DOCSLIB.ORG

Understanding Justice System of KP, FATA & Balochistan

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Understanding Justice System of KP, FATA & Balochistan Copyright © CAMP 2013 Community Appraisal & Motivation Programme (CAMP) Understanding Justice Systems of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, FATA and Balochistan: The Pakhtun Perspective All rights reserved Citation, reproduction or translation of this publication, in whole or part, for educational or other non-commercial purposes is authorised but with written permission, provided the source is fully acknowledged. ISBN: 978-969-9534-07-02 Copies and more information available from: P.O. Box 765 Email: [email protected] & [email protected] Download from: www.camp.org Authors: Naveed Ahmed Shinwari & Neha Ali Gauhar Design & Printed by: Waya Communications, Islamabad Illustrations: Rehan ud Din Khattak Paper: EU, 100 gm, FSC certified Table of Contents Map of Pakistan- showing FATA, KP and Balochistan ii List of Acronyms iii Preface V Executive Summary Vii Chapter 1: The political and administrative structure of FATA, 1 Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan Chapter 2: The Formal Structure of Courts in Pakistan 11 Chapter 3: Nizam-e-Adl – A New Addition To The Formal System 15 Chapter 4: Knowledge of Formal and Informal Justice Systems and 21 their use Chapter 5: Pakhtun awareness and opinion of the institutions and 27 actors in KP and Balochistan Chapter 6: The Jirga: A traditional Justice system 43 Chapter 7: The state of Fundamental Rights and Jirga 59 Chapter 8: Women and the Jirga system 77 Chapter 9: Access To Justice and Conflict Dynamics 95 Chapter 10: Legality and Legitimacy; Formal and Informal systems 111 Compared Chapter 11: The Way Forward – Jirga Evolution 139 Annex I Methodology 152 Annex II Questionnaire 160 Annex III Target Demographics 189 List of Acronyms Alternate Dispute Resolution ADR Anti-Terrorism Courts ATC Awami National Party ANP Convention on the Rights of the Child CRC Community Appraisal and Motivation Programme CAMP Code of Civil Procedure CPC District Coordination Officer DCO District Police Officer DPO FATA Tribunal FT Federally Administered Tribal Areas FATA Federal Board of Revenue FBR Federal Shariat Court FSC Focus Group Discussions FGDs First Information Report FIR Frontier Regions FRs Frontier Crimes Regulation FCR Government of Pakistan GoP Human Rights Commission of Pakistan HRCP International Convention for the Elimination of all forms ICERD of Racial Discrimination Internally Displaced Persons IDPs Key Informant Interviews KIIs Khyber Pakhtunkhwa KP Musalihati Anjumans MAs National Assembly NA National Finance Commission NFC Nizam-e-Adl Regulation NAR Non-Governmental Organisations NGOs North West Frontier Province NWFP Pakistan Penal Code PPC Political Agent PA Peshawar High Court PHC Post Crisis Needs Assessment PCNA Provincially Administered Tribal Areas PATA Supreme Court of Pakistan SCP iii Tehreek-e-Nafaz-e-Shariat-e-Mohammadi TNSM Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan TTP United Nations Development Programme UNDP iv Preface Historically, individuals, social groups and The subject of this report is the opinion of societies have disputed with and competed Pakhtun people living in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa against one another over scarce commodities (KP) and Balochistan with regard to the systems and resources - land, money, political power, of justice in those Provinces. In 2010, similar and ideology. In many parts of the world, research was conducted among the Pakhtuns in traditional systems of justice and dispute FATA. In this report, comparisons between these resolution are being approached to resolve provinces and FATA are presented. conflicts, and to ensure peace and stability within local societies or tribes. Often those The judicial structure in Pakistan is derived systems are suitable to resolve modern, from the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) 1908 current conflicts because they satisfy the and the West Pakistan Civil Courts Ordinance local cultural and religious sentiments. This (II of 1962). However, the formal court system aspect, the traditions related to religion and has evolved to meet circumstances demanding local codes of justice, often make them more changes; one of the latest ones was the addition successful than the contemporary or modern of the Nizam-e-Adl courts as part of the justice systems. The existing body of literature agreement to resolve the conflict in Malakand confirms that the nature and causes of conflicts Division of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa