CALVARY VERSUS EARTHLY PARADISE in Late Antiquity the Story

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

CALVARY VERSUS EARTHLY PARADISE in Late Antiquity the Story CHAPTER FOUR THE CAVE OF TREASURES: CALVARY VERSUS EARTHLY PARADISE In late antiquity the story of Adam and Eve’s expulsion from paradise drew the attention of both Jewish and Christian writers,1 among them early Syriac authors such as Ephrem and the anonymous writer of Liber Graduum discussed earlier in Chapters 2 and 3. Closely con- nected to it was interest in the biblical account of Cain’s crime and punishment, which might itself have functioned as a reiteration of sorts both of Adam’s original sin and of his expulsion from paradise.2 No wonder then that according to some early Jewish traditions the primordial disaster to the human race had to do not so much with the expulsion from paradise but with Cain’s crime (or, alternatively, his hideous nature).3 Traditions of this kind were further developed in a number of Gnostic sources from late antiquity.4 Related motifs and themes attested in Greek and Syriac texts have been studied in detail by J. B. Glenthoj,5 whose work has provided very useful data for further comparative study. On the Syriac side we have, in addition to a number of relevant passages in biblical commentaries and homi- lies by such authors as Ephrem and Jacob of Serugh, a Syriac Life of Abel published by S. Brock6 and an untitled composition published by A. Levene.7 1 See, for example, G. Anderson, The Genesis of Perfection; B. L. Visotsky, Fathers of the World: Essays in Rabbinic and Patristic Literatures (Tübingen, 1995). 2 See P. R. Davies, “Sons of Cain,” in J. D. Martin and P. R. Davies (eds.), A Word in Season: Essays in Honour of William McKane, Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement Series 42 (1986), pp. 35–56. 3 E.g., attested in Philo (Questions on Genesis 60; On the Posterity and Exile of Cain 2–4) and Aramaic Targums (e.g., Tg. Ps.-J. to Gen 6:4). 4 See B. A. Pearson, “Cain and Cainites,” in idem, Gnosticism, Judaism, and Egyp- tian Christianity (Minneapolis, 1990), pp. 95–107, esp. 103. 5 J. B. Glenthoj, Cain and Abel in Syriac and Greek Writers (4th–6th centuries) (Louvain, 1997). 6 See S. P. Brock, “A Syriac Life of Abel,” Le Muséon 87 (1974), pp. 467–492, who suggested a late fifth or early sixth century date for its composition. 7 A. Levene, The Early Syrian Fathers on Genesis (London, 1951). 88 chapter four This chapter deals with The Cave of Treasures (CT), another original Syriac work that in its opening sections extensively addresses both the story of the protoplasts and that of Cain and Abel. There seems to be a scholarly consensus that CT was originally composed in Syriac; the text has been presented by Ri as extant in two—West-Syriac and East-Syriac—recensions (R. Oc. and R. Or. respectively).8 The fourth century has often been seen as the time of compilation of an earlier version of the text; Ri in his edition of CT proposes the first half of the third century, but in any case it is plausible that earlier traditions found their way into the text. A final redaction at the beginning of the sixth century by an East-Syrian scholar is usually assumed.9 As a whole, CT narrates the history of salvation from the days of the creation and Adam’s fall all the way to Jesus’ death and resurrection and the Pentecost. Our investigation focuses on the salient narrative strategies of CT, employing a number of unique motifs, such as play- ing down the negative effects of Adam’s sin and the expulsion from paradise, presenting the ritual swearing by Abel’s innocent blood as a self-sufficient salvific act, and highlighting the remoteness of Jeru- salem and Golgotha—the traditional arena of Christian redemption discourse—from the initial locus of earthly bliss in the East. Some of these peculiar motifs are backed in CT by references to certain oddi- ties in the Old Testament text itself. CT seems to be aware of both the exegetical problems posed by the biblical source and a spectrum of existing exegetical solutions. The unique trends attested inCT will be outlined vis-à-vis relevant traditions in both Christian and Jew- ish exegesis of late antiquity; this analysis will make possible a better appreciation of the polemical stance of the cult-oriented community behind CT. Expulsion or Orderly Exodus? The notion that having been expelled from paradise Adam continued to dwell in its vicinity is strongly present in the Greek Life of Adam 8 S.-M. Ri, La Caverne des Tresors. Les deux recensions Syriaces, CSCO (Louvain, 1987). 9 For a recent discussion of the status quaestionis and new suggestions, see C. Leon- hard, “Observations on the Date of the Syriac Cave of Treasures,” in M. Daviau, J. W. Wevers, and M. Weigl (eds.), The World of the Arameans III. Studies in Language and Literature in Honour of Paul-Eugène Dion (Sheffield, 2001), pp. 255–294. .
