarantee shall be for five years. 3. The Bank Guarantee of Rs. 5,40,000/- is to be deposited by the PP towards Remediation plan, Natural & Community Resources Augmentation Plan and the amount of economic benefit derived due to violation of EIA Notification with the RSPCB before the EC is granted by SEIAA. The Bank Guarantee shall be released by the RSPCB after successful implementation of the Remediation plan and Community Resources Augmentation Plan and after recommendation by the Regional Office of the Ministry, Expert Appraisal Committee or State Level Expert Appraisal Committee and approval of the regulatory authority. 4. The PP shall give an undertaking by way of affidavit to comply with all the statutory requirements and judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others before grant of ToR/EC. The undertaking shall inter-alia include commitment of the PP not to be repeat any such violation in future. 5. In case of violation of the above undertaking/ affidavit, the ToR/EC shall be liable to be terminated forthwith. 6. The environmental clearance will not be operational, till such time the project proponent complies with all the statutory requirements and judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others. 7. The department of Mines & Geology shall ensure that the mining operations shall not commence till the entire compensation for illegal mining, is paid, by the project proponent through the Department of Mines and Geology, in strict compliance of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others.
Agenda no. 19. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18813)/ 2019-20
Project Name- ToR for Soap Stone & China Clay Mining Project, ML. No.- 443/2010(Old ML. No.- 1/90), Area- 67.875 ha., Production capacity- 1,50,0000 TPA, Near Vill.- Nathun, Tehsil- Jahazpur, Distt.- Bhilwara, (Raj.). (Proposal No.- 58568)
Project Proponent Name- M/s Mahadev Mining Works, Add.- Near Bus Stand, Jahazpur, Tehsil- Jahazpur, Distt.- Bhilwara (Raj.)Email-Not Given Consultant Name- M/s Overseas Min- Tech Consultans , Add.- 501, 5th Floor, Apex Tower, Tonk Road, Jaipur Raj.Email:- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 29.06.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting.
Agenda no. 20. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18199)/ 2019-20
Project Name:- Environmental Clearance/ TOR for Bhankri Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 23/99, Area- 1.00 ha., Production Capacity- 1,11,873 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No.- 253, Near Village- Bhankri, Tehsil- Dausa, District- Dausa (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 161170).
Project Proponent Name:- Sh. Narayan Lal Meena S/o Sh. Ratan Lal Meena, Add.- Aam Ka Jhahera, Tehsil- Nadhoti, District- Karoli, (Raj.)Email- [email protected]
Consultant Name:- M/s. N.S. Enviro-Tech Laboratories & Consultant, Add.- Corpo Office- P No 69/318, V.T. Road Chouraha, Madhyam Marg, Mansarovar Jaipur, (Raj.)Email- [email protected], [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing lease. The mining lease was granted over an area of 1.0 ha. for mineral Masonry stone in favour of Sh. Ramphool Meena S/o.- Sh. Sawanta vide order dated 24.09.1999 & 28.02.2000. The lease was executed on 28.02.2000 & registered on 03.03.2000 for 20 years. Lease transferred to Sh. Murari Lal Meena S/o.- Sh. Ratan Lal Meena vide order dated 22.08.2003 & 04.02.2004. The transfer lease was executed on 06.02.2004 & registered on 21.02.2004. Lease was again transferred to Sh. Narayan Lal Meena S/o Sh. Ratan Lal Meena vide order dated 13.08.2015.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 1.0 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificate dated 04.01.2021 of AME, Dausa, production of mineral in the year 2012-13 (base year) was 33,504 Ton. Thereafter production of mineral exceeded to 42,000 Ton in the year 2013-14, in comparison to base year’s production level, in violation of the provisions of the EIA Notification. Production of mineral thereafter, up to, 24.01.2021, has either been less than base years production level or nil. The project, therefore, is one of violation of the EIA Notification. The project is therefore being dealt with as a case of violation of EIA notification/ Common Cause Judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has submitted application for Environmental Clearance/ TOR for Bhankri Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 23/99, Area- 1.00 ha., Production Capacity- 1,11,873 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No.- 253, Near Village- Bhankri, Tehsil- Dausa, District- Dausa (Raj.)(Proposal No.- 161170). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Jaipur vide letter dated 28.05.2020. DCF, Dausa in his certificate dated 27.12.2019 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
During presentation the SEAC noted that the cluster certificate issued by AME, Dausa, on 18.12.2020 neither have any reference of Notification dated 15.01.2016 and 01.07.2016 of the MoEF & CC nor the certificate is clear as to whether there is cluster formation or not. Besides this the Aravalli certificate dated 24.12.2019 issued by AME, Dausa is vague and does not clearly state that the applied lease area does not fall in Aravalli hills. The SEAC, therefore, decided to ask the PP to submit Aravalli certificate and Cluster certificate clearly stating whether the applied lease falls in Aravalli or not and whether there is cluster formation or not, within a period of 45 days failing which the project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Agenda no. 21. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18579)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environmental Clearance for expansion of Koliya Masonry Stone Mining Project from 3000 TPA to 1,00,360 TPA(ROM), M.L. No.- 37/1993, Area- 1.00 ha., at Khasra no.- 645, Near Vill.- Koliya, Tehsil- Didwana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.), (Proposal No. -168207)
Project Proponent Name- Shri Kamlesh Kumar Panwar, Add.- Near Railway Station, Tehsil- Didwana, District- Nagaur (Raj.), [email protected]
Consultant of Name:- M/s. N.S. Enviro-Tech Laboratories & Consultant, Add.- Plot No- 51,Ganeta House, Shiv Colony,Near Patrakar Colony Road,Mansarovar,Jaipur (Raj.), Email- [email protected], [email protected]
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
1. Category /Item No.(In Schedule): 1(a) B2 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
2 Location of Project KOLIYA Masonry Stone Mine Project ML No 37/1993, Near village- Koliya, Tehsil- Didwana, District- Nagaur, Rajasthan 3 Project Details ML. No. / Production Capacity Production of Mine – Proposed-100360, Existing-3000 TPA of Masonry Stone Existing Mining lease area – 1.00hectare 4 Project Cost: 10.00 Lacs 5 Water Requirement & Source: 3.00 KLD 6 Fuel & Energy:- 0.5 KLD (HSD) 7 Application No. & Date & Document Proposal No: SIA/RJ/MIN/168207/2020, Submitted:- 8 Information About Aravalli Certificate. Aravalli letter was issued by ME Nagaur, vide letter no. ME/ Nagaur /Map /2015/ Minor/M.L.-37/1993/663 on dated 18/05/2015 9 Date of Air/Water/Noise/Monitoring 10/12/2018 10 Information About 500 mts Composite Map 500 M Map was issued by ME Nagaur, vide letter no. ME/NGR/DRG/2015/Minor/M.L37/1993 on dated 18/05/2015 11 Environment Management Plan EMP Cost :- Capital Cost is 0.45 Lac Recurring cost is 0.40 Lac per years. Recurring cost S. No. Particulars Capital Cost in RS. in Rs. per years . 1 Pollution control ( water sprinkling for dust -- 12,000 suppression ) 2 Pollution monitoring (Air. -- 10,000 Water ,Noise, Soil) 3 Greenbelt Sr. Particulars Amount No 8,000 1 Plant 8,000 330 2 Treegaurd 7,000 330 3 Water Tanker 6,000 4 Maintains & 4,000 security Total 25,000
4 Occupation health 10,000/- 5,000 5 Miscellaneous (Fencing, etc.) 10,000/- 5,000 Total 45,000/- 40,000/-
12 Green Belt/ Plantation 0.25Lac Places of Plantation: About 330 saplings will be planted in an area of 0.330 ha (33% of applied area) upto the end of 5 years. About 330 Sapling will be planted outside the lease boundary at Gram panchayat Mandabasni (Swai Chak indokli nadi Mandabasni) Along the On Outside the Top Soil lease Backfilled Total lease area Dumps boundary area Year Area No. No. of Area Area No. of Area No. of Area No. of (Ha. of (Ha.) (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees ) Trees Trees 2021-22 ------0.066 66 -- -- 0.066 66 2022-23 ------0.066 66 -- -- 0.066 66 2023-24 ------0.066 66 -- -- 0.066 66 2024-25 -- -- 0.066 66 0.066 66 2025-26 -- -- 0.066 66 0.066 66 Total ------0.360 330 -- -- 0.360 330 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
As per Office Memorandum 16.01.2020: Commitment by PP The mining lease holders shall after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activates and restore the land to a condition which is for growth of fodder, Flora, Fauna etc.” 13 Budgetary Breakup For Labor Labor Welfare Capital Cost is 0.27 Lac, and Recurring Cost is 0.20 lac. S. Capital Cost Recurring Cost Facility Provided for Laborers No. in RS. In RS. Per Year 1. Drinking water provided by Tanker 8,000/- 5,000/- 2. First Aid Box 2,500/- 1,500/- 3. Rest Shelter 5,000/- 2,500/- 4. Washroom Facilities for laborers 6,500/- 4,000/- Safety Shoes, hand gloves, Dust 5 5,000/- 2,000/- mask, Ear plugs, Helmet 6 Insurance --- 5,000/- Total 27,000/- 20,000
Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal submitted by the PP and also the presentation made by him through VC/Electronic media in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan.
This is an existing lease. The mining lease was granted over an area of 1.0 ha. for mineral Masonry Stone in favour of Sh. Kamlesh Kumar Panwar S/o Sh. Sundaram Panwar vide order dated 25.01.1994. The lease was registered on 01.03.1994 for 20 years i.e. from 01.03.1994 to 29.02.2024.
The DEIAA, Nagaur vide letter dated 08.06.2016 had granted EC in favour of Sh. Kamlesh Kumar Panwar S/o Sh. Sundaram Panwar for production capacity of 3000 TPA of Masonry Stone, M.L. No.- 37/1993, Area- 1.00 ha., at Khasra no.- 645, Near Vill.- Koliya, Tehsil- Didwana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.).
The PP has submitted compliance report, vide letter dated 04.03.2021, of the RO, RSPCB, Kishangarh certifying compliance of conditions of the earlier EC issued vide letter dated 08.06.2016.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 1.0 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificates dated 04.10.2016 and 28.06.2021 of ME, Nagaur, production of mineral in the year 2012-13 (base year) was 780 Ton. Thereafter production of mineral has either been less than or nil in comparison to base year’s production level or as per EC dated 08.06.2016 issued by DEIAA, Nagaur up to, 2020-21. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has now submitted application for Environmental Clearance for expansion of Koliya Masonry Stone Mining Project from 3000 TPA to 1,00,360 TPA (ROM), M.L. No.- 37/1993, Area- 1.00 ha., at Khasra no.- 645, Near Vill.- Koliya, Tehsil- Didwana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.), (Proposal No. -168207). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 15.07.2019. ME, Nagaur in his certificate dated 18.05.2015 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Nagaur in his certificate dated 13.03.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The SEAC considered the certificate dated 21.08.2020 issued by ME, Nagaur. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1,Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Kamlesh Kumar Panwar for expansion of Koliya Masonry Stone Mining Project from 3000 TPA to 1,00,360 TPA (ROM), M.L. No.- 37/1993, Area- 1.00 ha., at Khasra no.- 645, Near Vill.- Koliya, Tehsil- Didwana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.), (Proposal No. -168207), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent: - Shri Kamlesh Kumar Panwar, Add.- Near Railway Station, Tehsil- Didwana, District- Nagaur (Raj.), [email protected], Consultant of Name:- M/s. N.S. Enviro- Tech Laboratories & Consultant, Add.- Plot No-51,Ganeta House, Shiv Colony, Near Patrakar Colony Road, Mansarovar, Jaipur (Raj.), Email- [email protected], [email protected].
Agenda no. 22. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(16313)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environmental Clearance (EC) for Moras Calcite Mine (M.L.No. 01/80), Near Village Moras, Tehsil Pindwara & District Sirohi (Raj.), and Lease Area-49.25 hect, production capacity-107600 TPA.(Proposal No. 33357)
Project Proponent Name- M/s. 20 Microns Limited R/o.-9-10, Gidc Industrial Estate Waghodia-391760 District Vadodara (Gujarat).E. [email protected] Consultant Name- M/s. N.S. Enviro- Tech Laboratories & ConsultantReg.Office Address-:A- 8, Neha Medical Building, Opposite ESI Hospital, Hasanpura Road, Sodala, Jaipur- (Raj.).E. [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 29.06.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting.
Agenda no. 23. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(16217)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environment Clearance for expansion & inclusion of mineral Quartzite for Panchota Masonry Stone & Quartzite Mines, (ML no.- 65/07,Area- 1.0 ha.), Production Capacity- 56,000 TPA(ROM) at Khasra no.- 31, Near Village Panchota, Tehsil- Nawa, District- Nagaur Rajasthan.(Proposal No. 35415)
Proponent name :- Shri Mahesh Kumar, S/o. Sh. Lala Ram Meena R/o Panchota, Tehsil Nawa, District Nagaur (Raj.). E. [email protected]
Name of Consultant:- M/s N.S. Enviro-Tech Laboratories& Consultant Corp. Office: Applied No. 69/318, V.T. Road Chouraha, Madhyam Marg, Mansarovar, Jaipur Rajasthan. E. mail- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 29.06.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting. Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Agenda no. 24. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18198)/ 2019-20
Project Name: EC for Bhankri Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 33/95, Area- 1.0 ha., Production capacity- 1,07,715 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No.- 251, 252 & 253, Village- Bhankri, Tehsil- Dausa, District- Dausa, (Raj.) (Proposal No.-161108)
Project Proponent Name:- Smt. Usha Sharma W/o Shri Banwari Lal Sharma, Add.- Behind Roy Nursing Home, Opp. P.G. Collage, Distt.- Dausa (Raj.), Email- [email protected].
Consultant Name:- M/s. N.S. Envro- Tech Laboratories & Consultant, Corpo OFFICE Add Plot No. 69/318, V.T. Road Chouraha, Madhyam Marg, Mansarovar, Jaipur (Raj.). Email:- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing lease. The mining lease was granted over an area of 1.0 ha. for mineral Masonry stone in favour of Sh. Lallulal Saini S/o.- Sh. Chiranji lal Saini vide order dated 20.12.1995. The lease was registered on 04.09.1996 for 20 years. Lease was transferred to Smt. Usha Sharma W/o Shri Banwari Lal Sharma vide order dated 11.03.2005. The mining lease is valid from 04.09.1996 to 03.09.2026.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 1.0 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificate dated 30.12.2020 of AME, Dausa, production of mineral in the year 2012-13 (base year) was 28 Ton. Thereafter production of mineral has been nil from 2013-14 to 2019-20. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Bhankri Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No.- 33/95, Area- 1.0 ha., Production capacity- 1,07,715 TPA(ROM) at Khasra No.- 251, 252 & 253, Village- Bhankri, Tehsil- Dausa, District- Dausa, (Raj.) (Proposal No.-161108). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Jaipur vide letter dated 28.05.2020. DCF, Dausa in his certificate dated 27.12.2019 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
During presentation the SEAC noted that the cluster certificate issued by AME, Dausa, on 18.12.2020 neither have any reference of Notification dated 15.01.2016 and 01.07.2016 of the MoEF & CC nor the certificate is clear as to whether there is cluster formation or not. Besides this the Aravalli certificate dated 24.12.2019 issued by AME, Dausa is vague and does not clearly state that the applied lease area does not fall in Aravalli hills. The SEAC, therefore, decided to ask the PP to submit Aravalli certificate and Cluster certificate clearly stating whether the applied lease falls in Aravalli or not and whether there is cluster formation or not, within a period of 45 days failing which the project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Agenda no. 25. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(15673)/ 2019-20
Project Name- ToR for Mevda Kalan Granite Mining Project, M.L. No.- 48/2018, Area-1.6231 ha., Production Capacity- 1,90,400 TPA (ROM){Saleable mineral- 67,900 TPA, Soil- 81,760
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
TPA & Waste- 40,740 TPA} at Khasra no.- 2420 & 2421/3604, Near village-Mevda Kalan, Tehsil- Kekri, Dist- Ajmer,(Raj) (Proposal no.-91823).
Project Proponent Name- M/S Shri Mahi Minerals, R/o-A-93 Talwandi Kota, Dist-Kota, (Raj), [email protected]
Consultant Name- Vardan Environet Add:- 142, Sushant Lok-III,sec.57, Gurgaon (Haryana) E-Mail:- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
The PP has submitted application for ToR for Mevda Kalan Granite Mining Project, M.L. No.- 48/2018, Area-1.6231 ha., Production Capacity- 1,90,400 TPA (ROM){Saleable mineral- 67,900 TPA, Soil- 81,760 TPA & Waste- 40,740 TPA} at Khasra no.- 2420 & 2421/3604, Near village-Mevda Kalan, Tehsil- Kekri, Dist- Ajmer,(Raj) (Proposal no.-91823). The SME, Ajmer vide order dated 18.09.2018 has issued LoI to the PP for mining of Granite. SME, Ajmer vide order dated 23.04.2021 has extended the validity of LOI for 18 months (i.e. up to 17.09.2021). The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 25.09.2018. AME, Sawar in his certificate dated 11.06.2019 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Ajmer in his certificate dated 25.11.2019 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
It is a project having capital cost of Rs. 70 lacs. The AME, Sawar in his certificate dated 11.06.2019 has stated that total area of all the mining leases in the cluster is 12.9199 hectare. The project, therefore, requires to be dealt with as ‘B1’ category project.
The SEAC therefore, observed that the PP is required to conduct Environmental Impact Assessment Study and prepare Environmental Management Plan for the entire cluster in order to capture all the possible externalities. These reports are required to incorporate carrying capacity of the cluster, transportation and related issues, replenishment and recharge issues, geo- hydrological study of the cluster.
Keeping in view the presentation made by the PP and examination of documents submitted by him the SEAC was of the view that the PP is required to get public hearing conducted and carry out detailed EIA and prepare comprehensive EIA report as per the provisions of the EIA notification 2006. The EIA/EMP may be prepared by the state or state nominated agency or group of PP in the cluster or the PP in the cluster. As per the provisions of the EIA Notification the PP should get one public consultation done covering all the mining leases in the cluster and prepare final EIA/EMP reports.
The SEAC, in pursuance of the Notification dated 17.02.2020 of the MoEF & CC resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of ToR as mentioned in Annexure ‘B’.
Agenda no. 26. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(18463)/ 2019-20
Project Name:- ToR for China Clay (Minor Mineral) Mining Project, ML No.- 26/2018, Ref. no.-201810000880, Area- 3.5926 ha., Production Capacity- 69,900 TPA (ROM) {Saleable Mineral- 62,910 TPA & Waste- 6,990 TPA} at Khasra No.- 258 & 259, Near Vill.- Pateli, Tehsil- Jayal, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.-56080).
Project Proponent Name:- Shri Shivji Ram S/o Shri Sanwata Ram Jat, Add.- Pateli, Tehsil- Jayal, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.)Email – [email protected].
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Consultant Name:- VARDAN ENVIRONET, Add: Plot No.-82-A, Sector- 5, IMT Manesar, Gurgaon-122003 (Haryana).Email:- [email protected].
Observations & Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
The PP has applied for ToR for China Clay (Minor Mineral) Mining Project, ML No.- 26/2018, Ref. no.-201810000880, Area- 3.5926 ha., Production Capacity- 69,900 TPA (ROM) {Saleable Mineral- 62,910 TPA & Waste- 6,990 TPA} at Khasra No.- 258 & 259, Near Vill.- Pateli, Tehsil- Jayal, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 56080). The Additional Director (Mines), Jaipur has granted LOI of mineral on 19.02.2019 and corrigendum dated 24.05.2019 regarding lease area. The LOI has been extended vide order dated 26.04.2021 and now is valid up to 18.08.2021. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 06.03.2019. ME, Nagaur in his certificate dated 20.06.2019 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Nagaur in his certificate dated 18.06.2019 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
It is a project having capital cost of Rs. 65 lacs. The ME, Nagaur in his certificate dated 12.10.2020 has stated that total area of all the mining leases in the cluster is 95.1936 hectare. The project, therefore, requires to be dealt with as ‘B1’ category project.
The SEAC therefore, observed that the PP is required to conduct Environmental Impact Assessment Study and prepare Environmental Management Plan for the entire cluster in order to capture all the possible externalities. These reports are required to incorporate carrying capacity of the cluster, transportation and related issues, replenishment and recharge issues, geo- hydrological study of the cluster.
Keeping in view the presentation made by the PP and examination of documents submitted by him the SEAC was of the view that the PP is required to get public hearing conducted and carry out detailed EIA and prepare comprehensive EIA report as per the provisions of the EIA notification 2006. The EIA/EMP may be prepared by the state or state nominated agency or group of PP in the cluster or the PP in the cluster. As per the provisions of the EIA Notification the PP should get one public consultation done covering all the mining leases in the cluster and prepare final EIA/EMP reports.
The SEAC, in pursuance of the Notification dated 17.02.2020 of the MoEF & CC resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of ToR as mentioned in Annexure ‘B’.
Agenda no. 27. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(19309)/ 2019-20
Project Name- EC for expansion in Production Capacity from 1,50,000 TPA to 2,99,998 TPA of Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No. 174/06, Area- 1.000 ha. at Khasra No. 1549/1456, N/v.- Tal Ki Dhani, Rasulpur, Tehsil- Khetri, District- Jhunjhunu, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 200535)
Project Proponent Name- Smt. Ratni Devi W/o Shri- Gopi Siloniya, Add.- Bhagwati Bhawan, Fatehpur Road, Sikar, Distt.- Sikar, (Raj.) Email- [email protected]
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur,Nasik),email:[email protected].