in 2009. and the mechanisms for resolving them are deeply rooted in the culture and history of The approach of Pakhtuns is distinct from every society; they are in many important ways the Pakistani judicial structure when it comes unique to them. to accessing justice in those areas where Pakhtunwali, the “ways of the Pakhtun.” However, such traditional systems are being prevails. To them ‘Jirga’ is still the preferred criticised for their incongruence with modern form of informal or parallel justice mechanism. justice systems or their tendency to violate Formally, the Jirga is still the mechanism for some very basic principles of human rights, dispensing justice and resolving conflicts in especially women’s and minority rights. the FATA under the Frontier Crimes Regulation (FCR). However, Jirga is informal, i.e., not The Pakhtun Jirga’ is one such traditional or codified in Pakistani civil law in other parts of tribal justice system being practiced by the Pakhtun dominated areas of Pakistan. Pakhtun or Pashtun ethnic group that lives in Pakistan and Afghanistan. There are over On the other hand, in Pakistan, it is generally forty million Pakhtuns living on both sides of perceived, by the Pakhtun, that the formal justice the Durand Line in Pakistan and Afghanistan. system does provide a system that is comparable Pakhtuns inhabit an area of more than 100,000 to the Jirga. Generally, the Pakistani public lacks square miles bisected by the Durand Line since confidence in the formal justice system, which 1893. In Pakistan, Pakhtuns reside in Khyber has undermined the Rule of Law and contributed Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan and the Federally to rising violence, including crime, terrorism and Administered Tribal Areas (FATA). In addition, human rights abuses. For a majority of Pakistanis, v Karachi also hosts some 3 to 4 million Pakhtuns the formal justice system is seen as expensive; who migrated from different parts of the has no provision for compensation for victims; is Pakhtun dominated areas of Pakistan. slow and is widely perceived as corrupt, biased and dominated by the rich. These beliefs provide a conducive environment for the Jirga to remain lawyer by training and a Human Rights activist, the preferred option over the modern justice Neha did a wonderful job in highlighting and system in Pakhtun areas. Hence such a situation comparing the human rights issues in the has provided a favourable environment for Jirga informal justice system, especially that of to flourish and remain the only available option women and minorities in the Pakhtun region. for the Pakhtun community. Fareeha Sultan, project manager for CAMP’s The findings of CAMP’s two research studies Rule of Law Programme, deserves special on Jirga – this one and the one conducted in appreciation for coordinating numerous 2010 on FATA – suggest that underestimating activities and achieving some very ambitious the efficiency and effectiveness ofJirga would and difficult targets for the project. I appreciate be a mistake, especially because it plays an the efforts of Naveed Akhtar, field researcher/ essential role in the maintenance of social consultant, for assisting Riaz-ul-haq, our Senior order and has proved successful in the past. Manager Research/surveys in coordinating It is inexpensive, speedy and accessible to field activities in the field. the poor. It is concluded that traditional approaches to conflict resolution are able to I am very grateful to Riaz-ul-haq (Sr. Manager deal with conflict before they spread because Research), who assisted this research in of their decentralized and local availability, plus terms of coordinating field work, organising the confidence gained in the cultural context enumerators trainings, and focused group and belief systems. discussions, supervising and managing the data gathering and data feeding, and, finally, In developing this understanding, many providing me with cleaned data sets. Special people have contributed to this report. The thanks to Mariam A. Khan our Director compilation of this report would have never Programme and Meher Khan for their support been possible without the active involvement and proof reading the report. My appreciation and intellectual insight of 2,400 men and goes to Irum Ali Khan and Aezaz Khan for their women respondents of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa help in compiling information on the structure and Balochistan, who are most familiar with of formal justice system in Pakistan and their the subject. They were extremely helpful in support in proof reading. sharing their knowledge of and insight into the institution and dynamics of Jirga and the tribal Without the generous financial support of the way of life, which have remained a mystery to German Embassy, Islamabad, this research the outsiders till this day. Their willingness to would not have been possible; I am extremely contribute to this report helped Community grateful. Special gratitude to Ms. Barbara Voss, Appraisal and Motivation Programme (CAMP) First Secretary Political and Mr. Andreas Dauth, develop a perspective on various aspects of Third Secretary Political for their constant Jirga, which is the focus of this report. support and encouragement. I am equally
