ANNEX 2 a) WITNESSES WHO GAVE ORAL EVIDENCE IN PUBLIC TO THE COMMISSION OF INQUIRY

BELL, Allan Member of the - 1984 to date Minister for Tourism - 1986 to 1994 Minister for Industry - 1996 Minister for Home Affairs - 1996 to 2002 Minister for the Treasury - 2002 to date

BROWN, Anthony Member of the House of Keys - 1981 to date Minister for Health and Social Security - 1986 to 1989 Minister for Local Government and the Environment - 1989 to 1994 Minister for Tourism - 1994 to 1996 Minister for Transport - 1996 to 2002 Speaker of the House of Keys - 2001 to date

BROWN, Roger Representative of the Society for the Preservation of the Manx Countryside and Environment

CALLIN, Arnold Member of the House of Keys - 1976 to 1985 Member of the Legislative Council - 1985 to 1995 Minister for Highways, Ports and Properties (later Department of Transport) - 1986 to 1991 Minister for Home Affairs - 1991 to 1995

CASHEN, John Chief Financial Officer, the Treasury 8th May 1991 to 31st August 2001

CLARK, Geoffrey Planning Officer, Department of Local Government and the Environment in 1991

CLIFFE, John Divisional Officer, and Rescue Fire Service

COOIL, Roy Chief Executive, Department of Highways, Ports and Properties (later Department of Transport) - 1988 to 2001

CORKILL, Richard Member of the House of Keys 1991 to date Minister for the Home Affairs 1993 to 1996 Minister for the Treasury 1996 to 2002 Chief Minister 2001 to date

CORLETT, Sarah Planning Officer, Department of Local Government and the Environment - 1990 to date

CRETNEY, David Member of the House of Keys - 1985 to date Chairman of the Planning Committee - 26th January 1990 to 23rd April 1993 Minister for Tourism - 1996 to date

277 CROW, Professor Stephen Author of Report of an Inquiry into Planning and Development and other matters at Mount Murray (30 December 2000)

CROWE, Alan Member of the House of Keys - 1995 to 1998 Member of the Legislative Council - 1998 to 2003 Chairman of the Planning Committee - 1999 to 2002 Chairman of the Financial Supervision Commission - 2002 to 2003

CROWE, Pamela Member of the House of Keys - 1996 to 2003 Member of the Legislative Council - 2003 to date Minister for Local Government and the Environment - 2002 to date

DELANEY, Dominic Member of the House of Keys - 1976 to 1996 Member of the Legislative Council - 1996 to date Minister for Local Government and the Environment - 1986 to 1989

DOWNIE, Alex Member of the House of Keys - 1991 to date Member of the Department of Tourism - 1991 to 1993 Chairman of the Planning Committee - 1993 to 1996 Chairman, Isle of Man Postal Authority - 1997 to 1999 Minister for Agriculture - 1999 to 2002 Minister for Trade and Industry – 2002 to date

FARAGHER, Charles Member of the House of Keys - 1982 to 1986 Member of the Planning Committee - 1990 to 1995

FARGHER, Maurice Secretary, Planning Committee, Local Government Board – 1979 to 1984 Deputy Chief Executive, the Department of Local Government and the Environment (formerly the Local Government Board) - 1984 to 1994 Chief Executive, the Department of Local Government and the Environment - 1994 to 1996

GARDNER, Michael, Audit Partner, KPMG, external auditors to – 1989 to 1995 and 1999 to date

GELLING, Donald Member of the House of Keys - 1986 to 2002 Member of the Legislative Council - 2002 to date Minister for the Treasury - 1989 to 1996 Chief Minister - 1996 to 2001

GILBEY, Walter Member of the House of Keys - 1982 to 2001 Minister for Local Government and the Environment 1999 to 2002

GOUGH, Tracey Employed in the Sales Office at Mount Murray from May 1996 to October 1996

GUARD, Charles Member of the Planning Committee - 1990 to 1994

278

GUBAY, Albert Formerly Director of Fairport Limited, the company that built the Mount Murray Hotel, and of other companies.

HAMILTON, Antony Chief Executive, the Department of Local Government and the Environment 24th June 1996 to date

HANNAN, Hazel Member of the House of Keys - 1986 to date Minister for Education – 1991 to 1995 Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry – 1995 to 1999

HANNAY, Bruce Director of Highways, Highways Division (formerly Director of Engineering Design) Department of Highways, Ports and Properties (later Department of Transport) - 1991 to date

JACKSON, James Director, JG Kelly Homes Limited, purchasers of land at Mount Murray in 1997 and builders of houses at Mount Murray thereafter.

