Regulating the Livestock Economy of Somaliland

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Regulating the Livestock Economy of Somaliland DRAFT ONLY Regulating the Livestock Economy of Somaliland Academy for Peace and Development Hargeysa, Somaliland July 2002 DRAFT Regulating the Livestock Economy of Somaliland 2 Principal Researcher: Maxamed Xasan Gaani Working Group Members: Dr. Cali Yuusuf Axmed Dr. Maxamed Cige Kille Jaamac Nuur Xasan Cabdullaahi Maxamed Xasan Maxamed Jibriil Ibraahim Cabdixakiim M. Axmed Xasan Ibraahim DRAFT Regulating the Livestock Economy of Somaliland 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 Introduction................................................................................................................4 2 An Overview of the Somaliland Economy.................................................................5 The Productive Sectors...................................................................................................................5 Trade and Commerce ...................................................................................................................11 Characteristics of the Private Sector...........................................................................................12 3 The Nomadic Pastoral Production System ............................................................. 15 The Transformation of the Pastoral Production System.........................................................17 Interventions to Protect the Environment................................................................................31 Towards a Sustainable Pastoral Production System.................................................................35 4 The Livestock Trade................................................................................................ 37 Post-war Restructuring of the Domestic Livestock Trade......................................................37 Livestock export ............................................................................................................................44 Market diversification ...................................................................................................................54 Product diversification..................................................................................................................54 5 Animal Health.......................................................................................................... 56 A Brief History of Animal Health Services ...............................................................................56 Animal Health Services in Somaliland since 1991....................................................................58 Veterinary Regulation as a Constraint to International Trade................................................67 6 Conclusion and Recommendations......................................................................... 75 Overall Policy, Strategy and Legislation.....................................................................................75 Recommendations for regulating pastoral environment and livestock trade .......................77 Livestock Trade, diversification and Marketing........................................................................79 Recommendations for improving export animal health services...........................................82 Bibliography................................................................................................................. 85 DRAFT Regulating the Livestock Economy of Somaliland 4 1 Introduction Pastoralism, in one form or another, is the primary production system in Somaliland. The majority of people directly or indirectly obtain their livelihoods from animal husbandry, and the resilience of this mode of production has been critical to Somaliland’s recovery from the war. Taxation on livestock exports is the main source of government revenue and of funding for the re-establishment of government institutions. As pastoral production is closely linked to the social structure of pastoral groups, pastoralism as a ‘way of life’ has a profound impact on the politics and culture of Somaliland. Various economic, social and environmental problems threaten to undermine this economy and the pastoral nomadic way of life. The WSP Somaliland Project Group therefore identified the status of the livestock economy as an Entry Point for in-depth research. A Working Group was formed to take this forward, comprising livestock traders, members of the Somaliland Chamber of Commerce, government officials, elders, professionals and local and international NGOs. After lengthy discussions, the Working Group identified three themes on which to focus the research: • Livestock trade • The pastoral environment • Animal health services Three workshops were held on these themes between August 2000 and March 2001. The first, on the subject of the livestock trade was held in Burco, the second, on animal health, was held in Hargeysa and the third, on the environment, in Oodweyne. Workshop participants included regional and district government officials, Ministry of Livestock officials, pastoralists, livestock exporters, brokers, butchers, enclosure owners, veterinarians, drug importers, women’s NGOs, charcoal makers, fodder farmers, berked owners, members of the Chamber of Commerce, transporters and members of the media. This study is based on discussions and recommendations generated by these workshops, as well as meetings of the Working Group, additional interviews and a review of relevant litreature. A symbiotic relationship exists between livestock production and the environment, and the social and economic well-being of