L-G-0012831965-0046432386.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Fictions of John Fowles This page intentionally left blank The Fictions of John Fowles POWER, Creativity, Femininity Pamela Cooper with a foreword by Linda Hutcheon University of Ottawa Press Ottawa • Paris University of Ottawa Press, 1991 Printed and bound in Canada ISBN 0-7766-0299-3 Canadian Cataloguing in Publication Data Cooper, Pamela, 1955- The fictions of John Fowles Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 0-7766-0299-3 1. Fowles, John, 1926- — Criticism and interpretation. I. Title. PR6056.O85Z56 1991 823'.914 C91-090461-8 UNIVERSITE D'OTTAWA UNIVERSITY OF OTTAWA This book has been published with the help of a grant from the Canadian Federation for the Humanities, using funds provided by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. Cover Design: Judith Gregory Text Design: Marie Tappin CONTENTS Acknowledgements vi Foreword Linda Hutcheon vii Introduction 1 1 The Collector 19 2 The Magus 51 3 The French Lieutenant's Woman 103 4 The Ebony Tower 143 Conclusion — Daniel Martin, Mantissa, A Maggot 193 Bibliography 223 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The production of this book owes much to the hard work and energy of various contributors, to whom I should like to extend my thanks. Linda Hutcheon has been a consistent source of critical wisdom and personal encouragement. Her enthusiasm for and commitment to the book sustained and inspired me throughout its production. John Baird was not only enlightening but supportive, generous, and wise — when the going got rough as well as when it was smooth. For invaluable work on the manuscript and thought- provoking critical insights, I am grateful to Barry Olshen, Henry Auster, Jay Macpherson, and Sylvia Van Kirk. The commitment, professionalism, and good judgement of my editor, Janet Shorten, have been indispensable to me throughout the book's publication; I appreciate also the well-judged editorial work of Jennifer Wilson. For the friendships that provided me with a sustaining context in which to work, affectionate thanks go particularly to Catherine Griffiths, Ginny Lovering, and Lally Grauer. And special gratitude goes unstintingly to my spouse, Keith Hayes, upon whose literary and linguistic acumen, patience, love, and knowledge of computer software the creation of this work has, at every stage, depended. I am grateful to the University of Toronto, the Trustees of the Connaught Fund, the Government of Ontario, and the Canadian Federation for the Humanities for financial aid during the production of the manuscript and its publication. This book is dedicated to the memory of my parents, Mervienne Vickers Cooper and Clive Cooper. Pamela Cooper University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 1991 FOREWORD Linda Hutcheon Pamela Cooper's The Fictions of John Fowles: Power, Creativity, Femininity marks an important departure from other work on a major British writer who has managed to straddle the line between the popular and the academic in his appeal and success. This is not an introductory or descriptive survey; we have several of these already. Instead, it presents a carefully argued thesis that radically challenges the received wisdom, so to speak, or the now canonical reading of Fowles's work primarily from the perspective of his interest in how the artist comes to terms with existential freedom. Cooper has turned that relatively benign interest in freedom upside down and revealed its dark postmodern underside — power. In so doing, she has probably put her finger on at least one of the reasons for Fowles's popularity': the interplay and tensions between power and freedom aren't exactly foreign to the experience of any of us today. Fowles has proved a particularly difficult author to write about with any degree of fairness. By this I mean that his novels certainly have their detractors (and their name is legion): paradox- ically, perhaps, they are usually found either too ethically conser- vative or too postmodernly formalist, too "tricky." This study goes beyond such first-level responses to tease out the complexities and ambiguities — moral and psychological, as well as literary — of the power relations between author and character, between author and reader. In Fowles's world, creator figures can be both tyrants and liberators, masters and slaves. Fowles's consistent ambivalence is one of the reasons he can and does end up being the darling (or the bane) of what seem like mutually incompatible camps of readers. He seems in tune with the liberal humanist values of the British tra- dition (such as a belief in the individual creative imagination and ethical responsibility); at the same time he is exploring more cur- rent and problematic issues of class and gender, while deploying what are considered postmodern narrative and linguistic strategies of reflexivity. His novels have always openly challenged notions of genre, narrative authority, textual singularity, and closure. vii PAMELA COOPER The complexity of these kinds of paradoxes is explored in Cooper's study primarily through examining the representation