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Death-Penalty-Pakistan
    Report Mission of Investigation Slow march to the gallows Death penalty in Pakistan Executive Summary. 5 Foreword: Why mobilise against the death penalty . 8 Introduction and Background . 16 I. The legal framework . 21 II. A deeply flawed and discriminatory process, from arrest to trial to execution. 44 Conclusion and recommendations . 60 Annex: List of persons met by the delegation . 62 n° 464/2 - January 2007 Slow march to the gallows. Death penalty in Pakistan Table of contents Executive Summary. 5 Foreword: Why mobilise against the death penalty . 8 1. The absence of deterrence . 8 2. Arguments founded on human dignity and liberty. 8 3. Arguments from international human rights law . 10 Introduction and Background . 16 1. Introduction . 16 2. Overview of death penalty in Pakistan: expanding its scope, reducing the safeguards. 16 3. A widespread public support of death penalty . 19 I. The legal framework . 21 1. The international legal framework. 21 2. Crimes carrying the death penalty in Pakistan . 21 3. Facts and figures on death penalty in Pakistan. 26 3.1. Figures on executions . 26 3.2. Figures on condemned prisoners . 27 3.2.1. Punjab . 27 3.2.2. NWFP. 27 3.2.3. Balochistan . 28 3.2.4. Sindh . 29 4. The Pakistani legal system and procedure. 30 4.1. The intermingling of common law and Islamic Law . 30 4.2. A defendant's itinerary through the courts . 31 4.2.1. The trial . 31 4.2.2. Appeals . 31 4.2.3. Mercy petition . 31 4.2.4. Stays of execution . 33 4.3. The case law: gradually expanding the scope of death penalty .
    [Show full text]
  • The Politics of Federalism in Pakistan
    The Politics of Federalism in Pakistan: An Analysis of the Major Issues of 18th and 20th Amendments Submitted by: Kamran Naseem Ph. D. Scholar Politics &I R Reg. No.22-SS/ Ph. D IR/ F 08 Supervisor: Dr. Amna Mahmood Department of Politics and IR Faculty of Social Sciences International Islamic University Islamabad 1 Table of Contents Introduction …………………………..……………………….…………………... 20-30 I.I State of the Problem I.II Scope of Thesis I.III Literature Review I.IV Significance of the Study I.V Objectives of the Study I.VI Research Questions I.VII Research Methodology I.VIII Organization of the Study Chapter 1 Theoretical Framework ………..……………………………...……… 31-56 1.1 Unitary System 1.2 Some Similarities in Characteristics of the Federal States 1.2.1 Distribution of Powers 1.2.2 Independence of the Judiciary 1.2.3 Two Sets of Government 1.2.4 A Written Constitution 1.3 Federalism is Debatable 1. 4 Ten Yardsticks of Federalism 1.4.1 One: Comprehensive Control over Foreign Policy 1.4.2 Two: Exemption against Separation 1.4.3 Three: Autonomous Domain of the Centre 1.4.4 Four: The Federal Constitution and Amendments 1.4.5 Five: Indestructible Autonomy and Character 1.4.6 Six: Meaningful and Remaining Powers 1.4.7 Seven: Representation on parity basis of unequal Units and Bicameral Legislature at Central Level 1.4.8 Eight: Two Sets of Courts 1.4.9 Nine: The Supreme Court 2 1.4.10 Ten: Classifiable Distribution of Power 1.4.11 Debatable Results of Testing the Yardsticks of Federalism 1.5 Institutional theory 1.5.1 Old Institutionalism 1.5.2 The New Institutionalism
    [Show full text]
  • THE MINORITY SAGA a Christian, Human Rights Perspective
    THE MINORITY SAGA A Christian, Human Rights Perspective Yousuf Jalal Gill Publisher UMEED ACADEMY Umeed Partnership Pakistan (UPP) 1 Book: THE MINORITY SAGA A Christian, Human Rights Perspective Author: Yousuf Jalal Gill Publisher: UMEED ACADEMY Umeed Partnership Pakistan (UPP). House # 198/199, Block J-3, M.A. Johar Town, Lahore E-mail:[email protected], [email protected] Tel 0092 42 35957302, Cell. 0092 300 9444482 Website: uppakistan.org, umeedpartnership.org.uk Printer: Zafarsons Printers, Lahore Edition: First Year: 2016 Print 1000 Price: Rs.200 UMEED ACADEMY Umeed Academy is the publishing arm of Umeed Partnership Pakistan (UPP) that is involved in developing disadvantaged communities through education and training. Umeed Academy publishes, in particular, research works on downtrodden, women and minorities and helps disseminate people-oriented publications so as to facilitate transformation of society through sustainable social change. The publications of Umeed Academy reflect views of the researchers and writers and not necessarily that of the UPP. 2 Dedicated to: Dr. John Perkins A consistent and fervent supporter of UPP in its endeavors to serve the most disadvantaged communities in Pakistan. 