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
1. Category / Item no.(in B2 Schedule):
2. Location of Project Near Village-Tal Ki Dhani, Rasalpura, Tehsil-Khetri, Distt.-Jhunjhunu (Rajasthan) 3. Project Details ML Area-1.0 ha
M.L. No. /Production M.L. No.-174/2006 capacity Expansion In Production of Masonry Stone from 1,50,000 TPA to 2,99,998 TPA
Khasra No- 1549/1456
4. Project Cost: Rs.30Lakhs
Details Available in Submitted Documents – (PFR)
5. Water Requirement Total Water Required- 3.0 KLD
& Source Drinking & Domestic Use- 2.5 KLD
Dust Suppression & Plantation- 0.5 KLD
6. Fuel & Energy:- Fuel will be required for mining machineries and No electricity will be required because mining activities will operate in day shift only
7. Application No. & Date & Proposal No. SIA/RJ/MIN/200535/2021 documents submitted :- Hardcopy submitted on 2/03/2021
8. Information about ME/Jhunjhunu/Map/M L No-174/06/825dated 31.8.2020 Aravalli Certificate.
9. Date of Air/Water/Noise Monitoring was conducted by Noida Testing Laboratories., Approved by Monitoring NABL, Noida
10. Information about 500 ME/ Jhunjhunu/DRGdated 31.8.2020 mts composite map Area falling within 500 m is 1.0 ha
11. Environment Annual expenditure of in Rs.- 1,50,000 per year Management Plan (EMP) S. No. Description of Item Cost Per Year (inRs.) 1 Air Pollution Control –Water Sprinkling 60,000 3 Environmental Monitoring and Management 60,000 Occupational Health and Safety 4 Green Belt Development 30,000 Total 1,50,000
12. Corporate Environment Annual expenditure of in Rs.- 60,000 per year Responsibility (CER)
13. Green Belt/ Plantation Annual expenditure of in Rs.- 40,000 per year
Year Un-worked Waste Inside Top Soil Total Area Dump Dump Dumps (Outside) (Reclaimed Area) Area No. Area No. Area No. Area No. Area No. (Ha.) Of (Ha.) Of (Ha.) Of (Ha.) Of (Ha.) Of Trees Trees Trees Trees Trees Existing - - 0.10 100 - - - - 0.10 100
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
I - - 0.12 120 - - - - 0.12 120 II - - 0.11 110 - - - - 0.11 110 III ------IV ------V ------VI years ------onwards
Total 0.33 330 - - - - 0.33 330
Note:- As per O.M. dated 16.01.2020 “The Mining Lease holders shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc.
Note:-At the end of third year Green Belt /Plantation will be done in 0.33 ha. Area i.e. (330 trees) out of which 0.10 ha.( 100 Plants) Already Planted(Existing) & remaining i.e. 0.23 ha. (230 Plants) Plantation will be plated outsidse the lease area. Native specie which are more suitable to the local environment are preferred to be planted such as like Neem (Azadiracta indica), Pipal (Ficus religiosa), Babool (Acacia nilotica), Kher (Acacia catechu) etc.
Source-Approved Mining Plan with Progressive Mine closure plan
14. Budgetary Breakup for Annual expenditure of in 55,000 per year Labour S.No. Facilities Provided For Labourers Cost (in Rs.)
1. Shelter, Supply of PPE equipment's 25,000 (Earplugs, Masks, Safety shoes) 2. Supply of fuel for cooking 15,000 3. Drinking Water & Sanitation Facility- Mobile 15,000 Toilets Total 55,000
15. Present Status :- This is an Existing mining lease for an area 1.0 ha. The mining lease was grant in favour ofSmt. Ratni Devi W/o. Shri Gopal Sinoliya by State Govt. of Rajasthan. The mining lease was Registered and executed for 50 years.The project got Environmental Clearance under Aravali Notification vide letter No.F 14(332) Env 2009 Dated 09.11.2009 also project got Environmental clearance under EIA notification. The mining plan with Progressive Mining plan was approved under rule 37 G (1) and Rule37 E (vi) of RMMCR 1986 (amended 2012) vide the order no SME/Jai/ Simplified M.P./P-63/2021/768 Dated-18/02/2021. As per EIA Notification dated 14.09.2006, as amended from time to time this mining project comes under ‘B2’ Category. Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
This is an existing mine. Initially lease was granted in favour of Smt. Ratni Devi W/o Shri- Gopi Siloniya over an area of 1.0 ha. for mineral Masonry stone. The lease deed was executed on 16.05.2007 for 20 years.
The SEIAA, Rajasthan vide letter dated 19.05.2016 had granted EC to Smt. Ratni Devi W/o Shri- Gopi Siloniya for mining of Masonry stone with production Capacity of 1,50,000 TPA, M.L. No. 174/06, Area- 1.0 ha. at Khasra No. 1430, N/v.- Tal Ki Dhani, Rasulpur, Tehsil- Khetri, District- Jhunjhunu, (Raj.).
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 1.0 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificate dated 26.02.2021 of ME, Jhunjhunu, production of mineral from 2012-13 (when project came under the purview of EIA Notification) to 2019-20 has been nil. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has submitted compliance report, vide letter dated 28.06.2021, of the RO, RSPCB, Sikar certifying compliance of conditions of the earlier EC issued vide letter dated 19.05.2016.
The PP has submitted application for EC for expansion in Production Capacity from 1,50,000 TPA to 2,99,998 TPA of Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No. 174/06, Area- 1.000 ha. at Khasra No. 1549/1456, N/v.- Tal Ki Dhani, Rasulpur, Tehsil- Khetri, District- Jhunjhunu, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 200535). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Jaipur vide letter dated 18.02.2021. ME, Jhunjhunu in his certificate dated 31.08.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Jhunjhunu in his certificate dated 03.06.2021 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine and the nearest forest land is at a distance of 800 meter from the applied lease area. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The SEAC considered the certificate dated 31.08.2020 issued by ME, Jhunjhunu. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Smt. Ratni Devi W/o Shri- Gopi Siloniya, for expansion in Production Capacity from 1,50,000 TPA to 2,99,998 TPA of Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No. 174/06, Area- 1.0 ha. at Khasra No. 1549/1456, N/v.- Tal Ki Dhani, Rasulpur, Tehsil- Khetri, District- Jhunjhunu, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 200535), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent Smt. Ratni Devi W/o Shri- Gopi Siloniya, Add.- Bhagwati Bhawan, Fatehpur Road, Sikar, Distt.- Sikar, (Raj.), Email- [email protected], Consultant Name:- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik), email:- [email protected].
Agenda no. 28. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(19268)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Application for Transfer of EC/ToR from Sh. Lala Ram Choudhary to M/s Shri Balaji Stone crusher for Masonry Stone Mining Project, and enhancement of Production Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Capacity of mineral Masonry Stone from 99,000 TPA to 2,90,000 TPA (ROM) {2,75,500 Masonry Stone and 14,500 TPA Waste}, M.L. No.- 471/06, Area 1.00 ha., at Khasra No. 376/1/1, 373/1, N/v.- Kundala Ki Dhani, Tehsil- Neem Ka Thana, District- Sikar, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 60776).
Project Proponent Name: M/s Shri Balaji Stone Crusher, Add.- R/o -9, Leela Mention, Raj Bhawan Road, Civil Lines, Jaipur, Distt.- Jaipur (Raj.) Email.- [email protected]
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add.- Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). email:[email protected].
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing mining lease. Initially lease was granted in favour of Sh. Lala Ram Choudhary S/o.- Sh. Ghisaram Jat over an area of 1.0 ha. for mineral Masonary stone vide order dated 24.09.2009. Lease deed was executed on 18.12.2009 & registered on 23.12.2009 for 20 years. Further lease was transferred to M/s Shri Balaji Stone Crusher vide order dated 08.02.2019. Transfer deed was executed on 14.02.2019 & registered on 18.02.2019. Lease validity auto extended for 50 years i.e. from 23.12.2009 to 22.12.2059.
The DEIAA, Sikar vide letter dated 04.08.2016 had granted EC in favour of Sh. Lala Ram Choudhary S/o.- Sh. Ghisaram Jat for mining of Masonary stone with production Capacity 99,000 TPA, M.L. No.- 471/06, Area 1.00 ha., at Khasra No. 376/1/1, 373/1, N/v.- Kundala Ki Dhani, Tehsil- Neem Ka Thana, District- Sikar, (Raj.).
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 1.0 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificates dated 17.08.2012, 04.08.2015, 21.06.2017, 04.08.2018, 05.07.2019 and 24.07.2020 of ME, Sikar, production of mineral in the base year i.e. 2012-13 was nil, thereafter the PP mined out 4550 Ton of mineral in the year 2014-15 and 7800 Ton of mineral in the year 2015-16 without obtaining prior EC from the regulatory authority in violation of the provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006. Production of mineral, thereafter, has either been nil or less than the quantity sanctioned by DEIAA, Sikar in its EC dated 04.08.2016. The project is therefore being dealt with as a case of violation of EIA notification/ Common Cause Judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has applied for Transfer of EC/ TOR from Sh. Lala Ram Choudhary to M/s Shri Balaji Stone crusher for Masonry Stone Mining Project, and enhancement of Production Capacity of mineral Masonry Stone from 99,000 TPA to 2,90,000 TPA (ROM) {2,75,500 Masonry Stone and 14,500 TPA Waste}, M.L. No.- 471/06, Area 1.00 ha., at Khasra No. 376/1/1, 373/1, N/v.- Kundala Ki Dhani, Tehsil- Neem Ka Thana, District- Sikar, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 60776). The modified simplified mining scheme has been approved by the SME, Jaipur vide letter dated 24.07.2020. AME, Neem Ka Thana in his certificate dated 31.07.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Sikar in his certificated dated 02.09.2020 stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The SEAC considered the certificate dated 31.07.2020 issued by AME, Neem Ka Thana. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The SEAC examined the project in the light of OM dated 12.11.2020 of the MoEF & CC. This OM provides that while considering the application for EC under violation category as per Notification dated 14.03.2017 of the MoEF & CC, the SEAC may insist upon public hearing to be conducted only for those category of projects for which EIA Notification, 2006 itself requires public hearing to be conducted. The project, under consideration, is one of ‘B2’ category and being so does not require public hearing as per EIA Notification, 2006 read with various OM’s and guidelines issued by the MoEF & CC, from time to time.
Though the project document submitted by the PP is both for transfer of EC from Sh. Lala Ram Choudhary to M/s Shri Balaji Stone crusher for Masonry Stone Mining Project, and for enhancement of Production Capacity of mineral Masonry Stone from 99,000 TPA to 2,90,000 TPA (ROM) {2,75,500 Masonry Stone and 14,500 TPA Waste}, the project at present under consideration of SEAC is only for enhancement of production capacity. The project for transfer of EC shall be undertaken by the SEAC as and when the same is received from SEIAA.
The PP while submitting application for enhancement of production capacity of mineral Masonry Stone has not submitted report of compliance of conditions of EC as certified by the MoEF & CC/ RSPCB. The SEAC in view of this asked the PP to submit the same at the time of final presentation of the project for obtaining EC.
The SEAC, in view of the project being one of violation of the EIA notification as also in terms of Common Cause judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, decided that the PP is required to conduct Environmental Impact Assessment Study and prepare Remediation Plan, Natural Resource Augment Plan and Community Resource Augmentation Plan.
Keeping in view the presentation made by the PP/ Consultant and examination of documents submitted by them, the SEAC resolved to recommend to SEIAA for prescribing the ToR mentioned at ‘Annexure B’, as a case of violation of the EIA notification, for preparing comprehensive EIA/EMP reports and Assessment of Ecological Damage, preparation of Remediation Plan and Natural Community Resource Augmentation Plan as a case of violation, of the EIA notification.
Agenda no. 29. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(19102)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environmental Clearance for Sandstone Mining Project, QL No.- 2318, Area- 0.18 ha, Production Capacity-1697 TPA (ROM) at Near Vill.- Keru, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Jodhpur, (Raj.) (Proposal No.-192493)
Project Proponent Name- Smt. Kamla W/o Sh. Jagdish Ram, Add.- N/v- Keru, Tehsil & Distt.- Jodhpur(Raj.), [email protected].
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik), [email protected].
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 29.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing quarry license. Initially lease was granted in favour of Sh. Panji S/o Sh. Andaram Ji over an area of 0.18 ha. for mineral Sandstone vide order dated 30.09.1996. Further quarry license was transferred to Smt. Kamla W/o Sh. Jagdish Ram vide order dated 29.07.2005. Quarry license is valid for 31.03.2025.
The PP has submitted application for Environmental Clearance for Sandstone Mining Project, QL No.- 2318, Area-0.18 ha, Production Capacity-1697 TPA (ROM) at Near Vill.- Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Keru, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Jodhpur, (Raj.) (Proposal No.-192493). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining scheme has been approved by the ME, Jodhpur vide letter dated 21.06.2021. ME, Jodhpur in his certificate dated 18.12.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF (WL), Jodhpur in his certificate dated 18.06.2020 stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The SEAC considered the certificate dated 18.12.2020 issued by ME, Jodhpur. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of W.P. (Civil) No. 114.2014 Common Cause Vs Union of India in its judgment dated 02.08.2017 has directed that in case mining activity has been carried out or its expansion has been affected without obtaining Environmental Clearance of the regulatory authority, such activities are illegal and 100% penalty has to be levied in such cases. Since the project is less than 5.0 ha., it came under the purview of the EIA Notification on 09.09.2013, therefore, the PP is required to submit production figures from the base year i.e. 2012-13 onwards in order to secure compliance of the mandate of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The SEAC, therefore, in view of the above asked the PP to submit certified production figures from 2012-13, within a period of 45 days failing which project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Agenda no. 30. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(19103)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Enviornmental Clearance for Sand Stone Mining Project (QL. Area-1.00 ha, and Plot No.- 42, Khasra No.- 543) with Production Capacity of 77777 TPA (ROM) Near Vill.- Kasti, Tehsil- Baori Distt.- Jodhpur, (Raj.) by Sh. Laxmi Narayan (Proposal No.-192840)
Project Proponent Name- Sh. Laxmi Narayan, Add.- Raiko Ka Baas, Birai, Tehsil- Bhopalgadh, Distt.-Jodhpur(Raj.)[email protected]
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD, Add., Hall No.- 1NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik).Email- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP vide letter dated 29.06.2021 has submitted an application for deferment of the case. The SEAC agreed to the request of the PP and deferred the matter. The project shall be taken up again on receipt of his request for consideration of the project by the PP, in the subsequent proposed meeting.
Agenda no. 31. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(Cluster/Nagaur-6/No.of lease)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Application for obtaining EC/ approval of EIA-EMP with respect to the proposed China Clay Cluster No. 6 mining project Nagaur, Number of Lease 122, Cluster Area- 436.9278 ha., production capacity of Cluster- 72,88,005 TPA (ROM), N/v.- Firojpura charna, Borwa, Jayal, Jhunjala, Khera Narnoliya, Palri Jodha, Pateli, Chhota Kalan, Bhadana, Tehsil- Jayal, Mundwa & Nagaur, District- Nagaur, Raj., (Proposal No- 57305).
Project Proponent Name- Shri Gunsai Baba Society, Jhunjhala, through ME, Nagaur, Reg. Add- Office of Mining Engineer, Department of Mines and Geology, Khanij Bhawan, College raod, Nagaur, Dist- Nagaur, [email protected], me.nagour.rajasthan.gov.in.
Consultant Name- IN SITU ENVIRO CARE PVT.LTD., Add-E-7/829,Shahpura, Area Colony , Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh,[email protected] Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered the for obtaining EC/ approval of EIA-EMP with respect to the proposed China Clay Cluster No. 6 mining project Nagaur, Number of Lease 122, Cluster Area- 436.9278 ha., production capacity of Cluster- 72,88,005 TPA (ROM), N/v.- Firojpura charna, Borwa, Jayal, Jhunjala, Khera Narnoliya, Palri Jodha, Pateli, Chhota Kalan, Bhadana, Tehsil- Jayal, Mundwa & Nagaur, District- Nagaur, Raj., (Proposal No- 57305) in its 4.91st meeting held on 30.06.2021 through VC/ electronic media in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan.
The project was also considered earlier in terms of OM dated 12.12.2018 of the MoEF & CC by SEAC in its 4.23rd meeting held on 23-26th Sept., 2019 prescribing ToR for undertaking EIA studies and for preparing EMP as the size of the cluster in which the proposed project lies exceeded 5.0 ha. The SEAC, in pursuance to the decision taken in the meeting prescribed ToR vide letter dated 03.10.2019.
One season post monsoon primary base line data of the ambient air quality PM2.5, PM10, SO2 and NOX, Water Quality, Noise level, Soil quality and Flora and Fauna were collected during October 2017 to December 2017.
The PP following the above decision got public notice published in 25.06.2020 edition of The Rajasthan Patrika Nagaur and 26.06.2020 edition of Times of India and for holding public hearing for China Clay cluster no. 6 Nagaur cluster for ascertaining material concerns for local affected persons and it such concerns into account in the EIA/EMP report.
Public hearing for was accordingly held on 28.07.2020 at 11.00 AM in Office of Panchayat Samiti Village Mundwa, Tehsil Mundwa and District Nagaur, in reference to application for EC for mining activity for China Clay cluster No.6 Nagaur, Number of Leases 122, Cluster Area- 436.9278 ha., production capacity of Cluster- 72,88,005 TPA (ROM), N/v.- Firojpura charna, Borwa, Jayal, Jhunjala, Khera Narnoliya, Palri Jodha, Pateli, Chhota Kalan, Bhadana, Tehsil- Jayal, Mundwa & Nagaur, District- Nagaur, Raj., under the Chairmanship of Sh. Manoj Kumar, Add. District Magistrate, Nagaur. Sh. Rakesh Gupta, Regional officer, RSPCB, Kishangarh, was also present during public hearing.
The SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 10.06.2021 has approved mining plan for mining of Granite with respect to the said cluster. According to the information submitted by the PP, mining leases covered under the cluster do not fall in Aravalli hills and that there is no National Park/ Wildlife Sanctuary within the periphery of 10 Km from the mining leases in the cluster. No litigation is pending against the project and/ or land in which the project is proposed to be setup. The PP has given an undertaking that cluster EMP shall be implemented by the LOIs/ mining lease holders collectively in consultation and supervision of the concerned Mining Engineer.
The PP has submitted application for obtaining EC/ approval of EIA-EMP with respect to the proposed China Clay Cluster No. 6 mining project Nagaur, Number of Lease 122, Cluster Area- 436.9278 ha., production capacity of Cluster- 72,88,005 TPA (ROM), N/v.- Firojpura charna, Borwa, Jayal, Jhunjala, Khera Narnoliya, Palri Jodha, Pateli, Chhota Kalan, Bhadana, Tehsil- Jayal, Mundwa & Nagaur, District- Nagaur, Raj., (Proposal No- 57305). ME, Nagaur in his certificate dated 27.08.2019 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Nagaur in his certificate dated 08.04.2021 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site. Sh. Bhoora Ram Bhakar, President of Sri Gunsai Baba Clay Society, Jhunjala has taken the responsibility for implementation and execution of EMP/ ESR activity along with development of green belt with respect to cluster No. 6 of China Clay mining project comprising 122 mining leases, Cluster Area- 436.9278 ha., production capacity of Cluster- 72,88,005 TPA (ROM). Sh. Bhoora Ram Bhakar has also submitted an affidavit to this affect. According to the cluster certificate and map dated Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
09.06.2021 prepared by ME, Nagaur, total area of all the 122 mining leases in the cluster is 436.9278 ha. It is further stated in the certificate that the China Clay LOIs having area of 63.2822 ha., which were revoked and have also been included in the cluster by virtue of order dated 11.07.2019 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 5698/2018.
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP for cluster are as follows:
1. Category / Item no.(in Schedule): 1(a)B1 (Cluster)
2. Location of Cluster Revenue Village- Borwa, Jhunjhala, Khera Narnoliya, Pateli Chhaota Kalan, Rupathal Firojpura Charna, Palri Jodhra. Tehsil: Jayal & Mundwa, District-Nagaur, State – Rajasthan. 3. Cluster Details Cluster Area-436.9278 ha.
M.L. No. /Production capacity` of Cluster Production- 72,88,005 MTPA Cluster Mineral- China Clay
Total Leases- 122
Toposheet No.- 45E/16
4. Project Cost of Cluster 64 Crores for 122 China Clay Mines of Cluster
5. Water Requirement for Cluster & Total water requirement of Cluster is (apx.) 291 KLD.
Source 70 KLD is proposed for domestic uses, 121 KLD for dust suppression and 100 KLD for Plantation purposes.
Water will be procured from villages Gothad, Rupathal, Borwa and Tangla Gram Panchayat. Respective NOC has already been obtained from their Sarpanch.
6. Fuel & Energy for Cluster The mining operation at Cluster shall take place in the
day light (One shift only). Henceforth, No electricity is required.
Mining equipment as well as transportation vehicles shall be diesel operated.
7. Application No. & Date & documents Proposal No- SIA/RJ/MIN/57305/2019 submitted :- Submitted online on - 19.10.2020
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
8. Information about Cluster Map & Issue Date- 09.06.2021 Certificate Issuing Authority – Mining Engineer, Nagaur
Reference No- Ha.A./Nagaur./Maachi/EMP/2021/1364
Issue Date- 10.06.2021
Issuing Authority – Superintending Mining Engineer, Ajmer
Information about Approved Cluster Reference No- A KHA A/AJ./Nagaur./Cluater No-6 / Mine Plan 2021/ 3710
Issue Date- 27.08.2019
Issuing Authority – Mining Engineer, Nagaur
Reference No.- Kha.A./Nagaur./Maachi/2019/2053
9. Date of Air/Water/Noise Monitoring of ClusterInforma tion about Aravalli Certificate OctoberIssue Date 2017- 08 to.0 4December.2021 2017 of Cluster 10. Information about 500 mts composite IssueIssuing Date Authority- 09.06 –.2021 Deputy Forest Officer, Nagaur map of the Cluster Reference No. F/SURVEY/UWAS/2020-2021/2227 Issuing Authority – Mining Engineer, Nagaur
Environment Management Plan of the Total recurring cost for cluster EMP is Rs. 15 lakhs and 11. Reference No- Ha.A./Nagaur./Maachi/EMP/2021/1364 Cluster capital cost is Rs. 5,50,000/- lakh per annum. ThereS. is noDescription Wild Life Sanctuary /Capital National ParkRecurring in 10
Information about Forest land KMSNo radius of the Cluster – 6,Cost China (Rs. Clay, In Nagaur.Cost (Rs.
Involvement in the Cluster lakh) @ In lakh) @
Annual Annual
1 Air quality 3 monitoring
2 Water quality 2.5 monitoring
3 Noise level 2 abatement Date- 09.06.2021 4 Environment 2 No.-Kha.A./Nagaur./Maachi/EMP/2021/1364 ( Cluster monitoring and Map) management
5 Green 1 3 belt/Plantation (including plant cost, tree guard and its maintenance)
6 Dust suppression/ 1 2.5 water spray
7 Conservation of 3,50,000 local Flora and Fauna with peacock
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
conservation Plan
Total 5,50,000 15
12. Environmental Social Responsibility For each mine, INR 50,000 as Capital cost and INR (ESR) of the Cluster under EMP 10,000 is proposed as the Recurring cost under ESR activities activities.