Recommended publications
  • Cave of Treasures (Occidental Recension)1
    CAVE OF TREASURES (OCCIDENTAL RECENSION)1 §2 Regarding the making of Adam. During the first week, on Friday, while stillness ruled over all the hosts of heaven, God the Father said to the Son and to the Holy Spirit: ‘Come, let Us make humanity in Our image and in accordance with Our likeness.’ When the heavenly hosts heard this sound, they grew agitated and said to one another: ‘Presently we will behold a great marvel—the form of our God and our Creator!’ They watched God’s right hand as it reached out and spread open beyond the entire world, and gathered into the palm of His hand every created thing which He had created. They observed that He took from the whole earth (only) a particle of dirt, and from all the fluid substances (only) a drop of water, and from the entire upper atmosphere (only the) ‘living soul,’2 and from the element of fire (only some) heat. The angels watched while those scant parts of the four elements were compounded, (and) God made Adam. [Why did God construct Adam from the elements?]3 Only to indicate through these (elements) that everything which is in him will be subject to him: the particle of dirt (indicates) that all substances originating from earth will be subject to him; the drop of water (indicates) that everything in the seas and rivers will belong to him; the breath of air (indicates) that all the beings who fly through the air will be his; and the heat from fire (indicates) that the angels and powers exist for his benefit.
    [Show full text]
  • Adam and Seth in Arabic Medieval Literature: The
    ARAM, 22 (2010) 509-547. doi: 10.2143/ARAM.22.0.2131052 ADAM AND SETH IN ARABIC MEDIEVAL LITERATURE: THE MANDAEAN CONNECTIONS IN AL-MUBASHSHIR IBN FATIK’S CHOICEST MAXIMS (11TH C.) AND SHAMS AL-DIN AL-SHAHRAZURI AL-ISHRAQI’S HISTORY OF THE PHILOSOPHERS (13TH C.)1 Dr. EMILY COTTRELL (Leiden University) Abstract In the middle of the thirteenth century, Shams al-Din al-Shahrazuri al-Ishraqi (d. between 1287 and 1304) wrote an Arabic history of philosophy entitled Nuzhat al-Arwah wa Raw∂at al-AfraÌ. Using some older materials (mainly Ibn Nadim; the ∑iwan al-Ìikma, and al-Mubashshir ibn Fatik), he considers the ‘Modern philosophers’ (ninth-thirteenth c.) to be the heirs of the Ancients, and collects for his demonstration the stories of the ancient sages and scientists, from Adam to Proclus as well as the biographical and bibliographical details of some ninety modern philosophers. Two interesting chapters on Adam and Seth have not been studied until this day, though they give some rare – if cursory – historical information on the Mandaeans, as was available to al-Shahrazuri al-Ishraqi in the thirteenth century. We will discuss the peculiar historiography adopted by Shahrazuri, and show the complexity of a source he used, namely al-Mubashshir ibn Fatik’s chapter on Seth, which betray genuine Mandaean elements. The Near and Middle East were the cradle of a number of legends in which Adam and Seth figure. They are presented as forefathers, prophets, spiritual beings or hypostases emanating from higher beings or created by their will. In this world of multi-millenary literacy, the transmission of texts often defied any geographical boundaries.