3 “The harvest is past, the summer is ended, and we are not saved.” -Jeremiah 8:20 4 “The test of courage comes when we are in the minority; the test of tolerance comes when we are in the majority.” -Ralph W. Sockman (American Writer) 5 6 About the Author The formative years of Yousuf Jalal Gill (b.1957) were spent with the Oblate Missionaries whom Pope Pius XI (1857 – 1939) referred to as the “Specialists in the most difficult missions…” Moreover, his youthful days witnessed an era of political upheaval after the dismemberment of erstwhile East Pakistan in 1971.
    [Show full text]
  • The Impact of Presidential Appointment of Judges: Montesquieu Or the Federalists?
    The impact of Presidential appointment of judges: Montesquieu or the Federalists? BY SULTAN MEHMOOD∗ March 2021 A central question in development economics is whether there are adequate checks and balances on the executive. This paper provides causal evidence on how increasing constraints on the executive, through removal of Presidential discretion in judicial appointments, promotes rule of law. The age structure of judges at the time of the reform and the mandatory retirement age law provide us with an exogenous source of variation in the removal of Presidential discretion in judicial appointments. According to our estimates, Presidential appointment of judges results in additional land expropriations by the government worth 0.14 percent of GDP every year. (JEL D02, O17, K11, K40). Keywords: President, judges, property rights, court subversion, expropriation risk. ∗ Centre for Economic Research in Pakistan (CERP) and New Economic School (E-mail: [email protected]). First Draft: August 2016. This Version: March 2021. A previous version of this paper was entitled, Judicial Independence and Economic Development: Evidence from Pakistan. I would like to thank Eric Brousseau, Daron Acemoglu, Esther Duflo, Abhijit Banerjee, Andrei Shleifer, Daniel Chen, Ekaterina Zhuravskaya, Ruben Enikolopov, James Robinson, Henrik Sigstad, Ruixue Jia, Saad Gulzar, Yasir Khan, Jean-Philippe Platteau, Thierry Verdier, Sergei Guriev, William Howell, Georg Vanberg, Anandi Mani, Adam Szeidl, Monika Nalepa, Nico Voigtlaender, Christian Dippel, Paola Giuliano, Thomas
    [Show full text]
  • Freedom of Religion & Religious Minorities in Pakistan: a Study Of
    Fordham International Law Journal Volume 19, Issue 1 1995 Article 5 Freedom of Religion & Religious Minorities in Pakistan: A Study of Judicial Practice Tayyab Mahmud∗ ∗ Copyright c 1995 by the authors. Fordham International Law Journal is produced by The Berke- ley Electronic Press (bepress). http://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ilj Freedom of Religion & Religious Minorities in Pakistan: A Study of Judicial Practice Tayyab Mahmud Abstract Pakistan’s successive constitutions, which enumerate guaranteed fundamental rights and pro- vide for the separation of state power and judicial review, contemplate judicial protection of vul- nerable sections of society against unlawful executive and legislative actions. This Article focuses upon the remarkably divergent pronouncements of Pakistan’s judiciary regarding the religious status and freedom of religion of one particular religious minority, the Ahmadis. The superior judiciary of Pakistan has visited the issue of religious freedom for the Ahmadis repeatedly since the establishment of the State, each time with a different result. The point of departure for this ex- amination is furnished by the recent pronouncement of the Supreme Court of Pakistan (”Supreme Court” or “Court”) in Zaheeruddin v. State,’ wherein the Court decided that Ordinance XX of 1984 (”Ordinance XX” or ”Ordinance”), which amended Pakistan’s Penal Code to make the public prac- tice by the Ahmadis of their religion a crime, does not violate freedom of religion as mandated by the Pakistan Constitution. This Article argues that Zaheeruddin is at an impermissible variance with the implied covenant of freedom of religion between religious minorities and the Founding Fathers of Pakistan, the foundational constitutional jurisprudence of the country, and the dictates of international human rights law.