The total Budget for Cluster 6 is approximately Rs. 73.2 lakhs/- per year.
Rain water harvesting, Construction of Toilets and maintenance, Medical camps and improvement of educationalS. Activities facilities areCapital need based Cost subject.Recurring No. INR @ Cost INR Annum @Annum
1 Construction Construction- Maintenance- of toilets and Rs 20,000/- Rs 5,000/- their regular maintenance
2 Monthly Rs 10,000/- -- medical camps
3 Improvement Rs 20,000/- Rs 5,000/- in educational facilities in the nearby schools
Total Rs 50,000/- Maintenance- Rs 10,000/-
4 Construction of rainwater harvesting at Rs 6,00,000/- Rs 50,000/- nearby 04 villages or school
Total Rs 6,50,000 per rainwater harvesting system
Shri Bhoora Ram Bhakar, President of Sri Gunsai Baba Clay Society, Jhunjala has taken the responsibility for implementation and execution of EMP/ ESR activity along with development of greenbelt with respect to Cluster No 6 of China Clay mining project comprising 122 mining leases, cluster area-436.9278 Ha, Production Capacity of Cluster- 72,88.005 TPA(ROM).
13. Green Belt/ Plantation in the Cluster Capital cost for each plant is taken @ Rs. 100 and recurring cost @ 200 = INR 300 each plant
12200 * 300 = 36,60,000/- For each year for Cluster
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Year No. of Capital Cost @ Recurring cost plants* Per Annum Per Annum
2021- 12200 2022
2022- 12200 2023
@ INR 100 PER 2023- 12200 @ INR 200 PER PLANT PLANT 12200 2024 12200 * 100 *200 2024- 12200 2025
2025- 12200 2026
Total 61000 12,20,000/- 24,40,000/=
Grand Total for 36,60,000/- for each year Cluster INR
Plant species of Neem, Sisham, Bel, Siris, Aam, Imli, Jamaun, Gulmohar and other native species shall be planted on the land allotted by Tahsildar , Mundwa at Veer Teja Mahila Sikshan evam Sodh Sansthan at Tehsil Mundwa, Nagaur on Khasra no. 1334, 1339 and 1342 having area of 150 Ha, (apx.)
14. Budgetary Breakup for Labour welfare Annual Expenditure for the cluster is approx Rs. 79.30 for Cluster lakh per year (@Rs 65,000 per lease for 122 mine lease). S. Facility for Capital Recurring No. Laborers
1 Safe drinking 14,30,000 2,50,000 water
2 Shelters 10,00,000 2,50,000
3 Health facility 4,00,000 1,00,000
4 Fuel for cooking 5,00,000
5 Sanitation facility 30,00,000 10,00,000
Total 58,30,000 21,00,000
Grand Total 79.30 Lakhs / Year
15. Present Status The proposal is for Environmental clearance of Cluster of 122 China Clay Mines of Nagaur District, Rajasthan.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The details of issue raised by the public and commitments made by the PP during public hearing and the action plan for implementation thereof are as follows:-
S.No. Name & Question/Remarks Reply Action Plan Budget Address of Stakeholder 1. Shri Pappu He asked about that In This regard the -- -- Ram Dukiya , what are the benefits consultant of this R/o Village- will get to the nearby project replied that by Firozpura areas peoples by this this project Charna project. employment will be generated & the economic situation of the peoples of nearby areas will be increased & CER works carried out by the project proponent of the cluster in the nearby areas also be helps to increase the social & environment aspects. 2. Shri Shaitan He asked about that In This regard the The green belt A budget of Rs. Ram, R/o- what is the Rules for consultant of this would be 17 Lakhs/year is Chuchara plantation project replied that developed at the proposed for plantation will be 33% of the total EMP activities done as the rules of mining lease out of which Rs. CPCB & plantation area. 4 Lakhs/year will be done in inside Under Greenbelt have been the cluster mining Development proposed for the leases area & if the programme local Green Belt land is short for the species of plants Development. desired plantation than would be plantation will also be preferred i.e. done in outside the Neem, Amla, cluster mining lease Jamun, Ashok, area. Gmelina (Gamharr), Karanj, Aam, Peepal, Bargad, Shisham etc. For better growth and maintenance of plants proper FYM, watering and cleaning will be done till the end of life of mine. The locations of greenbelt development programme are around the lease periphery, backfilled area, both side of internal village road, undisturbed area/non mining zone & nearby Govt. Schools & Gram Panchayats.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
3. Sh. Ramkumar, He asked about the In This regard the ------R/o-Rupathal generation of consultant of this employment. project replied that by this project employment will be generated & the economic situation of the peoples of nearby areas will be increased ADM, Nagaur also replied that by this cluster mining project the peoples of nearby areas will get employment as per their qualification. 4. Shri He asked about that In This regard the --- -- Omprakash , what the mitigation consultant of this R/o Village- measurers for project replied that to Firozpura controlling the dust control the dust Charna pollution are. pollution regular water sprinkling will be done on haul roads & unpaved areas. The dust masks will be provided to The labors working in the cluster mining project.
The PP following issue of ToR, has submitted application vide letter dated 03.12.2020 for obtaining EC along with the final EIA/ EMP report and the proceedings of public hearing.
The particulars of individual mining/ leases including their budget for EMP/ Labour welfare are as follows:
S.No Name of Particulars of individual ML in the Cluster China Clay Cluster-6, Nagaur Holder of M.L. Date of Nam Are Khasra Produc Project Mining Wheth Bud Budg ML No. sanctio e of a No./Topos tion Cost of Plan er EC, get et n Mine heet No. capacit Cluster Appro obatai for for ral y (Cummula ving ned, if EMP labo tive) in Author yes ur Crores ity name welf with of are date authori ty date 1 Subh 35/20 27/08/2 Chin 4.07 45 E/16 27767 SME, Yes 0.14 Laxmi 12 013 a 37 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 2 Amtulla 27/20 19/08/2 Chin 4.61 45 E/16 47588. SME, Yes 0.14 Minerals 12 013 a 47 75 Ajmer Pvt. Ltd. Clay 0.65 3 Jeevan 23/20 16/07/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 69350 SME, No 0.14 Mata 12 013 a 52 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 4 Neelkant 30/20 07/08/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 203805 SME, No 0.14 h Mines 13 014 a 07 Ajmer & Clay Minerals 0.65 5 Shri R.K. 9/201 - Chin 4.03 45 E/16 39134. SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 4 a 7 2 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 6 Gogaji 175/2 06/03/2 Chin 4.33 45 E/16 95295 SME, Yes 0.14 Minerals 013 014 a 81 Ajmer & Mines Clay 0.65 7 Balaji 123/2 12/05/2 Chin 4.0 45 E/16 30000 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 011 012 a Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 8 Shiv 117/2 12/05/2 Chin 4.24 45 E/16 25000 SME, Yes 0.14 0.65 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Shakti 011 013 a 81 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 9 Baba 03/20 28/03/2 Chin 4.01 45 E/16 50435. SME, Yes 0.14 Ramdev 12 013 a 51 1 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 10 Manavta 06/20 01/03/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 90000 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 12 014 a 05 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 11 Mahadev 05/20 14/10/2 Chin 4.03 45 E/16 95526 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 12 013 a 64 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 12 R.R.R. 29/20 30/09/2 Chin 4.04 45 E/16 49300 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 12 013 a 66 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 13 Guna 183/2 - Chin 4.01 45 E/16 21819. SME, No 0.14 Gunsai 013 a 3 2 Ajmer Baba Clay Mines & Minerals 0.65 14 Jai 38/20 05/06/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 38817. SME, Yes 0.14 Bhawani 13 014 a 43 21 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 15 Dev 07/20 27/05/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 53175 SME, Yes 0.14 Narayan 12 014 a 02 Ajmer Minerals Clay & Mines 0.65 16 Maa 178/2 25/07/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 87500 SME, Yes 0.14 Kripa 013 014 a 84 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 17 Gajanand 179/2 07/07/2 Chin 4.18 45 E/16 60000 SME, No 0.14 Mines 013 014 a 14 Ajmer Clay 0.65 18 Guru 116/2 19/08/2 Chin 4.45 45 E/16 45009 SME, Yes 0.14 Kripa 011 013 a Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 19 Sangawa 05/20 30/01/2 Chin 4.08 45 E/16 90045 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 13 014 a 43 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 20 Ganesh 02/20 17/12/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 151553 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 12 012 a 45 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 21 Munni 11/20 22/01/2 Chin 4.02 45 E/16 90005 SME, No 0.14 13 014 a 27 Ajmer Clay 0.65 22 Gunsai 03/20 27/08/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 90000 SME, No 0.14 Baba 10 013 a 17 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 23 Shree 10/20 Chin 4.01 45 E/16 75000 SME, No 0.14 Dadi Sati 12 a 68 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 24 Surya 26/20 14/08/2 Chin 4.12 45 E/16 90045 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 12 013 a 86 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 25 Sudarsha 172/2 05/06/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 28263. SME, Yes 0.14 n Mines 013 014 a 14 6 Ajmer & Clay Minerals 0.65 26 Vasudev 118/2 12/05/2 Chin 4.16 45 E/16 70472 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 011 012 a 8 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 27 Shiv 14/20 10/01/2 Chin 4.01 45 E/16 116505 SME, No 0.14 Shakti 13 013 a 77 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 28 Shri 29/20 05/06/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 38795. SME, No 0.14 Ramdev 13 014 a 21 88 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 29 Shri Shiv 22/20 05/06/2 Chin 4.50 45 E/16 90187 SME, No 0.14 Shankar 12 014 a 59 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
30 Vasudev 11/20 30/08/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 35000 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 17 008 a 01 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 31 Shri 10/20 05/06/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 90099 SME, No 0.14 Keshariy 13 014 a 22 Ajmer a Clay Kanwarji Mines & Minerals 0.65 32 Jai Sri 01/20 06/05/2 Chin 4.38 45 E/16 84000 SME, Yes 0.14 Balaji 07 007 a Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 33 Vishnun 22/20 13/11/2 Chin 4.14 45 E/16 100291 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 07 009 a .5 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 34 M/s Veer 110/2 05/07/2 Chin 3.99 45 E/16 36225 SME, Yes 0.14 Tejaji 007 008 a 78 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 35 Manda 14/20 13/09/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 48400 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 07 017 a 18 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 36 M/s Maa 10/20 17/10/2 Chin 4.85 45 E/16 144717 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 07 008 a 08 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 37 Dev 04/20 22/01/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 29023 SME, Yes 0.14 Narayan 12 014 a 07 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 38 Daduday 01/20 15/02/2 Chin 4.02 45 E/16 74000 SME, Yes 0.14 al China 06 007 a 08 Ajmer Clay Clay Splares 0.65 39 Balaji 05/20 14/02/2 Chin 4.0 45 E/16 15000 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 06 007 a Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 40 Daduday 08/20 30/07/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 201066 SME, Yes 0.14 al Khanij 06 007 a 03 Ajmer Udhyog Clay 0.65 41 Shri Ram 176/2 06/09/2 Chin 4.29 45 E/16 66000 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 013 014 a Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 42 J.P Mines 23/20 01/04/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 38835. SME, Yes 0.14 & 07 008 a 62 63 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 43 Ajay 13/20 01/07/2 Chin 4.54 45 E/16 19757 SME, Yes 0.14 Lodha 08 009 a 38 Ajmer Clay 0.65 44 Siddhi 04/20 03/04/2 Chin 4.27 45 E/16 30238 SME, Yes 0.14 Vinayak 08 009 a 2 Ajmer Enterpris Clay es 0.65 45 Sobha 115/2 12/05/2 Chin 4.38 45 E/16 60000 SME, Yes 0.14 Devi 011 012 a 39 Ajmer Clay 0.65 46 Baba 08/20 10/01/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 70005 SME, No 0.14 Ramdev 12 013 a 13 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 47 Chhotudi 24/20 15/07/2 Chin 4.04 45 E/16 42222 SME, Yes 0.14 12 013 a 09 Ajmer Clay 0.65 48 Ganpati 40/20 17/07/2 Chin 4.71 45 E/16 44334 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 12 013 a 2 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 49 Shri Ram 07/20 22/01/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 97312. SME, No 0.14 Prasad 13 014 a 19 5 Ajmer Clay 0.65 50 Ugra 01/20 22/01/2 Chin 4.35 45 E/16 70000 SME, No 0.14 Ram 13 014 a 61 Ajmer Clay 0.65 51 Binja 09/20 30/01/2 Chin 4.07 45 E/16 45000 SME, Yes 0.14 Ram Jat 13 014 a 52 Ajmer Clay 0.65 52 Sukhsaga 41/20 30/01/2 Chin 4.0 45 E/16 141327 SME, No 0.14 r 12 014 a .5 Ajmer Minerals Clay & Mines 0.65 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
53 Parma 01/20 25/07/2 Chin 4.62 45 E/16 90000 SME, No 0.14 Devi 12 013 a 8 Ajmer Clay 0.65 54 Charbhuj 13/20 30/01/2 Chin 4.69 45 E/16 44388 SME, Yes 0.14 a Mines 13 014 a 39 Ajmer & Clay Minerals 0.65 55 Maa 187/2 07/10/2 Chin 4.16 45 E/16 70000 SME, No 0.14 Shishani 013 014 a 34 Ajmer Mata Clay Mines 0.65 56 Shri 177/2 05/06/2 Chin 4.50 45 E/16 30729. SME, No 0.14 Barahpur 013 014 a 53 4 Ajmer i Baba Clay Mines & Minerals 0.65 57 D.M. 31/20 05/06/2 Chin 4.00 45 E/16 84000 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 13 014 a 16 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 58 Prakash 119/2 02/10/2 Chin 4.30 45 E/16 77700 SME, No 0.14 Chand 011 014 a 59 Ajmer Patwa Clay 0.65 59 Appar 43/20 05/06/2 Chin 4.05 45 E/16 26252. SME, No 0.14 Mines & 13 014 a 25 2 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 60 J.L. Daga 120/2 31/01/2 Chin 4.01 45 E/16 78700 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 011 014 a 42 Ajmer Minerals Clay Pvt. Ltd. 0.65 61 Hari Om 25/20 21/08/2 Chin 4.0 45 E/16 25062 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 12 013 a Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 62 Gajanand 12/20 30/01/2 Chin 4.1 45 E/16 45022 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 13 014 a Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 63 Asha 08/20 - Chin 4.0 45 E/16 100004 SME, Yes 0.14 Ram Jat 13 a Ajmer Clay 0.65 64 Ganpat 04/20 27/01/2 Chin 4.8 45 E/16 46530. SME, No 0.14 Ram & 13 014 a 63 Ajmer Ramdev Clay Mines & Mineral 0.65 65 Daisy 09/20 06/05/2 Chin 4.61 45 E/16 44688. SME, Yes 0.14 Minerals 07 007 a 79 Ajmer Pvt. Ltd. Clay 0.65 66 Jai Baba 34/20 30/09/2 Chin 4.16 45 E/16 41818 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 12 013 a Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 67 Shri Ram 173/2 08/01/2 Chin 4.37 45 E/16 42362. SME, No 0.14 Mines & 013 014 a 26 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 68 Balaji 31/20 17/07/2 Chin 4.18 45 E/16 44100 SME, No 0.14 Mines & 12 013 a 23 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 69 Laxmi 196/2 - Chin 4.18 45 E/16 162810 SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 013 a 79 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 70 Shri 192/2 - Chin 4.02 45 E/16 14782 SME, Yes 0.14 Ganga 013 a 25 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 71 Om Sai 16/20 - Chin 4.13 45 E/16 38775. SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 13 a 04 52 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 72 Shri 01/20 - Chin 4.71 45 E/16 22002. SME, No 0.14 Balaji 14 a 42 5 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 73 Mateshw 174/2 - Chin 4.00 45 E/16 38775. SME, Yes 0.14 ari Mines 013 a 08 52 Ajmer & Clay Minerals 0.65 74 Dariyav 171/2 - Chin 4.36 45 E/16 95262. SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 013 a 46 5 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 75 Jai 193/2 - Chin 4.34 45 E/16 38775. SME, Yes 0.14 Hanuma 013 a 6 52 Ajmer n Mines Clay 0.65 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
& Minerals 76 Nagaur 06/20 09/03/2 Kaoli 4.00 45 E/16 38868. SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 14 014 n 96 59 Ajmer Minerals 0.65 77 Khayam 08/20 18/09/2 Kaoli 4.01 45 E/16 38775. SME, Yes 0.14 Mines & 14 014 n 85 53 Ajmer Minerals 0.65 78 Kalu Ram 4/201 - Chin 1.67 45 E/16 47200 SME, No 0.14 8 a 7 Ajmer Clay 0.65 79 Ram 07/20 - Chin 1.37 45 E/16 48500 SME, No 0.14 Kishor 18 a 98 Ajmer Clay 0.65 80 Urja Ram 08/20 - Chin 1.22 45 E/16 48500 SME, No 0.14 18 a 9 Ajmer Clay 0.65 81 Hira Ram 09/20 - Chin 1.25 45 E/16 41875 SME, No 0.14 18 a 56 Ajmer Clay 0.65 82 Shrawan 11/20 - Chin 1.06 45 E/16 27600 SME, No 0.14 Ram 18 a 74 Ajmer Clay 0.65 83 Rampal 12/20 - Chin 1.01 45 E/16 30000 SME, No 0.14 18 a 82 Ajmer Clay 0.65 84 Kushal 15/20 - Chin 1.68 45 E/16 35000 SME, No 0.14 Ram 18 a Ajmer Clay 0.65 85 Hira Das 18/20 - Chin 1.72 45 E/16 50000 SME, No 0.14 18 a 65 Ajmer Clay 0.65 86 Asa Ram 21/20 - Chin 1.03 45 E/16 67500 SME, No 0.14 18 a 47 Ajmer Clay 0.65 87 Shivaji 26/20 - Chin 3.59 45 E/16 40600 SME, No 0.14 Ram 18 a 26 Ajmer Clay 0.65 88 S Ankit 32/20 - Chin 1.01 45 E/16 69900 SME, No 0.14 Jain 18 a Ajmer Clay 0.65 89 S Ankit 33/20 - Chin 1.01 45 E/16 54870 SME, No 0.14 Jain 18 a Ajmer Clay 0.65 90 Ganpat 35/20 - Chin 3.83 45 E/16 54870 SME, No 0.14 Ram 18 a 45 Ajmer Clay 0.65 91 Kailash 36/20 - Chin 1.00 45 E/16 42400 SME, No 0.14 18 a 06 Ajmer Clay 0.65 92 Ramniwa 37/20 - Chin 1.16 45 E/16 76945 SME, No 0.14 s 18 a 1 Ajmer Clay 0.65 93 Monika 38/20 - Chin 3.99 45 E/16 83805 SME, No 0.14 18 a 89 Ajmer Clay 0.65 94 Hanuma 39/20 - Chin 3.99 45 E/16 150319 SME, No 0.14 n Ram 18 a 96 Ajmer Clay 0.65 95 41/20 Chin 3.91 45 E/16 153304 SME, No 0.14 PremaRa 18 a Ajmer m Clay 0.65 96 Shankar 42/20 - Chin 1.34 45 E/16 90000 SME, No 0.14 Ram 18 a 17 Ajmer Clay 0.65 97 Keilash 43/20 - Chin 1.00 45 E/16 50000 SME, No 0.14 Dukiya 18 a 06 Ajmer Clay 0.65 98 Parma 44/20 - Chin 1.85 45 E/16 52400 SME, No 0.14 18 a 45 Ajmer Clay 0.65 99 Bhura 45/20 - Chin 1.65 45 E/16 45600 SME, No 0.14 Ram 18 a 35 Ajmer Clay 0.65 100 Pukhraj 48/20 Chin 1.69 45 E/16 57000 SME, No 0.14 18 a Ajmer Clay 0.65 101 Achuki 51/20 - Chin 1.68 45 E/16 61051. SME, No 0.14 18 a 11 05 Ajmer 0.65 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Clay 102 PanchaR 55/20 Chin 1.63 45 E/16 50000 SME, No 0.14 am 18 a Ajmer Clay 0.65 103 SukhRam 56/20 Chin 1.13 45 E/16 29250 SME, No 0.14 18 a Ajmer Clay 0.65 104 SahdevIn 58/20 Chin 1.55 45 E/16 85650 SME, No 0.14 aniyan 18 a 84 Ajmer Clay 0.65 105 Dayal 62/20 - Chin 1.00 45 E/16 27600 SME, No 0.14 Nath 18 a 05 Ajmer Clay 0.65 106 Balkishan 01/20 - Chin 1.03 45 E/16 30000 SME, No 0.14 ath 19 a 27 Ajmer Clay 0.65 107 Prakash 25/20 - Chin 1.00 45 E/16 46500 SME, No 0.14 Chaudha 19 a 07 Ajmer ry Clay 0.65 108 Shri Guru 09/20 - Chin 4.01 45 E/16 46107. SME, No 0.14 Gunsai 12 a 62 6 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 109 Sandan 188/2 - Chin 4.10 45 E/16 39150 SME, No 0.14 Mata 013 a 54 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 110 Puna 183/2 - Chin 4.01 45 E/16 34257. SME, No 0.14 Ram Jat 013 a 84 5 Ajmer Clay 0.65 111 Bharat 189/2 - Chin 4.00 45 E/16 36196. SME, No 0.14 Mines 013 a 25 4 Ajmer &Mineral Clay s 0.65 112 Hanuma 190/2 - Chin 4.53 45 E/16 19591. SME, No 0.14 n Mines 013 a 7 Ajmer & Clay Minerals 0.65 113 Ashok 191/2 - Chin 4.90 45 E/16 32992. SME, No 0.14 Mines & 013 a 08 8 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 114 Maa 21/20 - Chin 4.00 45 E/16 38775. SME, No 0.14 Sharda 14 a 7 52 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 115 Sachchiy 24/20 - Chin 4.00 45 E/16 38775. SME, No 0.14 ay Mata 14 a 68 52 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 116 Shree 07/20 - Chin 4.31 45 E/16 25042 SME, No 0.14 Hanuma 14 a 7 Ajmer n Mines Clay & Minerals 0.65 117 Ummeda 185/2 - Chin 4.00 45 E/16 24015 SME, No 0.14 Ram Jat 013 a 05 Ajmer Clay 0.65 118 Ummeda 184/2 - Chin 4.23 45 E/16 37134. SME, No 0.14 Ram Jat 013 a 76 8 Ajmer Clay 0.65 119 Prateek 05/20 - Chin 4.22 45 E/16 25810. SME, No 0.14 Mines & 14 a 78 5 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 120 Shri 186/2 - Chin 4.16 45 E/16 22178. SME, No 0.14 Salasar 013 a 56 3 Ajmer Balaji Clay Mines & Minerals 0.65 121 Arihant 10/20 - Chin 4.74 45 E/16 57531. SME, No 0.14 Mines & 14 a 18 6 Ajmer Minerals Clay 0.65 122 Chawand 04/20 - Chin 4.00 45 E/16 38775. SME, No 0.14 a Mata 14 a 48 52 Ajmer Mines & Clay Minerals 0.65 64 Crores Resolution
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The SEAC, upon appraisal of the project and having regard to the information contained in Form-1, Form-2, final EIA/ EMP reports and other documents, submitted by the PP and presentation made by the PP/ Consultant, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for Grant of EC/ approval of EIA-EMP with respect to the proposed China Clay Cluster No. 6 mining project Nagaur, Number of Leases- 122, Cluster Area- 436.9278 ha., production capacity of Cluster- 72,88,005 TPA (ROM), N/v.- Firojpura charna, Borwa, Jayal, Jhunjala, Khera Narnoliya, Palri Jodha, Pateli, Chhota Kalan, Bhadana, Tehsil- Jayal, Mundwa & Nagaur, District- Nagaur, Raj., (Proposal No- 57305), covered under the above mentioned cluster comprising total lease area of 436.9278 ha., with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. It is also recommended that the EC shall be subject to the outcome of the pronouncement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 5698/2018.