the population is thus greatly affected by environmental and meteorological conditions. The study begins, therefore, with a brief description of Somaliland’s environment and climate. The livestock economy is then described within the context of Somaliland’s emerging post-war economy, before the themes of trade, marketing, and animal health services are dealt with. DRAFT Regulating the Livestock Economy of Somaliland 5 2 An Overview of the Somaliland Economy The Somaliland economy has undergone important structural changes since the war. In a deregulated free market economy, the private business sector has grown rapidly. The dissolution of state monopolies and rigid economic controls, together with private sector expansion, has significantly contributed to the growth of Somaliland’s economy in the aftermath of war, providing employment opportunities and capital investment for the process of reconstruction. Trade through Berbera port has surpassed pre-war levels. The service sector has experienced rapid growth in the post-war period, with a proliferation of companies providing the latest communication facilities, airlines and financial services. Small enterprises like bakeries, restaurants, convenience stores and office supplies have returned to the marketplaces of the urban centres. The Productive Sectors Livestock production Much of Somaliland’s post-war economic growth has been linked, directly or indirectly, to the livestock trade. Livestock husbandry is the dominant system of production in Somaliland. Over half the population of Somaliland is involved in some form of animal husbandry, either as nomadic (or transhumant) pastoralists or as agro-pastoralists. Always the backbone of the economy before the civil conflict, livestock production continues to be main source of daily subsistence for nomadic families and the main source of income and employment for urban dwellers. According to the Somaliland Ministry of Agriculture, about 60% of Somaliland’s population relies for daily subsistence on the main livestock products, meat and milk (Ministry of Agriculture 1998). Livestock production is estimated to represent 60-65% of the national economy (Ministry of Agriculture, 1998), and government revenue is heavily dependent on livestock exports. Between 1991 and 1997, livestock export on the hoof grew considerably, exceeding pre-war levels when Somaliland exported some three million heads of livestock in 1997, mostly to Saudi Arabia (UNDP, 1998). The value of livestock exports in 1997 was estimated to be US$ 120.8 million, yielding as much as 80% of the total hard currency income for Somaliland's population (UNDP 1998). Four species of domestic livestock - sheep, goats, camels and cattle - are reared in Somaliland. Sheep and goats are herded in the largest numbers, although trends in population growth, increased sedentarisation and markets demands have resulted in greater numbers of cattle being reared in recent years. No concrete data exists on the present DRAFT Regulating the Livestock Economy of Somaliland 6 number and distribution of livestock in Somaliland.1 Many observers believe, however, that numbers of livestock have been decreasing during the 1990s, as result of pastoral rangeland degradation and insufficient of grassing space in some areas. Even at a time in which livestock export ban by Saudi Arabia has minimized exports from Somaliland, participants in this study asserted that the livestock population is not increasing, because most of the livestock for export comes from beyond Somaliland’s borders. There are also indications that pastoralists are selling more animals at lower prices into local markets in order to compensate for their lost export earnings as well as for household consumption. Nomadic pastoralism is a complex and sophisticated system, well adapted to Somaliland’s arid environment, and the most efficient way of exploiting the erratic seasonal forage and water conditions. However, environmental pressures, inadequate
Recommended publications
  • Somaliland Paper 18 May Anniversary-Edited
    Somaliland: Africa’s longest de facto independent state May 2021 cademy for Peace and Development Akaademiga Nabadda iyo Horumarka 1 Contents 1. Introduction .................................................................................................................... 1 2. Drivers of peace and state-building: Somaliland’s unique model of statecraft .............. 2 3. Somaliland: Creative Destruction .................................................................................... 4 3.1 Neo-patrimonial culture .......................................................................................................... 4 4. Big Stuck .......................................................................................................................... 5 5. Status Quo Leadership .................................................................................................... 6 6. Our proposed Development Road Map .......................................................................... 7 6. 1 Democratic Developmental State ........................................................................................... 7 7. Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 9 References .......................................................................................................................... 10 cademy for Peace and Development Akaademiga Nabadda iyo Horumarka 1 1. Introduction In 2021, the Horn of Africa-one of Africa’s volatile regions-
    [Show full text]
  • Somaliland Food and Water Security Strategy (FSWS) Is a Crucial Component of This Long-Term Outlook