    [Show full text]
  • Part I] the Gazette of Pakistan, Extra., December 18, 2020 753
    PART I] THE GAZETTE OF PAKISTAN, EXTRA., DECEMBER 18, 2020 753 __________________________________________________________________ ISLAMABAD, FRIDAY, DECEMBER 18, 2020 __________________________________________________________________ PART I Acts, Ordinances, President’s Orders and Regulations GOVERNMENT OF PAKISTAN MINISTRY OF LAW AND JUSTICE Islamabad, the 17th December, 2020 No. F. 2(1)/2020-Pub.—The following Ordnance promulgated on 14th December, 2020 by the President is hereby published for general information:— ORDINANCE No. XVI OF 2020 AN ORDINANCE to ensure expeditious redressal of rape and sexual abuse crimes in respect of women and children through special investigation teams and special Courts providing for efficacious procedures, speedy trial, evidence and matters connected therewith or incidental thereto; AND WHEREAS the Senate and the National Assembly are not in session and the President is satisfied that circumstances exist which render it necessary to take immediate action; (753) Price : Rs. 20.00 [6538(2020)/Ex. Gaz.] 754 THE GAZETTE OF PAKISTAN, EXTRA., DECEMBER 18, 2020 [PART I NOW THEREFORE, in exercise of the powers conferred by clause (1) of Article 89 of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, the President is pleased to make and promulgate the following Ordinance:— 1. Short title, extent, and commencement.—(1) This Ordinance may be called the Anti-Rape (Investigation and Trial) Ordinance, 2020. (2) It extends to the whole of Pakistan. (3) It shall come into force on such date as the Federal Government
    [Show full text]
  • Defining Shariʿa the Politics of Islamic Judicial Review by Shoaib
    Defining Shariʿa The Politics of Islamic Judicial Review By Shoaib A. Ghias A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the Requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Jurisprudence and Social Policy in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in Charge: Professor Malcolm M. Feeley, Chair Professor Martin M. Shapiro Professor Asad Q. Ahmed Summer 2015 Defining Shariʿa The Politics of Islamic Judicial Review © 2015 By Shoaib A. Ghias Abstract Defining Shariʿa: The Politics of Islamic Judicial Review by Shoaib A. Ghias Doctor of Philosophy in Jurisprudence and Social Policy University of California, Berkeley Professor Malcolm M. Feeley, Chair Since the Islamic resurgence of the 1970s, many Muslim postcolonial countries have established and empowered constitutional courts to declare laws conflicting with shariʿa as unconstitutional. The central question explored in this dissertation is whether and to what extent constitutional doctrine developed in shariʿa review is contingent on the ruling regime or represents lasting trends in interpretations of shariʿa. Using the case of Pakistan, this dissertation contends that the long-term discursive trends in shariʿa are determined in the religio-political space and only reflected in state law through the interaction of shariʿa politics, regime politics, and judicial politics. The research is based on materials gathered during fieldwork in Pakistan and datasets of Federal Shariat Court and Supreme Court cases and judges. In particular, the dissertation offers a political-institutional framework to study shariʿa review in a British postcolonial court system through exploring the role of professional and scholar judges, the discretion of the chief justice, the system of judicial appointments and tenure, and the political structure of appeal that combine to make courts agents of the political regime.