    [Show full text]
  • The Exaltation of Seth and Nazirite Asceticism in the "Cave of Treasures" Author(S): Jason Scully Source: Vigiliae Christianae, Vol
    The Exaltation of Seth and Nazirite Asceticism in the "Cave of Treasures" Author(s): Jason Scully Source: Vigiliae Christianae, Vol. 68, No. 3 (2014), pp. 310-328 Published by: Brill Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/24754367 Accessed: 12-04-2019 14:08 UTC REFERENCES Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article: https://www.jstor.org/stable/24754367?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references. JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at https://about.jstor.org/terms Brill is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Vigiliae Christianae This content downloaded from 128.228.0.55 on Fri, 12 Apr 2019 14:08:55 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms VIGILIAE CHRISTIANAECHRISTIANAE 68 68 (2014) (2014) 310-328 310-328 Vigiliae Vigiliae Christianae BRILL brill.com/vc The Exaltation of Seth and Nazirite Asceticism in the Cave of Treasures Jason Scully 47 Napoleon St. #2 Newark, NJ 07105, USA Jason. [email protected] Abstract This article argues that the Cave of Treasures mixes Jewish themes concerning the exal tation of Seth with ascetical themes found in Syrian Christian writings about Nazirite purity.
    [Show full text]
  • Temple Symbolism in the Conflict of Adam and Eve
    Studia Antiqua Volume 2 | Number 2 Article 7 February 2003 Temple Symbolism in The onflicC t of Adam and Eve Duane Wilson Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/studiaantiqua Part of the Biblical Studies Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Wilson, Duane. "Temple Symbolism in The onflC ict of Adam and Eve." Studia Antiqua 2, no. 2 (2003). http://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/studiaantiqua/vol2/iss2/7 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the All Journals at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Studia Antiqua by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Temple Symbolism in The Conflict of Adam and Eve Duane Wilson The Conflict of Adam and Eve is a fascinating pseudepigraphic work that tells the story of the couple after they are cast out of the Garden of Eden. After they left the garden, God commanded them to live in a cave called the Cave of Treasures. This paper explores the function of the Cave of Treasures as a temple to Adam and Eve. Some of the aspects of temple worship discussed include the gar- ment, the use of tokens, and aspects of prayer and revelation. The Conflict of Adam and Eve with Satan is a pseudepigraphic work of unknown authorship that was written in Arabic between the seventh and ninth centuries a.d.1 It was later translated into Ethiopic. The text is divided into three parts, the first of which contains a lengthy story about Adam and Eve after they were cast out of the Garden of Eden.
    [Show full text]
  • Temple Symbolism in the Conflict of Adam and Ve E
    Studia Antiqua Volume 2 Number 2 Article 7 February 2003 Temple Symbolism in The Conflict of Adam and vE e Duane Wilson Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/studiaantiqua Part of the Biblical Studies Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Wilson, Duane. "Temple Symbolism in The Conflict of Adam and vE e." Studia Antiqua 2, no. 2 (2003). https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/studiaantiqua/vol2/iss2/7 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Studia Antiqua by an authorized editor of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. Temple Symbolism in The Conflict of Adam and Eve Duane Wilson The Conflict of Adam and Eve is a fascinating pseudepigraphic work that tells the story of the couple after they are cast out of the Garden of Eden. After they left the garden, God commanded them to live in a cave called the Cave of Treasures. This paper explores the function of the Cave of Treasures as a temple to Adam and Eve. Some of the aspects of temple worship discussed include the gar- ment, the use of tokens, and aspects of prayer and revelation. The Conflict of Adam and Eve with Satan is a pseudepigraphic work of unknown authorship that was written in Arabic between the seventh and ninth centuries a.d.1 It was later translated into Ethiopic. The text is divided into three parts, the first of which contains a lengthy story about Adam and Eve after they were cast out of the Garden of Eden.
