`Late' Male Sperm Precedence in Polyandrous Wool-Carder Bees And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Animal Behaviour 90 (2014) 211e217 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Animal Behaviour journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/anbehav ‘Late’ male sperm precedence in polyandrous wool-carder bees and the evolution of male resource defence in Hymenoptera Kathrin P. Lampert, Vanessa Pasternak, Philipp Brand, Ralph Tollrian, Florian Leese, Thomas Eltz* Department of Animal Ecology, Evolution and Biodiversity, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Bochum, Germany article info The mating system of European wool-carder bees, Anthidium manicatum, differs from that of most bees in Article history: three important aspects: females (1) are polyandrous and (2) mate continuously over the course of their Received 2 October 2013 reproductive life, while males (3) exhibit resource defence polygyny, that is, defend patches of food Initial acceptance 4 November 2013 plants where copulations occur. To shed light on the evolution of this mating system we investigated Final acceptance 9 January 2014 male paternity using a combination of cage experiments and microsatellite genotyping of brood. We Published online found that, although females possess a spermatheca for long-term sperm storage, most brood was MS. number: 13-00824R fathered by males that had very recently mated with the breeding female, indicating pronounced last (or at least ‘late’) male sperm precedence. In the absence of males (male exclusion experiment) a large Keywords: proportion of eggs remained unfertilized (resulting in haploid male offspring), but some diploid Anthidium manicatum daughters arose from fathers that had been removed at least 11 days prior to egg laying. It appears that interspecific territoriality most A. manicatum eggs are fertilized with sperm from the bursa copulatrix, while the spermatheca last male sperm precedence fi microsatellites serves only as a backup reservoir. This is the rst demonstration of last male sperm precedence in ‘ ’ multiple mating aculeate Hymenoptera (bees, wasps, ants). We suggest that it has coevolved with resource defence or paternity ‘patrolling’-like male mating strategies in Hymenoptera, and with polyandry in anthidiine bees. polyandry Ó 2014 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. polygyny promiscuity resource defence Mating behaviours and mating systems of bees have received studied in detail, but those that have all appear to be polyandrous considerable attention from evolutionary biologists owing to their (Alcock, Eickwort, & Eickwort, 1977). Among them, the European diversity and potential for comparative analysis (Paxton, 2005; wool-carder bee, Anthidium manicatum, was unintentionally Thornhill & Alcock, 1983), but also because of their relevance to introduced to the Americas and New Zealand in the late 1960s and the evolution of sociality (Brown & Schmid-Hempel, 2003; Crozier is now the most widely distributed unmanaged bee species of the & Fjerdingstad, 2001; Strassmann, 2001). In the majority of bee world (Strange, Koch, Gonzalez, Nemelka, & Griswold, 2011). species, both solitary and social, the females are sexually receptive Anthidium manicatum represents an extreme case of polyandry that only at the beginning of adult life, mate only once with a single is combined with male territoriality and floral resource defence male, and store sperm from this copulation for use throughout their (Severinghaus, Kurtak, & Eickwort, 1981). Females forage on pollen reproductive life. Such single mating (monandry) in females ap- and nectar mostly from Lamiaceae and Fabaceae, which often grow pears to be the ancestral state in aculeate Hymenoptera, whereas in aggregated patches. Males establish territories centred on such polyandry is a derived exception (Hughes, Oldroyd, Beekman, & patches, fend off conspecific males and other flower visitors, and Ratnieks, 2008; Strassmann, 2001). Eusocial honeybees (Apis spp.) mate with females that forage within the territory (Severinghaus are a particularly notable and well-studied exception (Franck et al., et al., 1981; Wirtz, Kopka, & Schmoll, 1992; Wirtz, Szabados, 2002; Haberl & Tautz, 1998; Oldroyd et al., 1996; Schlüns, Moritz, Pethig, & Plant, 1988). Copulations are an extremely common Neumann, Kryger, & Koeniger, 2005). A less prominent exception sight at a given territory and repeated copulations of the same in- are bees within the Anthidiini, of which few species have been dividual regularly occur within a few minutes in both sexes (Severinghaus et al., 1981). The number of female visits and copu- lations that a male obtains was found to be positively correlated with territory quality, that is, the number of flowers in the territory, * Correspondence: T. Eltz, Department of Animal Ecology, Evolution and Biodi- versity, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Universitätsstraße 150, 44780 Bochum, Germany. and with male size (Severinghaus et al., 1981). Males that cannot E-mail address: [email protected] (T. Eltz). defend a territory, often the smaller males, adopt an alternative http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2014.01.034 0003-3472/Ó 2014 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. 