Besides the general conditions mentioned in Annexure “A” the SEAC also resolved to recommend to SEIAA to impose following additional condition:
Sh. Bhoora Ram Bhakar, President of Sri Gunsai Baba Clay Society, Jhunjala shall be responsible for implementation and execution of EMP/ ESR activity along with development of green belt with respect to cluster No. 6 of China Clay mining project comprising 122 mining leases, Cluster Area- 436.9278 ha., production capacity of Cluster- 72,88,005 TPA (ROM), N/v.- Firojpura charna, Borwa, Jayal, Jhunjala, Khera Narnoliya, Palri Jodha, Pateli, Chhota Kalan, Bhadana, Tehsil- Jayal, Mundwa & Nagaur, District- Nagaur, Raj., (Proposal No- 57305).
Agenda no. 32. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18639)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environmental Clearance/ ToR for Bodki Quartz & Feldspar Mining Project, Plot No- 17/2018, Area- 4.0744 ha., Production Capacity- 5,56,355 TPA (ROM) at Khasra no.- 01, Vill.- Bodki, Tehsil- Lasadiya, Distt.- Udaipur (Raj.) (Proposal No. -37301)
Project Proponent Name- Shri Simardeep Singh, Add.- House No.-7, Shiv Shakti School, Vishal Nagar, Jagadhri, Yamuna Nagar, Haryana (Raj.)Email – [email protected].
Consultant Name- Cognizance Research India Private Ltd., Add.-Office GT-20, Sec 177, Noida- 201301 (U.P.)email:- [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 30.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
The PP has submitted application for EC/ToR for Bodki Quartz & Feldspar Mining Project, Plot No- 17/2018, Area- 4.0744 ha., Production Capacity- 5,56,355 TPA (ROM) at Khasra no.- 01, Vill.- Bodki, Tehsil- Lasadiya, Distt.- Udaipur (Raj.) (Proposal No. - 37301). The project is covered under B2 category. The ADM, Udaipur has granted LOI of mineral Quartz & Feldspar on 15.01.2019. ADM, Udaipur vide letter dated 28.09.2020 & 19.02.2021 has extended the validity of LOI for 06 months & 12 months, respectively. The LOI is now valid up to 14.01.2022. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Udaipur vide letter dated 08.05.2019. AME, Salumbar in his certificate dated 16.09.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF (WL), Udaipur in his certificated dated 24.09.2020 stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine and the nearest Wildlife Sanctuary Jaisamand is at a distance of 25.6 Km from the applied lease area. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
It is a project having capital cost of Rs. 4.0 Crores. The AME, Sallumber in his certificate dated 16.09.2020 has stated that total area of all the mining leases in the cluster is 16.5207 hectare. The project, therefore, requires to be dealt with as ‘B1’ category project.
The SEAC therefore, observed that the PP is required to conduct Environmental Impact Assessment Study and prepare Environmental Management Plan for the entire cluster in order to capture all the possible externalities. These reports are required to incorporate carrying capacity of the cluster, transportation and related issues, replenishment and recharge issues, geo- hydrological study of the cluster.
Keeping in view the presentation made by the PP and examination of documents submitted by him the SEAC was of the view that the PP is required to get public hearing conducted and carry out detailed EIA and prepare comprehensive EIA report as per the provisions of the EIA notification 2006. The EIA/EMP may be prepared by the state or state nominated agency or group of PP in the cluster or the PP in the cluster. As per the provisions of the EIA Notification the PP should get one public consultation done covering all the mining leases in the cluster and prepare final EIA/EMP reports.
The SEAC, in pursuance of the Notification dated 17.02.2020 of the MoEF & CC resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of ToR as mentioned in Annexure ‘B’.
Agenda no. 33. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B1(18921)/ 2019-20
Project Name:- ToR/Environmental Clearance for existing Mudh Kotri Ball Clay and Fire Clay Mining Project, M.L. No.- 09/1993, Area- 89.3645 ha., with production capacity of – 3,75,290 TPA of Mineral Ball Clay and Fire Clay at Khasra No.- 868, 873, 867, 871, 878, 4, 133 & 134, Near Vill. Mudh- Kotri, Tehsil- Kolayat, Distt.- Bikaner (Raj.) under EIA Notification, 2006, and its subsequent amendments and MoEF & CC Notification dated- 06.04.2018, 14.08.2018 & NGT order (Proposal No. - 45488).
Project Proponent Name:- M/s Rama Devi Sharma, Add.- 99-100, RIICO Road No.-9 Industrial Area, Rani Bazar, Bikaner (Rajasthan), [email protected], [email protected]
Consultant Name:- (EGCIPL) Envirogreen Consultans (India) Private Limited, 1-B, Machhla Magra, Near Patel Circle, Udaipur.Email- [email protected],
Observations and Resolution of the Committee:
The PP vide letter dated 30.06.2021 has requested to withdraw the project. The SEAC in view of the application of PP resolved to recommend to SEIAA to close and delist the matter.
Agenda no. 34. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(19255)/ 2019-20
Project Name- EC for Granite Mining Project, Ref. No.-20201000028740, Area- 1.0435 ha., Production Capacity- 1,40,000 TPA (ROM) at Khasra no.- 332 & 333, N/v.- Bijwar, Tehsil – Deoli, Distt.- Tonk, (Raj.),(Proposal No. 198909)
Project Proponent Name- Smt. Suman Bhambi W/o Shri- Chhagan Lal, Add.- Gulab Villa, Near Jagdamba Mata Ji Ka Mandir Brij Lal Nagar, Malpur, Distt.- Tonk, (Raj.) Email- [email protected]. Consultant Name- : M/s Globus Environment Engg. Services, #326-AB, 3rd floor Sahara Shopping Center, Lekhraj crossing, Faizabad Road, Lucknow-226016, E-mail- [email protected].
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
S. Particulars Details / Information No.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
1. Cat. / Item no. Category - ‘B2’ Mining (in Schedule): 2. Location of Khasra No.: 332 & 333 Project Village:- Bijwar Tehsil:- Deoli District:- Tonk (Rajasthan) 3. Project Details M.L. Reference No. 20201000028740 M.L. No. / M.L. Area: 1.0435 ha Production Production – 1,40,000 TPA (ROM) capacity (Page no. 1. of Power Point Presentation) 4. Project Cost: Project Cost: 60 Lakhs (Page no. 1. of Power Point Presentation) 5. Water Water Requirement- 6 KLD Requirement Source of Water: from Nearby Villages & Source (Page no. 15. of Power Point Presentation) 6. Fuel & Energy:- Fuel & Energy- The electric power will not be used in mining. Only HSD Fuel will be required for operating machineries (Page no. 8 of Form 1) 7. Application No. Proposal No. SIA/RJ/MIN/198909/2021 & Date & Date of documents submitted-18.02.2021 documents submitted :- 8 Information Date and dispatch No.: Project does not fall in Aravali, Aravali NOC issued about Aravalli by Assistant Mining Engineer Tonk vide letter No. Certificate. AME/Tonk/ENVIRONMENT/2021/40 Dated 04.02.2021. (Annexure No. 5 of Agenda compliance) 9 Date of Date of Monitoring- Summer Season – 10.02.2021 to 16.02.2021 Air/Water/Noise (Annexure No. 11 of Agenda compliance) Monitoring 10 Information Surrounding Cluster area is 3.1004 ha. (After dated 09.09.2013 the granted about 500 mts lease area is 2.0569 ha) of proposed Project as per cluster map issued by composite map Assistant Mining Engineer Tonk vide letter No. AME/Tonk/Cluster/2021/106, Dated 15.06.2021. (Annexure No. 7 of Meeting Notice compliance) 11 Environment Expenditure of EMP: Management S. Activities Capital Cost Recurring Plan NO. (IN Rs.) Cost/Annum (in Rs.) 1. Environmental / - 20,000/- Pollution Monitoring 2. Plantation / Green 3,00,000/- 80,000/- Belt 3. Water Sprinkling 2,50,000/- 50,000/- on haul roads 4. Rain Water 50,000/- 10,000/- Harvesting Total Cost 6,00,000/- 1,60,000 (Page no. 21 of Power Point Presentation) 12 CSR /ESR CSR/ESR Activates will be done as per MoEFCC Office Memorandum dated Activates 30.09.2020 and 20.10.2020. 13 Green Belt/ Out Side the Lease Plantation Waste Along & area Unworked Worked Out Year Dump Peripheral charagah Total Area Area (Inside) Road land Khasra No. 339 & 342 of Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Bijwar No. No. No. No. No. No. Area Area Area Area Area Area of of of of of of (Ha.) (Ha.) (Ha.) (Ha.) (Ha.) (Ha.) trees trees trees trees trees trees
Existing ------
I 0.17 170 ------0.20 200 0.37 370 II ------0.20 200 0.20 200 III ------0.06 60 0.06 60 IV ------V ------Conc. - - 0.05 50 ------0.05 50 Stage Total 0.17 170 0.05 50 - - - - 0.46 460 0.68 680 Total 0.68 ha (680 trees) {0.22 ha within lease area (220 trees) and 0.46 ha area outside the lease area (460 trees) i.e. Khasra No. 339 & 342 charagah land of Bijwar village} will be covered under Green belt/Plantation which will be more than 33% of the total lease area. Outside Plantation NoC issued by Office of Gram Panchayat, Bijwar vide letter GPO/2020-21 dated 16.06.2021. Plant species will be planted under guidance of Forest Department i.e. Azadirachta indica (Neem), Cassia fistula (Amaltas), Mangifera indica (Mango), Delonixregia (Gulmohar), Phyllanthus emblica (Amla), Psidium guajava (Guava), Prosopis cinereria (Khejri), Albizia spp. (Siris), Syzygiumcumini (Jamun), Citrus lemon (Lemon), Bauhinia variegata (Kachnar), Tamarindus indica (Imli), Terminalia arjuna (Arjun), etc. (Page no. 13 of Power Point Presentation) 14 Budgetary Expenditure for Labour: Breakup for S.N. Activities to be done by PP Capital Cost Recurring Labour (in Rs.) Cost/Annum (in Rs.) 1. Shelter 1,00,000/- 10,000/- 2. Health Facility 30,000/- 20,000/- 3. Drinking Water & Sanitation 80,000/- 15,000/- Facility 4. Education for Children 20,000/- 30,000/- Total contribution for labourers 2,30,000/- 75,000/- (Page no. 21 of Power Point Presentation) 15 Present Status :- Presently mine is Non Operational phase. Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 30.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Granite Mining Project, Ref. No.- 20201000028740, Area- 1.0435 ha., Production Capacity- 1,40,000 TPA (ROM) at Khasra no.- 332 & 333, N/v.- Bijwar, Tehsil – Deoli, Distt.- Tonk, (Raj.),(Proposal No. 198909).The project is covered under B2 category. The SME, Jaipur has granted LOI of mineral Granite on 03.02.2021. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Jaipur vide letter dated 16.02.2021. AME, Tonk in his certificate dated 04.02.2021 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Tonk & DCF Ajmer in their certificates dated 23.02.2021 & 18.06.2021, respectively has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by AME, Tonk on 15.06.2021, the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster having area of 3.1004 ha.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Smt. Suman Bhambi W/o Shri- Chhagan Lal, for Granite Mining Project, Ref. No.-20201000028740, Area- 1.0435 ha., Production Capacity- 1,40,000 TPA (ROM) at Khasra no.- 332 & 333, N/v.- Bijwar, Tehsil – Deoli, Distt.- Tonk, (Raj.),(Proposal No. 198909),with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent Smt.- Suman Bhambi W/o Shri- Chhagan Lal, Add.- Gulab Villa, Near Jagdamba Mata Ji Ka Mandir Brij Lal Nagar, Malpur, Distt.- Tonk, (Raj.), Email- [email protected] Consultant Name:- : M/s Globus Environment Engg. Services, #326-AB, 3rd floor Sahara Shopping Center, Lekhraj crossing, Faizabad Road, Lucknow-226016, E-mail- [email protected].
Agenda no. 35. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(19253)/ 2019-20
Project Name- EC for Granite Mining Project, M.L. No.- 25/2020, Area- 1.3161 ha., Production Capacity- 1,32,000 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No.- 563, N/v.- Baghera, Tehsil – Kekri, Distt.- Ajmer, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 198714).
Project Proponent Name- Shri- Shankar Lal Jat S/o Shri- Kishan Jat, Add.- Jat Maholla, Vill- Baghera, Tehsil- Kekri, Distt.- Ajmer, (Raj.), Email- [email protected].
Consultant Name- M/s Globus Environment Engg. Services, #326-AB, 3rd floor Sahara Shopping Center, Lekhraj crossing, Faizabad Road, Lucknow-226016, E-mail- [email protected].
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
S. Particulars Details / Information No. 1. Cat. / Item no. (in Category - ‘B2’ Mining Schedule): 2. Location of Khasra No.: 563 Project Village:- Baghera Tehsil:- Kekri District:- Ajmer (Rajasthan) (Page no. 1. of Power Point Presentation) 3. Project Details M.L. No. – 25/2020 M.L. No. / M.L. Area: 1.3161 Ha. Production Production – 1,32,000 TPA (ROM) capacity (Page no. 1. of Power Point Presentation) 4. Project Cost: Project Cost: Rs. 65 Lakhs/- (Page no. 1. of Power Point Presentation) 5. Water Water Requirement- 6 KLD Requirement Source of Water: from Nearby Villages & Source (Page no. 14. of Power Point Presentation) 6. Fuel & Energy:- Fuel & Energy- The electric power will not be used in mining. Only HSD Fuel will be required for operating machineries (Page no. 8 of Form 1) 7. Application No. & Application/Proposal No.- 198714 Date & documents Date of documents submitted-17.02.2021 submitted :- 8 Information about Date and dispatch No.: Project does not fall in Aravali, Aravali NOC Aravalli issued by Assistant Mining Engineer Sawar vide letter No. Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Certificate. AME/Sawar/Map/ML(LOI)-25/2020/188, Dated 21.12.2020. (Annexure No. 6 of Agenda compliance) 9 Date of Date of Monitoring- 05.02.2021- 06.02.2021 Air/Water/Noise (Annexure No. 12 of Agenda compliance) Monitoring 10 Information about Surrounding Cluster area is Nil Ha. (After dated 09.09.2013 the granted 500 mts lease area is 0 Ha.) of proposed Project as per cluster map issued by composite map Assistant Mining Engineer Sawar vide letter No. AME/Sawar/ML(LOI)- 25/2020/189, Dated 21.12.2020 & vide letter No. AME/Sawar/ML(LOI)-25/2020/149, Dated 23.06.2021. (Annexure No. 8 of Meeting Notice compliance) 11 Environment Annual expenditure of EMP: Management Plan Capital Cost: Rs. 5.50 Lakhs/- (Approx. 8% of Project Cost) Recurring Cost: Rs. 1.50 Lakhs/Annum S. Activities Capital Cost Recurring Cost NO. (IN Rs.) (IN Rs.) 1. Environmental - 20,000/- / Pollution Monitoring 2. Plantation / 70,000/ 4,25,000/- Green Belt 3. Water 50,000/- Sprinkling on 75,000/- haul roads 4. Rain Water 10,000/- 50,000/- Harvesting Total Cost 5,50,000 1,50,000 (Page no. 20 of Power Point Presentation) 12 CSR /ESR CSR/ESR Activates will be done as per MoEFCC Office Memorandum Activates dated 30.09.2020 and 20.10.2020. 13 Green Belt/ Out Side the Lease Plantation area (Khasra Waste Worked Out Along & Unworked No. Dump Area Peripheral Total Area 563/5046 (Inside) (Backfilled) Road Year Aaraji Bhumi Near M. L. Area) No. No. No. No. No. Area Area Area No. of Area Area Area of of of of of (Ha.) (Ha.) (Ha.) trees (Ha.) (Ha.) (Ha.) trees trees trees trees trees Existing ------0.15 150 0.25 250 I 0.10 100 ------II 0.10 100 ------0.10 100
III 0.10 100 ------0.10 100
Conceptual - - - - - 0.3955 395 - - - 0.3955 395 Stage
0.15 150 Total 0.30 300 - - - 0.3955 395 - 0.8455 845 Total 0.8455 ha. [(845 trees) {i.e. 0.30 ha.(300 trees) on Virgin area, 0.3955 ha. (395 trees) on Backfilled area and 0.15 ha area (150 trees) outside the lease area i.e. Khasra No. 563/5046 Aaraji Bhomi Near M. L. Area}] will be covered under Greenbelt/Plantation which will be equal to 64% of the total lease area. Outside Plantation NoC issued by Office of Gram Panchayat, Baghera vide letter No. Gra. P/SPL/06 dated 07.06.2021 Plant species will be planted under guidance of Forest Department i.e. Azadirachta indica (Neem), Cassia fistula (Amaltas), Mangifera indica
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
(Mango), Delonixregia (Gulmohar), Phyllanthus emblica (Amla), Psidium guajava (Guava), Prosopis cinereria (Khejri), Albizia spp. (Siris), Syzygiumcumini (Jamun), Citrus lemon (Lemon), Bauhinia variegata (Kachnar), Tamarindus indica (Imli), Terminalia arjuna (Arjun), etc. (Page no. 12 of Power Point Presentation) 14 Budgetary Annual expenditure for Labour: Breakup for Capital Cost: Rs. 2.70 Lakhs /- Labour Recurring Cost: Rs. 0.70 Lakhs/Annum S.N. Activities to be Capital Cost Recurring Cost done by PP (in Rs.) (in Rs.) 1. Shelter 1,40,000 20,000 2. Health Facility 30,000 20,000 3. Drinking Water & 50,000 10,000 Sanitation Facility 4. Education for 50,000 20,000 Children Total contribution for 2,70,000 70,000 labourers (Page no. 20 of Power Point Presentation) 15 Present Status :- Presently mine is Non Operational phase. Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 30.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Granite Mining Project, M.L. No.- 25/2020, Area- 1.3161 ha., Production Capacity- 1,32,000 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No.- 563, N/v.- Baghera, Tehsil – Kekri, Distt.- Ajmer, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 198714). The project is covered under B2 category. The SME, Ajmer has granted LOI of mineral Granite on 07.12.2020. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 09.02.2021. AME, Sawar in his certificate dated 21.12.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Tonk & DCF Ajmer in their certificates dated 23.02.2021 & 10.11.2020 respectively has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The SEAC considered the certificate dated 23.06.2021 issued by AME, Sawar. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Shankar Lal Jat S/o Shri Kishan Jat, for Granite Mining Project, M.L. No.- 25/2020, Area- 1.3161 ha., Production Capacity- 1,32,000 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No.-563, N/v.- Baghera, Tehsil – Kekri, Distt.- Ajmer, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 198714), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent Shri- Shankar Lal Jat S/o Shri- Kishan Jat, Add.- Jat Maholla, Vill- Baghera, Tehsil- Kekri, Distt.- Ajmer, (Raj.) Email- [email protected] Consultant Name:- M/s Globus Environment Engg. Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Services, #326-AB, 3rd floor Sahara Shopping Center, Lekhraj crossing, Faizabad Road, Lucknow-226016, E-mail- [email protected].
Agenda no. 36. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18375)/ 2019-20
Project Name- EC Masonry Stone mining Project, M.L. No.- 82/209, Area- 1.00 ha., Production Capacity- 22,406.8 MT at Khasra No. 1906, N/v.- Village- Karnu, Tehsil- Khinwsar, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 137034).
Project Proponent Name- Shri – Kishan Ram Choudhary, Add.- Karnu, Tehsil- Khimsar, District- Nagaur, (Raj.) [email protected]. Consultant Name- OCEAO-ENVORO Management Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P 201012 email:-www.oceaoenviro.com [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the Committee:
The project has already been considered by the SEAC in its 4.75th VC meeting held on 08 to 10 March, 2021 and recommendation made to SEIAA accordingly. The SEAC, therefore decided to drop the agenda item listed for presentation on 30.06.2021 at agenda item no. 36. No further action is required in the matter, at the level SEAC.
Agenda no. 37. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18374)/ 2019-20
Project Name- E C Masonry Stone mining Project (M.L.No. 84/209, M.L. area 1.00 Ha) with Production Capacity 22,407 MT Khasra No. 1906, Add.- Village- Karnu, Tehsil- Khinwsar, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) By Shri Omprakash, (Proposal No.- 138640)
Project Proponent Name- Shri – Omprakesh, Add.- Karnu, Tehsil- Khimsar, District- Nagaur,([email protected]
Consultant Name- OCEAO-ENVORO Management Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P 201012 email:-www.oceaoenviro.com [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the Committee:
The project has already been considered by the SEAC in its 4.75th VC meeting held on 08 to 10 March, 2021 and recommendation made to SEIAA accordingly. The SEAC, therefore decided to drop the agenda item listed for presentation on 30.06.2021 at agenda item no. 37. No further action is required in the matter, at the level SEAC.