    [Show full text]
  • The Book of Adam and Eve, Also Called the Conflict of Adam and Eve
    -t - ». UNIVERSITY OF 9AUF0RNIAS>W DIEGO 3 1822 02258 0948 ^^K^^ ''^'':'*^-" LIBRARY ^ UNivf.oiit or I C*UfOKNlA SAN DIEGO THE BOOK OF ADAM AND EVE. THE BOOK or ADAM AND EVE, ALSO CALLED THE CONFLICT OF ADAM AND EVE WITH SATAN, A Booh of the early Eastern Churchy STransIatetJ from tf)c ^tfjiopic, WITH NOTES FROM THE KUFALE, TALMUD, MIDRASHIM, AND OTHER EASTERN WORKS, BY THE REV. a C. MALAN, D.D., VICAR OF BR0ADWIND80R. CM/IRLCS Ci^RRINGTON, 15, Faubourg Montmartrc, 13, A. LONDON G, NURMAK AND SON, PRINTERS, HART STREET, COVENT GARDEN, To THE KEV. DR. ERNEST TRUMPP, EEOIUS PROFR880R OF ORIENTAL LANGUAGES AND LITEKATUBB IN tHG USIVKRSITY OF MUNICH, AND ORDINARY MEMBER OF THE ROYAL BAVARIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES, In token of respect for his accurate and profound Oriental scholarship, from the Translator. Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2007 with funding from IVIicrosoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/bookofadamevealsOOmalaiala PREFACE. In the Sixth Book of the Apostolic Constitutions,* we find a severe censure of certain early works, among which are reckoned ^i^ia aTroKpvtpa Mcao-eo)? kuX 'Ei/wp^, koX *A8afx, 'Haatov re koI Aa^tS k. t. X. *'The apocryphal Books of Moses, of Enoch, of Adam, as well as those of Isaiah and David," etc. Those works, however, do not deserve all that the Apostles are made to say of them. The apocryphal " Book of Moses," there alluded to, is probably the XeTTTf) Fei/eo-f? or " lesser Genesis," known as having existed of old in Greek, under that name; and also under that of *A'KOKd\v'^L<i M., or TO, ^lovfitjXaia "the Apocalypse of Moses," or " the Book of Jubilees," quoted by S.
    [Show full text]
  • The Book of the Cave of Treasures
    THE BOOK OF THE CAVE OF TREASURES A HISTORY OF THE PATRIARCHS AND THE KINGS, THEIR SUCCESSORS FROM THE CREATION TO THE CRUCIFIXION OF CHRIST TRANSLATED FROM THE SYRIAC TEXT OF THE BRITISH MUSEUM MS. ADD. 25875 BY E. A. WALLIS BUDGE 1927 The Book of the Cave of Treasures by E. A. Wallis Budge. This edition was created and published by Global Grey ©GlobalGrey 2018 globalgreyebooks.com CONTENTS Preface Introduction THE BOOK OF THE CAVE OF TREASURES The First Thousand Years The Second Thousand Years The Third Thousand Years The Fourth Thousand Years The Fifth Thousand Years The Five Hundred Years from the Second Year of Cyrus to the Birth of Christ Testamentum Adami Supplementary Translations From The "Book Of The Bee." Abraham And The City Of Ur Illustrations Bibliography Sumerian relief in copper on wood representing Imdugud, or Imgig, the lion-headed eagle of Ningirsu, the great god of Lagash, grasping two stags by their tails. It is probable that it was originally placed over the door of the temple of Nin-khursag or Damgalnun at the head of the stairway leading on to the temple platform. This remarkable monument was made about 3100 B.C., and was discovered by Dr. H. R. Hall in 1919 at Tall al-`Ubêd, a sanctuary at "Ur of the Chaldees" in Lower Babylonia. It is now in the British Museum (No. 114308). 1 PREFACE THE present volume contains a complete translation of the Syriac text of the compendious history of the world from the Creation to the Crucifixion of our Lord, which is commonly known as "Me`ârath Gazzê," or the "Cave of Treasures." In the Syriac title the composition of the work is attributed to Ap[h]rêm Suryâyâ, i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • The Forgotten Books of Eden Edited by Rutherford H
    The Forgotten Books Of Eden edited by Rutherford H. Platt, Jr. New York, N.Y.; Alpha House [1926] Scanned, proofed and formatted at sacred-texts.com, April 2004, by John Bruno Hare. This text is in the public domain in the US because its copyright was not renewed in a timely fashion. THE ORDER OF ALL THE BOOKS OF THE FORGOTTEN BOOKS OF EDEN The First Book of Adam and Eve The Second Book of Adam and Eve The Secrets of Enoch The Psalms of Solomon The Odes of Solomon The Letter of Aristeas The Fourth Book of Maccabees The Story of Ahikar The Testament of Reuben Simeon Levi Judah Issachar Zebulun Dan Naphtali Gad Asher Joseph Benjamin PREFACE TODAY the medley of outward life has made