Bio-Terrorism on Six Legs: Insect Vectors Are the Major Threat to Global Health Security
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Article ID: WMC001282 Bio-terrorism On Six Legs: Insect Vectors Are The Major Threat To Global Health Security Author(s):Dr. Manas Sarkar Corresponding Author: Dr. Manas Sarkar, Deputy Assistant Director, Centre for Medical Entomology & Vector Management, National Centre for Disease Control, National Centre for Disease Control, 110054 - India Submitting Author: Dr. Manas Sarkar, Deputy Assistant Director, Centre for Medical Entomology & Vector Management, National Centre for Disease Control, National Centre for Disease Control, 110054 - India Article ID: WMC001282 Article Type: My opinion Submitted on:04-Dec-2010, 06:46:01 PM GMT Published on: 07-Dec-2010, 09:28:50 PM GMT Article URL: http://www.webmedcentral.com/article_view/1282 Subject Categories:PUBLIC HEALTH Keywords:Bio-terrorism, Bio-weapon, Entomology, Insect; Mosquito, Vector-borne diseases How to cite the article:Sarkar M. Bio-terrorism On Six Legs: Insect Vectors Are The Major Threat To Global Health Security . WebmedCentral PUBLIC HEALTH 2010;1(12):WMC001282 Source(s) of Funding: Not Applicable Competing Interests: None Webmedcentral > My opinion Page 1 of 5 WMC001282 Downloaded from http://www.webmedcentral.com on 07-Dec-2010, 09:28:51 PM Bio-terrorism On Six Legs: Insect Vectors Are The Major Threat To Global Health Security My opinion countries [13, 14]. Use of arthropod as bio weapon: history Lockwood [15] discussed the devastating military Most people are only concerned with eradicating impact of vector-borne diseases such as plague arthropod vectors, because they see them as a (carried by fleas), yellow fever and malaria nuisance or only as a causative agent of many deadly (mosquitoes), typhus (lice), Q fever (ticks), and diseases. The problem is many individuals do not dysentery (flies) in conflicts from the Napoleonic realize there are many more issues then just killing campaigns through World War I. Until the modern era, vectors. One major concern for vector biology far more soldiers died from diseases spread by insects research and controls nationwide is the threat of than from bullets or artillery fire. Insects have carried bio-terrorism. One of the cheapest and most disease onto the battlefield for more than two destructive weapons available to terrorists today is thousand years. Using creature like arthropods in also one of the most widely ignored insect vectors. warfare is not new. Armies also made deliberate use These biological warfare agents are easy to sneak of vector-borne pathogens as weapons of war, a across borders, reproduce quickly, and spread practice that reached its dark apotheosis during the disease in an indefatigable march. Indeed, a great late 1930s in Imperial Japan. Lockwood [15] in his strategic lesson of 9/11 in America has been book Six-Legged Soldiers: Using Insects as Weapons overlooked. Actually, terrorists need only a little of War described that General Ishii Shiro established a cleverness, not sophisticated weapons, to cause top-secret biological warfare program in occupied enormous damage. In world's biggest terror attack in Manchuria, where Japanese scientists cultivated America, terrorists, armed only with box cutters, billions of fleas infected with Yersinia pestis, the hijacked planes and brought down the towers of the bacterium that causes plague, and loaded them into World Trade Center. Insects are the box cutters of porcelain bombs for attacks on Chinese cities. biological warfare – cheap, simple, and wickedly Knowhow of entomological weapons effective. The main aim and objective of this opinion piece is to discuss the recent concern over the use of While all quit possible, it is not exactly easy to use insects as bio-weapon, which is a major issue of insect vectors for bioterrorism; especially, it is health security worldwide. We also like to draw the labor-intensive to produce infected insects. However, attention of the world scientific leaders towards this transovarial transmission occurs in certain arthropod potential health hazards and focus future research vectors as they transmit disease-causing priorities. bacteria/viruses from parent arthropod to offspring arthropod. For instance, Rickettsia rickettsii, carried Arthropod as vectors of diseases within ticks, dengue virus carried within Aedes Entomological warfare can be induced by employing mosquitoes are passed on from parent to offspring by insects for direct attacks against humans, as vectors transovarial transmission. These types of for transmitting infectious diseases. Arthropod vectors viruses/bacteria are easy to rear within arthropod transmit many new and reemerging diseases. vectors and easy to infect a large colony of arthropod Mosquitoes transmit malaria [1, 