of women and thus the relation between art and gender in Fowles's novels. Those strong, self-reliant, seemingly independent female characters appear to be empowered by their creator to combat their age's restrictions, but the argument here is a convincing one: they are, in fact, re-inscribed and re-confined in other ways by the texts' reflexive narrative techniques as much as by the plots. These women end up being rendered passive, manipulated by both the narrative and its narrator, their creative potential contained by its relegation to the "feminine" instinctual realm, their voice muted. The paradigm? From being a "master" fiction-maker, Sarah Woodruff (in The French Lieutenant's Woman) becomes, in the end, a model for a male artist. This critical study deconstructs the latent politics beneath Fowles's apparently feminist sympathies, and anal- yzes the contradictions that result in the final attribution of full and mature artistic "potency" only to the male in all Fowles's fiction. Though obsessively his subject matter and alleged inspiration, woman has no creative power here. The passive object of the male gaze, she is always the represent^; never does she do the represent- ing. In this her role differs little from the one she had been assigned by those male authors and artists of the past whose work forms the dense intertextual background of Fowles's writing. Working from this point of view, Cooper rereads Fowles's use of the ethical and psychological principles of the traditional Bildungsroman. She also asks us to rethink the romance tradition upon which Fowles depends so much, but this time in terms of gen- der and control — psychosexual, moral, and aesthetic. In activating the concerns of feminist theory, she raises the questions of textuality and sexuality, of the politics of language and its usage. What is par- ticularly original about this book's central thesis is its reading of The Ebony Tower as the moment of potential breakthrough, the moment when new ideas could have altered the carefully constructed and internally consistent universe of Fowles's fiction. However, the chal- lenge was not taken, Cooper argues. The novels after 1974 are here read as retrenchment, as the retreading of safe and familiar terrain. One of the many pleasures of reading The Fictions of John Fowles: Power, Creativity, Femininity is having one's former readings of these well-known novels turned on their head. But another is watching the author foreground in such an articulate way her own ambivalence towards the novels about which she writes. Her admira- tion and her suspicion, in about equal doses, shine through, and the mixture feels just right. INTRODUCTION The intensity of John Fowles's interest in power is matched by the ambiguity of his attitude towards it and the com- plexity with which he treats it in his fictions. Most of the significant relationships depicted in his work involve some sort of power strug- gle, for Fowles is at once suspicious of and fascinated by the efforts of individuals to control and influence each other. His first pub- lished novel, The Collector (1963), presents this struggle in its sim- plest form, as Miranda Grey's fight to wrest physical freedom from her jailer Clegg — although the spiritual antipathy between the two lends an important moral dimension to their clash. Subsequent works analyze more subtle, intricate or abstract power relationships. In Fowles's second novel, The Magus (1966, revised 1977), Conchis is a kind of psychological bully who tries to torment Nick Urfe into emotional growth. The ambiguously benevolent despot- ism of a teacher/magician is questioned here in the alacrity with which Conchis combines seduction and brutality. The sadistic but enlightened older man rapidly becomes a symbolically resonant fig- ure for Fowles; he does in fact appear as far back as The Collector, in the form of Miranda's shadowy and rather sinister mentor, George Paston. In The French Lieutenant's Woman (1969), Sarah Woodruff battles the conventional sexual attitudes of an era that seeks — mainly through Doctor Grogan as the representative of canonical scientific wisdom — to brand her a lunatic. Here Fowles's ambivalence about power is expressed in his authorial and narratorial refusal fully to grant Sarah the independent identity she seems to crave. This sense of literary characters as potentially and 2 PAMELA COOPER disruptively autonomous — despite their status as projections of the authorial imagination — reflects not only Fowles's awareness of the nouvectu roman, but the more palpable influence of one of his older contemporaries: Fowles evidently admires Flann O'Brien's boister- ous and anarchic At Swim-Two-Birds more than Robbe-Grillet's chilly and disengaged La Jalousie. O'Brien experiments as energetically with the stylistic legacy of Joyce as Fowles does with that of his favoured modernist, Eliot. Expanding their predecessors' interrogations of literary form in explicitly metafictional directions, both O'Brien and Fowles use the strategies of fictional self-consciousness to explore the different possible freedoms available within and operating upon the text.