Agenda no. 38. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18372)/ 2019-20
Project Name- E C Masonry Stone mining Project (M.L.No. 83/209, M.L. area 1.00 Ha) with Production Capacity 20,583 MT Khasra No. 1906, Add.- Village- Karnu, Tehsil- Khinwsar, Distt.- Nagaur, (Raj.) By Shri Kishan Ram Choudhary, (Proposal No.- 139310)
Project Proponent Name- Shri – Kishan Ram Choudhary, Add.- Karnu, Tehsil- Khimsar, District- Nagaur, (Raj.) [email protected] Consultant Name- OCEAO-ENVORO Management Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P 201012 email:-www.oceaoenviro.com [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the Committee:
The project has already been considered by the SEAC in its 4.75th VC meeting held on 08 to 10 March, 2021 and recommendation made to SEIAA accordingly. The SEAC, therefore Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
decided to drop the agenda item listed for presentation on 30.06.2021 at agenda item no. 38. No further action is required in the matter, at the level SEAC.
Agenda no. 39. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18749)/ 2019-20
Project Name: - Environmental Clearance for Marble stone Mining Project, (Gunawati Range) QL. No.- 157, Area- 0.2491 ha., Production Capacity- 4500 TPA (ROM), Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 179375)
Project Proponent Name- :- M/s Gulam Suleman & Sons, Sh. Noor Hasan (Proprietor), Add.- Near Vill.- Bordiya Bada Makrana, Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.-Nagaur(Raj.) Email. [email protected]
Consultant Name- OCEAO-ENVORO Management Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara,Ghaziabad, U.P 201012, Email:-www.oceaoenviro.com, [email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 30.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing mining project. ME, Makrana vide order dated 01.01.1967 granted QL in favour of M/s Gulam Suleman & Sons, Makrana. The QL is valid up to 31.0.3.2025.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 0.2491 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificate dated 28.09.2020 of ME, Makrana, production of mineral from 2012-13 (base year) to 2019-20 has been nil. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The PP has submitted application for Environmental Clearance for Marble stone Mining Project, (Gunawati Range) QL. No.- 157, Area- 0.2491 ha., Production Capacity- 4500 TPA (ROM), Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 179375). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 10.01.2017. ME, Makrana in his certificate dated 24.09.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Nagaur in his certificate dated 17.01.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by ME, Makrana on 24.09.2020, the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster having area of 4837.7944 Sq.mt.
The PP in environment sensitivity part of Form-1 has mentioned the distance of Turfuri Temple- Hindu Temple, Gunawati, Makrana as approximately 0.06 Km in North direction. Since the Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 4315/ Sh. Kailash Sharma S/o Ramesh Chandra Sharma Vs State of Rajasthan & Oth., vide order dated 26.10.2016 has directed that no mining operation shall be stopped beyond 45 meter from Turfuri Temple, the SEAC considered it proper to get the said information mentioned in Form-1, confirmed/ certified from the mining department. The SEAC, therefore, asked the PP to furnish the said information, authenticated by the mining department, within a period of 45 days failing which the project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Agenda no. 40. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(18753)/ 2019-20
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Project Name: Environmental Clearance for Marble stone Mining Project (Gunawati Range), QL. No.- 157/A, Area- 0.4907 ha., Production Capacity- 4500 TPA (ROM), Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 179393).
Project Proponent Name:- Sh. Salauddin S/o Shri Gulam Suleman, Add.- Near Vill.- Guljarpura Makrana, Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.-Nagaur(Raj.), Email. [email protected].
Consultant Name:- OCEAO-ENVORO Management Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd., Add.- 217, 1st Floor, Sector 12, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P 201012, Email:-www.oceaoenviro.com, [email protected].
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
1. Category / Item As it is a mining project it falls in schedule 1(a) of the EIA notification, 2006. The area of the project no.(in is below 5 ha hence it is categorized as B-2 category. Schedule): 2. Location of Project is located at Village: Makrana ,Tehsil Makrana District Nagaur,Rajasthan Project
3. Project Details (Q. L. No. 157/A)
M.L. No. Area- 0.4907 ha., Production (TPA)- 4500 TPA ROM /Production capacity Above details are mentioned in page no. 2 of the pre-feasibility report submitted.
4. Project Cost: 25 lacs 5. Water 4.5 KLD, Source: Nearby villages. Requirement & Source
6. Fuel & Energy: Diesel is the only fuel which will be required for transportation purposes. Approx. 100 liters per day is required. 7. Application No. SIA/RJ/MIN/179393/2020 dated 31.10.2020 ; SEAC NO 18753 & Date & documents submitted: 8. Information Vide letter No. Akh/Mk/Machi/Vividh/2018/32 Dated : 24.09.2020 about Aravalli Certificate. Date of 15.10.2020 Air/Water/Noise Monitoring 9. Information Vide letter No. Akh/Mk/736 about 500 mts composite map Dated : 24.06.2021
10. Environment Capital EMP Cost is 265900 Rs & Annual expenditure is 50000/- as recurring Management Plan S.No. HEAD Annual Expenditure in Rs.
1. Environmental Monitoring 50,000 2. Water Sprinkling 10,000 3. Green belt development 1,74,900 4. Progressive reclamation of Mine pits 20,000 5. Settling tank & Garland drains 11,000 Total 2,65,900
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
11. CSR /ESR Total expenditure 50000/- Activates
12. Green Belt/ Capital expenditure is 1,63,440 Rs, Annual expenditure is 63,560 Rs.Total 908 Trees will be planted Plantation in 5 years in the area of 1.340 Ha in the safety zone in the Mine site.
Unworked area Charagaah land Backfilled TOP soil Dump Total (Reclaimed area)
Area(Ha) No. Area(Ha) No. Area(Ha) No. Area(Ha) No. Area(Ha) No. of of of of of Trees Trees Trees Trees Trees
Existing ------
1st …. …. ……… …… …… …… 0.05397 54 0.0539 54 2nd ….. ….. ……. ……… ……… ……… 0.05397 54 0.0539 54 3rd … …. ……… ……. ……. ……. 0.0539 7 54 0.0539 54 4th Maintenance
5th maintenance
TOTAL 0.161931 162 … …. ……… ……. ……. ……. 0.161931 162
• As per the Office Memorandum dated 16.01.2020 : The Project Proponent will undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc., after ceasing mining operations.
• 33% of cluster has to be converted into green area by lease holders. Hence plantation in the designated area will be done by association of Q.L holder in the allotted land of around 0.4907 Ha.
• There will be 162 Plants will be Planted in Next 3 Years after getting E.C. in 0.1619 Ha. The plantation will be done in the safety barrier zone at the quarry lease area located at Village- Makrana, District Nagaur (Rajasthan) (Gov. Land) for plantation/green belt development. The additional land will be met by the Khasra no 52 of Gram Panchayat Gailasair.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
13. Budgetary Capital expenditure is 80,000 Rs, Annual expenditure is 1,15,600 Rs Breakup for Labour LABOUR WELFARE AMENTIES FOR WORKERS Recurring Capital Cost S. No. Description Cost/annum (INR) (INR) Rest Shelters, Drinking Water Facility, 1. 75,000 20,000 Sanitation Facility Provision for personal protection equipment (PPE’s) like ear plug, face 8400 mask, helmet, shoes etc for 12 workers. 6000 Safety shoes @350 Rs (twice a year) 2. 7200 Hand Gloves @ 250 Rs (twice a year) 7200 Face mask @ 25 Rs (twice a month) 7500 Ear plugs @ 25 Rs (twice a month) Helmet @ 500 Rs (yearly basis) 3. First Aid Box 10,000 2000 4. Fire Safety 20,000 5000 Total 1,05,000 63,300
14. Present Existing Lease Status:-
Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 30.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing mining project. ME, Makrana vide order dated 04.03.1986 granted QL in favour of Sh. Salauddin S/o Shri Gulam Suleman, Makrana. The QL is valid up to 31.0.3.2025.
The PP has submitted application for Environmental Clearance for Marble stone Mining Project (Gunawati Range), QL. No.- 157/A, Area- 0.4907 ha., Production Capacity- 4500 TPA (ROM), Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 179393). The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 01.02.2017. ME, Makrana in his certificate dated 24.09.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Nagaur in his certificate dated 17.01.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site. ME, Makrana in his certificate dated 30.06.2021 has stated that the applied lease is at a distance of 50 meters from the plinth of temple.
As per cluster certificate issued by ME, Makrana on 24.09.2020, the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster having area of 7263.7944 Sq.mt.
Resolution:
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Sh. Salauddin S/o Shri Gulam Suleman for Marble stone Mining Project (Gunawati Range), QL. No.- 157/A, Area- 0.4907 ha., Production Capacity- 4500 TPA (ROM), Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil- Makrana,
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 179393), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. The Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 4315/2010 Sh. Kailash Sharma S/o Ramesh Chandra Sharma Vs State of Rajasthan & Oth., vide order dated 26.10.2016 has directed that no mining operation shall be stopped beyond 45 meters from Turfuri Temple, therefore, the PP shall not undertake any mining activity within the prohibited distance of 45 meters from the temple. Project Name: Environmental Clearance for Marble stone Mining Project (Gunawati Range), QL. No.- 157/A, Area- 0.4907 ha., Production Capacity- 4500 TPA (ROM), Vill.- Makrana (Gunawati Range), Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.- Nagaur (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 179393). Project Proponent Name:- Sh. Salauddin S/o Shri Gulam Suleman, Add.- Near Vill.- Guljarpura Makrana, Tehsil- Makrana, Distt.-Nagaur(Raj.), Email. [email protected].
Agenda no. 41. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(19104)/ 2019-20
Project Name- Environmental Clearance for Sandstone Mining Project, QL No.- 2317, Area- 0.18 ha., Production Capacity- 1677 TPA (ROM) Near Vill.- Keru, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Jodhpur, (Raj.) (Proposal No.-193196).
Project Proponent Name- Sh. Sugna Ram, Add.- Vill.- Keru, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Jodhpur,(Raj.), [email protected].
Consultant Name- MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD Hall No.- 1 NICE Sankul Plot No.- A-9, Opp. Nasik Marchant Co Op Bank Ltd, ITI Signal, MIDCSatpur, Nasik). email:[email protected]
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal on 30.06.2021 by way of VC in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan in the presence of PP and his Consultant.
This is an existing quarry license. Initially lease was granted in favour of Sh. Bhagwan Ram over an area of 0.18 ha. for mineral Sandstone vide order dated 28.10.1988 by ME, Jodhpur. Further quarry license was transferred to Smt. Sugna Ram vide order dated 04.07.2017. Quarry license is valid for 31.03.2025.
The PP has submitted application for Environmental for Sandstone Mining Project, QL No.- 2317, Area-0.18 ha., Production Capacity- 1677 TPA(ROM) Near Vill.- Keru, Tehsil- Jodhpur, Distt.- Jodhpur, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 193196). The project is covered under B2 category. The ME, Jodhpur in his letter dated 18.06.2021 has stated that the simplified mining scheme has been approved with affect from 12.02.2020. ME, Jodhpur in his certificate dated 18.12.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Jodhpur in his certificate dated 18.06.2020 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by ME, Jodhpur on 18.12.2020, there is no other mining lease and the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster having area of 0.18 ha.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of W.P. (Civil) No. 114.2014 Common Cause Vs Union of India in its judgment dated 02.08.2017 has directed that in case mining activity has been carried out or its expansion has been affected without obtaining Environmental Clearance of the regulatory authority, such activities are illegal and 100% penalty has to be levied in such cases. Since the project is less than 5.0 ha., it came under the purview of the EIA Notification on 09.09.2013, therefore, the PP is required to submit production figures from the base year i.e. Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
2012-13 onwards in order to secure compliance of the mandate of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The SEAC, therefore, in view of the above asked the PP to submit certified production figures from 2012-13, within a period of 45 days failing which project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Additional Agenda:
S.No File Subject Project Proponent Name & Consultant No Name 1. 18737 EC for Red Ochre Mining Project, Project Proponent Name- Shri. Samip M.L. No.- 07/2019, Area- 2.5061 Choudhary and Smt. Kala Bai, Add.- 65, ha., Production Capacity- 1,00,440 Station Road, Neemuch, (M.P.) Email. TPA at Khasra No. 477, Near Vill.– [email protected] Jalodiya Kelukhera, Tehsil – Chhoti Consultant Name: - Fulgro Sadri, Distt.- Pratapgarh, (Raj.) Environmental & Engineering Services (Proposal No. 180940) India Pvt. Ltd., Add. 27, Ashok Vatika, Khatipura Road, Jhotwara, Jaipur (Raj.)Email:- [email protected], .
2. 18439 EC for Piplai Masonary Stone Project Proponent Name:- Shri Rodu Lal, Mining Project ,Ref. No. Add.- Pagriya, Tehsil- Panchpahad, Distt.- 20191000013685,, Area – 1.2589 Jhalawar, (Raj.) Email.- Hect., Production Capacity- 101860 [email protected] TPA (ROM), Khasra No. 521, Near Consultant Name:- Cognizance Research Village- Piplai, Tehsil- Gangdhar, India Private Ltd., Add.-Office GT-20, Sec District- Jhalawar, (Raj.), (Proposal 177, Noida- 201301 (U.P.)Email:- No. 167053) [email protected].
3. 17684 Application for transfer of EC from Project Proponent Name:- M/s Jagdamba Smt. Genda Sharma W/o.- Shri Mines & Minerals, Project In Charge- Shri Badri Vishal Sharma to M/s Panna Lal Tanwar S/o Late Shri Gorakh Jagdamba Mines and Minerals, for Ram Tanwar, Add.- 16, Vikas Nagar B Babaycha Masonry Stone Mining Murlipura Scheme, Jaipur, (Raj.), Email- Project, M.L. No. - 111/2007, Area- [email protected] 1.00 ha., Production capacity- Consultant Name:- Cognizance Research 50,000 TPA, Khasra No.- 243 & 77, India Private Ltd., Add.- Office GT-20, Sec Near Village- Babayacha, Tehsil- 177, Noida- 201301 (U.P.) email:- Ajmer, District- Ajmer, (Raj.) [email protected] (Proposal No.- 125243).
4. 17452 EC for Parana Sandstone Mining Proponent name:- Shri Prabhu Lal Karad, Project, (M.L. No.- 239/1995, Area- Add.- 179-B, Talwandi, Distt.- Kota, 1.67 ha.), Production Capacity– (Rajasthan) Email- 88,779 TPA(ROM) at Khasra No. [email protected] 297, 298, 300, 304, 305, 306 & 308, Name of Consultant:- Cognizance Near Village – Parana, Tehsil - Research India Private Ltd. Add.- Office Talera, District – Bundi, GT-20, Sec 177, Noida- 201301 (U.P.), (Rajasthan). (Proposal No. Email:- 130908) [email protected]. [email protected].
Additional Agenda no. 01. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. 1(a)B2(18737)/ 2019-20
Project Name- EC for Red Ochre Mining Project, M.L. No.- 07/2019, Area- 2.5061 ha., Production Capacity- 1,00,440 TPA at Khasra No. 477, Near Vill.– Jalodiya Kelukhera, Tehsil – Chhoti Sadri, Distt.- Pratapgarh, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 180940)
Project Proponent Name- Shri. Samip Choudhary and Smt. Kala Bai, Add.- 65, Station Road, Neemuch, (M.P.) Email. [email protected]
Consultant Name: - Fulgro Environmental & Engineering Services India Pvt. Ltd., Add. 27, Ashok Vatika, Khatipura Road, Jhotwara, Jaipur (Raj.)Email:- [email protected], .
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
1. Category / 1 (a) /Category-B2 Item no. (in Schedule): 2. Location of Near Village- Jalodiya Kelukhera, Tehsil- Chhoti Sadri & Project District- Pratapgarh (Raj.)
3. Project Details M.L. No. 07/2019, Area: 2.5061 Ha. REF. No./Production capacity Proposed Production Capacity- 1,00,440 TPA (ROM) (Production of Red Ochre: 1,00,440 TPA, Waste: Nil) 4. Project Cost Rs. 45 Lac 5. Water Total Water Requirement-4.15 KLD Requirement Source: Water will be made available by nearby villageJalodiya & Source Kelukherathrough water tanker. 6. Fuel &Energy: - Diesel operated machinery will be used. Fuel will be required for the operation of, mines machineries etc. which will be taken care by the contractor itself. Electricity connection will be taken from concerned electricity department. 7. Application No. Online Proposal No. SIA/RJ/MIN/180940/2020 & Date & Documents:FORM-I & PFR along with approved mining plan & all the documents requisite documents for grant of EC have been submitted. submitted: - 8. Information Aravali Certificate was issued by ME, Pratapgarh vide letter no. about ME/Pratap/C.C.- Minor/M.L. 07/2019/2020-21/7308 on dated Aravalli 09/10/2020. Certificate. 9. Date of Date of Air Monitoring: - 21/10/2020 Air/Water/Nois Date of Water Sampling: - 21/10/2020 e Monitoring Date of Noise Monitoring: - 21/10/2020 10 Information Cluster certificate was issued by ME, Pratapgarh vide letter no. . about 500 mts ME/Pratap/CC-Minor/M.L. 07/2019/2020-21/7307 on dated 09/10/2020. composite map One other mine leases area exits within the 500 m radius from the said mine lease area
11 Environment Annual Expenditure of Rs. 3.00 Lac Per year . Management Recurring cost S. No. Particulars Plan (in Lac) 1. Pollution Monitoring- Air, Water, Noise 1.00 2. Water Requirement (For dust suppression 1.25 and green belt/plantation purpose) 3. Greenbelt development/Plantation (Tree 0.65 guards, plantation and its maintenance etc) 4 Contribution towards construction and maintenance of the kachha roads to make them metalled till the nearest approach 0.10 roads after consultation with the concerned gram Panchayat. Total 3.00
12 GreenBelt/ Annual expenditure of Rs. 0.65 Lac Per Year (Recurring Cost) Backfilled Top Soil Plantation Year Un-worked Area Waste Dump Total Area Dumps No. No. No. Are Are Are Area No. of of of of Area No. of a a a (Ha) Trees Tree Tree Tree (Ha) Trees (Ha) (Ha) (Ha) s s s Existin ------g I 0.278 278 ------0.278 278 II 0.276 276 ------0.276 276 III 0.276 276 ------0.276 276 IV ------V MAINTENANC ------MAINTENANC End of E TO BE DONE -- -- 1.50 1500 -- -- E TO BE DONE life of
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
mine 1.50 1500
Total 0.83 830 -- -- 1.50 1500 -- -- 2.33 2330
Note:Total 2330 saplings will be planted over an area of 2.33 hectare, out of which 830 saplings will be planted at undistributed land of 0.83 ha. During first three years within mine lease area (i.e.: 33 % of the mine lease area) and 1500 saplings will be planted over the backfilled area of 1.50 ha. At the end of life of mine and It will be ensured that after ceasing mining operations re-grassing of the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to the mining activities is done and will restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc. as per the MoEF & CC O.M vide No. 22- 34/2018-IA.III dated 16th Jan 2020. Native species which are more suitable to the local environment are preferred to be planted such as Neem, Khair, Babool Kanjari etc.
13 Budgetary Annual Expenditure of Rs. 1.1255Lac Per year Breakup for Sr. Capital Recurring Cost Labours Facility Provided for Laborers No. Cost in Rs. in Rs. Shelters, Safe drinking water, Maintenance Sanitation facility 100000 Cost: 30000 Periodical medical Examination 7000 per year @1000 ₹ per labor Fuel for cooking (LPG Cylinder) @ 950 9500 ₹ for 10 months Education for children of labors @ 2,400 16800 ₹ per labor Group Insurance @1500 ₹ per worker 10500 -
Provision for personal protection equipment (PPEs) like ear plug, dust mask, Helmet, shoes etc., for 7 workers
Safety shoes@350 ₹ (2 times/year) Hand Gloves @300 ₹ (2 4900 times/year) 4200 Dust mask@25 ₹ (2 times in 10 3500 month) 3500 Ear plugs@25 ₹ (2 times in 10 3150 month) Helmets @450 ₹ (1 time/years) First aid Box 10000
Fire Safety 30000 20,000
Total 1,40,500 1,12,550
14 Present Status Fresh LOI now proposed for the grant of Environmental Clearance. Observations of the committee:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal submitted by the PP and also the presentation made by him through VC/Electronic media in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan.
The PP has submitted application for EC for Red Ochre Mining Project, M.L. No.- 07/2019, Area- 2.5061 ha., Production Capacity- 1,00,440 TPA at Khasra No. 477, Near Vill.– Jalodiya Kelukhera, Tehsil– Chhoti Sadri, Distt.- Pratapgarh, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 180940). The project is covered under B2 category. The ADM, Udaipur has granted LOI for mineral on 21.09.2020. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Udaipur vide letter dated 20.10.2020. ME, Pratapgarh in his certificate dated 09.10.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF (WL) Chittorgarh in his letter dated 10.11.2020 has stated that the Sitamata WLS is at a distance of 22.0 Km from the applied lease area. DCF Neemuch, Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
M.P in his certificate dated 03.03.2021 has stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park within 10 km periphery of the mine.
The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
As per cluster certificate issued by ME, Pratapgarh on 09.10.2020, the total area of all the mining leases in the cluster having area of 3.5585 ha.
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, the members resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Samip Choudhary and Smt. Kala Bai, for Red Ochre Mining Project, M.L. No.- 07/2019, Area- 2.5061 ha., Production Capacity- 1,00,440 TPA at Khasra No. 477, Near Vill.– Jalodiya Kelukhera, Tehsil – Chhoti Sadri, Distt.- Pratapgarh, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 180940), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent:- Shri – Samip Choudhary, Smt. Kala Bai, Add.- 65, Station Road, Neemuch, (M.P.) Email. [email protected] Consultant Name: - Fulgro Environmental & Engineering Services India Pvt. Ltd., Add. 27, Ashok Vatika, Khatipura Road, Jhotwara, Jaipur (Raj.), Email:- [email protected].