    [Show full text]
  • Pakistan Security Challenges.Pdf
    Balochistan January 2011 REPORTS I. Causes of Instability in Pakistan 14 II. Balochistan – Pakistan's Festering Wound! 83 III. Karachi – Seething Under Violence and Terror 135 CRSS - 2010 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Causes of Instability in Pakistan SECTION I Structural Causes of Instability 14 1. Objectives Resolution 14 1.1 The Question of Minorities 16 2. Imbalanced Civil-Military Relations 18 3. Absence of Good Governance 21 3.1 Institutional Deficiencies 22 3.2 Corruption 25 3.3 Deficient Rule of Law 27 3.4 Incapacities of Public Sector Personnel 28 3.5 Lack of Political Will within Ruling Elite 28 3.6 Flawed Taxation System 29 3.7 Rising Inflation 30 4. Inter-Provincial Disharmony 31 4.1 Distribution of Resources among Provinces 31 4.2 Provincial Autonomy under 18th Amendment 32 4.3 Nationalist Movements 33 4.3 (a) Balochistan Movement 33 4.3 (b) Seraiki Movement 35 4.3 (c) Hazara Movement 36 4.4 Inter-Provincial Water Distribution Row 37 4.5 Provinces' Representation in the Army 38 4.6 Federal Legislative List-Part II (of the Constitution of Pakistan) 40 5. Socio-Economic Problems 40 5.1 Poverty 40 5.1 (a) Growing Trend of Militancy 42 5.1 (b) Increase in Suicide Incidents 42 5.2 Illiteracy 43 5.3 Unemployment 44 CRSS - 2010 6. Army's Predominance of Foreign Policy 45 6.1 Army's Role in Kashmir Policy 46 6.2 Army's Role in Afghan Policy 47 6.3 Army's Role in U.S. Policy 48 7. Geography 49 7.1 Pakistan's Border with India 50 7.2 Pakistan's Border with Afghanistan 51 7.3 Pakistan's Border with Iran 51 7.4 America's Interests in the Region 53 8.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2011
    2012-14 ANNUAL REPORT Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan, Supreme Court Building, Constitution Avenue, Islamabad THE ANNUAL REPORTS ARE ALSO AVAILABLE ON THE COMMISSION’S WEBSITE. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT THE COMMISSION’S SECRETARIAT AT THE FOLLOWING ADDRESS: LAW AND JUSTICE COMMISSION OF PAKISTAN SUPREME COURT BUILDING CONSTITUTION AVENUE ISLAMABAD, PAKISTAN TEL: 092-51-9208752 FAX: 092-51-9214797 092-51-9214416 EMAIL: [email protected] WEBSITE: www.ljcp.gov.pk TABLE OF CONTENTS S. # CONTENTS PAGE NUMBER Foreword Introduction 1. Profiles of Chairmen and Members of Law and Justice Commission 6 of Pakistan 1.1 Mr. Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, 6 Chief Justice of Pakistan 1.2 Mr. Justice Tassaduq Hussain Jillani, 9 Chief Justice of Pakistan 1.3 Mr. Justice Nasir-ul-Mulk 17 Chief Justice of Pakistan 1.4 Mr. Justice Agha Rafiq Ahmed Khan 18 Chief Justice, Federal Shariat Court 1.5 Mr. Justice Sardar Muhammad Raza 20 Chief Justice, Federal Shariat Court 1.6 Mr. Justice Sh. Azmat Saeed 21 Chief Justice, Lahore High Court 1.7 Mr. Justice Mushir Alam 22 Chief Justice, High Court of Sindh 1.8 Mr. Justice Dost Muhammad Khan 23 Chief Justice, Peshawar High Court 1.9 Mr. Justice Umar Ata Bandial 24 Chief Justice, Lahore High Court 1.10 Mr. Justice Qazi Faez Isa 25 Chief Justice, High Court of Balochistan 1.11 Mr. Justice Maqbool Baqar, 26 Chief Justice, High Court of Sindh 1.12 Mr. Justice Mian Fasih-ul-Mulk 27 Chief Justice, Peshawar High Court 1.13 Mr. Justice Muhammad Anwar Khan Kasi 28 Chief Justice, Islamabad High Court 1.14 Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Pakistan's War on Free Speech. Challenges and Probable Solutions
    9. Pakistan’s war on free speech Challenges and probable solutions Altaf Ullah Khan The record of freedom of expression and journalism, viewed through the history of Pakistani governments is rather shabby. However, what has happened lately, and is still going on, is highly alarming. It appears to be a fight between, on one hand, the status quo, the negative morality espoused by the state as a force of unification rooted in tradition, and on the other, the positive alternative, which is inherently present in the status quo (Drolet, 2007). What we mean by negative morality is one that focuses on discipline and order. It is rooted in tradition and resists change. In the very best of its forms, it maintains order and ensures steady social processes, avoiding social disorder by checking and constraining the forces of innovation. The Pakistani state and other organizations responsible for group cohesion use negative morality to maintain order. However, in a democratic dispensation, such a point of view is not against innovation. Innovation, the liberal thought, and its accompanying boons are inherent in the negative morality, thus, the very antithesis that justifies the thesis. The liberal strands in a human society represent what can be called the positive morality. A good state and government, or ruling system for that matter, would ensure Altaf Ullah Khan is a Professor of Mass Communication at Forman the balance between the negative and positive. While not espousing Christian College University, Laho- the positive one, the balanced state gives it enough room to thrive. In re, Pakistan. He has been a visiting scholar at Ohio University, USA autocracies, dictatorships, anarchies, and all societies ruled by closed in two periods, and taught at the and obscurantist ideologies this balance is lost.
