Theory and Practice of Lineage Tracing
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REGENERATIVE MEDICINE Theory and Practice of Lineage Tracing a,b YA-CHIEH HSU Key Words. Cell surface markers • Stem cell-microenvironment interactions • Cell cycle • Cell biology • Adult stem cells aDepartment of Stem Cell ABSTRACT and Regenerative Biology, Lineage tracing is a method that delineates all progeny produced by a single cell or a group of Harvard University, cells. The possibility of performing lineage tracing initiated the field of Developmental Biology Cambridge, Massachusetts, and continues to revolutionize Stem Cell Biology. Here, I introduce the principles behind a suc- USA; bHarvard Stem Cell cessful lineage-tracing experiment. In addition, I summarize and compare different methods for Institute, Cambridge, conducting lineage tracing and provide examples of how these strategies can be implemented Massachusetts, USA to answer fundamental questions in development and regeneration. The advantages and limita- Correspondence: Ya-Chieh Hsu, tions of each method are also discussed. STEM CELLS 2015;33:3197–3204 Department of Stem Cell and Regenerative Biology, Harvard University, 7 Divinity Ave., SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA. Telephone: Lineage relationships allow one to understand the cellular hierarchy of a tissue or organ, which (617) 496-3757; Fax: (617) 496- is central to both Developmental Biology and Stem Cell Biology. Different approaches have 3763; e-mail: yachiehhsu@fas. been developed to conduct lineage tracing. Understanding the underlying basis of these harvard.edu approaches, as well as their advantages and limitations, will allow one to choose the most Received March 26, 2015; appropriate method for a given question. accepted for publication June 23, 2015; first published online STEM CELLS in EXPRESS August 3, cells that are marked at the initial time point, 2015. INTRODUCTION so that the starting populations are clearly VC AlphaMed Press In a lineage-tracing experiment, the cells of defined. (b) The markers used to mark the 1066-5099/2014/$30.00/0 interest are marked at one time point, and the cells remain exclusively in the original cells progeny derived from these marked cells are and their progeny and will not diffuse to the http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1002/stem.2123 revealed at a later time point. In the 1870s, neighboring cells. (c) These markers are suffi- Charles Otis Whitman observed the early divi- ciently stable and are not toxic to the cells sion of leech embryos and followed the fate during the entire tracing period. Violation of of individual cells from the one-cell stage to any of these requirements can result in label- the germ-layer stage [1, 2]. This seminal work ing of unrelated cells or alteration in cell suggested that a definite developmental fate behavior, thus leading to misinterpretation of could be assigned to each cell in the early the tracing results. cleavage eggs and its clonal progeny. As such, Below, some of the most commonly used cell fate determination is not a stochastic pro- lineage-tracing strategies are summarized, cess as previously speculated. Since the early beginning with historical perspectives, followed 20th century, developmental biologists have by recent notable examples. Understanding the developed numerous ways for tracking pros and cons and the underlying principles of descendants produced by specific cells, with each tracing method can greatly facilitate the desire to unravel how a complex organism experimental design and data interpretation. develops from a single cell. The same principle has now been widely adapted by stem cell biologists, as the central theme of adult stem NONSELECTIVE MARKERS cell biology is to understand how a diverse array of cell types is formed and maintained. Many membrane, cytoplasmic, and nuclear In fact, lineage tracing remains the most rigor- dyes have been developed for a wide variety ous method to define adult stem cells for a of applications. Although these dyes are often given tissue. nonselective in terms of which cells get Although the actual strategies evolve with labeled, when combined with carefully time, a successful lineage-tracing experiment designed strategies, it is sometimes possible to always needs to fulfill the following three label only a specific subset of cells. This nonse- requirements. (a) A careful assessment of the lective nature can therefore become STEM CELLS 2015;33:3197–3204 www.StemCells.com VC AlphaMed Press 2015 3198 Theory and Practice of Lineage Tracing Figure 1. Lineage tracing with nonselective dyes. (A): Strategies employed by Walter Vogt to mark small areas of embryos with vital dyes. (B): Schematic representation of the bitransgenic strategy to mark slow-cycling cells. Abbreviations: CMV, cytomegalovirus pro- moter; Doxy: doxycyclin; GFP, green fluorescent protein; H2B, histone H2B subunit; TetR: Tet repressor; TRE: tetracycline response ele- ment; VP16, virion protein 16. advantageous as it can be used when genetic labeling meth- Therefore, these dyes are less effective for labeling