    REPUBLIC OF SOMALILAND SOMALILAND FOOD & WATER SECURITY STRATEGY SOMALILAND VISION 2030 A Stable and Democratic Somaliland Where Citizens Enjoy Sound Quality of Life by 2030 1. Agriculture Vision - A nation that utilizes agricultural (including livestock and fisheries) resources sustainably for income generation and food security; 2. Water Vision - A society whose citizens enjoy access to safe and sufficient water DMS/SDI 10/19/2011 ABBREVIATIONS “DEYR” Short rainy season in Somali “GU” Long rainy season in Somali AFLC Acute Food And Livelihood Crisis CBS Cereal Balance Sheet CMR Rude Mortality Rate CPI Consumer Price Index DGs Director Generals EW Early Warning EWS Early Warning System FAO Food and Agricultural Organization FSNAU Food Security and Nutrition Analysis Unit FSWIS Food Security and Water Information System FWSS Food and Water Security Strategy FWSSO Food and Water Security Strategy Office GDP Gross Domestic Product HA Hectare HE Humanitarian Emergencies HFS Household Food Security HIV/AIDS Human Immunodeficiency Virus/Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome IDP Internally Displaced Persons IDR Import Dependency Ratio IFAD International Fund for Agricultural Development IGAD Intergovernmental Authority for Development KGs Kilograms KLM kilometer LTR litters MEB Minimum Expenditure Basket MMEWR Ministry of Mining, Energy and Water Resources MNPD Ministry of National Planning and Development MOA Ministry of Agriculture MOF Ministry of Finance MT Metric Ton NDP National Development Plan NGO Non-governmental Organization NPC National Planning Commission PCCC Per Capita Cereal Consumption PHL Post Harvest Losses SFR Strategic Food Reserves SLD SH Somaliland Shilling SSR Self Sufficiency Ratio SWALIM Somalia Water and Land Information Management TOT Terms Of Trade UAE United Arab Emirates UNDP United Nations Development Programme WFP World Food Programme WFS World Food Summit i FORWARD The election of 2010 ushered new government into power.
    [Show full text]
  • Post-Conflict Education Development in Somaliland
    Post-Conflict Education Development in Somaliland Post-Conflict Education Development in Somaliland Samuel Ayele Bekalo, Michael Brophy and Geoff Welford Abstract In the light of fresh international initiatives to achieve Universal Basic Education (UBE) and gender equality in education by 2015, this paper examines factors affecting its realisation in the context of Somaliland. In a country where over 80% of school age children are receiving little meaningful education, the paper reflects on more flexible education approaches to provide sustainable education for children and disadvantaged adults. The paper draws on fieldwork data from a DfID funded study [1] and the authors' own experiences. The discussion highlights the peculiar circumstances of Somaliland. It charts the provision of Education in the then Somalia from the colonial era through post-independence times to the civil conflict which led to the destruction of education in the country. It goes on to look at the progress being made at the present time following “stop-gap” measures for emergency education towards revitalising enhanced education. It completes the picture by describing challenges to the achievement of the UBE target. The authors review aspects of alternative and flexible educational approaches and urge the integration of these non-formal systems with the formal, governmentally controlled school systems being restored in Somaliland. They do so while sounding a note of caution that for all the energy and enthusiasm associated with these approaches, they have yet to be evaluated for their effectiveness in providing quality basic education. This paper looks at education in Somaliland. It presents a brief summary of the development of education from colonial times, through the recent civil conflict into the present time.
    [Show full text]
  • Somaliland Assistance Bulletin January—March 2007
    Somaliland Assistance Bulletin January—March 2007 I. HUMANITARIAN SITUATION which were received in western parts of the country Finalized on January 2007, FAO/FSAU led Post- (Awdal and Hargeisa regions), have improved Deyr assessment indicated above normal rains in pasture and water resources. If such good to normal most parts of Somaliland leading to improved rains are received in this Gu season, the rural livelihoods through increased availability of water livelihoods particularly pastoral communities are and pasture. Improved body conditions combined expected to have better post-drought recovery with Haji (pilgrimage) season improved livestock including building up of assets and improved prices enhancing the purchasing power. However, resilience to shocks. due to reported rift valley, meat and livestock export According to Somalia Food Security Emergency has been stopped right after the Haj by Arab Release of FEWSNET released on 23rd March 2007, countries. Unknown camel disease has significantly the recent climate outlook for the Greater Horn of reduced herd sizes of many families throughout the Africa including Somalia predict the likelihood of country with no indication of containing it. The near normal Gu rains (April to June 2007) which is disease was a cross-border disease, as the same expected to sustain further livelihood recovery. disease was reported in Ethiopian Somali region FSAU Post-Deyr forecast better livestock build up as before it was patterned in Somaliland. there is high kidding rate expected for sheep/goats in April and May 2007 due to high conception in According to FSAU, crop assessment in Somaliland October-December 2006 while medium to low indicated higher crop harvest; about 147% of the calving is expected for the camels due to low Post War Average (PWA: 1998-2006) and the conception during October-December 2006.