Observations and Resolution of the Committee: The SEIAA vide noting dated 15.06.2021 has sent the record to SEAC for reconsideration of the proposal for grant of EC to the above project. The SEAC in its 4.91 meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021 reconsidered the proposal particularly in the light of facts mentioned by the PP in Environmental Sensitivity part of Form-1 Hadiya Kesarpura RF is 4.4 Km away from the lease area and other RF/PF are more than 4.4 Km away from the applied lease area. The SEAC in view of these observations again resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Samip Choudhary and Smt. Kala Bai, for Red Ochre Mining Project, M.L. No.- 07/2019, Area- 2.5061 ha., Production Capacity- 1,00,440 TPA at Khasra No. 477, Near Vill.– Jalodiya Kelukhera, Tehsil – Chhoti Sadri, Distt.- Pratapgarh, (Raj.) (Proposal No. 180940), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Name of Proponent:- Shri – Samip Choudhary, Smt. Kala Bai, Add.- 65, Station Road, Neemuch, (M.P.) Email. [email protected] Consultant Name: - Fulgro Environmental & Engineering Services India Pvt. Ltd., Add. 27, Ashok Vatika, Khatipura Road, Jhotwara, Jaipur (Raj.), Email:- [email protected].
Additional Agenda no. 02. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. 1(a)B2(18439)/ 2019-20
Project Name:- EC for Piplai Masonary Stone Mining Project ,Ref. No. 20191000013685,, Area – 1.2589 Hect., Production Capacity- 101860 TPA (ROM), Khasra No. 521, Near Village- Piplai, Tehsil- Gangdhar, District- Jhalawar, (Raj.), (Proposal No. 167053)
Project Proponent Name:- Shri Rodu Lal, Add.- Pagriya, Tehsil- Panchpahad, Distt.- Jhalawar, (Raj.) Email.- [email protected]
Consultant Name:- Cognizance Research India Private Ltd., Add.-Office GT-20, Sec 177, Noida- 201301 (U.P.)Email:- [email protected].
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
S.N Particu Details/Information o. lars 15. Cat./ 1 (a)-B2 Item no. (in schedul e): 16. Locatio Near village – Piplai, Tehsil:- Gangdhar, District :– Jhalawar, State – Rajasthan n of the Project 17. Project Reference No. : 2019100001368 Details Khasra No. : 521 M.L Area : 1.2589 HECT. No./ Production (TPA) : 101860 TPA (ROM) Product Details are given in cover page of Proposal obtaining of Environmental ion Clearance (Slides No.: 1) Capacit y 18. Project Project Cost: Rs 40 Lac. Cost Details are given in cover page of Proposal obtaining of Environmental Clearance (Slides No.: 1) 19. Water Total water requirement is about 4.0 KLD = 2.0 KLD (Drinking & Domestic Uses) + 1.0 require KLD (Plantation) + 1.0 KLD (Dust Suppression). Water for Drinking, dust suppression ment & and plantation will be collected from nearby villages. Source Details are given in Slide no. 32 of Power Point Presentation. 20. Fuel & No electricity will be required in mining operations as mining will be carried out in day Energy time only. 21. Applica Category : B2 tion no., SEAC FILE NO. : 18439 Date of Date of documents Submitted : 14/08/20 Docum SEAC Meeting No. : 4.70thMeeting ents Agenda Sr. No. : 29 Submitt Date of Presentation : 03/02/2021 ed 22. Informa Aravalli Certificate has been issued by Assistant Mining Engineer, Jhalwara , Jhalwara tion vide letter No. AME/Machi/2020/10831 on date 28/07/2020. on date 28/07/2020 as about Slide No.. 11 Aravalli certifica te 23. Date of Monitoring was conducted by Noida Testing Laboratories., Approved by NABL, Noida Air, as Slide No.: 35-36 Water, Noise, monitor ing 24. Informati 500 mts composite map has been issued by Assistant Mining Engineer, Jhalwara vide on about letter No. AME/Machi/2020/10832on date 28/07/2020 500 mts as Slide No..: 11 composit Area falling within 500 mts 1.2589 ha. e map 25. CER Environment Management Plan Expenditures: Capital Cost: Rs. 2,00,000/- Recurring Activiti Cost: Rs. 2,00,000/- per annum. es Exp. Cost in Rs. Exp. Cost in Rs. SI. No. Measures (Fixed) (Recurring) Pollution Control 1 1,00,000/ 1,00,000/- i) Dust Suppression Pollution Monitoring 2 i) Air pollution 10,000/-
ii) Water pollution 3 Green Belt 1,00,000/ 90,000/- Total 2,00,000/ 2,00,000/
26. Greenb Expenditure of Green Belt Rs 90,000/- elt & Total green belt will be planted 33% of the ML area 0.417 Ha. in the 7.5m Statutory
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Plantati Barrier & Part of own khatedari land at village Piplai in Khasra No. 521...Native specie on which are more suitable to the local environment are preferred to be planted such as like Aam (Mangifera indica), Imli(Tamarindus indica), Neem (Azadirachta Indica), Shisham (Dalbergia sisso) etc. it is the proposed to invest 3.40Lac. Rs. Per annum for greenbelt devlopment Along the lease boundary & Top Soil Dumps Total Outside the lease area Year No. of Area No. of Area No. of Area (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees 1st 0.139 139 -- -- 0.139 139 Year 2nd 0.139 139 -- -- 0.139 139 Year 3rd 0.139 139 -- -- 0.139 139 Year Total 0.417 417 -- -- 0.417 417 Note:- As per O.M. dated 16.01.2020 “The Mining Lease holders shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc. 27. Budgeta The information regarding Budgetary breakup for labour has been given in Power Point ry Presentation (Slide No.: 18) breakup Exp. Cost in Exp. Cost in Sr. Facility to be Provided for for Rs. Rs. No. Laborers labour (Fixed) (Recurring) 1. Drinking water facility 10,000/- 10,000/- Health Facility (First aid box, 2. Rest shelter, Medicine & 10,000/- 10,000/- Washroom) & Insurance 3. Education for Labours children 10,000/- 10,000/- Safety equipment like Ear plug, 4. Dust mask, hand gloves, Safety 10,000/- 10,000/- Shoes etc. Total 40,000/ 40,000/-
28. Present Proposed Mine site. Status Brief details of the project:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal submitted by the PP and also the presentation made by him through VC/Electronic media in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan.
The PP has applied for EC for Piplai Masonary Stone Mining Project, Ref. No. 20191000013685,, Area – 1.2589 Hect., Production Capacity – 1,01,860 TPA (ROM), Khasra No. 521, Near Village- Piplai, Tehsil- Gangdhar, District- Jhalawar (Proposal No. 167053). The project is covered under B2 category. The ADM, Kota vide order dated 02.03.2020 has issued LoI to the PP for mining of Masonry Stone. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Kota vide letter dated 09.07.2020. AME, Jhalawar in his certificate dated 21.01.2021 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills.
As per cluster certificate issued by AME, Jhalawar on 21.01.2021, there is no other mining lease and the total area of the mining lease in the cluster is 1.2589 ha.
The PP has submitted the certificate dated 01.02.2021 of DCF, Jhalawar stating that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park in area under his jurisdiction Jhalawar district. The interstate boundary is 5.0 Km from the applied lease area. The area of MHTR also comes in Jhalawar district. Therefore, the PP is required to give the certificate from nearby MP district forest office and DCF, MNP Kota, regarding existence or otherwise of National Park or Wildlife Sanctuary from the applied lease area. The SEAC, therefore, decided to ask the PP to submit the same within a period of 45 days failing which the project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment. Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The PP, in response to the query made by SEAC vide letter dated 22.03.2021, has submitted reply vide letter dated nil received on 15.06.2021. The SEAC in its 4.91st meeting held on 28-30 June, 2021 went through the reply. The PP, in compliance of the query, has submitted copy of a letter issued by DCF, WL, MNP, Kota dated 26.03.2021, stating that lease is at a distance of 96.0 Km from MHTR and outside of its ESZ. The PP has also submitted letter dated 04.05.2020 of DFO, Mandsaur, which states that lease is at a distance of 67.93 Km from Gandhi Sagar Sanctuary.
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, the members resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Rodu Lal, for Piplai Masonary Stone Mining Project ,Ref. No. 20191000013685,, Area – 1.2589 Hect., Production Capacity- 101860 TPA (ROM), Khasra No. 521, Near Village- Piplai, Tehsil- Gangdhar, District- Jhalawar, (Raj.), (Proposal No. 167053), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Project Name:- EC for Piplai Masonary Stone Mining Project ,Ref. No. 20191000013685, Area – 1.2589 Hect., Production Capacity- 101860 TPA (ROM), Khasra No. 521, Near Village- Piplai, Tehsil- Gangdhar, District- Jhalawar, (Raj.), (Proposal No. 167053), Project Proponent Name:- Shri Rodu Lal, Add.- Pagriya, Tehsil- Panchpahad, Distt.- Jhalawar, (Raj.), Email.- [email protected].
Additional Agenda no. 03. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(17684)/ 2019-20
Project Name: - Application for transfer of EC from Smt. Genda Sharma W/o.- Shri Badri Vishal Sharma to M/s Jagdamba Mines and Minerals, for Babaycha Masonry Stone Mining Project, M.L. No. - 111/2007, Area- 1.00 ha., Production capacity- 50,000 TPA, Khasra No.- 243 & 77, Near Village- Babayacha, Tehsil- Ajmer, District- Ajmer, (Raj.) (Proposal No.- 125243).
Project Proponent Name:- M/s Jagdamba Mines & Minerals, Project In Charge- Shri Panna Lal Tanwar S/o Late Shri Gorakh Ram Tanwar, Add.- 16, Vikas Nagar B Murlipura Scheme, Jaipur, (Raj.), [email protected]
Consultant Name:- Cognizance Research India Private Ltd., Add.- Office GT-20, Sec 177, Noida- 201301 (U.P.) email:- [email protected]
Brief details of the project:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal submitted by the PP and also the presentation made by him through VC/Electronic media in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan.
This is an existing mine. The initially lease no. 111/2007 for mining of Masonry Stone having an area of 1.0 ha., was grated in favour Smt. Genda Sharma W/o.- Shri Badri Vishal Sharma on dated 30.07.2008. Later on the lease was transferred to M/s Jagdamba Mines & Minerals vide letter dated 14.12.2018. Lease deed was executed and registered on 24.12.2018 for 50 years i.e. from 06.10.2008 to 05.10.2058.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 1.00 ha., came under the purview of the EIA Notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. According to the certificate dated 19.10.2020 of ME, Ajmer, production of mineral in the base year i.e. 2012-13 was 3200 Ton and thereafter, there has been no increase in production of mineral till the PP obtained EC from DEIAA, Ajmer vide order dated 08.06.2016 for production capacity of 50,000 TPA. The project, therefore, is not one of violation of the EIA Notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the affect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA Notification and Common Cause Judgment pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
The DEIAA, Ajmer vide letter dated 08.06.2016 had granted EC to Smt. Genda Sharma W/o.- Shri Badri Vishal Sharma for mining of Masonry Stone at M.L. No. - 111/2007, Area- 1.00 ha., Production capacity-50,000 TPA, Near Village- Babayacha, Tehsil- Ajmer, District- Ajmer, (Raj.).
The PP has now submitted application in Form-7, for transfer of EC granted by DEIAA vide 08.06.2016, for mining of Masonry Stone at M.L. No. - 111/2007, Area- 1.00 ha., Production capacity- 50,000 TPA, Near Village- Babayacha, Tehsil- Ajmer, District- Ajmer, (Raj.) in favour of Smt. Genda Sharma to M/s Jagdamba Mines and Minerals.
The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Ajmer vide letter dated 29.05.2019. ME, Ajmer in his certificate dated 19.10.2020 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF, Ajmer in his certificated dated 22.10.2019 stated that there is no Wildlife Sanctuary/National Park/ Conservation Reserve within 10 km periphery of the mine. The project does not involve approval/ clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Wild Life Protection Act, 1972 as no forest land is involved and neither there is any Wild Life Sanctuary/ National Park within 10 Km from the project site.
The SEAC considered the certificate dated 19.10.2020 issued by ME, Ajmer. In the certificate, it is stated that as per the MoEF & CC notification, dated 01.07.2016 there is no other mining lease within the periphery of 500 meter and therefore, there is no cluster formation.
The PP while submitting application for transfer of EC has not submitted report of compliance of conditions of earlier EC granted by DEIAA vide letter dated 08.06.2016, as certified by the RSPCB/ MoEF & CC. The PP has also not submitted no objection certificate of the transferor i.e. Smt. Genda Sharma. PP has also not submitted undertaking from the transferee stating that he will comply with the conditions of earlier EC. The SEAC, therefore, asked the PP to submit the same within a period of 45 days failing which the project shall be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP, in response to the query made by SEAC vide letter dated 21.12.2020, has submitted reply vide letter dated 15.06.2021. The SEAC in its 4.91st meeting held on 28-30 June, 2021 went through the reply. The PP, in compliance of the query, has submitted copy of compliance report certified by RO, RSPCB, Kishangarh vide letter dated 04.03.2021. The PP has also submitted no objection certificate of Smt. Genda Sharma for transferring EC to M/s Jagdamba Mines and Minerals. The PP has also submitted undertaking regarding compliance of the environment safeguards, the terms and conditions stipulated in EC.
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Form-7 and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for transfer of EC granted vide letter dated 08.06.2016 in favour of Smt. Genda Sharma W/o.- Shri Badri Vishal Sharma to M/s Jagdamba Mines and Minerals, for mining of Masonry Stone at M.L. No. - 111/2007, Area- 1.00 ha., Production capacity- 50,000 TPA, Near Village- Babayacha, Tehsil- Ajmer, District- Ajmer, (Raj.), subject to compliance of conditions enclosed herewith at Annexure ‘A’.
Additional Agenda no. 04. File no. F1 (4)/SEIAA/SEAC-Raj/Sectt/Project / Cat. B2(17452)/ 2019- 20
Project Name- EC for Parana Sandstone Mining Project, (M.L. No.- 239/1995, Area- 1.67 ha.), Production Capacity– 88,779 TPA(ROM) at Khasra No. 297, 298, 300, 304, 305, 306 & 308, Near Village – Parana, Tehsil - Talera, District – Bundi, (Rajasthan). (Proposal No. 130908)
Proponent name:- Shri Prabhu Lal Karad, Add.- 179-B, Talwandi, Distt.- Kota, (Rajasthan) Email- [email protected]
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Name of Consultant:- Cognizance Research India Private Ltd. Add.- Office GT-20, Sec 177, Noida- 201301 (U.P.), Email:- [email protected]. [email protected].
The particulars of the project, in brief, as submitted by the PP are as follows:
1. Category / Item 1(a) B2 no.(in Schedule):
2. Location of Village – Parana, Tehsil – Talera, District –Bundi, State – Rajasthan Project Latitude : 25006’13.6" to 25006’18.4" N Longitude : 750 28’39.6" to 750 28’46.6" E 3. Project Details M.L NO.– 239/1995 M.L. No. Khasra No. 297, 298, 300, 304, 305, 306 & 308 /Production Area - 1.67Hect. capacity Production (TPA)- 88779 TPA (ROM) 4. Project Cost: Rs. 80 Lac.
5. Water Total water requirement is about 5.0 KLD = 2.0 KLD (Drinking & Domestic Requirement Uses) + 1.5 KLD (Plantation) + 1.5 KLD (Dust Suppression). Drinking water & Source will be brought from the nearby Tube-wells and water for dust suppression and plantation will be collected from nearby villages.
6. Fuel & Energy:- Only diesel will be required to run vehicles for transportation. No electricity will be needed in the proposed project.
7. Application No. & Category : B2 Date & documents SEAC FILE NO. : 17452 submitted :- Date of documents Submitted : 12/11/2019 SEAC Meeting No. : 4.53rd Meeting Agenda Sr. No. : 25 Date of Presentation : 7/10/2020
8. Information about Aravalli Certificate has been issued by Mining Engineer, Bundi vide order no. Aravalli ME/Bundi/Map/2020/196 dated 30/9/2020. Certificate. Date of Monitoring was conducted by Noida Testing Laboratories., Approved by NABL, Air/Water/Noise Noida Monitoring
9. Information about 500 mts composite map has been issued by Mining Engineer, Bundi vide order 500 mts composite no. ME/Bundi/Map/2020/197 dated 30/9/2020. map Area falling within 500 mts is 1.67 ha
10. Environment Environment Management Plan Expenditures: Capital Cost: Rs. 4,00,000/- Management Plan Recurring Cost: Rs 4,00,000/- per annum
Exp. Cost in Rs. Exp. Cost in Rs. SI. No. Measures (Recurring (Fixed) Yearly) Pollution Control i) Road Preparation and 1 maintenance 2,00,000/- 2,00,000 ii) Dust Suppression & Wet Drilling & other Pollution Monitoring 2 i) Air pollution -- 15,000/- ii) Water pollution 3 Green Belt 2,00,000/- 1,85,000 Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Total 4,00,000/- 4,00,000/-
11. Green Belt/ Expenditure cost of Green Belt Rs 1,85,000/- per year Plantation Total green belt will be the 33% of the lease area 0.552 Ha. of the area will be planted in the road connected to mine, Statutory barrier and Nalla ke Mataji Bhavanipura Khasra No. 319,320,321, Devji ka Khera, Shri Gopal Goshala Dabi & Part of Govt. land.
Native specie which are more suitable to the local environment are preferred to be planted such as like Neem (Azadiracta indica), Pipal (Ficus religiosa), Babool (Acacia nilotica), Kher (Acacia catechu) etc. it is the proposed to invest 3,35,000 Rs. Per annum for greenbelt development
Along the lease boundary Top Soil Dumps Total & Outside the lease area Year No. of Area No. of Area No. of Area (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees (Ha.) Trees 1st Year 0.184 184 -- -- 0.184 184 2nd Year 0.184 184 -- -- 0.184 184 3rd Year 0.184 184 -- -- 0.184 184 0.552 552 -- -- 0.552 552 Total Hect. Hect. Note:- As per O.M. dated 16.01.2020 “The Mining Lease holders shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to their mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc. 12. Budgetary The information regarding Budgetary breakup for labour has been given in PFR & Breakup for Power Point Presentation Labour Exp. Cost in Exp. Cost in Sr. Facility to be Provided for Rs. Rs. No. Laborers (Recurring (Fixed) Yearly) 1. Drinking water facility 20,000 20,000 Health Facility (First aid box, Rest 2. shelter, Medicine & Washroom) & 20,000 20,000 Insurance 3. Education for Labours children 20,000 20,000 Safety equipment like Ear plug, 4. Dust mask, hand gloves, Safety 20,000 20,000 Shoes etc. Total 80,000 80,000
13. Present Status :- M.L Granted
Brief details of the project:-
The SEAC considered/examined the project proposal submitted by the PP and also the presentation made by him through VC/Electronic media in accordance with letter dated 27.05.2020 of SEIAA, Rajasthan.
This is an existing mining lease. The mining lease was initially granted for an area of 1.67 hectare for mineral Sand stone in favour of Shri Prabhu lal Karad vide order dated 16.06.2000 for a period of 20 years from the date of registration. The lease was registered on 28.08.2000. The lease period was auto extended for a period of 50 years from the date of registration.
The project being one of minor mineral having lease area of 1.67 hectare, came under the purview of the EIA notification dated 09.09.2013 of the MoEF & CC. The base year in such
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
cases is 2012-13 in terms of Common Cause judgement pronounced by the Hon’ble Supereme Court of India. According to the certificates dated 22.09.2020 of ME, Bundi-II, production of mineral has been nil from 2000-2001 to 2019-20. The project therefore, is not one of violation of EIA notification. The PP has also submitted affidavit to the effect that no activity has been carried out in violation of the EIA notification and Common Cause judgement pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
The PP has applied for E C for Parana Sandstone Mining Project, (M.L. No.- 239/1995, Area- 1.67 ha.), Production Capacity– 88,779 TPA (ROM) at Khasra No. 297, 298, 300, 304, 305, 306 & 308, Near Village – Parana, Tehsil - Talera, District – Bundi, (Rajasthan). (Proposal No. 130908).The project is covered under B2 category. The mining plan has been approved by the SME, Kota vide letter dated 20.02.2019.
As per cluster certificate issued by ME, Bundi-II dated 30.09.2020, there is no cluster formation as per the MoEF & CC notification dated 01.07.2016.
ME, Bundi-II in his certificate dated 19.11.2019 has stated that the mining lease does not fall in Aravalli hills. DCF (Wildlife) MNP, Kota in his certificate dated 06.01.2020 has `stated that MHTR is 8.90 km away from the applied lease area and the ESZ of the same has not yet been notified. PP has submitted copy of application dated 18.03.2018 made to NBWL. However, the PP has not submitted certificate regarding distance of the lease area from the Ramgarh Vishdhari WLS.
The SEAC in view of above asked the PP to submit the certificate from the concerned authority of forest department regarding the distance of the applied lease area from Ramgarh Vishdhari WLS, with in a period of 45 days failing which the case will be recommended to SEIAA for closure and delistment.
Observations and Resolution of the committee:-
The PP, in response to the query made by SEAC vide letter dated 25.11.2020, has submitted reply vide letter dated 20.06.2021. The SEAC in its 4.91st meeting held on 28-30 June, 2021 went through the reply. The PP, in compliance of the query, has submitted copy of a letter dated 31.12.2020 of DCF, WL, Kota, according to which Ramgarh WLS is at a distance of 40.26 Km from the applied lease area.
The SEAC upon appraisal of the project in the light of information contained in Form-1, Form-2, Pre-feasibility report and other documents and having regard to the submissions made during presentation, resolved to recommend to SEIAA for grant of EC to Shri Prabhu Lal Karad, for Parana Sandstone Mining Project, (M.L. No.- 239/1995, Area- 1.67 ha.), Production Capacity– 88,779 TPA(ROM) at Khasra No. 297, 298, 300, 304, 305, 306 & 308, Near Village – Parana, Tehsil - Talera, District – Bundi, (Rajasthan). (Proposal No. 130908), with the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual production scheduled specified in mining plan and that any deviation there in will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws, with the specific and general conditions annexed at Annexure ‘A’. Project Name- E C for Parana Sandstone Mining Project, (M.L. No.- 239/1995, Area- 1.67 ha.), Production Capacity– 88,779 TPA(ROM) at Khasra No. 297, 298, 300, 304, 305, 306 & 308, Near Village – Parana, Tehsil - Talera, District – Bundi, (Rajasthan). (Proposal No. 130908), Proponent name:- Shri Prabhu Lal Karad, Add.- 179-B, Talwandi, Distt.- Kota, (Rajasthan) Email- [email protected].
