Reader's Guide for Maaza Mengiste's Beneath the Lion's Gaze
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Wright State University CORE Scholar Ten Years of the Dayton Literary Peace Prize Class Materials Accords: Peace, War, and the Arts Spring 2015 Reader's Guide for Maaza Mengiste's Beneath the Lion's Gaze Andrew Strombeck Wright State University - Main Campus, [email protected] Victoria Carson Abigail Booher Wright State University - Main Campus Andrew Hurst Wright State University - Main Campus Follow this and additional works at: https://corescholar.libraries.wright.edu/celia_ten_years_dlpp_class Part of the Education Commons Repository Citation Strombeck, A., Carson, V., Booher, A., & Hurst, A. (2015). Reader's Guide for Maaza Mengiste's Beneath the Lion's Gaze. https://corescholar.libraries.wright.edu/celia_ten_years_dlpp_class/1 This Guide is brought to you for free and open access by the Accords: Peace, War, and the Arts at CORE Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Ten Years of the Dayton Literary Peace Prize Class Materials by an authorized administrator of CORE Scholar. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Reader’s Guide for Beneath the Lion’s Gaze Victoria Carson, Abigail Booher, Andrew Hurst Beneath the Lion's Gaze Reader's Guide 2 Table of Contents Thematic Threads .................................................................................................. 3 1. The family as a frame through which to view conflict. ............................................................. 3 2. Violence as both enchanted and disenchanted. ....................................................................... 3 3. The appropriate response to social injustice. ........................................................................... 4 Historical Contexts ................................................................................................. 5 Emperor Selassie ........................................................................................................................... 5 Lost Families .................................................................................................................................. 5 Executions of November 24, 1975 ................................................................................................ 6 Torture ........................................................................................................................................... 6 Sources .......................................................................................................................................... 7 Reader’s Guide: Review Summary ......................................................................... 8 Strong Points of the Novel ............................................................................................................ 8 Weak Points of the Novel .............................................................................................................. 8 Literary Placement of the Novel and Mengiste ............................................................................ 9 Purpose or Focus of the Novel ...................................................................................................... 9 Works Cited ................................................................................................................................... 9 Annotated Bibliography- ...................................................................................... 10 Beneath the Lion's Gaze Reader's Guide 3 Thematic Threads 1. The family as a frame through which to view conflict. Maaza Mengiste has deliberately chosen to examine the Ethiopian revolution and its effects through the lens of a family unit. While this family, including all the members of Hailu’s compound, has a variety of voices and viewpoints, readers get a local and personal sense of the violence instead of a regional or national one. Each of the family members has a unique approach to and experience of the growing violence around them. Dawit gets involved right from the beginning, Mickey ends up on the wrong side of the conflict, and Hailu, Sara, and Yonas are all initially focused on their personal lives. These different approaches not only give the reader different angles of the conflict, but also show the pervasiveness of the violence. From following Dawit and Mickey, readers understand the separate situations of the revolutionaries and the Derg. Hailu supported Emperor Selassie and did not have any revolutionary tendencies at the beginning of the novel, but when the revolution overtakes and corners Hailu into taking a stand either for or against the Derg, he defies their orders and commits a mercy killing (Mengiste 166). Sara also attempts to ignore the revolution at first (Mengiste 93), but she is also dragged into an active role in the revolution by helping Dawit. This focus on the family not only gives readers a personal view of the violence and its affects, it also shows how the violence affects familial relationships. Dawit and Mickey were like brothers but find themselves on opposing sides. Yonas and Sara are driven apart as Sara “pushed him away, aware that his presence would only raise questions she couldn’t answer” (Mengiste 246). The violent environment that this family are put into forces wedges between members, especially between characters who have experienced violence and those who have not. As readers view the Ethiopian revolution mostly through the eyes of a single family compound (with brief interludes of Emperor Selassie’s perspective), they only know as much as the characters. This lack of omniscience for the reader emphasizes the overwhelming presence of the violence and the inescapability of it; both the characters and the readers don’t know if the characters will make it through this violence in one piece. 2. Violence as both enchanted and disenchanted. Descriptions of violence and pain are interspersed throughout the novel, which is not surprising considering it is about a revolution. In many ways, the violence is this book is uncomplicated in the sense that it is committed by a relatively clear antagonist; the Derg is brutal and merciless. However the violence in the novel is complex as it seems to both reject and accept the concept of enchantment according to literary critic Sarah Cole’s definition: “Enchantment refers to the tendency to see in violence some kind of transformative power” (1633). The Communist Derg has an enchanted view of violence in that they expect the nation of Ethiopia to be transformed into something better through their violent overtaking. However the results in the novel as well as the results in history discredit this view. The Derg’s violence is not represented as accomplishing any good for the nation. On the contrary, although one of the primary complaints against Emperor Selassie was that he “lost touch with his subjects” (Whitman 40), especially as many of his subjects were suffering from a drought and associated famine (Keller 609), another greater famine savaged Ethiopia from 1983 to 1986 during the Beneath the Lion's Gaze Reader's Guide 4 Derg’s rule. Not only did the violence cause a lot of harm, it did not accomplish the transformative good it set out to do. On the other hand, the violence in the novel does have strong transformative power. The violence transforms the everyday lives of this family unit, changing their decisions and focuses. After Hailu is exposed to the violence that was committed against the girl in the hospital, he does something that he would have never considered doing otherwise: the mercy killing (Mengiste 166). Sara’s entire focus was wrapped up in Tizita, but as the violence infiltrates her world, she says “I don’t want [Tizita] growing up thinking we didn’t fight back” (Mengiste 234). So on the individual level, the novel seems to accept an enchanted and transformative view of violence. 3. The appropriate response to social injustice. A primary question throughout the novel concerns the appropriate individual response to social injustice and violence. In the first chapter of her book Regarding the Pain of Others, Susan Sontag discusses Virginia Woolf’s belief “that the shock of such pictures [of destruction caused by violence] cannot fail to unite people of good will” (Sontag 6). Sontag, however, goes on to question this stance, saying that while for some people these images of the aftermath of violence will trigger feelings of sympathy and longing for peace, the images for others will “quicken hatred of the foe” (Sontag 10). We see these different reactions played out in Hailu’s living room as the family watches footage of the drought stricken parts of Ethiopia. As they look at the “gaping faces…destitute land…another body, another helpless mother, another bloated boy,” Yonas is moved to tears, Dawit is incensed against Emperor Selassie and his government, and Hailu dismisses it as “More propaganda…Haile Selassie loves his country. We’re not being told everything” (Mengiste 50-51). These varying responses expose the complexity of the situation and push the question of what an individual should do in the face of social injustice. Both the Derg and the revolutionary students are pushing against Emperor Selassie, largely triggered by the starvation in parts of the country. Although the starvation was due to a drought and not malicious violence against the peasants, nearly 200,000 people had died by the end of 1973 (Keller 611) and the revolutionaries blamed the government for ignoring the crisis while continuing to live in luxury. The images