    [Show full text]
  • A/53/344 General Assembly
    United Nations A/53/344 Distr.: General General Assembly 4 September 1998 Original: English Fifty-third session Item 20 (b) of the provisional agenda* Strengthening of the coordination of humanitarian and disaster relief assistance of the United Nations, including special economic assistance: special economic assistance to individual countries or regions Assistance for humanitarian relief and the economic and social rehabilitation of Somalia Report of the Secretary-General Contents Paragraphs Page I. Introduction .............................................................. 1 3 II. Emergencypreparedness,responseandreliefoperations....................... 2–6 3 III. Food security ............................................................. 7–12 3 A. Assessmentoffoodsecurity........................................... 9 4 B. Agriculture,livestockandfisheries .................................... 10–12 4 IV. Reintegration............................................................. 13–16 4 A. Refugeesandreturnees ............................................... 14–15 4 B. Internally displaced people ............................................ 16 5 V. Rehabilitation ............................................................ 17–37 5 A. Health and nutrition .................................................. 18–27 5 B. Waterandenvironmentalsanitation .................................... 28–29 6 * A/53/150. 98-26217 (E) 071098 A/53/344 C. Education........................................................... 30–33 6 D. Infrastructure rehabilitation
    [Show full text]
  • 'Nobody Likes Women Except God'
    ‘NOBODY LIKES WOMEN EXCEPT GOD’ EXAMINING THE CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCES OF GENDER-BASED VIOLENCE IN SOMALILAND ‘Nobody likes women except God’ Causes and consequences of gender-based violence in Somaliland Acknowledgements: This study would not have been possible without many people. Progressio would like to thank all of the civil society organizations who participated in the Amplify Civil Society Voices on Gender-Based Violence Coalition (NAGAAD, WORDA, WAAPO, CCBRS, SWLA, IRADA, SONYO, GAVO, YPEER, VOSOMWO, NAFIS Network & SOFHA). We would also like to thank all of the researchers in Somaliland, who made this study possible through their hard work and commitment (Muse Jama Essa, Deka Hassan Ahmed, Hamse Ali, Fathia Hussein, Khalid Ismail Hussein, Mohamed Damac, Nasra Cabdilaahi, Shabac Abdi, Hibo Mahamud, Amina Mohamed, Abdirahman Mohamed, Awo Harir, Faisa Abdillahi, Fardous Ibrahim, Farhan Hidig, Abdirahman Ismail Muse, Mohamed Abdirahman, Sahardiid Osman, Abdiwasic Abdillahi, Muna Essa, Ayaan Hussein, Khadra Ahmed and Khadra Ali Abdi). We appreciate the time that many organizations took to talk to us, including the Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs, the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Religion, the Ministry of Youth, Tourism & Sport, Members of Parliament, & the Baahi Koob Centre. We also appreciate the insights from legal representatives, judges, police, traditional leaders, religious leaders, and civil society organizations across Somaliland. Most importantly, we want to thank the many women and men who shared their stories with the research team. Without their voices, this would not have been possible. We would like to thank the project management team for their oversight and strategic guidance, including Cris Bautista, Elijah Mulumba, and Suad Abdi (Progressio), as well as Kinzi Kowden and Muse Jama (WORDA).