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
ANNEXURE-“A”
1. Statutory compliance:
i. This Environmental Clearance (EC) is subject to orders/ directions of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, Hon’ble High Court, Hon’b1e NGT and any other Court of Law, as is applicable.
ii. The Project proponent complies with all the statutory requirements and judgments of Hon’b1e Supreme Court dated 2nd August, 2017 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014 in matter of Common Cause versus Union of India & Ors before commencing the mining operations.
iii. The Department of Mines & Geology, Government of Rajasthan (DMG, GoR) shall ensure that mining operation shall not be commenced till the entire compensation levied, if any, for illegal mining paid by the Project Proponent through Department of Mining & Geology in strict compliance of Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 2nd August, 2017 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014 in matter of Common Cause versus Union of India & Ors.
iv. In case the project falls within a distance of 10 Km from the boundary of a National Park/ Wildlife Sanctuary, wherein final ESZ Notification has not been issued so far, the EC shall come into effect only after the PP obtains clearance from the Standing Committee of National Board for Wildlife (SCNBWL) as per OM dated 08.08.2019 of MoEF & CC.
v. This Environmental Clearance shall become operational only after receiving formal SCNBWL Clearance from Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, (MoEF & CC), Government of India (GoI) subsequent to the recommendations of the Standing Committee of National Board for Wildlife, if applicable to the Project.
vi. This Environmental Clearance shall become operational only after receiving Forest Clearance (FC) under the provision of Forest Conservation Act, 1980, if applicable to the Project.
vii. Project Proponent (PP) shall obtain Consent to Operate after grant of EC and effectively implement all the conditions stipulated therein. The mining activity shall not commence prior to obtaining Consent to Establish/ Consent to Operate from the State Pollution Control Board.
viii. The PP shall adhere to the provision of the Mines Act, 1952, Mines and Mineral (Development & Regulation), Act, 2015 and rules & regulations made there under. PP shall adhere to various circulars issued by Directorate General Mines Safety (DGMS) and Indian Bureau of Mines (IBM) from time to time.
ix. The Project Proponent shall obtain consents from all the concerned land owners, before start of mining operations, as per the provisions of MMDR Act, 1957 and rules made thereunder in respect of lands which are not owned by it.
x. The Project Proponent shall follow the mitigation measures provided in MoEF CC’s Office Memorandum No. Z-11013/57/2014-IA.II (M), dated 29th October, 2014, titled “Impact of mining activities on Habitations-Issues related to the mining Projects wherein Habitations and villages are the part of mine lease areas or Habitations and villages are surrounded by the mine lease area”.
xi. The Project Proponent shall obtain necessary prior permission of the competent authorities for drawl of requisite quantity of surface water and from CGWA for
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
withdrawal of ground water for the project.
xii. A copy of EC letter will be marked to concerned Panchayat/ local NGO etc. if any, from whom suggestion/ representation has been received while processing the proposal.
xiii. State Pollution Control Board shall be responsible for display of this EC letter at its Regional office, District Industries Centre and Collector’s office/ Tehsildar’s Office for 30 days.
xiv. The Project Authorities should widely advertise about the grant of this EC letter by printing the same in at least two local newspapers, one of which shall be in vernacular language of the concerned area. The advertisement shall be done within 7 days of the issue of the clearance letter mentioning that the instant project has been accorded EC and copy of the EC letter is available with the State Pollution Control Board and website of the Department of Environment, Govt. of Rajasthan, RSPCB for compliance and record.
xv. The Project Proponent shall inform the MoEF & CC/ SEIAA for any change in ownership of the mining lease. In case there is any change in ownership or mining lease is transferred then mining operation shall only be carried out after transfer of EC as per provisions of the para 11 of EIA Notification, 2006 as amended from time to time.
xvi. The Mining Department will ensure that while executing the mining lease, if the mining lease forms a cluster of total area of more than 5.0 ha, in accordance with EIA notification dated 15.01.2016 and 01.07.2016, then such mining lease will be executed/ registered only after public hearing has taken place for the entire cluster and there has been EIA/EMP study of the entire cluster. The Mining Department will further ensure that revised EC is also obtained by such mining lease holder (s) in the cluster. xvii. The Mining lease holder shall, after ceasing mining operations, undertake re-grassing the mining area and any other area which may have been disturbed due to the mining activities and restore the land to a condition which is fit for growth of fodder, flora, fauna etc. xviii. That the grant of this E.C. is issued from the environmental angle only, and does not absolve the project proponent from the other statutory obligations prescribed under any other law or any other instrument in force. The sole and complete responsibility, to comply with the conditions laid down in all other laws for the time-being in force, rests with the project proponent. xix. No further expansion or modifications in the project shall be carried out without prior approval of the SEIAA/MoEF & CC as the case may be. In case of deviations or alterations in the project proposal from those submitted to this Authority for clearance, a fresh reference shall be made to the Authority to assess the adequacy of conditions imposed and to include additional environmental protection measures required, if any. xx. The EC is liable to be rejected/ revoked, in case it is found that the PP has deliberately concealed and/or furnished false and misleading information or data which is material to screening or scoping or appraisal or decision on the application for EC. xxi. Officials from the Department of Environment, Government of Rajasthan, Jaipur/ Regional Office of MoEF & CC, Lucknow, RSPCB who would be monitoring the implementation of Environmental safeguards should be extended full cooperation, facilities and documents/data by the project proponents during their inspection. A complete set of all the documents submitted to SEIAA should be forwarded to the Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
CCF, Regional Office of MoEF, Lucknow, Department of Environment, Government of Rajasthan, Jaipur / RSPCB. xxii. The Authority reserves the right to add additional safeguard measures subsequently, if found necessary, and to take action including revoking of the environment clearance under the provision of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, to ensure effective implementation of the suggested safeguard measures in a time bound and satisfactory manner. xxiii. The above condition shall be enforced among others under the provisions of Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981, the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, the Public Liability (Insurance) Act, 1991 and EIA Notification, 2006, along with their amendments and rules. xxiv. The PP shall obtain prior clearance from forestry and wildlife aspects including clearance from Standing Committee of National Board of Wild Life (if applicable). It is further categorically stated that grant of EC does not necessary imply that Forestry and Wildlife clearance shall be granted to the project by the concerned authorities. Proposals for forestry and wildlife clearance will be considered by the concerned authorities on its merits and decision taken accordingly. The investment made in the project, if any based on EC so granted, in anticipation of clearance from Forestry and Wildlife aspects shall be entirely at the cost and risk of the PP and MOEF & CC/SEIAA/ SEAC/ DOE shall not be responsible in this regard in any manner. xxv. The SEIAA, Rajasthan may revoke or suspend the Environmental Clearance, if implementation of any of the above conditions is not satisfactory. xxvi. The PP shall submit an environmental statement for the financial year ending 31st March in Form-V as prescribed under the environment (Protection) Rules, 1986, as amended subsequently on or before the 30th day of September every year, to the Rajasthan State Pollution Control Board/SEIAA and shall also be put on the website of the company/ unit/ industry along with the status of compliance of environmental clearance conditions and shall also be sent to the Lucknow Regional offices of MoEF/SEIAA/ RSPCB by e-mail as well as hard copy duly signed by competent person of company. xxvii. This EC is granted for mining of the mineral with production mentioned in the above table subject to the stipulation that the PP shall abide by the annual/ permitted production schedule specified in the mining plan and that any deviation therein will render the PP liable for legal action in accordance with Environment and Mining Laws.
xxviii. The PP shall spend the various amounts in the respective heads as mentioned in Annexure G.
xxix. Drills shall either be operated with dust extractors or equipped with water injections system.
xxx. Data on ambient air quality and stack emissions should be submitted to Rajasthan State Pollution Control Board once in six months. The monitoring/ sampling and analysis are to be carried out by MOEF/ NABL/ CPCB/ RSPCB/ Government approved lab.
xxxi. Blasting operations, if permitted, should be carried out only during the daytime with safe blasting parameters.
xxxii. The PP shall carry out mining activities with open cast method. The PP to undertake underground mining only if permitted specifically.
xxxiii. In the project related to Bajri mining the PP shall follow the ‘Sustainable Sand Mining Guidelines 2016’ and ‘Enforcement and Monitoring Guidelines for Sand Mining, 2020’ laid down by the MoEF & CC, GOI. The Bajri sand mining activity is restricted to three meters from ground level or water level whichever is less and the PP shall carry out river sand (Bajri) mining activity only manually or semi mechanized method as provided under the ‘Sustainable Sand Mining Management Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
Guidelines, 2016’ and ‘Enforcement and Monitoring Guidelines for Sand Mining, 2020’.
xxxiv. Any appeal against this environmental clearance shall lie with the National Green Tribunal, if preferred, within a period of 30 days as prescribed under section 16 of the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010.
2. Air quality monitoring and preservation:
i. The Project Proponent shall install a minimum of 3 (three) online Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Stations with 1 (one) in upwind and 2 (two) in downwind direction based on long term climatological data about wind direction such that an angle of 120° is made between the monitoring locations to monitor critical parameters, relevant for mining operations, of air pollution viz. PMI 0, PM2.5, NO2; CO and SO2 etc. as per the methodology mentioned in NAAQS Notification No. B-29016/20/90/PCI/I. dated l 8.11.2009 covering the aspects of transportation and use of heavy machinery in the impact zone. The ambient air quality shall also be monitored at prominent places like office building, canteen etc. as per the site condition to ascertain the exposure characteristics at specific places. The above data shall be digitally displayed within 03 months in front of the main Gate of the mine site.
ii. Effective safeguard measures for prevention of dust generation and subsequent suppression (like regular water sprinkling, metalled road construction etc.) shall be carried out in areas prone to air pollution wherein high levels of PM10 and PM2.5 are evident such as haul road, loading and unloading point and transfer points. The fugitive dust emissions from all sources shall be regularly controlled by installation of required equipments/ machineries and preventive maintenance. Use of suitable water-soluble chemical dust suppressing agents may be explored for better effectiveness of dust control system. It shall be ensured that air pollution level conform to the standards prescribed by the MoEF & CC/ Central Pollution Control Board.
3. Water quality monitoring and preservation: i. In case, immediate mining scheme envisages intersection of ground water table, then Environmental Clearance shall become operational only after receiving formal clearance from CGWA. In case, mining operation involves intersection of ground water table at a later stage, then PP shall ensure that prior approval from CGWA and MoEF & CC is in place before such mining operations. The permission for intersection of ground water table shall essentially be based on detailed hydro-geological study of the area.
ii. Regular monitoring of the flow rate of the springs and perennial nallahs flowing in and around the mine lease shall be carried out and records maintain. The natural water bodies and or streams which are flowing in an around the village, should not be disturbed. The Water Table should be nurtured so as not to go down below the pre-mining period. In case of any water scarcity in the area, the Project Proponent has to provide water to the villagers for their use. A provision for regular monitoring of water table in open dug well located in village should be incorporated to ascertain the impact of mining over ground water table. The Report on changes in Ground water level and quality shall be submitted on six-monthly basis to the Regional Office of the Ministry, CGWA and State Groundwater Department / State Pollution Control Board.
iii. Project Proponent shall regularly monitor and maintain records w.r.t. ground water level and quality in and around the mine lease by establishing a network of existing wells as well as new piezo-meter installations during the mining operation in consultation with Central Ground Water Authority/ State Ground Water Department. The Report on
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
changes in Ground water level and quality shall be submitted on six-monthly basis to the Regional Office of the Ministry, CGWA and State Groundwater Department / State Pollution Control Board.
iv. The Project Proponent shall undertake regular monitoring of natural water course/ water resources/ springs and perennial nallahs existing/ flowing in and around the mine lease and maintain its records. The project proponent shall undertake regular monitoring of water quality upstream and downstream of water bodies passing within and nearby/ adjacent to the mine lease and maintain its records. Sufficient number of gullies shall be provided at appropriate places within the lease for management of water. PP shall carryout regular monitoring w.r.t. pH and included the same in monitoring plan. The parameters to be monitored shall include their water quality vis-a-vis suitability for usage as per CPCB criteria and flow rate. It shall be ensured that no obstruction and/ or alteration be made to water bodies during mining operations without justification and prior approval of MoEF & CC. The monitoring of water courses/ bodies existing in lease area shall be carried out four times in a year viz. pre- monsoon (April-May), monsoon (August), post-monsoon (November) and winter (January) and the record of monitored data may be sent regularly to Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change and its Regional Office, Central Ground Water Authority and Regional Director, Central Ground Water Board, State Pollution Control Board and Central Pollution Control Board. Clearly showing the trend analysis on six –monthly basis.
v. Quality of polluted water generated from mining operations which include Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) in mines run-off; acid mine drainage and metal contamination in runoff shall be monitored along with Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), Dissolved Oxygen (DO), pH and Total Suspended Solids (TSS). The monitored data shall be uploaded on the website of the company as well as displayed at the project site in public domain, on a display board, at a suitable location near the main gate of the Company. The circular No.I-20012/1/2006-IA.II (M) dated 27.05.2009 issued by Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change may also be referred in this regard.
vi. Project Proponent shall plan, develop and implement rainwater harvesting measures on long term basis to augment ground water resources in the area in consultation with Central Ground Water Board/ State Groundwater Department. A report on amount of water recharged needs to be submitted to Regional Office MoEF & CC annually.
vii. Industrial waste water (workshop and waste water from the mine) should be properly collected and treated so as to conform to the notified standards prescribed from time to time. The standards shall be prescribed through Consent to Operate (CTO) issued by concerned State Pollution Control Board (SPCB). The workshop effluent shall be treated after its initial passage through Oil and grease trap.
viii. The water balance/water auditing shall be carried out and measure for reducing the consumption of water shall be taken up and reported to the Regional Office of the MoEF & CC and State Pollution Control Board.
4. Noise and vibration monitoring and prevention:
i. The peak particle velocity at 500m distance or within the nearest habitation, whichever is closer shall be monitored periodically as per applicable DGMS guidelines.
ii. The illumination and sound at night at project sites disturb the villages in respect of both human and animal population. Consequent sleeping disorders and stress may affect the health in the villages located close to mining operations. Habitations have a right for darkness and minimal noise levels at night. PPs must ensure that the Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
biological clock of the villages is not disturbed; by orienting the floodlights/ masks away from the villagers and keeping the noise levels well within the prescribed limits for day /night hours.
iii. The Project Proponent shall take measures for control of noise levels below 85 dBA in the work environment. The workers engaged in operations of HEMM, etc. should be provided with ear plugs/ muffs. All personnel including laborers working in dusty areas shall be provided with protective respiratory devices along with adequate training, awareness and information on safety and health aspects. The PP shall be held responsible in case it has been found that workers/ personals/ laborers are working without personal protective equipment.
iv. The ambient noise level should confirm to the standards prescribed under E (P) A Rules, 1986 viz 75 dB (A) during day time and 70 dB (A) during night time.
5. Mining plan:
i. The Project Proponent shall adhere to the working parameters of mining plan which was submitted at the time of EC appraisal wherein year-wise plan was mentioned for total excavation i.e. quantum of mineral, waste, over burden, inter burden and top soil etc.. No change in basic mining proposal like mining technology, total excavation, mineral & waste production, lease area and scope of working (viz. method of mining, overburden & dump management , O.B & dump mining, mineral transportation mode, ultimate depth of mining etc.) shall not be carried out without prior approval of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change/ SEIAA, which entail adverse environmental impacts, even if it is a part of approved mining plan modified after grant of EC or granted by State Govt. in the form to Short Term Permit (STP), Query license or any other name.
ii. The Project Proponent shall get the Final Mine Closure Plan along with Financial Assurance approved from Indian Bureau of Mines/Department of Mining & Geology as required under the Provision of the MMDR Act, 1957 and Rules/ Guidelines made there under. A copy of approved final mine closure plan shall be submitted within 2 months of the approval of the same from the competent authority to the concerned Regional Office, MoEF & CC/ SEIAA/ SPCB for record and verification.
iii. The land-use of the mine lease area at various stages of mining scheme as well as at the end-of-life shall be governed as per the approved Mining Plan. The excavation vis-a-vis backfilling in the mine lease area and corresponding afforestation to be raised in the reclaimed area shall be governed as per approved mining plan. PP shall ensure the monitoring and management of rehabilitated areas until the vegetation becomes self- sustaining. The compliance status shall be submitted half-yearly to the MoEF & CC/ SEIAA/ SPCB and its concerned Regional Office.
6. Land reclamation:
i. The Overburden (O.B.) generated during the mining operations shall be stacked at earmarked OB dump site(s) only and it should not be kept active for a long period of time. The physical parameters of the OB dumps like height, width and angle of slope shall be governed as per the approved Mining Plan as per the guidelines/circulars issued by D.G.M.S w.r.t. safety in mining operations shall be strictly adhered to maintain the stability of top soil/OB dumps. The topsoil shall be used for land reclamation and plantation.
ii. The reject/waste generated during the mining operations shall be stacked at Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
earmarked waste dump site(s) only. The physical parameters of the waste dumps like height. width and angle of slope shall be governed as per the approved Mining Plan as per the guidelines/circulars issued by DGMS w.r.t. safety in mining operations shall be strictly adhered to maintain the stability of waste dumps.
iii. The reclamation of waste dump sites shall be done in scientific manner as per the Approved Mining Plan cum Progressive Mine Closure Plan.
iv. The slope of dumps shall be vegetated in scientific manner with suitable native species to maintain the slope stability, prevent erosion and surface run off. The selection of local species regulates local climatic parameters and help in adaptation of plant species to the microclimate. The gullies formed on slopes should be adequately taken care of as it impacts the overall stability of dumps. The dump mass should be consolidated with the help of dozer/ compactors thereby ensuring proper filling/ leveling of dump mass. In critical areas, use of geo textiles/ geo-membranes / clay liners / Bentonite etc. shall be undertaken for stabilization of the dump.
v. The Project Proponent shall carry out slope stability study in case the dump height is more than 30 meters. The slope stability report shall be submitted to concerned regional office of MoEF & CC/ RSPCB.
vi. Catch drains, settling tanks and siltation ponds of appropriate size shall be constructed around the mine working, mineral yards and Top Soil/OB/Waste dumps to prevent run off of water and flow of sediments directly into the water bodies (Nallah/ River/ Pond etc.). The collected water should be utilized for watering the mine area, roads, green belt development, plantation etc. The drains/ sedimentation sumps etc. shall be de-silted regularly, particularly after monsoon season, and maintained properly.
vii. Check dams of appropriate size, gradient and length shall be constructed around mine pit and OB dumps to prevent storm run-off and sediment flow into adjoining water bodies. A safety margin of 50% shall be kept for designing of sump structures over and above peak rainfall (based on 50 years data) and maximum discharge in the mine and its adjoining area which shall also help in providing adequate retention time period thereby allowing proper settling of sediments/ silt material. The sedimentation pits/ sumps shall be constructed at the corners of the garland drains.
viii. The top soil, if any, shall temporarily be stored at earmarked site(s) within the mine lease only and should not be kept unutilized for long. The physical parameters of the top soil dumps like height, width and angle of slope shall be governed as per the approved Mining Plan and as per the guidelines framed by DGMS w.r.t. safety in mining operations shall be strictly adhered to maintain the stability of dumps. The topsoil shall be used for land reclamation and plantation purpose.
7. Transportation:
i. No Transportation of the minerals shall be allowed in case of roads passing through villages/ habitations. In such cases, PP shall construct a 'bypass’ road for the purpose of transportation of the minerals leaving an adequate gap (say at least 200 meters) so that the adverse impact of sound and dust along with chances of accidents could be mitigated. All costs resulting from widening and strengthening of existing public road network shall be borne by the PP in consultation with nodal State Govt. Department. Transportation of minerals through road movement in case of existing village/ rural roads shall be allowed in consultation with nodal State Govt. Department only after required strengthening such that the carrying capacity of roads is increased to handle the
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
traffic load. The pollution due to transportation load on the environment will be effectively controlled and water sprinkling will also be done regularly. Vehicular emissions shall be kept under control and regularly monitored. Project should obtain Pollution Under Control (PUC) certificate for all the vehicles from authorized pollution testing centers.
ii. The Main haulage road within the mine lease should be provided with a permanent water sprinkling arrangement for dust suppression. Other roads within the mine lease should be wetted regularly with tanker-mounted water sprinkling system. The other areas of dust generation like crushing zone, material transfer points, material yards etc. should invariably be provided with dust suppression arrangements. The air pollution control equipments like bag filters, vacuum suction hoods, dry fogging system etc. shall be installed at Crushers, belt-conveyors and other areas prone to air pollution. The belt conveyor should be fully covered to avoid generation of dust while transportation. PP shall take necessary measures to avoid generation of fugitive dust emissions.
8. Green Belt:
i. The Project Proponent shall develop greenbelt in 7.5m wide safety zone all along the mine lease boundary as per the guidelines of CPCB in order to arrest pollution emanating from mining operations within the lease. The whole Green belt shall be developed within first 5 years starting from windward side of the active mining area. The development of greenbelt shall be governed as per the EC granted by the Ministry/ SEIAA irrespective of the stipulation made in approved mine plan.
ii. The Project Proponent shall carryout plantation/ afforestation in backfilled and reclaimed area of mining lease, around water body, along the roadsides, in community areas etc. by planting the native species in consultation with the State Forest Department/ Agriculture Department/ Rural development department/ Tribal Welfare Department/ Gram Panchayat such that only those species be selected which are of use to the local people. The CPCB guidelines in this respect shall also be adhered. The density of the trees should be around 2500 saplings per Hectare. Adequate budgetary provision shall be made for protection and care of trees.
iii. The Project Proponent shall make necessary alternative arrangements for livestock feed by developing grazing land with a view to compensate those areas which are coming within the mine lease. The development of such grazing land shall be done in consultation with the State Government. In this regard, Project Proponent should essentially implement the directions of the Hon’b1e Supreme Court with regard to acquisition of grazing land. The sparse trees on such grazing ground, which provide mid-day shelter from the scorching sun, should be scrupulously guarded/ protected against felling and plantation of such trees should be promoted.
iv. The Project Proponent shall undertake all precautionary measures for conservation and protection of endangered flora and fauna and Schedule-I species during mining operation. A Wildlife Conservation Plan shall be prepared for the same clearly delineating action to be taken for conservation of flora and fauna. The Plan shall be approved by Chief Wild Life Warden of the State Govt.
v. And implemented in consultation with the State Forest and Wildlife Department. A copy of Wildlife Conservation Plan and its implementation status (annual) shall be submitted to the Regional Office of the Ministry/ SEIAA.