2], dengue-dengue within the laboratory. During dry periods, mosquito hemorrhagic fever [3, 4, 5], yellow fever [6], eggs can survive for months or years, with the dengue Venezuelan equine encephalitis [3, 7], and filariasis [8]; and/or Rift Valley fever virus biding its time along with sand flies transmit leishmaniasis [7]; ticks transmit the insect embryo and on set of rain, the infected eggs Lyme disease and ehrlichiosis [9, 10]; fleas and lice hatch, and within days, a swarm of hungry, transmit Bartonella [11]; and fleas, lice, and ticks disease-carrying adults begins to search for blood. transmit various rickettsioses [12]. Vector borne The infected females pass the virus through their eggs diseases causes extensive morbidity and mortality and into the next generation (i.e., transovarial transmission) are a major economic burden within disease endemic and the cycle is complete. With the enormous Webmedcentral > My opinion Page 2 of 5 WMC001282 Downloaded from http://www.webmedcentral.com on 07-Dec-2010, 09:28:51 PM reproductive potential of the virus and its vectors, effective. The main aim and objective of this opinion disease spreads like living wildfire. Moreover, millions piece is to discuss the recent concern over the use of of infected eggs from arthropod vectors where insects as bio-weapon, which is a major issue of transovarial transmission of diseases pathogens health security worldwide. We also like to draw the occurred could be collected from a base laboratory attention of the world scientific leaders towards this and exported across the countries. For example, potential health hazards and focus future research transovarian transmission of dengue virus was priorities. demonstrated for Aedes mosquitoes [16], which laid Arthropod as vectors of diseases eggs on wet towels or strips of wet papers in the Entomological warfare can be induced by employing laboratory and the eggs remain viable for years. insects for direct attacks against humans, as vectors Moreover, a strip of papers can contain billions of eggs, for transmitting infectious diseases. Arthropod vectors which can easily be transported from one place to transmit many new and reemerging diseases. other. Mosquitoes transmit malaria [1, 2], dengue-dengue Without the scientific and technical support of a hemorrhagic fever [3, 4, 5], yellow fever [6], military industrial complex, terrorists may be unable to Venezuelan equine encephalitis [3, 7], and filariasis [8]; culture and formulate pathogenic organisms into sand flies transmit leishmaniasis [7]; ticks transmit effective weapon systems. Lockwood [15] described Lyme disease and ehrlichiosis [9, 10]; fleas and lice insects as a low-tech, “safe, and effective” alternative transmit Bartonella [11]; and fleas, lice, and ticks weapon: they are easily collected or reared, robust to transmit various rickettsioses [12]. Vector borne environmental adversity, and able to disperse on their diseases causes extensive morbidity and mortality and own. Although, insects or arthropods are slow-acting are a major economic burden within disease endemic bioterrorism agents, but it belongs to a low-cost, countries [13, 14]. high-impact operations that takes time to unfold. In Use of arthropod as bio weapon: history 1983, the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) published a meticulous analysis of the Lockwood [15] discussed the devastating military most likely pathogens to be developed as biological impact of vector-borne diseases such as plague weapons (Geissler, A New Generation of Biological (carried by fleas), yellow fever and malaria Weapons) [15]. Of the 22 prime candidates, half were (mosquitoes), typhus (lice), Q fever (ticks), and arthropod-borne viruses. A similar study in 2000 by the dysentery (flies) in conflicts from the Napoleonic World Organization for Animal Health generated a campaigns through World War I. Until the modern era, watch-and-worry roster of livestock diseases, and six far more soldiers died from diseases spread by insects of the 15 A-list diseases were carried by insects [15]. than from bullets or artillery fire. Insects have carried disease onto the battlefield for more than two st people are only concerned with eradicating thousand years. Using creature like arthropods in arthropod vectors, because they see them as a warfare is not new. Armies also made deliberate use nuisance or only as a causative agent of many deadly of vector-borne pathogens as weapons of war, a diseases. The problem is many individuals do not practice that reached its dark apotheosis during the realize there are many more issues then just killing late 1930s in Imperial Japan. Lockwood [15] in his vectors. One major concern for vector biology book Six-Legged Soldiers: Using Insects as Weapons research and controls nationwide is the threat of of War described that