    [Show full text]
  • Somalia: Window of Opportunity for Addressing One of the World's Worst Internal Displacement Crises 9
    SOMALIA: Window of opportunity for addressing one of the world’s worst internal displacement crises A profile of the internal displacement situation 10 January 2006 This Internal Displacement Profile is automatically generated from the online IDP database of the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC). It includes an overview of the internal displacement situation in the country prepared by the IDMC, followed by a compilation of excerpts from relevant reports by a variety of different sources. All headlines as well as the bullet point summaries at the beginning of each chapter were added by the IDMC to facilitate navigation through the Profile. Where dates in brackets are added to headlines, they indicate the publication date of the most recent source used in the respective chapter. The views expressed in the reports compiled in this Profile are not necessarily shared by the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre. The Profile is also available online at www.internal-displacement.org. About the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre The Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre, established in 1998 by the Norwegian Refugee Council, is the leading international body monitoring conflict-induced internal displacement worldwide. Through its work, the Centre contributes to improving national and international capacities to protect and assist the millions of people around the globe who have been displaced within their own country as a result of conflicts or human rights violations. At the request of the United Nations, the Geneva-based Centre runs an online database providing comprehensive information and analysis on internal displacement in some 50 countries. Based on its monitoring and data collection activities, the Centre advocates for durable solutions to the plight of the internally displaced in line with international standards.
    [Show full text]
  • Candlelight-Annual-Report-2017.Pdf
    1 2 Message from the Chairman ear donors, friends and supporters of Candlelight for Environment, Education & Health: DIt is my pleasure to let you know that twenty two fruitful years have passed since the organization’s inception which, when we look back, reminds us all of the excellent work we have done as a team. The immenseness and diversity of the needs to be addressed against the inhibiting factors viz financial and human resource was a challenge for our organization, however, the motivation and the appreciation from the communities who witnessed the outstanding work that Candlelight carried out over the years sustained our efforts in 2017. The following report will give you a clear picture of the depth and breadth of Candlelight’s activities for 2017. It contains project briefs on the multi-faceted interventions of the organization in the areas of livelihoods and community resilience building, environmental conservation, water sources development, hygiene and sanitation promotion, education and training, etc. On behalf of the Board, I would like to thank the Somaliland communities and the supportive role of the government for facilitating our work and continuing to be our partners. I would like to extend a special THANK YOU to our funding agencies for their financial and technical assistance without which we would not be able to do the outstanding work. Lastly, to the staff of Candlelight for their dedication and commitment to make a difference to the vulnerable people of Somaliland. Ahmed Ibrahim Awale Chairman 3 Message from the Executive Director andlelight Organization has been implementing humanitarian interventions Cincluding faming prevention and disease outbreaks, water and sanitation, treatment of sick and malnourished children and lactating and pregnant mothers and many other interventions supporting the communities faced by humanitarian crises in Somaliland.
    [Show full text]
  • Consultations with the Poor National Synthesis Report Somaliland
    CONSULTATIONS WITH THE POOR NATIONAL SYNTHESIS REPORT SOMALILAND Date: 15.8.1999 The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the World Bank, its Board of Executive Directors, or the governments they represent. Preface This study is part of a global research effort entitled Consultations with the Poor, designed to inform the World Development Report 2000/1 on Poverty and Development. The research involved poor people in twenty-three countries around the world. The effort also included two comprehensive reviews of Participatory Poverty Assessments completed in recent years by the World Bank and other agencies. Deepa Narayan, Principal Social Development Specialist in the World Bank's Poverty Group, initiated and led the research effort. The global Consultations with the Poor is unique in two respects. It is the first large scale comparative research effort using participatory methods to focus on the voices of the poor. It is also the first time that the World Development Report is drawing on participatory research in a systematic fashion. Much has been learned in this process about how to conduct Participatory Poverty Assessments on a major scale across countries so that they have policy relevance. Findings from the country studies are already being used at the national level, and the methodology developed by the study team is already being adopted by many others. We want to congratulate the network of 23 country research teams who mobilized at such short notice and completed the studies within six months. We also want to thank Deepa Narayan and her team: Patti Petesch, Consultant, provided overall coordination; Meera Kaul Shah, Consultant, provided methodological guidance; Ulrike Erhardt, provided administrative assistance; and the Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex provided advisory support.
