Language Families of the Nigerian and the historical implications of their distribution

Language families of the Nigerian Middle Belt and the historical implications of their distribution

Jos Linguistic Circle , July 25th 2007 Roger Blench Kay Williamson Educational Foundation

- - -

4 6 8 10 12 14

------

N - - - Republic of Niger Lake Chad Jibiya Lake SOKOTO

I

A Jalaa

H K A G N

N C H A D I C U - 12 - R - 12 - O KANO I • has a single language isolate, the Jalaa or Cen S

E MAIDUGURI M A N D Tiga Lake E A A Tuum language spoken among the Cham in the Gombe A L W K JA A S E (West CHADIC) T I (Central CHADIC) n S i T N n J area.

e K I

B Kainji A P L A T E A U f A o I

Lake N W c Dadin Kowa Lake i A l J I - 10 - b - 10 - • Analysis so far suggests that it is unrelated to any other M u A

p R Shiroro Lake

e D U R D A G I N U P O I D O language in the world and thus is probably a survival Jebba Lake K O R A Ri T D A K O I D ver from the hunting-gathering period when Ni ger Republic of e would have been occupied by small foraging bands AKOKO I D I D O M O I D enu B Cameroon ver - 8 - OKO Ri - 8 - B J U K U N O I D speaking a diverse range of now disappeared languages E N U E - C O N E D O I D G O Y O R U B O I D • Evidence from Mali (Onjougou), Birimi (Ghana) and I D O K E Y LAGOS I L B M R A Shum Laka (Cameroun) puts the settlement of West M K A I N J I Benue-Congo subgroup E I G B O I D

V G B E I ENUGU R G U R Niger-Congo subgroup Africa by modern humans at ca. 40,000 BP

- 6 - - 6 -

S Atlantic Ocean S

O K A N U R I Nilo-Saharan subgroup

R • Other language isolates are Laal (Chad) and Bangi Me

C C H A D I C Afroasiatic subgroup 0 100 200 (Mali) Kilometres Mallam Dendo Cartographic services, July 2007

- - -

12 14

- -

8 10 4 6

-

- - -

- -

-

Nigeria: meeting place of three of

- -

-

-

10 - 8 Africa’s language phyla 6 - ©Mallam Dendo cartographic services 2007 K E Y State capital

E Jukunoid Benue-Congo subgroup A • Nigeria is one of the regions of Africa where three of its S BEROMIC Plateau subgroup T BAUCHI KADUNA four language phyla overlap and interact K t r A a l I Shall-Zwall n N e (Beromic) - 10 - J - 10 - • These are; I N C Bijim cluster a - Beromic (Tarokoid) n o t JOS • Nilo-Saharan (Songhay, Saharan) u r d t s c

a Shiroro Lake h K - i r W e e • Afroasiatic (Chadic, Semitic, Berber) v z i e

R s Alumic D Jilic n East I

t W Ndunic O • Niger-Congo (Mande, Gur, Atlantic, Volta-Niger, Ijoid, i K

O Benue-Congo, Adamawa, Ubangian) N Ake R J L Eggon CTA • The Benue-Congo languages (which include Bantu) are R ABUJA Jilic iv LAFIA e N r the richest and most numerous family, including Plateau, N ue ig en D East and West Kainji, Cross River, Dakoid, Mambiloid e Eloyi B I r er O iv N and other Bantoid, as well as Bantu proper (Jarawan and - 8 - R U - 8 - K

-

- U

-

J

- 6- 10 Ekoid) 8

-

Roger Blench Talk to Jos Linguistic Circle 25/07/2007 1 Language Families of the Nigerian Middle Belt and the historical implications of their distribution

Plateau languages Plateau languages • How many are there? • What is their status? • Ca. 40 at last count with perhaps 2/3 to be • Almost all Plateau languages are threatened, discovered excluding Kainji and Jukunoid except perhaps Berom and Tarok, and a few are moribund, such as Sambe and Yangkam. The • How many speakers are there? main source of threat is the spread of Hausa and • Excluding Jukunoid and East Kainji, ca. 1 further south, English. million. This is largely made up of groups • What classification should be adopted? such as Berom and Eggon. Most groups are • Evidence for a Plateau grouping is present but small (2-10,000). More claim ethnic affiliation has never been published in towns but have poor command of the • Relationship with Kainji and Jukunoid still languages undetermined Membership of Eloyi (previously ascribed to Idomoid) seems likely