212 K. P. Lampert et al. / Animal Behaviour 90 (2014) 211e217 ‘sneaking’ tactic, but receive fewer copulation opportunities than on a chip (Hybond Nþ, GE Healthcare) with DNA from Mus mus- territory owners (Severinghaus et al., 1981). culus. As a modification to Leese et al. (2008), 0.03 U/ml Hotmaster The territorial mating behaviour of A. manicatum, and that of the Taq (5Prime) were used in PCR reactions. Also, nick repair and PCR similar Anthidium maculosum (Alcock et al., 1977), is probably were carried out in one reaction tube by incubating for 10 min at derived from behaviours where mate-seeking males patrol at floral 70 C prior to PCR (94 C for 2 min followed by 25 cycles of 15 s at resources, which is relatively common in bees, especially in species 94 C, 30 s at 52 C, 60 s at 65 C and 15 min final elongation at with nonaggregated nesting sites (Paxton, 2005). In fact, male 65 C). For elution, hybridization chips were transferred into 500 ml territoriality at flower patches can be considered a ‘localized’ case TE buffer (pH 8.0, 80 C) for 10 min. DNA was precipitated using a of patrolling which happens when floral resources are sufficiently standard isopropanolesodium acetate protocol. The enriched aggregated to allow monopolization and defence by individual fragments were PCR amplified in 50 ml reactions and cloned into males. pGEM-T easy (Promega) vectors and transformed into competent Floral resource defence by males may benefit females because JM109 E. coli (Promega). males fend off heterospecific flower visitors such as honeybees and Plasmid preparation of 48 colonies and shotgun sequencing bumblebees, which would otherwise compete for pollen and nectar using a standard M13-forward primer was conducted by GATC- (Wirtz et al., 1988). If females prefer to forage in defended sites, and Biotech (Konstanz, Germany). Analysis of electropherograms, vec- the costs of additional matings are low, then male resource defence tor clipping, assembly of contigs, redundancy filtering and primer and polyandry might coevolve. However, for males the benefits design were performed with the software Geneious 5.6 from resource defence will depend strongly on patterns of sperm (Drummond, Ashton, Buxton, & Cooper, 2011). Microsatellites in use by females. Female anthidiine bees, as is typical for solitary the final contigs were searched using the search tool Phobos bees, lay their eggs more or less continuously throughout the version 3.12 (Mayer, 2011). Primers were designed for six loci (see breeding season, ovipositing briefly before closing each consecutive Table 1) using Primer3 (Rozen & Skaletsky, 2000). To enable fluo- brood cell (see e.g. Westrich, 1989; this study). If only sperm from rescent marking for fragment size analyses an M13 tail was added the first copulation(s) is used by a female to fertilize eggs to either the forward or reverse primer of each primer pair throughout the season, then a ‘sit-and-wait’ strategy such as (Table 1). The decision was based on a NetPrimer (Premier Biosoft, resource defence is unlikely to be favoured by selection over more Palo Alto, CA, U.S.A.) analysis. ‘pre-emptive’ male strategies such as patrolling at nest sites. If, however, delayed mating has a high probability of siring offspring, Flight Cage Experiments then resource defence is more beneficial. Clearly, establishing patterns of sperm use is important for understanding the evolution Mesh-covered flight cages of 4 Â 2 Â 2 m were installed in the of male resource defence. Botanical Garden of the Ruhr-Universität Bochum in the summers The term ‘last male sperm precedence’ (henceforth LMSP) of 2011 and 2012 (Fig. 1). The cages contained two longitudinal usually refers to experimental situations in which two males are rows of freely planted Betonica officinalis (for pollen and nectar), allowed to mate in sequence and the second mate sires more than potted plants of Stachys byzanthina (for plant wool, which females 50% of the offspring. It has been found in many species and groups use to construct brood cells), potted plants of Pelargonium sp. and of insects, and might be caused by a range of mechanisms including Crepis capillaris (for trichome secretions, which females apply on stratification of sperm from different males in the sperm-storing collected plant wool; Müller, Töpfl, & Amiet, 1996), and clusters of organ of the female (last in, first out), sperm digestion or removal split bamboo internodes (length 9e27 cm, inner diameter 1.2e by the female, or sperm removal by the second male (Simmons, 2.2 cm) fixed to wooden poles (see also Payne, Schildroth, & Starks 2001). In bees, the contribution of sequential mates to paternity 2011). Wild female and male A. manicatum were captured at their has only been studied in honeybees, Apis mellifera, with mostly food plants in the Botanical Gardens of Bochum and Düsseldorf, negative results, that is, sperm from sequential copulations appears marked individually with dots of acrylic paint on the mesosoma, to be mixed in the queen spermatheca to an extent that no and introduced into these cages.