KARRAN, Peter Member of the House of Keys - 1985 to date Proposer of the Resolution of dated 19th February 2002, requesting His Excellency, the Lieutenant Governor to appoint the Commission of Inquiry

KILLIP, David Secretary, Planning Committee, Department of Local Government and the Environment - 1st July 1991 to 31st December 1994

KISSACK, Fred Chief Secretary - 1989 to 2002

LEWIN, Charles Clerk to Braddan Parish Commissioners

McCAULEY, Ian Director of Planning and Building Control, Department of Local Government and the Environment – 2nd July 2001 to date

McGREAL, Clive Chief Internal Auditor, the Treasury 1st May 1999 to date

MAGEE, Colin Secretary, Planning Committee, Department of Local Government and the Environment - 1986 to 30th June 1991

MOORE, Dr David Member of the House of Keys - 1978 to 1986 Member of the Planning Committee in 1991

MOORE, Paul Director of Mount Murray Country Club Limited (formerly Radcon Village Developments Limited) - 21st September 1990 to 4th March 2002

279 NEWTON, Patricia Planning Officer, Department of Local Government and the Environment - 1990 to 1996

NORTH, David Member of the House of Keys - 1988 to 2001 Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food - 1989 to 1991 Minister for Highways, Ports and Properties - 1991 to 1994 Minister for Transport - 1995 to 1996 Minister for Trade and Industry - 1996 to 2002

OLSEN, Stephen Enforcement Officer, Department of Local Government and the Environment, 1992 to date

PALMER, Sara Employed in the Sales Office at Mount Murray from April 1996 to August 1996

QUINE, Edgar Member of the House of Keys - 1986 to date Minister for Local Government and the Environment - 1996 to 1999 Seconder of the Resolution of Tynwald dated 19th February 2002, requesting His Excellency, the Lieutenant Governor to appoint the Commission of Inquiry

REEVES, Richard Interested parties who reside close to the Mount and Murray development REEVES, Mrs H

RODAN, Stephen Member of the House of Keys - 1995 to date Chairman of the Planning Committee - 1997 to 1999 Minister for Education - 1999 to date

SINDEN, Brian Planning Officer, Department of Local Government and the Environment - 1975 to date

SKILLICORN, Brenda Chief Officer, Personnel Office

TEARE, Alan Senior Assistant Drainage Engineer, Department of Highways, Ports and Properties (later Department of Transport) in 1991(involvement with Mount Murray ended in September, 1991)

TOOHEY, Terry Chief Executive of the Department of Tourism (formerly Director of Tourism) - 1st September 1986 to date

VAKIL, Neville Interested party who resides at Mount Murray

VANNAN, Barry Architect and Planning Officer (Deputy Head of the Planning Office) in the Department of Local Government and the Environment) - 1983 to 1993 Director of Planning (Head of the Planning Office) in the Department of Local Government and the Environment – 1993 to 2001

280

WAFT, George Member of the House of Keys - 1991 to 1994 Member of the Legislative Council - 1994 to date Chairman, Civil Service Commission - 1996 to date

WALKER, Sir Miles Member of the House of Keys - 1976 to 2001 Chief Minister - 1986 to 1996

WATSON, Malcolm Chief Architect and Planning Officer (Head of the Planning Office), the Department of Local Government and the Environment (formerly the Local Government Board) - June 1964 to March 1993

WILLERS, Peter Director of Mount Murray Country Club Limited (formerly Radcon Village Developments Limited) - 4th April 2002 to date. Legal Adviser to Albert Gubay

WILLIAMSON, Peter Forester, Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (formerly Board of Agriculture) - 1978 to date

WILSON, Leslie Development and Planning Manager, (formerly Engineering Technician/Engineer Planning Engineer) Highways and Traffic Division, Department of Highways, Ports and Properties (later Department of Transport) – June 1973 to date

WINSTANLEY, Peter Director of Drainage, Department of Transport - February 2001 to date

b) OTHER PERSONS WITH MATERIAL ROLE REFERRED TO IN REPORT

SPENCE, Gary Director of Radcon Village Developments Limited (later Mount Murray Country Club Limited) - 5th December 1990 to 6th November 1998, now apparently residing in the United States

McAVOY, Kenneth Muir Associates, engineering consultants, Dublin

MITCHELL, Stuart Development Consultant and from 1993 until approximately 1995, full time officer in the Department of Tourism, now residing in England

SAVAGE, Michael Chief Executive, the Department of Local Government (deceased) and the Environment, 3rd August 1987 to 1st March 1994 - deceased September 1995.

281

282