Plateau languages: classification Beromic languages

Proto-Central Ni gerian Proto-Beromic

Kainji Plateau Jukunoid Dakoid

Tarokoid Shall-Zwall

Northern Beromic Central Ninzic Alumic Ndunic Southern Southeastern Eloyi Iten

North South Jilic Eggonic Cara Berom

Alumic languages Jilic-Eggonic languages

J Proto-Alumic L C Jijili Koro-Ija Koro Zuba Jili Ake Eggon

Alumu-Tesu Toro Sambe Hasha

Roger Blench Talk to Jos Linguistic Circle 25/07/2007 2 Language Families of the Nigerian Middle Belt and the historical implications of their distribution

East Plateau languages Tarokoid languages

Proto-Tarokoid

East Plateau

Kwanka Sur cluster Bo-Rukul Yaŋkam

Tarok Pe Horom Fyem

Plateau languages: conclusions I East I • Subgrouping at present is nearly all lexical and • The East Kainji languages were originally identified morphological. I have yet to find any convincing by Greenberg in 1955 as Plateau 1b. This was phonological innovations defining groups. Syntax is ignored by Westermann and Bryan and Rowlands still poorly known. Language contact is extensive seems to have rediscovered this in 1962, using the and regular correspondences (as opposed to wordlists of Meek (1931) like/like correspondences) are hard to find • The idea that Kainji languages were a branch co- • It is also the case that the affix systems of Plateau ordinate with Plateau rather than simply a branch and Kainji have eroded and been rebuilt many seems to have surfaced in the Benue-Congo times; hence the difficulties of finding regular Working Group as did the informal use of the name correspondences with for example Bantu noun Kainji, following the creation of the Lake in 1974. classes. Verbs and their extensions can be Hoffman’s listing in the Index of Nigerian Languages borrowed as a package, hence spurious similarities (1976) calls them ‘Western Plateau’. But Kainji seems to have only been formally recognised in print between Izere and Berom. by Gerhardt (1989).

East Kainji languages II • Published evidence for the unity of East Kainji as a group East Kainji languages III and for its subclassification is non-existent. Scattered wordlists, some very short, are found in the BCCW and in East Kainji languages abut the Hausa-speaking the publications of Shimizu. Since the field trips area and their speakers tend to be fluent in conducted by Shimizu in the 1970s there have been Hausa. Many are threatened by the declining virtually no new materials published on East Kainji languages. competence of the children in their own • John Nengel, made a number of visits to some of these languages. Ziriya is completely dead, Sheni has communities in the 1980s to collect historical data but just six speakers and Zora is clearly in decline. studies of East Kainji languages have largely languished. As a consequence,J we began to undertake a survey of LIt is unlikely the trend will be easily reversedC for East Kainji communities, especially in the Jos area, and smaller groups, but larger speech communities focusing on languages reported by Shimizu as severely threatened. such as the Boze, where there is an articulate • So far data has been collected on the Boze [=Buji], Loro, older generation with an interest in language Panawa, Sheni, Tunzu, Ziriya and Zora [=Cokobo] development, are a more realistic proposition. languages. A dictionary project is underway for Boze

Roger Blench Talk to Jos Linguistic Circle 25/07/2007 3 Language Families of the Nigerian Middle Belt and the historical implications of their distribution

East Kainji languages: classification East Kainji languages Impressionistically, Atsam • How many speakers are there? (Chawai) and Piti are somewhat • No reliable or even unreliable figures available but most groups are very small and language competence different from the others. The declining. Perhaps 100,000 maximum. Kuda-Chamo languages have • What is their status? clearly changed under the • Almost all East Kainji languages are threatened, except perhaps Amo and Chawai and many reported influence of the encircling to exist may well be extinct. The main source of threat Chadic languages. But all the is the spread of Hausa. The isolated lects among the Hausa such as Kuda-Chamo are virtually gone. The remainder seem to form a main source of endangerment is the spread of Hausa continuous chain and the small size of communities. There is some energy now to protect larger languages like Boze, Tunzu and Amo

East Kainji languages East Kainji Morphologically, East Kainji languages are simple tiSeni nominal plural forms compared with their Plateau neighbours, with regular affix alternations, transparent concord and Gloss sg. pl. usually CV syllable structures. Nonetheless, there have been some important seed ùgbέrù ùgbέgbέrù morphological changes under the influence of competing languages. tiSeni, in particular has forest ùshìrím ùshìríshím only six speakers. The nominal plural morphology recorded in our survey shows a reduplication of the first syllable instead of the expected affix neck iyâw iyâwyâw alternation. This is not recorded in neighbouring languages and Shimizu did not note it. ear ùtùway tutuwáy

East Kainji languages East Kainji languages The last It suggests influence from non- ‘remember’ of Hausa Chadic; although there are no Ziriya such languages in the area today. Hasha, a Plateau language, has undergone a similar development. Despite this, tiSeni is lexically J Lconventional C

Roger Blench Talk to Jos Linguistic Circle 25/07/2007 4 Language Families of the Nigerian Middle Belt and the historical implications of their distribution

East Kainji languages East Kainji languages

Linguistically, these languages have East Kainji languages are all very one very surprising feature, namely close to one another, to the extent four level tones in a region generally that they could be regarded as a long marked by three-level systems. The dialect chain rather than as distinct fourth tone has arisen as a languages. Clearly, why this should superhigh, created by a pluralising be so when compared to the highly tone-raising rule but is in the diverse West Kainji languages is an process of being generalised across intriguing problem. the system.