highly pro- ods (see below) are not feasible. Since each marker has dis- liferating cells. Nevertheless, these dyes were successfully tinct properties, it is particularly important to keep in mind applied to studying the development of trunk neural crests and the three abovementioned requirements and evaluate the endothelial cell lineage [4, 5] and were used to construct whether the cells of interest are indeed specifically labeled. an impressive fate map of zebrafish neural plate [6]. Vital Dye Nucleotide Pulse-Chase Using a colored substrate to label cells seems like an intuitive Initially designed as a method to identify slow-cycling cells idea—a dyed cell can be distinguished easily from the rest of within a tissue, nucleotide pulse-chase experiments can also the tissues. However, how a dye can be specifically applied to be used to determine lineages. The idea is simple: when pro- a small number of cells and whether the dye is harmful to viding a Thymidine analog (3H-Thymidine, BrdU, or EdU) to an the cells are among the biggest challenges. In 1929, embryol- organism at a specific time (pulse), all the proliferating cells ogist Walter Vogt pioneered the use of “vital dye” (a dye that will incorporate the labeled Thymidine into their newly syn- stains but does not kill cells) to study cell fate in Xenopus thesized DNA. However, labeled cells that continue to prolifer- embryos. He implanted a tiny agar chip containing Nile Blue ate after the pulse period will dilute out the incorporated on top of the cells of interests. The dye is absorbed by the Thymidine analog through each round of division. On the cells underneath the chip, and the fate of the labeled cells other hand, cells that do not proliferate much after the initial can be followed over time (Fig. 1A). By altering the position pulse will retain the labeled Thymidine analog even after a of the chip, Vogt was able to label different areas of the long period of time (chase). The fate of these label-retaining cleavage embryo. The information gathered from this cells (LRCs) can therefore be followed using the incorporated approach allowed Vogt to construct a “fate map” of the 32- nucleotide as a marker. Inspired by this idea, Tumbar et al. cell blastula Xenopus embryos [3]. further developed a bi-transgenic strategy that uses green flu- orescent protein (GFP)-labeled histone H2B (H2B-GFP). In this Carbocyanine Dyes and Dextrans approach, H2B-GFP is initially induced in all of the cells Vital dyes are water-soluble and might diffuse to neighboring intended to be monitored (pulse). During the chase period, cells, which violates the second principle of lineage tracing. As the synthesis of new H2B-GFP is turned off. Cells that are a result, a dye-positive cell can either be the progeny of the slow-cycling retain their H2B-GFP, while fast-cycling cells dilute cells labeled originally or an unrelated cell that absorbs the dif- their H2B-GFP and become GFP negative [7] (Fig. 1B). fused dye. The invention of carbocyanine dyes (lipid-soluble but By contrast, if only the cells of interest are proliferative water-insoluble dyes) such as DiI or DiO and high-molecular- and all the other cells are quiescent at a specific time point, weight dextrans (large molecules that cannot pass through cell it is also possible to introduce a short pulse of BrdU and fol- junctions) conjugated with fluorochromes circumvented this low the fate of these proliferating cells before BrdU becomes issue. These molecules are often directly injected into specific too diluted to detect. For this strategy to work effectively, a cell(s) of interests, which requires substantial technical skills. In thorough understanding of proliferation timing and division addition, they are diluted through each round of cell division. pattern within a tissue is essential. One successful example is VC AlphaMed Press 2015 STEM CELLS Hsu 3199 seen in determining the fate of outer root sheath (ORS) cells sequence variants can also be used as inherited genomic sig- in the hair follicle [8]. By first performing a detailed prolifera- natures that allow lineage relationships to be reconstructed. tion analysis of the hair follicle, specific parts of ORS cells can One important consideration is that somatic mutations can be be labeled with either H2BGFP or BrdU by altering the timing used to construct cell lineages only if the mutations do not of pulse and chase. As different parts of ORS cells share the confer a growth advantage or disadvantage since such same genetic markers, it would otherwise be impossible to changes can bias lineage contributions. Based upon this idea, determine their fate using genetic strategies. Ehud Shapiro’s group conducted DNA sequencing of the highly One major pitfall of using radioactive 3H-Thymidine or mutated DNA satellite regions and used this information to BrdU/EdU to label cells is its potential cytotoxicity. While the build cell lineage trees [15, 16]. They demonstrated that toxicity of short-term BrdU labeling is minimal, 10-day contin- mouse lymphoma likely begins from a single aberrant cell uous BrdU labeling was shown to force normally dormant [17].