    [Show full text]
  • Pakistani Nationalism and the State Marginalisation of the Ahmadiyya Community in Pakistan
    Sadia Saeed: Pakistani Nationalism and the State Marginalisation of the Ahmadiyya Community in Pakistan Pakistani Nationalism and the State Marginalisation of the Ahmadiyya Community in Pakistan Sadia Saeed University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, USA Abstract This paper examines the relationship between nationalism, state formation, and the marginalisation of national minorities through an historical focus on Pakistani state’s relationship with the Ahmadiyya community, a self-defined minority sect of Islam. In 1974, a constitutional amendment was enacted that effectively rendered the Ahmadiyya community a non-Muslim minority, in spite of claims by the community that it was Muslim and hence not a minority. This paper attempts to account for this anti-Ahmadiyya state legislation by arguing that the genealogy of the idea of a Pakistani state is key for understanding the politics of exclusion of the Ahmadiyya community from ‘Muslim citizenship’ – that is, who is and isn’t a Muslim. Introduction This paper explores the relationship between nationalism, state formation, and the marginalisation of national minorities. In the literature on the nation and nationalism, the relationship between state formation and nationalist exclusions is often under-theorised, with the implicit assumption made that processes of nation building occur independently of the construction of state institutions. Many works have shown the pitfalls of this neglect by demonstrating that the articulation of nationalist ideologies, and the processes which take place in the national community as a result of such nationalisms, are either aided by, or are articulated in response to, the formation of state institutions and practices of social closure (Brubaker 1992; Balibar 2004; Omi and Winant 1994).
    [Show full text]
  • Judicial Activism in Pakistan Is Challenging for Foreign Investor in the Context of China and Pakistan Economic Corridor
    Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization www.iiste.org ISSN 2224-3240 (Paper) ISSN 2224-3259 (Online) Vol.95, 2020 Judicial Activism in Pakistan is Challenging for Foreign Investor in the Context of China and Pakistan Economic Corridor Li Youxing 1 Muhammad Farhan Qureshi 2 1 .Professor of law, Guanghua Law School, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou,Zhejiang Province, 310008 China 2. Doctoral Candidate in Law,Guanghua Law School,Zhejiang Univesity,Hangzhou. Zhejiang Province 310008 China Abstract The judiciary has an important role in Pakistan. If the judicial system of any state provides appropriate law and justice,it would not only benefit local investors, but also provide a favorable environment for foreign investors to enhance their business. The support of the judiciary system is crucial for foreign investors in order to enhance FDI. In the past few years foreign investors were facing challenges by the courts in Pakistan. Due to judicial activism not only Pakistan being a host state had to experience failure in investment projects, but also the foreign investors had to become a victim of massive loss.In the constitution of Pakistan the courts have the power to take action against any case in the interest of the public. Suo moto is a constitutional power and judiciary have the right to use this power in any case.China is initiating a huge investment in Pakistan, which will not only provide great scope to the investors in growing their businesses but also will promote job opportunities, technology transfer,economics and prosperity of Pakistan. The judiciary system of Pakistan is likely to impose great challenges to the Chinese investors.It has been observed in the past that the judiciary in Pakistan had played a role in creating issues in the development of foreign investment leading to termination of the investment agreement.Moreover in some cases foreign investors were compelled to leave the country.
    [Show full text]