West Kainji languages West Kainji languages

• The West Kainji languages constitute one

Reshe of the most widespread and typologically *Lake Laru diverse groups of Benue-Congo. Some *Upper Lopa Niger exist for there is still no lexical data. Cicipu *Central Kambari • They include the Lake languages (Laru, Basa *Basa-Kamuku *Proto-West Kamuku Lopa and Reshe), the Kambari languages, Pongu Kainji the Lela languages and the Basa chain Gurmana Pongu cluster Baushi cLela • The following trees represent an attempt Ura Hun-Saare to order the main subgroups of West Kainji *Northwest Main RMB October 2004 Gwamhi-Wuri

Kambari cluster Basa cluster

tsiGadi Cicipu Basa-Kontagora tsuVadi Kambari I Basa-Gumna ciShingyini

Koromba ciBaangi Proto Yumu* [?] Basa-Gurara Basa J Proto-Kambari L C Basa-Kwali tsiGaushi Kambari II Basa-Benue tsiKimba Basa- tsiW?nci RMB 2007

Roger Blench Talk to Jos Linguistic Circle 25/07/2007 5 Language Families of the Nigerian Middle Belt and the historical implications of their distribution

Kamuku cluster Pongu cluster

Rin Hu?gw?r? Pongu W´g´

S?g?muk Gurmana

Proto Sambuga Kamuku Madaka Proto Sama Pongu Supana* Rogo Baushi Wayam* Cinda

Regi Rubu* * No lexical data. RMB Tiyal Fungwa

cLela cluster Jarawan Bantu • The Jarawan form a closely related cluster, stretching from Northern Cameroun, into Adamawa and across into Plateau Lela and Bauchi Ribah • They are very closely related to Bantu, indeed to

Hun the A60 languages and they have only not been Proto Northwest treated as Bantu because their nominal prefixes Saare Kainji are now ‘frozen’ possibly due to contact with

Main cluster Chadic. • However, on lexical grounds they should be Gwamhi RMB treated as Bantu proper. Their exclusion is Wuri typological rather than genetic • But of course this does not explain the motivation for their extraordinary migrations..

Migrations of the Jarawan Bantu

- - -

4 6 8 10 12 14

------

N - - - Historical synthesis I Republic of Niger Lake Chad SOKOTO

K • The earliest occupation of what is now North-Central A N C H A D I C U - 12 - R - 12 - KANO I Nigeria must have been that of Pleistocene foragers,

n

i

n MAIDUGURI A )

e and perhaps the only trace of these is the Jalaa A E L IC

B A JA D

K Bauchi A

f KADUNA (West CHADIC) A S H T

o I cluster C N l • Nilo-Saharan speakers, probably fishing people, to A ra c B J t i I W n l E e A C ( b N M judge by their harpoon points, expanded across the

u U P L A T E A U A Mbula-Bwazza - 1 0 - - 10 - p D E A e - R C region ca. 10-8000 years ago O Kantana N U P O I D N G Kulung • This was followed by the Gur-Adamawa speakers, ABUJA O Nagumi D D A K O I D R I Bille K E Y iv O Mboa e K stretching from Burkina Faso to Chad, perhaps 6- r O N I D O M O I D R e ig A u K A I N J I Benue-Congo subgroup er T n - 8 - e - 8 - 8000 years ago B I D C H A D I C Afroasiatic subgroup r O e N U iv K J R J U L C D • It is likely the East Benue-Congo speakers then I O L B I M LAGOS A spread northwards, disrupting the Gur-Adamawa M chain Atlantic Ocean - 6 - d - 6 - i Republic of 0100200 o • Probably then the Nupoid languages expanded k Kilometres E Cameroon Presumed homeland of northwards and broke apart the two branches of Mallam Dendo Jarawan Bantu Cartographic services, July 2007 Kainji

- - -

12 14

- -

8 10

4 6

-

- - -

- -

-

Roger Blench Talk to Jos Linguistic Circle 25/07/2007 6 Language Families of the Nigerian Middle Belt and the historical implications of their distribution