9. Public hearing and human health issues:
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
i. The Project Proponent shall appoint an Occupational Health Specialist for Regular as well as Periodical medical examination of the workers engaged in the mining activities, as per the DGMS guidelines. The records shall be maintained properly. PP shall also carryout Occupational health check-ups in respect of workers which are having ailments like nr, diabetes, habitual smoking, etc. The check-ups shall be undertaken once in s1x months and necessary remedial/ preventive measures be taken. A status report on the same may be sent to MoEF & CC/ SEIAA/ Regional Office and DGMS on half-yearly basis.
ii. The Project Proponent must demonstrate commitment to work towards ‘Zero Harm’ from their mining activities and carry out Health Risk Assessment (HRA) for identification workplace hazards and assess their potential risks to health and determine appropriate control measures to protect the health and wellbeing of workers and nearby community. The proponent shall maintain accurate and systematic records of the HRA. The HRA for neighborhood has to focus on Public Health Problems like Malaria, Tuberculosis, HIV, Anaemia, Diarrhoea in children under five, respiratory infections due to bio mass cooking. The proponent shall also create awareness and educate the nearby community and workers for Sanitation, Personal Hygiene, Hand wasting, not to defecate in open, Women Health and Hygiene (Providing Sanitary Napkins), hazard of tobacco and alcohol use. The Proponent shall carryout base line HRA for all the category of workers and thereafter every five years.
iii. The Proponent shall carry out Occupational health surveillance which be a part of HRA and include Biological Monitoring where practical and feasible, and the tests and investigations relevant to the exposure (e.g. for Dust a X-Ray chest; For Noise Audiometric; for Lead Exposure Blood Lead, For Welders Full Ophthalmologic Assessment; for Manganese Miners a complete Neurological Assessment by a Certified Neurologist, and Manganese (Mn) Estimation in Blood; For Inorganic Chromium- Fortnightly skin inspection of hands and forearms by a responsible person. Except routine tests all tests would be carried out in a Lab accredited by NABH. Records of Health Surveillance must be kept for 30 years, including the results of and the records of Physical examination and tests. The record of exposure due to materials like Asbestos. Hard Rock Mining, Silica, Gold, Kaolin, Aluminium. Iron, Manganese, Chromium, Lead, Uranium need to be handed over to the Mining Department of the State in case the life of the mine is less than 30 years. It would be obligatory for the State Mines Departments to make arrangements for the safe and secure storage of the records including X-Ray. Only conventional X-Ray will be accepted for record purposes and not the digital one). X-Ray must meet ILO criteria (17 x14 inches and of good quality).
iv. The Proponent shall maintained a record of performance indicators for workers which includes (a) there should not be a significant decline in their Body Mass Index and it should stay between 18.5 -24.9, (b) the Final Chest X-Ray compared with the base line X-Ray should not show any capacities ,(c) At the end of their leaving job there should be no Diminution in their Lung Functions Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1),Forced Vital Capacity (FVC), and the ratio) unless they are smokers which has to be adjusted, and the effect of age, (d) their hearing should not be affected. As a proof an Audiogram (first and last need to be presented), (e) they should not have developed any Persistent Back Pain, Neck Pain, and the movement of their Hip, Knee and other joints should have normal range of movement, (f) they should not have suffered loss of any body part. The record of the same should be submitted to the Regional Office, MoEF & CC/ SEIAA annually along with details of the relief and compensation paid to workers having above indications.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
v. The Project Proponent shall ensure that Personnel working in dusty areas should wear protective respiratory devices and they should also be provided with adequate training and information on safety and health aspects.
vi. Project Proponent shall make provision for the housing for workers/labors or shall construct labor camps within/outside (company owned land) with necessary basic infrastructure/ facilities like fuel for cooking, mobile toilets, mobile STP, safe drinking water, medical health care, creche for kids etc. The housing may be provided in the form of temporary structures which can be removed after the completion of the project related infrastructure. The domestic waste water should be treated with STP in order to avoid contamination of underground water.
vii. The activities proposed in Action plan prepared for addressing the issues raised during the Public Hearing shall be completed as per the budgetary provisions mentioned in the Action Plan and within the stipulated time frame. The Status Report on implementation of Action Plan shall be submitted to the concerned Regional Office o1 the Ministry along with District Administration.
10. Miscellaneous:
i. The Project Proponent shall prepare digital map (land use & land cover) of the entire lease area once in five years purpose of monitoring land use pattern and submit a report to concerned Regional Office of the MoEF & CC/ SEIAA/ SPCB.
ii. The Project Authorities should inform to the SEIAA/ Regional Office regarding date of financial closures and final approval of the project by the concerned authorities and the date of start of land development work.
iii. The Project Proponent shall submit six monthly compliance reports on the status of the implementation of the stipulated environmental safeguards to the MOEFCC & its concerned Regional Office, Central Pollution Control Board and State Pollution Control Board.
iv. A separate ‘Environmental Management Cell’ with suitable qualified manpower should be set-up under the control of a Senior Executive. The Senior Executive shall directly report to Head of the Organization. Adequate number of qualified Environmental Scientists and Mining Engineers shall be appointed and submit a report to RO, MoEF & CC/ SEIAA/ SPCB.
v. The MoEF & CC/ SEIAA/ SPCB shall randomly monitor compliance of the stipulated conditions. The project authorities should extend full cooperation to the MoEF & CC/ SEIAA/ SPCB officer(s) by furnishing the requisite data / information / monitoring reports.
vi. Project Proponent shall keep the funds earmarked for environmental protection measures in a separate account and refrain from diverting the same for other purposes. The Year wise expenditure of such funds should be reported to the MoEF & CC/ SEIAA/ SPCB and its concerned Regional Office.
Additional conditions recommended in view of OM dated 08.08.2019 of the MoEF & CC (applicable where the project falls within a distance of 10 Km from the boundary of National Park/ Wildlife Sanctuary and outside notified ESZ):
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
1. The mining activity should be carried out in a manner so that the water regime/system of the sanctuary is not disturbed. The mining activity should not adversely affect any existing water course, water body, catchment etc. The PP shall while carrying out mining activity ensure compliance of the provisions of Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1981, Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1974 and the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 so that the wildlife in the area is not adversely affected.
2. The processes like blasting, drilling, excavation, transport and haulage resulting into noise, should be carried out in such an manner so that such activities do not disturb wild animals and birds particularly during sunset to sunrise. The level of noise should be kept within the permissible limits.
3. The mining activity should not create any obstacle in the way of free movement of wildlife and adversely affect wildlife corridors.
4. The mineral waste/ slurry should be dumped only at the designated places only and such waste dumps should be reclaimed in accordance with the conditions of the mining plan/ consent issued by the RSPCB under the Water and Air act.
5. The PP shall cooperate with the concerned DCF, Wildlife in their efforts towards protection and conservation of wildlife in the Sanctuary/ Park.
6. The PP shall ensure that the transporter and labor employed by him should not damage flora and fauna in the ESZ and the Wildlife Sanctuary/ National Park.
Specific Conditions applicable, in the cases of violation in terms of the Notification dated 14.3.2017 and 8.3.2018 and OMs dated 30.5.2018, 4.7.2018 of the MoEF & CC :
1. The PP shall give an undertaking by way of affidavit to comply with all the statutory requirements and judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others before grant of ToR/EC. The undertaking inter-alia include commitment of the PP not to be repeat any such violation in future. 2. In case of violation of above undertaking/ affidavit, the ToR/EC shall be liable to be terminated forthwith. 3. The environmental clearance will not be operational, till such time the Project Proponent complies with all the statutory requirements and judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others. 4. The department of Mines & Geology shall ensure that the mining operations shall not commence till the entire compensation levied, if any, for illegal mining, is paid, by the Project Proponent through the Department of Mines and Geology, in strict compliance of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02.08.2017 in the matter of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014, Common Cause V/s Union of India & others.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
ANNEXURE-“B”
TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR CONDUCTING ENVIRONMENT IMPACT ASSESSMENT STUDY FOR NON-COAL MINING PROJECTS AND INFORMATION TO BE INCLUDED IN EIA/EMP REPORT
1) Year-wise production details since 1994 should be given, clearly stating the highest production achieved in any one year prior to 1994. It may also be categorically informed whether there had been any increase in production after the EIA Notification 1994 came into force, w.r.t. the highest production achieved prior to 1994. 2) A copy of the document in support of the fact that the Proponent is the rightful lessee of the mine should be given.
3) All documents including approved mine plan, EIA and Public Hearing should be compatible with one another in terms of the mine lease area, production levels, waste generation and its management, mining technology etc. and should be in the name of the lessee.
4) All corner coordinates of the mine lease area, superimposed on a High Resolution Imagery/ toposheet, topographic sheet, geomorphology and geology of the areashould be provided. Such an Imagery of the proposed area should clearly show the land use and other ecological features of the study area (core and buffer zone).
5) Information should be provided in Survey of India Toposheet in 1:50,000 scale indicating geological map of the area, geomorphology of land forms of the area, existing minerals and mining history of the area, important water bodies, streams and rivers and soil characteristics.
6) Details about the land proposed for mining activities should be givenwith information as to whether mining conforms to the land use policy of the State; land diversion for mining should have approval from State land use board or the concerned authority.
7) It should be clearly stated whether the Proponent Company has a well laid down Environment Policy approved by its Board of Directors? If so, it may be spelt out in the EIA Report with description of the prescribed operating process/procedures to bring into focus any infringement/deviation/ violation of the environmental or forest norms/ conditions? The hierarchical system or administrative order of the Company to deal with the environmental issues and for ensuring compliance with the EC conditions may also be given. The system of reporting of non-compliances / violations of environmental norms to the Board of Directors of the Company and/or shareholders or stakeholders at large,may also be detailed in the EIA Report.
8) Issues relating to Mine Safety, including subsidence study in case of underground mining and slope study in case of open cast mining, blasting study etc. should be detailed. The proposed safeguard measures in each case should also be provided.
9) The study rea will comprise of 10 km zone around the mine lease from lease periphery and the data contained in the EIA such as waste generation etc. should be for the life of the mine / lease period.
10) Land use of the study rea delineating forest area, agricultural land, grazing land, wildlife sanctuary, national park, migratory routes of fauna, water bodies, human settlements and other ecological features should be indicated. Land use plan of the mine lease area should be prepared to encompass preoperational, operational and post operational phases and submitted. Impact, if any, of change of land use should be given.
11) Details of the land for any Over Burden Dumps outside the mine lease, such as extent of land area, distance from mine lease, its land use, R&R issues, if any, should be given.
12) A Certificate from the Competent Authority in the State Forest Department should be provided, confirming the involvement of forest land, if any, in the project area. In the event of any contrary claim by the Project Proponent regarding the status of forests, the site may be inspected by the
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
State Forest Department along with the Regional Office of the Ministry to ascertain the status of forests, based on which, the Certificate in this regard as mentioned above be issued. In all such cases, it would be desirable for representative of the State Forest Department to assist the Expert Appraisal Committees.
13) Status of forestry clearance for the broken up area and virgin forestland involved in the Project including deposition of net present value (NPV) and compensatory afforestation (CA) should be indicated. A copy of the forestry clearance should also be furnished.
14) Implementation status of recognition of forest rights under the Scheduled Tribes and other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 should be indicated.
15) The vegetation in the RF / PF areas in the study area, with necessary details, should be given.
16) A study shall be got done to ascertain the impact of the Mining Project on wildlife of the study area and details furnished. Impact of the project on the wildlife in the surrounding and any other protected area and accordingly, detailed mitigative measures required, should be worked out with cost implications and submitted.
17) Location of National Parks, Sanctuaries, Biosphere Reserves, Wildlife Corridors, Ramsar site Tiger/ Elephant Reserves/(existing as well as proposed), if any, within 10 km of the mine lease should be clearly indicated, supported by a location map duly authenticated by Chief Wildlife Warden. Necessary clearance, as may be applicable to such projects due to proximity of the ecologically sensitive areas as mentioned above, should be obtained from the Standing Committee of National Board of Wildlife and copy furnished.
18) A detailed biological study of the study area [core zone and buffer zone (10 km radius of the periphery of the mine lease)] shall be carried out. Details of flora and fauna, endangered, endemic and RET Species duly authenticated, separately for core and buffer zone should be furnished based on such primary field survey, clearly indicating the Schedule of the fauna present. In case of any scheduled-I fauna found in the study area, the necessary plan alongwith budgetary provisions for their conservation should be prepared in consultation with State Forest and Wildlife Department and details furnished. Necessary allocation of funds for implementing the same should be made as part of the project cost.
19) Proximity to Areas declared as 'Critically Polluted' or the Project areas likely to come under the 'Aravali Range', (attracting court restrictions for mining operations), should also be indicated and where so required, clearance certifications from the prescribed Authorities, such as the SPCB or State Mining Department should be secured and furnished to the effect that the proposed mining activities could be considered.
20) R&R Plan/compensation details for the Project Affected People (PAP) should be furnished. While preparing the R&R Plan, the relevant State/National Rehabilitation & Resettlement Policy should be kept in view. In respect of SCs /STs and other weaker sections of the society in the study area, a need based sample survey, family-wise, should be undertaken to assess their requirements, and action programmes prepared and submitted accordingly, integrating the sectoral programmes of line departments of the State Government. It may be clearly brought out whether the village(s) located in the mine lease area will be shifted or not. The issues relating to shifting of village(s) including their R&R and socio-economic aspects should be discussed in the Report.
21) One season (non-monsoon) [i.e. March-May (Summer Season); October-December (post monsoon season) ; December-February (winter season)]primary baseline data on ambient air quality as per CPCB Notification of 2009, water quality, noise level, soil and flora and fauna shall be collected and the AAQ and other data so compiled presented date-wise in the EIA and EMP Report. Site-specific meteorological data should also be collected. The location of the monitoring stations should be such as to represent whole of the study area and justified keeping in view the pre-dominant downwind direction and location of sensitive receptors. There should
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
be at least one monitoring station within 500 m of the mine lease in the pre-dominant downwind direction. The mineralogical composition of PM10, particularly for free silica, should be given.
22) Air quality modeling should be carried out for prediction of impact of the project on the air quality of the area. It should also take into account the impact of movement of vehicles for transportation of mineral. The details of the model used and input parameters used for modeling should be provided. The air quality contours may be shown on a location map clearly indicating the location of the site, location of sensitive receptors, if any, and the habitation. The wind roses showing pre-dominant wind direction may also be indicated on the map.
23) The water requirement for the Project, its availability and source should be furnished. A detailed water balance should also be provided. Fresh water requirement for the Project should be indicated.
24) Necessary clearance from the Competent Authority for drawl of requisite quantity of water for the Project should be provided.
25) Description of water conservation measures proposed to be adopted in the Project should be given. Details of rainwater harvesting proposed in the Project, if any, should be provided.
26) Impact of the Project on the water quality, both surface and groundwater, should be assessed and necessary safeguard measures, if any required, should be provided.
27) Based on actual monitored data, it may clearly be shown whether working will intersect groundwater. Necessary data and documentation in this regard may be provided. In case the working will intersect groundwater table, a detailed Hydro Geological Study should be undertaken and Report furnished. The Report inter-alia, shall include details of the aquifers present and impact of mining activities on these aquifers. Necessary permission from Central Ground Water Authority for working below ground water and for pumping of ground water should also be obtained and copy furnished.
28) Details of any stream, seasonal or otherwise, passing through the lease area and modification / diversion proposed, if any, and the impact of the same on the hydrology should be brought out.
29) Information on site elevation, working depth, groundwater table etc. Should be provided both in AMSL and bgl. A schematic diagram may also be provided for the same.
30) A time bound Progressive Greenbelt Development Plan shall be prepared in a tabular form (indicating the linear and quantitative coverage, plant species and time frame) and submitted, keeping in mind, the same will have to be executed up front on commencement of the Project. Phase-wise plan of plantation and compensatory afforestation should be charted clearly indicating the area to be covered under plantation and the species to be planted. The details of plantation already done should begiven. The plant species selected for green belt should have greater ecological value and should be of good utility value to the local population with emphasis on local and native species and the species which are tolerant to pollution.
31) Impact on local transport infrastructure due to the Project should be indicated. Projected increase in truck traffic as a result of the Project in the present road network (including those outside the Project area) should be worked out, indicating whether it is capable of handling the incremental load. Arrangement for improving the infrastructure, if contemplated (including action to be taken by other agencies such as State Government) should be covered. Project Proponent shall conduct Impact of Transportation study as per Indian Road Congress Guidelines.
32) Details of the onsite shelter and facilities to be provided to the mine workers should be included in the EIA Report.
33) Conceptual post mining land use and Reclamation and Restoration of mined out areas (with plans and with adequate number of sections) should be given in the EIA report.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
34) Occupational Health impacts of the Project should be anticipated and the proposed preventive measures spelt out in detail. Details of pre-placement medical examination and periodical medical examination schedules should be incorporated in the EMP. The project specific occupational health mitigation measures with required facilities proposed in the mining area may be detailed.
35) Public health implications of the Project and related activities for the population in the impact zone should be systematically evaluated and the proposed remedial measures should be detailed along with budgetary allocations.
36) Measures of socio economic significance and influence to the local community proposed to be provided by the Project Proponent should be indicated. As far as possible, quantitative dimensions may be given with time frames for implementation.
37) Detailed environmental management plan (EMP) to mitigate the environmental impacts which, should inter-alia include the impacts of change of land use, loss of agricultural and grazing land, if any, occupational health impacts besides other impacts specific to the proposed Project.
38) Public Hearing points raised and commitment of the Project Proponent on the same along with time bound Action Plan with budgetary provisions to implement the same should be provided and also incorporated in the final EIA/EMP Report of the Project.
39) Details of litigation pending against the project, if any, with direction /order passed by any Court of Law against the Project should be given.
40) The cost of the Project (capital cost and recurring cost) as well as the cost towards implementation of EMP should be clearly spelt out.
41) A Disaster management Plan shall be prepared and included in the EIA/EMP Report.
42) Benefits of the Project if the Project is implemented should be spelt out. The benefits of the Project shall clearly indicate environmental, social, economic, employment potential, etc.
43) Besides the above, the below mentioned general points are also to be followed:-
a) Executive Summary of the EIA/EMP Report
b) All documents to be properly referenced with index and continuous page numbering.
c) Where data are presented in the Report especially in Tables, the period in which the data were collected and the sources should be indicated.
d) Project Proponent shall enclose all the analysis/testing reports of water, air, soil, noise etc. using the MoEF&CC/NABL accredited laboratories. All the original analysis/testing reports should be available during appraisal of the Project.
e) Where the documents provided are in a language other than English, an English translation should be provided.
f) The Questionnaire for environmental appraisal of mining projects as devised earlier by the Ministry shall also be filled and submitted.
g) While preparing the EIA report, the instructions for the Proponents and instructions for the Consultants issued by MoEF&CC vide O.M. No. J-11013/41/2006-IA.II(I) dated 4th August, 2009, which are available on the website of this Ministry, should be followed.
h) Changes, if any made in the basic scope and project parameters (as submitted in Form-I and the PFR for securing the TOR) should be brought to the attention of MoEF&CC with reasons for such changes and permission should be sought, as the TOR may also have to be altered. Post Public Hearing changes in structure and content of the draft EIA/EMP (other than modifications arising out of the P.H. process) will entail conducting the PH again with the revised documentation. Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
i) As per the circular no. J-11011/618/2010-IA.II(I) dated 30.5.2012, certified report of the status of compliance of the conditions stipulated in the environment clearance for the existing operations of the project, should be obtained from the Regional Office of Ministry ofEnvironment, Forest and Climate Change, as may be applicable. j) The EIA report should also include (i) surface plan of the area indicating contours of main topographic features, drainage and mining area, (ii) geological maps and sections and (iii) sections of the mine pit and external dumps, if any, clearly showing the land features of the adjoining area.
Specific ToR in the cases of cluster situation:
1. The PP shall conduct Environmental Impact Assessment Study and prepare Environmental Management Plan for the entire cluster in order to capture all the possible externalities. These reports are required to incorporate carrying capacity of the cluster, transportation and related issues, replenishment and recharge issues, geo- hydrological study of the cluster. 2. The EIA/EMP shall be prepared by the state or state nominated agency or group of PP in the cluster or the PP in the cluster. The PP shall get one public consultation done for the entire cluster and after which prepare final EIA/EMP reports.
Specific ToRs applicable, in the cases of violation in terms of the Notification dated 14.3.2017 and 8.3.2018 and OMs dated 30.5.2018, 4.7.2018 of the MoEF & CC :
1. The PP shall undertake assessment of ecological damage, remediation plan and natural and community resource augmentation plan. Such plan shall be prepared as an independent chapter in the Environment Impact Assessment report. The report shall be prepared by the accredited consultant. Collection and analyses of data for assessment of ecological damage, preparation of remediation plan and natural and community resource augmentation plan shall be done by an environmental laboratory duly notified under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 or an environmental Laboratory, accredited by the National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories or a Laboratory of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research Institution working in the field of environment. 2. The Environment Management Plan shall comprise remediation plan and natural and community resource augmentation plan corresponding to ecological damage assessed and economic benefit derived due to the violation. 3. The PP shall undertake Final Environment Impact Assessment and prepare Final Environment Management Plan after conducting Public Hearing. 4. The PP shall be required to submit a bank guarantee equivalent to the amount of remediation plan and natural and community resource augmentation plan with the State Pollution Control Board and the PP shall deposit the bank guarantee prior to the grant of Environmental Clearance and which shall be released after successful implementation of the remediation plan and natural and community resource augmentation plan and after recommendation by Regional Office of the Ministry, State Level Expert Appraisal Committee and approval of SEIAA. 5. The project Proponent shall give an undertaking by way of affidavit to comply with all the statutory requirements and judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated the 2nd August 2017 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014 in the matter of Common Cause versus Union of India and Ors. before grant of ToR/ EC the undertaking inter-alia include commitment of the PP not to repeat any such violation in future. 6. In case of violation of above undertaking, the Environmental Clearance shall be liable to be terminated forthwith as per OM dated 30.5.2018 of the MoEF&CC. 7. The Environmental Clearance will not be operational till such time the project Proponent complies with all the statutory requirements and judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated the 2nd August 2017 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014 in the matter of Common Cause versus Union of India and Ors.
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021
8. State Government concerned shall ensure that mining operation shall not commence till the entire compensation levied, if any, for illegal mining is paid by the Project Proponent through their respective Department of Mining & Geology in strict compliance of judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 2nd August 2017 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 114 of 2014 in the matter of Common Cause versus Union of India and Ors.
The validity period of this ToRs letter would be for a period of four years from the date of dispatch of the ToRs letter.
S. No Items in the letter of the ToRs Reply / Response by the PP
Final minutes of 4.91st meeting held on 29-30 June and 01 July 2021