a perplexity of inward life. We moderns have ruffled our old incertitudes to an absurd point--incertitudes that are older than theology. Not without justification have priests mounted altars for generations and cried, "Oh my soul, why dost thou trouble me?" We are active, restless both in body and mind. Curiosity has replaced blind faith. We go groping, peering, searching, scornful of dogmas, back, further back to sources. And just as the physicist thrills at the universes he discovers as he works inward in the quest of his electrons, so the average man exults in his apprehension of fundamentals of psychology. New cults spring up, attesting to the Truth--as they see it--countless fleets of Theism, Buchmanism, Theosophy, Bahai'ism, etc., sail under brightly colored flags; and Atheism is flaunting itself on the horizon.
    [Show full text]
  • Pirke De-Rabbi Eliezer and Eastern Christian Exegesis∗
    Pirke de-Rabbi Eliezer and Eastern Christian Exegesis ∗ Helen SPURLING – Emmanouela GRYPEOU University of Cambridge Resumen: This paper will discuss the use of traditions from the Christian Orient for the understanding of the development of the motifs in Pirke de-Rabbi Eliezer. The process of the development of the material in PRE is much discussed, with particular reference to other Jewish literature. However, a number of the motifs that represent a new development in PRE are also common ideas in sources from the Christian Orient. This paper will focus on four examples from PRE which reflect exegesis also found in traditions of the Christian Orient, and mark an initial endeavour to identify the material in PRE that may have been influenced by Christian thought. Abstract: Este artículo estudia la utilización de las tradiciones procedentes del Oriente Cristiano para poder comprender el desarrollo de los motivos contenidos en el Pirke de-Rabbi Eliezer. El proceso del desarrollo del material contenido en el PRE es analizado en detalle, con especial referencia al resto de la literatura judáica. Sin embargo, un número de motivos que representan un nuevo desarrollo en el PRE son, así mismo, ideas comunes en fuentes del Oriente Cristiano. Este artículo se ocupa de cuatro ejemplos del PRE, que reflejan una exégesis que se encuentra también en tradiciones del Oriente Cristiano y marcan una tentativa inicial para identificar aquel material del PRE que puede haber sido influenciado por el pensamiento cristiano. Palabras clave: Pirke de-Rabbi Eliezer. Oriente cristiano. Exégesis. Génesis. Keywords: Pirke de-Rabbi Eliezer. Christian Orient. Exegesis. Genesis.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Thanks to Dr. Monty White, Charles Martin, and Dr. Tommy Mitchell
    First printing: May 2014 Printed by Toppan Excel, Guangzhou, Guangdong, China Copyright ©2014 Master Books. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or Cover Design: Diana Bogardus; Book Design: Terry White; Illustrations: Bill Looney reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission of the publisher, except in the Other Images: Thinkstock.com, istockphoto.com, Wikimedia Common and Answers in Genesis USA. case of brief quotations in articles and reviews. For information write: Unless otherwise noted, Scripture quotations are from the New King James Version of the Bible. Master Books®, P. O. Box 726, Green Forest, AR 72638. Please visit our website for other great titles: www.masterbooks.net Master Books is a division of the New Leaf Publishing Group, Inc. For information on author interviews, please contact the publicity department at (870) 438-5288. ISBN 13: 978-0-89051-801-4; Library of Congress Number: 2014931473 Please consider requesting that a copy of this volume be purchased by your local library system. Special thanks to Dr. Monty White, Charles Martin, and Dr. Tommy Mitchell. Water, Water, and Water Everywhere! It sounds like a scenario straight out of Hollywood — a massive Flood sweeps across the surface of the planet and wipes out all life except for a small band of survivors and a handful of animals. But this is not just a biblical reference to Noah and his ark — it is an event echoed by hundreds of legendary accounts from all around the world (Morris 2001), possibly as many as 500 according to some sources (Conolly and Grigg 2000).