Early Nilo-Saharans in Nigeria The Gur-Adamawa expansion

- - -

4 6 8 10 12 14

------

P - - ro- Republic of Niger to

- - -

- 8 10 12 14 4 6

- - -

- - - S

y - - - gha Jibiya Lake s a ay -Son SOKOTO h N gh Proto pe a on a ra S Republic of Niger S Lake s Lake k n a Chad aker er ha spe Chad s SOKOTO ran - 12 - - 12 - KANO

n

i - 12 - - 1 2 -

n MAIDUGURI Tiga Lake KANO

e

n

B

i MAIDUGURI

n

f KADUNA

e

o

B

c

i

f l JALAAIC Gu o r

b - Ad

c a u m

i a - 1 0 - - 10 - w p l a-U

e b ban u g R ia - 10 - n - 1 0 - (Unidentified hunter-gatherers) p

e Shiroro Lake

R R K E Y ive r N R ABUJA ig e K E Y iv K A I N J I Benue-Congo subgroup er u er - 8 - n - 8 - N e B e ig u C H A D I C Afroasiatic subgroup E N U B K A I N J I Benue-Congo subgroup e E - 8 - r n - 8 - C - r N e O N G O e B v Afroasiatic subgroup r Ri C H A D I C ve Ri LAGOS

LAGOS

Atlantic Ocean - 6 - - 6 - Republic of Atlantic Ocean 0 100 200 - 6 - Republic of - 6 - 0 100 200 Kilometres Cameroon Kilometres Mallam Dendo Cameroon Cartographic services, Mallam Dendo July 2007 Cartographic services,

- - -

12 14

July 2007

- - 4 6 8 10

-

The Benue-Congo expansion The Volta-Niger expansion

- - -

8 10 12 14

4 6

- - -

- - -

ay - - -

- - -

h

N 8 10 g 4 6 12 14

-

- - - - - n

S

o S Republic of Niger S Lake y - - aha- a Chad N a ra har Republic of Niger Lake n SOKOTO h an g Chad G n SOKOTO ur o S - 12 - - 1 2 - G KANO u K - 12 - - 12 -

n r KANO i A MAIDUGURI

n

n W

i

e I MAIDUGURI n E

B

N e K I f S B T J

o J T

f A S N D

c I I o

i A U I A l I c N E

i b A K l

u J

E b - 1 0 - - 1 0 - U O p I

u T P L A T E A U e - 10 - - 10 - A Ad p A P a e R L maw E Ada a R m P U T awa N A R e L i u ABUJA ver n Ri P N Be D ve ig r I r N I D er e O L ig - 8 - iv N - 8 - ikely er e O R - 8 - Vol u N - 8 - U ho ta- n I D me Nig e O U Likely Benue-Congo K lan er B N U d a r U K rea e KU nucleus area J v U Ri J J LAGOS LAGOS

Atlantic Ocean Atlantic Ocean R Republic of - 6 - - 6 - E Republic of - 6 - V - 6 - 0 100 200 I R 0 100 200 R E DE SS Cameroon Kilometres V Kilometres LT I A C O R Cameroon RO R S SS C Mallam Dendo OS Mallam Dendo Cartographic services, R Cartographic services, July 2007 C July 2007 I j o I d

- - - 14 - - - 14

12 12

- -

- -

8 10 8 10

4 6 4 6

-

-

- - -

- - -

- -

- -

-

-

The Chadic expansion

- - -

8 10

4 6 12 14

- Historical synthesis II

- - - - -

S

y - - aha- N a ran h Republic of Niger Lake g Chad n SOKOTO Secondary Gur o • This would have been followed by the Secondary Kanuri S Expansion - 12 - Hausa - 12 - expansion first of West Chadic (2-3000 years KANO

n Expansion i W MAIDUGURI n West Chadic ago) and then the secondary expansion of e E B K Central Chadic

f S D o T I A Hausa (? 1000 years ago) further breaking up I T J c

i I S N l N I b A O A u J E the Kainji and Plateau populations and pressing e P L A T E A U - 10 - K - 10 - p d I P e n U Ada R m a U A aw southwards M E a N T A ABUJA L Ri P • At the same time there would have been a ver N I D ige e O Republic of secondary expansion of Kanuri cluster - 8 - r u N - 8 - n D e IU O id B NK o r U Cameroon languages from north of Lake Chad b e K ru U U o J iv J J L C Y R LAGOS Edoid • Shuwa Arabs are likely to begin incursions into Igboid NE Nigeria in the 13th century Atlantic Ocean ER - 6 - IV - 6 - 0 100 200 R D S EL S • And sometime around this period the Jarawan Kilometres T A C O RO R Bantu homeland SS C Mallam Dendo Cartographic services, Bantu migrations begin July 2007 I j o I d

- - - 14 12

- -

8 10

4 6

-

- - -

- -

-

Roger Blench Talk to Jos Linguistic Circle 25/07/2007 7