WALTON-DISSERTATION-2019.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Language of Rebellion in the Hebrew Bible and the Ambivalent Attitude(s) It Represents The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Walton, Andrew Edward. 2019. The Language of Rebellion in the Hebrew Bible and the Ambivalent Attitude(s) It Represents. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:42029728 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA ! ! "#$!%&'()&($!*+!,$-$../*'!/'!0#$!1$-2$3!4/-.$!&'5!0#$!67-/8&.$'0!600/0)5$9:;!/0!,$<2$:$'0:! ! ! 6!5/::$20&0/*'!<2$:$'0$5!! -=! 6'52$3!>53&25!?&.0*'! 0*! "#$!@$<&207$'0!*+!A$&2!>&:0$2'!%&'()&($:!&'5!B/8/./C&0/*':! ! /'!<&20/&.!+).+/.7$'0!*+!0#$!2$D)/2$7$'0:!! +*2!0#$!5$(2$$!*+! @*E0*2!*+!F#/.*:*<#=! /'!0#$!:)-G$E0!*+!! 6'E/$'0!A$&2!>&:0$2'!H0)5/$:! ! ! 1&28&25!I'/8$2:/0=! B&7-2/5($J!K&::&E#):$00:! ! 6<2/.!LMNO! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! P!LMNO!6'52$3!>53&25!?&.0*'! ! 6..!,/(#0:!,$:$28$5Q! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! @/::$20&0/*'!658/:*2R!F2*+$::*2!F$0$2!K&E#/'/:0! ! ! !!!!!!!!6'52$3!>53&25!?&.0*'! ! "#$!%&'()&($!*+!,$-$../*'!/'!0#$!1$-2$3!4/-.$!&'5!0#$!67-/8&.$'0!600/0)5$9:;!/0!,$<2$:$'0:! ! ! 6-:02&E0!! ! ,$-$../*'!#&:!-$$'!&'!/'E$::&'0!+$&0)2$!*+!#)7&'!#/:0*2=!&'5!$8$2=!:*E/$0=!#&:!#&5!0*! :02)((.$!3/0#!/0Q!"#$!:0&0$:!*+!S:2&$.!&'5!T)5&#!3$2$!'*!5/++$2$'0!/'!0#/:!2$(&25Q!"#$:$!03*! :*E/$0/$:J!/':*+&2!&:!0#$=!&2$!2$<2$:$'0$5!/'!0#$!1$-2$3!4/-.$J!5/:E)::$5!0#$!0*</E!*+!2$-$../*'! 3/0#!:*7$!+2$D)$'E=Q!"#$/2!5/:E)::/*':!<2*8/5$!2$&5$2:!3/0#!&!3/'5*3!/'0*!3#&0!:*7$!/'! &'E/$'0!S:2&$.!0#*)(#0!&-*)0!0#/:!<*./0/E&.!&E0Q!6:!/:!0#$!E&:$!3/0#!7&'=!:*E/$0/$:J!0#$!.&'()&($!*+! 2$-$../*'!/'!&'E/$'0!S:2&$.!3&:!8&:0!&'5!E*7<./E&0$5Q!6:!&!2$:).0J!7*5$2'!:E#*.&2:!#&8$!*+0$'! E*'+):$5!0#$!')7$2*):!2$-$../*'!0$27:!&<<$&2/'(!/'!0#$!1$-2$3!4/-.$!9$Q(Q!drm!"ovp!"rvq!"afh;! &'5!#&8$!+&/.$5!&5$D)&0$.=!0*!5/:E)::!*0#$2:!&:!2$-$../*'!0$27:!9$Q(Q!ovy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drmJ!ovp!&'5! rvqQ!"#$=!#&5!$U<2$::/*':!0#&0!E*).5!:0&'5!/'!0*!5$:E2/-$!2$-$../*'!&:!/'!b dy MwrQ!"#$2$!&2$!&.:*! <*:/0/8$!2$-$../*'!0$27:Vovy!&'5!lxnV0#&0!+*E):!*'!0#$!&:<$E0!*+!./-$2&0/*'Q!S'!E*'02&:0!0#$! -/-./E&.!32/0$2:!&.:*!$7<.*=!0$27:!E*''$E0$5!0*!E2/7/'&.!-$#&8/*2!9$Q(Q!afj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drm, ovp, rvq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`/'`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a!8*.:Q!A$3!b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`6::=2/&'!F$2/*5! CD-! ! C&#%%&[6/'*!1&4!-,,:46'%'26&!A*1!5'41&4#,6#+6,.8&*!-4.8I'%'26&U!\!8*.:;U! B--! ! H0&0$!62E#/8$:!*+!6::=2/&! B--7! ! B+#+&!-4.865&,!'(!-,,:46#!7A%%&+6*!! B--B!