    [Show full text]
  • The Cave of Treasures a History of the Patriarchs and the Kings Their Successors from the Creation to the Crucifixion of Christ
    The Book of the Cave of Treasures A History of the Patriarchs and the Kings Their Successors from the Creation to the Crucifixion of Christ Translated from the Syriac Text of the British Museum Ms. Add. 25875 By Sir E. A. Wallis Budge, Kt. M.A., Litt.D. (Cambridge), M.A., D.Litt. (Oxford), D.Lit. (Durham), F.S.A. Sometime Keeper of Egyptian and Assyirian Antiquities, British Museum; Corresponding Member of the Academy of Sciences, Lisbon; and Corresponding Member of the Philosophical Society of America London The Religious Tract Society Manchester, Madrid, Lisbon, Budapest 1927 1 of 130 Contents Preface Introduction: The Sources of the "Cave of Treasures" And Its Contents Translation of the Cave Of Treasures: The First Thousand Years The Second Thousand Years The Third Thousand Years The Fourth Thousand Years The Fifth Thousand Years The Five Hundred Years from the Second Year of Cyrus to the Birth of Christ Testamentum Adami Supplementary Translations from the "Book of the Bee:" The Assumption of the Virgin Our Lord's Ten Appearances after His Resurrection The Last Supper The Apostles--The Twelve and the Seventy The Names of the Apostles Chronology Gog And Magog The Coming Of Anti-Christ The Names Of The Translators Of The Bible From Hebrew Into Greek Bibliography 2 of 130 Preface THE present volume contains a complete translation of the Syriac text of the compendious history of the world from the Creation to the Crucifixion of our Lord, which is commonly known as "Me`ârath Gazzê," or the "Cave of Treasures." In the Syriac title the composition of the work is attributed to Ap[h]rêm Suryâyâ, i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • Late Paganism As Witnessed by the Syriac Cave of Treasures Alexander Toepel
    Late Paganism as Witnessed by the Syriac Cave of Treasures Alexander Toepel HE SIXTH CENTURY CE is commonly seen as the final twilight of Greco-Roman religion. With the emperor T Justinian prohibiting the performance of pagan rites even in private, the religious tradition of ancient Greece and Rome practically had come to an end.1 The closing of the Neoplatonic Academy at Athens in 529 and subsequent flight of its last scholarch Damascius to Persia effectively destroyed if not the theoretical basis of paganism then at least an important part of its educational infrastructure.2 At the same time the demoli- tion of temples or their rededication as churches had become endemic in all parts of the empire. In spite of this, the Syriac Book of the Cave of Treasures (henceforth CT ), a Christian apocryphal work of the late sixth or early seventh century written on Persian ground, bears witness to an apparently still vibrant practice of 1 Cf. K. W. Harl, “Sacrifice and Pagan Belief in Fifth- and Sixth-century Byzantium,” PastPres 128 (1990) 7–27, here 22–26. Whereas public displays of pagan beliefs had been banned from the early fifth century onward, Justinian’s measures “made it against the law even to be a pagan” (Alan Cam- eron, “Paganism in Sixth-century Byzantium,” in Wandering Poets and Other Essays on Late Greek Literature and Philosophy [Oxford 2016] 255–286, here 255). On the anti-pagan legislation of Theodosius II in the first half of the fifth century see J. Hahn, “Gesetze als Waffe? Die kaiserliche Religionspolitik und die Zerstörung der Tempel,” in Spätantiker Staat und religiöser Konflikt (Berlin 2011) 201–220.
    [Show full text]