    [Show full text]
  • Research Paper 23
    DLPPolicy and Practice for Developmental Leaders, Elites and Coalitions DEVELOPMENTAL LEADERSHIP PROGRAM Research Paper 23 Political Settlements and State Formation: The Case of Somaliland Sarah Phillips, University of Sydney December 2013 www.dlprog.org DLPPolicy and Practice for Developmental Leaders, Elites and Coalitions DEVELOPMENTAL LEADERSHIP PROGRAM The Developmental Leadership Program (DLP) is an international policy initiative informed by targeted research and directed by an independent steering committee. DLP is supported by a global network of partners and currently receives its core funding from the Australian aid program. The views expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent those of the Australian Government or any of DLP’s other partner organisations. 1 Contents Executive Summary 3 Brief Timeline of Key Events 8 1. Violence and Political Settlements 11 2. Somaliland’s Unusual Structural Context 20 3. Agents and Ideas 38 4. Institutions 53 5. Political Analysis 72 6. The Wider Implications of Somaliland’s Story 77 References 81 2 Acknowledgements I want to thank the many Somalilanders who so kindly and eloquently dissected the history of their political processes for me. A very special thanks is due to Maxamed (Amin) Ali, whose patience, perseverance and kindness made the research for this project not only possible but also very enjoyable. Thanks also to Ahmed Du’ale Cajab for helping me to access some of the empirical detail that had continued to elude me. I am very grateful to the Developmental Leadership Program for funding this research, and would particularly like to thank David Hudson for helpful comments on earlier drafts and Steve Hogg for leading a program as interesting and worthwhile as the DLP.
    [Show full text]
  • Somaliland Trade, Exports and Imports: an Overview
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by International Institute for Science, Technology and Education (IISTE): E-Journals Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online) Vol.6, No.8, 2016 Somaliland Trade, Exports and Imports: An Overview Muhumed Mohamed Muhumed Department of Political Science and International Relations, Istanbul Aydin University. Istanbul, Turkey. Abstract The self-declared Republic of Somaliland has accomplished a tangible economic and political reconstruction since its secession in 1991. This study aims to shed light on the international trade pattern of Somaliland and its export/import components. Livestock is the major export of Somaliland accompanied by its byproducts i.e. hides and skins while the country heavily depends on imports of food, fuel and manufactured products. Although livestock trade considerably contributes to the economy, it faces a number of challenges and losses due to the absence of financial system, dependency on single foreign market and multiple taxation. Saudi Arabia is the leading destination of Somaliland livestock exports followed by Yemen, UAE and Omen. On the contrary, imports originate from neighboring countries, Gulf countries, South East Asia and beyond. Keywords: exports, imports, livestock, Somaliland, trade 1. Introduction Somaliland has been an independent economy since its break away from Somalia in 1991. Due to a destructive civil war between Somali National Movement (SNM) and the military regime of Somalia, the country’s economy was started from scratch. People returned to their demolished homes with empty hands from refugee camps in 1991 and onwards.
    [Show full text]
  • Reading for Development: the Somali Rural Literacy Campaign of 1975
    Reading for Development: The Somali Rural Literacy Campaign of 1975 A dissertation presented to the faculty of The Patton College of Education of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy M. Shariff Osman March 2012 © 2012 M. Shariff Osman. All Rights Reserved. 2 This dissertation titled Reading for Development: The Somali Rural Literacy Campaign of 1975 by M. SHARIFF OSMAN has been approved for the Department of Educational Studies and The Patton College of Education by Francis E. Godwyll Associate Professor of Educational Studies Renée A. Middleton Dean, The Patton College of Education 3 Abstract OSMAN, M. SHARIFF, Ph.D., March 2012, Educational Studies, Cultural Studies Reading for Development: The Somali Rural Literacy Campaign of 1975 Director of Dissertation: Francis E. Godwyll This historiography study investigates the Somali Literacy Campaign of 1975, which was implemented to improve the socioeconomic development of the country through literacy. The Somali language did not have orthography until 1972 and the media of administration and education instruction was English, Italian, and Arabic. Moreover, the illiteracy rate was 90% and the use of foreign languages in the country denied the majority of the population access to education, health, employment, and many other vital services. In 1969, the government took the initiative of devising a Somali language orthography. Subsequently, the government organized a mass literacy campaign to disseminate the reading and writing of the Somali language throughout the country, and this was followed by the Somalization of administration and education. This process was completed between 1973 and 1975. The study uses oral historiography and/or narratology approaches to examine the objectives and the outcomes of the campaign.
    [Show full text]